Content Type: Article

  • International News: Private Equity

    International News: Private Equity

    INTERNATIONAL NEWS / REPORT

    International News: Private Equity

    December 2019

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Final and Proposed BEAT Regulations Provide Some Relief

    Final and Proposed BEAT Regulations Provide Some Relief

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Final and Proposed BEAT Regulations Provide Some Relief

    December 18, 2019

    Read time: 14 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Final and new proposed regulations on the base erosion anti-abuse tax (the BEAT) under section 59A have been issued by the United States Treasury and IRS, providing clarifications and some relief tied to inbound liquidations and reorganizations and transfers of loss property. However, many changes requested by the business community were not adopted, such as exceptions for payments that give rise to subpart F income or global intangible low-taxed income (GILTI).

    In depth

    The United States Treasury Department and the Internal Revenue Service have issued final and new proposed regulations on the base erosion anti-abuse tax (the BEAT) under section 59A. The new BEAT regulations provide some helpful relief, such as for inbound liquidations and reorganizations and transfers of loss property, as well as several welcome clarifications. At the same time, Treasury and the IRS declined to adopt many of the more ambitious changes that the business community had requested, such as exceptions for payments that give rise to subpart F income or global intangible low-taxed income (GILTI).

    As background, the BEAT imposes a minimum tax on US corporations (and certain foreign corporations, which are not the focus of this On the Subject) that consistently have annual gross receipts of $500 million or more and claim more than a de minimis amount of “base erosion tax benefits” for a taxable year. In general, as base erosion tax benefits increase, a corporate taxpayer’s BEAT liability increases. The regulations include guidance for determining the base erosion payments that will give rise to annual base erosion tax benefits. Consistent with the proposed regulations, Treas. Reg. § 1.59A-3(b) applies the same four categories of base erosion payments found in section 59A(d) for amounts paid or accrued to a related foreign party. The two categories that should affect the most corporate US taxpayers are the general category for currently deductible items and the special category for the acquisition of depreciable or amortizable property.

    Relief Provided for Certain Situations

    A controversial aspect of the earlier proposed regulations was that the proposed regulations treated stock consideration in non-cash transactions as BEAT “payments,” thereby creating the potential for BEAT liability in situations involving certain liquidations, tax-free reorganizations and other non-cash transactions. [See Proposed BEAT Regulations: Tax-Free Transactions May Give Rise to a Liability Insight]. While the final regulations adopt the rule in the proposed regulations that an amount paid or accrued to a related foreign party includes any form of consideration (including both cash and non-cash consideration such as property, stock, or the assumption of a liability), the final regulations generally exclude transfers and exchanges of stock made in connection with a corporate non-recognition transactions from the definition of a base erosion payment. Thus, as a general matter, corporate US taxpayers may acquire depreciable or amortizable property in an inbound related party exchange described in section 351, a liquidation described in section 332, or a reorganization described in section 368 without triggering base erosion tax benefits when claiming future depreciation or amortization deductions on acquired property.

    Corporate US taxpayers should be aware of two potential exceptions to this rule when undertaking inbound corporate non-recognition transactions. First, the use of “other property” or money (such as types of consideration described in sections 351(b), 356(a)(1)(B), and 361(b), including liabilities described in section 357(b)) in an inbound corporate non-recognition transaction are not subject to the exception and will be treated as base erosion payments. Second, the broad anti-abuse rule in Treas. Reg. § 1.59A-9 is potentially applicable and may override the exclusion for inbound corporate non-recognition transactions in some situations in which the corporate taxpayer undertakes a basis step-up transaction shortly before the inbound non-recognition transaction.

    Moreover, the final regulations adopted the rule from the proposed regulations that depreciation or amortization deductions claimed on property acquired in connection with a “pure” inbound section 301 distribution will not give rise to base erosion tax benefits. However, the beneficial treatment was not extended to dividend-equivalent redemptions under section 302(d) (including by operation of section 304) or redemptions of section 306 stock even though such distributions are otherwise generally taxed at the shareholder-level as a section 301 distribution.

    The final regulations also provide relief for losses triggered on transfers of built-in loss property to foreign affiliates. To the extent a corporate taxpayer transfers built-in loss property to a related foreign party in a taxable exchange, the loss realized from the transfer of built-in loss property will not be treated as a base erosion tax benefit. There will be, however, a base erosion payment to the extent of the fair market value of the transferred property.

    In addition, the final regulations retained the non-statutory exclusion of section 988 losses from the definition of base erosion payments. Section 988 losses are defined as exchange losses within (the meaning of Treas. Reg. § 1.988-2) from “section 988 transactions.” Such losses are also excluded from the numerator of the base erosion percentage. The proposed regulations had also provided that all exchange losses from section 988 transactions (including losses with respect to section 988 transactions with unrelated persons) were to be excluded from the denominator of the base erosion percentage. In response to comments, the final regulations now provide that section 988 losses are excluded from the denominator of the base erosion percentage only to the extent such losses result from transactions with foreign affiliates that are also excluded from the numerator.

    General Adherence to Proposed Regulations’ Approach of Accommodating Self-Help Approaches

    Similar to the initial proposed regulations, the final regulations generally do not establish specific bright-line rules for determining whether a payment is treated as a deductible payment, which as noted above is one of the four enumerated categories of “base erosion payments.” As described below, comments to the proposed regulations requested explicit carve-outs regarding transactions involving a middleman or a passthrough payment or divisions of revenues in connection with profit split arrangements. The final regulations generally provide that the determination of whether a taxpayer’s payment or accrual to a foreign related party falls within one of these categories is made under general principles of US federal income taxation (for example, the reimbursement doctrine, and agency, conduit, and assignment of income principles).

    Therefore, taxpayers are permitted to rely on general US federal income tax principles, including common law doctrines, in structuring intercompany and third-party contracting and payment arrangements in a tax efficient manner, and should consider modifying their business processes to comport with their desired treatment.

    Requests Denied by the Treasury and IRS

    As described below, the Treasury and IRS declined to extend specific relief to many common business arrangements and payment structures involving (1) passthrough payments, (2) netting arrangements, (3) outbound payments to a controlled foreign corporation (CFC) that result in subpart F or GILTI, (4) profit split methods, or (5) payments for generally high-margin services.

    No Exception for Passthrough Payments & Netting Arrangements between Related Parties

    The Treasury and IRS declined to issue specific guidance concerning transactions involving passthrough payments and divisions of revenues in connection with global service arrangements.  The “passthrough payment” scenario may involve situations where a taxpayer serves as a middleman for a payment to a foreign related party, which in turn remits a corresponding payment for third party costs. Commenters cited business exigencies as one of the key reasons for driving the form of such arrangements, and suggested solutions to exempt these payments from constituting “base erosion payments.” Treasury and IRS rejected these suggestions, citing a number of reasons. For example, an exception for payments that arise because of non-tax business considerations would create the need for even more rulemaking to regulate the inherent subjectivity of using an exception for business versus non-business reasons. Further, Treasury and IRS concluded that the suggested solutions would cause BEAT to be imposed on a “net” rather than “gross” basis, thereby undermining Congress’ intent.

    The final regulations also do not include a general netting rule that would allow corporate US taxpayers to reduce the gross amount of base erosion payments made to foreign related parties by the amount of payments received from such foreign related parties. As a result, base erosion payments will generally still be determined on a gross basis.

    Corporate US taxpayers that make payments to foreign related parties may wish to re-evaluate their internal arrangements and business operations to determine whether their payments should be characterized as deductions incurred to a related party under common law doctrines. For example, a payment that flows through a US taxpayer’s hands solely in the taxpayer’s capacity as an administrative clearinghouse may be better characterized as never being included in or deductible from the taxpayer’s income under general principles, on the basis that the taxpayer serves as a mere agent and never has a claim of right to the funds.

    No Exception for Payments that Produce Subpart F or GILTI

    The final regulations do not adopt an exception from base erosion payments for payments made by a domestic corporation to a CFC that result in subpart F or GILTI inclusions. This creates the possibility of double taxation when these regimes and BEAT apply simultaneously. In declining to provide an exception for such inclusions, Treasury and IRS cited policy reasons underlying BEAT and difficulty in administering a GILTI exception due to tracing of payments and differences in tax rates.

    Taxpayers faced with the predicament of being subject to double taxation should consider eliminating payments from domestic corporations to CFCs to the extent manageable from a business perspective, or affirmatively plan into exceptions under the Subpart F or GILTI rules, such as the high-tax exceptions, so that the payment does not result in a taxable inclusion.

    No Exception for Profit Split Method

    Comments recommended that payments by the domestic corporation to foreign related parties should not be base erosion payments if the parties have adopted a profit split as their best method of pricing the related-party transactions for purposes of section 482. Some of these comments asserted that parties to such payments could be viewed as splitting the customer revenue for purposes of section 59A. Under this view, the payments received by the foreign related party would be treated as received directly from the third-party customer, with the result that there would be no corresponding deductible payment from the domestic corporation to the foreign related party. The Treasury and IRS declined to adopt an exception for the profit split method or similar transfer pricing method that is used for purposes of section 482. The preamble notes that the use of a particular method, whether the profit split method or another method, does not change the contractual relationship between the parties. Accordingly, the final regulations do not adopt this recommendation because the proper characterization depends on the underlying facts and the relationships between the parties. Again, taxpayers in some cases may be able to achieve the intended tax treatment by modifying their agreements.

    No Expansion of SCM Exception

    Furthermore, the Treasury and IRS declined to expand the scope of the services cost method exception (the SCM Exception). The SCM Exception is generally based on satisfying the requirements in Treas. Reg. § 1.482-9 except that the recordkeeping requirements are modified and the business judgment rule is turned off (i.e., services may qualify for the SCM Exception even if the service contributes significantly to the success or failure of the corporate taxpayer’s business). Taxpayers had asked Treasury and the IRS to expand the SCM Exception to cover the cost-component of payments for services that are not eligible for the SCM on the basis that the services are on the per se excluded list under Treas. Reg. § 1.482-9 (for example, research and development). Taxpayers had suggested that the business judgment rule and the per se excluded list operate together in pursuit of the same policy, such that the policy rationale for turning off the business judgment rule should imply a turning off of the per se excluded rule. Treasury declined to adopt these recommendations, stating that the excluded services list and the business judgment rule serve similar, but ultimately different, policy objectives. As a result, corporate taxpayers who are adversely affected by the application of the BEAT to per se excluded services should continue to pursue other planning strategies, such as moving high-margin offshore services into a foreign branch or outsourcing such services altogether.

    Treatment of Qualified Derivative Payments

    As background, section 59A(h)(2) exempts qualified derivative payments (QDPs) from the definition of base erosion payments, provided that no payment is a QDP for a taxable year unless the taxpayer includes the information relating to such payments that is required to be reported under section 6038B with respect to such taxable year.

    The final regulations clarify that, for purposes of the QDP exception, the section 6038B information reporting requirement applies regardless of whether or not a taxpayer is a “reporting corporation” (as defined) and that all taxpayers must report the information required by Treas. Reg. § 1.6038A-2(b)(7)(ix) for a particular payment to be eligible for QDP status. In addition, the final regulations eliminate the rule in the proposed regulations that would have required a taxpayer to report the aggregate amount of QDPs as determined by type of derivative contract, the identity of each counterparty, and the aggregate amount of QDPs made to each counterparty.  Under the final regulations, a taxpayer satisfies the reporting requirement by including a QDP in the aggregate amount of all QDPs on Form 8991 or a successor form. The final regulations also extend the transition period for meeting the complete QDP reporting requirements to taxable years beginning before June 7, 2021.

    Proposed Regulations Provide an Explicit Deduction-Waiver Procedure to Manage the Base Erosion Percentage

    Deduction-Waiver Election

    The new proposed regulations provide a taxpayer favorable deduction-waiver procedure to manage the base erosion percentage. To be considered an “applicable taxpayer” and potentially subject to BEAT, a taxpayer must satisfy the “base erosion percentage” test. A taxpayer satisfies this test when it has base erosion payments that account for at least 3% of its total deductions (2% for certain financial institutions). The base erosion percentage test is calculated by dividing the taxpayer’s aggregate amount of base erosion tax benefits (the “numerator”) by the sum of the taxpayer’s aggregate amount of deductions plus certain other base erosion tax benefits (the “denominator”). For purposes of the numerator, a “base erosion tax benefit” includes any deduction that is allowed under Chapter 1, Subtitle A of the Code for the taxable year with respect to the base erosion payment (Allowed Deduction).

    The proposed regulations provide that a taxpayer may forgo a deduction on an item-by-item basis and that those forgone deductions will not be treated as base erosion tax benefits if the taxpayer elects to waive the deduction for all US federal income tax purposes, subject to certain exceptions provided by the proposed regulations. The effect of making the election is that the numerator should decrease, thereby resulting in a lower base erosion percentage. A taxpayer is permitted to make the election on an annual basis, and must follow certain procedural requirements. Further, a taxpayer is permitted to make the election retroactively by filing an amended return or during the course of an examination for the relevant tax year. As a baseline, the proposed regulations provide that any deduction that a taxpayer is permitted to claim is generally considered an Allowed Deduction, unless the taxpayer elects to waive certain deductions. The proposed regulations provide that if a taxpayer takes advantage of the deduction waiver with respect to a particular deduction for a prior year, the taxpayer is not permitted to recover the waived deduction in a subsequent year by making an accounting method change.

    Although waiving deductions generally will not be anyone’s first choice as a tax planning strategy, taxpayers that find themselves at risk of satisfying the base erosion percentage test and that could otherwise suffer the “cliff effect” of falling into the BEAT should consider the availability of the deduction waiver as a fallback option. The ability to assert waiver on examination should be particularly helpful in ensuring that relatively small increases in deductions don’t ultimately lead to very large BEAT liabilities. As the election is made on an annual basis, taxpayers with BEAT exposure should review their deductions currently, prospectively, and should also review their prior 2018 US federal income tax data to determine if they can benefit from applying the deduction waiver retroactively. Taxpayers may rely on the proposed regulations to make the election until final regulations are issued.

    Authors

    Caroline H. Ngo

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    David G. Noren

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Michael J. Bruno

    Partner

    Miami

    More insights

  • CFTC Amendments to Registration and Compliance Rules — Lessons for Private Fund Managers

    CFTC Amendments to Registration and Compliance Rules — Lessons for Private Fund Managers

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    CFTC Amendments to Registration and Compliance Rules — Lessons for Private Fund Managers

    December 17, 2019

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On Nov. 25, 2019, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission approved amendments[1] that impact several registration and reporting exemptions, which will affect many hedge fund and private equity fund managers. While, in general, these are long-needed changes that streamline administrative processes or harmonize CFTC rules with those of other regulators or with actual market practice, every private fund manager relying on a CFTC exemption should review the details of the changes.

    Rule 4.13 “Qualified Eligible Person” and “Non-United States Person” Updates

    Many private fund managers rely on the Regulation 4.13(a)(3) “de minimis” exemption from CFTC registration as a commodity pool operator. Among other requirements, Rule 4.13(a)(3) requires that each participant in a qualifying pool fall into one of the following categories:

    • An “accredited investor” as defined in Rule 501 under the Securities Act of 1933 (or a trust that was formed by an accredited investor for the benefit of a family member);
    • A “knowledgeable employee” as defined in Rule 3c-5 under the Investment Company Act of 1940; or
    • Certain categories of “qualified eligible persons” listed in CFTC Rule 4.7(a)(2)(viii)(A).

    The November 2019 amendment expanded the qualified eligible person prong to include any qualified eligible person (and not just those listed in clause (a)(2)(viii)(A) of Rule 4.7). This change removed needless complexity and also ratified “the general market practice” of permitting non-United States persons (a non-United States person is, by definition, a qualified eligible person, but is not one listed in CFTC Rule 4.7(a)(2)(viii)(A)) to invest in Rule 4.13 pools. It also clarified that Rule 4.7’s definition of “non-United States person” (which includes a natural person who is not a resident of the United States, estates and trusts outside of U.S. income tax jurisdiction, business associations organized for passive investment located outside of the United States, passive investment vehicles that have under 10% U.S. ownership, and non-U.S. pension plans) should also be used for this purpose.

    No Replacement for Advisory 18-96

    The CFTC’s amendments were widely expected to contain a codification of Advisory 18-96 relief, which provides reporting, disclosure and recordkeeping relief to registered operators of commodity pools with no U.S. administration, marketing or sources of income. The CFTC had proposed replacing Advisory 18-96 with a new Regulation 4.13(a)(4), which would have offered a full exemption from CPO registration (and thus reporting on Form CPO-PQR, which remains an obligation under Advisory 18-96 relief). The CFTC has withdrawn this proposal, although it notes that it may revisit the subject in the future.

    Family Office Exemption Claims

    Family offices that engage in commodity interest trading have been able to rely on two CFTC no-action letters, 12-37 and 14-143, to avoid registering with the CFTC and the National Futures Association as commodity pool operators or commodity trading advisors. New Rule 4.13(a)(6) and new Rule 4.14(a)(11) substantially codify the CFTC’s older CPO and CTA no action relief but, notably, neither of the new exemptions requires any filing with the NFA or CFTC (which was the case with the no-action letters).

    • New Regulation 4.13(a)(6) provides an exemption from CPO registration for a person with respect to a qualifying commodity pool if: (a) interests in the pool are exempt from registration under the Securities Act, and such interests are sold only to “family clients” (as defined in Securities Act Rule 202), (b) the commodity pool qualifies as a “family office” (also as defined in Rule 202) and (c) the person reasonably believes, at the time of investment, that each person who participates in the pool is a “family client” of the “family office.”
    • New Regulation 4.14(a)(11) provides an exemption from CTA registration to a person who directs commodity trading advice solely to (and for the sole use of) “family clients.”

    Regulations 4.13(a)(6) and 4.14(a)(11) will supersede No Action Letters 12-37 and 14-143 (although not prior staff letters determining that a particular entity is “not a pool”).

    Legal and compliance personnel for private fund managers whose principals have family offices (or who are planning to start a family office) should be aware that, although neither of the new rules requires a notice filing to be effective, the CFTC has guided that qualifying family offices should create and maintain an internal record that documents their intent to claim relief under either of these rules, including their qualifications for these exemptions.

    All managers that are registered with the CFTC will also need to plan on reviewing and revising their NFA Bylaw 1101 questionnaires to reflect the CFTC’s new rules and documentation requirements for family offices.

    General Solicitation Under § 506(c)

    The CFTC’s November amendments also harmonized Rule 4.13(a)(3) and Rule 4.7 pool investments with offerings conducted under the SEC’s Rule 506(c), which allows certain general solicitation activities for unregistered securities; provided that accredited investor verification efforts are undertaken.[2]

    Prior to these amendments, managers of Rule 4.13 or Rule 4.7 pools that were engaging in a 506(c) offering had to rely on CFTC no-action letter 14-116, which required a notice filing. The November amendments clarify that:

    • Rule 4.7’s prohibition on marketing to the public does not apply to a registered CPO that offers or sells participations in a pool offered pursuant to Rule 506(c);
    • The relief under Rule 4.7(b) is available to otherwise eligible pools, even if participations in such pools are resold under Rule 144A; and
    • The marketing and advertising of interests in Rule 4.13(a)(3) (de minimis) pools to the public is permissible if done in compliance with Rule 506(c) or Rule 144A.

    No further action is required for firms that have already filed the notice required by that Letter. CPOs interested in using general solicitation with respect to future pools that qualify for Regulation 4.7 or 4.13(a)(3) will need to furnish the standard NFA notices required by those exemptions.

    Form CPO-PQR and CTA-PR Exclusions for Reporting Persons

    The CFTC’s new amendments to Regulation 4.27(b) substantively codify its prior no action letters 14-115 and 15-47, which provided relief from reporting:

    • On Form CPO-PQR, for CPOs that exclusively operate Regulation 4.13(a)(3) pools or pools subject to a definitional exclusion under Regulation 4.5; and
    • On Form CTA-PR, for CTAs that are registered, but are not yet directing client accounts.

    Additionally, the CFTC’s amendments to Regulation 4.27(b) extend Form CTA-PR reporting relief to CTAs that comply with the CTA registration exemptions in Regulation 4.14(a)(4) (where the CTA is already registered as a CPO), and Regulation 4.14(a)(5) (where the CTA is exempt from CPO registration), but are nevertheless registered as CTAs. In the first case, the CFTC has deemed further Form CTA-PR reporting to be duplicative of information already being provided on Form CPO-PQR, and in the latter case, incongruent with lack of a requirement to provide Form CPO-PQR at all. No notice filing is required to take advantage of the amended relief in Regulation 4.27(b).

    Authored by Brian T. Daly and Joshua B. Wright.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] See “CFTC, Registration and Compliance Requirements for Commodity Pool Operators (CPOs) and Commodity Trading Advisors: Family Offices and Exempt CPOs” (Nov. 25, 2019), available here; See also CFTC, Registration and Compliance Requirements for Commodity Pool Operators and Commodity Trading Advisors: Registered Investment Companies, Business Development Companies, and Definition of Reporting Person (Nov. 25, 2019), available here.

    [2] See “Eliminating the Prohibition Against General Solicitation and General Advertising in Rule 506 and Rule 144A Offerings,” 77 FR 54464 (Sept. 5, 2012) and 78 FR 44771 (Jul. 24, 2013) (“JOBS Act Adopting Release”) (amending Regulation D, 17 CFR 230.500-230.508, and Rule 144A, 17 CFR 230.144A).


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2019 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • 4 NLRB Rulings Revamp Employer Private Property Rights

    ARTICLE

    4 NLRB Rulings Revamp Employer Private Property Rights

    December 16, 2019

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Code Sec. 367(a) and (d) After the TCJA

    ARTICLE

    Code Sec. 367(a) and (d) After the TCJA

    December 2019

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors

    Lowell D. Yoder

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • Emerging Risks 2020: Social Inflation, Examined

    ARTICLE

    Emerging Risks 2020: Social Inflation, Examined

    December 13, 2019

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors

    Thomas M. Dawson

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • SCOTUS Rules PTO Not Entitled to Attorney’s Fees in Appeals to E.D. Virginia from Adverse PTAB Decisions

    SCOTUS Rules PTO Not Entitled to Attorney’s Fees in Appeals to E.D. Virginia from Adverse PTAB Decisions

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    SCOTUS Rules PTO Not Entitled to Attorney’s Fees in Appeals to E.D. Virginia from Adverse PTAB Decisions

    December 13, 2019

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On December 11, the US Supreme Court held that the US Patent and Trademark Office is not entitled to recover its attorney’s fees in an appeal to the Eastern District of Virginia from an adverse decision of the Patent Trial and Appeal Board under 35 U.S.C. § 145. This maintains more than a century of practice under which a patent applicant who is dissatisfied with a PTAB decision may appeal to the district court under 35 U.S.C. § 145, without incurring an obligation to pay the PTO’s attorney’s fees.

    In depth

    In a unanimous decision on December 11, 2019, the US Supreme Court held that the US Patent and Trademark Office (PTO) is not entitled to recover its attorney’s fees in an appeal to the Eastern District of Virginia (E.D. Va.) from an adverse decision of the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) under 35 U.S.C. § 145. Peter v. NantKwest, Inc., Case No. 18-801, 589 US ___ (December 11, 2019). Justice Sotomayor framed the question presented in this case as:

    [W]hether such “expenses” [in § 145 proceedings] include the salaries of attorney and paralegal employees of the United States Patent and Trademark Office (PTO).

    The answer was a resounding “No.”

    Background

    The Patent Act provides two options to patent applicants for judicial review of an adverse PTAB decision. The applicant may appeal directly to the Federal Circuit under 35 U.S.C. § 141, in which “[the court] shall review the decision from which an appeal is taken on the record before the [PTO],” 35 U.S.C. § 144. Alternatively, the applicant may file a civil action against the Director of the PTO in the E.D. Va. under 35 U.S.C. § 145, in which case the applicant may present additional evidence. If the applicant elects to bring such an action, Section 145 provides that “[a]ll the expenses of the proceedings shall be paid by the applicant.”

    The en banc US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit previously reversed a divided Federal Circuit panel decision and held that 35 U.S.C. § 145 does not require applicants appealing to the E.D. Va. to pay the PTO’s attorney’s fees in the form of a pro rata share of the PTO personnel’s salaries. NantKwest, Inc. v. Iancu, 898 F. 3d 1177 (IP Update Vol. 21, No. 8).

    In its en banc decision, the Federal Circuit found that “the American Rule prohibits courts from shifting attorney’s fees from one party to another absent a ‘specific and explicit’ directive from Congress.” The Federal Circuit held that the phrase ‘[a]ll the expenses of the proceedings’ falls short of this stringent standard.

    However, in a case interpreting a similar provision of the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1071(b)(3) (relating to appeals to the E.D. Va. from a Trademark Trial and Appeal Board’s decision denying a trademark application), the Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit previously held that Section 1071(b)(3) does require a trademark applicant to pay the pro rata share of the PTO’s personnel expenses in defending the trademark action, win or lose. Shammas v. Focarino, 784 F.3d 219 (4th Cir. 2015) (IP Update Vol. 18, No. 5).

    The Supreme Court’s Decision

    The Supreme Court resolved the question in favor of patent applicants, adopting the view of the Federal Circuit’s en banc decision that attorney’s fees are not encompassed in the phrase “[a]ll the expenses of the proceedings” in Section 145.

    The Supreme Court agreed with the Federal Circuit’s en banc ruling that the “American Rule” is a bedrock principle that “[e]ach litigant pays its own attorney’s fees, win or lose, unless a statute or contract provides otherwise,” and provides a starting point for assessing whether §145 authorizes payment of the PTO’s legal fees.

    The Supreme Court emphasized that it had never suggested that any statute is exempt from the presumption against fee shifting or limited its American Rule inquiries to prevailing party statutes. Instead, the Supreme Court stated that it has developed a line of precedents addressing statutory deviations from the American Rule that do not limit attorney’s fees awards to prevailing parties. The Court also stated that the presumption against fee shifting was particularly im­portant in this case because reading §145 to permit an unsuccessful govern­ment agency to recover attorney’s fees from a prevailing party “would be a radical departure from longstanding fee-shifting principles ad­hered to in a wide range of contexts.”

    Further, the Supreme Court held that Section 145’s plain text does not overcome the American Rule’s presumption against fee shifting, stating that definitions of “expenses,” while broad enough to include attorney’s fees, provided little guidance. The mere failure to foreclose a fee award “neither specifically nor explicitly authorizes courts to shift [fees].” Rather, the Supreme Court found that the complete phrase “expenses of the proceeding” would not have been commonly understood to include attorney’s fees at the time §145 was enacted. The Court also found that the modifier “all” did not transform “expenses” to reach an outlay it would not otherwise in­clude.

    Further, the Supreme Court found that in common statutory usage, the term “expenses” alone has never been considered to authorize an award of attorney’s fees with sufficient clarity to overcome the American Rule’s presumption. The Court stated that the appearance of “expenses” and “attorney’s fees” together across various statutes in­dicated that Congress understands the terms to be distinct and not in­clusive of each other. Other statutes that refer to attorney’s fees as a subset of expenses show only that “ex­penses” can include attorney’s fees when so defined. The Court also stated that its precedent did not support the Government’s po­sition that the Court has used “expenses” to mean “attorney’s fees.”

    The Court held that the Patent Act’s history reinforces that Congress did not intend to shift attorney’s fees in § 145 actions, and there was no evidence that the Patent Office ever paid its personnel from sums collected from ad­verse parties. Also, the Court found that the PTO, until this litigation, had never sought its attorney’s fees under §145. The Court concluded that when Congress intended to provide for attorney’s fees in the Patent Act, it has stated so explicitly, citing as an example 35 U. S. C. §285.

    Conclusion

    The Supreme Court’s NantKwest decision maintains more than a century of practice under which a patent applicant who is dissatisfied with a PTAB decision may appeal to the district court under 35 U.S.C. § 145, without incurring an obligation to pay the PTO’s attorney’s fees.

    Authors
    More insights

  • SCOTUS Focus

    ARTICLE

    SCOTUS Focus

    December 2019/January 2020

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • The Sprint to Modernize and Clarify the Stark Law—Part I

    ARTICLE

    The Sprint to Modernize and Clarify the Stark Law—Part I

    December 2019

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    ©Copyright 2019, American Health Lawyers Association, Washington, DC. Reprint permission granted.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Untangling VBEs, ACOs and CINs: What to Know about CMS and OIG’s Proposed Regulations

    Untangling VBEs, ACOs and CINs: What to Know about CMS and OIG’s Proposed Regulations

    ARTICLE / REPORT

    Untangling VBEs, ACOs and CINs: What to Know about CMS and OIG’s Proposed Regulations

    December 9, 2019

    Read time: 2 min

    Overview

    The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services and the Office of Inspector General recently released notices of proposed rulemaking relating to the Stark Law and the Anti-Kickback Statute. We break down the new proposed value-based care arrangement exceptions and safe harbors, and implications for provider contracting networks such as accountable care organizations and clinically integrated networks.

    In depth
    Tabs

    Ashley M. Fischer

    Partner

    Chicago

    Tony Maida

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights
    Endnotes