Content Type: Article

  • Departments Issue Final Rule Implementing Certain No Surprises Act Provisions

    Departments Issue Final Rule Implementing Certain No Surprises Act Provisions

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Departments Issue Final Rule Implementing Certain No Surprises Act Provisions

    August 25, 2022

    Read time: 16 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On August 19, 2022, the US Departments of Health and Human Services (HHS), Labor and Treasury posted a final rule revising portions of the federal No Surprises Act (NSA). Generally, the rule finalizes three aspects of the two-part interim final rule that the Departments published along with the Office of Personnel Management in 2021. First, the final rule expands the information about the qualifying payment amount (QPA) that plans and issuers (collectively, payers) must disclose to providers and facilities (collectively, providers). Second, it reinterprets the provisions of the NSA that govern the determination of the appropriate out-of-network rate through the federal independent dispute resolution (IDR) process, and prescribes how certified IDR entities are to weigh the QPA and other considerations when selecting one of the parties’ offers. The certified IDR entity must now consider the QPA first, and then give weight to other considerations only if those other considerations are not accounted for in the QPA. Third, the final rule expands the information that a certified IDR entity must provide in its written payment determination to include a statement explaining why the QPA did not already account for other considerations weighed by the IDR entity.

    In depth

    The Departments also released three pieces of related guidance:

    The guidance address a wide range of NSA implementation issues, including how payers are to determine the provider specialties for which QPAs are required, and the model disclosure notice and required notice and consent documentation applicable to providers.

    The changes will be effective within 60 days of publication in the Federal Register.

    The final rule is extremely narrow in focus, responding to comments and making revisions on just a few issues. Scores of issues raised by commenters have not yet been addressed in formal rulemaking. The Departments note that they still intend to address the public comments on other aspects of the interim final rule at a later date. Moreover, there are whole aspects of the statute that have not yet been implemented by regulation, including processes for auditing payer QPAs or governing good faith estimates for insured individuals.

    Background

    The Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021, signed into law on December 27, 2020, included the NSA, among other provisions. In July and October 2021, the Departments issued a two-part interim final rule implementing core aspects of the NSA (Requirements Related to Surprise Billing; Part I, 86 Fed. Reg. 36872 (July 13, 2021) (IFR Part I); Requirements Related to Surprise Billing; Part II, 86 Fed. Reg. 55980 (Oct. 7, 2021) (IFR Part II)). We previously described IFR Part I, and IFR Part II.

    Pursuant to the NSA and IFR Part I, if a participant, beneficiary or enrollee (collectively, an enrollee) with benefits under a group health plan or group or individual health insurance coverage receives emergency services at an emergency department of a hospital or an independent freestanding emergency department, a nonparticipating provider or a nonparticipating emergency facility may not balance bill the enrollee for any amount in excess of the enrollee’s in-network cost-sharing amount. Similarly, if an enrollee receives nonemergency services provided by a nonparticipating provider in connection with a visit at a participating facility, a nonparticipating provider may not balance bill the enrollee in excess of the enrollee’s in-network cost-sharing amount, unless the nonparticipating provider provides the enrollee with notice and obtains consent to waive the balance billing protections in advance of the service (as long as the service provided is not an “ancillary” service for which consent to balance bill may never be obtained).

    The NSA and IFR Part I also specify enrollees’ cost-sharing amounts for emergency services furnished by nonparticipating providers or facilities, as well as for nonemergency services furnished by nonparticipating providers at certain participating facilities. Specifically, an enrollee’s cost-sharing amount for such services must be calculated based on the “recognized amount,” which is defined as follows:

    • An amount determined by an applicable All-Payer Model Agreement under Section 1115A of the Social Security Act
    • If there is no applicable All-Payer Model Agreement, an amount determined by a specified state law
    • If there is no such applicable All-Payer Model Agreement or specified state law, the lesser of the billed charge or the QPA.

    The NSA and IFR Part I establish the methodology for calculating the QPA, which in most circumstances is the payer’s median contracted rate for that item or service.

    The NSA also directs the Departments to specify the information that a payer must share with a nonparticipating provider, nonparticipating emergency facility or nonparticipating provider of air ambulance services after determining the QPA. The NSA and IFR Part I require payers to make certain disclosures about the QPA with each initial payment or notice of denial of payment, and to provide certain additional information to providers upon request when the QPA serves as the “recognized amount.”

    In addition to implementing other components of the NSA, as discussed in greater detail here, IFR Part II expanded on the federal IDR process that payers and providers are to use to determine the out-of-network rate for items and services to which the NSA applies, where an All-Payer Model Agreement or specified state law does not apply. IFR Part II provided that each party submit to the certified IDR entity an offer for a payment amount for the item or service in dispute and other information related to the offer as may be requested by the certified IDR entity. To determine which payment offer to select, the certified IDR entity should “begin with the presumption that the QPA is the appropriate out-of-network rate” (86 Fed. Reg. at 55984) for the qualified IDR item or service under consideration, and then select the offer “closest to the QPA” unless the certified IDR entity determined that credible information submitted by either party clearly demonstrated that the QPA was “materially different from the appropriate out-of-network rate,” according to the implementing regulations.

    Within months of the Departments issuing the regulations, various stakeholders sued in federal district court, alleging, among other things, that the regulatory instructions to certified IDR entities were inconsistent with the statute. Two federal courts vacated the regulatory text favoring the QPA in the determination of the out-of-network rate on the ground that it was contrary to the text of the NSA. Tex. Med. Ass’n v. U.S. Dep’t of Health and Human Services, No. 6:21-cv-425-JDK, 2022 WL 542879, at *8-9 (E.D. Tex. Feb. 23, 2022); LifeNet, Inc. v. U.S. Dep’t of Health and Human Services, No. 6:22-cv-162-JDK, 2022 WL 2959715, at *8-9 (E.D. Tex. July 26, 2022). Two of the three changes that the Departments included in the final rule are intended to respond to the litigation.

    Summary of Final Rule

    As noted, the final rule finalizes three discrete aspects of IFR Parts I and II. First, it expands the information about the QPA that payers must disclose to providers. Second, it reinterprets the provisions of the NSA that govern the determination of the appropriate out-of-network rate through the federal IDR process, and prescribes how certified IDR entities are to weigh the QPA and other considerations when selecting one of the parties’ offers. Third, it requires that the certified IDR entity’s written payment determination explain why the QPA did not already account for other considerations weighed by the IDR entity.

    QPA Disclosure Requirements

    The NSA and IFR Part I require that with an initial payment or notice of denial of payment, a payer must provide the QPA for each item or service involved, as well as a statement certifying that the QPA applies for purpose of the recognized amount. The Departments stated in the preamble to the final rule that many commenters on IFR Part I stressed that the methodology of calculating the QPA should be more transparent, and that the Departments should expand the range of information that is shared with providers with respect to the QPA.

    Along the same lines, commenters expressed concern that some payers might review claims and alter the service code or modifier submitted by the provider to another service code or modifier that the payer determines to be more appropriate (a practice referred to as “downcoding” when the adjustment results in a lower reimbursement). Commenters stated that providers need to be apprised when a payer downcodes a particular claim that is subject to the balance billing prohibitions in the NSA to ensure they receive sufficient information that may be relevant to the open negotiation and federal IDR processes.

    In response to these comments, the Departments expanded the information that payers must furnish with an initial payment or notice of denial of payment in instances where the payer has downcoded the billed claim. The Department also defined the word “downcode” in regulatory text to mean “the alteration by a plan or issuer of a service code to another service code, or the alteration, addition, or removal by a plan or issuer of a modifier, if the changed code or modified is associated with a lower QPA than the service code or modified billed by the provider, facility, or provider of air ambulance services.” If a QPA is based on a downcoded service code or modifier, a payer must now provide a statement that the service code or modifier billed by the provider was downcoded; an explanation of why the claim was downcoded (including a description of which service codes were altered, if any, and which modifiers were altered, added or removed, if any); and the amount that would have been the QPA had the service code or modifier not been downcoded.

    The Departments are still considering whether additional disclosures related to the QPA calculation methodology should be required to be provided with an initial payment or notice of denial of payment, or upon request. They stressed that their view is that payment determinations in the federal IDR process should center on a “determination of a total payment amount for a particular item or service based on the facts and circumstances of the dispute at issue, rather than an examination of a plan or issuer’s QPA methodology.”

    Determination of Out-of-Network Payment in the Federal IDR Process

    The final rule replaces the regulatory text that favored the QPA in IFR Part II with new regulatory text that directs IDR entities on how to weigh the QPA and information about other circumstances when selecting one of the parties’ offers as the appropriate out-of-network rate. The certified IDR entity is now to “select the offer that the certified IDR entity determines best represents the value of the qualified IDR item or service as the out-of-network rate.” To make that selection, the certified IDR entity must consider the QPA and “then consider” other information submitted by a party that relates to circumstances set forth in the statute. See 42 CFR §§ 149.510(c)(4)(iii)(A)-(D) (providers and facilities), 149.520(b)(1) (applying 42 CFR § 149.510 to air ambulance) (emphasis added). In this way, the Departments suggested a sequential review by the IDR entity: first the QPA, then other considerations. In weighing those considerations, “the certified IDR entity should evaluate whether the information is credible and relates to the offer submitted by either party,” 42 CFR §§ 149.510(c)(4)(iii)(E) (providers and facilities), 149.520(b)(3) (air ambulance). The Departments directed that “[t]he certified IDR entity should not give weight to information to the extent that is not credible, it does not relate to either party’s offer for the payment amount . . . , or it is already accounted for by the [QPA] . . . or other credible information,” 42 CFR §§ 149.510(c)(4)(iii)(E), 149.520(b)(3) (emphasis added).

    The Departments stated in the preamble to the final rule that “in all cases, the QPA, which is generally based on the median contracted rate for a qualified IDR item or service, will be relevant to a payment determination, as it represents the typical payment amount.” Final rule at 34. The Departments “are of the view that it will often be the case that the QPA represents an appropriate out-of-network rate,” although “additional factors may be relevant in determining the appropriate out-of-network rate, because the QPA may not account for information specific to a particular item or service.” Id. at 37. “The certified IDR entity should consider whether the additional information is already accounted for in the QPA and should not give weight to information related to a factor if the certified IDR entity determines the information was already accounted for in the calculation of the QPA, to avoid reweighing the same information twice.” Id. at 40. “For example, because the plan or issuer is required to calculate the QPA using median contracted rates for services codes, as well as modifiers (if applicable), and because service codes and modifiers in many cases reflect patient acuity and the complexity of the services provided, these factors will often already be reflected in the QPA.” Id.

    According to the Departments, “[t]he QPA is generally calculated to include characteristics that affect costs, including medical specialty, geographic region, and patient acuity and case severity . . . . Therefore, in the Departments’ view, giving additional weight to information that is already incorporated into the calculation of the QPA would be redundant, possibly resulting in the selection of an offer that does not represent the value of the qualified IDR item or service.” Id. at 41.

    Certified IDR Entity’s Written Decision

    IFR Part II required the certified IDR entity to explain its payment determination and underlying rationale in a written decision submitted to the parties and the Departments. The certified IDR entity was also required to explain what credible information demonstrated that the QPA was materially different from the appropriate out-of-network rate.

    The final rule changes those requirements. It requires a certified IDR entity to include in its written determination an explanation of the following:

    • What information the certified IDR entity determined demonstrated that the offer selected as the out-of-network rate is the offer that represents the value of the qualified IDR item or service
    • The weight given to the QPA and any other credible information submitted in accordance with the final rule.

    If the certified IDR entity relies on other information or circumstances in selecting an offer, its written decision must include an explanation of why the certified IDR entity concluded that this information was not already accounted for in the QPA.

    Payer Determination of the Provider Specialties for Which QPAs Are Required

    In addition to the final rule, the Department issued new summaries and guidance documents. The accompanying Frequently Asked Questions document conveys new policy (or new articulations of the Departments’ thinking on existing policy), some of which is notable. In the FAQ set, the Departments answer “yes” to question 14 regarding whether payers must “calculate a median contracted rate separately for each provider specialty, if the [payer’s] contracted rates for service codes vary based on provider specialty (as a result of the [payer’s] contracting process)[.]”

    The Departments begin FAQ 14 by explaining that they have been informed that some payers establish contracted rates “by offering most providers the same fee schedule for all covered services,” and then leaving it “up to the providers to negotiate increases to the rates for the services that they are most likely to bill. After the negotiation process, the entire fee schedule may be included in the provider contract, with the contracted rate modifications made only to certain service codes based on the negotiations.” This results in the payer using rates that are not negotiated, and perhaps never even billed, to determine the QPA for a provider specialty.

    Many providers refer to this phenomenon as “ghost rate contracting,” and it has significant operational and economic consequences for many physician specialties. The Departments take steps to address the ghost rate contracting problem by stating that “[f]or the purpose of identifying provider specialties for which QPAs must be separately calculated, a [payer’s] contracted rates for an item or service are considered to vary based on provider specialty if there is a material difference in the median contracted rates for a service code between providers of different specialties, after accounting for variables other than provider specialty.” For example, “if a [payer’s] contracted rates for a given anesthesia service are clustered at one rate for anesthesiologists and at another rate for all other provider specialties because those providers do not provide and bill for anesthesia services, the [payer] must calculate one median contracted rate for the anesthesia service code for anesthesiologists, and one separate median contracted rate for the same anesthesia service code for all other provider specialties.”

    The Departments’ effort to address the ghost rate contracting problem now, through guidance, suggests they have elevated the issue above many other important ones presented by the NSA. The Departments commit in FAQ 14 to “monitor [payer’s] compliance with the July 2021 interim final rules, as interpreted in [FAQ 14],” and to continue to “monitor contracting practices that affect the calculation of the QPA, to determine whether additional guidance is needed.” This supplemental guidance may benefit providers in payment resolution, whether through the normal course or through the IDR process, or even in up-front contract negotiation, but it is unclear how providers can confirm payer adherence to the guidance.

    Model Disclosure Notice and Notice and Consent Documentation Requirements

    The NSA allows nonparticipating providers and facilities to seek consent from an individual to waive the balance billing and cost-sharing protections in certain situations. HHS previously issued standard notice and consent documents that must be used to satisfy this exception, although states may also develop state-specific documents for this purpose. The NSA also requires certain providers, facilities and payers to provide disclosures to patients advising of their protections against balance billing. Such disclosures must be made publicly available on the entity’s website (if applicable) and provided to participants in the form of a one-page notice. HHS previously issued a model disclosure notice that may (but is not required to) be used to satisfy the balance billing disclosure requirement.

    As noted, along with the final rule, the Departments issued FAQs announcing that HHS has revised both the required standard notice and consent form and the model disclosure form. For the remainder of 2022, providers and facilities may use either the initial or revised versions of the forms. On and after January 1, 2023, providers and facilities may only use the revised forms. The revisions include minor changes to the instructions and form templates.

    Conclusion

    The final rule primarily addresses issues related to the IDR process that were pressing because of the court orders vacating regulatory text from IFR Part II. The final rule is not the end of the rulemaking process or the implementation of the NSA. The final rule and new sources of guidance note that the Departments will publish additional rules and guidance in the future, on topics that include the auditing of payers for compliance with requirements related to the QPA; what constitutes “ancillary services” for purposes of the balance billing notice and consent exception; and the good faith estimate requirement pertaining to co-providers and co-facilities, set forth in IFR Part II and set to become effective on January 1, 2023. The Departments did not indicate when they will publish additional rules and guidance, and stakeholders therefore should continue to closely monitor regulatory action by the Departments.

    For more information, contact Brian Stimson, Jamie Gelfman, Drew McCormick, Emily Cook, Kristen O’Brien, Eric Zimmerman, Jason Caron, Emily Curran, or Judith Wethall.

    Authors

    Jamie B. Gelfman

    Partner

    Miami

    Emily R. Curran

    Associate

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • CDC Updates Its COVID-19 Guidelines: What Does It Mean for Your Business?

    CDC Updates Its COVID-19 Guidelines: What Does It Mean for Your Business?

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    CDC Updates Its COVID-19 Guidelines: What Does It Mean for Your Business?

    August 25, 2022

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On August 11, 2022, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) unveiled its updated COVID-19 guidelines, revising both quarantine and isolation guidelines in the process. The updates reflect the growing number of vaccinated individuals (meaning, those individuals who have received initial doses and all recommended boosters) and past exposures, leading to a greater level of herd immunity than in previous eras of the virus. These adjustments to the CDC’s guidance also serve, in large part, to clarify existing recommendations or to loosen restrictions. This article provides a closer look at what exactly the updated guidance requires and how to best approach these updates in the workplace.

    In depth

    WHAT DOES THE CDC RECOMMEND YOU DO IF YOU ARE EXPOSED TO COVID-19?

    First, irrespective of vaccination status, individuals are no longer required to quarantine simply because they are exposed to COVID-19 as long as they do not develop COVID-19 symptoms or test positive. The CDC advises that exposed individuals can continue to go to work, attend school and continue life as normal so long as they wear a well-fitting, high-quality mask for 10 days after exposure.

    The CDC also recommends that individuals who are exposed and experiencing symptoms get tested for the virus five days after exposure. If those test results are positive, the individual should isolate away from others. If the results are negative, the individual can end their quarantine period but should continue to wear a mask as a precaution. Exposed individuals should take particular care when around people who are more likely to get very sick from COVID-19.

    WHEN DOES THE CDC RECOMMEND THAT SOMEONE ISOLATE FROM OTHERS?

    The CDC still recommends people isolate under certain circumstances. As a reminder, quarantine is the term used for individuals who are exposed, while isolation is the term used for individuals who are actively sick with the virus.

    If someone tests positive for COVID-19, they should stay at home and isolate themselves from others for at least five days. If someone with COVID-19 must be around others (such as a family member who the person lives with), they should wear a high-quality mask until 10 days after the first positive test result. The positive individual should avoid being around people who are more likely to get very ill from COVID-19 until at least day 11 after testing positive. If symptoms worsen after the isolation period ends (meaning day 11), the isolation clock should be restarted, and a healthcare provider should be consulted about when to end isolation. The 10-day masking period after a positive result can end early if the individual takes two rapid result tests 48 hours apart and both of those tests are negative for COVID-19.

    Isolation is counted in days as follows:

    • If the individual who has tested positive for COVID-19 has no symptoms, Day 0 is the day a person tests for COVID. Day 1 is the first full day following the test. If the individual develops symptoms within 10 days of testing, the clock restarts at Day 0 of the day of symptom onset.
    • If the individual has symptoms, Day 0 of isolation is the day of symptom onset—regardless of when someone may test positive. Day 1 is then the first full day after the onset of symptoms.

    ARE THERE ANY UPDATES TO THE CDC’S RECOMMENDATIONS ON COVID-19 PREVENTION?

    The CDC continues to recommend contact tracing and notification, and efforts should be focused on identifying and notifying individuals who are exposed to COVID-19 and providing such individuals with information and resources, including information on access to testing.

    The CDC also continues to recommend up-to-date vaccination as the best form of prevention.

    HOW DOES THIS AFFECT EMPLOYERS?

    The biggest change for employers with these newest guidelines is the effective end of the quarantine requirement following exposure to COVID-19. Employees are no longer required to stay away from the workplace because they have been exposed to the virus so long as they wear a high-quality mask. However, employees should remain at home if they have tested positive for COVID-19 or if they present symptoms of COVID-19.

    As has always been the case, CDC guidance is not law, however, it provides employers with a national recommended standard for COVID-19 safety. Employers are permitted to have more protective standards than the CDC recommends, where permitted by law. The loosening of CDC guidance does not impact employer obligations to comply with state and local COVID-19 requirements, which may remain more stringent. Likewise, employers must still comply with other employment laws such as the Americans with Disabilities Act and similar state laws, which may still require engagement in the interactive process and implementation of reasonable accommodations for employees based on their health conditions.

    If employers have questions regarding their current COVID-19 policies and approach, please contact the McDermott employment team, who can provide advice on how to implement a sound COVID-19 policy in the workplace.

    Authors

    Abigail M. Kagan

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    Melis Solaksubasi

    Associate

    Chicago

    More insights

  • California Attorney General Announces First CCPA Settlement

    California Attorney General Announces First CCPA Settlement

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    California Attorney General Announces First CCPA Settlement

    August 25, 2022

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On August 24, 2022, the California Attorney General (AG) announced a first-of-its-kind settlement with Sephora, Inc. (Sephora) over Sephora’s alleged violation of the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA). The settlement imposed a $1.2 million fine and injunctive measures—as well as a two-year monitorship—to ensure Sephora’s compliance with certain parts of the CCPA related to consumer opt-outs from the sale of information, including through recognition of the Global Privacy Control (GPC).

    In depth

    The CCPA includes provisions that require businesses subject to the CCPA to allow consumers to opt out of the “sale” of their personal information by the business. The definition of “sale” under the CCPA is very broad, as highlighted by the AG’s complaint against and settlement with Sephora. In the Sephora matter, the AG’s complaint describes how a business’ use of “widely-used” advertising and analytics technologies can, in the AG’s view, constitute a “sale” of information for which consumers must be given the right to opt out of, including through the GPC.

    The AG’s press release and complaint details how in June 2021 the AG conducted an “enforcement sweep” of large online retailers to assess their compliance with the CCPA’s opt-out of sale requirements and their ability to process GPC. The AG alleges that, although Sephora collected and shared internet activity data with third-party advertising networks and analytics providers, Sephora’s privacy policy represented that it did not “sell” personal information and that Sephora’s website did not include a “Do Not Sell” link, nor did it recognize the GPC. The AG alleges that it sent Sephora a notice of noncompliance with the CCPA and that Sephora did not cure the noncompliance within 30 days, leading to the AG’s enforcement action and, ultimately, the settlement announced yesterday.

    Pursuant to the settlement, in addition to a $1.2 million payment, Sephora was ordered to provide notice of its “sale” of personal information practices, provide a “Do Not Sell” mechanism on its website and implement the capability to process GPC signals. Sephora was also given 180 days to develop the following:

    • A program to assess whether it is effectively processing consumer opt-out requests and requests submitted via GPC, including annual reports submitted to the AG for two years after the 180-day implementation period, detailing its implementation of the opt-out mechanisms and an analysis of any errors or technical problems encountered and remediated; and
    • A program to conduct an annual review of its website and mobile applications to determine the entities to which it makes personal information available as well as annual reports submitted to the AG for two years after the 180-day implementation period, detailing the names of the entities to which Sephora makes personal information available, its purpose for making that information available, whether Sephora characterizes such entities as service providers and to ensure proper categorization of its service providers.

    Sephora did not admit any wrongdoing in connection with the settlement.

    Aside from being the first public CCPA settlement, there are several noteworthy aspects of the AG’s announcement:

    • First, the timing is significant. The California Privacy Protection Agency (CPPA)—the new regulatory agency tasked with enforcing the CCPA—just closed the window for public comment to its proposed CCPA regulations, which include a controversial set of regulations related to opt-out browser signals. The AG’s focus on GPC in its complaint against Sephora is hard to see as a coincidence.
    • Second, and related, the AG’s focus on GPC should be a wake-up call to companies that may have not previously focused on that requirement in the existing regulations.
    • Third, the settlement should be a reminder to companies that the 30-day cure period is an opportunity to act to avoid this same outcome.
    • Fourth, the inclusion of a monitorship, while not surprising, highlights what many companies will consider among the highest costs of CCPA noncompliance.

    Finally, the AG’s announcement takes a clear stance on the contested debate over the meaning of “sale” under the CCPA. Like Sephora, many other companies had taken the position that the use of web advertising and analytics technologies does not amount to a “sale” under the CCPA. This issue will largely become moot when the CCPA amendments, which take effect next year, introduce a new right to opt out of “sharing” that is specifically drafted to cover targeted advertising technologies. Still, through the Sephora settlement, the AG is making clear its view that the CCPA’s “sale” provisions already cover these technologies, and that companies that do not currently provide an opt-out of targeted advertising are out of compliance with the CCPA. Companies should assess their compliance posture—and the timeline for implementing any new opt-out rights—accordingly.

    QUESTIONS?

    If you have questions about sale obligations under the CCPA or need any assistance with privacy program compliance, please reach out to your McDermott lawyer or contact Michael G. Morgan, David P. Saunders, Amy C. Pimentel, Elliot R. Golding or Fran P. Forte.

    Authors

    David P. Saunders

    Partner

    Chicago

    Michael G. Morgan

    Partner

    Los Angeles, Silicon Valley

    More insights

  • Update on the Gas Levy and Outlook for the Emergency Stage of the German Gas Emergency Plan

    Update on the Gas Levy and Outlook for the Emergency Stage of the German Gas Emergency Plan

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Update on the Gas Levy and Outlook for the Emergency Stage of the German Gas Emergency Plan

    August 16, 2022

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The amount of the gas procurement levy was set at 2.419 cents per kWh on 15 August 2022. Are end consumers threatened by further adverse effects in addition to the general price increase and these additional costs?

    In depth

    1. Status Quo
    Die Trading Hub Europe GmbH (THE) hat als zuständiger Marktgebietsverantwortlicher am 15. August 2022 die Höhe der Gasbeschaffungsumlage zu Beginn des Umlagezeitraumes (1. Oktober 2022) mit 2,419 Cent pro Kilowattstunde festgelegt. Rechtsgrundlage dafür ist die am 9. August 2022 in Kraft getretene Gaspreisanpassungsverordnung, mit der die Bundesregierung von ihrer Ermächtigung gemäß § 26 des Energiesicherungsgesetzes Gebrauch gemacht und eine Gasbeschaffungsumlage durch saldierte Preisanpassung verordnet hat.

    Mit der bis zum 1. April 2024 befristeten Gasbeschaffungsumlage wird für betroffene Gasimporteure ab dem 1. Oktober 2022 die Möglichkeit geschaffen, für Kosten, die für die Beschaffung von Ersatzgas anfallen, unter bestimmten weiteren Voraussetzungen einen finanziellen Ausgleich von dem Marktgebietsverantwortlichen (THE) zu erhalten. Die Umlage dieser Kosten erfolgt sodann von dem Marktgebietsverantwortlichen (THE) gegenüber den Bilanzkreisverantwortlichen (in der Regel den Energieversorgern), die die betreffenden Kosten unter Umständen an die Letztverbraucher weitergeben können. Dies kann dazu führen, dass sich die Gaspreise für Letztverbraucher neben den allgemeinen Preissteigerungen ab dem 1. Oktober 2022 noch weiter um die Gasbeschaffungsumlage erhöhen.

    2. Ausblick auf die Notfallstufe des Notfallplans Gas
    Für den Fall, dass die Maßnahmen der derzeit geltenden Alarmstufe unter dem Notfallplan Gas für die Bundesrepublik Deutschland (Notfallplan Gas) nicht ausreichen sollten oder eine dauerhafte Verschlechterung der Versorgungssituation in der zweiten Jahreshälfte eintreten sollte, kann die Bundesregierung die dritte Stufe des Notfallplans Gas, die sog. Notfallstufe, per Verordnung ausrufen. In diesem Fall übernimmt die Bundesnetzagentur (BNetzA) die Rolle des sogenannten Bundeslastverteilers und es können hoheitliche Maßnahmen ergriffen werden, um den lebenswichtigen Bedarf an Gas zu sichern und Folgeschäden der Mangelversorgung abzuwenden. Darunter können u.a. (i) die Anordnung der Substitution von Erdgas durch andere Brennstoffe, (ii) die Anordnung der Nutzung von Strom, der nicht mit Gas erzeugt wird, oder auch (iii) die Anordnung der Gasverbrauchsreduktion oder Abschaltung von bestimmten Letztverbrauchern fallen. Mit der Ausrufung der Notfallstufe können für bestimmte Letztverbraucher insofern einschneidende Beeinträchtigungen ihrer betrieblichen Abläufe einhergehen.
    Die BNetzA hat für die Notfallstufe Kriterien aufgestellt, die bei Maßnahmen, die zur Verhinderung von Versorgungsengpässen umgesetzt werden sollen, im Rahmen der Abwägung zu berücksichtigen sind. Dazu zählen unter anderem (i) die Dringlichkeit der Maßnahme, (ii) die Wirkung einer Gasversorgungsreduktion, (iii) die benötigte Vorlaufzeit zur Anpassung der Produktionsketten an einen verminderten Bezug, (iv) die zu erwartenden (volks-/betriebs-)wirtschaftlichen Schäden, (v) die Kosten und Dauer der Wiederinbetriebnahme nach einer Gasversorgungsreduktion, sowie (vi) die Bedeutung für die Versorgung der Allgemeinheit. Daneben bemüht sich die BNetzA, weitere Kriterien in ihre Abwägungsentscheidung mit einzubeziehen.

    Die derzeit wohl noch vorherrschende lückenhafte Datenlage und der weite Ermessensspielraum der BNetzA führen dazu, dass sich ein Unternehmen vor Erlass einer konkreten Maßnahme durch die BNetzA nicht sicher sein kann, wie prioritär seine Versorgungsinteressen, insbesondere im Vergleich zu anderen Marktteilnehmern, eingestuft werden. Die Versorgungslage kann zudem starken Schwankungen unterliegen, so dass eine feste Abschaltreihenfolge nach Mitteilung der BNetzA nicht festgelegt werden kann. Als nach dem Energiewirtschaftsgesetz „geschützte Kunden“ gelten zudem im Grundsatz nur Haushaltungskunden und grundlegende soziale Dienste .

    Die BNetzA führte im Mai 2022 eine Befragung von Letztverbrauchern mit einer technischen Anschlusskapazität von mindestens 10 MWh/h durch, um für den Fall einer Gasmangellage bei der Entscheidung zur Gasverteilung auf eine möglichst breite Datenlage zurückgreifen zu können. Eine vorherige Ankündigung der als Allgemein- oder Einzelverfügungen ergehenden Maßnahmen der BNetzA gegenüber den betroffenen Adressaten muss nicht erfolgen. Letztverbraucher können somit sehr kurzfristig vor dem Problem stehen, dass ihre Gasversorgung erheblich eingeschränkt oder ganz abgeschaltet wird. Die Auswirkungen von angeordneten Gasversorgungsreduktionen oder -unterbrechungen für produzierende Gewerbe liegen auf der Hand. Aber auch bei gewerblichen Vermietern kann eine Gasversorgungsreduktion oder -unterbrechung dazu führen, dass vermieterseitige Pflichten im Zusammenhang mit dem vertraglich geschuldeten Gebrauch der Mietsache, insbesondere soweit die Beheizbarkeit und die generelle Nutzbarkeit der vermieteten Räumlichkeiten betroffen sind, nicht mehr erfüllt werden können. Zu einzelnen mietvertraglichen Fragestellungen im Zusammenhang mit drohenden Engpässen und Ausfällen bei Gaslieferungen, wie Minderungs- und Kündigungsvoraussetzungen, haben wir in unseren ausführlichen FAQs Stellung genommen.

    3. Gibt es (vorbeugende) Rechtsschutzmöglichkeiten?
    Hat die BNetzA eine Entscheidung darüber getroffen, dass die Gasversorgung eines Letztverbrauchers reduziert oder unterbrochen wird, kann der betroffene Letztverbraucher gerichtlich mit einer Beschwerde vor dem OLG Düsseldorf gegen diese Entscheidung vorgehen. Ein solches gerichtliches Rechtsschutzverfahren kann sich erfahrungsgemäß über einen langen Zeitraum erstrecken und wird im Regelfall nicht dafür sorgen, dass eine temporär angeordnete Gasversorgungsreduktion oder -unterbrechung auf kurze Sicht wieder sicher hergestellt wird.
    Will sich ein Letztverbraucher im Vorfeld einer möglichen Anordnung gegen die Gefahr einer Gasversorgungsreduktion oder -unterbrechung wehren, gibt es nur eingeschränkte Handlungsmöglichkeiten. Es ist derzeit kein formelles Verfahren vorgesehen, um (gerichtlich) feststellen zu lassen, ob das eigene Unternehmen zur schützenswerten Infrastruktur gehört, für die keine Gasversorgungsreduktion oder -unterbrechung angeordnet werden soll.

    Es kann sich aber zur Vermeidung von etwaigen mit einer Gasversorgungsreduktion oder -unterbrechung verbundenen betriebswirtschaftlichen Schäden empfehlen, an die BNetzA im Vorfeld der Notfallstufe heranzutreten und die besondere Schutzwürdigkeit des eigenen Unternehmens hervorzuheben. Ein solcher „Schutzantrag“ ist gesetzlich zwar nicht vorgesehen und stellt keinen formellen Antrag auf Feststellung zur Zugehörigkeit zum Kreis der schützenswerten Infrastruktur dar. Die BNetzA kann allerdings die so vorgebrachten Umstände unter Umständen im Rahmen ihres weiten Ermessensspielraums berücksichtigen, da sie im Grundsatz zu einer ermessensfehlerfreien Entscheidung unter Wahrung des Verhältnismäßigkeitsgrundsatzes verpflichtet ist. Der „Schutzantrag“ kann jedoch keine Gewähr dafür bieten, dass das Unternehmen von einer etwaigen Gasversorgungsreduktion oder -unterbrechung geschützt oder nur in geringem Maße betroffen sein wird.

    Bei Rückfragen sprechen Sie uns gerne an.

    (1) Der „Notfallplan Gas für die Bundesrepublik Deutschland“ basiert auf der sog. Verordnung (EU) 2017/1938 des Europäischen Parlaments und des Rates vom 25. Oktober 2017 über Maßnahmen zur Gewährleistung der sicheren Gasversorgung und zur Aufhebung der Verordnung (EU) Nr. 994/2010 – sog. SoS-Verordnung.
    (2) Der Notfallplan Gas der EU, der basierend auf der Verordnung (EU) 2022/1369 des Rates vom 5. August 2022 über koordinierte Maßnahmen zur Senkung der Gasnachfrage am 9. August 2022 in Kraft getreten ist, sieht ähnliche Kriterien für die Priorisierung von Maßnahmen zur Nachfragesenkung, wie die Auswirkung auf systemrelevante Lieferketten, langfristige Schäden an Industrieanlagen und die Möglichkeiten zur Senkung des Verbrauchs und zur Substitution von Produkten in der Union, vor.
    (3)Im Einzelnen zu den „geschützten Kunden“ vgl. § 53a Energiewirtschaftsgesetz, der auf der SoS-Verordnung basiert.

    Authors

    Thomas A. Beisken, LL.M.

    Partner

    Düsseldorf

    Dr. Alexa Ningelgen

    Partner

    Düsseldorf

    More insights

  • Federal Reserve Board Issues Letter Regarding Crypto-Asset-Related Activities

    Federal Reserve Board Issues Letter Regarding Crypto-Asset-Related Activities

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Federal Reserve Board Issues Letter Regarding Crypto-Asset-Related Activities

    August 23, 2022

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On Aug. 16, 2022, the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (“FRB”) issued a letter (“Letter”)[1] regarding FRB-supervised banking organizations (“Covered Entities”) engaging in crypto-asset-related activities (“C-A-R activities”).[2] While the Letter stated that the crypto-asset sector could potentially present beneficial opportunities for Covered Entities, the Letter cautioned that C-A-R activities could also pose risks, specifically concerning consumer protection, safety and soundness, and financial stability. 

    The Letter elucidated several requirements—as well as suggestions—applicable to Covered Entities regarding C-A-R activities, including the following:

    • A Covered Entity must ensure—prior to conducting new activities—that such new activities are legally permissible.
    • A Covered Entity seeking to engage in—or currently engaged in—C-A-R activities must analyze whether such activities would be permissible under relevant state and federal laws. In addition, the Covered Entity must evaluate whether any filings are required per federal banking laws (including g., the Home Owners’ Loan Act, the Bank Holding Company Act, the Federal Deposit Insurance Act, or the Federal Reserve Act) or corresponding promulgated regulations, as applicable.
    • Prior to engaging in any C-A-R activity, a Covered Entity should notify its lead supervisory point of contact at the FRB.
    • If a Covered Entity is already engaged in C-A-R activities, then that Covered Entity should promptly notify its lead supervisory point of contact at the FRB, assuming the Covered Entity has not already done so.
    • Covered Entities with questions regarding the permissibility of any C-A-R activities or the applicability of any filing requirements should consult their lead supervisory point of contact at the FRB.
    • In all circumstances, prior to engaging in C-A-R activities, a Covered Entity should ensure that it maintains appropriate risk management, systems and controls to conduct C-A-R activities “in a safe and sound manner and consistent with applicable laws, including applicable consumer protection statutes and regulations.”[3] The Letter further states that such systems should cover financial risk, legal risk, operational risk (g., risks posed by new and evolving technologies, hacking risks, third-party risks), compliance risk (including e.g., anti-money laundering and sanctions risks) and “any other risk necessary to ensure the activities are conducted in a manner that is consistent with safe and sound banking and in compliance with applicable laws, including applicable consumer protection statutes and regulations.”[4]
    • Prior to engaging in C-A-R activity, a Covered Entity which is a state member bank should also notify its state regulator.

    The Letter noted that, given the novel and heightened risks that crypto-assets pose, the FRB will continue to closely monitor developments in the crypto-asset sector and participation by Covered Entities in C-A-R activities.

    Schulte Roth & Zabel’s lawyers are available to assist you in preparing a public comment or addressing any questions you may have regarding these developments. Please contact the Schulte Roth & Zabel lawyer with whom you usually work, or any of the following attorneys:

    Donald J. Mosher – New York (+1 212.756.2187)

    Kara A. Kuchar – New York (+1 212.756.2734)

    Melissa G.R. Goldstein – Washington, DC (+1 202.729.7471)

    Adam J. Barazani – New York (+1 212.756.2519)

    Jessica Romano – New York (+1 212.756.2205)

    Jessica Sklute – New York (+1 212.756.2180)

    Hadas A. Jacobi – New York (+1 212.756.2055)

    Steven T. Cummings – New York (+1 212.756.2251)

    Rebecca A. Raskind – New York (+1 212.756.2396)

    Jesse Weissman – New York (+1 212.756.2460)


    [1] Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, Engagement in Crypto-Asset-Related Activities by Federal Reserve-Supervised Banking Organizations (Aug. 16, 2022), available here.

    [2] The Letter defines crypto-asset-related activities as including “crypto-asset safekeeping and traditional custody services; ancillary custody services; facilitation of customer purchases and sales of crypto-assets; loans collateralized by crypto-assets; and issuance and distribution of stablecoins.” See Letter, supra note 1.

    [3] See id.

    [4] See id.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2022 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Donald J. Mosher

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Melissa G.R. Goldstein

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Adam J. Barazani

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • New York Launches Hotline for Workplace Sexual Harassment Complaints

    New York Launches Hotline for Workplace Sexual Harassment Complaints

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    New York Launches Hotline for Workplace Sexual Harassment Complaints

    August 22, 2022

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On July 19, 2022, Governor Kathy Hochul announced the launch of a new state-wide, toll-free, confidential hotline for complaints of workplace sexual harassment. The New York State Division of Human Rights (NYSDHR) was required to establish and maintain this hotline in connection with an amendment to the New York State Human Rights Law, N.Y. Exec. Law § 295, which Governor Hochul signed into law on March 16, 2022 and which became effective on July 14, 2022. New York employees and individuals who visit a workplace in the course of their own work (e.g., consultants, delivery drivers, repair technicians, salespersons) may now call the hotline at 1-800-HARASS-3 (1-800-427-2773) during regular business hours (Monday through Friday from 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.) to make complaints and receive pro bono counsel and assistance regarding workplace sexual harassment. The pro bono attorneys staffing the hotline are New York State attorneys who have expertise in employment law and sexual harassment issues.

    The law further requires the NYSDHR to disseminate information about the hotline and to work with the New York State Department of Labor (NYSDOL) “to ensure that information on the hotline is included in any materials employers must post or provide to employees regarding sexual harassment.” Though no guidance has been released from the NYSDHR and/or the NYSDOL concerning updated related materials to be provided to employees, employers should review their handbooks and standalone policies, workplace postings and training materials regarding sexual harassment and include the new hotline telephone number in such materials. Forthcoming guidance from the NYSDHR and/or the NYSDOL is expected, and we will provide an update once such guidance is released.

    Authored by Mark E. Brossman, Ronald E. Richman, Max Garfield, Scott A. Gold, Donna K. Lazarus and Michelle M. Orge.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2022 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Mark E. Brossman

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Ronald E. Richman

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Max Garfield

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Donna K. Lazarus

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Michelle M. Orge

    Associate

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • The 411 on Employment Background Checks in Stock and Asset Transactions

    The 411 on Employment Background Checks in Stock and Asset Transactions

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    The 411 on Employment Background Checks in Stock and Asset Transactions

    August 19, 2022

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Employment background checks help employers hire individuals with integrity whom they can trust, and who do not present a risk to the business, other employees, or the customers and clients that the business serves. Buyers in transactions may view target businesses that run background checks as lower risk for employee performance and retention issues. Background checks also constitute an important area for employment diligence in transactions because an employer or background check vendor’s failure to follow the hypertechnical disclosure and authorization requirements of the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) and other applicable state and local laws risks potentially material class action exposure and $1,000 penalties per violation. This article explores mitigation strategies that buyers may use in due diligence to identify and valuate potential FCRA exposure.

    In depth

    THE LAW

    The FCRA requires that prior to procuring a background check on a job applicant, employers provide job applicants with a clear and conspicuous disclosure, made in writing and in a document consisting solely of the disclosure, regarding the fact of the contemplated background check. The FCRA also requires that employers obtain the job applicant’s authorization for the background check, which may be included in the same written disclosure.

    Plaintiffs may recover actual damages for negligent violations of the FCRA, or statutory damages of $100 to $1,000 per each willful violation of the FCRA. Courts have found that certain provisions in disclosure forms (for example, liability waivers or state-specific disclosures) are per se violations of the FCRA automatically entitling plaintiffs to statutory damages. Because statutory damages do not require proof of actual injuries, these types of claims are low-hanging fruit for plaintiffs’ lawyers that can point to a noncompliant disclosure form as proof of a common unlawful policy applicable to a class of individuals and, on this basis, file a class action. Statutory damages on a class basis can quickly add up where a company has a practice of procuring hundreds or thousands of background checks annually.

    POTENTIAL BACKGROUND CHECK PITFALLS

    A California district court recently opined that FCRA disclosure forms should contain nothing more than a plain statement disclosing “that a consumer report may be obtained for employment purposes,” along with some concise explanation of what that phrase means. The court noted that a disclosure form could briefly describe what a “consumer report” entails, how it will be “obtained,” and for what type of “employment purposes” it may be used.

    While these may sound like simple propositions, neither the courts nor the Federal Trade Commission (the administrative agency tasked with enforcing the FCRA) have provided clear guidance on the definition of “document that consists solely of the disclosure” (the stand-alone requirement) or “clear and conspicuous.” For this reason, it is no surprise that many employers may currently rely on disclosure forms that inadvertently include language constituting a per se violation of the FCRA.

    The courts have, however, made clear that the following statements trigger statutory damages (and should be avoided as noted):

    • Liability Releases. FCRA disclosures should not include any language purporting to release any party from liability in connection with procuring the background checks, such as “I hereby release Employer . . . ,” “I waive . . . ” and “liability.”
    • State-Specific Disclosures. FCRA disclosures should not include state-specific notices or disclosures. These belong on a separate document. Such notices include, for example, disclosures about the applicant’s rights to a consumer report if they live in the states of California, Minnesota and Washington. Some states’ notices must also be in their own stand-alone document and should not be combined with other state-specific disclosures.

    Courts have also found statements regarding nondiscrimination in hiring, or general statements regarding the job applicant’s rights, as problematic in disclosure forms.

    Buyers should confirm that the target’s human resources professionals understand and are trained in the FCRA’s disclosure requirements. In an unpublished 2022 California Court of Appeal opinion in Hebert v. Barnes & Noble, Inc., the court reversed the trial court’s order granting Barnes & Noble’s summary judgment motion on the issue of whether Barnes & Noble willfully violated the FCRA by including extraneous business-to-business language in its background check disclosure form, thereby allowing the claims to move forward on a class basis. Barnes & Noble inadvertently left a footnote in its disclosure form that was intended to be an internal disclaimer from its third-party background check vendor and published it in the live disclosure form that it provided to its job applicants for the following two years.

    The court opined that a reasonable jury could find that Barnes & Noble willfully violated the FCRA based on the following:

    • The disclosure form at issue violated an unambiguous provision of the FCRA.
    • At least one of Barnes & Noble’s employees was aware of the extraneous information (the footnote) in the disclosure before the disclosure was displayed to job applicants.
    • Barnes & Noble may not have adequately trained its employees on FCRA compliance and Barnes & Noble’s person most knowledgeable admitted as much in their deposition.
    • Barnes & Noble may not have had a monitoring system in place to ensure that its disclosure complied with the FCRA.

    MITIGATION STRATEGIES

    FCRA class action litigation arising from employment background check disclosure forms has been increasing since 2017, when the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit found that liability waivers in disclosure forms were a violation of the FCRA as a matter of law. Plaintiffs’ lawyers continue to exploit this underdeveloped area of law. Employers that run background checks on applicants and employees continue to be a target for class action litigation, and representations and warranties insurers have made employment background check practices a focus of inquiry.

    Buyers and their employment counsel should carefully review the following issues with respect to a target’s employment background check and hiring practices to assess this potentially material area of risk:

    • FCRA disclosure and authorization form (often provided by third-party vendors);
    • State-specific disclosures (including California, which has its own stand-alone form requirement);
    • Background check policies in employee handbooks and other stand-alone policies;
    • Offer letters (including for language making employment contingent on satisfactory passage of a background check);
    • Employment applications (to ensure that FCRA disclosures are separate and apart, including on a separate computer screen); and
    • Third-party vendor agreements with background check companies (to confirm existence of a strong indemnity clause favoring the employer).

     

    Authors
    More insights

  • Driving the Deal: Healthcare Antitrust in the Biden Administration

    Driving the Deal: Healthcare Antitrust in the Biden Administration

    ARTICLE / PODCAST / US POLICY

    Driving the Deal: Healthcare Antitrust in the Biden Administration

    August 17, 2022

    About this episode

    In the newest episode of Season 2: Driving the Deal, Krist Werling, McDermott partner and co-head of the Private Equity Practice Group, and Brian Fortune, senior managing director at Farragut Square Group, are joined by Ashley Fischer, McDermott health antitrust partner.. Together, they discuss the following concerning healthcare antitrust in the Biden administration:

    • The Federal Trade Commission’s (FTC) signaled interest in the effect of private equity on competition
    • How the FTC views hospital consolidation
    • Major cases in the physician market and subsequent enforcement activity
    • Tips for investing with new scrutiny
    • Labor market competition and recent significant cases

    Kristian A. Werling

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • Federal Reserve Board Approves Guidelines for Evaluating Reserve Bank Account Requests

    Federal Reserve Board Approves Guidelines for Evaluating Reserve Bank Account Requests

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Federal Reserve Board Approves Guidelines for Evaluating Reserve Bank Account Requests

    August 17, 2022

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On Aug. 15, 2022, the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (“FRB”) unanimously voted to approve guidelines (“Guidelines”) for Federal Reserve Banks (“Reserve Banks”) to use in evaluating requests by institutions — including those with novel charters — to access Reserve Bank accounts and services.[1] The Guidelines, in development for over a year, potentially mark an important step forward in allowing novel charter types — such as so-called state “crypto banks” (e.g., Wyoming special purpose depository institutions (“SPDIs”)) to access the Federal Reserve System.

    The Guidelines

    Citing the rapidly evolving landscape of the payments system as well as new financial products and services that are changing the provision of traditional banking services, the FRB emphasizes that the Guidelines offer a “transparent and consistent” set of factors by which Reserve Banks can evaluate requests for master accounts.[2] Broadly, the Guidelines seek to provide a route by which Reserve Banks can consider master account requests while keeping six main principles in mind: (1) legal eligibility of institutions seeking access; (2) prevention of undue risk to the Reserve Bank presented by the applying institution; (3) prevention of undue risk to the entire payments system presented by the applying institution; (4) prevention of undue risk to the stability of the U.S. financial system presented by the applying institution; (5) prevention of undue risk of money laundering and other illicit activity presented by the applying institution; and (6) prevention of any adverse effect on the FRB’s ability to implement monetary policy.[3]

    Notably, the Guidelines include a tiered review framework that strives to “provide additional clarity on the level of due diligence and scrutiny that Reserve Banks will apply to different types of institutions with varying degrees of risk.”[4] These tiers are organized as follows:

    • Tier 1 institutions are eligible institutions that are federally insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. In light of their deposit insurance status, such institutions would be generally subject to a “less intensive and more streamlined review.”[5]
    • Tier 2 consists of eligible institutions that are not federally insured but are subject to prudential supervision by a federal banking agency and (1) if the institution is state chartered, any holding company of which would be subject to FRB oversight, or (2) if the institution is federally chartered, any holding company of which that is subject to FRB oversight. Tier 2 institutions would receive a moderate/intermediate level of scrutiny and review.[6]
    • Tier 3 is made up of eligible institutions that are not federally insured and not subject to Tier 2 scrutiny. Such institutions would receive the highest amount of scrutiny and review.[7]

    The Guidelines will become effective upon publication in the Federal Register.

    Implications of Guidelines

    As noted above, the Guidelines contemplate a path for novel institutions — namely cryptocurrency banks — to gain access to the Federal Reserve System, and in doing so obtain master account access. Specifically, the Guidelines come in the wake of certain SPDIs (i.e., Custodia and Kraken Bank), applying for Reserve Bank master account access last year.

    Schulte Roth & Zabel’s lawyers are available to assist you in preparing a public comment or addressing any questions you may have regarding these developments. Please contact the Schulte Roth & Zabel lawyer with whom you usually work, or any of the following attorneys:

    Donald J. Mosher – New York (+1 212.756.2187, donald.mosher@srz.com)

    Kara A. Kuchar – New York (+1 212.756.2734, kara.kuchar@srz.com)

    Melissa G.R. Goldstein – Washington, DC (+1 202.729.7471, melissa.goldstein@srz.com)

    Adam J. Barazani – New York (+1 212.756.2519, adam.barazani@srz.com)

    Jessica Romano – New York (+1 212.756.2205, jessica.romano@srz.com)

    Jessica Sklute – New York (+1 212.756.2180, jessica.sklute@srz.com)

    Hadas A. Jacobi – New York (+1 212.756.2055, hadas.jacobi@srz.com)

    Steven T. Cummings – New York (+1 212.756.2251, steven.cummings@srz.com)

    Rebecca A. Raskind – New York (+1 212.756.2396, rebecca.raskind@srz.com)

    Jesse Weissman – New York (+1 212.756.2460, jesse.weissman@srz.com)


    [1] Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, Guidelines for Evaluating Account and Services Requests (Aug. 15, 2022), https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/pressreleases/files/other20220815a1.pdf, at 2 [hereinafter Guidelines].

    [2] Press Release, Federal Reserve Board announces final guidelines that establish a transparent, risk-based, and consistent set of factors for Reserve Banks to use in reviewing requests to access Federal Reserve accounts and payment services (Aug. 15, 2022), https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/pressreleases/other20220815a.htm [hereinafter Press Release].

    [3] Guidelines, supra note 1, at 2–3.

    [4] Press Release, supra note 2.

    [5] Memorandum from Federal Reserve Staff to Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (Aug. 2, 2022), https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/pressreleases/files/board-memo-20220815.pdf, at 2.

    [6] Id. at 5.

    [7] Id.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2022 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Donald J. Mosher

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Melissa G.R. Goldstein

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Adam J. Barazani

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Climate Change Regulatory Update for US Insurers: August 2022

    Climate Change Regulatory Update for US Insurers: August 2022

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Climate Change Regulatory Update for US Insurers: August 2022

    August 16, 2022

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    This year started off with a surge of enthusiasm among US proponents of increased climate-related financial risk disclosure by insurers and others:

    • Soon after the late-2021 Conference of the Parties (COP) 26 event in Glasgow, Scotland, the New York Department of Financial Services (NYDFS) finalized its climate change regulatory framework.
    • The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) completed the first full year of work by its Climate and Resiliency Task Force (Task Force), with several more states signing up to require insurers domiciled in their states to submit climate disclosure surveys modified to align more closely with the climate disclosure survey developed by the Financial Stability Board’s (FSB) Task Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosure (TCFD).
    • In March 2022, the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) published its proposed climate change financial disclosure rules, borrowing some of the TCFD’s content and receiving many comments from interested parties in the ensuing months.

    On the international front, development continued on a common language for climate change financial disclosures by the International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB). All of this activity occurred against a steady drumbeat of announcements of new environmental, social and governance (ESG)-compliant investment funds, commitments from insurers to refrain from underwriting new and/or existing coal mining and similar ventures, and pledges from many companies—including insurers—with respect to emissions reductions and sustainability generally.

    More recently, as the summer of 2022 wears on—with high temperatures and drought conditions in much of the country, wildfires proliferating in the western United States, recent deadly flooding in Kentucky, and the approaching peak of the Atlantic hurricane season—even climate change skeptics must be wondering if there isn’t something to this climate change phenomenon.

    But as one commentator recently noted, the day that pro-ESG activity began is also the day that anti-ESG activity began. With this in mind, how should US insurers approach climate change financial disclosures for the remainder of the year?

    In depth

    US INSURANCE REGULATION

    Where We Stand

    The only state that continues to have a more-or-less fully developed climate change regulatory framework is New York. For insurers that are domiciled in New York—meaning that the NYDFS is the insurer’s primary solvency regulator—the NYDFS expects that as of August 15, 2022, affected insurers will have begun to incorporate climate change into governance structures and enterprise risk management processes with board-level supervision and senior management support.

    The NYDFS will monitor insurer compliance by examining responses to the NAIC’s recently revised climate disclosure survey (again, revised earlier this year by the Task Force to align more closely with the TCFD format). The NAIC pushed back the submission of responses to its climate disclosure survey to November 30, 2022, and New York has also agreed to the delay (along with the 14 other states that require domestic insurers to complete the survey). Apparently, the NYDFS has also sent requests for information (RFIs) to insurers that are not required to submit responses to the NAIC survey.

    As noted above, the NAIC progressed to the extent of revising its Climate Disclosure Survey earlier this year. More precisely, it was the NAIC’s executive committee that revised the survey, not the full membership (see below for more on “red” vs. “blue” state divergence with respect to climate change disclosure requirements), and, practically speaking, that is the sum total of the progress that the NAIC has made.

    Specifically, at the NAIC’s August 2022 Summer National Meeting in Portland, Oregon, the Task Force convened to listen to reports of activity by its five subgroups: climate risk disclosure, solvency, innovation, technology and pre-disaster mitigation. There was scant activity to report, apart from some progress in developing proposed edits to the NAIC’s Financial Condition Examiners Handbook (which will need to be considered for adoption by other NAIC committees) and planning for meetings later this year to explore the possible use of scenario analyses (e.g., the Bank of England’s Climate Biennial Exploratory Scenario (CBES) exercise) by regulators and insurers.

    Where We May Be Headed

    Given the extended, November 30, 2022, deadline for submission of NAIC climate disclosure reports, it is unlikely that the NAIC and state regulators will be able to analyze responses until sometime in 2023, even assuming that regulators decide to use a new service of an artificial intelligence/machine learning (AI/ML)-powered climate change disclosure analysis algorithm that Ceres’ Executive Director Steve Rothstein mentioned during a brief August 2022 presentation to the Task Force. Ceres is apparently testing out the software on 28 TCFD reports filed via the California Department of Insurance last year.

    At the NAIC level, by year-end 2022 it seems unlikely that the Task Force and its various workstreams will have made significant progress on developing either an overarching climate risk regulatory framework or discrete portions of a framework. There will be new NAIC leadership in 2023 (when Chlora Lindley-Myers, director of the Missouri Department of Insurance, replaces Dean Cameron, director of the Idaho Department of Insurance, as NAIC president) but not until 2024 (when Connecticut Insurance Commissioner Andrew Mais takes office as president) will there be a strong proponent for climate change risk advances. One variable that could prompt the NAIC to move a bit more quickly in 2023, however, will be what the Federal Insurance Office (FIO) says in its gap analysis report on state progress on climate-related issues that is due to be published by the end of 2022.

    Nevertheless, it seems highly unlikely that the NAIC as a whole will take the bull by the horns and follow the lead of New York. But will other states follow New York’s lead and proceed to develop the same or similar regulatory frameworks to guide insurers in integrating climate change risk into existing enterprise risk management processes?

    The answer in Republican-controlled (red) states is almost certainly “no.” We have seen multiple examples of red-state governors, treasurers and attorneys general firing warning shots across the bows of certain asset managers and banks hoping to manage state pension and other funds or handle local bond issuances. If asset managers and bankers have been too public in their pledges to cease investing in coal, oil and gas projects or too vocal about the use of ESG factors in making investment decisions, they cannot expect to be awarded new contracts and assignments. Most recently, in late July, West Virginia State Treasurer Riley Moore published the state’s first Restricted Financial Institution List, disqualifying five financial institutions from being awarded state banking contracts. Larger states (e.g., Florida and Texas) are in the West Virginia camp. It seems unlikely that state insurance commissioners (at least those appointed by governors in the states just mentioned) will be thinking about subjecting domestic insurers to mandatory climate change disclosure standards.

    There are multiple variables, apart from 2022 US election outcomes, that could alter red-state positions on climate change generally. First, natural catastrophe events or conditions of one sort or another can change views. Second, economic activity (e.g., new electric vehicle assembly plants, new battery factories, new renewable energy projects), all of which will proliferate during the balance of this decade thanks to the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 (IRA) that both houses of US Congress have now approved, may change minds. Third, expanded tax breaks in the IRA for individuals and businesses acquiring electric vehicles or installing renewable power equipment will also change minds. Fourth, geopolitical events that cause spikes in the price of oil could prompt changes as well.

    FEDERAL SECURITIES REGULATION

    As mentioned briefly above, and as is well known by now, a divided SEC (where the two Republican commissioners have repeatedly expressed their opposition to the current climate change risk disclosure proposal) will presumably publish a final climate change risk disclosure regulation by the end of 2022 or early in 2023 at the latest. If comments from 24 attorneys general from red states, characterizing the SEC’s proposed rule as “an ill-advised misadventure into environmental regulation,” are any guide, it is nearly certain that once the SEC does publish a final version of its regulation there will be multiple lawsuits filed by various parties in an effort to prevent the proposal from becoming effective.

    Whether red states, SEC-registered companies or other interested parties will be filing suits remains to be seen, of course. However, these suits will take years to conclude and one or more may well wind up before the Supreme Court of the United States that, at the end of its 2021–2022 term, delivered a decision in West Virginia v. Environmental Protection Agency (No. 20-1530, decided June 30, 2022) that opponents will likely cite as support for the proposition that, for the SEC, the comprehensive climate change disclosure proposal is a bridge too far. Opponents consider such a proposal as a “major question” that our elected representatives, not an administrative agency itself, ought to be addressing absent “clear congressional authority.” Regardless, some—perhaps many—of the roughly 110 insurers that are SEC registrants will either continue or decide to begin preparing and publishing NAIC or TCFD-type climate risk financial disclosures that SEC staff will be scrutinizing in the future.

    Authors

    Thomas M. Dawson

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights