Content Type: Article

  • SEC Settlements Signal Increased Scrutiny of Cybersecurity Disclosures

    SEC Settlements Signal Increased Scrutiny of Cybersecurity Disclosures

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    SEC Settlements Signal Increased Scrutiny of Cybersecurity Disclosures

    November 25, 2024

    Read time: 11 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On October 22, 2024, the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC, or Commission) brought settled actions against four publicly traded companies that were downstream victims of the Russia-linked cyberattack on SolarWinds known as SUNBURST. The four companies – all prominent technology and communications companies – had unknowingly installed SUNBURST malware and were compromised by a likely nation-state threat actor during the SolarWinds attack.

    In announcing these enforcement actions, the SEC alleged the companies “negligently minimiz[ed] [the SolarWinds] cybersecurity incident,” thereby “victimiz[ing] their shareholders” and other investors. The SEC’s settlements focused on different time frames in the arc of a company’s response to the security incident and varying disclosure documents, highlighting the importance of full and accurate disclosures related to an incident itself, as well as in annual risk-factor disclosures. Announcing the settlements together sent a clear warning about increased regulatory scrutiny related to cybersecurity disclosures.

    Below, we summarize each settlement and provide some considerations for public companies to keep in mind as they navigate the challenging balance of responding to cybersecurity incidents and complying with securities regulatory disclosure obligations.

    In depth

    Unisys

    Unisys is an American information technology (IT) service provider to large commercial and public-sector entities, including the US government. In its order, the SEC alleged that the company mischaracterized cybersecurity risks as “hypothetical,” despite knowing that the SolarWinds attack had actually compromised Unisys’s network and non-customer facing cloud environment beginning in 2020.

    The cybersecurity risk disclosures in the company’s 2020 and 2021 Forms 10-K stated that a cybersecurity incident “could … result in the loss … or unauthorized disclosure or misuse of company information” and that “[i]f our systems are accessed without our authorization … we could … experience data loss and impediments to our ability to conduct our business, and damage the market’s perception of our services and products” (emphasis in the order). The order states that Unisys’s use of hypothetical language was “inaccurate” because at the time of the disclosures, Unisys knew that “intrusions had actually happened and in fact involved unauthorized access and exfiltration of confidential and/or proprietary information.” In addition, the SEC alleged that the company lacked effective procedures to elevate cybersecurity concerns to senior management and sufficient log data to cover the scope of the incident, in violation of the Exchange Act.

    The SEC’s order called out that Unisys cooperated with the investigation and presented to the SEC on key factual issues, and that Unisys implemented remedial measures to its cybersecurity reporting procedures. While neither admitting nor denying the SEC’s findings, Unisys agreed to pay a $4 million penalty.

    Check Point

    Check Point is an Israeli technology company that provides cybersecurity solutions for IT companies worldwide. The SEC alleged that Check Point made materially misleading statements in its 2021 and 2022 Forms 20-F cybersecurity risk-factor disclosures. The SEC characterized the disclosures as “generic” and identical to previous disclosures, despite Check Point learning of installation and use of unauthorized software typically associated with malicious data exfiltration and network reconnaissance in late 2020. The disclosures stated that “[w]e regularly face attempts … to gain unauthorized access through the Internet or to introduce malicious software to our … systems,” that “malicious hackers may attempt to gain unauthorized access,” but that “[t]o date, [no attempts] have resulted in any material adverse impact to our business or operations.”

    The SEC alleged that Check Point’s failure to update its annual cybersecurity risk disclosures after learning about the cybersecurity compromise was negligent, and that it was materially misleading for the company to frame the cybersecurity compromises as immaterial. The agency suggested that the incidents were material because the threat actor had access to Check Point’s network “unmonitored for several months,” deployed unauthorized software, and “attempted” to move laterally in the network. The SEC also suggested that the nation-state threat actor’s identity was material because of Check Point’s status as a cybersecurity solutions provider.

    The order acknowledged that Check Point cooperated with the SEC’s investigation, including by conducting its own internal investigation, sharing its findings with SEC staff, and enhancing its cybersecurity controls. While neither admitting nor denying the SEC’s findings, Check Point agreed to pay a $995,000 penalty.

    A US Digital Communications Provider

    The SEC alleged that a US digital communications provider (the company) made materially misleading statements about the SolarWinds cybersecurity incident in its quarterly Form 10-Q disclosure after learning that a threat actor had accessed 145 files and a cybersecurity employee’s email account.

    The company disclosed in its quarterly Form 10-Q that it “believed” a cybersecurity incident “resulted in unauthorized access to our email system” and to “a limited number of . . . email messages.” The filing also stated, “we do not believe that this incident has had or will have a material adverse impact on our business or operations.” The SEC found that the statements “minimized” the cybersecurity incident and “omitted material facts,” including that the activity was attributable to “a nation-state threat actor.” Although the SEC’s new cybersecurity disclosure rules do not require identification of the threat actor in disclosures, the order suggested that a nation-state threat actor’s identity was material because the company provided services to “large enterprises and governments” and the company’s “ability to protect information and data stored on and transmitted over its systems was critically important to its reputation and ability to attract and retain customers.”

    The order acknowledged that the company cooperated with the SEC’s investigation, including by conducting its own internal investigation, sharing its findings with SEC staff, and enhancing its cybersecurity controls. While neither admitting nor denying the SEC’s findings, the company agreed to pay a $1 million penalty.

    Mimecast

    Mimecast is an American-British cloud security and risk-management services provider. The SEC alleged that the company made materially misleading statements when disclosing the SolarWinds cybersecurity incident in Forms 8-K.

    In January 2021, Mimecast learned that the threat actors had accessed its internal emails and exfiltrated an authentication certificate, large parts of its software code, a database with encrypted login details for 31,000 customers, and server and setup information for around 17,000 customers. Shortly thereafter, Mimecast filed three Forms 8-K in January and March 2021 disclosing the incident. The Forms 8-K stated a “low single digit” and a “small” number of customers were targeted. The Forms 8-K also stated that the threat actor exfiltrated a “limited number” of emails, and that the incident did not have “any impact on our products.” The SEC found these statements downplayed the scale of the incident and omitted key information, including the number of customers affected and the large amount of software code exfiltrated.

    The order acknowledged that Mimecast cooperated with the SEC’s investigation, including by conducting its own internal investigation, sharing its findings with SEC staff, and enhancing its cybersecurity controls. While neither admitting nor denying the findings in the order, Mimecast agreed to pay a $990,000 penalty.

    Republican Commissioner Dissent

    Commissioners Hester M. Peirce and Mark T. Uyeda dissented from the SEC’s settlement orders. The dissent accused the SEC of “playing Monday morning quarterback” by “engag[ing] in a hindsight review to second-guess the disclosure and cit[ing] immaterial, undisclosed details to support its charges.”

    The dissent argued the SEC’s finding that disclosures needed to include details such as “specific percentages and types of source code” contradicted its previous statements that called for disclosures to focus on the impact of an incident. As a result, according to the dissent, companies will disclose immaterial details or events in order “to avoid being second-guessed by the Commission.” The dissent also criticized the SEC’s conclusion that improperly omitting the threat actor’s identity was material, a detail the SEC never previously stated was material.

    The dissent argued that using hypothetical language or omitting immaterial cybersecurity incidents in risk-disclosure statements is not improper. The dissent noted the similar facts in the SEC’s case against SolarWinds, where Judge Paul A. Engelmeyer of the US District Court for the Southern District of New York dismissed some SEC claims based on SolarWinds’ use of hypothetical language in cybersecurity-risk disclosures. The dissent added that the purpose of risk-factor statements is to “warn investors about events that could occur … to the extent that an event has occurred and has materially affected the company, it is generally required to be disclosed in another part of the filing” (emphasis in original). The dissent warned that the SEC’s reasoning will lead to a proliferation of disclosures of immaterial events.

    Key Takeaways

    Notwithstanding the vigorous dissent, and the possibility of a changed SEC enforcement agenda in the Trump administration, we believe that the orders convey important lessons for public companies facing cybersecurity events.

    • When making a disclosure decision:
      • The SEC settlements illustrate the importance of the SEC’s new rules regarding Form 8-K Item 1.05 disclosure requirements, which require domestic registrants to disclose material cybersecurity incidents within four business days of determining that an incident is material. However, the rules did not define materiality. Instead, the SEC’s explanation of the new rules stated that whether information regarding a cybersecurity incident is material should be assessed “through the lens of the reasonable investor.” The orders reflect that the SEC’s lens may be more of a microscope, as at least two orders focused on the failure to identify a nation-state threat actor.
      • The SEC also explained that the new rules do not require a “quantifiable trigger” for disclosure of a cybersecurity incident. The SEC explained that “an incident that results in significant reputation harm to a registrant may not be readily quantifiable … but it should nonetheless be reported if the reputational harm is material.” Instead, it will be up to companies to develop policies and processes that include quantitative and qualitative triggers that properly investigate, escalate, and disclose incidents.
      • The SEC settlements, coupled with the SEC’s explanation of the new rules, show that the SEC views materiality in the cybersecurity context broadly, and expects companies – particularly companies with large enterprise or government clients and that transmit and store their data on the companies’ networks – to promptly report cybersecurity incidents in filings.
    • Content of the disclosure:
      • These SEC settlements also show that when a company experiences a significant cyber incident, enforcement staff will scrutinize public statements about the incident, including those made at the time of the incident and which describe how the incident effects annual risk-factor disclosures. That scrutiny will be done with the benefit of hindsight.
        • Companies should be cautious about describing cybersecurity risks in hypothetical terms when an incident has occurred. The SEC found that Check Point failed to update its annual report cybersecurity risk disclosures despite knowledge of a cybersecurity incident. Check Point’s annual report included affirmative disclosures that it faced regular attempts to compromise its network by threat actors, but that none of those attempts was material. The SEC viewed Check Point’s claim of immateriality to be misleading, because the company’s risk profile “had increased” following the SolarWinds cybersecurity attack.
        • Companies should also consider quantifying aspects of the attack to the extent possible. The new Form 8-K Item 1.05 requires companies reporting material incidents to “describe the material aspects of the nature, scope, and timing of the incident, and the material impact or reasonably likely material impact on the registrant, including its financial condition and results of operations.” Companies should focus on the duration and scope of threat-actor access and potentially consider the relevance of the threat actor’s identity to a reasonable investor. Companies should also evaluate the number of customers affected and the amount of information exfiltrated.
    • During an investigation:
    • Even in the upcoming Trump administration, we expect continued emphasis by the SEC in the cybersecurity space, which has been championed by Republicans and Democrats. That said, we expect the SEC to be more willing to entertain the argument that victimized companies already have been harmed and to engage in less second guessing of timely, good-faith disclosures of incidents.
    Authors

    Paul M.G. Helms

    Partner

    Chicago, Washington, DC

    Sagar K. Ravi

    Partner

    Washington, DC, New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • What to Expect During the Presidential Nominee Vetting Process

    What to Expect During the Presidential Nominee Vetting Process

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    What to Expect During the Presidential Nominee Vetting Process

    November 22, 2024

    Read time: 10 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    US presidential nominees, especially those nominated to positions requiring Senate confirmation, should expect to undergo a rigorous vetting and financial disclosure process. The complexity of these requirements can be daunting, particularly for nominees with extensive business and financial interests.

    This article provides a high-level overview of the vetting process and identifies steps potential nominees can take to facilitate a smoother process and minimize the impact on their financial holdings.

    In depth

    The Role of the Office of Government Ethics and Financial Disclosure Requirements

    The US Office of Government Ethics (OGE) is an independent government agency tasked with preventing financial conflicts of interest across the more than 140 executive branch agencies.

    The OGE’s most significant responsibility is aiding the transition between presidential administrations. The Ethics in Government Act, which established the OGE, mandates that nominees for certain executive branch positions – including those requiring Senate confirmation – file detailed financial disclosure reports. The two primary disclosure reports are the Executive Branch Personnel Public Financial Disclosure Report (OGE Form 278e) and the supplemental Periodic Transaction Report (OGE Form 278-T). These reports require nominees to disclose income, assets, liabilities, transactions, gifts, and other financial interests, as well as any positions held outside of government. Nominees must also disclose similar information for the nominee’s spouse and dependent children.

    The OGE, in conjunction with the White House’s Office of the General Counsel ethics office and the relevant federal agency, is tasked with reviewing these financial disclosure reports to ensure they are complete and to identify potential sources of conflict. If the OGE identifies potential conflicts, the nominee will be required to take steps to resolve them. These can include:

    • Divestiture: Divestiture simply means that the nominee resigns from the position in question or sells the asset posing a potential conflict. Under the past administration, divestiture became the default method to eliminate conflicts, as it created a clean break that prevents future conflicts from arising.
    • Recusal: A nominee may elect to recuse themselves from matters that could affect their financial interests. In past administrations, recusal has been a less favored method than divestiture, as it is seen as potentially hamstringing a nominee’s ability to perform the duties of the position.
    • Waivers: In some instances, an agency, in consultation with the OGE, will elect to grant a written waiver. The OGE may grant a waiver when it determines a nominee’s financial interest is not likely to impact the nominee’s integrity. The first Trump administration favored waivers to address the complexity of the disclosure process and to reduce the burden on nominees. We expect the incoming Trump administration to bring conflict waivers back into favor to expedite a vetting process that could otherwise deter potential nominees from serving in the government. It should be noted, however, that a waiver from the OGE waives only the conflict; it is not a waiver of the nominee’s disclosure obligations.

    Once the OGE reviews the nominee’s financial disclosure and is satisfied that any potential conflicts can been resolved, the agency enters into an ethics agreement with the nominee. The agreement outlines the steps the nominee and the OGE will take to resolve any conflicts of interest and ensure the nominee adheres to ethical standards throughout the nominee’s tenure. For example, if the nominee has agreed to resolve potential conflicts through recusal or divestiture, the ethics agreement will detail the scope of the recusal or divestiture and the steps the nominee must take to ensure compliance.

    What Potential Nominees Should Expect, and How They Can Prepare

    Preparing for the vetting process can be daunting, but understanding the requirements and expectations can help a nominee avoid extensive back and forth with the OGE. What follows are some key points potential nominees should consider.

    1. Understand the Scope of the Disclosure Process

    Nominees must disclose detailed information about their financial interests, professional history, and personal background. For some nominees, the disclosure and conflict resolution process may be more than they are willing to take on. We have worked with clients who, after reviewing the requirements and the steps needed to resolve potential conflicts, decided that the process was too burdensome and chose not to pursue the nomination. It is important for potential nominees to understand the scope of the disclosure process and discuss the process with a lawyer and financial adviser before moving forward.

    The OGE requires nominees to disclose:

    • Financial Holdings: Be prepared to provide comprehensive information about your and your spouse’s assets, income, liabilities, real estate holdings, and other financial interests, including the terms and assets of family trusts. Nominees must disclose all sources of income, including salaries, investments, consulting fees, speaking engagements, book royalties, and any other forms of compensation. Collect all relevant financial documents, including bank statements, investment portfolios, tax returns, and records of any liabilities like mortgages or personal loans.
    • Professional History: Expect to disclose all positions held outside the federal government, including directorships, partnerships, trustee positions, employment with private organizations, and even volunteer positions.
    • Personal Background: Be prepared for a thorough background check examining your personal and professional history. This includes any lawsuit in which the nominee is or has been a named party, as well as any other relevant legal proceedings.

    One of the most time-consuming aspects of the vetting process is gathering and organizing financial information, especially for nominees with diverse investments and business interests. Potential nominees can review the OGE’s Form 278e guide for a full overview of the information that must be disclosed and begin collecting the required information. The agency typically engages in an extensive back and forth with the nominee to ensure the OGE Form 278e is complete. A nominee can expedite this process by collecting comprehensive information in advance.

    In addition to the OGE 278e, nominees must also complete the Standard Form 86 (SF-86), which collects the information necessary for a background check. Past administrations have also required nominees to complete a SF-86 supplement, which requests additional information, along with Form 14767, Consent to Disclose Tax Compliance Check, and a federal campaign contribution report.

    The disclosure process does not end with confirmation. Throughout their government service, senior government officials must track reportable transactions and submit an OGE 278-T within 30 days of being notified of the transaction or within 45 days of the transaction occurring, whichever is shorter. Reportable transactions may include any purchase, sale, or exchange by the nominee – or the nominee’s spouse or dependent child – of stocks, bonds, commodity futures, or other securities if the amount of the transaction exceeds $1,000. In addition to these periodic reports, senior officials are also subject to annual and termination reporting requirements.

    2. Understand the Options Available to Minimize Financial Impact

    Nominees who hold financial assets that the OGE believes may cause a conflict of interest must develop a plan, approved by the OGE, to resolve the conflict upon confirmation.

    We have helped clients negotiate with the OGE and establish approved plans that resolve conflict issues while avoiding significant financial burdens. As noted above, resolving a conflict may entail divesting assets, recusal from matters with the potential to impact the nominee’s financial holdings, or obtaining a waiver from the OGE. We have assisted nominees in navigating each of these options.

    As previously discussed, divestiture is the most common avenue for resolving conflicts. Once an asset is divested and reinvested on an approved basis, there is no ongoing risk of a conflict of interest. While it may seem prudent for potential nominees with assets that could pose a conflict to divest those assets before undergoing vetting by the OGE, there are benefits to waiting to divest. If a conflict requires a nominee to divest an asset, the OGE can issue a Certificate of Divestiture, allowing the nominee to defer federal taxes on capital gains from the sale of the asset. This is a potentially attractive tax option for nominees, as it offsets the financial burden of divesting the asset and provides a potentially beneficial proposition. However, Certificates of Divestiture are only available in limited instances, and the OGE may not offer divestiture for assets held in trust or when there are other ways to address the conflict.

    While nominees required to divest an asset must do so within 90 days of confirmation, Certificates of Divestiture are only effective if obtained before divestiture. Therefore, nominees must plan to seek a Certificate of Divesture from the OGE and obtain it before divesting the asset and before the 90-day window expires.

    Nominees may also work with the OGE to request a waiver for certain holdings. Pursuant to 18 US Code § 208(b)(1), waivers are available if the nominee has disclosed the financial interest and receives, in advance, a written determination “that the interest is not so substantial as to be deemed likely to affect the integrity of the services which the government may expect from such officer or employee.” The OGE will only consider a waiver when nominees are fully transparent regarding their financial holdings. We have worked with the OGE to explain the nature of a nominee’s particularly complex financial holdings and have successfully obtained a waiver by demonstrating to the OGE that certain assets would not impact the nominee’s integrity and ability to perform the position if confirmed.

    In instances where the nominee’s assets and financial positions are particularly extensive or complex, nominees will benefit from advanced planning to avoid unexpected consequences that may harm their financial position in the long run. Nominees should be ready to educate the OGE on the nuances of certain complex assets, trusts, and financial relationships. While the OGE continues to issue new guidance, particularly regarding private investment funds and trusts, nominees should not assume that the OGE has a set precedent for every type of holding. For example, we worked with the OGE to develop an approved plan to restructure a client’s assets so that the divested assets could receive a Certificate of Divestiture, while other assets were placed in an irrevocable trust that the OGE determined qualified for a waiver.

    The incoming Trump administration is likely to nominate several wealthy Americans who will be subject to the OGE vetting process. While we anticipate that the incoming administration may reform the vetting process to relax certain requirements seen by some as unduly burdensome, the disclosure and conflict requirements are statutory, and certain bedrock principles will remain.

    3. Be Prepared for Scrutiny

    The vetting process involves a high level of public scrutiny. Potential nominees should be prepared for:

    • Public Disclosure: The recent trend is to make financial disclosure forms and ethics agreements publicly available. Be ready for your financial interests and potential conflicts to be scrutinized by the public and the media.
    • Investigation: Prior administrations have relied on the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) to assist in the vetting process of senior nominees. While it remains to be seen how much the incoming Trump administration will rely on the FBI, nominees should be prepared to undergo an extensive background check.
    • Senate Hearings: The Senate confirmation process includes public hearings where your qualifications and background will be examined in detail. Be prepared to answer questions and address any concerns that may arise.

    Preparing for the presidential nominee vetting process requires careful planning, transparency, and a thorough understanding of ethical standards. By understanding the process and organizing financial information, potential nominees can navigate the process more smoothly and increase their chances of a successful confirmation.

    Authors

    Llewelyn M. Engel

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    James H. Cundiff

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • Proposed Disregarded Payment Loss Rules Create Traps for the Unwary

    Proposed Disregarded Payment Loss Rules Create Traps for the Unwary

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Proposed Disregarded Payment Loss Rules Create Traps for the Unwary

    November 19, 2024

    Read time: 10 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Be wary: The US Department of the Treasury’s proposed disregarded payment loss (DPL) regulations lay surprising new traps for multinational taxpayers – and those ensnared are unlikely to see what’s coming.

    Under the proposed regulations, disregarded payments from a foreign disregarded entity to its domestic corporate parent can give rise to a US income inclusion without any offsetting deduction.[1] This phantom income can be substantial and because the inclusion results from payments that are disregarded as a matter of US tax law, it is sure to be an unwelcome surprise for some taxpayers.

    Multinational taxpayers with US corporate entities that hold or acquire interests in foreign disregarded entities should understand the proposed regulations, determine their potential exposure, and consider steps to mitigate potential tax liabilities. This article provides a high-level overview of the proposed regulations and reviews the questions that multinational companies should ask themselves before the traps are sprung.

    In depth

    The DPL rules are included in proposed regulations that were published on August 7, 2024.[2] The proposed regulations address, among other topics, how the Section 1503(d) dual consolidated loss (DCL) rules apply in the context of Pillar Two taxes. Though the proposed regulations include both DCL and DPL rules and the DPL rules use similar timing and concepts as the DCL rules, the DPL rules operate separately and apply to a different set of circumstances.[3]

    While the DCL rules prevent taxpayers from deducting the same loss twice (once in the United States and once in a foreign jurisdiction), the DPL rules target “deduction/no inclusion” (D/NI) outcomes. In a D/NI scenario, a domestic corporation owns a foreign disregarded entity that makes payments to its domestic corporate parent. The payments are regarded for foreign tax purposes and may give rise to a foreign deduction or loss but are disregarded for US tax purposes, so there is no corresponding US income inclusion. Under foreign tax law, the foreign deduction or loss can be used to offset other foreign income and reduce foreign tax.[4]

    To prevent D/NI outcomes, the proposed DPL rules identify certain foreign tax losses attributable to disregarded payments and then require the domestic corporate parent to include a corresponding amount of income for US tax purposes. However, the rules are extremely broad and may require US income inclusions where there is no D/NI outcome or potentially when the foreign disregarded entity is not actually in a loss position from a foreign tax perspective.[5]

    As explained below, the rules (1) apply only to domestic corporations that are deemed to consent to their application, (2) may require domestic corporations to include a substantial “DPL inclusion amount” as ordinary income with no offsetting deduction, and (3) will require such inclusion whenever one of two triggering events occur, namely, a “foreign use” of the DPL or a failure to satisfy the rules’ certification requirements.

    Deemed Consent

    The DPL rules apply only to consenting domestic corporations but set a low bar for what this “consent” requires. Essentially, a domestic corporation consents to the rules if it owns a foreign disregarded entity, with the applicability date depending on when the domestic corporation acquired or checked the box on the foreign disregarded entity.

    First, a domestic corporation consents to the DPL rules if it directly or indirectly owns interests in a “specified eligible entity”[6] that makes a check-the-box election on or after August 6, 2024, to be a disregarded entity.[7]

    Second, a domestic corporate owner is deemed to consent to the DPL rules if, as of August 6, 2025, the entity directly or indirectly owns interests in a disregarded entity and has not otherwise consented to the rules. To avoid such deemed consent with respect to a disregarded entity, the disregarded entity may instead elect to be treated as a corporation prior to August 6, 2025. Of course, the related consequences of such an election can be significant.[8]

    The DPL Inclusion Amount

    Domestic corporations that consent to the rules may be required to include a DPL inclusion amount as income. For a specified eligible entity or foreign branch of a consenting domestic corporation (such specified eligible entity or foreign branch is referred to as a “disregarded payment entity”), the DPL for a given tax year is the disregarded payment entity’s net loss for foreign tax purposes that is composed of certain items of income and deduction that are disregarded for US tax purposes.[9] The notice of proposed rulemaking (NPRM) provides the following example:

    [I]f for a foreign taxable year a disregarded payment entity’s only items are a $100x interest deduction and $70x of royalty income, and if each item were disregarded for U.S. tax purposes as a payment between a disregarded entity and its tax owner (but taken into account under foreign law), then the entity would have a $30x disregarded payment loss for the taxable year.

    The DPL inclusion amount is the DPL amount reduced by the positive balance of the “DPL cumulative register.” The DPL cumulative register reflects the cumulative amount of disregarded payment income attributable to the disregarded payment entity across multiple years. The NPRM also provides the following example:

    [I]f a disregarded payment entity incurs a $100x disregarded payment loss in year 1 and has $80x of disregarded payment income in year 2, only $20x of the disregarded payment loss is likely available under the foreign tax law to be put to a foreign use. As such, if a triggering event occurs at the end of year 2, then the specified domestic owner must include in gross income $20x (rather than the entire $100x of the disregarded payment loss).

    Taxpayers who expect to benefit from the DPL cumulative register should keep in mind that the register only reflects disregarded payments that would be interest, royalties, or structured payments if regarded for US tax purposes. It reflects no other disregarded payments, and it reflects no regarded payments of any sort.

    Notably, disregarded payment entities “for which the relevant foreign tax law is the same” are generally combined and treated as a single disregarded payment entity for purposes of the DPL rules. As a result, disregarded payments between entities formed in the same foreign jurisdiction generally should not give rise to DPL inclusions. However, this rule applies only where the entities have the same foreign tax year and are owned by the same consenting domestic corporation or by consenting domestic corporations that are members of the same consolidated group. Further, to ensure the items of foreign income and deduction net against one another within the combined disregarded payment entity, taxpayers should analyze the applicable foreign tax rules to confirm that these items accrue in the same foreign taxable year.

    The Triggering Events

    Consenting domestic corporations will be forced to include the DPL inclusion amount as ordinary income if one of two triggering events occurs within a certification period. A certification period includes the foreign tax year in which the DPL is incurred, any prior foreign tax year, and the subsequent 60-month period. These certification periods and triggering events are somewhat similar to the ones used in the DCL rules. In the case of the DPL rules, however, there is no ability to make a domestic use election, as for US tax purposes there is no regarded loss that can be used to offset US tax.

    The first triggering event is a “foreign use” of the DPL. A foreign use is determined under the principles of the DCL rules. Thus, a foreign use generally occurs when any portion of a deduction taken into account in computing the DPL is made available to offset or reduce income under foreign tax law that is considered under US tax law to be income of a related foreign corporation (and certain other entities in limited circumstances).

    The second triggering event occurs if the domestic corporation fails to comply with certification requirements. Specifically, where a consenting domestic corporation’s disregarded entity has incurred a DPL, the domestic corporation must certify annually throughout the certification period that no foreign use of the DPL has occurred.

    Hybrid Mismatch Rules and Pillar Two

    The DPL rules provide that if a relevant foreign tax law denies a deduction for an item to prevent a D/NI outcome, the item is not taken into account for purposes of computing DPL or disregarded payment income. These so-called “hybrid mismatch rules” go some way toward softening the headache the DPL rules are likely to cause taxpayers.

    However, foreign countries’ adoption of Pillar Two rules will exacerbate their impact. The rules make clear that for purposes of a qualified domestic minimum top-up tax (QDMTT) or income inclusion rule (IIR) top-up tax, foreign use is considered to occur where a portion of the deductions or losses that comprise a DPL is taken into account in determining net Global Anti-Base Erosion Rules income for a QDMTT or IIR or in determining qualification for the Transitional Country-by-Country Safe Harbor.[10] There is also a transition rule providing that, for this purpose, QDMTTs and IIRs are not taken into account for taxable years beginning before August 6, 2024.[11] This means that calendar year taxpayers who have not consented early to the DPL rules generally should not have a DPL inclusion amount in 2024 solely as a result of Pillar Two taxes, but, depending on their facts, could have an inclusion next year if proactive measures are not taken.

    Next Steps

    Now is the time for multinational taxpayers to evaluate their risk under the DPL rules. Taxpayers with a domestic corporation in their structure should think carefully before making check-the-box elections to treat foreign entities as disregarded entities.[12] Moreover, taxpayers should determine whether their domestic corporations own any foreign disregarded entities or other specified entities that will cause them to be deemed to consent to the rules as of August 6, 2025.

    Multinational taxpayers also should determine whether they have disregarded interest payments, structured payments, or royalties that fall under the purview of the rules. If so, they should consider whether they will be able to avoid future triggering events or if “foreign uses” of DPLs will be unavoidable. One should pay particular attention to Pillar Two, including the Transitional Country-by-Country Safe Harbor, when considering whether there could be a foreign use.

    Taxpayers who cannot avoid triggering events should consider whether, and when, to take some defensive measures. Such actions might include winding up foreign disregarded entities that could be subject to the rules, eliminating disregarded payments that would result in DPL income inclusions,[13] or taking other restructuring steps (e.g., electing to treat certain foreign disregarded entities as associations, as the Treasury suggests). When determining whether to take defensive actions, taxpayers should consider the impact that DPL inclusions could have on their overall tax profile, including sourcing issues, foreign tax credits, and the Section 163(j) limitation on business interest deductions. In terms of timing, taxpayers also should consider whether they have until August 5, 2025, to unwind any arrangements subject to the DPL rules or whether it may be prudent to unwind any such arrangements before the end of the year.

    Finally, taxpayers concerned about these rules should watch for news about whether they will be issued in final form. The results of the 2024 US presidential election call into question whether the proposed rules will be finalized or, conceivably, shelved.[14] These considerations further complicate the question of whether and when multinational taxpayers should act in response to the rules, particularly as the clock continues to tick toward the deemed consent date of August 6, 2025.

    To further discuss the proposed DPL regulations and their potential impact, reach out to your regular McDermott lawyer or the authors of this article.

    Authors

    Jeffrey Maydew

    Partner

    Chicago

    Bradford E. LaBonte

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    Elizabeth Chao

    Partner

    Chicago

    Samuel J. Preston

    Associate

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • DOJ Proposes Restrictions on Transactions Involving Bulk Sensitive Data

    DOJ Proposes Restrictions on Transactions Involving Bulk Sensitive Data

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    DOJ Proposes Restrictions on Transactions Involving Bulk Sensitive Data

    November 15, 2024

    Read time: 15 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On October 29, 2024, the US Department of Justice (DOJ) issued a proposed rule to implement US President Joe Biden’s Executive Order (EO) 14117 aimed at preventing access to Americans’ sensitive personal data and US-government-related data by countries of concern.

    The proposed rule would prohibit or restrict certain transactions involving bulk sensitive data (the thresholds of which are defined in this proposed rule), particularly those that pose the national security risk described in the EO. The proposal includes health data as one of the categories of sensitive personal data that could be exploited by countries of concern. This includes personal health data of individuals, which could be used to analyze lifestyles, spending habits, and personal visits to sensitive locations such as health clinics.

    While this proposed rule tackles issues beyond health-specific data, this +Insight article focuses on information relevant to those operating in healthcare. Stakeholders who operate in human genomics, pharmaceutical research and development, and clinical research should review this proposed rule closely.

    Comments are due by November 29, 2024. For assistance preparing comments, contact the author of this piece, or your regular McDermott+ consultant or McDermott lawyer.

    In depth

    Background

    On February 28, 2024, President Biden issued EO 14117, entitled “Preventing Access to Americans’ Bulk Sensitive Personal Data and United States Government-Related Data by Countries of Concern.” The EO directs the Attorney General to issue regulations that prohibit or otherwise restrict US persons from engaging in “any acquisition, holding, use, transfer, transportation, or exportation of, or dealing in, any property in which a foreign country or national thereof has any interest (transaction),” where the transaction:

    • Involves US-government-related data or bulk US sensitive personal data, as defined by final rules implementing the EO;
    • Falls within a class of transactions that has been determined by the Attorney General to pose an unacceptable risk to the national security of the United States because the transactions may enable access by countries of concern or covered persons to government-related data or bulk US sensitive personal data; and
    • Meets other criteria specified by the EO.

    DOJ’s proposed rule identifies six countries of concern:

    • People’s Republic of China, along with the Special Administrative Region of Hong Kong and the Special Administrative Region of Macau.
    • Russian Federation.
    • Islamic Republic of Iran.
    • Democratic People’s Republic of Korea.
    • Republic of Cuba.
    • Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela.

    The goal of the proposed rule is to protect “sensitive personal data” from being exploited by a country of concern to harm US national security, particularly if that data is linked or linkable to any identifiable US individual or to a discrete and identifiable group of US persons. As a result, relevant entities would be prohibited from sharing bulk sensitive data with the six countries identified as a threat to national security.

    The proposed rule provides specific definitions of sensitive personal data and what constitutes “bulk.” It clarifies exceptions and exemptions (which are particularly relevant for certain healthcare entities), as well as proposed penalties.

    Definitions and Proposed Thresholds

    The proposed rule defines of six categories of sensitive personal data:

    • Covered personal identifiers.
    • Precise geolocation data.
    • Biometric identifiers.
    • Human genomic data.
    • Personal health data.
    • Personal financial data.

    DOJ also proposes four tiers of sensitivity, which tie to numerical thresholds for bulk sensitive personal data. Relevant proposed definitions and thresholds are discussed below.

    Bulk US sensitive personal data. The proposed rule defines this as a collection or set of sensitive personal data relating to US persons, in any format, regardless of whether the data is anonymized, pseudonymized, de-identified, or encrypted.

    The proposed rule defines “bulk” as any amount of such data that meets or exceeds the specified thresholds during a given 12-month period, whether through one covered data transaction or multiple covered data transactions involving the same US person and the same foreign person or covered person.

    Covered person. The proposed rule identifies a “covered person” as an individual or entity that the Attorney General has designated as a covered person or that falls into one of the following classes of covered persons:

    • Is 50% or more owned, directly or indirectly, by a country of concern.
    • Is organized or chartered under the laws of a country of concern.
    • Has its principal place of business in a country of concern.

    An entity is also a covered person if it is a foreign person that is 50% or more owned, directly or indirectly, by a covered person. Any foreign individual who is an employee or a contractor of such an entity or of the country of concern itself is also a covered person.

    The proposed rule would not treat any US person, including a US subsidiary of a covered person, as a covered person unless the DOJ has designated the US subsidiary as a covered person pursuant to the process described in the proposed rule. No US person, including the US subsidiary of a covered person, would be categorically treated as a covered person under the proposed rule.

    Human genomic data. The proposed rule has been identified as the most sensitive category, and DOJ proposes that human genomic data be on its own in the first tier of sensitivity. The bulk threshold for human genomic data would be more than 100 US persons. Anything below this amount would not trigger the limitations in the proposed rule.

    The proposed rule defines “human genomic data” as data representing the nucleic acid sequences that constitute the entire set or a subset of the genetic instructions found in a human cell, including the result or results of an individual’s “genetic test” and any related human genetic sequencing data. The term “human genomic data” does not include non-human data, such as pathogen genetic sequence data, that is derived from or integrated into human genomic data.

    Biometric identifiers. Biometric identifiers and precise geolocation data would be grouped under tier two of sensitivity. The proposed bulk threshold for biometric identifiers is more than 1,000 US persons. Anything below this amount would not trigger the limitations in the proposed rule.

    The proposed rule defines “biometric identifiers” as measurable physical characteristics or behaviors used to recognize or verify the identity of an individual, including facial images, voice prints and patterns, retina and iris scans, palm prints and fingerprints, gait, and keyboard usage patterns that are enrolled in a biometric system and the templates created by the system.

    Personal health data. Personal health data and personal financial data would be grouped in the third tier of sensitivity. The proposed bulk threshold for personal health data is more than 10,000 US persons. Anything below this amount would not trigger the limitations in the proposed rule.

    The proposed rule uses the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA) definition of “individually identifiable health information” as the starting point for its personal health data definition and then revises it so that the proposed rule’s definition does not turn on whether data is handled by HIPAA covered entities or business associates. Personal health data is not defined in terms of whether the data identifies an individual, because the proposed rule would apply regardless of whether data is de-identified.

    The proposed rule defines “personal health data” as health information that relates to:

    • The past, present, or future physical or mental health or condition of an individual;
    • The provision of healthcare to an individual; or
    • The past, present, or future payment for the provision of healthcare to an individual.

    The personal health data includes:

    • Basic physical measurements and health attributes (such as bodily functions, height and weight, vital signs, symptoms, and allergies);
    • Social, psychological, behavioral, and medical diagnostic, intervention, and treatment history;
    • Test results;
    • Logs of exercise habits;
    • Immunization data;
    • Data on reproductive and sexual health; and
    • Data on the use or purchase of prescribed medications.

    The proposed rule would operate on a categorical basis and would determine that the category of personal health data generally meets the requirements of being “exploitable by a country of concern to harm U.S. national security” and “is linked or linkable to any identifiable U.S. individual or to a discrete and identifiable group of U.S. individuals.”

    Covered personal identifiers. The proposed rule would place covered personal identifiers into the fourth tier. The proposed bulk threshold for covered personal identifiers is more than 100,000 US persons. Anything below this amount would not trigger the limitations in the proposed rule.

    The EO defined “covered personal identifiers” as “specifically listed classes of personally identifiable data that are reasonably linked to an individual, and that – whether in combination with each other, with other sensitive personal data, or with other data that is disclosed by a transacting party pursuant to the transaction and that makes the personally identifiable data exploitable by a country of concern – could be used to identify an individual from a data set or link data across multiple data sets to an individual,” subject to certain exclusions.

    The proposed rule provides three subcategories of covered personal identifiers:

    • Listed identifiers in combination with any other listed identifier.
    • Listed identifiers in combination with other sensitive personal data.
    • Listed identifiers in combination with other data that a transacting party discloses pursuant to the transaction that make the listed identifier exploitable by a country of concern, if they could be used to identify an individual from a dataset or to link data across multiple datasets to an individual.

    There are two proposed exceptions:

    • Demographic or contact data that is linked only to other demographic or contact data.
    • A network-based identifier, account-authentication data, or call-detail data that is linked only to other network-based identifiers, account authentication data, or call-detail data as necessary for the provision of telecommunications, networking, or similar services

    Exclusions and Exemptions

    Exclusions from definition of sensitive personal data. The proposed rule would exclude certain categories of data from the definition of the term “sensitive personal data.” These exclusions include:

    • Public or nonpublic data that do not relate to an individual, including trade secrets and proprietary information.
    • Data that are, at the time of the transaction, lawfully publicly available from government records or widely distributed media.
    • Personal communications.

    Exclusions from data-brokerage transactions. The proposed rule also includes a prohibition specific to data brokerage to address transactions involving the onward transfer or resale of government-related data or bulk US sensitive personal data to countries of concern and covered persons. The proposed rule defines “data brokerage” as the sale of data, licensing of access to data, or similar commercial transactions involving the transfer of data from any person (the provider) to any other person (the recipient), where the recipient did not collect or process the data directly from the individuals linked or linkable to the collected or processed data.

    The proposed rule includes an exemption relevant to healthcare entities. Specifically, grantees and contractors of federal departments and agencies, including the US Department of Health and Human Services, the US Department of Veterans Affairs, the US National Science Foundation, and the US Department of Defense, would be exempt. The exemption allows these agencies to pursue grant- and contract-based conditions to address risks that countries of concern can access sensitive personal data in transactions related to their agencies’ own grants and contracts, without subjecting those grantees and contractors to dual regulation under the rule and the grant or contract.

    Drug, biological product, and medical device authorizations exemption. Under the proposed rule, certain data transactions necessary to obtain and maintain regulatory approval to market a drug, biological product, medical device, or combination product in a country of concern would be exempt from the prohibitions in the proposed rule.

    This exemption aims to balance the need to mitigate US national security risks related to unrestricted transfer of bulk US sensitive personal data to countries of concern against scientific, humanitarian, and economic interests in enabling the sale of medicines in those countries. This exemption would be limited to data that is:

    • De-identified;
    • Required by a regulatory entity to obtain or maintain authorization or approval to research or market a drug, biological product, device, or combination product (i.e., covered product); and
    • Reasonably necessary to evaluate the safety and effectiveness of the covered product.

    For example, de-identified data that is gathered in the course of a clinical investigation and would typically be required for US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approval of a covered product would generally fall within the exemption. Conversely, clinical participants’ precise geolocation data, even if required by a country of concern’s regulations, would fall outside the scope of the exemption because such data is not reasonably necessary to evaluate safety or effectiveness. DOJ recognizes that data collection and submission continue beyond the initial regulatory approval process, and it intends the term “regulatory approval data” to include data from post-market clinical investigations (conducted under applicable FDA regulations), clinical care data, and post-marketing surveillance (including data on adverse events).

    For example, where continued approval to market a drug in a country of concern is contingent on submission of data from ongoing product vigilance or other post-market requirements, the exemption would apply. The exemption would apply even where FDA authorization for a product has not been sought or obtained. DOJ does not, in the proposed rule, intend to require US companies to seek authorization to market a product in the United States before seeking regulatory approval from a country of concern. The proposed exemption is limited to transactions that are necessary to obtain or maintain regulatory approval in the country of concern.

    Other clinical investigations and post-marketing surveillance data exemption. The proposed rule would exempt data that is “ordinarily incident to and part of clinical investigations regulated by the FDA or clinical investigations that support applications to the FDA for research or marketing permits for drugs, biological products, devices, combination products, or infant formula.”

    It also would exempt data that is “ordinarily incident to and part of the collection or processing of clinical care data indicating real-world performance or safety of products, or the collection or processing of post-marketing surveillance data (including pharmacovigilance and post-marketing safety monitoring), and necessary to support or maintain authorization by the FDA, provided the data is deidentified.”

    Other FDA-regulated research exemptions. In the proposed rule, DOJ acknowledges the challenge of balancing national security risk and biomedical innovation that benefits the United States. DOJ is considering how to effectively strike that balance and how to scope an exemption for transactions related to or supporting FDA-regulated research to meet that goal. The DOJ is considering the scope of a possible exemption along three axes:

    • Types of data included in the exemption: DOJ anticipates that any exemption would concern data obtained in the course of clinical investigations related to drugs, biological products, devices, and combination products, as those terms are defined in the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act and FDA regulations. DOJ believes that these products raise the most significant countervailing economic, health, and scientific concerns that might outweigh the national security interests otherwise at stake.

    The exemption would also apply to clinical care data indicating real-world performance or safety of products, or post-marketing surveillance data (including pharmacovigilance and post-marketing safety monitoring), where necessary to support or maintain authorization by the FDA.

    DOJ also recognizes the existing regulatory framework in these contexts and is evaluating whether these provisions adequately reduce the national security risk associated with the transfer of bulk US sensitive personal data to a country of concern or covered person.

    • Types of transactions involving the data that would be exempted. The proposed rule considers what kinds of transactions to exempt when they involve data that implicate the exemption. This could include bulk US sensitive personal data collected in the course of an FDA-regulated clinical investigation to develop a drug.

    One proposal would exempt all transactions that are part of the conduct of the investigation. An alternative proposal would limit an exemption to only certain types of transactions that are especially important to the conduct of a clinical investigation and that cannot feasibly be avoided without jeopardizing the clinical investigation.

    The proposed rule contemplates implementing an exemption for clinical investigations, clinical data, and post-marketing surveillance through one or more general licenses as opposed to including the exemption in the final rule. The DOJ believes general licenses may be a more flexible regulatory tool that can be adjusted to varying circumstances, but for the short term, the DOJ believes that a codified exemption would provide more clarity and certainty for relevant entities.

    • Duration of exemptions. The proposed rule considers whether any exemption, or parts of it, could feasibly be time-limited to allow industry to shift existing processes and operations out of countries of concern over a transition period. If DOJ does not broadly exempt clinical research from the scope of the prohibitions, the agency may consider delaying the effective date of the proposed rule with respect to such research to enable affected entities to complete ongoing or imminent trials without disruption or delay, while transitioning planning and policies for future trials.

    Advisory Opinions

    The proposed rule would create a mechanism for potentially regulated parties to seek opinions about the application of the final regulations and/or the EO to specific transactions. The proposed rule would permit a US person seeking to engage in a transaction potentially subject to the final regulation to request an interpretation of any provision. The proposed rule would require that advisory opinions only be requested regarding actual (not hypothetical) transactions. Advisory opinions could cover, for example:

    • Whether a particular transaction is a prohibited transaction or restricted transaction.
    • Whether a person is a US person, foreign person, or covered person.

    Penalties

    The proposed rule includes civil monetary penalties based on noncompliance, material misstatements or omissions, false certifications or submissions, or other actions and factors.

    The proposed maximum civil monetary penalty for violations would be the greater of $368,136 or twice the amount of the transaction that is the basis of the violation with respect to which the penalty is imposed. DOJ proposes to make annual adjustments, based on inflation, to the civil monetary penalty. Willful violations would lead to criminal fines of up to $1 million and up to 20 years’ imprisonment.

    Next Steps

    The proposed rule is open for public comment through November 29, 2024. Healthcare entities and other interested stakeholders should consider commenting on the appropriateness of the proposed exemptions and exclusions, as well as the adequacy and accuracy of the proposed definitions and related thresholds.

    Authors

    Daniel F. Gottlieb

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • COP29 Week One: Conference Is Told “Parties Must Remember That the Clock Is Ticking” as They Struggle To Make Progress on How To Raise $1 Trillion a Year

    COP29 Week One: Conference Is Told “Parties Must Remember That the Clock Is Ticking” as They Struggle To Make Progress on How To Raise $1 Trillion a Year

    ARTICLE

    COP29 Week One: Conference Is Told “Parties Must Remember That the Clock Is Ticking” as They Struggle To Make Progress on How To Raise $1 Trillion a Year

    November 15, 2024

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The previous annual finance goal (the New Collective Quantified Goal (NCGC)) of $100 billion expires this year. However, wealthy countries only met the pledge in full starting in 2022. Negotiation teams are working on draft texts, but there remains a wide divergence in the levels of funding that countries are willing to commit to.

    In depth

    Key developments from the end of the first week of the 29th Annual United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP29) include:

    • A report from the Independent High-Level Expert Group on Climate Finance said the NCGC would need to increase to at least $1.3 trillion a year by 2035 if countries fail to act now.
    • Although countries are struggling to agree on the revised annual amount, the Taskforce on Net Zero Policy released a report that found that while progress on net zero policy is advancing in a significant number of regions globally, the policy landscape is still insufficiently aligned with a 1.5°C future, consistent with ongoing global misalignment with the goals of the Paris Agreement.
    • Germany’s Climate Envoy Jennifer Morgan has called China’s climate finance contributions in recent years “an important mini step.” She pointed to a statement from China’s Vice-Premier Ding Xuexiang who told world leaders on November 12 that China has provided $24.5 billion to support other countries’ climate efforts since 2016. However, developed countries are reported to be lobbying to increase commitments from China, Russia, Saudi Arabia, and the United Arab Emirates, among other “new polluters.”
    • Multilateral development banks, such as the World Bank, are looking at how they can increase their share of funding. Ten have already indicated they plan to increase their funding by 60% to $120 billion a year.
    • Separately, 50 global business leaders from high-emitting industries and the Industrial Transition Accelerator, a network of more than 700 financial institutions, issued an open letter urging governments to use proven policy measures to stimulate demand for green products and better seize the potential of industrial decarbonization.
    • The Industrial Transition Accelerator has said that by putting appropriate policies in place, governments could unlock up to $1 trillion of investments and bring more than 500 green industrial plants awaiting financing to construction by 2030.
    • The Colombian government’s call for a global treaty on energy transition minerals has been backed by several countries at COP29. Such a treaty would set global standards for the governance of mineral supply chains (for cobalt, lithium, and nickel in particular), look to increase economic opportunities for countries and people at the beginning of the chain, and establish “no-go zones” to protect nature.
    • Countries are being urged to commit to an energy storage target of 1.5 terawatt by 2030, which would enable the much talked about tripling of world renewable energy capacity.
    • The likely withdrawal of the United States from any future funding deal is pressuring delegates to find ways to secure much needed funds. As the first week of COP29 draws to a close and only limited progress appears to have been made, negotiation teams have been reminded that the clock is ticking.
    Authors

    Carl J. Fleming

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Shah Jahan H. Khandokar

    Partner

    London – 22 Bishopsgate

    More insights

  • COP29 Day Three: Progress Is Made Toward Tripling Nuclear Capacity by 2050 as Cracks Appear Within Funding Models

    COP29 Day Three: Progress Is Made Toward Tripling Nuclear Capacity by 2050 as Cracks Appear Within Funding Models

    ARTICLE

    COP29 Day Three: Progress Is Made Toward Tripling Nuclear Capacity by 2050 as Cracks Appear Within Funding Models

    November 14, 2024

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Day three of the 29th Annual United Nations Climate Change Conference COP29 saw the end of the first part of the high-level segment for heads of state and other global leaders in Baku as well as the announcement of significant pledges.

    In depth

    Below we share key developments:

    • While Azerbaijan President Ilham Aliyev noted his country’s “minimal global emissions” (its total emissions equals 0.1%) and plans to increase gas production by up to one third over the next decade, UN Secretary-General António Guterres stated that the world is at the “final countdown” to limit a global temperature rise to 1.5°C.
    • Guterres restated the disparity between the rich causing climate change issues and the poor suffering the most from said issues and set out three immediate actions for world leaders to focus on:
      • Emergency emissions reductions – cutting emissions by 9% annually to reach 43% of 2019 levels by 2030.
      • Enhanced protection for people from climate change’s impact, bridging the adaptation finance gap.
      • A new climate finance goal with increased public finance, innovative funding sources, and improved accessibility and transparency.
    • In anticipation of President-elect Donald Trump withdrawing the United States from the Paris Agreement, many may look to the United Kingdom for global climate change leadership.
    • UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer confirmed that his country will aim for an 81% cut in emissions by 2035, updating a previous 78% pledge.
    • Prime Minister Starmer also confirmed the end of a ban on new onshore wind projects and pledged not to issue new oil and gas licenses in the North Sea. He also confirmed the recent closure of the UK’s last coal power plant. However, no new funding was announced.
    • Six new countries – El Salvador, Kazakhstan, Kenya, Kosovo, Nigeria, and Turkey – joined the COP28 pledge to triple global nuclear capacity by 2050, bringing the total number to 31 countries.
    • White House National Climate Advisor Ali Zaidi announced new domestic nuclear energy deployment targets and a framework for action, which includes a target of 200 gigawatts of new US nuclear energy capacity by 2050 and outlines how to meet this goal. Meeting this target would triple the current US domestic nuclear energy capacity.
    • Despite apparent progress, some climate change campaigners are unhappy about the climate finance investment models currently under discussion, which are not on par with grant-based financing. This matches the tone of some government leaders, such as Muhammad Yunus, the chief adviser to Bangladesh, who said countries responsible for global warming should simply provide the funds to deal with the crisis.
    • As most world leaders leave COP29 on day three, their teams of negotiators now turn to the details of the agenda and the high-level pledges announced over the last few days.
    Authors

    Carl J. Fleming

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Shah Jahan H. Khandokar

    Partner

    London – 22 Bishopsgate

    More insights

  • COP29 Day Two: The US Continues to “Work Together With Global Partners To Be Successful in Outcomes That Keep 1.5 Alive”

    COP29 Day Two: The US Continues to “Work Together With Global Partners To Be Successful in Outcomes That Keep 1.5 Alive”

    ARTICLE

    COP29 Day Two: The US Continues to “Work Together With Global Partners To Be Successful in Outcomes That Keep 1.5 Alive”

    November 13, 2024

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Day two of  the 29th Annual United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP29) saw the US Special Presidential Envoy for Climate make its first post-election statements in Baku.

    In depth

    Below we share key developments from day two:

    • The message from US Climate Envoy John Podesta and the Biden administration’s Climate Adviser Ali Zaidi was clear: The US is “at COP29 to continue to work together with global partners to be successful in outcomes that keep 1.5 alive.”
    • Both Podesta and Zaidi emphasized that withdrawal from the Paris Agreement would be a setback for the American people, but one that can be overcome in time.
    • While policy may change, Zaidi pointed out that the United States already has infrastructure in the ground or under construction back home.
    • According to Zaidi, it is improbable that the incoming Trump administration will uproot renewable energy plants and, importantly, battery factories that are located in many Republican-governed states under the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 (IRA).
    • Some of those governors have openly acknowledged the need to maintain demand for clean tech economies. This includes the domestic market and exports.
    • Zaidi also pointed out that the IRA and subsequent related regulations received bipartisan support and as such, are unlikely to be repealed wholesale.
    • In addition to renewable energy the US government will likely look to clean tech in traditional heavy and oil and gas industries. These include methane abatement measures; geothermal technology; and the greening of steel, aluminum, and asphalt plants (to name a few).
    • The US, the People’s Republic of China, and Azerbaijan convened a summit to accelerate actions to cut methane and other non-CO2 greenhouse gases.
    • The US Environmental Protection Agency announced a final rule to reduce methane emissions from the oil and gas sector. The rule facilitates the implementation of US Congress’ directive in the IRA to collect a Waste Emissions Charge to better ensure valuable natural gas reaches the market rather than polluting the air.
    • The Waste Emissions Charge applies only to high-emitting oil and gas facilities that report emissions of more than 25,000 metric tons of carbon dioxide equivalent per year to the Greenhouse Gas Reporting Program, beginning with methane emissions reported in calendar year (CY) 2024.
    • The Waste Emissions Charge starts at $900 per metric ton of wasteful emissions in CY 2024, increasing to $1,200 for CY 2025 and $1,500 for CY 2026 and beyond. It only applies to emissions that exceed statutorily-specified methane intensity levels.
    Authors

    Carl J. Fleming

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Shah Jahan H. Khandokar

    Partner

    London – 22 Bishopsgate

    More insights

  • News on business premises and place of management

    News on business premises and place of management

    ARTICLE

    News on business premises and place of management

    2024

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Dr. Gero Burwitz with his article on “News on business premises and place of management”, published in Neue Zeitschrift für Gesellschaftsrecht (NZG), issue 31/2024.

    In depth
    Authors

    Dr. Gero Burwitz

    Partner

    Munich

    More insights

  • Sanctions Update: OFAC Extends Recordkeeping Requirements to 10 Years and Amends Reporting Regulations

    Sanctions Update: OFAC Extends Recordkeeping Requirements to 10 Years and Amends Reporting Regulations

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Sanctions Update: OFAC Extends Recordkeeping Requirements to 10 Years and Amends Reporting Regulations

    November 13, 2024

    Read time: 15 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In recent weeks, the US Department of the Treasury’s Office of Foreign Assets Control (“OFAC”) has introduced an interim and a final rule amending its regulations with important implications for sanctions compliance programs. First, OFAC’s general recordkeeping requirements under 31 C.F.R. § 501.601, as well as other provisions, will be extended from 5 years to 10 years, effective March 12, 2025. Second, OFAC finalized additional amendments to its Reporting, Procedures and Penalties Regulations, adding four exceptions to the reporting requirements for blocked property that is unblocked or transferred, as well as clarifying certain other changes.

    Extension of Recordkeeping Requirements Aligns With Statutory Amendments to National Security Statutes

    On April 24, 2024, President Joe Biden signed into law an emergency supplemental appropriations bill for foreign aid (“Supplemental Act”), which included amendments to the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (“IEEPA”) and the Trading With the Enemy Act (“TWEA”) that, among other things, increased the statute of limitations for sanctions violations from 5 years to 10 years.[1] In light of this change, OFAC issued an interim final rule on Sept. 11, 2024 (the “IFR”), extending the length of the record retention period across its regulations to align with the longer statute of limitations.[2] The IFR amends OFAC’s Reporting, Procedures and Penalties Regulations and the Cuba Assets Control Regulations (“CACR”) to increase applicable record retention periods from 5 years to 10 years.[3]

    Given that OFAC requires that records be kept for “every person engaging in any transaction subject to” its regulations,[4] the expanded 10-year recordkeeping obligation may significantly increase the administrative burden of compliance for any US person that engages in significant international dealings. Because the recordkeeping requirement starts from the date of a covered transaction, the retention period will effectively require US persons to retain covered records for longer than 10 years, since a “full and accurate record” of any covered transaction likely includes pre-transaction documentation.[5] Similarly, because the amendment requires retention of “a full and accurate record” of blocked property as long as it is blocked, and then “for at least 10 years after the date such property is unblocked,” US person holders of blocked property are subject to a virtually indefinite recordkeeping period.[6] The IFR also amends the calculation of penalties for late report filings (e.g., blocked property reports) to allow penalties to accrue for 10 years.[7]

    OFAC Amends its Reporting, Procedures and Penalties Regulations

    On Oct. 7, 2024, OFAC announced that it would be issuing a final rule (“Final Rule”) to amend its Reporting, Procedures and Penalties Regulations.[8] The Final Rule implements the amendments made pursuant to an interim final rule published on May 10, 2024 (“May 2024 Rule”).[9] But in response to public comments on the interim final rule, OFAC included several changes to clarify the scope of a US person’s reporting obligations.[10]

    The May 2024 Rule revised § 501.603(b)(3)(i) to require US persons to submit reports within 10 business days of when blocked property is unblocked or transferred, including pursuant to a valid order issued by a US government agency or US court. OFAC noted that the purpose of this change was to “enable OFAC to ascertain the current status of blocked and unblocked property.”[11] With the publication of the Final Rule, which is effective Nov. 8, 2024, OFAC has now clarified that reports on blocked property that has been unblocked or transferred are not required in the following circumstances:

    • authorized debits to blocked accounts for normal service charges;
    • authorized transfers of funds or credits by a financial institution between blocked accounts in its branches or offices;
    • blocked property that is unblocked or transferred pursuant to a general or specific license, unless the license includes a condition that requires the submission of an unblocking report; or
    • blocked property that is unblocked pursuant to OFAC’s removal of a person from the SDN List.[12]

    OFAC states that these changes are meant to reduce the reporting burden on US persons and that it is not requiring reports for unblocked property “about which [it] does not have a strong interest in obtaining additional information or for which information is received via other reporting channels.”[13]

    The compliance release procedures released by OFAC at § 501.608 for unblocking property that is believed to have been blocked in error (“Compliance Release Procedures”) were also amended by the May 2024 Rule. Under the updated Compliance Release Procedures, a person who has blocked property due to mistaken identity or typographical error may submit a request to OFAC for authorization to unblock such property.[14] Only the original reporting party may use the Compliance Release Procedures to submit the request, which must be sent by email to OFAC and include certain specified information about the property.[15]

    The Final Rule notes that US persons are not required to use the Compliance Release Procedures for “unblocking property believed to have been blocked and reported in error due to mistaken identity or typographical or similar errors.”[16] Moreover, US persons “can treat the property that was blocked in error as not blocked in the event they determine that there was never any valid blockable interest in the property, provided that they notify OFAC of the change.”[17]

    Concurrent with publishing the Final Rule, OFAC issued an FAQ stating that US persons that have blocked and reported property to OFAC due to mistaken identity or a typographical error may unblock such property and file an unblocking report with OFAC.[18] Unblocking reports must be submitted electronically, either by email or through OFAC’s Online Reporting System (“ORS”).[19] The Compliance Release Procedures may be used as an alternative to filing an unblocking report. As the Final Rule and the FAQ note, this guidance applies only to property in which there was never a blockable property interest.[20] For property that was correctly blocked, but for which the status of the property has changed (such as due to “a change in the portion of ownership by a blocked person”), US persons must still apply to OFAC for a specific license to unblock such property.[21]        

    Conclusion

    While the amendments to OFAC’s recordkeeping regulations were expected, they could require significant changes for some US firms’ sanctions compliance programs. Firms will need to review their internal policies and procedures, contracts with outside service providers, and agreements with investment counterparties to ensure they are prepared to comply with the new 10-year retention period when it becomes effective on March 12, 2025.

    Additionally, US firms that currently possess or control any blocked property should also ensure that they are maintaining records of such property for the appropriate time period, consistent with the new regulations. The exceptions added to OFAC’s reporting requirements with respect to unblocked property provide needed clarity and may help to reduce some of the administrative burdens related to the overall expansion of the recordkeeping requirements.

    Authored by Betty Santangelo, Melissa G.R. Goldstein, Gregoire P. Devaney, and Ashley A. Bogdan.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] 21st Century Peace Through Strength Act, Pub. L. 118-50, Div. E, Title I, Sec. 3111(a)–(d) (codified at 50 U.S.C. §§ 1705(d), 4315(d)). For additional commentary, see Schulte Alert, Sanctions Update: Statutory Amendments and an Interim Final Rule Create Significant Implications for OFAC Sanctions Compliance (Jun. 11, 2024), available here (“Schulte Alert, Sanctions Update: Statutory Amendments”). Following enactment of these statutory amendments, OFAC issued guidance noting that it expected to change its regulations to extend recordkeeping requirements to 10 years. OFAC, Guidance on Extension of Statute of Limitations (Jul. 22, 2024), available here.

    [2] Interim Final Rule, Reporting, Procedures and Penalties, 89 Fed. Reg. 74832 (Sept. 13, 2024), available here.

    [3] IFR, 89 Fed. Reg. at 74834 (to be codified at 31 C.F.R. §§ 501.601, 515.572).

    [4] Id. at § 501.601.

    [5] Id.

    [6] Id.

    [7] Id. at 74834 (to be codified at 31 C.F.R., paragraph IV.B of Part 501).

    [8] Press Release, OFAC, Counter Terrorism Designations; Issuance of Counter Terrorism General Licenses; Amendment of the Reporting, Procedures and Penalties Regulations and Issuance of Related Frequently Asked Question (Oct. 7, 2024), available here.

    [9] Interim Final Rule, Reporting, Procedures and Penalties Regulations, 89 Fed. Reg. 40372 (May 10, 2024), available here.

    [10] Final Rule, Reporting, Procedures and Penalties Regulations, 89 Fed. Reg. 81358 (Oct. 8, 2024), available here.

    [11] May 2024 Rule, 89 Fed. Reg. at 40373.

    [12] Final Rule, 89 Fed. Reg. at 81359, 81361 (to be codified at 31 C.F.R. § 501.603(b)(3)(i)(A)–(D)).

    [13] Final Rule, 89 Fed. Reg. at 81359.

    [14] 31 C.F.R. 501.806.

    [15] Id.; May 24, 2024 Rule, 89 Fed. Reg. at 40374.

    [16] Final Rule, 89 Fed. Reg. at 81360.

    [17] Id.

    [18] OFAC FAQ 1196 (Oct. 7, 2024), available here. OFAC notes that unblocking reports should be submitting in accordance with 31 C.F.R. § 501.603(b)(3) and should reference FAQ 1196.

    [19] 31 C.F.R. § 501.603(d)(2). Submissions by email should be sent to OFACReport@treasury.gov; Access OFAC’s ORS. Note that as of Aug. 8, 2024, initial reports on blocked property and annual reports on blocked property may only be submitted through ORS. 31 C.F.R. § 501.603(d)(1); Schulte Alert, Sanctions Update: Statutory Amendments, supra.

    [20] OFAC FAQ 1196, supra.

    [21] Id.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. © 2024 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP. All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Betty Santangelo

    Counsel

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Melissa G.R. Goldstein

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Gregoire P. Devaney

    Associate

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Ashley A. Bogdan

    Associate

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • COP29 Day One: Trump’s Victory Is “Not the End of Our Fight for a Cleaner, Safer Planet”

    COP29 Day One: Trump’s Victory Is “Not the End of Our Fight for a Cleaner, Safer Planet”

    ARTICLE

    COP29 Day One: Trump’s Victory Is “Not the End of Our Fight for a Cleaner, Safer Planet”

    November 11, 2024

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On the first day of the 29th Annual United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP29), US Climate Envoy John Podesta said the fight against climate change will not stop under President-elect Donald Trump’s next term.

    In depth

    Below are key insights shared during day one of COP29:

    • “Although under Donald Trump’s leadership the US federal government placed climate-related actions on the back burner, efforts to prevent climate change remain a commitment in the US and will confidently continue,” Podesta said.
    • Trump has pledged to deregulate the energy sector and pull the United States from the Paris Agreement. However, Podesta said, “This is not the end of our fight for a cleaner, safer planet.”
    • Under US President Joe Biden, the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 was passed, the largest downpayment on the green transition seen in US history.
    • “The fight is bigger than one election, one political cycle in one country,” said Podesta. COP29 represents a “critical opportunity to cement our progress.”
    • Among the US’s top goals for upcoming climate talks is securing mitigation plans for greenhouse gases other than CO2, such as methane. On November 12, the US will co-host a summit on the issue with China and COP29 host Azerbaijan.
    • According to Podesta, other major priorities will be reaching an agreement on the use of carbon trading and increasing ambition on clean energy deployment.
    • Another crucial component of the climate talks, Podesta said, will be ensuring small economies have access to climate finance from rich nations.
    • “COP29 is a crucial opportunity to solidify our progress and keep 1.5 degrees alive, accelerate progress in reducing all greenhouse gases, and perhaps most importantly, strengthen global cooperation in adaptation and climate finance,” said Podesta. “We are here to work, and we are committed to achieving a successful outcome at COP29.”
    • At the end of the first day, diplomats have greenlit key rules that govern the trade of “carbon credits,” breaking a yearslong deadlock over contentious carbon markets. It means a global “carbon market” can now been established, allowing richer nations to pay for projects in developing nations that reduce emissions and to meet their climate obligations. Initial projections estimate that this could be worth up to $250 billion of funding for projects in emerging and developing economies.
    Authors

    Carl J. Fleming

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Shah Jahan H. Khandokar

    Partner

    London – 22 Bishopsgate

    More insights