Content Type: Article

  • CDTFA Proposes Significant Revisions to Chapters 4 and 13 of the Sales Tax Audit Manual

    CDTFA Proposes Significant Revisions to Chapters 4 and 13 of the Sales Tax Audit Manual

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    CDTFA Proposes Significant Revisions to Chapters 4 and 13 of the Sales Tax Audit Manual

    February 9, 2022

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On February 2, 2022, the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) held an interested parties meeting (IPM) to discuss proposed amendments to sales tax audit manual (AM) Chapter 13, “Statistical Sampling,” and Chapter 4, “General Audit.”

    In depth

    Prior to the IPM, the CDTFA released a lengthy discussion paper outlining the extensive proposed changes to the AM, which includes:

    1. Removing the three error rule. The current text of AM 1308.05 explains that when a sample produces only one or two errors, the auditor must evaluate whether these errors are representative or whether it is possible they indicate problems in certain areas that could be examined separately. Under the proposed amendment, the same evaluation standards would still be in place without the minimum error requirement. According to the CDTFA, the proposed removal of the three error rule is because of the fact that “the number of errors identified in a sample does not give any indication whether the sample is representative or not…If the combined evaluation evaluates within Department [CDTFA] standards, it is justified to project the results even if one or two errors are found.”

    2. Requiring 300 minimum sample items per stratum unless the auditor obtained approval from CAS to select fewer than 300. Currently, the “minimum sample size of at least 300 items of interest is to be used in all tests, except where the auditor can support a smaller sample size and it evaluates well.” (AM 1303.05) Under the new subsection titled “Materiality,” a minimum of 300 sample items per test stratum is recommended. Computer Audit Specialist (CAS) approval is required for selecting less than 300 sample items per test stratum.

    3. Refunding Populations: A minimum of 100 sample items per stratum is required. In the section addressing sampling refund populations (AM 1305.10), the proposed amendment would permit auditors to select as few as 100 sample items per test stratum without CAS approval, provided the expected error rate is sufficiently high (greater than 20%). No such rule exists under the current text of Chapter 13.

    4. Contacting CAS when the prior audit had 300 hours charged to it is now mandatory. In contrast, under the current rule, it is mandatory that CAS be contacted when the prior audit expended 400 or more hours or if CAS was involved in the prior audit.

    5. Replacing Credit Methods 1, 2 and 3 with one recommended approach to handling credits in a statistical sample. The subsection (AM 1303.25) currently lists three types of credit methods that can be used for a statistical sample. The CDTFA now only recommends one credit method for use in a stratified statistical sample, which is referred to as “Method 1” in the current AM text. When auditors review electronic data, attempts should be made to match credit invoices to original invoices (including partially) if it is certain that the credit invoices are related to the original invoice. For all credit memos that are not matched to original invoices, those credits will be removed from the population prior to selecting samples. However, those credits, and any other credits not originally provided, are available to be used to offset any invoices that are selected during the sampling process. This is to ensure that the final net amount related to the transaction in question is used to project any errors related to that transaction. Credits may not be used to offset invoices not included in the sample base.

    6. Removing the mean-per-unit projection technique. Under the current rule, the mean-per-unit estimation technique allows estimates to be made from the audited values in the sample. (AM 1303.06) Specifically, the mean-per-unit projection technique estimates the total value of the population by taking the average audited value of the sample items multiplied by the number of units in the population.

    The last major rewrite of Chapter 13 occurred in 2001. The deadline for interested parties to provide written submissions regarding this discussion paper is February 23, 2022.

    IMPLICATIONS

    The implications of the proposed changes on taxpayers should not be discounted as some of the new proposals reverse formal decisions of the elected California State Board of Equalization, which were based upon statistical experts. For example, eliminating the three error rule can have enormous consequences by allowing an auditor to make projections based on less accurate data. When the California State Board of Equalization adopted the chapter including this requirement in the early 2000s, it relied upon outside expert statisticians following considerable debate from interested parties.

    Additionally, the CDTFA’s proposed policy of requiring that a minimum sample size of 300 items of interest per test stratum be used in all statistical samples may be too high, particularly when compared to national voting poll projections based on sample sizes of 1000.

    Finally, the discussion paper released by CDTFA states that “the proposed amendments include the addition and removal of some key policies.” Taxpayers are forewarned that these alterations of well-established policies may have adverse consequences that are not readily apparent.

    Authors

    Charles Moll III

    Partner

    San Francisco

    Troy M. Van Dongen

    Partner

    San Francisco

    Marcy Jo Mandel

    Counsel

    Los Angeles

    More insights

  • Does the ADP in Your LNG SPA Meet Your Needs?

    Does the ADP in Your LNG SPA Meet Your Needs?

    ARTICLE

    Does the ADP in Your LNG SPA Meet Your Needs?

    February 9, 2022

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Partner, Merrick White bylined this article in Energy Law Report explaining the process that typically takes place when sellers and buyers of long-term liquefied natural gas sales and purchase agreements agree on the annual delivery program.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • SEC Proposes New Rules for Private Fund Managers

    SEC Proposes New Rules for Private Fund Managers

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT / US POLICY

    SEC Proposes New Rules for Private Fund Managers

    February 9, 2022

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On Feb. 9, 2022 the Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) proposed a series of new rules, and amendments to existing rules, (the “Proposed Rules”)[1] under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940 (the “Advisers Act”) applicable to private fund managers. The Proposed Rules seek to, among other things: (i) require specified and standardized quarterly disclosures regarding performance, fees and expenses, (ii) prohibit private fund managers from engaging in certain activities, (iii) require disclosure of, and in some cases limit, preferential treatment provided to certain private fund investors, (iv) require that all private funds be subject to annual audit, (v) add a written documentation requirement for annual reviews and (vi) create requirements to keep records of compliance with the Proposed Rules. Certain of the Proposed Rules apply only to SEC-registered investment advisers to private funds (“Registered Advisers”) and others apply to all investment advisers to private funds (“Private Fund Advisers”), even when such Private Fund Advisers are not SEC-registered.

    Quarterly Statements Rule. The Proposed Rules would require Registered Advisers to distribute to investors a quarterly statement for each private fund within 45 days of the end of the calendar quarter. These statements must include the following items relating to the private fund for the applicable reporting period:[2]

    • A detailed accounting of all compensation, fees and other amounts allocated or paid to the Registered Adviser or any of its related persons, with separate line items for each category of allocation or payment (e.g., management, sub-advisory, performance-based compensation, similar fees or payments);
    • A detailed accounting of all fees and expenses paid during the reporting period, with separate line items for each category of expense (e.g., organizational, accounting, legal, administration, audit, tax, due diligence, travel);
    • For each portfolio investment that paid the Registered Adviser or its related persons compensation during that quarter, a detailed accounting of such compensation and the fund’s ownership percentage of the applicable portfolio investment;
    • Prominent disclosures of the calculation methodologies for all expenses, payments, allocations, rebates, waivers and offsets, including cross-references to the private fund’s organizational and offering documents; and
    • performance information that is calculated using methodologies specified in the Proposed Rule, with the required performance metrics different for “liquid” vs “illiquid” funds.

    Prohibited Activities Rule. The Proposed Rules prohibit all Private Fund Advisers (including advisers not registered with the SEC) from engaging in certain specified activities. These prohibitions would apply regardless of whether the private fund’s governing documents permit such activities, including when investors have given explicit or implicit consent to such activities. Private Fund Advisers would be prohibited from, with respect to a private fund or any investor in a private fund:

    • Seeking reimbursement, indemnification, exculpation, or limitation of the Private Fund Adviser’s liability by the private fund or its investors for a breach of fiduciary duty, willful misfeasance, bad faith, negligence or recklessness in providing services to the private fund;
    • Charging the private fund for fees or expenses associated with (i) an examination or investigation of the Private Fund Adviser or its related persons by any governmental or regulatory authority, or (ii) regulatory or compliance fees or expenses of the Private Fund Adviser or its related persons;
    • Reducing the amount of any adviser clawback by actual, potential or hypothetical taxes applicable to the Private Fund Adviser, its related persons or their respective owners or interest holders;
    • Charging or allocating fees and expenses related to a portfolio investment (or potential portfolio investment) on a non-pro rata basis when multiple private funds and other clients advised by the Private Fund Adviser or its related persons have invested (or propose to invest) in the same portfolio investment;
    • Charging a portfolio investment for monitoring, servicing, consulting or other fees in respect of any services that the investment adviser does not, or does not reasonably expect to, provide to the portfolio investment; and
    • Borrowing money, securities or other private fund assets, or receive a loan or an extension of credit, from a private fund client.

    Preferential Treatment Rule. The Proposed Rules would prohibit all Private Fund Advisers (including advisers not registered with the SEC) from giving certain forms of preferential treatment to investors in a private fund, and would require disclosure of all other kinds of preferential treatment given to investors. Private Fund Advisers would be prohibited from:

    • Granting an investor in a private fund or a “substantially similar pool of assets”[3] the ability to redeem its interest on terms that the Private Fund Adviser reasonably expects to have a material, negative effect on other investors in that private fund or substantially similar pool of assets and
    • Providing information regarding the portfolio holdings or exposures of a private fund, or of a substantially similar pool of assets, if the Private Fund Adviser reasonably expects that providing that information would have a material, negative effect on other investors in that private fund.

    The Proposed Rules would also require Private Fund Advisers to specifically disclose all other preferential treatment given to an investor in a private fund to all prospective and current investors in that fund. These written disclosures must be provided to prospective investors in writing prior to their investment, and an annual notice describing preferential treatment given would need to be provided to all existing investors.

    Private Fund Audit Rule. The Proposed Rules would require Registered Advisers to obtain a financial statement audit from an independent public accountant for each private fund they advise at least annually and upon liquidation. Although an annual audit conducted in compliance with Advisers Act Rule 206(4)-2 (the “Custody Rule”) will in many cases satisfy the conditions of the Proposed Rules, compliance with the Custody Rule is not sufficient to satisfy the Proposed Rules (or vice versa). The Proposed Rules differ from the Custody Rule’s audit approach in certain key respects, including, among other things:

    • Annual audits are required for a private fund client even if the Registered Adviser obtains a surprise examination;
    • Auditor engagement letters must require the auditor to notify the SEC’s Division of Examinations upon the auditor’s termination or issuance of a modified opinion;
    • Audited financial statements must be distributed to investors “promptly” upon completion of the audit, and not necessarily within 120 days of the end of the fund’s fiscal year (please note that private fund managers relying on the audit approach under the Custody Rule would still need to comply with the Custody Rule’s distribution timing requirements);
    • The Proposed Rules do not provide an exception from the audit requirement for fee deduction or where the adviser has custody solely because a related person has custody of a client’s funds or securities (as is the case for the Custody Rule); and
    • Registered Advisers that do not control, are not controlled by and are not under common control with, a private fund that they advise (e.g., certain subadvisers) would be required to take all reasonable steps to cause the private fund to undergo a financial statement audit.

    Adviser-Led Secondaries Rule. The Proposed Rules would require a Registered Adviser engaging in an adviser-led secondary transaction for a private fund client to distribute to investors, prior to the completion of the transaction:

    • A fairness opinion prepared by an independent opinion provider (i.e., an entity that provides fairness opinions in the course of its business and is not a related person of the Registered Adviser) and
    • A written summary of any material business relationships within the past two years between the Registered Adviser and the independent opinion provider.

    Compliance Rule Amendments. The Proposed Rules include amendments to Advisers Act Rule 206(4)-7 (the “Compliance Rule”) requiring that annual reviews conducted under the Compliance Rule be documented in writing.

    Books and Records Rule Amendments. The proposal includes amendments to Advisers Act Rule 204-2 (the “Books and Records Rule”) that would require Registered Advisers to retain records related to the proposed rules.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact Marc E. Elovitz, Kelly Koscuiszka, Meghan J. Carey, Christopher S. Avellaneda, Tarik M. Shah, or your attorney.

    Further, we are gathering feedback from our clients about the impact of the SEC’s proposed rules as we prepare a comment letter. You can submit comments to CommentLetters@mcdermottlaw.com or discuss them directly with one of the authors or your attorney.

    In depth
    Authors

    Marc E. Elovitz

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Kelly Koscuiszka

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Christopher S. Avellaneda

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Tarik M. Shah

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Women’s Network—Say “No” to Say “Yes”: Five Steps to Decluttering Your Work Life

    Women’s Network—Say “No” to Say “Yes”: Five Steps to Decluttering Your Work Life

    ARTICLE

    Women’s Network—Say “No” to Say “Yes”: Five Steps to Decluttering Your Work Life

    February 1, 2022

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • State Law Privacy Video Series | Privacy and Sensitive Information

    State Law Privacy Video Series | Privacy and Sensitive Information

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT / VIDEO

    State Law Privacy Video Series | Privacy and Sensitive Information

    February 8, 2022

    Read time: 2 min

    Overview

    California, Virginia and Colorado have new privacy laws coming into effect in 2023. But now is the time to start preparing your business or organization for compliance.

    In this video series, we examine the different aspects of these laws and provide you the knowledge and tools you need for proper compliance.

    In depth

    Each of the three state data privacy laws takes a slightly different approach when it comes to “sensitive” data. In the video below, Counsel Jessi Sawyer goes over each law and what businesses need to know about handling “sensitive” data.



    McDermott’s State Law Privacy Video Series: Privacy and Sensitive Information overview, 2022 (runtime: 3m9s)

    Conclusion

    Jessica McGahie Sawyer

    Counsel

    Los Angeles

    More insights

  • Recent Tax Developments Concerning Staking Rewards

    Recent Tax Developments Concerning Staking Rewards

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Recent Tax Developments Concerning Staking Rewards

    February 4, 2022

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Stakers—taxpayers involved in proof of stake (PoS) validation of blockchain transactions—continue to operate in uncharted tax waters. PoS blockchains represent over half of the $1.68 trillion cryptocurrency market capitalization, with five of the top 10 PoS blockchains having a stake rate greater than 50%. Despite the remarkable growth of the PoS market in the last two years, there is no government guidance about the tax treatment of staking rewards.

    In a closely followed case in the US District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee, Jarrett v. United States, No. 3:21-cv-00419 (M.D. Tenn.), a taxpayer paid tax on staking rewards and sued for a refund. The question before the district court is whether the receipt of staking rewards generates taxable income at the date the rewards are received.

    On February 3, 2022, it was reported that the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) offered to refund the taxpayer’s money for taxes paid on staking rewards. The taxpayer rejected the IRS’s offer to receive a definitive ruling that will be binding on the IRS.

    In this article, we look at the issue before the district court and address the significance of the recent offer by the IRS to refund the taxpayer’s tax payment.

    In depth

    VIRTUAL CURRENCY STAKING

    In PoS systems, stakers are chosen by combinations of random selection plus the amount of units making up their stake and/or the amount of time they agree to lock up the stakes in a specific digital wallet. Staked units support the blockchain operations by validating transactions on the blockchain and earning rewards. Unlike the mining activities of proof of work (PoW) blockchain miners, stakers validate new blocks by forging the next block on the blockchain without mathematical computations. Certain platforms participate in staking by pooling their customers’ tokens and sharing the staking rewards.

    Although each blockchain protocol is different, PoS protocols require stakers to hold (for an agreed amount of time) and post a minimum number of units (stake) to participate in the validation process. Stakers receive, as staking rewards, a specified number of units. These rewards can redistribute value to owners that participate in staking and away from owners that do not participate.

    The IRS has addressed the tax treatment of PoW blockchain miners but has not addressed the tax treatment of staking rewards. This means that taxpayers must consider general tax principles that apply to property transactions and adopt a tax methodology they believe is supportable on audit, subject to judicial and administrative review.

    Stakers take a wide range of positions with respect to the tax character and tax timing of staking rewards. For example, some stakers take the position that the receipt of staking rewards result in taxable income from the performance of services, while others assert that staking rewards are not taxable until they sell, exchange or otherwise dispose of the rewards. The policy considerations behind each of these positions vary as well, with the timing of taxation on staking rewards currently being litigated in Jarrett v. United States.

    JARRETT V. UNITED STATES

    In 2019, Joshua Jarrett (the taxpayer) engaged in staking activities where he posted Tezos tokens to contribute to the creation of new blocks of the Tezos public blockchain. The taxpayer received 8,876 new Tezos tokens worth $9,407 at the time of receipt. Following receipt, the tokens were available to be sold or exchanged for other cryptocurrencies, government-backed (fiat) currency, or for goods or services. During 2019, the taxpayer did not sell or exchange any of the 8,876 newly created Tezos tokens.

    On the 2019 federal income tax return, the taxpayer reported $9,407 as “other income.” After filing the return, the taxpayer timely filed an amended 2019 tax return, asserting that the $9,407 in staking income is not taxable. The taxpayer asked for a refund of the $3,293 tax paid on the Tezos tokens (along with a $500 increase in tax credits that resulted from the reduction of the taxpayer’s income for a total refund request of $3,793).

    The taxpayer did not receive a timely response from the IRS; he filed a complaint on May 26, 2021, in Tennessee district court seeking a refund. The taxpayer argued that the newly created Tezos tokens were only taxable at the time of sale, not at the time of receipt, and asserted that the foundational basis of US tax law is that newly created property (such as creating a cake or a book) is not an accession to wealth that is “clearly realized.” Under US federal income tax principles, an accession to wealth is a requirement that is necessary for an item to be included as income.

    In a notice filed with the district court on February 3, 2022, the US Department of Justice (DOJ) Tax Division informed the taxpayer that a full refund had been approved and directed the IRS to issue the refund. In response, the taxpayer refused to accept the refund because the IRS will not provide any assurance with respect to whether tokens created through staking activities constitute taxable income at the time of creation. The taxpayer is continuing his efforts to receive a formal judgement from the court.

    While some media reports are suggesting that the offer to refund suggests that the IRS has signaled or taken the position that staking income is not taxed at the time of receipt, this is not the situation. The DOJ did not explain the reason for the offer. Such an offer may be the result of the government hoping to delay the issue until it can cherry-pick a case with better facts in the government’s view or to otherwise avoid creating judicial precedence unfavorable to the government. The offer is nonbinding and does not provide guidance for which Jarrett or other taxpayers can rely.

    WHERE ARE WE NOW?

    Taxpayers still have no government guidance about the tax treatment of staking activities. This means that taxpayers continue to operate in uncharted tax waters. While a judicial opinion from Jarrett v. United States could provide some guidance, the case could take years to litigate and is only binding precedent for taxpayers in the Middle District of Tennessee—assuming any resulting favorable decision is not appealed.

    In an effort to seek government guidance, a bipartisan group of members of Congress sent a letter to the IRS in July 2020 asking that staking rewards for validators in PoS networks be taxed when sold, rather than treated as income upon receipt. The IRS has not taken any action on this request. As a result, taxpayers must continue to proceed with caution.

    For a detailed discussion of staking and US federal income tax considerations, please see Taxation of Virtual Currency Staking Activities. For a detailed discussion of PoW mining taxation, please see Taxation of Virtual Currency Mining Activities.

    If you have questions about the tax implications of staking activities, please do not hesitate to contact the authors or your McDermott contact(s).

    Authors

    Andrew M. Granek

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    John T. Lutz

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • SEC Survives Initial Challenge in First Enforcement Action Alleging ‘Shadow Trading’

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    SEC Survives Initial Challenge in First Enforcement Action Alleging ‘Shadow Trading’

    February 3, 2022

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On January 14, 2022, the US District Court for the Northern District of California denied an individual defendant’s motion to dismiss in SEC v. Panuwat, an insider trading case accusing a former pharmaceutical company employee of trading in a competitor’s stock ahead of a merger. This novel US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) enforcement action involves “shadow trading”—using inside information relating to one company to trade the stock of a separate, but comparable, company.

    In depth

    According to the SEC’s complaint, Matthew Panuwat was the senior director of business development at a mid-sized biopharmaceutical company. Panuwat allegedly purchased short-term stock options in a competing company in the same industry a few days before his employer announced its acquisition by a global pharmaceutical company. Panuwat allegedly learned that investment bankers had identified the comparable company as part of its analysis, and he anticipated that the acquisition would lead to an increase in the competitor’s share price. Following the announcement of the acquisition, the competitor’s share price rose approximately 8%, and Panuwat’s trades allegedly generated profits of $107,066.

    This action is the first time the SEC has tried to extend the “misappropriation theory” of insider trading to trading in the securities of one company while in possession of material nonpublic information about another comparable company. Under the misappropriation theory, a person violates the law when he misappropriates confidential information for securities trading purposes, in breach of a duty owed to the source of the information. Here, the court held that the SEC adequately pled that the information about the acquisition was nonpublic, confidential and material to the competitor; that Panuwat breached his duty to his employer by using information to purchase the stock options; and that he acted with the requisite scienter.

    With respect to the SEC’s breach of duty claim, the court focused on the language of the employer’s insider trading policy. The complaint alleges that the policy broadly prohibited trading in “the securities of another publicly traded company, including all significant collaborators, customers, partners, suppliers or competitors.” The court found that the word “including” does not limit the policy’s applicability to only the types of companies listed but is simply illustrative of the types of companies it covers.

    TAKEAWAYS

    • The SEC will perceive this ruling as a win, and the case may encourage the agency’s staff to pursue other related or novel theories for insider trading liability. The court ruling no doubt will embolden the SEC as it considers future cases.
    • Public companies may want to review their insider trading policies. Recently, the SEC proposed amendments to Rule 10b5-1 under the Securities Exchange of 1934. The proposed rules require public companies to disclose in their insider trading policies and procedures their annual reports. If they have not adopted insider trading policies and procedures, the proposed rules require that companies disclose why not. The SEC explained that specific disclosures concerning insider trading policies will benefit investors by enabling them to evaluate the extent to which those policies protect shareholders from the misuse of material nonpublic information. In Panuwat, the court focused on the precise language in the insider trading policy, holding that the broadly worded policy prohibited trading in the securities of another company. The court did not resolve whether “shadow trading” would be unlawful absent an explicit policy prohibiting the conduct. The SEC’s focus on shadow trading may mean that the specific prohibitions in a company’s policy may come under greater scrutiny.
    • Public companies should also be mindful of the heightened risk faced by individual officers, directors and employees in this environment. SEC investigations can be costly and disrupt the work of key personnel. Dedicated execution of reasonably designed policies and procedures in this area can protect those executives and the company itself.
    Authors

    Paul M.G. Helms

    Partner

    Chicago, Washington, DC

    More insights

  • Effects of the Corporate Income Tax Option on Inheritance and Gift Taxes

    Effects of the Corporate Income Tax Option on Inheritance and Gift Taxes

    ARTICLE

    Effects of the Corporate Income Tax Option on Inheritance and Gift Taxes

    January 29, 2021

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Dr. Nils Wighard and Jonathan Storz with article on “Effects of the Corporate Income Tax Option on Inheritance and Gift Tax,” published in Deutsches Steuerrecht (DStR), Issue 4, 2022, p. 132 et seq.

    In depth
    Authors

    Jonathan Storz

    Counsel

    Munich

    More insights

  • Former Government Contractor Executive Convicted of Procurement Fraud

    Former Government Contractor Executive Convicted of Procurement Fraud

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Former Government Contractor Executive Convicted of Procurement Fraud

    February 2, 2022

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On February 1, 2022, a federal jury found a former engineering firm executive guilty of conspiring to rig bids and defraud the North Carolina Department of Transportation (NCDOT) of hundreds of public works contracts worth more than $23 million. From at least 2009 through fall 2018, Brent Brewbaker was responsible for crafting and submitting bids to NCDOT on behalf of Contech Engineered Solutions LLC, an engineering firm that makes products used in bridge construction, water drainage and other public works projects.

    In depth

    The US Department of Justice (DOJ) previously indicted Brewbaker and Contech in October 2020 for participating in the long-running conspiracy. In June 2021, Contech pleaded guilty to one count of bid-rigging and one count of conspiracy to commit mail and wire fraud after a federal judge denied its motion to dismiss the bid-rigging charges and found that the alleged conduct would be considered a per se, or automatic, violation of the antitrust laws. Contech was sentenced to pay a $7 million fine, as well as over $1.5 million in restitution to NCDOT. It also agreed to cooperate with the DOJ in its ongoing investigation.

    After a five-day trial, Brewbaker was convicted on all six charged counts: one count of bid rigging in violation of federal antitrust laws, one count of conspiracy to commit mail and wire fraud, three counts of mail fraud, and one count of wire fraud. Sentencing is currently set for April 12.

    The conviction underscores the DOJ’s commitment to the Procurement Collusion Strike Force (PCSF) and its efforts to hold individuals and contractors accountable for collusion and fraud in government contracting. The PCSF is a strategic partnership between the DOJ, numerous US Attorney’s Offices and seven national law enforcement partner agencies. The PCSF has several ongoing investigations ranging from local conduct related to a single bid to multidistrict, nationwide and even international conduct involving multiple bids and contracts. According to October 2021 remarks by the Director of the PCSF, the task force is focusing its enforcement priorities on collusion related to government programs designed to facilitate participation from underserved communities (known as “set-aside fraud”) and collusion related to infrastructure contracts.

    Companies doing business with government agencies should continue to expect increased scrutiny of procurement bids and the bid award process. They should be attentive in ensuring compliance with antitrust and government procurement laws, particularly in teaming agreements, joint ventures and other dealings with competitors.

    Based on our recent experience with the PCSF, companies can minimize their risks in the following ways:

    • Carefully review and document any no-bid or high-bid decisions and provide business justifications for such decisions;
    • Have counsel review any decisions to team and/or joint bid with other companies in advance;
    • Have counsel review any subcontracting arrangements with other companies that bid (or regularly bid) on the same projects in advance;
    • Ensure bids are legitimate and pricing decisions are determined in good faith and without collusion;
    • Monitor the procurement process;
    • Understand the red flags of collusion (indicators, patterns and/or circumstances where collusion may exist) and other indicators that suggest to the government that additional scrutiny of the bid process is warranted;
    • Ensure your corporate compliance program is consistent with DOJ guidance and appropriately tailored to your company and industry; and
    • Regularly train procurement personnel on appropriate conduct with respect to competitors and the consequences of collusion.
    Authors

    Lisa P. Rumin

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • International News: Spotlight on Private Equity

    International News: Spotlight on Private Equity

    INTERNATIONAL NEWS / REPORT

    International News: Spotlight on Private Equity

    February 2022

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    This is a phenomenally interesting time to be a Private Equity investor. The dramatic shifts in focus caused by the global COVID-19 pandemic, the increasing challenge of climate change, and the growing emphasis on corporate governance, have converged to create a perfect storm of opportunity and demand for investment.

    Nowhere is this more apparent than in the healthcare and life sciences sectors, which are seeing unprecedented expansion as a result of the existing, pre-pandemic move towards a new world of healthcare delivery, and the reinforcement of healthcare services as a major priority across the globe. Our HPE New York 2021 panel of experts provide insight on how the most successful funds are maximising the current opportunities.

    Running a close second, the shift towards renewable energy has opened up avenues for investment that might not be immediately obvious: the upstream oil and gas industry. Demand for oil continues to surge, but the current importance of environmental, social, and governance considerations, has rendered hydrocarbons unattractive for public investment. PE and private wealth look poised to step into the void.

    Of course, these opportunities also create challenges and potential pitfalls for over-enthusiastic but unprepared investors who may fear they are missing out on the next big thing. A clear-eyed understanding of risk, and a strong commitment to mitigating it, have never been more valuable.

    Please contact our authors directly if you have any comments on our articles, or would like to discuss any of the issues raised.

    In depth
    Authors

    Kristian A. Werling

    Partner

    Chicago

    Sharon Lamb

    Partner

    London – 22 Bishopsgate

    Aymen Mahmoud

    Partner

    London – 22 Bishopsgate

    David Kiefer

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    Mark Fine

    Partner

    London – 22 Bishopsgate

    More insights