Content Type: Article

  • Recent Developments in Tax Law: European Court of Justice on the Restructuring Clause: Annulment of the Commission Decision

    ARTICLE

    Recent Developments in Tax Law: European Court of Justice on the Restructuring Clause: Annulment of the Commission Decision

    August 2018

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Dr. Gero Burwitz authored the article “Recent Development in Tax Law: European Court of Justice on the Restructuring Clause: Annulment of the Commission Decision”, featured in Neue Zeitschrift für Gesellschaftsrecht (NZG), p. 978-980 in August, 2018.

    In depth
    Authors

    Dr. Gero Burwitz

    Partner

    Munich

    More insights

  • An Intro to Distribution Agreements

    ARTICLE

    An Intro to Distribution Agreements

    Summer 2018

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • What’s Next After the Affordable Care Act?

    What’s Next After the Affordable Care Act?

    ARTICLE

    What’s Next After the Affordable Care Act?

    August 5, 2018

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Gary Scott Davis authored this bylined article about the future of the Affordable Care Act (ACA). “We need to learn from both the strengths and weaknesses of the ACA to build a long-term sustainable approach that promotes access to care, brings insurance coverage within the reach of the many, contains costs, and aligns economic incentives among payors, providers and patients, while improving the nation’s overall level of health,” he wrote.

    In depth
    Authors

    Gary Scott Davis PA

    Senior Counsel

    Miami

    More insights

  • Responding to Fed. Circ.’s Latest Patent Damages Test

    ARTICLE

    Responding to Fed. Circ.’s Latest Patent Damages Test

    August 2, 2018

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Amol Parikh co-authored this bylined article on the implications of Power Integrations v. Fairchild, in which the US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit took a narrow view of the entire market value rule. “Given the stricter ‘sole driver of demand’ requirement outlined in Power Integrations, we might expect district courts to be increasingly wary of allowing entire products to be used as the royalty base,” the authors wrote.

    In depth

    This article was originally published in Law360 on August 2, 2018.

    The Federal Circuit’s position on apportionment in reasonable royalty damages has been a moving target for several years now. The latest juke comes in Power Integrations v. Fairchild,[1], where the court vacated a $140 million jury verdict, taking a narrow view of the entire market value rule and finding that the royalty base should have been reduced to account for nonpatented features. Although the ruling appears to raise the bar on using an entire product as the royalty base, other recent decisions appear to relax requirements for certain plaintiffs or even provide an alternate path to the same damages figure.

    Power Integrations and Fairchild both manufacture power supply controller chips used in chargers for electronic devices, such as cellphones and laptops. Power Integrations owns a patent directed to switching regulators that direct power delivery and sued Fairchild asserting infringement of that patent. At trial, a jury had awarded Power Integrations $140 million in damages.[2] Fairchild appealed.

    On appeal, Fairchild argued the damages award should be vacated because it used the entire controller chip as the royalty base. Power Integrations countered that its expert properly used the entire controller chip as the royalty base since the entire market value rule had been met because:

    The patented feature was essential to some customers;
    Some customers asked for the patented feature;
    Products with the patented feature outsold products without the patented feature; and
    Technical marketing materials promoted the patented feature.

    The Federal Circuit agreed with Fairchild and vacated the damages award, noting that both parties agreed that the accused products contained other valuable features, including jittering, the subject of a separate lawsuit over different patents. The court ultimately concluded that Power Integrations “did not meet its burden to show that the patented feature was the sole driver of consumer demand, i.e. that it alone motivated consumers to buy the accused products.”

    The Federal Circuit explained that “the entire market value rule is appropriate only when the patented feature is the sole driver of customer demand or substantially creates the value of the component parts,” citing the court’s prior rulings in LaserDynamics,[3] Versata[4] and VirnetX.[5] However, this “sole driver of customer demand” requirement is not found in LaserDynamics, Versata or VirnetX. In LaserDynamics, the court applied a standard of “drives the demand,” or “creates the basis for customer demand,” or that “demand … is attributable to the patented feature.”[6] Versata describes the requirement as “creates the basis for customer demand or substantially creates the value of the component parts.”[7] The court in VirnetX repeated the standard enunciated from Versata.[8] Hence, the court’s new use of “sole driver of customer demand” seems to be a new, more stringent requirement.

    The Federal Circuit further explained that in order to use the broader royalty base under the entire market value rule, “[w]hen the product contains other valuable features, the patentee must prove that those other features did not influence purchasing decisions.” This, too, was not a requirement of LaserDynamics, Versata and VirnetX.

    Certainly the recent Power Integrations decision aligns with the court’s stricter apportionment decisions, as opposed to the more flexible structure from its Ericsson[9] and Exmark[10] rulings. For example, in VirnetX, widely seen as a strict ruling on apportionment, the court ruled that “a patentee’s obligation to apportion damages only to the patented features does not end with the identification of the smallest salable unit if that unit still contains significant unpatented features.” Yet in Ericsson (and the later Exmark), the court seemed to relax this requirement, finding that apportionment could be applied in the royalty rate instead of the base, or a combination thereof. However, the apportionment issue addressed by the court in Power Integrations (like VirnetX)[11] was limited to whether or not apportionment was required at all (i.e., had the entire market value rule been met). In Ericsson and Exmark, on the other hand, the patent owners had already acknowledged that apportionment was required, but disputed whether it should be applied to the royalty base or the royalty rate.

    Going forward, patent owners have several possible strategies to deal with this higher bar to meet the entire market value rule. First, as the Federal Circuit ruled in AstraZeneca,[12] a patent owner can show that “the other features are simply generic and/or conventional and hence of little distinguishing character.” In these instances, “it may be appropriate to use the entire value of the product because the patented feature accounts for almost all of the value of the product as a whole.”[13]

    Second, the Federal Circuit’s Ericsson and Exmark decisions suggest that a patent owner might succeed in achieving the same damages award, but using a different methodology where it accepts that apportionment is required, but argues that apportionment should be achieved through the royalty rate. In other words, the royalty base would be the entire product, but the royalty rate would be apportioned in some manner. The court ruled in Exmark that apportionment could be applied to the royalty rate (instead of the royalty base) because: (1) the patent covered the entire device at issue, and (2) industry licensing practices suggested a royalty base of the entire device. In applying this methodology, a patent owner would need to show that its royalty rate methodology considered the other features sufficiently enough to be deemed “apportioned,” which Exmark states could be done through a traditional Georgia-Pacific factor analysis.

    Exmark, however, offers little clarity on the standards by which a royalty rate may be considered “apportioned.” The Federal Circuit’s decisions in Ericsson and Mentor Graphics, however, offer practitioners some guidance. In Ericsson, the court found that the expert properly apportioned damages by apportioning the royalty rate (not royalty base) since his analysis “separated the value of the patents at issue from any other patents covered by the licenses he referenced.” Ericsson also describes apportionment in the general sense, not as an arithmetic paring-down necessarily, but rather a process of separating the patented “results distinctly from those of the other parts, so that the benefits derived from it may be distinctly seen and appreciated.”[14] Along those lines, in Mentor Graphics, the court stated that lost profits had been “apportioned” not by dividing or reducing them, but rather by virtue of the Panduit factor analysis that entails a market reconstruction and consideration of the unpatented features.[15]

    Given the stricter “sole driver of demand” requirement outlined in Power Integrations, we might expect district courts to be increasingly wary of allowing entire products to be used as the royalty base. For now, some patent owners may be able to apply the guidance suggested in Exmark and Ericsson by apportioning damages through the royalty rate, while still using the entire product as the royalty base. It remains to be seen if that option will remain open, and what methods courts will accept for “apportioning” a royalty rate.
    Eric J. Phillips is a damages and valuation consultant at VLF Consulting Inc., where he is president.

    Amol Parikh is a partner at McDermott Will & Emery LLP.

    The opinions expressed are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the firm, its clients, or Portfolio Media Inc., or any of its or their respective affiliates. This article is for general information purposes and is not intended to be and should not be taken as legal advice.

    [1] Power Integrations, Inc. v. Fairchild Semiconductor Int’l., No. 16-2691, 17-1875, slip op. (Fed. Cir. July 3, 2018).

    [2] Power Integrations’ expert based his reasonable royalty damages on (1) expected sales by defendant that plaintiff would lose; (2) expected sales by plaintiff at a lower price given competition (i.e. price erosion); and (3) additional sales by defendant not included in item (1). (see Brief of Plaintiff-Appellee in case 2016-2691, document no. 54, p. 71).

    [3] LaserDynamics, Inc. v. Quanta Computer, Inc., 694 F. 3d 51 (Fed. Cir. 2012).

    [4] Versata Software, Inc. v. SAP America, Inc., 717 F. 3d 1255 (Fed. Cir. 2013).

    [5] VirnetX, Inc. v. Cisco Systems, Inc., 767 F. 3d 1308 (Fed. Cir. 2014).

    [6] LaserDynamics, 694 F.3d at 67-68.

    [7] Versata, 717 F.3d at 1268.

    [8] VirnetX, 767 F.3d at 1326.

    [9] Ericsson, Inc. v. D-Link Systems, Inc., 773 F.3d 1201 (Fed. Cir. 2014).

    [10] Exmark Manufacturing Company Inc. v. Briggs & Stratton Power Products Group, LLC, 879 F.3d 1332 (Fed. Cir. Jan. 12, 2018).

    [11] In VirnetX, the expert “did not even attempt to subtract any other unpatented elements from the base…” and “failed to apportion value between the patented features and the vast number of non-patented features …” VirnetX, 767 F.3d at 1328-1329.

    [12] AstraZeneca AB v. Apotex Corp., 782 F.3d 1324, 1338-40 (Fed. Cir. 2015).

    Authors

    Amol Parikh

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • OCC Begins Accepting Fintech Charter Applications

    OCC Begins Accepting Fintech Charter Applications

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    OCC Begins Accepting Fintech Charter Applications

    August 1, 2018

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On July 31, 2018, the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (“OCC”) issued a news release announcing that it will begin accepting special purpose national bank (“SPNB”) charter applications from financial technology (“fintech”) companies that do not take deposits but are engaged in the business of lending money or paying checks (including the modern equivalent thereof, which the OCC suggests includes issuing debit cards or otherwise facilitating payments electronically).[1]

    The OCC’s decision was announced shortly after the U.S. Department of the Treasury (“Treasury”) released an extensive report endorsing SPNB charters for fintech companies.[2] In its report, the Treasury “recommend[ed] that the OCC move forward with prudent and carefully considered applications for [SPNB] charters” and noted that fintech companies receiving such a charter “. . . should not be permitted to accept FDIC-insured deposits, to reduce risks to taxpayers.”[3] The Treasury also emphasized the importance that the “. . . [SPNB] charter not provide an undue advantage to newly chartered firms relative to the banks that have operated within the existing regulatory system for years.”[4]

    As part of its announcement, the OCC also published a Policy Statement on Financial Technology Companies’ Eligibility to Apply for National Bank Charters (“Policy Statement”)[5] as well as a supplement to the Comptroller’s Licensing Manual (“Supplement”).[6] In the Policy Statement, which the OCC notes is intended to clarify its “intent to exercise its existing chartering authority,”[7] the OCC explains that, under the National Bank Act, it has broad authority to grant charters for national banks to carry on the “business of banking,” including the authority to grant charters for SPNBs. Because the OCC’s regulations define the “business of banking” to include any of the three core banking functions of taking deposits,[8] paying checks or lending money, the OCC concludes that it “has authority to grant a national bank charter to a fintech company that engages in one or more of those core banking activities.”[9] The Policy Statement also provides an overview of the OCC’s support for responsible innovation in the financial services industry as well as a summary of the chartering standards for applicants and supervisory expectations applicable to fintech company SPNBs.

    The Supplement is a revised version of a draft supplement published in March 2017, and is intended to (i) provide detail on how the OCC would evaluate applications from a fintech company for an SPNB charter; (ii) clarify the OCC’s expectations that fintech SPNBs demonstrate a commitment to financial inclusion; (iii) explain the contingency planning each fintech SPNB will be expected to undertake and (iv) describe the OCC’s approach to supervising newly chartered fintech company SPNBs.[10] The Supplement further provides that fintech SPNBs will be supervised like similarly situated national banks — including with respect to capital, liquidity, financial inclusion commitments and risk management, as appropriate[11] — and that new fintech SPNBs will be subject to heightened supervision at the outset, consistent with longstanding OCC de novo supervision policy.[12]

    The Supplement notes the OCC’s application process for an SPNB consists of four phases:

    1. A prefiling phase, in which potential applicants engage with the OCC in formal and informal meetings to discuss the proposal, the chartering process and application requirements.
    2. The filing phase, in which the organizers submit a complete application.
    3. The review phase, in which the OCC reviews and analyzes the application to assess whether the proposed bank has a reasonable chance of success, will be operated in a safe and sound manner, will provide fair access to financial services, will promote fair treatment of customers, will ensure compliance with laws and regulations, and will foster healthy competition.
    4. The decision phase, in which the OCC decides whether to approve a charter application. The decision phase includes the preliminary conditional approval stage, in which the OCC imposes requirements and conditions for receiving a charter; the organization stage, in which the bank raises capital and prepares for opening; and the final approval stage.[13]

    A fintech company interested in an SPNB charter should contact the Office of Innovation at innovation@occ.treas.gov. While it appears the OCC is prepared to accept applications immediately, there exists the possibility that soon-to-be-filed lawsuits could jeopardize the chartering process in the near term.

    For example, the Conference of State Bank Supervisors (“CSBS”) and the New York State Department of Financial Services (“NYDFS”) each filed lawsuits in 2017 challenging the OCC’s original fintech SPNB charter proposal. In those lawsuits, state regulators argued that the proposal exceeded the OCC’s statutory authority, and that its actions to create a new charter violated both the National Bank Act and the 10th Amendment to the Constitution, which provide that each state retains those sovereign powers not expressly delegated under the Constitution to the federal government. These lawsuits were eventually dismissed due to a lack of ripeness; that is, the cases could not proceed because the OCC had not reached a final fintech SPNB charter decision. However, it is likely that such lawsuits will be refiled in the near future. Immediately following the publication of the Policy Statement and the Supplement, the NYDFS issued a statement re-emphasizing its fierce opposition to a fintech SPNB charter.[14]

    Authored by Donald J. Mosher, Joseph P. Vitale and Adam J. Barazani.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert or would like assistance in engaging with the OCC regarding an SPNB charter, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] See News Release, available here.

    [2] See Report, available here.

    [3] See Id. at p. 73.

    [4] See Id.

    [5] See Policy Statement, available here.

    [6] See Supplement, available here.

    [7] Policy Statement at 2, supra n.5.

    [8] The Supplement, however, clarifies that the definition “SPNB” as used in the Supplement means a fintech company applying for an SPNB charter “. . . that would engage in one of the core banking activities of paying checks or lending money, but would not take deposits and would not be insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC).” Supplement at 2, supra n.6. This is consistent with the March 2017 version of the Supplement.

    [9] Policy Statement at 2, supra n.5.; see also 12 C.F.R. § 5.20.

    [10] Supplement at 1, supra n.6.

    [11] See Id. at 8-10, 15.

    [12] See Id. at 14.

    [13] See Id. at 3-4.

    [14] See Statement, available here (“[NYDFS] also strongly opposes today’s decision by the [OCC] to begin accepting applications for national bank charters from nondepository [fintech] companies. [NYDFS] believes that this endeavor, which is also wrongly supported by the Treasury Department, is clearly not authorized under the National Bank Act. As [NYDFS] has noted since the OCC’s proposal, a national fintech charter will impose an entirely unjustified federal regulatory scheme on an already fully functional and deeply rooted state regulatory landscape”).


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2018 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Donald J. Mosher

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Adam J. Barazani

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • When Shareholders Determine the Remuneration of the Management Board

    ARTICLE

    When Shareholders Determine the Remuneration of the Management Board

    August 1, 2018

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Thomas Gennert authored this bylined article on how a new EU directive could make it the rule for shareholders to determine the compensation of their executive board members.

    In depth
    Authors

    Dr. Thomas Gennert

    Partner

    Düsseldorf

    More insights

  • 100% DRD for CFC Dividends

    ARTICLE

    100% DRD for CFC Dividends

    August 2018

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Lowell Yoder wrote a bylined article discussing the 100% dividends received deduction that is available for dividends received from CFCs beginning in 2018. The DRD is also available for other amounts that are treated as a dividend for tax purposes, such as dividend-equivalent redemption distributions and gain on the sale of stock in a CFC that is re-characterized as a dividend under section 1248. This article also highlights several issues to be addressed by regulations.

    In depth
    Authors

    Lowell D. Yoder

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • SEC Adopts New Transparency Requirements for NMS Stock Alternative Trading Systems

    SEC Adopts New Transparency Requirements for NMS Stock Alternative Trading Systems

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    SEC Adopts New Transparency Requirements for NMS Stock Alternative Trading Systems

    July 31, 2018

    Read time: 14 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On July 18, 2018, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission approved amendments (“Amendments”) to Regulation ATS and Rule 3a1-1 under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended (“Exchange Act”).[1] The Amendments impose extensive new transparency requirements on alternative trading systems[2] (“ATSs”) that effect transactions in NMS Stocks.

    The Amendments will require ATSs that trade in NMS Stocks (such ATSs, “NMS Stock ATSs”) to file new Form ATS-N and publicly disclose detailed information regarding the manner of operation of the ATS and the ATS-related activities of both the ATS’s broker-dealer operator and the operator’s affiliates.[3] The Amendments also require ATS operators to memorialize their safeguards and procedures relating to the protection of subscribers’ confidential trading information.[4]

    The Amendments will become effective 60 days from the date that they are published in the Federal Register. However, operators of NMS Stock ATSs will not have to comply with the requirements of Form ATS-N until Jan. 7, 2019. Additionally, an NMS Stock ATS operating pursuant to a previously filed Form-ATS (a “Legacy NMS Stock ATS”) as of Jan. 7, 2019 will be required to file a Form ATS-N no later than Feb. 8, 2019.

    Background and Current Regulatory Framework

    The existing regulatory framework for ATSs was adopted by the SEC in 1998 to address advances in technology and the proliferation of electronic trading systems. Under Regulation ATS, an ATS operator is required to file an initial operation report with the SEC disclosing certain information about the ATS. This includes, among other things, the ATS’s manner of operation and the identity of third parties involved in the operation of the ATS. Material amendments to Form ATS must be filed at least 20 days before the change is implemented. Under the current ATS regulatory regime, the filing of Form ATS and all amendments thereto are “notice-filings” (i.e., the SEC cannot declare a filing ineffective) and are confidential.

    Amendments to Regulation ATS

    New Written Policies and Procedures

    The Amendments require ATS operators to memorialize (i.e., put into writing) their safeguards and procedures designed to limit access to the confidential trading information of ATS subscribers. ATS operators are currently required to have such policies and procedures under Exchange Act rule 301(b)(10), although the rule does not require that these policies and procedures be in writing. ATS operators must comply with this requirement within 60 days of publication of the Adopting Release in the Federal Register.

    Additionally, Form ATS-N will require NMS Stock ATS operators to include a description of their written safeguards and procedures designed to protect subscriber confidential trading information.[5] This will include a description of the “written standards controlling employees of the ATS that trade for employees’ accounts.”[6] This will also include a summary of the “roles and responsibilities” of individuals with access to confidential trading information.[7]

    Form ATS-N

    Effective Jan. 7, 2019, an operator of an NMS Stock ATS will be required to use Form ATS-N. All Form ATS-N filings will be subject to SEC review and, once effective, will be made publicly available. Importantly, Form ATS-N will only apply to ATSs that effect transactions in NMS Stocks. An ATS that transacts in NMS Stocks and other securities (e.g., fixed income securities or options) will have to file Form ATS-N for their NMS Stock operations and Form ATS for their non-NMS Stock operations.

    Commission Review of Form ATS-N Filings

    The amendments to Regulation ATS establish a process for the Commission to review Form ATS-N filings. Among other things:

    • An NMS Stock ATS’s initial Form ATS-N will become effective, unless declared ineffective,[8] upon the earlier of (1) the completion of the Commission’s review and (2) the expiration of the Commission’s review period (including, if applicable, any extension thereof).[9]
    • Material amendments to Form ATS-N must be filed at least 30 calendar days prior to the implementation of the change (such amendments, “Material Amendments”). The Adopting Release notes that a change is “material” if there is a substantial likelihood that a reasonable market participant would consider the change important when evaluating the NMS Stock ATS as a potential trading venue.[10] The amended Form ATS-N will be made public upon the expiration of the 30 calendar day period, although a brief summary of the change will be made public upon filing.[11]
    • In addition, the operator of an NMS Stock ATS generally must submit an amended Form ATS-N when any information contained therein has become inaccurate or incomplete (such amendments, “Updating Amendments”).[12] Updating Amendments must be made no later than 30 calendar days after the end of each calendar quarter.[13] Where, however, an NMS Stock ATS operator discovers that information in a previously filed Form ATS-N was “materially inaccurate or incomplete,” the operator must submit an amended Form ATS-N promptly.[14]
    • The amendments to Regulation ATS will provide a process for the Commission to review all Form ATS-N filings and, after notice and opportunity for hearing, and upon certain findings, declare, by order, an NMS Stock ATS’s Form ATS-N ineffective. Form ATS-N includes a mechanism to withdraw a previously submitted Form ATS-N.

    Transition for Legacy NMS Stock ATSs

    As noted above, operators of Legacy NMS Stock ATSs must file their initial Form ATS-N with the Commission no earlier than Jan. 7, 2019, and no later than Feb. 8, 2019. The initial Form ATS-N will supersede and replace the Form ATS then on file with the SEC. The SEC will permit the Legacy NMS Stock ATS to continue to operate, on a temporary basis, pursuant to the filed initial Form ATS-N, and any amendment thereto, during the SEC’s review of the initial Form ATS-N.

    Form ATS-N Disclosures

    Form ATS-N will require information about the manner of operation of the NMS Stock ATS, including:

    • The means of entry for orders and trading interests;
    • Trading services, facilities and rules of the NMS Stock ATS;
    • Display of orders and other trading interests;
    • Procedures for stopping or suspending trading;
    • Fees and counter-party selection;
    • Procedures regarding trade reporting, clearance and settlement; and
    • Sources and uses of market data.

    Form ATS already requires information regarding a number of these disclosures. As such, NMS Stock ATS operators should have the requested information readily available. However, NMS Stock ATS operators may find some of the new disclosure obligations onerous. For instance, Form ATS-N requires disclosures relating to the fees charged to subscribers of the NMS Stock ATS. Required information includes the fee structure (e.g., fixed fee, volume-based or transaction-based), variables that may impact the fees, differentiation among the types of subscribers and the range of fees charged. Accordingly, operators of NMS Stock ATSs will need to identify and publicly disclose the highest and lowest fee charged to subscribers to trade on the NMS Stock ATS. Multi-service broker-dealers that charge a bundled fee appear to be granted some relief from this obligation. The Adopting Release notes that “[t]o the extent [] a broker-dealer operator bundles its services with its NMS Stock ATS services, and the ATS services do not have an explicit fee, then the [] operator would not be required to provide a range of fees charged for the bundled services.”[15] (Emphasis added). While the Adopting Release does not provide an example of what would be considered an “explicit fee,” this language appears to provide some relief from the requirement of Part III, Item 19(b) of Form ATS-N, which requires the disclosure of fees charged for bundled services, including the range of such fees. Multi-service broker-dealers may want to review pricing arrangements across customers to determine whether separate fees to access their NMS Stock ATSs are being charged.

    Additionally, Form ATS-N will require information regarding the ATS-related activities of the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates, including:

    • The trading activities of the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates on the ATS;
    • Whether subscribers to the ATS can opt out from interacting with orders and trading interest of the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates; 
    • Arrangements between the broker-dealer operator or its affiliates and trading centers to access the ATS services;
    • Products and services offered to ATS subscribers by the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates;
    • The activities of service providers to the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates; and
    • Safeguards and procedures established to protect the confidential trading information of subscribers.

    Areas of disclosures that may prove particularly burdensome to operators of NMS Stock ATSs are (1) affiliate trading activity on the ATS; (2) products and services offered to ATS subscribers by the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates; and (3) the activities of service providers to the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates.

    Affiliate Trading Activity on the ATS

    NMS Stock ATS operators will have to identify those affiliates and business units that may enter orders into the NMS Stock ATS. Importantly, this appears to include any affiliate or business unit whose orders may be routed to the NMS Stock ATS by the operator’s smart order router (“SOR”).[16] This disclosure also includes any affiliate that may direct orders to the NMS Stock ATS through a third-party broker-dealer.[17]

    Disclosures Regarding Products and Services Offered to ATS Subscribers by the Broker-Dealer Operator and Its Affiliates

    An operator of an NMS Stock ATS will be required to provide information about the products and services offered to subscribers for the purpose of effecting transactions, or submitting, disseminating or displaying order and trading interest on the NMS Stock ATS.[18] This obligation extends to products and services offered by affiliates of the NMS Stock ATS operator.[19] While the Adopting Release attempts to distinguish between products and services that relate to the functions of the ATS and those that do not (disclosures about the latter would not be required), making this distinction will ultimately require a facts and circumstances analysis given that broker-dealers offer various products and services to their customers. This will include an analysis of how such products and services may be used by a subscriber to an NMS Stock ATS, which will vary. Further, operators of an NMS Stock ATS may be required to submit an amended Form ATS-N where the activity of an affiliate is changing. This will require enhanced communication between affiliates, and may require updates to the operator’s policies and procedures.

    Disclosures Regarding the Activities of Service Providers to the Broker-Dealer Operator and Its Affiliates

    An operator of an NMS Stock ATS will be required to provide information about its employees who service the NMS Stock ATS as well as other business units of the broker-dealer operator and its affiliates. These disclosures, which require a summary of the role and responsibilities of the relevant employee, are only required for shared employees with access to confidential trading information on the ATS. Maintaining and updating these disclosures may prove burdensome as employee roles and responsibilities shift periodically.

    The disclosures related to third-party service providers is intended to expand on the current requirement that ATS operators identify any third party (including any affiliate(s)) that will be involved in the operation of the ATS, including the execution, trading, clearing and settling of transactions on behalf of the ATS, and also provide a description of the role and responsibility of each such third party (including any affiliate(s)). NMS Stock ATSs will now be further required to disclose whether these third-party service providers, including any affiliates, use the NMS Stock ATS services, and if so, which ATS services the third party uses. These disclosures are intended to provide information about the extent to which a third-party service provider may be able to influence or control the operations of the ATS.

    Implications

    The increase in regulatory burdens associated with operating an NMS Stock ATS and the need to disclose potentially sensitive business information could alter the competitive landscape among NMS Stock ATSs. It is further worth noting that:

    • Amendments to Form ATS-N will likely become public before the NMS Stock ATS introduces a new functionality to the ATS. This may confuse market participants (e.g., market participants may see a Form ATS-N discussing a functionality that’s not yet active).
    • NMS Stock ATS operators will have to file amendments at least 30 days before the operator or its affiliate implements changes that require a Material Amendment. This may require both operators and their affiliates to adopt policies and procedures designed to ensure that applicable changes are not implemented prior to the effectiveness of a Material Amendment.
    • The SEC’s ability to declare a Form ATS-N amendment ineffective could impact the willingness of operators to introduce new functionality, particularly where projected development costs are high.
    • The SEC is not making a merit-based assessment of Form ATS-N. Rather, the SEC’s review will focus on the completeness and comprehensibility of the disclosures.

    While the requirement to use Form ATS-N does not go into effect until Jan. 9, 2019, ATS operators should, given the scope of the required disclosures, start assessing their ATS operations and related policies and procedures to ensure they are ready for the compliance date.

    Authored by Julian Rainero and William J. Barbera.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or the authors.


    [1] Regulation of NMS Stock Alternative Trading Systems, Release No. 34-34-83663, July 18, 2018 (“Adopting Release”).

    [2] As that term is defined in Section 300(g) of Regulation ATS.

    [3] Form ATS-N filings will be publicly posted through the SEC’s Electronic Data Gathering, Analysis, and Retrieval system (EDGAR).

    [4] Currently, ATS operators must have in place safeguards and procedures to protect subscribers’ confidential trading information under Exchange Act rule 301(b)(10). Rule 301(b)(10), however, does not require that these safeguards be in writing.

    [5] See Part II, Item 7(a) of Form ATS-N.

    [6] Id.

    [7] See Part II, Item 7(d) of Form ATS-N.

    [8] A Form ATS-N may be declared ineffective if, for example, the entity making the filing did not meet the definition of an NMS Stock ATS, the filing reveals non-compliance with federal securities laws, or one or more disclosures are materially deficient with respect to their completeness or comprehensibility. See the Adopting Release at p. 85. The Adopting Release further states that “an NMS Stock ATS will have the opportunity to be heard before the Commission declares its Form ATS-N ineffective” and that “if Form ATS-N is declared ineffective by the Commission, the Commission’s order will provide the basis for the declaration of ineffectiveness, and the NMS Stock ATS will have the opportunity to file another Form ATS-N that addresses the basis for the ineffectiveness determination.” See the Adopting Release at p. 105, 106.

    [9] The initial review period for both Legacy NMS Stock ATSs and non-Legacy NMS Stock ATSs is 120 calendar days. See the Adopting Release at p. 79. The extended review period is 120 calendar days for Form ATS-N filings by Legacy NMS Stock ATSs and 90 calendar days for filings by non-Legacy NMS Stock ATSs that are unusually lengthy or raise novel or complex issues. Id. The operator of the NMS Stock ATS and the SEC may, however, agree to a longer extension period. See the Adopting Release at p. 116.

    [10] The Adopting Release notes that “… an NMS Stock ATS should consider whether the cumulative effect of a series of changes to the operations of the NMS Stock ATS or the activities of the broker-dealer operator or its affiliates with regard to the NMS Stock ATS is material.” The Commission further notes that an ATS should consider the following regarding whether a change is material: the competitive dynamics among the ATS subscribers, the execution quality or performance of the orders of any subscribers, the fees that the subscriber would pay to access and/or use the ATS, the nature of counterparties with which a subscriber may interact and the relative speed of access or execution of a subscriber. See the Adopting Release at p. 129.

    [11] The cover page of the filed material amendment will be made public by the Commission upon filing, and unless the Commission declares the material amendment ineffective, the entire material amendment will be made public following the Commission’s 30 calendar day review period. The cover page indicates that the NMS Stock ATS has filed a material amendment and provides a brief narrative about the content of the amendment.

    [12] See Exchange Act rule 304(a)(2)(i)(B).

    [13] Id.

    [14] See Exchange Act rule 304(a)(2)(i)(C).

    [15] See the Adopting Release at p. 330.

    [16] See p. 214 of the Adopting Release.

    [17] Id. Specifically, the Adopting Release states that “[l]ikewise, if an affiliated asset manager of the broker-dealer operator uses the services of a third-party broker-dealer to route directed orders to the NMS Stock ATS (i.e., the asset manager instructs the third-party broker-dealer to send its orders to the NMS Stock ATS), the NMS Stock ATS would be required to list that affiliated asset manager under Item 2(a).”

    [18] See Part II, Item 5(a) of Form ATS-N.

    [19] See Part II, Item 5(c) of Form ATS-N.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2018 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    William J. Barbera

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Osborn v. Griffin: When Is Prejudgment Interest Appropriate?

    Osborn v. Griffin: When Is Prejudgment Interest Appropriate?

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Osborn v. Griffin: When Is Prejudgment Interest Appropriate?

    July 31, 2018

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The US Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit recently affirmed the largest award of prejudgment interest in Kentucky history. In Osborn v. Griffin, 865 F.3d 417 (6th Cir. 2017), the Sixth Circuit affirmed the District Court’s award of more than $250 million in prejudgment interest in this dispute among siblings. Courts vary about whether and to what extent prejudgment interest will be awarded. The Osborn case shows, however, that when a fiduciary’s breach of duty is egregious, a large prejudgment interest award could be warranted.

    In depth

    Osborn v. Griffin

    In Osborn, the plaintiffs were four sisters (Sisters) who alleged that two of their six brothers (Defendants) cheated them out of stock and real property relating to the family’s business, Griffin Industries. The Sisters noted that their parents’ estate plans expressed a “clear and consistent desire to bequeath their property equally to their eleven living children.”

    Notwithstanding this clear intention, Defendants used their positions as executors of their mother’s estate and as agents for their disabled father to engage in a series of stock transactions. As a result of those transactions, the six Griffin sons owned all of their parents’ shares of Griffin Industries, controlling approximately 87 percent of the stock, to the exclusion of their sisters. Defendants also used a sham corporation to acquire their father’s real estate interests, also to the exclusion of their Sisters. Defendants misled the Sisters about their mother’s estate plan.

    After discovering Defendants’ misdeeds, the Sisters sued Defendants. The breach of fiduciary duty claim proceeded to trial. At trial the court determined that Defendants’ conduct violated their fiduciary duties to the Sisters and awarded disgorgement of $330 million in profits. The court also ordered Defendants to pay more than $250 million in prejudgment interest to the Sisters. The Sixth Circuit affirmed the District Court’s judgment, including the prejudgment interest award in this first decision of its kind on the issue.

    Sixth Circuit Decision

    In affirming the $580 million prejudgment interest award, the Sixth Circuit carefully considered the District Court’s determination that the Sisters’ damages were liquidated. The Sixth Circuit explained that a “damages claim is liquidated if it is of such a nature that the amount is capable of ascertainment by mere computation, can be established with reasonable certainty, can be ascertained in accordance with fixed rules of evidence and known standards of value, or can be determined by reference to well-established market values.” On the other hand, an unliquidated claim is “unspecified and undetermined prior to a breach.” The Sixth Circuit disagreed with the District Court about whether the damages were liquidated and concluded that they were not. However, under Kentucky law, that decision did not end the question of whether the prejudgment interest award was nevertheless warranted.

    Under Kentucky law, prejudgment interest is mandatory when damages are liquidated at a rate of 8 percent per annum. However, Kentucky law permits a court to exercise discretion to award prejudgment interest even when the damages are unliquidated, at a rate up to 8 percent per annum. Thus, even though the Sixth Circuit concluded that the damages were unliquidated, it nevertheless affirmed the prejudgment interest award because of the egregious nature of the Defendants’ conduct.

    Equity Matters

    The Sixth Circuit recognized that its decision was somewhat unprecedented. The court noted that “Kentucky courts rarely award prejudgment interest on unliquidated claims on equitable grounds.” However, the court reasoned that “such awards are more frequently appropriate in cases where there are allegations of bad faith.” The Sixth Circuit expressly referred to the Defendants’ “repeated and flagrant” violations of their fiduciary duties that “functionally disinherit[ed] their own Sisters, who reposed great trust in their brothers.” The Defendants’ “extraordinary” and “brazenly wrongful conduct,” which “span[ned] decades,” clearly informed both the award and affirmance of the prejudgment interest award.

    But What About Due Process?

    The entire Sixth Circuit panel, however, did not agree with the prejudgment interest award. To the contrary, the dissent rejected the majority’s decision concluding that the damages were “excessive, unreasonable, and probably in violation of due process.” The dissent focused on the fact that the prejudgment interest award of more than $250 million was almost as much as the $330 million in damages awarded. The dissent observed that the prejudgment interest award was “intended more to punish the defendants than to compensate the plaintiffs for the time-value of the disbursements involved in the case.” The dissent argued that the imposition of punishment requires due process scrutiny, and this award did not survive such stringent standards.

    What Did We Learn?

    The trust reposed in fiduciaries is of utmost importance. And, when those fiduciaries are also related to the beneficiaries they serve, their breach of their duties can be considered that much more egregious. Courts in equity have the power to take such circumstances into consideration—and the Osborn court clearly did just that.

    Authors

    Lisa A. Linsky

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • IP Update, Vol. 21, No. 7

    IP Update, Vol. 21, No. 7

    ARTICLE

    IP Update, Vol. 21, No. 7

    July 2018

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Dive into the July 2018 issue of IP Update: Vol. 21, No. 7

    In depth
    Authors

    Paul Devinsky

    Senior Counsel

    Washington, DC

    Amol Parikh

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights