Content Type: Article

  • The Next Frontier in Privacy Class Actions: Video Players, Session Replay and Chatbots

    The Next Frontier in Privacy Class Actions: Video Players, Session Replay and Chatbots

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    The Next Frontier in Privacy Class Actions: Video Players, Session Replay and Chatbots

    December 21, 2022

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Plaintiffs’ Bar is well-known for pushing the boundaries of existing (and sometimes very old) laws with new and novel privacy claims. The most recent targets of this trend are (1) the Video Privacy Protection Act (VPPA), 18 U.S.C. § 2710 (and similar state video privacy acts); and (2) state wiretap laws, particularly the California Invasion of Privacy Act (CIPA), Cal. Penal Code § 630 et seq. Plaintiffs’ claims seek to extend dated statutory requirements to modern technologies, such as online video players, chatbots and session replay tools. Many of these actions have advanced past motions to dismiss, which means that companies employing certain types of common website technologies should take notice.

    In depth

    THE VIDEO PRIVACY PROTECTION ACT

    The VPPA was enacted in 1998 to prevent video rental services from sharing private information about their customers’ rental history. The law prohibits a “video tape service provider” (i.e., a person who provides rental, sale or delivery of prerecorded video cassette tapes or similar audio-visual materials) from knowingly disclosing information that identifies a customer as having requested specific video materials.

    While the VPPA was designed to apply to a very specific set of business practices, the scope of it has been expanding for years, including to digital videos, because of aggressive litigation before the courts. Now, the most recent lawsuits focus on online video services embedded in web properties that use cookies and similar tracking technologies such as pixels. These tracking technologies capture information about a user’s interactions with the videos embedded in the web property and, in some cases, share it with third parties like social media companies. The data shared often contains identifiers that could (at least in theory) be used to determine viewing history. The claims made in the most recent spate of lawsuits allege that this form of data sharing violates the VPPA.

    Plaintiffs have so far been met with mixed success in their efforts to further extend the VPPA. For example, in a recent ruling against the National Football League (NFL), the US District Court for the District of Rhode Island denied the NFL’s motion to dismiss as to tracking technologies embedded in prerecorded videos but granted the NFL’s motion with respect to live broadcasts, concluding that those were not “recorded” materials. Louth v. NFL Enterprises LLC, No. 1:21-cv-00405 (D.R.I. Sept. 12, 2022). The NFL ruling mirrors other recent rulings. (See, e.g., Ambrose v. Boston Globe Media Partners, LLC, N. 1:22-cv-10195 (D. Mass. Sept. 19, 2022).)

    STATE WIRETAP LAWS

    State wiretap laws, such as the CIPA, have similarly been extended to modern technologies through litigation. Among other provisions that have been litigated in privacy-related lawsuits, CIPA prohibits the interception of a communication, or the attempt to read or learn the contents of a communication, while in transit without the consent of all parties to the communication. CIPA also prohibits the “eavesdrop[ping]” or “record[ing]” of a confidential communication without the consent of the parties to the communication. Recent class actions have sought to apply this law to modern Internet technologies, focusing on two technologies in particular: session replay tools and chatbots.

    Session replay tools collect information about a user’s interactions with a webpage, such as mouse movements, clicks and pageviews, to recreate a user’s experience on the website in a session. Session replay tools can also monitor a user’s movement on a particular webpage, including, for example, recording the details a user has entered into a webform. Plaintiffs now allege that the recording of these actions, often by a third party who provides the session replay tool, violate CIPA because users are unaware of and have not consented to the recording. Some of these claims have had success though. In Javier v. Assurance IQ, LLC, the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reversed the trial court’s dismissal, holding that use of session replay tools without prior consent can be a violation of CIPA. No. 1:21-cv-16351 (9th Cir. May 9, 2022). The success of Javier has opened the door to a barrage of session replay and other similar claims.

    As an extension of the session replay claims, CIPA actions have also begun to focus on chatbots. The gist of these claims is similar to those involving session replay tools: chatbots violate CIPA by recording or learning the contents of a user’s communications without the user’s consent.

    And the drumbeat is not stopping in California. Plaintiffs are bringing similar claims under wiretap laws in other states, such as Florida and Pennsylvania.

    HOW TO PREPARE

    Companies should evaluate whether they use any of these tools that are being targeted by Plaintiffs, such as chatbots, session replay or tracking technologies embedded in videos (including, for example, training videos or commercial advertisements), and assess the risk posed by this recent wave of class actions. Companies can also take steps to mitigate their risk, such as clearly disclosing the use of these technologies in privacy notices and just-in-time notices where feasible. Reach out to your regular McDermott contact or one of the authors of this article for help preparing.

    Authors

    Kathryn Linsky

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    David P. Saunders

    Partner

    Chicago

    Jonathan Ende

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • NSA Update: HHS Indefinitely Delays Co-Provider, Co-Facility Requirements for Good Faith Estimates

    NSA Update: HHS Indefinitely Delays Co-Provider, Co-Facility Requirements for Good Faith Estimates

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    NSA Update: HHS Indefinitely Delays Co-Provider, Co-Facility Requirements for Good Faith Estimates

    December 21, 2022

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On December 2, 2022, the US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) issued an FAQ announcing that it will not enforce the requirement for convening providers and convening facilities to include expected charges for co-providers and co-facilities in good faith estimates (GFEs) furnished to uninsured (or self-pay) individuals as required under the No Surprises Act (NSA) until future rulemaking has occurred. This delay extends a prior exercise of enforcement discretion that was slated to end on January 1, 2023.

    In depth

    On December 27, 2020, the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021, was signed into law and included, among other provisions, the NSA. In October 2021, HHS issued its second interim final rule (IFR Part II) implementing the NSA requirements for convening providers and convening facilities to provide GFEs of expected charges to uninsured (or self-pay) individuals prior to a scheduled appointment or upon request. Among other requirements, a GFE must include pricing information from the convening provider or convening facility, as well as “co-providers” or “co-facilities,” defined as other providers or facilities that are reasonably expected to furnish items or services in conjunction with and in support of the primary item or service (e.g., laboratory, pathology and anesthesiology services).

    The FAQ addresses a single question regarding implementation of the GFE requirements related to co-providers and co-facilities. In response, HHS stated that it is extending its exercise of enforcement discretion beyond the January 1, 2023, deadline as provided in IFR Part II. The further exercise of enforcement discretion under the FAQ is indefinite “pending future rulemaking.” The FAQ also notes that any future rulemaking will include a prospective applicability date in order to give providers and facilities a reasonable amount of time to comply with any new requirements.

    Originally, HHS determined that an exercise of enforcement discretion was necessary for calendar year 2022 to allow time for providers and facilities to develop mechanisms for convening providers and convening facilities to request, and for co-providers and co-facilities to provide, complete and accurate pricing information for the convening provider or convening facility to incorporate into the GFE for uninsured (or self-pay) individuals. In the most recent FAQ, HHS cited additional stakeholder feedback as the basis for its further exercise of discretion. The FAQ states that given the complexities involved in exchanging GFE data among convening providers, convening facilities, co-providers and co-facilities, stakeholders have requested that HHS establish a standard technology to automate the creation of comprehensive GFEs and give providers and facilities sufficient time to implement such standard.

    HHS further stated in the FAQ that in order to achieve industry-wide interoperability for the transmission of GFE data between convening providers and convening facilities and co-providers and co-facilities, providers and facilities will need to adopt a standards-based application programming interface. The FAQ notes that this is part of a larger HHS strategy to encourage and support the adoption of health information technology to promote data exchange to improve the quality of care and promote a more efficient healthcare system. The FAQ also notes that HHS has indicated that the Health Level 7 Fast Healthcare Interoperability Resources standard holds potential for supporting interoperability and enabling new entrants and competition throughout the healthcare industry, and that HHS continues to support efforts towards developing such a standard. By extending this exercise of enforcement discretion, HHS aims to promote further interoperability across the healthcare industry and encourage providers, facilities and other industry members to focus resources towards adopting interoperable processes for exchange of information.

    Finally, the FAQ states that HHS is encouraging states that are primary enforcers of the GFE requirements to take a similar approach. According to the FAQ, HHS will not consider a state to be failing to substantially enforce the GFE requirements if it takes such an approach during HHS’s further exercise of enforcement discretion.

    This announcement likely comes as welcome news to the healthcare industry, which has struggled to operationalize the burdensome GFE requirements. Convening providers and convening facilities should continue to provide GFEs to uninsured (and self-pay) individuals inclusive of their own estimated charges while awaiting further rulemaking from HHS regarding the co-provider and co-facility requirements.

    Authors

    Emily Jane Cook

    Partner

    Los Angeles, Washington, DC

    Jamie B. Gelfman

    Partner

    Miami

    Eric Zimmerman

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • IRS Issues Final Regulations Extending ACA Information Reporting Deadlines, Clarifies Additional ACA Issues

    IRS Issues Final Regulations Extending ACA Information Reporting Deadlines, Clarifies Additional ACA Issues

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    IRS Issues Final Regulations Extending ACA Information Reporting Deadlines, Clarifies Additional ACA Issues

    December 21, 2022

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On December 15, 2022, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) finalized regulations regarding Information Reporting of Health Insurance Coverage and Other Issues Under Internal Revenue Code (Code) Sections 5000A, 6055 and 6056 (the Regulation).

    Compliance with Code Sections 5000A, 6055 and 6056 generally requires minimum essential coverage providers (e.g., insurers, government-sponsored programs and some self-funded plan sponsors and others) to annually file Forms 1094-B and 1095-B. In addition, Applicable Large Employers (ALEs) must file Forms 1094-C and 1095-C to demonstrate their compliance with the Affordable Care Act’s (ACA) employer shared responsibility rules. These forms provide information that the government needs to provide premium tax credits on the health insurance marketplace and to administer the ACA’s employer shared responsibility rules.

    In depth

    The Regulation, which adopts the substance of a proposed rule issued back in December 2021, makes the following changes:

    Status of Certain Medicaid Coverage as Minimum Essential Coverage

    The Regulation clarifies that Medicaid coverage that is limited to COVID–19 testing and diagnostic services provided under the Families First Coronavirus Response Act is not minimum essential coverage under the ACA. This change ensures that individuals with only this limited coverage can still qualify for premium tax credits.

    Deadline for Furnishing Statements to Individuals

    The ACA requires that insurers and plans furnish Forms 1095-B or 1095-C to covered individuals by January 31 of the following year. Under a long-standing rule, the IRS may grant extensions of up to 30 days for good cause upon request. The Regulation makes this extension permanent and automatic, removing the need for a filing or the demonstration of good cause.

    Method for Furnishing Statements to Individuals

    To ease administrative burdens on employers, the Regulation separately provides that for any year that the penalty applicable to individuals is $0, a reporting entity is permitted to furnish an alternative notice to comply with the ACA’s Section 6055 reporting requirements. (This is in response to a provision of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 that reduced the penalties imposed on individuals for failing to maintain minimum essential coverage). The Regulation requires that a reporting entity first must post a clear and conspicuous notice on the entity’s website that meets specific content requirements and states that responsible individuals may receive a copy of the statement upon request. The reporting entity also must provide Form 1095-B to the requesting individual within 30 days of the date of receipt of the individual’s request.

    Importantly, the alternative notice relief does not apply to full-time employees of an ALE that sponsors a self-funded group health plan; these notices must still be distributed directly to full-time employees under the Section 6056 reporting rules. As a result, the ALE may only use the alternative notice method for part-time and non-employees who are enrolled in the ALE’s self-funded group health plan.

    Termination of the Good Faith Compliance Period

    The ACA imposes penalties where the reports required by Code Sections 6055 and 6056 are inaccurate or incomplete. Recognizing the complexity of these rules, the IRS granted penalty relief for good faith reporting errors from 2015 to 2020. Consistent with the 2021 preamble to the proposed rule, however, the Regulation discontinues this good faith relief. This means that those taxpayers who are penalized for filing reports that contain incomplete or inaccurate information are held to a higher standard to qualify for relief  (i.e., they must establish that the lapse was because of reasonable cause and not willful neglect.)

    Employers and other Section 6055 reporting entities should review the Regulation—in addition to updated reporting forms and instructions—to familiarize themselves with the timing of information that must be provided and alternative reporting methods under these updated reporting requirements. Employers should also coordinate with their payroll and/or human resource information systems providers to ensure that they meet the Regulation’s requirements.

    For more information on these tax and employment benefit issues, please contact your regular McDermott lawyer or one of the authors listed below.

    Marchan Clark, a law clerk in the Washington, DC, office, also contributed to this article.

    Authors

    Jacob M. Mattinson

    Partner

    Chicago

    Sarah G. Raaii

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • SEC Adopts Amendments to Rules Governing Rule 10b5-1 Trading Plans and Section 16 Insider Filings on Forms 4 and 5

    SEC Adopts Amendments to Rules Governing Rule 10b5-1 Trading Plans and Section 16 Insider Filings on Forms 4 and 5

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    SEC Adopts Amendments to Rules Governing Rule 10b5-1 Trading Plans and Section 16 Insider Filings on Forms 4 and 5

    December 21, 2022

    Read time: 9 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On Dec. 14, 2022, the Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”) adopted amendments to Rule 10b5-1 under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (the “Exchange Act”), that include, among other things, changes to Rule 10b5-1(c)(1)’s affirmative defense to insider trading liability under Section 10(b) and Rule 10b-5 under the Exchange Act. These changes are aimed at addressing concerns that have long been raised as to whether corporate insiders purport to utilize 10b5-1 plans under the affirmative defense in situations that in fact involve opportunistic trading while in possession of material non-public information (“MNPI”). As discussed below, the amendments may impact fund managers who have board representation or otherwise have access to MNPI. The SEC also adopted amendments to Forms 4 and 5 filed under Section 16 of the Exchange Act to require that filers identify transaction that have been executed pursuant to 10b5-1 plans as well requiring Forms 4 to be filed to report gifts of securities (and no longer allow for deferred reporting of gifts on Form 5).

    1. Changes to Plan Requirements: Mandatory Cooling Off Periods and Certifications

    A. Mandatory Cooling-Off Periods: The SEC’s most prominent change to Rule 10b5-1 is the new requirement for mandatory cooling-off periods. Though many issuers already require cooling-off periods under their insider trading policies,[1] Rule 10b5-1 will now mandate that no trading under a newly-adopted or modified 10b5-1 plan can take place until:

    (i) For directors and “officers,”[2] the later of: (1) 90 days after the date the plan was adopted or modified and (2) two business days following the issuer’s filing of a Form 10-K or Form 10-Q[3] disclosing the issuer’s financial results for the fiscal quarter in which the plan was adopted or modified (but not to exceed 120 days following plan adoption or modification); and

    (ii) For non-directors or officers (other than the issuer)[4], 30 days after the plan was adopted or modified.

    The Adopting Release indicates that the mandated cooling-off period is aimed at “reducing information asymmetries” and providing “separation[s] in time” so that insiders are less likely to be trading on MNPI.

    B. Director and Officer Certifications: Rule 10b5-1 has always required that persons “demonstrate[]” that they adopted their trading plan in good faith and at a time that they were not aware of material non-public information. Now, an amendment to Rule 10b5-1(c)(1)(ii) will impose a certification requirement in order to help ensure directors and officers are cognizant of their responsibilities at the adoption of a plan and to assess if they are in possession of material non-public information before adopting a 10b5-1 plan. Accordingly, the amendments require that directors and officers provide in the plan itself a written certification or representation stating that, at the time the 10b5-1 plan is adopted or an existing plan is modified, the director or officer:

    (i) Is not aware of material non-public information about the issuer or its securities, and

    (ii) That the director or officer is adopting the contract, instruction or plan in good faith and not as part of a plan or scheme to evade the prohibitions of Rule 10b-5.

    This amendment does not require the certification to be filed with the SEC and would not be an independent basis of liability for directors or officers under Section 10(b) or Rule 10b-5.

    2. Restrictions on Types of Plans, Trading Arrangements and Use of Plans

    A. Prohibition on Overlapping Plans: The new amendments to Rule 10b5-1’s affirmative defense will provide that persons (other than issuers) may not have more than one outstanding (and may not subsequently enter into any additional) contract, instruction or plan that would qualify for the affirmative defense under Rule 10b5-1 for purchases or sales of any class of securities of the issuer on the open market during the same period. Despite the fact that the SEC originally proposed limiting the restriction to only the “same class of securities” of an issuer, the SEC ultimately decided to broaden the restriction to apply to all “contracts, instructions or plans for any class of securities of the issuer.” It is worth noting that:

    (i) In general, plan participants cannot circumvent these restrictions by trading through multiple brokers.

    (ii) Persons may, however, maintain two separate 10b5-1 plans at the same time so long as trading under the later-commencing plan is not authorized to begin until after all trades under the earlier-commencing plan are completed or expire without execution.

    (iii) Certain “sell-to-cover” transactions will still be permitted.

    (iv) The restriction on the availability of the affirmative defense for multiple overlapping trading arrangements will not apply to plans not involving open-market transactions, such as employee benefit plans, ESOPs or DRIPs.

    B. Limitations on Single-Trade Plans: Given the SEC’s concerns that single-trade plans may be used to trade based on MNPI, Rule 10b5-1(c)’s affirmative defense will no longer be available to persons (other than the issuer) who, during a 12-month period, purchased or sold securities pursuant to another single-trade plan.

    C. Plans Must Be “Operated” in Good Faith: In an attempt to “discourage insiders from attempting to evade the prohibitions of the rule,” the amendments also expand the existing requirement that a Rule 10b5-1 trading arrangement must be “given or entered into” in good faith to add the condition that the trader “act in good faith” with respect to the trading arrangement during the life of the plan. This requirement is aimed at activities related to plan cancellations and the timing of corporate disclosures when plans are in place.

    3. Additional Disclosure Requirements

    Finally, the amendments to Rule 10b5-1 impose additional disclosure requirements on insiders and issuers. Those subject to the reporting requirements under Section 16 of the Exchange Act will be required to:

    (i) Indicate using checkboxes on Forms 4 or 5 if a reported transaction was intended to satisfy the affirmative defense conditions of Rule 10b5-1(c) and to disclose the date of adoption of the trading plan; and

    (ii) Report dispositions of bona fide gifts of equity securities on Form 4 (rather than on Form 5) in accordance with Form 4’s two business day filing deadline.

    In addition, issuers will be required to make annual disclosure regarding insider trading policies and procedures in corresponding amendments to Form 10-K, quarterly disclosure regarding the use of 10b5-1 plans and certain other trading arrangements under amendments to Form 10-Q, make period disclosures under Form 8-K regarding the timing of options grants and the release of material non-public information as well as other disclosures, and abide by additional information tagging requirements under Items 402 and 408 or Regulation S-K, as such information may be disclosed in proxy statements or other materials.

    Will These Amendments Affect Fund Managers?

    Fund managers with employees on boards of public companies will be most impacted by the new mandatory 90-120 day cooling-off period. Under the cooling-off period, trading isn’t likely to be permitted to commence prior to the next open trading window following plan adoption or modification. It remains to be seen whether these insiders will find a material benefit to using a 10b5-1 plan versus conducting their trading during open trading windows.

    The 30 day cooling-off period for shareholders other than officers and directors will likely be less impactful, as many shareholders who use 10b5-1 plans, as well as brokers, have imposed their own cooling-off periods (unusually in the range of 30 days) as a matter of best practice. The other amendments will likely be similarly less impactful as the use of multiple overlapping plans and the focus on adopting and administering plans in good faith are issues that fund managers have been sensitive to for some time.

    The final rules will become effective 60 days following publication of the adopting release in the Federal Register (on Feb. 27, 2023). Section 16 reporting persons will be required to comply with the amendments to Forms 4 and 5 for beneficial ownership reports filed on or after April 1, 2023 and issuers will be required to comply with the new Exchange Act disclosure requirements on or after April 1, 2023 as well.

    Authored by Eleazer Klein, Adriana Schwartz and Daniel A. Goldstein.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] As indicated in footnote 448 of the Adopting Release, cooling off periods tend to range from 30 to 60 days under current industry practice.

    [2] As defined in Rule 16a-1(f) under the Exchange Act: “an issuer’s president, principal financial officer, principal accounting officer (or, if there is no such accounting officer, the controller), any vice-president of the issuer in charge of a principal business unit, division or function (such as sales, administration or finance), any other officer who performs a policy-making function, or any other person who performs similar policy-making functions for the issuer. Officers of the issuer’s parent(s) or subsidiaries shall be deemed officers of the issuer if they perform such policy-making functions for the issuer. In addition, when the issuer is a limited partnership, officers or employees of the general partner(s) who perform policy-making functions for the limited partnership are deemed officers of the limited partnership. When the issuer is a trust, officers or employees of the trustee(s) who perform policy-making functions for the trust are deemed officers of the trust.”

    [3] Or, for foreign private issuers, in a Form 20-F or Form 6-K.

    [4] A cooling off period is not required for issuer 10b5-1 plans.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2022 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Ele Klein

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Daniel A. Goldstein

    Counsel

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Substantial Penalty Against Major Bank Highlights Aggressive CFPB Enforcement

    Substantial Penalty Against Major Bank Highlights Aggressive CFPB Enforcement

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Substantial Penalty Against Major Bank Highlights Aggressive CFPB Enforcement

    December 21, 2022

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (“Bureau”) reached a consensual resolution with Wells Fargo, N.A. (the “Bank”), which calls for restitution to consumers totaling $2 billion, in addition to a $1.7 billion civil penalty — the largest penalty to date.[1] The historic fine will go into the CFPB’s Civil Penalty Fund, which the CFPB can use to provide relief to victims of consumer financial law violations in future cases.

    The practices at issue affected auto and mortgage loans, as well as deposit accounts. With respect to the Bank’s lending, the Bureau found consumers faced improper fees and charges, made payments that were misapplied, and in some circumstances wrongfully had their cars repossessed or homes foreclosed upon.[2] With respect to deposit accounts, the Bureau identified unwarranted charges including “surprise” overdraft fees.

    Although the bottom line value of this settlement stands out, it reflects several of the Bureau’s current priorities. First, the Bureau is keenly focused on identifying and penalizing the providers it views as repeatedly violating consumer financial law. Second, the Bureau continues to leverage its expansive authority to address unfair, deceptive, and abusive acts and practices (“UDAAPs”), which are the only violations cited in this order. Third, the Bureau is closely scrutinizing add-on products and comparing how providers’ practices line up with their advertising disclosures.

    In public remarks, Director Chopra classified the Bank as a “repeat offender,” referring to earlier fines the Bank paid under the Bureau’s watch.[3] He stressed the need for “long-term reform”[4] and suggested that the Bureau would continue to be vigilant. This framing matches several statements and initiatives by the Bureau,[5] including most recently its proposed rule seeking to create a “registry” of offenders to assist the Bureau and other regulators in identifying the providers of consumer financial products and services that qualify (in the Bureau’s view) for harsher penalties on account of their “recidivism.”[6]

    The order also furthers the trend of the CFPB relying on its UDAAP authority to impose penalties and revised procedures on companies. Indeed, every practice the Bureau found to violate federal consumer financial law was on the basis of its UDAAP authority, rather than a violation of any regulations applicable to the Bank.

    Specifically, the Bureau determined that the Bank’s automobile-loan-servicing systems experienced a number of failures that caused the Bank to misapply payments, charge improper fees, and make improper repossessions, and concluded that such acts and practices constituted an unfair practice.[7] Likewise, the Bureau considered certain mortgage servicing failures to be unfair practices, including computer errors that caused the Bank to misclassify certain borrowers as ineligible for loan modifications. Further, the Bureau determined that it was an unfair practice to charge overdraft fees on deposit accounts in situations where the account had a sufficient balance at the time of the transaction, even where processing the amount (at the time and in the order the Bank processed it) in fact resulted in a negative balance.[8] Finally, the Bureau found it unfair that the Bank’s fraud detection systems sometimes resulted in freezing a consumer’s entire account for up to two weeks, rather than only the amount of the suspicious transaction.[9]

    Consistent with another recent theme in Bureau enforcement, the Bureau found that the Bank’s handling of certain add-on products was an unfair practice. For example, many auto loan consumers entered into Guaranteed Asset Protection (“GAP”) contracts. A GAP contract protects the consumer from paying the outstanding balance of the loan beyond the depreciated value of the car following a major accident or theft. In several instances, consumers rolled the cost of their GAP contracts into their auto loans but the Bank did not refund the unearned portion of the GAP fees when the consumer repaid the loan early.[10] Notably, even though GAP contracts are governed by applicable state law, the Bureau required the Bank to agree that it will refund unused portions of GAP contracts nationwide.[11]

    In addition, the Bureau considered the Bank charging monthly service fees where account holders satisfied the conditions specified in the Bank’s advertisements and disclosures for a waiver of those fees to be a deceptive practice.[12] Regulators have indicated they will closely review the accuracy of consumer-facing advertisements compared with the financial product or service consumers ultimately receive.[13]

    Finally, in what may be early signs of an emerging trend, the CFPB flagged that it’s “work here” is not “done,” and that it, alongside other partner authorities, will hold individuals accountable.[14] In this regard, the CFPB is seeking to match the enforcement models of other authorities, to look inside companies to find and hold responsible the individuals involved in illegal conduct.

    The CFPB’s action against the Bank is illustrative of the Bureau’s overall priorities and demonstrates that the Bureau will continue to wield its enforcement authority to alter practices it disfavors.

    Schulte Roth & Zabel’s lawyers are available to assist you in addressing any questions you may have regarding these developments. Please contact the Schulte Roth & Zabel lawyer with whom you usually work, or any of the following attorneys:

    Donald J. Mosher – New York (+1 212.756.2187, donald.mosher@srz.com)

    Melissa G.R. Goldstein – Washington, DC (+1 202.729.7471, melissa.goldstein@srz.com)

    Douglas I. Koff – New York (+1 212.756.2773, douglas.koff@srz.com)

    Kara A. Kuchar – New York (+1 212.756.2734, kara.kuchar@srz.com)

    Adam J. Barazani – New York (+1 212.756.2519, adam.barazani@srz.com)

    Jessica Romano – New York (+1 212.756.2205, jessica.romano@srz.com)

    Jessica Sklute – New York (+1 212.756.2180, jessica.sklute@srz.com)

    Noah N. Gillespie – Washington, DC (+1 202.729.7483, noah.gillespie@srz.com)

    Hadas A. Jacobi – New York (+1 212.756.2055, hadas.jacobi@srz.com)

    Rebecca A. Raskind – New York (+1 212.756.2396, rebecca.raskind@srz.com)

    Jesse Weissman – New York (+1 212.756.2460, jesse.weissman@srz.com)


    [1] Press Release, CFPB Orders Wells Fargo to Pay $3.7 Billion for Widespread Mismanagement of Auto Loans, Mortgages, and Deposit Accounts (Dec. 20, 2022), available here. The Bank consented to the issuance of the order without admitting or denying any of the findings of fact or conclusions of law, except with respect to the Bureau’s jurisdiction. Order ¶ 2.

    [2] As of the date of the order, the Bank had already provided $1.3 billion in remediation to 11 million auto loan borrower accounts. Order, In re Wells Fargo, N.A., No. 2022-CFPB-0011 (Dec. 20, 2022) ¶ 8, available here.

    [3] Prepared Remarks of CFPB Director Rohit Chopra on the Wells Fargo Law Enforcement Action (“Speech”) at 1 (Dec. 20, 2022), available here.

    [4] Press Release at 1; Speech at 2.

    [5] E.g., Director Chopra, “Reining in Repeat Offenders,” 2022 Distinguished Lecture on Regulation, University of Pennsylvania Law School (Mar. 28, 2022), available here.

    [6] SRZ Client Alert, CFPB Proposes Rule to Establish Public Registry of Nonbanks with Consumer Financial Law Enforcement Orders (Dec. 19, 2022), available here.

    [7] Order ¶¶ 7-22.

    [8] Order ¶¶ 43-47.

    [9] Order ¶¶ 31-37

    [10] Order ¶¶ 17-19.

    [11] Order ¶ 50.

    [12] Order ¶¶ 38-42.

    [13] E.g., Press Release, CFPB Warns that Digital Marketing Providers Must Comply with Federal Consumer Finance Protections (Aug. 10, 2022), available here; Press Release, FTC Puts Hundreds of Businesses on Notice about Fake Reviews and Other Misleading Endorsements (Oct. 31, 2021), available here.

    [14] Speech at 2 (“While today’s order addresses a number of consumer abuses, it should not be read as a sign that . . . the CFPB’s work here is done. Importantly, the order does not provide immunity for any individuals, nor, for example, does it release claims for any ongoing illegal acts or practices.”)


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2022 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Donald J. Mosher

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Melissa G.R. Goldstein

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Douglas I. Koff

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Adam J. Barazani

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • SEC Imposes New Restrictions on Availability of Rule 10b5-1 Defense to Insider Trading

    SEC Imposes New Restrictions on Availability of Rule 10b5-1 Defense to Insider Trading

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    SEC Imposes New Restrictions on Availability of Rule 10b5-1 Defense to Insider Trading

    December 20, 2022

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    At an Open Meeting on December 14, 2022, the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) adopted amendments to Rule 10b5-1 promulgated under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (Exchange Act), which impose new limitations on the ability of insiders of public companies to trade company shares without risking insider trading liability.

    The amendments reflect the SEC’s conclusion that the affirmative defense afforded by 10b5-1 trading plans to company insiders included too much room for abuse. While the SEC recognized the role 10b5-1 plans play in providing flexibility to insiders to plan securities transactions in advance when they are not in possession of material nonpublic information (MNPI) about the issuer, the new amendments adjust the balance between company insiders’ interest in trading flexibility and the public’s interest in restricting trading by insiders in possession of MNPI.

    In depth

    During the Open Meeting, SEC Chairman Gary Gensler said that he believed the new limitations would increase investor confidence by further aligning shareholder and insider interests, decreasing the cost of capital for public companies and ensuring greater liquidity for insiders seeking to sell company shares.

    To ensure the continued availability of the affirmative defense against allegations of insider trading, we recommend that companies review and update their insider trading policies to comport with the new rules, track compliance with the mandatory cooling-off periods and prepare to file the periodic disclosures called for by the new Rule 10b5-1 plan requirements. With the imposition of these new requirements and disclosure burdens, we expect the SEC Enforcement staff to employ even more resources in policing the Rule 10b5-1 landscape.

    NEW CONDITIONS TO THE AVAILABILITY OF THE RULE 10b5-1 AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE FOR PERSONS OTHER THAN ISSUERS

    The amendments include the following new conditions for establishing a Rule 10b5-1 affirmative defense for persons other than issuers:

    • Directors and officers, as defined in Section 16a-1(f) of the Exchange Act, may not commence trading of shares under a 10b5-1 plan during a cooling-off period, which runs from the date of adoption or modification of a 10b5-1 plan until the later of: (1) 90 days following plan adoption or modification or (2) two business days following the disclosure in a Form 10-Q or Form 10-K of the issuer’s financial results for the fiscal quarter in which the plan was adopted or modified (unless such disclosure exceeds 120 days following plan adoption or modification). Accordingly, the cooling-off period during which the Rule 10b5-1 affirmative defense is unavailable will never exceed 120 days.
    • Persons other than directors and officers must refrain from selling company shares for 30 days following the adoption or modification of a 10b5-1 plan.
    • Persons other than the issuer can only have one 10b5-1 trading plan at a time for all classes of securities of the issuer, except for the limited purpose of satisfying tax obligations incident to equity compensation awards. This limitation prevents insiders and rank-and-file employees from adopting overlapping 10b5-1 plans that could be used to selectively cancel certain trades while they are aware of MNPI, allowing them to buy or sell securities under the plans that provide the most advantageous price.
    • The adoption of an additional 10b5-1 plan used solely to sell shares to satisfy tax withholding obligations incident to the vesting of equity compensation (sell-to-cover) will not jeopardize the availability of the affirmative defense for trades already completed pursuant to the pre-existing 10b5-1 plan. However, after the completion of the necessary sell-to-cover transactions, insiders are nonetheless required to pause trading on any pre-existing plan for the applicable cooling-off period.
    • Persons other than an issuer can only utilize one single-trade 10b5-1 plan during a consecutive 12-month period.
    • At the time of the adoption or modification of a 10b5-1 plan, directors and officers must include a representation in the plan in which they certify that they are: (1) not aware of any MNPI and (2) adopting the plan in good faith and not as part of a plan or scheme to evade the prohibitions of Rule 10b-5.

    NEW FILING REQUIREMENTS FOR SECTION 16 FILERS

    • Insiders making filings under Section 16 of the Exchange Act (Section 16 filers) must indicate in their Form 4 and Form 5 filings whether the purchase or sale reported on the form was made pursuant to a 10b5-1 plan by checking a new box on the topic that was added to these forms by the new rule.
    • Section 16 filers must report any gifts of securities within two business days on Form 4 and may no longer report such gifts on a deferred basis on Form 5.

    NEW FILING REQUIREMENTS FOR ISSUERS

    The amendments treat issuer 10b5-1 plans differently from those of insiders as the amendments do not impose issuer cooling-off periods or restrict issuers from single-trade or overlapping plans. However, the amendments impose new disclosure requirements on issuers:

    • New Item 402(x) under Regulation S-K of the Exchange Act requires an issuer to provide narrative and tabular disclosures regarding any options and stock appreciation rights awarded by the issuer within four business days before and one business day after the release of MNPI. These narrative disclosures must discuss the issuer’s policies and practices regarding the timing of award grants, as well as how the issuer takes MNPI into account when determining the timing and terms of an award. Smaller reporting companies (SRCs) and emerging growth companies may limit their disclosure to option grants awarded to principal executive officers (PEOs) and the two most highly compensated executive officers other than the PEO.
    • New Item 408 under Regulation S-K requires an issuer to make: (1) quarterly disclosures in its Form 10-Q filings of the use of 10b5-1 plans and certain other trading arrangements by its officers and directors for the trading of its securities and (2) annual disclosure in its Form 10-K filings of its insider trading policies and procedures.

    IMPLEMENTING THE NEW AMENDMENTS

    The amendments will become effective 60 days following publication of the final rule in the Federal Register. While the amendments will impact 10b5-1 plans adopted or modified on or after the effective date, the amendments will not impact plans adopted before such date unless subsequently modified. The compliance deadline for SRCs is deferred by six months. The SEC stated that the disclosure obligations imposed by the amendments will commence as follows:

    Starting April 1, 2023 (October 1, 2023, for SRCs), directors and officers will be required to disclose gifts of securities on Form 4 in accordance with the two-business day deadline, and to disclose whether trades were made pursuant to a 10b5-1 plan, by responding to the new checkbox when reporting trades on Forms 4 and 5.

    Beginning with the filing that covers the first full fiscal period beginning on or after April 1, 2023 (or October 1, 2023, for SRCs), issuers will be required to comply with the new disclosure requirements in Forms 10-Q, 10-K and 20-F and in any proxy or information statements. For issuers with a December 31 fiscal year-end other than an SRC, the first periodic report to which the new disclosure requirements apply will therefore be the second calendar-quarter Form 10-Q.

    McDermott’s Capital Markets & Public Companies and White-Collar Practice Groups can help public companies and their directors and officers meet the challenges of complying with these new Rule 10b5-1 plan requirements.

    Charles Darantiere, a law clerk in the Washington, DC, office, also contributed to this article.

    Authors

    Thomas P. Conaghan

    Partner

    Washington, DC, New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    Mark J. Mihanovic

    Partner

    Silicon Valley, Los Angeles

    Eric Orsic

    Partner

    Chicago

    Heidi J. Steele

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • 10 Things Providers Should Know About California’s Data Exchange Framework

    10 Things Providers Should Know About California’s Data Exchange Framework

    CLIENT ALERT / INTEROPERABILITY

    10 Things Providers Should Know About California’s Data Exchange Framework

    December 20, 2022

    Read time: 15 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    By January 31, 2023, general acute care hospitals, clinical labs and certain physician organizations and medical groups in California are required to enter into the Single Data Sharing Agreement (DSA) to participate in the California Health and Human Services Agency (CalHHS) Data Exchange Framework (DxF).

    California Health and Safety Code § 130290 (adopted as part of Assembly Bill 133 in July 2021) established the DxF and requires providers and other health care organizations participating in the DxF (Participants) to share Health and Social Services Information (HSSI). The DxF is intended to “accelerate and expand the exchange of health information among health care entities, government agencies, and social services programs” by January 31, 2024. The key requirements of the DxF are set forth in the DSA and policies and procedures (P&Ps) published by CalHHS. Providers should be aware of the following 10 issues when assessing how the DxF will impact their health information sharing activities and privacy and security practices.

    In depth

    1. Most Providers Are Required to Sign the DSA by January 1, 2023
    The DSA is a legal agreement that sets forth a common set of terms, conditions and obligations to support secure, real-time access to, or exchange of, HSSI between and among Participants. The DSA incorporates by reference P&Ps that further detail Participants’ compliance responsibilities under the DxF.

    On November 29, 2022, CalHHS launched a Signing Portal to allow health care providers, plans and other health care organizations to sign the DSA.

    By January 31, 2023, the following health care provider types are required to sign the DSA:

    • General acute care hospitals
    • Physician organizations and medical groups
    • Skilled nursing facilities
    • Health care service plans and disability insurers that provide hospital, medical or surgical coverage
    • Clinical laboratories
    • Acute psychiatric hospitals.

    By January 31, 2026, the following providers must sign the DSA:

    • Physician practices with less than 25 physicians
    • Rehabilitation hospitals
    • Long-term acute care hospitals
    • Acute psychiatric hospitals
    • Critical access hospitals
    • Rural general acute care hospitals with less than 100 acute care beds
    • State-run acute psychiatric hospitals
    • Nonprofit clinics with less than 10 providers.

    2. The DxF Does Not Take Full Effect until January 31, 2024, and Additional P&Ps Have Yet to Be Published or Finalized

    While most providers are required to sign the DSA by January 31, 2023, the DxF does not take full effect until January 31, 2024, allowing providers time to develop the necessary technical and compliance infrastructure to implement the DxF.

    Furthermore, in anticipation of the January 31, 2023, deadline to sign the DSA, CalHHS is in the process of finalizing several additional P&Ps. As of December 15, 2022, there are at least five P&Ps still under construction:

    • Information blocking
    • Monitoring and auditing
    • Required transaction patterns and technology requirements for exchange
    • Real-time data exchange
    • The qualified health information organization (QHIO) designation process.

    CalHHS is currently accepting stakeholder comments on the information blocking and monitoring and auditing P&Ps and is considering the introduction of a P&P governing early exchange of data under the DxF.

    3. The DxF Incorporates Federal Information Blocking Prohibition and Exceptions
    The DSA contains a general prohibition against information blocking, stating that “Participants shall comply with any information-blocking provisions set forth in the [P&P].” The current publicly available draft of the information blocking P&P includes exceptions that mirror most of the information blocking exceptions included in the final rule (ONC Final Rule) adopted by the US Department of Health and Human Services Office of the National Coordinator for Health Information Technology (ONC) under the 21st Century Cures Act’s information blocking provisions, but excludes the ONC Final Rule’s Content and Manner Exception, Licensing Exception and Fees Exception. However, based on the DxF Data Sharing Agreement Policies & Procedures Subcommittee webinar on December 15, 2022, it appears the next draft of the P&P will include the ONC Final Rule’s Content and Manner and Licensing Exception but not the Fees Exception.

    Specifically, CalHHS has suggested that Participants will not be able to use the Fees Exception in a manner that would result in withholding data requested for a required purpose outlined in P&P #4 (Permitted, Required and Prohibited Purposes). This may result in a situation where fees for data exchange permitted under the ONC Final Rule and HIPAA are effectively prohibited under the DxF—limiting Participants’ ability to cover their costs to share health data. Additionally, some stakeholders are advocating for the exclusion of the Licensing Exception in the final P&P. Since the ONC Final Rule’s Content and Manner Exception cross-references the Fees and Licensing Exceptions, it is not clear how CalHHS will modify the Content and Manner Exception to address their omission from the P&P.

    Due to significant ongoing discussion, CalHHS has not finalized the information blocking P&P and is still accepting public comments. Stakeholders can submit comments to CalHHS to help shape the next draft of the information blocking P&P. California providers should consider advocating for CalHHS to align the DSA and P&Ps with the ONC Final Rule to avoid inconsistent, burdensome requirements. We expect CalHHS to publicly release a new draft on the DxF website soon.

    4. The DSA Requires the Exchange of HSSI
    The DSA requires providers to exchange HSSI, defined in the DSA as “any and all information received, stored, processed, generated, used, transferred, disclosed, made accessible, or shared pursuant to the DSA, including . . . : data elements as set forth in the P&P; information related to the provision of health care services, including . . . PHI; and information related to the provision of social services.” While the DSA does state that HSSI “may include” de-identified data, pseudonymized data, metadata, digital identities and schema, P&P #8 (Data Elements to Be Exchanged), which is intended “to define the [HSSI] to which access is to be provided or that is to be exchanged by Participants,” appears to take a narrower approach in line with current federal standards (and the DSA prioritizes P&P language when it conflicts with DSA language). For example, P&P #8 may effectively narrow the definition of HSSI and align it with the definition of electronic health information (EHI) under the ONC Final Rule.

    5. The DxF Does Not Replace Existing or Future Agreements That Provide for a Broader Amount of Data Sharing
    The DxF creates a data sharing floor for California providers, but providers remain free to create agreements among themselves that allow for more data sharing, in compliance with applicable state and federal law.

    6. Providers Must Get Authorization from Patients to Disclose Certain Information in the DxF
    Before disclosing a patient’s Protected Health Information (PHI) or personally identifiable information (PII) through the DxF, providers must obtain all required authorizations under state and/or federal law from the patient. Participants who disclose PHI and/or PII through the DxF expressly represent that all patient authorizations or other consents required under state and/or federal law have been obtained.

    7. The DxF Requires Health Information Exchange Beyond HIPAA’s Permissive Data Sharing Rules
    While HIPAA permits the exchange of health information for treatment, payment, health care operations and public health activity purposes, the DxF requires Participants to exchange and provide access to HSSI for those purposes. Participants can also exchange or provide access to data under the DxF for other non-specified purposes, including to facilitate the sale of data, as permitted by law and with the appropriate authorizations and legal agreements.

    8. Participants Are Required to Exchange HSSI in Real Time through the Avenue of Their Choice
    The DSA requires Participants to exchange HSSI in real time. However, CalHHS has yet to finalize what constitutes as real-time data exchange. In a recent webinar, CalHHS indicated that if a Participant receives a request for diagnostic, health or social services, the Participant must share HSSI associated with such request as soon as practicable and no more than 24 hours after the data is available or immediately upon receipt of the request in emergency or urgent care situations.

    Participants may exchange HSSI either through: (1) a QHIO, which is a state-designated non-participant data exchange intermediary that facilitates HSSI exchanges and access between Participants; (2) another Participant’s technology; or (3) the Participant’s own technology.

    9. Participants Can Seek Amendment of the DSA and Modifications to the P&Ps
    While Participants cannot negotiate personalized changes to the DSA with CalHHS, under P&P #1 (Process for Amending the DSA), Participants and any other stakeholders can submit a written request for amendment to the DSA for all Participants. CalHHS will determine if the proposed amendment merits consideration, followed by a comment period and an objection period. A task force established by CalHHS, in consultation with local partners and a stakeholder advisory group, will determine whether to approve the request for amendment of the DSA.

    In addition, under P&P #2 (Modifications to Policies and Procedures), any Participant or other stakeholder can submit a written request to amend, repeal or establish a new P&P. CalHHS will evaluate these requests similarly to requests to amend the DSA.

    10. California’s DxF Is Separate and Distinct from the Federal Trusted Exchange Framework and Common Agreement
    Before the California legislature established the DxF, Congress directed ONC to create the voluntary Trusted Exchange Framework and Common Agreement (TEFCA) to govern the exchange of EHI between health information networks across the United States. While DxF and TEFCA have similar expectations for health information interoperability, those who participate in both frameworks must comply with both data sharing agreements.

    If your organization has questions about the DxF, including its potential impacts on your privacy, security or information blocking compliance plans, please reach out to your McDermott lawyer or one of the contacts listed below.

    Authors

    Daniel F. Gottlieb

    Partner

    Chicago

    Reuben Bank

    Associate

    Los Angeles

    More insights

  • DOL Proposes Significant Changes to VFCP Program

    DOL Proposes Significant Changes to VFCP Program

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    DOL Proposes Significant Changes to VFCP Program

    December 19, 2022

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On November 21, 2022, the US Department of Labor’s (DOL) Employee Benefits Security Administration (EBSA) released a proposed amendment and restatement of the Voluntary Fiduciary Correction Program (VFCP), along with a proposed amendment to the Prohibited Transaction Exemption (PTE) 2002-51.

    The VFCP allows plan sponsors to voluntarily correct certain fiduciary breaches to avoid civil enforcement actions and civil penalties imposed under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA) and its accompanying regulations. The most relevant components of the proposed changes for plan sponsors relate to delinquent contributions of participant deferrals and loan repayments as these tend to occur more frequently than other issues corrected through the VFCP. Importantly, the proposed amended and restated VFCP would add a new self-correction feature, clarify existing transactions currently eligible for correction and simplify certain administrative or procedural requirements for participation in and correction of transactions under the VFCP. This would be the first time the DOL has allowed self-correction under VFCP. The proposed changes are intended to encourage greater VFCP participation by providing for more efficient and less costly corrections.

    In depth

    THE SELF-CORRECTION COMPONENT

    The most significant and practical change affecting plan sponsors under the proposed changes to VFCP is the addition of a new Self-Correction Component (SC Component) for certain failures to timely transmit participant contributions and participant loan repayments to pension plans. The DOL notes that delinquent participant contributions are the type of transaction most commonly corrected under the VFCP. The new SC Component is intended to offer a more streamlined correction process that incentivizes the correction of late remittances of participant contributions, especially those that involve small dollar amounts. To utilize the SC Component, certain conditions must be satisfied, including each of the following:

    • Participant contributions or loan repayments are remitted within 180 calendar days after they were received or withheld by the employer.
    • The amount of lost earnings (as determined by using the VFCP online calculator) must not exceed $1,000. This low threshold could limit the use of the SC Component to small employer plans, as earnings for large employer plans are more likely to result in higher lost earnings amounts (though we note that senior officials at the DOL have requested comments specifically on this issue). Historically, many corrections we have seen under VFCP have not exceeded the $1,000 lost earnings threshold.
    • The plan or self-corrector must not be under investigation as defined in the VFCP. The term “under investigation” is revised from the current rule, and the proposed amendment clarifies that receipt of a participant-initiated inquiry from an EBSA investigator would not constitute being under investigation unless the transaction requiring correction is the basis of such inquiry.
    • Self-correctors must submit an electronic notice form on the EBSA website to complete and file the SC Component notice and complete and retain the self-correction retention record checklist.

    While self-correctors under the SC Component will not receive a “no action” letter from EBSA, the amendment clarifies that self-correction under the SC Component will nevertheless exempt the plan and its fiduciaries from penalties or civil enforcement actions.

    CHANGES UNDER THE PTE 2002-51

    Along with the proposed amendment under the VFCP, EBSA proposed a corresponding amendment to PTE 2002-51 that provides relief from excise taxes under Section 4975 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended, for transactions that are corrected pursuant to the SC Component. The amendment also eliminates the three-year lookback limitation rule that prohibited applicants from seeking relief under such provisions more than once during a three-year period.

    The proposed amendment also exempts self-correctors from the requirement to provide written notice to interested persons of the transactions for which relief is sought pursuant to the VFCP. Instead, the amount of the excise tax that otherwise would be required to be paid under Section 4975 is paid to the plan and allocated to the participant’s accounts. A copy of the completed IRS Form 5330, along with proof of payment to the appropriate EBSA Regional Office, would no longer be required. Instead, the self-correctors must retain a copy of the completed Form 5330 (or other written documentation of the applicable excise taxes) and proof of payment of the amounts paid to the plan and submit a copy to the plan administrator.

    Comments on the proposed amendments must be submitted by interested parties no later than January 20, 2023.

    Authors

    Jennifer D. Hill

    Associate

    Atlanta

    Jacob M. Mattinson

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • CFPB Proposes Rule to Establish Public Registry of Nonbanks with Consumer Financial Law Enforcement Orders

    CFPB Proposes Rule to Establish Public Registry of Nonbanks with Consumer Financial Law Enforcement Orders

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    CFPB Proposes Rule to Establish Public Registry of Nonbanks with Consumer Financial Law Enforcement Orders

    December 19, 2022

    Read time: 15 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On Dec. 12, 2022, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (“Bureau”) issued a proposed rule (“Proposed Rule”) which would require nonbank covered persons (subject to certain exceptions) that offer consumer financial products or services to report to the Bureau certain final public orders issued by a court or federal, state or local agency.[1] Covered persons would be required to register with the Bureau, and the Bureau would publish the orders on its website. Notably, the registry would include alleged violations of law.[2]

    The Proposed Rule would also require larger covered persons subject to the Bureau’s supervision and examination authority who register to identify a senior executive to submit an annual statement and attestation describing how the executive has reviewed and overseen the company’s compliance with the public order. While the annual statement and attestation would remain confidential, the Bureau proposes to publish the name and title of the executive responsible for compliance with the order, and highlights that it will scrutinize these attestations closely in determining its supervision priorities.

    The Bureau is pursuing the Proposed Rule as a tool to better identify the companies that pose risks to consumers by violating consumer protection laws. The rule cannot fully go into effect until the Bureau sets up the nonbank registration system (“NBR”), which the Bureau anticipates will be “no earlier than January 2024.”[3] Nonetheless, the Bureau appears to be moving forward quickly, noting that it has already completed its required consultations with state authorities, prudential regulators and tribes.[4]

    Public comments are due 60 days after forthcoming publication in the Federal Register. The central features of the Proposed Rule are summarized below.

    • Who Would Need to Register and Report. The Proposed Rule applies to any entity that provides financial products or services to consumers, meaning for primarily personal, family or household use. The Proposed Rule expressly exempts individuals from the registration requirement. An entity must register if, on or after the effective date of the Proposed Rule, there is a public order of any federal, state or local agency that (1) finds that it violated any provision of federal consumer financial protection law and (2) requires the entity to take some action or refrain from taking some action. The initial registration and any later updates must be made within 90 days of a change in circumstances. When the Proposed Rule first goes into effect, public orders dating back as far as Jan. 1, 2017 may be relevant.[5] By March 31 of each year after first registering and for so long as the public order remains in effect, the larger, supervised entities must submit a statement identifying the senior executive of the entity responsible for the entity’s compliance with the public order and describing the good faith steps the entity has taken to achieve and maintain compliance with the public order.
    • Which Laws Implicate the Reporting Requirement. The registry would apply to orders related to violations of the enumerated federal consumer financial laws under the Bureau’s jurisdiction, other laws the Bureau may enforce (including, for example the Consumer Financial Protection Act’s prohibition against unfair, deceptive or abusive acts or practices (“UDAAP”)), section 5 of the Federal Trade Commission Act and state laws prohibiting UDAAPs.[6] Notably, the Proposed Rule’s inclusion of federal UDAAP law may pose difficulties for covered entities in determining whether they must register. The Proposed Rule calls for registration if the violations in the public order would also qualify as violations of federal consumer financial protection law.[7] However, given the breadth of federal UDAAP principles and that the Bureau often asserts that violations of other law amount to UDAAPs, covered entities may be left in doubt about whether a public order that otherwise does not implicate registration might be deemed in hindsight to constitute a UDAAP violation.
    • What the Bureau Will Do With This Information. The Bureau will post the public orders online in a searchable database to help the public and other regulators identify patterns and repeat offenders. While the Bureau does not plan to post the attestations online, it will list the name of the identified senior executives. Further, the Bureau will scrutinize the attestation closely, and if, in the Bureau’s view, the attestation does not demonstrate the entity is taking the necessary steps to comply with the public order, the Bureau will exercise its supervision authority to examine that entity.[8] Additionally, the Bureau expects that the designated senior executive will have reviewed sufficient underlying materials to justify the attestation and requires the entity to maintain those underlying documents for at least five years.[9]
    • Identifying Risks to Consumers. As is being widely reported, the Bureau intends to spotlight in the proposed national database the “repeat offenders” that have received multiple orders and that have failed to comply with existing orders as particularly risky for consumers.[10] At the same time, the Bureau would view a dearth of orders related to certain consumer financial products as a warning that some areas of consumer financial products lack sufficient oversight.
    • Public Shame. The Bureau expects publication of the NBR and easy access to the public orders to benefit consumers by providing a national and readily accessible database that “consumer advocacy organizations, researchers, or the media”[11] could use to identify “the most egregious repeat offenders.”[12] Here and elsewhere, the Bureau expects that the Proposed Rule would cause covered entities to improve compliance by pinning their reputation on careful compliance.
    • Broad Reach. Although part of the focus of the Proposed Rule is to identify “repeat offenders” and egregious noncompliance, any covered provider of consumer financial products and services who is subject to a covered order would be subject to the rule. The broad reach of the proposed rule would implicate entities that may not know if they are covered by the rule. The Bureau recommends, as one option, voluntarily registering with the NBR.[13] The Proposed Rule also includes an option to submit an attestation to the NBR that the entity believes it is not subject to registration.[14] While the Bureau asserts that only a small percentage of nonbanks are subject to public orders, meaning only those few nonbanks will have to register, the Proposed Rule — if finalized as currently drafted — may result in many of the more than 150,000 nonbanks that the Bureau estimates exist to register out of caution.[15]

    The Bureau’s proposal to establish a registry of violators is appropriately gathering the attention of many nonbanks who will be required to navigate its provisions once the NBR is launched. It appears that part of the motivation for the NBR is that the Bureau is not finding the extent of cooperation it has with other authorities or its existing supervision efforts sufficient to provide the visibility it wants into covered entities’ performance.[16] It is noteworthy that the Bureau is not proposing an overall registry for all nonbanks to provide a census of the entities that may be subject to the Bureau’s oversight but instead is focused on magnifying the prior shortcomings of entities already subject to public orders.

    Persons interested in submitting a comment to address the Proposed Rule have about two months to do so, but “early submission” is always encouraged.[17]

    Schulte Roth & Zabel’s lawyers are available to assist you in preparing a public comment or addressing any questions you may have regarding these developments. Please contact the Schulte Roth & Zabel lawyer with whom you usually work, or any of the following attorneys:

    Donald J. Mosher – New York (+1 212.756.2187)

    Melissa G.R. Goldstein – Washington, DC (+1 202.729.7471)

    Kara A. Kuchar – New York (+1 212.756.2734)

    Adam J. Barazani – New York (+1 212.756.2519)

    Jessica Romano – New York (+1 212.756.2205)

    Jessica Sklute – New York (+1 212.756.2180)

    Noah N. Gillespie – Washington, DC (+1 202.729.7483)

    Hadas A. Jacobi – New York (+1 212.756.2055)

    Rebecca A. Raskind – New York (+1 212.756.2396)

    Jesse Weissman – New York (+1 212.756.2460)


    [1] Available at CFPB. The Bureau issued the Proposed Rule on its website, but it is not yet published in the Federal Register.

    [2] See, e.g., Proposed Rule at 188 (Section (201(c)), at 189 (Section 201(e)(4)), and at 191 (Section 201(m)).

    [3] Proposed Rule at 155.

    [4] Id. at 14.

    [5] Id. at 190.

    [6] The state laws are enumerated in an appendix.

    [7] See, e.g., Proposed Rule at 36-39.

    [8] See Proposed Rule at 44.

    [9] Proposed Rule at 196.

    [10] Id. at 12; see also SRZ Alert, CFPB Invokes “Dormant” Authority to Conduct Exams of Fintech Companies (Apr. 27, 2022).

    [11] See at or around footnote 113 and surrounding text.

    [12] Ibid.

    [13] See Proposed Rule at 161.

    [14] Proposed Rule at 194 (Section 202(g)).

    [15] Proposed Rule at 160.

    [16] See id. at 28.

    [17] Proposed Rule at 2.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2022 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Donald J. Mosher

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Melissa G.R. Goldstein

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Adam J. Barazani

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • European Commission Begins Process for Adoption of US Adequacy Decision

    European Commission Begins Process for Adoption of US Adequacy Decision

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    European Commission Begins Process for Adoption of US Adequacy Decision

    December 14, 2022

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Since Schrems II invalidated the US/EU Privacy Shield, the flow of personal data from the European Union to the United States has been subject to intense regulatory scrutiny. Companies transferring personal data to the United States have had to rethink their strategy for lawfully transferring personal data, which commonly included adopting the EU Standard Contractual Clauses and conducting time-consuming transfer risk assessments in line with the guidance from the European Data Protection Board (EDPB) and regional data protection authorities. However, companies may soon get a reprieve from these challenges. On December 13, 2022, the European Commission adopted a draft adequacy decision designating the EU-U.S. Data Privacy Framework (Framework) as “adequate” under the EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). The European Commission’s proposal of this draft adequacy decision paves the way for a reliable mechanism for EU-U.S. data transfers, at least until it faces the inevitable legal challenges.

    In depth

    DRAFT ADEQUACY DECISION

    Based in significant part on the October 2022 issuance of US President Joe Biden’s Executive Order, the European Commission proposed an adequacy decision for the United States premised on (1) additional safeguards for EU individuals whose information is sent to US-based companies who have certified compliance to the Framework and (2) additional safeguards related to the collection of personal data by US intelligence agencies, including limiting US intelligence authorities’ access to personal data and enhancing oversight of US intelligence authorities’ data collection activities.

    The draft decision reinforces the privacy obligations on US companies committing to join the Framework. For example, certifying companies will need to comply with traditional privacy principles of data minimization, provide data subjects with a privacy notice, offer data subjects rights with respect to their personal data and execute contracts with companies with whom they share personal data. Many companies will already be familiar with similar obligations under the various US state privacy laws, and the requirements are not materially different from prior iterations of the EU-U.S. Privacy Shield. The European Commission’s announcement also highlights the fact that under the new Framework, EU citizens “will benefit from several redress avenues if their personal data is handled in violation of the Framework, including free of charge before independent dispute resolution mechanisms and an arbitration panel.”

    Taking direct aim at the criticisms of the Privacy Shield, the European Commission explained that the new Framework is different from the Privacy Shield because it “establishes a new two-layer redress mechanism [for individuals], with independent and binding authority.” This includes establishing a new Data Protection Review Court to investigate and resolve individual complaints regarding access to their data by US national security authorities.

    Between this new redress mechanism, limitations on US intelligence data collection and the detailed process that will be required for compliance with the Framework, the European Commission is signaling that it believes the new Framework can withstand legal challenges.

    WHERE DO WE GO FROM HERE?

    The adequacy decision process began with the European Commission publishing this draft adequacy decision. That draft decision now goes to the EDPB, which will review and issue an opinion. The draft decision will then move through committee for EU Member State approval. Once that process is completed—and assuming that the decision survives those different layers of scrutiny—the European Commission can adopt the final adequacy decision. This process could take as little as one month, but there is an expectation that it could take up to six months.

    WHAT CAN US COMPANIES DO NOW?

    Past attempts to create a trans-Atlantic data framework have been invalidated twice by the Court of Justice of the European Union, in 2015’s Schrems I and 2020’s Schrems II. This time, however, the European Commission is taking the affirmative position that the new EU-U.S. Data Privacy Framework addresses the issues raised by the Court of Justice of the European Union in Schrems II. Mr. Schrems, however, has already said: “As the draft decision is based on the known Executive Order, I can’t see how this would survive a challenge before the Court of Justice. It seems that the European Commission just issues similar decisions over and over again—in flagrant breach of our fundamental rights.” It is thus a near certainty that he will file yet another action to challenge this latest framework.

    Today’s announcement is still welcome news for US companies who are eagerly awaiting a simplified data transfer mechanism for their increasingly global businesses. A new cross-border data transfer framework will ease the administrative burden many are contending with alongside alternative solutions, such as Standard Contractual Clauses. US-based importers of personal data should evaluate the Framework’s requirements and determine whether they will join the Framework. Companies can take steps now to assess what gaps in their compliance programs may need to be remediated before certification to best position themselves for quick certification once the Framework is formally adopted.

    ***

    If you have any questions about the implementation of the new EU-U.S. Data Privacy Framework or other cross-border transfer questions, please contact your regular McDermott lawyer or the authors listed below.

    Authors

    Kathryn Linsky

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    Amy C. Pimentel

    Partner

    Boston

    David P. Saunders

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights