ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
LabCFTC Releases Primer on Virtual Currencies without Broadly Addressing Blockchain Tokens
November 13, 2017
Read time: 7 min
On October 17, 2017, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s LabCFTC released “A CFTC Primer on Virtual Currencies.” The Primer provides an overview or virtual currencies and their potential uses, discusses the role of CFTC in virtual currencies and the scope of its jurisdiction, and notes the risks associated with virtual currencies. However, the Primer does not offer insight on the breadth of the definition of “virtual currency” or which blockchain tokens may be subject to CFTC jurisdiction.
On October 17, 2017, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s LabCFTC recently released “A CFTC Primer on Virtual Currencies” (the Primer). LabCFTC was launched by the CFTC in May 2017, as the “focal point for the CFTC’s efforts to promote responsible FinTech innovation and fair competition.” LabCFTC was “designed to make the CFTC more accessible to FinTech innovators … to inform the Commission’s understanding of new technologies… [and as] an information source for the Commission and the CFTC staff on responsible innovation that may influence policy development.” It is notable that LabCFTC’s first publication, in PowerPoint format, addresses virtual currency and related issues; however, the first publication states that the Primer “is not intended to describe the official policy or position of the CFTC, or to limit the CFTC’s current or future positions or actions.”
The Primer is divided into three sections: first, it provides an overview of virtual currencies and potential uses of virtual currencies and blockchain technologies; second, it discusses the role of the CFTC in respect to virtual currency and related permitted and prohibited activities; and third, it notes the risks of virtual currencies. It does not, however, offer any insight into the CFTC’s view on the breadth of the definition of “virtual currency” or on whether any particular types of transactions involving blockchain tokens will be subject to CFTC jurisdiction.
Overview
To define virtual currency, the Primer refers to and imports the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) definition from IRS Notice 2014-21: “a digital representation of value that functions as a medium of exchange, a unit of account, and/or a store of value… In some environments, it operates like ‘real’ currency … but it does not have legal tender status” in the US Virtual currency that has an equivalent value in real currency, or that acts as a substitute for real currency, is referred to as ‘convertible’ virtual currency; the Primer cites Bitcoin as one example of a convertible virtual currency. Though the Primer cites the IRS definition, it expressly disclaims that the CFTC is adopting that definition; it “is instead offered as an aid to enhance public understanding of virtual currencies.”
Sample Potential Use Cases of Blockchain Technology. The Primer recognizes that blockchain or distributed ledger technology can be used within public and private systems in a wide variety of applications, including by financial institutions for trading and payment platforms, regulatory reporting, compliance with know your customer and anti-money laundering requirements, by governments for general records management and regulatory reporting and oversight, and cross-industry, for smart contracts, resource and asset sharing agreements and proof of identity when entering into a contract. The examples do not, however, make clear whether the CFTC considers all digital asset represented on blockchains to fall within the definition of virtual currency, or otherwise to be a commodity.
Role of the CFTC
Virtual Currencies are Commodities; Jurisdiction of the CFTC. The Primer notes that the definition of commodity included in the Commodity Exchange Act is broad, and can include a physical commodity such as an agricultural product or a natural resource, a currency or interest rate, and includes “all services, rights, and interests … in which contracts for future delivery are presently or in the future dealt in.” The CFTC first found that Bitcoin and other virtual currencies are properly within the ambit of “commodity” in 2015. The CFTC has oversight over futures, options and derivatives contracts and its jurisdiction is implicated “when a virtual currency is used in a derivatives contract, or if there is fraud or manipulation involving a virtual currency traded in interstate commerce.”
Initial Coin Offerings, Virtual Tokens and CFTC Oversight. The Primer mentions that the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) last summer released a Section 21(a) report on the DAO tokens, determining that those particular tokens met the definition of “security” under the federal securities laws. The Primer asserts that “there is no inconsistency between the SEC’s analysis and the CFTC’s determination that virtual currencies are commodities and the virtual tokens may be commodities or derivatives contracts depending on the particular facts and circumstances.” The CFTC “looks beyond form and considers the actual substance and purpose of an activity when applying the federal commodities laws and CFTC regulations.”
Accordingly, both the CFTC and SEC have now announced that they will consider these issues on a case-by-case basis, depending on the particular facts and circumstances. Coinbase’s Securities Law Framework provides guidelines in applying existing regulation to each blockchain project’s facts and circumstances. It is important to note that depending on the structure of a transaction or platform, both the CFTC and SEC could assert overlapping jurisdiction, based on facts and circumstances and each Commission’s interpretation of its statutes. In other words, being subject to the jurisdiction of the CFTC does not insure that there will be no SEC regulatory implications and vice versa.
Risks
The “Risks” section of the Primer is structured by the CFTC as a series of warnings to investors and includes several risks, as follows.
Operational Risks. The Primer acknowledges that the virtual currency market has many platforms for converting one type of virtual currency into another currency, or into fiat currency. However, the CFTC cautions that many of these platforms are not subject to the supervision that applies to regulated exchanges and may be missing critical system safeguards and customer protection related systems.
Cybersecurity Risk. Virtual currency may present cybersecurity risk since some platforms may commingle customer assets in shared accounts, which can affect whether and how the currency can be withdrawn, and may be vulnerable to hacks, resulting in the theft of virtual currency and the loss of customer assets.
Speculative Risks. Virtual currency may present speculative risk since, among other things, the market has been subject to substantial volatility and may be subject to price manipulation.
Fraud and Manipulation Risk. The Primer also cautions against the risk of fraud and manipulation.
Conclusion
The Primer represents another regulator contribution to the world of blockchain tokens. For blockchain projects that create tokens, we reiterate our often expressed view that the features and functions of the platform and the tokens must be analyzed carefully when determining which regulatory regime(s) apply. In other words, the context determines the regulation.
Finally, (and most importantly) don’t commit fraud.
Artificial Intelligence Requires Real Leadership
ARTICLE
Artificial Intelligence Requires Real Leadership
November 13, 2017
Read time: 2 min
Dale Van Demark and Jennifer Geetter wrote this bylined article on the challenges of using artificial intelligence in healthcare. “The common elements with all of these challenges are preparation and leadership,” the authors wrote, and they urged the necessity of “effective leadership, from the board and C-suite, to consider the implications of technology, set a system strategy, adopt processes to ensure appropriate evaluation and implement solutions.”
Counting Temporary Workers when Including the Number of Works Council Members Freed from Normal Work
ARTICLE
Counting Temporary Workers when Including the Number of Works Council Members Freed from Normal Work
November 11, 2017
Read time: 2 min
Dr. Sandra Urban-Crell with commentary on German Federal Labour Court decision dated August 2, 2017 “Counting Temporary Workers when Including the Number of Works Council Members Freed from Normal Work.”
IRS and Taxpayers Continue to Battle Over IRC Section 199 Deduction for Computer Software
ARTICLE
IRS and Taxpayers Continue to Battle Over IRC Section 199 Deduction for Computer Software
November 10, 2017
Read time: 2 min
Kevin Spencer and Robin Greenhouse wrote this bylined article about IRS attacks on taxpayer ability to claim the IRC Section 199 deduction for computer software and qualified film production. The authors wrote that “there are presently several docketed cases seeking judicial determinations” regarding the use of the deduction.

House Tax Reform Bill: Potential Dramatic Changes for U.S. Compensation Arrangements
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
House Tax Reform Bill: Potential Dramatic Changes for U.S. Compensation Arrangements
November 7, 2017
Read time: 9 min
The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (the “House Tax Reform Bill”), introduced by House Committee on Ways and Means Chairman Kevin Brady (R-TX) on Nov. 2, 2017 (and amended on Nov. 3 and Nov. 6), proposes changes to the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended (the “Code”), that would have dramatic effects on U.S. compensation arrangements.
The Death of Deferred Compensation – New Section 409B
The most monumental change affecting compensation under the House Tax Reform Bill is that it appears to supersede Code Section 409A with a new Code Section 409B. Like Code Section 409A, Code Section 409B addresses nonqualified deferred compensation arrangements. However, unlike Code Section 409A, which allows for the deferral of payment and taxation of vested compensation subject to compliance with specific requirements, Code Section 409B simply would eliminate the ability to defer taxation of vested nonqualified deferred compensation arrangements. Under Code Section 409B, an employee would be taxed on compensation, including most stock options and stock appreciation rights (“SARs”), when it is no longer subject to a “substantial risk of forfeiture” (i.e., vested) — regardless of when the compensation is payable, if it is actually ever paid or whether the employer’s obligation to pay the compensation is funded.
Important aspects of Code Section 409B:
- Stock Options and SARs. Unlike Code Section 409A, which provides an exemption for stock options and SARs granted with an exercise/strike price equal to fair market value, most companies’ stock options and SARs would be treated as deferred compensation and subject to Code Section 409B. Accordingly, the unique tax advantage of those stock options and SARs – the ability to delay income tax on vested awards until exercised – would be eliminated. There is one new limited exception included in the House Tax Reform Bill. The new tax provision would permit an employee (other than a CEO, CFO and certain highly compensated officers) of certain private companies to elect to defer tax on vested “Qualified Equity Grants” for up to five years. The election only applies to awards of stock options and restricted stock units relating to illiquid stock granted by a company that has never been public and has granted such awards to at least 80 percent of the company’s employees (excluding the CEO, CFO and certain highly compensated employees) during the calendar year. The amount of income recognized by the employee at the end of the deferral period would be based on the value of the stock on the vesting date, even if the value of the stock has declined.
- Other Equity Awards. In addition to stock options and SARs, Code Section 409B generally would apply to all forms of equity-based compensation other than restricted stock and profits interests. As a result, except for the Qualified Equity Grants (described above), a person would be taxed on the value of an equity award whenever vested, which, like Code Section 409A, could be at grant if the holder can become vested upon his or her “retirement” or involuntary termination for “good reason” (depending on the definition of good reason).
- Short Term Deferrals. Unlike Code Section 409A, the exception from deferred compensation for “short term deferrals” would be narrowed under Code Section 409B only to amounts paid by the 15th day of the third month following the end of the employer’s taxable year in which the right to the compensation vested. Code Section 409A contains a broader exception for amounts paid by the 15th day of the third month following the end of the later of the employer’s taxable year and employee’s taxable year.
- Severance Benefits. Under Code Section 409A, if an employee has the right to severance benefits upon an involuntary termination for “good reason,” depending on the definition of good reason, the severance benefits could constitute deferred compensation, but the taxation could be deferred until termination of employment by complying with the Code Section 409A deferral requirements. Under Code Section 409B however, such severance would be deemed vested and taxable to the employee at the time that he or she became subject to the agreement or arrangement. In addition, even if an employee is only entitled to severance benefits upon an involuntary termination (i.e., termination without “cause”), the employee would be subject to accelerated taxes on any portion of those severance benefits that are paid after the 15th day of the third month following the end of the employer’s taxable year – the portion that isn’t a short term deferral (regulations would need to specify if the employee would be taxed on the termination date or a later date before the 15th day of the third month following the end of the employer’s taxable year).
- Vesting. Like Code Section 409A, compensation is subject to a “substantial risk of forfeiture” if the person’s rights are conditioned upon his or her future performance of substantial services. However, unlike Code Section 409A, the occurrence of a condition related to a purpose of the compensation other than the future performance of services does not render such compensation subject to a “substantial risk of forfeiture.”
- Non-Competes. Like Code Section 409A, a right to compensation would not be subject to a “substantial risk of forfeiture” solely by reason of a covenant not to compete. As a result, under Code Section 409B, an employee would be taxed on any vested compensation that his or her employer mandatorily defers to ensure compliance with restrictive covenants.
- Withholding. While Code Section 409A generally obligates employers to report deferred compensation, employers are not responsible for withholding the penalty taxes imposed under Code Section 409A. In contrast, because Code Section 409B would cause employees to have taxable income upon vesting, employers would be required to satisfy their tax withholding obligations with respect to any compensation that is treated as no longer being subject to a substantial risk of forfeiture under Code Section 409B. Significantly, despite the withholding requirement, it appears that the employer would not be entitled to a deduction for the compensation until it is actually paid.
New Section 409B would be effective with respect to compensation earned (and, presumably, first becoming vested) after Dec. 31, 2017. An employee’s compensation that is attributable to services performed before 2018 would be grandfathered from Code Section 409B but must be taxable to the employee by the later of the last taxable year beginning before 2026 and the taxable year in which there is no substantial risk of forfeiture of the rights to such compensation. In addition, Sections 457A and 457(f), which cover certain compensation arrangements with tax indifferent employers, would be repealed with respect to compensation attributable to services performed after 2017.
Section 162(m) — $1 Million Compensation Deduction Cap – No More Exceptions
Under current Code Section 162(m), a publicly held corporation – a corporation with common equity securities required to be registered under Section 12 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (the “Exchange Act”) – generally may not deduct the compensation paid during a taxable year to any of its “covered employees” that is in excess of $1 million. The one major exception under Code Section 162(m) that is commonly used by publicly held corporations is the unlimited deduction for “performance-based compensation.” The House Tax Reform Bill would amend Code Section 162(m) to eliminate the exception for performance-based compensation, and no compensation paid to a covered employee above $1 million would be deductible. Also, the House Tax Reform Bill would expand the coverage of Code Section 162(m) by:
- Amending the definition of “publicly held corporation” to remove the limitation that it applies only to issuers of common equity and to include any corporation that is required to file reports pursuant to 15(d) of the Exchange Act. Accordingly, corporations with only public debt would be become subject to Code Section 162(m).
- Amending the definition of a “covered employee” to include any person who:
- Served as a chief executive officer or chief financial officer (previously excluded due to a “glitch” in the law) at any time during a year (not just the last day of the year), or
- Was a covered employee for any preceding taxable year beginning after Dec. 31, 2016.
The changes to Code Section 162(m) would be effective starting in 2018 and would appear to apply to performance-based compensation granted prior to 2018 but paid in 2018 or later.
20 Percent Excise Tax on Excess Tax-Exempt Organization Compensation
The House Tax Reform Bill would also add a new Section 4960 that, starting in 2018, would impose an excise tax on any tax-exempt organization on compensation paid to any employee who is one of the organization’s five highest-compensated employees for the taxable year or who was a covered employee for any preceding taxable year beginning after Dec. 31, 2016, equal to 20 percent of:
- The employee’s compensation in excess of $1 million and
- The employee’s “excess parachute payments” – any severance payments in excess of three times the employee’s average taxable compensation over the past five years (“base amount”).
Now what?
Although the Republican-controlled Congress intends to push to enact the House Tax Reform Bill in the short time before the end of the year, it may undergo significant changes before being passed, if ever. However, given the ground-shaking changes in the House Tax Reform Bill that would dramatically affect U.S. compensation arrangements if the House Tax Reform Bill were enacted in its current form, or if any bill similar to it were enacted, and how soon those changes could become effective, employers should stay aware of the progress and possible evolution of the House Tax Reform Bill over the coming weeks.
Authored by Ian L. Levin, Mark E. Brossman, Stephen I. Brecher, Aaron S. Farovitch, and Susan E. Bernstein.
If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your lawyer or one of the authors.

To Scan or Not to Scan: Surge in Lawsuits under Illinois Biometrics Law
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
To Scan or Not to Scan: Surge in Lawsuits under Illinois Biometrics Law
November 7, 2017
Read time: 6 min
The Illinois Biometric Information Privacy Act is having its moment. At least 32 class action lawsuits have been filed by Illinois residents in state court in the past two months challenging the collection, use and storage of biometric data by companies in the state. This may cause a reassessment of company strategies and development of new defenses in the use of advancing biometric technology.
The Illinois Biometric Information Privacy Act (BIPA) is having its moment. At least 32 class action lawsuits have been filed by Illinois residents in state court in the past two months challenging the collection, use and storage of biometric data by companies in the state. This may cause a reassessment of company strategies and development of new defenses in the use of advancing biometric technology.
Although BIPA has been on the books for nearly a decade, the recent surge in lawsuits has likely been brought on by developments in biometric scanning technology and its increased use in the workplace. In the vast majority of these lawsuits, the plaintiffs allege BIPA noncompliance against their employers based on the employers’ use of fingerprint-operated timeclocks. Specifically, they claim that the collection, use and storage of fingerprints in this manner violates BIPA’s requirement of consent, notice and disclosure.
Components of the Illinois Statute
Illinois enacted BIPA in 2008 in response to the introduction of biometrics across multiple industries. At the time, many large companies were piloting biometric scanning applications in Chicago and elsewhere in Illinois, such as finger-scan technologies for authentication purposes in financial transactions. 740 ILCS 14/5(a). The Illinois legislature voiced concern over the privacy implications of biometrics because, unlike many other types of sensitive information, biometrics are immutable and cannot be changed in the event of a compromise. 740 ILCS 14/5(c).
At its core, BIPA sets out to regulate companies’ collection and storage of biometric data by creating a private right of action for consumers and employees. BIPA broadly defines “biometric information” to include “any information, regardless of how it is captured, converted, stored, or shared, based on an individual’s biometric identifier used to identify an individual.” 740 ILCS 14/10. A “biometric identifier” is defined to mean “a retina or iris scan, fingerprint, voiceprint, or scan of hand or face geometry.” 740 ILCS 14/10. It does not include photographs, digital signatures, writing samples and biological samples used for screening, which are not protected under the statute. 740 ILCS 14/10.
With the privacy of consumers and employees in mind, BIPA requires that companies be transparent about their practices regarding the collection, use and storage of biometric data. BIPA imposes three requirements:
- Creating a publicly available written policy that establishes the retention schedule and outlines guidelines for permanently destroying biometric data in the company’s possession;
- Fully informing the data subject and receiving the data subject’s written consent prior to collecting or storing the data subject’s biometric data; and
- Protecting the biometric data in its possession using the industry’s reasonable standard of care and in the same or more protective manner that the company stores other confidential and sensitive information. 740 ILCS 14/15.
BIPA also prohibits companies from selling, trading, leasing or otherwise profiting from biometric data in its possession. 740 ILCS 14/15(c).
Potential Damages
Failure to comply with BIPA can be costly. Under the statute, each wronged party is entitled to receive actual damages or liquidated damages of $1,000 for each negligent violation and actual damages, or liquidated damages of $5,000 for each intentional or reckless violation. 740 ILCS 14/20. BIPA also provides the prevailing party reasonable lawyers’ fees and costs, as well as injunctive relief. 740 ILCS 14/20. These remedies create incentives for the filing of cases, especially class actions where the potential exposure can be massive in instances where large volumes of biometric information are involved.
This potential exposure arises even in situations where the violation appears technical or procedural in nature and does not appear to have caused any tangible loss to any individual. There are multiple legal issues and defenses that arise in this type of case, and will inevitably be the subject of litigation. Nevertheless, and like many privacy-focused statutes, Illinois courts have not yet interpreted BIPA’s key components or the requirements for recovering in an individual or class action. Current litigation remains in the early stages. It remains unknown how damages will be calculated or if plaintiffs will be entitled to liquidated damages for alleged technical or procedural violations.
Other States’ Biometric Data Laws
Illinois is one of three states with privacy laws pertaining to biometric data; however, it is the only statute of its kind that creates a private right of action for violations of the law. Texas and Washington have similar statutes that regulate the collection, use and storage of biometric data, but both statutes leave enforcement of the law up to their respective Attorneys General. State legislatures in Alaska, Connecticut, Massachusetts and New Hampshire are currently considering similar statutes. If adopted, the statutes in Alaska and New Hampshire would create a private right of action that mirrors BIPA in terms of potential damages for negligent and intentional violations.
Company Strategies
Companies that collect, use or store biometric data of Illinois residents should assess their current policies and practices to ensure they are in compliance with BIPA. Companies should also review their cyber liability and other insurance policies to determine the likelihood of coverage in the event of a lawsuit.
If a claim is brought, it is possible that privacy and/or cyber liability insurance policies may cover the costs related to defending actions brought under BIPA. These claims may be covered under certain types of cyber, wrongful data collection or related policies.
Beware of “Gun Jumping:” EU Court Confirms Fine on Norwegian Seafood Company
ARTICLE
Beware of “Gun Jumping:” EU Court Confirms Fine on Norwegian Seafood Company
November 7, 2017
Read time: 2 min
Daniel von Brevern and Patryk Wcislo wrote this bylined article on the European Commission’s fine against a Norwegian seafood company for acquiring another seafood processor before getting EC approval “The decision is an impressive reminder that gun jumping, i.e. the implementation of transactions prior to clearance by the competent antitrust authorities, can entail severe consequences,” the authors wrote.

Settling the Standard for Prudence? Fall Brings New Guidance for ESOP Trustees
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
Settling the Standard for Prudence? Fall Brings New Guidance for ESOP Trustees
November 6, 2017
Read time: 9 min
Through a series of recent settlements, the US Department of Labor has outlined the process steps fiduciaries should follow in connection with a transaction involving a purchase from, or sale to, an employee stock ownership plan.
Through a series of recent settlements, the US Department of Labor (DOL) has outlined the process steps fiduciaries should follow in connection with a transaction involving a purchase from, or sale to, an employee stock ownership plan (ESOP). Largely based on the “fiduciary process steps” first introduced by the DOL in the 2014 settlement of Perez v. GreatBanc Trust Co., this new guidance has neither the force of law nor the ability to change any current laws or regulations. The recent settlements may, however, provide helpful insight into the DOL’s position regarding what is required to meet fiduciary obligations under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA) when engaging in an ESOP transaction.
Background
Approximately 90 percent of ESOPs hold stock of closely held corporations. The ESOP will purchase stock from one or more company owners at a price determined by an ESOP fiduciary. Because most ESOP fiduciaries are not valuation experts, ERISA generally requires the fiduciary to determine the stock’s fair market value by relying upon the work of an independent appraisal expert. If the fiduciary relies on an inadequate appraisal, however, the fiduciary can breach its duties and/or violate ERISA’s prohibited transaction rules.
ERISA requires that an ESOP’s fiduciaries—which generally include its trustees, the sponsoring employer, the individuals that sit on the sponsoring employer’s board of directors, and any employees involved in the administration and operation of the ESOP—establish and operate the ESOP for the exclusive purpose of providing benefits to ESOP participants and beneficiaries, while defraying reasonable expenses of administering the plan. This is a high standard that is often expressed as the idea that an ESOP fiduciary must act as a “prudent expert” would act. Given this “prudent expert” standard, ERISA permits, and may in fact require, the ESOP fiduciary to rely on an independent appraisal expert to assist the ESOP fiduciary in determining the value of closely held employer stock.
Process Steps
The DOL has not (in more than 20 years) promulgated formal rules addressing when a fiduciary may reasonably rely on a valuation provided by an independent appraisal expert. When the DOL settled GreatBanc Trust Co. in 2014, however, it noted that the ESOP industry would “do well to take notice” of the process steps it put in place. The recent settlements in Acosta v. First Bankers Tr. Servs., Inc., and Acosta v. BAT Masonry build on these process steps and provide guidelines that the DOL believes an ESOP fiduciary is required to follow to establish that the fiduciary’s reliance on an independent appraisal of closely held employer stock was reasonable.
These guidelines are outlined below. In all instances involving an institutional trustee, all employees of the institutional trustee involved in the process must also be identified and their participation documented.
Selecting an Appraisal Expert
- When selecting an appraisal expert, a fiduciary should retain written documentation of at least three references checked and a discussion of those three references’ views.
- The fiduciary must discuss, in writing, whether the selected appraisal expert has been the subject of criminal, civil or regulatory proceedings and/or investigations in connection with its previous valuation work, as well as the results of such criminal, civil or regulatory actions.
- The above requirements are not applicable if the fiduciary has recently (within the last year if an institutional trustee and the last two years if an individual trustee) vetted the appraisal expert and the appraisal expert certifies, in writing, that the results of the fiduciary’s prior investigation are still accurate. This marks a distinct change from GreatBanc Trust Co., which required that an institutional trustee’s previous analysis be completed within the prior 15 months.
- A fiduciary may not rely on an appraisal expert that has previously performed any work—including a preliminary valuation—on behalf of the plan sponsor’s ESOP committee.
- The fiduciary must document all the steps it took to determine that the appraisal expert received complete, accurate and current information, and to ensure the fiduciary understood the advice of the appraisal expert.
Overseeing the Appraisal Expert
- The valuation report should include background about the individuals that provided the projections, as well as how the projections compare to the company’s history, and the historic metrics of comparable public companies. If these details are absent, the fiduciary must prepare a supplement to the valuation report (if an individual trustee) or request that supplementary documents be prepared (if an institutional trustee).
- The valuation report should include the risks facing the plan sponsor that could cause the plan sponsor’s financial performance to fall materially below the projections relied upon by the appraisal expert, and any material differences between the present valuation and the most recent prior valuation of the plan sponsor performed within the past 24 months by any valuation firm for any purpose (if any).
- If the fiduciary is an individual trustee and its valuation report does not include any reliance on the discounted cash flow (DCF) valuation methodology, the valuation report must specifically explain, in writing, why the DCF methodology is missing.
- The fiduciary must also include details regarding the terms of any loans the ESOP receives in connection with the transaction, and must ensure that the loan terms are as favorable as the terms of any loans between the plan sponsor and any executive of the plan sponsor made within the two years preceding the transaction.
Requirements for Financial Statements
- In the absence of audited, unqualified financial statements, the fiduciary may only engage in a transaction if the stock purchase agreement includes a provision requiring the selling or purchasing shareholders who are officers, managers or members of the board of directors of the plan sponsor to compensate the ESOP for any losses or other harms caused by or related to financial statements that did not accurately reflect the plan sponsor’s financial condition.
Fiduciary Review Process
- All employees of the fiduciary who participated in decisions regarding (1) whether to proceed with the transaction or (2) the price of the transaction are expected to engage in reasonably prudent investigation and retain—for six years—all notes, minutes or other documentation on which they relied.
- If the fiduciary believes the projections in the valuation report are unreasonable, the fiduciary must ask the appraisal expert to account for the unreasonable projections in its valuation, request new and reasonable projects from management, or reject the transaction, and must document the basis for its decision.
- The fiduciary must ensure that the information the appraisal expert obtains from the plan sponsor and purchasing or selling shareholder(s) includes each of the following, to the extent it exists:
- Any prior attempts by the purchasing or selling shareholder(s) to purchase or sell their stock in the plan sponsor within the proceeding two years
- Any prior defaults within the past five years by the plan sponsor under any lending or financing agreement
- Any management letters provided to the plan sponsor by its accountants within the past five years
- Any information related to a valuation of the plan sponsor provided to the Internal Revenue Service within the past five years
Requirements Relating to Control
- If a fiduciary approves a transaction in which the ESOP cedes any degree of control to which it would otherwise be entitled based on its ownership interest, including but not limited to the unencumbered ability to vote its shares (for example, by electing members of the board of directors), the fiduciary must document any consideration received in exchange for such limitation on the ESOP’s control (or how the limitation on control is otherwise reflected in the purchase price) and why it is fair to the ESOP.
- If a fiduciary approves a transaction in which the ESOP pays a control premium, the fiduciary must document why it believes that the ESOP is obtaining voting control, and control in fact, and identify any limitations on such control as well as the specific amount of consideration the ESOP received for such limitations.
Insurance Coverage – Individual Trustee Only
Before agreeing to serve as a trustee or fiduciary in connection with any transaction for the purchase or sale of ESOP stock, an individual trustee should make a good faith effort to obtain insurance coverage under a non-wasting policy that is sufficient to provide coverage for liability under ERISA in connection with the proposed transaction.
In the event that the individual trustee is unable to obtain its own insurance after good faith efforts, the individual trustee must obtain a written agreement from the ESOP sponsor that that the individual trustee must be named as a covered individual under the ESOP sponsor’s insurance policy as a condition for the individual trustee to serve as trustee or fiduciary of the ESOP.
Conclusion
It is important to note that the recent DOL settlements discussed in this article do not specify all of a fiduciary’s obligations under ERISA, nor do they supersede such obligations in any way. Rather, such guidance provides additional detail as to the DOL’s expectations for fiduciaries to meet their obligations as ERISA fiduciaries. Ultimately, the fiduciary is the party responsible for understanding the full risks posed by a transaction involving a private company ESOP and for asking serious questions about any government audits or legal action, customer concentration, industry risk, and financial and legal disclosures.

Public Procurement Law: Innovations in Restructuring Taxation Law
ARTICLE
Public Procurement Law: Innovations in Restructuring Taxation Law
November/December 2017
Read time: 2 min
Dr. Kian Tauser and Dr. Heiko Kermer on changes in restructuring taxation law which affect liquidation with residual liabilities and real property inbound investments.

Proposed Changes to Federal Transfer Taxes Introduced in Tax Cuts and Jobs Act
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
Proposed Changes to Federal Transfer Taxes Introduced in Tax Cuts and Jobs Act
November 3, 2017
Read time: 3 min
The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, introduced by the House Committee on Ways and Means Chairman Kevin Brady on Nov. 2, 2017, proposes substantial changes to the federal gift, estate, and generation-skipping transfer taxes and the charitable income tax deduction limit imposed under existing law.
The proposed legislation has not yet been voted on by Congress. If the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act were to be enacted in its present form, transfer tax laws would change as follows:
- Beginning Jan. 1, 2018, the amount of each person’s (i) exemption from federal gift and estate taxes and (ii) exemption from federal generation-skipping transfer tax would double. Such exemption amounts would rise from the $5.6 million per person scheduled under existing law to $11.2 million per person (indexed for inflation in the future).
- The federal estate tax would be eliminated with respect to the estate of any person who dies on or after Jan. 1, 2024. Until that date, federal estate tax would continue to be imposed on certain estates at a maximum rate of 40 percent.
- The federal gift tax would be retained, but beginning Jan. 1, 2024, the maximum rate of federal gift tax imposed on certain gifts would be reduced to 35 percent.
- No changes would be made to an existing provision of law that permits a so-called “stepped-up basis” in certain assets inherited by beneficiaries upon the death of a decedent. (The stepped-up basis operates to eliminate unrealized capital gains attributable to assets included in a decedent’s estate.)
In addition, under existing law, a person may not deduct for income tax purposes the amount of her or his cash contributions to public charities and certain other charitable organizations to the extent such contributions exceed 50 percent of her or his adjusted gross income (without regard to net operating loss carrybacks). Under the proposed legislation, beginning Jan. 1, 2018, this limitation would increase from 50 percent to 60 percent, and the current five-year carryover period would be retained.
Please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel at your earliest convenience if you wish to discuss the proposed legislation.
This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP (“SRZ”) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.