ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
Expected Legislation Amending CFIUS Will Affect a Broad Range of Foreign Investments in US Businesses
July 11, 2018
Read time: 6 min
In response to increasing concerns about foreign investment and access to sensitive US technology, particularly by Chinese investors, the US Senate and House of Representatives recently passed slightly different versions of a bill, the Foreign Investment Risk Review Modernization Act (FIRRMA).
This legislation will update and expand the role of the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States (CFIUS) in reviewing possible US national security implications of acquisitions and investments in US businesses by foreign parties. House and Senate conferees will now meet to form a single bill, which is expected to pass into law with firm support from the Trump administration.
Parties to transactions involving foreign investment in US business are well advised to consider the impact of FIRRMA’s amendments to the CFIUS process.
A bipartisan group from the US Senate and the House of Representatives introduced legislation in 2017 to update and expand the role of the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States (CFIUS) in reviewing possible US national security implications of acquisitions and investments in US businesses by foreign parties. Congress has continued to debate and refine the legislation, known as the Foreign Investment Risk Review Modernization Act (FIRRMA). Riding a wave of increased scrutiny surrounding foreign investment and access to sensitive technology in US businesses, particularly by Chinese investors, a version of FIRRMA passed the Senate on June 18, 2018. A slightly different FIRRMA bill passed the House of Representatives on June 26, 2018, with significant bipartisan support. House and Senate conferees will now meet to form a single bill, which is expected to pass into law with firm support from the Trump administration. FIRRMA will impact a wide range of new foreign acquisitions and investments in the United States.
Parties to transactions involving foreign investment in US business are well advised to consider the impact of FIRRMA’s amendments to the CFIUS process.
Both versions of FIRRMA would broaden the scope of CFIUS’s jurisdiction to include review of any investment (other than passive investment) by a foreign person in any US critical technology business, including:
- Emerging or breakthrough technologies;
- Real estate transactions with access to air, land (i.e. border crossings), or sea ports or with proximity to sensitive US government facilities;
- Bankruptcy and other default transactions;
- Existing investments under which a foreign stakeholder has gained rights of control or influence over the US entity; and
- Any other investments which CFIUS deems designed to evade CFIUS review.
The House bill would additionally require CFIUS to review transactions allowing a foreign investor to influence or gain access to sensitive personal information of US citizens.
While the new versions of FIRRMA would significantly expand CFIUS’s authority, certain limitations would be introduced as well. Under the Senate’s version, CFIUS could exempt from review transactions in which all foreign investors involved are from “friendly countries” (i.e., countries that have shared security interests with the US and effective review processes to safeguard them, NATO member countries and major non-NATO allies, and countries that adhere to nonproliferation control means). The Senate bill would also expand the definition of “passive” investments (which are exempt from CFIUS oversight) to include transactions involving investment funds with non-controlling foreign investors.
Both current versions of FIRRMA removed language included in the original draft of the FIRRMA bill that would have allowed CFIUS to review licensing and joint venture transactions with foreign parties for the transfer of US intellectual property.
For FIRRMA to become law, the two houses of Congress must agree on an identical version of the bill, and President Trump must sign it. The president has stated that he expects Congress to pass “strong FIRRMA legislation that better protects the crown jewels of American technology and intellectual property from transfers and acquisitions that threaten our national security—and future economic prosperity.” However, if Congress does not pass a bill, or if it passes a bill that does not contain language sufficiently strong in the eyes of the administration, then President Trump may seek to impose additional foreign investment restrictions.
Specifically, the president has raised the possibility of imposing restrictions under Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974 (Section 301) on China’s laws, policies, and practices relating to technology transfer, intellectual property, and innovation. Section 301 grants authority to “investigate foreign trade practices and take action to compel another country to eliminate unfair, unreasonable or discriminatory practices that burden US commerce.” On March 22, 2018, President Trump issued a Memorandum directing the Secretary of Treasury to report within 60 days regarding measures “to address concerns about investment in the United States directed or facilitated by China in industries or technologies deemed important to the United States,” including “options for new investment restrictions using ‘any available statutory authority.’” The investment restrictions were expected to target China’s key sectors, including information technology, aerospace, marine engineer, pharmaceuticals, advanced energy vehicles, robotics and other technologies.
On June 27, 2018, President Trump announced that he would not enforce new investment restrictions against China under Section 301, provided that Congress passes FIRRMA. It remains to be seen whether any final version of FIRRMA will impose restrictions stringent enough to satisfy the president and forestall additional China-specific restrictions pursuant to Section 301.
Companies planning transactions or investments pursuant to which a foreign (non-US) party would acquire an interest in a US business should carefully consider and take appropriate steps to address whether/how the deal would be treated by CFIUS, as amended by FIRRMA. Such consideration would be particularly important in the case of a Chinese investment.

SEC Approves Rule Amendments That Expand the Number of Public Companies That Qualify for Smaller Reporting Company Scaled Disclosures
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
SEC Approves Rule Amendments That Expand the Number of Public Companies That Qualify for Smaller Reporting Company Scaled Disclosures
July 9, 2018
Read time: 3 min
On June 28, 2018, the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) adopted rule amendments that raise the thresholds in the “smaller reporting company” definition. Under the amendments, the public float threshold for determining if a company qualifies as a smaller reporting company increased from less than $75 million to less than $250 million. The final rule amendments also expand the smaller reporting company definition to include companies with less than $100 million in annual revenues if they also have either no public float or a public float of less than $700 million. This reflects a change from the prior revenue test, under which companies with no public float and revenue of less than $50 million qualified as smaller reporting companies. The SEC rule amendments will become effective 60 days after publication in the Federal Register.
As a result of the higher thresholds, more companies will be eligible to comply with the current scaled disclosure requirements applicable to smaller reporting companies. The scaled disclosure requirements for smaller reporting companies permit them to, among other things, include in their SEC periodic reports and filings less extensive executive compensation disclosure than required of other reporting companies and provide audited financial statements for two years instead of three. The SEC estimates that an additional 966 companies will be eligible for smaller company reporting status in the first year under the new definition.
The SEC rule amendments do not change the threshold in the “accelerated filer” definition in Rule 12b-2 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 that requires filers to provide the auditor’s attestation of management’s assessment of internal control over financial reporting as required by Section 404(b) of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002. Consequently, companies with $75 million or more of public float that qualify as smaller reporting companies will remain subject to the requirements that apply to accelerated filers, including the timing of the filing of periodic reports and the requirement that accelerated filers provide the auditor’s attestation required by Section 404(b) of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act.
An Analytic Approach to Patents
ARTICLE
An Analytic Approach to Patents
July 6, 2018
Read time: 2 min
Ahsan Shaikh authored this bylined article on how data-driven decision-making can help software companies facing uncertain patent applications and outcomes. “With patents on software being harder to obtain than at any time in recent history, patent analytics provide an important additional data point to help companies make more informed and successful decisions with respect to their software patents,” he wrote.

DOL Fiduciary Duty Rule Officially Dead
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
DOL Fiduciary Duty Rule Officially Dead
July 5, 2018
Read time: 3 min
It’s official – after months of uncertainty, the DOL regulation that expanded the definition of who is a fiduciary in the context of marketing investment products to Individual Retirement Accounts and ERISA-covered pension plans (“Fiduciary Rule”) died at the end of June 2018.
In March 2018, relying on the Administrative Procedures Act, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit issued a judgment in Chamber of Commerce of the U.S. v. U.S. Dep’t. of Labor, No. 17-10238, 2018 U.S. App. LEXIS 6472 (5th Cir. Mar. 15, 2018) vacating the Fiduciary Rule. Because the deadline for petitioning either the Fifth Circuit for a rehearing or the Supreme Court for a review has passed, the Fiduciary Rule is effectively vacated from the books.
Many private fund managers have been complying with the Fiduciary Rule since it went into effect on June 9, 2017, by requiring IRAs and ERISA plans to make certain representations drawn from the Fiduciary Rule prior to investing. Now that the Fiduciary Rule is no more, these managers should remove the Supplement to the Subscription Agreement, ERISA Representations and Warranties (available here) that we distributed in June 2017 from their subscription agreements, as it is no longer required. Accordingly, fund managers should no longer feel constrained when marketing fund interests to unrepresented IRAs and retail ERISA plans.
While the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission has proposed a rule to address the standard applicable to securities recommendations by broker-dealers, unlike the now-defunct DOL Fiduciary Rule, the SEC’s proposed “Regulation Best Interest” would apply only to funds offered by a registered broker-dealer to retail customers primarily for personal, family or household purposes.
Authored by David M. Cohen, Ian L. Levin and Melissa J. Sandak.
If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.
This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2018 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.
All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.
ABA Books Provide Tools and Resources
ARTICLE
ABA Books Provide Tools and Resources
July 2, 2018
Read time: 2 min
Byron Kalogerou co-authored “Using Legal Project Management in Merger and Acquisition Transactions,” a guide for planning, managing and executing M&A transactions published by the American Bar Association.
Cartels 2019
ARTICLE
Cartels 2019
July 2, 2018
Read time: 1 min
Joel Chefitz, Stefan Meisner, Mary Strimel and Chelsea Black authored the 2019 Chambers USA Cartel Practice Guide.

AI & Machine Learning Is Shaping the Future of Healthcare Delivery
ARTICLE
AI & Machine Learning Is Shaping the Future of Healthcare Delivery
June 27, 2018
Read time: 2 min
Dale Van Demark authored this bylined article on legal and regulatory issues related to the adoption of artificial intelligence and machine learning in the health care industry. “As technology’s disruption of traditional healthcare continues, organizations must be aware of and prepared for the implications of digital health innovation—mitigating risk to ensure compliance and a strong foundation for growth,” he wrote.

IP Update, Vol. 21, No. 6
ARTICLE
IP Update, Vol. 21, No. 6
June 2018
Read time: 1 min
Dive into the June 2018 issue of IP Update: Vol. 21, No. 6
DOL Reacts to Fifth Circuit Ruling Vacating Expansion of Fiduciary Rule
ARTICLE
DOL Reacts to Fifth Circuit Ruling Vacating Expansion of Fiduciary Rule
June 2018
Read time: 2 min
Chris Nemeth, Brian Tiemann and Samantha Souza wrote this bylined article about the Department of Labor’s guidance following the Fifth Circuit ruling to strike down the New Fiduciary Rule and the possibility of the SEC developing its own regulations. “Plan sponsors should continue to follow developments related to the enforceability of the New Fiduciary Rule and the SEC’s proposed fiduciary regulations,” they said.

Compliant Structures for Securities Offerings of Blockchain Tokens
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
Compliant Structures for Securities Offerings of Blockchain Tokens
June 26, 2018
Read time: 10 min
Proceeds from ICOs topped $5 billion in 2017, $1 billion of which originated in the United States. Since blockchain technology has a variety of applications and blockchain tokens may have a variety of characteristics, it is important to be aware of potential options for structuring sales of tokens that constitute securities offerings in compliance with US securities laws.
Proceeds from blockchain token sales (popularly known as initial coin offerings or “ICOs”) reportedly topped $5 billion in 2017, with approximately $1 billion of such offerings originating in the United States (EY research: initial coin offerings [ICOs] [Dec. 2017]). Blockchain technology has a variety of potential applications, and blockchain tokens may have a variety of characteristics. For example, some blockchain tokens may function as a virtual currency, or as a license or right to receive a good or service or to use certain software. Even traditional assets like real estate or stock in a company may be “tokenized.” Depending on the characteristics of the token and the manner in which the token is sold, the US securities laws may be applicable.
Under the Securities Act of 1933 (the Securities Act) and the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (the Exchange Act), the definition of a security includes an investment contract. Supreme Court decisions dating back to SEC v. W. J. Howey, 328 US 293 (1946), define an investment contract as an investment of money in a common enterprise premised on a reasonable expectation of profits to be derived from the entrepreneurial or managerial efforts of others. As first noted in the DAO Token Report, and recently reiterated by the US Securities and Exchange Commission’s (the SEC’s) Director of the Division of Corporation Finance, the Howey test is often applied to determine whether a blockchain token sale is a securities offering.
Barring an applicable exemption, Section 5(a) of the Securities Act prohibits the sale of securities in interstate commerce unless a registration statement containing the required disclosure has been filed with the SEC and become effective. The surge in ICOs has been accompanied by regulatory scrutiny over whether ICOs constitute securities offerings, and must therefore comply with federal securities registration requirements or be exempt therefrom. For example, in June 2018, the SEC created a new advisory position to coordinate efforts across all SEC Divisions and Offices regarding the application of US securities laws to emerging digital asset technologies and innovations, including initial coin offerings and cryptocurrencies.
This article discusses potential options for structuring sales of tokens that constitute securities offerings in compliance with US securities laws.
Exemptions from Registration
Regulation D and Regulation S
Issuers looking to offer securities to investors without registration typically utilize one of two exemptions from registration under the Securities Act: Regulation D and Regulation S. Under Regulation D, issuers may offer securities without registration in a “private placement,” as long as the offering complies with the provisions of Rule 506 of the Securities Act. Under Rule 506(c), an issuer may even broadly solicit and generally advertise an offering and still be deemed in compliance with Regulation D, so long as all purchasers are “accredited investors,” as defined by SEC rules, and the issuer takes reasonable steps to verify that each purchaser is in fact an accredited investor. Under Regulation S, issuers may offer securities to non-US investors in offshore transactions without registration, as long as the offering complies with the provisions of Rule 903 of the Securities Act.
Both Regulation D and Regulation S offer issuers a relatively quick and straightforward route to selling an unlimited number of securities to investors in compliance with the Securities Act. However, both of these routes have their own shortcomings. Because Regulation D and Regulation S are exemptions from registration, investors who purchase securities in such offerings will receive “restricted” securities that are not easily resold absent compliance with the requirements of Rule 144 of the Securities Act. In addition, issuers are limited in the types of investors to whom they can sell the security. In a Regulation D offering, securities generally may only be sold to “accredited” investors who meet certain income or net worth thresholds. In a Regulation S offering, securities may only be sold to non-US investors in offerings conducted outside the United States and, depending on the issuer, resale restrictions may be required to limit “flow back” into the United States. For issuers looking to sell tokens to a larger investor base, both of these may be disqualifying limitations.
Regulation A+
One potential alternative is for issuers to sell securities pursuant to Regulation A under the Securities Act by filing a Form 1-A for review and qualification with the SEC. Prior to July 2015, Regulation A was a rarely used exemption from registration, as it limited sales to $5 million in a 12 month period. However, following the implementation of the Jumpstart Our Business Startups (JOBS) Act-mandated amendments to Regulation A on July 19, 2015 (frequently referred to as Regulation A+), Regulation A has become a much more attractive option for issuers. Because of the limitations inherent in utilizing the Regulation D and S exemptions, issuers should consider Regulation A. Several companies have filed Forms 1-A for token offerings, though to our knowledge, none has yet been qualified by the SEC.
Regulation A+ permits most non-public US and Canadian companies to sell up to $50 million of securities in a 12 month period without registration. Offerings made pursuant to Regulation A are often referred to as “mini IPOs,” as they are public offerings that can be made using general solicitation and advertising. Before an issuer may offer securities under Regulation A, it must first file an offering statement on Form 1-A with the SEC, which includes an offering circular (OC) for distribution to investors. This is similar to filing a registration statement in a registered offering. Form 1-A filings are subject to review and comment by the SEC. Once the SEC has reviewed a Form 1-A offering statement, an issuer will receive a “notice of qualification” and it may commence its offering.
Subject to compliance with certain conditions, an issuer may “test the waters,” both prior to and after filing a Form 1-A. However, an issuer may not sell any securities until the offering has been qualified by the SEC, and any testing the waters communications must include a legend that complies with the requirements of Rule 255 of Regulation A.
Regulation A includes two offering tiers: Tier 1, which provides an exemption for offerings of up to $20 million in a 12 month period, including up to $6 million of secondary sales by affiliates; and Tier 2, which provides an exemption for offerings of up to $50 million in a 12 month period, including up to $15 million of secondary sales by affiliates. Because of the larger offering size permitted by Tier 2, the requirements for conducting a Tier 2 offering are significantly more stringent than for a Tier 1 offering.
Companies that conduct a Tier 1 offering are required to file up to two years of unaudited financial statements. They must also file an exit report on Form 1-Z upon the termination or completion of an offering. However, there are no other ongoing reporting requirements for Tier 1 companies.
In contrast, companies that conduct a Tier 2 offering must provide up to two years of audited financial statements. Like Tier 1 companies, Tier 2 companies must file exit reports on Form 1-Z; however, Tier 2 companies are also subject to ongoing reporting requirements similar to reporting companies, and are required to file annual, semi-annual and current event reports with the SEC, similar to Forms 10-K, 10-Q and 8-K, respectively, that reporting companies are required to file.
However, there are many benefits to conducting a Tier 2 offering as opposed to a Tier 1 offering. Tier 2 offerings are exempt from state registration and qualification requirements (i.e., state blue sky laws), a major change from the old Regulation A regime. In addition, Regulation A contains a condition exemption from Exchange Act registration for Tier 2 issuers who are subject to, and current in, their Regulation A periodic reporting obligations, even if an offering might otherwise take them over the threshold for registration. Alternatively, an issuer may utilize a simplified process for entering Exchange Act-reporting company status when they complete a Tier 2 offering, streamlining the process for listing securities on the NYSE or NASDAQ.
Regardless of the offering tier, another key benefit to sales under Regulation A is that, unlike sales made pursuant to Regulation D and Regulation S, securities sold in reliance on Regulation A are not restricted securities. This means that they may generally be freely resold by non-affiliates of the issuer.
Registered Offerings
Preparing for and executing a registered offering is the initial step in becoming a public company. It is intensive and time-consuming and requires issuers to wade through the registration process administered by the SEC, which has discretion over whether or not a registration statement will be declared effective.
Although all offerings and issuers are different, the basic process of “going public” is relatively consistent. In addition to putting in place corporate governance structures and policies and processes that comply with securities laws, an issuer conducting a registered offering must file a registration statement with the SEC containing a prospectus with financial statements and detailed disclosures about the issuer, the issuer’s business and the offering. Most issuers undertaking a registered offering will need to file a registration statement on Form S-1 or, in the case of foreign private issuers, on Form F-1. Typically, within 30 days after an initial or amended registration statement is filed, the SEC will review and provide comments on it (though with a coin offering, the initial response may take longer). Then, an issuer attempts to resolve the issues raised in the SEC comments by responding to the SEC in writing and amending the registration statement. Once an issuer has satisfactorily resolved all of the SEC’s comments, the SEC will declare a registration statement effective, and only then may the issuer commence the registered offering.
The benefit of a registered ICO is that it permits an issuer to sell securities to all types of investors, and there is no limit to the amount of money that may be raised. In addition, registered securities may be freely resold and traded. Compared to conducting an exempt offering however, a registered offering involves extensive regulatory requirements and is significantly more expensive due to increased filing, legal and accounting fees. Additionally, an issuer will become a full reporting company, and therefore will be required to file periodic reports disclosing financial and other material information about the issuer’s business and operations. The challenges of undertaking a registered offering, including the relatively higher cost and perceived difficulty of successfully shepherding the registration statement through the SEC comment process, may be why most security token offerings to date have relied on an exemption from the registration requirements of the Securities Act.
Conclusion
Depending on the characteristics of the token and the manner in which the token is sold, a token sale may be a security offering requiring registration or an exemption therefrom. Notwithstanding the technological development represented by blockchain tokens, the test enunciated more than 70 years ago in SEC v. W.J. Howey Co. remains the standard for gauging whether the sale of a blockchain token represents an investment contract subject to the US securities laws. Issuers contemplating a token sale should consider whether the securities laws will apply to their token sale and, if so, which of the offering structures best suit their goals. Although many issuers have utilized the exemptions from registration provided by Regulation D and Regulation S to sell securities, these exemptions are subject to numerous limitations. As a result, issuers seeking to sell securities to a broader investor base with greater liquidity for secondary transactions may find that Regulation A+ or a registered offering is a more attractive option for them.
The authors would like to acknowledge and thank Daniel Engoren, Verity Van Tassel Richards, Joseph Williams and former McDermott associate Robert Stelton-Swan for their contributions to this article.