Content Type: Article

  • COVID-19 Update: Options for Non-Payment of Rent for Commercial Landlords

    COVID-19 Update: Options for Non-Payment of Rent for Commercial Landlords

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    COVID-19 Update: Options for Non-Payment of Rent for Commercial Landlords

    June 26, 2020

    Read time: 9 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Failure by tenants to pay rent due under commercial leases is becoming a common occurrence in the Coronavirus (COVID-19) world. Unsurprisingly, rent collection difficulties are having far-reaching consequences on the property industry, particularly in relation to commercial property landlords and their financiers.

    In response to the current economic climate, and in advance of the June quarter day, the UK Government recently announced new measures to protect commercial tenants, including an extension of the temporary ban on landlords forfeiting leases for non-payment of rent. The initial ban (set out under the Coronavirus Act 2020) was due to expire on 30 June 2020, but has now been extended until 30 September 2020.

    In light of the temporary curtailments of well-trodden remedies which were previously available to landlords faced with rental arrears, we have produced a user-friendly table below which summarises the current position on these options. The options referred to in the table are by no means exhaustive and should of course be considered in the context of the terms of the relevant lease. In these unprecedented times, we recommend that both landlords and tenants review their lease documentation to ensure that all options, remedies and reliefs are sufficiently explored.

    The latest announcement in relation to the extension of protection measures for tenants follows the publication of a new voluntary Code of Practice for Landlords and Tenants. We have highlighted further key details on the Code below. Importantly, the Code confirms that tenants will remain liable for rent and service charge payments (subject to any contrary agreement being reached) – landlords and tenants need to be aware that, notwithstanding recent legislative changes, rent and other sums of money will continue to accrue during this “holding period”.

    Whether you are a landlord, tenant or financier, please feel free to contact the McDermott real estate team for advice and guidance on your next steps.

    In depth

    OPTION

    SUMMARY

    COVID-19 LIMITATIONS

    Forfeiture

    This remedy allows a landlord to end a lease before the expiry date. Landlords will “re-enter” the premises and take possession of the premises – effectively terminating the lease. This can occur peaceably (for example, by changing the locks) or through court action.  

    Landlords were initially prohibited from forfeiting a lease for non-payment of rent (or other sums, including service charges and insurance rent) until 30 June 2020. This period is now extended until 30 September 2020, providing business tenants with an additional three-month window. The extension of this moratorium on forfeiture will come into force on 29 June 2020.

    Some landlords have been exploring the possibility of forfeiting leases for reasons other than for non-payment of rent, e.g., for a business tenant’s insolvency. This may be a viable option because it does not fall within the suspension provisions, but will bring additional complexities (see the insolvency provisions below).

    In March 2020, the Government confirmed that correspondence between a landlord and tenant during the moratorium would not amount to waiving the right to forfeit (this provision expires on 30 June 2020). Landlords should be careful not to waive any such right if they enter into discussions with tenants going forward.    

    Debt Proceedings

    Landlords can issue debt proceedings in court to recover unpaid rent.

    There is currently no curtailment on a landlord’s ability to issue debt proceedings.

    However, landlords should remain alert to the financial and reputational costs of issuing debt proceedings in these unprecedented times. In addition, given the backlog of cases with HM Courts & Tribunals Service, it would likely take several months for any debt claim to be satisfied.

    Commercial Rent Arrears Recovery (CRAR)

    Landlords can instruct an enforcement agent to take control of a tenant’s goods and sell them in order to recover an equivalent value to any rental arrear.

    Landlords can only pursue CRAR if a tenant has at least 90 days’ net unpaid rent outstanding until 30 June 2020. 

    The UK Government has announced that from 30 June 2020, landlords will only be able to use CRAR if a tenant has at least 189 days’ net unpaid rent outstanding. This requirement will expire on 30 September 2020. We await review of the final legislation to confirm the position.

    Statutory Demands

    Landlords can issue a written/statutory demand for payment of a debt. A statutory demand that has not been satisfied within 21 days can be used by a landlord to trigger insolvency of the tenant entity (assuming the sum or sums demanded exceed £750).

    Landlords are unable to issue statutory demands between 1 March 2020 and 30 June 2020 (or one month after the Corporate Insolvency and Governance Bill comes into force, if later) if the demand forms the basis of a winding-up petition presented at any point after 27 April 2020.

    These proposals form part of the Corporate Insolvency and Governance Bill, which is currently progressing through Parliament but at the time of writing has yet to receive Royal Assent).

    An amendment that extends the temporary ban until 30 September 2020 has been tabled. This amendment is expected to appear in the next iteration of the Bill.

    Statutory demands that do not form the basis of a winding-up petition can still be served. However, a statutory demand without the threat of a winding-up petition will be of limited use to a landlord. 

    Winding-Up Petitions

    Landlords can issue a winding-up petition to place a tenant entity into compulsory liquidation because the tenant is unable to pay its debts.

    Landlords are unable to present a winding-up petition between 27 April 2020 and 30 June 2020 (or one month after the Bill comes into force, if later) unless they have a reasonable belief that one of the following is true:

    ·         COVID-19 has not had a financial effect on the debtor.

    ·         The debtor would have been unable to pay its debts even if COVID-19 had not had a financial effect on the debtor.

    “Financial effect” means the debtor’s financial position worsened in consequence of, or for reasons relating to, COVID-19.

    The proposals similarly form part of the Corporate Insolvency and Governance Bill.

    An amendment that extends the temporary ban until 30 September 2020 has been tabled. This amendment is expected to appear in the next iteration of the Bill.

    These measures will likely prevent almost any debt-based winding-up petition from being presented.

    Administration Orders

    Landlords can file an Administration Order to appoint an administrator to pursue a tenant for unpaid rent.

    Unlike the other insolvency procedures, there is no limitation of a landlord’s ability to appoint an administrator. However, due to the cost of the procedure, landlords are unlikely to pursue this option.

    Security Enforcement

    Landlords can enforce any available security to recover the cost of any outstanding sums, i.e., a bank guarantee, a surety, a former tenant, a rent deposit or an authorised guarantee agreement.

    There is currently no curtailment of a landlord’s ability to enforce these forms of available security. Prior to any enforcement, a landlord should review the security documents to ensure that any such right is correctly exercised.

    New Code of Practice for Landlords and Tenants

    On 19 June 2020, the UK Government published a new voluntary Code of Practice for Landlords and Tenants (“The Code”), encouraging landlords to engage in fair and transparent discussions with tenants over rental payments. The Code applies to all commercial tenancies, although it is expected to be of greater significance for landlords and tenants operating in the retail and hospitality/leisure sectors.

    The Code will apply until 24 June 2021. Find out more information in the article “Code of Practice for commercial property relationships during the COVID-19 pandemic.”

    Key points to note include the following:

    1. Rent Arrears

    The Code confirms that tenants will remain liable for rent arrears, subject to a contrary agreement being reached with their landlords. Tenants that struggle to pay rent when it falls due should seek to enter into a rent payment plan, seek rent deferrals, or ask a landlord to waive contractual default interest on unpaid sums. Where reasonable, landlords should provide such concessions while taking into account their own duties and financial commitments.

    Notably, where tenants have received funds and savings from government support schemes, these should be used to pay rents as well as other financial liabilities.

    2. Service Charges

    Service and insurance charges should continue to be paid in full (subject to any contrary agreement with the landlord). However, where practicable, e.g., in cases where the lack of full use of the property means running costs are lower than forecasted, charges should be reduced where appropriate.

    3. Impact on Banking Covenants and Financiers

    Where a landlord’s commercial property is subject to a mortgage, a landlord will owe obligations to the bank. These obligations will typically extend to ensuring the protection of any rental income stream relating to the property. Importantly, the Code and the COVID-19-related legislation do not suspend any obligations owed by a landlord to its lender. However, as the financial sector is encouraged to assist businesses during the current crisis (with UK Finance stating its commitment to showing flexibility to commercial borrowers), it is generally considered that lenders may (or should) be more sympathetic in their dealings with borrowers in circumstances where the borrower is in breach of its financial covenants under their facility agreement due to legislative changes and/or COVID-19-related circumstances.

    As a practical measure, it is recommended that landlords are proactive in terms of initiating a dialogue with their lender about any actual or likely future breach of their financial covenants. The decision will, of course, rest with the lender in terms of whether they are prepared to waive any breach but early communication is paramount to ensure productive discussions and preserve the relationship between the parties.

    4. Status

    The Code is voluntary and therefore places no legal obligation on landlords at this time. The Code does not undermine or alter the basis of the legal relationship or existing lease contracts, or override arrangements that have already been put in place. Nonetheless, the Code confirms the legal position that tenants are still required to pay their rent in full, with any variation in payment terms only becoming effective on agreement with their landlord.

    This article was authored with contribution from Ryan Clarke, Trainee

    Authors

    Rosemary Tulloch

    Senior Associate

    London – 22 Bishopsgate

    More insights

  • Prudential Regulators Amend Swap Margin Rules; Prudential Regulators/CFTC Propose Extension of Compliance Dates

    Prudential Regulators Amend Swap Margin Rules; Prudential Regulators/CFTC Propose Extension of Compliance Dates

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Prudential Regulators Amend Swap Margin Rules; Prudential Regulators/CFTC Propose Extension of Compliance Dates

    June 26, 2020

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On June 25, 2020, federal agencies (the Department of the Treasury, Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, Farm Credit Administration and Federal Housing Finance Agency, collectively, the “Agencies”) finalized changes to their final rule (“Final Rule”)[1] in order to facilitate implementation of prudent risk management strategies at banks and other companies having significant swap activities. The Agencies and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (“CFTC”) also both separately published interim rule announcements and requests for comment (“Interim Final Rules”),[2],[3] proposing to extend the swap initial margin compliance dates for smaller covered entities.

    The Final Rule amends the Agencies’ regulations adopted in 2015 (“Swap Margin Rule”)[4] requiring swap dealers and security-based swap dealers under the Agencies’ respective jurisdictions to exchange margin with their counterparties for swaps that are not centrally cleared.

    Under the Final Rule[5]:

    1. Entities within the same banking organization will not be required to hold a specific amount of initial margin for non-cleared inter-affiliate swaps. The Final Rule will allow firms greater flexibility to transfer collateral internally and support prudent risk management.[6]
    2. Phase-five compliance (with compliance date of Sept. 1, 2020) has been changed to cover entities falling within $50 billion up to $750 billion of average daily aggregate notional amounts (“AANA”), and an additional phase-six compliance date of Sept. 1, 2021 will be available for the smallest covered swap entities and financial end-users falling within $8 billion up to $50 billion of AANA.[7]
    3. In order to aid transition from the London Interbank Offered Rate (“LIBOR”) to alternative reference rates, swap entities may amend legacy swaps (grandfathered from Swap Margin Rule compliance) to replace LIBOR (or other interbank offered rates which are also expected to undergo cessation) without triggering margin exchange requirements and thus retain their legacy status.
    4. Swap entities may effect risk-reducing portfolio compression, or make other non-substantive technical amendments or notional reductions to their legacy swaps portfolios, without altering their legacy status.
    5. Pursuant to documentation requirements under the Swap Margin Rule requiring execution of trading documentation regarding credit support arrangements, a covered swap entity is not required to execute initial margin trading documentation with a counterparty prior to the time that it is required to collect or post initial margin.
    6. Previously published rules allowing certainty for covered swap entities as they prepare for Brexit remain unchanged.[8]

    Under the Interim Final Rules:

    The Agencies’ Interim Final Rule adds an additional proposed grace period for phase-five and phase-six entities, extending their respective compliance dates to Sept. 1, 2021 (for phase five) and Sept. 1, 2022 (for phase six). The CFTC also announced a proposal for an extension for phase-six covered entities for initial margin compliance to Sept. 1, 2022. Comments on each will be accepted for 60 days following their respective publications in the Federal Register.

    Authored by Craig Stein, Atul Joshi and Sean D. Locklear.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] View the Final Rule.

    [2] View the Interim Final Rule from the Agencies.

    [3] View the proposed interim rule announcement from the CFTC.

    [4] View the Swap Margin Rule.

    [5] In addition to other changes, the Final Rule makes certain technical changes to relocate the provision within the rule addressing amendments to legacy swaps in order to comply with qualified financial contract rules.

    [6] The inter-affiliate swap will still, however, remain subject to variation margin requirements. Initial margin will also still be required in the case of a depository institution’s total exposure to all affiliates exceeding 15% of its tier 1 capital. “Tier 1 capital” means the sum of common equity tier 1 capital as defined in 12 CFR 3.20(b) and additional tier 1 capital as defined in 12 CFR 3.20(c), as reported in the institution’s most recent Consolidated Reports of Income and Condition (Call Report).

    [7] The Swap Margin Rule took effect under a phased compliance schedule from 2016 to 2020 for both initial and variation margin. Swaps entered into by a covered entity prior to its effective phase-in date, and which continue to be held, are grandfathered from the Swap Margin Rule’s requirements until they expire. While variation margin was completely phased-in for all covered entities by March 1, 2017, initial margin has been phased in over five phases from Sept. 1, 2016 to Sept. 1, 2020, depending on the size of the covered swap entity’s portfolio of non-cleared swaps and the counterparty’s portfolio of non-cleared swaps.

    [8] The previously published interim final rule provided a covered swap entity with the ability to continue to service its cross-border clients in the event that the United Kingdom withdrew from the European Union without a withdrawal agreement. A withdrawal agreement was later ratified in January 2020.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2020 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Craig Stein

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Sean D. Locklear

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • The COVID-19 Outbreak at the Soldiers’ Home in Holyoke

    The COVID-19 Outbreak at the Soldiers’ Home in Holyoke

    ARTICLE

    The COVID-19 Outbreak at the Soldiers’ Home in Holyoke

    June 25, 2020

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Mark Pearlstein was appointed by MA Gov. Baker to conduct an independent investigation into the COVID-19 outbreak at the Holyoke Soldiers’ Home.

    In depth
    Authors

    Mark W. Pearlstein

    Partner

    Boston

    More insights

  • District of Columbia Powers of Attorney

    ARTICLE

    District of Columbia Powers of Attorney

    July 2020

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Caitlin Orr provides a guide on this topic in Practical Law, a resource by Thomson Reuters.

    Access the guide by clicking here.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Preparing Your Workforce: How to Avoid Legal Landmines when Bringing Employees Back

    Preparing Your Workforce: How to Avoid Legal Landmines when Bringing Employees Back

    ARTICLE

    Preparing Your Workforce: How to Avoid Legal Landmines when Bringing Employees Back

    June 24, 2020

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Preparing Your Workforce: How to Avoid Legal Landmines when Bringing Employees Back

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Taxation of Virtual Currency Staking Activities

    Taxation of Virtual Currency Staking Activities

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Taxation of Virtual Currency Staking Activities

    June 24, 2020

    Read time: 9 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Stakers—taxpayers involved in proof of stake (PoS) validation of blockchain transactions—are operating in uncharted tax waters. Treasury and the IRS have provided no guidance regarding when or whether staking rewards are included in taxable income. This article reviews various considerations that may help stakers document activities, rewards and expenses that support their federal and state tax positions.

    In depth

    Taxpayers involved in proof of stake (PoS) validation (stakers) have no direct tax guidance as to the tax treatment of their staking rewards, which makes it difficult for them to evaluate possible tax positions as they prepare their federal and state tax returns. This means that taxpayers must adopt a tax methodology that they believe is supportable on audit, subject of course to judicial review. This article discusses federal tax issues—as of the date of publication—of income and expenses associated with virtual currency PoS staking activities.

    Virtual currencies are based on blockchains (digital ledgers) that, given the absence of a trusted third party, require some type of consensus algorithm to achieve consensus among participants (distributed consensus) as to the validity of groups of transactions (blocks). This validation process is designed to assure that the next block of transactions added to the blockchain represents the most current transaction, eliminating the possibility of double-spending coins, tokens or units. The two principal mechanisms for achieving distributed consensus are PoS and proof of work (PoW). Virtual currencies such as Tezos rely on PoS mechanisms. Virtual currencies such as Bitcoin rely on PoW. Both PoS and PoW are subject to the terms of the respective protocol in place for the particular transactions being verified or confirmed. (There are wide variations between and hybrids of PoW and PoS blockchains.) For a discussion of PoW mining activities, see McDermott’s article, “Taxation of Virtual Currency Mining Activities.”

    Virtual Currency Staking

    In PoS systems, stakers are chosen by combinations of random selection plus the amount of units making up their stake and/or the amount of time they have agreed to lock up the stakes in a specific digital wallet. Staked units support the blockchain operations. Unlike the mining activities of PoW blockchains miners, stakers validate new blocks by forging on the next block without mathematical computations. PoS protocols require stakers to hold and stake a minimum number of units to participate in the validation process. As staking rewards, stakers receive a specified number of units. These reward units can redistribute ownership stakes away from computers (nodes) that do not put up a stake to those nodes that put up stakes.

    When Are Staking Rewards Includable in Taxable Income?

    Before turning to the issues of when staking rewards are included in taxable income, it is useful to consider what the IRS has said about mining fees in PoW blockchains. IRS Notice 2014-21 (2014-16 I.R.B. 938, Q&A 8) sets out the IRS’s position that miners receive taxable income when they receive mining fees. Notice 2014-21 is silent, however, about the taxation of staking activities. The Notice says that miner’s fees are taxable at their fair market value as ordinary income as of the date they receive the units. The IRS also asserts that miners cannot wait to include the value of these units in income until they subsequently purchase goods or services or otherwise convert these units into US dollars or another currency. According to the Notice, all Bitcoin miners—even small-scale miners that receive minimal fee income—must report their mining fees as ordinary income when they receive them.

    Because the Notice does not address staking and there is no other governmental guidance, stakers take a wide range of tax positions with respect to the taxation of staking rewards. Some taxpayers take the position that staking rewards are sufficiently similar to payments received by successful virtual currency miners, and that staking rewards should be taxed under the Notice upon receipt (see McDermott’s article, “Taxation of Virtual Currency Mining Activities”). This tax position would need to take into account inflation payments that are made to all stakers.

    Other taxpayers assert that their staking rewards are not taxable until they sell, exchange or otherwise dispose of the rewards. Some of these taxpayers argue that staking rewards are more like the extraction of actual minerals where some taxpayers do not pay tax until they subsequently dispose of the extracted minerals. (Taxpayers should consider Rev. Rul. 77-176 and the oil and gas and mining industry responses with structuring tax partnerships to minimize the current taxability of certain extraction operations; see Bitkker and Lokken, Federal Taxation of Income, Estates & Gifts.) Taxpayers seeking to rely on the tax treatment of oil and gas transactions, however, need to be aware that oil and gas transactions are quite specialized, “primarily because many of the basic concepts were the result of liberal administrative interpretations of various sections of the Internal Revenue Code by the Treasury Department during a period when the Congressional policy was to encourage the development and production of oil and gas properties” (BNA Tax Portfolio, Oil and Gas Transactions, No. 605, 2017, A-1). Obviously, there is no assurance that similarly favorable policies and interpretations will ultimately be applied to virtual currency.

    Other taxpayers take the position that their staking rewards are not taxable at receipt because their staking activities are similar to harvesting of agricultural products or the offspring of livestock. They argue that staking rewards should not be taxable until disposed of.

    And yet other taxpayers assert that staking rewards are not taxable under I.R.C. § 61 because their rewards (or at least some portion of the rewards) do not meet the definition of income, while others assert that staking rewards do not represent an “undeniable accession to wealth” that is “clearly realized” and to which the taxpayer “has complete dominion” (Commissioner v. Glenshaw Glass, 348 U.S. 426 (1955)).

    There is no direct authority with respect to any of these tax positions, so taxpayers must proceed with caution.

    Are Stakers in a Trade or Business?

    To deduct business expenses related to staking operations, stakers need to be “traders” (who seek profits based on market fluctuations, not from passively overseeing their virtual currency investments) or “dealers” (who enter into virtual currency transactions with their customers in the ordinary course of their business). Whether a staker’s activities rise to the level of a trade or business boils down to two things: the volume of their transactions and their ability to establish that these activities constitute an active trade or business (Paoli v. Commissioner, 54 T.C.M. (CCH) 1574, 1578 (1988); Chen v. Commissoner, 87 T.C.M. (CCH) 1388 (2004)). The phrase “trade or business” is not defined in the Internal Revenue Code or Treasury regulations. Whether mining activities qualify as a trade or business is a question of fact. Various factors are considered, with no one factor dispositive. Elements of a trade or business include (1) activities that occupy “the time, attention and labor” of the taxpayer for the purpose of “a livelihood or profit”; (2) the continuity and regularity of the taxpayer’s activities; and (3) a profit motive.

    In Commissioner v. Groetzinger, for example the Supreme Court held that a professional gambler could be in a “trade or business” if the gambler devotes his full-time activity to gambling and it was his intended livelihood source. In this situation, his activity should be regarded as a trade or business “just as any other readily accepted activity” (480 U.S. 23 (1987)).

    Stakers who delegate their tokens to others to stake are not likely to have activities that would rise to the level of a trade or business without more activities.

    If staking activities rise to the level of a trade or business, stakers can deduct appropriate trade or business expenses (I.R.C. § 162). Deductible staking expenses include, for example, office rental and other office expenses, salaries, computer equipment, software programs, Internet access fees and electricity. Deductible business expenses and depreciation reduce their taxable income.

    Those stakers who engage in staking activities for investment or as a hobby are not in a trade or business. As a result, they do not have deductible business expenses (see McDermott’s article, “Virtual Currency Losses Disallowed on Infrequent Activities”). Limited itemized deductions might be available for some investment expenses, but such stakers do not have business expenses deductible against income. (See Chapter 10 of Publication 334, Tax Guide for Small Business, for more information on self-employment tax and Publication 535, Business Expenses, for more information on determining whether expenses are from a business activity carried to make a profit.)

    Selling, Exchanging, or Disposing of Staking Rewards

    Without regard to whether stakers treat their rewards as taxable upon receipt or only at the time when they sell their rewards, all stakers have a taxable event when they dispose of the units they receive from successful staking operations.

    Staking Pools and Entity Considerations

    Stakers often join together with others to pool their units to increase their stake and to, thereby, increase the likelihood that they will successfully validate blocks and receive staking rewards. These business relationships are subject to a wide range of financial relationships. Stakers who join with others, therefore, need to consider whether they will be treated as being in a partnership or taxable association, and they need to consider the federal and state tax implications of their entity selection. Stakers deemed to be in an entity are subject to the federal and state tax rules and tax reporting requirements that apply to such an arrangement.

    * * * *

    As with all taxpayers, stakers should carefully document their staking activities, staking rewards and related expenses to support their federal and state tax positions. Because stakers are in totally unchartered tax waters, they need to work closely with their tax advisors to prepare their federal and state tax returns. In addition, they need to keep in mind the fact that many states do not follow the federal tax Code in computing state taxes.

    Authors
    More insights

  • Taxation of Virtual Currency Mining Activities

    Taxation of Virtual Currency Mining Activities

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Taxation of Virtual Currency Mining Activities

    June 24, 2020

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Proof of work (PoW)—one of the consensus methodologies through which blockchain (digital ledger) transactions can be validated—relies on data miners whose mining activities involve solving complex mathematical calculations. This article discusses key tax issues for miners and the IRS’s preliminary views involving taxation of Bitcoin PoW mining activities.

    In depth

    All blockchain (digital ledger) transactions require some type of consensus mechanism by which the transactions can be validated through distributed consensus. The two popular consensus methodologies are proof of work (PoW) and proof of stake (PoS). PoW relies on “miners” who conduct mining activities by solving complex mathematical calculations. Virtual currencies such as Bitcoin rely on PoW. PoS is a consensus validation mechanism where “stakers” validate virtual currency being confirmed on the blockchain. Virtual currencies such as Tezos rely on a PoS blockchain. Both PoW and PoS are subject to the terms of the respective protocol in place for the particular virtual currency transactions being confirmed.

    This article discusses the tax issues—as of the date of publication—of income and expenses associated with virtual currency PoW mining activities. For a discussion of PoS staking activities, see McDermott’s article, “Taxation of Virtual Currency Staking Activities.”

    Virtual Currency Mining

    Miners confirm virtual currency transactions by sophisticated and high-powered computer processes to solve complex mathematical problems. When a miner validates the addition of a new block (group of transactions), that participant (node) is paid for its services in pre-specified units of a pre-specified virtual currency.

    There are no Internal Revenue Code sections, Treasury regulations or judicial decisions with respect to virtual currency mining. The only government guidance is IRS Notice 2014-12 (2014-16 I.R.B. 938, Q&A-8, 9). The IRS set out its preliminary views on the taxation of Bitcoin mining in that Notice.

    IRS Notices do not have the force of law, and courts do not need to follow IRS pronouncements. Although IRS Notices set out the IRS’s interpretation of tax law, they do not have precedential value. The force of an IRS position is only as strong as the legal authorities the IRS cites in a Notice, the correctness of the IRS’s application of the tax laws and the particular facts in a given transaction. For a discussion of the legal effect of IRS Notices, see McDermott’s article, “The Legal Effect of IRS Pronouncements on Virtual Currency.”

    Miners of PoW virtual currencies other than Bitcoin should determine if the mining processes for those virtual currencies are sufficiently similar to that for Bitcoin so that those miners address possible application of the IRS’s analysis.

    All Miners—Even Small-Scale Miners—Earn Income

    The IRS’s position in the Notice is that by performing the PoW validation service, the fees the miners receive in virtual currency units are ordinary income, taxable at the fair market value as of the date they receive the units. The IRS asserts that miners cannot wait to include the value of the units in income until they subsequently purchase goods or services or otherwise convert their units into US dollars or another fiat currency. According to the Notice, all Bitcoin miners—even small-scale ones that receive minimal fee income—must report their fees as ordinary income when received.

    Given the fact that the Notice is simply the IRS’s litigating position, some miners take a contrary tax position, treating the units they receive from mining as not being taxable upon receipt but only when sold, exchanged or otherwise disposed of. Such taxpayers argue that the units they receive from mining are more like certain forms of extraction of actual minerals where taxpayers do not pay tax on extracted minerals until they subsequently dispose of the minerals. (Taxpayers should consider Rev. Rul. 77-176 and the oil and gas and mining industry responses with structuring tax partnerships to minimize the current taxability of certain extraction operations; see Bitkker and Lokken, Federal Taxation of Income, Estates & Gifts.)

    Miners in a Trade or Business

    To have deductible business expenses, miners need to be traders (who seek profits based on market fluctuations, not from passively overseeing their virtual currency investments) or dealers (who are in the business of buying and/or selling virtual currency to customers in the ordinary course of their business). Whether a miner’s activities rise to the level of being a trader often boils down to two things: the volume of their transactions and the ability to establish that these activities constitute an active trade or business (Paoli v. Commissioner, 54 T.C.M. (CCH) 1574, 1578 (1988); Chen v. Commissioner, 87 T.C.M. (CCH) 1388 (2004)). The phrase “trade or business” is not defined in the Internal Revenue Code or Treasury regulations. Whether mining activities qualify as a trade or business is a question of fact. Various factors are considered, with no one factor dispositive. Elements of a trade or business include (1) activities that occupy “the time, attention and labor” of the taxpayer for the purpose of “a livelihood or profit”; (2) the continuity and regularity of the taxpayer’s activities; and (3) a profit motive.

    In Commissioner v. Groetzinger, for example, the Supreme Court held that a professional gambler could be in a “trade or business” if the gambler devotes his full-time activity to gambling and it was his intended livelihood source. In this situation, his activity should be regarded as a trade or business “just as any other readily accepted activity” (480 U.S. 23 (1987)).

    Whether miners are dealers turns on if they have customers in the ordinary course of business.

    If mining activities rise to the level of a trade or business, miners can deduct appropriate business expenses and losses against their ordinary income (I.R.C. § 162). Deductible mining expenses can include office rental, other office expenses, computer equipment, software programs, Internet access fees and electricity. In fact, some computer equipment might be eligible for depreciation deductions.

    Miners who work for themselves have net earnings from self-employment, treated as self-employment income and subject to self-employment tax (Notice 2014 -21, Q&A-9). Their income and expenses are reported on Schedule C. Miners who are employees receive wages from their employers.

    Not All Miners Are in a Trade or Business

    Not all mining activities qualify as a trade or business. Miners who are not in a trade or business engage in mining transactions for their personal use or as a hobby. Although such miners would receive income for successful mining activities, they would not be able to deduct their losses or business expenses (see McDermott’s article, “Virtual Currency Losses Disallowed on Infrequent Activities.”). Limited itemized deductions might be available for some expenses if the miners were viewed as investors, but investors are not allowed to deduct business expenses against their income. (See Chapter 10 of Publication 334, Tax Guide for Small Business, for more information on self-employment tax and Publication 535, Business Expenses, for more information on determining whether expenses are from a business activity carried to make a profit.)

    Selling, Exchanging or Disposing of Mined Virtual Currency

    Whether miners treat the receipt of units they receive from successful mining as taxable when they receive the units or only when they sell those units, all miners have a taxable event when they sell, exchange or dispose of the virtual currency they receive from successful mining operations.

    Entity Considerations

    Miners often join together with others in pools or business relationships that are subject to a wide variety of financial arrangements. Miners who work with others need to consider whether they will be treated as being in a partnership or taxable association and the federal and state tax implications of entity selection. If mining pools are deemed to be an entity, they are subject to the federal and state tax rules and tax reporting requirements that apply to such arrangements.

    * * * * *

    As with all taxpayers, miners should carefully document their mining activities and related expenses to support their federal and state tax positions. The IRS has the authority to deny deductions if taxpayers do not properly document their deductions. Non-US taxpayers should carefully evaluate whether to file protective tax returns to prevent unpleasant US tax surprises if they find themselves taxed on their gross income without an ability to deduct any of their losses and expenses.

    Authors
    More insights

  • Can Virtual Currency Traders Elect into Special Rules that Allow Current Deductions  for Trading Losses?

    Can Virtual Currency Traders Elect into Special Rules that Allow Current Deductions for Trading Losses?

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Can Virtual Currency Traders Elect into Special Rules that Allow Current Deductions for Trading Losses?

    June 24, 2020

    Read time: 11 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Traders in virtual currency seeking to deduct trading losses and avoid application of the capital loss limitations would want to elect into the special tax rules found at I.R.C. § 475(f). However, such taxpayers should analyze the definitions of “securities” and “commodities,” determine whether they are eligible for either of the trader elections, and consider the federal and state tax implications of making such an election.

    In depth

    Traders in virtual currency might want to currently deduct their trading losses and avoid application of the capital loss limitations that apply to traders. To do so, they would want to elect into the special tax rules found at I.R.C. § 475(f) for electing traders in securities or commodities. Taxpayers who qualify for and elect into either of these trader elections would mark their virtual currency gains and losses to market at ordinary income rates.

    Electing into I.R.C. § 475 means taxpayers would receive ordinary income and loss on positions closed out during the year and on all positions open at the end of the year. In exchange for ordinary tax treatment and accelerating tax on open positions, electing traders can report their losses without applying capital loss limitations, the tax wash sales rule at I.R.C. § 1091 or the tax straddle rules at I.R.C. § 1092.

    This article addresses the analysis that taxpayers who hold virtual currency positions need to make to evaluate whether they are eligible for the I.R.C. § 475(f) election as a trader in securities or a trader in commodities (collectively, trader elections). For a discussion of the tax wash sales rule, see McDermott’s article, “When Virtual Currency Positions Are Subject to the Wash Sales Rule.” For a discussion of the tax straddle rules, see McDermott’s article, “When Virtual Currency Positions Are Subject the Straddle Rules.”

    The trader elections depend on meeting two requirements. First, the taxpayer’s virtual currency transactions must qualify for tax purposes as “securities” to make the securities trader election (I.R.C § 475(f)(1)) or as “commodities” to make the commodities trader election (I.R.C § 475(f)(2)). Second, assuming the virtual currency transactions meet the I.R.C. § 475 definitions of “securities” or “commodities,” the taxpayer’s trading activities must rise to the level of active trading under applicable case law.

    Virtual Currency Positions as Securities or Commodities

    To make a valid trader election, virtual currency traders must determine if the particular virtual currency positions they trade qualify as securities or commodities.

    Securities Defined

    A “security” is broadly defined in I.R.C. § 475 to include any (1) share of stock, (2) partnership or beneficial ownership interest in a widely held or publicly traded partnership or trust, (3) debt interest (I.R.C § 475(c)(2)), and (4) interest rate, currency, or equity “notional principal contracts” (such as swaps, caps and floors).

    A security also includes at item (5) any evidence of any interest in, or any derivative financial instrument in, any currency or security within the terms of items (1) through (4), including options, forwards, short positions and similar financial instruments. Further, it includes at item (6) a “position” that is not itself a security under items (1) through (5) but the position is a “hedge” of such a position and it is clearly identified as a hedge with respect to that security (I.R.C § 475(c)(2)(F)(ii)). There is no requirement that the item, itself, must be “actively traded.” (Although the term “security” does not include section 1256 contracts, such contracts, as defined in I.R.C. §1256(g), can be treated as securities to the extent they qualify as hedges under item (6). For a discussion of section 1256 contracts, see McDermott’s article, “Special Tax Rules Apply to Bitcoin Futures and Options and Might Apply to Positions in Ether and Other Virtual Currencies in the Future.”)

    Because the items that qualify as “securities” are carefully enumerated in I.R.C. § 475(c)(2), it is not likely that the IRS will try to treat other items as “securities” for purposes of I.R.C. § 475 just because they are treated as securities for federal securities law purposes. It is likely that the IRS will only treat items as securities if the items clearly fit into the items that are enumerated. This means that taxpayers who enter into positions in virtual currency need to carefully consider item 5 (set out above) to see whether their positions might meet the definition of that item. For a discussion of the tax definitions of securities, see McDermott’s article, “Can a Virtual Currency Position Be Treated as a Security for Tax Purposes?”

    Commodities Defined

    The term “commodity” is broadly defined in I.R.C. § 475 to include any commodity that is actively traded for purposes of the straddle rules in I.R.C. § 1092(d)(1). (I.R.C. § 475(c)(2)(A). Treas. Reg. § 1.1092(d)-1(c)(1) provides that the actively traded standard requires an established financial market, ranging from an interdealer market to an established financial market.) For a discussion of the straddle rules, see McDermott’s article, “When Virtual Currency Positions are Subject to the Straddle Rules.” Commodities include physical commodities, derivative instruments in any commodity and evidences of interests in any commodity. Unlike the I.R.C. § 475 statutorily enumerated definitions of a “security,” which term specifically excludes section 1256 contracts, the term commodity specifically includes section 1256 contracts, making them subject to I.R.C. § 475 rather than I.R.C. § 1256. For a discussion of I.R.C. § 1256, see McDermott’s article, “Special Tax Rules Apply to Bitcoin Futures and Options and Might Apply to Positions in Ether and Other Virtual Currencies in the Future.” As with the definition of security, the commodity definition includes any position that is not itself a commodity if it serves as a hedge with respect to a commodity.

    Although not free from doubt, the IRS “has historically deferred to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) and its predecessor agencies as to what constitutes a ‘commodity’ for US federal tax purposes” (NYBA Tax Section, “Report on the Taxation of Cryptocurrency,” January 26, 2020; see also Rev. Rul. 73-158, 1973-1 C.B. 337). The word “commodities” is used in I.R.C. § 864(b)(2)(B) in its ordinary financial sense and includes all products that are traded in and listed on commodity exchanges located in the United States. Furthermore, the word “commodities” includes actual commodities and commodity futures contracts. This makes it possible that I.R.C. § 475 will include actively traded items that are treated as commodities under the federal commodity laws. For a discussion of the tax definitions of commodities, see McDermott’s article, “Can a Virtual Currency Position Be Treated as a Commodity for Tax Purposes?”

    Securities or Commodities?

    Most virtual currencies, in and of themselves, are more likely to be taxed under I.R.C. § 475 as commodities rather than as securities. With that said, there is no definitive answer one way or the other as to whether certain virtual currency positions can be treated as securities or commodities. There are good arguments that certain virtual currency positions are securities and that other actively traded virtual currency positions are commodities.

    This leads us to the question of which of the two trader elections a virtual currency trader might consider making for appropriate virtual currencies and positions in those virtual currencies. Which virtual currency positions are securities, and which ones are commodities? This “commodity or security” definitional conundrum might not ultimately matter if the IRS is willing to allow taxpayers who believe they might fall into both categories to elect under both the securities trader and the commodities trader provisions. Although there is no specific authority for making such a dual election, the author is prepared to explore this possibility with the IRS in appropriate client situations.

    Taxpayers Must be Active Traders

    If a particular virtual currency qualifies as a security or a commodity, electing traders must also meet another requirement: their activities must be substantial and carried on in a continuous and regular basis. Trader tax status is a fact-based determination, subject to the taxpayer’s actual facts and circumstances.

    The trader election will be effective only if the electing taxpayer is a trader in either securities or commodities. (For the definition of “trader” to be applied for these purposes, see Chen v. Commissioner, 87 T.C.M. (CCH) 1388 (T.C. 2004); Arberg v. Commissioner, 94 T.C.M. (CCH) 215 (T.C. 2007); and Holsinger v. Commissioner, 96 T.C.M. (CCH) 85 (T.C. 2008). See also Bielfeldt v. Commissioner, 231 F.3d 1035 (7th Cir. 2000), describing the difference between a trader and a dealer, noting that a “dealer’s income is based on the service he provides in the chain of distribution of the goods he buys and resells, rather than on fluctuations in the market value of those goods, while the trader’s income is based not on any service he provides but rather on fluctuations in the market value of the securities or other assets that he transacts in.”) The courts essentially apply a merchant analogy to determine whether a taxpayer sells securities to customers (see Bradford v. United States, 444 F.2d 1133 (Ct. Cl. 1971) [71-2 U.S.T.C. 9542], and Kemon v. Commissioner, 16 T.C. 1026 (1951).

    Traders must profit from daily market movements, not from dividends, interest, or capital appreciation. IRS Publication 550 identifies some factors to consider, including the length of holding periods, frequency of trades, whether the taxpayer is engaged in the activity to produce a principal source of income, and the amount of time the taxpayer devotes to the trading activity. (See also Paoli v. Commissioner, 54 T.C.M. (CCH) 1574, 1578 (1988), and Chen v. Commissionr, 87 T.C.M. (CCH) 1388 (2004).) The phrase “trade or business” is not defined in the Code or Treasury regulations. Various factors are considered, with no one factor dispositive. Elements of a trade or business include (1) activities that occupy “the time, attention and labor” of the taxpayer for the purpose of “a livelihood or profit”; (2) the continuity and regularity of the taxpayer’s activities; and (3) a profit motive. In Commissioner v. Groetzinger, the US Supreme Court held that a professional gambler could be in a “trade or business” if the gambler devotes his full-time activity to gambling and it was his intended livelihood source. In this situation, his activity should be regarded as a trade or business “just as any other readily accepted activity”(480 U.S. 23 (1987)).

    Trade or Business Expenses 

    Traders’ trade or business expenses are deductible under I.R.C. §162. Deductible expenses can include office rental, other office expenses, salaries, computer equipment, software programs, Internet access fees and utilities.

    Application of Trader Elections

    Electing traders receive ordinary gain or loss for their securities and commodities positions that are held in connection with their business of being securities or commodities traders. Because taxes are paid on recognized and unrecognized gains and losses, electing traders can be required to pay tax on gains that, in fact, they may never actually realize. If they continue to hold contracts that were marked-to-market at year end, gains and losses realized in a subsequent tax year are adjusted to reflect gains and losses taken into account in the preceding taxable year. The requirement to mark open positions to market can, therefore, distort income and cause economic hardship if gains that were reported in the first year do not materialize in a subsequent tax year.

    In evaluating the costs of accelerating gains under the mark-to-market regime, electing traders must also evaluate the fact they can deduct their trading losses against trading profits and their ordinary income from other sources. Losses of electing traders are not limited to the standard $3,000 capital losses amount.

    Elections and Revocations

    Elections into I.R.C. § 475 and revocations of elections are subject to detailed reporting and filing requirements. Late elections or revocations are not generally allowed, except in unusual and compelling circumstances that comply with Treasury regulations and IRS guidance.

    ****

    Taxpayers who are interested in exploring an election into I.R.C. § 475 should consult with their tax advisors about the availability of the election and the federal and state tax implications of making such an election. Many states do not follow federal tax returns in computing state taxes.

    Authors
    More insights

  • DOL Confirms Private Equity Can Be Small Components of Defined Contribution Plan Investments

    DOL Confirms Private Equity Can Be Small Components of Defined Contribution Plan Investments

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT / US POLICY

    DOL Confirms Private Equity Can Be Small Components of Defined Contribution Plan Investments

    June 24, 2020

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Earlier this month, the U.S. Department of Labor (“DOL”) issued an Information Letter confirming the widely held view that private equity can be small components of professionally managed diversified investment portfolios, such as target date funds and balanced funds, offered to participants in 401(k) plans and other defined contribution plans. The Information Letter identifies a number of specific factors that a plan fiduciary of a defined contribution plan, who is evaluating the addition of an investment portfolio using private equity, must consider to meet its fiduciary obligations under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, as amended (“ERISA”).

    While ERISA does not expressly restrict private equity as an investment in defined contribution plans, the inherent qualities of private equity restrict it from being offered directly as an investment alternative in a participant-directed plan. Accordingly, investments in private equity are more commonly utilized by defined benefit pension plans. In compliance with the general fiduciary principles imposed by ERISA, however, various defined contribution plans have also offered managed investment portfolios with private equity components (as well as other private investment fund components).

    Noting the important differences between private equity funds and publicly traded investments (e.g., more complex organizational structures, investment strategies, fee structures and longer time horizons), the Information Letter describes a number of considerations that, in the view of the DOL, plan fiduciaries of defined contribution plans must evaluate when contemplating an investment portfolio using private equity. The DOL does not, however, clarify in the Information Letter what weight plan fiduciaries should assign to each of these considerations. None of the considerations and issues noted by the DOL are unexpected and likely would otherwise have been a necessary part of a fiduciary’s analysis to meet ERISA’s obligations.

    Among the reasons for the DOL’s issuance of the Information Letter is “to address uncertainties regarding ERISA that may be impeding plan fiduciaries from considering private equity investment opportunities.” Importantly however, the DOL also cautioned that the Information Letter:

    “Does not address any fiduciary or other ERISA issues that would be involved in a defined contribution plan allowing individual participants to invest their accounts directly in private equity investments. Such direct investments in private equity investments present distinct legal and operational issues for fiduciaries of ERISA-covered individual account plans.”

    Such legal and operational issues primarily refer to federal securities laws and the lack of liquidity inherent to private equity and generally inapposite to the tax law-required design of defined contribution pension plans. Accordingly, it is unlikely that the Information Letter will result in a surge of private equity investments by defined contribution plans.

    Authored by Ronald E. Richman, David M. Cohen, Ian L. Levin, Susan E. Bernstein, and Melissa J. Sandak.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney or one of the authors.

    In depth
    Authors

    Ronald E. Richman

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    David M. Cohen

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Ian L. Levin

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Does Force Majeure Apply? Answering Questions About Contracts in the Time of Coronavirus

    Does Force Majeure Apply? Answering Questions About Contracts in the Time of Coronavirus

    ARTICLE

    Does Force Majeure Apply? Answering Questions About Contracts in the Time of Coronavirus

    June 23, 2020

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors

    Lisa M. Richman

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Shawn C. Helms

    Partner

    Dallas

    Jason D. Krieser

    Partner

    Dallas

    More insights