Content Type: Article

  • CFIUS Review Flowcharts: Existing & Proposed Rules

    CFIUS Review Flowcharts: Existing & Proposed Rules

    ARTICLE / REPORT

    CFIUS Review Flowcharts: Existing & Proposed Rules

    December 9, 2019

    Read time: 2 min

    Overview

    In September, the US Treasury Department issued proposed regulations that would comprehensively implement legislation passed last year, FIRRMA, to broaden the jurisdiction of CFIUS. We offer flowcharts to help navigate the regulations.

    In depth
    Tabs

    Byron S. Kalogerou

    Partner

    Boston

    David J. Levine

    Senior Counsel

    Washington, DC

    Raymond Paretzky

    Counsel

    Washington, DC

    More insights
    Endnotes

  • M&A Review – International Arbitration

    ARTICLE

    M&A Review – International Arbitration

    December, 2019

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Arne Fuchs and Pauline Walde published the article “Internationale Schiedsgerichtsbarkeit” in the M&A Review, discussing the many facets and advantages of international arbitration both for disputes between companies and for disputes between companies and states. Read the full article in German here.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • The California Consumer Privacy Act: Key Points for Private Fund Managers

    The California Consumer Privacy Act: Key Points for Private Fund Managers

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    The California Consumer Privacy Act: Key Points for Private Fund Managers

    December 6, 2019

    Read time: 11 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Jan. 1, 2020 is the effective date of the California Consumer Privacy Act (“CCPA”), the country’s first comprehensive privacy law. For many private fund managers, the compliance burden presented by the CCPA is likely to be relatively limited. Still, there are several key aspects that are important for fund managers to keep in mind.

    Who Must Comply?

    Despite its name, the CCPA goes well beyond California “consumers,” as that term is typically used — the Act defines a “consumer” as any “natural person who is a California resident.”[1] The law applies to any business with at least $25 million in gross annual revenue[2] that collects personal information from “consumers,” which in the private fund context could be an investor, prospective investor, employee, job applicant, independent contractor or potentially even a business contact who resides in California.[3] A business that does not meet the threshold may still be subject to the CCPA if it controls, or is controlled by, a business that meets the criteria and shares common branding.[4] This expansive covered business concept means that, in the private fund context, managers will need to assess the potential coverage of the CCPA at both the adviser or sponsor level as well as for the funds themselves.

    Like “consumers,” the definition of “personal information” receives broad treatment, being defined as information that “identifies, relates to, describes, is reasonably capable of being associated with, or could reasonably be linked, directly or indirectly, with a particular consumer or household.”[5] This is much broader than other privacy laws and expressly includes items such as email addresses, internet protocol addresses and biometric information.[6]

    What Does the Law Require?

    At a high level, the CCPA requires covered businesses that collect personal information about California residents to:

    • Make certain disclosures concerning the collection and use of personal information, including the purposes for which the personal information is used and the categories of third parties with whom the personal information is shared;
    • Inform individuals of their rights to request detailed information about how their personal information is used or to request deletion of their personal information, and implement policies to comply with such requests;
    • Provide “conspicuous” notice and a means for individuals to opt out of the sale[7] of their personal information; and
    • Be accountable for data breaches that result from a failure to maintain reasonable security practices.

    What Is the Timing?

    The CCPA goes into effect on Jan. 1, 2020.

    The California Attorney General, who is primarily tasked with enforcement, is still in the process of finalizing regulations. Because final regulations are unlikely to be published before Jan. 1, 2020, the CCPA precludes the commencement of any enforcement actions prior to July 1, 2020;[8] actions brought after July 1, however, may relate to conduct between Jan. 1 and July 1, 2020. The attorney general may assess civil penalties of up to $2,500 per unintentional violation and $7,500 per intentional violation. A business is not liable if it cures any noncompliance “within 30 days after being notified of alleged noncompliance,”[9] although the Attorney General has stated some violations may not be capable of being cured after the fact.

    The private right of action provided for in the CCPA is limited solely to consumers whose personal information (defined more narrowly for these purposes)[10] has been subject to unauthorized access or disclosure as a result of the covered business’ failure to maintain reasonable security procedures.[11] Further, a consumer must give the business 30 days’ written notice and an opportunity to cure (if a cure is possible) prior to bringing any action.[12] A consumer may seek statutory damages in an amount of not less than $100 and not greater than $750 per consumer per incident, or actual damages, whichever is greater, as well as an injunction or any relief a court deems proper.[13]

    What Investor Information Is Covered?

    Personal information that private fund managers collect from existing investors who are individuals (i.e., natural persons) typically will be exempt from the CCPA, but other categories of information are covered:

    • Existing Individual Investors. Undoubtedly the most pertinent CCPA provision for private fund managers is the exemption for any information collected “pursuant to” the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (“GLBA”).[14] The GLBA regulates information privacy practices of financial institutions and covers personal information that is collected in the specific context of providing an individual with a financial product or service. This exemption for information collected under the GLBA effectively covers all information that funds collect about their existing investors. For example, name, contact information, social security or other tax identification number and bank routing information collected in the context of a subscription agreement is covered by the GLBA and therefore CCPA exempt.
    • Prospective Individual Investors. Because the GLBA does not reach prospective investors, personal information collected from prospective individual (natural person) investors in California will be subject to the CCPA, requiring CCPA disclosures at the point of collection. The method of making these disclosures will depend on the context in which the personal information is collected. For example, a fund manager that makes substantive information available to prospective investors via its website might add CCPA disclosures to an existing online privacy policy. A manager may also add a CCPA disclosure along with other disclosures in pitch books or other marketing materials, or as a notice at the bottom of investor relation emails.
    • B2B Contacts. Unlike most privacy laws, the CCPA’s expansive definition of “personal information” encompasses information that identifies an individual person exchanged in a purely business-to-business context, such as the email address of a California resident acting on behalf of an institutional investor or service provider. Due to the difficulties raised by businesses over complying with the CCPA for this category of information, the California legislature has placed a one-year moratorium on the statute’s coverage for personal information obtained by a business from a California resident acting for another entity occurring “solely within the context of the business conducting due diligence regarding, or providing or receiving a product or service to or from” the other entity.[15] As such, the moratorium delays enforcement for things like the professional email address of a California resident working on behalf of an institutional investor or service provider but does not appear to apply to information obtained from a third party, such as a list provider.

    What HR-Related Information Is Covered?

    The CCPA requires disclosures to be made to employees, job applicants and independent contractors in California about the categories of personal information collected and the purposes for which the personal information will be used. This can be accomplished by adding notices in job applications, employee handbooks and independent contractor agreements. For persons already engaged by a fund manager, disclosure can be made through circulating an email with a link to the disclosures. In this context, there is a one-year moratorium during which the disclosure requirements are limited to a description of the categories of information being collected and the purpose for which the categories of information will be used. Absent an extension to the moratorium or amendment, the CCPA’s more extensive disclosure requirements will apply commencing Jan. 1, 2021.[16]

    Is Alternative Data Covered by the CCPA?

    Alternative data in which personal information has been “deidentified” or “aggregated” is excluded from the CCPA.[17] Fund managers should undertake vendor diligence to confirm the data has been “de-identified” consistent with the specific requirements of the CCPA (e.g., the service provider must implement business processes that specifically prohibit re-identification of the information)[18] and confirm service provider agreements contain language required for CCPA compliance.

    What About Sharing Personal Information with Service Providers?

    The CCPA imposes various obligations with respect to sharing consumer information. As a threshold matter, a business must disclose to consumers the purposes for which it shares personal information.[19] This can be accomplished by adding language in an online privacy policy or similar disclosure. The CCPA contains certain more burdensome obligations with respect to the “sale” or use for a “commercial purpose”[20] of consumer information, such as providing the ability to “opt out,” providing consumers the right to request deletion of their information or responding to other individual information requests.[21] However, transferring a consumer’s personal information to a service provider for a “business purpose” is generally an exception to what constitutes a “sale” under the CCPA.[22] Most of the purposes for which fund managers share information with service providers will fall into one of the CCPA’s seven categories of “business purposes,” which are, in short:

    (1) Auditing interactions with consumers;

    (2) Detecting security incidents and protecting against illegal activity;

    (3) Debugging to repair errors;

    (4) Short-term “transient” uses;

    (5) Performing services on behalf of the business that collected the information;

    (6) Internal research for technological development; and

    (7) Maintaining and verifying quality and safety.[23]

    Thus, these additional requirements are likely inapplicable to how many private fund managers share information with service providers.

    The CCPA requires businesses to contractually prohibit its service providers from retaining, using or disclosing the consumer’s personal information for any purpose other than performing the services specified in the contract.[24] Therefore, fund managers will want to review, and possibly amend, existing agreements with service providers that have access to personal information of consumers and update vendor due diligence questionnaires to account for CCPA-related requirements.

    How Does CCPA Compliance Relate to GDPR Compliance?

    Despite frequent analogies between the GDPR and the CCPA, GDPR compliance does not ensure CCPA compliance because there are significant differences in requirements, definitions and scope.[25] That said, the data inventorying and mapping that many firms have already undertaken for purposes of GDPR compliance can be leveraged to assess the categories of information collected and how such information is used for purposes of CCPA compliance.

    Conclusion

    This is a rapidly changing and dynamic regulatory environment, in which the CCPA is one of the many pieces. The requirements of the CCPA are themselves evolving as the Attorney General has yet to issue final regulations. There is also the likelihood that further amendments will be proposed in 2020. As other states are considering comprehensive privacy regulation similar to the CCPA, many businesses are advocating for a federal law that would create uniform requirements.

    Authored by Brian T. Daly, Marc E. Elovitz, Edward H. Sadtler and Kelly Koscuiszka.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] California Consumer Privacy Act, CAL. CIV. CODE § 1798.140(g).

    [2] Id. § 1798.140(c)(1)(A). The statute does not specify whether the $25-million gross annual revenue threshold is based on gross revenue in California, the United States or worldwide. For the time being, fund managers are advised to assume it is worldwide revenue.

    [3] Id. § 1798.145(a)(6). For a company without a physical presence or affiliate in California, the statute provides a narrow exemption if the “commercial conduct takes place wholly outside of” and it is not otherwise “doing business” in California. This requires not having a single investor, prospective investor, employee or independent contractor in California.

    [4] Id. § 1798.140(c)(2). Two other criteria less likely to apply to private funds are businesses that (i) annually buy, sell, receive or share, for commercial purposes, personal information of 50,000 or more consumers, households or devices; or (ii) derive 50% or more of annual revenue from selling consumer’s personal information. Id. § 1798.140(c)(1)(B)-(C).

    [5] Id. § 1798.140(o)(1).

    [6] Id. § 1798.140(o)(1)(A).

    [7] “Sale” is defined broadly to include any disclosure or dissemination of personal information “for monetary or other valuable consideration.” Id. § 1798.140(t).

    [8] Id. § 1798.185(c).

    [9] Id. § 1798.155(b).

    [10] For purposes of the private right of action, the definition of “personal information” is defined as an individual’s unencrypted and non-redacted first name or initial and/or last name combined with certain other types of personal information, such as social security number, account number or credit card number. Id. § 1798.150(a)(1).

    [11] Id. § 1798.150(a)(1).

    [12] Id. § 1798.150(b).

    [13] Id. § 1798.150(a)(1).

    [14] Id. § 1798.145(e). The CCPA contains exemptions in relation to certain other statutes, including the California Information Privacy Act, but the GLBA exemption is the most relevant to fund managers.

    [15] Id. § 1798.140(o) (as amended by AB-1355). The moratorium does not apply to the private right of action or the right to opt out of selling for these type of business contacts.

    [16] Id. § 1798.145(h).

    [17] See, e.g., Id. §§ 1798.140(o)(2); 1798.145(a)(5).

    [18] Id. § 1798.140(h).

    [19] Id. § 1798.100(b), 1798.140(t)(2)(C)(i).

    [20] “Commercial purposes” means to advance a person’s commercial or economic interests, such as by inducing another person to buy, rent, lease, join, subscribe to, provide, or exchange products, goods, property, information, or services, or enabling or effecting, directly or indirectly, a commercial transaction. Id. § 1798.140(f).

    [21] Id. § 1798.140(t)(2)(C); 1798.140(v).

    [22] Id. § 1798.140(t)(2).

    [23] Id. § 1798.140(d).

    [24] Id. § 1798.140(v).

    [25] The California Attorney General has in fact specifically rejected a safe harbor exemption for GDPR-compliant businesses. See OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GEN., STATE OF CAL. DEP’T OF JUSTICE, INITIAL STATEMENT OF REASONS (ISOR) (2019), available here.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2019 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Marc E. Elovitz

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Kelly Koscuiszka

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • New Guidance on Medicare Payment Rule Enforcement

    New Guidance on Medicare Payment Rule Enforcement

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    New Guidance on Medicare Payment Rule Enforcement

    December 5, 2019

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth

    A few days before Thanksgiving, the news media published an internal memo by the Office of General Counsel (OGC) at the US Department of Health and Human Services (Department) to officials at the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS). The memo expressed OGC’s views on the impact of the Supreme Court’s Azar v. Allina Health Services, et. al., No. 17-1484 decision earlier this year on the enforcement of various CMS guidance. Specifically, OGC states that Medicare payment rules that meet the Court’s standard that did not go through notice-and-comment rulemaking cannot form the basis for an enforcement action, including an overpayment finding.

    The issue in this case was whether the Department’s determination that Medicare Part C patients should be included in the Medicare fraction represented a change in a “substantive legal standard” within the meaning of Section 1871(a)(2) of the Social Security Act (SSA). If the answer was yes, then notice-and-comment procedures were required under the title 18 of the SSA. In a 7-1 decision, the court held that the inclusion of Part C patients in the Medicare fraction was “substantive.” The court explained that the “substantive legal standard” under Section 1871(a)(2) of the SSA means any legal standard or determination that creates rights and obligations, such as the scope of benefits, payment for services, eligibility of individuals to receive benefits, or eligibility of individuals, entities or organizations to furnish services.

    OGC concludes that, according to the Supreme Court, Congress imposed a notice-and-comment requirement for substantive Medicare rules in a broader range of circumstances than otherwise would be required under the Administrative Procedure Act. Therefore, CMS guidance documents, such as the Medicare Internet-Only Manuals, setting forth interpretive payment rules, are legally nonbinding and may not be used as the basis of an enforcement action. As an example, if a “broadly worded statute or regulation can be interpreted a variety of ways,” sub-regulatory policy statements may be viewed as creating a new substantive rule, and thus cannot be enforced as binding rules under the Court’s ruling. According to OGC’s memo, CMS guidance documents that are “closely tied to a statutory or regulatory requirement” may provide additional clarity through such guidance and enforcement actions implicating the guidance can still be brought. Further, even if the sub-regulatory guidance is not specifically enforceable as a substantive legal standard, it can be used for other purposes, such as scienter or materiality, as stated in the Department of Justice Brand Memo.

    OGC indicates that it does not believe Local Coverage Decisions (LCDs) require notice-and-comment rulemaking because LCDs reflect payment determinations of the local Medicare Administrative Contractor (MAC) and are not binding on the Department. They accordingly do not create any substantive legal standards.  In its memo, OGC concludes, that LCDs cannot be solely used as the basis for a “government enforcement action,” including an overpayment demand. OGC also notes that codifying guidance in a retroactive regulation could create other legal risks for enforceability.

    The primary takeaway is that providers should examine carefully the basis for any enforcement action, including an overpayment determination, for whether the decision is based on sub-regulatory guidance that offends the Court’s standard. Providers should also be on the lookout for attempts by CMS to codify sub-regulatory guidance in notice-and-comment rulemaking in order to prospectively avoid this problem.

    Authors

    Emily Jane Cook

    Partner

    Los Angeles, Washington, DC

    Tony Maida

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    Paul M. Thompson

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Monica Wallace

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • Frozen 2: IRS Expands Nondiscrimination Relief for Frozen Defined Benefit Pension Plans

    Frozen 2: IRS Expands Nondiscrimination Relief for Frozen Defined Benefit Pension Plans

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Frozen 2: IRS Expands Nondiscrimination Relief for Frozen Defined Benefit Pension Plans

    December 5, 2019

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) expanded the temporary relief for frozen defined benefit plans to include nondiscrimination requirements relating to benefits, rights and features, available for plan years beginning before 2021. The expanded relief enables frozen pension plans to satisfy the nondiscrimination requirements that apply to benefits, rights or features.

    In depth

    The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) expanded the temporary relief for frozen defined benefit plans to include welcome relief from nondiscrimination requirements relating to benefits, rights and features. “Frozen” (or “closed”) pension plans are plans that have been closed to new participants but continue to provide benefit accruals for certain participants. Under the recently issued IRS Notice 2019-60, this new temporary relief is available for plan years beginning before 2021.

    The expanded relief enables pension plans to satisfy the nondiscrimination requirements that apply to benefits, rights or features. Generally, benefits, rights and features must be available to a group of employees that satisfies minimum coverage requirements and does not substantially favor highly compensated employees. Frozen pension plans often struggle to meet these nondiscrimination requirements if the frozen plan offers benefits, rights and features not provided under the other pension formulas or under other retirement plans of the employer.

    In most cases, the expanded relief provides that a pension plan frozen prior to December 13, 2013, will be deemed to satisfy the nondiscrimination rules for benefits, rights and features, provided that either: (a) the employer did not amend the plan after January 29, 2016, to expand or restrict the eligibility for the benefit, right or feature; or (b) if the employer did adopt such an amendment, the amendment did not favor highly compensated employees.

    The IRS originally provided temporary nondiscrimination testing relief for frozen pension plans in Notice 2014-5. The IRS repeatedly extended this relief, most recently in Notice 2019-49 as covered in our earlier blog post, and has now expanded the relief to apply to nondiscrimination requirements for benefits, rights and features. Many are advocating for legislation to permanently fix this issue by shielding frozen defined benefit pension plans from unintended nondiscrimination rule violations. The Setting Every Community Up for Retirement Enhancement Act (the SECURE Act), which includes nondiscrimination reform provisions, passed the US House of Representatives on May 21, 2019, but it is still pending in the US Senate. The IRS issued proposed regulations on this topic in 2016, but those regulations have not been finalized.

    For more information and advice for maintaining your frozen defined benefit plan, contact the authors or your regular McDermott Employee Benefits lawyer.

    Authors

    Alan D. Nesburg

    Counsel

    Chicago

    More insights

  • First Circuit Court of Appeals Finds Private Equity Funds Not Liable for Pension Liabilities of Portfolio Company

    First Circuit Court of Appeals Finds Private Equity Funds Not Liable for Pension Liabilities of Portfolio Company

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    First Circuit Court of Appeals Finds Private Equity Funds Not Liable for Pension Liabilities of Portfolio Company

    December 5, 2019

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Court of Appeals for the First Circuit (“First Circuit”) ruled on Nov. 22, 2019 that separate private equity funds (“Sun Funds”) managed by Sun Capital Advisors (“Sun Capital”) were not in the same controlled group because they were not a “partnership-in-fact.” Consequently, the Sun Funds were not liable for the withdrawal liability arising from the withdrawal of one portfolio company of the Sun Funds from a multiemployer pension plan. The latest ruling in Sun Capital Partners III, LP v. New England Teamsters & Trucking Indus. Pension Fund by the First Circuit reversed a 2016 decision of a district court. This is SRZ’s third Alert on the Sun Capital case and more details can be found in the prior Alerts referenced below.

    As described in our prior SRZ Alert,[1] Sun Capital involves the 2007 investment in Scott Bass Inc. (“SBI”) by the Sun Funds. Sun Capital Partners IV LP owned 70% of SBI and two “parallel funds” — Sun Capital Partners III LP and Sun Capital Partners III QP LP — owned the remaining 30% of SBI. In 2008, SBI stopped contributing to a multiemployer pension plan (“Teamsters Plan”) which triggered withdrawal liability. The Teamsters Plan assessed withdrawal liability on SBI and the Sun Funds. The Teamsters Plan claimed the Sun Funds were liable for withdrawal liability because they were members of SBI’s ERISA-controlled group. Under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (“ERISA”), all trades or businesses which are under “common control” are treated as a single employer. ERISA incorporates tax regulations which provide that, to be liable as a member of a contributing employer’s controlled group, the entity must be (1) a “trade or business” and (2) under “common control” with the obligated entity through ownership of at least 80%.

    District Court’s Decision

    As described in our prior SRZ Alert,[2] using the First Circuit’s “investment plus” test, the district court found that the Sun Funds were trades or businesses based on, among other things, the economic benefits they received from their management activities with respect to SBI through fee waivers and offsets.

    The district court then determined that the Sun Funds should be deemed to have formed a de facto partnership — a “partnership-in-fact” — in connection with their investment in Sun Scott Brass LLC, which, in turn, owned SBI. As a result, the district court determined that the Sun Funds were jointly and severally liable for SBI’s withdrawal liability.

    First Circuit’s 2019 Decision

    The latest First Circuit decision determined it was unnecessary to address the district court’s findings that the Sun Funds was engaged in a trade or business, although it found the district court was correct that fee waivers and offsets are direct economic benefits that a passive investor would not accrue.

    The First Circuit, instead, focused on whether there was a partnership-in-fact. It concluded that application of the eight-factor test[3] established by the Tax Court’s Luna decision in 1964 favored a finding of no partnership-in-fact. The First Circuit found that some factors favored finding a partnership-in-fact, but concluded that most of the factors did not. According to the First Circuit, the facts that the Sun Funds (i) disclaimed any sort of partnership, (ii) had mostly different limited partners from each other, (iii) filed separate tax returns, (iv) kept separate books and (v) maintained separate bank accounts, supported its determination that there was no partnership-in-fact. The First Circuit further noted it was reluctant to impose withdrawal liability because neither Congress nor the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation (“PBGC”) had provided guidance on what it viewed as the conflicting policy choices between better ensuring payment of promised pension benefits versus establishing disincentives to “much-needed private investment in underperforming companies with unfunded pension liabilities …[which] could, in turn, worsen the financial position of multiemployer pension plans.”

    Conclusion

    The First Circuit’s decision is the only appellate decision addressing whether the investment interests in a company held by separate private equity funds, but which are managed by the same or affiliated investment management firm or individuals, could be aggregated to satisfy the 80% test. The First Circuit’s decision is based on the specific facts concerning its application of the Luna test. We expect that other circuit courts, and possibly the U.S. Supreme Court, will also address the legal issue decided by the First Circuit. It is unlikely that multiemployer pension plans and the PBGC will become less aggressive in pursuing private equity funds for a portfolio company’s withdrawal liability.

    Authored by Ronald E. Richman, David M. Cohen, Ian L. Levin and Scott A. Gold.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] “ERISA Liabilities of Private Equity Funds: First Circuit Addresses Control Group Liability” SRZ Alert, Aug. 2, 2013, available here.

    [2] “Federal Court Finds Private Equity Funds Liable for Pension Liabilities of Portfolio Company” SRZ Alert, April 8, 2016, available here.

    [3] The Tax Court said “[T]he following factors, none of which is conclusive, bear on the issue: The agreement of the parties and their conduct in executing its terms; the contributions, if any, which each party has made to the venture; the parties’ control over income and capital and the right of each to make withdrawals; whether each party was a principal and coproprietor, sharing a mutual proprietary interest in the net profits and having an obligation to share losses, or whether one party was the agent or employee of the other, receiving for his services contingent compensation in the form of a percentage of income; whether business was conducted in the joint names of the parties; whether the parties filed Federal partnership returns or otherwise represented to respondent or to persons with whom they dealt that they were joint ventures; whether separate books of account were maintained for the venture; and whether the parties exercised mutual control over and assumed mutual responsibilities for the enterprise.” Luna v. Commissioner, 42 TC 1067, 1077-78 (1964) (internal citations omitted).


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2019 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Ronald E. Richman

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    David M. Cohen

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Ian L. Levin

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Evolving Deference Principles May Affect Tax Matters

    ARTICLE

    Evolving Deference Principles May Affect Tax Matters

    December 3, 2019

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Challenges for the New Silk Road – European responses to China’s international expansion

    ARTICLE

    Challenges for the New Silk Road – European responses to China’s international expansion

    December, 2019

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    China has been building the “New Silk Road” for six years – still without broad German participation. After the economy and politics initially observed the situation in a wait-and-see manner, more and more initiatives are taking China’s geopolitical strategy seriously as a challenge or want to help shape it. The EU even wants to emulate them. The ICC is committed to a concrete improvement in the framework conditions for business investments.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • CFTC 2019 Enforcement Report — Lessons for Private Fund Managers

    CFTC 2019 Enforcement Report — Lessons for Private Fund Managers

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    CFTC 2019 Enforcement Report — Lessons for Private Fund Managers

    December 4, 2019

    Read time: 10 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s Enforcement Division released its second annual report on Nov. 25, 2019, disclosing higher penalties and more parallel criminal cases. The number of actions brought in 2019 (69) was slightly lower than in 2018 (83), but it is noteworthy that a supermajority of this enforcement activity took place following Chairman Heath Tarbert’s assumption of office two-thirds of the way through the 2019 fiscal year.

    Private fund managers that trade futures contracts, options or swaps (who are classified as “commodity pool operators” under the Commodity Exchange Act) should consider the implications of this report within the CFTC’s active supervision initiatives over them and the markets in which they trade. (For example, the CFTC announced that it will begin examining hedge fund managers and other CPOs in 2020.[1])

    Market Misconduct and Fraud

    While the data in the 2019 Enforcement Report covers a wide variety of alleged violations, the two main focuses of the 2019 Enforcement Report are market misconduct and fraud, areas in which the CFTC has brought numerous actions against private fund managers.

    Fraud. In keeping with its focus on the protection of investors, the CFTC continues to focus on fraud, stating:

    Since its inception, the Commission has focused on protecting customers in its markets from fraud and other abuse. That focus remained a priority during FY 2019. The Division aggressively prosecuted fraud in some of the historical areas of focus [but also] continued to track down fraudsters as they entered new markets — and sometimes entirely new asset classes, like digital assets[.]

    The Enforcement Division underscored this by highlighting a case brought against the principal of a fund manager for soliciting, and then misappropriating, invested funds. While that case involved particularly egregious conduct (the principal was also charged criminally), it is not isolated. The CFTC also employed the anti-fraud section of the CEA to bring charges against registered CPOs and their employees for mismarking futures, physical commodity positions and swaps, and highlighted those cases in its annual report as well. In one mismarking case, brought in tandem with an SEC action for the same conduct, the CFTC charged a hedge fund portfolio manager with inflating interest rate swap valuations to show better trading profits. The portfolio manager was fined and given a three-year CFTC registration and trading ban.[2]

    Market Misconduct. The 2019 Enforcement Report referenced a CFTC core belief that the futures markets exist primarily to allow producers of goods to “hedge the risk that this year’s output might not be as good as the last, which protects them and consumers against price increases” and to “allow companies and individuals to allocate capital more efficiently, which contributes to the growth of the broader American economy.”

    Spoofing and other “disruptive” trading patterns, according to the CFTC, undermine the integrity of the markets and, in prosecuting these cases, the CFTC serves its “dual priorities” of protecting market integrity and market participants. As in prior years, the CFTC was especially focused on spoofing, which accounted for 23% of its enforcement actions. Most notable among these actions was a $67-million fine for spoofing assessed against a trading firm earlier this month. Traders at the firm had sent thousands of non-bona fide orders to Globex opposite their actual orders in an attempt to move the price of the instruments they were trading.[3]

    Market misconduct cases may present the greatest source of risk for private fund managers; this area also can be one of the most difficult for compliance officers to police, for several reasons. In general, it is simply harder to identify and isolate improper trading activity in an environment of contract “rolls,” complex hedges involving different categories of instruments, and a relatively fractured global market structure. Most third-party trade surveillance systems, for example, were developed to address equities trading, and futures trading surveillance tools are less accessible. In addition, the surveillance of swaps activity can be especially challenging. Compliance officers at private fund managers should utilize their annual review as an opportunity to assess the adequacy of their relevant surveillance tools and skills and seek to implement improvements where necessary.

    Emphasis on Compliance Programs

    The CFTC emphasized the importance of adequate compliance programs as being central to its enforcement investigations. Specifically, the 2019 Enforcement Report indicated that the adequacy of an entity’s compliance program will significantly impact how the CFTC views the severity of any misconduct, the penalty imposed and the need for undertakings.

    The 2019 Enforcement Report footnotes two different cases where the CFTC found that compliance failures “directly resulted in the underlying substantive misconduct,” and two additional cases where it brought “failure to supervise” charges in addition to charging the underlying activity. An effective compliance program, according to the CFTC, must be able to both detect and deter misconduct.

    For private fund managers, this only extends a theme heard in actions, guidance, and rulemaking at several other regulators and SROs. The message here is clear: a fund manager trading in the commodity interests markets needs to invest in its compliance infrastructure and provide adequate support to skilled compliance professionals. The message for supervisors and chief compliance officers is equally clear: documented, effective supervision measures are crucial to warding off personal liability or the prospect of being named in a failure to supervise case.

    Digital Assets

    The 2019 Enforcement Report emphasized the CFTC’s commitment to aggressively prosecuting misconduct involving digital assets. The CFTC has, since 2015, taken the position that Bitcoin and other virtual currencies are properly defined as commodities within the meaning of the Commodities Exchange Act.[4]

    The 2019 Enforcement Report discussed several actions involving digital currencies and highlighted favorable rulings in significant, litigated enforcement actions, “affirming the Commission’s authority to prosecute fraud and manipulation involving digital assets that satisfy the statutory definition of a commodity.” In these litigated actions, the CFTC argued that, because cryptocurrency futures can be traded on markets the CFTC regulates, the underlying asset is a commodity for the purposes of the CEA’s anti-fraud statute.[5]

    For the moment, the CFTC has focused its digital asset enforcement activity on fraud cases. It remains to be seen whether the CFTC will extend its enforcement activities to wash trading, spoofing or other market integrity cases involving digital assets, although there is no impediment to such an extension.

    Parallel Criminal Proceedings

    The annual report touts the CFTC’s increasing cooperation with criminal authorities, citing a new high-water mark of 16 cases brought with parallel criminal proceedings. The 2019 Enforcement Report labeled this “a trend we expect to continue.” Similarly, Director of Enforcement James McDonald, in a July 25, 2019 speech, specifically stressed inter-agency cooperation as an initiative in which the CFTC had “made great strides.” According to Director McDonald, the CFTC’s specialized expertise in complex markets and market data allows it to identify misconduct that would otherwise not be readily apparent to the Department of Justice and other criminal authorities. Director McDonald also noted the CFTC’s cooperative efforts with other regulators, including the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission.

    “Bad Actor” Disqualifications

    The CFTC’s increasing involvement with the SEC already has raised questions about where the two agencies’ regulatory mandates intersect. For example, a recent spoofing settlement revealed internal disagreement at the CFTC about the extent to which the CFTC can, or should, opine on whether its enforcement actions should trigger a “bad actor” disqualification from certain private placements under SEC Rule 506.[6] In separately published opinions, two commissioners took issue with the CFTC’s recommendation to the SEC that the company should not be disqualified.[7] As the CFTC continues stepping up enforcement for manipulation, or other activities that fall within the “bad actor” definitions in Rule 506, these issues are likely to recur.

    Cooperation and Self-Reporting

    The 2019 Enforcement Report also touted the CFTC’s “robust” cooperation and self-reporting program, crediting the involvement of cooperating witnesses or corporations in some of its most significant matters. Recent CFTC press releases accompanying settlements, like those of the SEC and DOJ, have emphasized that lower civil penalties were imposed because of significant cooperation afforded to CFTC staff. Similarly, the 2019 Enforcement Report noted the CFTC’s practice of bifurcating liability and penalties for cooperating witnesses, and assessing reduced penalties after cooperation is substantially complete, a mirror of the criminal cooperation paradigm.

    Cooperation and self-reporting have been emphasized by the CFTC since 2017. As with the SEC and DOJ, to obtain cooperation credit from the CFTC, companies are expected to:

    1. Voluntarily report wrongdoing before the start of any investigation, promptly after becoming aware of it;
    2. Fully cooperate in investigations, including identifying individuals involved in the wrongdoing; and
    3. Timely and appropriately remediate the issue, including enhancing compliance and internal controls.

    The 2019 Enforcement Report echoes these sentiments and adds the corollary that enhanced penalties will be sought for those obstructing or undermining investigations.

    Takeaways

    The leadership of the new chair, and the tone of the 2019 Enforcement Report, make clear that the CFTC is embracing its regulatory and enforcement mandate and managers should pay heed to the warning contained in the CFTC’s press release: “enforcement activity at the Commission shows no sign of slowing down as we enter the new Fiscal Year.” In choosing to characterize its activity in 2019 as part of a trend upward, the CFTC signaled its intent to continue to regulate the futures markets in a robust way. The Enforcement Division appears to be modeling its program on the enforcement programs we have seen from other regulators, including formal cooperation programs and parallel proceedings with criminal authorities.

    While this is not news to private fund managers, it is worth repeating that the CFTC’s enforcement scope is not limited to “plain vanilla” agricultural futures contracts. The CFTC has jurisdiction over a myriad of financial futures, licenses many of the key financial exchanges and now oversees swap execution facilities (“SEFs”). As the CFTC gets more familiar with digital assets, the extension of its enforcement reach should be expected to continue.

    Authored by Craig S. Warkol, Brian T. Daly, Harry S. Davis and Katherine M. Sullivan.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] See, e.g., “CFTC 2020 Examination Initiative — Guidance for Private Fund Managers,” SRZ Alert, Nov. 8, 2019.

    [2] See Rel. No. 7979-19, CFTC Orders Former Hedge Fund Portfolio Manager to Pay More than $700,000 in Monetary Sanctions for Fraudulently Mismarking Swaps, July 18, 2019, available here.

    [3] The individual traders were also charged by the CFTC in 2018, and criminally prosecuted as well. See, e.g., Order In the Matter of Kamaldeep Ghandi, CFTC Doc. No. 19-01, Oct. 11, 2018, available here.

    [4] See In the Matter of: Coinflip, Inc., d/b/a Derivabit, and Francisco Riordan, CFTC Docket No. 15-29, available here; See also A CFTC Primer on Virtual Currencies, Oct. 17, 2017, available here.

    [5] See, e.g., CFTC v. McDonnell, CFTC Release 7702-18, March 6, 2018; CFTC v. My Big Coin Pay, Inc. CFTC Rel. No. 7820-18, Oct. 3, 2018.

    [6] SEC Rule 506 allows entities to raise almost unlimited capital through “Reg D” private placements, but disqualifies felons and other “bad actors” from participating in such offerings.

    [7] See Statement of Commissioner Rostin Benham Regarding Tower Research Capital LLC, Nov. 7, 2019, available here; Dissenting Statement of Commissioner Dan M. Berkovitz, In re Tower Research Capital LLC: Waiver of SEC “Bad Actor” Disqualifications, Nov. 7, 2019, available here.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2019 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • The Brexit and Its Consequences for German-British Contractual Relations

    The Brexit and Its Consequences for German-British Contractual Relations

    ARTICLE

    The Brexit and Its Consequences for German-British Contractual Relations

    December 2, 2019

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors

    Dr. Boris Uphoff

    Partner

    Munich, Düsseldorf

    More insights