ARTICLE
Heard at the 2026 Antitrust Law Section Spring Meeting
March 30, 2026
Read time: 8 min
The American Bar Association Antitrust Law Section’s annual Spring Meeting took place from March 25 – 27, 2026, in Washington, DC, this year. The Spring Meeting features updates from federal, state, and international antitrust enforcers as well as extensive discussion of antitrust issues and enforcement priorities affecting various industries. This client alert highlights key takeaways from the Spring Meeting.
Antitrust and the Trump 2.0 administration: One year later
- The US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and Department of Justice (DOJ) have explicitly stated that they are not independent from the White House, embracing the top-down unitary executive theory of antitrust enforcement. Presidential priorities will continue to guide the focus of the antitrust agencies’ enforcement actions and litigation.
- Over the past year, the administration’s pro-business agenda has been furthered by the antitrust agencies. The agencies seek to reduce barriers to entry for transactions caused by regulations that affect market behavior. The agencies are also more willing to engage in settlements with structural and behavioral remedies.
- The new Hart-Scott-Rodino (HSR) rules have recently been struck down by the US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit. The agencies have expressed a desire to maintain both the new HSR rules and the 2023 merger guidelines despite the fact that both policies were established by the previous administration. Practitioners suggest that in maintaining the new guidelines and rules, the FTC may be playing defense to make it more difficult for future agency actions to be challenged.
Here to stay: Scrutiny of labor, private equity, minority shareholders
- Anticompetitive labor practices, including no-poach and wage-fixing schemes, continue to face increased scrutiny from US and European regulators and courts. Some jurisdictions like Canada have even updated their laws to more explicitly pursue labor market cases, as many Canadian companies are still unaware of the problematic nature of some noncompetes. American noncompetes continue to attract scrutiny.
- Though private equity (PE) no longer garners the same amount of public criticism from the agencies as it did during Lina Khan’s tenure at the FTC, the private equity business model continues to pose concerns, particularly around affordability in healthcare and housing. The FTC has investigated several PE-backed healthcare transactions, and states are enacting premerger notification statutes aimed, in part, at private equity investment in healthcare and housing. Private equity investors should be aware of this developing body of state law that may impact transaction timelines and risk.
- The current administration continues to develop an enforcement interest in minority ownership. In response, practitioners are exploring solutions for minority investors concerned about antitrust scrutiny, including contracting away corporate government rights while maintaining economic rights in the investment.
Antitrust and AI
- Practitioners expressed concerns that traditional antitrust tools are not well suited to address modern forms of consolidation, and artificial intelligence (AI) has created a gap in antitrust enforcement. Certain agreements among AI and tech companies fall outside of traditional scrutiny under the Clayton and HSR acts, such as “acquihires” (instead of buying a company outright, a buyer will hire a key person from the target and license intellectual property (IP) from that company) and nonexclusive licensing. Nonetheless, the US agencies have expressed an interest in investigating such agreements.
- US monopolization theories are difficult to enforce due to the nascent nature of AI. Agencies struggle to define AI and how AI tools impact the market. That said, unlawful conduct by an AI would be illegal if, done by a human, it was unlawful as well. This leads to questions around whether information provided by AI tools could be considered illegal information sharing if a competitor used the same tool.
- In contrast, international agencies have additional tools in their belts to pursue enforcement against AI-specific agreements. Global enforcers have shifted from discussions on regulating AI toward taking action. The UK Competition and Markets Authority (CMA)’s share of supply and material influence tests allow for review where a target may have little to no revenue or where control is more flexible than US control tests, respectively. The EU European Commission uses the Digital Markets Act to fill enforcement gaps for AI and has launched several cases under this theory.
- AI platforms also create issues for cartel enforcement, as AI-informed collusion does not rely on conversations or words but can effectuate the same kind of traditional conspiracy. As a result, antitrust agencies struggle with how to properly investigate cartels based on algorithms or AI.
Pricing algorithms
- Despite difficulties with AI, there have been some developments in enforcement against anticompetitive pricing algorithms. Though the law is still developing, enforcers and plaintiffs have argued that when competing firms adopt an algorithmic pricing software, there exists an agreement among the parties who use the algorithm.
- It is not clear that the use of algorithmic pricing tools result in supracompetitive prices, but litigation on that question and others will continue as regulators and courts tease out the appropriate use of these algorithms.
Increased US and international attention on cartel enforcement
- The expansion of tariffs under the Trump administration has weakened traditional market pressures. Some US practitioners argue this has gone so far as to protect cartels from enforcement, as leniency programs lose effectiveness due to the erosion of trust in institutions and enforcement becomes more politicized in the United States. As a result, the United States is at risk of losing its status as a leader in cartel enforcement and other jurisdictions are stepping up to fill the gap, even creating alliances and cooperation agreements without the US antitrust agencies. However, the partnership between DOJ and the US Postal Service creates a strong whistleblower pathway for antitrust enforcement.
- Conversely, international enforcers from Mexico, Canada, Europe, Brazil, and Japan have collectively increased their efforts to prosecute anticompetitive cartels engaged in bid-rigging and no-poach agreements. International leniency schemes have seen an uptick in applications, and enforcers rely heavily on their leniency programs to incentivize whistleblowers; they have collectively agreed that staying ahead of cartel activity requires staying ahead of data technology and AI trends.
Strong state antitrust enforcement continues
- State enforcement priorities align with the populist antitrust goals of the Trump administration’s antitrust agencies, namely housing, healthcare, labor, food, and other consumer-facing sectors. States have a particular interest in conduct that directly affects local market conditions and their residents.
- States are increasingly staffing their attorney general (AG) offices with former federal enforcers, indicating a serious interest in evaluating complaints and remedies even where the state ultimately does not take enforcement action. States are also increasing penalties for antitrust violations in order to overcome the cost-prohibitive nature of bringing antitrust enforcement actions.
- Similarly, states continue to pass mini-HSR acts modeled after the Uniform Law Commission Act, which requires parties to make HSR filings to the states concurrently with federal HSR filings. These filings allow states increased visibility into transactions with local impacts.
- Washington and Colorado were the first states to pass these laws, with California the latest to follow (as of early March 2026).
Expanding merger control globally
- Foreign jurisdictions are expanding merger review powers. Australia added mandatory merger filings, with 100 filings reviewed in 2026 (as of this publication). Canada removed the efficiencies defense from its antitrust guidelines, and the EU has asked parties to engage on efficiencies earlier in the merger review process.
- Cross-border merger review remains strong despite divergent policies. The EU and Mexico have successfully coordinated with the United States on enforcement actions. International enforcers continue to encourage information-exchange waivers to allow for inter-agency coordination and to prevent conflicting remedy decisions.
- Some international agencies also ask parties to submit more information than required by merger review processes and to work alongside the agencies in order to ensure deal review quality persists.
Consumer protection
- Price transparency remains the center of gravity and states are driving the agenda. Expect continued dual-track enforcement under unfair or deceptive acts or practices (UDAP) and antitrust against “drip,” partitioned, and algorithmic pricing, with transparency as the touchstone. Panelists emphasized that neither all-in nor unbundled pricing is categorically better for consumers; the risk turns on deception and execution. Watch for divergent state disclosure regimes (e.g., New York’s algorithmic pricing disclosure law, effective November 2025) and active inquiries and sweeps (California AG; congressional letters), alongside growing scrutiny of vendor-provided pricing tools and potential “autonomous” tacit collusion.
- Deceptive influencer endorsements and their AI-driven variants remain top of mind for enforcers and plaintiffs. Plaintiffs are testing disclosure theories (placement, prominence, “material connection”) and pressing premium price/overpayment claims, while defendants are finding traction at the Rule 9(b) stage when complaints do not link specific posts to reliance. The FTC’s Endorsement Guides remain the roadmap; brands should hard wire compliance into influencer contracts, and disclosures should not be buried among a slew of hashtags.
- “Made in USA” claims are an active enforcement lane with parallel class action exposure. The FTC’s Labeling Rule enables monetary relief and is being used alongside Section 5, with recent matters underscoring substantiation, net impression, and prominence (including imagery) as recurring pitfalls. National Advertising Division (NAD) challenges continue to shape expectations for qualified origin claims, while California’s bright line statute and rising private actions elevate forum risk. Practical takeaways include inventorying claims across channels, verifying supply chain inputs, using precise qualified language, and aligning federal and state standards before marketing “US origin” themes.
David Koeller, a law clerk in the Los Angeles office, also contributed to this client alert.

The Employee Retention Credit: Ninth Circuit affirms denial of injunction, but leaves door open on merits
ARTICLE
The Employee Retention Credit: Ninth Circuit affirms denial of injunction, but leaves door open on merits
Mar 27, 2026
Read time: 3 min
Case: ERC Today, LLC v. McInelly, Case No. 25-2642 (9th Cir. Mar. 17, 2026)
We previously discussed the US District Court for the District of Arizona’s April 2025 order denying a motion for a preliminary injunction filed by two tax preparation firms challenging the Internal Revenue Services’ (IRS) automated “risking” model for processing Employee Retention Credit (ERC) claims. The firms appealed, and on March 17, 2026, the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit affirmed the district court’s denial – but the way in which it did so warrants attention.
Standing, but not substance
The Ninth Circuit affirmed on the narrow ground that the tax preparation firms failed to demonstrate Article III standing. The Court found that the firms offered no evidence that they were making less money or spending more on representations because of the IRS’s processing approach. The Court also rejected claims of procedural and reputational injury, holding that IRS administrative procedures are designed to protect taxpayers, not the economic interests of third-party contingency fee firms.
Given the standing ruling, the Court did not address whether the IRS’s Disallowance During Processing program, which uses automated risk models to categorically disallow thousands of claims without individualized review, violates the Administrative Procedure Act or is otherwise unlawful. Those questions remain open. A challenge brought by a party with proper standing could reach those merits and might reveal the program to be infirm.
The future of taxpayer challenges
This decision comes as the IRS closes the book on ERC processing. In February 2026, the IRS announced it had closed all non-examined ERC claims as of December 31, 2025, meaning businesses whose claims were closed without payment must now pursue litigation to secure their refunds.
Unlike the tax preparation firms in ERC Today, taxpayers whose claims have been disallowed can engage the jurisdiction of a refund court under Internal Revenue Code Sections 6532 and 7422 and would have no standing issues. They would be better positioned to test the legality of the IRS’s automated processing procedures on the merits and should consider raising the argument in their complaint. As we have previously cautioned, however, taxpayers must remain vigilant about statutes of limitations: Administrative delay does not eliminate judicial deadlines, and a protest to the IRS Independent Office of Appeals does not suspend the two-year period under Section 6532(a) to file a refund suit.

CMS imposes Medicare DMEPOS moratorium (and Florida says, “Hold my beer”)
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
CMS imposes Medicare DMEPOS moratorium (and Florida says, “Hold my beer”)
March 27, 2026
Read time: 9 min
On February 27, 2026, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) announced a six-month nationwide enrollment moratorium prohibiting initial Medicare enrollment for seven types of durable medical equipment, prosthetics, orthotics, and supplies (DMEPOS) suppliers – the first nationwide DMEPOS enrollment freeze in the program’s history (the moratorium). The moratorium represents a significant escalation of CMS’s fraud enforcement posture under Administrator Dr. Mehmet Oz and aligns with the Trump administration’s broader anti-fraud agenda, including US President Donald Trump’s March 16, 2026, executive order establishing the Task Force to Eliminate Fraud under Vice President JD Vance’s leadership. On March 25, 2026, Florida became the first state to implement a parallel Medicaid DMEPOS moratorium, signaling that the federal-state partnership model CMS invited may soon expand nationwide. For DMEPOS suppliers, investors, and transaction parties, the regulatory landscape has fundamentally shifted.
The broader enforcement context
The moratorium aligns with President Trump’s March 16, 2026, executive order establishing the Task Force to Eliminate Fraud, chaired by Vice President Vance. The task force is charged with coordinating a national strategy to combat fraud in federal benefit programs and has 90 days to develop implementation plans, suggesting rapid regulatory evolution ahead. CMS Administrator Dr. Oz has emphasized the DMEPOS moratorium as a key component, stating that CMS is taking steps to “fight fraud, protect taxpayer dollars, and keep seniors safe from harmful low-quality products.” In imposing the moratorium, CMS cited longstanding Office of Inspector General (OIG) concerns regarding DMEPOS fraud, analysis of enrollment and claims data, and criminal convictions and Department of Justice (DOJ) investigations. DMEPOS suppliers should anticipate heightened scrutiny across multiple program integrity fronts, including enrollment, billing, site visits, and ownership changes.
CMS’s authority and duration
Under 42 C.F.R. § 424.570(a)(2), CMS may impose a temporary moratorium on newly enrolling providers and suppliers upon determining significant potential for fraud, waste, and abuse with respect to a particular provider or supplier type, geographic location, or both. While CMS previously imposed geographic moratoria targeting home health agencies in South Florida, Los Angeles, Houston, and Detroit between 2013 and 2018, the current moratorium marks the first nationwide enrollment freeze.
The moratorium runs through August 27, 2026, and may be extended in six-month increments, with any extensions announced in the Federal Register.
Impact on DMEPOS suppliers
The moratorium applies to seven categories of medical supply company DMEPOS suppliers: medical supply company; medical supply company with orthotics personnel; medical supply company with pedorthic personnel; medical supply company with prosthetics personnel; medical supply company with prosthetic and orthotic personnel; medical supply company with registered pharmacist; and medical supply company with respiratory therapist.
A “medical supply company” is a business whose principal function is to furnish DMEPOS directly to another party. The moratorium generally does not apply to grocery stores, retail pharmacies, or medical providers whose “principal function” is not DMEPOS provision. CMS will closely screen all applications during the moratorium and has cautioned that circumvention attempts could result in 10-year re-enrollment bars and OIG referral.
Initial enrollment applications submitted during the moratorium will be denied, but applications received before February 27, 2026, remain unaffected. CMS has published Q&As that provide further interpretation of the moratorium’s scope.
The 36-month rule and M&A implications
Effective January 1, 2026, CMS expanded the “36-month rule” (42 C.F.R. § 424.551) to include DMEPOS suppliers. Under this rule, a supplier that undergoes a change in majority ownership (CIMO) within 36 months after its initial enrollment or most recent CIMO must enroll as a new supplier, thus subjecting it to the Moratorium. A CIMO occurs when an individual or organization acquires more than 50% direct ownership interest via asset sale, stock transfer, merger, or consolidation. Certain exceptions apply, such as internal corporate restructurings or changes in corporate form.
The moratorium can create significant M&A structuring challenges, as asset purchases typically require the buyer to enroll as a new supplier. Absent further CMS guidance, which could be issued pursuant to its Q&As, such transactions would be prohibited during the moratorium unless the buyer can operate without Medicare/Medicaid revenue or delay closing. Similarly, stock or equity purchases dependent upon maintaining existing Medicare/Medicaid enrollment cannot proceed if the 36-month rule is triggered and, even if the transaction is structured at an indirect level to avoid the 36-month rule, stock transactions expose buyers to full historical liability of the seller.
Alternative structures such as management agreements may accomplish business objectives without triggering new enrollment, but CMS has warned that circumvention attempts will be met with heightened scrutiny and potential 10-year re-enrollment bars.
Florida becomes the first state to implement a Medicaid DMEPOS moratorium
CMS declined to impose a federal Medicaid moratorium but encouraged states to implement tailored moratoria. On March 25, 2026, CMS Administrator Dr. Oz announced that Florida had become the first state to receive CMS approval for a Medicaid-specific enrollment pause. The same day, the Florida Agency for Health Care Administration (AHCA) issued a health care alert (the alert) to Florida Medicaid providers (details shown in the the following chart). This alert was disseminated via email to individuals registered with Florida Medicaid for program-related alerts and appears as an archived alert on AHCA’s “Managed Care Alerts” website. However, providers that did not receive the email distribution may be unaware of this development.
| Element | Florida Medicaid Moratorium |
|---|---|
| Effective Date | March 20, 2026 |
| Duration | Initial six-month period (through approximately September 20, 2026) |
| Scope | DME providers (provider type 90) in all Florida counties |
| Exclusions | Pharmacies, hospitals, or other medical providers that provide DME as a “secondary function” |
| Pending Applications | Applications submitted on or before March 20, 2026, will continue to be processed |
| Existing Providers | May continue to deliver and bill for authorized servic |
Medicare and Florida Medicaid alignment
The two moratoria are not perfectly aligned, creating potential complexity for suppliers navigating both programs. The Florida moratorium runs through approximately September 20, 2026, while the Medicare moratorium runs through August 27, 2026, creating a potential three-week period where Medicare enrollment could resume while Florida Medicaid remains frozen.
Florida’s moratorium became effective March 20, 2026, but AHCA did not issue its alert until March 25th. Suppliers who submitted applications between March 20 and March 25 should contact AHCA immediately.
While the Medicare Moratorium applies to seven specific medical supply company specialty codes with designated personnel types, Florida’s moratorium applies broadly to provider type 90 suppliers, without specifying subcategories. Accordingly, a supplier blocked under one moratorium may or may not be blocked under the other.
How will the moratorium impact Florida managed care?
Florida suppliers now face moratoria on both Medicare and Medicaid enrollment, significantly constraining market entry for suppliers serving Florida’s large dual-eligible population. The vast majority of Florida Medicaid beneficiaries are enrolled in managed care plans, and it is unclear whether the Florida moratorium will create network adequacy challenges if managed care organizations (MCOs) cannot add new DME suppliers to their networks during the moratorium. MCOs typically credential providers before adding them to networks, but credentialing presupposes Medicaid enrollment. Incumbent DME suppliers already enrolled in MCO networks may be the only available option for the duration of the moratorium, which could shift negotiating leverage in MCO contracting toward existing enrolled suppliers.
How will the “principal function” versus “secondary function” exception be interpreted?
Both moratoria exempt providers for which DME is not the “principal function,” and Florida explicitly carves out pharmacies, hospitals, and other medical providers furnishing DME as a “secondary function.”
However, neither moratorium specifies how “principal function” is determined (e.g., revenue percentage, personnel devoted to the different operations, location) and if investigated, what documentation would be required to support principal function.
While a pharmacy or medical practice, for example, could expand into DME by characterizing DME as “secondary” to their primary function, CMS has explicitly warned that circumvention attempts will be met with 10-year re-enrollment bars and OIG referral. Accordingly, suppliers navigating the secondary function exception must consider potential enforcement exposure.
Which states may follow Florida?
CMS’s invitation for states to implement Medicaid moratoria suggests additional states may follow Florida. Key indicators include historical DME fraud concentration (Texas, California, Michigan); active Medicaid fraud control unit (MFCU) participation in federal enforcement (California, Texas, Michigan, Ohio, Georgia, Arizona); and political alignment with the Task Force to Eliminate Fraud. The speed with which Florida obtained approval – less than one month after the federal moratorium – suggests states with prepared requests could receive approval within weeks. Suppliers operating in multiple states should monitor state-level developments closely.
Ongoing CMS enforcement against DMEPOS suppliers
The moratorium is the latest in a series of CMS program integrity actions. CMS has actively scrutinized DMEPOS suppliers’ compliance with enrollment requirements, DMEPOS supplier standards (42 C.F.R. § 424.57(c)), and quality standards – exercising revocation authority even for minor deficiencies such as surety bond reporting failures or signage violations. Revoked suppliers face re-enrollment bars of at least one year, and if the moratorium is extended, suppliers subject to such bars may be unable to re-enroll upon bar expiration.
Takeaways
- Monitor developments: Watch for moratorium extension notices and state Medicaid moratoria. Monitor the moratorium FAQs for updates.
- Maintain compliance: Ensure timely enrollment updates, maintain organized documentation, prepare for site visits, and conduct internal auditing. CMS will closely scrutinize all DMEPOS activity during the moratorium.
- Evaluate M&A structures: Analyze ownership history for CIMO trigger risks; consider transaction structures that avoid the 36-month rule and new enrollment requirement but ensure appropriate purchase agreement protection and due diligence review.
- Prepare for enforcement: Engage counsel promptly upon receiving inquiries from HHS-OIG, DOJ, state MFCUs, CMS, or the Medicare administrative contractors (MACs).
- Florida-specific: DME providers that submitted applications between March 20 and March 25 should contact AHCA immediately regarding application status.
Please contact the authors or your regular McDermott Will & Schulte lawyer with any questions.

IRS roundup: March 9 – March 25, 2026
ARTICLE
IRS roundup: March 9 – March 25, 2026
Mar 26, 2026
Read time: 4 min
Check out our summary of significant Internal Revenue Service (IRS) guidance and relevant tax matters for March 9, 2026 – March 25, 2026.
AI controversy developments
March 20, 2026: The US Tax Court is considering developing a disciplinary framework for the misuse of artificial intelligence (AI) in litigation following concerns raised by Judge Mark V. Holmes regarding lawyers citing AI-generated, nonexistent cases. Judge Holmes indicated that the Court is proceeding cautiously given that a large share of its docket involves pro se taxpayers and emphasized the difficulty of crafting appropriate sanctions in that context. The discussion highlights broader concerns about hallucinated authorities, potential IRS misuse of AI, and the need to protect sensitive taxpayer information as the Court balances enforcement with legitimate AI uses.
IRS guidance
March 13, 2026: The IRS announced that the secretary of the US Department of the Treasury is no longer serving as acting IRS commissioner following the expiration of authority under the Federal Vacancies Reform Act of 1998. Chief Executive Officer Frank J. Bisignano is currently leading the IRS’s day-to-day operations.
March 16, 2026: The IRS issued Revenue Ruling 2026-11, updating the rules and technical specifications for substitute versions of Form 941, Form 8974, and related schedules, including Schedules B, D, and R. The guidance provides standards for paper and computer-generated substitutes used by software developers and payroll providers and supersedes prior guidance.
March 17, 2026: The IRS issued Notice 2026-19, providing updated interest rates for pension the corporate bond monthly yield curve, spot segment rates under Internal Revenue Code (Code) § 417(e)(3), and 24-month average segment rates under Code § 430(h)(2). The notice also includes the applicable 30-year Treasury rate for February 2026 (4.76%) and related weighted average rates.
March 18, 2026: The IRS issued Notice 2026-20, extending for one additional year the temporary relief provided by Notice 2025-7, which allows taxpayers to use alternative methods to identify which units of digital assets are sold, disposed of, or transferred when held with a broker. Under this relief, taxpayers may identify units on their own books and records, including through standing orders, rather than communicating with brokers. The notice clarifies that this does not prevent taxpayers from complying with § 1.1012-1(j)(3)(ii).
March 20, 2026: The IRS issued Revenue Procedure 2026-17, providing transition relief under Code § 163(j) that allows certain taxpayers to withdraw previously irrevocable elections to be treated as electing real property trades or businesses, electing farming businesses, or excepted regulated utility trades or businesses. The guidance also permits taxpayers withdrawing those elections to make a late election out of bonus depreciation, allows taxpayers to revoke or make controlled foreign corporation group elections without regard to the 60-month limitation, and permits eligible Bipartisan Budget Act of 2015 (BBA) partnerships to file amended Forms 1065 and issue amended Schedules K-1.
The IRS also released its weekly list of written determinations (e.g., Private Letter Rulings, Technical Advice Memorandums, and Chief Counsel Advice).
Recent court decisions
March 9, 2026: The Tax Court held that the IRS timely issued a notice of final partnership adjustment (FPA) to Mammoth Cave Property, LLC under the centralized partnership audit regime enacted by the BBA. The case arose after the IRS disallowed a charitable contribution deduction. The partnership argued that the FPA was invalid because the statute of limitations had expired, contending that the IRS’s earlier notice of proposed partnership adjustment (NOPPA) contained errors, including addressing the notice to the partnership’s former representative and using an outdated address.
The Court rejected these arguments, finding that the NOPPA provided adequate notice because it was received by the correct designated individual and the partnership’s counsel, and the partnership actively responded by requesting an extension of time and submitting a modification request regarding the imputed underpayment. The Court further held that the partnership’s modification request extended the limitations period under § 6235(a)(2), giving the IRS additional time to issue the FPA. Because the IRS issued the FPA within that extended period, the Court concluded that the notice was valid and the partnership’s statute-of-limitations defense failed.

The global impact of the UK’s new tax adviser registration regime
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
The global impact of the UK’s new tax adviser registration regime
March 26, 2026
Read time: 6 min
The UK’s tax authority, HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC), has confirmed that the requirement for UK and non-UK firms of tax advisers to register with HMRC will not apply to asset managers and other firms in the financial services sector before 31 March 2027. This postponement follows representations made by industry sector bodies and advisers as to the difficulties that financial services firms may have in understanding how they are affected by the new rules.
HMRC has indicated that the reason for delay is to give it time to work through the issues as to how the mandatory registration regime should apply to financial services firms. Managers should therefore also take this opportunity to get to grips with the requirements of the new regime – which they might be forgiven for expecting would not apply to them – and to start thinking about the actions they may need to take to comply with their obligations in the future.
Definition of a ‘tax adviser’ under the new regime
Under legislation introduced in Finance Act 2026, a firm that is a ‘tax adviser’ (as defined) and interacts in any way with HMRC is required to register with HMRC.1 Interaction with HMRC comprises any communication with HMRC of any kind in relation to the tax affairs of another person.
Despite what you might expect, the new registration regime potentially affects asset managers and other financial services firms, because the definition of a ‘tax adviser’ includes any organisation which, in the course of its business, assists another person with their tax affairs. Relevant activities include:
- Advising another person in relation to tax;
- Acting as an agent on behalf of another person in relation to tax; and
- Providing assistance to another person with any document relied on by HMRC to determine the other person’s tax position.
These criteria are likely to bring within scope of the tax adviser registration requirement any asset manager who interacts with HMRC (in any way) in relation to the affairs of the investment manager’s funds and clients. Relevant activities might include an investment manager’s applications on behalf of clients for reporting fund status, requests for HMRC to confirm that certain conditions of the investment manager exemption will be treated as met, and clearance applications under the share-for-share exchange or tax-free reorganisation provisions in respect of fund mergers or reorganisations, among others.
It is important to note that registration with HMRC is required for any ‘tax adviser’ firm which interacts with HMRC, regardless of where in the world that tax adviser or its clients are located. US asset managers, for example, with no activities in or other connection to the UK, could be required to register with HMRC and meet onerous registration conditions (see further below) before they can have any communication with HMRC on behalf of their funds and clients.
Scope of the tax adviser registration regime
The scope of the registration itself is also onerous. Registration requires a tax adviser firm to identify its ‘relevant individuals’ as part of the registration. These are all individuals who play a significant role in managing the tax adviser activities of the firm. Firms with more than five ‘officers’ (i.e., directors or LLP members) must identify at least five officers as relevant individuals, together with all other persons (officers or not) who meet the definition of a relevant individual.
Once the relevant individuals have been identified to HMRC, the tax adviser firm and every relevant individual must also meet the registration conditions. The most significant condition is that every relevant individual (and the firm itself) must be up to date with their own tax returns and tax payments. This applies wherever in the world a firm or a relevant individual files tax returns and pays taxes. For example, a US taxpayer who was a relevant individual of a US asset manager would cause the US manager to be non-compliant with the registration condition – and at risk of suspension of its registration – if that taxpayer were late in filing their US tax return with the IRS.
The registration conditions are ongoing requirements. HMRC has the power to suspend a tax adviser firm’s registration and issue a compliance notice in the event of a breach of the registration condition which is not quickly rectified (such as an overdue tax return) – and intends to monitor compliance with the registration conditions by firms and relevant individuals. Firms whose registration has been suspended are required to notify their clients of the suspension (with a penalty of £5,000 per client if they fail to do so) and can also be subject to financial penalties if they attempt to interact with HMRC whilst suspended.
Impact on asset managers and financial services firms
The mandatory HMRC tax adviser registration requirement, as currently drafted, would seem to require asset managers and other financial services firms to register with HMRC as ‘tax advisers’ – including a substantial number of US and other non-UK firms who might have some occasional communications with HMRC – and meet the onerous requirements of the registration regime. It is hard to believe that this is what is intended by the legislation.
It is therefore welcome that HMRC has decided to delay the introduction of the registration regime for financial services firms until April 2027 and intends to use the time before then to ensure that the requirements of the regime for such firms are “proportionate and workable” and that the regime applies only where intended.
Nonetheless, asset managers in the UK and in other countries who might have any communications with HMRC in respect of their funds and clients should start to familiarise themselves now with the requirements of the registration regime, such as the identification of relevant individuals, and follow developments over the next year. Asset managers and other relevant financial services firms should ensure they are suitably prepared to fulfil their obligations if and when they come within scope of the registration regime in April 2027.

SEC Speaks 2026: What public companies and investment advisers need to know
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
SEC Speaks 2026: What public companies and investment advisers need to know
March 25, 2026
Read time: 5 min
The US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) participated in the annual SEC Speaks conference on March 19 and 20, 2026, bringing together Commissioners and staff to discuss recent developments and share the agency’s priorities going forward. This year’s remarks offered useful insight into enforcement risks for public companies and investment advisers, highlighting areas that may see increased scrutiny.
Materiality: Returning to first principles
Materiality emerged as a defining theme during the conference. Commissioners Mark Uyeda and Hester Peirce emphasized a renewed focus on traditional financial materiality – information that meaningfully affects investor decision-making – while cautioning that the concept has been stretched in recent years to encompass political, environmental, and social matters without a clear financial nexus. This signals a likely move away from expansive, policy-driven disclosure expectations and toward a more economically grounded standard.
Chair Paul Atkins reinforced this approach, describing a forthcoming “spring cleaning” of the SEC rulebook, with materiality as the guiding principle for reassessing disclosure requirements. Atkins emphasized that unnecessary or overly complex disclosures impose real costs and can deter market participation. As an example, he pointed to criticism of the SEC’s approach in recent “off-channel communications” cases, suggesting that recordkeeping requirements for broker-dealers had been extended beyond a common-sense reading of the governing standards.
The ACT agenda
Consistent with the SEC’s effort to refine its definition of materiality, Chair Atkins announced the SEC’s new ACT (Advance, Clarify, Transform) framework, which reflects a broader effort to recalibrate the SEC’s approach to compliance and enforcement:
- Advance. The SEC will seek to modernize the regulatory framework to reflect current market realities and develop clear, workable rules, particularly in emerging areas, rather than relying on enforcement to shape policy.
- Clarify. The SEC will work to reduce regulatory uncertainty by drawing clearer jurisdictional lines and improving coordination across agencies, including with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission.
- Transform. The SEC has begun streamlining existing requirements by eliminating immaterial or overly burdensome rules and refocusing disclosure on what matters most to investors.
Enforcement: A sharper focus on investor harm
In the same vein, Acting Enforcement Director Sam Waldon signaled a continued shift toward more “impact-driven” enforcement, prioritizing cases that deliver meaningful investor protection. The Division will still pursue nonfraud violations but Acting Director Waldon indicated that it will place less emphasis on technical violations or fully remediated conduct and instead prioritize cases involving investor harm, such as fraud and market manipulation.
Acting Director Waldon’s remarks follow the apparent launch of a specialized Sarbanes-Oxley (SOX) Group within the Enforcement Division. According to an SEC job posting, this new group will be tasked with investigating and litigating matters involving potential violations of auditing and related professional standards and provisions of the SOX Act and other relevant federal securities laws – functions historically shared, in part, with the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB). These structural changes, coupled with significant budget reductions at the PCAOB, signal the SEC’s intent to centralize auditing oversight and intensify its internal scrutiny of corporate financial disclosures, internal controls, and gatekeepers.
Self-disclosure and cooperation credit
The SEC continued to incentivize early self-reporting of potential misconduct and issued a stern reminder regarding the “window of opportunity” for cooperation. Meaningful credit is increasingly reserved for companies that report misconduct before the SEC learns of it from other sources (such as media or whistleblowers).
Takeaways
SEC Speaks 2026 reflects an agency that is recalibrating and placing greater emphasis on economic materiality, respect for statutory limits, and streamlined requirements. For in-house counsel, this points to a more disciplined, cost-conscious regulatory environment. At the same time, companies should remain proactive:
- Continue to be vigilant with respect to financial controls. The decreased emphasis on nonfinancial disclosures arguably means a renewed focus on financial misstatement irregularities. The commission’s recent formation of a SOX taskforce shows that it is on the hunt for these cases.
- Expect more targeted enforcement. The SEC is likely to focus on cases involving meaningful investor harm, with less emphasis on technical or fully remediated violations, though core fraud risks remain a top priority. When the SEC identifies a case, it is likely to pursue it vigorously, particularly as to individuals. Acting Director Waldon’s comments also show that registered investment advisers remain exposed to regulatory-type cases, such as custody rule violations.
- Act quickly on potential misconduct. The SEC views early self-reporting as critical; companies that delay until the SEC is already aware of an issue should expect little to no cooperation credit.

Federal court vacates FinCEN real estate reporting rule obligations
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
Federal court vacates FinCEN real estate reporting rule obligations
March 25, 2026
Read time: 4 min
On March 19, 2026, Judge Jeremy Kernodle of the US District Court for the Eastern District of Texas issued an opinion in Flowers Title Cos., LLC v. Bessent vacating the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network’s (FinCEN) final rule extending anti-money laundering requirements to persons involved in certain real estate closings and settlements (Real Estate Reporting Rule). The final rule went into effect on March 1, 2026, and required the reporting of information of certain residential real estate transfers in which the purchaser or other recipient of an interest in real property is a legal entity (Transferee Entity) or trust (Transferee Trust). Each report was required to be electronically submitted to FinCEN and include information concerning the transferred property and identifying information for the Transferee Entity or Transferee Trust and its beneficial owners, the transferor, and the person filing the real estate report.
Judge Kernodle’s memorandum opinion and order held that FinCEN, in issuing the Real Estate Reporting Rule, exceeded its authority under the Bank Secrecy Act of 1970 (BSA) (31 U.S.C. §§ 5311 – 5336) on two grounds. First, although FinCEN may require reporting of “suspicious” transactions, the court concluded that non-financed residential real estate transactions to legal entity or trust recipients are not categorically suspicious. Second, although the BSA contains § 5318(a)(2), the court concluded that this language only authorizes FinCEN to require procedures that include reporting information; it does not authorize FinCEN to require the reports mandated by the Real Estate Reporting Rule. This order stops all reporting obligations under the Real Estate Reporting Rule.
FinCEN has updated its website to clarify that the filing of real estate reports is not required at this time, providing: “In light of a federal court decision, reporting persons are not currently required to file real estate reports with FinCEN and are not subject to liability if they fail to do so while the order remains in force.”
The government may appeal Judge Kernodle’s ruling to the US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit and may seek a stay of his order. As of the date of this publication, the government has not filed a notice of appeal but has 60 days from the date of the order to do so. If Judge Kernodle’s order is stayed, enforcement of the Real Estate Reporting Rule may continue pending a final decision by an appellate court on FinCEN’s authority to issue the Real Estate Reporting Rule.
We will continue to monitor any developments related to this case and other relevant cases and whether the US Department of the Treasury or FinCEN engage in any regulatory action.
Please contact your regular McDermott Will & Schulte lawyer with any questions regarding compliance with obligations imposed by the Real Estate Reporting Rule and the effect of this ruling.

Better sooner than later: Oklahoma passes a new consumer privacy law
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
Better sooner than later: Oklahoma passes a new consumer privacy law
March 24, 2026
Read time: 9 min
On March 20, 2026, Oklahoma Governor Kevin Stitt signed SB 546 into law, codifying Oklahoma’s comprehensive consumer privacy law. The law takes effect January 1, 2027, and, while it follows the familiar omnibus state privacy model, it contains notable drafting choices and omits some features found in other state laws.
Who does SB 546 apply to?
SB 546 follows the familiar threshold-based model. It applies to a controller or processor that conducts business in Oklahoma or produces a product or service targeted to Oklahoma residents and, during a calendar year, engages in either of the following:
- Controls or processes personal data of at least 100,000 consumers.
- Controls or processes personal data of at least 25,000 consumers and derives more than 50% of gross revenue from the sale of personal data.
Who is a consumer?
SB 546 defines a “consumer” as an individual who is a resident of Oklahoma acting only in an individual or household context, and excludes individuals acting in a commercial or employment context.
What is personal data?
“Personal data” means information, including sensitive data, that is linked or reasonably linkable to an identified or identifiable individual. The definition includes pseudonymous data when used in conjunction with additional information that reasonably links the data to an identified or identifiable individual, but excludes de-identified data and publicly available information.
What is sensitive data?
SB 546 defines “sensitive data” in a manner that generally tracks other omnibus state privacy laws and includes:
- Personal data revealing racial or ethnic origin, religious beliefs, mental or physical health diagnosis, sexual orientation, or citizenship or immigration status.
- Genetic or biometric data processed for the purpose of uniquely identifying an individual.
- Personal data collected from a known child.
- Precise geolocation data.
For these purposes, “precise geolocation data” means information derived from technology, including GPS-level latitude and longitude coordinates or other mechanisms, that directly identifies the specific location of an individual with precision and accuracy within a radius of 1,750 feet.
Who can enforce?
The Oklahoma attorney general has exclusive enforcement authority. Before bringing an action, the attorney general must provide written notice at least 30 days in advance identifying the alleged violations. If the violation is cured within that period and the controller or processor provides a written statement with supporting documentation showing the cure and representing that no further violations will occur, the attorney general may not bring the action. Civil penalties may reach $7,500 per violation, injunctive relief is available, and the bill expressly disclaims a private right of action. Unlike several other states, this cure period does not sunset.
Who is exempt?
SB 546 contains entity-level and data-level exemptions. At the entity level, it exempts state agencies and political subdivisions (and service providers processing on their behalf), financial institutions subject to the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (GLBA), covered entities and business associates regulated by the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA), nonprofit organizations, and institutions of higher education.
At the data level, the exemptions are broad and largely familiar, notably including personal data subject to GLBA, HIPAA, federal research laws, the Fair Credit Reporting Act, the Driver’s Privacy Protection Act, and the Farm Credit Act, among others.
Like other state privacy laws, SB 546 also includes separate carve-outs preserving certain processing for legal compliance, investigations, security and fraud response, legal claims, requested products or services, qualifying research, product recall, technical repair, and certain internal operations, subject to certain limits.
What obligations are imposed?
SB 546 imposes operational obligations on controllers and direct assistance and contracting obligations on processors. In particular, controllers must:
- Limit the collection of personal data to what is adequate, relevant, and reasonably necessary in relation to the purposes for which the personal data is processed, as disclosed to the consumer.
- Establish, implement, and maintain reasonable administrative, technical, and physical data security practices appropriate to the volume and nature of the personal data at issue.
- Refrain from processing personal data for a purpose that is neither reasonably necessary to nor compatible with the disclosed purpose unless the controller first obtains the consumer’s consent.
- Avoid processing personal data in violation of state or federal laws that prohibit unlawful discrimination against consumers, and avoid discriminating against consumers for exercising their rights, subject to the law’s loyalty-program and related carve-out.
- Obtain the consumer’s consent before processing sensitive data and, in the case of sensitive data of a known child, process that data in accordance with the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act.
- Establish two or more secure and reliable methods for consumers to submit rights requests, without requiring the consumer to create a new account; if the controller maintains a website, provide a mechanism on the website for requests, although an online-only controller with a direct relationship to the consumer may provide only an email address.
- Provide consumers with a reasonably accessible and clear privacy notice describing the categories of personal data processed (including, if applicable, sensitive data), the purposes of processing, how consumers may exercise and appeal their rights, and, if applicable, the categories of personal data shared with third parties and the categories of third parties.
- Clearly and conspicuously disclose in the privacy notice any sale of personal data to third parties or processing for targeted advertising, together with the manner in which a consumer may exercise the right to opt out.
- With respect to de-identified data, take reasonable measures to ensure the data cannot be associated with an individual, publicly commit to process the data only in de-identified fashion and not attempt to reidentify it, and contractually obligate recipients to comply with the same requirements.
Processors, in turn, must follow controller instructions and assist controllers, as reasonably practicable, with consumer-rights requests, security-of-processing and breach-notification compliance, and the information needed to conduct and document data protection assessments.
Controller-processor contracts must contain specified terms, including instructions, purpose, data type, duration, party rights and obligations, confidentiality, deletion/return, compliance information, assessment cooperation, and written subprocessor flow-downs. SB 546 also voids contractual provisions that waive or limit rights under its consumer-rights, response, or appeal provisions.
What consumer rights are created by SB 546?
SB 546 gives Oklahoma consumers a familiar set of omnibus privacy rights, including:
- The right to confirm whether a controller is processing the consumer’s personal data and to access that data.
- The right to correct inaccuracies in the consumer’s personal data, considering the nature of the data and the purposes of processing.
- The right to delete personal data provided by or obtained about the consumer.
- The right, if the data is available in digital format, to obtain a portable copy of personal data previously provided by the consumer, in a readily usable format where technically feasible and where processing is carried out by automated means.
- The right to opt out of targeted advertising, the sale of personal data, and profiling in furtherance of a decision that produces a legal or similarly significant effect concerning the consumer.
- The right to appeal a controller’s refusal to take action on a request. With respect to a known child, a parent or legal guardian may exercise these rights on the child’s behalf.
The bill enumerates these rights and does not add a separate right to obtain a list of specific third parties or a standalone right to a profiling explanation, reevaluation, or outcome report.
Response to consumer requests
Controllers must respond to an authenticated consumer request within 45 days after receipt, with one additional 45-day extension available when reasonably necessary in light of the complexity and number of requests. If a controller declines to act, it must explain the basis for the denial and provide appeal instructions within the same 45-day period. Responses must be provided free of charge up to twice annually per consumer, subject to a reasonable-fee or refusal mechanism for manifestly unfounded, excessive, or repetitive requests. The bill also provides a specific compliance pathway for deletion requests where the controller obtained the personal data from a source other than the consumer.
The appeal process must be conspicuously available and similar to the process for submitting an initial rights request. The controller must decide the appeal within 60 days after receipt and, if the appeal is denied, provide the online mechanism through which the consumer may submit a complaint to the Oklahoma attorney general.
Data protection assessments
SB 546 requires a controller to conduct and document a data protection assessment for:
- The processing of personal data for purposes of targeted advertising.
- The sale of personal data.
- The processing of personal data for purposes of profiling, where the profiling presents a reasonably foreseeable risk of unfair or deceptive treatment, financial, physical, or reputational injury, a physical or other intrusion on the private affairs of consumers, or other substantial injury to consumers.
- The processing of sensitive data.
- Any processing activities involving personal data that present a heightened risk of harm to consumers.
The assessment must identify and weigh benefits and risks and take into account de-identified data, consumer expectations, context, and the controller-consumer relationship. A single assessment may address comparable processing operations, and an assessment prepared for another law may satisfy if it has a reasonably comparable scope and effect. Notably, assessments are confidential, may be requested by the Oklahoma attorney general through a civil investigation demand, and apply prospectively to processing activities that commence on or after the effective date.
When does SB 546 take effect?
If signed into law, SB 546 becomes effective January 1, 2027.
***
The state privacy law landscape continues to become more complex as each new omnibus law is introduced. Organizations should review applicability, consumer-rights workflows, notices, controller-processor contracts, sensitive-data consent flows, and assessment practices to determine whether targeted Oklahoma updates are warranted. If you have questions or need assistance with readiness work for new state consumer privacy laws, please contact your regular McDermott lawyer.

SEC issues groundbreaking interpretation on crypto asset regulation
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
SEC issues groundbreaking interpretation on crypto asset regulation
March 24, 2026
Read time: 10 min
After more than a decade of regulatory uncertainty, on March 17, 2026, the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) issued an interpretation clarifying how federal securities laws apply to crypto assets and that most crypto assets are not securities (“the interpretation”).[1] The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) has stated it will administer the Commodity Exchange Act consistent with this interpretation, and has confirmed that non-security crypto assets could meet the definition of “commodity” under that statute.[2] This interpretation represents the SEC’s most comprehensive effort to date to articulate a coherent framework for crypto asset regulation.
Background and context
The interpretation marks a shift from what critics described as “regulation by enforcement” to a more principles-based regulatory framework.[3] Following the 2017 DAO Report, the SEC, particularly during the previous administration and under Chairman Gary Gensler, applied the US Supreme Court’s Howey test to crypto assets primarily through enforcement actions rather than comprehensive rulemaking, creating significant uncertainty for market participants.[4] In 2019, the SEC issued its “Framework for ‘Investment Contract’ Analysis of Digital Assets” (the “framework”), outlining how it applied the Howey test to crypto assets and identified a set of non-exhaustive factors to determine whether a cryptocurrency was being offered as a security.[5] The framework emphasized economic reality over form and highlighted “consumptive use” as a mitigating factor, while recognizing that assets with both consumptive and speculative characteristics may still be securities.[6]
Current SEC Chairman Paul S. Atkins has emphasized that “most crypto assets are not themselves securities” and that “investment contracts can come to an end,” reflecting a departure from the prior administration’s approach.[7] This interpretation follows extensive engagement through the SEC’s Crypto Task Force and implements recommendations from the president’s Working Group on Digital Asset Markets to provide greater regulatory clarity and support blockchain-based innovation in the United States.[8] Since Chairman Atkins assumed office, the SEC has also issued a series of statements providing additional clarity across key areas of the crypto asset ecosystem.[9] This interpretation consolidates and formalizes many of the views expressed in previous SEC statements.
Investment contract framework
The interpretation is clear that it does not supersede or replace the Howey test. Instead, through the interpretation, the SEC is clarifying how the Howey test applies to crypto assets and transactions involving crypto assets.
Creation of investment contracts. The interpretation clarifies that a “non-security crypto asset becomes subject to an investment contract when an issuer offers it by inducing an investment of money in a common enterprise with representations or promises to undertake essential managerial efforts from which a purchaser would reasonably expect to derive profits.”[10] A purchaser’s reasonable expectation of profit depends on the issuer’s representations or promises to perform essential managerial efforts.[11] Absent such representations or promises, it would not be reasonable for purchasers to expect profits.[12] The interpretation emphasizes that the manner of communication is central to shaping investor expectations. It notes that purchasers may reasonably rely on representations conveyed through “the issuer’s website or official social media accounts… direct private communications… [or] a whitepaper.”[13] Detailed and specific business plans are more likely to create reasonable profit expectations than vague or aspirational statements.[14] The interpretation also draws a significant distinction between primary and secondary market transactions, stating that “a non-security crypto asset that has been subject to an investment contract does not remain subject to the associated investment contract in secondary market transactions where purchasers would not reasonably expect such representations or promises to remain connected to the non-security crypto asset.”
Separation from investment contracts. The interpretation confirms that a “non-security crypto asset that was offered and sold subject to an investment contract does not necessarily remain subject to the associated investment contract in perpetuity.”[15] Separation may occur where the issuer has fulfilled its promised essential managerial efforts or where it becomes clear those efforts will not be performed, including through abandonment.[16] In such cases, purchasers would no longer reasonably expect profits based on those efforts.[17] The initial offer and sale of the investment contract must still have been registered or be exempt, and issuers remain subject to liability: The issuer “may be subject to liability under the anti-fraud provisions… even if the… investment contract ceases to exist.”[18]
Five-category taxonomy
The interpretation creates a five-part taxonomy for crypto assets: digital commodities, digital collectibles, digital tools, stablecoins, and digital securities.[19]
Digital commodities. Digital commodities are crypto assets whose value derives from the programmatic operation of a functional crypto system and market supply and demand, rather than from expectations of profits based on the essential managerial efforts of others.[20] Digital Commodities do not have a central party that “oversees participation or distributes rewards to users.”[21] The Interpretation defined a central party as “a person, entity, or group of persons or entities having operational, economic, or voting control of a crypto system.”[22] Examples of Digital Commodities include APT, AVAX, BTC, BCH, ADA, LINK, DOGE, ETH, HBAR, LTC, DOT, SHIB, SOL, XLM, XTZ, XRP, and similar assets.[23] They are used to validate transactions, secure networks, and enable system functionality, and are not themselves securities.[24]
Digital collectibles. Digital collectibles are crypto assets designed to be collected or used, potentially representing artwork, music, videos, trading cards, in-game items, or references to internet memes, characters, or trends.[25] Examples of Digital Collectibles include CryptoPunks, Chromie Squiggles, Bored Apes, Fan Tokens, WIF, VCOIN, meme coins. Their value is driven by popularity or scarcity, not managerial efforts, and they do not confer rights in a business enterprise.[26] They are not themselves securities, although the offer and sale of fractionalized interests in a digital collectible could constitute the offer and sale of a security.[27]
Digital tools. Digital tools are crypto assets that provide functional utility, such as memberships, tickets, credentials, or domain names.[28] Examples of Digital Tools include ENS domains, access tokens, and ticketing non fungible tokens (NFTs) such as Ethereum Name Service domain names and CoinDesk “Microcosms” NFT Consensus tickets. Often non-transferable, they are acquired for use rather than investment and are not themselves securities.[29]
Stablecoins. Stablecoins are crypto assets designed to maintain stable value relative to a reference asset.[30] Certain payment stablecoins are excluded from the definition of a security under the GENIUS Act, while others may be securities depending on their structure and surrounding facts.[31]
Digital securities. Digital securities are tokenized versions of financial instruments that fall within the statutory definition of “security.”[32] Tokenization does not alter the analysis. If an instrument has the economic characteristics of a security, it remains a security whether issued onchain or offchain.[33]
Treatment of key crypto activities
Protocol mining. The interpretation confirms that mining activities on proof-of-work networks do not involve offers and sales of securities.[34] Miners contribute computational resources to secure the network and earn protocol-based rewards, which are treated as payments for services rather than profits derived from the essential managerial efforts of others.[35] The same conclusion applies to mining pools, where pool operators perform administrative or ministerial functions.[36]
Protocol staking. The interpretation similarly provides that staking on proof-of-stake networks does not involve securities transactions.[37] This position is consistent with the SEC’s prior statement that “participants in Protocol Staking Activities do not need to register with the Commission transactions under the Securities Act” and that, in such activities, service providers engage in “administrative or ministerial” rather than “managerial or entrepreneurial efforts.”[38] This applies across staking models, including self-staking, third-party staking, custodial arrangements, and liquid staking. In each case, participants earn rewards for validating network activity, and service providers act in an administrative or ministerial capacity rather than providing essential managerial efforts.[39] This conclusion depends on service providers acting in a non-discretionary, agent-like capacity, without guaranteeing returns or exercising control over staking decisions. Arrangements that introduce discretion, fixed returns, or reliance on managerial efforts may fall outside the scope of the interpretation.[40] Ancillary services such as slashing coverage, early unbonding, alternative reward payment schedules and amounts, and the aggregation of digital commodities, when provided to owners and depositors in connection with protocol staking, were likewise characterized as administrative or ministerial in nature and not as essential managerial efforts.[41]
Staking receipt tokens. The interpretation provides that staking receipt tokens are not securities where they represent non-security crypto assets that are not subject to an investment contract and merely evidence deposited assets in a protocol-level staking arrangement.[42] In these circumstances, the tokens do not themselves generate returns and do not involve reliance on the essential managerial efforts of others. However, where the underlying asset is a security or is subject to an investment contract, the staking receipt token will also be treated as a security.[43]
Wrapping. The interpretation provides that “wrapping” arrangements, where crypto assets are deposited and one-to-one redeemable tokens are issued, do not involve the offer and sale of securities, so long as the tokens simply represent the underlying assets and do not provide any additional return or profit opportunity.[44] In such cases, the tokens are treated as receipts for non-security crypto assets and do not involve investment contracts, as the arrangement is administrative in nature and does not rely on the essential managerial efforts of others.[45] The interpretation clarifies that, in contrast, wrapping arrangements that merely create a one-to-one redeemable “receipt,” without additional rights or profit expectations, do not give rise to such an investment contract. This interpretation builds on the SEC’s view of custodial arrangements, in which it explained that “merely offering a more convenient way for investors to purchase, hold, and transfer the underlying” assets, without “anything resembling active management,” does not involve managerial efforts.[46]
Airdrops. The interpretation clarifies that airdrops do not involve securities transactions where recipients provide no consideration in exchange for the distributed assets.[47] In such cases, the “investment of money” prong of the Howey test is not satisfied, and registration is not required.[48] This analysis applies only where the airdrop is not conditioned on the provision of consideration by recipients.
Practical implications and next steps
The interpretation provides a clearer framework for analyzing when crypto assets and related activities fall within the federal securities laws, confirming that digital commodities, collectibles, and tools are not themselves securities while emphasizing that the investment contract analysis remains fact-specific and driven by issuer representations and market expectations. It also clarifies the treatment of key activities such as staking, wrapping, and airdrops, and underscores that the regulatory status of a crypto asset may evolve over time depending on whether an associated investment contract exists or ceases to exist. The interpretation is effective now that the interpretation has been published in the Federal Register on March 23, 2026 and will be applied by the SEC and CFTC in administering their respective statutes, and may be further refined through the ongoing public comment process as part of broader efforts under “Project Crypto” to provide clearer regulatory frameworks for crypto asset markets.
McDermott’s FinTech and blockchain team can help you navigate the nuances and implications of this new Interpretation. McDermott’s crypto-exclusive team spends 100% of its time on matters for the crypto and FinTech industries.

DOJ clarifies stance on information-sharing practices with statement of interest
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
DOJ clarifies stance on information-sharing practices with statement of interest
March 23, 2026
Read time: 6 min
The US Department of Justice (DOJ) recently filed a statement of interest (SOI) in an antitrust class action reminding businesses that participating in information exchanges – even when the information shared is aggregated, anonymized, and backward-looking – is not presumed lawful. Information exchanges are subject to a fact-intensive assessment to determine whether the information exchange harms competition. The statement provides guidance on the legality of information exchanges while the DOJ pursues its own enforcement agenda in this area.
What happened?
On February 27, 2026, the DOJ filed an SOI in In re Frozen Potato Products Antitrust Litigation, an antitrust class action against four producers of frozen potato products and the data analytics platform to which the producers subscribed.
The plaintiffs, who are direct and indirect purchasers of frozen potato products, allege that these four producers shared competitively sensitive information with one another through a data analytics platform. The producers allegedly sent weekly sales and volume data to the platform and received reports comparing their data to those of their three competitors. The data also allegedly contained company projections.
The plaintiffs claim that the information exchange violated Section 1 of the Sherman Act for two reasons: The information exchange facilitated an agreement to fix prices and, even in the absence of a price-fixing agreement, the information exchange, standing alone, resulted in anticompetitive effects. The defendants filed motions to dismiss the plaintiffs’ consolidated complaints, suggesting that information exchange alone is insufficient to establish the concerted conduct requirement of a Section 1 claim and that sharing backward-looking data is insufficient to establish an anticompetitive effect.
The DOJ’s statement responds to the defendants’ motions to dismiss to correct potential misstatements of the legal framework applicable to Section 1 claims involving information exchanges.
DOJ’s framework for analyzing information exchanges
In its SOI, DOJ first states that information sharing, with the mutual expectation that others will do the same, is sufficient to establish the concerted action required for a Sherman Act Section 1 claim.
According to the DOJ, this is because “concerted action can take on many forms,” including both “express or implied agreements.” Citing Supreme Court precedent, the DOJ states that concerted action can occur when a defendant, in response to a request from its competitors for price data, “furnish[es] the data with the expectation that it would be furnished reciprocal information when it wanted it.” No prior agreement need exist. And it “makes no difference” whether the information is exchanged between the parties directly or through an intermediary, like a data analytics platform.
Second, the DOJ emphasized that information exchanges “are not presumed lawful,” even in circumstances where competitors are sharing aggregated, anonymized, and backward-looking data.
An information exchange itself can violate Section 1 under a rule of reason analysis according to the DOJ. Information exchanges can result in overall anticompetitive effects because “different information exchanges work in diverse ways and have distinct effects.” The point, according to the DOJ, is whether the information exchange has a “tendency…to suppress competition.”
Sharing information with competitors “can soften competition,” resulting in anticompetitive effects even when performed without an agreement to fix prices. Armed with knowledge of a competitor’s price, a firm can match it, ultimately depriving the market of fierce price competition and resulting in “market stabilization.”
Why does it matter?
Businesses should regularly reevaluate their information-sharing and benchmarking practices in light of the DOJ SOI and enforcement actions on this topic. Any reevaluation should include benchmarking, third-party data analytics platforms, surveys, and trade association data, among other data exchange mechanisms.
In the past, businesses across industries relied upon antitrust safety zones as defined in various DOJ and Federal Trade Commission (FTC) policy statements, including an information exchange safety zone defined in the 1996 Statements of Antitrust Enforcement in Health Care. The 1996 statement indicated that the agencies would not challenge exchanges involving price or cost information if:
- A third party managed the exchange;
- The data provided was more than three months old; and
- At least five participants were providing data, no one participant’s data represented more than 25% of a statistic, and no individual participant’s data could be identified.
In 2023, however, the agencies withdrew the 1996 statement – and with it, this safe harbor – in favor of a case-by-case approach to information exchanges. Since then, the DOJ has pursued several enforcement actions against information exchanges that involved sharing competitively sensitive information through third parties.
The DOJ’s SOI in In re Frozen Potato Products provides the latest indication of the agencies’ thinking on information-sharing practices. Combined with the 1996 statement, which still has informative value, companies should evaluate their information-sharing practices under the following principles:
- Businesses should have a strong, procompetitive rationale for participating in an information exchange. Businesses should consider their reasons for agreeing to exchange data, as well as how and how much the results influence their pricing and sales decisions.
- Public data presents less competitive risk than private data, and older data presents less competitive risk than more recent data and forecasts. Data tends to present more concern the more granular or detailed it is, too. Even if businesses share backward-looking data, businesses should consider the extent to which the information can be used to infer the current price a competitor charges to a specific consumer.
- Information exchanges involving a small number of participants or a participant that represents an outsized share of the reported statistics raise more competitive concerns than exchanges that aggregate data across numerous, smaller competitors; across a portion of the market; or from entities across different geographic markets. Even if the data is aggregated and anonymized, businesses should consider whether the data can still be attributed to a particular competitor or a small set of competitors.
These factors are not determinative but provide guidance for assessing risk. And businesses that share data through intermediaries that offer pricing algorithms should be mindful of the unique antitrust risks those models present, taking careful note of new and pending state laws that address these kinds of algorithmic software products.
If you have questions about your entity’s information-sharing practices, McDermott Will & Schulte’s antitrust team can help you assess the antitrust risk involved and devise strategies to mitigate that risk.

