Content Type: Article

  • NAIC Continues to Refine Multiyear Work Plan to Expand Scrutiny of Holding Company Act Filings

    NAIC Continues to Refine Multiyear Work Plan to Expand Scrutiny of Holding Company Act Filings

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    NAIC Continues to Refine Multiyear Work Plan to Expand Scrutiny of Holding Company Act Filings

    May 5, 2022

    Read time: 9 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In our report published on April 26, 2022, we discussed the New York Department of Financial Services’ (NYDFS) Circular Letter No. 5 in which it reminded the industry that acquiring less than 10% of an insurer’s voting securities does not necessarily mean that the acquirer (1) is not a “controller” and (2) does not have to submit a Form A application to the insurer’s home state or domestic regulator seeking approval for the change of control. This topic is one of several related matters that various committees, task forces and working groups of the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) are studying and will continue to study over a multiyear period (the Project). The NAIC’s Macroprudential (E) Working Group (Working Group) is overseeing the Project. In December 2021, when the NAIC’s Financial Stability (E) Task Force and the Working Group developed a “List of [13] Regulatory Considerations – PE Related and Other” (List), we reported on that development. We now report on the Working Group’s publication of regulators’ reactions to the List. (The Working Group will accept comments on the regulators’ reactions until June 13, 2022.)

    In depth

    INTRODUCTION

    The NAIC and the Working Group have continuously stressed that while many of the issues in the List arise in the context of Form A filings submitted by private equity funds (PE Funds) and subsequent related holding company act filings, the issues can also be spotted in other contexts. That said, some of the issues that seem of most concern to regulators are associated with services provided to insurers by fellow PE Fund portfolio companies, investments structured by such companies or debt obligations issued by portfolio companies. One of the regulatory considerations listed back in December 2021 was whether to define “private equity funds,” however, regulators have now decided (at least for the moment) that a definition is not needed. In any case, regulators are concerned with all owners and controllers of insurers, not just PE Funds. Anyone interested in Holding Company Act matters should pay attention to the Working Group, the progress of the Project and the inputs it will receive from a wide variety of regulators here and abroad in the coming years.

    We lead off with regulator reactions to Form A filing considerations. These reactions, in the form of possible “stipulations” or conditions to Form A approvals, will provide a good indication of the direction in which regulators may be headed. However, the remaining sections of this article highlight the concerns that regulators have been expressing in recent NAIC meetings, both with respect to Form A filings and to other Holding Company Act disclosure requirements, including:

    • Corporate developments that current Holding Company Act filing requirements do not capture
    • Influence and activities of less than 10% shareholders, particularly vis-à-vis investment management agreements
    • Identify and understand complex, structured securities and their features
    • Use of “offshore reinsurance”
    • Whether (and when) explicit capital support for an insurer’s balance sheet is needed and from whom it can be obtained.

    FORM A CHANGE OF CONTROL FILINGS

    The Working Group’s latest report begins with a variety of “stipulations” that regulators have suggested could be used in connection with Form A change of control application approvals, with some of the stipulations or conditions being time limited.

    Limited Duration Stipulations

    • Requiring risk-based capital (RBC) levels to be maintained more than company action/trend test levels
    • Requiring RBC reports quarterly rather than annually
    • Prohibiting dividends, even ordinary dividends
    • Requiring applicants to provide capital maintenance support, possibly in a funded trust account
    • Requiring insurers to disclose “material changes” (with accompanying financial projections) in items, such as operations, dividends, investments, affiliated agreements (particularly cost-sharing agreements) and reinsurance that would otherwise not be reportable or subject to prior approval or non-disapproval under existing Holding Company Act laws.

    Continuing Stipulations

    • Prior approval is required for all material reinsurance agreements, even those with non-affiliates
    • Early notification (within 30 days) of all changes in directors and executive officers (including the filing of biographical affidavits)
    • Sharing all disclosure documents provided to prospective investors or to lenders involved with the acquisition of the insurer in question
    • Disclose all involved parties. Those with voting equity or with any economic interest in intermediate companies/entities are up to the ultimate controller to disclose
    • Require all of the above parties to supply financial statements.

    REFERRALS TO OTHER NAIC WORKING GROUPS

    As mentioned above, there are a number of NAIC committees, task forces and working groups that are contributing to the review of the 13 regulatory considerations, with some of the other bodies having already begun their work. Below are the issues being referred to each group.

