Content Type: Article

  • DOJ’s New CFAA Policy: Relief for White Hat Hackers and Web Scrapers?

    DOJ’s New CFAA Policy: Relief for White Hat Hackers and Web Scrapers?

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    DOJ’s New CFAA Policy: Relief for White Hat Hackers and Web Scrapers?

    May 26, 2022

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In an effort to “promote privacy and cybersecurity by upholding the legal right of individuals, network owners, operators, and other persons to ensure the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of information stored in their information systems,” the US Department of Justice (DOJ) recently announced an updated policy directing that good-faith security research not be charged under the federal Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (CFAA), provided that:

    • The activity involves accessing a computer solely for purposes of good-faith testing, investigation and/or correction of a security flaw or vulnerability;
    • Such activity is carried out in a manner designed to avoid any harm to individuals or the public; and
    • The information derived from the activity is used primarily to promote the security or safety of the class of devices, machines or online services to which the accessed computer belongs, or those who use such devices, machines or online services.[1]

    Security “research” for the purpose of discovering security holes in devices, machines or services in order to “extort” the owners of such devices, machines or services is not considered in good faith.

    The new policy also provides further clarity on CFAA charging in the wake of the US Supreme Court’s decision in Van Buren v. United States, 141 S. Ct. 1648 (2021). The DOJ has announced that it will not charge defendants with:

    • Accessing computers “without authorization” unless when, at the time of the defendant’s conduct, (1) the defendant was not authorized to access the protected computer under any circumstances by any person or entity with the authority to grant such authorization; (2) the defendant knew of the facts that made the defendant’s access without authorization; and (3) prosecution would serve the DOJ’s goals for CFAA enforcement; and
    • “Exceeding authorized access” unless, at the time of the defendant’s conduct, (1) a protected computer is divided into areas, such as files, folders, user accounts or databases; (2) that division is established in a computational sense, that is, through computer code or configuration, rather than through contracts, terms of service agreements or employee policies; (3) a defendant is authorized to access some areas, but unconditionally prohibited from accessing other areas of the computer; (4) the defendant accessed an area of the computer to which his authorized access did not extend; (5) the defendant knew of the facts that made his access unauthorized; and (6) prosecution would serve the DOJ’s goals for CFAA enforcement.

    The DOJ’s new policy provides needed clarity to a dynamically evolving area of the law, but questions remain about the distinction between “extortion” and legitimate remuneration for discovered vulnerabilities, the boundaries of permissible offensive cybersecurity activities, and civil relief under the CFAA and state CFAA analogues, among other areas.

    In depth
    Authors

    Robert Duffy

    Counsel

    Washington, DC

    David Sorenson

    Associate

    Los Angeles

    More insights

  • Value Investing Forum 2022 Interactive Case Studies: Hot Sectors in Value Investing

    Value Investing Forum 2022 Interactive Case Studies: Hot Sectors in Value Investing

    ARTICLE

    Value Investing Forum 2022 Interactive Case Studies: Hot Sectors in Value Investing

    May 25, 2022

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In this session, Felicia Perlman, Partner & Head of McDermott’s Business Restructuring Practice Group, and Fred Levenson, Partner & Co-Head of McDermott’s Private Equity Practice Group, moderated a discussion that explored lessons from several real-life scenarios during which fund managers and advisors discussed how to protect investments while also maximizing returns. These industry leaders also shared their insights on evaluating investments and determining the strategies to best manage changing circumstances and financial challenges. Session panelists included:

    • Peter Chadwick, Managing Director, Berkeley Research Group
    • Jeffrey Finger, Co-Head of US Debt Advisory & Restructuring, Managing Director, Jefferies
    • Suzanne Gibbons, Managing Member – Distressed Investments, Davidson Kempner Capital Management
    • Randy Raisman, Managing Director, Marathon Asset Management
    In depth

    Below are key takeaways from the discussion:

    1. The discussion kicked off  by providing a survey of the current state of the market. They highlighted that the leveraged credit market today is more than double what it was in 2008, with leverage levels back to historical highs as companies have benefited from strong capital markets. It was also noted that the significant amount of leveraged debt outstanding indicates that even a modest uptick in default rates should yield a meaningful increase in restructuring and distressed investment opportunities. Furthermore, they pointed out that private debt markets have grown significantly over the past few years and that there is still a good amount of dry powder looking for opportunities to put it to work. It was concluded with the observation that opportunities for distressed investing are increasing.
    2. It was then discussed where they saw the most opportunity in healthcare. Panelists said 30% of transactions last year were in the areas of physician specialists, behavioral health, services and technology, oral health and post-acute care. They emphasized three new trends that were observed in 2021: (1) maximizing revenue (e.g., building value-based care into one’s business plan); (2) being strategic vs. just focusing on scaling for its own sake; and (3) not just identifying, but also defining responses to future risks.
    3. The discussion then shifted to a hypothetical case study involving two companies: one that has public, syndicated debt and another with private debt. They underscored the difficulty of being part of a public deal compared with the relative ease of a private, club deal. It was also noted that while the pricing of private deals is strong, owners of private debt typically own it for a relatively long period (e.g., five-to-six years), which is not usually the case with syndicated debt. Thus, credit investors must be aware of the relative value of their potential investments. Upon being asked by Felicia how to decide whether to double down to protect an already-existing investment or seek out and look for something new, it was noted that it is extremely difficult to find someone new to step into a broken capital structure, so using one’s balance sheet to protect oneself should be an option that is taken into consideration in such a scenario. A recent out-of-court deal was also discussed in which private debt involving five lenders was converted to equity; this illustrated the importance of investors believing in a company’s business plan. It was concluded by explaining that in order to decide if something is worthwhile, their team typically aims to be on the steering committee and hold a significant portion of the debt.
    4. Next, Fred asked about what decision trees look like when an investor is part of a company’s capital stack. Panelists responded that as most of their clients are involved with private equity-style capital, they tend to take a multiyear view. It was also discussed that one strategy is buying debt when one believes a sector or company is undervalued but one has a positive opinion of the company’s management. Under such circumstances, it was noted, one might buy debt at well below par and exit at par. They explained, however, that one must also be aware that they may end up owning the company if things don’t go as planned.
    5. The conversation then turned toward covenants. Felicia pointed out that the trend 15 years ago was toward covenant-lite deals, yet it seems the canary in the coal mine simply and suddenly disappeared, as covenants had already vanished by the time people got to the table to have a discussion. She asked the panelists to discuss how to evaluate an investment under such circumstances. Panelists agreed covenants truly do not exist anymore, and one added that there is not usually a default because of covenants. It was then discussed the various ways that one’s position in the capital stack impacts one’s decision-making process.
    6. Finally, the panelists responded to a question from Felicia as to what red flags to look out for in 2022. A panelist reiterated that the primary consideration in making any investment should be one’s belief in the business and whether one can see the other side of whatever issue is causing distress; they added that if one is not involved in a situation and it is looking like a dumpster fire, they will not get involved. One panelist responded that one should exercise caution if one is “not big enough to be in the room,” and another panelist discussed keeping an eye out for fraudulent transfer liability, especially if it is possible a company might file for bankruptcy in less than two years.
    Authors
    More insights

  • Value Investing Forum 2022: Maximizing Value for Stakeholders

    Value Investing Forum 2022: Maximizing Value for Stakeholders

    ARTICLE

    Value Investing Forum 2022: Maximizing Value for Stakeholders

    May 24, 2022

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In this session, Stephanie McCann, Partner and Co-Head of McDermott’s Finance Practice Group, and Frank Steinherr, Partner and Co-Head of McDermott’s Private Equity Practice Group, hosted a discussion that explored strategies for value creation for equity and debt investors. Session panelists included:

    • Alex Greeley, Partner, Linden Capital Partners
    • Ilya Koffman, Managing Partner, Turnspire Capital Partners
    • Dan Lee, Partner, Comvest Partners
    • Seth Pearson, Managing Director, Private Equity, York Capital Management
    In depth

    Below are key takeaways from the discussion:

    1. During a discussion about the impact of rising interest rates, inflation and geopolitical uncertainty affecting the current “seller’s” market in M&A, it was said non-economic terms may shift towards buyers; however, they also said they expect pricing and EBITDA multiples to remain seller-friendly given the unprecedented amount of capital competing for a finite number of potential deals. Some panelists agreed with that perspective and indicated that they were surprised that markets had not yet corrected more. It was added that they expect recessionary concerns to be built into the underwriting process for new financings going forward to ensure new credits can withstand a potential recession.
    2. Panelists said sponsors must bring subject-matter expertise to drive value creation in today’s competitive market. They said that such expertise is often supplied through the connections and relationships a sponsor can provide with industry experts and operational advisors to provide improvements around the margins and increase efficiency in existing operations.
    3. During a discussion about whether lender co-investment helps to align the interests of sponsors and lenders in terms of value maximization, a panelist said they don’t believe such co-investments make a meaningful difference because the small return on the equity co-investment in relation to the size of the facility is not enough for lenders to change their view on a particular business. In their view, value maximization is a byproduct of transparency between sponsors and lenders with respect to the health of a particular business. They added that the market is trending towards transparency and away from the old-school view that lenders should receive only the information they are contractually obligated to receive. There was agreement that transparency is critical in today’s market and they noted that transparency should also extend to the lender in their belief in a company so that a sponsor can accurately assess the situation. They discussed the role that providers of junior capital can play in helping to drive value creation via alignment of sponsor and lender interests through products like preferred equity paper and Holdco PIK notes. It was added that junior capital can provide buyers with a turn or more additional leverage when competing to purchase assets at high valuations.
    4. One panelist noted they anticipate large companies will divest underperforming segments of current operations if the current market downturn continues, and they identified carve-out transactions as a place for buyers to drive value creation. In their view, sponsors that can identify the root causes of underperforming businesses will have an opportunity for high returns on carve-outs.
    Authors

    Stephanie S. McCann

    Partner

    Chicago

    Frank P. Steinherr

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • Rock Health: Is Digital Health In a Bubble?

    Rock Health: Is Digital Health In a Bubble?

    ARTICLE

    Rock Health: Is Digital Health In a Bubble?

    May 19, 2022

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Learn about the state of digital health and health tech with a data-driven overview of the industry from Rock Health.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • SEC Proposes Rules to Increase SPAC Disclosure Requirements to More Closely Align with Traditional IPO Requirements

    SEC Proposes Rules to Increase SPAC Disclosure Requirements to More Closely Align with Traditional IPO Requirements

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    SEC Proposes Rules to Increase SPAC Disclosure Requirements to More Closely Align with Traditional IPO Requirements

    May 18, 2022

    Read time: 14 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) has proposed new rules and amendments that would enhance disclosure requirements and investor protections in initial public offerings (“IPOs”) by special purpose acquisition companies (“SPACs”) and in business combination transactions involving shell companies, such as SPACs (“de-SPACs”).[1]

    Overall, the proposed rules aim to better align the regulatory treatment of SPAC transactions with that of traditional IPOs in light of the SEC’s view that the method in which a company chooses to go public should not affect investor protections.[2] Such increased scrutiny may expose many of the entities involved in the SPAC process to increased liability due to increased disclosure requirements with respect to (1) sponsors, (2) conflicts of interest, (3) dilution and (4) the fairness of these business combination transactions.

    The proposal also includes a new safe harbor provision that exempts SPACs that satisfy certain conditions from being considered investment companies under the Investment Company Act of 1940 (“1940 Act”), including a new fixed timeline for de-SPAC transactions.

    This Alert highlights key aspects of the proposed SEC rules for SPAC participants to be aware of in this potentially evolving landscape.

    New Specialized Disclosure Requirements

    The four key specialized disclosure requirements applicable to SPACs focus on:

    1. Sponsors: The proposed rules would require additional disclosures about the sponsor, its affiliates and any promoters of the SPAC in registration statements and schedules filed in connection with SPAC registered offerings and de-SPAC transactions, including disclosure regarding the experience and material roles played by, as well as a description of any material agreements between, each party to the de-SPAC transaction; structure charts showing the relationship between the SPAC and its sponsors, as well as details regarding control persons of the sponsor; and information regarding compensation paid to the sponsor and promoters of the de-SPAC transaction.[3]
    2. Conflicts of Interest: Within a SPAC structure, there can be a number of conflicts of interest between the sponsor and public investors that could influence the actions of the SPAC, most importantly, conflicts that may influence whether a business combination transaction is recommended to shareholders. The proposed rules (i) set forth additional disclosure requirements relating to conflicts of interest experienced by SPAC sponsors or their affiliates, (ii) require disclosure of any actual or potential material conflicts of interest between (x) the sponsor or its affiliates or the SPAC’s officers, directors or promoters and (y) unaffiliated security holders[4] and (iii) would require disclosure regarding the fiduciary duties each officer and director of a SPAC owes to other companies.[5]
    3. Dilution: The proposed rules would require additional disclosure about the potential for dilution in (i) registration statements filed by SPACs, including those for IPOs, and (ii) de-SPAC transactions.[6]

    Other than in connection with a de-SPAC transaction, the proposed rules would require:

    • Tabular disclosure incorporating a range of potential redemption levels on the prospectus cover page in registered offerings by a SPAC on Form S-1 and F-1;
    • A description of material potential sources of future dilution following a SPAC’s IPO; and
    • Tabular disclosure of the amount of potential future dilution from the public offering price that will be absorbed by non-redeeming SPAC shareholders.[7]

    In de-SPAC transactions, the proposed rules would require:

    • Disclosure of each material potential source of additional dilution that non-redeeming shareholders may experience at different phases of the SPAC lifecycle by electing not to redeem their shares in connection with the de-SPAC transaction; and
    • A tabular sensitivity analysis that shows the amount of potential dilution under a range of reasonably likely redemption levels and quantifies the increasing impact of dilution on non-redeeming shareholders as redemptions increase.[8]

    4. Fairness of the Business Combination Transaction:

    Prospectus Cover Page and Summary Disclosures – The proposed rules would require that certain information be included on the prospectus cover page and prospectus summary, including (i) the anticipated timeline for, and anticipated dilutive effects of, the de-SPAC transaction and details regarding sponsor compensation[9], (ii) a summary of the process used to identify potential business combination candidates[10], (iii) a description of the fairness of the de-SPAC transaction (if applicable)[11] and (iv) details regarding the financing of the overall transaction.

    Disclosure and Procedural Requirements in De-SPAC Transactions – The proposed rules would require a number of significant disclosures, including:

    • Background, material terms and effects of the SPAC transaction, including (i) a summary of the background of the transaction and any relevant negotiations, (ii) a description of any related financing transactions, (iii) the reasons for engaging in the particular de-SPAC transaction and (iv) a description of any material differences in the target company’s shareholders’ rights as a result of the transaction.[12]
    • A statement as to whether a SPAC reasonably believes that the de-SPAC transaction and any related financing transaction are fair or unfair to the SPAC’s unaffiliated security holders, as well as the basis for the statement and whether any director voted against or abstained from voting on the transaction or any related financing.[13]
    • A detailed discussion of the material factors upon which a reasonable belief regarding the fairness of a de-SPAC transaction and any related financing is based on and the weight assigned to each factor.[14]
    • Disclosure on whether the de-SPAC transaction sought, or was approved by, a majority vote of either unaffiliated shareholders or directors of the SPAC who are not employees of the SPAC, as well as whether such SPAC directors retained any unaffiliated representatives to assist with negotiating or assessing the fairness of the de-SPAC transaction.
    • Disclosure as to whether or not the SPAC or its sponsor has received any report, opinion or appraisal obtained from an outside party[15] relating to the consideration to be offered to security holders or the fairness of the de-SPAC transaction or any related financing transaction to the SPAC, the sponsor or unaffiliated security holders.[16]
    • Disclosure of, among other things, (i) the identity and qualifications of any such outside party, (ii) the material relationships, if any, between such outside party and the SPAC, its sponsor or their affiliates and (iii) whether compensation paid to or valuation of the target company were considered.[17] These proposed rules would also dictate the format for disclosures reporting the negotiation, opinion or appraisal reached by such parties.
    • A Schedule TO filed in connection with a de-SPAC transaction should contain substantially the same information about a target private operating company that is required under the proxy rules that a SPAC must comply with the procedural requirements of the tender offer rules when conducting the transaction for which the Schedule TO is filed.[18]

    Aligning De-SPAC Transactions with IPOs

    Given the SEC’s belief that a private company’s method of becoming a public company should not negatively impact investor protections, the proposed rules and amendments are meant to provide investors with similar disclosures and protections to those present in a typical IPO. The proposed new rules and amendments would:[19]

    • More closely align the non-financial statement disclosure requirements with respect to the private operating company in disclosure documents for a de-SPAC transaction with the disclosure required in a Form S-1 or F-1 for an IPO;
    • Require a minimum dissemination period for disclosure documents in de-SPAC transactions;[20]
    • Treat the private operating company as a co-registrant of the Form S-4 or Form F-4 for a de-SPAC transaction when a SPAC is filing the registration statement;[21]
    • Require a re-determination of smaller reporting company status within 4 days after the consummation of a de-SPAC transaction;[22]
    • Amend the definition of “blank check company” for purposes of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995, such that the safe harbor for forward-looking information would not apply to projections in filings by SPACs and certain other blank check companies that are not penny stock issuers; and
    • Provide that underwriters who participate in a SPAC IPO or related financing[23] are deemed to be engaged in the distribution of the securities of the surviving public entity in a subsequent de-SPAC transaction, meaning they are deemed underwriters.[24]

    In an effort to also provide reporting shell company shareholders with more consistent protections regardless of transaction structure, the proposed rules would deem any business combination of a reporting shell company involving another entity that is not a shell company to involve a sale of securities to the reporting shell company’s shareholders.

    Enhanced Projections Disclosure

    The SEC’s proposal sets forth the SEC’s concerns that projected financial information commonly used in de-SPAC transactions does not have a reasonable basis, is displayed more prominently than historical data and/or uses non-GAAP measures without clear explanations. The proposed amendment requires that such projections be clearly distinguished from projected measures based on historical financial results, and requires that any projections based on non-GAAP financial measures include clear explanations of such measures and why the most closely analogous GAAP measure was not used.[25]

    The proposed rules would require a registrant in de-SPAC transactions to provide disclosures discussing, among other things, (i) the purpose for any projections disclosed and the identity of the party that prepared them, (ii) all material bases for such projections and (iii) whether such projections still accurately reflect the views of the board and management as of the filing date.[26]

    Proposed Safe Harbor under the Investment Company Act

    In order to assist SPACs in identifying when they may be subject to investment company regulation, the proposed rule provides a safe harbor from the definition of “investment company” under Section 3(a)(1)(A) of the 1940 Act for SPACs that meet certain conditions, including:[27]

    • Nature and Management of SPAC Assets. The SPAC’s assets must consist solely of government securities, government money market funds and cash items prior to the completion of the de-SPAC transaction.[28] Further, such assets may not at any time be acquired or disposed of for the primary purpose of recognizing gains or decreasing losses resulting from market value changes.[29]
    • SPAC Activities. The SPAC must seek to complete a single de-SPAC transaction as a result of which the surviving public entity (i) will primarily be engaged in the business of the target company, which is not that of an investment company and (ii) would have at least one class of securities listed for trading on a national securities exchange.[30] The SPAC is only able to engage in one de-SPAC transaction but such transaction may involve the combination of multiple target companies if the SPAC treats them for all purposes as part of a single de-SPAC transaction.[31] The SPAC must be primarily engaged (i) in the business of seeking to complete a de-SPAC transaction in the manner and within the time frame set forth in the rule and (ii) in a business other than that of investing, reinvesting or trading in securities.[32] Such engagement must be evidenced by the SPAC’s board of directors adopting an appropriate resolution that is contemporaneously recorded in its minute books.[33]
    • Duration. The SPAC would be required to file a report on Form 8-K announcing that it has entered into an agreement with the target company (or companies) to engage in a de-SPAC transaction no later than 18 months after the effective date of the SPAC’s registration statement for its IPO and then complete the de-SPAC transaction no later than 24 months after the effective date of its registration statement for its IPO.[34] Any assets that are not used in connection with the de-SPAC transaction would need to be distributed in cash to investors as soon as reasonably practicable following the completion of the de-SPAC transaction.[35] If the SPAC failed to meet either the 18- or 24-month deadline, the SPAC would be required to distribute the SPAC’s assets in cash to investors.[36]

    What This Might Mean

    The proposed rules in many respects represent a significant deviation from the SEC’s historical treatment of and stance towards SPACs. Among other things, many of the new disclosure-related rules, which include adjustments to address the use of projections and forward-looking statements in connection with de-SPAC transactions, mirror the enhanced disclosure requirements the SEC has typically used in connection with going-private transactions, where the SEC believes similar conflicts exist. In addition, if adopted, several of the rule changes will likely have a material impact on both de-SPAC transactions and the SPAC market generally, including:

    • The shift in underwriter liability in connection with de-SPAC transactions will likely dampen the market for new SPAC IPOs, at least in the near term, while potential underwriters evaluate the relative risk they may face from the shift in liability to the de-SPAC portion of the SPAC lifecycle.
    • The proposed 1940 Act “safe harbor” will likely create a de facto timeline for announcement and completion of de-SPAC transactions moving forward. While SPACs could potentially deviate from the time frames set forth in the proposed exemptive rule, the perceived risk of doing so may mean that most future SPACs follow the requirements of the safe harbor. Accordingly, some SPACs that may have sought extensions from shareholders in order to complete pending de-SPAC transactions may instead opt to liquidate in lieu of completing a business combination.
    • The increased transparency regarding sponsor structures and potential conflicts – including with third-party investors – may discourage the use of some of the more creative structures SPACs have utilized recently to secure successful de-SPAC transactions. As a result, the new rules may lead to great uncertainty in general regarding the success of proposed de-SPAC transactions.
    • There is significant uncertainty regarding the applicability of the proposed rules to existing SPACs that have not yet completed de-SPAC transactions. In particular, SPACs that completed IPOs prior to the adoption of any proposed rules could nonetheless be subject to applicability of the more strict requirements at the time they announce and attempt to complete de-SPAC transactions.

    Comments on these proposed rules should be received by May 31, 2022 or within 30 days after the date of publication on the Federal Register, whichever is later.

    Authored by Charles J. Clark, Eleazer Klein, Gayle R. Klein, Shaina L. Maldonado and David M. Rothenberg.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] See Securities and Exchange Commission, Proposed Rules, Special Purpose Acquisition Companies, Shell Companies, and Projections, Release No. 33-11048 (March 30, 2022), available at https://www.sec.gov/rules/proposed/2022/33-11048.pdf.

    [2] See id. at 66.

    [3] See id. at 29.

    [4] See id. at 33.

    [5] See id. at 34.

    [6] See id. at 36.

    [7] See id. at 36-37.

    [8] See id. at 39.

    [9] See id. at 41-42.

    [10] See id. at 43-44.

    [11] See id. at 42.

    [12] See id. at 46-47.

    [13] See id. at 52-53.

    [14] See id. at 53.

    [15] See id. at 57 (Proposed Item 1607(c) would require all such reports, opinions or appraisals to be filed as exhibits to Form S-4, Form F-4, and Schedule TO for the de-SPAC transaction or included in the Schedule 14A or 14C for the transaction, as applicable).

    [16] See id. at 55.

    [17] See id. at 56-57.

    [18] See id. at 58.

    [19] See id. at 66.

    [20] See id. at 71. (The SEC proposes that the prospectuses and proxy and information statements filed in connection with de-SPAC transactions be distributed to shareholders at least 20 days in advance of a shareholder meeting or the earliest date of action by consent, or maximum period for disseminating such disclosure documents permitted under the applicable laws of the SPAC’s jurisdiction of incorporation or organization if such period is less than 20 calendar days).

    [21] See id. at 76-77. (This requirement would make the additional signatories to the form, including the principal executive officer, principal financial officer, controller/principal account officer and a majority of the board of directors or persons performing similar functions of the target company, liable under Section 11 of the Securities Act of 1933 for any material misstatements or omissions in Form S-4 and Form F-4, thereby mitigating the risk of the target company’s directors and management not being held accountable for the accuracy of disclosures in the registration statement and incentivizing such additional signatories to more carefully review disclosures and conduct due diligence).

    [22] See id. at 79-80.

    [23] See id. at 97. (Activities that could constitute “participation” in the transaction include: (i) acting as a financial advisor to the SPAC; (ii) engaging in activities necessary to the de-SPAC transaction including identifying potential target companies, negotiating merger terms or finding investors for and negotiating PIPE transactions; and (iii) receipt of compensation in connection with the de-SPAC transaction).

    [24] See id. at 96.

    [25] See id. at 128-139.

    [26] See id. at 133-134.

    [27] See id. at 136.

    [28] See id. at 142.

    [29] See id. at 143.

    [30] See id. at 145, 147.

    [31] See id. at 145.

    [32] See id. at 148.

    [33] See id.

    [34] See id. at 152-153.

    [35] See id. at 152-153.

    [36] See id. at 157.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2022 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Ele Klein

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Global Legal Insights: Cartels 2022 | Belgium

    ARTICLE

    Global Legal Insights: Cartels 2022 | Belgium

    May 2022

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The GLI Cartels 2022 covers key topics including law & enforcement, investigative powers, cartel enforcement activity, decision making procedures, leniency / amnesty, settlement of cases, third party complaints, sanctions and cross-border issues.

    Hendrik Viaene, Karolien Van der Putten and Hannelore Wiame have contributed an extensive chapter relating to the law in Belgium.

    To read the Belgium chapter, please click here.

    To access the full Guide, please click here.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Belgian Competition Authority Publishes Its Notice On Enforcement Priorities For 2022

    Belgian Competition Authority Publishes Its Notice On Enforcement Priorities For 2022

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Belgian Competition Authority Publishes Its Notice On Enforcement Priorities For 2022

    May 17, 2022

    Read time: 9 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On May 16, 2022, the Belgian Competition Authority (BCA) published its long-awaited notice on enforcement priorities for 2022 (Notice).

    The BCA explains that, with a view to making the best use of its resources, it will focus its interventions on matters where the expected positive effect of its actions is greatest. One of the factors that will determine its priority focus is the strategic importance of the investigation which will in turn depend on (1) the “impact” of the direct damage caused by the infringement, (2) the strategic importance of the investigation (e.g. where the matter concerns a priority sector, may create a precedent or may provide an opportunity for the BCA to clarify the law), (3) the likelihood that the investigation will yield a “useful result”, and (4) the resources required.

    Unsurprisingly, the digital economy, services industry, energy sector, pharma sector and telecom sector remain high on the BCA’s agenda. The agro-food and sports sectors have now been added to that list in line with the growing competition law concerns relating to those sectors.

    In addition, the BCA has announced that it will, in the future, set up a special “merger control team”, that it will beef up its enforcement tools (surveys, e-discovery, anonymous whistleblower tools), and that there will be a further strengthening of expertise regarding the implementation of the Law on economic dependency.

    Lastly, the Notice refers to the BCA’s desire to tackle new challenges, such as competition in labour markets which follows a trend in other EU countries as well as the US (see, e.g., here and here for a summary of the case brought against DaVita and its former senior executive that was successfully defended by McDermott) and the application of the competition policy in the context of a green and circular economy in Belgium.

    In depth

    Introduction

    The Notice starts off by referring to the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, rising energy prices and the Russian invasion of Ukraine. The BCA remarks that the latter has led to an even further increase of energy prices given the fact that Russia is an important energy supplier, and that the invasion has led to a brake being put on the supply of raw materials and intermediate goods as well as on the export activities of Belgian companies to both countries. The Notice highlights that these events may influence certain sectors significantly, such as the food, construction and industrial sectors that depend heavily on the international supply of raw materials (including certain metals and minerals). The BCA explains that a “healthy and fair market” provides for the best protection of general economic prosperity both in the sectors experiencing serious difficulties as well as in the sectors in which new opportunities have arisen as a result of this new economic reality.

    Strategic Priorities for 2022

    Before setting out its “strategic priorities”, the BCA refers to, and summarises, the recent changes made to the Belgian Code of Economic Law (CEL) and the Belgian Criminal Code in March 2022 (for further information on these changes, see our article here).

      • Recruitment, specialisation & collaboration

    The 20 percent increase in the BCA’s budget will be used to recruit personnel and to invest in (1) new IT infrastructure and support, (2) knowledge management and internal processes and more specifically the available enforcement instruments (such as surveys, e-discovery, anonymous whistleblower tools, etc).

    The BCA will, in the future, set up a special “merger control team” which will, according to the BCA, lead to the more efficient processing of merger notifications and to increased capacity to deal with investigations into anticompetitive practices (on the basis of ex officio investigations). The Notice also explains that there will be further strengthening of the expertise regarding the implementation of the Law on economic dependency (enshrined in the CEL).

    The BCA’s increased budget will also allow the BCA to be more active in relation to its informal and strategic policy – and in particular it will lead to an increase / strengthening of already existing collaborations with ECN working groups and national and international regulators. As an example of collaborations with national regulators, the BCA refers to the Price Observatory and the National Bank of Belgium.

      • Sectors Impacted by the COVID-19 crisis

    Another strategic priority for the BCA will be the sectors positively or negatively impacted by the COVID-19 crisis, in particular where impact is reinforced by the increased digitalisation of society. The BCA makes explicit reference to:

    – Distribution markets
    – The agri-food value chain
    – Financial services
    – Healthcare (including distribution of medicines, vaccines and medical equipment)

      • Focus on the application of the competition policy in the pursuit of a green and circular economy in Belgium

    The BCA explains that competition is the motor of innovation which, in turn, is necessary to develop new, green technologies. As per the Notice, healthy competition encourages companies to use scarce raw materials and resources efficiently and ensures that new innovative products are offered to consumers at affordable prices. A healthy, well-functioning competition policy is therefore an important factor in promoting innovation and technological development to contribute to the further greening of the Belgian economy. In line with initiatives from other Member States, the BCA will also take additional steps in developing its position on, inter alia, how competition rules correspond with sustainable policy measures and how it can further support that policy, in particular in relation to the application of competition law to sustainability agreements. To this end, the BCA will also provide additional informal advice and interact with various stakeholders as part of its advocacy policy.

      • Competition in labour markets

    Thanks to an increase in its budget, the BCA now also has more resources to “tackle new challenges”, such as competition in labour markets. This follows a trend seen in other EU countries in the last few years. For example, in Hungary, France and Portugal the national competition law authorities have investigated so-called wage-fixing and/or “no poach” agreements (i.e. where companies agree not to hire each other’s employees).

    The European Commission has not yet taken any enforcement action against no-poach agreements. However, in a speech on October 22, 2021, EU Competition Commissioner Margrethe Vestager referred to the harm caused “when companies collude to fix the wages they pay; or when they use so-called “no-poach” agreements as an indirect way to keep wages down, restricting talent from moving where it serves the economy best”, implying that the European Commission will not shy away from enforcement action in this area.

    No-poach agreements have already been a hot topic in the US for several years. One of the latest developments is the antitrust case brought against DaVita and its former senior executive, which constituted the first criminal “no poach” trial ever prosecuted by the DOJ. McDermott successfully represented DaVita and its former senior executive in this case (for more information, see here and here).

    Priority Sectors for 2022

    The BCA has identified the following sectors as being a “priority” for 2022:

      • Services to businesses and consumers – and especially where the sector is regulated (e.g. financial services, accounting, quality control). This is in line with the BCA’s 2021 priorities.
      • The pharma sector – in line with other EU countries’ enforcement focus in recent years as well as the BCA’s own 2021 priorities. In the Notice, the BCA refers to its most recent enforcement actions in the sector and stresses that it will “pay attention” to all actors in the value chain: prices set by laboratories, the competition between wholesalers and distributors, the innovation and competitive dynamics at the level of the pharmacies, etc
      • The digitalisation of the economy – also in line with the BCA’s 2021 priorities and where the BCA will be “especially alert” to possible abuses of a dominant position, abuses of economic dependency and for competition law infringements resulting from the digital transformation in several sectors (in particular in the service industry, including services to businesses and government agencies). Sectors characterized by further digitization are, according to the BCA, media and communication, with new developments on both the content and advertising side.
      • The agro-food sector – new to the list. The BCA refers to the fact that the Belgian food chain has already demonstrated, at various levels, its vulnerability in maintaining a healthy competitive environment. In particular, the BCA refers to an increasing trend for food price inflation which is higher than in any of the neighboring countries.The BCA will focus on healthy market forces throughout the food chain, and will in particular focus on pricing mechanisms, territorial supply restrictions as well as competitive dynamics in the agricultural sector.
      • The energy sector – also in line with the BCA’s 2021 priorities. In relation to the energy sector, the BCA refers again to the rising energy prices (in particular for electricity and gas) caused by the economic recovery after the COVID-19 crisis in combination with declining gas reserves and an increase in the price of CO2 rights, further exacerbated by consequences of the Russian invasion of Ukraine. Given the importance of energy for business, the BCA explains that it will ensure that, especially in the current environment of partial phasing out of nuclear energy, gas and electricity suppliers do not take advantage of the tense situation to pursue anti-competitive policies. To this end, the BCA is in close contact with the CREG, the federal energy regulator in Belgium, as well as with the regional regulators. “Necessary attention” is required to prevent energy companies from making exceptional profits during periods of price spikes (so-called “windfall profits”).

    The sports sector – new to the list. The BCA highlights the fact that the sports sector has become an important economic sector and refers to its previous enforcement practice in the industry. Going forward, the BCA will, based on expertise already acquired, pay greater attention to enforcement of competition rules in the sports sector, focusing on fair access to sport leagues, the organisation of sports competitions and events, no poaching agreements, and the rise of e-sports and (online) sports betting.

    • The telecom sector – a “classic” priority for the BCA. In this year’s Notice, the BCA explains that consumers are increasingly opting for bundled offers and are less likely to change operators. Other focus points for the BCA are (1) the further rollout of the 5G network, (2) further consolidations in the telecom market (which will be subjected to close scrutiny), (3) the increased interactions and spillover effect between the digital sector and the telecom sector, with attention also paid to any competitive effects of vertical and conglomerate mergers connecting the two sectors.
    Authors
    More insights

  • SEC Proposal to Redefine the Definition of ‘Dealer’ Would Cover Certain Private Funds and Private Fund Advisers

    SEC Proposal to Redefine the Definition of ‘Dealer’ Would Cover Certain Private Funds and Private Fund Advisers

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT / US POLICY

    SEC Proposal to Redefine the Definition of ‘Dealer’ Would Cover Certain Private Funds and Private Fund Advisers

    May 16, 2022

    Read time: 12 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In the first quarter of 2022, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) proposed a slew of new rules and rule amendments directed at private fund managers and their investment activities. One proposal that has garnered less attention is directed at proprietary trading firms but would cover certain private funds and private fund advisers.

    Proposed Exchange Act Rule 3a5-4 (“Rule 3a5-4”) would require persons “engage[d] in a routine pattern of buying and selling securities for their own account that has the effect of providing liquidity” to register as a dealer.

    Proposed Exchange Act Rule 3a44-2 (“Rule 3a44-2,” and together with Rule 3a5-4, the “Proposed Rules”), would require any person who, in four of the last six calendar months, bought or sold over $25 billion in government securities to register as a government securities dealer.[1]

    The Proposed Rules exempt registered investment companies but not private funds or registered investment advisers; instead, the Proposing Release expressly anticipates that certain advisers and private funds would have to register as dealers if the Proposed Rules are adopted. In its present form, the Proposed Rules are written broadly and would capture advisers and their funds if they engage in day trading, arbitrage strategies or otherwise regularly buy and sell roughly equivalent quantities of the same or “substantially similar” securities during a day. The Proposed Rules would require certain private funds to register as dealers if their trading activity, viewed on a legal-entity basis, constitutes Dealer Activity (defined below) and would also require certain private fund advisers to register if their trading, viewed either on a legal entity-basis or when aggregated with certain trading activity in client accounts, constitutes Dealer Activity.

    Comments on the Proposed Rules should be submitted on or before May 27, 2022. Schulte Roth & Zabel is gathering feedback from our clients about the impact of the SEC’s proposed rules as we prepare a comment letter.

    Proposed Rule 3a5-4

    Proposed Rule 3a5-4 would require, subject to limited exceptions, any person who “engages in a routine pattern of buying and selling securities for their own account that has the effect of providing liquidity” to register as a dealer.

    Proposed Rule 3a5-4 identifies certain activities that would be considered to have the effect of providing liquidity to other market participants, including:

    1. routinely making roughly comparable purchases and sales of the same or substantially similar securities (or government securities) in one day;
    2. routinely expressing trading interests that are at or near the best available prices on both sides of the market; or
    3. earning revenue primarily from capturing bid-ask spreads or from capturing incentives offered by trading venues to liquidity-supplying trading interests (collectively, “Dealer Activity”).[2]

    “Routine” Activity

    The Proposing Release explains that while “routinely” means more than occasionally, it does not need to be continuous. With respect to “expressing trading interests,” the “routinely” standard would apply to the frequency with which a person expresses two-sided trading activity both intraday and over time. Accordingly, individuals or entities that utilize strategies that express two-sided trading interest continuously throughout a trading day or that routinely express such interest during discrete timespans (e.g., into the closing auction) may need to register as dealers under the Proposed Rules.

    “Substantially Similar” Securities

    For purposes of the Proposed Rules, the requirement that purchases and sales be of the same or “substantially similar” securities is intended to capture instances where the purchase (sale) of a security is designed to offset the risk undertaken through the sale (purchase) of another security.[3] Whether securities constitute ‘‘substantially similar’’ securities would require a facts and circumstances analysis, and would consider factors such as whether (1) the fair market value of each security primarily reflects the performance of a single firm or enterprise or the same economic factor or factors, such as interest rates and (2) changes in the fair market value of one security are reasonably expected to approximate, directly or inversely, changes in, or a fraction or a multiple of, the fair market value of the second security.[4] Examples of “substantially similar” securities includes buying an exchange traded fund (“ETF”) and selling the underlying securities that make up the ETF, buying a European call option on a stock and selling a European put option on the same stock with the same strike and maturity or buying an OTC call option on a stock and selling a listed option on the same stock with the same strike and maturity.[5] However, buying stock in one company (e.g., Ford) and selling stock in another company in the same industry (e.g., Chrysler) would not constitute “substantially similar” securities. Nor would buying stock and selling bonds issued by the same company.[6]

    “Roughly Comparable” Purchases and Sales

    Under the Proposing Release, whether a person makes “roughly comparable” purchases and sales is determined through an analysis of the net imbalance of the dollar volume, number of shares or risk profile of the same or similar securities on a given day. While the Proposed Rules do not contain a quantitative threshold, the Proposing Release suggests that a buy/sell imbalance of 20 percent or less may qualify as dealer activity and trigger a registration obligation.

    Earning Revenue by Capturing Bid-Ask Spreads or Trading Venue Incentives

    Proposed Rule 3a5-4 would define any trading strategy that primarily generates revenue from capturing spreads, rebates or incentives as dealer activity. The Proposing Release distinguishes routine trading from dealer activity by defining the latter as being primarily directed at earning compensation from spreads and incentives rather than compensation that is “attributable to changes in the value of the security traded.” While Proposed Rule 3a5-4 does not provide a bright-line test, the Proposing Release notes that a person who derives the majority of revenue from capturing spreads, rebates or incentives would likely be in a regular business of buying and selling securities for his or her own account.

    “Dealer Activity” by Private Funds

    Dealer registration is triggered when a person is in the business of buying and selling securities for such person’s “own account.” This would require any private fund to register as a dealer if its trading activity, viewed on a legal-entity basis, constitutes Dealer Activity. The Commission justifies the inclusion of private funds as a means to provide greater oversight of their trading activities as part of the Commission’s overall focus on market functionality.[7]

    The SEC has requested comment on the inclusion of private funds in the Proposed Rules, including whether private funds could comply with dealer requirements and also whether the Proposed Rules would cause private funds to cease or reduce investment strategies that constitute Dealer Activity and the potential impact on markets.[8]

    Additional Trading Activity by RIAs and their Funds Captured by Aggregation Requirements

    For registered investment advisers, the Proposed Rules adopt a broad definition of trading for one’s “own account,” which captures proprietary trading activity as well as certain fund trading activity based on an adviser’s right to control or sell the voting securities of the private fund, an adviser’s capital contributions to or rights to amounts on dissolution of the private fund or the parallel structure of the funds or accounts. Where the adviser’s and/or the private funds’ trading activity falls under the definition of “own account” and the private fund is not otherwise required to register based on its trading activity viewed on a legal-entity basis, the Proposing Release details that the relevant consideration is whether the aggregated trading activity constitutes Dealer Activity.

    Definition of “Control” for Purposes of Evaluating Trading for One’s “Own Account”

    In addition to capturing advisers that engage in Dealer Activity in their proprietary trading accounts, the definition of “own account” could also capture Dealer Activity by accounts managed by the adviser.[9]

    While not expressly defined in the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended (“Exchange Act”), the term “own account” has historically been viewed as distinguishing between principal and agency activities (with certain principal securities activities requiring dealer registration, and certain agency securities activities requiring registration as a “broker”). The Proposed Rules would, for the first time, define the term “own account” as any account that, subject to certain exclusions, is (i) held in the name of that person or (ii) held in the name of a person over whom that person exercises control or with whom that person is under common control. The Proposed Rules would incorporate the definition of “control” from Exchange Act Rule 13h-1.[10]

    Under the Proposed Rules, an adviser would be deemed to control a private fund if it (i) controls the fund through a capital contribution of 25 percent or more, (ii) has the right to receive 25 percent or more of fund assets upon dissolution, (iii) directly or indirectly has the right to control or vote 25 percent or more of the voting shares of the fund or (iv) has the power to sell or direct the sale of 25 percent or more of the voting securities of the fund.

    The proposed definitions of “own account” and “control” raise a number of questions regarding the potential impact for registered investment advisers, including whether commonplace private fund structures would be viewed as being under the “control” of the adviser and therefore treated as the adviser’s “own account.”

    Traditionally, “control” under Rule 13h has been interpreted broadly such that most advisers are deemed to control the private funds they manage.

    Parallel Fund Structure

    Under the Proposed Rules, accounts generally would not be deemed to be in an adviser’s “own account” simply because they are managed by the same adviser. The Proposed Rules, however, include an exception for accounts that constitute a “parallel account structure” – “a structure in which one or more private funds (each a ‘parallel fund’), accounts or other pools of assets (each a ‘parallel managed account’) managed by the same investment adviser pursue substantially the same investment objective and strategy and invest side by side in substantially the same positions as another parallel fund or parallel managed account.” Under certain circumstances, the trading activities of accounts in a parallel account structure would need to be aggregated. As it is not uncommon for an adviser to have multiple funds that pursue the same strategy, this could result in a situation where the adviser is not required to aggregate with the private funds under its common control and management but such private funds are required to aggregate with each other.

    The SEC has requested comment on the aggregation issues and how the Proposed Rules might otherwise impact advisers, private funds and other market participants based on the different corporate structures employed by such entities.

    Proposed Rule 3a44-2

    Proposed Rule 3a44-2 would require any person who, in four of the last six calendar months, engaged in buying and selling more than $25 billion of trading volume in government securities to register as a government securities dealer. Notably, this quantitative standard would only apply to market participants trading in government securities (e.g., Treasuries), and would not apply to persons who limit their trading to NMS securities or other non-government securities.

    Enforcement Implications for Unregistered Dealer Activity

    Even where an adviser is not deemed to control an account over which it exercises discretion, the adviser may be subject to enforcement action where it causes the client account to engage in unregistered dealer activity.

    Overview of “Dealer” Registration

    Dealers are subject to a number of rules and requirements not currently applicable to registered investment advisers, private funds or principal trading firms. While we anticipate that certain market participants will adjust or curtail their fund structures and/or trading activities in order to avoid triggering dealer registration requirements, we nevertheless highlight certain considerations relating to dealer registration.

    SRO Membership

    A dealer must register with one or more self-regulatory organizations (“SROs”), and most dealers are required to become members of FINRA. SRO members are subject to the relevant SRO’s rules, including a number of technical rule requirements that are not applicable to other market participants (e.g., consolidated audit trail and trade reporting obligations), and periodic examinations by the SRO.

    New Issues (IPO) Restrictions

    FINRA Rules 5130 and 5131 (the “new issues” rules) restrict certain market participants from receiving shares in initial public offerings (“IPOs”), including broker-dealers, associated persons of a broker-dealer and certain persons owning a broker-dealer. If a private fund is registered as a dealer, the fund would be restricted from receiving shares in an IPO and, relatedly, its owners (e.g., its limited partners) might similarly become restricted.

    Capital Withdrawals

    Dealers are subject to the net capital requirements of Exchange Act Rule 15c3-1 (the “Net Capital Rule”). Generally, the Net Capital Rule requires that dealers maintain more than a dollar of highly liquid assets for each dollar of liabilities. The Net Capital Rule highly discourages withdrawals of capital within one year of contribution, providing, generally, that any capital withdrawn within one year of contribution should never have been considered part of a firm’s equity. Accordingly, assuming an adviser elected to register a private fund (or other vehicle) as a dealer, any investor in such fund or vehicle would likely be subject to a mandatory one-year lockup on each contribution.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact Marc E. Elovitz, Julian Rainero, Craig S. Warkol, Kelly Koscuiszka, Jennifer M. Dunn, Derek N. Lacarrubba, William J. Barbera or your attorney.

    In depth
    Authors

    Marc E. Elovitz

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Kelly Koscuiszka

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    William J. Barbera

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • CFPB Obtains $10 Million Penalty Against Major Bank Using Expansive UDAAP Authority

    CFPB Obtains $10 Million Penalty Against Major Bank Using Expansive UDAAP Authority

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    CFPB Obtains $10 Million Penalty Against Major Bank Using Expansive UDAAP Authority

    May 11, 2022

    Read time: 11 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (“CFPB” or the “Bureau”) reached a settlement with Bank of America, N.A. (the “bank”), including a penalty of $10 million.[1] This settlement provides a powerful example of the flexibility of the Bureau’s authority to pursue unfair, deceptive or abusive acts and practices (“UDAAPs”). In fact, the entire settlement relates exclusively to UDAAPs, and arises out of alleged conduct that violates state laws rather than other federal consumer financial statutes or regulations.

    The Bank of America Settlement

    Under a process called garnishment, a creditor can recover the amounts a consumer owes from a third party who holds the consumer’s assets, such as in the consumer’s account at a depository institution. There are several limitations on which assets are subject to garnishment under state law, which vary from state to state, and federal law protects federal benefits from garnishment.

    The Bureau found fault with several aspects of the bank’s response to out-of-state garnishment orders, meaning orders issued in a state other than the state where the consumer lived. In the settlement, the Bureau asserts that garnishments against consumers should be governed by the law of their state of residence. Instead, the bank applied the law of the issuing state, and, as a result, failed to apply the protections available in the state of residence but not the issuing state. A few states prohibit out-of-state garnishment entirely, and, while the bank had policies and training that correctly identified some of these states, the policies overlooked others and the bank’s employees did not consistently follow these policies in any event.

    Out of this alleged conduct, the CFPB identified five practices it concluded were unfair or deceptive:

    1. Most notably, the CFPB considered statements that the bank had made to third parties — rather than to consumers — to be an unfair practice. In the Bureau’s view, the bank should have informed the issuing court and the garnishing creditor that the consumer’s assets were held out of state.[2] When the bank “failed to disclose” this information, consumers then lost access to funds that became frozen or were delivered to creditors, in addition to overdraft, insufficient funds, account maintenance or similar fees that resulted from taking these assets from the consumer’s account, as well as attorney’s fees and court costs the bank sometimes passed onto consumers.[3]
    2. The CFPB expressed serious concern with waivers in the bank’s deposit agreement with consumers. The deposit agreement states that the consumer “directs” the bank not to contest garnishment, including from out of state, and purports to release the bank from all liability for acting on garnishment orders.[4] However, federal law prohibits banks from requiring consumers to waive certain exemption rights over federal benefits.[5] Moreover, this release prevented consumers from challenging the losses they suffered.
    3. These statements in the deposit agreement also constituted a deceptive practice that may have dissuaded consumers from taking action to defend their rights.[6]
    4. The Bureau labeled the bank’s application of the wrong state’s law an unfair practice.[7]
    5. And finally, it was a separate, deceptive practice for the bank to have “implicitly represented” to consumers that the issuing state’s law governed, because that representation likely limited consumers’ efforts to identify and assert their rights under the laws of their state of residence.[8]

    In justifying its conclusion that these practices were unfair, the Bureau explains that it is “not reasonable to expect consumers to have the necessary understanding” of their rights under state law or the procedure to assert them within a garnishment proceeding, instead placing the responsibility on the bank to protect the consumer.[9]

    Here, the bank was able to resolve this enforcement matter without admitting any of the allegations.[10] The bank agreed to a civil monetary penalty of $10 million, and committed to refund at least $592,000 in fees it imposed on consumers after it garnished their accounts.[11] The settlement sets out numerous requirements for the bank to include in its revised procedures, which will govern for the next five years.[12]

    UDAAP Enforcement on the Rise

    The CFPB has authority to initiate enforcement to stop UDAAPs in the offering or provision of any consumer financial product or service.[13] This authority has figured prominently in enforcement actions and settlements this year and is sure to be a centerpiece of CFPB enforcement to come.

    For example, the CFPB and the New York Attorney General filed an enforcement action against MoneyGram that includes allegations of “failing to timely make remittance transfers available to recipients or to timely make refunds available to senders,” which these authorities consider unfair.[14] In another settlement the Bureau reached so far this year, relating to student loan servicing, also identified no violations aside from unfair and deceptive practices.[15]

    Further, as the CFPB uses its supervisory authority to conduct exams of companies in the consumer finance industry — including companies it has not previously examined using a recently announced “dormant” authority[16] — exam staff will likely be looking to identify practices that the Bureau believes are unfair, abusive or deceptive.

    The CFPB will continue to press its UDAAP authority to put an end to practices it seeks to curb, encouraging payment processors, fintech companies, banks and other financial institutions to carefully consider impacts on consumers.

    Schulte Roth & Zabel’s lawyers are available to assist you in addressing any questions you may have regarding these developments. Please contact the Schulte Roth & Zabel lawyer with whom you usually work, or any of the following attorneys:

    Donald J. Mosher – New York (+1 212.756.2187)

    Kara A. Kuchar – New York (+1 212.756.2734)

    Doug Koff – New York (+1 212.756.2773)

    Melissa G.R. Goldstein – Washington, DC (+1 202.729.7471)

    Adam J. Barazani – New York (+1 212.756.2519)

    Jessica Romano – New York (+1 212.756.2205)

    Jessica Sklute – New York (+1 212.756.2180)

    Noah N. Gillespie – Washington, DC (+1 202.729.7483)

    Hadas A. Jacobi – New York (+1 212.756.2055)

    Steven T. Cummings – New York (+1 212.756.2251)

    Rebecca A. Raskind – New York (+1 212.756.2396)


    [1] Consent Order, In the Matter of Bank of America, N.A., No. 2022-CFPB-0002 (May 4, 2022).

    [2] Id. 30.

    [3] Id. 31, 34.

    [4] Id. 49.

    [5] Id. 24, 50.

    [6] Id. 58.

    [7] Id. 38.

    [8] Id. 46.

    [9] Id. 35, 40.

    [10] Id. 2.

    [11] Id. 69, 76.

    [12] Id. 106.

    [13] 12 U.S.C. § 5531.

    [14] See, e.g., Complaint 5, 77-82, CFPB v. MoneyGram Int’l, Inc., No. 1:22-cv-3256 (S.D.N.Y. filed April 21, 2022).

    [15] Consent Order, In the Matter of Edfinancial Services, LLC, No. 2022-CFPB-0001 (March 30, 2022).

    [16] CFPB Invokes “Dormant” Authority to Conduct Exams of Fintech Companies, SRZ Client Alert (April 27, 2022).


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2022 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Donald J. Mosher

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Douglas I. Koff

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Melissa G.R. Goldstein

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Adam J. Barazani

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • New York City’s Wage Transparency Law to Take Effect November 1, 2022

    New York City’s Wage Transparency Law to Take Effect November 1, 2022

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    New York City’s Wage Transparency Law to Take Effect November 1, 2022

    May 6, 2022

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On January 15, 2022, the New York City Council enacted Local Law 32 of 2022 (Wage Transparency Law or Law) to amend the New York City Human Rights Law (NYCHRL) to require that most employers include compensation data in their job advertisements. The Law was supposed to take effect on May 15, 2022, however, it faced criticism over a number of ambiguities, including undefined penalties. In response, on April 28, 2022, the New York City Council passed an amendment to the Wage Transparency Law. Among the biggest changes is that employers now have until November 1, 2022—more than six months—to ensure compliance with the Law’s requirements. If Mayor Eric Adams signs the Law, which he is expected to do, New York City will become the second jurisdiction in the country (the first being Colorado) to require employers to include minimum and maximum potential salary amounts for open positions in job postings.

    In depth

    WHAT THE LAW COVERS

    The Wage Transparency Law makes it an “unlawful discriminatory practice” for an employment agency, employer or any employee or agent of any employment agency or employer to advertise a job, promotion or transfer opportunity without stating the minimum and maximum hourly wage or salary compensation in a job advertisement. Employers must list the compensation that it believes in good faith at the time of the posting it would pay for the advertised job, promotion or transfer opportunity. According to the factsheet on the original Law published by the New York City Human Rights Commission (Commission), because the NYCHRL’s protections extend to many groups of workers, job postings are covered regardless of whether they are seeking full- or part-time employees, interns, domestic workers, independent contractors or any other category of worker protected by the NYCHRL. The Commission further explains that an “advertisement” is a written description of an available job, promotion or transfer opportunity that is publicized to a pool of potential applicants. Such advertisements are covered regardless of the medium in which they are disseminated. Covered listings include postings on internal bulletin boards, internet advertisements, printed flyers distributed at job fairs and newspaper advertisements.

    The Wage Transparency Law applies to all New York City employers with at least four employees. The four employees do not need to work in the same location nor do they all need to work in New York City. As long as one of the employees works in New York City, the workplace is covered.

    There are two exemptions to the Wage Transparency Law. First, job advertisements for “temporary employment at temporary help firms” are exempted. The Commission defines temporary help firms as businesses that recruit and hire their own employees and assign those employees to perform work at, or perform services for, other organizations or businesses. Second, employers are exempted from wage disclosure requirements for positions that “cannot and will not be performed, at least in part, in the city of New York.”

    One key change of the amendment was pushing the effective date of the Law to November 1, 2022. This new date gives employers nearly six additional months to bring their job advertisements into compliance.

    FILING A COMPLAINT

    Notably, under the Law as amended, only current employees may bring an action against their employer for violation of the Law. Considering the Wage Transparency Law mandates wage disclosure in job advertisements geared toward applicants and not just current employees, this provision appears to prohibit relief for unsuccessful applicants applying for noncompliant positions.

    PENALTIES

    The civil penalty for an employer’s first violation of the Wage Transparency Law is $0 if the employer can show (to the Commission’s satisfaction) that it has cured the violation within 30 days of service of the complaint. Submission of proof of a cure can be submitted electronically or in person. If proof of a cure is accepted by the Commission, it is considered “an admission of liability for all purposes.” The Wage Transparency Law does not define the meaning of “all purposes,” nor does the Law specify fines for subsequent violations.

    JOINING A NATIONWIDE MOVEMENT FOR GREATER WAGE TRANSPARENCY

    Once the Law goes into effect in November, New York City will join several states and cities that have already passed wage transparency laws in recent years. States and cities have implemented various methods to mandate wage transparency, from banning employers from asking applicants about their salary history to requiring employers to disclose the pay range for a job if an applicant asks for it during the application process (i.e., after an initial interview, only when the employee asks for it). New York City’s Wage Transparency Law, however, requires employers to list the minimum and maximum salary for all job postings, promotions or transfer opportunities.

    WHAT THIS MEANS FOR EMPLOYERS

    With the amendment, employers now have another six months to ensure their job advertisements are compliant. Given the Wage Transparency Law’s good faith requirement, employers should start preparing now by gathering documentation about each job position and determining wage ranges using existing data. If no such data exists, employers should create benchmark data to identify a wage range for each position. Employers can use the Commission’s factsheet for guidance, although they should expect the Commission to publish additional guidance before the Law takes effect.

    Authors

    Abigail M. Kagan

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights