Content Type: Article

  • New Blog: HR News Germany

    New Blog: HR News Germany

    ARTICLE

    New Blog: HR News Germany

    2023

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Our latest blog, HR News Germany, provides regular updates on the latest developments in German employment law relating to COVID and beyond. From the right to work from home, legislation on crowdworking , parental rights and more our skilled Employment team are closely monitoring and reporting on the most recent news.

    Visit the blog for regular updates (provided in German).

    In depth
    Authors

    Dr. Thomas Gennert

    Partner

    Düsseldorf

    Volker Teigelkötter

    Partner

    Düsseldorf

    Dr. Philip Uecker

    Associate

    Düsseldorf

    More insights

  • Massachusetts Enacts Legislation Promoting Access to Quality and Affordable Care, Telehealth

    Massachusetts Enacts Legislation Promoting Access to Quality and Affordable Care, Telehealth

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Massachusetts Enacts Legislation Promoting Access to Quality and Affordable Care, Telehealth

    February 8, 2021

    Read time: 12 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On January 1, 2021, Governor Charlie Baker signed an omnibus healthcare law entitled “An Act promoting a resilient health care system that puts patients first,” which is aimed at addressing pressing healthcare issues in Massachusetts, many of which have been exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic.

    In depth

    The act addresses a wide variety of healthcare issues, such as surprise billing, advanced practitioner scope of practice, telehealth, mental health parity and healthcare accessibility. Governor Baker initially proposed several of these measures in late 2019 in “An Act to improve health care by investing in value.” While the January 2021 act incorporates many of the core concepts from the 2019 proposal, in some cases these concepts were substantially modified and new provisions (specifically, those related to addressing the COVID-19 pandemic) were introduced into the final version of the act. Key features of the act are summarized below.

    Surprise Billing

    In recent years, various federal and state governmental authorities have taken steps to address so-called “surprise” medical bills, which are bills considered to be significantly higher than a patient would otherwise anticipate at the time she receives the service. A “surprise bill” typically arises when an insured patient receives a bill from an out-of-network provider for services rendered in an emergency situation, or where such services were rendered by an out-of-network provider at an in-network facility.

    The act:

    • Requires providers to disclose their out-of-network status to patients prior to admission
    • Requires providers, upon patient request, to disclose the amount to be charged for admission, a procedure, or service, including the amount for any healthcare services rendered by an out-of-network provider and any facility fees
    • Requires providers making referrals to notify patients if the provider to whom the patient is referred is out-of-network for the patient
    • Prohibits providers from billing an insured patient for healthcare services in excess of the applicable coinsurance, copayment, or deductible that would be imposed for such services if they were rendered by a participating provider
    • Directs the Secretary of the Executive Office of Health and Human Services (EOHHS) to work with the Health Policy Commission (HPC), Center for Health Information and Analytics (CHIA), and Division of Insurance to recommend, among other things, a default rate for out-of-network billing by September 2021.

    The new requirements and restrictions under the act impose additional compliance obligations for out-of-network providers that may affect patient utilization in the short term, and ultimately push providers that had previously pursued an out-of-network strategy to contract with major commercial payors in the Commonwealth. The act does not explicitly create a private right of action for patients, but directs the Department of Public Health (DPH) commissioner to implement and impose penalties for noncompliance not to exceed $2,500 per instance. Unlike similar laws in other jurisdictions, the act does not create any dispute resolution or similar mechanism for providers and insurers to determine what additional amount, if any, an out-of-network provider may be reimbursed for services rendered to an insured patient and for which such patient’s financial responsibility is limited to the applicable in-network coinsurance amount.

    On December 21, 2020, the US Congress passed its own surprise billing legislation, which you can read more about here. The new federal law defers to existing state requirements with respect to state-established payment amounts, meaning that the federal law does not fully preempt or otherwise displace state payment standards. States also can continue to pass surprise billing laws and regulations in the future.

    Scope of Practice

    The act also expands the scope of practice for nurse anesthetists, nurse practitioners, and psychiatric nurse mental health clinical specialists (collectively, advance practice registered nurses or APRNs), allowing APRNs who meet certain qualifications (including two years of supervised practice) to practice independently and prescribe drugs to patients. This cements the DPH emergency administrative order responding to the initial wave of the COVID-19 pandemic, which lifted prescribing restrictions and physician supervision requirements for APRNs. Under the act, psychiatric nurse mental health clinical specialists also have expanded authority with respect to determinations on psychiatric evaluations, restraints, and hospitalizations.

    The act also overhauls the optometrist scope of practice, adding new prescriptive authority (including both topical and oral therapeutics), allowing optometrists to treat glaucoma in certain instances, and creating a pathway for reciprocity for optometrists licensed by other jurisdictions.

    Telehealth

    The COVID-19 pandemic resulted in sweeping changes at the state and federal levels to expand access to telehealth services, as in-person care presented relatively more risk than telehealth or was otherwise infeasible. The act incorporates several of these emergency changes into law, focusing on parity in access and reimbursement between telehealth and in-person healthcare services. The act:

    • Revises the definition of “telehealth” to include audio-only services
    • Removes the requirement for providers to document barriers to in-person healthcare visits and the limitation on location settings for telehealth services [1]
    • Prohibits healthcare insurers from declining coverage for healthcare services solely on the basis that such services were delivered through the use of telehealth, as long as (i) the healthcare services are otherwise covered when done in-person, and (ii) the healthcare services may be appropriately provided through telehealth
    • Requires payment parity, as between copays and deductibles for in-person services and telehealth services, and extends temporary rate parity across all healthcare services for 90 days after the expiration of the COVID-19 state of emergency in the Commonwealth
    • Requires, on a permanent basis, licensed hospitals, insurance companies and health maintenance organizations, medical service corporations, preferred provider organizations, and the EOHHS to ensure that the rate of payment for in-network providers of behavioral health services and chronic disease management services delivered via telehealth is no less than the rate of payment for the same services delivered in-person.

    Healthcare Accessibility

    Access to care and controlling healthcare spending have been decades-long priorities for Massachusetts, and the spotlight on these matters has only intensified during the COVID-19 pandemic. The act ushers in several changes to address those priorities. Under the new law:

    • Massachusetts Medicaid (MassHealth) patients are no longer required to seek a primary care provider (PCP) referral prior to an urgent care visit, removing barriers to access for MassHealth patients to urgent care services
    • Eligible Massachusetts community hospitals will receive enhanced monthly Medicaid payments for two years
    • Insurers, including MassHealth, are required to cover all COVID-19-related emergency, inpatient, and cognitive rehabilitation services, as well as medically necessary COVID-19 testing (including for asymptomatic individuals in certain circumstances)

    HPC and CHIA must analyze and produce a report on the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic, including its effects on healthcare accessibility, Massachusetts’s fiscal sustainability, the quality of healthcare services, and long-term impacts on social, economic, and health disparities.

    * * * *

    The changes under the act present opportunities, as well as a few challenges, for Massachusetts healthcare providers and other industry stakeholders, including the following:

    • The act’s surprise billing requirements stepped away from the rigid rate setting approach initially proposed in the 2019 act and instead put the onus on state agencies to study the matter and produce a proposal on next steps by September 2021. This approach is flexible, giving stakeholders an opportunity to provide comments to EOHHS and other state agencies on a reasonable surprise billing framework. The absence of arbitration provisions in the act, however, creates significant operational uncertainty as to whether, and to what extent, an out-of-network provider may seek additional reimbursement from a third-party payor for services rendered to an insured patient in a “surprise billing” situation, and for which the patient’s financial responsibility is limited to the in-network coinsurance amount. The Secretary of EOHHS is required to analyze the advisability of establishing a process for healthcare providers or carriers to dispute the accuracy or appropriateness of a non-contracted, out-of-network commercial payment rate and to review best practices in other states.
    • The increased independence for certain APRNs and the expanded scope of practice for optometrists may allow providers (including health systems) more flexibility in staffing and potentially enable them to lower costs for providing certain services (such as primary care services). Independent APRNs may also alleviate some of the PCP scarcity in the Commonwealth, especially in rural areas, allowing providers and insurers to expand their PCP networks and expand access to PCP services.
    • Lastly, because the Act cements access parity and out-of-pocket expense parity for telehealth, providers can more confidently invest in expanding their telehealth services and platforms, especially relative to behavioral health services, which have been a critical backstop for delivering healthcare services during the COVID-19 pandemic.

    Table of Key Provisions

    Topic Area Summary
     1.  Surprise Bills  – The act requires healthcare providers to disclose, upon request from a patient or prospective patient, the amount to be charged for admission, a procedure or service, including the amount for any healthcare services rendered by an out-of-network provider and any facility fees, and to provide the patient with the estimated maximum if an exact quote is not ascertainable. The provider must notify the patient prior to admission as to whether it is an out-of-network provider. 

    – A provider referring a patient to another provider must notify the patient if the provider to whom the patient is referred is represented by the same provider organization and if the other provider is out-of-network.

    – The act prohibits healthcare providers who do not participate in the patient’s health benefit plan from billing an insured for healthcare services in excess of the applicable coinsurance, copayment or deductible that would be imposed for such healthcare services if the services were rendered by a participating provider. 

    – The act directs the Secretary of the EOHHS to work with the HPC, CHIA, and Division of Insurance to recommend a default rate for out-of-network billing by September of 2021. 

     2.  Scope of Practice – The act permits nurse anesthetists, nurse practitioners, and psychiatric nurse mental health clinical specialists to prescribe drugs and practice independently if they meet certain supervised practice experience criteria.

    – The “practice of optometry” and related licensure regime are revised, granting optometrists greater authority to prescribe topical and oral therapeutics, including to treat glaucoma.

    – Psychiatric nurse mental health clinical specialists have expanded authority with respect to determinations on psychiatric evaluations, restraints, and hospitalizations.

     3.  Telehealth – The definition of “telehealth” now includes audio-only services.[2]

    – A third party payor shall not require a healthcare provider to document a barrier to an in-person visit, nor limit the type of setting where telehealth services may be provided. However, patients may decline receiving services via telehealth in order to receive in-person services. 

    – The act prohibits insurers from denying coverage for healthcare services solely on the basis that such services were delivered using telehealth, as long as (i) the healthcare services are covered by way of in-person consultation or delivery, and (ii) the healthcare services may be appropriately provided through telehealth. Co-pays and deductibles must also be the same for in-person services and telehealth services. This applies to nonprofit hospital service corporations, medical service corporations, and health maintenance organizations.

    – The Group Insurance Commission shall ensure that the rate of payment for in-network providers of behavioral health services delivered via interactive audio-video technology and audio-only telephone is no less than the rate of payment for the same behavioral health service delivered via in-person methods. This also applies to the division of medical assistance within the executive office of health and human services, insurance companies, hospital service corporations, medical service corporations, health maintenance organizations, and provider organizations.[3] 

    – The Group Insurance Commission, the division of medical assistance, insurance companies, nonprofit hospital service corporations, medical service corporations, health maintenance organizations, and preferred provider organizations must ensure that the rate of payment for in-network providers of chronic disease management and primary care services delivered via telehealth is not less than the rate of payment for the same services delivered via in-person methods.

    – The act requires rate parity for all telehealth services for 90 days past the COVID-19 state of emergency. 

     4.  MassHealth – The act eliminates for MassHealth beneficiaries (i) the need to obtain a referral from a PCP before urgent care visits, and (ii) requirements for care coordination with the beneficiary’s primary care physician.[4] 

    – The act provides enhanced monthly Medicaid payments for two years to eligible Massachusetts community hospitals. An “eligible hospital” means a nonprofit or municipal acute care hospital that, as calculated by CHIA: (i) has a statewide relative price less than 0.90; (ii) has a public payer mix equal to or greater than 60%; and (iii) is not owned, financially consolidated, or corporately affiliated, with a provider organization that (a) owns or controls two or more acute care hospitals, and (b) has total net assets of all affiliated acute care hospitals greater than $600 million.

     5.  COVID-19 – Insurers, including MassHealth, are required to cover all COVID-19 related emergency, inpatient, and cognitive rehab services.

    – The act requires coverage for medically necessary outpatient COVID-19 testing, including for asymptomatic individuals under specific circumstances outlined by the Secretary of EOHHS.

    – The act directs HPC and CHIA to analyze and report on the effect of COVID-19 on healthcare accessibility; the quality of healthcare services; fiscal sustainability in the short term; and long-term policy considerations, including an examination of existing healthcare disparities due to economic, geographic, racial or other factors. 

    Footnotes:
    [1] Note: these are only state-level flexibilities, and providers should keep in mind applicable Medicare requirements.
    [2] “Telehealth” means the use of synchronous or asynchronous audio, video, electronic media or other telecommunications technology, including, but not limited to: (i) interactive audio-video technology; (ii) remote patient monitoring devices; (iii) audio-only telephone; and (iv) online adaptive interviews, for the purpose of evaluating, diagnosing, consulting, prescribing, treating or monitoring of a patient’s physical health, oral health, mental health or substance use disorder condition.
    [3] Additionally, the fiscal year 2021 state budget prohibits insurance carriers from denying coverage for any behavioral health service or any evaluation and management office visit solely because the two services were delivered on the same day in the same practice or facility, provided that the two services are not delivered by the same provider, or providers of the same specialty.
    [4] The fiscal year 2021 state budget requires MassHealth and commercial insurers to use a standardized credentialing form so providers only need to complete one application.

    McDermott Will & Emery’s new Associate, Allyn N. Rosenberger also contributed to this article.

    Authors
    More insights

  • Navigating the New Post-Brexit VAT Rules for Non-UK E-Commerce Sellers and Online Marketplace Operators

    Navigating the New Post-Brexit VAT Rules for Non-UK E-Commerce Sellers and Online Marketplace Operators

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Navigating the New Post-Brexit VAT Rules for Non-UK E-Commerce Sellers and Online Marketplace Operators

    February 8, 2021

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    At the end of the Brexit transition period, new UK VAT rules entered into force which from 1 January 2021 will have UK VAT consequences for overseas e-commerce sellers and online marketplaces that sell imported low-value consignments of goods into the United Kingdom, or that sell UK-based goods to UK customers.

    A consequence of these new rules is that, from 1 January 2021, e-commerce sales of imported goods worth more than £135, or of imported goods of any value subject to excise duties, to UK-based customers will attract import VAT when they are imported into the United Kingdom and declared under an appropriate customs procedure. This will be the case whether the goods are sold to the customer directly or through an online marketplace.

    In depth

    Generally, the person liable for import VAT will be the importer. In practical terms, this means that the seller or buyer (as appropriate) will need to settle the VAT with their customs agent or freight forwarder, which will pay the import VAT (together with any customs duty) at the customs border. However, VAT-registered customers should be able to use postponed VAT accounting to account for and recover the import VAT on the same VAT returns as their UK domestic supplies for the relevant VAT period (subject to normal UK VAT recovery rules) instead of having to pay the import VAT upfront and recover it later. Either way, neither the online marketplace operator nor the overseas seller will be liable to account for the import VAT in these circumstances, although they may indirectly be required to bear the cost of it, depending on the nature of their contractual arrangements with the importer.

    Overseas sellers and online marketplace operators may nevertheless find themselves liable to account for UK VAT on business-to-consumer (B2C) sales of UK-based goods, or on B2C sales of imported consignments of goods worth less than £135 (low-value imported goods), to their UK-based customers. The overall effect of these requirements is to treat such sales as domestic supplies for UK VAT purposes, rather than imports under the import VAT rules. This means that online marketplace operators will need to either register for VAT themselves or check that their overseas sellers or buyers (as appropriate) are VAT-registered. Non-UK e-commerce sellers that have not previously been required to register for UK VAT may find that they must do so as a result of these new rules.

    This article contains some guidelines to help potentially affected entities navigate the new UK VAT requirements and take action as needed. This article does not apply to goods arriving in Northern Ireland, for which there are special VAT and customs rules under the Northern Ireland Protocol.

    For the purposes of this note, an “online marketplace operator” means the person who controls access to, and the contents of, the online marketplace, provided that the person is involved in (a) determining any terms or conditions applicable to the sale of goods; (b) processing, or facilitating the processing of, payment for the goods; and (c) the ordering or delivery, or facilitating the ordering or delivery, of the goods. An “online marketplace” for these purposes means a website, or any other means by which information is made available over the internet, which facilitates the sale of goods through the website or other means by persons other than the operator, whether or not the operator also sells goods through the marketplace.

    Online B2C Direct Sales by Overseas Sellers to UK Consumers

    Low-Value Imported Goods

    Because these sales will attract UK VAT under the new rules, the overseas seller will need to charge UK VAT to the customer at the online checkout and include that VAT as output tax on its VAT return. To do this, the overseas seller must first register for UK VAT.

    Online business-to-business direct sales of low-value imported goods to VAT-registered customers will be subject to a new reverse-charge rule, meaning that the business customer will need to account for the VAT on its VAT return on a reverse-charge basis. However, the overseas seller must obtain a valid VAT registration number from the customer to ensure that such reverse charge treatment applies, and must also include a note to that effect on its VAT invoice. If the seller cannot obtain of this information, then the sale should be treated as a B2C sale, with the overseas seller being liable to account for the UK VAT accordingly.

    UK-Based Goods (of Any Value)

    If the goods are located in the United Kingdom at the point of sale, the sale will be treated as a domestic supply for UK VAT purposes. In these circumstances, the overseas seller will be required to charge UK VAT on those sales under existing UK VAT rules and should be VAT-registered accordingly.

    Online B2C Sales by Overseas Sellers to UK Customers Through an Online Marketplace

    Low-Value Imported Goods

    For UK VAT purposes, these sales are now characterised as two separate deemed supplies under the new rules, namely, (i) a deemed supply to the online marketplace operator, which is outside the scope of UK VAT, and (ii) a deemed supply by the online marketplace operator to the UK customer, which attracts VAT at the standard rate (currently 20%), for which the online marketplace is liable.

    To collect and account for the VAT on the second deemed supply, the online marketplace operator will need to charge UK VAT to the customer at the online checkout and account for that VAT as output tax on its VAT return. To do this, the online marketplace operator will need to register for UK VAT. If the customer has already accounted for some or all of the VAT due, the online marketplace operator will not be liable for any excess VAT over and above that already accounted for by the customer, provided that the online marketplace takes all reasonable steps to ascertain the seller’s place of establishment and the location of the goods at the time of the supply, and to satisfy itself that the amounts charged were correct.

    The above rules do not apply if the customer is VAT registered, and the online marketplace operator obtains a VAT registration number from the customer and passes it on, together with details of the sale, to the seller within seven days of the applicable tax point date. In these circumstances, one would expect the customer to reverse-charge the VAT instead.

    UK-Based Goods (of Any Value)

    Where UK-based goods are concerned, the deemed supply rules are the same as those applicable to low-value imported goods, except that the deemed supply to the online marketplace operator is zero-rated, rather than outside the scope of UK VAT.

    Again, the deemed supply rules will not apply if the customer is VAT registered, and the online marketplace operator obtains a VAT registration number from the customer and passes it on, together with details of the sale, to the seller within seven days of the applicable tax point date. Instead, the sale should be treated as a domestic UK supply for VAT purposes under existing rules, meaning that the overseas seller, rather than the online marketplace, will be required to charge VAT on the sale, and should register for UK VAT accordingly.

    If the overseas seller is not VAT registered when it should be, or is otherwise non-compliant with the UK VAT rules (for example, by failing to charge UK VAT when it should) the online marketplace operator will be jointly and severally liable to HMRC for the amount of VAT due in respect of all VAT-able sales made by the overseas seller during the period of non-registration or non-compliance, unless the online marketplace operator prevents that seller from offering its goods for sale through the online marketplace for a specified period. This same rule applies in cases of non-compliance by UK sellers as well.

    Recommendations

    Online marketplace operators and overseas sellers should have a due diligence checklist for all buyers and sellers making use of their website to help them ascertain whether they have a UK VAT obligation under any of the above-mentioned rules.

    For online marketplace operators, the checklist should include:

    • The UK VAT registration status of the buyer and seller
    • The location of the buyer and seller
    • The value of the goods being sold
    • The location of the goods being sold.

    For overseas sellers, the checklist should include:

    • The UK VAT registration status of the buyer
    • The location of the buyer
    • The value of the goods being sold
    • The location of the goods being sold.

    In checking the VAT registration status of the transaction parties, consider asking them to confirm if they are liable to be VAT registered, particularly if they are unable to provide a VAT registration number.

    Authors
    More insights

  • Full Disclosure Required: Lifetime Income Estimates on Defined Contribution Plan Benefit Statements

    Full Disclosure Required: Lifetime Income Estimates on Defined Contribution Plan Benefit Statements

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Full Disclosure Required: Lifetime Income Estimates on Defined Contribution Plan Benefit Statements

    February 5, 2021

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The US Department of Labor (DOL) unveiled an interim final rule (the “Lifetime Income Disclosure Rule”) that adds a new lifetime income disclosure requirement for administrators of defined contribution plans (e.g., plans covered by Internal Revenue Code (Code) section 401(k) or Code section 403(b), profit-sharing plans and employee stock ownership plans). The Lifetime Income Disclosure Rule implements the provisions of the Setting Every Community Up for Retirement Enhancement Act of 2019 (SECURE Act)—passed by Congress at the end of 2019—which require that defined contribution plan administrators include an estimated lifetime income stream of payments on the periodic participant benefit statements. For plans that are otherwise required to issue quarterly benefit statements, the Lifetime Income Disclosure Rule is clear that the lifetime income estimates may be provided on an annual basis.

    In depth

    Under the Lifetime Income Disclosure Rule—which is currently scheduled to become effective on September 18, 2021—a plan administrator must provide each defined contribution plan participant with an annual estimate of their retirement savings illustrated as both: (a) a single life income stream, and (b) a separate income stream that factors in a survivor benefit (a Qualified Joint & Survivor Annuity or QJSA). This disclosure requirement applies regardless of whether the defined contribution plan actually offers an annuity form of payment. Further, the QJSA illustration is required regardless of whether the participant is married on the statement date.

    The rule contemplates that lifetime income illustrations will be disclosed to participants as part of their periodic benefit statement, and will include an explanation of the assumptions used to generate the illustration. The Lifetime Income Disclosure Rule includes model disclosure language and lists several key assumptions:

    • That periodic payment amounts shown are solely for purposes of illustration and are not guaranteed.
    • That the annuity commencement date is the last day of the benefit statement period. For example, if the benefit statement covers the period ending on December 31, 2025, the assumed annuity commencement date is December 31, 2025.
    • That the participant is 100% vested in their account (regardless of the participant’s current vested percentage).
    • That a participant’s account balance includes the outstanding balance of any loan (assuming that the loan will be repaid).
    • That interest rates fluctuate based on market conditions and may affect a participant’s monthly benefit amount.
    • That the participant is at least age 67 on the commencement date, regardless of the participant’s actual age. If a participant is older than age 67, the plan administrator must use the participant’s actual age as of the last day of the statement period.
    • For purposes of the QJSA illustration, that a participant is married to a spouse that is the same age as them (regardless of the actual age of any spouse).
    • For the QJSA illustration, that the survivor annuity percentage is equal to 100% of the monthly payment that is payable during the joint lives of the participant and spouse.

    The Lifetime Income Disclosure Rule also includes special assumptions and model disclosure language for plans that offer an in-plan annuity option. For example, if the plan offers an in-plan annuity option, the plan administrator may base the required lifetime income disclosures on the actual assumptions used by the in-plan annuity contract (within certain limitations), as opposed to the assumptions set forth by the DOL.

    To address the fiduciary risk inherent in providing a lifetime income illustration, the Lifetime Income Disclosure Rule includes provisions for relief from fiduciary liability under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA) so long as plan administrators draft all lifetime retirement savings illustrations using the model disclosure language contained in the Lifetime Income Disclosure Rule or language that is “substantially similar in all material respects” to the DOL’s model language.

    The comment period for the Lifetime Income Disclosure Rule ended on November 17, 2020. McDermott’s ERISA practice will closely monitor the Lifetime Income Disclosure Rule and provide additional guidance as it becomes available. The DOL has stated that it intends to issue a final rule in advance of the proposed September 18, 2021, effective date.

    Authors
    More insights

  • President Releases Executive Order Implementing “Buy American” Campaign

    President Releases Executive Order Implementing “Buy American” Campaign

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    President Releases Executive Order Implementing “Buy American” Campaign

    February 5, 2021

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On January 25, 2021, US President Joe Biden signed an Executive Order, “Ensuring the Future Is Made in All of America by All of America’s Workers,” that implements the “Buy American” campaign to tighten existing “Made in America Laws” by setting clear directives with a centralized coordinated effort.

    In depth

    “Made in America Laws” Overview

    Key directives from the Executive Order that every government contractor should be aware of include the following:

    • Creation of a Made in America Office within the White House Office of Management and Budget (OMB) helmed by a Made in America Director to oversee the implementation of “Made in America Laws,” which include all statutes, regulations, rules and Executive Orders relating to federal financial assistance or awards or federal procurement, including those that refer to “Buy America” or “Buy American,” that require or provide a preference for goods, products or materials produced in the United States.
    • Increased scrutiny and centralized review of the Made in America waiver process by requiring an agency to provide the Made in America Director with a description and detailed justification of its proposed waiver. The Made in America Director, within 45 days of the date of appointment, will publish a list of the required information agencies must include when submitting a proposed waiver. Additionally, the granting agency must assess whether a significant portion of the cost advantage of a foreign-sourced product is the result of the use of dumped steel, iron or manufactured goods or the use of injuriously subsidized steel, iron or manufactured goods before granting a waiver in the public interest. The General Services Administration will publicly post waivers and associated information on a website.
    • Promoting enforcement of the Buy American Act (BAA) of 1933 by directing the Federal Acquisition Regulatory Council (FAR Council) to consider amendments to applicable provisions in Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR), title 48, Code of Federal Regulations, within 180 days of this Order (e., before of by July 25, 2021), including:
      • Replacing the “component test” in Part 25 of the FAR with a test under which domestic content is measured by the value added to the product through US-based production or US job-supporting economic activity
      • Increase the numerical threshold for domestic content requirements for end products and construction materials
      • Increase the price preferences for domestic end products and domestic construction material
    • Review and development of recommendations by the FAR Council for lifting existing constraints on the extension of the Made in America Laws to information technology to promote the policies under this Order.
    • Reporting requirements by the head of each agency within 180 days of this Order (and biannually thereafter) describing implementation and compliance with Made in America Laws and recommendations on how to further effectuate the policies under this Order. The biannual reports also require reporting concerning the agency’s analysis of goods, products, materials and services that are exempt or waived from Made in America Laws and the agency’s analysis of spending as a result of waivers issued pursuant to the Trade Agreements Act of 1979, as amended, 19 USC 2511.
    • Updates to the list of nonavailable articles by directing the Director of the OMB, through the Administrator of the Office of Federal Procurement Policy (OFPP) with the Secretary of Commerce and Made in America Director to review any proposed amendments by the FAR Council to determine whether there is a reasonable basis to conclude that the article is not reasonably available.
    • Supplier scouting to identify American companies that are able to produce goods, products and materials in the United States that meet federal procurement needs by requiring agencies to partner with the Hollings Manufacturing Extension Partnership (MEP), discussed in the Manufacturing Extension Partnership Improvement Act.
    • Administrator of General Services must submit to Made in America Director recommendations for ensuring implementation of administration policy on federal government property within 180 days of this Order.
    • Revocation of certain prior Executive Orders, including:
      • Executive Order 13788 of April 18, 2017 (Buy American and Hire American)
      • Executive Order 13858 of January 31, 2019, section 5 (Strengthening Buy-American Preferences for Infrastructure Projects)
      • Executive Order 13975 of January 14, 2021 (Encouraging Buy American Policies for the United States Postal Service)
      • Executive Order 10582 of December 17, 1954 (Prescribing Uniform Procedures for Certain Determinations Under the Buy-America Act) and Executive Order 13881 of July 15, 2019 (Maximizing Use of American-Made Goods, Products, and Materials) are superseded to the extent they are inconsistent with this Order.

    Conclusion

    The Made in America Executive Order will have significant impacts to the vast majority of companies that contract with or supply or sell to the US government. As such, federal contractors and subcontractors should continue to closely monitor the implementation of the regulations under this Order.

    Authors

    Mandy H. Kim

    Partner

    Orange County, Los Angeles

    Peter M. Routh

    Associate

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • US-China Agreement Supports International Injunction Against Alleged Chinese Counterfeiter Under State Law

    US-China Agreement Supports International Injunction Against Alleged Chinese Counterfeiter Under State Law

    ARTICLE

    US-China Agreement Supports International Injunction Against Alleged Chinese Counterfeiter Under State Law

    Feb 4, 2021

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Addressing for the first time whether state law has extraterritorial scope, the US Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit upheld a worldwide preliminary injunction against an alleged Chinese counterfeiter’s use of alleged trade secrets, citing a new US-China trade agreement. AtriCure, Inc. v. Meng, Case No. 20-3264 (6th Cir. Jan. 21, 2021) (McKeague, J.)

    AtriCure is an Ohio company that sells surgical tools for the treatment of atrial fibrillation. AtriCure needed a Chinese agent to register and sell its product in China. Dr. Meng became AtriCure’s distributor in China from 2005 to 2017. After Meng signed multiple distribution agreements with AtriCure, including non-compete clauses and confidentiality agreements, he was given access to confidential technical documents describing AtriCure’s products. Unbeknownst to AtriCure, Meng was the president of AtriCure’s Chinese competitor, Med-Zenith. When Med-Zenith released a line of products that were strikingly similar to AtriCure’s in both form and operation, AtriCure sued for trade secret misappropriation under the Ohio Uniform Trade Secrets Act and sought a worldwide preliminary injunction to prevent Meng from continuing to manufacture and sell counterfeit versions of AtriCure’s medical devices. After the district court granted the preliminary injunction, Meng appealed.

    Addressing Meng’s arguments on likelihood of success, the Sixth Circuit found that:

    • The district court defined the alleged trade secrets with sufficient specificity because AtriCure had given Meng detailed drawings and manufacturing specifications.
    • The district court had not clearly erred in relying on evidence that AtriCure provided the trade secret information to Meng or that Meng used the information where Med-Zenith had copied its entire product line from AtriCure.
    • The district court had not clearly erred in holding that the production of an adapter that did not copy but still took advantage of AtriCure’s proprietary algorithm (i.e., by allowing Med-Zenith accessories to be used with AtriCure’s system) was likely a misappropriation of trade secrets.

    Addressing the extraterritorial aspect of a worldwide injunction, the Sixth Circuit held that the district court did not abuse its discretion in issuing a worldwide injunction because the international reach of the injunction comports with the equities of the case and does not offend international comity. As to the equities, the Court noted that worldwide injunctions are common in trade secret misappropriation cases. As to comity, the Court found that Meng had failed to articulate any conflict and cited a recently signed agreement between the United States and China that “emphasizes trade secret protection” (Economic and Trade Agreement Between the Government of the United States of America and the Government of the People’s Republic of China, Jan. 15, 2020).

    Finally, the Court addressed whether the Ohio Uniform Trade Secrets Act itself was entitled to extraterritorial scope. Because Ohio courts had not yet addressed the question, the Court conducted its own statutory interpretation and found that the intent of the statute (“the lodestar of statutory interpretation in Ohio”) favored extraterritorial application “at least in this case.”

    Authors

    Paul Devinsky

    Senior Counsel

    Washington, DC

    More insights
    Endnotes

  • FTC and DOJ Issue Surprise Announcement: Temporary Suspension to Early Terminations to HSR Act Merger Filings

    FTC and DOJ Issue Surprise Announcement: Temporary Suspension to Early Terminations to HSR Act Merger Filings

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    FTC and DOJ Issue Surprise Announcement: Temporary Suspension to Early Terminations to HSR Act Merger Filings

    February 4, 2021

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Federal Trade Commission announced today that the FTC and the Antitrust Division of the Department of Justice (“DOJ”) will not grant early termination (“ET”) to filings under the Hart-Scott-Rodino Antitrust Improvements Act of 1976, as amended (“HSR Act”), until further notice, citing “the transition to the new Administration.”[1] In the announcement, the FTC said that it anticipates “this temporary suspension will be brief.”

    The HSR Act requires that certain transactions be reported to the PNO and DOJ and a 15 or 30 day waiting period be observed prior to consummation if, as a result, the acquiring person will hold voting securities, assets and/or non-corporate interests of an acquired person valued above $94 million ($92 million from March 4, 2021 onward).

    This action marks a sharp departure from past practice, as the only other times that there have been blanket suspensions on ET were during government funding shutdowns and a brief suspension in March 2020 during the move to electronic HSR filing and staff telework in response to the COVID pandemic. A change in administration has never prompted such a suspension.

    The two Republican FTC Commissioners criticized the move: “we see no rationale sufficient to justify suspending all grants of ET. In 45 years of administering the HSR Act, the Agencies have done so only when a crisis made them unable to discharge their duties. . . . We are concerned that freezing grants of ET will delay the consummation of competitively innocuous transactions. Particularly during a time of economic difficulty, impeding the transfer of assets could have knock-on effects that harm employees, small businesses, and financially imperiled firms.”[2] These Commissioners also noted that “the suspension announcement today comes more than two weeks after the most recent early termination was granted . . . In the future, we hope major changes to agency practice that affect external stakeholders will be announced simultaneously with the action taken, if not before.”

    As a result of today’s FTC announcement, any parties with a pending HSR filing should expect to observe the full 30-day HSR waiting period (15 days for cash tender offers and bankruptcies) before being able to consummate their notified transactions, and parties currently negotiating deals or contemplating acquisitions should assume that any HSR notification will require observing the full waiting period.

    Authored by Peter Jonathan Halasz and Gregory L. Kinzelman.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/press-releases/2021/02/ftc-doj-temporarily-suspend-discretionary-practice-early

    [2] https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/public_statements/1587047/phillipswilsonetstatement.pdf


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2021 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

     

     

    In depth
    Authors

    Peter Jonathan Halasz

    Of Counsel

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • BOEM Takes Specific Actions to Boost Offshore Wind Efforts Under Biden Administration Executive Orders

    BOEM Takes Specific Actions to Boost Offshore Wind Efforts Under Biden Administration Executive Orders

    ARTICLE / US POLICY

    BOEM Takes Specific Actions to Boost Offshore Wind Efforts Under Biden Administration Executive Orders

    February 3, 2021

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

     

     

    In depth
    Authors

    Carl J. Fleming

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Heather Cooper

    Partner

    Miami

    Elle Hayes

    Partner

    Miami

    More insights

  • Second Circuit: No Appellate Jurisdiction to Review Post-Verdict Appeal of Previously Denied Summary Judgment Motion

    Second Circuit: No Appellate Jurisdiction to Review Post-Verdict Appeal of Previously Denied Summary Judgment Motion

    ARTICLE

    Second Circuit: No Appellate Jurisdiction to Review Post-Verdict Appeal of Previously Denied Summary Judgment Motion

    February 3, 2021

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

     

     

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Make Explicit Contractual Agreements

    Make Explicit Contractual Agreements

    ARTICLE

    Make Explicit Contractual Agreements

    February 3, 2021

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The drafting and failure of contractual negotiations in M&A transactions with particular reference to the Covid 19 pandemic. An article by Prof. Dr. Clemens Just, Isabelle Suzanne Müller and Lisa Schickling.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights