Content Type: Article

  • DOJ Highlights Self-Disclosure and Cooperation by Corporate Entities

    DOJ Highlights Self-Disclosure and Cooperation by Corporate Entities

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    DOJ Highlights Self-Disclosure and Cooperation by Corporate Entities

    January 24, 2023

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On Jan. 17, 2023, the head of the Criminal Division of the Department of Justice, Assistant Attorney General Kenneth Polite, announced[1] revisions to the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (“FCPA”) Corporate Enforcement Policy[2] (“CEP”) designed to further encourage self-reporting and cooperation by corporate entities. The Criminal Division created a voluntary self-disclosure program for FCPA cases in 2016, which became DOJ policy for all of their corporate prosecutions in 2018. The revised policy that Polite announced last week applies to all corporate criminal matters the Criminal Division of DOJ handles,[3] and seeks to directly incentivize voluntary self-disclosure for all corporate entities in all federal criminal prosecutions.

    This comes four months after Deputy Attorney General Lisa Monaco released a memorandum[4] (“Monaco Memo”), directing each DOJ Division involved in prosecuting corporate crime to adopt policies to be “sufficiently transparent such that the benefits of voluntary self-disclosure are clear and predictable.” Like Monaco, Polite emphasized the strong focus on prosecuting corporate crime and the key role voluntary self-disclosure plays in that effort. These changes strongly encourage self-disclosure and cooperation when, for example, an investment fund learns of potential criminal violations at a company during due diligence or after acquisition of an equity interest in that company.

    The DOJ’s Voluntary Self-Disclosure Program

    The prior CEP created a presumption that DOJ would decline to prosecute corporate entities that voluntarily self-disclosed, fully cooperated, and appropriately remediated the problem. There was an exception to this presumption when aggravating circumstances existed, including egregious misconduct, involvement of executive management, significant unlawful profits and criminal recidivism. The prior policy did not specify whether a declination was possible if aggravating circumstances were present. According to Polite, this “may have led companies and their outside counsel to conclude, under the prior version of the CEP, that it is more prudent not to disclose the misconduct.”

    DOJ’s Revised Corporate Enforcement Policy

    Unlike the former version of the Criminal Division’s CEP, the revised policy creates a clear path to declination even where aggravating circumstances are present. Under the new policy, prosecutors may still determine that a declination of prosecution for the corporate entity would be appropriate if:

    • The voluntary self-disclosure was made immediately upon the company becoming aware of the allegation of misconduct;
    • At the time of the misconduct and disclosure, the company had an effective compliance program and system of internal accounting controls, which enabled the identification of the misconduct and led to the company’s voluntary self-disclosure; and
    • The company provided extraordinary cooperation with the Department’s investigation and undertook extraordinary remediation efforts.

    Polite commented that not all corporations will be able to overcome aggravating circumstances, but the revised CEP provides incentives for entities to cooperate even where one or more aggravating circumstances are present. Previously, the Monaco Memo stated that the DOJ ordinarily “will not seek a guilty plea where a corporation has voluntarily self-disclosed, fully cooperated, and timely and appropriately remediated the criminal conduct.” The revised CEP reaffirms this principle.

    The revisions to the CEP strongly encourage self-reporting and cooperation by significantly increasing the fine reductions that corporations can receive by doing so. Under the prior CEP, when a corporation self-disclosed the unlawful conduct but aggravating circumstances dictated a criminal resolution and not a declination of charges, the Criminal Division “offer[ed] 50% off of the low end of the applicable Sentencing Guidelines penalty range.” The revised CEP increases the incentive to cooperate by providing that, in this circumstance, the Criminal Division will offer at least 50% and up to 75% off of the low end of the applicable penalty range. If a corporation is a recidivist, the revised CEP provides that the reduction generally will not be from the low-end of the fine range, although prosecutors have the discretion to determine the starting point within the penalty range.

    The revised CEP incentivizes cooperation by corporations that do not voluntarily self-disclose but do fully cooperate. Entities that do not self-disclose but fully cooperate with DOJ in a timely manner with appropriate remediation will be offered up to 50% off of the low end of the applicable fine range. This doubles the maximum amount of a reduction available under the prior CEP.

    Polite explained that the Criminal Division will evaluate “extraordinary cooperation” by entities in the same way it evaluates individuals: “[W]hen an individual begins to cooperate immediately, and consistently tells the truth; individuals who allow us to obtain evidence we otherwise couldn’t get, like quickly obtaining and imaging their electronic devices, or having recorded conversations; cooperation that produces results, like testifying at a trial or providing information that leads to additional convictions.” Polite’s message to corporations is that they must go above and beyond the standard criteria to receive full credit for cooperation, stating: “[W]e know ‘extraordinary cooperation’ when we see it.”[5]

    Discovery of Potential Criminal Conduct

    One common way corporate misconduct is uncovered is when a firm uncovers evidence of criminal conduct during the course of due diligence of an acquisition target. Discovery can also occur post-acquisition, after the acquiring entity takes some level of control over the target. If the misconduct is promptly and voluntarily self-disclosed, the new DOJ policy creates a presumption of declination of prosecution. The misconduct must be uncovered “through thorough and timely due diligence or, in appropriate instances, through post-acquisition audits or compliance integration efforts.” Even where aggravating circumstances exist, acting in accord with the CEP and performing appropriate remediation can now lead to a declination of prosecution. This directly echoes guidance from high ranking officials at the Securities and Exchange Commission regarding increased transparency in awarding cooperation credit to entities that voluntarily self-disclose, and may materially change the risk/reward analysis when firms become aware of potential criminal conduct at potential or current portfolio companies.

    Authored by Peter H. White and Craig S. Warkol.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] Kenneth A. Polite, Jr., Assistant Attorney General, Remarks on Revisions to the Criminal Division’s Corporate Enforcement Policy (Jan. 17, 2023), https://www.justice.gov/opa/speech/assistant-attorney-general-kenneth-polite-jr-delivers-remarks-georgetown-university-law (“Polite Remarks”).

    [2] Criminal Division Corporate Enforcement and Voluntary Self-Disclosure Policy, JM 9-47.120, available at https://www.justice.gov/opa/speech/file/1562851/download.

    [3] DOJ’s Antitrust Division has its own Leniency Program which differs in some respects as to the criteria required for a corporate declination of prosecution. See Antitrust Division Leniency Policy and Procedures, JM 7-3.300, available at https://www.justice.gov/atr/page/file/1490246/download.

    [4] Memorandum from Deputy Attorney General Lisa Monaco, Further Revisions to Corporate Criminal Enforcement Policies (Sept. 15, 2022).

    [5] Polite emphasized that individual accountability is “[o]ur number one goal in this area.” Polite Remarks. In order to receive credit for extraordinary cooperation, DOJ expects cooperating entities to identify all culpable individuals and to take timely disciplinary measures against them regardless of seniority; otherwise “a company runs the risk of increasing its criminal exposure and monetary penalties.” Id.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2023 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

     

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • NYDFS Announces $100 Million Settlement with Coinbase for Anti-Money Laundering Compliance Deficiencies

    NYDFS Announces $100 Million Settlement with Coinbase for Anti-Money Laundering Compliance Deficiencies

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    NYDFS Announces $100 Million Settlement with Coinbase for Anti-Money Laundering Compliance Deficiencies

    January 23, 2023

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The New York Department of Financial Services (“NYDFS”) announced on January 4 that it had reached a $100 million settlement with Coinbase, Inc. (“Coinbase”), a NYDFS-licensed money transmitter and “Bitlicensee,” to resolve deficiencies in Coinbase’s anti-money laundering (“AML”) compliance program.[1] As part of the $100 million in the settlement, Coinbase will pay $50 million as a civil penalty to the NYDFS and invest an additional $50 million over the next two years to improve its AML compliance program, including by appointing a NYDFS-selected independent monitor.

    The Consent Order between the NYDFS and Coinbase describes how NYDFS’ supervision of Coinbase led to a discovery of significant deficiencies in Coinbase’s compliance program, including failures to (1) conduct adequate Know Your Customer (“KYC”) due diligence at customer onboarding, (2) timely clear alerts identified by Coinbase’s transaction monitoring systems; (3) timely file suspicious activity reports; (4) conduct proper politically exposed person (“PEP”) and sanctions screening, and (5) take required cybersecurity measures in response to a cyberattack.

    Below please find the “key takeaways” for NYDFS regulated financial institutions:

    • Ensure you are risk rating your customers and collecting KYC information commensurate with such risk — collecting the same KYC information for all customers is not necessarily sufficient;
    • Ensure your customer due diligence process considers the purpose of a customer’s account, expected annual activity, and enhanced due diligence for high-risk customers;
    • Ensure you increase the size of your compliance staff as your business grows in order to prevent a backlog of transaction monitoring alerts and other compliance deficiencies;
    • Maintain proper oversight of any third-party contractors retained to do compliance-related work;
    • Conduct ongoing sanctions and PEP screening to adjust your risk for customers, including those using Virtual Private Networks (“VPNs”) or The Onion Router (“TOR”);
    • Test or audit your reporting procedures to ensure that your financial institution is in a position to notify the NYDFS within 72 hours of a cybersecurity event in accordance with Part 500 of the New York Superintendent’s Regulations; and
    • Dedicate adequate resources to ensure timely compliance with NYDFS examination findings and implementation of remediation efforts.

    Background on NYDFS Supervision of Coinbase

    In May 2020, the NYDFS conducted a supervisory examination of Coinbase for the time period of July 2018 to December 2019 and found numerous significant deficiencies in Coinbase’s compliance program. Such problems continued into the present, despite Coinbase having engaged an independent consultant soon after the examination and the NYDFS installing an independent monitor in February 2022.

    KYC Deficiencies

    According to the Consent Order, Coinbase had severe KYC and customer due diligence deficiencies. The Consent Order states that Coinbase treated customer onboarding requirements “as a simple check-the box exercise.”[2] Examples of such deficiencies included, but were not limited to, failing to assign a “risk rating” to retail customers, retail customer due diligence files often consisting of only a copy of a photo ID, allowing customers to open accounts without providing the purpose of the account or expected annual activity, and failing to conduct enhanced due diligence on high-risk customers.

    Transaction Monitoring Deficiencies

    Coinbase also failed to maintain a proper transaction monitoring system, as mandated by Part 504 of the New York Superintendent’s Regulations.[3] It failed to review transaction monitoring alerts as a backlog of such alerts grew. The Consent Order describes that Coinbase failed to have adequate compliance staff to review the unexpected high alert volume, and when Coinbase hired third-party contractors to “burn through” the backlogged alerts, Coinbase failed to provide sufficient oversight of the contractors.

    • Examples of the insufficient oversight that Coinbase conducted of the contractors included failing to (1) monitor attendance of contractors at training sessions, and (2) implement a system to audit the contractors’ quality of work.
    • Coinbase also failed to notify the NYDFS of the poor results of a Coinbase quality check of the contractors’ work.[4] Specifically, after a Coinbase Quality Assurance review in March 2022 revealed quality issues with the work of certain outside contractors, Coinbase retained a third-party audit firm to review and check the quality of a few contractors who together “cleared” more than 73,000 transaction monitoring alerts. The third-party audit firm reported in July 2022 to Coinbase that the clearance of more than half of the 73,000 alerts failed a quality check. Coinbase did not inform the NYDFS of these issues until July 2022, despite Coinbase already being subject to a Memorandum of Understanding with the NYDFS in February 2022 to inform the NYDFS of these issues as they arose.

    Failure to Timely Report Suspicious Activity

    The Consent Order also states that as a result of Coinbase’s transaction monitoring system accruing a large backlog of transaction monitoring alerts, Coinbase failed to timely report suspicious activity to the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network within the required 30 days of the detection of the suspicious activity. The Consent Order also states that Coinbase often had poor recordkeeping of its own suspicious activity investigations and reporting.[5] For example, after the NYDFS made a request for data related to Coinbase’s suspicious activity identification and reporting from 2018 to 2019, Coinbase could not meaningfully respond to the request.

    Improper Sanctions and PEP Screening

    The Consent Order states that Coinbase failed to conduct sufficient sanctions and PEP screening. With regard to sanctions screening, Coinbase did not use a risk-based system to adjust the risk for customers using VPNs or TOR (as VPNs and TOR allow people to make their location appear different than where the user is actually physically located, and thus can be effective tools for dodging sanctions screening).[6] With regard to PEP screening, the Consent Order states that although Coinbase conducted initial PEP screening at customer onboarding, Coinbase did not conduct ongoing PEP screening on its institutional customers until December 2020, and as a result, Coinbase had not been aware if some of those institutions were at a higher risk for corruption, bribery, money laundering and any other illegal activity.

    Failure to Report Cybersecurity Event

    Finally, in 2021, Coinbase failed to inform the NYDFS within 72 hours that thousands of Coinbase’s customers’ accounts were illegally accessed due to a phishing scam. [7] Part 500 of the New York Superintendent’s Regulations require reporting of cybersecurity events to the NYDFS within 72 hours of the event.[8]

    Remediation

    Under the terms of the Consent Order, Coinbase must invest $50 million into its compliance function and must also be subject to supervision of an independent monitor (who already was installed by the NYDFS prior to the Consent Order) for an additional year. The NYDFS at its sole discretion may extend the tenure of the independent monitor.[9]

    Conclusion

    The NYDFS’ settlement and consent order with Coinbase is a reminder to any New York-regulated financial institutions that such institutions should ensure their AML and sanctions programs do not have the same deficiencies that Coinbase had. Moreover, the targeting of Coinbase by the NYDFS is demonstrative that state regulators hold cryptocurrency exchanges to high AML and sanctions compliance standards typical of more traditional financial institutions.

    Schulte Roth & Zabel’s lawyers are available to assist you in addressing any questions you may have regarding these developments. Please contact the Schulte Roth & Zabel lawyer with whom you usually work, or any of the following attorneys:

    Donald J. Mosher – New York (+1 212.756.2187, donald.mosher@srz.com)

    Betty Santangelo – New York (+1 212.756.2587, betty.santangelo@srz.com)

    Melissa G.R. Goldstein – Washington, DC (+1 202.729.7471, melissa.goldstein@srz.com)

    Kara A. Kuchar – New York (+1 212.756.2734, kara.kuchar@srz.com)

    Adam J. Barazani – New York (+1 212.756.2519, adam.barazani@srz.com)

    Jessica Romano – New York (+1 212.756.2205, jessica.romano@srz.com)

    Jessica Sklute – New York (+1 212.756.2180, jessica.sklute@srz.com)

    Noah N. Gillespie – Washington, DC (+1 202.729.7483, noah.gillespie@srz.com)

    Hadas A. Jacobi – New York (+1 212.756.2055, hadas.jacobi@srz.com)

    Rebecca A. Raskind – New York (+1 212.756.2396, rebecca.raskind@srz.com)

    Jesse Weissman – New York (+1 212.756.2460, jesse.weissman@srz.com)


    [1] In the Matter of: Coinbase, Inc., Consent Order (Jan. 4, 2022), available here; Press Release, Superintendent Adrienne A. Harris Announces $100 Million Settlement with Coinbase, Inc. after DFS Investigation Finds Significant Failings in the Company’s Compliance Program (Jan. 4, 2023), available here.

    [2] Consent Order at 13-14.

    [3] 3 NYCRR Part 504. For more information on New York’s transaction monitoring requirements, please see our prior Alert “NYDFS Issues AML/Sanctions Programs and Annual Certification Requirements for Banks, Money Transmitters and Check Cashers.”

    [4] Consent Order at 16-18.

    [5] Id., at 18-19.

    [6] Id., at 19-20.

    [7] Id., at 21.

    [8] 23 NYCRR § 500.17.

    [9] Consent Order at 23-25.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2023 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Donald J. Mosher

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Betty Santangelo

    Counsel

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Melissa G.R. Goldstein

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Adam J. Barazani

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • European Regulators Provide Some Key Clarifications on Cookie Banners

    European Regulators Provide Some Key Clarifications on Cookie Banners

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    European Regulators Provide Some Key Clarifications on Cookie Banners

    January 20, 2023

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The European Data Protection Board (EDPB) adopted a draft report of the work undertaken by the Cookie Banner Taskforce (the Report). The Report describes how regulators apply cookie legislation in handling certain types of cookie complaints. While some of the conclusions indicate regulatory unity across the European Union, others confirm divergent views between the regulators.

    One of the most relevant findings is that for the vast majority of EU authorities, not having a dedicated ‘reject cookies’ button constitutes an infringement of the law. However, companies are still left wondering whether the reject button should be in the first layer of the cookie banner (as the French Commission Nationale Informatique & Libertés (CNIL) requires) or in one of the subsequent layers (as the Spanish Data Protection Authority (AEDP) allows).

    The Report is the result of more than a year of work by the group of EU supervisory authorities and is a response to complaints filed by a digital rights activists’ group NOYB.

    In depth

    CAN WE NOW RELY ON ONE STANDARD ACROSS THE EUROPEAN UNION?

    For those businesses who hoped that the Report will unify the understanding and enforcement of European cookie legislation, it will disappoint.

    Although it is helpful in confirming some long ‘suspected’ positions of EU supervisory authorities, its conclusions make it clear that when it comes to cookies, the rules and their enforcement will continue having a national flavor. Multinational companies will have to either comply with local standards or adopt the maximum common denominator.

    REPORT FINDINGS & TAKEAWAYS FOR BUSINESSES

    The Report investigates the following cookie banner practices:

    • No reject button in the first layer of the cookie banner

    What is it about: Some cookie banners contain an ‘Accept’ & ‘Manage Cookies/Preferences’ buttons, but they do not offer dedicated ‘Reject’ cookies button in the first layer (the user has to click on Manage Cookies and then reject cookies by category or one by one, but without being able to click on ‘reject’ in the first instance and reject them all at once).

    What is the takeaway: Most, but not all, authorities agreed that a Reject button on any layer is required for compliance with the ePrivacy Directive (ePD), and businesses need to take this into account. Some authorities, like the French CNIL and UK Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO), have been clear in their guidance that a Reject button is required in the first layer of a cookie banner, whilst others, like the Spanish AEPD, retain a less stringent approach, allowing the reject button to be placed in the second layer.

    • Preselected consents

    What is it about: Some cookie banners contain preselected options for cookies that the website operator wishes to place, even though they are not strictly necessary for the operation of the website and its services.

    What is the takeaway: Such preselected consents are not valid under ePD (which applies to the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) consent rules).

    • Deceptive design of the reject cookie function

    What is it about: Instead of providing a Reject button in their banner, some businesses display only a hyperlink (by clicking such a link, the user could either reject cookies or get to the second layer to do so).

    What is the takeaway: Such reject links embedded in the text of the banner/outside of the banner entirely, without anything to draw the user’s attention to them, invalidate the consent.

    • Deceptive buttons colors and contrast

    What is it about: Websites often make the ‘Accept’ button more prominent or attractive for the user to click on that the ‘Reject’ button by using colors or contrast.

    What is the takeaway: There is no general standard, and each banner will be reviewed on a case-by-case basis. At least where the Reject button is essentially unreadable (e.g., because the color of the text is identical to the color of the button), this would be considered a misleading practice.

    • Use of legitimate interest versus consent

    What is it about: Some controllers integrated ‘legitimate interest’ as a legal basis for subsequent processing of data collected via cookies.

    What is the takeaway: Authorities confirmed that consent is the only legal basis for placing cookies and accessing cookie IDs (subject to the ePD). The subsequent processing of personal data, however, is subject to the GDPR, which does not limit the legal basis to consent only. The Report, however, fell short of confirming whether legitimate interest specifically could be used for such further processing. Authorities agreed to resume discussions should they encounter concrete cases.

    • Inaccurately classified ‘essential cookies’

    What is it about: Only cookies that are essential to providing services to the user can be placed without their consent.

    What is the takeaway: The Report recognized that cookie classification may be challenging for businesses. Automated cookie classification tools available on the market today are seldom perfect, and companies are forced to dedicate additional internal resources to fully understand what cookies are being placed on their websites (‘false’ essential cookies often originate from third-party providers).

    • No consent withdraw icon

    What is it about: Controllers must allow users to withdraw their consent given through the cookie banner at any time. Withdrawal must be as easy as it was to give consent.

    What is the takeaway: The Report confirms there is no standardized way to do this. For example, businesses can implement a persistent hovering icon on all pages of the website or place a link in a standardized and visible place on the website (which is often a much easier option to implement). Each solution will be assessed on a case-by-case basis.

    THE TASKFORCE AND (FURTHER?) NATIONAL ENFORCEMENT

    In September 2021, the European Data Protection Board (EDPB) set up a taskforce to coordinate the EU supervisory authorities’ response to hundreds of complaints concerning the alleged cookie banner compliance violations. These complaints were filed with several European Economic Area (EEA) supervisory authorities by the digital rights activists’ group NOYB. This followed national enforcement by EU Member State supervisory authorities in their home countries, such as several rounds of French CNIL’s investigations into cookie compliance practices of private, national and international organizations as well as public bodies; all told, this resulted in tens of orders being issued by the regulator. CNIL also imposed a number of significant fines for not making refusing cookies easy to accept and for placing IDs on users’ devices for advertising purposes without their consent. These fines ranged from €8 million to €150 million.

    We expect EU supervisory authorities to continue their enforcement in this area. For many regulators, the placement and reading of cookies being regulated by the ePD, rather than the EU GDPR, became a way to investigate companies they would otherwise have to investigate only in the context of the EU GDPR cooperation mechanism. The EU GDPR’s one-stop-shop allows multinationals to interact with one ‘lead’ EU supervisory authority (usually the country of their EU headquarters) in the context of cross-border data processing (whilst the lead EU supervisory authority then must cooperate with other concerned authorities on the back end).

    ***

    If you have any questions about the implementation of cookie banners or other questions related to tracking technologies, please contact your regular McDermott lawyer or the authors listed below.

    Authors
    More insights

  • IRS Releases Memorandum on Deducting Cryptocurrency Donations

    IRS Releases Memorandum on Deducting Cryptocurrency Donations

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    IRS Releases Memorandum on Deducting Cryptocurrency Donations

    January 18, 2023

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On January 13, 2023, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) released a memorandum (CCA 202302012) concluding that a qualified appraisal is required when a taxpayer claims a charitable contribution deduction exceeding $5,000 for donated cryptocurrency. Valuations reported by cryptocurrency exchanges do not qualify as “qualified appraisals.” The memorandum is relevant to any taxpayer who has donated (or plans to donate) cryptocurrency if they also intend to claim a charitable deduction.

    In depth

    SUBSTANTIATION REQUIREMENTS FOR CHARITABLE CONTRIBUTION DEDUCTIONS

    Internal Revenue Code Section 170 generally allows deductions for charitable contributions in the taxable year that the contributions are made. However, these deductions are allowed only if they are verified under US Department of the Treasury (Treasury) regulations. Deductions may be denied if the taxpayer does not meet certain substantiation requirements outlined in Section 170(f)(11).

    The substantiation requirements for charitable contribution deductions generally require that, for contributions of property for which a deduction of more than $5,000 is claimed, the taxpayer must obtain a “qualified appraisal” of the property.

    MEETING THE QUALIFIED APPRAISAL REQUIREMENT

    An appraisal can only be qualified if it is conducted by a qualified appraiser in accordance with generally accepted appraisal standards. To be qualified, an appraiser must (1) be an individual, (2) have earned an appraisal designation from a recognized professional appraiser organization or meet minimum education and experience requirements set by the Treasury or the IRS, and (3) regularly perform appraisals for which he or she receives compensation.

    Furthermore, the appraisal must not be made and signed by the appraiser sooner than 60 days before the donation or later than the due date (with extensions) of the tax return on which the deduction is claimed. The qualified appraiser must sign and date the appraisal report and include a declaration that such person (1) understands the appraisal will be used in connection with a return or claim for refund, (2) understands that such person may be subject to a penalty if the appraisal contains a substantial or gross valuation misstatement of the value of the property and the taxpayer claims a deduction based on the appraisal, and (3) has not, within the past three years, been barred from presenting evidence or testimony before the Treasury or the IRS. The appraiser may not receive a fee that is based to any extent on the appraised value of the property.

    EXCEPTIONS TO THE QUALIFIED APPRAISAL REQUIREMENT

    While the qualified appraisal requirement may seem to impose an onerous burden on taxpayers, given the philanthropic purpose of charitable donations, this is mitigated by rules excepting certain readily valued property from the qualified appraisal requirement. For example, a taxpayer is not required to obtain a qualified appraisal for cash donations, stock in trade, inventory, inventory property, publicly traded securities and certain vehicles.

    Notably, “publicly traded securities” for this purpose is limited to mean corporate stock; a right to subscribe for or to receive a share of corporate stock; or a bond, debenture, note, certificate, or other evidence of indebtedness issued by a corporation, a government or a political subdivision thereof.

    Failure to properly comply with the appraisal requirements will not result in denial of the deduction if the taxpayer establishes the failure was due to “reasonable cause” rather than “willful neglect.” However, such reasonable cause exception will not apply to the extent no appraisal was obtained.

    CRYPTOCURRENCY, CRYPTO DONATIONS AND THE QUALIFIED APPRAISAL REQUIREMENT

    Cryptocurrency (also referred to as digital assets, virtual currency, tokens or coins) uses cryptography to secure transactions that are digitally recorded on a distributed ledger such as a blockchain. While virtual currencies can be used as payment for goods and services and can be freely traded on public exchanges and exchanged into other currencies or digital assets, the IRS does not treat these assets as currency (also known as fiat), but rather as property.

    While cryptocurrency may experience value fluctuations similar to assets such as stocks or bonds, the value attributed to cryptocurrency is different. Specifically, stocks represent a company’s fractional ownership, while bonds represent the value of debt that will be repaid upon maturity. In contrast, the value of a particular cryptocurrency often simply reflects the amount that people are willing to pay for it. This distinction can create problems for prospective donors.

    While taxpayers may wish to donate their cryptocurrency to charitable organizations, claiming deductions for these donations may implicate hurdles that would not ordinarily apply to the donation of more conventional publicly traded assets. Cryptocurrency is not cash, a publicly traded security (as defined above) or any other listed type of readily valued property. Accordingly, taxpayers donating cryptocurrency may not rely on the readily valued exception to the qualified appraisal requirement and must seek a “qualified appraisal” to be eligible for cryptocurrency donation deductions exceeding $5,000.

    In June 2022, the Lummis-Gillibrand Responsible Financial Innovation Act was introduced and required the IRS to issue guidance removing the appraisal requirement for digital assets for contributions exceeding $5,000 as readily valued property not requiring a qualified appraisal. However, the bill has not made much traction in US Congress as of this date.

    CONCLUSION

    Because cryptocurrency is not considered readily valued property, taxpayers who wish to donate more than $5,000 in cryptocurrency seem to be left with few options: either obtain a qualified appraisal that meets the IRS’s requirements or forgo deductions for the donated cryptocurrency. While none of these options are particularly convenient for the prospective donor, relief may be on the way if sufficient interest in cryptocurrency donations can create a market for qualified appraisers.

    Anthony Teng, a law clerk in the New York office, also contributed to this article.

    Authors

    John T. Lutz

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    Andrew M. Granek

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • The SEC’s Staff Issues a New Marketing Rule FAQ on Net Performance Requirements

    The SEC’s Staff Issues a New Marketing Rule FAQ on Net Performance Requirements

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    The SEC’s Staff Issues a New Marketing Rule FAQ on Net Performance Requirements

    January 18, 2023

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On Jan. 11, 2023, the staff of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission’s Division of Investment Management (“Staff”) issued an FAQ update (“FAQ”), excerpted below,[1] stating the Staff’s belief that Investment Advisers Act Rule 206(4)-1 (“Marketing Rule”) prohibits registered investment advisers from disseminating advertisements showing the gross performance of one investment or a group of investments in a private fund without showing, with equal prominence, the net performance of such single investment or group of investments. This FAQ addresses a key point of ambiguity and market divergence, and comes over two months after the Marketing Rule’s compliance date on Nov. 4, 2022.

    Background on the Net and Gross Debate

    The Marketing Rule prohibits any presentation of “gross performance” in an advertisement unless accompanied by “net performance” that is shown with equal prominence, calculated over the same time period and uses the same type of return and methodology. Gross and net performance are both defined as relating to the “performance results of a portfolio (or portions of a portfolio that are included in extracted performance, if applicable).”[2] Prior to the FAQ, the Staff had not formally indicated whether it views “extracted performance”, which is defined as a “subset of investments extracted from a portfolio”[3] (and is inherently plural), as including the performance of a single investment.

    What the Staff Said in the FAQ

    In the FAQ, the Staff articulated its belief that presenting the performance of one investment or a group of investments in a private fund is an example of extracted performance under the Marketing Rule, and such performance must be shown on a net basis.

    The Staff cites as its rationale the risk that advisers “would present misleadingly selective profitable performance with the benefit of hindsight.” The FAQ reminded advisers to ensure that their presentation of net extracted performance complies with other applicable disclosure requirements (i.e., the requirement to provide or offer to promptly provide the performance results from the total portfolio from which the performance was extracted). The Staff also noted that such performance is subject to the Marketing Rule’s general prohibition against referencing specific investment advice in a manner that is not fair and balanced.

    What the Staff Didn’t Say in the FAQ

    The FAQ does not address why the presentation of net performance is necessary to address the identified risk of presenting “misleadingly selective profitable performance” when the Marketing Rule already prohibits presenting individual investments in a manner that is not fair and balanced, and it does not detail how the requirement to show net performance would address that problem.

    The FAQ also did not specifically address several critical points, including:

    • What methodologies are acceptable for calculating net performance for individual investments or groups of investments;
    • The level of disclosure required in order to ensure that net performance calculations are not themselves misleading;
    • Timing expectations for managers switching to comply with the FAQ’s guidance; and
    • Whether comprehensive presentations of each individual investment or category of investments (e.g., schedules of investments; attribution reports), when shown alongside the fund’s net and gross performance, can be treated differently because such presentations show the entire portfolio and do not raise the same concerns about selective performance cited in the FAQ.

    Key Takeaways for Private Fund Managers

    Private fund managers should be prepared to support on examination the approach they have taken to presenting performance in advertisements, including how that approach addresses the Marketing Rule, the SEC’s adopting release,[4] and the Staff’s FAQ.

    Attribution Reports and Schedules of Investments. The FAQ does not specifically address the common practice of showing, in close proximity to the fund’s overall gross and net performance, the performance of (i) each of a fund’s individual investments (e.g., schedules of investments) or (ii) each aspect of a fund’s portfolio grouped into categories (e.g., an attribution report). Nonetheless, the FAQ should be considered when preparing such materials and assessing the risks associated with presenting gross performance in those contexts.

    Calculation Methodology. The Staff has not articulated a specific calculation methodology for preparing net performance of single investments or sections of a fund’s portfolio where fees and expenses are taken at the fund level. Several methodologies have evolved through market practice, each of which has limitations and requires fulsome disclosures of the methodologies, assumptions and limitations of such performance calculations in order to comply with the Marketing Rule’s general prohibitions. Some examples of common items we have observed requiring consideration in the preparation of such returns include: the impact of a hedge fund’s “high water mark,” the operation of different waterfall carried interest structures, how to incorporate clawbacks (if applicable), the impact of hedging and leverage, the timing of investment dispositions and how to determine an appropriate expense allocation for an investment or attribution category.

    Authored by Christopher S. Avellaneda, Allison Scher Bernbach, Marc E. Elovitz, Kelly Koscuiszka, Tinika M. Brown and Tarik M. Shah.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] The SEC’s FAQs relating to the Marketing Rule can be found here.

    [2] 17 C.F.R. § 275.206(4)-1(e)(7), 1(e)(10).

    [3] Id. at 206(4)-1(e)(6).

    [4] Investment Adviser Marketing, 86 Fed. Reg. 13024 (March 5, 2021). The adopting release can be found here.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2023 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.


    EXCERPT FROM THE FAQ

    Gross and Net Performance

    Q. When an adviser displays the gross performance of one investment (e.g., a case study) or a group of investments from a private fund, must the adviser show the net performance of the single investment and the group of investments?

    A. Yes. The staff believes that displaying the performance of one investment or a group of investments in a private fund is an example of extracted performance under the new marketing rule.[1] Because the extracted performance provision was intended, in part, to address the risk that advisers would present misleadingly selective profitable performance with the benefit of hindsight, the staff believes the provision should be read to apply to a subset of investments (i.e., one or more). Accordingly, an adviser may not show gross performance of one investment or a group of investments without also showing the net performance of that single investment or group of investments, respectively.[2] In addition, the adviser must satisfy the other tailored disclosure requirements as well as the general prohibitions, including the general prohibition against specific investment advice not presented in a fair and balanced manner, when showing extracted performance.[3]


    [1] Extracted performance means “the performance results of a subset of investments extracted from a portfolio.” Rule 206(4)-1(e)(6). See section II.E.5 of the adopting release.

    [2] The rule prohibits any presentation of gross performance in an advertisement unless the advertisement also presents net performance. See section II.E.1 of the adopting release. The gross and net performance requirement applies to not only an entire portfolio but also to any portion of a portfolio that is included in extracted performance. See sections II.E.1(a) and (b) and the definitions of gross and net performance in rule 206(4)-1(e)(7) and (10) (“Net performance means the performance results of a portfolio (or portions of a portfolio that are included in extracted performance…”)). The adopting release also states that the rule requires that advisers that show extracted performance must show net and gross performance for the applicable subset of investments extracted from a portfolio. See section II.E.1.a. of the adopting release (discussing gross performance).

    [3] The adopting release states that “advisers should evaluate the particular facts and circumstances that may be relevant to investors, including the assumptions, factors, and conditions that contributed to the performance, and include appropriate disclosures or other information such that the advertisement does not violate the general prohibitions…or other applicable law.” See section II.E.1 of the adopting release (discussing the net performance requirement). In addition, it would be considered “misleading under the final rule to present extracted performance in an advertisement without disclosing whether it reflects an allocation of the cash held by the entire portfolio and the effect of such cash allocation, or of the absence of such an allocation, on the results portrayed.” See section II.E.5 of the adopting release (discussing extracted performance).

    In depth
    Authors

    Christopher S. Avellaneda

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Allison Scher Bernbach

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    Marc E. Elovitz

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Kelly Koscuiszka

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Tarik M. Shah

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • The Practitioner’s Guide to Global Investigations | 7th Edition

    The Practitioner’s Guide to Global Investigations | 7th Edition

    ARTICLE

    The Practitioner’s Guide to Global Investigations | 7th Edition

    January 2023

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    (1) The Practitioner’s Guide to Global Investigations – United Kingdom (7th Edition)

    The Practitioner’s Guide to Global Investigations is the leading resource in relation to global white-collar practice. In this chapter, Simon Airey, James Dobias and William Merry provide an in depth analysis of the UK’s white-collar sector, including general context, key principles and hot topics.

    (2) Beginning an Internal Investigation: the UK Perspective

    Decisions that must be made at speed, from a position of limited information and at a time when the business, and the individuals involved, may be under significant pressure or scrutiny. Choices made at this early stage, and a failure to take into account the full context (including potential cross-jurisdictional issues), can have far-reaching repercussions. In this chapter, Simon Airey and James Dobias identify the key factors for companies to consider when grappling with these difficult issue.

     

    In depth
    Authors

    Simon Airey

    Partner

    London – 22 Bishopsgate

    James Dobias

    Partner

    London – 22 Bishopsgate

    William Merry

    Senior Associate

    London – 22 Bishopsgate

    More insights

  • The 2023 Pension Answer Book

    The 2023 Pension Answer Book

    ARTICLE

    The 2023 Pension Answer Book

    January 12, 2023

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    A standard in its field, The 2023 Pension Answer Book discusses in detail the full spectrum of pension topics—from qualification requirements to taxation of distributions, from minimum distribution requirements to 401(k) plans. It covers the most up-to-date and significant legislative, regulatory, and case law developments affecting these plans. As a decision-making tool, combining theory and practice-based guidance, The 2023 Pension Answer Book offers insight and clarification on the critical issues affecting pension administration and compliance. In short, The 2023 Pension Answer Book is the one reference tool that provides subscribers with the most current and comprehensive answers to the issues pension professionals face daily in their practice.

    See more

    In depth
    Authors

    Todd A. Solomon

    Partner

    Chicago

    Jacob M. Mattinson

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • Extended Notice and Required Severance: Impending Expansions to New Jersey’s WARN Act

    Extended Notice and Required Severance: Impending Expansions to New Jersey’s WARN Act

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Extended Notice and Required Severance: Impending Expansions to New Jersey’s WARN Act

    January 12, 2023

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On December 19, 2022, the New Jersey Senate passed Assembly Bill No. 4768 (A-4768), which, when effective, will implement a drastic expansion to New Jersey’s Millville Dallas Airmotive Plant Job Loss Notification Act (NJ WARN Act) and require that employers provide their employees with 90 days’ notice and severance pay in connection with mass-layoff events. These new provisions of the NJ WARN Act will become effective 90 days after Governor Phil Murphy signs the bill.

    In depth

    All New Jersey employers who choose to discharge a significant number of employees, whether in connection with a transaction or not, will need to pay careful attention to the requirements of the state and federal laws that apply to mass layoff events and plant closings. Substantial additional requirements could be imposed on New Jersey employers as early as April 2023.

    WARN ACTS GENERALLY

    Federal and New Jersey state law require employers with 100 or more eligible employees to provide notice in connection with a mass layoff or plant closing. This requirement stems from the federal Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification (WARN) Act, and some states, like New Jersey, have enacted their own statutes that exceed the federal baseline. Under federal and existing New Jersey law, employers are required to provide employees with 60 days’ notice if they plan to reduce their workforce by either of the following:

    • 500 or more full-time employees at a single worksite; or
    • 50 or more full-time employees at a single worksite, if those employees represent at least 33% of the full-time employees at the worksite.

    DELAYED IMPLEMENTATION

    In January 2020, New Jersey passed a law that would dramatically expand the state’s requirements under the NJ WARN Act. The law’s implementation has been delayed for more than two years due to the outbreak of the COVID-19 pandemic.

    However, last month, both houses of the New Jersey legislature passed a bill (A-4768) that would fast track the implementation of the NJ WARN Act expansion. The changes to New Jersey’s layoff law will take effect 90 days after Governor Phil Murphy signs the bill.

    REQUIREMENTS UNDER THE REVISED NJ WARN ACT

    The revised NJ WARN Act would impose a number of additional requirements on certain employers who reduce their workforces. A brief overview of the requirements follows:

    • The law will apply to employers with 100 or more employees, regardless of whether those employees are full-time or part-time workers, regardless of how long the employees have worked with the employer, and regardless of whether the employees are in one or multiple establishments within or outside of New Jersey.
    • The law will apply to any “establishment,” which is a single location or group of locations within New Jersey operated by the employer for at least three years, but excluding a temporary construction site.
    • The revised NJ WARN Act’s requirements are triggered as soon as a company terminates 50 or more full-time or part-time employees at an “establishment” for any reason (including layoff, transfer or termination of operations) within a 30-day period. Unlike federal WARN requirements, the revised NJ WARN Act may be triggered regardless of whether those terminations occurred at separate worksites within the state and regardless of whether the layoff affected 33% of the company’s workforce.
    • The law will require employers to provide 90 days’ notice to affected employees, as opposed to the prior 60-day requirement.
    • The law will mandate that employers provide terminated employees with severance pay equivalent to one week of pay for each full year that the respective employee worked. The law does not provide any limit on the amount of severance pay that must be distributed to employees. The rate of severance pay must be the higher of (a) the average regular rate of compensation received during the employee’s last three years of employment or (b) the final regular rate of compensation.
    • If employers fail to give 90 days’ notice to their employees, employers are required to provide each affected employee with an additional four weeks of severance pay. Employers will be permitted to credit any amount paid under the federal WARN Act to the amount owed in severance pay under the NJ WARN Act.
    • Employees cannot waive their severance benefit under the law without state or court permission.

    Interestingly, the broad definition of the term “employer” in the statute seems to leave open the potential for individual liability to individual owners of the employing entity (or an entity controlling the employing entity) to the extent such person is responsible for the termination action or operational closure. It remains to be seen how this portion of the law will be applied in practice.

    PREPARING FOR 2023 AND BEYOND

    New Jersey businesses contemplating workforce layoffs or closures in 2023 and beyond should be mindful of these impending restrictions and requirements under the NJ WARN Act. In addition, employers and investors in New Jersey healthcare businesses specifically should be aware of recent changes in state law that impact healthcare transactions and buyer and seller obligations to notify and retain healthcare workers, as discussed in our client alert here.

    If employers have questions regarding the changes in New Jersey or elsewhere, or want to learn more about how to best plan for anticipated workforce reductions in 2023, please contact the McDermott employment team.

    Nicholas Meyer, a law clerk in the New York office, also contributed to this article.

    Authors

    Nicholas C. Meyer

    Associate

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • New Jersey Healthcare Transactions Now Face Onerous Employment Requirements

    New Jersey Healthcare Transactions Now Face Onerous Employment Requirements

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    New Jersey Healthcare Transactions Now Face Onerous Employment Requirements

    January 12, 2023

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On November 16, 2022, New Jersey Senate Bill No. 315 (S-315) went into effect, providing new employment protections to eligible employees of certain private healthcare entities that undergo a “change in control.” The law imposes various requirements, including advance notice, offers of continued employment to eligible employees and enhanced protection against termination for at least four months post-close. New Jersey healthcare employers and investors must comply with these laws to avoid employment claims and penalties.

    In depth

    Under S-315, certain healthcare employers must provide advance notice of a sale of the company to employees, and buyers have reduced flexibility in hiring and downsizing their workforces following an acquisition.

    WHEN THE LAW APPLIES

    S-315 imposes new requirements on New Jersey healthcare employers that undergo a “change in control.” Change in control is defined broadly within the law, and refers to:

    “[A]ny sale, assignment, transfer, contribution or other disposition of all or substantially all of the assets used in a health care entity’s operations; or any sale, assignment, transfer, contribution or other disposition of a controlling interest in the health care entity, including by consolidation, merger, or reorganization, of the health care entity or any person who controls the health care entity; or any event or sequence of events, including a purchase, sale, or termination of a management contract or lease, that causes the identity of the health care entity employer to change, but shall not include a change in control in which both the former health care entity employer and the successor health care employer are government entities.”

    Given the way the definition is drafted, it is unclear whether the law is intended to apply to equity transactions where the employer entity pre- and post-close is the same legal entity. It is anticipated by the authors of this article that forthcoming guidance from the New Jersey legislature may provide clarification as to this and other ambiguities regarding undefined terms.

    S-315 applies to hospitals, healthcare and treatment centers, rehabilitation centers, nursing homes, outpatient clinics, dispensaries, residential healthcare facilities, and any other healthcare entities licensed under N.J.S.A. 26:2H-1 et seq. Moreover, the law applies to staffing registries and home healthcare services agencies as defined under N.J.S.A. 45:11-23 et seq.

    WHOM THE LAW PROTECTS

    The law provides rights to “eligible employees,” or those who were employed during the 90-day period before the effective date of a change in control, as well as any former employee with recall rights under a collective bargaining agreement. Neither managerial employees nor employees who are discharged for “cause” within the 90-day period are eligible employees under the law. (Notably, the law does not define what constitutes “cause.”)

    SELLER AND BUYER OBLIGATIONS UNDER THE LAW

    The law provides that all parties to the purchase agreement and all healthcare entities subject to the change in control (including the employer pre-close, referred to under the law as the “former health care entity employer,” and the employer post-close, referred to under the law as the “successor health care entity employer”) must comply with all provisions required by the law to be included in the contract.

    Pursuant to the law, not less than 30 days before the change in control, the former healthcare entity employer must do the following:

    • Provide the successor healthcare entity employer, and any collective bargaining representative the employees may have, with a list of information that includes the name, address, date of hire, phone number, wage rate and employment classification of each eligible employee.
    • Inform all eligible employees of their rights under the law.
    • Post a notice of employee rights under this law in a conspicuous location accessible to all employees.

    In addition to the former healthcare entity employer obligations above, pursuant to the law, no change in control of a healthcare entity employer can take place without a contract between the successor and former healthcare entity employers that provide the following:

    • The successor healthcare entity employer must offer continued employment to each eligible employee for a transition period of at least four months following the change in control, without any reduction in wages, paid time off, or the total value of benefits, including healthcare, retirement and education benefits. The offers of employment must be in writing and the offers must remain open for at least 10 business days. (If the total number of available positions with the successor healthcare entity employer is less than the total number of eligible employees, the successor healthcare entity employer is required to select eligible employees to retain based on seniority and experience.)
    • Eligible employees who choose to accept continued employment cannot be terminated without “cause” during the four-month transition period, except that the successor healthcare entity employer is permitted to lay off eligible employees, provided that (a) the employer reduces the total number of employees, (b) the choice of employees to be retained is based on seniority and experience, and (c) the laid off employees are offered any positions that they had previously held that are subsequently restored during the four-month (or greater) post-close transition period.
    • At the conclusion of the transition period, the successor healthcare entity employer must prepare a written performance evaluation for each retained eligible employee, who must then be offered continued employment if the employee’s performance during the transition period was “satisfactory.” (The term “satisfactory” is not defined within the statute.)
    • Finally, the successor healthcare entity employer is required to retain and provide to an employee or representative of the employee upon request, a written record of each offer of employment and evaluation made pursuant to S-315 for at least three years from the date of the offer or evaluation, with each record including the name, address, date of hire, phone number, wage rate and employment classification of the employee.

    EXCEPTION FOR COLLECTIVE BARGAINING AGREEMENT COMPLIANCE

    Notably, the law presents a carve-out to compliance with its provisions where compliance would conflict with an employer’s obligation to comply with obligations under a collective bargaining agreement entered into by an exclusive representative of employees of a healthcare entity subject to a change in control. The law also expressly provides that it does not limit the recognition of a collective bargaining representative of the employees of a successor healthcare entity employer or collective bargaining between the successor healthcare entity employer and a collective bargaining representative.

    NONCOMPLIANCE PENALTIES AND REMEDIES

    The law creates a private right of action for employees affected by their employer’s violations. Potential remedies available to employees include recovery of lost or unpaid wages, recovery of paid time off and benefits, recovery of attorneys’ fees, and liquidated damages of up to 200% of the unpaid wages. Furthermore, employees can seek injunctive relief for violations, including reinstatement into their previous positions. The law requires all parties to the transaction and the former and successor employers to comply with the law, even if the contract memorializing the transaction failed to include the required provisions.

    NEW JERSEY TRANSACTIONS: 2023 AND BEYOND

    Private equity and strategic investors transacting in the healthcare space should be mindful of these new requirements and restrictions applicable to many New Jersey-based healthcare entities. Investors should also be aware that New Jersey has also recently passed a bill (pending the governor’s signature) that will implement further restrictions with respect to mass layoffs covered by the state’s Millville Dallas Airmotive Plant Job Loss Notification Act (NJ WARN Act); more information on the updated New Jersey WARN provisions can be found in our client alert here.

    If employers have questions regarding the changes in New Jersey or elsewhere, please contact the McDermott employment team.

    Nicholas Meyer, a law clerk in the New York office, also contributed to this article.

    Authors

    Nicholas C. Meyer

    Associate

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • Cryptocurrency Update: Crypto in Celsius “Earn” Accounts Are Property of Bankruptcy Estate, Not Customer Assets

    Cryptocurrency Update: Crypto in Celsius “Earn” Accounts Are Property of Bankruptcy Estate, Not Customer Assets

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Cryptocurrency Update: Crypto in Celsius “Earn” Accounts Are Property of Bankruptcy Estate, Not Customer Assets

    January 12, 2023

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Judge Martin Glenn of the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of New York issued a ruling last week in the Celsius Network bankruptcy case addressing whether customer deposits on a cryptocurrency exchange or platform are property of the debtor or property of the customer. The answer, not surprisingly, depends on the Terms of Use governing the account in question. In this case, the Court found that the terms clearly and unambiguously provided that ownership of cryptocurrency assets deposited into “Earn Accounts” resides with Celsius. In re Celsius Network, et al., No. 22-10964 (MG), 2023 WL 34106 (Bankr. S.D.N.Y. Jan. 4, 2023).

    Background

    Celsius offered its customers an array of products, including Earn Accounts, which offered a high rate of interest on crypto assets deposited in them. In November 2022, Celsius filed a motion seeking a determination that assets in the Earn Accounts were property of the estate, rather than customer assets. Several state regulators, multiple Earn Account customers and the US Trustee objected. In support of its motion, Celsius argued that when customers agreed to the Earn Account Terms of Use, the parties formed a binding contract under which the depositors transferred ownership of the deposited assets to Celsius. The objectors primarily argued that the Terms of Use were ambiguous and that it was premature for the Court to determine who owned the assets.

    The Court’s Ruling

    The Court granted the motion, holding that the Terms of Use for the Earn Accounts constitute binding and unambiguous contracts between Celsius and the Earn Account customers and that, pursuant to the Terms of Use, the assets in the Earn Accounts are property of the estate. Under New York law, which governs the Terms of Use, for a contract to be formed there must be (1) an offer and acceptance (also called mutual assent), (2) consideration and (3) an intent to be bound. The Court found that all three elements were satisfied.

    The Terms of Use are so-called “clickwrap” agreements, meaning that a user manifests assent by clicking a button accepting the terms (or implying that they have accepted the terms), but the user is not necessarily required to view the terms. The Court empathized with “the frustrations Account Holders may feel if they did not read or understand the specific terms of the Terms of Use”, but held that New York law clearly provides that an accepted “clickwrap” agreement constitutes mutual asset.

    The Court further found that the language of the Terms of Use providing that customers “grant Celsius…all right and title to such Digital Assets, including ownership rights” in cryptocurrency deposited into Earn Accounts, was unambiguous and resulted in Celsius having ownership of the Earn Account assets.

    The Court acknowledged that Earn Account customers may have claims against Celsius for breach of contract, fraud, fraudulent conveyance, that the Terms of Use were unconscionable, or other theories of liability related to misleading customers and any subsequent misuse of Earn Account assets. But the customers will have to pursue those claims separately from the issue of whether the cryptocurrency assets in the Earn Accounts are property of the estate.

    The Court’s ruling is expressly limited to the Earn Accounts and does not determine the ownership of assets related to other types of Celsius accounts or programs, such as the Celsius Custody Program, Withhold Accounts or Borrow Program – the ownership of which was not before the Court.

    Takeaways and Implications

    This ruling does not settle the question of ownership of all deposits in cryptocurrency accounts generally. The Court clearly ruled on the facts at hand in regard to the Earn Accounts – based on the plain language of their governing Terms of Use. This question is likely to play out again with respect to other cryptocurrency accounts. In fact, two sets of customers have recently filed adversary complaints in the FTX bankruptcy cases seeking declaratory judgments that certain assets of FTX are customer property and not property of the estate. The plaintiffs argue that the governing FTX Terms of Service unambiguously provide that title to all digital assets remains with the customers and did not transfer to FTX. The Celsius ruling may serve as a guide-post for how bankruptcy courts will resolve these and other challenges to whether customer deposits are property of the estate of bankrupt crypto companies.

    Customers will need to review closely the Terms of Use on any products they have used. Courts will apply clear contractual analysis to those terms – irrespective of whether they may prove misleading or deceptive. Such plain language will likely prove decisive in the analysis of the treatment of potential customer claims – and could lead to divergent treatments of seemingly similar customer claims subject to different Terms of Use.

    Authored by Douglas S. Mintz, Abbey Walsh, Peter J. Amend and Robert D. Brown.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2023 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights