ARTICLE
Federal Alcohol Excise Taxes 101
Winter 2020
Read time: 1 min
ARTICLE
Winter 2020
Read time: 1 min

ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
January 3, 2020
Read time: 10 min
Proposed regulations under Sections 863(b) and 865(e)(2) implement changes by TCJA to section 863(b), the primary sourcing provision for income from the sale of inventory produced by a taxpayer without and sold within the United States, or produced by the taxpayer within and sold without the United States. The proposed regulations also provide guidance under section 865(e)(2), a re-sourcing provision that applies when a nonresident’s foreign-source income is attributable to an office or fixed place of business in the United States. However, in current form, the clash between the position announced in the proposed regulations and the taxpayer positions to the contrary, together with the aggressive proposed effective date, likely will create controversy between the IRS and affected taxpayers.
The US Treasury and the Internal Revenue Service issued proposed regulations revising the rules for sourcing income under sections 863 and 865 of the Internal Revenue Code. The proposed regulations were issued to implement changes made by the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) to section 863(b), the primary sourcing provision for income from the sale of inventory produced by a taxpayer without and sold within the United States, or produced by the taxpayer within and sold without the United States (Section 863(b)(2) Sales). The proposed regulations also provide guidance under section 865(e)(2), a re-sourcing provision that applies when a nonresident’s foreign-source income is attributable to an office or fixed place of business in the United States.
Section 863(b) – Sourcing of Income from the Sale of Inventory Produced outside of the US and Sold within the US (or Produced within the US and Sold outside of the US)
Income from the sale of inventory is generally sourced to the location of title and risk transfer. However, if the inventory sold was also produced by the taxpayer, under the pre-TCJA section 863, income from such sales was first apportioned between income attributable to production activity and income attributable to sales activity. The portion of income attributable to sales activity was sourced under the title transfer rule, but the portion attributable to production activity was sourced based on the location of the assets of the taxpayer used to produce the inventory (“production assets”). Thus, an export sale by a manufacturer generally achieved 50% foreign-source treatment, based on title and risk being transferred outside the United States. This could be advantageous from a foreign tax credit planning perspective.
Section 14303 of the TCJA added a sentence to the flush language of section 863(b) providing that income from the sale of inventory produced by a taxpayer would be sourced “solely on the basis of the production activities with respect to the [inventory].” That is, under the post-TCJA section 863(b), there is no longer any need for apportionment of the sales income between production activity and sales activity. Thus, an export sale by a manufacturer now generally will produce 100% US-source income. This typically will be disadvantageous from a foreign tax credit planning perspective, although the sales should benefit from the foreign derived intangible income (FDII) regime also added in TCJA.
To reflect the post-TCJA section 863(b), the proposed regulations would substantially revise Treas. Reg. § 1.863-3(b), the provision that applied the pre-TCJA apportionment between income attributable to production activity and income attributable to sales activity. The three apportionment methods (the 50/50 Method, IFP Method, and Books and Records Method) are removed and Proposed Treas. Reg. § 1.863-3(b) now simply reiterates the newly-added sentence in section 863, stating that income from Section 863(b)(2) Sales is sourced “solely on the basis of the production activities with respect to the inventory.”
The proposed regulations left the rule under section 863(b) largely intact, which sources income from Section 863(b)(2) Sales according to the location of a taxpayer’s production assets. Thus, for example, if a taxpayer’s production assets are located entirely outside of the United States, then all of such income is foreign-source under section 863(b), even if title to the inventory passes within the United States on the sale.
Although the proposed regulations reflect the post-TCJA section 863(b)’s exclusive reference to production activity, they do not provide any guidance regarding the circumstances in which a nonresident will be treated as producing the inventory it sells or what activities are considered as “production activities” with respect to inventory that it sells. The current regulations provide only that “production activity” is “activity that creates, fabricates, manufactures, extracts, processes, cures, or ages inventory” and that only production activity “conducted directly by the taxpayer” is taken into account for purposes of sourcing income from production activity The proposed regulations do not elaborate on these provisions, instead simply stating that they “do not otherwise modify the rules . . . for determining the location or existence of production activity, a topic the Treasury Department and the IRS may address in future guidance.” Thus, general tax principles for determining when a taxpayer is considered as manufacturing or producing property it sells should provide guidance for purposes of determining when a taxpayer is considered as producing property it sells and what activities are considered as production activities for purposes of section 863(b).
Section 865(e)(2) – Re-sourcing Rule for a Nonresident’s Foreign-Source Income Attributable to a US Office or Place of Business
In addition to revising the regulations under section 863, the proposed regulations add new regulations under section 865 to address the application of sections 863(b)(2) and 864(c)(5) in determining the foreign-source income subject to section 865(e)(2).
Section 865(e)(2) provides a special re-sourcing rule that, if a nonresident maintains an office or other fixed place of business in the United States (US FPB), then income from any sale of personal property (including inventory) attributable to the US FPB is sourced in the United States. Section 865(e)(3) states that, to determine whether income from a sale of inventory is attributable to a US FPB, “[t]he principles of section 864(c)(5) shall apply.” As relevant here, section 864(c)(5)(B) provides that income is attributable to a US FPB if the US FPB is a “material factor” in the production of such income and “regularly carries on activities” that generate such income. Furthermore, section 864(c)(5)(C) generally provides that the amount of income from sales of inventory attributable to a US FPB is limited to the amount of such income that is properly allocable to the US FPB.
The proposed regulations interpret section 864(c)(5)(C)’s reference to an amount of income that is properly allocable to a US FPB to mean the amount of such income that is allocable to sales activity, as opposed to the amount allocable to production activity. Thus, the proposed regulations provide that, if a nonresident maintains a US FPB, with respect to income from the sale of inventory that is produced outside the United States by the nonresident, generally 50% of the income is treated as sales income properly allocable to the US FPB, and the remaining 50% of the income is treated as production income sourced under section 863(b). In other words, notwithstanding the fact that a nonresident produces inventory entirely outside of the United States, if its US FPB is a material factor in earning the income associated with a sale of such inventory, then under the proposed regulations the 50/50 method applies to apportion such income between production activity and sales activity. The proposed regulations allow taxpayers to use the books and records method to apportion income in lieu of the 50/50 method.
With respect to income from the sale of inventory that is purchased by the nonresident and not sourced under section 863(b), the proposed regulations require that the entire income be properly allocable to the US FPB under section 865(e)(2). The books and records method is not available for purchased inventory property.
Inapplicability of Final Clause in Section 864(c)(5)(C) for Purposes of Section 865(e)(2)
The Preamble to the proposed regulations contains an extensive explanation about why the drafters concluded it was appropriate to maintain apportionment between production and sales activity when a foreign taxpayer maintains a US FPB that participates in sales of inventory produced outside of the United States, even though such apportionment is no longer necessary in the general sourcing rule under section 863(b). The Preamble notes that section 865(e)(2) applies “notwithstanding any other provisions of [sections 861 through 865],” and that the TCJA did not amend section 865(e)(2) when it amended section 863. The Preamble pointed in particular to footnote 1519 from the Joint Committee on Taxation’s Bluebook for the TCJA, which suggests that, “[w]hile sections 863(b) and 865(e)(2) may appear to conflict” when a foreign taxpayer produces property outside of the United States for sale within the United States and a US FPB materially participates in the sale, “in such cases the income [from the sale] generally is partly US-source and partly foreign-source.”
The Preamble also rejects a contrary argument that is based on the final clause in section 864(c)(5)(C). That clause provides that income from the sale of property that is “properly allocable” to a US FPB can be no greater than the amount of such income that would have been US-source income if the sale had taken place in the United States. Taxpayers and advisors had concluded that, since income from the sale of inventory produced by a taxpayer is sourced solely based on production activity under section 863(b), the application of the final clause of section 864(c)(5)(C) to section 865(e)(2) means that none of the income would be allocable to a US FPB under section 865(e)(2) when inventory is produced by a taxpayer entirely outside of the United States. The Preamble disagrees with this interpretation, stating that it would “inappropriately construe a provision (section 865(e)(2)) intended as a separate restriction on the source rule under section 863(b)(2) . . . to be determined solely by reference to the terms of such source rule itself (rather than at most in a manner giving effect to both rules).” Further, “such a construction would cause section 865(e)(2) to have no effect with respect to sales of inventory that are also described in section 863(b)(2), contrary to longstanding statutory construction principles,” explained by the Preamble.
The proposed regulations currently do not carry the force of law. However, the Treasury and IRS indicated in the Preamble that the proposed regulations under section 865(e)(2) reflect their interpretation of the current law, and the regulations are proposed to be effective for taxable years ending after the publication of the proposed regulations in the Federal Register (December 30, 2019). Therefore, if the proposed regulations are finalized in their current form the IRS may seek to apply the rules retroactively to income from the sale of inventory earned in the 2019 tax year, and indeed might take the position described in the proposed regulations even with respect to earlier years simply as an interpretative matter. The clash between the position announced in the proposed regulations and the taxpayer positions to the contrary, together with the aggressive proposed effective date, likely will create controversy between the IRS and affected taxpayers.
Conclusion
The section 863(b) proposed regulations require sourcing of Section 863(b)(2) Sales based solely on the location of production activities, consistent with section 863(b)(2), as amended. Thus, income from Section 863(b)(2) Sales would be foreign source under section 863(b)(2) if the production activities are entirely outside the United States. However, under the section 865(e)(2) proposed regulations, which turn off the application of the final clause of section 864(c)(5)(C), a portion of such income would still be re-sourced as US-source income subject to US federal income tax if (i) the nonresident maintains a US FPB and (ii) such US FPB is a material factor in generating the income.
As a result, in applying section 865(e)(2) in a fact pattern that potentially implicates the general sourcing rule of section 863(b), for a nonresident to avoid US-source income under the proposed regulations, it is necessary to establish that the nonresident does not have a US FPB or, if it does, such US FPB is not a material factor in generating the income.

ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
January 2, 2020
Read time: 8 min
On Dec. 13, 2019, the National Security Division (“NSD”) of the U.S. Department of Justice (“DOJ”) issued a revised policy, titled the Export Control and Sanctions Enforcement Policy for Business Organizations (“Revised Policy”), which expands protections for companies that voluntarily self-disclose export control and sanctions violations to the NSD’s Counterintelligence and Export Control Section.[1] Under the Revised Policy, there will be a presumption against a fine and in favor of a non-prosecution agreement (“NPA”) to companies who voluntarily disclose the violation, fully cooperate with the NSD, and timely and appropriately remediate any underlying causes.[2] The Revised Policy provides greater clarity for companies considering making voluntary disclosures, with the hope of encouraging more companies to self-report. In addition, the Revised Policy will cover financial institutions, which were previously excluded.[3]
Voluntary Self-Disclosure
In order for a business organization to qualify for the presumption against imposing a fine and for an NPA, companies must submit a voluntary self-disclosure to DOJ. To qualify, the disclosure must (1) be made prior to an imminent threat of disclosure or government investigation; (2) be made at a reasonably prompt time after becoming aware of the offense; and (3) include all relevant facts known to the company at the time, including any individuals substantially involved in, or responsible for, the misconduct.[4]
The Revised Policy makes clear that if a company chooses only to self-report to a regulatory agency and not to DOJ, the company will not qualify for the benefits of a voluntary self-disclosure from DOJ.
Full Cooperation
Companies must also fully cooperate with the NSD in order to qualify for the presumption. In order to receive credit for full cooperation the company must (1) timely disclose all facts relevant to the wrongdoing, including attribution of facts to specific sources; (2) engage in proactive, rather than reactive, cooperation; (3) timely preserve, collect, and disclose relevant documents, including overseas documents; (4) when requested, defer interviewing witnesses until DOJ has had an opportunity to do so; and (5) endeavor to make witnesses with relevant knowledge available for DOJ to interview.[5]
The Revised Policy highlights DOJ’s continued commitment to the principle that eligibility for cooperation credit will not be predicated on waiver of the attorney-client or work product privileges.[6] The Revised Policy also explicitly addresses situations where a company seeks credit for full cooperation, but overseas privacy statutes block disclosure of overseas documents relevant to the underlying issue. In such situations, the company will bear the burden of establishing the prohibition and must proactively seek ways it can legally provide the relevant information to DOJ.[7]
Companies that fail to meet all of the foregoing criteria of “full cooperation” may still be eligible for some cooperation credit if they provide all relevant information related to individual accountability. Ultimately, the extent of any cooperation credit will depend on the extent of the company’s cooperation.
Remediation
In order for a company to receive full credit for remediation under the Revised Policy, a company must (1) demonstrate a thorough analysis of the root causes of the misconduct and implementation of remediation to address the root causes of the failure; (2) implement an effective compliance program; (3) appropriately discipline employees and supervisors responsible for the misconduct; (4) appropriately retain business records, and implement guidance and controls regarding the use of personal communications and “ephemeral messaging platforms”; and (5) take additional steps designed to demonstrate the company’s recognition of the seriousness of the misconduct, accept responsibility for the misconduct, and reduce repetition of the misconduct.
The Revised Policy sets forth a list of non-exhaustive factors that indicate an effective compliance program, which are similar to the factors set forth in DOJ’s “FCPA Corporate Enforcement Policy” and consistent with the U.S. Department of the Treasury’s “A Framework for OFAC Compliance Commitments.”[8] The hallmarks of an effective compliance program include establishing a culture of compliance; allocating adequate resources to the compliance function; hiring quality and experienced compliance personnel; providing authority and independence to the compliance function; performing an effective risk assessment and audit; appropriately compensating and promoting personnel in the compliance function; and implementing an effective reporting structure within the company.[9]
Aggravating Factors
Companies will not be afforded the presumption against imposing a fine and in favor of a non-prosecution agreement if certain aggravating factors are present. DOJ has identified a non-exhaustive list of these factors, which include, among others, (1) exporting items controlled for reasons of nuclear nonproliferation or missile technology to countries known to be nuclear proliferators, (2) exporting items used in the construction of weapons of mass destruction, (3) exporting items to a Specially Designated Global Terrorist or Foreign Terrorist Organization, (4) exporting military items to a hostile country, (5) violating export controls or sanctions requirements repeatedly or (6) the knowing involvement of an organization’s upper management in criminal conduct.[10]
If aggravating factors are present, but the company has otherwise satisfied the requirements of the Revised Policy, the company may face a different criminal resolution than companies who do not have any aggravating factors. While the company may, for example, still face a deferred prosecution agreement or guilty plea, the Revised Policy specifies that companies that voluntarily self-disclose, fully cooperate and timely remediate may receive a 50% or greater reduction in the fine that would otherwise be levied for the misconduct, and a commitment not to appoint an independent monitor if the company has an effective compliance program at the time of resolution.[11]
This change in policy signifies a continued effort by the government to encourage voluntary self-disclosures by companies in the export control and sanctions context. The Revised Policy, which follows on the heels of, and parallels, DOJ’s FCPA cooperation policy, provides a clear roadmap for companies who are contemplating making a voluntary disclosure, setting forth what will be expected of them in order to receive full cooperation credit. The Revised Policy contemplates and addresses privilege issues, data privacy issues, and blocking statutes, all of which can be obstacles to cooperation by an otherwise willing company.[12] In addition, the Revised Policy makes cooperation a particularly attractive option in situations where a company uncovers potentially willful violations at a company it has recently acquired.[13] Further, the Revised Policy recognizes that there may be other relevant regulators and signals an intent of DOJ to coordinate with those other regulators to avoid piling on penalties.[14]
The Revised Policy and its accompanying release announcement also indicate, however, an increased focus by DOJ in prosecuting willful sanctions violations, and the disclosures required in order to receive full cooperation credit are substantial. Among other things, companies that are contemplating making a voluntary self-disclosure are expected to make a determination as to the extent of any willfulness, and identify responsible employees and supervisors early in their analysis in order to take advantage of the cooperation guidance. To receive full credit, their obligations to cooperate and provide disclosures will extend far beyond the initial disclosure.
In sum, the Revised Policy provides greater clarity for companies evaluating voluntary self-disclosure, and for the first time permits financial institutions to seek cooperation credit. The decision as to whether, when, and to whom a voluntary self-disclosure should be made requires an informed case-by-case analysis.
Authored by Betty Santangelo, Peter H. White, Marc E. Elovitz, Gary Stein, Jennifer M. Opheim, Melissa G.R. Goldstein and Hannah M. Thibideau.
If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.
[1] U.S. Dep’t of Justice, “Department of Justice Revises and Re-Issues Export Control and Sanctions Enforcement Policy for Business Organizations,” Dec. 13, 2019, available here. The primary statutes governing export control and sanctions requirements are the Arms Export Control Act (AECA); the Export Control Reform Act (ECRA); and the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA). U.S. Dep’t of Justice, “Export Control and Sanctions Enforcement Policy for Business Organizations,” Dec. 13, 2019, available here.
[2] See U.S. Dep’t of Justice, “Export Control and Sanctions Enforcement Policy for Business Organizations,” Dec. 13, 2019 (“Revised Policy”), available here.
[3] David Burns, Principal Deputy Assistant Attorney General, “Remarks Announcing New Export Controls and Sanctions Enforcement Policy for Business Organizations,” Dec. 13, 2019, available here.
[4] Id. at 2.
[5] Id. at 4.
[6] Id.
[7] Id.
[8] See U.S. Dep’t of Justice, “9-47.120 FCPA Corporate Enforcement Policy” (updated March 2019) at 3, available here; see generally U.S. Dep’t of the Treasury, “A Framework for OFAC Compliance Commitments” (issued May 2, 2019), available here.
[9] Revised Policy at 4.
[10] Id.
[11] Id. at 2.
[12] Id. at 4-5.
[13] Id. at 3 n.7.
[14] Id. at 2 n.5 and 5 n.10.
This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2020 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.
All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
January 1, 2020
Read time: 2 min
California’s new law (AB 51) criminalizing arbitration agreements in enforcement will not take effect as scheduled. A federal court issued a temporary restraining order to halt any enforcement of this law.
There are serious questions regarding whether the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA) preempts AB 51. States are not permitted to override the FAA. Here, the federal court found that even to permit brief enforcement of this law would impermissibly cause disruption in making employment agreements, particularly given the criminal penalties that the law imposes.
This temporary restraining order will remain in place until the court rules on whether to grant a preliminary injunction, which is scheduled to occur on January 10, 2020. It seems likely that the court will extend its moratorium on enforcement, and will ultimately conclude that the FAA preempts AB 51.
Meanwhile, employers will be able to continue to require arbitration as a condition of employment.
The case is Chamber of Commerce of the USA et al. v. Becerra et al. Case No. 2:19-cv-02456-KJM-DB (E.D. Cal. Filed Dec. 9, 2019).
ARTICLE
December 2019
Read time: 1 min

ARTICLE
December 27, 2019
Read time: 1 min

ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
December 23, 2019
Read time: 6 min
As 2020 approaches, New York employers should be aware of the following changes to ensure continuing compliance with federal, state and local laws and regulations.
New York State enacted two new laws to provide employees with additional protections against wage discrimination.
Effective Oct. 8, 2019, the New York Equal Pay Law was amended to prohibit an employer from paying any employee who is a member of any “protected class status” a lower wage rate than the rate at which an employee outside the same protected class in the same establishment is paid for equal work. Protected class status under New York State Human Rights Law includes: age, race, creed, color, national origin, sexual orientation, gender expression or identity, military status, sex, disability, predisposing genetic characteristics, familial status, marital status, and domestic violence victim status. Equal work is defined as work which requires an equal level of skill, effort and responsibility and which is performed in similar working conditions. Certain exceptions to this law still apply and an employer is permitted to pay a different wage if that wage is based on factors such as seniority, quantity or quality of production, a merit system, or a bona fide factor such as education, training or experience.
Effective Jan. 6, 2020, the Salary Inquiry Ban prohibits employers from making certain inquiries, whether oral or written, formally or informally, about salary history information. Employers are further prohibited from relying on that information in deciding whether to hire an individual or determining the wages or salary of such individual. Nothing in this law prevents an applicant or current employee from voluntarily disclosing their salary history information. New York State law follows the existing New York City law. For more information on New York City’s Salary Inquiry Ban, see this prior SRZ Alert.[1]
New York State now prohibits employers from discriminating on the basis of reproductive health decision making. Governor Cuomo signed the new law on Nov. 8, 2019, only a few months after New York City added “sexual and other reproductive health decisions” to the protected categories under the New York City Human Rights Law. As a reminder, New York City’s amended Human Rights Law provides that protected sexual and reproductive health decisions include, but are not limited to, fertility-related medical procedures; sexually transmitted disease prevention, testing and treatment; and family planning services and counseling, such as birth control drugs and supplies, emergency contraception, sterilization procedures, pregnancy testing and abortion.[2]
The State law broadly defines “reproductive health decision making” as “including, but not limited to, the decision to use or access a particular drug, device or service.” Under the new law, employers are prohibited from accessing employee’s or employee’s dependent’s personal information regarding reproductive health decisions unless the employee has provided consent in writing. The law also prohibits employers from discriminating or retaliating against an employee because of the employee’s or the employee’s dependent’s reproductive health decisions or requiring an employee to sign a waiver that infringes upon the employee’s right to make reproductive health decisions.
Effective Jan. 7, 2020, employers must include a notice of the employee’s rights and remedies under this law in employee handbooks. Please see here for a form policy.[3]
Effective Dec. 31, 2019, the minimum wage for all employees who work in New York City for a New York City employer will be $15.00 per hour. On Long Island and in Westchester County, the minimum wage will increase to $13.00 per hour for workers. In the remainder of New York State, the minimum wage will be $11.80.
New Threshold for Salaries to be Exempt From Overtime
Typically, to be considered an employee exempt from the overtime pay requirements, an employee must satisfy the duties test as well as the salary test. The threshold for salaries for the salary test for exempt executive and administrative employees will change, effective Dec. 31, 2019. New York City exempt employees must be paid at least $1,125.00 per week ($58,5000.00 per year). Nassau, Suffolk and Westchester County exempt employees must be paid at least $975 per week ($50,700.00 per year). Exempt employees in the rest of New York State must be paid at least $885 per week ($46,020.00 per year).
Effective Jan. 1, 2020, the U.S. Department of Labor increased the salary threshold to $107,432 to be considered an exempt “Highly Compensated Employee.” The Department of Labor also increased the “Standard Salary Level” to $35,568 but that increase is irrelevant in states such as New York that have higher salary levels for the exemption. In addition, in recognition of evolving pay practices, the new rule allows employers to use nondiscretionary bonuses and incentive payments (including commissions) that are paid at least annually to satisfy up to 10% of the standard salary level.
New York Shield Act
On July 25, 2019, Governor Cuomo signed into law The Stop Hacks and Improve Electronic Data Security Act (“Shield Act”) amending existing breach notification laws to, among other things, expand the scope of persons and businesses, and private information, covered by existing law. It also imposes new data security requirements. The Shield Act took effect on Oct. 23, 2019, except for the new data security requirements, which will take effect on March 21, 2020.
The Shield Act imposes additional requirements on employers to implement and maintain administrative, technical and physical safeguards to protect the security, confidentiality and integrity of private information and its disposal. The new definition of private information in the Shield Act includes, but is not limited to, biometric information such as fingerprints or facial patterns, email addresses and corresponding passwords or security questions and answers, and financial account number without a required security code if an unauthorized person could access the account. The existing law covered such private information as Social Security numbers.
Authored by Mark E. Brossman, Scott A. Gold, Donna K. Lazarus and Cristell M.S. Fortune.
If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.
[1] “New York City to Ban Employer Inquiries and Reliance on Salary History,” SRZ Alert, April 7, 2017, available here.
[2] “New Developments for Employers Regarding Employee Reproductive Health Decisions, Marijuana Drug Testing and Wage Reporting Requirements,” SRZ Alert, June 6, 2019, available here.
[3] “Prohibition Against Discrimination on the Basis of Reproductive Health Decision Making,”.
This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2019 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.
All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
December 20, 2019
Read time: 12 min
A decision in Texas v. United States was issued by a divided three-judge panel of the US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit on December 18, 2019. This case presented once again the question whether the Affordable Care Act (ACA) is constitutional and sustainable, and questions of severability remain for the near future.
On December 18, 2019, a divided three-judge panel of the US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit issued its decision in Texas v. United States, No. 19-10011, a case presenting once again the question whether the Affordable Care Act (ACA) is constitutional and sustainable. The court held that the individual mandate is unconstitutional, but it reversed the district court’s conclusion that the mandate cannot be severed from the ACA, and remanded to the district court for further proceedings on that critical issue. The practical consequence of the Fifth Circuit’s ruling is to preserve the ACA without the mandate, at least for the time being.
The California Attorney General’s office has indicated that it will seek expedited review by the US Supreme Court. The challengers may cross-petition on the question of severability, likewise urging Supreme Court review before the end of the current term in June. But with the district court’s severability holding now vacated, the Supreme Court is less likely to feel pressured to hear the case expeditiously, if at all. It is presently too early to predict the likelihood of Supreme Court review. But if the case is returned to the district court for further proceedings, we can expect another decision on severability in the coming months, all but ensuring subsequent appeals absent an intervening legislative fix.
Background
In 2012, in NFIB v. Sebelius, the Supreme Court upheld the ACA’s individual health insurance mandate against several constitutional challenges. The Court held that Congress lacks authority under the Commerce Clause of the Constitution to require individuals to purchase health insurance, standing alone. But it held that the law could be upheld under Congress’s taxing power, because the mandate is structured as a tax penalty—termed an “individual shared responsibility payment”—that applies if a taxpayer does not have health insurance.
In February 2018, 20 states led by Texas sued the federal government, once again challenging the constitutionality of the ACA’s individual mandate. The plaintiff states contend that the individual mandate has been made unconstitutional by Congress’s passage of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) in 2017, which set the amount of the tax penalty for taxpayers without health insurance at zero. In light of the TCJA, they argue, the mandate can no longer be considered an exercise of Congress’s taxing power, because there is no tax. The plaintiffs further argue that the individual mandate was not severable from the rest of the ACA and that, as a result, the entire ACA should be struck down.
In the district court, the federal government agreed with the plaintiffs’ position and declined to defend the constitutionality of the individual mandate. The government argued, however, that most of the provisions of the ACA were severable from the individual mandate, apart from the provisions dealing with preexisting conditions. Sixteen other states and the District of Columbia, led by California, intervened in the district court to defend the constitutionality of the ACA.
In December 2018, the district court granted partial summary judgment in favor of the plaintiff states, holding that the ACA must be struck down in its entirety. The district court concluded that the individual mandate is no longer a valid exercise of Congress’s taxing power because, now that the amount of the penalty is zero, the mandate will not produce any revenue for the government. And it held that because the individual mandate is “essential” to the ACA, the proper remedy was to invalidate the ACA in its entirety. The ACA remained valid and effective because the district court also issued only a declaratory judgment, and not an injunction order halting the ACA.
The intervenor states—joined by four new intervening states and the United States House of Representatives—appealed the district court’s decision to the Fifth Circuit. The federal government also initially appealed the decision, but after filing its appeal, the federal government changed its position on severability, informing the Fifth Circuit that it now believes that the entire ACA must be struck down. The federal government thus argued for affirmance of the district court’s decision.
Issues Presented
The parties’ briefs raised three principal issues for the Fifth Circuit’s consideration: (1) Whether the plaintiff states have standing to challenge the constitutionality of the ACA; (2) whether the individual mandate remains constitutional in light of Congress’s decision in the TCJA to set the penalty for noncompliance with the mandate at zero; and (3) whether, if the individual mandate is unconstitutional, it is severable from the other provisions of the ACA.
The Fifth Circuit’s Decision
Standing. The Fifth Circuit concluded first that the plaintiff states had standing to challenge the ACA. “Though the plaintiffs and the federal defendants are in almost complete agreement on the merits of the case,” the court reasoned, “the government continues to enforce the entire Act,” and “[t]he federal government has made no indication that it will begin dismantling any part of the ACA in the absence of a final court order.” What is more, according to the Fifth Circuit, there is ample evidence that each of the states is incurring costs to comply with the ACA. Most notably, the mandate “causes people to buy insurance, which increases the administrative costs of the states to report, manage, and track the insurance coverage of their employees and Medicaid recipients.” Thus, according to the court, the states had standing to seek the invalidation of the law despite the federal government’s agreement that the law should fall.
The court held also that the states that had intervened as defendants had standing to appeal the district court’s decision. “[T]he district court’s judgment, if ultimately given effect, would: (1) strip these states of funding that they receive under the ACA; and (2) threaten to hamstring these states in possible future litigation because of the district court judgment’s potentially preclusive effect.” This was adequate, in the Fifth Circuit’s view, to support standing to appeal. Having reached that conclusion, the court sidestepped the question whether the House of Representatives also had standing.
Unconstitutionality of the Individual Mandate. The Fifth Circuit next concluded that the individual mandate is unconstitutional in its current form. The court based its decision principally on an interpretation of National Federation of Independent Business v. Sebelius, 567 U.S. 519 (2012). The court described that opinion as “extremely fractured,” but pieced together separate statements that it concluded require invalidating the mandate. In particular, the court explained that the Chief Justice held that the mandate could not be justified under either the Commerce Clause or the Necessary and Proper Clause. Although no other justice joined that part of his opinion, the dissent of Justices Scalia, Kennedy, Thomas, and Alito reached the same conclusions. Thus, according to the Fifth Circuit, “[a] majority of the court . . . concluded that the individual mandate is not constitutional under either” of those clauses. And because failing to comply with the mandate no longer results in a tax, it cannot be justified by Congress’s taxing power.
Severability. Finally, on perhaps the most impactful question, the Fifth Circuit reversed the district court’s holding that the remainder of the ACA had to fall with the individual mandate. At a general level, the severability question asks whether Congress would have passed a given statute even with an invalidated provision struck from it; if the answer is no, the whole statute must fall with the invalidated provision. The district court held that the individual mandate was not severable; the Fifth Circuit expressed unease with that holding. Severability is a challenging inquiry into hypothetical congressional intent, as opposed to the usual bread-and-butter of determining what a statute means. The court expressed particular uneasiness undertaking the severability analysis in the context of “an extensive, complex, and oft-amended statutory scheme.”
At bottom, the court of appeals concluded that the district court’s severability analysis was “incomplete” and required a do-over. That was so in two respects, according to the court. “First, the [district court] opinion gives relatively little attention to the intent of the 2017 Congress, which appears in the analysis only as an afterthought despite the fact that the 2017 Congress had the benefit of hindsight over the 2010 Congress: it was able to observe the ACA’s actual implementation.” And “[s]econd, the district court opinion does not do the necessary legwork of parsing through the over 900 pages of the post-2017 ACA, explaining how particular segments are inextricably linked to the individual mandate.” The Fifth Circuit thus affirmed the district court’s holding with respect to the individual mandate but vacated the district court’s invalidation of the entire statute.
Judge King dissented. She would have held that the challengers lacked standing, that the individual mandate is constitutional, and that even if it weren’t, it would be severable
Immediate Practical Impact and Next Steps
The practical impact of the Fifth Circuit’s decision will be limited in the near term. Further appellate proceedings before the Supreme Court are nearly certain, as the California Attorney General has signaled his intent in media interviews to file a petition for expedited Supreme Court review. Whether the Supreme Court will grant review on an expedited basis, on a slower timetable, or at all remains to be seen. In the meanwhile, the status quo will remain. In all events, the Fifth Circuit’s judgment means, at most, that the individual mandate is un¬enforceable; the remainder of the ACA will remain in place pending Supreme Court review or, if the court declines to take the case, further proceedings before the district court.
The deadline for filing a petition for consideration by the Supreme Court is 90 days from the date of decision. The 90-day period can be extended up to 60 days, but the Attorney General of California has indicated that he intends to move faster. At this point in the Court’s calendar, it would be a significant challenge for the case to be heard during the current 2019-20 term, but not unheard of. More likely, the Court would either deny the petition (waiting for the case to return after the district court’s remand proceedings are concluded), or grant review and set the case for argument in the fall of 2020 for a decision by June of 2021. Either way, an ultimate decision by the Supreme Court is unlikely before 2021.
Looking Beyond the Remand or the Supreme Court
While the Supreme Court is likely to be the ultimate judicial arbiter of this dispute, stakeholders should understand that it might not be the final word. Even if the Supreme Court ultimately invalidated the entire law (an unlikely outcome given the Fifth Circuit’s punt on the issue of severability), it would not mean immediate chaos will ensue. All three branches of government have tools at their disposal to deal with the fallout from a wholesale invalidation of the ACA.
While Republicans in Congress have generally been supportive of repealing the ACA, and of the pending challenge, a significant cohort likely would be troubled by the prospect of an immediate, total unraveling of the law. Senator Thom Tillis (R-NC) has already introduced the “Protect Act,” S.1125, a law that would re-establish pre-existing condition protections, guaranteed issuance requirements, community rating and other popular insurance reforms. Twenty-four Republican senators have joined as cosponsors, revealing some consternation over political blowback that might ensue should Title I of the ACA be undone.
Senate Republicans also could restore a tax penalty to the mandate to resolve the claim that the law is no longer constitutional under Congress’ taxing authority. Because the plaintiffs’ claims in Texas v. United States depend on the fact that Congress set the tax penalty for noncompliance with the individual mandate at zero, Congress likely could undo any decision striking down the law on that basis by setting the penalty at some greater amount. Many Republicans in Congress, along with the White House, would be loath to save the ACA, and even more loath to do so by enacting a new tax, but they could do so on a short-term basis to buy time to figure out next steps.
The administration’s position also has been shifting, and could shift further when a case reaches the Supreme Court. The administration most recently asserted some parts of the ACA should remain intact, and that the court should invalidate the ACA only in the states that brought the suit. The administration could bring these or other arguments to the Supreme Court, should it get to that point. Moreover, it may not be this administration arguing before the Supreme Court. If the Court hears argument in the case during its 2020-21 Term, a Democratic administration may take the reins in the meanwhile and switch (again) to defending the ACA. The Court may take a potential “changing of the guard” into account in scheduling oral argument and briefing deadlines, signaling deference to the political process. Any administration, regardless who it is, could petition the Court delay an effective date of a ruling to allow it time to implement whatever decision the Court ultimately reaches.

ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
December 20, 2019
Read time: 8 min
Final regulations relating to the determination of the foreign tax credit following the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act were released earlier this month. Though largely similar to the proposed regulations, taxpayers may be interested in the clarifications on expense allocation and apportionment, foreign branch income and deemed paid taxes under section 960.
On December 2, 2019, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) and US Department of the Treasury (Treasury) released final regulations (TD 9882) (the Final Regulations) relating to the determination of the foreign tax credit following the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA). The Final Regulations finalize proposed regulations that were published on December 7, 2018 (the Proposed Regulations), as well as proposed regulations on overall foreign losses that were published on June 25, 2012, and certain portions of proposed regulations published on November 7, 2007, relating to a US taxpayer’s obligation to notify the IRS of a foreign tax redetermination. The IRS and Treasury also released new proposed regulations that provide additional guidance on the foreign tax credit, which will be addressed in a separate On the Subject.
The Final Regulations are substantially similar to the Proposed Regulations, with several important clarifications and amendments. In particular, taxpayers may be interested in certain aspects of the Final Regulations relating to expense allocation and apportionment, foreign branch income, and deemed paid taxes under section 960, each of which is discussed below.
Expense Allocation and Apportionment
Foreign Branch Category Income
Deemed Paid Taxes under Section 960
Takeaway Point
The Final Regulations are substantially similar to the Proposed Regulations, with several important clarifications and amendments. In particular, in light of the Final Regulations and clarifications provided in the preamble, taxpayers may want to review positions they have taken under the Proposed Regulations with respect to allocating and apportioning expenses for FDII purposes, the treatment of disregarded transactions involving foreign branches, and the treatment of deemed paid taxes associated with timing differences.

ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
December 19, 2019
Read time: 11 min
The Treasury Department and the IRS have issued highly anticipated guidance in the area of stewardship expenses and R&D expenses. The 2019 Proposed Regulations also provide extensive guidance on allocating and apportioning foreign taxes, including base and timing differences rules and somewhat surprising rules on allocating taxes related to disregarded payments. Taxpayers should be aware of these new rules regarding the allocation of foreign taxes, which could prevent taxpayers from obtaining foreign tax credits with respect to certain foreign taxes paid.
On December 2, 2019, the Treasury Department (Treasury) and the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) issued proposed foreign tax credit regulations (the “2019 Proposed Regulations”) that address, among other items, the allocation and apportionment of deductions and creditable foreign taxes. Three key allocation and apportionment issues addressed in the 2019 Proposed Regulations include allocation and apportionment of (1) stewardship expenses, (2) research and experimentation (R&E) expenses, (3) foreign taxes, including base and timing difference rules and rules regarding taxes related to disregarded payments. Of note, rules for allocating foreign taxes include several entirely new provisions that could prevent taxpayers from obtaining foreign tax credits associated with disregarded payments.
Allocation and Apportionment of Stewardship Expenses
The 2019 Proposed Regulations provide that stewardship expenses are definitely related and allocable not only to actual dividends, but also to inclusions received or accrued from related corporations, such as inclusions under sections 951 and 951A, and the section 78 gross-up. The 2019 Proposed Regulations also require stewardship expenses to be apportioned based on the relative values of a taxpayer’s stock assets, using the same method used to allocate and apportion interest expense. As a result, the fair market value method, which is not allowed for interest expense, is no longer allowed for stewardship expenses; rather, the book value of the taxpayer’s stock assets must be used. The proposed regulations extend stewardship expenses to include expenses incurred with respect to partnerships.
The 2019 Proposed Regulations also include a conforming change to the rules regarding the allocation and apportionment of stewardship expenses of an affiliated group. Stewardship expenses of an affiliated group are generally allocated and apportioned as if all members were a single corporation. In view of the treatment of stewardship expenses described above, it is unclear whether the proposed regulations suggest that expenses related to stewardship of US group members should be allocated against dividends and inclusions from related foreign corporations, e.g., subpart F and GILTI inclusions, thereby reducing the group’s ability to claim foreign tax credits.
Treasury and the IRS have requested comments on whether the general allocation and apportionment rules should include exceptions for stewardship expenses that are incurred to facilitate compliance with reporting, legal, or regulatory requirements, noting that such expenses might more appropriately be treated as definitely related to the gross income produced by the particular asset whose ownership mandated the stewardship expense. Comments were also requested on whether the definition of stewardship expenses, which did not change, should be adjusted to distinguish between oversight-related stewardship expenses and day-to-day management activities that are supportive in nature (and therefore not stewardship expenses). Finally, Treasury and the IRS requested comments on whether the stewardship allocation and apportionment rules should be further updated as a result of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, and increasingly global, and mobile, business practices.
Allocation and Apportionment of Research & Experimentation Expenses
The 2019 Proposed Regulations provide that no R&E expenses are allocated or apportioned to amounts included under section 951, 951A, or 1293. Thus, no R&E expenses are allocated to the section 951A category. The rationale for this rule is that section 174 R&E expenses generally give rise to intangible property, and that under sections 367(d) and 482, the person incurring the R&E expenses must be compensated when such intangible property gives rise to income. Therefore, R&E expenses of a US person should not give rise to income in the section 951A category or to subpart F income or PFIC inclusions. The 2019 Proposed Regulations accomplish this result by providing that R&E expenses are definitely related to all gross intangible income reasonably connected with the relevant Standard Industrial Classification Manual code category of the taxpayer, where gross intangible income does not include dividends or any amounts included under section 951, 951A, or 1293. It is notable that this approach, if applicable for FDII regulations, could result in a greater amount of R&E expense allocated to reduce the amount eligible for the FDII deduction under section 250.
The 2019 Proposed Regulations eliminate the optional gross income method of allocating R&E expenses. Under the new rules, taxpayers must allocate R&E expenses (other than expenses exclusively apportioned to the place the R&E is performed under Treas. Reg. 1.861-17(b)) on the basis of relative amounts of gross receipts from sales and services. The 2019 Proposed Regulations also eliminate (1) the legally mandated R&E rule, which provides that R&E expenses incurred solely to meet legal requirements in a specific jurisdiction and that cannot reasonably be expected to generate amounts of gross income outside a single geographic source, are allocated directly to gross income within that geographic source, and (2) the increased exclusive apportionment rule, which allows taxpayers to allocate a higher amount of R&E expenses exclusively to the specific geographic location where the R&D is performed.
The 2019 Proposed Regulations include other rules relating to R&E expenses, including rules relating to participants in cost sharing agreements and rules relating to taxpayers that own partnerships.
Foreign Taxes
The 2019 Proposed Regulations provide a detailed framework for allocating and apportioning foreign taxes in Prop. Reg. §1.861-20, including base and timing difference rules and rules for allocating taxes related to disregarded payments.
General Rules
The rules in the 2019 Proposed Regulations for allocating and apportioning foreign taxes are generally consistent with current law: taxes are allocated and apportioned on the basis of the income as computed under foreign law on which the tax is imposed. The 2019 Proposed Regulations provide more detailed guidance on how to apply this principle. In general, foreign gross income is assigned to the grouping to which the corresponding US item is assigned. If an item of foreign gross income arises from the same transaction as an item of gross income under US tax law, the foreign gross income item is assigned to the same statutory or residual grouping as the related US item. This concept is illustrated by several examples in the regulations. One example addresses a situation in which USP sells stock of CFC2 and recognizes $800 of local country gain and $800 of gain for US federal income tax purposes; the US gain is included in USP’s income as a dividend under section 1248. The $800 of local country gross income is assigned to the same separate category to which the US dividend would have been assigned, notwithstanding the fact that the local country gross income is treated for local purposes as gain from the sale of stock, not a dividend.
Timing Differences
Under Prop. Reg. § 1.861-20(d)(2), if there is no recognition of US gross income or loss in the US taxable year in which foreign gross income is included, the item of foreign gross income is characterized and assigned to the grouping to which the corresponding US item would be assigned if the foreign gross income were recognized in the US taxable year. Prop. Reg. §1.861-20(d)(2)(i). To illustrate how this rule works, assume $80 of foreign tax is imposed on $400 of foreign gross income in connection with the sale of an asset in Year 1, where there is no corresponding US item in that year. Assume further that if the $400 of foreign gross income were recognized for US tax purposes in Year 1, it would be assigned to the general category. Under the timing difference rule, the $400 of foreign law income is therefore allocated to the general category, and the $80 of foreign tax is also allocated to the general category.
Moreover, if the foreign gross income is of a type that is excluded from US gross income under federal income tax (but the taxes are not attributable to a base difference), then the item of foreign gross income is assigned to the grouping to which the item of gross income would be assigned if it were included in US gross income. Prop. Reg. §1.861-20(d)(2)(ii)(A).
Exclusive List of Base Differences
The 2019 Proposed Regulations provide an exclusive list of items of foreign gross income that are attributable to a base difference. This list consists of: (1) section 101 death benefits; (2) section 102 gifts and inheritances; (3) section 118 contributions to capital; (4) section 1032 receipts of money or other property in exchange for stock (including in a section 351(a) exchange); (5) a section 721 receipt of money or other property in exchange for a partnership interest; (6) a section 301(c)(2) distribution of property by a corporation as a return of basis, and (7) a section 733 distribution to a partner. If an item of foreign gross income is attributable to a base difference, that foreign gross income is assigned to the residual grouping, such that that taxes paid by a CFC are not creditable. Prop. Reg. §1.861-20(d)(2)(ii)(A). It should be noted that, under these rules, foreign taxes on common transactions such as a partnership distribution to a CFC partner would not be creditable. Foreign taxes that are paid by a domestic corporation and attributable to a base difference are assigned to the category described in section 904(d)(2)(H)(i) (which cross-references foreign branch income). Prop. Reg. §1.904-6(b)(1).
Taxes on Disregarded Payments
The 2019 Proposed Regulations provide specific rules for foreign taxes imposed with respect to disregarded payments. Prop. Reg. §1.861-20(d)(3)(ii). A disregarded payment by a foreign branch to its owner is assigned under section 987 principles to the statutory or residual grouping to which the income out of which the payment made is assigned (i.e., based on the type of income that the assets of the foreign branch generated). Prop. Reg. §1.861-20(d)(3)(ii)(A). Example 9 in Proposed Regulation section 1.861-20(g)(10) illustrates the application of this rule: USP owns CFC1, which owns a foreign disregarded entity (FDE). FDE owns all the stock of CFC2. The tax book value of the assets of FDE, including CFC2, include 75% general category assets and 25% passive category assets. FDE makes a $400 disregarded payment of interest to CFC1, with respect to which CFC1 pays $80 tax. The $400 is treated as made ratably out of all of FDE’s after-tax income, which is deemed to have been 75% general category and 25% passive category income. Therefore, 75% of the $80 foreign tax, or $60, is apportioned to the general category and the remaining 25% ($20) is apportioned to the passive category.
Surprisingly, a disregarded payment by a CFC to a foreign branch is assigned to the residual grouping, and therefore foreign taxes on such a disregarded payment cannot be deemed paid under section 960. Prop. Reg. §§1.861-20(d)(3)(ii)(B); 1.904-6(b)(2)(ii). The preamble to the 2019 Proposed Regulations provides no rationale for denying section 960 credits to such “southbound” disregarded payments.
In addition, the Proposed Regulations provide that foreign gross income attributable to foreign law gain on disregarded sales or exchanges of property is treated as a timing difference, and the foreign gross income is characterized and assigned to the grouping to which the US item would have been assigned if it had been recognized in that taxable year. Prop. Reg. §§1.861-20(d)(3)(ii)(C); 1.861-20(d)(2)(i). The Proposed Regulations also provide special rules on items of foreign gross income included by the taxpayer in its capacity as a shareholder; reverse hybrids, and gain on the sale of a disregarded entity. Prop. Reg. §1.861-20(d)(3)(i), (iii), (iv).
Other Items
The 2019 Proposed Regulations also address other issues, including the definition of financial services income, foreign tax redeterminations under section 905(c), the disallowance of certain foreign tax credits under section 965(g), and the application of the foreign tax credit limitation to consolidated groups.
Takeaways
Following the Tax Cuts and Jobs Acts, the allocation and apportionment rules are more important because (1) the US corporate tax rate was reduced from 35% to 21%, which correspondingly reduces a taxpayer’s ability to claim foreign tax credits under section 904, and (2) foreign income taxes assigned to the section 951A category cannot be carried forward or back, so if the taxes in that category cannot be used in the current year because of the section 904 foreign tax credit limitation, they effectively disappear.
The 2019 Proposed Regulations provide highly anticipated guidance in the area of stewardship expenses and R&D expenses. The 2019 Proposed Regulations also provide extensive guidance on allocating and apportioning foreign taxes, including base and timing differences rules and somewhat surprising rules on allocating taxes related to disregarded payments. In particular, taxpayers should be aware of these new rules regarding allocation of foreign taxes, which could prevent taxpayers from obtaining foreign tax credits with respect to certain foreign taxes paid.