Content Type: Article

  • CPPA Proposes Accessible Deletion Mechanism Regulations for Data Brokers

    CPPA Proposes Accessible Deletion Mechanism Regulations for Data Brokers

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    CPPA Proposes Accessible Deletion Mechanism Regulations for Data Brokers

    March 4, 2025

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Ahead of its next board meeting, scheduled for March 6 and 7, 2025, the California Privacy Protection Agency (CPPA) released even more proposed regulations, adding to an already full slate of proposed regulations, to amend existing data broker regulations in order to implement the California Delete Act, Cal. Civ. Code § 1798.99.80 et seq. The proposed regulations include specifics regarding the mechanics of a new Delete Request and Opt-out Platform (DROP), the processing of deletion requests, and notification to the CPPA in the event of a data breach associated with a DROP account or system.

    Although the CPPA’s automated decision-making technology, artificial intelligence, and cybersecurity audit regulations are under heavy scrutiny and the composition of the agency and its board have undergone changes, the CPPA is showing no signs of slowing. All data brokers should take stock of the newly proposed regulations and assess their readiness to implement them.

    In depth

    The Delete Act, enacted in 2023, required that the CPPA establish regulations related to a deletion mechanism that allows a California consumer to request that data brokers delete all non-exempt personal information related to that consumer via a single deletion request to the CPPA.

    California consumers must be able to access the DROP by January 1, 2026, and starting August 1, 2026, data brokers will be required to access the DROP every 45 days to obtain and act on consumers’ requests. Where data brokers deny a deletion request because it cannot be verified, they must process the request as an opt out of the sale or sharing of the individual’s personal information.

    The proposed regulations would require data brokers (including those not yet registered but required to register) to create a DROP account prior to operating as a data broker, pay a first-time access fee, and access the DROP within 45 days of commencing operation as a data broker, as well as every 45 days thereafter.

    Under the proposed regulations, in order to process deletion requests, a data broker will have to download consumer deletion request lists and:

    • Compare the consumer identifier information in each consumer deletion list with the applicable consumer personal information in the data broker’s own records.
    • Prior to this comparison, standardize the applicable personal information from the data broker’s records.
    • After completing the standardization, use the same hashing algorithm provided in the consumer deletion list to hash the consumer personal information within the data broker’s records.

    When comparing the data broker’s records to the consumer deletion list, if more than 50% of the unique identifiers match with the same consumer records in the data broker’s records, the data broker must delete all personal information associated with that consumer. The proposed regulations state as an example that if a data broker compares its records with a consumer deletion list that includes name, date of birth, and zip code and only finds a match for the name and zip code with a particular consumer record, the data broker must delete that consumer’s associated personal information because approximately 67% of the individual identifiers match with the consumer deletion list. Based on this example, if a data broker only maintains a consumer’s name, zip code, and date of birth in its records, and there happen to be two California residents who have the same name and reside in the same zip code but have different birth dates, a deletion request from one of those individuals would require the data broker to delete the personal information of the other individual, unless an exemption applies, such as the data was collected directly from the consumer (i.e., is first-party data). If the data broker associates multiple consumers with a matched identifier from the consumer deletion list, the data broker must opt each associated consumer out of the sale or sharing of their personal information, unless an exemption applies.

    The proposed regulations also require a data broker to immediately inform the CPPA in writing through the DROP if there is unauthorized use of the data broker’s credentials or account or a breach of security related to the data broker’s account, the DROP, or information derived from the DROP.

    What’s Next?


    During its board meeting on March 6 and 7, 2025, the CPPA will provide an update on the development and implementation of the DROP and discuss the proposed DROP regulations. Although the agency has yet to initiate the formal rulemaking process for these proposed regulations, companies currently in or planning to enter the data broker space should carefully evaluate their readiness to comply with these proposed regulations.

    If you have questions or would like to discuss any issues addressed in this client alert, contact your regular McDermott lawyer or one of the article’s authors.

    Authors

    David P. Saunders

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • Corporate Transparency Act Penalties Suspended; New Rulemaking Proposed

    Corporate Transparency Act Penalties Suspended; New Rulemaking Proposed

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Corporate Transparency Act Penalties Suspended; New Rulemaking Proposed

    March 4, 2025

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    What Happened?

    On March 2, 2025, and February 27, 2025, the US Department of the Treasury (Treasury) and the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN), a bureau of the Treasury, made significant announcements regarding the Beneficial Ownership Information Reporting Requirements final rule (31 C.F.R. 1010.380) (Reporting Rule) promulgated under the Corporate Transparency Act (CTA) (31 U.S.C. § 5336).

    In depth

    FinCEN announced that that there will be no penalties, fines, or enforcement actions for failing to comply with the new March 21, 2025, deadline to file beneficial ownership information (BOI) reports, which was previously announced on February 18, 2025. FinCEN also intends to further extend reporting deadlines and propose changes to the Reporting Rule later this year “to minimize burden on small businesses while ensuring that BOI is highly useful to important national security, intelligence, and law enforcement activities.”

    Treasury announced that it will not enforce any penalties or fines against US citizens or “domestic reporting companies” or their “beneficial owners” (which are defined in the CTA and Reporting Rule) even after any forthcoming deadline extensions or changes to the Reporting Rule. Treasury plans to issue proposed rulemaking to narrow the scope of the Reporting Rule, applying it only to “foreign reporting companies” (currently defined as a corporation, limited liability company, or other entity formed under the laws of a non-US country and registered to do business in the US by filing a document with a secretary of state or similar office under the laws of a US state, including any US territory, or Indian Tribe.

    What Now?

    1. No Immediate Action Required

    Reporting companies that have not yet submitted BOI reports should consider waiting to submit BOI reports until new guidance is issued by FinCEN/Treasury. No penalties or fines will apply for failing to file BOI reports by the current March 21, 2025, deadline.

    2. No Penalties for US Citizens and Domestic Reporting Companies

    Even after any new deadline extension or rule changes, Treasury will not impose penalties or fines on US citizens or domestic reporting companies (or their beneficial owners) in connection with BOI reporting.

  • 3. Potential Narrowing of Reporting Obligations

    If Treasury’s proposed rulemaking goes into effect, BOI reporting obligations will only apply to “foreign reporting companies” and not “domestic reporting companies” (currently defined as any corporation, limited liability company, or other entity created by filing a document with a secretary of state or similar office under the laws of a US state, including any US territory, or Indian Tribe.

    McDermott will continue to monitor relevant developments. If you have any questions or need advice on the CTA or its application to your business, please contact your regular McDermott lawyer or one of the authors of this client alert.

Authors

Nathan E. Barnett

Partner

Wilmington

Daniel J. Bell

Partner

Washington, DC

More insights

Back to top
  • Key Takeaways | Renewable Energy Developers’ Perspectives

    Key Takeaways | Renewable Energy Developers’ Perspectives

    ARTICLE

    Key Takeaways | Renewable Energy Developers’ Perspectives

    March 4, 2025

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On February 27, 2025, Partner Allison Perlman moderated a panel during Infocast’s ERCOT Market Summit 2025 that examined ongoing changes to the renewable energy development landscape within the Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT). The panelists shared their perspectives on how changes in siting options, price curves, supply chain conditions, interconnection timelines, financial risk tolerance, and new policies and regulations will impact how projects are accomplished in 2025.

    Speakers

    • Sabah Bayatli, President, OCI Energy
    • Devin Gaby, Associate Director, Customized Energy Solutions
    • John Larkey, Vice President, Power Marketing, National Grid Renewables
    • Brooke Malik, Director of Business Development, Lightsource bp
    • Tracy Stoddard, Senior Vice President of Business Development, Acciona Energy
    In depth

    Top takeaways included

    • Escalating electric power demand from the introduction of data centers, new manufacturing, and the influx of residential customers is driving investment in new renewable generation capacity in ERCOT. However, developers remain hesitant to engage, citing increased uncertainty and risk arising from anticipated federal and state regulatory reform of environmental and permitting regulations, decreased investment in infrastructure and emerging technologies, and potential rollbacks of federal tax credits and other incentives.
    • Historically, as other markets faced issues with prices, inflation, and supply chain delays, developers viewed ERCOT as an economically beneficial market due to the absence of such challenges. Now, growing market volatility and regulatory uncertainty present challenges to some developers’ long-term strategy, project financing, and overall outlook on the US and ERCOT market.
    • With ERCOT’s evolving permitting and siting requirements, developers’ strategies are shifting to a project-by-project approach to account for potential setbacks and timeline delays. Offtake agreements are also evolving to reflect the increased division of risk between developers and offtakers resulting from regulatory and market uncertainty.
    • Despite steep load growth projections for 2025 within ERCOT, proposed state legislative initiatives addressing pricing, real-time co-optimization, and siting will impact how many and what loads remain in the queue.
    Authors
    More insights

  • SEC Pumps Fun

    SEC Pumps Fun

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    SEC Pumps Fun

    March 4, 2025

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    While we anticipated a relaxed US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) under the new administration, even the biggest proponents of a lax SEC did not expect a “meme coin” blessing within weeks of a new SEC chair being appointed. On February 27, 2025, the SEC released a “Staff Statement on Meme Coins,” stating that meme coins are not securities (the Statement).

    In depth

    The Statement comes on the heels of a quarter-long period that saw a significant market move into meme coins, price increases, drastic drops, and seemingly weekly stories of meme coins exceeding hundreds of million-dollar market caps. Based on these and other developments, we now expect significant market moves and new players into the popular – often satirical – offerings of meme coins and platforms that make launching meme coins very simple.

    Meme coins are cryptocurrencies that follow trends, employ humor, and try to build a sense of community to attract users and investors. Meme coins currently represent a staggering $56 billion of the total cryptocurrency market cap, with some of them reaching market caps in the multiple billions of dollars. Lately, there also has been a surge of meme coins popularized by protocols such as Pump Fun (which allows users to launch a token without having to seed liquidity) and Clanker (which allows users to launch tokens using natural language on Farcaster). While meme coins are the latest profitability craze for retail investors hoping to make it big, certain data points suggest that only 0.41% of Pump Fun traders realized more than $10,000 in profit.

    The Statement indicates that meme coins do not constitute a “stock,” “note,” “bond,” or “investment contract.” In doing so, the SEC made clear that those who issue meme coins (that fit the SEC’s definition) do not need to register with the SEC.

    The SEC defined a “meme coin” as a type of crypto asset that is “inspired by internet memes, characters, current events, or trends.” The SEC also compared meme coins to collectibles, because meme coins “typically are purchased for entertainment, social interaction, and cultural purposes, and their value is driven primarily by market demand and speculation.”

    First, the SEC states that meme coin purchasers are not making an investment in an enterprise because “their funds are not pooled together to be deployed by promoters or other third parties for developing the coin or a related enterprise.”

    Second, the SEC states that meme coins do not meet an “expectation of profit derived from the efforts of others” because “the value of meme coins is derived by speculative trading and collective sentiment of the market, like a collectible.”

    There have been many public reports of popular meme coin launches that involved alleged market manipulation and “sniping.” Given this Statement, plaintiffs may not be able to rely on an “unregistered sale of securities” claim and instead could need to prove fraud or intentional market manipulation. This would put plaintiffs to their proof to establish actual misconduct – and not just a technical alleged violation of the securities laws which have been unclear for more than a decade.

    The SEC specifically made clear in the statement that “fraudulent conduct related to the offer and sale of meme coins may be subject to enforcement action or prosecution by other federal or state agencies under other federal and state laws.” There are other government enforcement tools to combat fraudulent actions connected with meme coins, including commodities laws and criminal laws such as wire fraud which don’t require proof that the underlying meme coin is a security.

    However, only certain tokens that meet this definition are covered under this Statement. As such, the SEC included certain disclaimer language in the Statement, including that the reasoning does not (i) extend to meme coins that are inconsistent with the Statement’s descriptions or (ii) apply to those who market their token as a “meme coin” to simply evade application of the securities laws. This suggests that there still could be future litigation (brought by the SEC or private plaintiffs) around whether certain cryptocurrencies fall within the “meme coin” category described in the Statement. We suspect there also may be litigation and disputes concerning cryptocurrencies that have some of the “meme coin” properties described in the Statement but have additional properties such as yield-earning opportunities or ties to a particular project team or company. Given the rise in popularity of meme coins, platforms that offer tools to launch meme coins may continue to see an increase in volume, and we expect that certain centralized exchanges may opt to list more meme coins as a result of the Statement.

    On balance, the SEC’s Statement is good for those who issue meme coins and platforms that make them easy to launch. The SEC pumped some fun into the meme coin market, which may lead to some interesting court battles and enforcement actions concerning which cryptocurrencies are covered by this “meme coin” non-securities blessing.

    Authors

    Joseph B. Evans

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    Daniel H. Kaltman

    Associate

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • SB 351 Proposes To Strengthen California CPOM and CPOD Doctrines

    SB 351 Proposes To Strengthen California CPOM and CPOD Doctrines

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    SB 351 Proposes To Strengthen California CPOM and CPOD Doctrines

    March 3, 2025

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On February 12, 2025, Senator Christopher Cabaldon introduced California Senate Bill (SB) 351, which would codify and strengthen California’s existing corporate practice of medicine (CPOM) and corporate practice of dentistry (CPOD) prohibitions. The bill borrows language from the Medical Board of California’s existing guidance on the state’s prohibition against CPOM while adding clarification around certain actions that trigger the CPOM and CPOD prohibitions. SB 351 continues a state-level trend of attempting to limit the influence of private equity and hedge funds in healthcare, seen also in Oregon’s SB 951 and Massachusetts H.5159.

    In depth

    To Whom Would SB 351 Apply?

    SB 351 would apply to two groups: hedge funds and private equity groups.

    The term “hedge fund” includes pools of funds managed by investors for the purpose of earning a return on those funds. SB 351 specifically excludes from the “hedge fund” definition any natural person or entity that contributes to, but does not manage, such fund, along with entities that solely provide or manage debt financing secured by assets of a healthcare facility.

    SB 351 defines “private equity group” to include investors that primarily engage in raising or returning capital, and that invest, develop, or dispose of specified assets. Therefore, this definition also appears to include venture capital funds and certain family offices and could potentially include the venture arms of larger organizations, including innovation investment funds of hospitals and health systems.

    The definitions of both hedge fund and private equity group specifically exclude passive investors in such funds.

    What Actions Would SB 351 Prohibit?

    SB 351 would expressly prohibit private equity groups or hedge funds involved in any manner with a physician or dental practice, including as an investor in the practice or as owner of the assets of the practice, from taking any actions that would interfere with the professional judgment of physicians or dentists in making healthcare decisions, or that would amount to the exercise of control over:

    • Owning patient records
    • Hiring and firing decisions for clinical staff based, in whole or in part, on clinical competency or proficiency
    • Setting the parameters under which a physician, dentist, or practice may enter contractual relationships with third-party payers or other providers
    • Making decisions related to coding or billing procedures
    • Approving the selection of medical equipment and medical supplies.

    Most of the bullet points above are drawn directly from the Medical Board of California’s existing guidance on CPOM. SB 351 would expand on the Medical Board of California’s guidance regarding the need for physicians to make decisions regarding the hiring and firing of physicians by explicitly prohibiting a private equity group or hedge fund from exercising control over contractual relationships with other providers. Interestingly, SB 351 references private equity groups or hedge funds as potential “investors in [a] physician or dental practice.” California’s existing codified CPOM and CPOD prohibitions already prevent nonlicensed professionals from directly investing in physician or dental practices. SB 351’s application to both dentistry practices and physician practices also represents an expansion of the Medical Board of California’s guidance, which has never been formally adopted by the Dental Board of California (although is generally viewed as persuasive authority).

    SB 351 would prohibit a private equity group or hedge fund, or an entity directly controlled by a private equity or hedge fund, from entering an agreement or arrangement that would enable interference with the professional clinical judgment of physicians or dentists. This provision serves to prevent subsidiaries or portfolio companies that do not directly meet the definitions of “hedge fund” or “private equity group” from engaging in any of the actions set forth above. This provision is similar to language that has appeared in past California legislation, including last year’s Assembly Bill 3129. While unclear, this language may call into question certain structures in California that would enable a private equity group or hedge fund to replace a friendly physician upon the occurrence of one or more events.

    Finally, SB 351 would continue the trend in California and elsewhere against the use of restrictive covenants. Under SB 351, any contract involving the management of a physician or dental practice by a private equity group or hedge fund, or the sale of real estate or other assets owned by a physician or dental practice to a private equity group or hedge fund, may not explicitly or implicitly include a noncompetition or nondisparagement clause for a provider in such practice. As currently drafted, the provision purports to allow noncompetition provisions arising from the sale of a business.

    Takeaways

    California has long had some of the strongest CPOM and CPOD prohibitions in the United States, supplemented by the Medical Board of California’s CPOM guidance. SB 351 reiterates the Medical Board of California’s guidance as it relates directly to private equity groups and hedge funds, and supplements that guidance to reflect growing concern about the influence of private equity and hedge fund investments in healthcare. While the Medical Board of California’s guidance has long been considered a helpful source to understand the state’s CPOM prohibition, SB 351’s codification of this guidance would provide the attorney general with mandatory, rather than persuasive, authority to enforce both the CPOM and CPOD prohibitions as they relate to private equity groups and hedge funds.

    Private equity groups and hedge funds should review existing management services arrangements with physician and dental practices to ensure that they do not provide for greater control of the physician practice than SB 351 would permit. They also might consider adding layers of protection into these agreements to make clear that such contracts do not implicitly or explicitly take clinical decision-making responsibilities away from licensed professionals. Additionally, private equity groups and hedge funds should review agreements related to friendly physician arrangements to evaluate the feasibility of existing noncompetition provisions. Even if SB 351 is not signed into law, such entities should be wary of the strong persuasive authority of the existing Medical Board of California guidance.

    *         *         *

    Reach out to one of the authors of this On the Subject or your regular McDermott lawyer(s) to discuss the potential legal implications of SB 351 for your business.

    Authors

    Patrick Zanayed

    Partner

    Chicago

    Stacey L. Callaghan

    Partner

    Chicago

    Larry C. Guess

    Partner

    Chicago

    Travis Jackson

    Partner

    Los Angeles

    Reuben Bank

    Associate

    Los Angeles

    More insights

  • KELVIN_TEST | Congress Extends Certain Telehealth Flexibilities Through March 31, 2025

    KELVIN_TEST | Congress Extends Certain Telehealth Flexibilities Through March 31, 2025

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    KELVIN_TEST | Congress Extends Certain Telehealth Flexibilities Through March 31, 2025

    February 27, 2025

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    KEY UPDATE

    At the close of 2024, US Congress passed a short-term extension of Medicare telehealth flexibilities as part of the American Relief Act, 2025 (ARA). The Medicare telehealth waivers, originally enacted as part of the COVID-19 public health emergency (PHE) and subsequently extended through legislation, were set to end on December 31, 2024. These flexibilities, along with the Acute Hospital Care at Home waiver program, are now set to expire March 31, 2025. The ARA failed to extend other waivers, such as the temporary safe harbor for high-deductible health plans (HDHPs) to provide first-dollar coverage of telehealth without interfering with health savings account (HSA) eligibility. While the short-term extension provides continued access to telehealth for Medicare patients, stakeholders should continue to engage with Congress for a more permanent solution.

    WHY IT MATTERS

    The ARA extension is limited to certain Medicare policies and is only effective through March 31, 2025. Some bipartisan policies, such as the extension of the telehealth HDHP safe harbor, were not included in the ARA. Additionally, the flexibilities related to coverage of cardiac and pulmonary rehabilitation services provided via telehealth were not extended.

    The extension indicates bipartisan support for continuing coverage for telehealth services, but the short timeline warrants continued stakeholder engagement for the extension and eventual permanence of the Medicare telehealth flexibilities and reinstatement of the HDHP safe harbor. As the new administration takes office, it is unclear where telehealth will fall on the list of priorities.

    In depth

    Historically, Medicare has provided coverage for telehealth services in instances where patients would otherwise be geographically distant from approved providers (e.g., physicians, nurse practitioners, and clinical psychologists). Section 1834(m) of the Social Security Act provides that telehealth services are covered if the beneficiary is seen:

    • At an approved “originating site” (e.g., physician office, hospital, or skilled nursing facility) that is located within a rural health professional shortage area that is either outside of a metropolitan statistical area (MSA), in a rural census tract, or in a county outside of an MSA
    • By an approved provider
    • For a defined set of services
    • Using certain telecommunications technologies.

    See more

    Authors

    Grayson I. Dimick

    Associate

    Washington, DC

    Stacey L. Callaghan

    Partner

    Chicago

    Amanda Enyeart

    Partner

    Chicago

    Marshall E. Jackson , Jr.

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Lisa Mazur

    Partner

    Chicago

    Sarah G. Raaii

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • Congress Extends Certain Telehealth Flexibilities Through March 31, 2025 Second

    Congress Extends Certain Telehealth Flexibilities Through March 31, 2025 Second

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Congress Extends Certain Telehealth Flexibilities Through March 31, 2025 Second

    February 27, 2025

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    KEY UPDATE

    At the close of 2024, US Congress passed a short-term extension of Medicare telehealth flexibilities as part of the American Relief Act, 2025 (ARA). The Medicare telehealth waivers, originally enacted as part of the COVID-19 public health emergency (PHE) and subsequently extended through legislation, were set to end on December 31, 2024. These flexibilities, along with the Acute Hospital Care at Home waiver program, are now set to expire March 31, 2025. The ARA failed to extend other waivers, such as the temporary safe harbor for high-deductible health plans (HDHPs) to provide first-dollar coverage of telehealth without interfering with health savings account (HSA) eligibility. While the short-term extension provides continued access to telehealth for Medicare patients, stakeholders should continue to engage with Congress for a more permanent solution.

    WHY IT MATTERS

    The ARA extension is limited to certain Medicare policies and is only effective through March 31, 2025. Some bipartisan policies, such as the extension of the telehealth HDHP safe harbor, were not included in the ARA. Additionally, the flexibilities related to coverage of cardiac and pulmonary rehabilitation services provided via telehealth were not extended.

    The extension indicates bipartisan support for continuing coverage for telehealth services, but the short timeline warrants continued stakeholder engagement for the extension and eventual permanence of the Medicare telehealth flexibilities and reinstatement of the HDHP safe harbor. As the new administration takes office, it is unclear where telehealth will fall on the list of priorities.

     

    In depth

    Historically, Medicare has provided coverage for telehealth services in instances where patients would otherwise be geographically distant from approved providers (e.g., physicians, nurse practitioners, and clinical psychologists). Section 1834(m) of the Social Security Act provides that telehealth services are covered if the beneficiary is seen:

    • At an approved “originating site” (e.g., physician office, hospital, or skilled nursing facility) that is located within a rural health professional shortage area that is either outside of a metropolitan statistical area (MSA), in a rural census tract, or in a county outside of an MSA
    • By an approved provider
    • For a defined set of services
    • Using certain telecommunications technologies.

    Many of these Medicare restrictions regarding coverage and payment for telehealth services were waived via authority delegated in the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act. Congress subsequently extended the waivers in other pieces of legislation, including the Consolidated Appropriations Act (CAA) 2022 and CAA 2023, with the flexibilities most recently set to expire on December 31, 2024.

    The ARA extended the following Medicare flexibilities through March 31, 2025:

    • Geographic restrictions and originating sites. Patients’ homes will continue to serve as eligible originating sites for all telehealth services (ARA § 3207(a)(2)). Geographic restrictions also remain waived (ARA § 3207(a)(1)).
    • Eligible practitioners. The expanded definition of the term “practitioner” will continue to apply. The expanded definition includes qualified occupational therapists, physical therapists, speech-language pathologists, and audiologists (ARA § 3207(b)).
    • Audio-only. Audio-only telehealth services remain eligible for reimbursement (ARA § 3207(e)).
    • Extending telehealth services for federally qualified health centers (FQHCs) and rural health clinics (RHCs). The US Department of Health and Human Services will cover telehealth services furnished via FQHCs and RHCs to eligible individuals (ARA § 3207(c)).
    • In-person requirements for mental health. The in-person requirement for mental health care to be reimbursed under Medicare has been delayed until April 1, 2025 (ARA § 3207(d)(1)).
    • Telehealth for hospice. Telehealth can continue to be used for the required face-to-face encounter prior to the recertification of a patient’s eligibility for hospice care (ARA § 3207(f)).

    The ARA also extended the Acute Hospital Care at Home waiver program through March 31, 2025. In the midst of the PHE, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) used its PHE flexibilities to issue waivers to certain Medicare hospital conditions of participation (CoPs). These waivers, along with the PHE-related telehealth flexibilities, allowed Medicare-certified hospitals to furnish inpatient-level care in patients’ homes. Addressing hospital bed capacity during the pandemic was a high priority for CMS. These waivers and flexibilities, collectively referred to as the AHCAH Initiative, included:

    • Waiver of the CoP requiring nursing services to be provided on-premises 24 hours a day, seven days a week.
    • Waiver of the CoP requiring immediate on-premises availability of a registered nurse for care of any patient.
    • Waiver of CoPs that define structural and physical environment criteria specific to the hospital setting.
    • Telehealth flexibility allowing the home or temporary residence of an individual to serve as an originating telehealth site.
    • Telehealth flexibility allowing a hospital to use remote clinician services in combination with in-home nursing services to provide inpatient-level care in the patient’s home.

    As with the Medicare telehealth flexibilities, these had been previously extended through December 31, 2024.

    Notable flexibilities that expired or were absent from the ARA include the following:

    • The telehealth safe harbor for HDHPs. The CARES Act created a temporary safe harbor that permitted HDHPs to cover telehealth and remote care services on a first-dollar basis without jeopardizing eligibility for HSA contributions. By permitting health plans to provide HDHP participants coverage for telehealth services without requiring them to first meet the minimum required deductible, the safe harbor increased access to telehealth services. Additionally, covered individuals who received these services were still able to make or receive contributions to their HSAs because telehealth services were temporarily disregarded in determining eligibility for HSA contributions. Previously, the telehealth HDHP safe harbor ceased for three months from January 1, 2022, to March 31, 2022, before the CAA 2022 renewed it. Most recently extended by the CAA 2023, the telehealth safe harbor for HDHPs expired on December 31, 2024. Starting on January 1, 2025, health plans, insurers, and health plan vendors that previously relied on the telehealth HDHP safe harbor may need to update telehealth coverage for HDHP participants, such as updating plan design and/or cost sharing, to prevent disqualifying HDHP participants from making or receiving HSA contributions.
    • The SPEAK Act, which would establish a task force to improve access to health IT for non-English speakers.
    • The PREVENT DIABETES Act, which would broaden access to diabetes prevention services through the Medicare Diabetes Prevention Program.
    • The Sustainable Cardiopulmonary Rehabilitation Services in the Home Act, which would permanently codify cardiopulmonary rehabilitation Medicare telehealth flexibilities.

    With the March 31, 2025, deadline in the not-too-distant future, stakeholders should continue to engage with Congress regarding an extension and permanent solution for the telehealth flexibilities, reinstatement of flexibilities that expired, and inclusion of the other bipartisan telehealth policies that were not included in the final ARA.

     

    Authors

    Grayson I. Dimick

    Associate

    Washington, DC

    Stacey L. Callaghan

    Partner

    Chicago

    Amanda Enyeart

    Partner

    Chicago

    Marshall E. Jackson , Jr.

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Lisa Mazur

    Partner

    Chicago

    Sarah G. Raaii

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • MARVIE_TEST | Congress Extends Certain Telehealth Flexibilities Through March 31, 2025

    MARVIE_TEST | Congress Extends Certain Telehealth Flexibilities Through March 31, 2025

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    MARVIE_TEST | Congress Extends Certain Telehealth Flexibilities Through March 31, 2025

    February 27, 2025

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    KEY UPDATE

    At the close of 2024, US Congress passed a short-term extension of Medicare telehealth flexibilities as part of the American Relief Act, 2025 (ARA). The Medicare telehealth waivers, originally enacted as part of the COVID-19 public health emergency (PHE) and subsequently extended through legislation, were set to end on December 31, 2024. These flexibilities, along with the Acute Hospital Care at Home waiver program, are now set to expire March 31, 2025. The ARA failed to extend other waivers, such as the temporary safe harbor for high-deductible health plans (HDHPs) to provide first-dollar coverage of telehealth without interfering with health savings account (HSA) eligibility. While the short-term extension provides continued access to telehealth for Medicare patients, stakeholders should continue to engage with Congress for a more permanent solution.

    WHY IT MATTERS

    The ARA extension is limited to certain Medicare policies and is only effective through March 31, 2025. Some bipartisan policies, such as the extension of the telehealth HDHP safe harbor, were not included in the ARA. Additionally, the flexibilities related to coverage of cardiac and pulmonary rehabilitation services provided via telehealth were not extended.

    The extension indicates bipartisan support for continuing coverage for telehealth services, but the short timeline warrants continued stakeholder engagement for the extension and eventual permanence of the Medicare telehealth flexibilities and reinstatement of the HDHP safe harbor. As the new administration takes office, it is unclear where telehealth will fall on the list of priorities.

    In depth

    Historically, Medicare has provided coverage for telehealth services in instances where patients would otherwise be geographically distant from approved providers (e.g., physicians, nurse practitioners, and clinical psychologists). Section 1834(m) of the Social Security Act provides that telehealth services are covered if the beneficiary is seen:

    • At an approved “originating site” (e.g., physician office, hospital, or skilled nursing facility) that is located within a rural health professional shortage area that is either outside of a metropolitan statistical area (MSA), in a rural census tract, or in a county outside of an MSA
    • By an approved provider
    • For a defined set of services
    • Using certain telecommunications technologies.

    Many of these Medicare restrictions regarding coverage and payment for telehealth services were waived via authority delegated in the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act. Congress subsequently extended the waivers in other pieces of legislation, including the Consolidated Appropriations Act (CAA) 2022 and CAA 2023, with the flexibilities most recently set to expire on December 31, 2024.

    The ARA extended the following Medicare flexibilities through March 31, 2025:

    • Geographic restrictions and originating sites. Patients’ homes will continue to serve as eligible originating sites for all telehealth services (ARA § 3207(a)(2)). Geographic restrictions also remain waived (ARA § 3207(a)(1)).
    • Eligible practitioners. The expanded definition of the term “practitioner” will continue to apply. The expanded definition includes qualified occupational therapists, physical therapists, speech-language pathologists, and audiologists (ARA § 3207(b)).
    • Audio-only. Audio-only telehealth services remain eligible for reimbursement (ARA § 3207(e)).
    • Extending telehealth services for federally qualified health centers (FQHCs) and rural health clinics (RHCs). The US Department of Health and Human Services will cover telehealth services furnished via FQHCs and RHCs to eligible individuals (ARA § 3207(c)).
    • In-person requirements for mental health. The in-person requirement for mental health care to be reimbursed under Medicare has been delayed until April 1, 2025 (ARA § 3207(d)(1)).
    • Telehealth for hospice. Telehealth can continue to be used for the required face-to-face encounter prior to the recertification of a patient’s eligibility for hospice care (ARA § 3207(f)).

    The ARA also extended the Acute Hospital Care at Home waiver program through March 31, 2025. In the midst of the PHE, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) used its PHE flexibilities to issue waivers to certain Medicare hospital conditions of participation (CoPs). These waivers, along with the PHE-related telehealth flexibilities, allowed Medicare-certified hospitals to furnish inpatient-level care in patients’ homes. Addressing hospital bed capacity during the pandemic was a high priority for CMS. These waivers and flexibilities, collectively referred to as the AHCAH Initiative, included:

    • Waiver of the CoP requiring nursing services to be provided on-premises 24 hours a day, seven days a week.
    • Waiver of the CoP requiring immediate on-premises availability of a registered nurse for care of any patient.
    • Waiver of CoPs that define structural and physical environment criteria specific to the hospital setting.
    • Telehealth flexibility allowing the home or temporary residence of an individual to serve as an originating telehealth site.
    • Telehealth flexibility allowing a hospital to use remote clinician services in combination with in-home nursing services to provide inpatient-level care in the patient’s home.

    As with the Medicare telehealth flexibilities, these had been previously extended through December 31, 2024.

    Notable flexibilities that expired or were absent from the ARA include the following:

    • The telehealth safe harbor for HDHPs. The CARES Act created a temporary safe harbor that permitted HDHPs to cover telehealth and remote care services on a first-dollar basis without jeopardizing eligibility for HSA contributions. By permitting health plans to provide HDHP participants coverage for telehealth services without requiring them to first meet the minimum required deductible, the safe harbor increased access to telehealth services. Additionally, covered individuals who received these services were still able to make or receive contributions to their HSAs because telehealth services were temporarily disregarded in determining eligibility for HSA contributions. Previously, the telehealth HDHP safe harbor ceased for three months from January 1, 2022, to March 31, 2022, before the CAA 2022 renewed it. Most recently extended by the CAA 2023, the telehealth safe harbor for HDHPs expired on December 31, 2024. Starting on January 1, 2025, health plans, insurers, and health plan vendors that previously relied on the telehealth HDHP safe harbor may need to update telehealth coverage for HDHP participants, such as updating plan design and/or cost sharing, to prevent disqualifying HDHP participants from making or receiving HSA contributions.
    • The SPEAK Act, which would establish a task force to improve access to health IT for non-English speakers.
    • The PREVENT DIABETES Act, which would broaden access to diabetes prevention services through the Medicare Diabetes Prevention Program.
    • The Sustainable Cardiopulmonary Rehabilitation Services in the Home Act, which would permanently codify cardiopulmonary rehabilitation Medicare telehealth flexibilities.

    With the March 31, 2025, deadline in the not-too-distant future, stakeholders should continue to engage with Congress regarding an extension and permanent solution for the telehealth flexibilities, reinstatement of flexibilities that expired, and inclusion of the other bipartisan telehealth policies that were not included in the final ARA.

    Authors

    Grayson I. Dimick

    Associate

    Washington, DC

    Stacey L. Callaghan

    Partner

    Chicago

    Amanda Enyeart

    Partner

    Chicago

    Marshall E. Jackson , Jr.

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Lisa Mazur

    Partner

    Chicago

    Sarah G. Raaii

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • SEC’s Division of Corporation Finance Says Meme Coins Are Not Securities

    SEC’s Division of Corporation Finance Says Meme Coins Are Not Securities

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    SEC’s Division of Corporation Finance Says Meme Coins Are Not Securities

    March 3, 2025

    Read time: 10 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On Feb. 27, 2025, the SEC’s Division of Corporation Finance (“Division”) issued guidance that meme coins — defined as speculative crypto assets inspired by internet memes, cultural trends, or social media phenomena — do not constitute securities under federal securities laws.[1] However, the Division’s guidance, which does not bind the Commission, was met with swift opposition from Commissioner Caroline A. Crenshaw, who criticized the guidance as “an incomplete, unsupported view of the law” and warned that it suggests, without sufficient legal basis, that an entire category of assets falls outside the SEC’s jurisdiction.[2]

    Although it does not have the force of law (e.g., it is not an act of Congress or the result of a judicial decision), the Division’s guidance is encouraging to many.[3] The statement does not resolve the regulatory uncertainty regarding crypto assets (including meme coins), but we expect formal Commission guidance on that topic in the near future.

    The Division’s Meme Coin Guidance

    The Division defined meme coins as those that “do not generate a yield or convey rights to future income, profits, or business assets.” Meme coins, according to the Division, are “typically purchased for entertainment, social interaction, and cultural purposes,” and are akin to collectibles. Their value, the Division argues, is primarily driven by speculative trading and market sentiment rather than any expectation of profits derived from a common enterprise or the efforts of others — factors central to the Howey test for determining whether an asset is a security. The Division opined that these meme coins do not qualify as “securities” under any definition in the Securities Act of 1933 (“Securities Act”) or the Securities Exchange Act of 1934.[4]

    Because they are not “securities,” the Division reasoned that participants in the offer or sale of meme coins are not required to register their transactions with the SEC under the Securities Act or seek an exemption from registration. While this determination is not binding on the Commission, it will make it more difficult for another government agency to classify meme coins as securities. It also does not shield fraudulent or other unlawful activity involving meme coins from enforcement actions, including by the DOJ, CFTC, FinCEN, and state and foreign regulators, and it does not prevent a court from determining that meme coins are securities.

    The Division’s stance comes with an important caveat: tokens that do not demonstrate the characteristics of meme coins and those that are marketed as “meme coins” to sidestep securities laws — but that functionally resemble securities — will still be evaluated based on their economic realities, not their labels. Participants should continue to exercise caution in evaluating whether a particular coin qualifies as a meme coin under the guidance.

    Commissioner Crenshaw’s Criticism

    Commissioner Crenshaw — the only Democrat on the SEC’s current three-person Commission — strongly opposed the Division’s guidance, arguing that it raises “more questions than it answers” about what qualifies as a meme coin and whether such a category has any meaningful legal distinction.

    She criticized the guidance as a potential loophole for promoters seeking to circumvent the Howey test, arguing that, in reality, “meme coins, like any financial product, are issued to make money.” Crenshaw emphasized that the market exists on a continuum, with some meme coins being tied to fraudulent schemes and some functioning similarly to traditional securities. She concluded that Howey’s individualized inquiry “cannot be reconciled” with the Division’s broad determination that meme coins are “generally not securities.”[5]

    Takeaways

    We expect continued formal and informal guidance from the SEC on meme coins and crypto more broadly. While the Division’s guidance should create new opportunities to offer, trade and list meme coins (on exchanges or other platforms), Commissioner Crenshaw’s sharp criticism of the Division’s guidance highlights that the SEC’s overall position on crypto remains unsettled. In addition, while the guidance does indicate that the SEC will not be particularly focused on meme coins, at the same time it may also bolster the CFTC’s nexus; if not a security, meme coins may be classified as commodities. While the CFTC’s direct jurisdiction would then only cover meme coin derivatives, it could also utilize its general anti-fraud and anti-manipulation authority over spot commodities for the meme coins themselves.

    To mitigate risks and ensure regulatory compliance, firms should:

    • Stay ahead of evolving regulations by maintaining rigorous compliance protocols.
    • Evaluate whether investing in speculative assets, like meme coins, is consistent with the firm’s investment strategy and disclosures.
    • Conduct legal assessments of tokens to determine potential classification as securities.
    • Maintain thorough records of crypto transactions.
    • Vet counterparties, platforms, and custodians rigorously to minimize exposure to regulatory scrutiny.

    Authored by Stephanie Breslow, Craig Warkol, John Nowak, Jake Preiserowicz and Kolby Loft.

    For assistance in navigating the CTA and Reporting Rule’s reporting requirements, please contact one of the authors or your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel.


    [1] See SEC Division of Corporation Finance, “Staff Statement on Meme Coins” (Feb. 27, 2025).

    [2] Caroline A. Crenshaw, “Response to Staff Statement on Meme Coins: What Does it Meme?” (Feb. 27, 2025).

    [3] The Division’s guidance follows the Commission’s decision to dismiss its enforcement action against Coinbase. See Joint Stipulation to Dismiss, and Releases at 1, SEC v. Coinbase, No. 23-cv-4738 (S.D.N.Y. Feb. 27, 2025); Press Release, SEC Announces Dismissal of Civil Enforcement Action Against Coinbase (Feb. 27, 2025). 

    [4] See SEC Division of Corporation Finance, “Staff Statement on Meme Coins” (Feb. 27, 2025), available at https://www.sec.gov/newsroom/speeches-statements/staff-statement-meme-coins?utm_medium=email&utm_source=govdelivery.

    [5] Id.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. © 2025 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP. All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Stephanie R. Breslow

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    John P. Nowak

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • SCOTUS: Trademark Infringement Damages Award Includes Only the Named Defendant’s Profits

    SCOTUS: Trademark Infringement Damages Award Includes Only the Named Defendant’s Profits

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    SCOTUS: Trademark Infringement Damages Award Includes Only the Named Defendant’s Profits

    February 28, 2025

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In a unanimous decision, the Supreme Court of the United States vacated and remanded a damages award for willful infringement under the Lanham Act (15 U.S.C. § 1117(a)) in Dewberry Group Inc. v. Dewberry Engineers Inc., holding that “defendant’s profits” is limited to the profits of the defendant named in the suit. The Supreme Court found that the appellate court erred in including the defendant’s affiliated companies in its calculation of “defendant’s profits.”

    Justice Elena Kagan delivered the unanimous opinion with Justice Sonia Sotomayor concurring in judgment. The Court noted that its decision was limited to the holding that the lower courts did not invoke the so-called just-sum provision of Section 1117(a) when calculating defendant’s profits and erred in treating the defendant and its affiliates as a single entity when the affiliates were not defendants to the case.

    On remand, the lower court may still decide whether and how a court can use the just-sum provision, if the petitioner forfeited their just-sum argument, whether a court can determine a defendant’s true financial gain by looking at their tax or accounting records, and whether the petitioner can pierce the corporate veil to assess a profits award.

    In depth

    Background

    Dewberry Engineers is a real estate company that owns a registered trademark for “Dewberry.” Dewberry Engineers previously sued and reached a settlement with another real estate company, Dewberry Group, for trademark infringement. However, Dewberry Group resumed use of “Dewberry” when it rebranded, leading to the current dispute. The lower courts found that Dewberry Group had willfully infringed, which was not at issue before the Supreme Court.

    After finding willful infringement, the district court awarded Dewberry Engineers $43 million as “defendant’s profits” under Section 1117(a), which provides a plaintiff with remedies for violations of its trademark rights, subject to the principles of equity, including a disgorgement of defendant’s profits. In calculating the $43 million, the district court considered Dewberry Group’s corporate structure and lack of profits attributed to the named defendant. John Dewberry owns Dewberry Group, which provides all necessary business services at below-market rates to about 30 affiliated companies (all of which John Dewberry commonly owns as well). Dewberry Group operates at a loss while its affiliates, despite having no employees to manage the operations, generated tens of millions of dollars in profit. To keep Dewberry Group afloat, John Dewberry provided occasional cash infusions. The district court found that Dewberry Group’s profits therefore “show up exclusively on the [property-owning affiliates’] books” and treated Dewberry Group and its affiliates as a single entity when calculating profits. The district court reasoned that this method prevented Dewberry Group from escaping liability. Dewberry Group appealed.

    The US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit affirmed, similarly reasoning that treating the affiliates as a single entity with Dewberry Group prevented the manipulation of corporate formalities to avoid financial consequences. However, one judge dissented, indicating he “would have held the District Court had no authority, in calculating a defendant’s profits, to simply add the revenues [of] non-parties.” Dewberry Group sought certiorari.

    The Supreme Court granted certiorari to determine whether “defendant’s profits” awarded under Section 1117(a) includes profits ascribable to a defendant’s affiliates who are not parties against whom relief is sought.

    Opinion of the Supreme Court

    The Supreme Court held that district courts can only award profits ascribable to the named defendant when calculating “defendant’s profits” under Section 1117(a). The Court defined a “defendant” as “the party against whom relief or recovery is sought in an action or suit,” citing Black’s Law Dictionary. Section 1117(a), therefore, does not provide for disgorging a defendant’s affiliates’ profits. Consequently, the Court found that the plaintiff only named Dewberry Group as the defendant, so only Dewberry Group’s profits could be considered.

    The Court reasoned that corporate law also supports construing “defendant” to mean only the corporate entity named. Even when entities are affiliated, corporate law treats “separately incorporated organizations [as] separate legal units with distinct rights and obligations” (internal citations omitted). The Court noted that piercing the corporate veil is possible in certain situations, but Dewberry Engineers conceded that it never raised the argument.

    Further, the Court was unconvinced by Dewberry Engineers’ argument that the lower courts properly relied on the just-sum provision of Section 1117(a) when considering the affiliates’ profits in its calculation of defendant’s profits. The just-sum provision requires a court to take two steps: assess the defendant’s profits and consider evidence, such as the affiliates’ profits, to determine if “a different figure better reflects the defendant’s true financial gain” (internal citations omitted). The Supreme Court found that the district court did not rely on the just-sum provision nor undertake the necessary two-step analysis. The district court merely added all of the affiliates’ profits without indicating that it was departing from Dewberry Group’s profits to better reflect Dewberry Group’s true financial gain. Additionally, the Supreme Court opined that if the district court had relied on the just-sum provision, it would have needed to specifically determine which affiliates’ profits were attributable to Dewberry Group and “could not plausibly have concluded that all of them were.” Like the district court, the Fourth Circuit did not rely on the just-sum provision.

    Although agreeing there was cause for concern that corporate formalities can shield defendants from liability, the Supreme Court held that the lower courts erred and acted beyond the bounds of Section 1117(a) by awarding non-defendants’ profits. The Court emphasized that its decision is limited to holding that the lower courts erred in treating “Dewberry Group and its affiliates as a single entity in calculating the ‘defendant’s profits.’” The Court left several questions unanswered for the lower courts to potentially decide on remand; namely:

    • Whether Dewberry Engineers’ interpretation of the just-sum provision is correct and whether Dewberry Engineers forfeited said argument
    • Whether and how courts can use the just-sum provision
    • Whether courts can determine a defendant’s true financial gain by looking at their tax or accounting records without the just-sum provision
    • Whether the petitioner can pierce the corporate veil on remand.

    Concurrence

    Justice Sotomayor filed a concurrence to “underscore that principles of corporate separateness do not blind courts to economic realities” but agreed with the opinion’s outcome. As an example of how defendant’s profits could be calculated, Justice Sotomayor explained that a court could consider what a defendant would have earned in an arms-length deal rather than what the defendant earned by providing below-market rates. Justice Sotomayor suggested finding guidance in the tax context, where a taxpayer is prevented from assigning economic gains to another party in a scheme to avoid taxes. Justice Sotomayor also suggested that the amount of cash infusions provided by the common owner could be considered in determining defendant’s profits without impermissibly awarding affiliates’ profits. Lastly, Justice Sotomayor emphasized that principles of equity underlie the purpose of the Lanham Act, and courts should not “close their eyes to the practical realties in calculating defendant’s profits.

    Practice Note: Plaintiffs should take care when naming applicable affiliates as defendants or, at the very least, raise the arguments offered by Justice Sotomayor in the concurrence or attempt to pierce the corporate veil.

    Authors

    Sarah Bro

    Partner

    Orange County, Los Angeles

    Ashley K. Justice

    Associate

    Chicago

    More insights