Content Type: Article

  • Are Crypto Loans Taxed as Loans?

    Are Crypto Loans Taxed as Loans?

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Are Crypto Loans Taxed as Loans?

    July 1, 2020

    Read time: 10 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Transactions involving the borrowing and lending of units of virtual currency (or crypto loans) are increasing in number and type. Lacking Treasury or IRS guidance with respect to crypto loans, potential tax issues that arise from these transactions must be analyzed and understood in accordance with broad, general tax principles established by case law and based on government guidance developed in other tax areas.

    In depth

    The number and types of transactions involving the borrowing and lending of units of virtual currency (“crypto loans”) are increasing rapidly, while the taxation of such transactions remains unclear. This article discusses the tax issues posed by two common types of crypto loans and makes some suggestions for supporting the taxation of these transactions as loans, not taxable sales or exchanges of property.

    At the date of this article, neither the Treasury nor the IRS has provided any tax guidance with respect to crypto loans. Moreover, these transactions are not directly covered by any existing Internal Revenue Code provisions, Treasury regulations or IRS pronouncements. (For a discussion of whether virtual currency can be a security for tax purposes, see McDermott’s article, “Can a Virtual Currency Position Be Treated as a Security for Tax Purposes?” As to whether virtual currency can be a commodity, see McDermott’s article “Can a Virtual Currency Position Be Treated as a Commodity for Tax Purposes?”) As a result, to understand the tax issues surrounding crypto loans, we must analyze them in accordance with broad, general tax principles established by case law as well as government guidance in other tax areas.

    Although there are many questions about the tax treatment of crypto loans, this article addresses one basic question: Are the transfers of virtual currency at the beginning and end of a crypto loan taxable at the time of the transfers, or are only the fees or interest paid and received in connection with the transaction taxable? The answer to this question is by no means free from doubt.

    What is a Loan for Tax Purposes?

    Let’s start with the question of what clearly qualifies as a loan for tax purposes. A loan is an indebtedness that is an existing, unconditional and legally enforceable obligation for one party (borrower) to pay a sum certain of money on demand or on a specified date to the other party (lender) (see Kovtun v. Commissioner, 54 T.C. 331 (1970), aff’d per curiam, 448 F.2d 1268 (9th Cir. 1971), cert. denied, 405 U.S. 1016 (1972); Titcher v. Commissioner, 57 T.C. 315 (1971)).

    For example, the borrower might borrow money from the lender, pay interest for the use of that money and agree to repay the money at a future date. Entering into such a loan is not taxable to either the borrower or the lender, nor is the repayment of the principal amount of the loan. The receipt or accrual of interest on the loan is, however, taxable as “compensation for the use or forbearance of money” (Deputy v. DuPont, 308 U.S. 488 (1940)). Although the term “interest” is not defined in the Code, it is generally viewed as a payment in return for the use of money or other property and is taxable as ordinary income (I.R.C. § 61(a)(4)) to the lender. The US Supreme Court has also described interest as the “amount which one has contracted to pay for the use of borrowed money” (Old Colony Railroad Co. v. Commissioner, 284 U.S. 552 (1932), rev’g 50 F.2d 896 (1st Cir. 1931), rev’g 18 B.T.A. 267 (1929)). The borrower’s payment of interest is not, however, deductible if the loan is for the borrower’s personal use and may be subject to certain limitations if it is for investment or business purposes.

    The major difficulty in treating crypto loans as loans for tax purposes is IRS Notice 2014-21, which states that (at least as far as the IRS is concerned) convertible virtual currency is property (Notice 2014-21, Q&A-2), and according to established case law, a loan for tax purposes is a “a debt [that] necessarily involves an obligation to pay money and not an obligation to deliver property” (R.S. Stahl v. United States, 441 F. 2d 999 (1970)). (For a discussion of the legal effect of IRS pronouncements, see McDermott’s article, “The Legal Effect of IRS Pronouncements on Virtual Currency.”)

    What Happens If a Crypto Loan is Not Treated as a Loan?

    In general, a transfer of money in exchange for property is treated as a taxable sale or exchange of property. As such, there is an immediate recognition of gain or loss on the exchange. Gain from a sale equals the excess of the amount realized over the seller’s adjusted basis. Loss from a sale equals the excess of the seller’s adjusted basis over the amount realized (I.R.C. § 1001(a)).

    If a crypto loan is deemed to be a sale or exchange of property and not a loan, the transaction would be broken into two separate transactions: the initial transfer of the virtual currency at the opening of the “loan” and the return of the virtual currency when closing the “loan.” For a discussion of how tax basis is calculated for virtual currency transactions, see McDermott’s article, “Specific Identification of Virtual Currency Positions.”

    Two Common Types of Crypto Loans

    The first type of crypto loan—here called a “crypto borrow transaction”—involves one party (the borrower) borrowing virtual currency from another party (the lender) with the borrower posting collateral (cash, another type of virtual currency or other agreed-upon property). The borrower agrees to return to the lender an identical amount of the same virtual currency at the end of the agreement and the lender agrees to return the collateral. Crypto borrow transactions are typically structured to resemble securities lending transactions that are subject to a specific Code provision that prevents gain or loss on the transfer of securities (I.R.C. § 1058). The borrower is free to sell or otherwise dispose of the virtual currency subject to the loan, and the lender is often allowed to sell or otherwise dispose of the collateral. If during the term of the agreement there is an airdrop or hardfork with respect to the particular virtual currency that was borrowed, the borrower transfers back to the lender units of virtual currency identical to those that were received in the airdrop or hardfork (not money or other property). In many crypto borrow transactions, the borrower or lender (or both) can terminate the agreement on demand, or on a specified number of days’ notice.

    In the second type of crypto loan—here called a “crypto collateral transaction”—a lender loans the borrower fiat currency (such as US dollars) and the borrower posts virtual currency (such as Bitcoin, Ether or a highly liquid virtual currency) with the lender as collateral. A principal objective of these transactions is for the borrower to monetize a virtual currency position without triggering a taxable sale. These transactions are relatively straightforward. When the loan matures, the borrower re-pays the lender the dollar amount of the loan plus interest, taking back identical virtual currency to that which the borrower had posted as collateral. If during the term of the loan there is an airdrop or hardfork, the lender must transfer to the borrower virtual currency units identical to what is received in the airdrop or hardfork (not money or other property). In a crypto collateral transaction, there is often a fixed term, but the borrower can repay the US dollar loan prior to maturity.

    Considerations to Bolster Arguments that a Crypto Loan is a Loan, Not a Sale or Exchange of Property

    Because of the importance that the tax law places on the substance of a transaction rather than its form, taxpayers must carefully examine the terms of each crypto loan to determine whether the transaction is more likely to be taxed as a sale or exchange of property or as a loan. Some of the key tax factors to consider when addressing the proper taxation of particular crypto loan transactions follow:

    • Consider the benefits and burdens of tax ownership as a result of the transaction. To the extent to which “ownership” of the virtual currency is deemed transferred at the opening of the crypto loan, the position that the transaction being taxed as a sale or exchange of property is straightforward.
    • The following factors, as set out by the Tax Court in Grodt & McKay Realty, Inc. v. Commissioner (77 T.C. 1221 (1981)), are generally considered in evaluating tax ownership:

    (1) Whether legal title passes

    (2) How the parties treat the transaction

    (3) Whether an equity interest is acquired in the property

    (4) Whether the contract imposes a present obligation on the seller to execute and deliver a deed and a present obligation on the purchaser to make payments

    (5) Whether the right of possession is vested in the purchaser

    (6) Which party pays the property taxes

    (7) Which party bears the risk of loss or damage to the property

    (8) Which party receives the profits from the operation and sale of the property.

    In evaluating these factors, the courts do not generally regard any one factor as determinative and recognize that not all factors are relevant in any given case. (See, e.g., Honeywell Inc. v Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 1992-453 (“The passing of legal title is among the factors to be considered in determining whether a sale has occurred for Federal income tax purposes… Because it is only one factor, however, it is not determinative”); see also Torres v. Commissioner, 88 T.C. 702 (1987) (“in analyzing the transaction in this case, we first note that some of the factors enumerated in Grodt & McKay Realty, Inc. … are either less relevant in this case or must be considered in a different light…”).) The important point, however, is that the more factors that point to the holder of the virtual currency after executing the transaction as being the “owner” of the virtual currency, the more the transaction looks like a sale, not a loan.

    • If the crypto loan is fully recourse, this points to the transaction being viewed as a loan.
    • The crypto loan should be structured and documented as a traditional loan transaction, and the parties should adhere to normal loan practices.
    • The parties should treat the transaction as a loan in their records and on their tax returns.
    • The repayment should be made in virtual currency units that are identical in value and denomination to the virtual currency that is transferred at the start of the transaction. The same rules should apply to any airdrops or hardforks that happen during the terms of the transaction.

    Other Possible Approaches to Avoiding a Crypto Loan Being Taxed as a Sale or Exchange of Property

    The possibilities include:

    • The borrower did not receive back property that was materially different either in kind or extent and, therefore, there should be no recognition under Treas. Reg. § 1.1001(a).
    • The transaction qualifies as a securities loan eligible for tax free treatment under I.R.C. § 1058.
    • The transaction qualifies as a loan under the general tax authority addressing repurchase agreements and reverse repurchase agreements.
    • The transaction is structured as a bailment transaction so that the bailor deposits fungible virtual currency with the bailee and the virtual currency is comingled with the goods of the bailee, so that when different but identical virtual currency is returned to the bailee the return is not treated as a taxable sale (G.C.M. 35183 (Jan. 2, 1973)).

    * * * *

    Taxpayers should carefully consider the tax factors that support treating their crypto loans as loans for tax purposes. They should carefully consider their transaction documents; keep detailed and accurate records of their transactions; and discuss their transactions with their tax advisors to determine appropriate tax reporting.

    In addition, crypto exchanges, wallet providers and custodians must consider these issues as they determine appropriate Form 1099 reporting obligations with respect to Forms 1099-B, 1099-MISC or 1099-INT. Such entities must also consider withholding taxes for foreign persons because gain is not treated as fixed, determinable, annual or periodic income although, income is (Treas. Reg. § 1.1441-2(b)(2)(i)).

    Authors
    More insights

  • Light Beer Sweetener – Not So Sticky After All

    ARTICLE

    Light Beer Sweetener – Not So Sticky After All

    June 30, 2020

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • SEC Identifies Private Fund Deficiencies: Conflicts of Interest, Fees and Expenses, and MNPI Controls

    SEC Identifies Private Fund Deficiencies: Conflicts of Interest, Fees and Expenses, and MNPI Controls

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    SEC Identifies Private Fund Deficiencies: Conflicts of Interest, Fees and Expenses, and MNPI Controls

    June 30, 2020

    Read time: 12 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On June 23, 2020, the SEC Office of Compliance Inspections and Examinations (“OCIE”) issued a Risk Alert[1] that highlights commonly encountered deficiencies in examinations of hedge fund managers and private equity fund sponsors.

    At the outset, the Risk Alert connects its observations with respect to private investment funds with the current Commission’s repeated focus on retail investors, noting that private funds “frequently have significant investments from pensions, charities, endowments and families.” Indeed, the Risk Alert is described as not only useful information for advisers to private funds; it is offered “to provide investors with information concerning private fund adviser deficiencies.”

    While the Risk Alert does not establish new standards of conduct, it does provide a concise summary of three categories of deficiencies the examination staff stated that it finds in its reviews of advisers to private funds. These findings are consistent with what we have observed on examination of private fund advisers.

    Every private fund manager should carefully evaluate whether its policies and procedures are consistent with the positions described in the Risk Alert. Compliance personnel should also integrate the various elements into the next annual compliance review and be prepared to discuss them with the examination staff in future examinations.

    Categories of Deficiencies

    While there is no single theme that unites all of the deficiencies highlighted in the Risk Alert, in general, they are matters that implicate the possibility of economic harm to clients (or a loss of economic benefits) or violations of the insider trading and other securities laws. These highlighted deficiencies fall into three general categories:

    • Gaps in client and investor disclosures regarding conflicts of interest;
    • Fees and expenses issues; and
    • Shortcomings in managers’ policies and procedures regulating the treatment of material nonpublic information (“MNPI”).

    Conflicts of Interest Deficiencies

    Conflicts of interest always present challenges for a fiduciary, as is the case in an advisory relationship. In the modern private fund environment, with many managers operating multiple funds and accounts for investors and clients with different economic terms, the existence of conflicts of interest is unavoidable. (The “conflicts” disclosures of fund offering documents, for example, can be quite lengthy.)

    Under Section 206 of the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, as explained in the SEC’s recent “fiduciary interpretation,”[2] investment advisers have an affirmative obligation either (i) to fully disclose; or (ii) to mitigate (or eliminate) conflicts of interest within an advisory context. In addition, SEC Rule 206(4)-8 prohibits an adviser from making material misstatements and omissions in communications to clients and from otherwise engaging in manipulative, deceptive or fraudulent business conduct; these anti-fraud measures also effectively require advisers to disclose material conflicts that could adversely affect clients.

    In the Risk Alert, OCIE highlights a number of conflicts of interest that it believes were often inadequately disclosed by examinees.

