Content Type: Article

  • Overtime Exemptions for Educational Institutions

    Overtime Exemptions for Educational Institutions

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Overtime Exemptions for Educational Institutions

    April 20, 2018

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Fair Labor Standards Act (“FLSA”) is the federal wage and hour law that generally requires covered employers to pay overtime (at time-and-one-half of employees’ regular hourly wage rates) if employees work over 40 hours in a workweek. The FLSA, however, contains certain broad exemptions. If an employee is “exempt,” the employer is not required to pay the employee overtime pay.

    The U.S. Department of Labor (“DOL”) issued a new Fact Sheet[1] for educational institutions on who may qualify as an exempt employee. Although the Fact Sheet references higher education institutions, the exemptions also apply to primary and secondary schools. The Fact Sheet discusses the exemptions for professional, administrative and executive employees in detail, including applicability to teachers and coaches.

    The Fact Sheet notes that the federal minimum salary rate of $455 per week may increase. Employers must also comply with state wage and hour laws. New York’s law on overtime exemptions generally follows federal law, except that the salary level for the exemptions under New York’s Labor Law has long exceeded the federal rate. Currently, the minimum salary required in New York for large employers (defined as 11 or more employees), in order for the executive or administrative exemption to apply, is $975 per week, increasing to $1,125 on Dec. 31, 2018.

    Employers should review their classifications of employees as exempt or non-exempt. Class-action lawsuits for overtime violations have become increasingly common and are likely to continue. These lawsuits can be extremely costly, as they can result in back pay of up to six years (under New York law), double damages and attorneys’ fees.

    Authored by Mark E. Brossman, Scott A. Gold and Donna Lazarus.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] Fact Sheet available here.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2018 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Mark E. Brossman

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Donna K. Lazarus

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • SEC Proposes Investment Adviser Standards of Conduct and Enhanced Regulation

    SEC Proposes Investment Adviser Standards of Conduct and Enhanced Regulation

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    SEC Proposes Investment Adviser Standards of Conduct and Enhanced Regulation

    April 19, 2018

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On April 18, 2018, the SEC proposed a set of rules and interpretations addressing the standards of care applicable to investment advisers and broker-dealers.[1] Two of the proposals apply only to retail investors: “Regulation Best Interest” — which would impose a standard of care on broker-dealers — and proposed Form CRS — which would require SEC-registered investment advisers (“RIAs”) and broker-dealers to provide a “relationship summary” to retail clients.

    The third proposal, however, applies to investment advisers more broadly and also includes a request for comment on enhancing investment adviser regulation. The “Proposed Commission Interpretation Regarding Standard of Conduct for Investment Advisers; Request for Comment on Enhancing Investment Adviser Regulation” includes four separate sections:

    1. A proposed interpretation of an investment adviser’s fiduciary duties under federal law;
    2. A request for comment on federal licensing and continuing education requirements for personnel of RIAs;
    3. A request for comment on the provision of account statements to RIA clients; and
    4. A request for comment on financial responsibility requirements.

    The broadest aspect of this proposal is the proposed interpretation of an adviser’s fiduciary duty, which is focused on fiduciary duty as a general concept and is not limited to the duties owed to a single category of clients (e.g., retail clients). The SEC proposal identifies and explores several subsidiary duties that are subsumed within an overall fiduciary duty:

    • The duty of care, which includes:
      • A duty to provide advice that is in the client’s best interest;
      • A duty to seek best execution; and
      • A duty to act and to provide advice and monitoring over the course of the relationship.
    • The duty of loyalty.

    While the proposed fiduciary duty interpretation reiterates general standards well-established in prior precedent, it also includes a discussion of conflicts of interest that reflects more recent SEC staff perspectives. For example, the proposed interpretation indicates that “an adviser disclosing that it ‘may’ have a conflict is not adequate disclosure when the conflict actually exists.”

    In its request for comment with respect to federal licensing and continuing education, the SEC focuses on “investment adviser representatives” — typically, a supervised person of an RIA who has more than five clients who are natural persons but not qualified clients and more than 10 percent of whose clients are natural persons but not qualified clients. However, while it is focused on investment adviser representatives, the request for comments also asks whether other advisory personnel should be included in any federal licensing and continuing education requirements, including all supervised persons or any individuals for whom an adviser must deliver a Form ADV Part 2B brochure supplement. This additional element of the SEC proposal, on its face, is not limited to advisers with retail clients.

    The request for comment on the provision of account statements is more narrowly focused on retail clients, but it also more generally asks about the costs and benefits of requiring the provision of account statements specifying dollar amounts of fees and expenses.

    Finally, the request for comments as to financial responsibility asks whether RIAs should be subject to net capital rules or other financial responsibility requirements, such as a fidelity bond, to ensure they can meet their financial obligations. The request also asks whether registered investment advisers should “be required to obtain annual audits of their own financials and to provide such information on Form ADV.”

    Comments on the proposals will be due within 90 days of publication in the Federal Register, and we look forward to discussing these issues with our clients as we prepare comments for submission.


    Authored by Brian T. Daly and Marc E. Elovitz.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your lawyer or one of the authors.

    In depth
    Authors

    Marc E. Elovitz

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • IRS Funding Woes Realised? Audit Rate at 15-Year Low

    ARTICLE

    IRS Funding Woes Realised? Audit Rate at 15-Year Low

    April 19, 2018

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Andrew Roberson and Kevin Spencer wrote in this bylined article that IRS funding woes led in 2017 to the lowest level of audits in 15 years. “The decreased funding of the IRS in the wake of bipartisan disagreements seems to have quelled in recent weeks,” the authors wrote, leading to “movement to get the IRS more funding in the wake of tax reform but it remains to be seen whether some of those funds will be used to increase the enforcement functions of the IRS.”

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • New York’s Response to Federal Tax Reform: Charitable Contributions Credit

    New York’s Response to Federal Tax Reform: Charitable Contributions Credit

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    New York’s Response to Federal Tax Reform: Charitable Contributions Credit

    April 18, 2018

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In an effort to mitigate the effects of the elimination of the individual SALT deduction as part of federal tax reform, New York has enacted a charitable contribution regime under which individuals may contribute to state or locally established charitable funds and receive a tax credit against their New York State income taxes or real estate property taxes. The hope is that taxpayers could claim the charitable contribution deduction federally in lieu of the foregone deduction for New York State and locality taxes paid, but many commentators believe this tax credit structure is legally suspect.

    In depth

    New York is the first state to pass legislation aimed at mitigating the effects of the elimination of the state and local tax deduction for individuals as part of federal tax reform. The changes came in two parts: (1) enactment of a charitable contribution regime, discussed in this article, and (2) enactment of an optional payroll tax, discussed in a separate On the Subject.

    The idea behind the charitable contribution regime is simple: individuals may contribute to state or locally established charitable funds and receive a tax credit against their New York State income taxes or real estate property taxes. The hope is that taxpayers could claim the charitable contribution deduction federally in lieu of the foregone deduction for New York State and locality taxes paid. However, many commentators are concerned that the law will not pass muster federally because the New York law appears to be a deliberate attempt to circumvent the impact of the federal tax changes, and contributions may be viewed as indirect payments of taxes. For more information, see McDermott’s On the Subject “Charitable Funds and the Disallowance of Federal Income Tax Deductions for State and Local Taxes.”

    Ultimately, it will be interesting to see if or how the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) deals with the new New York Law.

    Overview

    This law provides individuals with credits against their New York State personal income tax liability equal to 85 percent of the donations they make to certain charitable organizations.

    The law also authorizes localities (such as New York City) to establish similar charitable funds and to provide contributing individuals with a credit equal to 95 percent of the donation to use to offset the individual’s real property tax liability.

    Eligible Donations

    The State is authorized to form a charitable gift trust fund with two accounts: the health care charitable account and the elementary and secondary educational charitable account. The amounts that can be donated to these funds and qualify for the credit are unlimited.

    In addition, qualified donations to Health Research, Inc.; the SUNY Impact Foundation; and the CUNY Research Foundation are authorized, although the amount of total contributions to each of these organizations may not exceed $10 million. Because of the $10 million limitation, taxpayers will need to apply to make creditable donations to these entities.

    Personal Income Tax Credit Timing Issues

    Credit would apply for the tax year after the year in which the contribution is paid (i.e., a 2019 contribution would affect the employee’s 2020 New York State income tax credit).

    The anticipated federal benefit would relate to the tax year in which the contribution is paid (i.e., a 2019 contribution would affect the employee’s 2019 federal income tax return).

    Personal Income Tax Credit Documentation

    The law establishes a mechanism to provide each donor with a certificate/statement of his or her payment, which certificate can then be used to support taking the credit on the individual’s tax return.

    Real Property Tax Timing Provision and Mechanism

    Credits would be granted for payments made during the 12-month period within which real property taxes are due without interest or penalties (this period would be determined by local law).

    The taxpayer must present a certificate of contribution to the local authority before the last day on which property tax payments are due in order to receive a credit for taxes paid or due during that period. If the taxpayer presents the certificate late, he or she may receive a refund of property taxes paid.

    The anticipated federal benefit would relate to the tax year in which the contribution is paid (i.e., a 2019 contribution would affect the employee’s 2019 federal income tax return).

    Mitigation Provision

    The law requires the State to establish an online system for taxpayers to claim reimbursement for any interest paid to the IRS if the IRS disallows a deduction for the contribution, although the law does not say that taxpayers are entitled to such reimbursement. Taxpayers are required to request reimbursement via the online system within 60 days of making their payments of interest. Taxpayers may claim reimbursement for tax years 2019–2021 only.

    Commentary

    Many practitioners believe this tax credit structure is legally suspect.

    Authors

    Richard C. Call

    Partner

    Boston, New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • New York’s Response to Federal Tax Reform: Optional Payroll Tax

    New York’s Response to Federal Tax Reform: Optional Payroll Tax

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    New York’s Response to Federal Tax Reform: Optional Payroll Tax

    April 18, 2018

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In an effort to mitigate the effects of the elimination of the individual SALT deduction as part of federal tax reform, New York has enacted an optional payroll tax that would allow employees to receive a personal income tax credit against their New York income tax liability. The underlying economics of this provision are complex, however, and could make implementation difficult.

    In depth

    New York is the first state to pass legislation aimed at mitigating the effects of the federal elimination of the state and local tax deduction for individuals as part of federal tax reform. The changes came in two parts: (1) the enactment of an optional payroll tax, discussed in this article, and (2) enactment of a charitable contribution regime, discussed in a separate On The Subject.

    The idea of the payroll tax is simple: the employer pays a payroll tax, and employees receive a personal income tax credit against their New York income tax liability based on wages subject to the payroll tax. The underlying economics are anything but straightforward, however. Employers bear the cost of paying the new tax (should they decide to do so) while employees reap the benefit in the form of reduced New York State taxes. Employers opting into the tax might attempt to decrease employee compensation to mitigate the effect of the new cost to their business, even though the statute does not allow this to be done explicitly. Needless to say, lowering wages, albeit in a way that is intended to help employees, may be a tough sell to the employees. This will be made even more difficult for employers that have employees who are not New York residents, because those nonresident employees will not receive any benefit if their state of residence does not provide an offsetting credit for the optional payroll tax paid by the employer.

    In addition, any reduction in wages could affect other benefits that are based on wages, such as defined benefit pensions, social security and allowable 401(k) contributions. Even assuming a willingness on the part of employers and employees to work through the regime, calibrating the correct fluctuation in wages may be impossible from a practical perspective. Ultimately, it will be interesting to see how many employers decide to opt into the new tax.

    Overview

    The new provision allows employers to opt into payment of payroll tax. Tax will be paid on wages paid to each employee that exceeds $40,000/year. Employees will be provided with a credit against New York State personal income tax based on wages in excess of $40,000. This structure does not necessarily produce a dollar for dollar offset of federal taxes.

    Rate

    The optional payroll tax has a three-year phase-in starting in 2019:

    • 2019 rate – 1.5 percent of payroll expense
    • 2020 rate – 3 percent of payroll expense
    • 2021 rate – 5 percent of payroll expense

    Payroll expense would mean wages and compensation as defined under IRC §§ 3121 and 3231.

    Employee Credit

    The law provides a personal income tax credit for an employee equal to the product of (1) the employee’s taxable wages and compensation in excess of $40,000 received from the employer, (2) the optional payroll tax rate (1.5 percent for 2019), and (3) the result of one minus a fraction, the numerator of which is the New York State personal income tax imposed on the employee (before application of any credits) and the denominator of which is the employee’s state taxable income. The credit is independent of the payment of the payroll tax by the employer.

    Timing Issues

    Credit would apply for the same year in which the payroll tax is paid (i.e., 2019 payroll tax payment would affect the employee’s 2019 New York State income tax credit). The anticipated federal benefit would relate to the same tax year in which the payroll tax is paid, i.e., 2019 payments would affect the employee’s 2019 federal tax liability (2019 return filed in 2020).

    Due Dates

    Payroll tax payments would be due at the same time personal income tax withholding payments are remitted.

    Making the Election

    Election must be made on or before December 1, to take effect for the immediately succeeding calendar year. Elections made after December 1 would take effect in the second succeeding calendar year.

    If the employer is a corporation, any officer or manager of the employer who is authorized to make the election may do so.

    New York Wages

    The payroll tax applies to payments made to those employees who are currently subject to New York withholding on their wages; accordingly, the payroll tax would apply to payments made to New York State nonresident employees. The statute is unclear, however, as to whether withholding would have to be paid only on that portion of a nonresident’s wages that are earned in New York.

    The law imposes the payroll tax on the “payroll expenses” paid to all “covered employees.” This lack of clarity as to wages that are subject to the tax arises from the definition of covered employee and the lack of any defining limitation on payroll expenses that are subject to the tax. A “covered employee” is defined as any person for whom the employer is required to withhold New York taxes from wages, meaning that the employer would need to pay the tax for wages paid to nonresidents with any New York source income earned from the employer.

    “Payroll expenses,” however, are defined without a limitation for New York source income as follows: “Payroll expense means wages and compensation as defined in sections 3121 and 3231 of the internal revenue code (without regard to section 3121(a)(1) and section 3231(e)(2)(A)(i)), paid to all covered employees.” This definition makes sense for a New Jersey resident who works in New York and earns all of his or her wages in New York. However, it is unclear how this provision would apply to, for example, a Virginia resident that earns 50 percent of his or her wages from New York and 50 percent from Virginia. The state could arguably assert that the payroll tax applies to all of that employee’s wages, although this likely was not the intent.

    Because “covered employees” are defined as those for whom the employer is required to withhold for New York purposes, employers would not be required to pay the tax for payments to nonresident employees earning none of their income in New York. For example, an employer would not be required to pay the tax for a Virginia employee earning all of his or her wages in Virginia.

    Nonresidents

    Employees who are nonresidents of New York State may not get any benefit from the payroll tax because their state of residence may not provide a credit against the personal income tax for the payroll tax paid to New York State by the employer.

    New York City

    No similar New York City payroll tax applies.

    Commentary

    Some are speculating that it would be expensive for a company to elect to pay the payroll tax and that therefore the provision may be difficult to implement. Consequently, few employers may choose to opt in to the payroll tax. One possibility would be to place a small group of employees in a separate corporation or limited liability company and have that entity make the election. The election appears to be made on a separate entity basis, even for members of combined return groups.

    Authors

    Richard C. Call

    Partner

    Boston, New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • Cryptocurrencies & State Tax: Transactions with Virtual Currency

    Cryptocurrencies & State Tax: Transactions with Virtual Currency

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Cryptocurrencies & State Tax: Transactions with Virtual Currency

    April 18, 2018

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    To date, limited guidance on the taxation of cryptocurrencies has been released by tax authorities. Usage of cryptocurrencies in transactions creates significant ramifications concerning the determination of federal and state and local tax liabilities. While questions surround the tax treatment of the purchase and sale of cryptocurrencies for US dollars or other government-backed currencies, this article focuses on the state tax treatment of transactions where cryptocurrencies are used to pay for goods and services.

    In depth

    Recently, there has been much discussion regarding cryptocurrencies, particularly given their significant fluctuations in value and the increased level of governmental scrutiny. Uncertainties notwithstanding, usage of cryptocurrencies in transactions creates significant ramifications concerning the determination of federal and state and local tax liabilities. While questions surround the tax treatment of the purchase and sale of cryptocurrencies for US dollars or other government-backed currencies, this article focuses on the state tax treatment of transactions where cryptocurrencies are used to pay for goods and services.

    To date, limited guidance on the taxation of cryptocurrencies has been released by tax authorities. At the federal level, the IRS published a six-page Notice in March 2014 (Notice 2014-21). The Notice generally provides that cryptocurrencies that are designed to be used as a means of exchange are treated as property and not “currency” for US federal income tax purposes. The significant consequence of this treatment is that the use of cryptocurrency in purchasing an item is treated as a sale or exchange of the cryptocurrency, resulting in taxable gain or loss to the purchaser. This article does not discuss whether pre-Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, exchanges of cryptocurrency for another cryptocurrency could potentially be treated as tax-free like-kind exchanges under Code section 1031.

    In addition to the IRS guidance that has been issued, several states have opined on the sales tax treatment of cryptocurrencies. For instance, in March 2014, New York State (NYS) declared that purchases of taxable goods and services using cryptocurrencies should be treated as barter transactions, with the cryptocurrencies considered intangible property (New York Technical Service Bureau Memorandum No. TSB-M-14(5)C, 12/05/2014).

    Ordinarily, for NYS sales tax purposes a barter transaction between two parties is treated as two separate sale transactions. Each party is considered a seller and required to collect sales tax from the counterparty—who is considered a buyer—based on the value of the property or services received from the counterparty. However, a seller is not required to collect sales tax on the provision of intangible property to a counterparty (20 NYCRR 526.7(d)). Because NYS considers cryptocurrencies to be intangible property, there would be no sales tax collection requirement from the party exchanging cryptocurrencies in exchange for goods or services.

    Consider this example. Suppose an individual provides a pen to an associate, in exchange for which the associate provides a notebook to the individual. NYS considers the initiating individual to have sold the pen to his associate and requires the individual to collect sales tax on the “sale” of the pen. NYS also considers the associate to have sold the notebook to the individual and requires him to collect sales tax on the “sale” of the notebook. (In a traditional buyer-seller relationship where goods or services are exchanged for cash, only the seller of goods or services is required to collect sales tax; the cash-paying buyer has no requirement to collect sales tax on the money provided to the seller).

    In a deemed barter transaction, however, if the associate were to provide cryptocurrency to the seller in exchange for the seller’s pen, only the seller and not the associate would be required to collect and remit sales tax on the transaction because the sale of the cryptocurrency would be considered the sale of an intangible asset that is not subject to sales tax.

    Considering the issue from a sales tax compliance perspective, NYS requires a seller that makes sales in NYS and accepts cryptocurrencies in lieu of cash to:

    • Register for sales tax purposes;
    • Record the value of the cryptocurrency accepted at the time of each transaction, in US dollars;
    • Record the amount of sales tax collected at the time of each transaction, in US dollars; and
    • Report such sales and remit any sales tax due in US dollars when filing its periodic sales tax returns

    While the federal income tax and state sales tax consequences described above appear to be relatively straightforward, there remain many tax-related concerns regarding transactions involving cryptocurrencies.

    First, a business that decides to accept cryptocurrencies as payment for products will likely need to review its sales and use tax collection procedures and processes. In a typical cash-based transaction, sales and use tax is collected as cash and deposited into a bank account from which it is later withdrawn and remitted to the state or locality.

    Where cryptocurrency is accepted in a transaction, the seller must consider the intermediate step of converting the cryptocurrency to cash (or making sure that the company has enough cash to cover its tax liabilities if there is no conversion or if conversion cannot happen quickly enough) to enable it to remit the sales tax. Sellers must be able to assess the value of the cryptocurrency at the time of the transaction for sales and income tax purposes. Sellers must also maintain records reflecting the dollar value of the amount of tax collected for purposes of determining the appropriate amount of tax remitted. It is important to note that conversion of a cryptocurrency into cash in order to pay sales taxes would be viewed as a sale of the cryptocurrency for income tax purposes, producing taxable gain or loss. The passage of time between a sale and the remittance of the tax due could cause significant financial implications to sellers if the value of that cryptocurrency fluctuates during that time period.

    Second, businesses that accept cryptocurrencies as payment will need to determine how to refund purchase amounts to customers. Presumably, refunds would be expected to be based on the dollar value of the cryptocurrencies as of the time of the initial sale. But if refunds are expected to be given in cryptocurrency, is the refund treated as a new barter transaction resulting in additional tax consequences?

    Third, companies generating receipts from holding or transacting in cryptocurrency will need to review how to characterize those receipts for state income tax purposes, as business or non-business receipts. Similar issues have been raised in other industries where assets have been held to hedge against fluctuations in materials used in the business (See General Mills, Inc. et. al. v. Franchise Tax Board, 1st District Appellate Court, Dkt. A 131477, August 31, 2012).

    Finally, outside of the tax arena, businesses that accept and retain cryptocurrencies as payment should review any obligations that they may have as money transmitters, or as businesses engaged in the business of buying and selling cryptocurrencies, in addition to other legal or regulatory requirements. Visit McDermott’s Fintech and Blockchain page to see how our Firm has assisted clients with cryptocurrency issues and with blockchain technology.

    Authors
    More insights

  • The Free Partnership Company: An Effective Investment Tool for Managers in LMBOs?

    The Free Partnership Company: An Effective Investment Tool for Managers in LMBOs?

    ARTICLE

    The Free Partnership Company: An Effective Investment Tool for Managers in LMBOs?

    April 18, 2018

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Carole Degonse and Henri Pieyre de Mandiargues authored this bylined article about how the free partnership company, a type of alternative investment fund, can help managers and business leaders accomplish their goals.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • OCIE Issues Risk Alert on Fees and Expenses

    OCIE Issues Risk Alert on Fees and Expenses

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    OCIE Issues Risk Alert on Fees and Expenses

    April 17, 2018

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On April 12, 2018, the Office of Compliance Inspections and Examinations (“OCIE”) of the SEC released a National Exam Program Risk Alert identifying several issues relating to fees and expenses charged to clients by SEC-registered investment advisers.

    Fees and expenses have been a consistent focus of SEC examinations and enforcement actions for the past several years, and the Risk Alert highlights how important these issues are to OCIE. In particular, it identifies several common types of deficiencies with respect to fees and expenses. Some involve mistakes in calculations while others involve the interpretation of disclosure language and the implementation of allocation methodologies. Private fund advisers should view the Risk Alert as an impetus to (i) review their policies and practices with respect to advisory fees and expenses; (ii) confirm and document that their practices are consistent with their compliance policies and with disclosures made to clients and investors; and (iii) prepare for the requests and questions regarding fees and expenses that are likely to come up during an OCIE examination. Advisers also should try and identify possible weaknesses in their processes and evaluate the efficacy of their procedural checks and balances.

    The Risk Alert covers several areas that are of significance to private fund advisers, some of which are highlighted below.

    Valuation

    OCIE noted a number of frequent deficiencies in advisers’ valuation of client assets, often resulting in inflated advisory fees. Specifically, OCIE cites two common types of valuation deficiencies:

    • Advisers using a metric that differs from that which was disclosed (e.g., valuing an illiquid asset at cost rather than at fair market value); and
    • Advisers valuing assets using a process other than that which was disclosed (e.g., using market value at the end of a cycle rather than using an average daily balance).

    This is consistent with our experience advising clients in SEC examinations, where OCIE staff often requests materials related to an adviser’s valuation process, including valuation policies and procedures, valuation committee documentation (e.g., charters, agendas, meeting minutes and resolutions) and materials related to services performed by independent third-party valuation firms. OCIE staff frequently compares these materials against disclosures made to clients and investors to confirm whether internal practices align with the disclosures. In certain situations, OCIE staff will also examine the rigor of an adviser’s valuation process in order to address whether the adviser is fulfilling its fiduciary duties, even when valuation processes are consistent with applicable disclosures.

    Disclosure

    The Risk Alert identifies issues related to inconsistencies between advisory fee billing practices and disclosures made in the adviser’s Form ADV, as well as failures to disclose additional fees, fee-sharing arrangements or other sources of compensation. Specifically, OCIE notes instances where advisers did not disclose:

    • Fee-sharing arrangements with affiliates;
    • Compensation on asset purchases; and
    • Collection of brokerage expenses exceeding the cost for those services.

    During examinations, OCIE staff often compares fee disclosures (both in the Form ADV and in the fund offering documents) against actual billing practices. It is, therefore, important to routinely benchmark an adviser’s billing practices, which can change over time.

    Expense Allocations

    The Risk Alert reiterates the importance of allocating expenses to clients in accordance with applicable disclosure documents and, in particular, notes misallocations of:

    • Marketing expenses;
    • Regulatory filing fees; and
    • Travel expenses incurred by advisory personnel.

    OCIE notes that this has been a particular area of concern for advisers to private funds.

    OCIE staff has consistently inquired about these issues during the course of examinations, including asking to interview accounting personnel to review the expense payment process, requesting expense policies and any expense allocation matrices and comparing expense allocation disclosure provided to clients against actual practices. Maintaining an up-to-date expense matrix and including expense testing as part of the annual compliance review are helpful practices to prepare for OCIE’s questions during examination.

    OCIE also seeks to understand advisers’ financial relationships with third parties and service providers, often asking for information regarding relationships with consultants, joint ventures and other businesses in which the adviser or its personnel have an interest, to determine any undisclosed sources of compensation. To the extent that any third parties are affiliated with (or have commercial or financial ties with) an adviser, these relationships should be scrutinized in advance of an examination, and any changes to the adviser’s disclosures implemented.

    Substantive Review

    OCIE is also focused on mistakes in the financial calculation process. The Risk Alert highlighted examples of mistaken implementation and poor internal controls that can lead to improper charges to client accounts, including:

    • Improper billing frequency;
    • Failing to apply fee rebates and discounts; and
    • Applying incorrect fee rates.

    On examination, OCIE staff frequently requests data used in fee calculations and will “check the math” on the adviser’s calculations.

    This OCIE Risk Alert is a reminder of the SEC’s ongoing focus on fees and expenses, and the continued deficiencies OCIE finds. Compliance in this area requires detailed analysis of the relevant disclosures and practices, as well as an ongoing review.


    Authored by Marc E. Elovitz and Brian T. Daly.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your lawyer or one of the authors.

    In depth
    Authors

    Marc E. Elovitz

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • States Should Decouple From New Business Interest Expense Limit

    ARTICLE

    States Should Decouple From New Business Interest Expense Limit

    April 16, 2018

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Kathleen Quinn contributed to State Tax Notes discussing whether the States should decouple from new business interest expense limit

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • The New Rules for Taxing CFC Income

    ARTICLE

    The New Rules for Taxing CFC Income

    April 13, 2018

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Lowell Yoder wrote this bylined article on the modified rules for taxing US shareholders on income earned by a controlled foreign corporation (CFC). “A significant new inclusion rule was added that subjects to current U.S. taxation 50% of a CFC’s remaining income over a routine return on depreciable tangible assets,” Mr. Yoder wrote.

    In depth
    Authors

    Lowell D. Yoder

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights