ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
After Almost 25 Years, FTC Issues New Health Products Compliance Guidance
January 11, 2023
Read time: 6 min
The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) announced its Health Products Compliance Guidance on December 20, 2022. The 2022 guidance updates and replaces the FTC’s 1998 guidance, Dietary Supplements: An Advertising Guide for Industry. The scope of the new guidance is expanded to cover essentially all health-related product advertising. The guidance also discusses in greater detail the amount and type of evidence required to substantiate health-related product claims through illustrative examples, and clarifies the interrelationship between the FTC and the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) as it applies to health-related product promotion.
While the substantiation requirements remain essentially unchanged, the 2022 guidance memorializes decades of case law and enforcement actions applicable to “any health-related product,” such as foods, over-the-counter drugs, devices and homeopathic products. Since the 1998 guidance issued, marketing techniques, consumer sophistication and health concerns have significantly transformed, requiring FTC to consider novel issues. The 2022 guidance reflects these changes and provides greater insight into current practices that may be considered deceptive advertising.
Key Takeaways and Concepts
Clear and Conspicuous Disclosure Standard
The FTC requires companies to disclose all material qualifying information so that consumers can make informed decisions based on the advertisements. The 2022 guidance underscores the importance of “clear and conspicuous” qualifiers and disclosures. The “ultimate test” of an effective disclosure, according to the FTC, is “the net impression that consumers take from an ad with the disclosure.” If a significant minority of consumers are misled, then the disclosure is likely not sufficient. This is a difficult standard to meet, especially for complex concepts and claims based on limited or emerging science, but the advertiser is responsible for ensuring that consumers understand the extent of the scientific support and the existence of contrary evidence. For example, vague qualifiers and modifiers such as “helps” achieve the claimed benefit, “may” have the claimed benefit, “promising” and “preliminary” are likely inadequate under this standard.
Competent and Reliable Scientific Evidence Standard
In the 2022 guidance, the FTC emphasizes that the amount and type of substantiation required for product claims depends on a variety of factors, such as the type of claim, type of product, feasibility of substantiating the claim, consequences of a false claim, and what experts in the field view as reasonable. FTC suggests that health-related claims must be substantiated by “competent and reliable scientific evidence” in the form of “randomized, controlled human clinical testing” (RCTs). The research quality is more important than the quantity. Notably, there is no set number of RCTs that must be performed to meet the standard. Animal studies, in vitro studies, epidemiological or observational studies, anecdotal evidence, and public health recommendations and advisories are not generally considered to be competent and reliable scientific evidence. However, epidemiological or observational studies may substantiate a claim if they are “considered an acceptable substitute for RCTs by experts in the field” and “RCTs aren’t otherwise feasible.”
Quality of the Evidence
The 2022 guidance expands upon factors the FTC considers when assessing the quality of research for substantiating claims. Advertisers must ensure that the claim language accurately reflects the research evidence. To accomplish this, the research must be in compliance with basic testing principles to yield accurate and reliable results (e.g., control groups, double blinding, randomization, clear and detailed protocol), consistent with the surrounding body of evidence and relevant to the specific product and claimed effect. The FTC cautions against data mining or “p-hacking” (i.e., the post hoc analysis of data to pull a positive result from a study that failed to show an actual treatment effect) because such practice does not generally provide reliable evidence to substantiate claims.
Consumer Testimonials and Expert Endorsements
The 2022 guidance states that advertisers should not make claims through endorsements or consumer testimonials that would be deceptive or unsubstantiated if the advertiser made the claims directly. When using an expert endorser, advertisers must ensure that the expert is appropriately qualified and has actually examined or tested the product. Any personal, financial or other connection that would affect the weight or credibility of the endorsement must be clearly and conspicuously disclosed.
Traditional Use
The FTC clarifies its authority related to advertising statements involving “use of traditional medicine” and homeopathy, which historically have been perceived to fall within FDA’s jurisdiction. The FTC reiterates that there is no exception to the substantiation requirement (e.g., competent and reliable scientific evidence) for products traditionally used for alternative treatment methods, such as botanical supplements and homeopathic medicines. However, advertisements that describe these products’ traditional and historic use are permissible if they do not give a misleading impression that the products have scientifically backed health benefits. Given the inherent difficulty of crafting such advertisements, the FTC recommends performing copy tests or similar research to confirm that consumers are aware of the limited nature of such claims. The FTC warns advertisers not to make claims about traditional use for treatments or cures of serious medical conditions, even if sufficiently qualified, because of the likelihood that such claims could put consumers at risk.
DSHEA Disclaimers and Mischaracterization of FDA Approval
In the 2022 guidance, the FTC cautions advertisers against deceiving consumers by mischaracterizing the extent of FDA review, authorization or approval of a product or claim, such as by including Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act of 1994 (DSHEA) disclaimers on dietary supplement labels to imply that FDA approved the claim on that basis. This warning highlights the FTC’s intent to clearly establish its authority related to FDA’s regulations and to identify actions that it considers violative.
Third-Party Literature
The FTC cautions advertisers that they are legally responsible for the use of books, articles and other third-party literature to promote or market their products. Any implied or express claims referenced to third-party literature must be in compliance with FTC standards.
Next Steps
The 2022 guidance underscores the FTC’s commitment to closely scrutinizing health-related product advertising, particularly post-pandemic amid heightened public attention to wellness. Stakeholders should consider whether a reevaluation of their advertising and marketing materials for health-related products is warranted to ensure compliance with FTC standards in light of the 2022 guidance.
McDermott Will & Emery law clerk, Karis Jackson, also authored this On The Subject.

SECURE 2.0 Takes Second Bite at Retirement Security
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
SECURE 2.0 Takes Second Bite at Retirement Security
January 10, 2023
Read time: 11 min
The US Congress recently passed the SECURE 2.0 Act of 2022 (SECURE 2.0). Building on the Setting Every Community Up for Retirement Enhancement (SECURE) Act of 2019 (SECURE 1.0), SECURE 2.0 strives to expand retirement plan coverage and boost the savings potential for American employees. Many of the provisions are specifically aimed at enhancing savings opportunities for middle- and lower-income workers. This On the Subject summarizes the SECURE 2.0 provisions that are most likely to impact 401(k) and 403(b) plans sponsored by large employers. The article also denotes changes that may impact defined benefit pension plans. However, due to the expansive scope of SECURE 2.0, which includes over 90 retirement plan provisions, a summary of all the provisions included in SECURE 2.0 is beyond the scope of this article.
CHANGES TO REQUIRED MINIMUM DISTRIBUTIONS
- The required minimum distribution (RMD) age is increasing from the current age of 72 to age 73 on January 1, 2023, and age 75 on January 1, 2033. This change is mandatory and impacts both defined contribution and defined benefit plans.
- Effective January 1, 2024, participants will not be required to take RMDs on Roth contributions held in a retirement plan.
- Effective immediately, the penalty for failing to take an RMD will decrease from 50% of the amount of the missed RMD to 25% of such amount.
AUTOMATIC PLAN ENROLLMENT AND ESCALATION
New 401(k) and 403(b) plans must automatically enroll eligible employees in the plan starting at a deferral rate of at least 3% (and no more than 10%). Furthermore, new plans must automatically increase the employee’s deferral percentage annually until it reaches a maximum percentage (which percentage varies depending on plan type). Employees will have the ability to opt out of automatic enrollment. All current 401(k) and 403(b) plans will be grandfathered and will not be required to add automatic enrollment and escalation provisions. This requirement is mandatory for new plans established after the enactment of SECURE 2.0 and is effective for plan years beginning on or after January 1, 2025.
ALLOWANCE OF MATCHING CONTRIBUTIONS FOR ELECTIVE DEFERRED STUDENT LOAN REPAYMENTS
For plan years beginning after December 31, 2023, sponsors of 401(k) and 403(b) plans are permitted to provide employer-matching contributions based on the employees’ qualified student loan repayments outside the plan. Qualified student loan repayments include the repayment of certain qualified education loans incurred by an employee to pay qualified higher education expenses. Plan sponsors may rely on employee certification that payments have been made on such loans. For purposes of nondiscrimination testing, SECURE 2.0 allows the plan sponsor to conduct the actual deferral percentage (ADP) test separately for employees who receive this matching contribution. The US Department of the Treasury (Treasury) is expected to issue regulations with more details on how to administer student loan matching contributions. This change is optional for plan sponsors.
EMERGENCY SAVINGS OPTION
Starting in 2024, 401(k) and 403(b) plan sponsors can allow non-highly compensated employees to establish their own emergency savings accounts within the plan. Non-highly compensated employees can defer a total of $2,500 (indexed) into their emergency savings accounts. Investment earnings can cause the account balance to exceed $2,500, but no additional contributions can be made once the $2,500 limit is reached. These emergency savings contributions are generally treated as Roth contributions. Employers can automatically enroll non-highly compensated employees in these accounts, up to 3% of pay. To the extent an employer matches employee deferrals under its retirement plan, it must also match these emergency savings contributions. These emergency savings accounts must be invested in an investment option designed to preserve principal.
Additionally, these emergency savings accounts are intended to provide accessible funds to employees in the event of an emergency and, therefore, the initial four withdrawals from the account (per year) may not be subject to distribution fees by the plan’s recordkeeper. Highly compensated employees will not have the ability to make emergency savings contributions, but an employee who makes contributions when he or she is a non-highly compensated employee and later becomes a highly compensated employee can continue to access his or her account. We anticipate significant guidance from both the US Department of Labor (DOL) and Treasury regarding the implementation and use of these accounts. Employers are not required to offer these emergency savings accounts under their plans.
EXPANSION OF ROTH ACCOUNT CONTRIBUTIONS
- Effective January 1, 2024, if an employee has wages in excess of $145,000 (indexed) for the prior year, all catch-up contributions made to a 401(k) or 403(b) plan by that employee will be subject to Roth contribution tax treatment. Catch-up contributions made by employees with wages under the $145,000 indexed limit will continue to be treated as pre-tax contributions unless the employee affirmatively elects to make such contributions on a Roth basis. This change is mandatory. Therefore, to the extent a plan offers catch-up contributions, this feature effectively forces plan sponsors to implement a Roth catch-up contribution feature.
- Effective immediately, SECURE 2.0 allows plan sponsors to provide participants with the option to receive matching contributions or nonelective contributions on a Roth basis. This change is optional for plan sponsors and applies only to matching contributions and nonelective contributions that are fully vested when contributed to the plan.
SMALL FINANCIAL INCENTIVES TO ENCOURAGE PLAN PARTICIPATION
SECURE 2.0 permits employers to offer small financial incentives to employees, such as gift cards, to encourage participation in 401(k) and 403(b) plans. This change is effective for plan years beginning on or after January 1, 2023. Plan sponsors are not required to offer financial incentives, but they now have the option to do so.
INCREASED CATCH-UP CONTRIBUTION LIMIT
Effective January 1, 2025, participants who attain ages 60, 61, 62 and 63 during the year will have access to increased catch-up contribution limits. The increased limit is the greater of $10,000 (indexed) or 50% more than the regular catch-up limit. This is a required change.
IMPROVING COVERAGE FOR PART-TIME EMPLOYEES
SECURE 1.0 expanded retirement plan coverage for part-time employees by requiring 401(k) plan sponsors to allow part-time employees the option to make elective deferrals to the plan if they had attained age 21 and worked at least 500 hours of service in the past three consecutive years. SECURE 2.0 reduced the three-consecutive-year requirement to two consecutive years, and it also extended this requirement to apply to the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA)-covered 403(b) plans. Like SECURE 1.0, SECURE 2.0 does not require the employer to provide employer-matching or non-elective contributions on behalf of part-time employees otherwise covered by this provision. This is a required change.
AUTOMATIC CASHOUT CHANGES
Under current law, 401(k) and 403(b) plan sponsors have the option to automatically cash out participants and beneficiaries who have balances of $5,000 or less. For participants whose balances exceed $1,000 but are below the $5,000 cashout limit, the plan sponsor must roll these amounts into a third-party individual retirement account (IRA) established in the participant’s name instead of sending a check to the participant. Effective January 1, 2024, SECURE 2.0 increases the automatic cashout limit from $5,000 to $7,000. Utilization of the higher cashout limit is optional.
SECURE 2.0 also paves the way for “automatic portability providers” to automatically transfer a participant’s balance from a default IRA (established after an automatic cashout) into a defined contribution retirement plan sponsored by the participant’s new employer unless the participant affirmatively opts out of this transaction. The plan sponsor of the receiving plan would engage the automatic portability provider, and the provider would have to meet a number of specific regulatory requirements. The plan sponsor’s retention of an automatic portability provider would be optional. SECURE 2.0 requires the DOL to issue additional guidance on this feature within the next 12 months.
HARDSHIP CHANGES
Plan sponsors of both 401(k) and 403(b) plans may rely on the employee’s certification that he or she meets the deemed hardship criteria specified in the applicable regulations. Currently, plan sponsors can rely on an employee’s certification of the hardship withdrawal amount needed, but the employee must submit documentation to verify that the need for the withdrawal satisfies the deemed hardship criteria. This change applies for plan years beginning on or after December 29, 2022. Furthermore, for plan years beginning on or after January 1, 2024, SECURE 2.0 aligns the hardship withdrawal rules applicable to 403(b) plans with the hardship withdrawal rules currently applicable to 401(k) plans.
DISASTER CHANGES
SECURE 2.0 modified the distribution rules applicable in the event of a federally declared disaster. Under the new rules, if a participant is impacted by a federally declared disaster, they can request a distribution of up to $22,000 from their retirement plan. This distribution is not subject to the 10% early distribution penalty tax and can be taken into income over three years. Participants also have the ability to later repay these distributions to their retirement plans. SECURE 2.0 also allows plan sponsors to increase the maximum loan amounts available to a participant in the event of a federally declared disaster to $100,000 (or 100% of the participant’s account balance, if less). Plan sponsors can also extend the loan repayment period for such participants by one year. These changes are effective immediately and are optional. However, if a participant who is impacted by a federally declared disaster can otherwise request a different distribution from his retirement plan (e.g., the participant previously terminated employment), the participant may still be able to avoid the 10% early distribution penalty by completing his or her tax return accordingly; we are awaiting additional guidance on this point.
PENALTY-FREE DISTRIBUTIONS
SECURE 2.0 removes the 10% early distribution penalty tax on distributions taken by terminally ill individuals (effective immediately) or for certain emergency expenses (effective January 1, 2024) and limited withdrawals taken by victims of domestic abuse (effective January 1, 2024). These penalty tax exemptions apply to both defined contribution and defined benefit pension plans. Participants must have the ability to later repay these distributions to their retirement plans. SECURE 2.0 also provides for penalty-free withdrawals for up to $2,500 per year from a defined contribution plan to pay for certain long-term care insurance contracts. This provision takes effect in late 2025. These changes are optional. However, if a participant otherwise meets one of the criteria described above, the participant may still be able to avoid the 10% early distribution penalty by completing his or her tax return accordingly; we are awaiting additional guidance on this point.
MISCELLANEOUS CHANGES
- SECURE 2.0 requires the creation of a “Lost and Found” database to reunite missing participants with their retirement plan funds. This database will be maintained by the DOL and will cover both defined contribution and defined benefit plan funds.
- The Self Correction Program, the Internal Revenue Service’s (IRS) Employee Plans Compliance Resolution System (EPCRS), is expanded to allow more types of errors to be corrected through the self-correction component of EPCRS. This change is effective immediately, and SECURE 2.0 directs the IRS to update the applicable correction guidance accordingly within the next two years.
- The Saver’s Credit available under current law will be replaced with a retirement plan match. Under this revised program, qualifying low-income individuals who make contributions to their IRA or employer-sponsored retirement plan will receive a federally funded matching contribution to their IRA or retirement plan account of up to $2,000. This change takes effect on January 1, 2027. SECURE 2.0 also directs Treasury to better advertise this program to eligible individuals.
- SECURE 2.0 modified several participant notice provisions. Changes include (i) reducing the number and types of notices that a plan sponsor is required to provide to eligible employees who are not otherwise participating in the defined contribution plan, (ii) new paper statement requirements for both defined contribution and defined benefit plans and (iii) further modifications to the electronic distribution rules. Effective dates for these changes vary.
AMENDMENT DEADLINES
Plan amendments to implement these mandatory and optional provisions must be signed on or before the last day of the first plan year beginning on or after January 1, 2025. This is generally the same plan amendment deadline that was already in effect for the SECURE Act and Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act (CARES) Act amendments.
ACTION ITEMS
Plan sponsors should be mindful of the various effective dates and watch for communications from their third-party plan administrators requesting plan sponsor direction on the implementation of optional provisions. Plan sponsors should also be on the lookout for further guidance from the DOL, IRS and Treasury regarding the implementation of these new provisions. For more information on these changes, please contact your regular McDermott lawyer or one of the authors listed below.

FTC Proposes Rule to Ban Non-Compete Clauses
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
FTC Proposes Rule to Ban Non-Compete Clauses
January 10, 2023
Read time: 7 min
On Jan. 5, 2023, the Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”) released a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking to prohibit the use of non-compete clauses in worker contracts.[1] The proposed rule, if enacted in its present form, would (i) ban all non-compete agreements with workers and (ii) void all non-competes currently in existence. The proposed rule will soon be published in the Federal Register, after which the public will have 60 days to submit comments. The rule will become effective 60 days after a final rule is published.
The proposed rule is part of a larger challenge to non-compete agreements, which have come under increased political scrutiny in recent years. In July 2021, the Biden Administration published an executive order directing the FTC to curtail the use of such provisions in employment contracts. Since then, the FTC has taken legal action against three employers for imposing non-compete restrictions on workers in violation of the FTC Act.[2] Various states, including Oregon, Nevada, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Rhode Island, Virginia, Washington and Colorado have passed laws placing limitations on the use of non-compete agreements. Legislation limiting the use of non-competes has been proposed in other states including New York and Connecticut.
Proposed Rule
The proposed rule provides that it is an unfair method of competition and a violation of Section 5 of the FTC Act (which prohibits unfair competition) for an employer to “enter into or attempt to enter into a non-compete clause with a worker, maintain a non-compete with a worker, or, under certain circumstances, to represent to a worker that they are subject to a non-compete clause where the employer has no good faith basis to believe that the worker is subject to an enforceable non-compete clause.”[3]
The proposed rule defines a “non-compete clause” as a “contractual term between an employer and a worker that prevents the worker from seeking or accepting employment with a person or operating a business after the conclusion of the worker’s employment with the employer.” Importantly, the FTC proposes that a “functional test” be used to determine whether a clause is a “de facto non-compete.” A clause will be considered a non-compete provision if it will have “the effect of prohibiting the worker from seeking or accepting employment with a person or operating a business after the conclusion of the worker’s employment with the employer.” The FTC notes that while non-solicitation agreements and non-disclosure agreements typically do not prevent a worker from seeking or accepting employment or operating a business, if such covenants are “so unusually broad in scope that they function as such” by preventing a worker from seeking or accepting employment, then they would be considered de facto non-compete clauses. The FTC does not discuss whether long notice periods or “garden leave” periods would be considered de facto non-competes as well, though based on the fact they prevent a working from “seeking or accepting employment” it is a possibility.
Existing Non-Competes
The proposed rule would invalidate all existing non-competes. Employers will be required to rescind existing non-compete clauses no later 180 days after publication of the final rule, as well as refrain from entering into new non-compete agreements. Employers will be required to provide individualized notice to a worker that the worker’s non-compete has been rescinded and is no longer in effect within 45 days of the rescission. Notice requirements apply to both current workers and former workers for whom the employer has contact information readily available.
Sale of Business Non-Competes
The proposed rule provides for a limited exception for non-compete clauses between the seller and buyer of a business. A non-compete clause entered into by a person who is selling a business is permissible, but only if the restricted party is at least a 25 percent owner of the business.
Public Comments
Public comments to the proposed rule are due 60 days after it is published in the Federal Register. The FTC has the opportunity to adjust the proposed rule in response to public comment before it becomes finalized. The FTC invited comments on most aspects of the proposed rule and potential alternatives including:
- Whether non-compete clauses are “unfair” methods of competition under Section 5 that negatively affect competitive conditions in labor markets.
- Whether the rule should apply uniformly to all workers or whether there should be exemptions or different standards for different categories of workers, using one or more thresholds based on a worker’s job functions, earnings, some other factor or a combination of factors. This includes whether “senior executives” or other highly skilled workers should be exempted from the rule, or subject to a rebuttable presumption rather than a ban; and whether low and high wage workers should be treated differently under the rule.
Next Steps
The FTC may modify the proposed rule before it is finalized in response to public comments. In addition, legal challenges to the proposed rule are highly likely to occur and may delay its implementation once it becomes final. In her dissenting statement in the proposal, FTC Commissioner Christine S. Wilson questioned whether the FTC has the authority to engage in “unfair methods of competition” rulemaking, and argued that the rule may exceed the limits imposed by the Supreme Court’s major questions doctrine and the non-delegation doctrine.[4]
Authored by Mark E. Brossman, Benjamin Kozinn, Ian L. Levin, Ronald E. Richman, Martin L. Schmelkin, Max Garfield, Adam B. Gartner and Scott A. Gold.
If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.
[1] The proposed rule applies more broadly to “worker contracts” rather than “employment contracts” because it covers all workers, regardless of legal status, including independent contractors.
[2] The three cases all involved large employers who each required hundreds of their employees, including factory workers and security guards, to agree to non-compete clauses.
[3] Employer is broadly defined to include any natural person, partnership, corporation, association or other legal entity, including anyone acting under authority of state law, that hires or contracts a worker to work for the person. Worker is defined as a person who works, whether paid or unpaid, for an employer, including independent contractors, externs, interns, volunteers, apprentices or sole proprietors who provide a service to a client or customer.
[4] The major questions doctrine is the authority the Supreme Court can use to review FTC’s interpretation of the law, and to determine whether the FTC has exceeded its authority. The non-delegation doctrine is a principle in administrative law that Congress cannot delegate its legislative powers to other entities, including agencies like the FTC.
This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2023 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.
All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

2023 Regulatory Forecast
ARTICLE / REPORT
2023 Regulatory Forecast
January 2023
Read time: 4 min
The 2023 Regulatory Forecast outlines key regulatory developments and previews what to watch in the year ahead. We’re looking at top regulatory trends from the last year and how they will impact 2023 so that you and your business can be prepared.
Antitrust & Competition
The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and the US Department of Justice (DOJ) pursued aggressive antitrust and competition enforcement agendas this past year and show no signs of slowing down in 2023. Prepare for the year ahead by reviewing our 2023 Regulatory Forecast for the antitrust and competition space.
Click the links below to download a one-pager of takeaways and watch the videos for each area.
Antitrust & Competition | Merger Control: The Biden administration prioritized aggressive antitrust merger enforcement in 2022, especially in the healthcare, labor, consumer and technology sectors. Learn how this trend will continue in 2023 as the FTC and DOJ expand their toolbox to challenge transactions.

Antitrust Litigation: In 2022, the DOJ and FTC took boundary-shifting antitrust enforcement positions and proved they are not afraid to pursue novel legal theories. The DOJ alone has more open grand jury investigations and charged more cases in 2022 than it has in decades. The DOJ and the FTC also requested historic budget increases to support their aggressive agendas. Additional resources mean more regulators are available to investigate and litigate alleged anticompetitive conduct. Find out more about the aggressive enforcement by the antitrust agencies and private plaintiffs that is expected to continue in 2023.

Consumer Protection: Enforcement by the FTC, among other consumer protection regulators, was particularly vigorous in 2022 and the trend is expected to continue in 2023. In light of the increased regulatory focus on social media, marketing and advertising, businesses should be aware of the ever-evolving guidance in this realm. Read about the proposed rulemaking and revisions on the horizon this year.

Data Privacy & Cybersecurity
This year is likely to see significant changes to the laws and regulations dictating how companies collect, store, use and transfer personal data. Regulators in both the United States and Europe are increasing their focus on how companies collect data and publicly disclose their privacy and cybersecurity practices. We may see more frequent enforcement actions and greater potential liability for companies in 2023 as a result.
Prepare for the year ahead by downloading our 2023 Regulatory Forecast: Data Privacy & Cybersecurity and watching the video below.

Government Contracts
The federal government issued several mandates and proposed rules in 2022, the effects of which will no doubt be seen across the industry in 2023. Developments and requirements related to organizational conflicts of interest, as well as greenhouse gas emission disclosures, Cybersecurity Maturity Model Certification, COVID-19 vaccination requirements and more have the potential to affect federal contractors of all shapes, sizes, experience and ownership structures.
Prepare for the year ahead by downloading our 2023 Regulatory Forecast: Government Contracts.

The Clock Is Ticking: File Now to “Complete” the Louisiana Virtual Currency Business Activity Application by the Statutory Deadline
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
The Clock Is Ticking: File Now to “Complete” the Louisiana Virtual Currency Business Activity Application by the Statutory Deadline
January 9, 2023
Read time: 5 min
As the first state to follow New York’s lead in issuing a crypto-specific license, Louisiana began accepting Louisiana Virtual Currency Business Activity (VCBA) license applications as of January 1, 2023. All entities engaged in “virtual currency business activity” need to obtain licensure by July 1, 2023, to continue operations. This includes entities that are currently licensed money transmitters in Louisiana.
While VCBA licenses need to be obtained by July 1, Louisiana has stated that all applicants who file a “completed application” by April 1, 2023, will be guaranteed an official decision by June 30, 2023—the day before the licensure is required.[1] This does not mean, however, that a crypto exchange or other entity conducting “virtual currency business activity” can wait until April 1 to file its “completed application.”[2]
Applications are only deemed “completed” when the application has been officially noted as “Pending – Review” without any outstanding deficiencies.[3] Applicants can expect some back and forth after their initial filing of the VCBA application before Louisiana deems the application “complete.” Pursuant to the VCBA’s statutory language, “[a]n application for a license pursuant to the Section shall not be complete until the department receives all information required… and completes its investigation[.]”[4] The emergency rule language further provides that an “[a]pplication for licensure and notices of registration pursuant to this Section shall not be complete until the department: 1. Receives all information required by applicable provisions of the VCBA; and 2. Completes its investigation pursuant to R.S. 6:1385D.”[5] We anticipate that there will be an influx of filings in Louisiana and as a result, the completion of applications may be delayed. Getting on file sooner rather than later will be crucial to the efficient processing of an application.
Companies requiring licensure should act now as this process is anticipated to be similar to the NY BitLicense regime, which starts the clock on when the New York Department of Financial Services must make a decision upon an application that has been deemed officially “complete.”[6] This generally results in a series of meetings, letters, presentations and follow-ups prior to an application being deemed “complete.” We anticipate that Louisiana will be conducting similar diligence as it has explicitly stated in its statute that it must have “concluded” its investigation before the application is deemed “complete.” This means that crypto exchanges and others conducting “virtual currency business activity” need as much time as possible to prepare and file applications.
As of July 1, 2023, entities will be unable to continue conducting “virtual currency business activities” in Louisiana if they do not hold a VCBA license or are not otherwise exempt from licensure.[7] Entities that continue to conduct “virtual currency business activity” in Louisiana are subject to civil penalties for each individual violation of the VCBA and are further subject to additional “enforcement measures.”[8]
Louisiana defines “virtual currency business activity” as follows[9]:
(a) Exchanging, transferring, or storing virtual currency or engaging in virtual currency administration, whether directly or through an agreement with a virtual currency control services vendor.
(b) Holding electronic precious metals or electronic certificates representing interests in precious metals on behalf of another person or issuing shares or electronic certificates representing interests in precious metals.
(c) Exchanging one or more digital representations of value used within one or more online games, game platforms, or family of games for either of the following:
(i) Virtual currency offered by or on behalf of the same publisher from which the original digital representation of value was received.
(ii) Legal tender or bank credit outside the online game, game platform, or family of games offered by or on behalf of the same publisher from which the original digital representation of value was received.
A series of “regulated financial institutions” are exempt from VCBA licensing requirements.[10] Notably, registered money service businesses and licensed money transmitters are not among those exempt “regulated financial institutions.”[11]
For those entities that already hold a Louisiana money transmitter license, certain VCBA requirements will have already been uploaded to the Nationwide Multistate Licensing System (NMLS). Other obligations require information associated with the entity’s previous money transmission activity. There are also a series of requirements that are novel to the VCBA license. These include relatively comprehensive inquiries concerning the servers, a VCBA policy, and more robust disclosures concerning “investigations.”[12] Louisiana has just opened its doors to VCBA license applications. While many market participants believe they have until April 1 to file, the reality is that applications should be filed as soon as possible to ensure that Louisiana deems the application “complete” before the April 1 deadline.
McDermott’s fintech & blockchain team can help you navigate the nuances of the VCBA license application and meet its rapidly approaching deadline. McDermott’s crypto team, specifically, consists of lawyers who spend 100% of their time serving the crypto industry. We also have a sub-team of dedicated lawyers who focus exclusively on state crypto regulations and licensing.

New Proposed Regulations Would Affect the Taxation of Foreign Investors in U.S. Real Estate
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
New Proposed Regulations Would Affect the Taxation of Foreign Investors in U.S. Real Estate
January 6, 2023
Read time: 10 min
On Dec. 28, 2022, the Internal Revenue Service (“IRS”) released proposed regulations (REG-100442-22) (“Proposed Regulations”) that provide guidance on how indirect ownership is taken into account for purposes of determining whether a real estate investment trust (“REIT”) is “domestically controlled.” The Proposed Regulations also address the tax treatment of certain sovereign investing entities and modify the definition of “controlled commercial entity” under Section 892 of the Internal Revenue Code. The rules are particularly important for the real estate investment fund industry and for sovereign investors.
Proposed Regulations Under Section 897
Under the Foreign Investment in Real Property Tax Act of 1980 (“FIRPTA”), foreign corporations and nonresident aliens are generally subject to U.S. federal income tax on any gain arising from the disposition of a U.S. real property interest (“USRPI”). A USRPI includes an interest in a domestic corporation that was a United States real property holding corporation (“USRPHC”) at any time during the shorter of the five-year period ending on the date of the disposition of the interest or the period during which the taxpayer held the interest. A USRPHC is any corporation if the fair market value of its USRPIs equals or exceeds 50 percent of the sum of the fair market value of its real property interests and any other assets used or held for use in a trade or business. However, a USRPI does not include an interest in a REIT (or a regulated investment company (“RIC”) that is a USRPHC) that is “domestically controlled” (“DCREIT”). Accordingly, gain or loss on the disposition of stock in a DCREIT is not subject to tax under FIRPTA (“DCREIT Exception”) and ownership of a DCREIT would not cause a domestic corporation to become a USRPHC.
A REIT is generally considered “domestically controlled” if at all times during the five-year period ending on the date of the disposition of an interest in the REIT (or during the REIT’s existence if shorter) less than 50 percent of the value of the REIT’s stock is held “directly or indirectly” by foreign persons. Existing regulations generally define “foreign persons” as nonresident alien individuals, foreign corporations, foreign partnerships, foreign trusts or foreign estates. The Proposed Regulations clarify that qualified foreign pension funds (“QFPFs”) and certain entities owned by QFPFs are considered foreign persons for purposes of determining whether a REIT is domestically controlled.
Neither the statute nor existing regulations interpret the phrase “directly or indirectly,” which has resulted in uncertainty as to how non-U.S. ownership through a U.S. partnership and U.S. ownership through a non-U.S. partnership should be regarded. In addition, in Private Letter Ruling 200923001 (“PLR”), the IRS concluded that no look through was required in a case where two of the direct owners of the REIT in question were domestic C corporations. The PLR is cited in the legislative history accompanying the Protecting Americans from Tax Hikes Act of 2015 (“PATH Act”), which notes that, while a “private letter ruling may be relied upon only by the taxpayer to which it is issued,” it provides “some indication of administrative practice.” Furthermore, in a 2013 legislative discussion draft, Congress considered adding new constructive ownership rules that would address the possibility of looking through C corporations, but that proposal was not adopted by the PATH Act, while other proposals were. Based on the PLR, a common structuring technique has been to cause foreign investors in a REIT that would not otherwise have been a DCREIT to make a portion of their investment in the REIT through a domestic C corporation.
The Proposed Regulations offer an interpretation of the phrase “directly or indirectly” that clarifies the treatment of DCREIT ownership through partnerships and overturns the conclusion of the PLR as it relates to certain non-publicly traded corporations. Balancing ease of administration with the statutory requirement to take into account indirect ownership, the Proposed Regulations adopt a partial look-through approach, dividing owners into “non-look-through persons” and “look-through persons.” Only non-look-through persons are taken into account in determining whether a REIT is domestically controlled. Where a non-look-through person holds an interest in a REIT through a look-through person, the non-look-through person’s ownership of the REIT is determined based on the non-look-through person’s proportionate interest in the look-through person. No guidance is provided for a situation in which the look-through person is a partnership with diverging capital and profits interests.
Non-look-through persons include individuals, domestic C corporations (other than non-public foreign-owned domestic corporations discussed below), certain tax exempt organizations and governmental entities, foreign corporations (including foreign governments), publicly traded partnerships (domestic or foreign), estates (domestic or foreign), certain international organizations, certain public REITs, qualified foreign pension funds and qualified controlled entities. Non-look-through persons also include any person that holds less than five percent of any class of stock of a REIT that is regularly traded on an established securities market (with such person treated as a U.S. person unless the REIT has actual knowledge to the contrary). Look-through persons are any persons who are not non-look-through persons and include, for example, non-public REITs and RICs, S corporations, non-publicly traded partnerships (domestic and foreign) and trusts (domestic and foreign). The Proposed Regulations’ partnership look-through rule resolves existing uncertainty regarding the status of REITs owned by U.S. persons through foreign partnerships.
However, notwithstanding the general rule treating C corporations as non-look-through persons, the Proposed Regulations treat a “foreign-owned” domestic C corporation whose stock is not regularly traded on an established securities market as a look-through person. A domestic C corporation is considered foreign-owned if foreign persons hold directly or indirectly 25 percent or more of the fair market value of the corporation’s outstanding stock. The determination of whether a domestic C corporation is foreign-owned is made by applying the same rules that apply for purposes of determining whether a REIT is domestically controlled.
The Proposed Regulations relating to the determination of whether REITs are owned directly or indirectly by foreign persons are proposed to apply to transactions that occur on or after the date the regulations are published as final regulations in the Federal Register. Since there is generally a five-year look-back period from the date of the disposition of REIT shares for purposes of determining domestic control, the proposed effective date may cover structures that are already in place today, depending on when the regulations are finalized. In addition, the preamble to the Proposed Regulations states that the IRS “may challenge positions contrary to proposed §1.897-1(c)(3) and (4) before the issuance of final regulations relating to the topics addressed in those proposed rules.” While the scope of this warning is uncertain, funds that have structured non-U.S. investors’ investments in REITs through domestic blockers may wish to consider whether the benefits of the domestic blockers continue to outweigh their potential costs, and, if they do not, whether eliminating the blockers is feasible.
Proposed Regulations Under Section 892
Section 892 provides a U.S. tax exemption to foreign governments for certain specifically enumerated types of income. The exemption generally covers various categories of passive income including dividends and gain from the sale of non-controlled USRPHCs that would otherwise have been subject to tax under FIRPTA. However, the IRS has taken the position that dividends in respect of stock in a REIT (other than stock representing a 10-percent-or-less holding in a REIT listed on an established U.S. securities market) attributable to sales of underlying USRPIs generally are not exempt under Section 892.
Temporary regulations issued in 1988 under Section 892 (“Temporary Regulations”) provide that both the “integral parts” of a foreign government and its “controlled entities” are considered foreign governments for the purposes of the exemption. A principal distinction between an integral part of a foreign government and a controlled entity of a foreign government is that if a controlled entity becomes a “controlled commercial entity,” it loses the benefits of Section 892 entirely, whereas if an integral part of a foreign government engages in commercial activity, it loses the benefits of Section 892 only with respect to income from the commercial activity and not with respect to any other qualifying income. A controlled commercial entity is any entity that is owned 50 percent or more (directly or indirectly) by a foreign government (or with respect to which the foreign government exercises effective practical control) and is engaged in any commercial activity worldwide during the taxable year. Proposed regulations issued in 2011 (“2011 Proposed Regulations”) clarify that while the exemption is not available for REIT dividends attributable to sales of underlying USRPIs, such dividends do not cause the REIT shareholder to be considered to be engaged in a commercial activity. On the same day that the IRS released the Proposed Regulations, the IRS also re-opened the comment period relating to the 2011 Proposed Regulations, perhaps suggesting an intent to finalize the 2011 Proposed Regulations as well.
Notwithstanding the clarification of the 2011 Proposed Regulations, the Temporary Regulations have continued to be a source of consternation for sovereign investors. In particular, the rule that a foreign controlled entity will be deemed to be engaged in commercial activity (and will thus constitute a controlled commercial entity) if it is a USRPHC (“Deemed CCE Rule”), has created traps for the unwary. Under this rule, a foreign controlled entity holding nothing other than passive assets and a single minority interest in a USRPHC could be classified as a controlled commercial entity even if the value of the passive assets significantly exceeded the value of the interest in the USRPHC. Similarly, a foreign controlled entity whose only assets are minority interests in USRPHCs would be a controlled commercial entity. Gain from the sale of any underlying domestic USRPHC interests would be taxable even though, had the domestic USRPHC interests been held directly by the foreign government, the gain would have been eligible for the exemption. Finally, under the Deemed CCE Rule, a controlled QFPF that is a USRPHC, would be treated as a controlled commercial entity. This outcome frustrates the intention of Section 897(l) to exempt QFPFs from FIRPTA. These rules have been a source of disquiet for sovereign investors anxious to avoid inadvertently causing controlled investing entities, often established for commercial liability issues, to become controlled commercial entities.
The Proposed Regulations respond to these concerns by excluding from the application of the Deemed CCE Rule any foreign controlled entity that is either a QFPF or that would be a USRPHC solely by reason of its direct or indirect ownership interest in one or more other corporations that are not controlled by the foreign government. The exclusion is proposed to be effective for taxable years ending on or after Dec. 29, 2022 and may be relied upon by taxpayers until the Proposed Regulations are adopted as final in the Federal Register.
While the Proposed Regulations provide some welcome guidance regarding REITs and sovereign investors, they also reverse prior IRS policy that has formed the basis for a commonly used DCREIT planning technique.
Authored by Philippe Benedict, David S. Griffel, Andi Mandell, Joseph Reich, Shlomo C. Twerski, Alan S. Waldenberg, David S. Wermuth, Elie Zolty, Chaim Stern and Jacob A. Gach.
Please contact your Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP tax attorney for any questions about the Proposed Regulations.
This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2023 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.
All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

HSR Update: New Federal Law Substantially Increases Filing Fees for Large Deals and Imposes Foreign Subsidy Disclosure Requirements
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
HSR Update: New Federal Law Substantially Increases Filing Fees for Large Deals and Imposes Foreign Subsidy Disclosure Requirements
January 6, 2023
Read time: 5 min
On Dec. 29, 2022, President Joe Biden signed into law the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023 (also known as the Omnibus Funding Bill), which includes the Merger Filing Fee Modernization Act of 2022. The Merger Filing Fee Modernization Act significantly alters the framework for filing fees under the Hart-Scott-Rodino Antitrust Improvements Act of 1976 (“HSR Act”), lowering the filing fees for smaller deals but significantly increasing the filing fees for larger deals, with fees reaching $2.25 million for transactions valued at $5 billion or more. The Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”) has not yet disclosed the effective date of the new fees. In addition, the Merger Filing Fee Modernization Act adds disclosure requirements to HSR notification filings for companies receiving subsidies from certain foreign entities.
New HSR Filing Fee Framework
Unless an exemption applies, the HSR Act requires parties to acquisitions of voting securities, assets or non-corporate interests meeting certain thresholds to submit premerger notifications to the FTC and the Antitrust Division of the Department of Justice (“DOJ”), pay a filing fee (currently ranging from $45,000 to $280,000), and observe a waiting period before consummating their transactions.
The filing fees applicable to premerger notifications filed under the HSR Act have not changed in over two decades. Under Sections 2(c)(1)-(2) of the Merger Filing Fee Modernization Act, the filing fees will be divided into six tiers (instead of three) depending on transaction size. Deals valued less than $500 million will have modestly lower filing fees, but billion-dollar transactions will see significant fee increases, with the highest fee of $2.25 million being almost 10 times greater than the highest fee of $280,000 under the current framework.
The new HSR filing fees will be as follows:
|
Size of Transaction |
Filing Fee |
|
Greater than $50 million (as adjusted, currently $101 million) but less than $161.5 million |
$30,000 |
|
$161.5 million or more but less than $500 million |
$100,000 |
|
$500 million or more but less than $1 billion |
$250,000 |
|
$1 billion or more but less than $2 billion |
$400,000 |
|
$2 billion or more but less than $5 billion |
$800,000 |
|
$5 billion or more |
$2,250,000 |
*Beginning in Fiscal Year 2024, the filing tiers will be adjusted annually in accordance with changes in U.S. gross national product, and filing fees will be adjusted annually based on the Consumer Price Index as determined by the Department of Labor.
We expect the new filing fees will take effect in 2023, but the FTC has not yet announced the effective date. In the meantime, parties should proceed under the current fee framework.
New Foreign Subsidy Disclosure Requirement
The Merger Filing Fee Modernization Act also imposes new disclosure requirements on parties that receive subsidies from foreign entities that are considered strategic or economic threats to the United States.
Defined in Section 40207 of the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act, these “Foreign Entities of Concern” include:
- Entities owned by, controlled by or subject to the jurisdiction of China, Russia, Iran or North Korea;
- Entities designated as foreign terrorist organizations;
- Entities on the list of specially designated nationals and blocked persons maintained by the Office of Foreign Assets Control of the Department of Treasury;
- Entities alleged by the DOJ to have been involved in activities for which a conviction was obtained under the Espionage Act, Economic Espionage Act of 1996, the Arms Export Control Act, the Atomic Energy Act, the Export Control Reform Act or the International Emergency Economic Powers Act; and
- Entities determined to be engaged in unauthorized conduct that is detrimental to the national security or foreign policy of the United States.
“Subsidy” is defined broadly and includes direct subsidies, grants, loans, loan guarantees, tax concessions, preferential government procurement policies and government ownership or control. The new disclosure obligations will take effect after new rules are issued and revisions are made to the HSR form and instructions.
Key Takeaways
- Larger filing fees may impact negotiation strategies. The acquirer generally is responsible for the filing fee unless the parties negotiate otherwise. Parties to larger deals may more actively negotiate who will pay the increased filing fees. In addition, filing on letters of intent may decrease as parties may prefer to wait for the certainty of an executed and definitive agreement before submitting their HSR notifications.
- Consult experienced counsel regarding potential exemptions and accurate valuation. With significantly increased fees, it is critical for parties to accurately assess whether a filing is in fact required and, if so, the value of the transaction for HSR purposes (which can depend on a variety of factors, some industry-specific) in order to determine the relevant filing fee.
- Greater agency resources will enable increased antitrust scrutiny. The federal regulators have struggled to keep up with the pace of merger filings in recent years and to also fulfill the Biden administration’s promise of heightened antitrust scrutiny. The higher filing fees are expected to increase funding to the FTC and DOJ by about $1.4 billion over five years and could enable more staff to investigate more transactions.
Authored by Peter Jonathan Halasz, Ngoc Pham Hulbig and Jacob G. Shulman.
If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.
This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2023 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.
All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

FTC Proposes Rule Banning Noncompete Agreements
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
FTC Proposes Rule Banning Noncompete Agreements
January 5, 2023
Read time: 4 min
On January 5, 2023, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) issued a proposed rule that would prohibit employers from using noncompete agreements with their employees or independent contractors. This proposal arises from a preliminary finding by the FTC that noncompetes constitute an unfair method of competition in violation of Section 5 of the Federal Trade Commission Act (FTC Act). It comes on the heels of the FTC’s November policy statement asserting its intention to rigorously enforce and expand the scope of Section 5 of the FTC Act’s ban on unfair methods of competition.
If adopted, this rule would make it illegal for an employer to enter into a noncompete agreement with a worker, maintain a noncompete with a worker or represent to a worker that the worker is subject to a noncompete. Employers would also be required to rescind existing noncompetes and inform workers that they are no longer enforceable.
The proposed rule would apply to noncompetes with either employees or independent contractors. Other restrictive covenants such as non-disclosure agreements would not be affected by the FTC’s proposed rule unless they are so broad in scope that they essentially function as a noncompete agreement.
The FTC is inviting public comment on its proposed rule. Get the full text of the proposed rule and information on the public comment period. In particular, the FTC seeks comment on whether senior executives or franchisees should be covered by the rule, as well as whether low- and high-wage workers should be treated differently under the rule. Comments are due 60 days after the Federal Register publishes this proposed rule, after which the FTC is likely to issue a final rule. Should the rule become final, companies should be prepared for it to go into effect 180 days after the date of publication.
The proposed rule arrives with the FTC’s concurrent announcement of settlements in complaints it issued against three employers’ use of noncompetes. These settlements ban those employers from enforcing, threatening to enforce or imposing noncompetes against specified groups of employees and require that the companies notify all affected employees.
Historically, noncompetes were a matter of state law. With this new involvement from the FTC attempting to set a national ban on noncompetes, employers need to be aware of this latest attempt to regulate the use of noncompete agreements and restrictive covenants.
Whether the FTC will succeed remains an open question. Republican Commissioner Christine S. Wilson, in a dissenting statement, cautioned that the proposed rule is open to meritorious challenges that (1) the Commission lacks authority to engage in “unfair methods of competition” rulemaking and (2) the Supreme Court of the United States’ “major questions” doctrine suggests that the federal courts may preclude the FTC from venturing into this novel area of regulation absent legislative amendments to its enabling statute. Plus, interested parties may persuade the FTC to scale back its proposed regulation.
Entities interested in submitting such comments can obtain further guidance and drafting assistance from either Paul Hughes, Brian Mead or a member of the Firm’s antitrust group.

EU Foreign Subsidies Regulation Enters into Force in 2023
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
EU Foreign Subsidies Regulation Enters into Force in 2023
January 5, 2023
Read time: 9 min
On December 23, 2022, Regulation (EU) 2022/2560 of December 14, 2022 on foreign subsidies distorting the internal market (FSR) was published in the Official Journal of the European Union. The FSR introduces a new regulatory hurdle for M&A transactions in the European Union (EU), in addition to merger control and foreign direct investment screening. The FSR’s impact cannot be overstated as it introduces two mandatory pre-closing filing regimes and it gives the Commission wide-reaching ex officio investigative and intervention powers. Soon, the Commission will also launch a public consultation on a draft implementing regulation that should further detail and clarify a number of concepts and requirements of the FSR.
The bulk of the FSR will apply as of July 12, 2023. Importantly, the notification requirements for M&A transactions and public procurement procedures will apply as of October 12, 2023.
We highlight the key principles of the FSR below and provide guidance to start preparing for the application of the FSR. We refer to our On The Subject article ‘EU Foreign Subsidies Regulation to Impact EU and Cross-Border M&A Antitrust Review Starting in 2023’ of August 2, 2022 for a more detailed discussion of the then draft FSR. We also refer to our December 8, 2022 webinar on the FSR. Given the importance of the FSR, we will continue to report any future developments.
FSR in a Nutshell
The FSR tackles ‘foreign subsidies’ granted by non-EU governments to companies active in the EU and which ‘distort the internal market’.
- First, a ‘foreign subsidy’ will be considered to exist where a direct or indirect financial contribution from a non-EU country or an entity whose actions can be attributed to a non-EU country (public entities or private entities) confers a benefit on an undertaking engaging in an economic activity in the EU internal market, and where that benefit is not generally available under normal market conditions but is, instead, limited, in law or in fact, to assisting one or more undertakings or industries. A ‘financial contribution’ covers a broad spectrum and encompasses, amongst others, positive benefits such as the transfer of funds or liabilities, the foregoing of revenue otherwise due (e.g., tax breaks, the grant of exclusive rights below market conditions, or the provision or purchase of goods or services).
- Second, a ‘distortion in the internal market’ will be considered to exist in case of a foreign subsidy which is liable to improve the competitive position of an undertaking and which actually or potentially negatively affects competition in the EU internal market. The Regulation provides some guidance on when a foreign subsidy typically would not be a cause for concern:
– A subsidy that does not exceed EUR 200,000 per third country over any consecutive period of three years is considered de minimis and therefore not distortive;
– A foreign subsidy that does not exceed EUR 4 million per undertaking over any consecutive period of three years is unlikely to cause distortions; and
– A foreign subsidy aimed at making good/recovering from the damage caused by natural disasters or exceptional occurrences may be considered not to be distortive.
The FSR looks at ‘undertakings’, as is the case for merger control. Therefore, the Commission will not look merely at the legal entity concerned, but at the entire corporate group to which the entity belongs in order to calculate the total amount of foreign financial contributions granted to the undertaking. Even companies headquartered in the EU that have entities outside of the EU that have received foreign financial contributions are covered by the FSR.
The FSR introduces three tools for the European Commission (Commission): (i) a notification requirement for certain M&A transactions, (ii) a notification requirement for certain public procurement procedures (PPP) and (iii) investigations on a case by case basis.
Notification Requirement for Certain M&A Transactions
M&A transactions (or “concentrations”) involving a buyer and/or a target that has received a foreign financial contribution shall be notifiable if they meet the following cumulative conditions:
- At least one of the merging undertakings, the acquired undertaking (target, not buyer) or the joint venture is established in the EU and has an EU turnover of at least EUR 500 million, AND
- The combined aggregate financial contributions provided to the undertakings concerned in the three financial years (combined) prior to notification amounts to more than EUR 50 million.
M&A transactions that meet these criteria will need to be notified and approved by the Commission prior to implementation. During its review, the Commission will determine whether the foreign financial contributions received constitute foreign subsidies in the sense of the FSR and whether these foreign subsidies actually or potentially distort or negatively affect competition in the EU internal market. The Commission likely will consider certain indicators including the amount and nature of the foreign subsidy, the purpose and conditions attached to the foreign subsidy as well as its use in the EU internal market. For example, in a case of an acquisition, if a foreign subsidy covers a substantial part of the purchase price of the target, the Commission may consider it likely to be distortive.
Notification Requirement for Certain Public Procurement Procedures
A notifiable foreign financial contribution in the context of PPP shall be deemed to arise where the following cumulative conditions are met:
- The estimated value of the public procurement or framework agreement net of VAT amounts to at least EUR 250 million, AND
- The economic operator was granted aggregate foreign financial contributions in the three financial years prior to notification of at least EUR 4 million from a non-EU country.
Where the procurement is divided into lots, the value of the lot or the aggregate value of all lots for which the undertaking bids for must, in addition to the two criteria set out above, also amount to at least EUR 125 million.
Through this procedure, the Commission will ensure that companies that have received non-EU country subsidies do not submit unduly advantageous bids in public procurement procedures.
During the Commission’s review, all procedural steps may continue except for the award of the contract.
Even if the thresholds are not met, the Regulation requires undertakings to provide to the contracting authority in a declaration attached to the tender a list of all foreign financial contributions received in the last three financial years and to confirm that these are not notifiable, which the contracting authority will subsequently send to the Commission.
Investigations on a Case-by-case Basis
The Commission may on its own initiative investigate potentially distortive foreign subsidies (e.g. following a complaint). These investigations are not limited to M&A transactions or PPP. However, on the basis of this power, the Commission may investigate M&A transactions and awarded contracts under PPP which do not fall within the scope of the notification requirements set out above.
If the Commission carries out an ex-officio review, its analysis will be structured in two phases: a preliminary examination and an in-depth investigation. Although these phases have no time limits, the Commission will endeavor to take a decision within 18 months of the start of the in-depth investigation.
HOW TO PREPARE FOR THE APPLICATION OF THE FSR
Application of the FSR – Timetable
As mentioned above, the FSR will apply as of July 12, 2023. The FSR shall apply to foreign subsidies granted in the five years prior to July 12, 2023 where such foreign subsidies create effects at present, i.e., they distort the internal market after July 12, 2023. By way of derogation, the FSR shall apply to foreign financial contributions granted in the 3 years prior to July 12, 2023 where such foreign financial contributions were granted to an undertaking notifying a concentration or notifying a PPP pursuant to the FSR.
The FSR shall not apply to concentrations for which the agreement was signed before July 12, 2023. The FSR shall also not apply to public procurement contracts that have been awarded or procedures initiated before July 12, 2023.
In general, the FSR shall apply from July 12, 2023 while the notification obligations for M&A transactions and PPP shall only apply from October 12, 2023. However, it is advisable to start preparing immediately for the application of the FSR, given the substantial scope of the regulation.
Actions to Take Now
Businesses which conduct activities in the EU, should put in place a system to monitor and quantify foreign financial contributions received since at least July 2020 – to cover the three-year review – and, preferably, July 2018. In particular, attention should be paid to positive benefits and reliefs from certain costs normally due by the company. External counsel can assist in determining whether these foreign financial contributions constitute a ‘foreign subsidy’.
As soon as a company decides to engage in an M&A or PPP in the EU, the company should map all relevant foreign financial contributions for the relevant time period to check whether the relevant notification thresholds are met. Subsequently companies must carefully consider whether any such financial contribution constitutes a foreign subsidy and, if so, whether such foreign subsidy may have a distortive effect. It is also advisable to determine whether there any positive effects relating to the subsidy that could be invoked. Companies should ensure that the preparation above is ably assisted by external counsel.
In particular with regard to M&A transactions, companies should carry out an FSR analysis in addition to merger control and foreign direct investment reviews. Even at the stage of due diligence, it would already be advisable to check whether the target has received any foreign financial contributions. If the transaction might eventually trigger a notification to the Commission, the M&A agreement should provide for Commission approval in the closing conditions. When acting as a bidder for a target that meets the EU turnover threshold, your bid will be much better viewed when accompanied with clear assurances that no FSR filing is required or, alternatively, that a filing may be required but that the foreign subsidies received are not distortive of competition.

Prescription Drug Data Reporting: What the “Good Faith Compliance” Extension Really Means for Self-Funded Group Health Plans
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
Prescription Drug Data Reporting: What the “Good Faith Compliance” Extension Really Means for Self-Funded Group Health Plans
January 5, 2023
Read time: 8 min
We recently reported on an FAQ issued December 23, 2022 (FAQ About Affordable Care Act and Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021 Implementation Part 56) by the US Departments of Labor, Health and Human Services and the Treasury (collectively, the Departments). The FAQ provides limited, albeit welcome, relief by extending the time for reporting information under the prescription drug data collection (RxDC) rules, which were enacted by Section 204 of Title II of Division BB of the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021.
Under the statute, the first RxDC reports for the 2020 calendar (or reference) year, were due to be filed by December 27, 2021. However, in response to concerns expressed by stakeholders, enforcement was pushed back a full year to December 27, 2022, at which time the reports for both the 2020 and 2021 reference years were due. The RxDC reporting process required the submission of one or more “plan lists,” a series of eight data files (files D1 through D8) and an accompanying narrative response. (The contents of the plan lists, data files and narrative responses are comprehensively explained here (the Instructions).)
In the FAQ, the Departments pledged to not take enforcement action against any plan or issuer that makes a good faith effort to comply and establishes a submission grace period through January 31, 2023. The FAQ also provides a series of “clarifications” to the RxDC rules that relaxes the rules on multiple submissions, permits duplicative submissions by multiple reporting entities, loosens the standards governing data aggregation, allows for the submission of certain data by email and makes certain otherwise required reporting elements optional. A summary of their impact on self-funded group health plans is as follows:
- Multiple Submissions by the Same Reporting Entity Allowed. The interim final rule implementing the RxDC rules generally require a reporting entity that submits RxDC reporting data on behalf of more than one plan or issuer to combine the data of all clients within a single set of plan lists and data files. (Section 5.3 Instructions are in accord; Section 5.4 provides useful examples.) Compliance with this requirement has proven particularly troublesome for entities that have gone through one or more acquisitions and found they had missing information due to former plan vendors and/or plans who were unwilling or unable to provide the information necessary to complete the required reporting. In a subsequent Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) FAQ, the regulators permitted multiple data files of the same type from the same group health plan (e.g., two or more D2 files reporting the plan’s total annual healthcare spending), if there are “extenuating circumstances” preventing vendors from working together. The FAQ removes the qualifier. By way of example, a group health plan that covers employees of multiple corporations, trades or businesses under common control is, under the clarification, permitted to report by controlled-group entity instead of including data for all entities in a single set of plan lists and data files. More relief from the Departments specific to corporate transactions and/or merged plans would be welcome.
- Submissions by Multiple Reporting Entities Allowed. According to the Instructions (Section 3.3): “Multiple reporting entities should not submit the same data file for a plan, issuer, or carrier. For example, a TPA and PBM should not both submit D2 for the same group health plan.”
Under the FAQ’s clarification, more than one reporting entity may submit the same data file type on behalf of the same plan or issuer, instead of working together to consolidate all data into a single data file for each type of data. The D2, for example, includes information on medical spending by category. Categories for this purpose include hospital, primary care, specialty care, other medical costs and services and known and estimated medical benefit drugs. It is not uncommon for self-funded group health plans to have multiple service providers. The relief in this instance will allow information for the same file (here, D2) to come from multiple sources.
- Aggregation Restriction Suspended. The interim final rules require that if multiple reporting entities submit the required data on behalf of one or more plans or issuers in a state and market segment, the data submitted by each of these reporting entities must be aggregated to at least the aggregation level used by the reporting entity that submits data on the total annual spending on healthcare services on behalf of those plans or issuers. Total annual spending is reported in the D2 file. The FAQ relieves the entity submitting D3 through D8 files from having to ensure that the data in the D2 file for the 2020 and 2021 reference years is aggregated at the same level of detail. Thus, for example, a group health plan may submit data for the D2 file at the plan level, while the plan’s third-party administrator (TPA) may submit the remaining files using data that is aggregated across its entire self-funded book of business.
- Submission of Premium and Life-Years Data by Email. RxDC reports are submitted using the CMS Health Insurance Oversight System (HIOS), which requires users to go through the CMS Enterprise Portal (Instructions Section 3.1). Doing so requires users to register for a CMS Identity Management system account. Most carriers and TPAs already have HIOS accounts; most group health plans do not. The registration process is complicated, takes time and in most cases requires—or at least benefits from—competent (and patient) IT assistance. The need to establish the account has proven particularly nettlesome for a subset of self-funded plans with unique or overlapping funding and benefit structures and for multiple employer arrangements, among others. Submitting the information required by the P2 list and the D1 file is particularly challenging. The FAQs permit a group health plan or its reporting entity to submit only the plan list (P2 in the case of a group health plan), premium and life-years data and narrative response by email. The relief is directed at the D1 file, which includes premium and life-year data. In addition, the narrative response of a self-funded plan that estimates certain plan parameters (g., take-up rates) must explain their methodology if the plan deviates from the method prescribed. While the relief under this clarification is narrow, it will be particularly useful in the instances to which it applies.
- Reporting on Vaccines Optional. Under the FAQ, reporting entities of all stripes may, but are not required to, include certain vaccines in their data files. The relief applies to plans and issuers alike.
- Reporting Amounts Not Applied to the Deductible or Out-of-Pocket Maximum Optional. The FAQ exempts all reporting entities form having to report a value for “amounts not applied to the deductible or out-of-pocket maximum” and the “Rx amounts not applied to the deductible or out-of-pocket maximum.” Reporting entities are admonished not “to remove these columns from data files D2” but instead should “leave blank the data fields in these columns.” Like the previous bullet point, the relief applies across the board.
In recognition of the extensive reporting obligations and the compliance difficulties facing plan sponsors with multiple health plan vendors, the FAQ provides only limited enforcement relief. Plan sponsors that have submitted RxDC reports may consider whether they should adjust their reports considering the FAQ, and plan sponsors that have not submitted RxDC reports now have additional time to complete their submission. All plan sponsors should work with their health plan vendors to compile complete information by the updated enforcement deadlines of January 31, 2023, for the 2020 and 2021 reference years and June 1, 2023, for the 2022 reference year.
The statute imposes RxDC reporting obligations on the group health plan itself. Insured plans may satisfy the requirements by entering into a written agreement with a carrier to report the required information. If the carrier fails to report, the carrier (not the plan) violates the reporting requirements. A different rule applies to self-funded plans. While self-funded plans will inevitably contract with third parties to assist with their RxDC reporting obligations, if the third party fails to report the required information, the plan is responsible for the failure. Self-funded plans have encountered difficulties when current plan vendors have refused to assist with RxDC reporting for merged plans or plans of acquired entities, requiring the employees of the sponsor of the self-funded plan to make best efforts to complete the required reporting. The stakes for self-funded plans are, as a result, high, and any relief the Departments may choose to provide is welcome.
Employers and plan sponsors with questions about RxDC should contact their regular McDermott employee benefits lawyer or one of the authors listed below.
