Content Type: Article

  • SEC Adopts New Reporting Requirements for Form 13F Filers to Disclose “Say-On-Pay” Votes and Enhances Voting Disclosures Required by Registered Funds

    SEC Adopts New Reporting Requirements for Form 13F Filers to Disclose “Say-On-Pay” Votes and Enhances Voting Disclosures Required by Registered Funds

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    SEC Adopts New Reporting Requirements for Form 13F Filers to Disclose “Say-On-Pay” Votes and Enhances Voting Disclosures Required by Registered Funds

    November 10, 2022

    Read time: 13 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On Nov. 2, 2022, the Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) adopted new Rule 14Ad-1 and amendments to Form N-PX. Under new Rule 14Ad-1, Form 13F filers will be required to disclose their proxy votes on executive compensation matters, otherwise called “say-on-pay” [1] votes, annually on Form N-PX, a reporting form formerly required to be filed exclusively by investment companies registered under the Investment Company Act of 1940, as amended (“1940 Act”). In addition to expanding the scope of Form N-PX to certain private funds and their investment advisers, the changes to Form N-PX will also require more comprehensive information from mutual funds, exchange-traded funds and certain other investment companies registered under the 1940 Act, and will make the information provided by such funds easier to analyze. The new rules and form amendments will be effective for votes occurring on or after July 1, 2023, with the first filings subject to the amendments due in 2024.

    The changes were originally proposed in September 2021 and discussed by SRZ attorneys here.

    1. Reporting Obligations Extended to Investment Managers and Funds: Rule 14Ad-1 under the Exchange Act will now require “institutional investment managers” subject to the reporting requirements of Section 13(f) under the Exchange Act to file their “say-on-pay” votes pursuant to subsections 14A and 14(b) of the Exchange Act[2] with the SEC annually on Form N-PX by August 31 of each year.[3] This means that not only must registered investment companies file Form N-PX as previously required by Section 30 of the 1940 Act, but that certain private funds and managers must also do the same.[4]

    A manager is required to report its “say-on-pay” votes if it “exercised voting power” over a security with respect to such votes. The SEC has adopted a two-part test for determining if a manager exercised voting power over a security. The manager must (1) have the power to vote, or direct the voting of, a security and (2) “exercise” this power to influence a voting decision for the security. This test, according to the SEC’s Adopting Release, “focuses on the exercise, rather than the mere possession, of voting power.”[5] There will be no reporting requirement where a voting decision is entirely determined by a manager’s client or another party.

    A manager deciding not to vote or whether to recall loaned securities in advance of a record date for a vote in order to vote the shares is exercising voting power according to the SEC’s Adopting Release. For managers that have disclosed to their clients a policy of not voting proxies and who have not voted proxies during the reporting period, the SEC adopted a streamlined reporting option which would indicate this status and not include information on a security-by-security basis as managers reporting votes would be required to do.[6]

    2. More Stringent Information Organizing Requirements: With the aim of making the information on Form N-PX “easier to analyze, digest, and access,”[7] changes to Forms N-PX will now:

    a. Standardize votes into categories, such as director elections, say-on-pay and audit matters;

    b. Require reporting persons to identify proxy voting matters using the same language as disclosed in the issuer’s form of proxy, presented in the same order as the matters appear in the form of proxy, and identify directors separately for director election matters, if applicable; and

    c. Allow managers to indicate that they have a disclosed policy of not voting proxies and did not vote during the reporting period.

    In addition, Forms N-1A, N-2 and N-3 now require funds to disclose that their proxy voting records are available on (or through) their websites. These changes were instituted, in part, to help investors analyze voting reports, and therefore the new rules require filing using XML language which is a machine readable, or “structured,” data language.

    3. Disclosure of Securities Lending: In an attempt to provide greater transparency on fund lending practices and how these practices might affect voting practices, Form N-PX filers must also now disclose on Form N-PX the number of shares that were voted or instructed to be voted, as well as the number of shares loaned and not recalled and thus not voted. As stated in the Adopting Release, however, there would not be a disclosure requirement in instances where (a) a manager is not involved in, directly or indirectly, lending shares in a client’s account, such as in instances where a broker rehypothecates shares under a margin account, or (b) when a client hires a securities lending agent for securities in the client’s account.

    Effects of the Rules

    As we noted last year, these changes may have the following effects on fund managers:

    • Fund managers may now feel obliged to justify their say-on-pay voting positions to investors, activists and company management.
    • While the rule does allow for confidential treatment for “say-on-pay” votes, the SEC has cautioned that confidential treatment would only be granted in “narrowly tailored circumstances,” such as when a corresponding confidential treatment is granted for Form 13F.
    • Funds that are marketed as ESG funds are likely to face additional scrutiny with respect to how they cast these types of votes.
    • Funds that do not vote their shares and have no clearly disclosed policy on not voting now must report their abstention from voting.
    • Finally, although the SEC argues that the requirement to disclose securities that were loaned and not voted gives investors greater transparency into whether a fund manager has decided to recall a loaned security to vote or essentially determined not to vote, it is important to note that while the rule provides investors with the end result, the rule does not provide any insight into the manager’s process for weighing the relative benefits of voting versus lending[8]. As the SEC notes in the Adopting Release, the new loan disclosure requirements now create incentives for managers to recall loans in prior to a vote to conceal loans (or possibly also short positions), thus potentially impacting securities lending practices.[9]

    Authored by Marc E. Elovitz, Kelly Koscuiszka and Adriana Schwartz.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] “Say-on-pay” votes were introduced with the passage of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act (the “Dodd-Frank Act”) in 2010 and relate to shareholder votes approving compensation for “named” executive officers, including “golden parachute” compensation arrangements, as well as how frequently shareholders may approve these compensation arrangements. The reporting requirements for Form 13F filers implement requirements added by Dodd-Frank.

    [2] This includes “say-on-pay” votes of issuers who have a class of securities registered under Section 12 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended, subject to the proxy rules. The new reporting requirement is not however strictly limited to “say-on-pay” votes when voting Section 13(f) securities.

    [4] The SEC estimates that approximately 8,147 Form 13F filers will now need to file Form N-PX under the amendments.

    [5] “Enhanced Reporting of Proxy Votes by Registered Management Investment Companies; Reporting of Executive Compensation Votes by Institutional Investment Managers,” Exchange Act Release No. 34-96206 (Nov. 2, 2022) (the “Adopting Release”) at section II.B.2, available here.

    [6] Adopting Release at 22.

    [7] Statement of Commissioner Caroline A. Crenshaw; “Statement on Enhanced Reporting of Proxy Votes;” (Nov. 2, 2022) available at https://www.sec.gov/news/statement/crenshaw-statement-amendments-form-npx-110222.

    [8] The Adopting Release notes however that the form as amended will permit reporting persons to include additional disclosures which could be used to explain the rationale for not recalling loaned securities. Adopting Release at 40-41.

    [9] Adopting Release at 112.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2022 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Marc E. Elovitz

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Kelly Koscuiszka

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Daniel A. Goldstein

    Counsel

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • CMS Clarifies Coverage and Payment for Remote Therapeutic Monitoring Services

    CMS Clarifies Coverage and Payment for Remote Therapeutic Monitoring Services

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    CMS Clarifies Coverage and Payment for Remote Therapeutic Monitoring Services

    November 8, 2022

    Read time: 11 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On November 1, 2022, the US Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) released the calendar year (CY) 2023 final rule for services reimbursed under the Medicare Physician Fee Schedule (MPFS) (the Final Rule). The Final Rule establishes changes to Medicare Part B professional payment policies and rates for the upcoming year. The Final Rule provides much-anticipated clarity regarding Medicare coverage and payment for remote therapeutic monitoring (RTM) services and continues to develop CMS’s payment policies following the 2022 introduction of the RTM codes.

    CMS finalized certain changes to the existing CPT codes for RTM services but declined to finalize the proposed replacement of these CPT codes with four new, specific Healthcare Common Procedure Coding System (HCPCS) G-codes (G-codes) for RTM services. Most importantly, CMS has addressed the supervision standards for clinical staff, prerequisites for billing RTM codes, and the potential creation of a general device code for RTM. Finally, CMS has finalized its payment policy for the new RTM code for cognitive behavioral therapy.

    In depth

    Remote Monitoring Background

    In recent years, CMS has expanded its payment for remote monitoring services, which generally use digital technologies (primarily medical devices, together with software) to collect medical and other forms of health data from patients in one location to electronically transmit the information to the patient’s healthcare provider in a different location for assessment and care management. Beginning in 2019, with the introduction of CPT codes for remote physiological monitoring (RPM), CMS has gradually established payment rates and provided guidance on requirements and appropriate utilization for remote monitoring services.

    RTM refers to the use of medical devices to monitor a patient’s health or response to treatment using non-physiological data. RTM can be used to monitor medication adherence, response to therapy, musculoskeletal activity, and respiratory activity. This means that RTM can be used, for example, to monitor treatment specific to pain, functional status, and adherence and response to therapy. Effective in 2022, the American Medical Association (AMA) created five new codes for RTM services as a separate category of remote patient monitoring services. The five codes for RTM services were new CPT codes 98975, 98976, 98977, 98980 and 98981. These include three practice expense-only (PE-only) codes (98975, 98976 and 98977) and two codes for treatment management (98980 and 98981).

    CMS established payment policies for RTM last year and currently allows payment using the RTM codes for services that support an episode of therapy where the clinical issue ties to musculoskeletal, respiratory, or medication adherence and response. As Medicare is a major payor for healthcare items and services in the United States, the availability of reimbursement for RTM services has led to an explosion of interest from digital health companies, established providers and start-up companies in furnishing RTM services.

    Unlike remote physiological monitoring (RPM) codes, RTM allows for self-reported data from the patient and are categorized as general medicine, rather than as evaluation and management (E/M), services. RPM services, as E/M services, have been categorized by CMS as “designated care management” services, which permits billing professionals such as physicians and nurse practitioners (NPs) to bill for services furnished by clinical auxiliary personnel (generally, lower-level licensed or unlicensed personnel), provided the services were furnished under the billing professional’s general supervision and the requirements for billing “incident to” the billing professional’s services are met. “General” supervision means the procedure is furnished under the billing provider’s overall direction and control, but the billing provider’s presence is not required during the procedure. In contrast, “direct” supervision requires that the billing provider be present in the office suite and immediately available to furnish assistance and direction throughout the performance of the procedure.

    Physical therapists (PTs), occupational therapists (OTs), speech-language pathologists (SLPs) and clinical social workers (CSWs), among other similar licensed clinician types, are not generally eligible to furnish E/M services under Medicare payment requirements. These licensed clinicians could furnish RPM services under the general supervision of a physician or higher-level licensed clinician (for example, a nurse practitioner or physician assistant), but were not eligible to directly furnish and bill for RPM services. Accordingly, the availability of Medicare reimbursement for RTM services expanded the healthcare professionals who could directly provide and bill for RTM services. However, under the existing Medicare coverage and payment requirements, RTM services furnished by clinical auxiliary personnel required direct supervision by the billing professional. This, in turn, limited the ability of a PT, OT or other healthcare professional to bill for services that were provided in part by lower-level clinical auxiliary personnel.

    In the MPFS Proposed Rule issued on July 7, 2022 (the Proposed Rule), CMS proposed modifying the payment policies for RTM services by establishing four new G-codes that were intended to address these supervising and billing limitations inherent in the current RTM CPT codes. Specifically, while PTs, OTs, SLPs and CSWs were eligible to bill for RTM services, the Medicare benefits that are eligible to be furnished by these healthcare professionals do not include the ability to bill for services furnished “incident to” these individuals’ personally performed professional services. CMS noted that a primary reason for developing the RTM codes was to increase beneficiary access to remote monitoring services by allowing the services to be furnished by a broad array of qualified nonphysician healthcare professionals, but the design of the RTM codes could reduce the availability of RTM services.

    Two of the four proposed G-codes, as contemplated by the Proposed Rule, would have allowed certain non-physician qualified healthcare professionals to furnish RTM services. Meanwhile, the other two G-codes would have allowed for general supervision of auxiliary personnel by physicians and non-physician practitioners. In the Final Rule, however, CMS declined to finalize the new G-codes. CMS did, however, finalize guidance that the existing CPT codes for RTM services may be provided under general supervision, as opposed to direct supervision. In the Final Rule, CMS noted that it will continue to weigh the possible tradeoffs that would be necessary to further reduce coding and billing complexity for RTM and increase care delivery flexibility and retain appropriate beneficiary access to RTM services.

    In the Proposed Rule, CMS also requested feedback related to requests to develop a generic device code for RTM services. CMS requested information on RTM devices that could be used to deliver “reasonable and necessary” services to Medicare beneficiaries, including types of data collected using RTM devices, how data is used to assist in treating specific health conditions, and what those health conditions are, together with how long the typical episode of care may be, depending on condition type.

    In the Proposed Rule, CMS reviewed a new CPT code that is intended to be used for remote therapeutic monitoring for devices used to monitor cognitive behavioral therapy. However, during the AMA’s review of the code, specialty societies noted that the technologies for the service were still developing and there were no invoices for devices specific to cognitive behavioral therapy monitoring services that could be provided to price the code. In the Final Rule, CMS finalized its proposal to accept the AMA’s recommendation to have pricing set for the new CPT code 98978 (a PE-only device code) established by the Medicare Administrative Contractors (MACs). CMS also explained that it will work with MACs to examine devices and device costs incurred from claims for payment for the new cognitive behavioral monitoring code, CPT code 98978.

    ANALYSIS

    In line with CMS’s continuing trend of gradually expanding payment for remote monitoring services, CMS expanded the ability for RTM services to be furnished under the general supervision of the billing provider. However, there are marked differences between the Proposed Rule and the Final Rule.

    Due to concerns about the complexity of the proposed G-codes, CMS declined to finalize this proposal in the Final Rule. While commenters generally expressed support for the expansion of the non-physician healthcare professionals who could furnish and bill for RTM services, CMS explained that the totality of the comments warranted continued discussion before CMS finalizes changes to the current coding and payment policies. Some commenters expressed concern that CMS’s goals of increasing access to RTM services while reducing the associated burdens may not manifest due to the creation of four specific G-codes to replace the existing two CPT codes. Specifically, commenters noted that creating G-codes could instead generate confusion and increase the burden on RTM providers. Commenters suggested that, as an alternative to creating the proposed G-codes, CMS should modify the supervision requirements for services furnished incident to a practitioner’s professional service to require a general, rather than direct, level of supervision for the existing codes.

    CMS also noted continued public concern and confusion regarding the supervision and billing requirements for RTM services and expressed concern that finalizing the G-codes as proposed would create a possible chilling effect on the availability of RTM services. For example, CMS noted commenters’ apprehension that limitations, burdensome requirements, or possible payment denials or recovery actions may disincentivize providers from offering RTM services, thereby reducing beneficiary access. Given these concerns, the scope of the Final Rule was more limited than the Proposed Rule in that, rather than create additional G-codes, CMS merely refined the supervision and documentation requirements for RTM services under the existing codes (CPTs 98975, 98976, 98977, 98980 and 98981).

    In sum, in the Final Rule, CMS clarified and finalized its policies regarding billing requirements for the current RTM codes, effective January 1, 2023. All RTM services may be furnished under CMS’s general supervision requirements. General supervision does not require that the physician and clinical staff be in the same building at the same time as the RTM services are furnished. Rather, the billing provider may bill for services furnished by auxiliary clinical staff under general supervision, provided that the other requirements for “incident to” services are met.

    Finally, CMS discussed in the Final Rule requests from stakeholders to create a new generic RTM device code. The current RTM device codes (CPT codes 98976 and 98977) do not apply broadly to all conditions and systems encompassed by RTM. Rather, these codes are specific to devices that monitor respiratory, musculoskeletal, therapy adherence and therapy response, and do not extend to, for example, devices that monitor neurological, vascular, endocrine and digestive systems. CMS expressed concern about the ability to implement a generic device code for RTM, given the wide variability of devices that may be used and how the devices support delivery of RTM services. Finally, CMS noted that use of a generic device code could undermine the development of a wider set of specific codes for various devices that may be used to furnish RTM services.

    CMS explained in the Final Rule that it appreciated the insight from stakeholders about the key questions posed by CMS in the Proposed Rule:

    (1) RTM devices that are used to deliver services that are “reasonable and necessary” for a Medicare beneficiary
    (2) The types of data collected using RTM devices
    (3) How the data that are collected solve specific health conditions and what health conditions are particularly improved by RTM services
    (4) Costs associated with RTM devices that are available to collect RTM data
    (5) How long the typical episode of care by condition type might last
    (6) The potential number of beneficiaries for whom an RTM device might be used by the health condition type.

    While CMS did not take any action based on this feedback, it noted that it would consider stakeholder comments as it contemplates policies in future rulemaking cycles.

    Practical Implications

    There has been an explosion of interest in remote monitoring (both RTM and RPM) services over the past several years. Medicare has seen an explosion in the utilization of RPM services and it would not be surprising if there is a concomitant increase in the utilization of RTM services. With the Final Rule, CMS is aiming to reduce the coding and billing complexity for RTM services while increasing care delivery flexibility and promoting beneficiary access to RTM services. However, it remains to be seen whether CMS will accomplish these goals due to the limited nature and continued confusion regarding proper billing and supervision of RTM (and RPM) services. CMS is also actively considering the need for further guidance, education, program instructions or further rulemaking regarding remote monitoring services.

    Given the relatively quick development and implementation of CMS policies for RPM and RTM services and the increasing utilization of these codes by a wide variety of clinical specialties, affected stakeholders should monitor developments in CMS coverage and payment policies closely. CMS continues to request feedback from affected stakeholders on a wide variety of issues (as noted above), presenting the opportunity for continued engagement with CMS on these issues.

    Authors

    Caroline Reignley

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Rosalyn R. Broad

    Partner

    Austin

    Jayda Greco

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • CMS Finalizes 340B Payment Provisions in 2023 OPPS Final Rule

    CMS Finalizes 340B Payment Provisions in 2023 OPPS Final Rule

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    CMS Finalizes 340B Payment Provisions in 2023 OPPS Final Rule

    November 7, 2022

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Consistent with the US Supreme Court’s ruling in AHA v. Becerra and its statements in the 2023 Outpatient Prospective Payment System (OPPS) Proposed Rule, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) has finalized its proposal to return payments for 340B drugs under OPPS to the full average sales price (ASP) plus 6% rate, reversing the ASP minus 22.5% rate that was put in place beginning in 2018. The policy to reverse the payment cuts is included in the 2023 OPPS Final Rule released on the CMS website on November 1, 2022. Notably, the Final Rule does not address remedies for payments cuts made between 2018 and 2022 or clearly indicate whether CMS will restore payments for 340B drugs dispensed to hospital outpatients at certain off-campus locations to the ASP plus 6% payment rate.

    STAY CURRENT ON THE 340B LITIGATION THAT MAY IMPACT YOUR BUSINESS

    McDermott+Consulting has launched a 340B Litigation Tracking Tool, a real-time resource following the 40+ state and federal 340B program legal challenges. No more searching online or sorting through your newsfeed for important case developments. This tracker, available 24/7 and regularly monitored by our team, delivers concise updates to help you make informed risk analyses on what’s next for your business in the evolving 340B landscape. Learn more about the McDermott+ 340B Litigation Tracker.

    In depth

    Background

    Beginning in 2018, CMS implemented a 28.5% reduction to payments for most drugs purchased through the 340B Program and paid under OPPS, lowering the reimbursement amounts from ASP plus 6% to ASP minus 22.5%. (PPS-exempt cancer hospitals, PPS-exempt children’s hospitals, and rural sole community hospitals that participate in the 340B Program and are paid under OPPS were not subject to the payment cuts. Critical access hospitals are not paid under OPPS and therefore were not subject to the payment cuts.)

    The payment reduction was implemented in a “budget neutral” manner, such that the estimated dollars of the payment reduction for 340B drugs were used to increase payments on other items and services paid under OPPS. Hospitals subject to the reductions immediately sued the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) in federal district court, alleging that HHS did not have the authority to reduce 340B reimbursement rates in this manner. Ultimately, the hospitals prevailed in the Supreme Court. Further litigation related to the remedies for the past payment cuts is continuing in the US District Court for the District of Columbia. (For more information, see our previous client alerts on payment cuts and litigation: “CMS cuts payments for most 340B drugs,” “Court issues permanent injunction blocking Medicare 340B payment cuts,” “July surprise – Supreme Court agrees to review Medicare payment cuts to 340B drugs,” “DC Circuit upholds OPPS reimbursement reductions for 340B drugs,” and “District court vacates 340B cuts, but don’t expect immediate payment rate restoration.” )

    In the 2023 OPPS Proposed Rule, CMS formally proposed continuing the payment cuts, but noted that the Supreme Court decision occurred after the proposed rule had been prepared and that CMS actually intended to restore payments to the full ASP plus 6% rate in the Final Rule. CMS further indicated that the payment restoration would be accompanied by a reduction in the amount paid for other items and services under OPPS to ensure the payment increase was budget neutral. In addition to the 2023 payment rate proposal, CMS solicited comments from the public on how to remedy the payment cuts to 340B drug reimbursement rates for calendar years 2018-2022.

    2023 Final Rule

    As previewed in the Proposed Rule, the Final Rule restores payments for 340B drugs to ASP plus 6% and incorporates a corresponding budget neutrality adjustment to decrease payments on other items and services paid under OPPS by 3.09%. This adjustment amount is more favorable than the proposed budget neutrality adjustment of 4.04% set forth in the Proposed Rule, which would have canceled out the annual payment adjustment and resulted in lower payments under OPPS in 2023 than in 2022. The revised budget neutrality adjustment set forth in the Final Rule was calculated to correspond to (and therefore offset) the budget neutrality increase that was implemented in 2018, rather than to offset the costs associated with the restoration of the ASP plus 6% rate for 340B drugs.

    CMS responded to submissions in response to its request for comments on remedies for 340B claims paid at the reduced rate between 2018 and 2022, but indicated that it will issue a separate proposed rule addressing the remedy at some point prior to the release of the 2024 OPPS proposed rule (which is typically released in July).

    ANALYSIS

    Although the decision to pay for 340B drugs at the full ASP plus 6% rate for 2023 is favorable to hospitals previously subject to the payment cuts, the Final Rule does not represent the end of discussions related to the payment rates. Several issues remain outstanding and subject to continued—and possible future—litigation, following the Final Rule.

    A key concern for all hospitals paid under OPPS is the budget neutrality adjustment associated with both restoring the ASP plus 6% payment rate for 340B drugs as well as future adjustments implemented as part of any remedy to rectify the payment cuts for 340B drugs that were made from 2018 to 2022. Hospitals argued in the comments that CMS is not required to, nor does it have statutory authority to, make budget neutrality adjustments to offset the restoration of past and future payments for 340B drugs. CMS argues that it is required to ensure that the 340B payment policy does not result in additional outlays of federal funds, a view shared by the Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (MedPAC) in public comments on the Final Rule. MedPAC estimates the additional costs to the government if the payments are not budget neutral as approximately $2 billion for each year of the cuts. Rather than address the retrospective budget neutrality issue in the Final Rule, CMS opted to defer the issue until sometime in 2023.

    The Final Rule does not clarify the period for which CMS will be making future decisions on remedies and the dates for which the ASP plus 6% payments have been restored. CMS began paying for 340B drugs at the full ASP plus 6% rate beginning on September 28, 2022, in response to a court order in the ongoing remedies litigation. Some Medicare contractors have indicated that they will also reprocess claims back to January 1, 2022, at the higher rate, but this policy is not reflected in the Final Rule. The Final Rule suggests that CMS is still evaluating possible remedies for claims in 2022 prior to September 28 of that year.

    CMS also did not explicitly restore the full OPPS payment rate for 340B drugs dispensed at “non-excepted” off-campus outpatient locations. When CMS initially implemented the payment cuts in 2018, the payment cuts applied only to drugs dispensed at locations that were “excepted” from the “Section 603” site neutral payment provisions. This is because drugs dispensed at non-excepted locations (those off-campus locations that first billed Medicare after November 1, 2015) are considered to be paid under the Medicare Physician Fee Schedule, not OPPS. CMS expanded the 340B payment cuts to non-excepted locations in 2019 by reducing the payments under a different statutory provision than the one that applies to drugs paid under OPPS, and the Final Rule does not clearly address whether payments for 340B drugs at these locations will be returned to the full ASP plus 6% level in 2023.

    Finally, CMS will still require use of the “JG” and “TB” modifiers on claims for 340B drugs for informational purposes (both modifiers were introduced in 2018 to identify 340B drugs, and the use of modifier “JG” was intended to automatically trigger the payment cut for 340B drugs). CMS states that it still needs to collect information on 340B drugs dispensed to Medicare beneficiaries, even though no payment adjustment will be applied to claims with the modifiers.

    Authors

    Emily Jane Cook

    Partner

    Los Angeles, Washington, DC

    Cathy Ren

    Partner

    Los Angeles

    Kelsey R. Reinhardt

    Associate

    Los Angeles

    More insights

  • “Land Register Goes Transparency Register” – What Land Data Will Be Kept in the Transparency Register as of 2023

    “Land Register Goes Transparency Register” – What Land Data Will Be Kept in the Transparency Register as of 2023

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    “Land Register Goes Transparency Register” – What Land Data Will Be Kept in the Transparency Register as of 2023

    November 4, 2022

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Düsseldorf, November 4, 2022 – On October 26, 2022, the German Cabinet approved a draft bill for a Second Act on the More Effective Enforcement of Sanctions (Sanctions Enforcement Act II). The law is intended to continue and structurally improve the options for enforcing sanctions.

    In depth
    Authors

    Thomas A. Beisken, LL.M.

    Partner

    Düsseldorf

    Dr. Jens Ortmanns

    Partner

    Düsseldorf, Cologne

    More insights

  • Financial Institutions Invited to Comment on CFPB’s Initial Sketch of New Consumer Data Rights Rule

    Financial Institutions Invited to Comment on CFPB’s Initial Sketch of New Consumer Data Rights Rule

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Financial Institutions Invited to Comment on CFPB’s Initial Sketch of New Consumer Data Rights Rule

    November 3, 2022

    Read time: 10 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (“CFPB”) is beginning to craft a data portability rule it hopes will foster greater competition and consumer choice (the “Data Rule”).[1] The initial draft of the Data Rule applies to “financial institutions” under Regulation E and “credit card issuers” under Regulation Z.[2] This covers “financial institutions offering deposit accounts, credit cards, digital wallets, prepaid cards, and other transaction accounts.”[3] It would also reach companies who provide electronic fund transfer services through an “access device” even if that company does not hold the account.[4]

    The CFPB is seeking input from regulated entities to assist it in crafting these regulations. The burden the ultimate Data Rule will impose is far from clear. In addition to the costs of complying with an entirely new regulation, covered entities will also have to confront the technical challenge of making the data they hold accessible “upon request” to the universe of recipients the Data Rule envisions. The potential solutions are difficult to anticipate from the thumbnail sketch the CFPB’s current proposal provides.

    While Congress required that the CFPB specifically consult with small businesses in order to address the special burdens they will face, all regulated entities are invited to submit comments.

    Section 1033

    The Dodd-Frank Act provides that consumers have the right to request the information that a financial institution has about the consumer financial product or service the institution provided the consumer — but only once the CFPB implements regulations for how to do this.[5] The information could include, but is not limited to, the consumer’s transaction history, or the costs, charges or usage data related to that consumer.[6]

    Limited Existing Law on Consumer Data

    The CFPB acknowledges that there is little existing federal law on consumer data privacy, data rights or cybersecurity. For example, the Fair Credit Reporting Act (“FCRA”) protects the detailed personal information consumer reporting agencies and credit bureaus collect by limiting the “permissible purposes” for which they can release that information.[7] Additionally, the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (“GLBA”) and Regulation P require banking institutions to provide a notice of privacy practices to consumers at onboarding and annually thereafter.[8]

    Even though the CFPB administers these regulations, Director Chopra complained that “Much of [existing regulation] involves financial institutions handing consumers a lot of fine print that they may not even read, like those financial privacy notices companies send.”[9] He specifically criticized the GLBA’s “notice and opt-out regime” that in his view does not “give consumers meaningful control over how their data is being used.”[10]

    Some state laws, like the California Consumer Privacy Act/California Privacy Rights Act (“CCPA/CPRA”), grant individual consumers certain rights to control their data. A federal Data Rule is thus certain to break new ground by offering nationwide rights to individual consumers.

    The Benefits the CFPB Aims to Achieve

    The CFPB expects that its Data Rule will enhance competition. Once a consumer can require an existing service provider to share all of the consumer’s transaction history, the consumer can transition to a new provider as if they were a long-time customer. Director Chopra analogizes this ease of switching to the right to keep your phone number when you choose a new carrier — even though the old carrier does not transfer call logs and text chats to the new provider.[11]

    The Data Rule could also foster innovation. A consumer can grant a platform access to information from multiple providers to more easily manage their money, apply for credit or shop for lower fees. Currently, consumers often grant a third-party service visibility into an account by sharing their login credentials. In addition to the security concerns of sharing usernames and passwords, these services do not have real access to the underlying data, but only the web platforms the institution provides. As a result, the services engage in “screen scraping,” attempting to read the information from the webpage. If consumers had the right to require the institution to share the actual data with an authorized third-party, consumers would know the information they see in the third-party service is accurate, and would not have to reveal their passwords to enable the connection.[12]

    Recognizing that many financial institutions will not have the capacity to transfer consumer data themselves, the proposal envisions the emergence of “data aggregators” who will facilitate collecting the information from the origin financial institution and transmitting it to the consumer or an authorized third-party.[13]

    Looking further ahead, Director Chopra even envisions a new approach to credit, based on a lender’s direct access to the consumer’s transaction history rather than opaque three-digit credit scores.[14]

    Proposals Under Consideration

    The CFPB released a detailed outline of its anticipated proposals and a long list of questions on which it is seeking input.[15] Specifically, the CFPB is inviting comment on:

    Who Will Be Subject to the Data Rule. As noted above, the CFPB intends for the Data Rule to focus on accounts, including digital wallets, access devices, prepaid cards, credit cards and others presently subject to Regulation E or Regulation Z. The Data Rule may adjust the scope of the providers and accounts it governs, and may provide exemptions.[16]

    Who Can Receive Information. The CFPB’s proposal departs from the statute, which only commands institutions to make the consumer’s information “available to the consumer.”[17] To achieve its competition and innovation aims, the CFPB reads these words as empowering consumers to direct institutions to make their information available to whoever the consumer authorizes. Among other things, this broad reading requires the Data Rule to spell out how to obtain the consumer’s “informed, express consent” for the transfer, and intends to impose disclosure and compliance certification requirements on the third-party recipients.[18]

    What Third Parties Cannot Do With the Data. The CFPB is considering limiting authorized third parties’ processing, collection, use and retention of consumer financial data to what is “reasonably necessary to provide the product or service the consumer has requested.”[19] These obligations may include capping the maximum duration for a consumer authorization, providing methods for the consumer to revoke the authorization and prohibiting certain uses of the data.

    How Covered Entities Must Demonstrate Their Compliance. Covered entities may be required to maintain certain records to confirm their compliance with the Data Rule. Importantly, as Section 1033 emphasizes, covered entities are not obligated “to maintain or keep any information about a consumer.”[20] The inclination against storing consumer information echoes the CFPB’s concern with the “immense amounts of granular consumer data” some of the largest companies collect.[21]

    What Types of Information Should Be Made Available. The CFPB anticipates requiring institutions to supply the consumer data regarding: (1) periodic statement information regarding transactions and deposits that have settled; (2) transactions and deposits that have not yet settled; (3) prior transactions that are not typically shown on periodic statements; (4) online banking transactions that the consumer has prepared but have not yet occurred; (5) account identity information; and (6) “consumer reports obtained and used by the covered data provider in deciding whether to provide an account or other financial product or service.”[22]

    How and When Information Must Be Made Available. Consumer financial data would be made available directly to the consumer when a covered entity has “enough information from the consumer to reasonably authenticate the consumer’s identity and reasonably identify the information requested.”[23] With respect to third-party access, covered entities may be required to establish a third-party access portal, which the CFPB recognizes will pose burdens on covered entities and may also create new security issues.

    When the Data Rule Should Take Effect. Realizing that it will take time for covered entities to come into compliance and that the Data Rule is completely new, the CFPB is interested in the factors that should inform the appropriate timeline, including whether there should be a second phase for rolling out a requirement that covered entities establish their third-party portal.[24]

    Conclusion

    The CFPB’s entry into the consumer data space is novel in substance and approach. Director Chopra hinted that the Data Rule is the first in paradigm shift that would retire regulations that serve to entrench existing business models and prioritize technical compliance over consumers’ actual experiences, in favor of a generation of “procompetitive regulations” that could, among other things, “reduce switching costs or barriers to entry, promote price transparency and shopping, reduce conflicts of interest, and place limits on business activity in order to ensure that firms don’t exploit their control over critical networks.”[25]

    Financial institutions subject to Regulation E and credit card issuers subject to Regulation Z, who will be the first to have to comply with the Data Rule, should take this opportunity to shape the Rule and limit its associated burdens. The requirement to open transaction history upon request will sometimes conflict with other state and federal laws, and by creating more ways to access consumers’ personal information may impair the security and privacy of that information.

    The CFPB is accepting comment until January 25, 2023.[26]

    Schulte Roth & Zabel’s lawyers are available to assist you in preparing a public comment or addressing any questions you may have regarding these developments. Please contact the Schulte Roth & Zabel lawyer with whom you usually work, or any of the following attorneys:

    Donald J. Mosher – New York (+1 212.756.2187)

    Alexander M. Kim – New York (+1 212.756.2075)

    Melissa G.R. Goldstein – Washington, DC (+1 202.729.7471)

    Kara A. Kuchar – New York (+1 212.756.2734)

    Adam J. Barazani – New York (+1 212.756.2519)

    Jessica Romano – New York (+1 212.756.2205)

    Jessica Sklute – New York (+1 212.756.2180)

    Noah N. Gillespie – Washington, DC (+1 202.729.7483)

    Hadas A. Jacobi – New York (+1 212.756.2055)

    Rebecca A. Raskind – New York (+1 212.756.2396)


    [1] Press Release, CFPB Kicks Off Personal Financial Data Rights Rulemaking (Oct. 27, 2022), (“Press Release”).

    [2] CFPB, High-Level Summary and Discussion Guide of Outline of Proposals and Alternatives Under Consideration for SBREFA: Required Rulemaking on Personal Financial Data Rights, at 4 (Oct. 27, 2022), (“High Level Summary”).

    [3] Director Chopra, Speech, Prepared Remarks at Money 20/20, at 4 (Oct. 25, 2022), (“Money 20/20”).

    [4] High Level Summary at 4 (citing 12 C.F.R. § 1005.2(a)(1)).

    [5] In full, this section states “Subject to rules prescribed by the Bureau, a covered person shall make available to a consumer, upon request, information in the control or possession of the covered person concerning the consumer financial product or service that the consumer obtained from such covered person, including information relating to any transaction, series of transactions, or to the account including costs, charges and usage data. The information shall be made available in an electronic form usable by consumers.” 12 U.S.C. § 5533(a).

    [6] See id.

    [7] 15 U.S.C. §§ 1681b, 1681d.

    [8] 12 C.F.R. §§ 1016.4-.9.

    [9] Money 20/20, at 2.

    [10] Id. at 5.

    [11] Id. at 2.

    [12] Id. at 3; High Level Summary at 9-10.

    [13] High Level Summary at 2 n.3.

    [14] Money 20/20, at 4.

    [15] See Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Small Business Advisory Review Panel for Required Rulemaking on Personal Financial Data Rights, Outline of Proposals and Alternatives Under Consideration (Oct. 27, 2022).

    [16] High Level Summary at 4.

    [17] 12 U.S.C. § 5533(a).

    [18] High Level Summary at 5.

    [19] Id. at 15.

    [20] 12 U.S.C. § 5533(c).

    [21] E.g., CFPB, Final Rule, Limited Applicability of Consumer Financial Protection Act’s “Time or Space” Exception with Respect to Digital Marketing Providers, 87 Fed. Reg. 50,556, 50,557 (Aug. 27, 2022).

    [22] High Level Summary at 7.

    [23] Id. at 9.

    [24] Id. at 20-21.

    [25] Money 20/20 at 2 (cleaned up).

    [26] Press Release.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2022 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Donald J. Mosher

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Melissa G.R. Goldstein

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Adam J. Barazani

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • DOJ Prosecutes Attempted Collusion among Business Competitors for First Time in Decades

    DOJ Prosecutes Attempted Collusion among Business Competitors for First Time in Decades

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    DOJ Prosecutes Attempted Collusion among Business Competitors for First Time in Decades

    November 1, 2022

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On October 31, 2022, the US Department of Justice’s (DOJ) Antitrust Division (Division) made good on its intention earlier this year to revitalize efforts surrounding criminal enforcement of Section 2 of the Sherman Act when the president of a paving and asphalt contractor in Montana pleaded guilty to one count of attempting to monopolize the market for certain construction services in Montana and Wyoming. This is the Division’s first criminal prosecution of a Section 2 case in approximately 50 years. While criminal enforcement of antitrust laws has traditionally focused on per se anticompetitive agreements between two or more horizontal competitors, Section 2 primarily focuses on conduct by one firm or company with significant market power. This announcement—and subsequent criminal resolution—marks a significant departure from long-standing DOJ antitrust enforcement of monopolization claims and is a landmark result for the Division’s continued expansion of its criminal enforcement efforts.

    Most notably, seemingly unilateral conduct that “attempts” to collude is now subject to criminal prosecution under Section 2, even if such an attempt did not result in any agreement. In contrast, there is no “attempt” component of a Sherman Act Section 1 charge, where the Division has traditionally investigated and prosecuted per se criminal price fixing, bid rigging and market allocation conduct requiring an agreement or “meeting of the minds” between horizontal competitors.

    According to court documents, the DOJ alleged that Nathan Nephi Zito attempted to monopolize the markets for highway crack sealing services administered by Montana and Wyoming by proposing that his company and its competitor allocate regional markets. Zito approached a competitor about a “strategic partnership” and proposed that his company would stop competing for projects administered by South Dakota and Nebraska and the competitor would stop competing for projects administered by Montana and Wyoming. Zito allegedly offered a $100,000 payment as additional compensation for lost business in Montana and Wyoming and proposed that they enter into a transaction to “disguise their collusion.” The competitor company then approached the government and cooperated in its investigation, including by recording phone calls with Zito.

    This case, the first Section 2 criminal resolution in decades, was prosecuted in coordination with the Procurement Collusion Strike Force (PCSF), which remains a top priority for the DOJ. The PCSF has been quite active in recent months, obtaining several convictions and bringing new indictments.

    Although Section 2 is regularly associated with unilateral monopolist conduct, it also makes it a crime to attempt to monopolize or to conspire to monopolize. The “attempt” provision is what the Division relied on to obtain a conviction in this case, which is essentially an attempted but unconsummated Section 1 market allocation case where one of the potential conspirators cooperated with the government rather than entering into a potentially collusive agreement.

    Key takeaways from this case include the following:

    • Now companies need to consider potentially collusive agreements with competitors—or attempts to do the same—that may exclude other competitors from a market in their antitrust risk evaluations. In practice, this could significantly broaden the scope of any compliance or internal investigation to include all competitor communications, not only to determine which ones may have constituted an agreement but to determine which ones have made attempts to reach an agreement as well, even if no meeting of the minds occurred.
    • This case also broadens the range of potential criminal conduct falling short of an agreement or meeting of the minds between alleged horizontal competitors, expanding the complexities of risk evaluations for corporate compliance and risk officers and corporate executives.
    • This prosecution underscores the importance of continuing ongoing compliance reviews and audits, including developing controls around and identifying communications with competitors and responding to another company’s solicitation to collaborate or enter into a potentially collusive agreement.
    In depth
    Authors

    Paul M. Thompson

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • Fun for the Whole Family: More ACA Subsidies Apply

    Fun for the Whole Family: More ACA Subsidies Apply

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Fun for the Whole Family: More ACA Subsidies Apply

    November 1, 2022

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On October 11, 2022, the US Department of Treasury (Treasury) and the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) issued final regulations to modify how affordability under the Affordable Care Act (ACA) is determined for an offer of coverage to a family member by an employer-sponsored group health plan, effective for the tax year beginning after December 31, 2022. By changing the affordability analysis to look at the total cost to cover family members—rather than the cost to only the employee—the new rule expands eligibility to receive premium tax credits (PTCs) in the ACA marketplace to an employee’s spouse and dependents.

    In depth

    BACKGROUND

    The final rule is intended to resolve the “family glitch,” an inadvertent consequence of how affordability was previously determined by the ACA that caused family members to be disqualified from obtaining PTCs in the ACA marketplace. The ACA requires employer-sponsored health plans to offer coverage that meets the minimum value requirements and is affordable, but affordability was based only on the cost of coverage to the employee—not the employee’s family members. Prior to the implementation of the final rule, if a household member had access to employer-sponsored health coverage that met the minimum value and affordability requirements, the family members were disqualified from PTCs for the ACA marketplace. As a result, the family coverage offered by an employer might be unaffordable to the family members, but the spouses and dependents were still ineligible for PTCs for the ACA marketplace based on the affordability of employee-only coverage. The new rule changes the determination of whether family members are eligible for tax subsidies for the ACA marketplace to be based on the offer of coverage to a spouse or dependent.

    FINAL RULE

    1. Affordability and Minimum Value

    The final rule indicates that an offer of coverage from an employer-sponsored health plan is affordable for an employee’s family member if the cost of family coverage does not exceed 9.5% of household income, as adjusted annually. For 2023, the percentage is 9.12%. Similar to the existing regulations for an employee-only offer of coverage, a health plan is considered to provide minimum value to a family member if it has at least a 60% actuarial value and provides “substantial coverage” of inpatient hospital services and physician services. If the scope of benefits and cost-sharing offered to employees is the same as to family members, then the final rule clarifies that this will be considered minimum value.

    2. Employer Mandate 

    Even though affordability for family members will now be based on the cost of family coverage, affordability for employees under the employer mandate remains the same. As a result, the final rule confirmed that the liability of a large employer under the employer mandate will be unaffected by the new rule and penalties would only be assessed on the employer if the coverage is not affordable based on employee-only coverage. This is because the ACA only requires employer-sponsored health plans to provide minimum value and affordable coverage to employees. This differs from the requirement that the employer-sponsored health plans offer minimum essential coverage to full-time employees and their dependents, a much lower threshold. Thus, an employer can still avoid penalties under the ACA by offering coverage only to employees that meets both the minimum value and affordability requirements. However, any family members of such employees may now be eligible for a PTC if the coverage is not affordable based on the cost of family coverage—but this will not result in an employer mandate penalty to the employer. In addition, the final rules clarify that the safe harbors an employer may use to determine affordability under the employer mandate regulations also remain unchanged.

    NOTICE 2022-41

    Treasury and the IRS simultaneously issued Notice 2022-41 in connection with the final rule to permit employers with non-calendar year plans to amend their Section 125 plans (also known as a cafeteria plan or a flexible spending account plan) to allow for a midyear election change. Family members could then drop their employer-sponsored health plan coverage and move to the ACA marketplace if newly eligible for a PTC. This would take place either during annual open enrollment or during a special enrollment period for the ACA marketplace. The guidance is permissive and applies only to group health plan coverage that is minimum essential coverage under the ACA, not flexible spending accounts. The notice applies to elections effective on and after January 1, 2023. The expectation is that the regulations will eventually result in a decrease in employer spending, though few individuals may move to the ACA marketplace initially.

    NEXT STEPS

    It may be too late for employers who have finalized annual enrollment materials to consider plan design changes in response to the new rule. Other employers, though, may be tempted to increase the cost of family coverage to motivate the migration of spouses and dependents from the employer-sponsored health plan and allow family members to qualify for a PTC in the ACA marketplace. Employers should consider whether any such changes could cause low-risk spouses and dependents to move to the ACA marketplace, creating an imbalance of at-risk individuals covered by the plan. A change in the cost of family coverage might also be considered a special mid-year election change event under certain Section 125 plans, but employers would need to consider whether plan amendment and summary plan description changes are necessary to implement this change.

    It is anticipated that the final rule will be met with legal challenges. Regardless, employers should begin consulting with legal counsel and their health plan brokers and vendors to determine the best course of action for their health plans going forward.

    Authors

    Jacob M. Mattinson

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • CMS Downshifts on Expectations for Covered Healthcare Provider Staff COVID-19 Vaccination

    CMS Downshifts on Expectations for Covered Healthcare Provider Staff COVID-19 Vaccination

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    CMS Downshifts on Expectations for Covered Healthcare Provider Staff COVID-19 Vaccination

    October 31, 2022

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    CMS released guidance for surveyors that provides leeway in surveying for compliance with the November 2021 interim final rule with comment that imposed a vaccination mandate for most staff at certain covered provider types.

    In depth

    Healthcare providers impacted by the November 2021 interim final rule with comment (IFR) that effectively imposed a vaccination mandate for staff may be surprised by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) Quality and Safety Oversight Group memorandum issued October 26, 2022 (QSO-23-02-ALL) (updated QSO memo), which provides surveyors with newfound flexibility in determining levels of noncompliance with the IRC. This shift in approach is attributed to national efforts to attain a high level of vaccination and relatively low levels of hospitalization and death from Sars-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19.

    For hospitals, critical access hospitals, ambulatory surgery centers, hospice providers and other covered providers other than long-term care facilities and skilled nursing facilities, surveyors may now cite noncompliance at less than a “condition” level absent “egregious noncompliance.”

    While the new guidance from CMS continues to identify a less than 100% vaccinated staff or lack of even one vaccination-related policy as “noncompliance,” surveyors are instructed to look for egregious noncompliance and absence of “good faith” efforts to comply before citing a condition-level finding, the type of which would trigger the need for a plan of correction and follow-up survey activity. “Egregious noncompliance” is described as a circumstance…

    • …such as a complete disregard for the [CMS vaccination mandate] requirements…more than 50% of staff being unvaccinated (unless exempted, or temporarily delayed), and/or policies and procedures have not been implemented as required.

    For long-term care facilities and skilled nursing facilities, the updated QSO memo provides that facilities that are noncompliant but have “implemented a plan to achieve” a 100% staff vaccination rate would not be subject to an enforcement action. Surveyors are instructed to cite the level of severity and scope for noncompliance for Tag F888 (pertaining to vaccination compliance and related requirements) at severity level 1, with a scope of widespread, or “C.” Similar to the way in which the terms are defined for hospitals and other provider types, egregious noncompliance is described as “a complete disregard for the requirements” or “more than 50% of staff being unvaccinated” and without having requisite policies and procedures in place.

    Surveyors for all covered provider types are instead pointed toward a more wholistic approach that considers, regardless of staff vaccination compliance, a facility’s…

    • …infection prevention and control practices…such as proper use of personal protective equipment, transmission precautions which reflect current standards of practice, and/or other relevant infection prevention and control practices that are designed to minimize transmission of COVID-19.

    Prior guidance, detailed in our prior On the Subject, included a much more stringent approach, and over time, in conjunction with state healthcare vaccination mandates, was sometimes identified as one of the bases for covered providers’ decisions to terminate unvaccinated staff (examples here and here) to avoid threats to their provider agreements due to noncompliance.

    Covered providers should evaluate their current compliance with the CMS vaccination requirement in light of the updated QSO memo and consider updating existing policies and procedures to reflect this change in approach and interpretation.

    Authors

    Sandra M. DiVarco

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • The DOL Has Issued New Proposed Independent Contractor Classification Rules: What Now?

    The DOL Has Issued New Proposed Independent Contractor Classification Rules: What Now?

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    The DOL Has Issued New Proposed Independent Contractor Classification Rules: What Now?

    October 27, 2022

    Read time: 11 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On October 11, 2022, the United States Department of Labor (DOL) issued its Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM) seeking to undo the Trump administration’s 2021 independent contractor regulations and revert to the six-factor economic realities test. While the test factors remain the same (for the most part), the DOL’s NPRM advances interpretations of the various factors that support employment status at every turn.

    In depth

    LEGAL OVERVIEW

    For years, the DOL and federal courts have applied a five or six-factor “economic realities” test looking at the totality of the circumstances. Each factor is reviewed with a lens towards assessing whether the worker is economically dependent on the employer for work or in business for him or herself. These six factors are:

    1. Worker’s Opportunity for Profit or Loss Depending on Managerial Skill
    2. Investments by the Worker relative to the Employer’s Investment
    3. Degree of Permanence of the Work Relationship
    4. Nature and Degree of Control by the Employer (specifically: scheduling, supervision, price-setting, and ability to work for others)
    5. Extent to Which the Work Performed is an Integral Part of the Employer’s Business
    6. Skill and Initiative

    While no one factor is to be dispositive or given additional weight, various courts have held that the control factor should be afforded the most weight.

    In January 2021, near the end of President Trump’s presidency, the DOL, led by Eugene Scalia at the time, issued a final rule that gave lip service to the economic realities test and instead primarily considered two “core” factors: (1) the degree of control exercised or retained by the employer, and (2) the worker’s opportunity for profit or loss. Under this two-core factor test, an individual was presumptively an independent contractor if he/she exercised substantial control over for whom, when and on which specific projects he/she would work. If the two core factors were not determinative, the DOL instructed the courts and parties to assess three other “guideposts”: (3) the amount of skill required for the work; (4) the degree of permanence of the working relationship between the worker and the employer; and (5) whether the work is part of an integrated unit of production.

    Shortly before the DOL rule was set to take effect in March 2021, the Biden administration ushered in new leadership into the DOL naming Marty Walsh as Secretary of Labor, and under Walsh’s leadership, the DOL issued rules seeking to delay the effective date of the previously announced rule and ultimately withdrew it.

    On March 14, 2022, the withdrawal plans hit a snag when Judge Marcia Crone of the US District Court of the Eastern District of Texas opined that the DOL had not followed the proper procedures under the Administrative Procedure Act and voided the DOL’s withdrawal plans.

    WHY ARE THE PROPOSED REGULATIONS IMPORTANT?

    These new proposed regulations signal that the DOL is again attempting to “crack down” on the perceived misclassification of independent contractors by interpreting the economic realities test in a manner that will tilt towards employee status.

    It appears from the NPRM that the DOL is laser-focused on undercutting the specific arguments that companies (especially gig industry companies) have successfully advanced in courts to substantiate independent contractor status. The proposed regulations do this in a multitude of ways:

    • Control: The DOL not only deemphasizes the control factor (by among other things analyzing it close to last), but it also reformulates how this factor should be analyzed. In language aimed at the gig industry companies, the NPRM emphasizes that “employers may also exercise control in other ways, such as by relying on technology to supervise a workforce, setting prices for services, or restricting a worker’s ability to work for others—actions that can exert control without the traditional use of direct supervision, assignment, or scheduling.” This language is aimed at countering the fact that companies have learned to work with independent contractors without controlling them. The NPRM is also seeking to change the game by contending that the courts should consider as evidence of control “restrictions that result from a companies’ legal, safety, or quality control obligations.” To the DOL, control is control, no matter the reason.
    • Integral part of the employer’s business: Conversely, while the DOL is attempting to devalue the control factor, it appears to be placing greater emphasis on the integral to the business component. Indeed, the DOL pronounced that work that is integral to the hiring party’s primary business offering can only be performed by employees.
    • Opportunity for profit or loss: The NPRM narrowly construes the contractor’s opportunity for profit or loss in a manner that will make it very difficult for many gig industry workers and sole proprietors to qualify as independent contractors. Towards this end, the DOL delineated the following considerations that they say bear on this inquiry, including (a) whether the worker determines the charge or pay for the work provided (or at least can meaningfully negotiate it); (b) whether the worker accepts or declines jobs or chooses or can meaningfully negotiate the order and/or time in which the jobs are performed; (c) whether the worker engages in marketing, advertising or other efforts to expand their business or secure more work; and (d) whether the worker makes decisions to hire others, purchase materials and equipment and/or rent space (as opposed to the amount and nature of the worker’s investment).
    • Investments by workers and the employer: The NPRM requires a comparison of the worker’s investment relative to the hiring party. The DOL explained that any investments by the contractor should “serve a business-like function, such as increasing the worker’s ability to do different types of or more work, reducing costs, or extending market reach.” This interpretation is clearly designed to buttress the argument that a solo delivery driver or worker toiling away for a multi-billion-dollar gig company is an employee. To this end, the NPRM makes clear that the use of a personal vehicle that the worker already owns or leases to perform work is not an entrepreneurial investment covered by the spirit of the economic realities.
    • Degree of permanence: The DOL remarks on the one hand that “working exclusively for a particular employer speaks to the permanence of the work relationship” but that “working for others and having multiple jobs in which workers are economically dependent on each employer for work— as compared to a worker who is in business for themself and chooses to market their independent services or labor to multiple entities—does not weigh in favor of independent contractor status.” This interpretation is designed to undercut the valid argument that gig economy workers are free to choose which companies they will work with and when they will do so—sometimes working for both at the same time.

    WHAT IMPACT WILL THE REGULATIONS HAVE?

    If the proposed rules go into effect, it is very likely that industry groups will seek to invalidate the regulations.

    Additionally, the new rule, if adopted, will make it harder for companies to establish at the audit stage that individuals are independent contractors. It is also reasonable to expect that the current iteration of the DOL will seek to initiate investigations of companies that engage large groups of independent contractors to serve the same business function.

    However, the new rule is unlikely to have any significant impact on how courts analyze the question of whether an individual is an employee or an independent contractor. Courts are unlikely to assign significant deference to the DOL’s frequently shifting positions.

    It is also worth noting that the NPRM adopted the economic realities test rather than California’s ABC test which President Biden favored and lauded numerous times on the campaign trail. Under the ABC test, a business must establish that an individual satisfies all three elements in order to be an independent contractor: (a) the worker is free from the control and direction of the hiring party in connection with the performance of the work, both under the contract for the performance of the work and in fact; and (b) that the worker performs work that is outside the usual course of the hiring entity’s business; and (c) that the worker is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation or business of the same nature as that involved in the work performed. The DOL in issuing its NPRM recognized, however, that “because the ABC test is inconsistent with Supreme Court precedent interpreting the FLSA (Fair Labor Standards Act), the Department believes that it could only implement an ABC test if the Supreme Court revisits its precedent or if Congress passes legislation that alters the applicable analysis under the FLSA.”

    Of course, employers must continue to ensure that they comply with wage and hour laws in jurisdictions like California and Massachusetts that utilize the ABC tests.

    TAX LIABILITIES AND BENEFITS ISSUES

    Worker classification issues also impact federal tax liability, especially employment taxes. Generally, if a worker is classified as an employee, the employer must withhold and deposit federal income taxes (FITW) while also withholding and depositing both the employee and employer share of Federal Insurance Contributions Act (FICA) taxes on wage payments. However, if a worker is classified as an independent contractor, this tax liability shifts from the employer to the worker. As such, independent contractors are legally obligated to pay both the employee and employer shares of the FICA taxes (as self-employment (SECA) taxes) while also paying estimated income taxes. Conversely, if the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) reclassifies an independent contractor as an employee, the business faces full-rate tax exposure for these payroll taxes of about 35% of the amounts paid to the independent contractor over the past three years.

    In addition, the employer may also be required to provide to the worker certain benefits it makes available to other employees, including retirement and health and welfare benefits. Most health plans and tax-qualified retirement plans exclude independent contractors from coverage. Without an express plan document provision to the contrary, an independent contractor that is reclassified as an employee may become eligible for coverage—including retroactive coverage—under a plan. Some employers address this issue by including express language in their plans that excludes reclassified workers from coverage to protect an employer from claims for retroactive coverage and enable the employer to exclude reclassified workers from future coverage.

    It is important to note that the NPRM only addresses whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor under the FLSA. The IRS has its own set of guidelines to determine worker classification for tax purposes, including payroll and benefits. While the preamble of the NPRM states that employers are likely to keep the status of most workers the same, the determination of worker classification for tax purposes is not bound by the NPRM, even if finalized. Therefore, a worker can be an employee under these proposed rules but remain an independent contractor for tax purposes. While guidance under the IRS and the DOL differ, there is regular communication between these two agencies. Thus, it is reasonable to assume that employee misclassification audits under the IRS might increase over the coming years. Fortunately, proper plan documentation and several statutory and regulatory relief provisions can protect businesses from the draconian effects of IRS independent contractor audits, including one tax law provision that, if satisfied, allows employers to continue to treat workers as independent contractors without any past or future federal employment tax liability, regardless of whether the workers are actual common law employees. This relief provision does not determine whether a worker is an independent contractor or an employee but merely provides employers relief from such employment tax liabilities associated with worker misclassification.

    WHAT SHOULD COMPANIES DO NEXT?

    Employers have until November 28, 2022, to submit any comments to the DOL on the proposed rule. The rule will likely be effective in late 2023 or early 2024.

    Companies should also not wait to audit their practices for engaging independent contractors and implement systems to best protect themselves, especially if independent contractors are a significant component of the company’s workforce. Although the language of an independent contractor agreement is not dispositive, employers should seek counsel to ensure that their agreements reinforce the independent contractor relationship and do not on their face support employment status.

    Authors

    Joseph Mulherin

    Partner

    Chicago

    Jennifer D. Hill

    Associate

    Atlanta

    More insights

  • Remote Working 2022: Global Trends

    Remote Working 2022: Global Trends

    ARTICLE

    Remote Working 2022: Global Trends

    October 27, 2022

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In a global interview panel led by McDermott Will & Emery, New York-based partner Lindsay Ditlow, and London-based partners Paul McGrath and Katie Clark discuss how remote work has shifted to become the new norm across the globe in Lexology Getting The Deal Through, Market Intelligence. The authors explain how an employer can better prepare for the continuation of remote work and the legal implications that come with remote work based on different geographic requirements. Not following the applicable jurisdiction laws can lead to liability for wages, hours and time off entitlements.

    Remote Working 2022: Global Trends

    Remote Working 2022: United States

    Remote Working 2022: United Kingdom

    Reproduced with permission from Law Business Research Ltd. This article was first published in Lexology GTDT Market Intelligence – Remote Working 2022. For further information, please visit http://www.lexology.com/gtdt.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights