Content Type: Article

  • Mobility@McDermott: Recent legal developments in the mobility sector (06/2023)

    Mobility@McDermott: Recent legal developments in the mobility sector (06/2023)

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Mobility@McDermott: Recent legal developments in the mobility sector (06/2023)

    July 3, 2023

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    1. Antitrust: European Commission adopts new Horizontal Block Exemption Regulations and Horizontal Guidelines

    On 01 July 2023, two revised Horizontal Block Exemption Regulations (“HBER”) will enter into force. The European Commission adopted revised HBER on Research and Development and Specialisation Agreements and updated their Guidelines on Horizontal Cooperation that will provide businesses with clearer and up-to-date guidance to help them assess the compatibility of their horizontal cooperation agreements with EU competition rules.

    The HBERs exempt research and development and specialisation agreements from the prohibition in Article 101(1) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (“TFEU’”, subject to certain conditions, most important of which is that the agreements do not include so-called “hardcore” restrictions. Hardcore restrictions include, amongst others, limiting activities outside the scope of the agreements, limitation of output or sales (with exceptions) or the restriction of territories (again with exceptions). Insofar as no hardcore restrictions are included, as a consequence, certain agreements are block exempted from the competition rules.

    The new Guidelines on Horizontal Cooperation are broader in scope and provide guidance on a whole host of agreements between competitors. The Guidelines, amongst others, now provide a more detailed explanation of joint purchasing, differentiating permissible joint purchasing from buyer cartels. The Guidelines now also provide a degree of clarity on when joint bidding in response to RFQs may be permissible.

    Click here for further details
    Relevant for: Manufacturers

    2. European Parliament positions itself on the CSDDD

    Work on the EU Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (“CSDDD” or “CS3D”) continues to make progress. On June 2, the European Parliament voted on its negotiating position on the CSDDD.

    The CSDDD aims to provide legal certainty by introducing mandatory due diligence legislation at EU level to hold EU companies and non-EU companies operating in the EU accountable for potential risks to human rights and the environment in their global value chains. Company directors would be required to establish and oversee the implementation of appropriate due diligence structures and to integrate them into the corporate strategy.

    In Germany, the Supply Chain Due Diligence Act (Lieferkettensorgfaltspflichtengesetz) entered into force on 1 January 2023. The proposed scope of the CSDDD would go substantially beyond the current legislation. In particular, it would provide for civil law liability of companies and include comprehensive requirements on its strategy for complying with the due diligence obligations imposed, which extend to the entire value and supply chain.

    Click here for further details
    Relevant for: Manufacturers

    3. European Parliament adopts new regulation to regulate battery industry

    On June 14, the European Parliament approved new rules for batteries sold in the EU – ranging from design and production all the way to waste management. The aim of the regulation is to enable and control a more intensive circular economy of batteries to promote a more efficient and sustainable use of resources, i.a. by increasing recycling efficiency and material recovery.

    The regulation applies to, inter alia, electric vehicle batteries and batteries used in e-bikes and e-scooters. It addresses several issues that the market regarded as hindrances regarding the development of a more successful second life market for batteries, including by means of enabling better access to data regarding the state of health and expected lifetime of the batteries for the user and third parties (by, inter alia establishing a battery passport) as well as clarifying the obligations/liabilities of manufacturers and third parties that repurpose old batteries at the end of the first lifecycle.

    Next, the Council will have to formally endorse the text before it can be published and enter into force.

    Click here for further details
    Relevant for: Manufacturers, service provider in connection with second life batteries

    4. The Council of the European Union and the European Parliament reach a provisional agreement on the Data Act

    On June 27, the Council of the European Union and the European Parliament negotiators reached a provisional agreement on new rules for fair access and use of data laid down in the draft Data Act.

    One of the main purposes of the coming Data Act is to create a framework allowing users of “connected devices” to gain access to data generated by their use including visual or audio recordings. Connected devices also cover a wide range of IoT devices going from health devices, virtual assistants to connected vehicles.

    Under such circumstances, OEMs such as car manufacturers will be subject to a large set of new obligations requiring to design and manufacture products in a manner that enables easy access to data from users. Other stakeholders like data holders (which, under the latest version of the draft Data Act, refer to legal or natural persons which have the right or obligation to use or make data available) fall also within the scope of the coming regulation. In other words, even car dealers will have to share data with certain third parties to provide them with aftermarket or other data-driven innovative services.

    The provisional agreement will soon be endorsed and adopted by the Council and the European Parliament.

    Relevant for: Manufacturers

    5. Court judgment: Repossession of rental car without court title illegal

    The Higher Regional Court of Frankfurt/Main (Oberlandesgericht Frankfurt/Main, “OLG”) ruled on 25 May 2023 (2 U 165/21) that despite various provisions in the rental agreement (Mietvertrag) intended to achieve the contrary, the lessor of a vehicle does not have the right to repossess the rented vehicle from the lessee without the lessee’s consent, even after termination of the rental agreement, e.g. because the lessee has not paid the rental fees.

    The OLG ruled that the provisions of the general terms and conditions in the case at hand which aimed to allow recovery of the vehicle, were invalid. Therefore, the taking of the car constituted a prohibited interference with possession (verbotene Eigenmacht) pursuant to sec. 858 of the German Civil Code. The court ruled that the lessee was entitled to compensation for the period during which they were unable to use the vehicle.

    Instead of repossessing the vehicle, the lessor would have had to obtain a court title to recover the vehicle and then have it enforced by a court bailiff.

    Click here for court judgment (available only in German)
    Relevant for: Subscription and mobility providers; finance providers.

    6. German court submits question on public procurement law to European court of justice

    A dispute over electric vehicle charging stations for electric vehicles located on German highway service stations is headed to European Court of Justice.

    The formerly state-owned company Tank & Rast holds a concession for 90 percent of the rest areas and service stations along Germany’s Autobahnen. Recently, the concession was extended to include the construction and operation of EV charging stations without an award procedure.

    Following a complaint by competitors of Tank & Rast sued, the Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf (Oberlandesgericht Düsseldorf) has now referred key legal aspects of the case to the Court of Justice of the European Union. Depending on the outcome of the court’s decision, competitors may try to gain a foothold in this attractive market.

    Click here for further details (available only in German)
    Relevant for: Manufacturers, subscription and mobility providers

    In depth
    Authors

    Max Küttner

    Associate

    Düsseldorf

    More insights

  • Congress Cracks Down on Sales of Stolen and Counterfeit Goods

    Congress Cracks Down on Sales of Stolen and Counterfeit Goods

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Congress Cracks Down on Sales of Stolen and Counterfeit Goods

    June 30, 2023

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The requirements of the INFORM Consumers Act went into effect on June 27, 2023. The following includes need-to-know information for sellers, businesses that serve as an online platform for third-party sellers and customers purchasing goods on these marketplaces.[1]

    By way of background, on December 29, 2022, Congress passed H.R. 2617, the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2023, the omnibus spending bill funding the federal government. The bill included the “Integrity, Notification, and Fairness in Online Retail Marketplaces for Consumers Act,” otherwise known as the INFORM Consumers Act. The act is intended to combat the online sale of stolen, counterfeit and dangerous products.[2]  It requires online marketplaces that serve as a platform for third-party sellers to collect, verify and disclose certain information from high-volume third-party sellers; failing to do so carries steep consequences.

    In depth

    WHO IS A HIGH-VOLUME THIRD-PARTY SELLER?

    The INFORM Consumers Act defines a high-volume third-party seller as a participant in an online marketplace that conducts at least 200 discrete sales or transactions of new or unused products, resulting in at least $5,000 in total revenues during any continuous 12-month period over the previous 24 months.

    RESPONSIBILITIES FOR ONLINE MARKETPLACES

    The INFORM Consumers Act places much of the responsibility on the online marketplaces on which high-volume third-party sellers sell their consumer goods. However, many of those responsibilities impose requirements on sellers themselves. Online marketplaces are defined as any person or entity that operates a consumer-directed electronically based or accessed platform that is used by one or more third-party seller(s) and facilitates those sellers to engage in the sale of consumer goods. The requirements for these online marketplaces include:

    • Data collection. Within 10 days of a seller qualifying as a high-volume third-party seller, the online marketplace must require the seller to provide their (1) bank account number or name of the person paid by the marketplace for the transactions, (2) the contact information for the seller (if an individual, their name; if a business, its name, physical address, and government-issued record or tax document), (3) tax ID, and (4) working email and phone number. If the seller does not provide this information within 10 days, the online marketplace must suspend the seller.
    • Data verification. Within 10 days of receipt of the above information, the online marketplace must verify the information. The act provides that government-issued tax documents are presumptively verified, but it does not provide for such presumptions for all other documentation and information.
    • Data security. Marketplaces must implement reasonable security procedures and practices to protect the data the act requires them to collect and maintain. Furthermore, marketplaces cannot use the data collected for purposes of compliance with the act for any other purposes other than those required by the act.
    • Ongoing compliance. At least annually, the online marketplace must provide notice to high-volume third-party sellers that such sellers have a requirement to keep the above information accurate. The online marketplaces then have 10 days to certify that the high-volume third-party sellers provided changes to their required information disclosures or that there have been no new changes. If the seller doesn’t provide the certification within 10 days, the online marketplace must suspend the seller.
    • Information disclosures to consumers for large sellers. For high-volume third-party sellers that have a gross revenue of at least $20,000 on an online marketplace, that marketplace must provide to consumers the seller’s full name, physical address and contact information (a current working phone number, email address or other means of direct electronic messaging). Exceptions exist where the address of the seller is residential, in which case the marketplace may disclose only the state and country of residence of the seller. Additionally, for sellers with at least $20,000 of revenue, the marketplace must disclose whether the seller used a different seller to supply the consumer the product upon purchase, and, upon request by the purchaser, must provide this other seller’s full name, physical address and contact information.
    • Consumer reporting. Marketplaces must incorporate a “clear and conspicuous” reporting mechanism on each product listing posted by a high-volume third-party seller.

    ENFORCEMENT OF THE INFORM CONSUMERS ACT

    The INFORM Consumers Act has two methods of enforcement. These enforcement mechanisms are potent and present substantial liability for online marketplaces and third-party sellers that violate the act.

    First, the act treats violations as unfair and deceptive trade practices under the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) Act section 18(a)(1)(B). This means that each violation is subject to, among other things, a civil penalty of $46,517 per violation in an enforcement action brought by the FTC. Second, the act permits state attorneys general to bring civil actions to enjoin further violations, enforce compliance, obtain civil penalties, obtain state law remedies, and obtain compensation and damages on behalf of state residents.

    These consequences make it imperative for all affected parties to ensure they understand and implement these new requirements. If you have additional questions about the INFORM Consumers Act, please contact your regular McDermott lawyer or one of the authors.

    Royce Brosseau, a summer associate in the Washington, DC, office, also contributed to this article.

    Authors
    More insights

  • FTC Releases Proposed Changes to Premerger Notification Form and Process

    FTC Releases Proposed Changes to Premerger Notification Form and Process

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    FTC Releases Proposed Changes to Premerger Notification Form and Process

    June 29, 2023

    Read time: 10 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has proposed, for comment, significant changes to the information and documents to be submitted with premerger filings—even in transactions that do not raise significant antitrust issues. The changes proposed may not take effect and may be different when finalized. But if promulgated as proposed, every Hart-Scott-Rodino (HSR) filing will be more difficult and time-consuming, and transactions that might raise even marginal antitrust issues will require significant up-front work. We summarize below the most significant proposed changes and actions to take now to prepare for the changes if they are issued as proposed.

    In depth

    WHAT HAPPENED

    The FTC published proposed rules that, if promulgated as proposed, will extensively—and fundamentally—alter the HSR Antitrust Improvements Act filing regime. The proposed rules will create a more burdensome, intrusive filing system, which will add significant cost and time to M&A reviews.

    As part of the initial filing for every transaction, the proposed rules will require information and document production that the FTC previously would have sought only if it chose to open a preliminary investigation and issue a voluntary request letter or similar request, or to issue a second request. Parties will also need to make strategic decisions about product markets and present written responses and advocacy on core competitive issues as part of their initial filings.

    The proposed rules were published in the Federal Register on June 29, 2023, triggering a 60-day comment period. The FTC will consider any comments and can then publish final rules. We expect that a new filing regime may begin in 2024.

    CHANGES PROPOSED IN THE FTC RULES 

    The proposed rules and explanations are more than 130 pages long. Here, we set out a roadmap to guide you through the most important points:

    • Filings cannot commence on a simple letter of intent (LOI). To file on a LOI, parties will also need to submit a well-developed draft agreement or a detailed term sheet specifying key aspects of the transaction.
    • Narrative responses and advocacy will be required as part of the initial filing, even if there is no product overlap. Parties will need to provide:
      • A detailed written description of all rationales for the transaction.
      • A detailed timeline for the transaction.
      • Written descriptions of all existing business relationships between the parties, such as supply arrangements.
      • A detailed narrative analysis of competition, identifying product overlaps, sales data, top customers and contact information.
    • More deal documents will need to be submitted. The traditional Item 4(c)/4(d) materials required for filings still must be submitted, but the proposed rules will require more materials from more individuals, including:
      • Key transaction documents from supervisory deal team leaders (e.g., the corporate development staff), even if those materials were not provided to officers or directors.
      • Drafts of any responsive final documents prepared by or for an officer, director or supervisory deal team leader(s).
      • A broader range of transaction-related agreements between the parties or with any employees or third parties, as well as all schedules.
    • Ordinary course of business and strategic plans will need to be submitted with the initial filing. If there is any competitive overlap between the buyer and the target (no matter how small the overlap is, or the size of the two parties in that field), a party must assemble and submit one year’s worth of key, regularly prepared documents seen by the CEO, other key executives or board of directors.
    • Parties will need to implement document-preservation steps prior to making a filing. The proposed rule requires parties to identify the communications and messaging systems they use in their business, including “internal chat technologies” or “ephemeral messaging.” The officer certifying the filing will need to attest that steps have been taken to preserve communications and documents that could be relevant to the investigation, including stopping auto-delete features on any system used in any entity controlled by the filing party. This will create confidentiality and potential securities law issues in which a party must communicate with a broad group of employees or other individuals to ensure information is preserved, when a transaction may not have been publicly, or even internally, announced. This preservation obligation also goes beyond standard practice in litigation or an investigation by imposing preservation obligations on portions of the organization unrelated to the issues under investigation.
    • Parties will need to gather and submit data on their labor force, including:
      • Classifying their largest employee groups by occupational codes and reporting geographic information on their employee locations when the buyer and seller have employees in the same occupational codes.
      • Identifying any wage-and-hour violations, Occupational Safety & Health Administration violations and/or National Labor Relations Board actions against them within the previous five years.
    • More information will need to be reported on investors, limited partners, financiers and others with the potential ability to influence the post-merger company. This could create a significant change in disclosure obligations for private equity funds.
    • All board memberships will need to be provided. Parties will need to list all officers, directors and board observers of every entity within the corporate structure.
    • All prior acquisitions of any size within the prior 10 years will need to be reported by the acquiring and acquired person where there is any competitive overlap between the buyer and seller. This expands the current rule, which applies only to the buyer, has a five-year look back and does not require smaller transactions—particularly certain asset transactions—to be reported. This proposed rule increases the likelihood that the FTC and Department of Justice Antitrust Division (DOJ) may investigate consummated transactions that were not HSR-reportable.
    • All subsidies in the prior two years from certain entities or countries of concern (e.g., China and Russia, foreign terrorist organizations or individuals on the Office of Foreign Assets Control’s Specially Designated Nationals and Blocked Persons List) will need to be reported. Subsidies are defined by the Tariff Act of 1930 and include any financial contribution, income or price support provided or directed to be provided by a government authority.
    • All current defense and intelligence contracts valued at more than $10 million will need to be identified. This is not limited by any areas of horizontal or vertical overlap. Parties will need to provide identifying information for the contract and relevant Department of Defense (DoD) and intelligence community personnel. There is not a carve-out for classified information, but that information cannot be disclosed under the security restrictions governing that data.

    WHAT THIS MEANS

    It is hard to overstate the significance of these proposed changes to the HSR filing regime.

    • The HSR process will take longer to clear. The FTC is seeking to delay filings so they cannot be made on a bare-bones LOI. Preparing filings will take substantially longer, which will delay the start of any waiting periods. The FTC will also need to process more data with each filing. We predict the agencies will complain they have too much information to sort through in the initial waiting period, and parties may need to pull and refile more frequently.
    • Preparing filings will take longer and cost more. The FTC estimates that it will take four times longer to complete a filing, increasing from 37 hours to 144 hours per filing. There is a good chance these estimates understate the true burden involved.
    • Compliance fights with the agencies will become more likely. The agencies can try to bounce filings that are deemed deficient at the time of filing, or later in the second request process if the FTC or DOJ see materials that they believe should have been included with the HSR filing. The new rules allow for more judgment calls that can be second-guessed by the agencies. This raises the risks of the investigating agency challenging the adequacy of an HSR filing well into the review process.
    • Parties will need to create more off-the-shelf items to be used in future filings. Historically, some parties have created annual updates to the boilerplate information needed for HSR filings, such as their revenues by Census codes. These rules will create more categories of information that need to be provided with every filing, such as information on labor forces and violations, subsidies, DoD contracts and others. More information will need to be maintained to allow parties to file relatively quickly after reaching an agreement.
    • Parties will need to make sure corporate development staff is well schooled in document preparation. These personnel will prepare many of the key documents that will need to be produced with the filing, now including drafts.
    • It will be more important than ever for companies to invest in careful document creation for all business activities and know what their documents say. The proposed rules will require companies to submit many more documents, and those documents can have a major impact on the review process. Ordinary course of business and strategy documents that historically would not be disclosed unless the FTC or DOJ investigated a transaction closely and issued a second request (subpoena) now will be disclosed with the initial filing. More documents will be disclosed to regulators, even for transactions that do not raise substantive concerns. Therefore, companies will need to take a cautious approach to document creation, maintenance and production, including:
      • Implementing strong antitrust training for a broad range of employees, particularly those who may be involved in the creation of top-level strategic documents that are or may be shared with senior executives;
      • Ensuring that top-level strategic documents are accurate, fact-based and avoid content that could be misconstrued to reflect negatively on key competition issues (e.g., documents that suggest overly narrow product or geographic market definitions, or that exaggerate barriers to entry or diminish the importance of smaller or foreign competitors); and
      • Investing in up-front review of documents that may be candidates for submission under the proposed new HSR approach, to ensure that information contained in such documents is consistent with narrative content to be supplied in the HSR filing (e.g., the proposed Horizontal Overlap Narrative).

    WHAT’S NEXT

    Interested parties may file comments to the proposed rulemaking by August 28, 2023. The FTC may hold listening forums or other opportunities for public input. There is no mandatory timeline for finalization of new federal rules.

    Even if the FTC reduces the scope of its proposed modifications, the revised HSR rules will dramatically increase the time and cost to prepare the HSR filing and increase the likelihood that US antitrust regulators will investigate all horizontal and vertical issues in transactions, regardless of the size of the overlap.

    Because the revised HSR rules require buyers and sellers to identify all transactions of any size completed within the last 10 years, companies will need to establish a system to assess any regulatory issues for non-HSR-reportable transactions—and to better understand the antitrust agencies’ potential views on competitive issues associated with serial transactions, some of which might not appear to raise concerns when considered in isolation.

    Finally, it will be more important than ever for companies to take a strategic, holistic view of key documents, investing in sophisticated antitrust training for those who create such documents and the business leaders and decision-makers who use them.

    Authors

    Jon B. Dubrow

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Timothy (Ty) Carson

    Counsel

    Washington, DC

    Joel R. Grosberg

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Raymond A. Jacobsen , Jr.

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Ryan C. Tisch

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • Florida Passes Live Local Act to Incentivize Affordable Housing Development for the State’s Workforce

    Florida Passes Live Local Act to Incentivize Affordable Housing Development for the State’s Workforce

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Florida Passes Live Local Act to Incentivize Affordable Housing Development for the State’s Workforce

    June 29, 2023

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In March 2023, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis signed Senate Bill 102, also known as the Live Local Act (the Act), into law. The bill surpasses historical records for the state, represents the largest investment in housing opportunities to date and will go into effect on July 1, 2023. Its goal is to provide a comprehensive housing strategy to increase the availability of affordable housing opportunities for members of the Floridian workforce who desire to live in the communities in which they work.

    In depth

    The Act introduces several new Florida Statutes, which are aimed at improving affordable housing opportunities in Florida, and modifies several existing Florida Statutes. A summary of the modifications and additions to some of those existing statutes are as follows:

    • Section 2 of the Act modifies Fla. Stat. § 125.0103(1) to now state that local government may not impose price controls upon a lawful business activity that is not franchised by, owned by or under contract with the governmental agency. Additionally, Fla. Stat. § 125.0103(2) now precludes local government entities from imposing rent control.
    • Section 3 of the Act amends and expands Fla. Stat. § 125.01055 by inserting various provisions to facilitate the development of affordable housing, including:
      • A board of county commissioners may approve the development of affordable housing, including a mixed-use residential development, on any parcel zoned for commercial or industrial use so long as at least 10% of the units included in the project are for affordable housing.
      • The following provisions, which are included in Subsection (7), expire on October 1, 2033:
        • A county must authorize multifamily and mixed-use residential as allowable in any area zoned for commercial, industrial or mixed-use if at least 40% of the resident units in a proposed multifamily rental development are affordable for at least 30 years.
        • A county may not restrict the density of a proposed development below the highest allowed density on any unincorporated land where residential development is allowed.
        • A county may not restrict the height of a proposed development authorized under this subsection below the highest currently allowed height for a commercial or residential development located in its jurisdiction within one mile of the proposed development or three stories, whichever is higher.
        • A county must consider reducing parking requirements for a proposed development if the development is located within one-half mile of a major transit stop, as defined in the county’s land development code, and the major transit stop is accessible from the development.
    • Section 8 of the Act creates a new ad valorem tax exemption, codified in Fla. Stat. § 196.1978.
      • Subsection (2)(b) of the provision provides that any land owned by an Internal Revenue Service (IRS)-recognized 501(c)(3) organization that is leased for at least 99 years for the purpose of providing affordable housing for extremely-low-, very low-, low- or moderate-income (as defined in Fla. Stat. § 420.0004) is entirely exempt from ad valorem taxes. This exemption is applicable for tax years 2024 through 2059.
        • Section 420.0004 uses the following definitions:
          • “Extremely low-income persons” means one or more natural persons or a family whose total annual household income does not exceed 30% of the median annual adjusted gross income for households within the state.
          • “Very low-income persons” means one or more natural persons or a family, not including students, of which the total annual adjusted gross household income does not exceed 50% of the median annual adjusted gross income for households within the state or 50% of the median annual adjusted gross income for households within the metropolitan statistical area (MSA) or, if not within an MSA, within the county in which the person or family resides, whichever is greater.
          • “Low-income persons” means one or more natural persons or a family, of which the total annual adjusted gross household income does not exceed 80% of the median annual adjusted gross income for households within the state or 80% of the median annual adjusted gross income for households within the MSA or, if not within an MSA, within the county in which the person or family resides, whichever is greater.
          • “Moderate-income persons” means one or more natural persons or a family, of which the total annual adjusted gross household income is less than 120% of the median annual adjusted gross income for households within the state or 120% of the median annual adjusted gross income for households within the MSA or, if not within an MSA, within the county in which the person or family resides, whichever is greater.
        • Subsection (3), also a new tax exemption provision valid for taxable years 2024 through 2059, provides that some portions of a multifamily project can be considered charitable under the law and eligible for an ad valorem tax exemption. Specific requirements listed under the statute must be met to qualify.
    • Section 9 of the Act creates Fla. Stat. § 196.1979, which details county and municipal affordable housing property exemptions. This section states that the governing body of a county or municipality may adopt an ordinance to exempt portions of property used for affordable housing.
    • Section 12 of the Act amends and expands Fla. Stat. § 212.08(5)(v). This provision now allows building materials used in eligible residential units to be exempt from the tax imposed if an owner demonstrates (to the satisfaction of the department) that all necessary requirements have been met. This exemption inures to the owner at the time an eligible residential unit is substantially completed but only through a refund of previously paid taxes. A refund may not exceed the lesser of $5,000 or 97.5% of the Florida sales or use tax paid on the cost of the building materials.
    • Section 21 of the Act creates Fla. Stat. 220.1878, which states that for taxable years 2023 and later, all eligible contributions to the Live Local Program may be credited against any taxes due under chapter 220 of the Florida Statutes.
    • Section 23, “State-owned Land; Uses,” modifies Fla. Stat. § 253.034(5) to declare that non-conservation state-owned land use plans shall be used to determine whether the lands should be transferred to the local government in which the land is located to provide affordable multifamily rental housing.

    Members of Florida’s workforce who stand to benefit the most include frontline workers, like teachers, nurses and first responders, who are purchasing their first homes. Given the recent increase in private inbound investment into Florida, this new law aims to keep housing prices within reach for locals who are serving their communities.

    At almost double the 2022-2023 housing investment, the Act appropriates $711 million for housing projects through the Florida Housing and Finance Corporation (FHFC). The housing investment is broken down as follows:

    • $259 million is designated for the State Apartment Incentive Loan (SAIL) program, which provides low-interest loans to affordable housing developers.
    • An additional $252 million is allocated toward the State Housing Initiatives Partnership (SHIP), a program that grants funds to local governments as an incentive to create partnerships that will retain affordable homeownership and multifamily housing.
    • Another $100 million will support the second year of the Hometown Heroes Program so that qualified first-time homebuyers can purchase homes in neighborhoods in which they work. The Act has codified this down payment assistance program and increased the borrowing limit per loan.
    • Finally, $100 million is allocated to FHFC to implement a loan program to alleviate inflation-related cost increases for FHFC-approved housing builds.

    Aside from its multitude of funding benefits, the Act brings an array of tax incentives for Floridian taxpayers. For example, it creates a new tax donation program for corporations in the state (Fla. Stat. § 220.1878.) and corporations can now direct certain tax payments to help fund housing projects. (Fla. Stat. § 420.50872.) Additionally, the new law has increased the amount of available tax credits through the contribution tax credit program by more than $10 million, jumping from $14.5 million to $25 million. (Fla. Stat. § 212.08(5)(p)(1)(e).) Finally, and as noted previously, the Act creates additional tax benefits through the ability to obtain up to a $5,000 refund for sales tax spent on building materials for housing units funded through FHFC. (Fla. Stat. § 212.08(5)(v).) In turn, FHFC will have a greater capacity to invest in housing for foster care children who may be aging out of the state’s care soon. (Fla. Stat. § 420.5087(10).)

    Despite the Act’s significant benefits to the local Floridian workforce, it has also faced some criticism. Specifically, critics have expressed disapproval of the prevention of local rent control and possible preemption of local governments to enforce rules on zoning, building heights and density. Concerns relating to the bill’s ban on rent control and preemption from enforcing zoning restrictions are rooted in the fact that the state has limited decision-making authority from local governments who may best understand the specific needs and challenges of the area. The bill has also removed voters’ rights to advocate for rent control in their municipalities.

    This new law ultimately carries a host of benefits for affordable housing developers, “hometown heroes” who are first-time homebuyers, children needing housing through FHFC and other potential beneficiaries of affordable housing options. McDermott Will & Emery has begun advising clients on the implications of the Live Local Act. For assistance with this bill, please contact the authors of this article.

    Olivia Sica, a summer associate in the Miami office, also contributed to this article.

    Authors

    Elena Otero

    Partner

    Miami

    Kelly Shami

    Partner

    Miami

    More insights

  • Navigating Federal and State Youth Labor Laws

    Navigating Federal and State Youth Labor Laws

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Navigating Federal and State Youth Labor Laws

    June 29, 2023

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    With the summer job season in full swing, young people under the age of 18 are seeking employment opportunities while school is not in session. What employers may not be aware of is that 2023 has already seen increased focus and enforcement activity with respect to wage and hour laws applicable to minors (typically youth ages 14 to 17) in the workforce, including from the US Department of Labor (DOL) and the US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). To complicate matters, various state legislatures have rolled out, or are in the process of rolling out, legislation that at times may conflict with federal law. This article offers insights and best practices to help employers navigate the growing tension between federal lawmakers and state legislation.

    In depth

    RENEWED FEDERAL SCRUTINY

    On February 27, 2023, the DOL and HHS issued a joint announcement highlighting a 69% increase since 2018 in noncompliant practices with respect to the employment of minors. As a result, the federal government has renewed its focus on the use of child labor. To help combat noncompliance with child labor laws, the DOL and HHS have spearheaded a collaborative effort that will include, among other efforts, an interagency task force and a national strategic enforcement initiative on child labor. The announcement made clear that the DOL and HHS intend to hold all employers accountable for any noncompliance with child labor laws. The announcement called on Congress to increase the maximum civil monetary penalty for a child labor law violation, which is currently $15,138 per child. The announcement described the current penalty as “not high enough to be a deterrent for major profitable companies.”

    Members of both the US House of Representatives and the US Senate have echoed the efforts of the DOL and HHS. Both chambers have introduced pieces of legislation that seek to strengthen penalties for employers that violate child labor laws. The Senate’s version of the legislation would seek to establish new criminal penalties and increase maximum fines for employers that violate child labor laws, while the House’s bill would increase civil monetary penalties and establish a minimum monetary penalty for violation.

    STATE LEGISLATORS SEEK TO MODIFY RESTRICTIONS ON CHILD LABOR LAWS

    Against this backdrop, and partly in response to market pressures and increased demand for labor, state legislatures have increasingly been considering modifying restrictions on employers’ ability to hire minors. Recent examples include the following:

    • Iowa: Governor Kim Reynolds signed a bill into law allowing 14- and 15-year-olds to work in meat coolers and industrial freezers.
    • Minnesota: Lawmakers are considering legislation that would allow 16- and 17-year-olds to work in construction.
    • Arkansas: Governor Sarah Huckabee Sanders recently signed the state’s Youth Hiring Act of 2023, which allows workers as young as 14 to work without a permit.
    • Ohio: Lawmakers are considering a new law that would remove the cap on the number of hours minors as young as 14 can work with parent or guardian consent.
    • New Jersey: Governor Phil Murphy signed legislation last year allowing those aged 16 to 18 to work 50 hours a week during the summer with parent or guardian consent.

    Lawmakers in other states, like New York, recently encouraged employers in hospitality, restaurants, fast food and certain physically taxing industries such as manufacturing, food processing, construction, farming and landscaping to educate their employees on labor rights and the signs of labor trafficking. To help promote these efforts, New York rolled out a campaign to educate young workers on their rights in the workplace and debuted a labor trafficking response unit, tasked in part with cracking down on noncompliant practices with respect to the employment of child workers.

    LEGAL CONSIDERATIONS AND BEST PRACTICES

    With this developing patchwork of federal enforcement efforts and state laws, it is increasingly important for employers to review their policies and practices with respect to the employment of minors in the workplace and adjust if necessary. Here are a few recommended best practices to get employers started:

    • Obtain age permits. While several states require minor workers to obtain employer-specific permits to work, federal law has no such requirement. However, employers may nonetheless seek an age certificate from the DOL in order to mitigate any potential liability in the event a minor worker is revealed to be younger than their stated age. An effective age certificate contains the minor’s name and address, place and date of birth (and a statement indicating the evidence on which this is based), sex, signature, name and address of the minor’s parent or guardian, the signature of the issuing officer, and the date and place of issuance. If the minor is under 18, the age certificate should also include the name and address of the employer, the employer’s industry and the minor’s occupation. The DOL accepts state-issued work permits as valid age certificates; the DOL may also issue certificates for a minor under 18 years of age. 29 CFR Part 570 Subpart B, §§ 570.5-6.
    • Ensure that human resources and management teams understand industry-specific work restrictions. For the safety of youth workers, federal law prohibits minors from holding a variety of jobs, particularly those in “hazardous” fields such as trucking, logging, industrial freezers, compacting machines or occupations working with most types of heavy industrial equipment (e.g., meat processing, bakery machines, metallurgical equipment). State and local laws may expand or limit the list of prohibited jobs.
    • Ensure that human resources, management and youths are properly trained on legal compliance and individual rights. In industries that tend to employ youths at higher rates (e.g., fast food restaurants), ensure that managers who may be young themselves are appropriately trained to work with minors. For example, in California, all managers must go through mandatory sexual harassment prevention training. If an employer’s state does not have this requirement, and/or an employer has not implemented an official program, consider at minimum implementing one for persons that supervise and work with minors. The US Equal Employment Opportunity Commission offers several fact sheets, including one on sexual harassment, as part of its “Youth@Work” initiative. Even in fields without a typically young workforce, employers should ensure that managers are selected and trained to work with youth in compliance with applicable youth labor laws. Employers may consider implementing specialized training methods that are better suited for younger workers. For seasonal workers (perhaps teens picking up a summer job), employers may wish to consider tailoring training programs to make sure youths are aware of their rights as soon as possible, given their possible short tenure on the job.
    • Consider placing caps on the number of hours that minors can work per day, per week and dependent on whether school is in session. Federal law states that individuals aged 14 and 15 may not work during school hours while school is in session, before 7 am or after 7 pm (or after 9 pm from June 1 through Labor Day), more than three hours on a school day, more than 18 hours a week during a school week, more than eight hours a day on a non-school day, or more than 40 hours a week during a non-school week.
    • Provide industry-specific training on tools and machinery. Consider whether minors require additional training to use machinery or equipment in a given profession.
    • Conduct an internal privileged audit. Confirm that your organization is compliant with the federal, state and local minimum wage and overtime requirements, and any state or locally required meal periods or rest breaks for minor employees.

    THE MCDERMOTT DIFFERENCE

    The employment of minors is inherently a challenging subject, especially in light of recent trends. We are happy to advise you in the event you are seeking to bring minor workers to your organization, in order to help ensure that your organization has taken the appropriate steps and to protect the minor staff onboard.

    Authors

    Melis Solaksubasi

    Associate

    Chicago

    More insights

  • Double Jeopardy Doesn’t Attach to Venue and Vicinage Clause Violations

    Double Jeopardy Doesn’t Attach to Venue and Vicinage Clause Violations

    ARTICLE

    Double Jeopardy Doesn’t Attach to Venue and Vicinage Clause Violations

    Jun 29, 2023

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Supreme Court of the United States concluded that the Constitution’s Double Jeopardy Clause does not preclude retrial of a criminal defendant who was prosecuted in an improper venue and before a jury drawn from the wrong district. Smith v. United States, Case No. 21-1576 (Sup. Ct. June 15, 2023) (Alito, Justice.)

    Timothy Smith was indicted in the Northern District of Florida for stealing trade secrets from StrikeLines, a company that uses sonar equipment to identify private artificial reefs that individuals construct to attract fish. In particular, Smith was accused of “surreptitiously” obtaining portions of coordinates and data from StrikeLines’ website.

    At trial, the district court denied Smith’s motions to dismiss the indictment and for judgment of acquittal due to improper venue. Smith unsuccessfully argued that “he had accessed the data from Mobile, Alabama (in the Southern District of Alabama) and [that] the servers storing StrikeLines’ coordinates were located in Orlando, Florida (Middle District of Florida).” On appeal, the US Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit reversed but concluded that “the ‘remedy for improper venue is vacatur of the conviction, not acquittal or dismissal with prejudice,’ and that the ‘Double Jeopardy Clause is not implicated by a retrial in a proper venue.’” Smith appealed to the Supreme Court.

    On writ of certiorari, the issue before the Supreme Court was “whether the Constitution permits the retrial of a defendant following a trial in an improper venue and before a jury drawn from the wrong district,” or if retrial is barred by the Double Jeopardy Clause.

    Citing precedent and the text of the Venue and Vicinage Clauses, Smith advanced the theory that the purpose of the Clauses bars retrial and requires acquittal. However, as the Supreme Court explained, neither purpose nor precedent demanded that the Venue or Vicinage Clauses be excepted from the general rule that, unless prohibited by the Double Jeopardy Clause, “a defendant [who] obtains a reversal of a prior, unsatisfied conviction . . . may be retried in the normal course of events.” The Court rejected Smith’s argument that the Venue Clause is meant to prevent the hardship of undergoing trial in a distant forum because the clause is “keyed to the location of the alleged ‘Crimes’” and not the district in which the defendant resides. The Court similarly rejected Smith’s arguments related to the purpose of the Vicinage Clause, noting that the Court has “repeatedly acknowledged that retrials are the appropriate remedy for violations of other [Sixth Amendment] jury-trial rights.”

    Next, Smith appealed to the historical background of the Venue and Vicinage Clauses. The Supreme Court examined the relevant historical background and explained that the remedy at common law for a trial in an improper venue and before a jury drawn from the wrong vicinage did not preclude retrial. Moreover, the Court noted that it previously “embraced the retrial rule for a venue error” and that other federal and state courts have similarly ordered retrials for venue violations.

    Finally, Smith argued that the Venue and Vicinage Clauses are “inseparably interwoven” with the Double Jeopardy Clause, thus precluding retrial. The Supreme Court explained that a judicial decision on venue is “fundamentally different” from a general verdict of not guilty because only the latter contemplates the “general rule that ‘[c]ulpability . . . is the touchstone’ for determining whether retrial is permitted under the Double Jeopardy Clause.” Unlike a reversal from a general verdict of not guilty, reversal of a conviction based on a venue or vicinage violation does not resolve “the bottom-line question of criminal culpability” and is premised “on a basis unrelated to factual guilt or innocence.”

    Ultimately, the Supreme Court concluded that “the Eleventh Circuit’s decision that venue in the Northern District of Florida was improper did not adjudicate Smith’s culpability” and thus did “not trigger the Double Jeopardy Clause.” Therefore, the Court ruled that retrial was permissible.

    Authors

    Jake B. Vallen

    Associate

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights
    Endnotes

  • Mootness Requires Covenant Not to Sue to Be Unconditional and Irrevocable

    Mootness Requires Covenant Not to Sue to Be Unconditional and Irrevocable

    ARTICLE

    Mootness Requires Covenant Not to Sue to Be Unconditional and Irrevocable

    Jun 29, 2023

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Addressing a district court decision finding no trade secret misappropriation, the US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit agreed that the alleged trade secret holder had failed to moot the case because its covenant not to sue was both conditional and revocable. Synopsys, Inc. v. Risk Based Security, Inc., Case No. 22-1812 (4th Cir. June 15, 2023) (Agee, Rushing, Dawson, JJ.)

    In early 2021, Risk Based Security (RBS) sent a cease-and-desist letter to Synopsys, its competitor in the software security industry, alleging intellectual property misappropriation, including use of RBS’s private database of source code vulnerabilities. Synopsys responded by filing a declaratory judgment action asserting that it had not engaged in trade secret misappropriation. RBS later issued a covenant not to sue in express reliance on certain pretrial representations made by Synopsys, including that Synopsys was not planning to use RBS’s database. RBS moved to dismiss the case as moot based on its covenant, but the district court denied the motion. The district court then ruled on summary judgment that RBS had failed to establish that its alleged trade secrets satisfied the requirements that they have an independent economic value derived from their secrecy and were subject to reasonable efforts to maintain their secrecy. RBS appealed.

    The Fourth Circuit first affirmed the rejection of RBS’s covenant not to sue. The Court noted that the covenant was not unconditional and irrevocable because it was expressly premised on Synopsys’s planned future performance, which RBS could later claim was not being met. The Court also relied on the fact that the covenant was limited to the use of RBS’s private database and was thus narrower than the original cease-and-desist letter, which was explicitly not limited to that use. Finally, the Court concluded that there was a continuing live controversy, demonstrated by the fact that, after issuing the covenant, RBS added Synopsys to a pending trade secret case it had filed against Synopsys’s subsidiary. Accordingly, the Fourth Circuit affirmed the district court’s denial of RBS’s motion to dismiss.

    On the merits, the Fourth Circuit agreed with the district court that RBS had failed to show that its alleged trade secrets met the independent value or reasonable secrecy elements required by statute. In particular, the Court agreed that RBS’s evidence regarding its value as a company and the revenue it derived from licensing its database could not show independent value for the specific alleged trade secrets contained in the database.

    Authors
    More insights
    Endnotes

  • HRSA and OIG Begin Recovery and Audits of the COVID-19 Funding Programs

    HRSA and OIG Begin Recovery and Audits of the COVID-19 Funding Programs

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    HRSA and OIG Begin Recovery and Audits of the COVID-19 Funding Programs

    June 28, 2023

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA) reminded providers through a program update on Monday, June 5, 2023, that the Provider Relief Fund (PRF) and COVID-19 Uninsured Program (UIP) Terms and Conditions continue to apply to funding recipients. Recipients of PRF and UIP dollars must still meet the reporting and auditing requirements for the PRF and UIP, respectively.

    Separate from the reporting and auditing requirements, HRSA and the Office of the Inspector General (OIG) have initiated their own audits related to the PRF and UIP.

    Together, these developments suggest that agency oversight of past payments will continue as HRSA tries to wind down the PRF and UIP.

    In depth

    HRSA and OIG Audits of COVID-19 Relief Funding Programs

    PRF recipients have continued to receive letters from HRSA instructing them to report noncompliance with the terms and conditions of the program and repayment notices seeking to recover past payments based on such noncompliance.

    This year, HRSA began auditing select PRF recipients’ use of payments reported in reporting periods 1 and 2. Thus far, these audits focus on whether PRF recipients followed the terms and conditions of the program, including whether funds were used for permissible purposes. We expect these audits to continue and to expand to reporting periods 3 and 4.

    OIG is auditing both individual PRF/UIP recipients and HRSA itself. In total, OIG has announced at least seven PRF and UIP audits as part of its workplan. The purposes of these audits range from evaluating HRSA’s controls over calculating and distributing payments, to provider eligibility, to provider compliance with the applicable terms and conditions (e.g., balance billing prohibitions, use of funds) and reporting requirements. PRF and UIP recipients may be the target of these audits or receive requests to provide documentation in connection with OIG audits of HRSA.

    In recent audits, OIG requested recipients produce items such as:

    • General ledger transactions for all expenses attributable to COVID-19 within specified date ranges
    • Detailed lists of expenses that were reimbursed with COVID-19 funding payments during specified date ranges
    • Lists of employees and contractors whose salaries were charged to the COVID-19 funding sources and corresponding payroll summaries
    • General ledger transactions for patient care revenue from federal healthcare payors
    • Bank statements for the receipt of assistance payments from other sources
    • Board meeting minutes
    • Policies and procedures related to procurement and PRF payments and expenditures
    • Audited financial statements
    • Supporting documentation for other relief funding and insurance sources

    OIG’s first PRF audit report of HRSA reinforces that more oversight is expected. The first audit focused narrowly on certain HRSA controls over the calculation of correct Phase 1 payments and identified millions in improper PRF payments and weaknesses in HRSA’s collection and review of applicant documentation. OIG recommended that HRSA (1) ensure improper payments were properly reconciled in subsequent PRF distributions and recoup any remaining overpayments from providers, (2) review additional supporting documentation for certain providers and (3) ensure collection of more than $50 million in rejected Phase 1 payments.

    Consistent with HRSA’s response to OIG’s audit, providers should expect HRSA to:

    • Continue collecting outstanding rejected payments
    • Request supporting revenue data for certain providers who received $2 million or more in payments based on March and April 2020 losses (providers who received Phase 1, Round 2 payments on this basis may receive additional documentation requests from HRSA)
    • Increase improper payment recovery actions with the recent completion of Phase 4 disbursements [1]

    We recommend that PRF and UIP recipients consult legal counsel in responding to audits, inquiries and repayment demand letters and that they work proactively with legal counsel to prepare for additional oversight activity.

    Qui Tam Complaint for Violations of the False Claims Act: Singh v. Hudson Hospital OpCo

    On June 12, 2023, a PRF-related qui tam lawsuit was unsealed. The qui tam suit was brought by Vijayant Singh, M.D., a former officer of the New Jersey-based defendant hospitals, against a group of New Jersey hospital entities, their management companies and the hospitals’ chief executive and financial officers.

    Dr. Singh alleged that the defendant hospitals improperly obtained more than $50 million in CARES Act provider relief funds by submitting false claims for reimbursement for diagnosing and treating patients who had not tested positive for COVID-19; failed to return the funds; and improperly used the funds for purposes unrelated to diagnosing and treating COVID-19 patients.

    According to Dr. Singh, the hospitals claimed, in high impact area distribution application materials, that they had treated and sought reimbursement for between 2,400 and 3,300 patients who had tested positive for COVID-19. Dr. Singh alleges that 1,214 of those patients had not tested positive for COVID-19 and otherwise failed to meet the US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) inclusion criteria, thereby representing false claims for reimbursement. Dr. Singh also alleges that the improper retention of the PRF funds constitutes reverse false claims, by way of the government being “deprived of the use of these monies.”

    Dr. Singh also alleges that two of the hospitals entered into a consulting services agreement under which it made consulting payments in exchange for patient referrals in violation of the Anti-Kickback Statute.

    While the US Department of Justice (DOJ) declined to intervene, we expect to see an increase in relator actions based on application for, retention of and use of PRF funds.


    [1] HRSA signaled that it had postponed certain payment recovery efforts pending the completion of Phase 4 distributions.

    Authors
    More insights

  • Nevada and Connecticut Pass Consumer Health Data Laws

    Nevada and Connecticut Pass Consumer Health Data Laws

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Nevada and Connecticut Pass Consumer Health Data Laws

    June 28, 2023

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Following in the footsteps of Washington State’s My Health My Data Act, Nevada SB 370 and Connecticut SB 3 were both recently approved by their respective governors. As detailed below, the laws impose a number of new requirements on the processing of consumer health data. Nevada SB 370 will go into effect on March 31, 2024, while the consumer health data-related provisions of Connecticut SB 3 that amend the Connecticut Data Privacy Act (CTDPA) will take effect on July 1, 2023.

    In depth

    NEVADA

    Applicability

    SB 370 will apply to a “regulated entity,” which is any person who (1) conducts business in Nevada or produces or provides products or services that are targeted to consumers in Nevada and (2) alone or with other persons, determines the purpose and means of processing, sharing or selling consumer health data. This could include nonprofits. For purposes of SB 370, a “consumer” is a natural person who has requested a product or service from a regulated entity and who resides in Nevada or whose consumer health data is collected in Nevada. A “consumer” does not include a natural person acting in an employment context or as an agent of a governmental entity. Notably, this definition of “consumer” would potentially also cover non-Nevada residents, which is a broader applicability than other state privacy laws.

    What Is “Consumer Health Data”?

    SB 370 defines “consumer health data” as personally identifiable information that is linked or reasonably capable of being linked to a consumer and that a regulated entity uses to identify the past, present or future health status of the consumer. Consumer health data includes, without limitation:

    • Information relating to:
      • Any health condition or status, disease or diagnosis
      • Social, psychological, behavioral or medical interventions
      • Surgeries or other health-related procedures
      • The use or acquisition of medication
      • Bodily functions, vital signs or symptoms
      • Reproductive or sexual health care
      • Gender-affirming care
    • Biometric data or genetic data related to the information described in the above bullet points
    • Information related to the precise geolocation information of a consumer that a regulated entity uses to indicate an attempt by a consumer to receive healthcare services or products
    • Any information described in the above bullet points that is derived or extrapolated from information that is not consumer health data, including (without limitation) proxy, derivative, inferred or emergent data derived through an algorithm, machine learning or any other means.

    Consumer health data does not include information that is used to:

    • Provide access to or enable gameplay by a person on a video game platform, or
    • Identify the shopping habits or interests of a consumer if that information is not used to identify the specific past, present or future health status of the consumer.

    Exemptions

    As with other state consumer privacy laws, SB 370 contains a number of entity- and data-level exemptions. For example, SB 370 will not apply to:

    • Any person or entity subject to the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA) and health records governed by or created pursuant to other healthcare-related laws (e.g., 42 CFR Part 2, regulations regarding human subject research, public health reporting requirements, patient safety and other healthcare quality improvement activities).
    • Financial institutions or financial institution affiliates that are subject to the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (GLBA) or any personally identifiable information regulated by the GLBA that is collected, maintained or sold as provided in the GLBA.
    • Personally identifiable information regulated by the Administrative Simplification provisions of the Social Security Act, Fair Credit Reporting Act or Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act.
    • Information processed by or for any governmental or tribal entity for civic or governmental purposes and operations or related services and operations.
    • Any person who holds a nonrestricted license (meaning a state gaming license for: 16 or more slot machines; any number of slot machines together with any other game, gaming device, race book or sports pool at one establishment; or a slot machine route), or an affiliate.
    • Law enforcement agencies, contractors of law enforcement agencies and law enforcement activities.

    Data Controller Obligations

    SB 370 will require regulated entities to include additional privacy disclosures on their websites and take additional steps to, for example, obtain consent from customers when handling their consumer health data. Specifically, SB 370 will require regulated entities to:

    • Develop and maintain a consumer health data privacy policy.
    • Obtain a consumer’s affirmative, voluntary consent before collecting or sharing consumer health data (subject to certain exceptions).
    • Establish, implement and maintain policies and practices for the administrative, technical and physical security of consumer health data.
    • Enter into a contract with data processors related to their processing of consumer health data.

    While the addition of more disclosures into already lengthy privacy policies is likely frustrating to some, the remaining requirements above closely mirror those of the majority of new state consumer privacy laws.

    Consumer Rights

    Regulated entities must also provide a number of consumer rights, which likely look and feel standard to companies at this point:

    • Confirming whether the regulated entity is collecting, sharing or selling consumer health data relating to the consumer.
    • Providing the consumer with a list of all third parties with whom the regulated entity has shared consumer health data relating to the consumer or to whom the regulated entity has sold such consumer health data.
    • Ceasing the collection, sharing or selling of consumer health data relating to the consumer.
    • Deleting consumer health data concerning the consumer.

    A regulated entity must also establish a process by which a consumer may appeal the regulated entity’s refusal to act on a consumer request.

    Other Key Restrictions

    SB 370 will prohibit any person from selling or offering to sell consumer health data (1) without the written authorization of the consumer to whom the data pertains or (2) if the consumer provides such written authorization, in a manner that is outside the scope of or inconsistent with the written authorization.

    SB 370 will also prohibit any person from implementing a geofence within 1,750 feet of any medical facility, facility for the dependent or any other person or entity that provides in-person healthcare services or products for the purpose of (1) identifying or tracking consumers seeking in-person healthcare services or products, (2) collecting consumer health data, or (3) sending notifications, messages or advertisements to consumers related to their consumer health data or healthcare services or products.

    No Private Right of Action

    Unlike the Washington State health law on which SB 370 is modeled, there is no private right of action in SB 370.

    CONNECTICUT

    Connecticut SB 3, in part, amends the CTDPA to impose new limitations on the processing and sale of consumer health data and revises the CTDPA’s definition of “sensitive data” to explicitly include consumer health data. SB 3 defines “consumer health data” as any personal data that a controller uses to identify a consumer’s physical or mental health condition or diagnosis and includes, but is not limited to, gender-affirming health data and reproductive or sexual health data. New restrictions include prohibitions against (1) providing employees or contractors with access to consumer health data unless they are subject to a contractual or statutory duty of confidentiality; (2) using a geofence to establish a virtual boundary that is within 1,750 feet of any mental health facility or reproductive or sexual health facility for the purpose of identifying, tracking, collecting data from or sending any notification to a consumer regarding the consumer’s consumer health data; or (3) selling, or offering to sell, consumer health data without first obtaining the consumer’s consent.

    ***

    Creating a successful, effective, comprehensive privacy program for your organization requires a thorough understanding of both the relevant legal obligations and the personal information subject to compliance. Setting up a program that is prepared to respond to various state privacy laws as they come into effect will save organizations time in the long run, especially as many of these laws reflect one another.

    If you have questions or need assistance in readiness work for the new state consumer laws, please contact any of the authors of this article or your regular McDermott lawyer.

    Authors

    David P. Saunders

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • SECURE 2.0 Technical Corrections Are on the Way, Eventually

    SECURE 2.0 Technical Corrections Are on the Way, Eventually

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    SECURE 2.0 Technical Corrections Are on the Way, Eventually

    June 28, 2023

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In an open letter to Secretary of the Treasury Janet Yellen and IRS Commissioner Daniel Werfel, congressional leaders identified several technical errors in the SECURE 2.0 Act that they intend to correct. Those include fixes to new rules regarding:

    • Catch-up contributions: The act requires catch-up contributions made by certain high-wage earners making more than $145,000 to be made on a Roth basis beginning in 2024. But it also includes language that could be read to eliminate all existing and future catch-up contributions. The letter clarifies that Congress did not intend to do so.
    • Required minimum distributions (RMDs): The act increases the age at which RMD payments must begin from age 72 to age 73 (and eventually to age 75). The letter clarifies that Congress intended to increase the RMD age to 73 for participants who turn 73 after December 31, 2022, and to 75 for participants who turn 73 after December 31, 2032. The language in the act previously raised questions about whether the change in the RMD age from 73 to 75 would only apply to those who turn 74 (rather than 73) in 2032. But the letter makes it clear that such an interpretation is inconsistent with congressional intent.
    • Start-up credits: The act increases the start-up tax credit for small employers from 50% to 100% of the costs of starting a retirement plan, with a maximum credit of $5,000. The act also provides a tax credit for matching contributions made under such a plan, up to $1,000 per employee. The act could be read such that the $5,000 limit would apply to the matching contribution credit as well, meaning that it would be limited to $1,000 per employee, up to $5,000. However, the letter clarifies that was not the intent.
    • SIMPLE IRAs and SEPs: The act permits SIMPLE IRAs plans and SEP plans to include a Roth IRA. The act could be read to require that Roth contributions to such plans be included when determining if an individual exceeds the Roth IRA contribution limit. However, the letter clarifies that Congress did not intend for Roth contributions to SIMPLE IRA or SEP plans to be included in determining the Roth IRA contribution limit.

    Although the letter indicates that Congress intends to correct these technical errors and ambiguities in the legislation—rather than relying on the US Department of the Treasury to issue conforming regulations—the letter does not address the timetable for doing so. In addition, the letter does not address potential extended deadlines for complying with certain changes or clarify other issues that are the focus of many employer questions. However, the letter does note that the technical corrections bill may include items not addressed in the letter. In addition, industry groups are pushing for priority guidance, transition relief and delayed effective dates to provide employers sufficient time to work with their recordkeepers and payroll providers to implement this change.

    For any questions regarding SECURE 2.0 changes, please contact your regular McDermott lawyer or one of the authors.

    In depth
    Authors

    Brian J. Tiemann

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights