Content Type: Article

  • Why 2030 is the New 2050 after the Leaders Climate Summit and What President Biden’s Accelerated Transition to a Sustainable Economy Means for Renewables Developers, Investors and Corporates

    Why 2030 is the New 2050 after the Leaders Climate Summit and What President Biden’s Accelerated Transition to a Sustainable Economy Means for Renewables Developers, Investors and Corporates

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Why 2030 is the New 2050 after the Leaders Climate Summit and What President Biden’s Accelerated Transition to a Sustainable Economy Means for Renewables Developers, Investors and Corporates

    April 27, 2021

    Read time: 14 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    2030 is the new 2050 as US President Joe Biden has officially set a new goal for fighting climate change over the next decade in the United States. At the Leaders Climate Summit (the Summit) on Earth Day, he announced that America would aim to cut its greenhouse gas emissions at least 50% below its 2005 levels by 2030. If successful, this transition would lead to a very different America and would affect virtually every corner of the nation’s economy, including the way Americans get to work, the sources from which we heat and cool our homes, the manner in which we operate our factories, the business models driving our corporations and the economic factors driving our banking and investment industries. The effectiveness of this transition lies in the administration’s ability to pull on two historically powerful levers: Tax policy and infrastructure funding. However, tax policy will call upon multiple sublevers, such as increased tax rates, expanded tax credits, refundability, carbon capture, offshore wind, storage, transmission and infrastructure investment. All of this will be bolstered by the American corporate sector’s insatiable appetite for environmental, sustainability and governance (ESG) goal investment.

    In depth

    QUICK TAKEAWAYS

    There were six key announcements at the Summit for renewables developers, investors and corporates to take note:

    1. The United States’ commitment to reduce its greenhouse gas emissions by 50% – 52% below its 2005 emissions levels by 2030
    2. The United States’ economy to reach net-zero emissions by no later than 2050
    3. The United States to double the annual climate-related financing it provides to developing countries by 2024
    4. The United States to spend $15 billion to install 500,000 electric vehicle charging stations along roads, parking lots and apartment buildings
    5. A national goal to cut the price of solar and battery cell prices in half
    6. A national goal to reduce the cost of hydrogen energy by 80%

    President Biden’s goals are ambitious. It is clear from the history of renewable incentives in the United States as well as current developments that moving forward, the green agenda will predominately rely on two primary levers being pulled at the federal level: Tax policy and infrastructure funding. The federal tax levers mentioned above will not be pulled in a vacuum. Instead, they will be pulled in the midst of a tectonic shift among individual investors that now demand that institutional investors and corporations begin to create and meet ESG goals as individual customers are beginning to take a corporation’s climate goals and footprint into account when making purchasing decisions.

    As a result, we discuss the following areas in greater detail below:

    1. Tax policy
      1. increased tax rates
      2. expanded tax credits
      3. refundability
      4. carbon capture
      5. offshore wind
      6. storage
      7. transmission
    2. Infrastructure bill
    3. ESG environment

    DEEPER DIVE: BREAKING DOWN EACH LEVER AS WELL AS ITS OPPORTUNITIES AND CHALLENGES

    1. Tax Policy: The consistent message from the Biden Administration, at the Summit and elsewhere, makes clear that tax policy will likely play a significant role in the administration’s ambitious climate agenda. At this time, the administration is mostly speaking in terms of high-level policy proposals. Meanwhile, members of Congress have introduced specific bills with renewable energy tax policies—giving the public an idea of where we will see legislative priorities. Energy tax policy could lead climate action for a couple of key reasons. First, the use of tax incentives has been an effective tool over the past four decades to move the renewable energy industry forward and could continue to offer important incentives today. Second, and equally as important, because of the congressional reconciliation process, the administration’s proposed tax incentives and expenditures will have a decent chance of enactment even with a 50-50 divided Senate.
      1. Increased Tax Rates: Under the previous administration, we witnessed a substantial cut in the corporate tax rate. President Biden and the Democrats in Congress have already made it known that they intend to raise corporate tax rates and have proposed an increase in the capital gains tax rate for high earners. The potential increased tax liability may spur some renewable tax equity investors to increase their stake in projects, which should propel more projects to profitability and completion. Increased tax rates would make other tax incentives from renewable projects–like depreciation deductions–more valuable to investors, further helping to generate interest in the tax equity market. More significantly, these proposed tax rate increases would provide a substantial tax base for funding many of the other tax and infrastructure goals on the administration’s list. Although many of the administration’s other tax policy priorities are speculative at this time, most observers are fairly confident that we’ll see some increase in tax rates to underwrite the Biden Administration’s policy initiatives, including some climate change initiatives.
      2. Expanded Tax Credits: Since 1992, and for a short period prior to that, the US government has supported the expansion of renewable energy through a variety of tax credits. The current system includes both the production tax credit (PTC) and investment tax credit (ITC) and availability is dependent on the underlying technology. The PTC and ITC are both currently being phased out. The push for renewable energy priorities in 2021 will likely build off of, and expand on, the current tax credit system. We began to see what these tax credits might look like when US Senator Ron Wyden (D-OR) introduced the Clean Energy for America Act (the Act) on April 21, 2021. The Act would replace the current ITC and PTC regimes with technology-neutral tax investment and production credits for facilities with zero net or net negative carbon emissions. For the first time, stand-alone energy storage and qualifying transmission projects would be eligible for the tax credit. The Act would also provide further incentives and certainty for carbon capture technology, offshore wind and other renewable energy technologies. Instead of phasing out at a fixed date, like the current tax credits, the proposed credits would sunset once certain emission targets are achieved. The Act also includes prevailing wage requirements and increased tax credits for low income areas.Other congressional proposals have tinkered at the edges of the current ITC and PTC regime, extending the phaseouts by 10 years.An extension and expansion of renewable energy tax credits would bring many new players–both investors and developers–into the market and drive development of the renewable energy infrastructure needed to achieve President Biden’s climate goals. Whether expanded tax credits get passed in 2021, and in what form, remains to be seen but given the success of these programs in the past and the administration’s ambitious goals for climate change, there’s a good chance we will see expanded and extended renewable energy tax credits within the next year.
      3. Refundability: While these tax credit expansions are critically important, the renewable energy industry is facing a new and unique problem in 2021: It is a victim of its own success. The massive expansion of renewable energy development and the insatiable demand for clean energy from US utilities, corporations and consumers has led to a situation where, in 2021, there is likely more demand for tax equity investments from renewable developers than there is capacity for investors to utilize these tax credits. Under the current tax credit regime, tax credits can only be used to offset actual tax liability, but most renewable energy project developers are operating in a tax loss position and are unable to use the credits. Without new entrants into the renewable tax credit market, there is a limit to how effective tax credits could be. Moreover, some market participants, like utilities and electric cooperatives, may not be able to use the credits directly. Thus, there is a growing demand from renewable developers and a growing openness by congressional leaders that, in addition to tax credit extensions, the United States will need to provide direct pay tax credits to developers so as not to dampen the momentum of renewable energy in this country. A refundability mechanism also has the benefit of being simpler, which can bring more players into the market and reduce transactional costs for all parties. One consideration for taxpayers pushing for a refundability mechanism relates to timing: If the refund is taken on the tax return, will many developers be effectively foreclosed from benefitting because they need the cash on delivery (COD), and thus still beholden to tax equity? There has been much discussion since November about the possibility of incorporating a refund mechanism for renewable energy credits, with a handful of bills introduced in Congress. The proposals vary as to whether the refund would be a percentage of the tax credit otherwise available (e.g., 85%), versus for the full amount. Neither party in Congress has historically seemed very open to refundability, but there seems to be a new willingness to at least consider the possibility. Whether refundability is ultimately adopted in climate change tax policy is very much up in the air.
      4. Carbon Capture: Congress significantly expanded the tax credit available for carbon capture technologies in 2018. In response to the credit expanse, there has been a flurry of new activity in this space in recent years from both large and small players. Carbon capture credits may appeal to both investors and developers; the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) has effectively signed off on using tax equity structures for these projects, but many of the major carbon emitters are traditional fuel producers who have more than enough tax liability to take the credit directly.While there has not been any specific legislative actions or proposals for carbon capture this year, many experts believe that an ambitious climate change agenda will need to rely heavily on this technology. At the Summit, President Biden specifically mentioned a future that involves carbon capture technology. Expansion of the existing credits seems far more likely than the adoption of a new carbon tax on carbon emitters–an idea which has historically faced significant opposition in Congress and has no known support from President Biden.
      5. Offshore Wind: In December, Congress created a new standalone tax credit for offshore wind. These projects are notoriously expensive to build, and their economic viability will clearly turn on whether they are supported by a robust tax credit regime. Given the long lead time associated with offshore projects, it’s too early to see whether the new credit is enough to spur activity in this industry or whether offshore wind will get expanded support from Congress.
      6. Storage: Taxpayers have been clamoring for a standalone tax credit for renewable energy storage for years. Under the current tax credit system, storage associated with a renewable energy generation facility likely qualifies for credits, though the IRS has been promising guidance for some time to remove uncertainties surrounding the credits for these technologies. Because of these uncertainties, there may have been reluctance from investors and developers to commit to storage projects. As mentioned above, some early congressional proposals include credits for standalone storage, so this is something else that may be included in climate change tax policy.
      7. Transmission: Perhaps one of the biggest barriers when converting energy production to renewables is the lack of transmission capacity. There are several proposals to expand the ITC to transmission infrastructure, which would support the growth of renewable projects. President Biden has also been a vocal supporter of upgrading the nation’s grid. With all that said, there are some uncertainties as to whether tax credits are an economically efficient tool for achieving the administration’s goals for expanding the transmission network.
    2.  Infrastructure Bill: At the Summit, Biden touted his $2.3 trillion infrastructure plan, which aims to make electric vehicles more affordable, incentivize building electric vehicle charging stations, retrofit buildings, replace lead pipes and modernize the nation’s electrical grid. The limitations of the aforementioned reconciliation process and statements made by key moderate senators make it difficult to predict the eventual scope and impact of the infrastructure bill. However, all parties seem to recognize that an infrastructure bill is necessary, as evidenced by the bill submitted by the Republican Party on April 22. There is certainly a wide difference between the Biden-proposed infrastructure bill and the Republican-proposed infrastructure bill, including in the treatment of renewable energy. However, we have now seen the two end posts of what this bill might look like. We anticipate a great deal of negotiation moving forward on this bill and to eventually see some form of infrastructure bill to help the United States in its COVID-19 recovery. The renewable energy industry hopes that the final infrastructure bill will include provisions to help further transmission modernization and encourage climate resilience.

    PRIVATE SECTOR ESG APPETITE

    It is clear that the federal government is no longer standing alone in the fight against climate change and that prudent investors and corporations now have a role to play or risk becoming irrelevant. During the previous administration, we witnessed four years of record renewable energy growth and expect many more years of continued growth in the future because of the broad-based support for climate change mitigation approaches. More than ever before, state and local governments are craving clean energy to fuel their needs. We see that corporate offtakers and utilities are recognizing the economic benefits of renewable energy purchases and purchasing record amounts of clean electricity.

    Additionally and critically, individual investors are demanding that institutional investors and corporations begin to create and meet ESG goals as individual customers are beginning to take a corporation’s climate goals and footprint into account when making purchasing decisions. According to the Forum for Sustainable and Responsible Investment, there were over 830 registered investment companies with ESG assets, including 718 mutual funds and 94 exchange-traded funds (EFTs), in 2020. ESG assets managed by registered investment companies were over $3 trillion in 2020, up from $2.61 trillion in 2018.

    With the growth in the demand for ESG goals, corporations that need to evolve to adapt to the new climate-focused world we are entering. Corporations that create clear ESG missions and begin to look at the ways that they can help reduce their carbon footprint and mitigate climate change are likely to be the economic winners moving forward.

    GLOBAL SUPPORT FOR THE CLIMATE FIGHT AT THE LEADERS CLIMATE SUMMIT

    President Biden hosted over 40 world leaders at the Summit, including notable participants such as Brazil, China and Russia. It was a visible example of the actions of a concerned administration, as well as a global community, and was neither the beginning nor the end of what is being done to fight climate change. Instead, the Summit is likely a key step among many as the United States aims to promote global cooperation in the fight against climate change and to step back into a position of leadership on this issue.

    For instance, President Biden opened the first session by stating climate action was a moral imperative and pledging that the United States would not be waiting any longer. He stated that this was the decade in which action needed to be taken if the United States was to reach its net-zero goals by 2050. As such, he committed the United States to reducing its greenhouse gas emissions by 50% – 52% below its 2005 emissions levels by 2030 (which is nearly double the 2015 goal set by the Obama Administration). What followed throughout the Summit was world leaders providing strong climate commitments for their respective nations, as well as an appearance by Pope Francis who encouraged world leaders to unify in the fight against climate change.

    CONCLUSION

    Due to the constantly shifting US political winds, it is understandable that there might be some trepidation from those outside of the renewable energy industry as to the long-lasting commitment of the US government. However, the US Special Presidential Envoy for Climate Change John Kerry addressed such skeptics during the Summit by citing the economic forces that have been larger than domestic politics and projecting that the market demand for renewable energy would be too strong to be overcome moving forward. Kerry pledged that Biden would take active steps to confront climate change and rebuild American credibility abroad. The Summit, when accompanied by the plethora of other legislative, regulatory and executive announcements that we have seen within the first 100 days of the Biden Administration shows that climate will take center stage throughout this administration. The global demand for better environmental stewardship shows that the fight to combat climate change will continue to be a global priority long after the Biden Administration ends.

    Authors

    Carl J. Fleming

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Edward Zaelke

    Partner

    Los Angeles

    Heather Cooper

    Partner

    Miami

    Philip Tingle

    Partner

    Miami

    Elle Hayes

    Partner

    Miami

    Seth B. Doughty

    Partner

    Los Angeles

    More insights

  • Waiver in USPTO Trademark Appeals Applies “per Decision, Not per Case”

    ARTICLE

    Waiver in USPTO Trademark Appeals Applies “per Decision, Not per Case”

    April 27, 2021

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Convertible Loans and Private Equity: The Growth Opportunities in Germany

    Convertible Loans and Private Equity: The Growth Opportunities in Germany

    ARTICLE

    Convertible Loans and Private Equity: The Growth Opportunities in Germany

    April 26, 2021

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Dr. Nikolaus von Jacobs and Matthias Weingut with an article on “Convertible Loans and Private Equity: The Growth Opportunities in Germany”.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Managing the Home Office

    ARTICLE

    Managing the Home Office

    April 23, 2021

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The federal government has introduced a new Infection Protection Act that places even greater obligations on companies to contain the COVID 19 pandemic. In this article, Dr. Thomas Gennert explains what employers and employees need to know.

    In depth
    Authors

    Dr. Thomas Gennert

    Partner

    Düsseldorf

    More insights

  • FinCEN Commences Rulemaking Process for Implementation of Corporate Transparency Act Requiring Disclosure of Beneficial Ownership Information

    FinCEN Commences Rulemaking Process for Implementation of Corporate Transparency Act Requiring Disclosure of Beneficial Ownership Information

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    FinCEN Commences Rulemaking Process for Implementation of Corporate Transparency Act Requiring Disclosure of Beneficial Ownership Information

    April 26, 2021

    Read time: 22 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On April 5, 2021, the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, a bureau of the United States Department of the Treasury (“FinCEN” and “Treasury,” respectively) issued an advance notice of proposed rulemaking (“ANPRM”)[1] beginning the process of implementing regulations under the Corporate Transparency Act (“CTA”).[2] Enacted by Congress on Dec. 31, 2020, as part of the National Defense Authorization Act, the CTA requires certain companies created or registered to do business in the United States (each, a “Reporting Company”) to report certain identifying information, such as beneficial owners of 25% or more and certain control persons, directly to FinCEN.[3] That information is to be held in a non-public database maintained by FinCEN and will be shared with law enforcement and federal regulators, among others. The reporting obligations discussed herein will only take effect upon the promulgation of final regulations by FinCEN, which FinCEN is required to issue by Jan. 1, 2022. The ANPRM is the first step in this rulemaking process and requests public comment on numerous questions relevant to the implementation of the CTA. Comments are due May 5, 2021. Additionally, within a year of issuing a final rule under the CTA, FinCEN is required to issue implementing regulations to revise the existing customer due diligence (“CDD”) rule[4] to align it with the CTA implementing regulations.[5]

    This Alert highlights certain aspects of the CTA and the ANPRM including implications of the CTA on investment funds and their advisers.

    Information to Be Reported

    The CTA requires each Reporting Company to disclose information regarding (1) its beneficial owners and control persons, (2) individuals who register the Reporting Company or file the application necessary for the Reporting Company to do business in the United States (“Applicant”) and (3) other identifying information of the Reporting Company itself.

    1. Beneficial Owners and Control Persons

    The CTA defines a “beneficial owner” as an individual who, directly or indirectly, through any contract, arrangement, understanding, relationship, or otherwise (i) owns or controls not less than 25% of the ownership interests of the Reporting Company or (ii) exercises substantial control over the Reporting Company (each a “Beneficial Owner”). Reporting Companies must report information on both types of Beneficial Owners. In this way, the definition of Beneficial Owner is similar to the definition used in the CDD rule, which requires reporting under both the ownership prong and the control person prong.[6] Beneficial Owner does not include an individual acting as: (i) a nominee, intermediary, custodian or agent on behalf of another individual; (ii) an employee of a corporation, limited liability company, or other similar entity and whose control over or economic benefits from such entity is derived solely from the employment status of the person; (iii) an entity’s creditors, unless the creditor holds at least 25% of the entity or has substantial control over the entity; (iv) an individual whose only interest is through a “right of inheritance”; or (v) a minor child if the information of a parent or guardian is reported.[7]

    The CTA requires each Reporting Company to identity each of its Beneficial Owners by (i) full legal name, (ii) date of birth, (iii) current residential or business street address and (iv) a unique identifying number from an acceptable identification document.[8] The identification requirements in the CTA itself differ slightly from what is required of legal entity customers under the CDD rule and it seems likely that the CDD rule will eventually be changed to be consistent with the reporting requirements for each Beneficial Owner under the CTA.[9]

    The ANPRM asks for public comment on whether the definition of Beneficial Owner is “sufficiently clear, or are there aspects of this definition and specified exceptions that FinCEN should clarify by regulation?”[10] Question 3 of the ANPRM asks specifically whether FinCEN should “define either or both of the terms ‘own’ and ‘control’ with respect to the ownership interests of an entity” and, if so, should the definition “be drawn from or based on an existing definition in another area, such as securities law or tax law?”[11]

    With regard to the control prong of the term Beneficial Owner, the CTA does not define “substantial control,” or describe if it is to be limited to voting control or operational control, or the extent to which it differs from the concept of control in the CDD rule, which defines the control prong as: “A single individual with significant responsibility to control, manage, or direct a legal entity customer.”[12] The ANPRM requests comment on the extent to which the definition of substantial control in the CTA implementing regulations should “be the same as, or similar to, the current CDD rule’s definition or the standards used to determine who is a beneficial owner under 17 CFR 240.13d–3 adopted under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934?”[13] More specifically, the ANPRM asks for public comment on whether FinCEN should define “substantial control” to mean “[1] that no reporting company can have more than one beneficial owner who is considered to be in substantial control of the company, or [2] … to make it possible that a reporting company may have more than one beneficial owner with ‘substantial control’”.[14]

    FinCEN also asks for comments to help determine what steps Reporting Companies should take to confirm the accuracy of Beneficial Owner information, as well as what FinCEN should do to ensure that reported Beneficial Owner information is accurate and complete.[15]

    2. Applicants

    Reporting Companies are required to disclose the same identifying information for Applicants as for Beneficial Owners (i.e. name, date of birth, address and unique identification number).[16] The ANPRM asks whether the definition of Applicant is sufficiently clear “in light of current law and current filing and registration practices” or if FinCEN should expand the definition.[17] FinCEN also asks for comment on whether a Reporting Company should be required to report information on Applicants after the Reporting Company’s initial report to FinCEN.[18]

    3. Information About the Reporting Company

    While not specifically mentioned in the CTA, FinCEN has requested comment on what information a Reporting Company should be required to report about itself, including its corporate affiliates, parents, and subsidiaries, as well as its relationship to its Beneficial Owners.[19] These questions suggest that the information FinCEN may be seeking from Reporting Companies may be broader than information relating only to the Reporting Company’s Beneficial Owners and Applicants.

    The CTA also provides for Reporting Companies to obtain an identifier to expedite filings. FinCEN must issue an identifier to an entity or individual upon such entity’s or individual’s request, evidencing that beneficial ownership information has been previously reported to FinCEN (“FinCEN Identifier”).[20] Reporting Companies with a FinCEN Identifier may provide it to FinCEN instead of beneficial ownership information. The ANPRM asks for comment on several questions regarding the process of issuing FinCEN Identifiers and the form they will take.[21]

    Reporting Companies

    Subject to numerous exceptions which are designed to exclude many regulated entities and operating business, as discussed below, the CTA broadly defines a Reporting Company as any:

    Corporation, limited liability company or other similar entity that is (i) created by the filing of a document with a secretary of state or a similar office under the law of a State or Indian Tribe or (ii) formed under the law of a foreign country and registered to do business in the United States by the filing of a document with a secretary of state or a similar office under the laws of a State or Indian Tribe.[22]

    The CTA does not define the term “other similar entity.” The ANPRM includes several questions regarding what factors should be considered and what entities should be included or excluded in the category “other similar entity.”[23] More specifically, FinCEN asks if trusts and special purpose vehicles (“SPVs”) that are “formed by a filing with a secretary of state or a similar office” should be included or excluded from other similar entities.[24] The CTA requires an official study to identify each state’s procedures regarding the collection of beneficial ownership information for partnerships, trusts, and other legal entities to determine what should be included as an “other similar entity.” Considering the similarities between partnerships formed by the filing of a document with a secretary of state and limited liability companies, it may be that such partnerships will be included as an “other similar entity.”

    Moreover, it is currently unclear whether statutory trusts or non-statutory trusts will be subject to reporting requirements under the CTA.[25] But we note that the CTA exempts charitable trusts and split-interest trusts from the reporting requirements.[26]

    Entities Exempt from Definition of Reporting Company

    The CTA provides 23 exemptions from the definition of Reporting Company, many of which are designed to exclude entities already required to disclose beneficial ownership information publicly or to federal regulators. These include, among others[27]:

    1. An investment company[28] that is registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) under the Investment Company Act of 1940[29] (“40 Act”).[30]
    2. An investment adviser[31] that is registered with the SEC under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940[32] (“Advisers Act”).[33]
    3. An investment adviser: ‘‘(i) described in section 203(l) of the Advisers Act, and (ii) that has filed Item 10, Schedule A, and Schedule B of Part 1A of Form ADV, or any successor thereto, with the SEC (“an Adviser Relying on the Venture Capital Exemption”).[34]
    4. Banks,[35]
    5. Federal or state credit unions.[36]
    6. Broker-dealers.[37]
    7. Futures commission merchants, introducing brokers, swap dealers, major swap participants, commodity pool operators, and commodity trading advisers that are registered with the Commodities Futures Trading Commission.
    8. An insurance company as defined in section 2 of the 40 Act.
    9. Any “pooled investment vehicle” that is operated or advised by a (i) bank, (ii) Federal or State credit union, (iii) SEC-registered broker or dealer, (iv) SEC registered investment adviser, or (v) an Adviser Relying on the Venture Capital Exemption.[38]

      The CTA defines a “pooled investment vehicle” to mean (i) any investment company, as defined in section 3(a) of the 40 Act;[39] or (ii) any company that (a) would be an investment company under that section but for the exclusion provided from that definition by paragraph (1) or (7) of section 3(c) of the 40 Act,[40] and (b) is identified by its legal name by the applicable investment adviser in its Form ADV (or successor form) filed with the SEC.

    10. Any entity that (i) employs more than 20 employees on a full-time basis in the United States; (ii) filed in the previous year Federal income tax returns in the United States demonstrating more than $5,000,000 in gross receipts or sales in the aggregate, including the receipts or sales of (a) other entities owned by the entity and (b) other entities through which the entity operates; and (iii) has an operating presence at a physical office within the United States.

    The CTA also includes a provision allowing Treasury, in certain circumstances, to exempt other types of entities from the reporting requirements – this provision may be useful in obtaining exemptions for other types of entities. The CTA also provides for a truncated filing for Beneficial Owners of Reporting Companies that are, themselves, exempt from the definition of Reporting Company. If an entity that is exempt from the definition of Reporting Company is a Beneficial Owner of a Reporting Company, the Reporting Company is only required to report the name of the exempt entity Beneficial Owner and need not report any other information with regard to that exempt entity.[41]

    The ANPRM includes several questions to further formulate the exemptions, asks whether there are any categories of entities that are not currently subject to an exemption but should be, and also seeks comment on how exempt entities should be required to prove they fit into one of the exempt categories.[42] Specifically:

    a. What information should FinCEN require companies to provide to qualify for these exemptions, and what verification process should that information undergo?

    b. Should there be different information requirements for operating companies and holding companies, for active companies and dormant companies, or are there other bases for distinguishing between types of companies?

    c. Should exempt entities be required to file periodic reports to support the continued application of the relevant exemption (e.g., annually)?[43]

    Exemptions to the Definition of Reporting Company Relevant to Investment Funds and Investment Advisers

    The exemptions to the definition of Reporting Company include most private investment funds and their advisers, relieving most funds and advisers from reporting their beneficial ownership information to FinCEN. More specifically, the CTA exempts from the definition of Reporting Company: a mutual fund; an SEC registered investment adviser; an Adviser Relying on the Venture Capital Exemption; and, a pooled investment vehicle that is formed under the laws of the United States that is operated or advised by a bank, credit union, broker-dealer, SEC registered investment adviser, or an Adviser Relying on the Venture Capital Exemption. Each of these entities is not required to submit a report to FinCEN with beneficial ownership information.

    Advisers that are not registered with the SEC, such as state-registered investment advisers and advisers relying on the “private fund adviser exemption” available to advisers that solely advise private funds if the adviser has assets under management in the United States of less than $150 million, are not currently exempt from the definition of Reporting Company. Such advisers may be required to report beneficial ownership information to FinCEN unless an exemption applies. For example, an investment adviser that is not otherwise exempt may be able to rely on the exemption available for an entity that employs more than 20 employees on a full-time basis in the United States, has more than $5 million in gross receipts or sales in the aggregate, and maintains a physical office presence within the United States.

    Similarly, funds advised by advisers that are neither registered with the SEC nor Advisers Relying on the Venture Capital Exemption may not be exempt from the definition of Reporting Company. For example, a fund advised by an adviser relying on the “private fund adviser exemption” available to advisers that solely advise private funds if the adviser has assets under management in the United States of less than $150 million, may be required to submit a report to FinCEN with beneficial ownership information. Moreover, pooled investment vehicles managed by commodity trading advisers are not currently exempt from the reporting requirements.

    The CTA provides a modified reporting requirement for certain non-United States domiciled pooled investment vehicles. The CTA requires that “[a]ny corporation, limited liability company, or other similar entity that is an exempt entity described in subsection (a)(11)(B)(xviii) and is formed under the laws of a foreign country shall file with FinCEN a written certification that provides identification information of an individual that exercises substantial control over the pooled investment vehicle.” As discussed above, the CTA has not yet defined “substantial control.” The “exempt entity described in subsection (a)(11)(B)(xviii)” refers to a pooled investment vehicle that is exempt from the definition of Reporting Company because it is operated or advised by a bank, Federal or State credit union, SEC-registered broker or dealer, or SEC registered investment adviser, or an Adviser Relying on the Venture Capital Exemption.

    To clarify the modified reporting process, the ANPRM asks for comment on the method by which the written certification should be filed, what information should be included, whether filings should be made to foreign authorities first and then forwarded to FinCEN, or be made directly to FinCEN, and whether the certifications should be accessible to all database users or a subset of them, and whether they should be accessible on the same terms as beneficial ownership information of all other Reporting Companies.[44] Because private investment fund managers often employ numerous funds and SPVs, both foreign and domestic, it is important for them to understand the CTA’s requirements and FinCEN’s implementing regulations, once promulgated, and incorporate any applicable reporting obligations into their compliance functions.

    Sharing and Security of Registry Information

    Once reported, beneficial ownership information will be kept in a confidential FinCEN database and held for at least five years after the relevant Reporting Company ceases to exist.[45] Although the beneficial ownership registry will not be publicly available, upon request, FinCEN will be authorized to share information in certain circumstances, subject to compliance with protocol, treaty, agreement, convention or official request, as applicable, with (i) financial institutions (in connection with CDD requirements under applicable law with the consent of the Reporting Company); (ii) federal law enforcement, intelligence and national security agencies; (iii) state, local and Tribal law enforcement authorities; (iv) foreign law enforcement authorities; and (v) federal functional and other regulators.[46]

    As part of the ANPRM, FinCEN requests comment on the details of the registry. Notably, it asks: “How can FinCEN make beneficial ownership information available to financial institutions with CDD obligations so as to make that information most useful to those financial institutions?”[47]

    The CTA provides for certain cybersecurity protections for the database, including encryption.[48] FinCEN is required to identify and fix any vulnerabilities in the case of a cybersecurity breach that results in substantial unauthorized access to beneficial owner information.[49] The ANPRM requests comment on any additional security and privacy measures to protect the information and limit its use to authorized purposes.[50] FinCEN also asks whether misuse of database information should be subject to penalties under the Bank Secrecy Act and existing FinCEN regulations or if other protections should be implemented.[51]

    Report Timing

    The timing requirements to file the report with FinCEN differ based on whether the Reporting Company is formed before or after the effective date of the CTA’s implementing regulations.

    • Any Reporting Company that was formed or registered before the effective date of the CTA’s implementing regulations shall, in a timely manner, and not later than two years after the effective date of the CTA’s implementing regulations, submit the required beneficial ownership information to FinCEN.
    • Any Reporting Company that is formed after the effective date of the CTA’s implementing regulations must disclose beneficial ownership information to FinCEN at the time of formation or registration.

    Regardless of formation date, all Reporting Companies must, in a timely manner, and not later than one year after the date on which there is a change to any required beneficial ownership information, submit to FinCEN a report that updates the information relating to the change.

    With regard to Reporting Companies and individuals with FinCEN Identifiers, the ANPRM includes questions about how to satisfy the timely manner requirement including what should occur when Beneficial Owners or holders of FinCEN Identifiers (i) transfer substantial control to other individuals, (ii) change their legal names or their reported residential or business street addresses, (iii) die or (iv) when a previously acceptable identification document expires.[52]

    For Reporting Companies without FinCEN Identifiers, FinCEN asks “what should be considered a ‘timely manner’ for updating a change in beneficial ownership” and whether the period should differ based on the type of Reporting Company, what factors should be taken into account in determining the period, and how long Reporting Companies should have to update Beneficial Owner information upon a change of ownership.[53]

    Penalties

    The CTA proscribes penalties for failing to report or reporting inaccurate or incomplete information. Any person who (i) willfully provides, or attempts to provide, false or fraudulent beneficial ownership information, including a false or fraudulent identifying photograph or document; or (ii) willfully fails to report, complete or update beneficial ownership information (a) shall be liable to the United States for a civil penalty of not more than $500 for each day that the violation continues or has not been remedied and (b) may be fined not more than $10,000, imprisoned for not more than two years, or both.[54]

    However, there is a safe harbor if a report that contains inaccurate information is voluntarily corrected within 90 days so long as the inaccurate report was not submitted to evade the reporting requirements or with actual knowledge of its inaccuracy.[55] FinCEN requests comment on how to implement the safe harbor, asking: “How should FinCEN’s regulations define the scope of this safe harbor? Should the nature of the inaccuracy (e.g., a misspelled address versus the complete omission of a Beneficial Owner) be relevant to the availability of the safe harbor?”[56]

    Conclusion

    The CTA is an important step toward revealing beneficial ownership information often used to hide money laundering and terrorist financing. While the ANPRM sheds additional light on FinCEN’s understanding of the CTA, there are still many substantive and technical details to work through before the implementing regulations are issued.

    Authored by Betty Santangelo, Joseph P. Vitale, Melissa G.R. Goldstein and Kyle B. Hendrix.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] ANPRM, Beneficial Ownership Information Reporting Requirements, 86 Fed. Reg. 17,557 (Apr. 5, 2021), available here (hereinafter, “ANPRM”).

    [2] National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2021 (CTA §§ 6401–03), available at here.

    [3] For more information regarding the CTA and AML Act generally, please see our prior Alert “Passage of Anti-Money Laundering Act of 2020 Includes Comprehensive BSA/AML Reform Measures.”

    [4] See 31 CFR § 1010.230. The CDD rule requires covered financial institutions to collect identifying information from, and verify the identities of, the beneficial owners of their legal entity customers.

    [5] CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(d)).

    [6] CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(b)(2)).

    [7] CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(a)(3)(B)).

    [8] The CTA defines an “acceptable identification document” to mean, with respect to an individual, “(A) a nonexpired passport issued by the United States; (B) a nonexpired identification document issued by a State, local government, or Indian Tribe to the individual acting for the purpose of identification of that individual; (C) a nonexpired driver’s license issued by a State; or (D) if the individual does not have [such] document[s] … a nonexpired passport issued by a foreign government.” CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(a)(1)).

    [9] See CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(d)). The CDD rule requires that covered financial institutions obtain from their legal entity customers (i) name and title of natural person opening account; (ii) name and address of legal entity for which the account is being opened; and (iii) identification information for each beneficial owner (under ownership and control prongs). 31 CFR Appendix A to § 1010.230. Such beneficial ownership information includes: (i) name; (ii) date of birth; (iii) address; and (iv) for United States persons, social security number, or for non-United States persons, passport number and country of issuance or other similar identification number. Id. Documentary verification may be done by unexpired government-issued identification, such as a driver’s license or passport. Final Rule, Customer Due Diligence Requirements for Financial Institutions, 81 Fed. Reg. 29398, 29408 n.46 (May 11, 2016).

    [10] ANPRM, 86 Fed. Reg. at 17,561-62, Question 3.

    [11] Id.

    [12] The CDD rule defines beneficial owner as:

    (1) Each individual, if any, who, directly or indirectly, through any contract, arrangement, understanding, relationship or otherwise, owns 25% or more of the equity interests of a legal entity customer; and

    (2) A single individual with significant responsibility to control, manage or direct a legal entity customer, including:

    (i) An executive officer or senior manager (e.g., a Chief Executive Officer, Chief Financial Officer, Chief Operating Officer, Managing Member, General Partner, President, Vice President or Treasurer); or

    (ii) Any other individual who regularly performs similar functions.

    31 CFR § 1010.230(d).

    [13] ANPRM, 86 Fed. Reg. at 17,561-62, Question 3. Subject to numerous exemptions, under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 implementing regulations, a person who “is directly or indirectly the beneficial owner of more than five percent” of specified classes of equity securities must file a statement containing certain identifying information. 17 CFR § 240.13d–3(a).

    [14] Id.

    [15] ANPRM, 86 Fed. Reg. at 17,563, Questions 23 and 24. There is no obligation to confirm the accuracy of beneficial ownership information under the CDD rule. Rather, the individual acting on behalf of the relevant entity must certify that to the best of their knowledge, the information provided is complete and accurate. 31 CFR Appendix A to § 1010.230.

    [16] Under the CTA, the term “applicant” means any individual who (i) files an application to form a corporation, limited liability company or other similar entity under the laws of a State or Indian Tribe; or (ii) registers or files an application to register a corporation, limited liability company or other similar entity formed under the laws of a foreign country to do business in the United States by filing a document with the secretary of state or similar office under the laws of a State or Indian Tribe. See CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(a)(3)).

    [17] ANPRM, 86 Fed. Reg. at 17,562-63, Question 4.

    [18] ANPRM, 86 Fed. Reg. at 17,562-63, Question 25.

    [19] ANPRM, 86 Fed. Reg. at 17,562, Questions 10-13.

    [20] See CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(b)(3)).

    [21] ANPRM, 86 Fed. Reg. at 17,563-64, Questions 26-31.

    [22] CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(a)(11)(A)).

    [23] ANPRM, 86 Fed. Reg. at 17,561 Question 1. See also id., Question 2 (Requesting comment on whether the requirement that entities be created by or registered to do business by the filing of a document with a secretary of state or a similar office under the law of a State or Indian Tribe describes corporate filing practices and applicable law of the states and Indian tribes sufficiently to avoid confusion about whether an entity meets the requirement).

    [24] ANPRM, 86 Fed. Reg. at 17,562, Question 8.

    [25] Under the CDD rule, statutory trusts, but not non-statutory trusts are considered legal entities with beneficial owner identification requirements.

    [26] CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(a)(11)(B)(xix)).

    [27] For a full list of exemptions see CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(a)(11)(B)).

    [28] As defined in section 3 of the Investment Company Act of 1940 (15 USC § 80a-3).

    [29] 15 USC § 80a-1, et seq.

    [30] CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(a)(11)(A)(x)).

    [31] As defined in section 202 of the Advisers Act (15 USC § 80b-2).

    [32] 15 USC § 80b-1, et seq.

    [33] CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(a)(11)(A)(x)).

    [34] CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(a)(11)(A)(xi)).

    [35] As defined in (i) section 3 of the Federal Deposit Insurance Act (12 USC § 1813); (ii) section 2(a) of the 40 Act (15 USC § 80a-2(a)); and (iii) section 202(a) of the Advisers Act (15 USC § 80b-2(a)).

    [36] As defined in section 101 of the Federal Credit Union Act (12 USC § 1752).

    [37] That is registered under section 15 of the Securities Exchange Act (“Exchange Act”). 15 USC § 78o (and as defined in 15 USC § 78c).

    [38] CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(a)(11)(A)(xviii)).

    [39] 15 USC § 80a-3(a).

    [40] Id.

    [41] CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(b)(2)(B)).

    [42] ANPRM, 86 Fed. Reg. at 17,562, Question 7.

    [43] ANPRM, 86 Fed. Reg. at 17,562, Question 9.

    [44] ANPRM, 86 Fed. Reg. at 17,562, Question 15.

    [45] See CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(c)(1)).

    [46] CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(c)(2)(B)).

    [47] ANPRM, 86 Fed. Reg. at 17,564, Question 35. See also id. Questions 32-38.

    [48] See CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(c)(8)).

    [49] See CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(h)(5)(A)).

    [50] ANPRM, 86 Fed. Reg. at 17,563, Question 34.

    [51] Id.

    [52] ANPRM, 86 Fed. Reg. at 17,563, Question 19.

    [53] ANPRM, 86 Fed. Reg. at 17,563, Question 21.

    [54] CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(h)).

    [55] See CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(h)(4)(3)(C)(i)).

    [56] ANPRM, 86 Fed. Reg. at 17,563, Question 22.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2021 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Betty Santangelo

    Counsel

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Melissa G.R. Goldstein

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Kyle B. Hendrix

    Associate

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • Senate Democrats Propose Overhaul of Clean Energy Incentives

    Senate Democrats Propose Overhaul of Clean Energy Incentives

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Senate Democrats Propose Overhaul of Clean Energy Incentives

    April 23, 2021

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    US Senate Finance Committee Chairman Ron Wyden (D-OR) introduced the Clean Energy for America Act (the Act), along with two dozen Democratic co-sponsors, on April 21, 2021. The Act will likely be a starting point for the Biden administration tax proposals intended to limit carbon emissions. The Act would change the current system for incentives for the renewable energy industry to a technology-neutral approach for generation that is carbon free or has net negative carbon emissions. The Act would also provide tax incentives for qualifying improvements in transmission assets and stand-alone energy storage with the aim of improving reliability of the transmission grid. Instead of requiring that taxpayers who qualify for the clean energy incentives have current or prior tax liabilities, the Act would create a new direct pay option allowing for refunds of the tax credits.

    In depth

    The Act would replace the current renewable energy incentives with a new clean electricity production and investment credit, which would allow taxpayers to choose between a 30% investment tax credit (ITC) or a production tax credit (PTC) equal to 2.5 cents per kilowatt hour. The credit would apply to new construction of and certain improvements to existing facilities with zero or net negative carbon emissions placed in service after December 31, 2022. The Act would phase out the current system of credits for specific technologies. To provide time for transition relief and for coordination between the US Department of the Treasury (Treasury) and Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), the Act extends current expiring clean energy provisions through December 31, 2022.

    The Secretary of Treasury, in consultation with the Administrator of the EPA shall establish greenhouse gas emissions rates for types or categories of facilities which qualify for the credits. To incentivize additional emissions reductions from existing fossil fuel power plants and industrial sources, the Section 45Q tax credit would be extended until the power and industrial sectors meet emissions goals. The Act would modify the qualifying capture thresholds to require that a minimum percentage of emissions are captured. Once certain emissions targets are met—namely, a reduction in emissions for the electric power sector to 75% below 2021 levels—the incentives will phase out over five years.

    Qualifying transmission grid improvements are also eligible for the 30% ITC including standalone energy storage property. Storage technologies are not required to be co-located with power plants and include any technologies that can receive, store and provide electricity or energy for conversion to electricity. Transmission property includes transmission lines of 275 kilovolts (kv) or higher, plus any necessary ancillary equipment. Regulated utilities have the option to opt-out of tax normalization requirements for purposes of the grid improvement credit. However, the Act does not include a similar option to opt-out of the tax normalization provisions for other types of qualifying facilities, such as solar or wind projects.

    Under the Act, investments qualifying for the clean emission investment credit, grid credit or energy storage property in qualifying low-income areas qualify for higher credit rates. The Act also includes new provisions requiring taxpayers to pay wages at not less than prevailing local rates and utilize registered apprenticeship programs in order to qualify for the credits.

    In addition, the Act would provide for incentives for energy efficient homes and commercial buildings and for clean transportation technologies. Further, the Act proposes repeal of certain incentives for fossil fuels, including immediate expensing for intangible drilling costs, percentage depletion, deductions for tertiary injectants and credits for enhanced oil recovery, coal gasification and advanced coal projects.

    Authors

    Philip Tingle

    Partner

    Miami

    Heather Cooper

    Partner

    Miami

    Carl J. Fleming

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Elle Hayes

    Partner

    Miami

    Brian Moore

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • Data Protection: Works Agreements as Legal Basis for Processing Employee Data that is not Required

    Data Protection: Works Agreements as Legal Basis for Processing Employee Data that is not Required

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Data Protection: Works Agreements as Legal Basis for Processing Employee Data that is not Required

    April 23, 2021

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The BaWü Higher Labor Court (LAG) recently ruled on the pronounced options available to the parties to the agreement in the area of data protection law. Dr. Philip Uecker present the most important points of the decision in this context.

    In depth
    Authors

    Dr. Philip Uecker

    Associate

    Düsseldorf

    More insights

  • Inventions not made under employment agreement

    Inventions not made under employment agreement

    ARTICLE

    Inventions not made under employment agreement

    April 22, 2021

    Read time: 3 min

    Applying a “middle ground” standard of review, the US Court of Appeals for the First Circuit affirmed a district court’s decision denying a company’s request for a declaratory judgment asking a former employee to assign patent rights to the company under the employment and separation agreements, because there were inconsistencies in the jury verdict. Covidien LP; Covidien Holding Inc. v. Brady Esch, Case No. 20-1515 (1st Cir. Apr. 8, 2021) (Gelpi, CDJ.)

    During his employment with Covidien, Esch signed employment and separation agreements, which required a duty of confidentiality, an obligation to disclose any invention created during his employment with Covidien or within one year after leaving Covidien, and assignment of such inventions to Covidien. After his termination, Esch founded his own company (Venclose) and filed patent applications that were assigned to Venclose. Covidien sued Esch for breach of confidentiality and breach of obligation to disclose inventions.

    At trial, the jury found that Esch breached his duty of confidentiality by publication of the patent applications, but did not breach his obligation to disclose inventions to Covidien under the agreements (question 3 on verdict form). The verdict form also included questions 6-8 concerning whether inventions were made under the agreements, but the jury was not required to answer these questions if the answer to question 3 was negative. After trial, Covidien moved for a declaratory judgment requesting that Esch assign patent rights to Covidien pursuant to the assignment provision of the agreements. The district court denied the motion, finding that the jury verdict questions were “internally inconsistent” and that “the jury’s ‘decisive’ negative answer to Question 3 could only be read as a factual finding that no ‘Inventions’ were made that are encompassed under the Employment Agreement.” Covidien appealed.

    The First Circuit agreed with the district court, applying a “middle ground” standard, which is more rigorous than abuse of discretion but less open-ended than de novo review. This standard of review “requires attentively digest[ing] the facts and the district court’s stated reasons.” The Court found that the district court sufficiently addressed the agreements under applicable Massachusetts law and specifically explained the definition of “inventions” and the assignment requirement to the jury. The Court found that Covidien’s request that the jury should answer questions 6-8 regardless of the answer to question 3 was neither “substantively correct” nor “essential to an important issue,” and was an instruction “substantially covered in the charge.” Further, the Court found that the “internally inconsistent” jury verdict, namely that Esch met his disclosure obligation by violating his confidentiality duty via publication of the patent applications, could only be read as a factual finding that there were no inventions encompassed by the agreement. Accordingly, the First Circuit concluded that the district court did not abuse its discretion in denying Covidien’s post-trial declaratory judgment request.

    More insights

  • Pardon My French: France Wins ‘France.com’ Trademark Dispute Using Sovereign Immunity

    Pardon My French: France Wins ‘France.com’ Trademark Dispute Using Sovereign Immunity

    ARTICLE

    Pardon My French: France Wins ‘France.com’ Trademark Dispute Using Sovereign Immunity

    April 20, 2021

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors

    Joshua Revilla

    Associate

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • A Renewed Focus on Telehealth in New Jersey

    A Renewed Focus on Telehealth in New Jersey

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    A Renewed Focus on Telehealth in New Jersey

    April 19, 2021

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    New Jersey governing boards for dentistry, counseling, respiratory care and occupational therapy have introduced regulations to address licensure requirements for telehealth encounters, consistent with previous regulations adopted by governing boards of other health professionals in New Jersey. The New Jersey legislature is also considering a bill to expand reimbursement for covered services provided via telehealth and allow for new flexibilities, including on type of encounter, location and distance requirements and reimbursement parity. Comments for the four regulations from the governing bodies are due by May 14, 2021.

    In depth

    In 2017, New Jersey enacted sweeping new telehealth legislation when it passed P.L. 2017, c. 117, codified at N.J.S.A. § 45:1-61 et seq. The law established telemedicine and telehealth practice standards for several types of healthcare professionals and imposed insurance coverage requirements.

    Since then, governing boards have proposed and adopted telehealth regulations to effectuate the law. Specifically, the boards, examiners or advisory councils of social workers, veterinarians, psychologists, art therapists, physicians, nurses, audiologists, orthotic and prosthetic professionals, physical therapists and psychoanalysts have adopted telehealth-specific regulations. On March 15, 2021, the State Board of Dentistry; State Board of Marriage and Family Therapy Examiners, Alcohol and Drug Counselor Committee; State Board of Respiratory Care; and Occupational Therapy Advisory Council followed suit, proposing regulations establishing telemedicine and telehealth standards for their respective professionals. Comments for each of these four regulations are due by May 14, 2021.

    In their proposed form, the regulations are strikingly similar to each other and to nearly all of the other telehealth regulations adopted by New Jersey administrative bodies. In accordance with P.L. 2017, c. 117, the proposed regulations would prohibit out-of-state practitioners from providing care via telehealth to patients physically located in New Jersey without a New Jersey license. However, an out-of-state provider could use communications technology to consult with a New Jersey licensee, so long as the out-of-state provider was not directing patient care.

    Also in line with P.L. 2017, c. 117, the regulations would require New Jersey licensees who provide services through telehealth to provide those services in accordance with the standard of care for such services when provided in-person. Providers typically must use interactive, real-time, two-way communication technologies with a video component. Audio-only telehealth is only permissible if the provider, after reviewing a patient’s records, determines she can meet the standard of care without video. In this situation, the licensee must use interactive, real-time, two-way audio in combination with technology that supports the transmission of images, diagnostics, data and medical information.

    Pending Legislation

    In addition to these regulatory proposals, the New Jersey legislature is currently considering an amendment (S 2559) to the 2017 law that would expand reimbursement for covered services provided via telehealth and allow for new flexibilities.

    On March 22, 2021, the New Jersey Senate Budget and Appropriations Committee passed this legislation out of committee. In its current form, the bill, like the proposed regulations, requires telehealth providers to meet the same standard of care as if they were providing in-person services. Similarly, it allows for audio-only telehealth so long as a provider meets that standard of care.

    The bill would also expand reimbursement for telehealth services by requiring insurance providers and Medicaid to ensure payment parity between services provided via telehealth and services provided in-person. Current law provides that telehealth rates are negotiable up to the in-person rate, meaning the reimbursement rates for telehealth services are often lower than the rates a provider would have received had he performed the services in-person.

    Finally, the bill prohibits payors from imposing any restrictions on the location of the distant site the provider uses to provide telehealth services or on the location of the originating site where the patient is located when receiving telehealth services.

    ***

    From requiring payment parity to permitting audio-only telehealth, New Jersey’s proposed changes are emblematic of nationwide conversations around the future of telehealth. McDermott will continue to monitor such changes on our Telemedicine Resource Center.

    Please do not hesitate to contact your regular McDermott lawyer or the authors of this On the Subject if you would like assistance drafting comments to New Jersey’s proposed regulations or if you have any other questions about your telehealth arrangements.

    Authors

    Amanda Enyeart

    Partner

    Chicago

    Marshall E. Jackson , Jr.

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Lisa Mazur

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights