Content Type: Article

  • Understanding ONC’s Health AI Transparency and Risk Management Regulatory Framework

    Understanding ONC’s Health AI Transparency and Risk Management Regulatory Framework

    ARTICLE / INTEROPERABILITY / REPORT

    Understanding ONC’s Health AI Transparency and Risk Management Regulatory Framework

    April 10, 2024

    Read time: 2 min

    Overview

    The Health Data, Technology, and Interoperability: Certification Program Updates, Algorithm Transparency, and Information Sharing (HTI-1) final rule, issued by the US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) Office of the National Coordinator for Health Information Technology (ONC), went into effect on March 11, 2024, and establishes a new regulatory framework for certain artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning technologies that support decision-making in health care. Compliance is required beginning December 31, 2024.

    This Special Report provides an overview of the final rule’s algorithmic transparency and risk management requirements and the types of technologies that may be in scope. ONC released an initial proposal for this health AI regulatory paradigm in its HTI-1 proposed rule in April 2023, which we summarized in a previous Special Report. Throughout this Special Report we note some key differences between the proposed and finalized certification criterion for decision support interventions (DSIs).

    We provided an overview of the final rule’s updates to certain standards and other certification criteria in the ONC’s Health IT Certification Program (certification program) in a separate On the Subject, and discussed the final rule’s information blocking provisions in another On the Subject.

    In depth
    Tabs

    Daniel F. Gottlieb

    Partner

    Chicago

    James A. Cannatti III

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Karen S. Sealander

    Counsel

    Washington, DC

    Nathan Gray

    Associate

    Washington, DC

    More insights
    Endnotes

  • Introducing the New Regulatory & International Trade | RIT Blog

    Introducing the New Regulatory & International Trade | RIT Blog

    ARTICLE

    Introducing the New Regulatory & International Trade | RIT Blog

    April 8, 2024

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Our new Regulatory & International Trade blog is intended as a trusted resource for navigating the often tricky landscape of global business regulations.

    Our goal is to empower companies with operations in Europe and beyond with the knowledge and tools they need to stay ahead of regulatory challenges.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • UK Labour Party’s Statement on Non-Dom Tax Reforms

    UK Labour Party’s Statement on Non-Dom Tax Reforms

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    UK Labour Party’s Statement on Non-Dom Tax Reforms

    April 9, 2024

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Following the UK Government’s 6 March announcement of tax reforms for the current “non-dom” tax regimes, the opposition Labour party has begun to outline how its plans would differ if they win the next UK general election. In a series of interviews on 9 April, Rachel Reeves, the shadow Chancellor of the Exchequer, indicated that Labour would not allow individuals to benefit from inheritance tax protection by establishing excluded property trusts before 6 April 2025. This may mean an earlier cut-off point for when such trusts could be effectively created, or may mean the removal of inheritance tax protections for all such trusts already established. That said, neither of the two main UK parties have set out in detail how they envisage moving inheritance tax from a domicile-based test to a residence-based one. This remains an area of considerable uncertainty.

    Regarding income and capital gains tax reforms, Labour have indicated they would abandon the one-year grace period for former remittance basis taxpayers in 2025/26, during which their foreign income would be taxed at half the usual rates. Labour claim this would raise an extra £600 million in tax as a one-off. The fact that Labour’s comments do not go much wider than this could suggest a tacit acceptance of much of the Conservative party’s proposals, and the principle of a four-year arrival period of beneficial tax treatment for new residents. With a UK election on the horizon but not yet given a date, it may be some time before taxpayers and their advisors are given certainty for the UK tax landscape. Whatever the outcome of the election, advice to navigate the inevitable changes will be essential.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • April 2024: UK Employment Law Changes Take Effect

    April 2024: UK Employment Law Changes Take Effect

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    April 2024: UK Employment Law Changes Take Effect

    April 9, 2023

    Read time: 11 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Now that Spring has sprung, early April 2024 sees the introduction of a number of important changes to employment laws in the UK. In summary, these include:

    • Expansion of the existing right to request flexible working
    • New rules for the calculation of holiday and holiday pay entitlement for irregular hour workers and part-year workers
    • A new unpaid leave right for carers
    • Greater flexibility in respect of paternity leave
    • Enhanced redundancy protection for pregnant employees and employees taking certain family leave
    • Increases in minimum wage limits
    • Increases in the value of certain potential tribunal awards and other statutory payment entitlements
    • Increases in the value of potential injury to feeling awards in discrimination cases

    Read on for further information on these key changes and some of the important consequences for employers.

    In depth

    1. Flexible Working Requests

    From 6 April 2024, the right to request flexible working has become a day one right for all employees (previously, an employee needed to have worked for the same employer for at least 26 continuous weeks before gaining this right).

    The following additional changes have also taken effect:

    • Employees will be able to make two requests in any 12-month period (up from the one request in any 12-month period previously), though only one such request may be live at any one time.
    • Employers will now be required to respond to a flexible working request within two months (down from the three month period that applied previously).
    • Employees no longer need to explain the impact of their request when applying.
    • Employers are now required to consult with employees before rejecting a request.

    It remains the case that an employer may reject a request based on one or more prescribed statutory reasons and those eight potential reasons remain unchanged as follows:

    • the burden of additional costs
    • an inability to reorganise work amongst existing staff
    • an inability to recruit additional staff
    • a detrimental impact on quality
    • a detrimental impact on performance
    • a detrimental effect on ability to meet customer demand
    • insufficient work available for the periods the employee proposes to work
    • planned structural changes to the employer’s business

    Employers considering refusing a request based on any of these reasons should give careful consideration to the evidential basis underlying their assessment.

    Employers should also remain mindful of their separate obligations under the Equality Act 2010. Where protected characteristics are potentially engaged, employers will need to be satisfied that refusing a request is a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim (such that any indirect discrimination is objectively justified). In respect of employees who are disabled for the purposes of the Equality Act 2010, employers will need to consider whether the requested change might constitute a reasonable adjustment.

    The updated flexible working regime is supported by a new statutory Acas Code of Practice on requests for flexible working (accessible here) (the Code). The Code provides guidance for employers and employees on their legal rights, responsibilities and good practice in making and handling statutory requests for flexible working. A failure to follow the Code will not, in itself, make an employer liable to legal proceedings. However, employment tribunals will be permitted to take the Code into account when considering relevant cases.

    In addition to updating existing flexible working policies and procedures, employers may wish to provide additional training to managers to ensure awareness of the expanded rights and to ensure that any requests are recognised and dealt with in a timely and fair manner.

    2. Holiday Pay for ‘Irregular Hours Workers’ and ‘Part-Year Workers’: Leave Years Beginning on or After 1 April 2024

    For leave years beginning on or after 1 April 2024, holiday entitlement for irregular hour workers and part-year workers can now, if an employer wishes, be calculated and paid at an accrual rate of 12.07% (so-called “rolled-up holiday pay”).

    The changes are aimed at addressing anomalies in the previous rules as they applied to such workers. A Supreme Court decision in 2022 found that it was not permissible for the leave entitlement for such workers to be pro-rated downwards to reflect hours actually worked. This created the possibility of irregular hours and part-year workers potentially receiving a greater holiday and holiday pay entitlement than those workers with regular hours and/or who worked all year round.

    The new regime allows employers to include an additional amount with every pay slip to cover a worker’s holiday entitlement and pay, and in essence pay out for that holiday as it accrues.

    The payment of such rolled up holiday pay for holiday years beginning on or after 1 April 2024 is permissible provided that:

    • the particular individual counts as an irregular hours or part-year worker;
    • holiday pay is calculated at 12.07% of all pay for work done (this being the percentage arrived at by taking the 5.6 weeks of statutory holiday entitlement and dividing that by the remaining 46.4 working weeks in a year);
    • the extra 12.07% is paid at the same time as pay for the work done; and
    • the holiday pay is itemised separately on the payslip.

    For this purpose:

    •  an ‘irregular hours worker’ is a worker who works a ‘wholly or mostly variable’ number of paid hours in each pay period during the term of their contract; and
    • a ‘part-year worker’ is a worker who is required to only work part of the year and there are periods without that year of at least a week which they are not required to work and for which they are not paid.

    3. New Statutory Right to Carer’s Leave

    From 6 April 2024, employees have a statutory right to one week’s unpaid leave per year to provide or arrange care for a dependant with a long-term care need.

    This includes:

    • a spouse, civil partner, child or parent of the employee;
    • any person who lives in the same household as the employee (otherwise than by reason of being the employee’s boarder, employee, lodger or tenant); or
    • any person who reasonably relies on the employee to provide or arrange care.

    A long-term care need for this purpose means:

    • an illness or injury (whether physical or mental) that requires, or is likely to require, care for more than three months;
    • a disability for the purposes of the Equality Act 2010; or
    • care for a reason connected with old age.

    The leave can be taken in either individual days or half days, in up to a single block of one week.

    Employees will not be required to provided evidence in relation to a request for any such leave. They will, however, need to give notice, albeit this does not need to be in writing. The amount of notice required will be the longer of either (i) twice the length of time being requested or (ii) three days.

    Employers will not be permitted to refuse a carer’s leave request but can, in principle, ask the employee to take it at a different time. They can only do this, however, if the employee’s absence at the requested time would cause serious disruption to the organisation.

    Employees will have the right to claim to an employment tribunal if their employer unreasonably postpones a period of carer’s leave or prevents or attempts to prevent them from taking carer’s leave.

    In the usual way, employees will also be protected from detriment and dismissal if the reason is because they took or sought to take carer’s leave.

    In addition to introducing a new policy and procedure, it will be important for employers to provide appropriate training to managers to ensure awareness of this new right.

    4. Greater Flexibility for Eligible Employees in Respect of Paternity Leave

    For children whose expected week of childbirth (EWC) is after 6 April 2024 and children whose expected date of placement for adoption is on or after 6 April 2024, an employee may choose to take:

    • A single period of leave of either one week or two weeks; or
    • Two non-consecutive periods of leave of a week each.

    Generally, this must be taken within 52 weeks of a child’s birth or placement for adoption.

    For children with an EWC or expected date of placement prior to 6 April 2024, the statutory entitlement remains a single block of either one or two weeks leave that must be taken within the first eight weeks after the adoption or birth.

    5. Enhanced Redundancy Protection for Pregnant Employees and Employees Taking Certain Family Leave

    It has long been the case that women on maternity leave and employees on adoption or shared parental leave have, in any redundancy situation arising, benefited from the right to be offered an available suitable alternative vacancy in priority to other employees.

    From 6 April 2024, the period during which this enhanced protection applies has been extended as follows:

    • For pregnant employees – enhanced redundancy protection will start when an employee tells their employer about their pregnancy. If the employee is entitled to statutory maternity leave, the protected period of pregnancy will end on the day the statutory maternity leave starts. If the pregnancy ends and they are not entitled to statutory maternity leave, the protected period ends two weeks after the end of pregnancy.
    • For employees on maternity leave – the additional protected period will end 18 months after the EWC, unless the employee has informed the employer of the date of their child’s birth, in which case the additional protected period will end 18 months after that date.
    • For employees on adoption leave – the additional protected period will end 18 months after the child’s placement or the date they enter Great Britain (in the case of overseas adoptions).
    • For employees on shared parental leave – for those taking six or more consecutive weeks of shared parental leave but who have not taken maternity or adoption leave, the additional protected period will end 18 months after the date of the child’s birth or placement (or date they enter Great Britain).

    6. Increases in the Amount of Certain Potential Tribunal Awards and Other Statutory Payment Entitlements

    Various changes relating to the calculation of statutory redundancy payments and unfair dismissal award payments, as set out in the table below, took effect on 6 April 2024, and will apply to dismissals where the effective date of termination (EDT) occurs on or after that date.

    It is important for employers to note:

    • If an employee was given notice prior to 6 April 2024, but the notice period expires on or after 6 April 2024, the new limits will apply.
    • If an employee’s employment was terminated by means of a payment in lieu of notice, the EDT will be the actual date the dismissal took effect, plus the amount of statutory notice applicable to the employee, e.g., one week per year of employment, up to a maximum of 12 weeks. If the statutory notice would take the EDT to or beyond 6 April 2024, the new limits are applicable.

    Changes have also taken effect in early April 2024 in relation to the national minimum wage / national living, statutory sick pay and various family-related leave pay rates as also set out in the tables below.

    Employment Tribunal Awards: Changes from 6 April 2024

    Employment Tribunal Award / Statutory Rate  Old Rate New Rate
    One week’s pay for calculating redundancy and the unfair dismissal basic award £643 £700
    Maximum basic award for unfair dismissal and maximum statutory redundancy pay  £19,290 £21,000
    Maximum compensatory award for unfair dismissal £105,707 £115,115
    Maximum total award for unfair dismissal i.e., maximum unfair dismissal compensatory award plus maximum basic award £124,997 £136,115
    Minimum basic award for certain unfair dismissals (including dismissals relating to health and safety and pension scheme trustee duties) £7,386 £8,533
    Statutory sick pay per week £109.40 £116.75

    National Minimum Wage & National Living Wage: Changes from 1 April 2024

    23 and over 21 to 22 18 to 20 Under 18 Apprentice
    Old Rate £10.42 £10.18 £7.49 £5.28 £5.28
    21 and over 18 to 20 Under 18 Apprentice
    New Rate £11.44 £8.60 £6.40 £6.40

    Family-Related Leave Rights Pay Rates: Changes from 7 April 2024

    Old Rate New Rate
    Statutory maternity, paternity, adoption, shared parental and parental bereavement pay £172.48 per week £184.03 per week

    7. Injury to Feeling Awards in Discrimination Cases

    The “Vento Bands” are the levels of compensation that a successful claimant can be awarded for injury to feelings and psychiatric injury in discrimination, harassment and victimisation cases in employment tribunals.

    Although there is theoretically no limit on the compensation that may be awarded in discrimination and harassment cases, employment tribunals must follow official guidelines when making awards for injury to feelings. These guidelines set out three bands of compensation, depending on the seriousness of the discrimination and its effect on the victim.

    The new bands, in respect of claims presented on or after 6 April 2024, are as follows:

    Band Previous Award Range New Award Range
    Lowest band (less serious cases) £1,100 – £11,200 £1,200 to £11,700
    Middle band (cases that do not merit an award in the upper band) £11,200 – £33,700 £11,700 to £35,200
    Highest band (the most serious cases) £33,700 – £56,200 £35,200 to £58,700
    Authors
    More insights

  • Quarterly Sanctions Update | Q1 2024

    Quarterly Sanctions Update | Q1 2024

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Quarterly Sanctions Update | Q1 2024

    April 2024

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The European Union and the United Kingdom continue to tighten sanctions against Russia, particularly in the wake of the second anniversary of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and the sudden death of Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny. In this Quarterly Sanctions Update, we summarise the most recent and significant amendments introduced, or proposed, by the EU and the UK between December 2023 and April 2024.

    The EU amended EU Regulation 833/2014 concerning restrictive measures in view of Russia’s actions destabilising the situation in Ukraine (Regulation 833/2014) on 18 December 2023 (12th Sanctions Package) and 23 February 2023 (13th Sanctions Package). These amendments include new restrictions on the provision of business services to Russian subsidiaries of “partner companies” and new prohibitions on the importation of pig iron, certain precious metals and diamonds from Russia as well as the exportation of advanced technology to Russia. The amendments also include a new prohibition on the provision of software and a new requirement for EU exporters to ensure that their sales contracts related to certain goods contain “no re-export to Russia” obligation. The 12th and 13th Sanctions Packages were further supplemented by the proposal for a Directive on the definition of criminal offences and penalties for the violation of EU’s restrictive measures, the adoption of which is imminent.

    In line with the EU, the UK modified its Russia (Sanctions) (EU Exit) Regulations 2019 (UK Russia Regulations) on 15 and 26 December 2023 and on 1 January and 1 March 2024 (UK Amending Regulations). These measures prohibit the importation of metals and diamonds from Russia as well as the exportation of advanced technology to Russia, and they introduce a new reporting obligation relating to assets of sanctioned persons.

    Regulators continue to add additional individuals and entities to the asset freeze restrictions lists of EU Regulation 269/2014 concerning restrictive measures in respect of actions undermining or threatening the territorial integrity, sovereignty and independence of Ukraine (Regulation 269/2014) and the UK Russia Regulations.

    In depth

    Asset Freeze

    European Union & United Kingdom

    • Persons subject to asset freeze: The EU added more than 200 individuals and 172 entities to its list of persons subject to Regulation 269/2014’s asset freeze prohibitions. The UK followed suit, listing more than 56 individuals and entities under the UK Russia Regulations.

    Import

    European Union & United Kingdom

    • Pig iron and other precious metals: The 12th and 13th Sanctions Packages prohibited pig iron and other precious metal imports from Russia (including, among other things, copper or aluminium, listed in Annex XXI to Regulation 833/2014). The UK Amending Regulations also banned the importation of these goods into the UK (listed in Schedules 3B and 3BA to the UK Russia Regulations) to be read in connection with the Trade Licence authorising the acquisition of the above metals on the London Metal Exchange issued on 15 December 2023.
    • Diamonds: The 12th Sanctions Package prohibited the importation of diamonds and products incorporating diamonds (listed in Annex XXXVIIIA to Regulation 833/2014) from Russia as well as the provision of the related ancillary services. The new prohibition provides an exemption for diamonds that are for the personal use of natural persons who are traveling to the EU or for their immediate family members. The UK Amending Regulations introduced a similar prohibition regarding the importation of these goods into the UK (listed in Schedule 3GA to the UK Russia Regulations).

    Export

    European Union & United Kingdom

    • Advanced Technology: The 12th and 13th Sanctions Packages prohibited the exportation of additional advanced technology goods to Russia (including, among other things, electrical transformers and inductors, electrical capacitors, lithium batteries, thermostats and DC motors, listed in Annexes VII and XXIII to Regulation 833/2014). The UK Amending Regulations introduced a similar prohibition relating to the exportation of these goods from the UK, including computers, smartphones or other electronics (listed in Schedules 2A, 3C and 3E to the UK Russia Regulations).

    Services

    European Union

    • Business services: The 12th Sanctions Package introduced significant changes to the existing prohibition on the provision of business services (including accounting, auditing, bookkeeping and tax consulting, business and management consulting services) and legal advisory services (Restricted Services) to Russian entities.
    • Technical assistance: Providing technical assistance, brokering services and other ancillary services, as well as financing or financial assistance related to the Restricted Services, is now prohibited.
    • Partner countries exemption: The Restricted Services can now only be provided for the exclusive use of entities established in Russia owned by, or solely or jointly controlled by, entities established in the EU, European Economic Area (EEA) or any of the “partner countries” (including the UK, US, Australia, Canada, Japan, New Zealand, Norway, Switzerland and South Korea) until 20 June 2024. Following that date, licences must be obtained from the national competent authorities.

      On 20 February 2024, the German competent authority (Budensamt für Wirtschaft und Ausfuhrkontrolle) issued General Licence No 42, which authorised the provision of the Restricted Services for the exclusive use of entities established in Russia owned by, or solely or jointly controlled by, entities established in the EU, EEA or any of the “partner countries” from 21 June 2024 until 31 May 2025.

      However, on 2 April 2024, the European Commission updated its FAQ on professional services, clarifying that the national competent authorities do not have the power to issue general authorisations covering entire sectors or activities. The Commission also confirmed that operators will need to apply for specific licences in each EU Member State where they provide the Restricted Services. The processing time, information and documents relating to licence applications may vary depending on the EU Member State. For instance, the French competent authority (Direction générale du Trésor) confirmed that operators should use the Téléservice platform to submit the structure chart (in the form of an Excel sheet) indicating the ownership/control of the subsidiary in question and the expected use for each software/service.

    • Software: Providing software for the management of enterprises and industrial management and infrastructure, directly or indirectly, to entities established in Russia is prohibited from 19 December 2023, with derogations applying for contracts concluded before 19 December 2023. On 6 February 2024, the European Commission issued an FAQ on software, clarifying the types of software covered under this prohibition.

    Anti-Circumvention & Enforcement

    European Union

    • “No Russia” clause: The 12th Sanctions Package introduced a requirement applicable to exporters of certain goods and technology (including aviation, firearms and common high priority goods such as integrated circuits and semiconductors) to contractually prohibit re-exportation of their goods to and for use in Russia. On 22 February 2024, the European Commission published an FAQ on “no re-export to Russia” clause. The FAQ features a sample clause that can be used by exporters (including penalties for the breach of the clause and due diligence obligations). It is noteworthy that, following the introduction of the price cap on Russian crude oil, this is the next measure of the EU sanctions against Russia with de facto extraterritorial effect.
    • Non-Russian companies involved in circumvention: The 12th and 13th Sanctions Packages restricted the exportation of EU dual-use and advanced technology to certain entities (listed in Annex IV to Regulation 833/2014) established in the following countries: Armenia, China (including Hong Kong), India, Iran, Kazakhstan, Serbia, Singapore, Sri Lanka, Syria, United Arab Emirates, Uzbekistan, Thailand and Turkey.
    • Reporting on transfers: The 12th Sanctions Package introduced a requirement that affects EU entities with over 40% ownership by Russian entities. These entities must report any fund transfer of funds that they made out of the EU that exceeded EUR 100,000 to their competent authority.
    • Criminalisation of sanctions violations: Shortly after the publication of this Quarterly Sanctions Update, the Council of the EU will adopt the Directive that defines what criminal offences and penalties apply for violating the EU restrictive measures. This will require EU Member States to implement the Directive’s provisions into their national criminal laws within one year. The Directive provides the definitions of sanctions violations and circumvention offences, the applicable penalties as well as the test on when the liability for offences could be attributed to corporates. In line with the existing UK regime, the Directive amends the EU anti-money laundering legislation so that transactions involving property derived from sanction violations would constitute money laundering offences.

    United Kingdom

    • Reporting on frozen assets: The UK Amending Regulations introduced a new reporting requirement applicable to sanctioned persons. The requirement requires such individuals to report their worldwide or UK assets to HM Treasury, as applicable; sanctioned persons must also report any changes to these assets. The UK updated its Russia Guidance to clarify that sanctioned persons must report any change of funds exceeding £10,000.
    • First UK sanctions enforcement after Brexit: On 22 January 2024, the National Crime Agency arrested the former mayor of Sevastopol, Dmitry Ovsyannikov, on suspicion of sanctions violations and money laundering. The charges relate to Ovsyannikov opening a Lloyds Banking Group bank account and then depositing £76,000 into that account.

      This is the first time that UK prosecutors have charged a suspect under the UK sanctions regime post-Brexit. Interestingly, Ovsyannikov, who had been sanctioned by the UK since 2017, had his EU designation previously annulled by the Court of Justice of European Union on 26 October 2022 (Case T-714/20).

      On 23 January 2024, Ovsyannikov pleaded not guilty to all charges. Following a 20 February 2024 hearing, Ovsyannikov’s case will commence on 10 March 2025.

    *Marie Soriano (trainee) contributed to this article.

    Authors

    Raminta Dereskeviciute

    Partner

    London – 22 Bishopsgate

    Sabine Naugès

    Partner

    Paris

    More insights

  • White House Activates $20 Billion IRA Funding Program for Renewable Energy Projects

    White House Activates $20 Billion IRA Funding Program for Renewable Energy Projects

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    White House Activates $20 Billion IRA Funding Program for Renewable Energy Projects

    April 4, 2024

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On April 4, 2024, the White House activated a much-anticipated program meant to catalyze private investment in clean technology across the United States. It will award $20 billion in grant funding to eight recipients under the Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund, making the fund the single largest nontax investment within the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 (IRA) to build a clean energy economy while benefiting communities historically left behind. At least 70% of the capital will flow to low-income and disadvantaged communities and at least 20% will flow to rural communities.

    In depth

    Key Takeaways

    • The White House will award $20 billion in grant funding to eight recipients under the Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund, a green bank that was authorized under the IRA.
    • The grant funding will create a national network of clean technology lenders.
    • At least 70% of the capital will flow to low-income and disadvantaged communities and at least 20% will flow to rural communities.
    • Three of the awardees are nonprofit financing institutions: the Climate United Fund, the Coalition for Green Capital and Power Forward Communities. They will split $14 billion, which will help finance clean technology projects in partnership with private sector investors and developers.
    • Another five awardees – the Opportunity Finance Network, Inclusiv, the Native CDFI Network, Justice Climate Fund and Appalachian Community Capital– will split $6 billion to create hubs that deliver funding and technical assistance to community lenders in low-income and disadvantaged communities.
    • The Biden administration plans to ask grant recipients to track the impacts of their investments, including emission reductions, benefits to communities and private sector capital mobilization.
    • The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) will publish annual reports that disclose information from the awardees to ensure the program is working.
    • Democrats launched the $27 billion Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund to help spur the Biden administration’s plan to slash climate pollution by 50% from 2005 levels by 2030.
    • The Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund has an additional $7 billion for a “solar for all” competition that will award up to 60 grants across the US.

    A Deeper Dive Into the Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund

    The grants will support a national financing network that will fund tens of thousands of climate and clean energy projects across the US, especially in low-income and disadvantaged communities, as part of US President Joe Biden’s Investing in America agenda.

    The Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund advances the Biden-Harris administration’s Justice40 Initiative, which aims for 40% of the overall benefits from certain federal climate, clean energy and other investments to flow to disadvantaged communities that are marginalized by underinvestment and overburdened by pollution. At least 70% of the funds (i.e., more than $14 billion of capital) will be invested in low-income and disadvantaged communities, including historic energy communities that have powered the US for more than a century, communities with environmental justice concerns, communities of color, rural communities and tribal communities, among others.

    The $20 billion in grants will be deployed through eight selected applicants across two separate, complementary programs under the Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund: the $14 billion National Clean Investment Fund (NCIF) and the $6 billion Clean Communities Investment Accelerator (CCIA). Together, the two programs will create a first-of-its-kind national network of mission-driven, community-led financial institutions that will finance various US climate and clean energy projects.

    Through the NCIF, selected applicants will partner with the private sector, community organizations and others to provide accessible, affordable financing for new clean technology projects nationwide. While the EPA required that at least 40% of NCIF funds flow to low-income and disadvantaged communities, each selected applicant significantly surpassed said requirement. Thus, almost 60% of NCIF funds will flow to the communities that need it most. The three NCIF selectees are:

    • Climate United Fund ($6.97 billion award), a nonprofit formed by Calvert Impact that will partner with two US Department of the Treasury-certified community development financial institutions (CDFIs): Self-Help Ventures Fund and Community Preservation Corporation. Together, they will bring a decades-long track record of successfully raising and deploying $30 billion in capital with a focus on low-income and disadvantaged communities. Climate United Fund’s program will focus on investing in harder-to-reach market segments like consumers, small businesses, small farms, community facilities and schools, with at least 60% of its investments in low-income and disadvantaged communities, 20% in rural communities and 10% in tribal communities.
    • Coalition for Green Capital ($5 billion award), a nonprofit with almost 15 years of experience helping establish and work with dozens of state, local, and nonprofit green banks that have already catalyzed $20 billion into qualified projects – and that have a pipeline of $30 billion of demand for green bank capital that could be coupled with more than twice that in private investment. The Coalition for Green Capital’s program will place particular emphasis on public-private investing and will leverage the existing and growing national network of green banks as a key distribution channel for investment, with at least 50% of investments in low-income and disadvantaged communities.
    • Power Forward Communities ($2 billion award), a nonprofit coalition formed by five of the country’s most trusted housing, climate and community investment groups that is dedicated to decarbonizing and transforming American housing to save homeowners and renters money, reinvest in communities and tackle the climate crisis. The coalition members – Enterprise Community Partners, Local Initiatives Support Corporation, Rewiring America, Habitat for Humanity and United Way – will draw on their decades of experience, which includes deploying more than $100 billion in community-based initiatives and investments, to build and lead a national financing program that will provide customized and affordable solutions for single-family and multifamily housing owners and developers, with at least 75% of investments in low-income and disadvantaged communities.

    Through the CCIA, selected applicants will establish hubs that provide funding and technical assistance to community lenders working to finance clean technology projects in low-income and disadvantaged communities, leading to near-term deployment of climate and clean energy projects while building the capacity of community lenders to finance projects at scale for years to come. All of CCIA’s funds will flow to low-income and disadvantaged communities. The five selectees of the CCIA are:

    • Opportunity Finance Network ($2.29 billion award), a nonprofit CDFI intermediary that has been around for more than 40 years and provides capital and capacity building for a national network of more than 400 community lenders (predominantly Treasury-certified CDFI loan funds), which collectively hold $42 billion in assets and serve all 50 states, the District of Columbia and several US territories.
    • Inclusiv ($1.87 billion award), a nonprofit CDFI intermediary that has been around for more than 50 years and provides capital and capacity building for a national network of more than 900 mission-driven, regulated credit unions, which include CDFIs and financial cooperativas in Puerto Rico, that collectively manage $330 billion in assets and serve 23 million individuals across the country.
    • Native CDFI Network ($400 million award), a nonprofit that serves as a national voice and advocate for the more than 60 Treasury-certified native CDFIs, which have a presence in 27 states across rural reservation and urban communities and have a mission to address capital access challenges in native communities.
    • Justice Climate Fund ($940 million award), a purpose-built nonprofit supported by an existing ecosystem of coalition members and a national network of more than 1,200 community lenders to provide responsible, clean energy-focused capital and capacity building to community lenders across the country.
    • Appalachian Community Capital ($500 million award), a nonprofit CDFI with a decade of experience working with community lenders in Appalachian communities, which is launching the Green Bank for Rural America to deliver clean capital and capacity building assistance to hundreds of community lenders working in coal, energy, underserved rural and tribal communities across the US.
    Authors

    Carl J. Fleming

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • Sanctions Update: OFAC Re-Emphasizes Applicability of Sanctions to Non-US Persons

    Sanctions Update: OFAC Re-Emphasizes Applicability of Sanctions to Non-US Persons

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Sanctions Update: OFAC Re-Emphasizes Applicability of Sanctions to Non-US Persons

    April 4, 2024

    Read time: 13 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On March 6, 2024, the US Department of the Treasury’s Office of Foreign Assets Control (“OFAC”), the US Department of Justice (“DOJ”) and the US Department of Commerce (collectively, the “Agencies”) published their latest in a series of Tri-Seal Compliance Notes in which they emphasized that foreign-based persons have an obligation to comply with US sanctions and export controls.[1] The Compliance Note does not reflect any policy change, but serves as a reminder that the Agencies have enforced sanctions and export controls against non-US persons, and highlights that non-US firms should implement measures to mitigate their risk of violating US laws. The Compliance Note also comes just a few months after the issuance of Executive Order (“E.O.”) 14114, which authorizes OFAC to sanction foreign financial institutions that engage in significant transactions with Russia’s military-industrial sector.[2] Below, we focus on the Compliance Note’s description of transactions in which OFAC has asserted authority to bring enforcement actions against non-US persons for sanctions violations and summarize some key implications for non-US fund managers.

    OFAC’s Policy on Enforcement of US Sanctions Against Non-US Persons

    OFAC administers a variety of economic and trade sanctions measures that target foreign governments, private entities and individuals engaged in conduct that is adverse to the national security and foreign policy interests of the United States. OFAC sanctions may require US persons to “block” or freeze the property of designated persons, or refrain from transactions involving certain countries or territories or specific activities, such as dealing in the equity securities of a sanctioned target or providing designated services to persons located in certain jurisdictions. Importantly, OFAC sanctions are based on strict liability, and OFAC may impose a civil penalty for even an unknowing or inadvertent violation.[3]

    Typically, the obligations arising from OFAC sanctions apply to US persons.[4] However, the Compliance Note explains that OFAC’s enforcement authority extends to any non-US person that causes or conspires to cause a US person to “wittingly or unwittingly violate US sanctions,” or engages in evading US sanctions.[5]

    The Compliance Note summarizes the types of violative conduct which will cause OFAC to actively employ its enforcement authority as follows: the obscuring or omitting of a reference to the involvement of a sanctioned party or jurisdiction in a financial transaction involving a US person; misleading US persons into exporting goods to a sanctioned jurisdiction; and routing a prohibited transaction through the United States or the US financial system.[6] To highlight the types of conduct that OFAC may seek to penalize, the Compliance Note describes three recent enforcement actions:

    • Toll Holdings Limited (“Toll”), an international freight forwarding and logistics company headquartered in Australia, settled with OFAC for $6,131,855 for apparent violations of multiple OFAC sanctions programs arising from Toll’s originating or receiving payments through the US financial system in connection with its shipping business that involved North Korea, Iran and Syria — three jurisdictions subject to broad OFAC sanctions — as well as blocked entities.[7] According to OFAC, this action highlights that foreign companies who use the US financial system to engage in commercial activity must take care to avoid transactions with OFAC-sanctioned countries and persons.
    • Alfa Laval Middle East Ltd. (“Alfa Laval”), a UAE-based entity, settled with OFAC for $415,695 for apparent violations of the Iran sanctions program. Alfa Laval procured US-origin storage tank cleaning units on behalf of Iran-based companies, falsely listed a Dubai company as the end-user of the units on export documentation to conceal the ultimate destination of the tanks, and thereby caused a US company to indirectly export the tanks to Iran in violation of sanctions.[8]
    • Swedbank Latvia AS (“Swedbank”), a Latvian-based subsidiary of a Swedish financial institution, settled with OFAC for $3,430,900 for apparent violations of OFAC sanctions on Crimea, relating to Swedbank’s customer’s use of Swedbank’s e-banking platform to send payments to persons located in a sanctioned jurisdiction through US correspondent banks.[9]

    Recent Enforcement Action Against Swiss Financial Institution

    Separately, on March 14, 2024, shortly after publishing the Compliance Note, OFAC announced another enforcement action against EFG International AG (“EFG”), a non-US private banking group based in Switzerland with numerous subsidiaries located throughout the world (including Miami, FL). EFG settled with OFAC for $3.7 million for apparent violations of multiple OFAC sanctions programs.[10] EFG’s subsidiaries processed numerous securities-related transactions and funds transfers through omnibus accounts at US custodians or involving US persons, where those omnibus accounts held sub-accounts for persons located in Cuba or that were beneficially owned by Cuban nationals, or were designated under the Narcotics Trafficking Kingpin or the Russian Harmful Foreign Activities sanctions programs. EFG knew or had reason to know that the sub-account holders were sanctioned under US law, and caused US persons, including its own Miami-based subsidiary, to violate OFAC sanctions by processing the violative transactions without disclosing to their US custodians and other US securities firms that some of the omnibus accounts’ underlying beneficiaries were sanctioned. In some instances, EFG had implemented internal restrictions meant to comply with US sanctions, but failed to notify its US custodians and securities firms about the sanctioned beneficiaries.[11] This recent action against EFG serves as a reminder of the risks inherent in transacting with omnibus accounts where the underlying sub-account holders are undisclosed.

    Criminal Liability

    The above violations of OFAC sanctions resulted in civil monetary penalties. However, where the conduct constitutes a “willful” violation of US sanctions, the DOJ may bring criminal charges. The Compliance Note explains that the conduct prohibited under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (“IEEPA”), which authorizes imposition of sanctions, includes “caus[ing] a violation of any license, order, regulation, or prohibition issued” pursuant to IEEPA, and that willful violations are punishable by imprisonment of up to 20 years and a $1 million fine.[12] As an example of a recent criminal action for sanctions violations, among other charges, the Compliance Note references a criminal action brought by the DOJ in which Binance Holdings Limited (“Binance”), a non-US entity registered in the Cayman Islands that operated a large international cryptocurrency exchange, pled guilty to, among other charges, violations of IEEPA. Binance admitted that it had numerous users located in comprehensively sanctioned jurisdictions, including Iran, and that its cryptocurrency exchange system would cause US users to transact with the users in sanctioned jurisdictions and that it failed to implement controls to prevent such transactions.[13] Binance incurred financial penalties of $4.3 billion for these and other Bank Secrecy Act violations, of which the DOJ credited nearly one billion dollars towards Binance’s settlement with OFAC for violating multiple sanctions programs.[14]

    Foreign nationals may also be subject to criminal prosecution for aiding sanctioned persons in the evasion of US sanctions. In 2022, the DOJ charged a U.K. national, Graham Bonham-Carter, with violations of IEEPA and wire fraud in connection with transactions he conducted in the United States on behalf of an individual who was sanctioned by OFAC.[15] The DOJ alleges that Bonham-Carter was employed by Oleg Deripaska and continued to work for him even after Deripaska was sanctioned by OFAC. Bonham-Carter arranged to make payments for the upkeep of Deripaska’s real estate holdings in the United States and attempted to ship artwork owned by Deripaska from a New York auction house to the UK by misrepresenting the identity of the artwork’s owner.[16] According to the indictment, Bonham-Carter violated Section 1705 of IEEPA, in that his conduct constituted the “[provision of] funds, goods, and services to and for the benefit” of a sanctioned person, as well as the evasion and avoidance of “the requirements of United States law with respect to [OFAC sanctions].”[17] Bonham-Carter was arrested in the U.K. but has not been extradited as of the date of this publication.

    E.O. 14114 Authorizes Secondary Sanctions on Non-US Persons

    In addition to OFAC’s and DOJ’s inherent authority to take enforcement action against non-US persons, the Russian sanctions program was also recently expanded to enable OFAC to sanction foreign financial institutions (“FFIs”) that engage in certain transactions with companies in the Russian military-industrial base. E.O. 14114, issued on Dec. 22, 2023, authorizes OFAC to impose “secondary sanctions” on FFIs that facilitate significant transactions on behalf of designated persons operating in key sectors of the Russian economy that support Russia’s military capability, or that facilitate significant transactions or provide services involving Russia’s military-industrial base.[18] Foreign financial institutions that engage in such transactions may either be prohibited from opening or subject to strict conditions in maintaining correspondent accounts or payable-through accounts in the United States or may be subject to full blocking sanctions.[19] For FFIs that OFAC blocks, “all property and interests in property of those FFIs that are in the United States or in the possession or control of US persons are blocked and must be reported to OFAC.”[20]

    Compliance Considerations

    The Compliance Note provides several key compliance considerations for foreign-based persons, including employing a risk-based sanctions compliance program; establishing strong internal controls for payments involving affiliates, subsidiaries, agents or counterparties to detect “linkages to sanctioned persons or jurisdictions that may otherwise be obscured”; integrating know-your-customer information into sanctions screening protocols; ensuring personnel, subsidiaries and affiliates are trained on US sanctions requirements and can effectively identify red flags and will escalate any potential sanctions violations to management; and taking immediate and effective action when sanctions issues are identified and amending compliance policies to address weaknesses.[21]

    Consistent with OFAC’s recommendations, and in light of recent enforcement actions, a robust compliance program should include screening all investors against OFAC’s sanctions lists prior to onboarding and periodically thereafter, implementing controls to ensure the manager has up-to-date information on the sanctions status of any beneficiaries to omnibus accounts invested in their funds, and taking appropriate measures to ensure no transactions of the fund that are processed through the US financial institution will benefit, directly or indirectly, a sanctioned person.

    Takeaways

    OFAC has made clear that non-US persons cannot assume that US sanctions do not apply to them. Non-US fund managers must be aware that if they interact with the US financial system or take on US investors, they could be subject to an OFAC enforcement action if they cause a US person to violate OFAC sanctions, even inadvertently. Moreover, under the Russian sanctions program, non-US persons that transact with Russian companies operating defense-related industries could be subject to OFAC sanctions themselves. Accordingly, non-US fund managers should implement policies and procedures that are designed to ensure compliance with the Executive Orders, statutes, programs and regulations administered by OFAC, as well as those sanctions programs administered by the authorities of the jurisdictions in which they are located or registered.

    When undertaking any proposed activity or transaction, fund managers should consider the following:

    • Whether the activity will involve US investors by, among other things, requiring their approval or using their assets to make a particular investment;
    • Whether the activity will involve US personnel or US-based third-party service providers;
    • Whether any part of a transaction will be conducted in US dollars, routed through the US financial system, or otherwise involve US-based banks, brokers, or custodians; and
    • Whether the fund, its investors, or its personnel are subject to the sanctions regimes of another jurisdiction.

    Authored by Melissa G.R. Goldstein, Betty Santangelo, Anna Maleva-Otto and Gregoire Devaney.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] US Dep’t of Com., US Dep’t of the Treasury & US Dep’t of Justice, Tri-Seal Compliance Note: Obligations of Foreign-based Persons to Comply with US Sanctions and Export Control Laws (Mar. 6, 2024), available at https://ofac.treasury.gov/media/932746/download?inline (“Compliance Note”). For information on a prior Tri-Seal Compliance Note, see Schulte Alert, Sanctions Update: OFAC Encourages Voluntary Self-Disclosure for Sanctions Violations (Aug. 2, 2023), available at /insights/ofac-encourages-voluntary-self-disclosure-for-sanctions/.

    [2] Executive Order 14114 of Dec. 22, 2023, available at https://ofac.treasury.gov/media/932441/download?inline.

    [3] Compliance Note, at 2.

    [4] For OFAC sanctions purposes, “US person” means all US citizens and permanent resident aliens wherever located, all persons within the United States, and all US-incorporated entities and foreign branches. Compliance Note, at 2. Certain OFAC sanctions programs also apply to foreign persons that are owned or controlled by a US person, including the Iran, Cuba and North Korea sanctions programs. Id. at 2 n.1.

    [5] Compliance Note, at 2.

    [6] Compliance Note, at 3.

    [7] Department of the Treasury, Enforcement Release, “OFAC Settles with Toll Holdings Limited for $6,131,855 Related to Apparent Violations of Multiple Sanctions Programs” (Apr. 25, 2022), available at https://ofac.treasury.gov/media/922441/download?inline.

    [8] Department of the Treasury, Enforcement Release, “Alfa Laval Middle East Ltd. Settles Potential Civil Liability for Apparent Violations of the Iranian Transactions and Sanctions Regulations” (July 19, 2021), available at https://ofac.treasury.gov/media/911521/download?inline.

    [9] Department of the Treasury, Enforcement Release, “OFAC Settles with Swedbank Latvia for $3,430,900 Related to Apparent Violations of Sanctions on Crimea” (June 20, 2023), available at https://ofac.treasury.gov/media/931911/download?inline.

    [10] Department of the Treasury, Enforcement Release, “EFG Settles with OFAC for $3,740,442 for Apparent violations of Multiple Sanctions Programs” (March 14, 2023), available at https://ofac.treasury.gov/media/932766/download?inline.

    [11] Id. at 1–2.

    [12] Compliance Note, at 7–8 (citing 50 USC. § 1705(a)–(c)).

    [13] Compliance Note, at 9 (citing Press Release, Department of Justice, “Binance and CEO Plead Guilty to Federal Charges in $4B Resolution” (Nov. 21, 2023), available at https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/binance-and-ceo-plead-guilty-federal-charges-4b-resolution). In addition to sanctions violations, the charges against Binance also included anti-money laundering compliance failures and unlicensed money transmitting, and DOJ coordinated with US Treasury’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission, as well as OFAC in reaching a $4 billion settlement with Binance. DOJ Press Release, Binance, supra.

    [14] DOJ Press Release, Binance, supra; US Dep’t of the Treasury, “OFAC Settles with Binance Holdings, Ltd. for $968,618,825 Related to Apparent Violations of Multiple Sanctions Programs” (Nov. 21, 2023), available at https://ofac.treasury.gov/media/932351/download?inline.

    [15] Indictment, United States v. Carter, 22 Cr. 503 (S.D.N.Y. 2022); Press Release, DOJ, “U.K. Businessman Graham Bonham-Carter Indicted for Sanctions Evasion Benefitting Russian Oligarch Oleg Vladimirovich Deripaska” (Oct. 11, 2022), available at https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/uk-businessman-graham-bonham-carter-indicted-sanctions-evasion-benefitting-russian-oligarch.

    [16] DOJ Press Release, Bonham-Carter, supra.

    [17] Carter Indictment, ¶¶ 13, 26, supra. The DOJ alleges that the assistance Bonham-Carter knowingly provided to Deripaska violated Executive Orders 13660, 13661, and 13662, and 31 C.F.R. § 589.201 of the Ukraine-/Russia-Related Sanctions Regulations. Id. at ¶ 26.

    [18] E.O. 14114, supra; Press Release, US Dep’t of the Treasury, Statement from Secretary Yellen on President Biden’s Executive Order Taking Additional Steps With Respect to Russia’s Harmful Activities (Dec. 22, 2023), available at https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/jy2011.

    [19] OFAC FAQ 1149 (Dec. 22, 2023), available at https://ofac.treasury.gov/faqs/1149.

    [20] Id.

    [21] Compliance Note, at 10. OFAC also issued guidance for foreign financial institutions on compliance considerations with respect to E.O. 14114 in December 2023, which recommends, among other things, that FFIs review their customer bases, communicate compliance expectations to counterparties, take mitigating steps with respect to high-risk counterparties, ask counterparties to attest that they do not engage in activities covered by E.O. 14114, update sanctions risk assessments to include involvement in Russia’s military-industrial base, and use open-source information as part of due diligence and proactive investigation efforts to identify possible sanctions and export control evasion. OFAC, Sanctions Advisory: Guidance for Foreign Financial Institutions on OFAC Sanctions Authorities Targeting Support to Russia’s Military-Industrial Base (Dec. 22, 2023), available at https://ofac.treasury.gov/media/932436/download?inline.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. © 2024 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP. All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Melissa G.R. Goldstein

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Betty Santangelo

    Counsel

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Gregoire P. Devaney

    Associate

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • CMS Releases CY 2025 Rate Announcement for Medicare Advantage and Part D

    CMS Releases CY 2025 Rate Announcement for Medicare Advantage and Part D

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    CMS Releases CY 2025 Rate Announcement for Medicare Advantage and Part D

    April 2, 2024

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On April 1, 2024, the US Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) released the Announcement of Calendar Year (CY) 2025 Medicare Advantage (MA) Capitation Rates and Part C and D Payment Policies (Rate Announcement). CMS also issued a press release, fact sheet and Part D redesign program instructions. The Rate Announcement is released on an annual basis and includes updates to the capitation and risk adjustment methodologies used to calculate MA plan payments, as well as other payment policies that impact Part D. The Rate Announcement largely finalizes the policies CMS previously proposed in its Advance Notice released on January 31, 2024.

    In depth

    Among other provisions, the Rate Announcement includes the following updates:

    MA Payment Changes/Growth Rates: The effective growth rate for 2025 MA non-end-stage renal disease (ESRD) rates is 2.33%. Accounting for the impact of the benchmark rate cap, MA rebate and other policies, the net impact on the Medicare trust funds for CY 2025 is expected to be $8.8 billion. Payments from the government to MA organizations (MAOs) will increase by 3.70% on average from 2024 to 2025, as finalized in the Rate Announcement. Below is the year-to-year percentage change in MAO payments, which did not significantly change from the 2025 Advance Notice.

    Impact 2024 Advance Notice 2024 Rate Announcement 2025 Advance Notice 2025 Rate Announcement
    Effective Growth Rate 2.09% 2.28% 2.44% 2.33%
    Rebasing/Repricing — 0.00% — 0.07%
    Change in Star Ratings -1.24% -1.24% -0.15% -0.11%
    MA Coding Pattern Adjustment 0% 0% 0% 0%
    Risk Model Revision and Normalization -3.12% -2.16% -2.45% -2.45%
    MA Risk Score Trend 3.30% 4.44% 3.86% 3.86%
    Expected Average Change in Revenue +1.03% +3.32% +3.70% +3.70%

    Part C Risk Adjustment Model: For CY 2024, CMS implemented several changes to the hierarchical condition category (HCC) risk adjustment model, including restructuring the condition categories using the ICD-10 classification system, updating the underlying fee-for-service (FFS) data years, and revising the denominator year that is used in determining the average per capita predicted expenditures to create relative factors in the HCC model. Risk scores for CY 2024 are deduced using a blend of the risk scores calculated with the 2020 CMS-HCC model and those calculated with the 2024 CMS-HCC model. For CY 2025, CMS will continue this phased-in approach, despite pushback from stakeholders, and will calculate CY 2025 risk scores using 33% of the risk score calculated with the 2020 model and 67% of the risk score calculated with the 2024 model. The CY 2025 impact on MA risk scores of the blended models (compared to the blend in CY 2024) will be -2.45%, representing $9.2 billion in estimated net savings to the Medicare trust fund in 2025.

    CMS will use a calculation methodology for normalization factors that more accurately accounts for the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic. The methodology will allow CMS to incorporate recent average FFS risk scores without excluding any years of risk scores and includes using a COVID-19 “indicator flag” to differentiate risk scores that were based on diagnoses from before and after the onset of COVID-19.

    Part D Benefit/Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 (IRA): The Rate Announcement discusses several updates the IRA made for 2025, including:

    • Newly defined Part D benefit design composed of three phases: annual deductible, initial coverage and catastrophic coverage
    • A lower out-of-pocket threshold of $2,000
    • Sunset of the Coverage Gap Discount Program and establishment of the Manufacturer Discount Program
    • Changes to the liability of enrollees, sponsors, manufacturers and CMS.

    As a result of the IRA, CMS finalized updates to the Part D risk adjustment model to reflect the Part D benefit design.

    CMS is required to update the parameters for the defined standard Part D drug benefit annually. This is meant to ensure that the actuarial value of the drug benefit tracks changes in Part D expenses. For non-low-income subsidy beneficiaries, the Rate Announcement outlines the benefit parameters for defined standard benefits in 2025 as follows:

    2024 2025
    Deductible Phase Cost Sharing: 100% Cost Sharing: 100%
    Deductible: $545 Deductible: $590
    Initial Coverage Phase Cost Sharing: 25% Applicable Drugs Cost Sharing: 25% Non-Applicable Drugs Cost Sharing: 25%
    Initial Coverage Limit: $5,030 Initial Coverage Limit: N/A
    Coverage Gap Applicable Drugs Cost Sharing: 25% Non-Applicable Drugs Cost Sharing: 25% N/A
    Out-of-Pocket Threshold: $8,000 Out-of-Pocket Threshold: $2,000

    Source: Rate Announcement, Table V-6. Part D Benefit Parameters for Defined Standard Benefit for CY 2024 and CY 2025 Non-LIS Beneficiaries.

    Part C and D Star Ratings: The Rate Announcement includes the list of measures that will be used to calculate the 2025 Star Ratings, as well as a list of the emergency areas that were affected by emergency declarations in 2023 for purposes of making adjustments under the extreme and uncontrollable circumstances policy. Other updates include:

    • Patients’ Experience and Complaints and Access Measures: CMS reminds stakeholders that, beginning with the 2024 measurement year (for the 2026 Star Ratings), the weight of patients’ experience and complaints and access measures will be reduced to two.
    • Measures Under Consideration (MUC): As discussed in the 2025 Advance Notice, CMS reiterates that it submitted the Initiation and Engagement of Substance Use Disorder Treatment (Part C) and Initial Opioid Prescribing for Long Duration (IOP-LD) (Part D) measures to the 2023 MUC list. The MUC list includes measures that CMS is considering adopting through future rulemaking. CMS states in the Rate Announcement that it is reviewing stakeholders’ feedback regarding other possible measures to propose in the Star Ratings through future rulemaking.
    • Care for Older Adults – Pain Assessment (Part C): Because the National Committee for Quality Assurance (NCQA) has finalized the retirement of this measure for the 2025 measurement year, CMS will remove this measure starting with the 2027 Star Ratings.
    • New Measure Concepts: CMS requested feedback in the Advance Notice on potential new measure concepts for future years, including:
      • Health Outcome Survey (Part C)
      • Blood Pressure Control for Patients with Hypertension (Part C)
      • Breast Cancer Screening Follow-Up (Part C)
      • Social Connection Screening and Intervention (Part C)
      • Chronic Pain Assessment and Follow-Up (Part C)
      • Tobacco Use Screening and Cessation and Lung Cancer Screening and Follow-Up (Part C)
      • Functional Status Assessment Follow-Up (Part C)

    Medicare Plan Finder Drug Pricing Measure (Part D). In the Rate Announcement, CMS discusses feedback regarding the potential new measures, as well as the ongoing work it is undertaking to develop measures in these areas. In most instances, stakeholders requested additional information, raised potential challenges or expressed mixed support with the measure concepts. CMS notes that it will share this feedback with the NCQA and will provide additional information to support any proposals for new display measures in the future.

    McDermott will host a webinar breaking down the policies announced in the Rate Announcement and forthcoming CY 2025 Medicare Advantage and Part D Final Rule. Date and time to be released upon publication of the final rule.

    Authors

    Mimi Alexandre

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Emily R. Curran

    Associate

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • So, you’ve been sued in a labeling class action. Now what?

    So, you’ve been sued in a labeling class action. Now what?

    ARTICLE

    So, you’ve been sued in a labeling class action. Now what?

    Apr 1, 2024

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Many alcohol beverage industry clients are faced with lawsuits attacking product labels. These lawsuits can be frustrating for clients, particularly when the labels at issue were previously approved by the Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau (TTB). But approval by the TTB does not insulate a company from a lawsuit under various state consumer protection and unfair trade practices statutes.

    Try as companies may, even products that purport to conform with US regulations can still be characterized as “misleading” and “deceptive” by crafty and ambitious plaintiffs’ lawyers across the United States. Making matters worse, these lawsuits are typically styled as putative class actions, meaning the cases are brought by one or two alleged purchasers of the product, suing the company on behalf of all US purchasers of any allegedly deceptive product produced by the company, which makes both the defense of these suits as well as the potential damages quite costly.

    An entire cottage industry of plaintiffs’ lawyers in the US focuses on just these types of putative class actions targeting the food, alcohol, beverage and packaged goods industries. Indeed, they file hundreds to thousands of new cases each year. So, what should a company do when facing allegations that a product label is deceptive or misleading?

    In this post, we answer that question and provide an overview of the typical process in one of these cases. We also offer some practical tips to best protect your company if you are facing a threat of a lawsuit or if a class action lawsuit is filed against you.

    BEFORE THE LAWSUIT IS FILED: PRE-SUIT DEMANDS

    Many plaintiffs’ lawyers focused on suing alcohol industry clients send pre-suit demand letters, or letters asking for label changes and lofty payments in exchange for the plaintiff’s lawyer not filing a lawsuit. While one primary purpose of the pre-suit demand letters is to attempt to extort or extract a settlement from a company, there is another common purpose to these pre-suit demands. Many state statutes either require pre-suit notice or otherwise increase the types of recovery a plaintiff can pursue in a lawsuit if the pre-suit notice is served, such as in California.

    If you receive a pre-suit notice demanding changes to your product label and/or payment of money, you should immediately engage a lawyer to step in and represent you. Additionally, a pre-suit notice often includes a demand to preserve documentation and evidence related to the allegations in the demand letter. If such documentation is not preserved, that can create significant issues for companies in a lawsuit.

    The pre-suit notice period also offers an opportunity to persuade the plaintiff’s lawyer that there is no good faith or valid cause of action based on the allegations in their letter. To the extent those efforts are successful, you may avoid a lawsuit altogether. To the extent there is disagreement about the validity of the allegations, the notice period allows time to negotiate a pre-suit resolution on an individual basis which can be much cheaper than defending a nationwide class action. Most pre-suit resolutions require the company to share sales figures related to the at-issue products with the plaintiff’s lawyer before a specific demand will be made for a financial settlement of the case.

    THE LAWSUIT IS FILED

    If you do not receive a pre-suit demand, or if the notice period expires and a lawsuit is filed, you have an obligation to preserve potentially relevant documents, information and records. A lawyer can assist you in identifying what must be preserved.

    In addition, servicing a filed lawsuit on a defendant starts the clock on responding to the complaint that contains the allegations against your company. Depending on the jurisdiction, you could have anywhere from 21 to 30 days to respond to the complaint from the date you were served. An experienced class action litigator can roadmap all the deadlines and strategies to respond to the complaint and prepare a defense strategy to defeat the case.

    One method often employed is a motion to dismiss that challenges the sufficiency and plausibility of the allegations. This motion attempts to end a case early on by informing the court that there is no plausible legal claim that can be sustained based on the allegations against your company. Motions to dismiss are met with varying degrees of success and largely depend on the specific legal and factual allegations at issue in the case. They can, however, be an effective tool to try to end a case before it starts and to frame the issues for the judge and tell the defense story early on.

    THE CLASS ACTION ASPECT OF THE LAWSUIT

    As mentioned above, most of the lawsuits targeting alcohol industry labels are “putative” class actions, meaning they are styled as cases being brought by a few on behalf of all similarly situated consumers. The reason this procedure is utilized is to maximize the potential recovery for the lawyers bringing the lawsuit against the defendant company.

    Retaining a lawyer with experience defending class actions is key to successfully navigating this stressful situation. An often-confusing element of a class action, particularly for companies based in foreign countries who are not as familiar with this procedure under US law, is that a class action involves whether common issues of law and fact predominate over individualized issues of fact or law. That is: Does the common fact, law and question make sense when compared to all of the individual facts, law and answers to those questions such that the class action is a more efficient mechanism than hundreds of consumers each suing individually?

    That is an oversimplification of the class action process, but hey, this is a blog post.

    Any putative class action must be defended both on the merits (did you do the alleged bad thing and was anyone harmed by it) and on the class action basis (are there predominating individualized issues that make a class action inappropriate). Winning the class action battle and avoiding a court certifying a case as a class action can be just as important as a victory on the merits.

    The reality is, if you defeat class certification, the case effectively ends because there is not enough money in the individual consumer’s purchase of various alcohol products to make the case worthwhile for the plaintiffs’ lawyers.

    Take, for example, a consumer who purchased five bottles of high-end liquor at $500/bottle:

    • If the plaintiff was stripped of the total value of all five purchases because of some alleged deception or misleading label, that individual person is out, at most, $2,500.
    • If the amount is doubled or tripled, there isn’t much money in a case like that for the lawyer.
    • But, if a class of 10,000 consumers each experienced harm and damages of $2,500, that’s $25 million (of which the plaintiffs’ lawyers typically take 30 to 40%).

    In other words, defeating class certification often ends a case as swiftly as winning the case on the merits.

    CONCLUSION

    You should avoid getting sued in a class action and avert this mess altogether, if possible. Having excellent alcohol regulatory counsel can help mitigate such risk.

    But what should you do if you receive a pre-suit demand, or you get sued in a class action attacking one of your products? Here are a few practical steps to take:

    • First, engage a lawyer with experience defending class actions.
      • Bonus points if the lawyer has experience with the opposing counsel themselves.
    • Second, make sure you take steps to preserve evidence, information and documents related to the allegations. Your lawyer can help you navigate that.
    • Third, provide notice, or otherwise inform key business stakeholders and any applicable insurance carriers.
    • Fourth, obtain sales figures for the at-issue products for your lawyer to evaluate the general risk to the company in the case, and request a budget to evaluate the costs to defend various stages of the case.
    • Finally, decide whether you want to stand up and fight or attempt to resolve the case. Unfortunately, there can be repeat demands sent by serial filers of these types of cases and settling one may foster a reputation that your company is an easy target for future payouts. Sometimes the right answer is to stand tall and defend the product. An experienced lawyer can help you navigate those difficult decisions.
    Authors

    Daniel Campbell

    Partner

    Chicago

    Alva C. Mather

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    More insights
    Endnotes

  • FDA Clears First OTC Continuous Glucose Monitor

    FDA Clears First OTC Continuous Glucose Monitor

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    FDA Clears First OTC Continuous Glucose Monitor

    March 28, 2024

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On March 5, 2024, the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) granted clearance to market the first over-the-counter (OTC) continuous glucose monitor (CGM). Dexcom’s Stelo Glucose Biosensor System (Stelo) is an integrated CGM (iCGM) designed for individuals 18 years and older who do not use insulin. Previously, CGMs were only available by prescription and were primarily designed for diabetes management. However, CGMs may offer a new avenue for wellness, proactive health monitoring and accessibility to chronic care management – all without a prescription.

    In depth

    Underlying Technology

    A Brief History of CGMs

    A CGM is a wearable technology that enables users to track their blood sugar levels in real time. Historically, individuals with Type 1 or Type 2 diabetes could monitor their blood sugar levels with fingerstick checks. Individuals would prick their fingertips with a small lancet (i.e., a needle) to produce a blood sample. When a blood sample contacts a glucose meter test strip, the meter promptly displays a blood sugar reading. This information helps determine whether glucose levels are too low or too high, which is particularly useful after meals or when taking medications. However, fingerstick checks have several downsides. For example, they provide static reads, meaning individuals must take frequent samples throughout the day to comprehensively measure their blood sugar levels. Additionally, fingerstick checks can be cumbersome and painful.

    CGMs, in contrast, produce reads every five to 15 minutes without any intervention by the user. While CGMs are not new as the FDA first approved them in 1999, Stelo is the first of its kind to be cleared as an OTC device.

    The Stelo Glucose Biosensor System

    Stelo is an OTC CGM that detects glucose levels from the user’s interstitial fluid, which is the fluid just beneath the skin. It calculates glucose readings and provides this information to the user’s digitally connected device, such as a smartphone or smartwatch. However, it is not intended to be paired with insulin devices, such as insulin pens or automated insulin dosing systems.

    Dexcom leveraged the same principles of operation, fundamental design and physical characteristics for Stelo from its most recent G7 CGM system (Predicate Device). The Predicate Device is also an iCGM, but it requires a prescription. Stelo is an OTC advancement that is authorized for marketing via a 510(k) application that was supported, in part, by human factors validation data.

    Stelo consists of the following two subsystems:

    1. Glucose Sensing Subsystem: Wearable and Applicator

    For CGMs, the sensor serves a similar role to the lancet in fingerstick checks. Users insert the small, flexible wire sensor just beneath the skin on the back of the arm using an applicator. An overpatch adhesive secures the sensor in place. The sensor continuously measures glucose levels in the interstitial fluid and converts them into an electric current. The transmitter measures this current and converts it into estimated glucose values, which are then sent to the user’s mobile application.

    2. Mobile Applications Subsystem: iOS and Android Mobile Application (App)

    The App provides user and onboarding tutorials and updates the user on system status (e.g., warm-up period and signal loss), glucose readings and trend graphs.

    Comparison to the Predicate Device

    Stelo has the same hardware design as the Predicate Device (e.g., same sensor, patch, applicator and transmitter hardware). Additionally, Stelo’s transmitter firmware has the same primary responsibilities and capabilities as the Predicate Device but deviates notably by supporting extended wear for 15 days compared to 10 days. Users also cannot manually enter their blood glucose levels in the App. The Stelo System App is available on both iOS and Android platforms. Users can download the App to compatible Bluetooth Low Energy-enabled smart devices (e.g., mobile phones and smartwatches). The App inherited the Predicate Device app’s software development kit, functionality and user interface. However, the Stelo System App deviates from its predecessor in a few ways, notably sending read updates to the App every five minutes, with updated App entries every 15 minutes. Individuals also receive tailored onboarding and “insights,” aka daily reports summarizing glucose levels and sharing related wellness tips.

    OTC CGMs and Beyond

    The FDA’s clearance of the first OTC CGM paves the way for future devices beyond diabetes management and allows individuals to monitor meaningful health data without a prescription. For example, we may see OTC CGMs trend in the fitness industry. OTC CGMs provide real-time data, allowing individuals to understand how their bodies react to workouts and meal plans. This information can guide nutrition choices, optimize workouts and prevent extreme blood sugar fluctuations. Moreover, OTC CGMs may be used as a preventative tool for those with prediabetes. However, the costs related to replacing sensors every 15 days and the challenge of effectively interpreting the data remains uncertain for the broader population who decide to purchase OTC CGMs.

    For more information on CGMs or related developments, contact Jamie Ravitz, Paul Gadiock, Ashley Ogedegbe or any other member of McDermott’s Food, Drug & Medical Device Regulatory Group or Digital Health Group.

    Authors

    James R. Ravitz

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Paul S. Gadiock

    Partner

    San Francisco

    More insights