Content Type: Article

  • CMS Extends Remote Direct Supervision Flexibilities in CY 2025 Physician Fee Schedule Final Rule

    CMS Extends Remote Direct Supervision Flexibilities in CY 2025 Physician Fee Schedule Final Rule

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    CMS Extends Remote Direct Supervision Flexibilities in CY 2025 Physician Fee Schedule Final Rule

    November 11, 2024

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On November 1, 2024, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) issued the calendar year 2025 final rule for services reimbursed under the Medicare physician fee schedule. Among other developments, the final rule temporarily extends through December 31, 2025, flexibilities that allow physicians to provide direct supervision to auxiliary personnel remotely using real-time audio and visual interactive telecommunications. CMS made this flexibility permanent for a small subset of services and will continue to evaluate services that can safely be provided with remote direct supervision. Providers utilizing remote direct supervision should take this opportunity to review their supervision practices to ensure that they reflect the use of real-time audio and visual interactive telecommunications, and should further instruct practitioners on documentation for remote supervision.

    In depth

    Background

    Certain categories of medical services, including many diagnostic tests, pulmonary and cardiac rehabilitation services, incident-to services, and certain hospital outpatient services, may be furnished by auxiliary personnel under direct supervision by a physician or other provider, as determined by CMS. “Direct supervision” typically requires that the supervising practitioner be physically present in the office suite and immediately available to furnish assistance and direction to the auxiliary personnel throughout their performance of the service. These rules apply to services payable under the Medicare physician fee schedule and services furnished by rural health clinics (RHCs) and federally qualified health clinics (FQHCs).

    In response to the COVID-19 pandemic, CMS temporarily amended the definition of “direct supervision” to allow a supervisor to be “immediately available” by use of two-way, real-time audio/visual technology. This flexibility allowed physicians (and other supervising providers) to remotely provide direct supervision, as long as they were immediately reachable and able to provide assistance through real-time audio/visual technologies. The flexibility did not allow supervisors to be available via audio-only communications or asynchronous communications (e.g., phone calls or secure messaging platforms).

    Final Rule

    Following the expiration of the COVID-19 public health emergency, CMS extended these direct supervision flexibilities through the end of 2024. CMS has now extended the supervision flexibilities through December 31, 2025.

    In the final rule, CMS declined to make the remote direct supervision flexibilities permanent for all services, but did adopt its proposal to make remote direct supervision permanent for a limited subset of services. In making this decision, CMS stated that further review is necessary to evaluate patient safety and quality concerns related to remote supervision. CMS highlighted that in-person direct supervision is necessary for procedures such as surgeries and high-risk interventions where a patient’s clinical status may rapidly change. CMS also solicited commentary on any additional safeguards to prevent fraud, inappropriate use, and patient safety concerns related to remote direct supervision.

    CMS made the remote supervision flexibilities permanent only for the following services:

    • Services furnished incident to a physician’s service when they are provided by auxiliary personnel employed by the physician and working under the physician’s direct supervision and for which the underlying HCPCS code has been assigned a PC/TC indicator of “5.”
    • Services described by CPT code 99211: office and other outpatient visits for the evaluation and management of an established patient that may not require the presence of a physician or other qualified healthcare professional.

    CMS noted that these services are low risk by nature, do not often demand in-person supervision, and are typically furnished entirely by the auxiliary personnel. Thus, allowing for permanent remote supervision adequately balances patient safety concerns with patient access, in CMS’s view. CMS initially considered including Level I emergency department visits in this subset of services but ultimately concluded that such services are not wholly furnished by auxiliary personnel and therefore declined to include such services in the rulemaking.

    The flexibilities described above also apply to services provided by RHCs and FQHCs. CMS noted that there may be additional nuances in RHC and FQHC settings since auxiliary services are generally paid at all-inclusive rates or prospective payment systems, and CMS may address those nuances in future permanent rules. CMS stated that it may establish a final policy for RHCs and FQHCs after a final policy is determined under the physician fee schedule, in an effort to avoid any confusion. Further, patient access concerns are especially heightened in RHCs and FQHCs. Commentors have highlighted that remote direct supervision has enhanced the quality, accessibility, and provision of healthcare services in medically underserved rural communities.

    Takeaways

    Physicians and providers may use remote direct supervision through 2025. CMS has also started the process, albeit incrementally, of making remote direct supervision a permanent option for some services. Providers using remote direct supervision should consider developing written policies and procedures explaining how remote direct supervision is conducted, when it is permitted by the provider (which could be narrower than the scope approved by CMS), and how it should be documented.

    In its commentary, CMS acknowledged that remote direct supervision has become an essential part of healthcare delivery, and that any abrupt changes back to requiring in-person direct supervision would be detrimental for both patient access and the providers that have come to rely on remote supervision. This acknowledgement, combined with the new category of permanent remote supervision services, makes it unlikely that CMS will seek to fully roll back this COVID-19-era flexibility. Instead, CMS has expressed that it will continue to evaluate the balance between patient safety and patient access when it comes to remote direct supervision. While RHCs and FQHCs currently follow the same flexibilities as services paid under the Medicare physician fee schedule, future rulemaking could differentiate policies to account for differing needs of these service providers.

    In the final rule, CMS repeatedly expressed that it will continue to evaluate and monitor patient safety, access, safeguards, and other topics related to remote direct supervision. Healthcare providers that make use of remote direct supervision should consider gathering data and providing further comments as CMS continues to develop its policies in this area.

    Authors

    Emily Jane Cook

    Partner

    Los Angeles, Washington, DC

    Monica Wallace

    Partner

    Chicago

    Evelyn S. Atwater

    Associate

    Chicago

    More insights

  • Foreign Company Law

    ARTICLE

    Foreign Company Law

    2024

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Prof. Dr. Clemens Just is co-author of the 9th edition of the handbook “Foreign Company Law” published by C.H. Beck Verlag.

    The new edition deals with questions of formation and establishment conditions, the administrative burden, liquidation and insolvency, the tax framework and other strategic aspects, such as the special suitability of sectors or the similarity of types of company forms in different legal systems in different countries.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • The israeli judicial reform

    The israeli judicial reform

    ARTICLE

    The israeli judicial reform

    November 11, 2024

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Dr. Boris Uphoff with an article on ‘The Israeli judicial reform’, published in the current ICC-Germany Magazine.

    In depth
    Authors

    Dr. Boris Uphoff

    Partner

    Munich, Düsseldorf

    More insights

  • REMINDER: SEC Short Position (Form SHO) Filing Deadline Fast Approaching

    REMINDER: SEC Short Position (Form SHO) Filing Deadline Fast Approaching

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    REMINDER: SEC Short Position (Form SHO) Filing Deadline Fast Approaching

    November 11, 2024

    Read time: 10 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    As of Jan. 2, 2025, institutional investment managers (“Managers”) will need to comply with recently adopted SEC rule 13f-2 (“Rule 13f-2”) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended (“Exchange Act”),[1] which establishes a mandatory short position reporting regime on Managers.[2] Specifically, starting in January 2025, Managers will need to assess on a monthly basis whether they exercise investment discretion over a gross short position in any equity security that reaches an applicable reporting threshold and, if so, submit a Form SHO filing regarding such position(s) to the SEC via Edgar within fourteen (14) calendar days of month end. While industry group efforts to delay or vacate the rule continue, the SEC recently published a draft EDGAR submission taxonomy for Form SHO[3] and reconfirmed that the first Form SHO filing deadline will be Feb. 14, 2025.[4]

    Rule 13f-2’s reporting requirements are quite broad. Unlike Form 13F filing obligations, there is no exclusion under Rule 13f-2 for Managers who exercise investment discretion over securities below an aggregate threshold. Further, unlike Form 13F, the SEC will not be publishing a list of Rule 13f-2 securities; rather, the SEC has noted that all equity securities are potentially subject to reporting under Rule 13f-2.

    Below is an overview of certain key considerations relating to Rule 13f-2.  Additional information is available in Schulte’s Form SHO Alert.

    • Compliance Date
      • Rule 13f-2’s compliance date is Jan. 2, 2025.
      • The initial report required by Rule 13f-2, which will cover gross short positions that exceeded the applicable threshold during January 2025 (which may include gross short positions entered into prior to January 2025), is due Feb. 14, 2025.
    • Reporting Thresholds
      • Reporting is triggered where a Manager exercises investment discretion over a gross short position in an equity security that exceeds the relevant threshold below.
        • Reporting Company Issuers (Threshold A):[5]
          • Monthly average gross short position in the relevant equity security that equals or exceeds (i) $10 million (USD) or (ii) 2.5 percent of shares outstanding in the equity security.[6]
        • Non-Reporting Company Issuers (Threshold B):[7]
          • Gross short position in the relevant security that equals or exceeds $500,000 at the close of regular trading hours on any settlement day during the month.
        • Managers will need to ensure they identify and report each position that exceeds the applicable reporting threshold. Notably, elective over-reporting may itself be viewed as non-compliant with Rule 13f-2.
      • Submission Timing
        • As indicated above, reports required by Rule 13f-2, which are made on Form SHO, are due within fourteen (14) calendar days of the end of each calendar month.
        • Amended filings are required within 10 calendar days of discovering any error in a previously filed Form SHO, including “de minimis” errors.
      • Manner of Reporting
        • Submissions must be in XML format and submitted via EDGAR.
      • Public Dissemination
        • Information reported on Tables 1 and 2 of Form SHO will be published by the SEC on an aggregated and anonymized basis. Information identifying reporting managers (e.g., cover page information) will not be publicly disseminated.
        • The above data will be published approximately one (1) month following the end of calendar month covered in the report.  For instance, information relating to short positions from June 2025 will be published by the end of July 2025.

    Key Takeaways.

    Starting in January 2025, Managers will need to identify each equity security in which they met or exceeded an applicable Rule 13f-2 reporting threshold. This will require that Managers categorize equity securities as Reporting Company and Non-Reporting Company Issuer securities and pull third-party information necessary to determine whether a reporting threshold has been met (e.g., shares outstanding information for Threshold A calculations and pricing information for Thresholds A and B calculations) and identify all the information necessary to complete Form SHO. We anticipate this being a very involved process, and Managers will likely need to engage third-party vendors to identify certain information necessary to both identify reportable positions and accurately complete Form SHO, which must be submitted via EDGAR using a custom XML format within fourteen (14) calendar days of month end.

    Managers are strongly encouraged to analyze recent monthly data related to short positions prior to January 2025 in order to test their ability to comply with Rule 13f-2’s reporting requirements and troubleshoot their data sources and systems in relation to Rule 13f-2’s requirements prior to the end of January 2025 (particularly given the fourteen (14) calendar day turnaround time after month end). Managers that anticipate having SRZ attorneys assist with their Rule 13f-2 reporting obligations, including with respect to the EDGARization and submission of their Form SHO filings, should contact their attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of this alert’s authors promptly.

    Authored by Bill Barbera, Kelly Koscuiszka, Adriana Schwartz and Derek Lacarrubba.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] Exchange Act Release No. 34-98738 (Oct. 13, 2023) (“Adopting Release”).

    [2] An institutional investment manager is broadly defined under Section 13(f)(6)(A) of the Exchange Act to cover “any person, other than a natural person, investing in or buying and selling securities for its own account, and any person exercising investment discretion with respect to the account of any other person.”  The definition is the same as used in 13F.

    [3]  Technical specifications are available.

    [4] See the SEC’s Corrected Announcement: SEC Staff Publishes Draft Taxonomy for Form SHO (“The first reporting month is January 2025. The first Form SHO filings are due within 14 calendar days after the end of the reporting month.”)

    [5] Applies to “each equity security that is of a class of securities that is registered pursuant to section 12 of the Exchange Act or for which the issuer of that class of securities is required to file reports pursuant to section 15(d) of the Exchange Act.”

    [6] Calculated at the close of regular trading hours, as defined in Exchange Act rule 600(b)(88).

    [7] Applies to any equity security that does not qualify for the Reporting Company Issuer thresholds.

    In depth
    Authors

    William J. Barbera

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Kelly Koscuiszka

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Sanctions Update: OFAC Issues Guidance on Securities Held by US Persons in Russia’s National Settlement Depository and Escalates Efforts Against Russian Sanctions Evasion

    Sanctions Update: OFAC Issues Guidance on Securities Held by US Persons in Russia’s National Settlement Depository and Escalates Efforts Against Russian Sanctions Evasion

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Sanctions Update: OFAC Issues Guidance on Securities Held by US Persons in Russia’s National Settlement Depository and Escalates Efforts Against Russian Sanctions Evasion

    November 8, 2024

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On Oct. 10, 2024, the US Department of the Treasury’s Office of Foreign Assets Control (“OFAC”) issued guidance relating to the designation of the National Settlement Depository (“NSD”) in response to recent actions taken by the Russian Federation to evade OFAC sanctions on the NSD. OFAC’s guidance has important ramifications for US asset managers with Russian-issuer securities or with depositary receipts for securities custodied at the NSD or that were recently transferred to other Russian registrars. On Oct. 30, 2024, OFAC further expanded its Russian sanctions regime, designating hundreds of individuals and entities—many non-Russian—for dealing with entities connected to Russia’s military industrial sector. Notably, OFAC designated certain individuals and entities for providing trust and corporate services to Russian clients.

    Background – Designation of NSD and General Licenses 99A and 100A

    On June 14, 2024, pursuant to Executive Order (“E.O.”) 14024, OFAC added the NSD, as well as the Moscow Exchange and the National Clearing Center, to its Specially Designated Nationals and Blocked Persons List (“SDN List”).[1] Alongside this designation, OFAC issued, and subsequently extended, two general licenses allowing US persons to wind-down certain transactions involving the NSD and to divest securities held at the NSD, among other authorized activities (General License 99A and General License 100A, collectively, “General Licenses”).[2] The General Licenses were effective through 12:01 AM ET, Oct. 12, 2024.[3] OFAC has specifically stated that following the expiration of the General Licenses, any securities in the possession or control of US persons that are held at the NSD, or any dividends or other income received via the NSD, should be treated as blocked.[4]

    Russian Decree 840 Orders Removal of “Type C” Account Russian Shares from NSD

    Since March 2022, by decree of the Russian president, all non-Russian residents from designated “unfriendly jurisdictions”[5]—including the United States—have had their Russian-issuer securities recorded in special “Type C” custody accounts, which are effectively frozen due to the extensive restrictions Russia has applied to these accounts.[6] Notably, Russia’s “Type C” regime also applies to depositary receipts programs for securities maintained by Russian custodians where the nominee account holders are US legal entities.[7] On Oct. 2, 2024, the Russian president, Vladimir Putin, issued Russian Decree 840, requiring that all Russian custodians transfer their “Type C” holdings of Russian joint-stock companies from the NSD to local Russian registrars.[8]

    OFAC Issues FAQ Addressing Russian Decree No. 840

    On Oct. 10, 2024, OFAC issued new guidance addressing whether US persons with securities held at the NSD in “Type C” custody accounts that have been subsequently transferred to a local Russian registrar pursuant to Russian Decree 840 are required to block these securities (“FAQ 1197”).[9] OFAC cautions that the transfer of such securities to local Russian registrars may not be authorized under the General Licenses and would therefore be considered null and void under OFAC’s regulations.[10] OFAC also notes that these transactions may involve other blocked persons, including certain local Russian registrars, and that it is investigating non-blocked local Russian registrars for future designation under E.O. 14024.[11]

    Designation of Hundreds of Individuals and Entities and General Licenses 110 and 111

    On Oct. 30, 2024, OFAC added hundreds of individuals and entities to the SDN List for operating Russian-sanctions evasion networks spanning 17 countries, including India, the People’s Republic of China, Switzerland, Thailand and Turkey.[12] Notably, OFAC’s recent designation includes two Swiss attorneys and a Thailand-based entity that provided trust and corporate formation services[13] to Russian clients, including sanctioned Russian individuals.[14] Alongside these designations, OFAC issued a general license allowing US persons to wind-down certain transactions involving seven of the recently designated entities.[15] On this date, OFAC also issued a general license allowing US persons to engage in certain transactions ordinarily incident and necessary to the divestment or transfer of debt or equity issued or guaranteed by five of the recently designated entities (“Covered Entities”), in addition to authorizing the wind-down of derivative contracts involving the Covered Entities.[16] Both general licenses are effective through 12:01 AM ET, Dec. 14, 2024.

    Takeaways

    US asset managers holding securities at the NSD (or depositary receipts for securities custodied at the NSD) should be aware that, since the General Licenses expired as of Oct. 12, 2024, they may need to seek a specific license from OFAC to access these securities. Additionally, even if their securities held at the NSD were transferred to another local registrar pursuant to Russian Decree 840, such securities are still subject to sanctions risks and should continue to be treated as blocked. Moreover, blocked property must be reported to OFAC within 10 days of blocking,[17] and therefore US asset managers should evaluate whether they have any reporting obligation for their Russian-issuer securities. US asset managers should also review OFAC’s Oct. 30, 2024, SDN designations and General Licenses 110 and 111 to ensure they are not engaging in transactions with persons that are now blocked.

    Authored by Betty Santangelo, Melissa G.R. Goldstein, Gregoire P. Devaney and Noah A. Wright.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] OFAC, Press Release, “As Russia Completes Transition to a Full War Economy, Treasury Takes Sweeping Aim at Foundational Financial Infrastructure and Access to Third Country Support” (June 12, 2024), available here.

    [2] OFAC, General License 99A, “Authorizing the Wind Down of Transactions and Certain Transactions Related to Debt or Equity of, or Derivative Contracts Involving, MOEX, NCC, or NSD” (Aug. 2, 2024), available here; OFAC, General License 100A, “Authorizing Certain Transactions Related to Debt or Equity or the Conversion of Currencies Involving MOEX, NCC, or NSD” (Aug. 2, 2024), available here.

    [3] Id.

    [4] OFAC FAQ 1197 (Oct. 10, 2024), available here.

    [5] Russia’s list of “unfriendly” countries or jurisdictions also includes, among others, the United Kingdom and 27 EU member states. Since its 2022 invasion of Ukraine, Russia has imposed restrictions on assets from businesses in these “unfriendly” jurisdictions. US Dep’t of Treasury, Press Release, “Risks and Considerations for Doing Business in the Russian Federation and Russian-Occupied Territories of Ukraine” (Feb. 23, 2024), available here.

    [6] Bank of Russia Board of Directors, Resolution, “On the Establishment of a ‘C’ Type Account Regime for the Purpose of Fulfilling Commitments Owed by Residents to Non-residents as Set out in Decree of the President of the Russian Federation No. 95 of 5 March 2022, Entitled ‘On the Temporary Procedure for Fulfilling Commitments to Some Foreign Creditors’” (March 18, 2022).

    [7] Id.

    [8] OFAC FAQ 1197 (citing Presidential Decree of the Russian Federation No. 840 (Oct. 2, 2024)).

    [9] Id.

    [10] Id. (citing 31 C.F.R. Part 587.202).

    [11] OFAC FAQ 1197.

    [12] OFAC, Press Release, “Treasury Takes Aim at Third-Country Sanctions Evaders and Russian Producers Supporting Russia’s Military Industrial Base” (Oct. 30, 2024), available here.

    [13] For the purposes of E.O. 14024, OFAC interprets “trust and corporate formation services” to include: assisting persons in forming or structuring a legal person; acting or arranging for another person to act as director, secretary, administrative trustee, trust fiduciary, registered agent, or nominee shareholder of a legal person; providing a registered office, business address, correspondence address, or administrative address for a legal person; and providing administrative services for a trust. OFAC FAQ 1038 (May 11, 2022), available here.

    [14] Id.; see also US Embassy in Switzerland and Liechtenstein, Press Release, “US Government Announces Russia-Related Sanctions Designations” (Oct. 30, 2024), available here (noting that the two sanctioned Swiss nationals had facilitated the “illicit flow of funds” and sanctions evasion on behalf of Russian clients).

    [15] OFAC, General License 110, “Authorizing the Wind Down of Transactions Involving Certain Entities Blocked on Oct. 30, 2024” (Oct. 30, 2024), available here.

    [16] OFAC, General License 111, “Authorizing Certain Transactions Related to Debt or Equity of, or Derivative Contracts Involving, Certain Entities Blocked on Oct. 30, 2024” (Oct. 30, 2024), available here.

    [17] 31 C.F.R. § 501.603(b)(1)(i).

    In depth
    Authors

    Betty Santangelo

    Counsel

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Melissa G.R. Goldstein

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Gregoire P. Devaney

    Associate

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • The value of data and artificial intelligence in the alcohol industry

    The value of data and artificial intelligence in the alcohol industry

    ARTICLE

    The value of data and artificial intelligence in the alcohol industry

    Nov 7, 2024

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Members in the ever-evolving alcohol industry are leveraging data and artificial intelligence (AI) to drive innovation, enhance customer experiences, and optimize operations, all in an effort to increase efficiency and profitability in the market. There are several ways AI is being used to transform this industry:

    • Marketing and Insights

    Data is highly valuable and can provide a better understanding of consumer behavior, allowing companies to design their consumer approach in a more targeted manner. Purchase and demographic data allow companies to clearly identify trends and performance to improve their products and the way they communicate with consumers. This information is sometimes shared between suppliers and wholesalers to identify the best market opportunities for particular products. AI can also help track customer orders and provide recommendations for future ordering processes.

    This same information can be used in an analysis to highlight emerging customer preferences, providing data-based feedback to companies to help them plan their production schedules, purchases, marketing plans, and innovation projects.

    • Customer Interaction

    Industry members are increasingly turning to chatbots to answer frequently asked questions, shorten customer wait times, and reduce company workload. Virtual programs are also being used to provide personalized recommendations. For example, Diageo’s What’s Your Whisky program analyzes responses to specific questions and uses the data to make a whisky recommendation that is likely to match customer preferences.

    Regulatory Compliance

    While it may seem counterintuitive to use AI in the alcohol industry due to the large volume of varying regulations and industry guidelines, it can still be a useful tool, particularly for complying with reporting and payment deadlines, which may reduce the burden on your compliance team. However, there are key considerations when using, selling, or purchasing these tools:

    • Data Protection

    With US states increasingly passing more comprehensive data privacy laws, it is vital to work with your information technology team and data specialists to maintain the security and anonymity of the data your company uses. For your convenience, McDermott’s global privacy and cybersecurity team has developed an interactive map tracking the rapidly changing state consumer privacy laws.

    • Value

    Data and AI undoubtedly have and will continue to have intrinsic value; however, it is difficult to quantify this value given the intricacies and varying degrees of use. It is important to consider how the value of data should be accounted for particularly when sharing, purchasing, or selling data or AI tools across tiers to avoid running afoul of tied house restrictions.

    • Transparency

    Finally, once you have clear goals for using AI or data, make sure you understand the rules and responsibilities, particularly regarding the use of personally identifiable information. Always be transparent about your collection, use, and disclosure of AI or data, and ensure your privacy policies are up to date.

    We expect to see more industry guidelines develop as the use of data and AI continues to grow within the alcohol industry. Contact Alva Mather of McDermott’s alcohol team to learn more.

    Authors

    Alva C. Mather

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Michelle L. Draper

    Senior Alcohol Regulatory Specialist

    Wilmington

    More insights
    Endnotes

  • Post Expo Real and the UK Budget – UK Real Estate to Survive or Thrive in 2025?

    Post Expo Real and the UK Budget – UK Real Estate to Survive or Thrive in 2025?

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Post Expo Real and the UK Budget – UK Real Estate to Survive or Thrive in 2025?

    November 13, 2024

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Having taken time to reflect on the mood and sentiment at Expo Real 2024 among clients, contacts, and European real estate partners at McDermott, the general outlook within the Messe could be best described as one of cautious optimism.

    After some time now to digest the UK budget announcements from last week, our team has also considered the impacts of the UK budget on some of the prevalent market themes emerging from Expo, with a focus on some of the asset classes which featured heavily in Expo discussions.

    In depth

    Offices – A Return from Exile?

    Questions around the future of offices remain relevant at a point three years after the end of the pandemic. There is an undeniable split between amenity-rich, ESG-compliant Grade A offices deemed as essential to attract future occupiers and their workforce and secondary older offices requiring significant capital expenditure to achieve Grade A status.

    Within those challenges however, with the gap between seller and buyer pricing aspirations at both prime and secondary points in the market narrowing, the perception of offices as a buying opportunity was an increasing trend. This has been borne out by a marked uptick in investment activity in Q3 and Q4 2024, and a growing development pipeline to take advantage of occupier demand and rental growth.

    The UK budget contained little to alter this general market sentiment, although the confidence investors may take from increased government spending on key infrastructure, including the completion of HS2 at the Euston terminus, may be tempered by the impact on interest rates of the bond market’s reaction to the budget.

    Logistics – An Increased Focus on Ultra-Urban Logistics?

    This remains a very attractive distraction for investors seeking to deploy capital to serve the continuing growth in e-commerce and structural demand for final mile and ultra-urban logistics. Although there were no specific measures in the UK budget pertaining to logistics, the continuing focus of occupiers and investors on sustainable, ESG-compliant buildings remains a key market theme which may put pressure on some of the older secondary stock.  The availability of suitable land and the accessibility of green power will be key factors driving future development and decision-making, including with regard to which infrastructure projects receive government funding.

    Another key topic at Expo was the recent change in consumer habits to expect immediate delivery, which is driving the trend for repurposing light industrial facilities in densely populated urban areas as ultra-urban logistics developments. Balancing demand for industrial land against the need to increase the pace of house building on brownfield sites will be a key factor in the growth of this sector, driven in part by the specifics of government policy and funding priorities.

    Operational Real Estate – Continued Appetite?

    Appetite at Expo for operational real estate remained high, particularly with regard to student accommodation, multi-family properties, and data centres.  Looking at each of these in turn:

    • Student Accommodation (PBSA): The PBSA sector remains strong, driven by an undersupply of beds and high demand, especially from international students. Investment in this area has increased due to resilient rental growth and occupancy rates and a continued shortage of supply, with the new budget further disincentivising private landlords through increases in capital gains tax rates and in the Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) surcharge on second homes. This brings the affordability of new PBSA developments for occupiers into starker focus, if rents are pushed higher and there is an increased reliance on premium pricing as a hallmark of PBSA that could limit domestic student access and affect viability.
    • Multi-Family: Sentiment from investors towards the multi-family sector remained positive at Expo, driven by strong rental demand as further fuelled by the likelihood of interest rates staying higher for longer as a consequence of bond market reaction to the budget. The increased pressure on private landlords from the rises in capital gains tax and SDLT on second homes, when considered together with limited support for construction and affordable housing measures, may further reduce the supply of private rental properties and fuel further rental increases. While this places further economic pressure on individual tenants, from an institutional investor perspective it may serve to reinforce the potential for stable, long-term returns in multi-family investments, with an increased emphasis on single-family rental and affordable housing.
    • Data Centres: Demand for data centres is rising exponentially in the UK and Europe and was at the forefront of many investors’ minds at Expo. Sustainability is a key pillar and requirement of such growth, as data centres are power-intensive. As a result, investors are exploring energy-efficient options, and renewable energy sourcing is a priority. The budget did not introduce new specific incentives for data centres, but the overall focus on green infrastructure aligns with the sector’s investment trends.

      More generally, the ability of the sector to further develop data centre offerings at the requested scale will be contingent upon strong support from governments, through funding, adequate general policies and favourable regulatory frameworks. The UK has recently shown some obvious signs of encouragement to the industry when the UK’s Department of Science, Information, and Technology (DSIT) announced that data centres are to be designated as critical national infrastructure (CNI) as part of the government’s drive for economic growth. It will be interesting to keep on eye on the next steps taken by the UK in this direction.

    Conclusion

    The recent budget did not significantly change the outlook for any of these key real estate sectors. While it included modest support for affordable housing and infrastructure, it lacked direct stimulus for logistics, offices, or operational real estate sectors like PBSA and multi-family. The high cost of debt and inflation remain challenges, especially for sectors reliant on new construction or refurbishment. In summary, the budget’s influence on these sectors is likely to be indirect, with macroeconomic measures and infrastructure investment and government funding a key factor.

    Authors

    Devina Rana

    Partner

    London – 22 Bishopsgate

    Darren Rogers

    Partner

    London – 22 Bishopsgate

    Neeraj Tah

    Senior Associate

    London – 22 Bishopsgate

    More insights

  • FinCEN Issues Final Rule Requiring AML Reporting for Real Estate Sector

    FinCEN Issues Final Rule Requiring AML Reporting for Real Estate Sector

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    FinCEN Issues Final Rule Requiring AML Reporting for Real Estate Sector

    November 5, 2024

    Read time: 18 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On Aug. 29, 2024, the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (“FinCEN”), a bureau of the United States Department of the Treasury, issued a final rule (“Final Rule”)[1] extending anti-money laundering (“AML”) requirements to persons involved in real estate closings and settlements. The Final Rule requires certain persons involved in residential real estate closings and settlements to electronically submit reports to FinCEN (“Real Estate Reports”) and maintain records of certain non-financed transfers of US residential real property. The Real Estate Report must include, among other things, information concerning the property and identifying information on the entity or trust transferring the property and its beneficial owners, the transferor, and the person filing the Real Estate Report (“Reporting Person”). The Final Rule takes effect and the reporting obligations commence on Dec. 1, 2025.

    The Final Rule largely codifies the substance of the notice of proposed rulemaking issued by FinCEN on Feb. 16, 2024 (“Proposed Rule”).[2] This Alert highlights those areas where the Final Rule departs from the Proposed Rule, including the key modifications and clarifications to the reporting obligations.

    Authority for Rulemaking

    FinCEN draws its authority for this Final Rule from the Bank Secrecy Act (“BSA”) which permits FinCEN to require anti-money laundering and countering the financing of terrorism (“AML/CFT”) programs for “persons involved in real estate closings and settlements”[3] and from the provisions of the BSA which authorize the Secretary of the Treasury to require financial institutions to report, via suspicious activity reports (“SARs”), “any suspicious transaction relevant to a possible violation of law or regulation.”[4] More recently, the AML Act of 2020 added a provision to the BSA which directs FinCEN to “establish streamlined . . .processes to, as appropriate, permit the filing of noncomplex categories of reports of suspicious activity.”[5] FinCEN hopes to use these Real Estate Reports to identify illicit financial activity. The Final Rule follows FinCEN’s use of Residential Real Estate Geographic Targeting Orders (“GTOs”) since 2016 to collect information on a subset of transfers of residential real estate that FinCEN considers to present a high risk for money laundering. Recently, FinCEN renewed its GTOs in this sector through Apr. 14, 2025.[6]

    Transfers of Real Property that are Reportable

    The Final Rule imposes reporting requirements in connection with certain residential real estate transfers in which the purchaser or other party being transferred an interest in real property is a legal entity (“Transferee Entity”) or trust (“Transferee Trust”). Transfers made directly to individuals are not covered by the Final Rule. Real Estate Reports are only required where an ownership interest in residential real property is transferred to a Transferee Entity or Transferee Trust, not to an individual.

    Residential real property under the Final Rule includes: (1) real property containing a structure designed principally for occupancy by one to four families; (2) land on which the transferee intends[7] to build a structure designed principally for occupancy by one to four families;[8] (3) a unit designed principally for occupancy by one to four families within a structure[9] or (4) a share in a cooperative housing corporation (“Reportable Property”).[10] Reportable Property only includes property located in the US, including any state, the District of Columbia, Indian lands and territorial possessions of the US.

    An ownership interest is evidenced by rights to the property through a deed or, for an interest in a cooperative housing corporation, through stock, shares, membership, certificate or other contractual agreement evidencing ownership. The transfer is reportable even if one or more other transferees receive an ownership interest in the Reportable Property as part of the same transaction.

    Transfers of Real Property that are Exempt

    Transfers involving an extension of credit to a Transferee Entity or Transferee Trust are exempt from this reporting requirement if the credit is: (1) secured by the Reportable Property and (2) is extended by a financial institution that has an obligation to maintain an AML/CFT program and a requirement to file SARs (such as a bank). Transfers financed by a private lender or the seller do not fall within this exemption.

    The Final Rule largely adopts the list of exemptions as proposed, while adding exemptions relating to transfers as the result of judicial determination, tax deferral and commonly used estate planning techniques. The Final Rule exempts transfers: (i) that are the result of a grant, transfer or revocation of an easement; (ii) that are a result of the death of an owner of the residential real property;[11] (iii) that are the result of divorce or dissolution of a marriage or civil union; (iv) that are made to a bankruptcy estate; (v) that are supervised by a court in the United States; (vi) made to qualified intermediaries for the purpose of 26 C.F.R. 1.1031(k)-1 (also known as a 1031 or like-kind exchange);[12] (vii) for which there is no Reporting Person; and (viii) made without consideration by an individual (either alone or with the individual’s spouse), to a trust where the settlor or grantor of the trust is that same transferor individual, that individual’s spouse, or both of them.[13] Note that there are no exemptions based on the value of the property or the purchase price.

    Key Terms

    The definitions of Transferee Entity and Transferee Trust broadly include most entities or trusts obtaining an ownership interest in Reportable Property. However, there are exemptions to these definitions that cover certain highly regulated entities that are subject to an AML/CFT program and/or other significant regulatory reporting requirements, including certain pooled investment vehicles (“PIVs”).

    Definition of Transferee Entity. The Final Rule adopts the Proposed Rule’s definition of Transferee Entity as “any person other than a transferee trust or an individual”[14] that is not otherwise exempt. As discussed more fully below, many, although not all, of the entities exempt from reporting under the Corporate Transparency Act (“CTA”)[15] are also excluded from the definition of Transferee Entity. Those exempt entities include: registered investment companies, securities reporting issuers and certain banks, credit unions, depository institution holding companies, money service businesses, brokers or dealers in securities, securities exchange or clearing agencies, other Exchange Act registered entities, insurance companies, state-licensed insurance producers, Commodity Exchange Act registered entities, public utilities, financial market utilities and US governmental authorities. The Final Rule clarifies that legal entities controlled or wholly owned, directly or indirectly, by any entity that falls within the exempt CTA categories listed above are themselves exempt.

    PIVs that are investment companies and registered with the SEC are exempt from the definition of a Transferee Entity. However, PIVs that are not registered with the SEC may be Transferee Entities.[16] In the Proposed Rule, FinCEN reasoned that unregistered PIVs are not subject to comprehensive AML/CFT regulations and are therefore vulnerable to abuse by illicit actors.[17]

    Notably, large operating companies as defined under the CTA are not exempt from the definition of Transferee Entity unless they fall under other exemption categories. Non-profit organizations are also not exempt from the definition of Transferee Entity.

    Definition of Transferee Trust. The Final Rule adopts the Proposed Rule definition of Transferee Trust as “any legal arrangement created when a person (generally known as a settlor or grantor) places assets under the control of a trustee for the benefit of one or more persons (each generally known as a beneficiary) or for a specified purpose, as well as any legal arrangement similar in structure or function to the above, whether formed under the laws of the United States or a foreign jurisdiction”[18] that is not otherwise exempt. A Transferee Trust includes trust property titled in the name of the trustee in his or her capacity as trustee for the Transferee Trust. Excluded from Transferee Trusts are trusts that are securities reporting issuers or trusts that have a trustee that is a securities reporting issuer.[19] Statutory trusts are exempt from the definition of Transferee Trust but could be considered a Transferee Entity, unless subject to another exemption.

    Definition of Beneficial Owner. Real Estate Reports must identify beneficial owners of Transferee Entities and Transferee Trusts. Consistent with the CTA,[20] a beneficial owner of a Transferee Entity is “any individual who, directly or indirectly, either exercises substantial control over the transferee entity or owns or controls at least 25% of the ownership interests of the transferee entity.”[21] Each such person must be reported. In circumstances where a Transferee Entity does not have any direct or indirect 25% or more owners, such as a tax-exempt organization, for example, the reportable beneficial owners are limited only to the individuals who exercise substantial control over the Transferee Entity. Only those beneficial owners of the Transferee Entity on the date of closing must be reported.

    A beneficial owner of a Transferee Trust is any individual who, at the time of the real estate transfer to the Transferee Trust: (1) is a trustee; (2) otherwise has authority to dispose of Transferee Trust assets, such as may be the case with a trust protector; (3) is a beneficiary who is the sole permissible recipient of income and principal from the Transferee Trust or who has the right to demand a distribution of, or to withdraw, substantially all of the assets of the Transferee Trust; (4) is a grantor or settlor of a revocable Transferee Trust; or (5) is the beneficial owner of a legal entity or trust that holds one of the positions described in (1)-(4), taking into account the exemptions that apply to Transferee Entities and Transferee Trusts.

    Persons Responsible for Filing a Real Estate Report

    The Final Rule adopts the cascade approach to reporting obligations provided in the Proposed Rule. In other words, FinCEN identifies seven levels of persons who may be responsible for filing the Real Estate Report. The first level of persons in the cascade would have the obligation to file the Real Estate Report. However, “if no person is involved in the transfer as described in the first tier of potential reporting persons, the reporting obligation would fall to the person involved in the transfer as described in the second tier of potential reporting persons, if any, and so on.”[22] The categories are based on the functions performed in a closing or settlement prepared for the transferee only. That means that a Reporting Person could be a buyer representative, real estate agent, or attorney, among other persons. 

    The cascade order is, as follows:

    • First, real estate professionals providing certain settlement services in the settlement process (e., a title company). This is the person listed as the closing or settlement agent on a settlement or closing statement.
    • Second, if no one is listed as the closing or settlement agent, the reporting obligation next falls on the person that prepared the closing or settlement statement.
    • Third, the person that files with the recordation office the deed or other instrument that transfers ownership of the residential real property.
    • Fourth, the person that underwrites an owner’s title insurance policy for the transferee is responsible for filing the Real Estate Report. If no such person is so designated, then the next person would be responsible for filing the Real Estate Report.
    • Fifth, the person that disburses the greatest amount of funds in connection with the real estate transfer. Disbursement may be in any form, including from an escrow account, trust account or lawyer’s trust account. This includes persons disbursing funds through third-party accounts and excludes direct transfers from transferees as well as disbursements coming directly from banks.
    • Sixth, the person that prepares an evaluation of the title status in the form of a title check typically performed by the title insurance company.
    • Seventh and finally, if none of the above exists, the person who prepares the deed or, if no deed is involved, any other legal instrument that transfers ownership of the residential real property would be responsible for filing the Real Estate Report.

    There is no obligation of any persons identified in the cascade framework to verify that any other potential Reporting Person has filed a Real Estate Report. Although the cascade is the default way to determine the Reporting Person, those in the cascade can enter into a written agreement to designate another person in the cascade as the Reporting Person. However, the agreement can only apply to a specific transaction.[23]

    Notably, the Final Rule excludes financial institutions with an obligation to maintain an AML/CFT program from the definition of a Reporting Person, as these institutions are subject to the more comprehensive AML/CFT program responsibilities including the SAR filing requirement.[24] Accordingly, where financial institutions would have otherwise been a Reporting Person, the reporting obligation falls to the next available person in the reporting cascade.

    Where the Reporting Person is an employee, agent or partner acting within the scope of such individual’s employment, agency or partnership, then the individual’s employer, principal or partnership is deemed to be the Reporting Person. Accordingly, the employer, principal or partnership would have the responsibility to file a Real Estate Report with FinCEN. The following information must be included in a Real Estate Report for each Reporting Person: (1) name; (2) principal place of business and (3) category of Reporting Person in the cascade.

    Information that Must be Reported

    The following information must be included on a Real Estate Report for each Transferee Entity, as applicable:

    • Transferee Entity: (1) name; (2) trade name or “doing business as” name; (3) street address of principal place of business, and, if not in the US, the street address of the primary location in the US where the Transferee Entity conducts business; and (4) unique identifying number, such as a taxpayer identification number (“TIN”). Note that a legal entity identifier is not an acceptable unique identifying number.[25]
    • Beneficial owners of each Transferee Entity: (1) name; (2) date of birth; (3) residential street address; (4) citizenship and (5) unique identifying number, such as a TIN.
    • Signing individual(s)[26] of each Transferee Entity: (1) name; (2) date of birth; (3) residential street address; (4) unique identifying number, such as a TIN; (5) description of the capacity in which the individual is authorized to act as the signing individual; and (6) if the signing individual is acting in that capacity as an employee, agent, or partner, the name of the individual’s employer, principal, or partnership.

    The Final Rule modifies the required information for a Transferee Trust to align more closely with information available on trust certificates issued under State law.[27] Accordingly, the following information must be included on a Real Estate Report for each Transferee Trust, as applicable:

    • Transferee Trust: (1) name, such as the full title of the agreement establishing the trust; (2) date the trust instrument was executed; (3) unique identifying number, such as a TIN and (4) whether the trust is revocable.
    • Each trustee that is a legal entity: (1) name; (2) trade name or “doing business as” name; (3) street address of principal place of business, and, if not in the US, the street address of the primary location in the US where the transferee trustee conducts business; (4) name and business address of the trust officer assigned to the trust; and (5) unique identifying number, such as a TIN.[28]
    • Beneficial owners of each Transferee Trust: same as beneficial owners for Transferee Entities.
    • Signing individual(s) of each Transferee Entity: same as signing individuals for Transferee Entities.

    The following information must be included on a Real Estate Report for each transferor, as applicable:

    • Individual transferor: (1) name; (2) date of birth; (3) residential street address; and (4) unique identifying number, such as a SSN or TIN.
    • Transferor entity: (1) name; (2) trade name or “doing business as” name; (3) street address of principal place of business, and, if not in the US, the street address of the primary location in the US where the transferor entity conducts business; and (4) unique identifying number, such as a TIN.
    • Transferor trust: (1) name; (2) date the trust instrument was executed; (3) unique identifying number, such as a TIN; (4) for each individual that is a trustee, name, address and unique identifying number, such as a TIN; and (5) for each legal entity trustee: name, trade name or “doing business as” name, street address of principal place of business, and, if not in the US, the street address of the primary location in the US where the transferor trustee conducts business and unique identifying number, such as a TIN.

    The following information must be included in a Real Estate Report for each Reportable Property: (1) street address, if any; (2) the legal description, such as the section, lot and block; and (3) the date of the real estate transaction closing.

    The following information must be included on a Real Estate Report concerning payments made in connection with a Reportable Property, as applicable: (1) total amount paid by all transferees for the property; (2) total amount paid by the Transferee Entity or Transferee Trust; (3) method of each payment made by the Transferee Entity or Transferee Trust; (4) accounts and financial institutions used for each such payment; and (5) if the payor is anyone other than the Transferee Entity or Transferee Trust, the name of the payor. Payments made from escrow or trust accounts held by a Transferee Entity or Transferee Trust are exempt.

    The Real Estate Report must include whether the real estate transfer involved a credit extension by a person that is not a financial institution with an obligation to maintain an AML/CFT program and an obligation to file SARs.

    The Reasonable Reliance Standard

    The reasonable reliance standard under the Final Rule allows a Reporting Person to rely on information provided by any other person orally or in writing for purposes of reporting information or to make a determination necessary to comply with the Final Rule, “absent knowledge of facts that would reasonably call into question the reliability of the information.”[29] However, as emphasized in the Proposed Rule, a Reporting Person’s ability to rely on third party information is more limited when applied to the beneficial ownership information of Transferee Entities or Transferee Trusts. Accordingly, the Final Rule provides that the reasonable reliance standard only applies when beneficial ownership information is (i) provided by the transferee or the transferee’s representative; and (ii) such representative “certifies the accuracy of the information in writing to the best of their knowledge.”[30] This reasonable reliance standard is consistent with other customer due diligence requirements for financial institutions.[31]

    Real Estate Report Filing Deadlines

    The Final Rule requires a Reporting Person to file the Real Estate Report with FinCEN on the final day of the following month after which a closing took place, or 30 days after the date of the closing, whichever is later.[32] Unlike reports required under the CTA, the Final Rule does not require Reporting Persons to report changes to beneficial ownership of a Transferee Entity or Transferee Trust.[33]

    Confidentiality

    Real Estate Reports, like SARs, will be held in a secure FinCEN database and will not be publicly accessible. Unlike SARs, the Final Rule exempts Reporting Persons and Federal, State, local or Tribal government authorities from the confidentiality provision in 31 U.S.C. § 5318(g)(2), which prohibits disclosing the transaction that has been reported to any person involved in the transaction. The Real Estate Reports are not considered confidential from the other parties to the transaction.

    Recordkeeping

    Under the Final Rule, there is no obligation for a Reporting Person to retain a copy of a Real Estate Report they file, although it is a good practice for Reporting Persons to keep copies of such filed Real Estate Reports. The Reporting Person and each party to an agreement designating a Reporting Person must retain a copy of said agreement, as well as a copy of any beneficial ownership certification form provided to the Reporting Person for five years from the date of signing.

    Penalties

    The Final Rule does not provide specific penalties for omitted or inaccurate Real Estate Reports. Instead, FinCEN provides that penalties will follow the existing civil and criminal penalty structure under the BSA. As of the date of the Final Rule, civil penalties for negligent violations are $1,394 for each violation (up to $108,489 for a pattern of negligent activity) while the penalties for willful violations are the greater of the amount involved in the transaction (not to exceed $278,937) or $69,733.[34] Additionally, willful violations could result in up to five years of imprisonment or a criminal fine of up to $250,000, or both.[35]

    Summary

    The Final Rule reflects FinCEN’s increased focus on preventing illicit activities in the real estate sector. The Final Rule imposes AML compliance obligations on a broad group of participants in the US residential real estate sector; FinCEN estimates that over 170,000 Reporting Persons will be affected by the Final Rule, many of which were previously unregulated.[36] To ensure compliance and effective integration of the reporting requirements under the Final Rule, real estate industry participants should perform a pre-implementation review of their existing procedures to identify how they will meet these reporting obligations and address them before the Final Rule takes effect. Financial institutions involved in financings of real estate transactions should similarly review their procedures for such transactions to ascertain if they have any reporting requirements or if the transactions are exempt.

    The Final Rule notes that FinCEN will continue to engage with stakeholders to clarify the application of the rule. Accordingly, the information in this Alert should be considered in conjunction with any applicable guidance that FinCEN may issue. FinCEN has already issued frequently asked questions summarizing the Final Rule, which can be of assistance to members of the real estate sector seeking to comply with the Final Rule.[37] Additionally, FinCEN continues to issue GTOs for a subset of transfers of residential real estate that FinCEN considers to present a high risk for money laundering.[38]

    Authored by Betty Santangelo, Melissa G.R. Goldstein, Julian Wise, Kyle B. Hendrix, and Trey VanWieren.

    If you have any questions concerning this Client Alert, please contact your attorney or one of the authors.

    In depth
    Authors

    Betty Santangelo

    Counsel

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Melissa G.R. Goldstein

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Julian M. Wise

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Kyle B. Hendrix

    Associate

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • New Fact Sheet Highlights ASTP’s Concerns About Certified API Practices

    New Fact Sheet Highlights ASTP’s Concerns About Certified API Practices

    CLIENT ALERT / INFORMATION BLOCKING

    New Fact Sheet Highlights ASTP’s Concerns About Certified API Practices

    November 4, 2024

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On October 29, 2024, the US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) Assistant Secretary for Technology Policy (ASTP) released a fact sheet titled “Information Blocking Reminders Related to API Technology.” The fact sheet reminds developers of application programming interfaces (APIs) certified under the ASTP’s Health Information Technology (IT) Certification Program and their health care provider customers of practices that constitute information blocking under ASTP’s information blocking regulations and information blocking condition of certification applicable to certified health IT developers.

    In depth

    The fact sheet is noteworthy because it follows ASTP’s recent blog post expressing concern about reports that certified API developers are potentially violating Certification Program requirements and engaging in information blocking. ASTP also recently strengthened its feedback channels by adding a section specifically for API-linked complaints and inquiries to the Health IT Feedback and Inquiry Portal. It appears increasingly likely that initial investigations and enforcement of the information blocking prohibition by the HHS Office of Inspector General will focus on practices that may interfere with access, exchange, or use of electronic health information (EHI) through certified API technology. For more information about the ASTP blog post, see our On the Subject. For more information about how to prepare for enforcement of the information blocking regulations, view our webinar titled “Information Blocking: Defense of Cures Act Investigations and Enforcement.”

    The fact sheet focuses on three categories of API-related practices that could be information blocking under ASTP’s information blocking regulations and Certification Program condition of certification:

    • ASTP cautions against practices that limit or restrict the interoperability of health IT. For example, the fact sheet states that health care providers who locally manage their fast healthcare interoperability resources (FHIR) servers without certified API developer assistance may engage in information blocking when they refuse to provide to certified API developers the FHIR service base URL necessary for patients to access their EHI.
    • ASTP states that impeding innovations and advancements in access, exchange, or use of EHI or health-IT-enabled care delivery may be information blocking. For example, the fact sheet indicates that a certified API developer may engage in information blocking by refusing to register and enable an application for production use within five business days of completing its verification of an API user’s authenticity as required by ASTP’s API maintenance of certification requirements.
    • ASTP states that burdensome or discouraging terms, delays, or influence over customers and users may be information blocking. For example, ASTP states that a certified electronic health record (EHR) developer may engage in information blocking by conditioning the disclosure of interoperability elements to third-party developers on the third-party developer entering into business associate agreements with all of the EHR developer’s covered entity customers, even if the work being done is not for the benefit of the customers and HIPAA does not require the business associate agreements.

    The fact sheet does not address circumstances under which any of the above practices of certified API developers may meet an information blocking exception (established for reasonable practices that interfere with access, exchange, or use of EHI). Regulated actors should consider whether exceptions apply to individual circumstances.

    For information about steps that certified API developers and health care providers should take to avoid information blocking, see our On the Subject regarding the recent ASTP blog post. If you would like to evaluate your certified API compliance, contact any of the authors of this On the Subject or your regular McDermott lawyer or McDermott+ consultant.

    Authors

    Daniel F. Gottlieb

    Partner

    Chicago

    James A. Cannatti III

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Mark W. Pearlstein

    Partner

    Boston

    More insights

  • What Private Equity Companies Should Know About the SBA’s Proposed Size Standard Recertification Rule

    What Private Equity Companies Should Know About the SBA’s Proposed Size Standard Recertification Rule

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    What Private Equity Companies Should Know About the SBA’s Proposed Size Standard Recertification Rule

    November 4, 2024

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The US Small Business Administration (SBA) recently issued a proposed rule impacting the ability of small business government contractors to continue performance of set-aside awards following a merger or acquisition. The changes to 13 CFR § 121.404 are of significance to companies such as private equity firms seeking to acquire small business contractors.

    In depth

    The Current Rule

    Under the SBA’s current regulations, when a small or disadvantaged contractor merges with or is acquired by a large business resulting in the contractor losing its small or disadvantaged size status, the contractor generally remains eligible to continue performance on any existing government set-aside contracts. In most instances, the contractor may complete option periods on existing set-aside contracts and may be eligible for orders under an existing small business Multiple Award Contract (MAC).

    The SBA’s existing rules require contractors to recertify as to size and socioeconomic status within 30 days of a merger, sale, acquisition, or novation, or prior to the end of the fifth year of a long-term contract. However, even if the contractor certifies that it is no longer small or no longer disadvantaged, the government does not automatically terminate the contractor’s set-aside awards. Instead, the awarding agency is simply unable to count any remaining option periods towards the agency’s small business contracting goals.

    The Proposed Change

    The SBA is now proposing to limit a contractor’s ability to continue performance of certain set-aside awards after a transaction causes the contractor to lose its small or disadvantaged business status. The proposed rule modifies the triggering event for a recertification. The new language provides:

    Recertification of size and small business program status (i.e., 8(a), HUBZone, WOSB/EDWOSB, or SDVOSB) is required within 30 calendar days of an approved novation, merger, acquisition, or sale, including agreements in principle, of or by a concern or an affiliate of the concern, which results in a change in controlling interest.

    The current rule presently in effect makes no mention of “an agreement in principle,” meaning that if the proposed rule is approved, contractors may need to recertify as to size status even before a transaction is finalized.

    In addition, the proposed rule includes three significant changes to long-term contracts and pending proposals that will be of particular interest to companies considering acquiring a small or disadvantaged business:

    1. Under the proposed rule, when a contractor recertifies that it is no longer small, it will not be eligible for future task orders under a small business MAC. This is a significant change, as previously contractors that held a small business MAC could continue to be eligible for future task orders even after recertifying as other than small.
    2. The proposed rule similarly prevents contractors who recertify as other than small from receiving small business orders under their General Services Administration federal supply schedule contract.
    3. Finally, under the proposed rule, if a contractor recertifies as other than small within 180 days of submitting a proposal, but prior to an award, the contractor will be ineligible for an award of a small business contract. Under the current rules, if a small business submits a proposal for a small business contract and only later undergoes a change in its small business status, the contractor remains eligible for the contract award. The proposed change means that small businesses that may be eligible for an award when they bid on a contract could forfeit that eligibility by the time the contract is awarded if they undergo a merger or an acquisition.

    The Impact

    The proposed rule impacts the attractiveness of small business contractors as acquisition targets. Large companies and private equity firms are used to assuming that a small business will be able to complete any set-aside contract. Companies will now need to reassess the value of small business targets that derive a portion of their revenue from long term set-aside contracts.

    Authors

    Llewelyn M. Engel

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Daniel P. Graham

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    More insights