Content Type: Article

  • Are Changes Looming Over Tax Court’s Procedure Rules?

    ARTICLE

    Are Changes Looming Over Tax Court’s Procedure Rules?

    April 13, 2018

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Andrew Roberson and Kevin Spencer wrote this bylined article summarizing important differences between certain Tax Court procedure rules and those of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. “Taxpayers and practitioners should continue to monitor when the Tax Court will issue new amendments to its rules, as they will impact the conduct of litigation in the court and parties’ litigation strategy,” the authors wrote.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • New York State and City to Mandate Anti-Sexual Harassment Training for Private Employers

    New York State and City to Mandate Anti-Sexual Harassment Training for Private Employers

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    New York State and City to Mandate Anti-Sexual Harassment Training for Private Employers

    April 12, 2018

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On April 11, 2018, the New York City Council passed a package of legislation aimed at combating sexual harassment in New York City, the Stop Sexual Harassment in NYC Act, which the mayor is expected to sign. A key provision of the act mandates that private employers in New York City conduct sexual harassment trainings. In early April 2018, the New York State Legislature passed legislation with a similar mandate for employers in New York State, which the governor signed into law on April 12.

    New York City Law Changes

    The city law provides that trainings must be conducted by employers with 15 or more employees in New York City, and that the training must:

    • Be interactive;
    • Occur at least annually (and, for new employees, within 90 days of employment);
    • Explain that sexual harassment is a form of unlawful discrimination under local, state and federal law;
    • Describe what sexual harassment is, with examples;
    • Address the internal complaint process available to employees;
    • Explain that retaliation against complainants is prohibited, and list examples of retaliation;
    • Provide information concerning bystander intervention; and
    • Address the specific responsibilities of supervisors and managers in the prevention of sexual harassment and retaliation.

    The city law also has a record-keeping requirement. In addition to the training mandate, provisions of the city law affecting private employers, include a posting requirement, an extension of the statute of limitations for filing sexual harassment complaints with the New York City Commission on Human Rights under the New York City Human Rights Law from one year to three years, and a clarification to the New York City Human Rights Law to explicitly include sexual harassment. The city law will become effective in April 2019.

    New York State Law Changes

    New York State law will require that, in consultation with the New York State Division of Human Rights, the New York State Department of Labor must develop a model sexual harassment prevention guidance document, model sexual harassment prevention policy and model sexual harassment prevention training program. After the policy and training have been developed, New York employers must either adopt the policy, or a policy that meets or exceeds the state policy’s minimum standards, and administer the model training, or develop and administer a training that meets or exceeds the state training’s minimum standards. The model policy must:

    • Explain what sexual harassment is, and include examples;
    • Include a standard complaint form;
    • Include information about state and federal sexual harassment laws and remedies;
    • Include information about employee rights;
    • Include a clear statement that sexual harassment is considered a form of employee misconduct; and
    • Prohibit retaliation.

    The model training must provide the above information in an interactive format. Regulations regarding the state law have yet to be enacted, but it is expected that they will outline the timeline for employer compliance with the law, set parameters for the length and specific subject matter of the training, and carve out any exceptions for small employers. This provision will take effect 180 days after the governor signs the bill into law.

    The state bill also amends New York State Law to prohibit the sexual harassment of non-employees, such as vendors and contractors, in the workplace, effective immediately. The state bill institutes a 21-day period for settling complainants to consider nondisclosure provisions, and a seven-day revocation period after such agreements have been signed, effective 90 days after the bill becomes law. The state bill also bans mandatory workplace arbitration of sexual harassment claims, with a carve-out for collectively bargained arbitration procedures, effective 90 days after the bill becomes law. The mandatory arbitration amendment is likely to face a challenge grounded in the Federal Arbitration Act’s preemption provision. See AT&T Mobility LLC v. Concepcion, 131 S. Ct. 1740 (2011).

    Conclusion

    New York employers will need to take steps to comply with these statutory changes. These steps will include updates to existing sexual harassment trainings and policies, or the adoption of new trainings and polices, revisions to forms of employment agreements and settlement agreements, and the development of procedures to comply with the waiting periods set forth in the nondisclosure agreement provision.

    While the state and city laws will set minimum standards, the EEOC has stated that when it comes to training, one size does not fit all. “Training is most effective when tailored to the specific workforce and workplace, and to different cohorts of employees,” such as departments, bands and offices. A commitment across all levels of an organization, starting at the top, to preventing harassment and developing an inclusive workplace, combined with effective accountability systems, are an employer’s best lines of defense against the behaviors that lead to sexual harassment claims.

    Authored by Holly H. Weiss.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or the author.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2018 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Holly H. Weiss

    Retired Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Notice 2018-28 Regarding Limitations on Interest Deductions under Amended Section 163(j)

    Notice 2018-28 Regarding Limitations on Interest Deductions under Amended Section 163(j)

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Notice 2018-28 Regarding Limitations on Interest Deductions under Amended Section 163(j)

    April 12, 2018

    Read time: 10 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Section 163(j), as recently amended, may limit a taxpayer’s interest expense deduction. Notice 2018-28, in very general terms, provides interim guidance on the application of Section 163(j).

    Importantly, the Notice confirms that (1) a taxpayer with disallowed interest expense from taxable years prior to January 1, 2018 may carry forward such interest expense to the taxpayer’s first taxable year after December 31, 2017; (2) Section 163(j) applies at the consolidated group level; (3) Section 163(j) will not impact whether or when business interest expense reduces a corporation’s earnings and profits; and (4) taxpayers cannot “double count” business interest income earned through a partnership or S Corporation.

    In depth

    On April 2, 2018, the Department of Treasury (Treasury) and the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) released Notice 2018-28 (Notice). The Notice provides very helpful guidance to taxpayers complying with new limitations on the deductibility of business interest expense under Section 163(j). Treasury and the IRS intend to issue proposed regulations under Section 163(j) and the Notice describes certain of the rules that the proposed regulations will include to provide taxpayers with interim guidance as more comprehensive guidance is developed.

    Prior to the tax legislation commonly referred to as the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (Act), Section 163(j) disallowed a deduction for disqualified interest paid or accrued by a corporation if two threshold tests were met. The first test was satisfied if the corporate taxpayer’s debt-to-equity ratio exceeded 1.5 to 1.0. The second test was satisfied if the corporate taxpayer’s net interest expense (the amount by which all interest expense paid or accrued during the taxable year exceeds the amount of interest income includible by the taxpayer in gross income for such taxable year) exceeded 50 percent of its adjusted gross income (in general, taxable income computed without regard to deductions for net interest expense, NOLs, Section 199 domestic production activities, depreciation, amortization and depletion). For this purpose, disqualified interest included interest paid or accrued to foreign related parties when no federal tax was imposed on such interest, interest paid or accrued to unrelated persons if a related party guaranteed the debt (and certain other requirements were met), and interest paid or accrued by a taxable REIT subsidiary to a REIT. Interest expense disallowed under ‘old’ Section 163(j) was treated as paid or accrued in the succeeding taxable year and could be carried forward indefinitely. Any excess limitation (the excess, if any, of 50 percent of the corporation’s adjusted taxable income over its net interest expense) could be carried forward for three years. Under ‘old’ Section 163(j), proposed regulations contained a ‘super affiliation’ rule that treated all members of an affiliated group as one taxpayer for Section 163(j) purposes without regard to whether the affiliated group filed (or could file) a consolidated return.

    As amended by the Act, Section 163(j) limits a taxpayer’s annual deduction for business interest expense to the sum of the taxpayer’s business interest income, and 30 percent of the taxpayer’s adjusted taxable income (ATI). Business interest expense means any interest paid or accrued on indebtedness allocated to a trade or business and business interest income means any interest includible in the gross income of the taxpayer which is properly allocated to a trade or business. Accordingly, investment interest income and expense is outside the scope of Section 163(j). ATI means the taxable income of the taxpayer computed without regard to (1) any item of income, gain, deduction or loss which is not properly allocated to a trade or business, (2) any business interest expense or business interest income, (3) any NOL deduction under Section 172, (4) any deduction allowable under Section 199A, (5) for taxable years beginning before January 1, 2022, any deduction allowable for depreciation, amortization or depletion.

    Section 163(j) applies to all taxpayers, not just corporations. There are exceptions for taxpayers with average gross receipts for the three prior taxable years of $25 million or less and certain trades or businesses (generally, electing real property businesses, electing farming businesses, utilities, employees and floor plan financing). Any business interest expense that is not allowed as a deduction may be carried forward indefinitely. There is no carry forward for any excess limitation.

    There is a complicated rule for partnerships. Section 163(j) as amended applies at the partnership level and any deduction for business interest expense is taken into account in determining the partnership’s non-separately stated taxable income or loss. Each partner’s ATI is (1) determined without regard to such partner’s distributive share of any item of income, gain, deduction or loss of the partnership and (2) increased by such partner’s distributive share of the partnership’s excess taxable income (ETI). ETI means, with respect to any partnership, the amount which bears the same ratio of the partnership’s ATI as the excess, if any, of (1) 30 percent of the partnership’s ATI for the taxable year, over (2) the amount, if any, by which the partnership’s business interest expense exceeds the partnership’s business interest income, bears to 30 percent of the partnership’s ATI for the taxable year.

    Any excess business interest expense that is not allowed as a deduction to the partnership is not carried forward to the succeeding taxable year. Instead, it is allocated to each partner in the same manner as the partnership’s non-separately stated taxable income or loss. If a partner is allocated any excess business interest expense for the taxable year, such excess business interest expense is treated as business interest expense paid or accrued by the partner in the next succeeding taxable year in which the partner is allocated ETI from the partnership, but only to the extent of such ETI (the ETI limitation). The portion of any excess business interest expense remaining after applying the ETI limitation is treated as business interest expense paid or accrued in succeeding taxable years. Once all of such business interest expense for all preceding years has been treated as paid or accrued by a partner as a result of allocations of ETI to such partner, any remaining ETI that has been allocated to a partner will be taken into account when computing the partner’s own Section 163(j) limitation with respect to any business interest expense the partner has incurred at the partner level.

    Any excess business interest expense that is allocated to a partner reduces (but not below zero) such partner’s adjusted basis in its partnership interest. If a partner disposes of a partnership interest, the adjusted basis of the partner in the partnership interest is increased immediately before the disposition by the amount of the excess (if any) of the amount of such basis reduction over the portion of any business interest expense allocated to the partner which has previously been treated as business interest expense paid or accrued by the partner.

    Market participants had identified several issues regarding the application of Section 163(j) that required clarification. The Notice addresses many of these important issues in a manner that is helpful for taxpayers.

    There was some concern that C corporations would have to allocate interest income and expense between business activities and investment activities. The Notice states that Treasury and the IRS intend to issue regulations clarifying that, solely for Section 163(j) purposes, all interest income includible in gross income by a C corporation will be business interest income and all interest paid or accrued by a C corporation will be business interest expense. Such regulations will not apply to S corporations, but the regulations will address interest income and expense allocated to a C corporation that owns a partnership interest.

    In addition, as discussed above, the proposed regulations issued under ‘old’ Section 163(j) contained a super affiliation rule that treated all members of an affiliated group as one taxpayer for Section 163(j) purposes without regard to whether the affiliated group filed (or could file) a consolidated return. The Act eliminated the statutory provisions that treated an affiliated group as one taxpayer and permitting the super-affiliation rules. Treasury and the IRS, according to the Notice, intend to issue regulations that Section 163(j) applies on the consolidated group level. An affiliated group that does not file a consolidated return will not be treated as one taxpayer. The regulations will address, among other things, the allocation of the Section 163(j) limitation among group members, and the treatment of disallowed interest deduction carryforwards when a member leaves the group.

    The Act did not address the treatment of disqualified interest expense disallowed under Section 163(j) prior to the Act. Treasury and the IRS intend to address that issue by issuing regulations clarifying that taxpayers with disqualified interest disallowed under ‘old’ Section 163(j) may carry forward such interest to the taxpayer’s first taxable year beginning after December 31, 2017. Any business interest carried forward will be subject to potential disallowance under Section 163(j), as amended by the Act and will be subject to Section 59A (BEAT). In addition, the regulations will contain rules for allocating business interest expense from a super-affiliated group under the ‘old’ Section 163(j) proposed regulations.

    The Notice also states that regulations will clarify that the disallowance and carryforward of a deduction for a C corporation’s business interest expense under Section 163(j) will not affect whether or when such business interest expense reduces earnings and profits of the payor C corporation.

    Section 163(j) requires that the business interest expense limitation be applied at the partnership level and that the business interest expense be taken account in determining the partnership’s non-separately stated income. The Treasury and the IRS intend to issue regulations providing that, in general, for purposes of calculating a partner’s annual business interest expense deduction, a partner cannot include its share of the partnership’s business interest income for the taxable year except to the extent of the partner’s share of the excess of (1) the partnership’s business interest income over (2) the partnership’s business interest expense. Such regulations are intended to prevent a partner from “double counting” business interest income earned through a partnership for Section 163(j) purposes. Similar rules will apply to S corporations and their shareholders. A partner’s adjusted basis in its partnership interest is relevant to many common transactions between a partnership and its partners. For example, distributions in excess of basis are taxable under Section 731, including deemed distributions on repayment of partnership debt. In addition, allocations of partnership loss are allowed only to the extent of the partner’s basis in its interest. The basis adjustments required under Section 163(j) will need to be considered prior to a distribution or loss allocation to avoid an unintended tax consequence.

    In conclusion, the Notice addresses several important issues in a manner that is generally favorable to taxpayers. Treasury and the IRS have asked for (and have received) comments regarding the application of Section 163(j). We expect additional guidance on this important subject sometime later this calendar year.

    Authors

    Kristen E. Hazel

    Partner & Deputy General Counsel

    Chicago

    John T. Lutz

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    David G. Noren

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • The International Provisions of the TCJA

    ARTICLE

    The International Provisions of the TCJA

    March/April 2018

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Cym Lowell, Mark Thomas and Kristina Novak wrote this bylined article on the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act’s impact on multinational enterprises. The authors wrote that the Act “embraces a territorial system, as exists with most [US] trading partners; seeks to protect the US tax base from perceived cross-border erosion; and enacts an incentive for economic investment in the United States at a globally attractive effective tax rate (13.125%).”

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • OFAC “May” Include Virtual Currency Wallet Addresses on SDN List

    OFAC “May” Include Virtual Currency Wallet Addresses on SDN List

    ARTICLE

    OFAC “May” Include Virtual Currency Wallet Addresses on SDN List

    April 11, 2018

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Lee Schneider wrote this bylined article describing how the Office of Foreign Asset Control (OFAC) may publicly identify digital currency addresses associated with entities on its “blocked persons” list that US persons generally are prohibited from doing business with. If OFAC does this, Mr. Schneider wrote, “It could alter compliance and ‘Know Your Customer’ requirements for market participants.”

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • ESOP Litigation Trends: Department of Labor Voids Fiduciary Indemnification Agreements to Reach Settlements

    ESOP Litigation Trends: Department of Labor Voids Fiduciary Indemnification Agreements to Reach Settlements

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    ESOP Litigation Trends: Department of Labor Voids Fiduciary Indemnification Agreements to Reach Settlements

    April 11, 2018

    Read time: 9 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The US Department of Labor has taken the position that certain indemnification clauses are void against public policy under Section 410 of ERISA. This policy has been adopted by private plaintiff classes; as evident from a recent settlement, a policy that voids indemnity provisions can limit defense budgets, make settlements more likely and potentially create dangerous precedent for ESOPs.

    In depth

    In recent litigation involving employee stock ownership plan (ESOP)-owned companies, the US Department of Labor (DOL) has taken the position that indemnification clauses are void against public policy under Section 410 of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, as amended (ERISA). Though lacking clear precedent, this policy has also been adopted by private plaintiff classes in recent years. As evident from the settlement in Pfeifer v. Wawa, a policy of voiding indemnity provisions can limit defense budgets, make settlements more likely and potentially create dangerous precedent for ESOPs.

    Background

    ERISA sets minimum standards for employee benefit plans, like ESOPs, that are meant to protect plan participants and their beneficiaries. These protections include strict standards of duty and loyalty for the individuals responsible for the ESOP—known as the “plan’s fiduciaries”—and ready access to federal courts for ESOP participants, the DOL and other ESOP stakeholders.

    ERISA Section 502(a), the “civil enforcement provision” of ERISA, allows a plan participant to sue to recover benefits owed to the participant by the ESOP, to redress violations of ERISA’s fiduciary standards, and to seek “other equitable relief.” Similarly, the DOL can, and frequently does, bring civil actions for breaches of fiduciary duties and other provisions of ERISA.

    As one of the primary agencies charged with ERISA enforcement, the DOL has long maintained that Section 410 of ERISA prohibits blanket indemnification of fiduciaries by an ESOP sponsor or the ESOP itself. Specifically, Section 410 prohibits, “as a matter of public policy,” any provision in an agreement or instrument which purports to relieve a fiduciary from responsibility or liability under ERISA. Meant to prevent a plan fiduciary from shifting its own ERISA liability to a sponsoring company or plan participants or beneficiary, Section 410 expressly allows an ESOP or plan sponsor to purchase liability insurance for the ESOP’s fiduciaries. DOL regulations issued under Section 410 further permit “indemnification agreements” that function as insurance, but flat-out prohibit indemnification paid for with plan assets.

    In general, indemnity is a promise by one party, the indemnitor, to provide compensation for a loss suffered by another party, the indemnitee. Indemnification can be negotiated as provision of a larger contract or can exist as a stand-alone agreement. Indemnification is the basis for many insurance contracts, but can also be used to allocate risks amongst parties to many types of contracts, including an engagement agreement between a plan sponsor and plan fiduciary. It is common for ESOP trust agreements to contain a provision that states:

    Recognizing that engagements of the type contemplated in this agreement can result in government investigations, litigation, or other proceedings, the Company agrees to indemnify Trustee against and from any and all claims, damages, expenses, liabilities and losses whatsoever (including, but not limited to, any and all expenses reasonably incurred in investigating, preparing for, defending, or responding to discovery requests or other requests for information relating to, any government investigations, litigation, arbitration or other proceedings, commenced or threatened, or any claim whatsoever, whether or not resulting in any liability), to which any or all of them may become subject under any applicable federal or state law or otherwise relating to the Proposed Transaction or Trustee’s duties as Trustee (including all events that occurred prior to Trustee becoming the Trustee or after Trustee’s service as Trustee has terminated). However, the indemnification of Trustee shall not apply to any claim, damage, expense, liability or loss that is found by a court of competent jurisdiction, in a final judgment from which no appeal can be taken, to have resulted either from a breach by Trustee of its fiduciary duties under Title I of ERISA or, in non-fiduciary matters, from the bad faith, gross negligence, willful misconduct or material breach of the terms of this letter agreement by Trustee.

    While DOL has no objection to those indemnification arrangements that allow a fiduciary or plan sponsor to purchase fiduciary liability insurance for those who act in fiduciary roles, it has taken the position that allowing an ESOP-owned company to pay for any amount of a settlement or award in addition to the costs of an insurance policy would cause monetary harm directly or indirectly to the ESOP and its participants and beneficiaries.

    In Donovan v. Cunningham, the first major case to examine indemnity provisions, the Southern District of Texas found that ERISA 410 voided an agreement that provided for an ESOP sponsor would indemnify “each member of the Board of Directors, each member of the [plan committee], the trustee and any other person to whom any fiduciary responsibility with respect to the plan is allocated or delegated from and against any and all liabilities, costs, and expenses incurred by such persons as a result of any act or omission to act in connection with the performance of their fiduciary duties, responsibilities and obligations under the Plan and under the Act, except for liabilities and claims arising from such fiduciary’s willful misconduct.” The court found that such a broad indemnification provision was, in fact, an attempt to relieve the fiduciaries from responsibilities under ERISA.

    On the other hand, in Pfahler v. National Latex Products Company, a case involving a welfare benefit plan, the Sixth Circuit held that indemnification agreements are valid under ERISA 410, saying “Given that ERISA explicitly permits parties to insure against possible liability, it would be illogical to interpret the statute as prohibiting indemnification agreements, which accomplish the same thing.” In Schafer v. Multiband Corp, the Sixth Circuit noted that, while deciding the case on other grounds, the holding in Pfahler applies with equal weight to indemnification of ESOP trustees.

    At least one court has held that, in the context of a 100 percent ESOP-owned company, any costs borne by the company arguably impact the value of company stock held by the ESOP. In the often-cited Johnson v. Couturier, the Ninth Circuit held that a series of fiduciary indemnification agreements that excluded only “deliberate wrongful acts” and “gross negligence,” but included breaches of fiduciary duty, were void under Section 410.

    An important, but often overlooked, fact in Couturier is that the ESOP sponsor was in the process of liquidation, therefore any funds used to pay the fiduciaries’ defense costs would result in a dollar for dollar reduction in the funds available for distribution to ESOP participants. In Harris v. GreatBanc Trust Company, the Central District of California distinguished Couturier, allowing an indemnification agreement that expressly prohibited indemnification if a court entered a final judgment—from which no appeal could be filed—that found a trustee liable for breach of its fiduciary duties. Additionally, the court in GreatBanc noted that where the plan sponsor is an operating company, as opposed to a company in the process of liquidation, plan asset regulations (29 CFR Section 2510-3.101) apply, meaning the assets of the plan sponsor are not treated as assets of the ESOP.

    The Settlement Thicket

    The law is less clear on the limits of fiduciary indemnification, particularly as applied to settlement payments by ESOP sponsors. With the protections of indemnification provisions jeopardized, many ESOP trustees would lack the resources to defend a case through trial, increasing the incentive to settle claims and agree to terms that they otherwise would not.

    As the court in Harris v. GreatBanc pointed out, even if the DOL is mistaken in its interpretation of Section 410, it is still free to demand that indemnification agreements be void as a condition of settling a case. In fact, that was precisely what the DOL did in settling the Harris case, where GreatBanc ultimately agreed to not seek or accept indemnification from the sponsoring company.

    The pressure to settle can also be seen in cases between private parties. In Pfeifer v. Wawa, the Eastern District of Pennsylvania allowed the plaintiffs’ challenge to the indemnification of ESOP trustees and administrators to survive a motion to dismiss. The parties subsequently reached a settlement agreement before proceeding to trial. While not bound by the Ninth Circuit’s decision in Couturier, the court in Wawa declared Couturier the “majority view” on the validity of indemnification of fiduciaries without acknowledging its distinct facts, providing an attractively succinct, but inadequate summary of the issue for future plaintiffs to cite.

    The unique circumstances of settlements, where the defendant typically doesn’t admit liability but is not technically cleared of it either, can also pose challenges when applying the terms of indemnification agreements or insurance policies. For example, if the agreement provides for indemnification of defense costs only where the fiduciary is cleared of all wrongdoing, a settlement may not meet that criteria.

    * * *

    The recent trend highlights the importance of trustees seeking insurance and litigation budgets for costs that go above and beyond their coverage limit, in addition to indemnification provisions, when negotiating their engagement with the plan or plan sponsor. Adequately preparing for litigation is even more important for individual trustees, who may otherwise lack the resources to defend against prolonged litigation and feel more pressure to settle. Trustees should consult counsel when drafting indemnification language to ensure it complies with the most recent developments in ESOP case law. In addition, trustees should work with counsel to budget for potential legal claims with the understanding that indemnification provisions may not cover all costs associated with such claims.

    Authors

    J. Christian Nemeth

    Partner

    Chicago, Miami

    Allison Wilkerson

    Partner

    Dallas

    More insights

  • No-Poach Agreements Land Franchisors in Hot Water

    ARTICLE

    No-Poach Agreements Land Franchisors in Hot Water

    April 10, 2018

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Mary Strimel, Emre Ilter, and Matt Evola wrote this bylined article about antitrust litigation involving franchise businesses and hiring restraints. Noting a current wave of lawsuits, the authors wrote that “franchise businesses should carefully look at any employment restrictions in their franchise agreements, such as non-solicitation or no-hire agreements. Overbroad restrictions are likely to be challenged, and even narrow agreements with substantial justifications could face scrutiny.”

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Capital Markets & Public Companies Quarterly: SEC Issues Cybersecurity Guidance, BlackRock and Gender Diversity, and News from the SEC and NYSE

    Capital Markets & Public Companies Quarterly: SEC Issues Cybersecurity Guidance, BlackRock and Gender Diversity, and News from the SEC and NYSE

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Capital Markets & Public Companies Quarterly: SEC Issues Cybersecurity Guidance, BlackRock and Gender Diversity, and News from the SEC and NYSE

    April 10, 2018

    Read time: 18 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In a telling sign of current events, the SEC staff provided supplemental guidance related to the disclosure of cybersecurity risks and incidents, adding new commentary to its rules regarding disclosure and company controls. In addition, BlackRock, Inc. has joined other institutional investors in pushing for greater diversity in the boardroom.

    Our quarterly update also covers an enforcement action challenging a company’s reliance on Rule 701, a no action letter interpreting recent SEC guidance on shareholder proposals and a new NYSE rule regarding the delivery of proxy materials.

    In depth

    New SEC Statement and Guidance on Public Company Cybersecurity Disclosures

    On February 26, 2018, the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) staff released the Commission Statement and Guidance on Public Company Cybersecurity Disclosures. Coming on the heels of the Equifax data breach and ominously predating the more recent revelations from Facebook, the interpretive guidance does not create any new disclosure requirements; rather, it urges public companies to engage in a more robust disclosure of material cybersecurity risks and incidents and to consider how such disclosures may be prompted under existing disclosure requirements.

    Supplementing the SEC’s 2011 guidance on cybersecurity disclosure, the new guidance summarizes the ways in which cybersecurity risks or incidents may be described in disclosures that are generally required of public companies within their periodic and current reports. While many companies have integrated cybersecurity disclosure into their annual and quarterly risk factor disclosure, the SEC staff’s guidance also illustrates that disclosure of cybersecurity risks and preventative measures may be appropriate throughout an issuer’s annual and/or quarterly report, including in sections dealing with business and operations, risk factors, legal proceedings, financial performance and corporate governance. The SEC staff requested that public companies tailor and contextualize their disclosure and avoid boilerplate or generic language. However, the SEC staff provided that the disclosures need not be so specific as to provide a roadmap for any bad actor seeking to penetrate a company’s cybersecurity protections.

    The guidance also urges public companies to re-examine the sufficiency of their controls and procedures with regard to cybersecurity risks and incidents. After reminding public companies of their obligation to maintain disclosure controls and procedures, the guidance encourages public companies to develop a protocol for determining the potential materiality of any cyber risk or incident and emphasizes that the goals of effective disclosure are likely best served when information regarding the cybersecurity risks and incidents reaches the public company’s directors, officers and other persons responsible for developing and overseeing its disclosure controls and procedures. The SEC staff acknowledged that companies may require time to discern the true impact of a cybersecurity incident, while also cautioning time for consideration did not remove the company’s duty to timely disclose or to correct prior disclosures that become materially inaccurate.

    The guidance ended by warning public companies against trading in its securities by corporate insiders with knowledge of a material non-public cybersecurity risk or incident, as evidenced by recent SEC enforcement activity. The SEC staff also warned of the related risk regarding the selective disclosure of cybersecurity incidents and the prohibitions of Regulation Fair Disclosure (FD) with regard to selective disclosure of material non-public information.

    For more on this topic, see SEC Issues Cybersecurity Guidance to Public Companies published in Corporate Counsel. You can also get the latest updates on privacy and cybersecurity regulation from McDermott’s Global Privacy and Cybersecurity practice.

    BlackRock Proxy Voting Guidelines Update

    In February, BlackRock, Inc. (BlackRock) published updated proxy voting guidelines in which it stated that it would “expect boards to be comprised of a diverse selection of individuals” to facilitate an environment for constructive debate of competing views and opinions. In addition, the guidelines explicitly note that BlackRock “would normally expect to see at least two women directors on every board.” For companies that have not adequately accounted for diversity in its board composition, BlackRock “may vote against the nominating/governance committee members.”

    The guidelines follow on Larry Fink’s annual letter to CEOs, in which he wrote that BlackRock will continue to “emphasize the importance of a diverse board,” and that “boards with a diverse mix of genders, ethnicities, career experiences, and ways of thinking have, as a result, a more diverse and aware mindset.” Following the release of the guidelines, Michelle Edkins, BlackRock’s global head of investment stewardship, has also sent letters to approximately 300 companies in the Russell 1000 that have fewer than two women on their boards, asking them to disclose how they are approaching diversity in their workplace. The letter advised that “a lack of diversity on the board undermines its ability to make effective strategic decisions. That, in turn, inhibits the company’s capacity for long-term growth.”

    Through these actions, BlackRock joins other shareholders and shareholder groups that are taking a stronger position with regard to gender representation on public company boards. On March 21, 2018, the New York State Common Retirement Fund announced that it intends to oppose the re-election of all directors at hundreds of US corporate boards that have no women on their boards. Last year, proxy advisory firms Glass Lewis and Institutional Shareholder Services also released voting guidelines noting gender diversity issues in corporate boards, and expressed their intentions to highlight or generally discourage the re-election of boards with no women directors or support proposals requesting reports on a company’s efforts to diversify the board, respectively.

    For additional commentary on BlackRock’s proxy voting guidelines and other examples of the influence of pension funds and asset managers on corporate governance, see the March issue of Corporate Law & Governance Update.

    Rule 701 Enforcement Action

    On March 12, 2018, the SEC instituted cease-and-desist proceedings against Credit Karma, Inc., a San Francisco-based financial technology company, for the unregistered issuance of $13.8 million in stock options to its employees without following the financial information and risk disclosure requirements of Rule 701 of the Securities Act.

    Under Rule 701, a private company may issue its securities to employees pursuant to a written compensatory benefit plan without registering the securities under the Securities Act. The number of securities that may be annually issued under Rule 701 is limited by the dollar amount of the offering, the total assets of the company and the number of its securities that are outstanding. If the value of securities issued over a 12-month period exceeds $5 million, the company must provide its employees information regarding the risks associated with an investment in the securities and certain financial statements of the company. According to the order, Credit Karma attempted to rely on Rule 701, but failed to follow these disclosure requirements. Per the order, Credit Karma agreed to pay a civil money penalty of $160,000.

    In the current climate of emerging companies, one that continues to reward employees with grants of stock, options and (perhaps) tokens, coins or other securities, the order is a reminder of the SEC’s willingness to investigate and enforce violations of Rule 701 and other exemptions from registration. The order is also a reminder that exemptions from registration may come with “strings attached” and companies should remain vigilant of how their actions may trigger additional regulatory requirements.

    SEC No-Action Letter Permits Omission of Shareholder Proposal in Reliance of Rule 14a-8(i)(5)

    Following the SEC’s recent interpretive guidance on shareholder proposals (as covered in our last quarterly update), on February 22, 2018, the SEC staff issued a no-action letter permitting the omission of a shareholder proposal under Rule 14a-8(i)(5) of the Exchange Act, also known as the “economic relevance” exception. The permitted exclusion may mark the return to relevance of a substantive exclusion which had been largely rejected by the courts and the SEC.

    The “economic relevance” exception permits a company to exclude a proposal that “relates to operations which account for less than 5 percent of the company’s total assets at the end of its most recent fiscal year, and for less than 5 percent of its net earnings and gross sales for its most recent fiscal year, and is not otherwise significantly related to the company’s business.” After the District Court for the District of Columbia’s decision in Lovenheim v. Iroquois Brands, Ltd., 618 F. Supp. 554 (D.D.C. 1985), the SEC staff has narrowed its application of the exception to allow only the exclusion of proposals that touch on matters “not significantly related to the issuer’s business.” This more limited reading has largely negated company attempts to exclude proposals that raise issues of social significance, even when the subject matter falls below the economic thresholds set forth in the rule. However, it appears that Staff Legal Bulletin No. 14I may have brought this exclusion back to life.

    The shareholder proposal at issue, which was submitted to Dunkin’ Brands Group, Inc., requested that the board issue a report assessing the environmental impacts of continuing to use the company’s K-Cup Pods brand packaging. The no-action letter highlighted the following grounds for permitting the omission of the proposal:

    (1) the proposal relates to operations that account for less than 5 percent of the Company’s total assets at the end of its most recent fiscal year;

    (2) the proposal relates to operations that account for less than 5 percent of the Company’s net earnings and gross sales for its most recent fiscal year;

    (3) the proposal’s significance to the company’s business is not apparent on its face; and

    (4) the proponent of the proposal has not demonstrated that the subject matter of the proposal is otherwise significantly related to the company’s business.

    Assuming these conditions are satisfied, the SEC may permit the omission of a shareholder proposal under the “economic relevance” exception.

    NYSE Amends Requirement for Delivery of Proxy Materials

    On March 1, 2018, the SEC approved a New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) proposed rule change, limiting the requirement that public companies physically deliver proxy materials to NYSE. The amendments to Section 402.01 and Section 204.00(B) of the NYSE Listing Manual eliminate the requirement for listed companies to provide physical copies of proxy materials to the NYSE, so long as the proxy materials are included in an electronic SEC filing available on EDGAR. The only caveat to this rule applies where the proxy materials are available on EDGAR, but were “not filed pursuant to Schedule 14A” under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (such as proxy materials filed on Form S-4 or by foreign private issuers that file proxy materials under Form 8-K or Form 6-K), in which case the company must provide the NYSE with information sufficient to identify such EDGAR filing not later than the date on which the material is sent or given to any security holders using one of the means specified in Section 204.00(A).

    Any listed company that does not include proxy materials in their entirety in an SEC filing on EDGAR must provide the NYSE with three copies of the definitive proxy materials not later than the date on which the materials are sent or given to any security holder.

    Authors

    Robert H. Cohen

    Partner

    Miami

    Thomas P. Conaghan

    Partner

    Washington, DC, New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    William Hadler

    Partner

    Chicago

    Mark J. Mihanovic

    Partner

    Silicon Valley, Los Angeles

    Eric Orsic

    Partner

    Chicago

    Heidi J. Steele

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • Control of Subordinated Loans in General Terms and Conditions – Case Note on the Judgement of the Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf of December 20, 2017– I-12 U 16/17

    ARTICLE

    Control of Subordinated Loans in General Terms and Conditions – Case Note on the Judgement of the Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf of December 20, 2017– I-12 U 16/17

    April 2018

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Case note of Dr. Thiemo Schäfer on the judgement of the Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf of December 20, 2017– I-12 U 16/17.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Opinion on the Regulation of Tokens of the Finance Working Group of the Blockchain Association

    ARTICLE

    Opinion on the Regulation of Tokens of the Finance Working Group of the Blockchain Association

    April 6, 2018

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The paper analyses the status quo of the current regulation of Token sale related matters under EU and German law.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights