Content Type: Article

  • What Are the Maximum Retirement Plan Benefits and Dollar Limits for 2025?

    What Are the Maximum Retirement Plan Benefits and Dollar Limits for 2025?

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    What Are the Maximum Retirement Plan Benefits and Dollar Limits for 2025?

    November 4, 2024

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Secretary of the Treasury announced the 2025 limits for qualified retirement plans and IRAs based on cost of living increases. The Consumer Price Index for all Urban Consumers is the benchmark used to determine the index. With a cost-of-living increase of just 2.5%, employees will see modest dollar limits increases for 2025 for most of the key plan limits, as noted in the table on page 2 of this Alert.

    IRS Notice 2024-80 sets forth the annual dollar limitations on benefits and contributions to qualified plans, effective Jan. 1, 2025, as required under Section 415(d) of the Internal Revenue Code. For 2025, the cap on employee deferrals increases to $23,500, however, catch-up contributions will remain at $7,500. The new catch up for individuals ages 60-63 is $11,250. The annual additions limit for 401(k), 403(b) and other defined contribution plans increases from $69,000 to $70,000.

    For 2025, highly compensated employees, who participate in both qualified and non-qualified plans, will have a greater amount of their compensation allocated to their qualified plan due to the increase in the compensation limit from $345,000 to $350,000.

    Employers and Plan Sponsors of qualified retirement plans should communicate the new limits for 2025 to their plan participants. We are available to advise you on updating your enrollment materials, summary plan descriptions, employee handbooks and other employee communications. If you have any questions about the new limits or any other employee benefit matters, please feel free to contact one of the authors.

    Read this Alert: “What Are the Maximum Retirement Plan Benefits and Dollar Limits for 2025?“

    Authored by Mark E. Brossman, Ian L. Levin, Ronald E. Richman and Susan B. Niver.


     

    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. © 2023 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

     

    In depth
    Authors

    Mark E. Brossman

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Ian L. Levin

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Ronald E. Richman

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Government Announces 2025 Employee Benefit Plan Limits

    Government Announces 2025 Employee Benefit Plan Limits

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Government Announces 2025 Employee Benefit Plan Limits

    November 1, 2024

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) has announced the cost-of-living adjustments to the applicable dollar limits for various employer-sponsored retirement and welfare plans for 2025.

    Most of the dollar limits that are subject to adjustment for cost-of-living increases will increase for 2025. The Social Security Administration released separate adjustment amounts.

    In depth

    The table below compares the applicable dollar limits for certain employee benefit programs and the Social Security wage base for 2024 and 2025.*

    RETIREMENT PLAN LIMITS (guidance link) 2024 Δ 2025
    Annual compensation limit $345,000 ↑ $350,000
    401(k), 403(b) & 457(b) before-tax contributions $23,000 ↑ $23,500
    Catch-up contributions (if age 50 or older) $7,500 = $7,500
    Catch-up contributions (individuals who attain age 60, 61, 62, or 63 in 2025) N/A $11,250
    Highly compensated employee threshold $155,000 ↑ $160,000
    Key employee officer compensation threshold $220,000 ↑ $230,000
    Defined benefit plan annual benefit and accrual limit $275,000 ↑ $280,000
    Defined contribution plan annual contribution limit $69,000 ↑ $70,000
    Employee stock ownership plan (ESOP) limit for determining the lengthening of the general five-year distribution period $275,000 ↑ $280,000
    ESOP limit for determining the maximum account balance subject to the general five-year distribution period $1,380,000 ↑ $1,415,000
    HEALTH AND WELFARE PLAN LIMITS (guidance links here and here) 2024 Δ 2025
    Health Flexible Spending Accounts
    Maximum salary reduction limit $3,200 ↑ $3,300
    Health FSA Carryover Limit $640 ↑ $660
    Dependent Care Flexible Spending Accounts±
    If employee is married and filing a joint return or if the employee is a single parent $5,000 = $5,000
    In employee is married but filing separately $2,500 = $2,500
    Excepted Benefit Health Reimbursement Arrangements (EBHRAs) $2,100 ↑ $2,150
    Qualified Transportation Fringe Benefit and Qualified Parking (monthly limit) $315 ↑ $325
    High-Deductible Health Plans (HDHP) and Health Savings Accounts (HSA)
    HDHP – Maximum annual out-of-pocket limit (excluding premiums):
    Self-only coverage $8,050 ↑ $8,300
    Family coverage $16,100 ↑ $16,600
    HDHP – Minimum annual deductible:
    Self-only coverage $1,600 ↑ $1,650
    Family coverage $3,200 ↑ $3,300
    HSA – Annual contribution limit:
    Self-only coverage $4,150 ↑ $4,300
    Family coverage $8,300 ↑ $8,550
    Catch-up contributions (age 55 or older)± $1,000 ═ $1,000
    SOCIAL SECURITY WAGE BASE (guidance link) 2024 Δ 2025
    Social Security Maximum Taxable Earnings $168,600 ↑ $176,100

    Plan sponsors should update payroll and plan administration systems for the 2025 cost-of-living adjustments and incorporate the new limits into relevant participant communications, like open enrollment materials and summary plan descriptions.

    For further information about applying the new employee benefit plan limits for 2025, contact your regular McDermott lawyer or one of the authors below.


    * The dollar limits are generally applied on a calendar year basis; however, certain dollar limits are applied on a plan-year, tax-year or limitation-year basis.
    ± Not indexed for cost-of-living adjustments, with the exception of limited guidance issued for certain years.

    Authors

    Jeffrey M. Holdvogt

    Partner

    Chicago

    Jacob M. Mattinson

    Partner

    Chicago

    Brian J. Tiemann

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • Trick or Treat: Colorado AG Announces Public Hearing on Proposed CPA Regulations

    Trick or Treat: Colorado AG Announces Public Hearing on Proposed CPA Regulations

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Trick or Treat: Colorado AG Announces Public Hearing on Proposed CPA Regulations

    October 31, 2024

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On October 30, 2024, the Colorado attorney general (AG) announced a November 7, 2024, public rulemaking hearing to receive feedback on its latest proposed Colorado Privacy Act (CPA) regulations. The AG is also accepting written comments until the hearing date.

    In depth

    Accompanying the AG’s announcement was a slightly modified set of the proposed regulations. (We previously analyzed the proposed regulations in September.) The only change involves the effect of AG opinion letters, allowing the AG to specify in the opinion letter whether other entities can rely on the letter. Otherwise, there were no changes to the proposed regulations.

    As a refresher, the proposed regulations (i) require any business that collects biometrics to give a pre-collection notice to the consumer, (ii) expand the scope of data impact assessments to evaluate processing activities related to minors (consumers under age 18), and (iii) introduce methods by which companies can seek regulatory guidance from the Colorado AG.

    What’s Next?

    While subject to change pursuant to public consultation, assuming the proposed CPA amendments are finalized, they would become effective on July 1, 2025. Businesses interested in shaping and commenting on the draft amendments should consider promptly submitting comments to the Colorado AG.

    ***

    If you have questions or need assistance preparing for the new state consumer laws, please contact your regular McDermott lawyer or reach out to the authors.


    Consult our interactive state privacy law map to learn more about all of the enacted state consumer privacy laws.

    Authors

    David P. Saunders

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • Legal Lens on the Unified Patent Court | October 2024

    Legal Lens on the Unified Patent Court | October 2024

    ARTICLE

    Legal Lens on the Unified Patent Court | October 2024

    October 2024

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Unified Patent Court (UPC) is revolutionizing the way patents are enforced in Europe, and McDermott’s intellectual property (IP) team is here to help you navigate this dynamic landscape. Our Legal Lens on the Unified Patent Court newsletter is designed to keep patent holders and legal departments well-informed. And with an on-the-ground team in Germany, France, the United Kingdom and the United States, we offer a unique cross-border perspective.


     

    In depth
    Authors

    Diana Pisani

    European Patent Attorney

    London – 22 Bishopsgate

    Aashish Kapadia

    Partner

    Austin

    More insights

  • UK Autumn Budget 2024 – Headline Measures

    UK Autumn Budget 2024 – Headline Measures

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    UK Autumn Budget 2024 – Headline Measures

    October 31, 2024

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Autumn Budget delivered on 30 October included the following key measures:

    1. National Insurance Contributions (NICs)

    The rate of employers’ NICs will increase from 13.8% to 15% with effect from 6 April 2025. This will increase the overall effective tax rate (i.e. income tax and NIC) on employment compensation from 53.4% to 53.9%. Additionally, the threshold above which employers’ NICs becomes payable will be reduced from £9,100 to £5,000.

    2. Carried Interest

    The Government will bring the taxation of carried interest into the income tax regime with effect from 6 April 2026, albeit subject to the application of a 72.5% multiplier to give an effective tax rate of approximately 34% (including NIC). The Government also intends to explore the case for imposing further conditions, including a minimum co-investment requirement. In the interim, the rate of capital gains tax (CGT) on carried interest will increase from 28% to 32% with effect from
    6 April 2025.

    3. Capital Gains Tax (CGT)

    The rate of CGT will increase from 20% to 24% with effect from 30 October 2024 (today). The rates of CGT on gains qualifying for Business Asset Disposal Relief will increase from 10% to 14% with effect from 6 April 2025, and to 18% with effect from 6 April 2026.

    4. Taxation of Non-Doms

    The remittance basis of taxation as applying to non-UK domiciled individuals will be abolished with effect from 6 April 2025. Transitional rules will apply to previously unremitted foreign income and gains. A residence-based regime will apply to new arrivals to the UK in their first four years of UK tax residence. 

    5. Inheritance Tax (IHT)

    IHT will move to a residence-based system for non-UK assets with effect from 6 April 2025, catching individuals who have been resident in the UK for at least 10 out of the last 20 years.  Such individuals will remain within the charge to IHT on non-UK assets after leaving the UK for up to 10 years on a sliding scale depending on the number of years for which they were UK resident.

    6. Other points of interest…

    • From 1 January 2025 VAT will be imposed on private school fees
    • From 6 April 2026 IHT relief for (i) AIM shares will be reduced from 100% to 50%; and (ii) agricultural and business property will be reduced from 100% to 50% for (combined) amounts over £1m
    • From 6 April 2027 unused pension funds will be included within a person’s estate for IHT purposes
    In depth
    Authors

    Nick Fagge

    Partner

    London – One Eagle Place

    More insights

  • IBA Launches Site Visit Model Protocol for International Arbitration

    IBA Launches Site Visit Model Protocol for International Arbitration

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    IBA Launches Site Visit Model Protocol for International Arbitration

    October 30, 2024

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On September 10, 2024, the International Bar Association (IBA) published the Site Visit Model Protocol for International Arbitration (the Site Visit Model Protocol). This comprehensive document sets out international best practices for conducting site visits in the context of international arbitration. Site visits can be crucial for understanding the project in dispute and gathering evidence, ensuring a fair and efficient arbitration process. However, they must be meticulously planned, which usually requires the parties to agree in advance on a visit protocol.

    In depth

    The Site Visit Model Protocol provides a comprehensive set of standard clauses designed to address the most important issues that are likely to arise during a site visit. Each article is accompanied by drafting notes and commentary covering topics such as the selection of participants; the purpose, scope, and itinerary of the site visit; rules for the collection and admission of evidence; and general guiding principles.

    Purpose and Scope

    The Site Visit Model Protocol outlines the twofold purposes of site visits: to provide context for the arbitral tribunal and to facilitate evidence gathering.

    A visit to the project site allows the tribunal to gain a deeper understanding of the physical and operational aspects of the dispute, which provides a more comprehensive context for the parties’ submissions. Furthermore, site visits enable the collection of evidence that might otherwise be inaccessible, thereby ensuring that both parties have equal access to crucial information. The Site Visit Model Protocol highlights the need for comprehensive, preemptive discussions to avoid procedural complications and guarantee cost-effective site visits. It provides a starting point for parties to tailor the protocol to their particular circumstances, taking into account the distinctive context and industry of the dispute.

    Participants and Roles

    The document provides comprehensive guidance on the composition of the site visit team, including the roles and responsibilities of party representatives, experts, and arbitrators. The protocol specifies that the nature and purpose of the site visit will determine the necessary participants.

    For example, if the objective of the visit is to gather evidence, the input of experts will be essential. Additionally, the protocol also allows for flexibility in participation, including remote attendance via audio or video links. This flexibility is particularly useful in accommodating participants who may face logistical challenges. The protocol includes provisions for handling technological disruptions to ensure that remote participation does not hinder the process.

    The participation of the arbitral tribunal shall be carefully considered by the parties. It may facilitate the site visit and ensure compliance with the site visit protocol. However, the participation of the arbitral tribunal increases the number of issues to be dealt with, including what communications, if any, should be permitted between the arbitrators and other participants during the site visit.

    Logistics and Preparatory Work

    The Site Visit Model Protocol includes comprehensive instructions on logistical arrangements, which are a key feature of the protocol. These include transportation, security, and health and safety measures.

    The protocol places significant emphasis upon the necessity of thorough preparatory work to guarantee seamless access and the smooth execution of the site visit. This preparatory work may entail obtaining the necessary permissions, arranging for safety equipment, and ensuring that all participants are briefed on the itinerary and tasks.

    Sampling, Inspection, and Testing

    The protocol details the procedures for the collection and handling of samples, including the maintenance of the chain of custody and the use of independent laboratories for testing. It provides guidance on how to document and preserve evidence collected during the site visit. This guarantees the credibility of the evidence and its reliability in the arbitration process.

    Furthermore, the protocol addresses the need for transparency and collaboration between parties throughout the sampling and testing processes. By establishing transparent standards and procedures, the protocol helps to avoid disputes over the handling and interpretation of evidence.

    Guiding Principles and Compliance

    The Site Visit Model Protocol establishes a framework to guarantee fair, efficient, and productive site visits. It outlines key principles, including good faith cooperation, transparency, and cost-efficiency, to ensure a smooth and productive process.

    Any dispute that is not explicitly covered by the site visit protocol should be resolved by referring to the guiding principles. These principles set forth procedures for addressing and resolving objections during the site visit, ensuring procedural integrity. They are designed to foster a collaborative environment and to minimize the potential for conflicts that could disrupt the site visit.

    In addition, the protocol includes provisions for ensuring compliance with the agreed-upon procedures, including potential sanctions for noncompliance. This helps guarantee that all parties comply with the protocol and that the site visit is conducted in an efficient and orderly manner.

    Post-Site Visit Matters

    The protocol sets forth the requirements for sharing records and data obtained during the site visit. It allows for the submission of written site visit reports, which may be used either as evidence or treated as a submission in the arbitration proceedings the site visit supports. This ensures that all pertinent data is accessible to the arbitral tribunal and the parties, enabling well-informed decision-making.

    The document underscores the significance of transparency and prompt information sharing to prevent delays in the arbitration process. Its clear guidelines for post-site visit activities guarantee that the evidence gathered during the site visit is effectively integrated into the arbitration proceedings.

    Implications for Practitioners

    The Site Visit Model Protocol is an invaluable resource for legal professionals engaged in international arbitration. By providing a structured approach to site visits, it helps to mitigate risks and enhance the arbitral tribunal’s understanding of the project.

    We recommend that practitioners familiarize themselves with the Site Visit Model Protocol and consider its application in their arbitration cases to ensure compliance with best practices. The protocol’s comprehensive guidelines can assist practitioners in navigating the complexities of site visits, ensuring efficient and effective conduct. This can result in more informed decision-making and more equitable arbitration outcomes.

    ***

    The IBA’s Site Visit Model Protocol represents a significant step in the procedural management of international arbitration. It serves as a robust starting point for the parties to build upon. However, it is not a one-size-fits-all solution; it must be thoughtfully tailored to meet the specific requirements of each case.

    At McDermott, our team of highly skilled international arbitration practitioners focuses on the construction sector, and we are well equipped to assist with any construction-related disputes. We deliver efficient and effective legal solutions, and one of the tools we leverage is the Site Visit Model Protocol. By incorporating this innovative approach into our practice, we ensure a smoother arbitration process, offering enhanced clarity, informed decision-making, and a streamlined resolution.

    Authors

    David Kiefer

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    Maria Cristina Rosales del Prado

    Special Legal Consultant

    Washington, DC

    Maxime Delabarre

    Associate

    Paris

    More insights

  • EdTech and Privacy: Navigating a Shifting Regulatory Landscape

    EdTech and Privacy: Navigating a Shifting Regulatory Landscape

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    EdTech and Privacy: Navigating a Shifting Regulatory Landscape

    October 30, 2024

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Educational technology (EdTech) tools were critical during the COVID-19 pandemic and remain a key part of education, from digital textbooks and instructional material, to interactive applications for teachers, parents, and students. There are many benefits to EdTech, such as personalized learning and rapid feedback. But while these tools have incredible benefits in the classroom, they collect more personal data about students than ever before and have the potential to put students’ privacy at risk. Beyond typical student rosters and class enrollment, these technologies can gather more bespoke information, including survey results, school performance, and study habits, and they even can create psychological profiles and predict academic performance of classrooms and individual students.

    Entities in the education sector – from academic institutions to EdTech vendors and their investors – are all key players in protecting the privacy of students. Because of the personal data collected and processed by EdTech tools, there are a number of education-specific and broader privacy laws that should be considered: the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA) and the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA) at the federal level, as well as California’s Student Online Personal Information Protection Act (SOPIPA) and other state laws.

    This article will provide a high-level summary of these laws and highlight several key privacy and security issues that all entities in the education space should keep in mind while navigating a constantly shifting regulatory landscape.

    In depth

    Legal Overview

    FERPA

    The Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act is the primary federal privacy law regulating student data.[1] FERPA protects “education records,” i.e., records, files, documents, and other materials that 1) contain information directly related to a student and 2) are maintained by an educational agency or institution or by a party acting for the agency or institution.[2] The law prohibits the disclosure of education records except under certain conditions (e.g., to accrediting organizations, designated officials, school officials) or with the consent of the student/parent, and grants rights to parents and eligible students to review, request corrections to, and stop the release of their student records.

    FERPA applies directly to educational institutions and agencies that receive funds from programs administered by the US Department of Education. It applies indirectly to recipients of “education records,” such as EdTech vendors and other contractors. When contracting under FERPA, educational institutions and agencies should enter into a data processing agreement with all EdTech vendors that includes FERPA privacy requirements and imposes minimum data security requirements to protect the student records.

    COPPA

    The Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act applies to for-profit operators of commercial websites and online services that direct their online services to children under age 13 or knowingly collect personal information from children under 13. COPPA follows a notice-and-consent model. Before an online operator knowingly collects the personal information from someone under 13, it must first give notice to and obtain verifiable consent from the minor’s parent or guardian.[3] The business must also, among other things, provide a clear and comprehensive privacy policy, honor the parent or guardian’s rights to access and delete their child’s personal information, and maintain the confidentiality, security, and integrity of the information it collects.

    COPPA could apply to for-profit EdTech vendors in the K-12 setting to the extent their online products are targeted to or collect personal information (such as a name, email address, IP address, and screen name) of children under 13. Many educational institutions partner with EdTech vendors to offer online programs to benefit their students, such as online tutoring, education modules, and homework help lines. EdTech vendors and educational institutions need to have a clear understanding of what personal information is collected by the EdTech vendor, whether any of that personal information is subject to FERPA or other educational privacy laws, and how the parties will work together to obtain verifiable consent and honor rights in compliance with COPPA.

    State Student Privacy Laws

    A number of states have passed laws to protect student privacy. Most of these laws are based on California’s Student Online Personal Information Protection Act, which prohibits EdTech apps and services that target K-12 students from selling or using student personal information for targeted advertising or profiling.[4] Further, it requires EdTech vendors to maintain reasonable security procedures to protect student data and honor data-deletion requests from the school or district.[5] At least 13 states have followed suit by passing laws that are modeled after SOPIPA.

    Additionally, comprehensive privacy and data protection laws are becoming increasingly common and more are being passed each year. Many of these laws generally exempt FERPA-regulated data, and the California Consumer Privacy Act exempts consumer requests to delete certain student data, such as grades and educational scores held on behalf of local educational agencies. However, certain schools and EdTech vendors may still fall within the umbrella of these laws if they meet the requisite thresholds of applicability and process data outside of the scope of FERPA.

    Key Privacy and Security Issues

    Privacy of Student Data

    Over the last few years, the FTC has prioritized the privacy of student data, making it clear that companies cannot ask parents and schools to trade their children’s privacy rights in order to do schoolwork online or attend class remotely. As a result, those that handle student data should carefully examine their privacy practices and aim to minimize the collection, use, and sharing of student data to only the extent necessary to provide the services. EdTech vendors and schools should also be transparent in their data collection and processing practices through their privacy policies and COPPA notices. State privacy laws may also have strict contracting, disclosure, and data-security requirements, which range in scope and effect from state to state.

    EdTech Vendor Contracting

    Contracts between schools and EdTech vendors should take into account all privacy and security laws applicable to both parties and clearly state the data types that will be collected, used, and disclosed as part of the services. Contracts should also include data processing terms that detail the processing activities, ownership rights/control over the data, and any restrictions that must be placed on the data to protect student privacy and comply with applicable law. It is also a good idea to include the physical and technical security measures the EdTech vendor is required to deploy to safeguard student data.

    For EdTech vendors, we recommend incorporating into contract templates terms addressing FERPA’s “school official” exception (i.e., that the vendor performs an institutional service or function for which the institution would otherwise use employees, is under the direct control of the institution with respect to the use and maintenance of education records, and restricts certain uses and disclosures of personally identifiable information)[6] to streamline the procurement process.

    Security

    Security is an important issue for all entities that process and maintain student data. Elements such as encryption at rest and in transit, multifactor authentication, employee training, and role-based access controls are all critical to fostering and maintaining trust with educational institutions. External audits and certifications based on industry standards such as ISO 27001 or SOC2 can verify and improve existing cybersecurity processes. Better cybersecurity practices and the associated certifications can also help lower cyber-insurance premiums by demonstrating robust controls.

    Takeaways

    The legal and regulatory landscape for all involved in the education sector is complex and ever changing, as evidenced by COPPA 2.0 passing the US Senate in July 2024. If you have questions or would like to evaluate your practices, reach out to your McDermott lawyer or the authors of this article.

    Authors

    Amy C. Pimentel

    Partner

    Boston

    Jessica McGahie Sawyer

    Counsel

    Los Angeles

    James S. Mann

    Associate

    Los Angeles

    More insights

  • Intel’s EUR 1 Billion Fine Overturned: ECJ’s Landmark Ruling

    Intel’s EUR 1 Billion Fine Overturned: ECJ’s Landmark Ruling

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Intel’s EUR 1 Billion Fine Overturned: ECJ’s Landmark Ruling

    October 29, 2024

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On October 24, 2024, the European Court of Justice (ECJ) confirmed the annulment by the General Court (GC) of the European Commission’s (EC) decision to impose a EUR 1.06 billion fine on Intel for the abuse of a dominant position on the x86 Central Processing Units (CPUs) market, specifically through the use of exclusivity rebates granted to several computer manufacturers. With its judgment, the ECJ definitively settles a 15-years-long saga, rejecting the presumption that exclusivity rebates restrict competition and requiring the EC to conduct a detailed analysis to demonstrate any such restriction. The era of presuming that exclusivity rebates harm competition has ended with this judgment.

    In depth

    Background

    The saga began with a formal complaint from Intel’s competitor AMD in 2000 which resulted in a decision from the EC on May 13, 2009, imposing a record EUR 1.06 billion fine on Intel for abusing its dominant position in the x86 CPUs market. The sanction addressed two practices: (i) offering conditional rebates to computer manufacturers for purchasing all or nearly all of their x86 CPUs from Intel, and (ii) making direct payments to computer manufacturers or placing restrictions on the distribution of x86 CPUs to incentivize them not to purchase those products from Intel’s competitors (also known as “naked restrictions”). The central issue in this long-running dispute concerns the extent to which the EC needed to prove that Intel’s rebates restricted competition.

    The GC upheld the decision on June 12, 2014, qualifying the rebates granted by Intel as exclusivity rebates and ruling that such a practice constitutes by its very nature (“by object”) an abuse of dominance. It rejected Intel’s argument that such rebates should only be classified as abusive after applying the “as-efficient competitor” (AEC) test, i.e. after assessing whether an equally efficient competitor could offer similar rebates. In fact, even though the EC had found Intel’s rebate inherently abusive, it had also conducted an AEC analysis, which the GC did not review given its finding that the conduct was abusive by its very nature. On appeal, the ECJ set aside the GC’s judgment in its ruling of September 6, 2017, precisely for the GC’s lack of review of the EC’s AEC test, and referred the case back to the GC.

    On January 26, 2022, the GC adopted an effects-based approach and annulled the part of the EC’s decision concerning exclusivity rebates. It considered that, although exclusivity rebates are generally presumed to restrict competition, this presumption can be challenged as they are not anti-competitive by their very nature. The AEC test was necessary to evaluate the foreclosure effects of such rebates. An AEC test consists of assessing whether the total amount of the rebates applied to the “contestable share” of the market (i.e. proportion of the demand that is willing and able to switch to an alternative supplier) resulting in sales above or below costs. It is apparent from the GC judgment that the result of the AEC test is ultimately determined by means of a comparison of the “contestable share” and the “required share” (i.e. proportion of the customer’s requirement that a competitor as efficient as Intel must obtain in order for it to be able to enter the market without incurring losses). If the contestable share is higher than the required share, the AEC test result is positive for Intel, while the opposite situation leads to a negative result and means that the contested rebates are capable of foreclosing a competitor as efficient as Intel.

    The GC found that the EC’s analysis was distorted by several factual errors in applying this test regarding the calculation of the “contestable share” as well as the value of the rebates, the assessment of the advantages in nature granted by Intel and an insufficient extrapolation of data plus a lack of evidence over the entire relevant period. As a result, the GC annulled Intel’s EUR 1.06 billion fine because it couldn’t isolate the portion of the fine related specifically to the “naked restrictions” mentioned above. For more details on the GC’s judgment, see our previous client alert.

    The EC appealed the GC’s judgment on six grounds, arguing that the judgment contained several errors of law as well as misinterpretation and misapplication and infringed upon the EC’s right of defense in its assessment of the AEC test.

    The ECJ’s Judgment

    The ECJ confirmed the GC’s finding that the EC erred by assuming that Intel’s rebates were by their nature anti-competitive without sufficiently proving their capability to foreclose competition based on all relevant circumstances. According to the ECJ, the EC is not only required to assess the extent of the company’s dominance in the relevant market, the contestable share of the market affected by rebates, the conditions and terms under which the rebates were granted and their duration and amount, but also whether there is a strategy aimed at excluding competitors that are at least as efficient as the dominant company in the market.

    The ECJ confirmed that the AEC test, used by the EC to assess whether Intel’s rebates could exclude equally efficient competitors, contained multiple errors in its application regarding several computer manufacturers and retailers. These errors affected the EC’s conclusion that Intel’s rebates had a foreclosure effect. In particular, the EC failed to properly analyze the contestable share of the market covered by Intel’s rebates, which was crucial to assess whether the rebates had a significant foreclosure effect on competitors. It also failed to adequately assess the duration of Intel’s rebates and its potential impact on market foreclosure.

    No doubt the EC’s draft Guidelines on Exclusionary Abuses will need to be partly reevaluated in light of this landmark ruling. Stay tuned for more developments as the effects of the judgement ripple outward.

    Authors

    Stéphane Dionnet

    Partner

    Brussels

    More insights

  • Key Takeaways | Don’t Be Privileged When Asserting Privilege

    Key Takeaways | Don’t Be Privileged When Asserting Privilege

    ARTICLE

    Key Takeaways | Don’t Be Privileged When Asserting Privilege

    October 29, 2024

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    This session of the Private Client West Coast Forum 2024 identified common types of privilege, highlighting potential pitfalls to avoid and tools to protect a client’s privileged information. Types of privilege include attorney-client privilege, IRS Section 7525 Tax Practitioner Privilege, and work product protections. The panelists acknowledged the special issues pertaining to family offices and presented best practices, including execution of a Kovel waiver.

    Session panelists included Robert Barton and Elizabeth R. Glasgow.

    In depth

    Key takeaways included:

    • Attorney-client privilege protects communications between a lawyer and client made in confidence for the purpose of securing legal advice. Generally, the presence of a third party breaks the privilege, though certain non-lawyer third parties acting as consultants or advisors may fall within the scope of attorney-client privilege. Common exceptions and doctrines include testamentary exceptions, fiduciary exceptions, and the common interest/joint defense doctrine.
    • IRS Code Section 7525 Tax Practitioner Privilege applies common law attorney-client privilege to communications between taxpayers and federally authorized tax practitioners. Kovel engagement letters can be used to protect this privilege when an expert advisor is necessary to assist an attorney/tax practitioner in rendering legal or tax advice.
    • Privilege risk areas for advisors and family offices include defining the “client,” inadvertent waiver of privilege protections, and misunderstanding the limits of privilege protections. To mitigate these risks, several best practices should be considered. First, maintain documentation that establishes the legal relationship between the family office legal advisor and family members. Second, state in the initial paragraph of the engagement letter that the purpose of the engagement is to provide litigation risk analysis or assist in preparing a party in the event of litigation. Finally, educate privilege holders on the benefits of privilege and its scope with advisors and establish good habits. These should include, but are not limited to, limiting participants in calls and meetings, identifying privileged documents with headers or subject lines, and refraining from forwarding materials outside the circle of privilege.
    Authors

    Robbie Barton

    Partner

    Los Angeles

    More insights

  • Key Takeaways | Planning Ahead for Successful Post-Death Administration

    Key Takeaways | Planning Ahead for Successful Post-Death Administration

    ARTICLE

    Key Takeaways | Planning Ahead for Successful Post-Death Administration

    October 29, 2024

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    This session of the Private Client West Cost Forum 2024 discussed best avenues for family offices and their advisors to consider when managing a complex post-death administration, including steps to address and anticipate future challenges, minimize or avoid court proceedings and litigation, reduce tensions during administration, and account for liquidity needs and asset preservation.

    Session panelists included Laurelle M. Gutierrez and Nicole M. Pearl.

    In depth

    Key takeaways included:

    • Planning ahead is very important to ensure a successful trust administration that carries out the client’s intended estate plan. Clients should have a revocable trust and a pour-over will to avoid probate and court proceedings after death and should also anticipate notice requirements and address privacy concerns when making specific gifts.
    • To reduce tensions during trust administration, it is important to select the right fiduciaries. These fiduciaries should be individuals or organizations that can commit their time and have demonstrated an ability to communicate well and make informed decisions.
    • When preparing for trust administration, it is important to address potential liquidity needs to pay taxes, expenses, and to address the needs of the beneficiaries. Liquidity sources can include proceeds from the sale of assets, life insurance proceeds, or borrowed funds.
    • Lifetime planning structures should be reviewed to identify potential estate tax and audit risks, to ensure the efficient use of all available tax exemptions and to consider the impact of discounts and basis.
    Authors

    Laurelle M. Gutierrez

    Partner

    San Francisco, Silicon Valley

    Nicole M. Pearl

    Partner

    Los Angeles

    More insights