    Group Solvency Issues (E) Working Group

    • Develop an optimal disclosure protocol that covers otherwise unaddressed solvency concerns (e.g., drilling deeper into the motivations/purposes of the acquirer, understanding the acquirer’s expected sources of returns or profits, inquiring into the acquirer’s ability to provide capital support)
    • Train regulators in states that may not have a high volume of Form A applications to review
    • Identify sources of expertise for regulators in all states to utilize as needed (with applicants footing the bill for such assignments) concerning “complex transaction, especially to understand non-U.S. affiliations and when assessing multiple complex Form A applications”
    • Focus on persons/entities that do not have 10% or more ownership of voting securities, including:
      • Non-customary minority shareholder rights
      • Investment management agreement provisions, such as costly termination provisions or excessive control over investment decisions
    • Gather “detailed examples to address the complexity and creativity involved” in Form A applications
    • Consider ways to “better target…pertinent agreements to assess…” the impact of less than 10% owners
    • Consider enhanced Form B (annual holding company group registration) filings.

    Risk-Focused Surveillance (E) Working Group

    • Work on affiliate agreements and Form D (material transactions with affiliates) filings (which the group is already doing)
    • Focus on investment management agreement termination provisions on subadvisors (as well as any additional fees)
    • Create protocols to identify and evaluate securities/investments developed by affiliates of controllers or affiliates of a PE Fund’s portfolio companies, with respect to conflicts of interest and hidden or excessive fees
    • Evaluate whether to involve the NAIC’s Valuation of Securities (E) Task Force
    • Examine surplus notes, particularly those with floating interest rates; possibly liaison with the NAIC’s Statutory Accounting Principles (E) Working Group
    • Make capital support agreements stronger and focus on ensuring that such agreements are executed with proper parties, particularly for life and annuity issues where liabilities are long term
    • Consider PE Fund acquirers (and others) that may have little or limited experience in operating insurers, as well as possible overreliance on third-party service providers and:
      • More Form A disclosures
      • Compare with EU practices
      • Consider providing more guidance to financial examiners.

    Both the Statutory Accounting Principles (E) Working Group and the Risk-Focused Surveillance (E) Working Group

    • Develop codes to identify and facilitate the disclosure of related-party investments, particularly structured securities (e.g., collateralized loan obligations (CLOs)) where a related party may have originated one or more of the obligations included in the CLO held by the insurer
    • For CLOs, contemplate another referral—to the NAIC’s Examination Oversight (E) Task Force—to ascertain ways and means to obtain more detail about CLO investments, including obtaining copies of disclosures provided to potential investors
    • With respect to structured securities in general—whether issued or structured by related parties or not—the Working Group will draw upon expertise provided by the NAIC’s Capital Markets Bureau and its Securities Valuation Office to increase monitoring/analytic capabilities, including the use of rating agency reports to study potential credit, complexity and illiquidity risks as well as lack of transparency. Additionally, regulators plan to study:
      • Adequacy of insurer governance and controls with respect to investing and monitoring investments in complex securities
      • Improvement of regulatory tools and insurer disclosures (pursuant to a project to revamp Schedule D) to “automate” screening for investments in complex securities
      • Reliance on rating agency ratings, monitoring over the next several years as the project continues.

    DISCLAIMERS OF AFFILIATION

    The Working Group noted the NYDFS’ Circular Letter No. 5 and confirmed that copies had been sent to all members of the Working Group. The Working Group is particularly interested in disclaimers filed by entities that manage assets/investments. Regulators will use the information contained in the new-for-2021 Schedule Y, Part 3 to identify any disclaiming person/entity holding 10% or more of an insurer’s voting securities and will pursue ways and means to identify persons/entities of interest that hold less than 10% of an insurer’s voting securities.

    “OFFSHORE REINSURERS”

    Members of the Working Group have made known that they do not understand why insurers turn to offshore reinsurers, captives and sidecar entities. They plan to meet with industry participants and offshore regulators to understand the drivers and to answer the following questions:

    • Do US regulatory requirements mean that insurers are holding “excess reserves”?
    • Are there other drivers?

    PENSION RISK TRANSFERS

    The Working Group will be consulting with the US Department of Labor and working with a number of other bodies within the NAIC, including the Life Actuarial (A) Task Force, Statutory Accounting Principles (E) Working Group and the Life Risk-Based Capital (E) Working Group, to (1) better understand the role that more complex investments play in these large transactions, (2) evaluate the application of Life Actuarial (A) Task Force’s already exposed Actuarial Guideline to pension risk transfers and (3) study whether better disclosures regarding pension risk transfers are required. The Working Group will also continue to follow the work of the Longevity Risk Transfer subgroup of the Life Risk-Based Capital (E) Working Group.

    Authors

    Andrea T. Best

    Partner

    London – 22 Bishopsgate

    H. Michael Byrne

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    Thomas M. Dawson

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    Michael R. Halsband

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • International News: Spotlight on Tax

    International News: Spotlight on Tax

    INTERNATIONAL NEWS / REPORT

    International News: Spotlight on Tax

    May 2022

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    It is always the case that businesses must keep up with changes to tax rules, but never have tax rules had to pay equally close attention to changes in business. The evolution of technology and the internet age have driven seismic shifts in the ways companies operate, and presented new challenges for tax regimes.

    The long-awaited Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD)/G20 Global Anti-Base Erosion Model Rules, intended to address perceived challenges to longstanding international taxation principles by the increasing digitalisation of the economy, are coming closer to becoming a reality with the agreement by 137 OECD/G20 countries and jurisdictions to join the official statement of the Two-Pillar Solution. But we’re still not there yet. Similarly, despite the Non Fungible Token (NFT) market being worth US$21 billion, the US Internal Revenue Service (IRS) still hasn’t explicitly stated how NFTs will be taxed.

    Without clear rules and guidance, businesses need to be highly vigilant. The continuing trend of working outside the office means international companies must ensure their remote workforce doesn’t inadvertently trigger tax liabilities by creating a permanent establishment or permanent representative; and trustees must undertake regular reviews to ensure changes within the trust don’t generate new taxable events. In addition, companies need to be aware of how expected changes to tax laws may be more aggressive than anticipated, such as the withdrawal by the US IRS of certain foreign tax credits.

    Please contact the authors directly if you have any comments on our articles, or would like to discuss any of the issues raised.

    In depth
    Authors

    Priya Taneja

    Partner

    London – 22 Bishopsgate

    Brian H. Jenn

    Partner

    Washington, DC, Chicago

    Annette Keller

    Partner

    Munich

    Dr. Dirk Pohl

    Partner

    Munich

    Antoine Vergnat

    Partner

    Paris

    Romain Desmonts

    Partner

    Paris

    Dr. Gero Burwitz

    Partner

    Munich

    Jilali Maazouz

    Partner

    Paris

    Abdel Abdellah

    Counsel

    Paris

    More insights

  • Recent Developments in Tax Law: Taxes on the Transfer of Income under the ATAD Implementation Act – Draft ATAD III

    Recent Developments in Tax Law: Taxes on the Transfer of Income under the ATAD Implementation Act – Draft ATAD III

    ARTICLE

    Recent Developments in Tax Law: Taxes on the Transfer of Income under the ATAD Implementation Act – Draft ATAD III

    May 2022

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Dr. Gero Burwitz and Jonathan Storz authored the article “Recent Developments in Tax Law: Taxes on the Transfer of Income under the ATAD Implementation Act – Draft ATAD III”, featured in Neue Zeitschrift für Gesellschaftsrecht (NZG), p. 596 et seq. in May, 2022.

    In depth
    Authors

    Dr. Gero Burwitz

    Partner

    Munich

    Jonathan Storz

    Counsel

    Munich

    More insights

  • New York City Council Votes to Delay Effective Date of New Salary Transparency Law to Nov. 1, 2022

    New York City Council Votes to Delay Effective Date of New Salary Transparency Law to Nov. 1, 2022

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    New York City Council Votes to Delay Effective Date of New Salary Transparency Law to Nov. 1, 2022

    May 5, 2022

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On April 28, 2022, the New York City Council passed a bill amending New York City’s previously enacted salary transparency law, discussed here and here. Most notably, if the bill is signed by Mayor Adams, or he takes no action within 30 days of passage, the effective date of the salary transparency law will be changed from May 15, 2022 to Nov. 1, 2022.

    In addition to delaying the effective date of the law, the new bill:

    • Provides that an employer will not be subject to civil monetary penalties for a first violation if such employer proves to the New York City Commission on Human Rights (“NYCCHR”), within 30 days of an NYCCHR complaint, that the violation has been cured;
    • Only grants employees—and not applicants—a private right of action, allowing them to sue their current employers in court for violations of the salary transparency law. The NYCCHR retains enforcement authority in all circumstances; and
    • Codifies certain guidance from the NYCCHR’s previously issued fact sheet by (i) adding explicit language applying the salary transparency requirement to hourly paid workers and (ii) explicitly providing that the salary disclosure requirement does not apply to “positions that cannot or will not be performed, at least in part, in the city of New York.”

    The salary transparency law, regardless of whether it is amended, will cover employers that have four or more employees, or one or more domestic workers, as long as at least one of those employees works in New York City. Employment agencies are also covered, regardless of their size. Employers that work with temporary help firms are also required to comply.

    The amendments were the result of heavy lobbying by the business community to delay the effective date of the law to provide employers with additional time to prepare.

    Authored by Mark E. Brossman, Ronald E. Richman, Max Garfield, Scott A. Gold and Donna K. Lazarus.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2022 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Mark E. Brossman

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Ronald E. Richman

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Max Garfield

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Donna K. Lazarus

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Commerce Clarifies Scope of CSPV Circumvention Inquiry and Provides Opportunity to Comment on Proposed Certification Process

    Commerce Clarifies Scope of CSPV Circumvention Inquiry and Provides Opportunity to Comment on Proposed Certification Process

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Commerce Clarifies Scope of CSPV Circumvention Inquiry and Provides Opportunity to Comment on Proposed Certification Process

    May 4, 2022

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On March 25, 2022, pursuant to allegations made by Auxin Solar Inc., the US Department of Commerce (Commerce) initiated a circumvention inquiry into whether imports of crystalline silicon photovoltaic cells (CSPVs) from Cambodia, Malaysia, Thailand or Vietnam (collectively, the Target Countries) are circumventing antidumping duty (AD) and countervailing duty (CVD) orders (Orders) on CSPVs from China[1] that could profoundly affect the companies that import or rely on imported CSPVs in the United States.[2] On May 2, 2022, Commerce released a memorandum detailing three important aspects of its ongoing inquiry should it preliminarily or ultimately determine that CSPVs from the Target Countries are circumventing the Orders.[3] In those three aspects, Commerce:

    • Clarified the scope of the circumvention inquiry, noting that CSPVs incorporating wafers produced outside of China from China-sourced polysilicon are outside the scope of the inquiry
    • Stated that, in the event of affirmative circumvention findings, it intends to establish certification procedures that would allow exporters and importers of CSPVs to establish that particular entries do not incorporate key components or processes from China and should therefore be excluded from the Orders altogether
    • Indicated that the certification process could be used to establish the appropriate company-specific rate for those entries that are included in the scope of the circumvention inquiry. Specifically, Commerce proposed that exporters can certify the identity(ies) of the Chinese producer(s) that supplied the inputs.

    Commerce also invited interested parties to provide comments and relevant factual information on these potential certification requirements by 5:00 pm EDT on May 19, 2022. We discuss each of the above points in more detail below. For more information on the initiation of the circumvention inquiry and the process in general, read our client alert: “An analysis of the Auxin Petition and Commerce investigation and their impact on the solar industry.”

    In depth

    ANALYSIS

    1. Clarification of the Scope of the Circumvention Inquiry

    Commerce acknowledged that this inquiry differs from prior circumvention proceedings as it involves numerous inputs and multiple third countries. In addition, various steps of the production process (e.g., refining polysilicon, forming it into ingots, cutting wafers, doping wafers and assembling modules) can happen in different countries. Importantly, Commerce then clarified that “[w]afers produced outside of China with polysilicon sourced from China are not subject to these circumvention inquiries.”[4] While more clarity on the reach of the circumvention inquiry is needed, this is a useful first step. It should be noted, however, that this clarification reinforces Commerce’s apparent willingness to move from its prior position that “the essential component of the solar cell is the p/n junction”[5] and that the country in which the p/n junction is formed determines the country of origin of the CSPV for purposes of the Orders.[6]

    2. Proposed Certification Procedures That Will Allow for the Application of Company-Specific Rates on Chinese Manufacturers

    Typically, after making an affirmative circumvention finding, whether preliminary or final, Commerce establishes certification procedures to allow importers and exports to certify the source of materials used in the allegedly circumventing products and establish that such products are not subject to the underlying AD or CVD orders.[7] Commerce’s memorandum indicates that, in the event of an affirmative circumvention determination in this proceeding, it intends to establish a similar certification process but does not provide details as to which specific Chinese inputs or products will be considered key to bringing a product within the scope of the underlying Orders. Where an exporter/importer can provide a certification that specific entries of CSPVs do not include such key Chinese components, they will not be subject to the scope of the circumvention determination and will not be subject to any AD or CVD duties. Where they cannot, they will be subject to the circumvention finding and the importer will be required to post AD and CVD cash deposits on such entries.

    Commerce’s proposed structure for certifications differs from the structure of certifications in past circumvention cases in that it includes a process to allow “importers and exporters to certify as to the identity(ies) of the Chinese producer(s) that supplied the inputs.”[8] The identity(ies) of the Chinese producer(s) would then be used to determine the applicable AD and CVD company-specific cash deposit rates. As Commerce’s memo notes:

    [I]f Chinese-origin wafers are used in the completion of solar cells or modules in Vietnam, Thailand, Cambodia and/or Malaysia and were supplied by a Chinese manufacturer with a company-specific rate, for such imports, Commerce intends, in the event of an affirmative preliminary or final determination, that the cash deposit rate for the relevant imports from the third country will be equal to that Chinese manufacturer’s and/or exporter’s company-specific rate(s).[9]

    Thus, where entries are subject to the circumvention finding, this proposed certification process would allow exporters and importers to indicate the appropriate cash deposit rates to apply on such entries. This designation is particularly important in a case such as this where the rates vary widely. Accordingly, the establishment and use of this aspect of the certification process could allow interested parties to lower their tariff exposure risk to more manageable levels based on their choice of manufacturer.

    As Commerce’s memo notes, however, in prior circumvention inquiries, Commerce has excluded companies from the certification process if it determines that such companies did not cooperate to the best of their ability in the inquiry or if companies were unable to trace the inputs from the subject country to actual merchandise imported into the United States. Companies that are not eligible to participate in the certification process would have no ability to establish that their entries should be excluded from any circumvention finding or to establish the applicable cash deposit rate. Such entries would presumably be entered at the China-wide rates specified in the Orders.[10]

    CONCLUSION

    While the initiation of the circumvention investigation introduced numerous material uncertainties as to duty increases and the impact thereof upon suppliers and projects (as noted in our prior client alert), Commerce’s May 2 memorandum begins to provide some of the needed clarification. As we noted at the start, interested parties have until 5:00 pm (EDT) on May 19, 2022, to submit comments and factual information to Commerce regarding these proposed certification requirements.

    McDermott’s team of renewable energy transactional, trade and procurement specialists are currently assisting clients with their responses to Commerce’s memorandum. Please reach out to Carl Fleming if you would like to discuss this comment period further.

    Authors

    Carl J. Fleming

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • European Union, United Kingdom Propose New Sanctions Against Russia, Including Ban on Certain Services

    European Union, United Kingdom Propose New Sanctions Against Russia, Including Ban on Certain Services

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    European Union, United Kingdom Propose New Sanctions Against Russia, Including Ban on Certain Services

    May 4, 2022

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    As Russia continues to escalate its military operations in Ukraine, the European Union (EU) and the United Kingdom (UK) unveiled details of new sanctions against Russia. This alert summarises the proposed restrictions.

    In depth

    Ursula von der Leyen, President of the EU Commission, announced the newly proposed restrictions as part of the sixth package of sanctions against Russia. These restrictions include:

    • An import ban on Russian oil, with the supply of crude oil to be phased out within six months, and refined products by the end of 2022.
    • A ban on the provision of services to Russian companies by accountants, consultants, and public relations service providers. It is currently unclear which services will be in scope of the ban and whether a transitional period will be granted for EU service providers to comply with the new restrictions.
    • The expansion of the prohibition on the provision of financial messaging services (including SWIFT) to Sberbank and two additional “major banks” (yet to be named).
    • A ban on three additional Russian state-owned broadcasters (yet to be named).
    • Asset freeze restrictions on “high ranking military officers and other individuals who committed war crimes in Bucha and who are responsible for the inhuman siege of the city of Mariupol”.
    • Although not included in Ursula von der Leyen’s announcement, the EU is also considering restricting the provision of cloud services to Russia.

    The measures detailed above are not yet in force and will require approval from EU Member States. The proposed ban on Russian oil may be particularly contentious as Hungary previously indicated it would veto sanctions restricting energy imports.

    Similarly, UK Foreign Secretary Liz Truss also announced that the UK would impose further sanctions against Russia, including:

    • A ban on the provisions of management, consulting, accounting and public relationship services to Russia.
    • Further sanctions on Russian state-owned broadcasters and new organisations, including RT and Sputnik online.
    • New asset freeze restrictions on Russian individuals and organisations, including Russian journalists.

    The text of the new UK sanctions has not yet been published as of the time of writing this alert. It is therefore unclear which services will be affected, the scope of the new restrictions, and how closely the UK sanctions will align with those proposed by the EU.

    Our McDermott team will continue to closely monitor new developments in this area. If you are concerned about the impact of the proposed restrictions on your business, you can reach out to Raminta Dereskeviciute.

     

    Authors

    Raminta Dereskeviciute

    Partner

    London – 22 Bishopsgate

    Ludovica Rabitti

    Senior Associate

    London – 22 Bishopsgate

    William Merry

    Senior Associate

    London – 22 Bishopsgate

    Dr. Alexa Ningelgen

    Partner

    Düsseldorf

    More insights

  • State Law Privacy Video Series | Enforcement

    State Law Privacy Video Series | Enforcement

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT / VIDEO

    State Law Privacy Video Series | Enforcement

    May 4, 2022

    Read time: 2 min

    Overview

    California, Virginia and Colorado have new privacy laws coming into effect in 2023. But now is the time to start preparing your business or organization for compliance.

    In this video series, we examine the different aspects of these laws and provide you the knowledge and tools you need for proper compliance.

    In depth

    Enforcement under the new consumer privacy laws in Virginia, Colorado and Utah are straightforward and fairly similar. However, in California, there are three different enforcement mechanisms.

    In the last installment of our video series, Partner David Saunders explains what businesses need to know when it comes to enforcement under each of the state privacy laws.


    McDermott’s State Law Privacy Video Series: Enforcement overview, 2022 (runtime: 3m13s)

    Conclusion

    David P. Saunders

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • DOJ Demonstrates Commitment to COVID-19-Related Healthcare Enforcement with New Criminal Charges

    DOJ Demonstrates Commitment to COVID-19-Related Healthcare Enforcement with New Criminal Charges

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    DOJ Demonstrates Commitment to COVID-19-Related Healthcare Enforcement with New Criminal Charges

    May 2, 2022

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On April 20, 2022, the US Department of Justice (DOJ) announced a nationwide coordinated law enforcement action focused on COVID-19-related healthcare fraud. In total, DOJ brought criminal charges against 21 individuals, including physicians and healthcare executives, in connection with alleged fraud schemes resulting in almost $150 million in improper government claims. These new criminal charges, as well as recent civil and administrative actions, come on the heels of DOJ statements reaffirming its commitment to aggressively pursuing COVID-19-related healthcare frauds, and provide further evidence that DOJ’s enforcement efforts in this area are likely to continue for the foreseeable future.

    In depth

    The specific charges brought during the April 2022 enforcement action are consistent with DOJ’s longstanding COVID-19-related healthcare fraud priorities and are similar to charges pursued during a May 2021 COVID-19 healthcare fraud enforcement action. These new charges focus on the following COVID-19-related enforcement priorities:

    • Telehealth. In recent years, DOJ and the US Department of Health and Human Services Office of Inspector General (HHS-OIG) have consistently prioritized prosecuting fraudulent telehealth schemes. The April 2022 enforcement action follow this trend. For example, at least one medical professional was charged in connection with his role in a kickback scheme that involved billing for sham telemedicine encounters and agreeing to order unnecessary genetic testing in exchange for access to telehealth patients.
    • Provider Relief Fund. The April 2022 enforcement action also reflects DOJ’s continued focus on fraud in connection with the Provider Relief Fund (PRF), which was created as part of the Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security Act to provide direct payments to “eligible health care providers for health care-related expenses [and] lost revenues that are attributable to coronavirus.” Two defendants were charged with misappropriating PRF monies. Although the PRF cases to date all focus on blatant instances of fraud and abuse in connection with the PRF, more complex PRF cases are expected to follow, both in the criminal and civil space.
    • Improper Billing Schemes. DOJ and HHS-OIG continue to target improper billing schemes that involve COVID-19 services. Several cases in the April 2022 enforcement action involve defendants who allegedly offered COVID-19 testing, then used beneficiary information to submit false and fraudulent claims for other services that were either medically unnecessary or never provided.

    In announcing these new charges, DOJ Criminal Division Assistant Attorney General Kenneth A. Polite, Jr., emphasized DOJ’s “commitment to using all available tools to hold accountable medical professionals, corporate executives, and others who have placed greed above care during an unprecedented public health emergency.” HHS Inspector General Christi A. Grimm also highlighted HHS-OIG’s commitment to pursuing COVID-19-related fraud, stating that the “attempt to profit from the COVID-19 pandemic by targeting beneficiaries and stealing from federal health programs is unconscionable.”

    DOJ and HHS-OIG’s civil and administrative enforcement activity also appears to be picking up steam. For example, in early April 2022, DOJ settled a False Claims Act and Financial Institutions Reform, Recovery and Enforcement Act case involving a COVID-19-related improper billing scheme for almost $25 million. Among other things, DOJ alleged that a Florida healthcare provider attempted to compensate for lower revenues during the pandemic by requiring physicians to schedule unnecessary evaluation and management appointments and ordering medically unnecessary testing services. The provider also falsely claimed that it was not engaged in illegal activity when it applied for and obtained a $5.9 million Paycheck Protection Program loan.

    In connection with the April 2022 enforcement action, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services Center for Program Integrity announced that it had taken administrative actions against 28 providers for their alleged involvement in fraud, waste and abuse schemes related to the delivery of care for COVID-19, as well as other schemes that capitalized upon the public health emergency.

    Although the United States appears to be finally emerging from the pandemic, the federal government’s COVID-19-related healthcare enforcement activity shows no signs of slowing down. DOJ, HHS-OIG, and other federal and state agencies continue to aggressively pursue pandemic-related criminal, civil and administrative healthcare enforcement actions. Healthcare companies, hospital systems and providers should prepare for this increased scrutiny by taking proactive steps to minimize their enforcement risk. For specific practice pointers on how to mitigative these risks and improve existing compliance programs, please see McDermott’s recent Healthcare Enforcement Quarterly.

    Authors

    Julian L. André

    Partner

    Los Angeles

    Benton Curtis

    Partner

    Miami

    Brigid McCarthy

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • Connecticut Steps Up to the Consumer Privacy Law Plate

    Connecticut Steps Up to the Consumer Privacy Law Plate

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Connecticut Steps Up to the Consumer Privacy Law Plate

    May 2, 2022

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On April 28, 2022, the Connecticut House of Representatives joined the Connecticut Senate in passing the Connecticut Data Privacy Act (CTDPA), which now heads to Governor Ned Lamont for signature. Governor Lamont is expected to sign the bill (Senate Bill 6), making Connecticut the fifth state to pass a consumer privacy law.



    McDermott’s State Law Privacy Video Series: Connecticut Data Privacy Act overview, 2022 (runtime: 3m)

    In depth

    CTDPA would apply to businesses that:

    1. Conduct business in Connecticut or produce products or services targeted to Connecticut residents and
    2. Either (1) control or process the personal data of at least 100,000 residents annually or (2) derive over 25% of its gross revenue from the “sale” of personal data and control or process the personal data of at least 25,000 residents annually.

    As with other state laws, CTDPA contains broad exceptions for certain entities and data categories, including government entities, nonprofits, higher education institutions, national securities associations and information and entities regulated by both the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act and the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act. It also exempts personal data collected about employees and business contacts.

    CTDPA, which would take effect on July 1, 2023, includes many of the same rights, obligations and exceptions that have become common in other consumer privacy laws and proposals:

    • The “personal data” protected by CTDPA includes information that is linked or reasonably linkable to an identified or identifiable individual. “Personal data” does not include de-identified data or publicly available information.
    • CTDPA requires opt-in consent for the collection and processing of “sensitive” information, which includes information revealing racial or ethnic origin, religious beliefs, mental or physical health condition or diagnosis, sex life, sexual orientation, citizenship or immigration status, genetic or biometric data, children’s data and precise geolocation data.
    • CTDPA would provide consumers with the familiar rights of notice, access, portability, correction and deletion. Certain rights, however, are qualified by reasonable business-use exemptions such as detecting fraud and complying with a company’s legal obligations, while others (like the right to delete) are broader than we have seen in other states.
    • Like other laws, CTDPA would allow consumers to opt out of the use of their information for certain purposes, including targeted advertising, the sale of personal data and automated profiling decisions that “produce legal or similarly significant effects concerning the consumer.” Beginning in 2025, consumers may exercise their right to opt out by using a global opt-out device setting.
    • CTDPA requires businesses to obtain opt-in consent from children under the age of 16 before selling their personal data or using it for targeted advertising. Businesses that comply with the verifiable consent requirements of the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act would be deemed compliant with the parental consent obligations contained in CTDPA.
    • Consumers will have the right to appeal a denial of a consumer request, which mimics the rights to appeal provided under Colorado and Virginia laws.
    • CTDPA would be exclusively enforced through actions by the Connecticut Attorney General. Until December 31, 2024, there is a 60-day cure period for alleged violations. Beginning January 1, 2025, a cure period is granted at the discretion of the Connecticut Attorney General.

    McDermott Will & Emery’s Global Data Privacy and Cybersecurity team can help you assess the applicability of CTDPA and work with companies to ensure compliance. For assistance or more information, please contact either Amy Pimentel or David Saunders.

     

    Authors

    Amy C. Pimentel

    Partner

    Boston

    David P. Saunders

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • Big Data and AI: Connecticut Insurance Department’s New Annual Compliance Certification

    Big Data and AI: Connecticut Insurance Department’s New Annual Compliance Certification

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Big Data and AI: Connecticut Insurance Department’s New Annual Compliance Certification

    May 2, 2022

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Connecticut Insurance Department (CID) updated and amended its April 2021 Notice with a new Notice dated April 20, 2022 (Notice), reminding insurers and other licensees of compliance obligations when using “Big Data.” The new Notice adds a requirement for licensees using Big Data to complete an annual “Data Certification.”

    For the past several years, federal and state agencies have been investigating the use of data and artificial intelligence by financial services companies in a manner that may discriminate against certain consumers. The Notice is the most recent example of state insurance and other regulators taking an increasingly greater interest in how companies are using data sources for secondary purposes. As in other examples, the Notice focuses mainly on the application of existing laws and more regulation around such data (without discussing how the CID might facilitate compliant usage, for example, by expediting the review of new products or rates that comply with state law).

    It is also important to remember that state insurance regulators are only one set of regulatory agencies that can regulate the use of data to profile and underwrite customers, and that other limitations and requirements could apply to insurers, data brokers and other stakeholders.

    In depth

    REQUIREMENTS IN THE CID NOTICE

    The Data Certification, which is vague in certain respects, essentially requires the licensee to affirm its use of Big Data complies with the Notice. The Notice reminds licensees (insurers in particular) that the CID “continues to expect such entities … to use technology and Big Data in full compliance with anti-discrimination laws and have completed the data certification, which shall be due on or before September 1, 2022, and annually thereafter.” The Notice states these requirements apply to the use of “Big Data either internally or with vendors.”

    The Notice initially includes the CID’s recognition of the importance of industry innovation, stating the CID “is supportive of the insurance industry’s use of technological advances and opportunities to provide innovative products and services to consumers and to operate more effectively and efficiently.” “Big Data refers to a complex volume of data and the set of technologies that analyze and manage it,” and may include “algorithms, predictive models, and/or processes” the licensee develops on its own or purchases or jointly develops with third-party developers or vendors, as well as wide and varied sources of information including “consumer intelligence, social media, credit …, retail purchase history, geographic location tracking and telematics, mobile, satellite, behavioral monitoring, … sensors, wearable devices, RFID, etc.” The CID “recognizes the potentially transformative and diverse nature of the utilization of Big Data” and that “Big Data is aiding insurers’ underwriting, rating, marketing, claim settlement practices, [and] fraud [prevention], and every other facet of the insurance process life cycle.”

    More specifically, licensees must use Big Data “responsibly and transparently” and in “full compliance with Federal and State anti-discrimination laws.” The CID also states it “has the authority to require that insurance carriers and third-party data vendors, model developers, and bureaus provide the [CID] with access to data used to build models or algorithms included in all rates, forms, and underwriting filings.” Appendix A to the Notice provides examples of the types of information the CID may request during an examination specific to the usage of data brokers. The examples are categorized as: (i) information about the organization/data broker; (ii) the sources and nature of the data; (iii) data privacy and security; (iv) data curation—i.e., validation methods and standards—; and (v) data documentation and related processes including corrective action to prevent errors. The CID has been among the more active states in conducting such examinations over the past couple of years as insurers have expanded use of Big Data. Finally, the Notice reiterates the potential for regulatory concerns in internal data deployment, internal data governance, and risk management and compliance.

    OTHER STATE ACTIVITY

    Colorado enacted legislation in 2021 that prohibits unfair discrimination in the use of external consumer data and information sources, including in algorithms/predictive models. The New York Department of Financial Services (NYDFS) issued Insurance Circular Letter No. 1 in 2019 addressing Big Data in underwriting life insurance. On March 2, 2022, the NYDFS sent written requests to insurers writing private passenger automobile, commercial automobile and homeowners’ insurance in New York about their use of personal credit scores in underwriting and rating. These state activities complement ongoing discussions regarding the use of Big Data and related issues at the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC).

    The NAIC has been active in Big Data as well, charging its Big Data and Artificial Intelligence Working Group with researching and monitoring the use of Big Data and artificial intelligence (including machine learning). The NAIC’s model privacy and data security laws also apply to Big Data, both of which have been adopted in Connecticut.

    Insurance-specific laws and guidance are supplemented by other federal and state laws and guidance. In the past year, Colorado, Utah and Virginia have joined California in enacting comprehensive consumer privacy laws, and dozens of state legislatures (including Connecticut’s) have drafted bills modeled after these laws. In April 2022, Connecticut’s state Senate unanimously voted to approve the “Act Concerning Personal Data Privacy and Online Monitoring,” which focuses on ensuring individual data subjects are given notice of how a business will be using their personal data. While these state consumer privacy laws typically have broad exemptions that apply to the financial services industry (namely, institutions and data that are subject to the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act), insurance companies and other industry stakeholders should still be aware of how these laws might impact the personal data they collect.

    TAKEAWAYS

    There remains a relative vacuum in terms of legal standards governing the use of Big Data. However, the above activity illustrates the evolving views of state insurance and other regulators, as well as legislatures, and provides examples of how states may seek to regulate innovation efforts in the insurance industry, including outside of the formal legislative and rulemaking processes. Insurers, data vendors, investors and other stakeholders looking to leverage Big Data should be mindful of these and other regulatory developments.

    * * *

    McDermott Will & Emery represents a wide and diverse number of clients innovating in the insurance industry. We help clients develop groundbreaking insurance products, leverage private equity and venture capital opportunities, structure acquisitions for optimal tax benefits and defend against “bet the company” claims, disputes and multi-state regulatory investigations and enforcement proceedings. Our cross-border team includes lawyers from multiple practice areas—Transactions, Regulatory, Healthcare, Intellectual Property, Technology, Litigation, Tax and Privacy—delivering seamless, one-stop shop advice, no matter where you do business. Please do not hesitate to contact the authors or another McDermott contact.

    Authors

    H. Michael Byrne

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    Shawn C. Helms

    Partner

    Dallas

    Amy C. Pimentel

    Partner

    Boston

    David P. Saunders

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights