Content Type: Article

  • OSHA Hints at Permanent COVID-19 Standard, Withdraws Vax-or-Test ETS

    OSHA Hints at Permanent COVID-19 Standard, Withdraws Vax-or-Test ETS

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    OSHA Hints at Permanent COVID-19 Standard, Withdraws Vax-or-Test ETS

    January 25, 2022

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On January 25, 2022, the US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) announced that it would withdraw its controversial “vax-or-test” Emergency Temporary Standard (ETS), which required large employers to impose vaccination or testing requirements upon their employees. The withdrawal will be effective as soon as the announcement is published in the Federal Register, which is scheduled to occur on January 26, 2022.

    In depth

    In the same announcement, OSHA clarified that the text of the ETS will remain in place to solicit additional comments from the general public so that, according to OSHA, the agency can “prioritiz[e] its resources to focus on finalizing a permanent COVID-19 Healthcare Standard.” If OSHA follows this path, the final rule will be published no later than May 5, 2022.

    OSHA also confirmed that the 22 states that have OSHA-approved state OSHA plans are free to issue or withdraw their own COVID-19 health and safety regulations without regard to federal OSHA’s activities.

    This update follows the US Supreme Court’s January 13, 2022, ruling that blocked OSHA from enforcing its ETS while litigation regarding the merits of the ETS proceeded in the US Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit. The ETS, which was originally issued on November 5, 2021, was scheduled to expire on May 5, 2022.

    Authors

    Abigail M. Kagan

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • White House Office of Science and Technology Policy Seeking Information on Strengthening Community Health Through Technology

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    White House Office of Science and Technology Policy Seeking Information on Strengthening Community Health Through Technology

    January 25, 2022

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In a request for information issued on January 5, 2022, the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP) announced that it is seeking input from stakeholders across the healthcare spectrum on how digital health technologies are being—or may be—used to improve community health, individual wellness and health equity. Comments must be submitted to the OSTP by 5 pm on February 28, 2022.

    In depth

    On January 5, 2022, the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP) issued a request for information (RFI) on how digital health technologies are used or could be used in the future to improve community health, individual wellness and health equity. The RFI solicits stakeholders from across the spectrum to provide information about a wide range of issues, from examples of successful use cases in the United States and abroad to perspectives on training needs and barriers.

    This RFI is part of a larger effort of the Biden administration to promote and prioritize equity in policymaking. When President Biden took the oath of office back in January 2021, addressing the COVID-19 pandemic was a top priority; this continues to be the case today. But the pandemic also has brought into stark relief the social and racial disparities in healthcare as well as in many other aspects of American life. In response and as one of his first actions, President Biden signed Executive Order (EO) 13985, “Advancing Racial Equity and Support for Underserved Communities through the Federal Government.” This EO directed the entire federal government to “pursue a comprehensive approach to advancing equity for all.”

    While this directive to use the lens of equity for policy making is being implemented throughout the federal government, the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) has been especially active in this area and has made addressing healthcare disparities a critical component of numerous major regulations, RFIs and other guidance documents that were released in 2021.

    The prioritization of addressing health equity is also reflected in the strategic plans and mission statements of various HHS agencies:

    As we enter the second year of the Biden administration, we anticipate that there will be continued efforts in this area.

    Impetus for OSTP RFI

    The RFI notes that despite significant investment into digital health over many years, the COVID-19 pandemic uncovered “substantial limitation in the U.S. healthcare systems, including profound disparities in healthcare and associated poorer health outcomes within certain communities.” Noting that part of OSTP’s mission is to maximize the benefits of science and technology for all Americans, OSTP issued the RFI to gain information and perspective on how digital health can be used to improve community health, individual wellness and health equity. The RFI is part of a broader agenda dedicated to “Community Connected Health,” which OSTP describes as “an effort that will explore and act upon how innovation in science and technology can lower the barriers to access quality healthcare and lead healthier lives by meeting people where they are in their communities.”

    Specific Topics

    The RFI seeks information, impressions, descriptions and comments in relation to eight specific topics. It should be noted that the RFI defines “digital health technologies” broadly to include “any tool or set of tools that improve health or enable better healthcare delivery by connecting people with other people, with data, or with health information.” The eight topics are:

    1. Successful models within the United States: The RFI requests information and comments about how successful models have worked, including information about organization or technology features that support success, examples of user protections (such as privacy best practices), examples of positive user experiences and descriptions of potentially successful models.
    2. Barriers: The RFI requests information and comments about barriers for individuals and organizations to adopt digital health in community settings, such as cost, training, reimbursement, community or organizational buy-in, and training. The RFI specifically notes interest in understanding the impediments to user comfort, such as concerns about privacy, security and discrimination.
    3. Trends from the pandemic: The RFI requests impressions or data on how the use of digital health by individuals and community-based organizations has changed during the pandemic, including impressions on how permanent these trends may be.
    4. User experience: The RFI requests descriptions of how developers and community-based providers and stakeholders consider and evaluate user experience, with particular interest in descriptions of ways user experience-based barriers can be overcome.
    5. Tool and training needs: The RFI requests information about technology, infrastructure and training needs for community-based providers.
    6. Proposed government actions: The RFI requests ideas on opportunities for federal government support to improve digital health-based community health transformation and when the opportunity could be implemented (immediately, or over the next five or 10 years).
    7. Health equity: The RFI requests information about how digital health has been, or could be, used in community-based settings to reduce health disparities or achieve health equity. The RFI also solicits concerns about how digital health impacts health equity.
    8. International models: Similar to the request for information about successful US models, this topic seeks information about successful foreign models, particularly from low- or middle-income countries. The RFI encourages suggestions about how these models could be applied in the United States.

    Conclusion

    The federal government’s relationship with digital health tools has been difficult. Broad policy goals related to, for example, insurance coverage, value-based care and cost, have generally dominated healthcare policy, leaving digital health and its potential for fundamentally altering (and improving) care delivery subservient to these policy goals. This is largely as it should be, but it does hamstring some digital health potential. It is not surprising that this RFI is presented in the context of one of those broad policy issues: health equity. And while this RFI provides an opportunity for digital health stakeholders to make their case, it also must be understood for what it is: a request for information on how digital health can serve a broader policy goal that itself may not be the best vehicle to showcase the many benefits digital health has to offer.

    Regardless, this RFI provides digital health stakeholders with the opportunity to make the case for digital health tools, identify solutions to barriers to adoption that the federal government can correct and describe the benefits digital health can provide to all.

    Authors

    Lisa Mazur

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • Key Agenda Items for Board Committees, Third Edition: Supporting Committee Effectiveness in a Changing Environment

    Key Agenda Items for Board Committees, Third Edition: Supporting Committee Effectiveness in a Changing Environment

    ARTICLE / REPORT

    Key Agenda Items for Board Committees, Third Edition: Supporting Committee Effectiveness in a Changing Environment

    January 25, 2022

    Read time: 3 min

    Overview

    Welcome to the third edition in our Governing Health series of e-books designed to address the particularities of committee practice for the health system governing board.

    As we noted in the first (January 2021) edition of this series, a well-organized, thoughtfully composed and industry-attentive committee structure can provide substantial support to the governing board, especially when multiple items compete for attention on the board’s agenda. Delegating key tasks to standing and special committees can facilitate the efficiency and thoroughness with which the board fulfills its responsibilities.

    In our previous editions of this series, we focused on (i) committees’ ability to satisfy their delegated responsibilities through a keen understanding of the key topics and trends they are likely to encounter in the coming year; and (ii) the types of information committees need to receive and the frequency with which they should receive it.

    In this latest edition, we’re focusing on the unique and special issues committees should include in their 2022 agenda, especially those that are driven by the events of the last two years. An important note: The information that committees need does not come exclusively from their legal advisors. Committees operate best when they receive input from a wide variety of industry experts familiar with the key relevant issues. So we reached out to several of our friends in other advisory disciplines—names you’re sure to recognize—to help us with this third edition. We hope that you’ll find that this collaboration provides a fresh perspective on some traditional governance challenges.

    Internally at McDermott, we’ve referred to this as our “Duets” project, in reference to the manner in which famous recording artists collaborate with their friends to bring new life and energy to old standards. We’ve deeply enjoyed sharing various thoughts and perspectives with these accomplished colleagues. We think the “Duets” approach enhances the scope of the ebook and the value it provides to those who lead and those who support committee practice.

    External Contributors:

    In depth
    Tabs
    More insights
    Endnotes

  • Federal Reserve Releases Report on Central Bank Digital Currency

    Federal Reserve Releases Report on Central Bank Digital Currency

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Federal Reserve Releases Report on Central Bank Digital Currency

    January 25, 2022

    Read time: 10 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On Jan. 20, 2022, the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (“Federal Reserve”) released its report on central bank digital currency (“CBDC”) (“Report”).[1] The Report discusses and examines the potential benefits and risks of issuing a CBDC and identifies specific policy considerations. However, the Federal Reserve emphasizes they would not move forward with issuing a CBDC without congressional approval, stating “[t]he Federal Reserve does not intend to proceed with issuance of a CBDC without clear support from the executive branch and from Congress, ideally in the form of a specific authorizing law.”[2]

    What is a CBDC?

    The Report defines a CBDC as a “digital liability of the Federal Reserve that is widely available to the general public.”[3] Central bank money is generally a liability of the Federal Reserve. Specifically, in the United States, central bank money exists as either Federal Reserve-issued physical currency or as digital balances that are held by commercial banks at the Federal Reserve. Physical currency issued by the Federal Reserve is currently the only form of central bank money that the general public has available to use. Central bank money differs from digital money held in personal accounts at commercial banks (i.e., commercial bank money) and digital money held by non-bank financial service providers as balances (i.e., nonbank money) because central bank money does not need certain mechanisms in place (like deposit insurance for commercial bank money) for public confidence.[4] Further, unlike stablecoins,[5] a CBDC’s value would not depend on an underlying asset pool for its backing. Therefore, a CBDC, simply put, would be a way for the general public to make digital payments using central bank money.

    The Report outlines potential uses and functions of a CBDC. Individuals, businesses and governments could use a CBDC to purchase basic goods and services or pay bills.[6] Governments could use a CBDC to directly make benefit payments to citizens or to collect taxes. The Report also states that CBDC could potentially be programmed to deliver payments at specific, future times.

    Key Characteristics of a CBDC

    The Report indicates that if a U.S. CBDC were to be created, such a CBDC would be optimal for the needs of the United States by being (i) privacy-protected, (ii) intermediated, (iii) widely transferable and (iv) identity-verified.[7] Below please find more information on how the Report describes these characteristics:

    • Privacy-Protected. A CBDC would need to strike a balance between protecting the privacy rights of consumers and still being transparent enough to deter criminal activity with its use.
    • Intermediated. If a CBDC were to be created, it would be best for the CBDC to be intermediated — e., the private sector would offer digital wallets or accounts for CBDC holdings and payments (and not involve individuals having direct accounts at the Federal Reserve, stating “such accounts would represent a significant expansion of the Federal Reserve’s role in the financial system and the economy”). The Report states that such an intermediated approach would be optimal because it would not disrupt the current workings of the financial system and would allow reliance on the private sector’s long-established and innovative ways of holding money properly and safely.
    • Transferable. In order for a CBDC to be effective, a CBDC would need to be readily transferable between different intermediaries’ customers, so that money can flow through the economy more easily.
    • Identity-Verified. It would be important for a CBDC to be subject to anti-money laundering and counter-terrorism financing rules. Specifically, just like financial institutions that verify their customers’ identities, a CBDC intermediary would need to verify the identity of a customer accessing a CBDC.

    Potential Benefits of a CBDC

    The Federal Reserve identifies and describes the following potential benefits of a CBDC in the Report[8]:

    • Safely Meet Future Needs and Demands for Payment Services:
      • The proliferation of digital money relates to the need for fast and efficient payment delivery systems, but current digital money, like cryptocurrencies, carry many liquidity and credit risks. By creating a CBDC, the public could make fast digital payments while using an asset free from those risks.
      • Smaller businesses could gain access to a more level playing field by being able to use a CBDC because it is too cost-prohibitive for those smaller firms to create their own form of safe and private money. Thus, smaller businesses could focus on improving their offerings, instead of expending resources on making payments safely.
      • As noted above, a CBDC could make payments systems more efficient by generating new capabilities, like the ability to be programmed to make payments at specific times. Moreover, “microtransactions” (transactions involving a very small amount of money that usually take place online) are not well-suited for traditional payments systems and a CBDC could facilitate those transactions more easily.
    • Improvements to Cross-Border Payments. A CBDC could create improvements to cross-border payments by making such payments more efficient, creating opportunities for cross-border collaborations and potentially creating new technologies.
    • Support the Dollar’s International Role. A CBDC could potentially preserve the international dominance of the U.S. dollar (which benefits the United States by lowering international transaction costs for Americans and allows the United States to influence the global monetary system to its own benefit). If other countries were to create their own forms of CBDC, it would be paramount for the United States to have its own effective CBDC so those other forms of CBDC do not become so popular as to decrease the U.S. dollar’s popularity.
    • Financial Inclusion. Taking into account that many economically vulnerable households often lack access to rapid and cost-effective forms of payments (in order to receive wages, pay taxes and so forth), it is possible a CBDC would lower the transaction costs that lower-income households face when making and receiving payments.
    • Extend Public Access to Safe Central Bank Monkey. Noting that cash is currently the only form of central bank money available to the general public and that the use of cash is rapidly declining in both the United States and other countries, the Federal Reserve is committed to ensuring the safety and availability of cash, while expanding safe payment options, like a CBDC, that do not carry the same liquidity and credit risks as commercial bank or nonbank money.

    Potential Risks and Policy Considerations for a CBDC

    The Federal Reserve identifies and describes the following potential risks and policy considerations of a CBDC in the Report[9]:

    • Changes to Financial-Sector Market Structure. A CBDC (especially an interest-bearing one) could be so attractive to consumers that it ends up serving as a substitute for commercial bank money. In such a case, the deposits that banks are reliant on in order to give out loans would decrease and thus reduce credit availability for households and businesses. Moreover, such a CBDC could result in a shift away from other low-risk assets, like shares in money market mutual funds, and further raise credit costs or reduce credit availability for businesses and governments.
    • Safety and Stability of the Financial System. A CBDC would be very attractive to risk-averse consumers and the ability to convert other forms of money into a CBDC could create an incentive for people to “make a run” on the money in financial institutions during times of financial stress and crisis. However, the Report states that this risk could be mitigated somewhat by design choices for a CBDC, like making sure banks do not pay interest on a CBDC or limiting the amount of a CBDC an end-user could have.
    • Efficacy of Monetary Policy Implementation. The institution of a CBDC could greatly complicate Federal Reserve decisions over monetary policy. Currently, the Federal Reserve exercises control over interest rates without actively managing the supply of reserves. By creating a CBDC, the amount of reserves in the financial system would change. As a result, the Federal Reserve would potentially need to increase the level of reserves to accommodate CBDC growth (particularly if the CBDC were interest-bearing), which, in turn, could increase interest rates.
    • Privacy and Data Protection and the Prevention of Financial Crimes. It is paramount that a CBDC protect consumers’ financial transaction data (using banks’ existing tools), while still ensuring that CBDC intermediaries are identifying their customers and using other relevant tools (like recordkeeping) in order to prevent financial crime.
    • Operational Resilience and Cybersecurity. Current threats to payment systems, like cybersecurity risks, would also apply to a CBDC. In fact, a CBDC could be more vulnerable to risks than current payment systems because a CBDC network would have more points of entry than a traditional payment system. However, if offline capability were developed for a CBDC (i.e., it could be used without the Internet), such risks could be mitigated (and a CBDC would be available to use in emergencies where Internet is not available, like in disaster zones).

    Conclusion

    While the Report does not commit the Federal Reserve to any action, the Report demonstrates the serious attention that financial government agencies and regulators are giving to digital payments (and the potential desire by the government to create its own form of digital payment).[10] The Federal Reserve is requesting public comment on more than 20 questions on the benefits, risks and policy considerations for CBDCs, as well as CBDC design. Comments are being accepted through May 20, 2022.[11] 

    Schulte Roth & Zabel’s lawyers are available to assist you in preparing and submitting comments to the Report or addressing any questions you may have regarding these developments. Please contact the Schulte Roth & Zabel lawyer with whom you usually work or any of the following attorneys:

    Donald J. Mosher – New York (+1 212.756.2187, donald.mosher@srz.com)

    Kara A. Kuchar – New York (+1 212.756.2734, kara.kuchar@srz.com)

    Jessica Sklute – New York (+1 212.756.2180, jessica.sklute@srz.com)

    Melissa G.R. Goldstein – Washington, DC (+1 202.729.7471, melissa.goldstein@srz.com)

    Adam J. Barazani – New York (+1 212.756.2519, adam.barazani@srz.com)

    Jessica Romano – New York (+1 212.756.2205, jessica.romano@srz.com)

    Hadas A. Jacobi – New York (+1 212.756.2055, hadas.jacobi@srz.com)

    Steven T. Cummings – New York (+1 212.756.2251, steven.cummings@srz.com)


    [1] Money and Payments: The U.S. Dollar in the Age of Digital Transformation, Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (Jan. 2022), available here.

    [2] Id. at 3.

    [3] Id. at 13.

    [4] Id.

    [5] “Stablecoins are a more recent incarnation of cryptocurrency that peg their value to one or more assets, such as a sovereign currency or commodity.” Id. at 11.

    [6] Id. at 14.

    [7] Id. at 13.

    [8] Id. at 14-16.

    [9] Id. at 17-20.

    [10] The Federal Reserve, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, and the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency also recently conducted a series of interagency “policy sprints” focused on crypto-assets. See Joint Statement on Crypto-Asset Policy Sprint Initiative and Next Steps (Nov. 23, 2021), available here. For more information about the “policy sprints,” please refer to our prior Alert. The President’s Working Group on Financial Markets also issued an interagency report on stablecoins. President’s Working Group on Financial Markets, Federal Deposit Insurance Agency & Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, Report on Stablecoins (Nov. 2021), available here. For more information about the report, please refer to our prior Alert.

    [11] Id. at 21.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2022 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Donald J. Mosher

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Melissa G.R. Goldstein

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Adam J. Barazani

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Increased HSR Act Thresholds Announced for 2022

    Increased HSR Act Thresholds Announced for 2022

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Increased HSR Act Thresholds Announced for 2022

    January 24, 2022

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Hart-Scott-Rodino Antitrust Improvements Act of 1976, as amended (“HSR Act”), requires parties to acquisitions of voting securities, assets or non-corporate interests meeting certain thresholds to make a premerger notification to the Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”) and the Antitrust Division of the Department of Justice and to observe a waiting period prior to consummating such acquisitions. Today, the Federal Register published the annual adjustments to the current HSR Act thresholds. Any transaction that will be consummated on or after the Feb. 23, 2022 effective date of such adjustments may be reportable under the HSR Act if, as a result of such transaction, the acquiring person will hold voting securities, assets and/or non-corporate interests of the acquired person valued above $101 million (the current adjusted minimum threshold is $92 million). The new adjusted thresholds, which are revised annually, are adjusted for inflation. The size-of-person threshold looks at the total sales or assets of each party to a transaction, including its ultimate parent and certain affiliates, and is also being increased.

    The updated size-of-transaction and size-of-person thresholds under the HSR Act are set forth below:

    Threshold

    HSR Act Original

    2022 Adjusted

    Size-of-transaction when
    size-of-person test applies

    $50 million

    $101 million

    Size-of-person (if applicable)

    $10 million and $100 million

    $20.2 million and $202 million

    Size-of-transaction above which size-of-person test does not apply

    $200 million

    $403.9 million

     

    The filing fees applicable to premerger notifications filed under the HSR Act have not changed in over a decade and will continue as follows:

    Size-of-Transaction (as adjusted)

    Filing Fee

    Valued at greater than $101 million, but less than $202 million

    $45,000

    Valued at $202 million or greater, but less than $1,009.8 million

    $125,000

    Valued at $1,009.8 million or greater

    $280,000

     

    When a premerger notification has been filed under the HSR Act, and the applicable waiting period has expired or been terminated, any additional acquisitions by the same acquiring person of the same issuer’s voting securities will be exempt from notification, so long as:

    • The acquiring person’s holdings crossed the notification threshold with respect to which the premerger notification was made, within one year of the expiration or early termination of the HSR Act waiting period; and
    • The subsequent acquisition is consummated within five years following the expiration or early termination of the HSR Act waiting period;

    unless a higher notification level is met or exceeded. The various notification levels are set forth below:

    HSR Act Original

    2022 Adjusted

    $50 million

    $101 million

    $100 million

    $202 million

    $500 million

    $1,009.8 million

    25% if value of voting securities to be held
    is greater than $1 billion

    25% if value of voting securities to be held is greater than $1,009.8 million

    50% if value of voting securities to be held
    is greater than $50 million

    50% if value of voting securities to be held is greater than $101 million

     

    Any subsequent acquisition would be subject to the adjusted thresholds in effect when such subsequent acquisition is consummated.

    On Jan. 10, 2022, the FTC announced that the maximum civil penalty for violation of the HSR Act reporting requirements has been increased from $43,792 to $46,517 per day.

    Authored by Peter Jonathan Halasz and Gregory L. Kinzelman

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2022 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Peter Jonathan Halasz

    Of Counsel

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Distressed M&A – Quo vadis?

    ARTICLE

    Distressed M&A – Quo vadis?

    January 21, 2022

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The distressed M&A market on its way to an exciting future! An article by Dr. Uwe Goetker.

    In depth
    Authors

    Dr. Uwe Goetker

    Partner

    Düsseldorf

    More insights

  • Third-Party Releases Under Continued Fire in Ascena Retail Group Ruling

    Third-Party Releases Under Continued Fire in Ascena Retail Group Ruling

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Third-Party Releases Under Continued Fire in Ascena Retail Group Ruling

    January 21, 2022

    Read time: 9 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    For the second time in four weeks, a U.S. District Court has questioned the authority of bankruptcy courts to issue non-consensual third-party releases as part of a plan of reorganization. On Jan. 13, 2022, the Eastern District of Virginia vacated the confirmation order in the Mahwah Bergen Retail Group, Inc. (f/k/a Ascena Retail Group, Inc.) chapter 11 cases on the grounds that the plan contained impermissible non-consensual third-party releases. Patterson, et al. v. Mahwah Bergen Retail Group, Inc., Civ. No. 3:21cv167 (DJN) (E.D. Va. Jan. 13, 2022). The court attributed its ruling, in part, to the fact that the “ubiquity of third-party releases in the Richmond Division demands even greater scrutiny of the propriety of such releases.” 

    The Mahwah Bergen holding follows shortly after Southern District of New York Judge Colleen McMahon reversed confirmation of Purdue Pharma’s plan of reorganization due to its inclusion of non-consensual third-party releases.

    The Purdue Pharma holding found that third-party releases are not permissible under the Bankruptcy Code at all. Mahwah Bergen, in line with applicable Fourth Circuit precedent, does not ban third-party releases, but it imposes stringent limitations on their availability. The decision holds that third-party releases should be granted only “cautiously and infrequently” and sets up an onerous process for their consideration and approval, which may make many third-party releases practically unavailable, particularly if a plan seeks to release non-core claims.

    Summary

    Ascena Retail Group was a publicly held retailer of apparel for women and girls that filed for bankruptcy in 2020. Ascena owned brands such as Ann Taylor, LOFT, Lane Bryant and Lou & Grey. The Debtors liquidated their assets through a series of sales. The Debtors then proposed a plan that provided for the distribution of the remaining cash in the estate and the Bankruptcy Court confirmed the plan. 

    The Plan included broad third-party releases, covering any type of claim that existed or could have been brought against anyone associated with the Debtors as of the effective date of the plan, including a securities fraud class action lawsuit that was pending against certain prepetition executives of Ascena. The releases bound anyone that did not affirmatively “opt out” of such releases. 

    Due to the ability of parties to opt out of the third-party releases, the Bankruptcy Court treated the releases as consensual and conducted little to no analysis of (i) whether it had the Constitutional power to grant the releases (non-consensually); (ii) the nature of the claims being released and whether the claims were core or non-core; (iii) whether notice of the right to opt out was actually received by the releasing parties (of which the District Court estimated there may have been thousands); and (iv) whether the releases were permissible under the standard set forth in Behrmann v. Nat’l Heritage Found., 663 F.3d 704, 712 (4th Cir. 2011), the Fourth Circuit’s binding precedent on third-party releases.

    The U.S. Trustee appealed the confirmation of the plan and challenged the legality of the plan’s third-party releases and exculpation provisions, arguing that the Bankruptcy Court erred in the manner it conducted the plan’s approval process and in approving the releases. The District Court agreed with the U.S. Trustee and vacated the confirmation order, remanding the case to a Bankruptcy Judge outside of the Richmond Division. The District Court ordered the new court to redraft the exculpation provisions and then confirm the Plan without the third-party releases, which the District Court found to be severable from the remainder of the Plan.

    The District Court’s holding creates a two-pronged process for review of third-party releases.

    • First, the content of any proposed third-party releases must be analyzed to determine whether they have any relationship with or effect on the bankruptcy proceeding. As per the Supreme Court ruling in Stern v. Marshall, 546 U.S. 462 (2011), if they do not, then they are non-core issues over which the Bankruptcy Court lacks the Constitutional authority to issue a final order, unless the parties involved consent to the jurisdiction of the Bankruptcy Court over such claims.
      • The District Court held that a party’s failure to opt out of a third-party release does not constitute knowing and voluntary consent to the Bankruptcy Court’s jurisdiction over a non-core claim (or to the release of the claim itself). As such, without consent by action (as opposed to by inaction), a bankruptcy court will not have jurisdiction over non-core claims. Non-core releases approved by the Bankruptcy Court over which the bankruptcy court does not have jurisdiction will be treated as an advisory opinion subject to de novo review by a District Court.
    • Second, whether a third-party release relates to a core or non-core claim, if the release is non-consensual, then its permissibility must be determined using the seven-factor analysis set forth in the Fourth Circuit’s Behrmann ruling, which requires consideration of factors such as whether there is an identity of interests between the debtor and the released third parties, whether the released third parties are making a substantial contribution to the reorganization, whether the releases are essential to the reorganization, whether the class or classes of claims or interests affected by the releases have voted in favor of the plan and will be substantially paid under the plan.

    In applying this test to the facts in Mahwah Bergen, the District Court rejected the Debtors’ argument that Constitutional authority to grant the third-party releases stemmed from the inclusion of the releases in the Plan. The District Court held that “jurisdiction over confirmation proceedings [does not] cure[] any jurisdictional defects within those proceedings … . Article III simply does not allow third-party non-debtors to bootstrap any and all of their disputes into a bankruptcy case to obtain relief.” 

    The District Court further rejected the Bankruptcy Court’s holding that the releases were consensual because parties had the ability to opt out of them. As such, the District Court treated the third-party releases as non-core and non-consensual, thereby depriving the Bankruptcy Court of the authority to grant them. Accordingly, the District Court reviewed the confirmation order de novo as a Report and Recommendation with proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law. In conducting its review, the District Court noted that the Bankruptcy Court did not conduct the Behrmann analysis, but that if it had, there was ample evidence to support the rejection of the third-party releases.

    In response to the District Court’s decision, the Debtors announced that, although they disagreed with portions of the District Court’s opinion, they would seek reconfirmation of the Plan without the third-party releases in accordance with the decision. As a result, we do not expect the Mahwah Bergen opinion to be appealed.

    Practical Considerations

    In recent months, courts have asserted clear push-back on third-party releases, after years of uncertainty. This case represents another potential blow against the long-used bankruptcy tool. At least within the Eastern District of Virginia, there are several takeaways from this decision for debtors, creditors and other estate constituents to note:

    • While this case does not outright eliminate third-party releases, it imposes a significant barrier to their implementation. The need for a Bankruptcy Court to determine whether every claim released by third-party releases is a core or non-core claim will require that a debtor specifically identify each claim to be released and provide an explanation of how the claim relates to the bankruptcy case. And, the Bankruptcy Court will be required to conduct a full Behrmann analysis for non-consensual third-party releases (and consent cannot be obtained by a failure to opt out). In the face of these evidentiary burdens, debtors may well be forced to more narrowly tailor any third-party releases contained in a plan.
    • Narrowly tailored and specifically articulated release provisions will also allow a Bankruptcy Court to parse the requested releases and approve those that are permissible under Behrmann. In Mahwah Bergen, the Debtors drafted the releases in a vague and general manner such that the Bankruptcy Court could neither identify nor analyze each of the claims to be released. As a result, the District Court summarily rejected all of the third-party releases, including any that may have been permissible had they been specifically identified and subjected to the analysis set forth above. Parties seeking to obtain permissible third-party releases in a plan should ensure that the released claims are specifically identified in the plan so that they can be considered individually, rather than having the Bankruptcy Court approve or reject the releases as a whole.
    • Parties seeking an expeditious confirmation process should note that the inclusion of third-party releases of non-consensual, non-core claims in a plan will mean that the plan cannot be confirmed until after a District Court review of the Bankruptcy Court’s order. This will extend the amount of time needed to confirm a plan. Parties could require that the plan not include any releases of non-consensual, non-core claims to avoid the risk of undue delay in the confirmation process. However, this could reduce the post-confirmation protection for those parties.

    Authored by Adam C. Harris, Douglas S. Mintz, Abbey Walsh and Bucky Knight.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2022 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Adam C. Harris

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • New Attribution Requirement Denies Foreign Tax Credits for Certain Withholding Taxes (And Other Taxes)

    New Attribution Requirement Denies Foreign Tax Credits for Certain Withholding Taxes (And Other Taxes)

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    New Attribution Requirement Denies Foreign Tax Credits for Certain Withholding Taxes (And Other Taxes)

    January 20, 2022

    Read time: 16 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On January 4, 2022, the US Department of the Treasury (Treasury) and the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) issued final regulations (Final Regulations) that deny a foreign tax credit (FTC) for certain foreign withholding taxes and other taxes that have been creditable for as long as Section 901 has been in the Internal Revenue Code (Code). In particular, the Final Regulations adopt a new “attribution requirement” (Attribution Requirement) that restricts the availability of FTCs to foreign taxes that the Treasury and the IRS consider to be similar to US taxes.

    In depth

    Although these rules were previewed in 2020 proposed regulations that were intended to limit the creditability of certain “novel extraterritorial taxes” like gross-basis digital services taxes (DSTs), many observers expected that the Final Regulations would pare back the scope of the proposed regulations so as not to deny FTCs for withholding taxes commonly imposed around the world on royalties and service fees. To the surprise of many, the Treasury and the IRS held to the aggressively broad scope of the proposed regulations in the Final Regulations. As a result, taxpayers are now faced with cataloging the various foreign taxes for which they have claimed an FTC and determining whether an FTC will be available under the Final Regulations.

    Beyond the new Attribution Requirement, the Final Regulations include a wide range of other modifications to the rules governing whether a particular foreign tax is eligible for an FTC under Section 901 or 903. Changes to Treas. Reg. § 1.901-2 generally limit the extent to which foreign taxes may employ deeming mechanisms and allowances to approximate a net income tax base, abandoning the standard of prior case law and regulations that a foreign tax need merely have the “predominant character” of an income tax in the US sense. The changes to Treas. Reg. § 1.903-1 generally limit the circumstances in which a foreign tax that is not an income tax may be eligible for a credit under Section 903 as a tax imposed “in lieu of” an income tax, demanding taxpayers to establish a “close connection” between the exemption of certain receipts from the income tax base and the imposition of the non-income tax on those receipts. While these are significant changes to longstanding regulations, this article focuses specifically on the Attribution Requirement.

    The rules adopting the Final Regulations’ Attribution Requirement are generally applicable for taxable years beginning on or after December 28, 2021.

    THE ATTRIBUTION REQUIREMENT FOR INCOME TAXES

    Under prior Treas. Reg. 1.902-2, that finalized in 1983 (Prior Regulations), a foreign levy was considered an income tax if “the predominant character of that tax is that of an income tax in the U.S. sense.” A foreign tax was considered to have the predominant character of an income tax in the US sense if it was likely “to reach net gain in the ordinary circumstances in which it applies.” This meant a tax must satisfy three requirements:

    1. It is imposed upon certain realization events or pre-realization events (Realization Requirement).
    2. It is imposed on the basis of gross receipts or a measure of deemed gross receipts that is not likely to exceed actual gross receipts (Gross Receipts Requirement).
    3. It allows the recovery of significant costs attributable to the gross receipts or a measure of significant costs that is likely to approximate actual costs (Net Income Requirement).

    If a tax satisfied these conditions, it was creditable under the Prior Regulations. There was no other requirement that a foreign tax resemble a specific US tax.

    The Final Regulations retain the Realization, Gross Receipts and Net Income Requirements, albeit in a more stringent form, and add the new Attribution Requirement.[1] The Attribution Requirement takes a different form when applied to a tax on residents of the country imposing the tax, as compared to a tax on nonresidents.

    For a tax imposed on a resident of the country imposing the tax, the Attribution Requirement requires that allocations of income among related parties to the taxpayer (i.e., the country’s transfer pricing rules) must be determined under arm’s length principles. For the avoidance of doubt, the Final Regulations specify that allocations of income under the foreign tax must not “tak[e] into account as a significant factor the location of customers, users, or any other destination-based criteria.”[2]

    For a tax on a nonresident of the country imposing the tax, the Attribution Requirement generally provides that attribute gross receipts and costs must be attributed based on one of three principles—activities, source or the situs of property—and must satisfy one of the following conditions:

    1. Attribution based on activities. A foreign tax imposed on the basis of a nonresident’s activities must be limited to the gross receipts and costs that are attributable, “under reasonable principles,” to the nonresident’s activities within the foreign country imposing the tax.[3] Attribution based on reasonable principles includes attribution based on the nonresident’s functions, assets and risks located in the country, such as provided for under the Section 864(c) rules (ECI rules) for determining income effectively connected with a US trade or business. The Final Regulations specifically exclude foreign rules that consider the location of customers, users or similar destination-based criteria or the location of a supplier. They also exclude foreign rules that deem a permanent establishment, or attribute gross receipts or costs, based on the activities of a person other than the nonresident (besides an agent).
    2. Attribution based on source. A foreign tax imposed on a nonresident based on a source rule must be limited to gross income arising from sources within the foreign country that imposes the tax. The sourcing rules of the foreign tax law must also be “reasonably similar” to the sourcing rules of the Code.[4] When evaluating whether a foreign law source rule is reasonably similar to the rules that apply under the Code, the character of an item of gross income generally is determined under foreign law. For example, if a payment would be characterized as a service under US principles but as a royalty under foreign law, then to satisfy the Attribution Requirement, the foreign law source rule for royalties must be similar to the US source rule for royalties. Perhaps in recognition that the sourcing of service fees and royalties is not always perfectly clear under the source rules of Sections 861 to 865, the Final Regulations provide additional guidance on the conditions under which a source-based tax on such payments can satisfy the Attribution Requirement.[5] For services, the payment source must be determined based on where the services are performed, as determined under reasonable principles. The Final Regulations expressly state that reasonable principles do not include determining the place of performance based on the location of the service recipient. For royalties, the source of the payment must be determined based on the place of use of, or the right to use, the licensed intangible property.
    3. Attribution based on situs of property. A foreign tax based on gains of nonresidents from the sale or disposition of property, including stock or partnership interests, generally must only apply in cases where US law would tax a nonresident’s capital gains.[6] For a tax imposed on gains from the disposition of real property, the foreign law generally must only apply in circumstances analogous to those in which the Foreign Investment in Real Property Tax Act (FIRPTA) rules of Section 897 apply. For a tax imposed on gains from the disposition of property other than real property, the base may only include gross receipts that are attributable to property forming part of the business property of a taxable presence in the foreign country under rules reasonably similar to the ECI rules of Section 864(c).

    The Final Regulations provide that gross receipts from property sales must be included in the foreign tax base on the basis of the situs of the property or based on the nonresident’s in-country activities (as described above), rather than under a source rule.[7] Additionally, a transaction that is treated as a sale of copyrighted articles for US purposes can only satisfy the attribution requirement if the transaction is treated for foreign law purposes as a sale of tangible property and not as a license of intangible property (IP). This rule effectively overrides the general rule above that in the case of a source-based tax, foreign law controls the determination of character of gross income.

    THE ATTRIBUTION REQUIREMENT FOR SECTION 903 TAXES—INCLUDING WITHHOLDING TAXES

    Although the new Attribution Requirement is located in the Section 901 regulations, which apply for determining whether a foreign levy is an income tax, the Final Regulations include important changes to Treas. Reg. 1.903-1 that incorporate aspects of the Attribution Requirement into the Section 903 regulations for determining creditability of certain non-income taxes.

    Regarding whether a foreign levy qualifies as a tax imposed “in lieu of” an income tax, the Final Regulations provide that the general income tax which the foreign levy is imposed in substitution for must meet the Attribution Requirement. This rule prevents a jurisdiction from actually, or theoretically, expanding the reach of its general income tax beyond the scope reflected in US rules and then imposing a non-income tax purportedly in lieu of the broadly-scoped income tax. It appears to be aimed at an excise tax adopted by Puerto Rico in 2011 that applies in lieu of an expansion of the jurisdictional reach of the income tax that was adopted at the same time.[8]

    The Final Regulations contain special rules governing the circumstances under which a “covered withholding tax” is creditable under Section 903. In addition to being imposed on a nonresident and not overlapping in scope with the general income tax, the withholding tax must satisfy the conditions of the Attribution Requirement for a source-based tax. Meaning, the withholding tax must be imposed on the basis of a source rule rather than on the basis that it is an outbound payment (i.e., from resident to nonresident). The source rule must also be “reasonably similar” to the US source rule for a payment of the same character, as such character is determined under foreign law.

    RELIEF FOR TAXES COVERED BY A US TAX TREATY (BUT NOT CFC-PAID TAXES)

    Fortunately, the Attribution Requirement does not apply where a tax is directly paid by a US resident and is treated as an income tax under an applicable US income tax treaty.[9] To confirm that a particular foreign tax is creditable under a treaty, it’s important to determine whether that tax is a covered tax under the treaty, which may be a question of if the tax is imposed based on a law adopted or modified after the treaty was signed. Generally, a covered tax under a treaty is a tax that was in existence at the time the treaty was signed or a later-adopted tax that is “identical or substantially similar” to such pre-existing taxes.

    In the case of a tax paid by a controlled foreign corporation and deemed paid by a US shareholder under Section 960, no relief from the Attribution Requirement would be available under a treaty. For purposes of determining whether the Attribution Requirement is satisfied with respect to such a tax, however, any modifications to the foreign tax pursuant to a treaty between the country imposing the tax and another foreign country would be considered.

    Based on the Treasury’s general policy of limiting creditable taxes under a treaty to those that are creditable under the Code, it may be expected that in future treaty negotiations, the Treasury will seek to limit the scope of covered taxes to those that would satisfy the Attribution Requirement.

    FOREIGN TAXES FOR WHICH FTCS COULD BE DENIED UNDER THE FINAL REGULATIONS

    As noted above, although the Treasury and the IRS cited “novel extraterritorial taxes,” and particularly DSTs, as the motivation for modifying the Prior Regulations, the Final Regulations potentially apply to a significantly broader range of foreign taxes. Many common foreign withholding taxes—the creditability of which had never previously been in doubt—apparently would no longer be the basis for a claim of an FTC. Foreign taxes, both novel and run-of-the-mill, potentially affected by the Final Regulations include the following:

    • Royalty withholding taxes. In order for a withholding tax on what foreign law regards as a royalty payment (other than a payment for what US law regards as a sale of a copyrighted article) to satisfy the Attribution Requirement, withholding must be limited to royalties for the use of IP in that foreign country. This requirement seems to exclude the wide variety of royalty withholding taxes that countries impose, based on a residence principle, on any outbound payment.

    A pair of examples in the regulations reveal the Treasury’s intent for the Attribution Requirement to apply broadly in the case of royalty withholding taxes. The examples conclude that a withholding tax on a royalty paid for the use of IP does not employ a source rule reasonably similar to US source rules, and would not meet the Attribution Requirement, in a case where the country requires withholding on all royalties paid by a resident to a nonresident.[10]

    Because the Final Regulations only require that a foreign source rule be “reasonably similar” to US source rules—and because the location of IP use is not always clear under US law (particularly in the case of patents or manufacturing IP)—there should be some leeway for foreign law to employ different principles to determine the location where IP is used and still satisfy the “reasonably similar” requirement.

    • Service payment withholding taxes. Like royalty withholding taxes, withholding taxes imposed on service payments—including commonly used withholding taxes on fees for technical services—may not satisfy the Attribution Requirement. If imposed on a source basis, such withholding taxes would need to apply only to payments for services performed in-country and not based on the location of the service recipient. If any outbound service payment (for services of a specific kind, like technical services) would be subject to withholding based on a residence principle, the withholding tax may not satisfy the Attribution Requirement regardless of whether the nonresident performs services in-country. This treatment of service payment withholding taxes clearly reverses the result under the Prior Regulations, which included an example (now removed) explicitly concluding that a residence-based withholding tax on payments for technical services was creditable under Section 903.[11]
    • Capital gains taxes on share disposal. Taxes imposed by a country on a nonresident’s disposal of shares in a company organized in that country, or on the disposal of shares in an upper tier holding company directly or indirectly owning that company, may not satisfy the Attribution Requirement. To do so, any such capital gains tax generally would need to be imposed only in situations FIRPTA would tax a nonresident on disposal of shares of a real estate holding company.
    • Taxes on sales of copyrighted articles. A tax imposed by a country on the sale of a copyrighted article (g., software, whether or not digitally delivered) by a nonresident may not satisfy the Attribution Requirement if—as is the case in certain jurisdictions—the foreign country imposes the tax without regard to whether the nonresident has activities or a physical presence in the country.
    • Digital services taxes. Depending on the specifics of foreign law, a DST potentially may be analyzed as an income tax or an “in lieu of” tax. The Treasury considered both possibilities in the Final Regulations and included examples illustrating how various flavors of a DST would fail to satisfy the Attribution Requirement because the hypothetical tax does not satisfy the requirements for attributing gross income based on activities, source or the situs or property, as applicable.[12]
    • Diverted profits taxes. “Diverted profits taxes” (DPTs), such as those adopted by the United Kingdom and Australia, were explicit targets of the Final Regulations along with DSTs and unsurprisingly may fail the Attribution Requirement. DPTs generally apply in different ways to residents and nonresidents of the levying country. A DPT imposed on a resident of the country may fail the requirement that transactions with related parties are priced in a manner consistent with the arm’s length principle. A DPT imposed on a nonresident may fail the requirement that any activities-based principle for attribution of gross receipts be based on the nonresident’s activities within the foreign country.
    • OECD Pillar 1 and 2 taxes. Measures for taxing “Amount A” under a country’s rules implementing Pillar 1 of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) BEPS 2.0 project would employ a destination-basis principle to reallocate to a country income that, under the arm’s length principle, was properly allocated to another country. Such a tax would be problematic under the Attribution Requirement, which requires taxes on a nonresident to be applied consistent with the arm’s length principle.

    Under the Pillar 2 “undertaxed payment rule” (UTPR), a country would deny deductions or impose other adjustments to the income of a taxpayer that is a member of a multinational group with affiliates that have effective tax rates below 15%. Taxes paid under a UTPR also may fail the Attribution Requirement, assuming the UTPR is treated as a separate levy.

    Although the preambles to the Prior Regulations and the Final Regulations indicate that the Treasury and the IRS may revisit the application of the Final Regulations in the event a new international consensus is reached through the OECD, whether the United States will adopt Pillar 1 or fully comply with Pillar 2 remains to be seen, leaving open the possibility that the Final Regulations would not be amended to accommodate foreign taxes agreed on as part of BEPS 2.0.

    CONCLUSION

    The Final Regulations potentially disallow FTCs for foreign withholding taxes that have long been eligible for one, as well as the “novel extraterritorial taxes” explicitly targeted by the Treasury and the IRS. As such, taxpayers may need to survey the foreign taxes they currently incur around the world and consider whether these taxes satisfy the Attribution Requirement. In making this determination, it may be necessary to seek the advice of foreign counsel in order to understand the basis under foreign law for the imposition of the tax. If it is determined that a particular foreign tax is not eligible for an FTC under the Final Regulations, taxpayers may wish to consider alternative structures that could alter the particular mix of foreign taxes that apply with respect to their commercial engagement in a country.


    [1] The Net Income Requirement is redesignated as the “cost recovery requirement.”

    [2] Treas. Reg. § 1.901-2(b)(5)(ii).

    [3] Treas. Reg. § 1.901-2(b)(5)(i)(A).

    [4] Treas. Reg. § 1.901-2(b)(5)(i)(B).

    [5] Treas. Reg. § 1.901-2(b)(5)(i)(B)(1) and (2).

    [6] Treas. Reg. § 1.901-2(b)(5)(i)(C).

    [7] Treas. Reg. § 1.901-2(b)(5)(i)(B)(3).

    [8] The Final Regulations have a delayed applicability date with respect to the Puerto Rico tax, applying only for tax years beginning on or after January 1, 2023.

    [9] Treas. Reg. § 1.901-2(a)(1)(iii).

    [10] Treas. Reg. § 1.903-1(d), Ex. 3 and 4.

    [11] Prior Treas. Reg. § 1.903-1, Ex. 3.

    [12] Treas. Reg. § 1.901-2(b)(5)(iii), Ex. 1 and 2; Treas. Reg. § 1.901-3(d), Ex. 1 and 2.

    Authors

    Brian H. Jenn

    Partner

    Washington, DC, Chicago

    More insights

  • Accident Between Bedroom and Home Office Workplace – Is Insurance Coverage Available?

    ARTICLE

    Accident Between Bedroom and Home Office Workplace – Is Insurance Coverage Available?

    January 19, 2022

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    One of the biggest advantages of a home office is the reduction of commuting time. Most employees will not have a particularly long way to travel from their bedrooms to the office or workplace. Nevertheless, some people will have wondered whether they are covered by accident insurance if they suffer injuries on the way. In a departure from its previous case law, the Federal Social Court (BSG) has corrected the State Social Court (LSG) and provided clarity.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • We Have Not Yet Reached Our Goal at ESG!

    ARTICLE

    We Have Not Yet Reached Our Goal at ESG!

    January 10, 2022

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The current ESG regulation is complex, comprehensive and comes into force in stages. Where are we in this process? Frank Müller with an article on the new ESG requirements for investors and what asset managers, fund initiators and investors have to prepare for.

    In depth
    Authors

    Frank Müller

    Partner

    Frankfurt

    More insights