    • OCIE noted instances of inadequately disclosed conflicts concerning the allocation of investment opportunities among client vehicles and accounts, such as flagship funds, co-investment vehicles and SMAs. In addition to preferential allocations of limited investment opportunities to proprietary accounts or clients paying higher fees without adequate disclosure, OCIE identified preferential allocations of limited opportunities to “new accounts” without adequate disclosure. While “ramp up” periods for new accounts may be appropriate, OCIE may question whether a manager is seeking to show positive early performance returns to new clients and investors. OCIE also noted that some advisers fail to consistently apply their allocation policies.
    • Conflicting Client Investments. With an increasing number of clients and strategies, managers may more frequently face conflicts between investment positions taken by different clients. The Risk Alert cites inadequate disclosures of the conflicts arising from different clients investing in different parts of a portfolio company’s capital structure, such as debt versus equity. While the Risk Alert does not provide any indication of the type of disclosure language that would be satisfactory in these circumstances, they have squarely identified this as an issue requiring attention.
    • Financial Relationships. The Risk Alert identifies inadequacies in the disclosure of economic relationships between a manager and certain clients or investors, such as seed investors, and investors that provided financing to the adviser or its funds.
    • Preferential Liquidity Rights. The Risk Alert reports that some managers have entered into side letters including providing preferential liquidity, without adequately notifying other investors of the potential harm that could be caused. OCIE also identifies side-by-side vehicles or SMAs investing alongside a fund with more frequent liquidity as creating the same risk. The Risk Alert does not identify actual harm to investors in these circumstances, but emphasizes the importance of adequate disclosure to all investors, particularly in times of market dislocation.
    • Principal Investments. OCIE’s findings included failures to adequately describe the conflicts associated with principals or managers holding interests in investments recommended to clients.
    • Co-Investments. The Risk Alert also evidenced concerns over the accuracy and depth of disclosures on how co-investment procedures actually operate, as well as situations where managers did not follow their stated policies. OCIE specifies two particular scenarios: (1) advisers disclosed an allocation policy covering multiple different clients but then failed to follow the process as disclosed; and (2) advisers failed to adequately disclose agreements to provide co-investment opportunities to certain investors, such that other investors may not have understood “the scale of co-investment opportunities and in what manner co-investment opportunities would be allocated among investors.” Again, the degree of specificity in disclosure that would be satisfactory to the examination staff is not specified, but the focus on these disclosures is clear.
    • Service Providers. Advisers sometimes failed to adequately disclose conflicts arising from the use of affiliated service providers or service providers with a special relationship to the adviser or its portfolio companies. The Risk Alert also identifies other financial incentives, such as payments from discount programs, that could influence advisers’ choice of service providers for its clients and their portfolio companies. As a matter of process, advisers should seek to ensure that their practices with respect to affiliated service providers follow their disclosures. OCIE identified situations where advisers disclosed that services would be provided on terms no less favorable than from a third-party, but did not take appropriate steps to support such disclosures (e.g., obtaining quotes from comparable third-party service providers).
    • Fund Restructurings. Consistent with recent focus on examinations, OCIE identified situations where advisers failed to provide sufficient disclosures concerning conflicts raised by fund restructurings and “stapled secondary transactions.” Examples listed include inadequate disclosure by the adviser (1) regarding the valuation of the fund interest that the adviser is purchasing from investors; (2) of investor options during a restructuring; and (3) of the conflict of interest of the adviser about the economic benefits to the adviser.
    • Cross Transactions. The Risk Alert notes inadequate disclosure with respect to the conflicts inherent in cross transactions, particularly where the adviser determines the price of the securities and where either the purchaser or seller is disadvantaged.

    It is important to note, however, that these conflicts-related deficiencies all relate to insufficient disclosures (and — to be clear — do not assert that these conflicts were per se inconsistent with or were violative of an adviser’s fiduciary duty). The staff’s focus on disclosure is consistent with the Commission’s 2019 fiduciary interpretation, and highlights how critical it is for advisers to both identify and sufficiently disclose conflicts.

    Fees and Expenses Deficiencies

    Fees and Expenses. Six years after OCIE identified what it viewed as widespread deficiencies in connection with private fund managers charging fees and expenses, the Risk Alert identifies recurring “fee and expense issues that appear to be deficiencies under Section 206 or Rule 206(4)-8”. These items fall into two buckets:

    • Impermissible expenses (e.g., expenses that violate a fund’s organizational documents or fee calculation errors); and
    • Expenses that were assessed on the basis of disclosures that OCIE deemed to be too general or imprecise to constitute informed consent by investors.

    Many of the situations cited in the inadequate disclosure category were not only previously identified by OCIE, they have been the subject of enforcement actions settled over the past several years (e.g., pass-throughs of affiliated “operating partner” compensation, monitoring fees and “broken deal” expenses). Disclosures with respect to “operating partners” were identified as insufficient, both as to their roles and their compensation.

    Fees from portfolio companies were also cited as problematic, including in circumstances where (1) management fees were not offset because the portfolio company paid fees to an affiliate of the adviser and not the adviser itself; (2) portfolio company fees were allocated to clients that paid no management fee; (3) advisers did not have adequate policies and procedures to track the receipt of portfolio company fees, including compensation to operating partners; and (4) monitoring fees were accelerated despite the lack of specific disclosure of that practice.

    In addition to identifying specific issues with respect to fees and expenses, the Risk Alert notes deficiencies in advisers failing to comply with their stated policies. For example, the Risk Alert identifies advisers failing to comply with expense caps and failing to comply with their own travel and entertainment policies.

    Valuation. The Risk Alert also highlights the way in which valuation can impact fees received by managers. While this is not a new area of concern for the SEC or for OCIE, the Risk Alert does make clear that valuation has been and will continue to be a key focus area in private fund examinations. The Risk Alert cites situations where advisers valued client assets in a manner that was inconsistent with their valuation procedures as well as valuation practices that were not consistent with the disclosures made to clients and investors.

    MNPI and Code of Ethics Deficiencies

    The third category of OCIE concerns related to Section 204A of the Advisers Act, which requires advisers to establish and maintain written policies and procedures to prevent misuse of MNPI, and the Code of Ethics Rule, Rule 204A-1, which obligates advisers to establish standards of conduct for advisory personnel and resolve conflicts raised by their personal trading.

    Insider Trading. Despite the significant risks to advisers associated with insider trading, the examination staff identified what it viewed as insufficient policies and procedures to prevent the misuse of MNPI. The Risk Alert cites advisers as failing to address risks posed by employees interacting with people with access to MNPI, such as public company insiders, consultants retained through “expert networks” and “value-added investors.”

    Specific mention was made of advisers that had policies and procedures addressing such risks, but where enforcement was lacking. Two other specific issues were identified by OCIE with respect to insider trading polices: (1) the risk of employees obtaining MNPI through access to office space or systems of the adviser or its affiliates; and (2) the risk of employees with access to public company information such as PIPE transactions (private investment in public equities).

    Code of Ethics Rule. The Risk Alert identifies three discrete issues with respect to advisers’ Codes of Ethics and the prevention of the misuse of MNPI:

    • First, certain advisers failed to establish policies and procedures around their restricted trading lists. The staff observed a lack of specificity with respect to the process for adding and removing securities from the restricted trading list. But they also identified failures to enforce trading restrictions of names that were on the list.
    • Second, the staff observed deficient practices around enforcement of the gifts and entertainment sections of the Code of Ethics, specifically with respect to the receipt of gifts and entertainment from third parties.
    • Third, deficiencies were identified with respect to personal securities transactions approval and reporting, including failing to require the timely submission of such approvals and reports. In addition, advisers did not identify all individuals who should be treated as “access persons” for purposes of the Code of Ethics.

    These concerns have been reflected in numerous recent enforcement actions, where advisers have been fined and publicly sanctioned for shortfalls in the design or operation of their compliance programs. The inclusion of these items in the Risk Alert should act to dispel any notion that the staff is going to shift its focus away from critically assessing the compliance function.

    Next Steps

    The Risk Alert presents results from hundreds of examinations of private fund managers conducted by OCIE each year. Although it does not purport to address all types deficiencies noted in examinations of private fund managers, it covers a broad range of some of the most nuanced issues these managers face. In addition to its breadth, the Risk Alert drills down on certain issues, identifying the specific challenges private fund advisers face. The Risk Alert demonstrates the increased knowledge and understanding by the staff of private fund managers and the relevant legal and compliance challenges.

    The Risk Alert should be carefully reviewed by all SEC-registered private fund advisers, and compliance personnel should consider making the review as interdisciplinary and robust as their situations permit. A critical review of the disclosures relating to conflicts of interests, expenses and other key points of potential friction within a fiduciary relationship should be undertaken. It appears that the majority of the deficiencies described in the Risk Alert could have been avoided with direct, specific and understandable disclosures of the conflicts and their impact. Consistent with the Commission’s 2019 fiduciary interpretation, the more significant the conflict of interest, the higher the bar is for crafting effective conflicts disclosure.

    A review of MNPI policies and practices also is warranted. In addition to the Risk Alert’s warnings from OCIE, recent SEC enforcement actions have resulted in sanctions against private fund managers for failures to have adequate policies and processes in place, even where a substantive violation was not alleged. High-level policies that do not reflect operational realities or specific risks, compliance procedures that are not both tailored and detailed, and procedures (of whatever level of detail) that are not conscientiously enforced can result in a situation that will not meet the standards expected and identified by both the examination staff and the Enforcement Division of the SEC.

    Authored by Brian T. Daly and Marc E. Elovitz.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] SEC’s Risk Alert, “Observations from Examinations of Investment Advisers Managing Private Funds” (June 23, 2020), available here.

    [2] SEC Release No. IA-5248, “Commission Interpretation Regarding Standard of Conduct for Investment Advisers,” available here.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2020 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Marc E. Elovitz

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • German Ministry of Finance Amends Interpretation of Investment Tax Act

    German Ministry of Finance Amends Interpretation of Investment Tax Act

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    German Ministry of Finance Amends Interpretation of Investment Tax Act

    June 29, 2020

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    At the end of 2019, the German Ministry of Finance drafted an updated version of its circular commenting on the Investment Tax Act. In the area of special funds, the draft was heavily criticized as it stipulated that a participation in a real estate SPV or a security which at the same time qualifies as investment fund unit should only be eligible if it fulfilled all and any provisions for target fund units. This new interpretation would have negatively affected a large number of special funds, probably making them loose their tax status. The Ministry reacted to the industry’s concerns and recently presented a new draft stating that real estate SPVs and securities may be acquired and held as such, irrespective of their additional status as a fund or fund unit.

    Read the full article in German.

    In depth
    Authors

    Dr. Kian Tauser

    Partner

    Frankfurt

    Frank Müller

    Partner

    Frankfurt

    Dr. Heiko Kermer

    Partner

    Frankfurt

    More insights

  • Volcker Rule 2.0 — Impact of Final Rule on CLOs

    Volcker Rule 2.0 — Impact of Final Rule on CLOs

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Volcker Rule 2.0 — Impact of Final Rule on CLOs

    June 29, 2020

    Read time: 11 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On June 25, 2020, the Federal Reserve Board, the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission and the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (collectively, the “Agencies”) approved a new final rule (“Final Rule”) to amend the regulations implementing section 13 of the Bank Holding Company Act (commonly known as the “Volcker Rule”). A number of the Agencies’ revisions to the Volcker Rule (“Amendments”) will affect collateralized loan obligations (“CLOs”), their managers and their investors. View a copy of the Final Rule. The Final Rule goes into effect on Oct. 1, 2020.[1]

    The Final Rule makes a number of important changes to the application of the Volcker Rule to CLOs and banking entities that invest in CLOs:

    • The Final Rule amends the “loan securitization exclusion” to permit a loan securitization to hold up to 5% of its assets in debt securities (excluding asset-backed securities and convertible securities), calculated at par value at the time a debt security is purchased.[2] The Final Rule is narrower on this issue than the Proposed Amendments, which would have permitted a loan securitization to hold up to 5% of its assets in any non-loan assets, rather than limiting the non-loan bucket to non-convertible debt securities. Additionally, the Final Rule also codifies clarifications made by the staffs of the Agencies regarding “servicing assets”[3] and “cash equivalents”[4] that may be permissibly held by loan securitizations.
    • The Final Rule modifies the definition of “ownership interest” to allow for certain additional rights of creditors under a debt instrument (that are not triggered exclusively by an event of default under, or acceleration of, the debt instrument) with respect to the right to participate in the removal of a CLO’s investment manager “for cause,” as well as in the replacement of a CLO’s investment manager following its resignation or removal, that will not give rise to a banking entity having an ownership interest in a covered fund. In addition to such rights arising under events of default or acceleration, the Final Rule expands the scope of such “for cause” removals or replacements of a CLO investment manager to include (1) the bankruptcy, insolvency, conservatorship or receivership of the investment manager; (2) breaches of material provisions of a covered fund’s transaction agreements applicable to the investment manager; (3) breaches of material representations and warranties by the investment manager; (4) the occurrence of an act that constitutes fraud or criminal activity in the performance of the investment manager’s obligations under the covered fund’s transaction agreements; (5) the indictment of the investment manager for a criminal offense or any officer, member, partner or other principal of the investment manager for a criminal offense materially related to his or her investment management activities; (6) a change in control with respect to the investment manager; (7) the loss, separation or incapacitation of an individual critical to the operation of the investment manager or primarily responsible for the management of the covered fund’s assets; or (8) other similar events that constitute “cause” for removal of the investment manager, provided that such events are not solely related to the performance of the covered fund or the investment manager’s exercise of investment discretion under the covered fund’s transaction documents[5]; and
    • The Final Rule further amends the definition of “ownership interest” to create a safe harbor for “ordinary debt instruments” that were never intended to confer an ownership interest in the borrower to the holders of such debt instruments. Under the Final Rule, senior loans or other senior debt interests would not be treated as “ownership interests” in a covered fund if:
      • The holders of any such interest do not participate in the profits of the covered fund, but receive only interest payments that are not dependent on the performance of the covered fund and a fixed principal payment on or prior to a stated maturity date. The repayment of the fixed principal payment on or prior to a stated maturity date must be required by contract (and such terms may include prepayment premiums to compensate holders of the interest for forgone income from an early prepayment);
      • The amount of interest payable to the holders of any such interest is not contingent (i.e., subject to write-down or other adjustment arising from losses incurred by the covered fund); and
      • The holders of any such interest are not entitled to receive the underlying assets of the covered fund or any assets remaining after the repayment in full of all other interests (excluding creditor rights to exercise remedies upon an event of default or an event giving rise to acceleration).[6]

    The Agencies declined to clarify whether “senior loans or other senior debt interests” include all investment grade loans, so it is not clear that the Final Rule covers interests other than AAA-rated notes.

    The 5% non-loan asset bucket for the “loan securitization exclusion” was expected to be included in the Final Rule following the Proposed Amendments. While the non-loan asset bucket does provide some flexibility for CLOs, the amendments to the “ownership interest” definition in the Final Rule provide significantly more flexibility for CLOs. As long as the “for cause” removal provisions of a CLO’s collateral management agreement conform to the Volcker Rule’s parameters, the new definition of “ownership interest” will allow a CLO to avoid relying on the “loan securitization exclusion” because CLO notes will not constitute an “ownership interest” for purposes of the Final Rule’s covered fund provisions. We also expect that new CLOs issued prior to Oct. 1, 2020 (the effective date of the rule) will include a springing bond bucket that will take effect without the requirement of any amendment or consents.

    Authored by Phillip J. Azzollini, Daniel Oshinsky, Craig Stein, Adam M. Singer, James V. Williams, III and Sanjana V. Nafday.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] On Jan. 30, 2020, the Agencies requested comments on proposed amendments to the Volcker Rule (“Proposed Amendments”). Several of the Proposed Amendments affected CLOs, as we described in our Alert published on Jan. 31, 2020.

    [2] Final rule § __.10(c)(8)(i)(E).

    [3] Final rule § __.10(c)(8)(i)(B).

    [4] Final rule § __.10(c)(8)(iii)(A).

    [5] See the exclusions under Final Rule § __.10(d)(6)(i)(A)

    [6] Final Rule § __.10(d)(6)(ii)(B)


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2020 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Phillip J. Azzollini

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Daniel V. Oshinsky

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Craig Stein

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Adam M. Singer

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Bankruptcy Court Grants Tenant Partial Rent Abatement Under Force Majeure Clause (COVID-19)

    Bankruptcy Court Grants Tenant Partial Rent Abatement Under Force Majeure Clause (COVID-19)

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Bankruptcy Court Grants Tenant Partial Rent Abatement Under Force Majeure Clause (COVID-19)

    June 29, 2020

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In a decision of first impression entered on June 3, 2020, a Chicago bankruptcy court (“Court”) held that a restaurant tenant was excused from paying a significant portion of its rent under the force majeure provisions of its lease because of the governor’s executive order prohibiting in-house dining during the COVID-19 pandemic.[1] This decision is highly significant for landlords and tenants whose ability to service their clients has similarly been restricted by government orders. Unlike other tenants that have merely sought to defer rent payments, here, the tenant sought to couple the force majeure clause in its lease with the governor’s executive order, to eliminate a portion of its rent obligation altogether, and succeeded in doing so.

    Background

    Hitz Restaurant Group (“Tenant”) operated a restaurant under a lease (“Hitz Lease”) with Kass Management Services Inc. (“Landlord”). On Feb. 24, 2020, Tenant filed for bankruptcy after, among other things, failing to pay its February rent. Soon after Tenant filed for bankruptcy, Illinois Governor Pritzker issued an executive order (“Executive Order”) limiting restaurant operations to curbside pickup and delivery, and expressly prohibited in-house dining.

    Landlord moved for an order instructing Tenant to pay its February, pre-bankruptcy filing, and to timely pay all post-petition rent.[2] Landlord cited section 365(d)(3) of the Bankruptcy Code, which requires a debtor to “timely perform all the obligations of the debtor … arising from and after the order for relief under any unexpired lease of nonresidential real property until such lease is assumed or rejected … .” 11 U.S.C. § 365(d)(3). Under the Bankruptcy Code, rent payments are “not mere administrative expenses” because they must be timely paid pursuant to the lease terms, whereas other administrative expenses may be paid as late as the end of the bankruptcy case.[3]

    Tenant argued that the Executive Order triggered the force majeure clause in its lease and excused Tenant from paying post-petition rent. The lease’s force majeure clause provided:

    “Landlord and Tenant shall each be excused from performing its obligations or undertakings provided in this Lease, in the event, but only so long as the performance of any of its obligations are prevented or delayed, retarded or hindered by … laws, governmental action or inaction, orders of government … Lack of money shall not be grounds for Force Majeure.” (emphasis added)[4]

    Determining whether the Executive Order triggered the lease’s force majeure provision required the Court to examine Illinois state law. Under Illinois law, a force majeure clause will excuse performance under a contract only if the triggering event was the proximate cause of such nonperformance.[5]

    Force Majeure Clause ‘Unambiguously Applies’

    While courts generally interpret force majeure clauses in leases narrowly, here the Court held that the force majeure provision was “unambiguously triggered” by the Executive Order because the order was a “governmental action” and an “order of government” as set forth in the clause.[6]

    The Court rejected as “specious” Landlord’s argument that Tenant was physically able to pay rent because banks and post-offices remained open.  It also rejected Landlord’s argument that Tenant could have applied for a Small Business Administration loan to cover its rent obligations, as that was not required by the plain language of the lease’s force majeure clause.

    In reaching its decision, the Court considered that the Executive Order did not absolutely proscribe restaurant operations and “not only permitted, but also encouraged, restaurants to continue to perform take-out, curbside pick-up, and delivery services.”[7] Therefore, the Court determined that Tenant remained obligated to pay partial rent for the duration of the Executive Order, but only “in proportion to [Tenant’s] reduced ability to generate revenue due to the [Executive Order].”[8] Neither party proposed a methodology by which the Court should calculate the proportionate rent owed, and therefore, the Court relied on Tenant’s estimation that 75% of its square footage was “rendered unusable” by the Executive Order.[9] Accordingly, the Court preliminarily ordered that Tenant pay 25% of the post-petition rent it owed to Landlord, pending the outcome of an evidentiary hearing.[10]

    Takeaways

    For Tenants

    This decision is important because many states’ governors have issued executive orders that, like the Illinois Executive Order, restrict or prohibit business activities for tenants. It should be noted that the decision was for a restaurant lease and the court might have reached a different conclusion for an office or retail lease. Plainly, the language of each state’s applicable executive orders must be carefully parsed. If such orders forbid in-house dining or other ordinarily allowable business activities that negatively impact a tenant’s income, and a lease’s force majeure clause contains language regarding government action or orders constituting force majeure events, then the tenant may be entitled to a rent abatement during the time such orders are in effect. Depending on the language in the force majeure clause of the lease, the decision stands as a persuasive (though not binding) authority that should give tenants confidence to make arguments based on this type of provision. It is important to note that, unlike the Hitz Lease, most force majeure clauses in commercial leases expressly exclude relief from rental payment obligations. Moreover, the methodology used by the Court to determine the amount of the rent abatement did not include other relevant factors, such as lost revenue or other concrete metrics. It’s possible that other methodologies might result in more (or less) significant rent abatements.

    For Landlords

    The Executive Order specifically states that it was not to be construed as relieving any tenant of the obligation to pay rent and to comply with other lease obligations. Landlord could have asserted that this language prohibited application of the force majeure clause, but surprisingly did not. Further, the force majeure clause provided that “[l]ack of money shall not be grounds for Force Majeure.” Landlord did argue that Tenant was not paying rent because it lacked money to do so, and, therefore, this sentence prohibited application of the force majeure clause.[11] While the Court acknowledged that this language created a potential conflict, it held that the preceding language “order of government” and “government action” in the force majeure clause were more specific than “lack of money.” The Court cited existing Seventh Circuit case law that provides “[i]n interpreting an Illinois contract, when there is a conflict between a clause of general application and a clause of specific application, the more specific clause prevails.”[12] It is apparent that courts may differ on interpreting the “lack of money” provision as being less specific.

    The Court also acknowledged that Landlord failed to make any arguments regarding the methodology it should use to calculate an appropriate rent abatement and, thus, was left solely with the Tenant’s proposed method. Therefore, landlords should propose a methodology to calculate a rent abatement as an alternative argument in connection with any court submission regarding this issue.

    This case exemplifies the importance of a carefully drafted lease agreement. Force majeure provisions are strictly construed, and so the specific language of such clauses is critical and should not be considered mere boilerplate. Courts likely will reach different conclusions in cases where a lease’s force majeure clause expressly excludes relief from rental payment obligations or excludes governmental action or orders as triggering events, or where the clause requires that performance be more than merely “hindered” before the force majeure clause is applicable.

    Authored by Taleah E. Jennings, Julian M. Wise, James T. Bentley and Kelly (Bucky) Knight.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] See Illinois Executive Order 2020-7. A subsequent order was issued on March 20, 2020, which contained substantially the same COVID-19 restrictions as Executive Order 2020-7, but added language that “[n]o provision contained in this Executive Order shall be construed as relieving any individual of the obligation to pay rent … or to comply with any other obligation that an individual may have under tenancy … .” See Ill. Exec. Order 2020-10. Governor Pritzker twice extended the duration of the COVID-19 restrictions as they related to in-house dining in restaurants through May 29, 2020. See Ill. Exec. Order 2020-18 and Ill. Exec. Order 2020-33. For purposes of this article, these orders are collectively referred to as the “Executive Order.”

    [2] The Court did not determine whether the pre-bankruptcy rent was due at this time because it was a pre-bankruptcy claim not entitled to immediate payment. If Tenant wants to assume the lease with Landlord, it will be required to cure all pre-bankruptcy defaults and pay the February rent. 11 U.S.C. § 365.

    [3] In re Hitz Rest. Grp., No. BR 20 B 05012, 2020 WL 2924523, at *1 (Bankr. N.D. Ill. June 3, 2020).

    [4] Id. at *2.

    [5] Id. at *3 (citation omitted).

    [6] Id. *2.

    [7] Id. at *3.

    [8] Id.

    [9] Id. at *4.

    [10] As March 2020 rent became fully due and payable on March 1, 2020, and the Executive Order did not become effective until two weeks thereafter, the Court concluded that the force majeure clause did not excuse payment of past-due March 2020 rent.

    [11] Id. at *3.

    [12] Id. at *5, FN 2 (citations omitted).


    This is a fast-moving topic and the information contained in this Alert is current as of the date it was published.

    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2020 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

     

    In depth
    Authors

    Taleah E. Baez

    Senior Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Julian M. Wise

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Addressing Facial Recognition Tech’s Discriminatory Potential

    ARTICLE

    Addressing Facial Recognition Tech’s Discriminatory Potential

    June 26, 2020

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Federal District Court Upholds Hospital Price Transparency Rule; Implementation and Compliance Questions Remain

    Federal District Court Upholds Hospital Price Transparency Rule; Implementation and Compliance Questions Remain

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Federal District Court Upholds Hospital Price Transparency Rule; Implementation and Compliance Questions Remain

    June 26, 2020

    Read time: 11 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The US District Court for the District of Columbia rejected a challenge to the legality of a rule requiring hospitals to publish their negotiated payment rates, increasing the likelihood that the rule will become effective on January 1, 2021. While the plaintiffs intend to appeal, hospitals should consider what steps may be necessary to comply with the rule’s requirements in the event that it is not invalidated or stayed within the next six months. This On the Subject highlights several key areas of ambiguity that pose potential risks and opportunities for hospitals as they begin their compliance preparations, including the scope of practitioner employment, service packages and shoppable service ancillary services, among others. We also address several potential legal risks for hospitals that do not comply with the rule’s requirements.

    In depth

    Background

    On November 15, 2019, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) issued a final rule (Final Rule) that requires hospitals to establish, update and make public a list of their standard charges for items and services they provide, including negotiated prices with third-party payors, by January 1, 2021. Less than a month after the Final Rule was issued, the American Hospital Association, several other hospital associations and individual hospitals promptly filed suit in the US District Court for the District of Columbia, arguing that CMS had exceeded its authority under the Administrative Procedure Act, that the Final Rule violates the First Amendment, and that the Final Rule is arbitrary and capricious.

    On June 23, 2020, the District Court sided with CMS on all arguments. The plaintiffs filed a Notice of Appeal the following day, and the American Hospital Association has stated that it will seek expedited review. Pending the results of the appeal, however, hospitals must contend with the fact that the Final Rule could very well go into effect on January 1, 2021. Accordingly, this On the Subject evaluates some key legal considerations that hospitals should evaluate in connection with the Final Rule.

    Determining Which Physicians Are “Employed”

    The Final Rule requires hospitals to make public their standard charges for all items and services provided by the hospital, which include “services of employed physicians and non-physician practitioners” (i.e., the professional component of services provided at a hospital). Despite receiving feedback from commenters that the designation of an “employed” physician or practitioner is not always straightforward, CMS declined to offer a specific definition of employment. In particular, commenters pointed out that large academic medical centers may have faculty that are affiliated with a separate business entity and are not necessarily employed by the hospital, and independent practices may assign billing rights to the hospital even though its practitioners are not considered hospital employees. Instead of providing more clarity in response to these questions, CMS opted to “preserve flexibility” for hospitals to identify employed practitioners.

    The scope of an employee is a key issue in this context: if a service is performed by a non-employed practitioner, it does not constitute an “item and service” provided by the hospital for which a charge must be made public. Hospitals that employ practitioners may be at a disadvantage because the charges that they disclose could be higher than those of other hospitals that are not required to include such charges because they are not technically “employing” the practitioner. This is a particularly critical distinction for “service packages” that aggregate several hospital services into a single charge. If certain hospitals exclude entire services from service packages because they are not performed by an “employed” practitioner, the service package rate will appear lower than that of a hospital that employs the professionals who furnish the same service that a non-employed practitioner performed at the first hospital. It will be important for hospitals to establish and consistently apply a definition of “employment” for purposes of implementing the requirements of the Final Rule.

    Determining Service Packages

    As noted, the Final Rule requires hospitals to report their standard charges for “service packages,” which are defined broadly and vaguely to simply mean an “aggregation of individual items and services into a single service with a single charge.” There are many operational questions associated with preparing and publishing charges for such service packages. In particular, service packages may vary based on the particular payor and may not align with particular CPT and HCPCS codes. In addition, the charges for service packages are not located on a hospital’s chargemaster, and as a result, hospitals will have to source the charges from other parts of the hospital’s billing and accounting systems, or from their various third-party payor contracts.

    It is important to distinguish “service packages” from shoppable services and ancillary services (described below), where service packages are groups of services for which a hospital has established a single negotiated rate with at least one third-party payor. Service packages may be found in rate tables or rate sheets in contracts with third-party payors, and service package rates may be listed on Explanations of Benefits (EOBs) of patients enrolled in the third-party payor plan. If a hospital has not established a charge for a set of services and negotiated a rate for that package of services, the services likely would not qualify as a “service package” under the Final Rule for purposes of publishing a rate for the set of services.

    Selecting Shoppable Services and Determining Their Scope

    In addition to requiring publication of charges for items and services, the Final Rule requires hospitals to publish the charges for so-called “shoppable services,” which are defined as “a service that can be scheduled by a healthcare consumer in advance.” The intent is for the term to encapsulate non-emergency services that a patient can schedule based on convenience and which are therefore more conducive to price shopping. CMS provides the examples of “delivery of babies” and cancer treatments, where the location of delivery is typically planned well in advance and patients with cancer diagnoses often seek information from various providers before committing to a treatment course by a particular provider.

    Hospitals’ published charges for “shoppable services” must also specify the charges for any ancillary services that a hospital “customarily provides (and bills for) … as part of or in conjunction with the primary service.” Examples of such ancillary services include laboratory, radiology, drugs and therapy services, although CMS also notes that there may be some items and services (including service packages) that hospitals customarily provide without any ancillary services.

    CMS does not specifically define what it means to “customarily provide” an ancillary service that must be included with the primary shoppable item or service, although it provides that ancillary services are “typically billed with the primary shoppable service,” and that the determination must be made on a hospital-by-hospital basis. To quote CMS, “identifying and listing the standard charges for ancillary services along with the primary shoppable service may take some thought and clinical input.” It will be important for hospitals to document and consistently apply their approach to determining which ancillary services are customarily provided with primary shoppable items or services.

    A hospital’s approach to selecting such ancillary services has important implications for the way consumers will view and use the charge information. If, for example, a hospital includes more ancillary services for a given primary service than competitor hospitals, it may be disadvantaged because consumers could falsely conclude that hospitals specifying fewer ancillary services will charge a lower global amount for the shoppable service. On the other hand, hospitals may be deemed noncompliant with the Final Rule if they do not include all ancillary services that are “customarily” or “typically” provided, notwithstanding the vagueness of these terms.

    Hospitals must make public the charges associated with a total of 300 shoppable services, and CMS indicates in the Final Rule that it may increase this number once hospitals are accustomed to posting charge information. CMS specified 70 shoppable services in the Final Rule, and hospitals must post their charges for as many of these services as they provide. The remaining shoppable services will be selected by the hospital, and in selecting such services, the hospital “must consider the rate at which it provides and bills for that shoppable service.” This language is intended to require hospitals to take into account the frequency with which services are provided.

    There is a significant amount of discretion and uncertainty regarding which items and services a hospital should select to meet the 300 shoppable services target. CMS indicated that hospitals must select services based on the utilization or billing rate of services in the past year; however, CMS expressly notes that it does not preclude hospitals from incorporating other criteria into their selection process, such as cost. While this is likely to result in a lack of uniformity across hospitals, it also offers a measure of flexibility to hospitals to determine how to best construct their list of shoppable services. Hospitals should develop and follow a consistent methodology for selecting their shoppable services not otherwise identified by CMS.

    Penalties for Noncompliance

    The Final Rule incorporates several mechanisms for monitoring and enforcing hospitals’ compliance. CMS has established a pathway for individuals and entities to report instances of alleged noncompliance, which CMS may then investigate (in the future, CMS may also self-initiate audits of hospital websites). In instances where hospitals are found to be noncompliant, CMS has specified three levels of enforcement:

    • CMS may issue a written warning to the hospital.
    • CMS may request a corrective action plan if the noncompliance constitutes a material violation of one or more requirements.
    • If a hospital fails to respond to a request for a plan or to comply with a plan’s terms, CMS may impose (and publish notice of) civil monetary penalties. The financial penalties are capped at $300/day, which equates to a maximum of $109,500 per year.

    CMS acknowledged that some hospitals may prefer to pay the penalties rather than comply with the provisions in the Final Rule. Although it refrained from altering the proposed penalties as a result, CMS indicated that it would monitor any such occurrences and may adjust the penalties in future rulemaking.

    When developing compliance plans, hospitals should consider both the financial costs as well as the potential reputational costs of noncompliance with the Final Rule. As far as the latter is concerned, consumers will be able to assess for themselves whether hospitals are publishing their charges and can file complaints directly with CMS. In addition, CMS will also publish the names of all hospitals that have been penalized for noncompliance on its website, alongside a notice of continuing violations. This may lead to additional financial cost if consumers opt to receive services elsewhere because they are unable to compare a hospital’s standard charges to charges published by other hospitals in compliance with the Final Rule.

    Finally, CMS expressly declined to adopt suggestions that it require hospitals to report or attest to CMS that they are in compliance with these requirements, but stated that it may revisit this issue in future rulemaking. There are many circumstances in which hospitals must certify or attest to compliance with laws that may be implicated by noncompliance with the Final Rule’s requirements. For example, the Medicare Enrollment Application and hospital Conditions of Participation require hospitals to “abide by” or “be in compliance with” applicable laws, and hospitals regularly enter into commercial transactions in which they must represent and warrant compliance with laws. Hospitals should be aware of the various potential implications of noncompliance with the Final Rule beyond financial penalties.

    Key Takeaways

    Despite the ongoing litigation surrounding the Final Rule, it likely could become effective on January 1, 2021. Even if the Final Rule is invalidated on appeal, its invalidation may not happen much before the implementation date. Hospitals may find it difficult to rush implementation if an appeals court upholds the law. Accordingly, hospitals should determine whether and how they will comply with the Final Rule’s provisions. In particular, they should consider what criteria to use in establishing their list of shoppable services, and how to evaluate which ancillary services are “customarily” provided alongside these services. Hospitals should document in their policies and procedures how they make these decisions, and should approach the decisions consistently. Hospitals would be wise to also consider the potential implications of noncompliance with the Final Rule, such as financial or reputational harm, or potential noncompliance with compliance attestations or certifications.

    Authors

    Eric Zimmerman

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Emily Jane Cook

    Partner

    Los Angeles, Washington, DC

    Steven J. Schnelle

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • Five Takeaways: What’s New in Energy Private Equity? Trends and Developments in a Shifting Investment Landscape

    Five Takeaways: What’s New in Energy Private Equity? Trends and Developments in a Shifting Investment Landscape

    ARTICLE

    Five Takeaways: What’s New in Energy Private Equity? Trends and Developments in a Shifting Investment Landscape

    June 26, 2020

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    McDermott recently hosted Andrew Ellenbogen of EIG Partners and Jeff Hunter of Apollo Global Management for a lively discussion about the trends and developments in today’s shifting investment landscape.

    Below are key takeaways from this week’s webinar.

    In depth
    1. The most impactful changes in energy investment over the last decade have been the drop in natural gas prices, the decrease in the cost of capital for renewable investments and the increase in renewable capacity factors (and a dramatic decrease in equipment pricing).
    2. As the energy market has become crowded for traditional operating assets, some investors are seeking opportunities in non-traditional spaces, such as investing in non-traditional technologies (such as solar plus storage or offshore wind) or investing in service providers or construction companies.
    3. In search of returns, some investors are continuing to take a greater amount of merchant risk or development risk than they previously would have accepted, and some investors are investing in platforms rather than projects.
    4. There are smart investments in power to be made in areas with higher barriers to entry (if you can make reasonable projections on the regulatory environment). For example, California peaking resources have provided interesting opportunities in recent years. Larger returns come from taking thoughtful positions on the market and taking carefully analyzed risks.
    5. Prudent investors pay attention to intrinsic risks of power investments, including risks that the market may not be pricing correctly. A successful investment in power assets requires realistic (and conservative) estimates of both basis risk and the merchant tail (and a view on back-end electricity prices).

    To begin receiving Energy updates, including invitations to the Renewables Roundtable and Q&A Webinar Series, please click here.

    Access past webinars in this series.

    Authors

    Edward Zaelke

    Partner

    Los Angeles

    Christopher Gladbach

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • Agencies Issue Helpful FAQs on COVID-19 Testing Coverage

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Agencies Issue Helpful FAQs on COVID-19 Testing Coverage

    June 25, 2020

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On June 23, 2020, the US Departments of Labor, Health and Human Services, and Treasury issued tri-agency FAQs (Part 43) that clarify important health and welfare provisions under the Families First Coronavirus Response Act (FFCRA), which became law on March 18, 2020, and the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act, enacted on March 27, 2020. Both laws addressed Coronavirus (COVID-19) testing and prevention coverage, as well as expansion of telehealth service availability. This is the second set of FAQs issued by the joint agencies addressing compliance with the FFCRA and the CARES Act. For more information, see our previous articles on the prior FAQ, the provisions of the FFCRA and the provisions of the CARES Act.

    In depth

    COVID-19 Testing Applies to Self-Insured/Self-Funded Plans

    Effective March 18, 2020, the FFCRA generally requires group health plans to provide benefits for certain items and services related to diagnostic testing to detect or diagnose COVID-19 without cost sharing (including deductibles, copayments and coinsurance), prior authorization or any other medical management requirement. Per the FAQs, multiple diagnostic tests must be covered if the attending healthcare provider determines such tests are medically appropriate. If a facility fee (e.g., a fee for using facilities or equipment that an individual’s provider does not own, or that are owned by a hospital) is charged for a visit that results in an order for, or administration of, a COVID-19 diagnostic test, a plan must cover that facility fee to the extent the fee relates to furnishing or administering a COVID-19 test, or to evaluating an individual to determine her need for testing. The new FAQs also provide that plans must cover at-home testing if the physician or other provider has determined that the test is medically appropriate for the individual, including tests where the individual performs self-collection of a specimen at home. There is no limit on the number of tests a plan must cover relating to a specific individual. Any number of tests must be covered as long as the tests are diagnostic and medically appropriate for the individual, as determined by an attending healthcare provider in accordance with current accepted standards of medical practice.

    The new FAQ confirms that FFCRA’s health plan provisions apply to self-insured/self-funded group health plans, which include private employment-based group health plans (plans governed by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974), non-federal governmental plans (such as plans sponsored by states and local governments) and church plans. Plans that do not cover at least two current employees, such as retiree-only plans, are not required to comply.

    Types of Tests Required

    The new FAQs clarify that all in vitro diagnostic tests for COVID-19 that have received an emergency use authorization from the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) must be covered. A list of such test can be found here.

    The FAQs also clarify that for purposes of covering an in vitro diagnostic test for which the developer has requested or intends to request emergency use authorization, a clinical laboratory or commercial manufacturer that is listed on FDA’s website as having provided notification under the FDA guidance can reasonably be assumed to have requested, or as intending to request, an emergency use authorization (except for laboratory-developed serology tests). Therefore, coverage must be provided for in vitro diagnostic tests for COVID-19 that are included on the FDA list.

    Lastly, for purposes of covering an in vitro diagnostic test that is developed in and authorized by a state that has provided proper notification, a list of states and territories that have provided notification can be found here.

    Return-to-Work Testing Need Not Be Covered

    The agencies note that COVID-19 testing for surveillance or employment purposes is not required to be covered under the FFCRA. Testing conducted to screen for general workplace health and safety (such as employee return-to-work programs), for public health surveillance for COVID-19, or for any other purpose not primarily intended for individualized diagnosis or treatment of COVID-19 or another health condition is beyond the scope of the FFCRA.

    Balance Billing Issues

    The new FAQs provide that the agencies interpret the FFCRA and the CARES Act (as well as related guidance) as intended to protect participants from being balance billed for an applicable COVID-19 test. Under the CARES Act, a plan will reimburse a COVID-19 testing provider either a negotiated rate or an amount that equals the cash price for such service that is listed by the provider on a public website. If the provider fails to post the cash price, the parties may have to negotiate the price, and the provider may be subject to penalties for failure to comply with the CARES Act. In either case, the amount the plan or issuer reimburses the provider constitutes payment in full for the test, with no cost-sharing to the individual or other balance due. Individuals may still be subject to balance billing for items and services furnished during a visit that are not covered by the CARES Act.

    Notice Requirements

    The expanded coverage for COVID-19 testing continues until a “outbreak” period ends. If an employer wants to align COVID-19 testing with its other benefits upon the end of the national emergency period and impose cost sharing, prior notice to participants is required unless the notice eliminating cost sharing included information about the temporary nature of the relief.

    Telehealth

    The FAQs confirm that employers may offer a telehealth-only plan (including other remote care service arrangements) to employees and dependents who are not otherwise eligible for the employer’s group health plan—at least during the pandemic, with the stipulation that the telehealth-only plan cannot have pre-existing condition exclusions, cannot discriminate based on health status, cannot conduct rescissions of coverage, and is still subject to mental health parity.

    Conclusion

    Many of the changes required or permitted by the FFCRA and the CARES Act as highlighted in these FAQs will require amendments to plan documents and updates to summary plan descriptions. Plan sponsors should work with third-party administrators, insurers and legal counsel to ensure that these changes are implemented correctly and to review any other legal requirements that might be implicated.

    Specifically, plan sponsors should work with their insurers and third-party administrators to ensure that cost sharing has been eliminated for COVID-19 testing and diagnostics. Plan sponsors also may wish to work with insurers and third-party administrators to ascertain pricing from out-of-network facilities, in light of the prohibition on balance billing. Participant communications also should be revised to reflect plan changes.

    If you have any questions regarding the above, please reach out to your regular McDermott lawyer or one of the listed authors.

    Authors

    Jacob M. Mattinson

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights