Content Type: Article

  • Estate planning documents: Key questions and answers

    Estate planning documents: Key questions and answers

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Estate planning documents: Key questions and answers

    March 16, 2026

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Keeping your estate planning documents up to date is essential, regardless of market conditions. Regular review helps ensure that your plan continues to reflect your wishes, protect your family, and operate as intended. It is also important to revisit these documents periodically in light of changes in your family circumstances, financial situation, or applicable law.

    Whether you are starting from scratch or reassessing an existing plan, our Q&A is here to help.

    In depth

    At a minimum, most estate plans include:

    • A will (or, in some cases, a revocable living trust (revocable trust) used as a “will substitute”).
    • A healthcare proxy.
    • A durable power of attorney.

    In addition, beneficiary designations for life insurance policies and retirement accounts should be reviewed regularly. Because these assets pass outside of a will or revocable trust, keeping them aligned with your broader estate plan is essential.

    Authors

    Anita S. Rosenbloom

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    Jay J. Scharf

    Partner

    Miami, Boca Raton

    Inri Panajoti

    Associate

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • Record-high 2026 federal tax exemptions expand opportunities for New Yorkers to permanently reduce future New York estate tax

    Record-high 2026 federal tax exemptions expand opportunities for New Yorkers to permanently reduce future New York estate tax

    ARTICLE

    Record-high 2026 federal tax exemptions expand opportunities for New Yorkers to permanently reduce future New York estate tax

    March 16, 2026

    Read time: 9 min

    Overview

    The federal gift and estate tax exclusions and the generation-skipping transfer (GST) tax exemption increased significantly under the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA) passed in 2025. Beginning in 2026, the new greatly expanded exclusion amounts took effect, providing extraordinary multigenerational estate planning opportunities.

    For New York residents, stock market volatility, depressed values for asset classes such as residential and commercial real estate, and the record-high federal exemption amounts open the door for powerful gifting opportunities. Advanced planning is crucial to avoid triggering the New York estate tax “cliff.”

    In depth

    How the exclusions impact New York residents

    New York state enacted legislation in 2014 reforming its estate tax laws. One of its major changes was the gradual increase of the New York state estate tax exclusion from $1,000,000 to the federal level, anchored, however, to the exclusions provided under then-existing federal tax law. As of January 1, 2026, the New York state estate tax exclusion amount increased from $7,160,000 to $7,350,000. It is indexed for inflation, with 2010 as the base year for this purpose. Although New York does not have a gift tax, gifts (other than annual exclusions gifts) made within three years of one’s death are “clawed back” and included in the New York state estate tax computation.

    To take advantage of the increased federal exclusion amounts, New Yorkers should plan to maximize both spouses’ New York exclusion amounts. Unlike federal law, the state does not recognize the portability of a deceased spouse’s unused exclusion amount to the surviving spouse. As a result, many New Yorkers will continue to incorporate credit shelter trusts or disclaimer trusts in their wills to maximize the benefits of both the New York and federal law exclusion and exemption amounts. This means that, without proper planning, at the death of a first spouse, the current New York exemption of $7,350,000 would be wasted if not used on the first spouse’s death. With proper planning, on the death of the first spouse, certain trusts could be funded to secure the use of the New York estate tax exemption and preserve the assets free of New York and federal estate tax on the death of the first spouse.

    Avoiding the New York estate tax cliff

    The doubling of the federal estate tax exclusion under the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 and the most recent increase under the OBBBA have created a $7,650,000 spread between the federal and New York state estate tax exclusion amounts. The benefits of an increased New York estate tax exclusion amount are effectively denied to wealthier New Yorkers because a “cliff” is built into the New York estate tax calculation that quickly phases out all benefits of the exclusion if the decedent’s New York taxable estate is between 100% and 105% of the exclusion amount available on the date of death. The cliff completely wipes out the benefits of the exclusion if the decedent’s New York taxable estate exceeds 105% of the exclusion amount available on the date of death.

    To avoid exceeding the New York estate tax exclusion and falling into the “cliff” range, New Yorkers should gift sooner rather than later and consider implementing the following strategies:

    • New York residents can make lifetime gifts within the parameters of the expanded federal exclusion (currently $15,000,000) and permanently move assets out of the New York taxable estate without incurring any state-level gift tax. Because New York has no gift tax (although a three-year add-back applies), residents can permanently insulate gifted property from New York estate tax and may have the added benefit of reducing their New York taxable estates below the applicable exclusion amount on the date of their death. For some, this can help avoid the confiscatory impact of the New York estate tax cliff.
      • For example, a gift of $15,000,000 by a New York resident can potentially save, at least, between $1,866,800 and $2,400,000 of New York state estate tax (depending on the total size of the taxable estate). The New York estate tax savings could potentially be doubled if both spouses were to fully use their federal exclusions by making lifetime gifts.
    • New Yorkers whose estates are within the 100% to 105% “cliff” range ($7,350,000 to $7,717,500) or whose estates only slightly exceed the New York estate tax exclusion amount may consider gifting an amount that would bring their taxable estate below the New York estate tax exclusion amount.
      • For example, a New Yorker who has assets with a current value of $7,717,500 and is in relatively good health may wish to consider gifting $400,000 at this time to their children or other intended beneficiaries. Considering the three-year clawback, it would be advantageous to make such a gift as soon as possible or to make gifts of that amount in a manner that qualifies for the annual gift tax exclusion. Suppose this person is married and has four children and eight grandchildren. If they make annual exclusion gifts of $19,000 to each child and grandchild (either outright or in a sprinkle trust) with each child and grandchild having temporary withdrawal rights, and if the person’s spouse is willing to split the gifts, then up to $456,000 (or the entire $400,000 in this example) would be treated as annual exclusion gifts that are not subject to the clawback.

    As always, the potential estate, gift, and GST tax savings should be weighed against the potential cost of the loss of the step-up of income tax basis for assets included in a decedent’s taxable estate under current law.

    Authors

    Anita S. Rosenbloom

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    Jay J. Scharf

    Partner

    Miami, Boca Raton

    Inri Panajoti

    Associate

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • Inflation adjustment sends federal estate, gift, GST tax exemptions soaring

    Inflation adjustment sends federal estate, gift, GST tax exemptions soaring

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Inflation adjustment sends federal estate, gift, GST tax exemptions soaring

    March 16, 2026

    Read time: 15 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Following recent inflation adjustments, federal estate, gift, and generation-skipping transfer (GST) tax exemptions have soared to a record-high $15 million per person and $30 million per married couple. Even individuals who had previously exhausted their exemptions have now gained another $1,010,000 of exemption per individual, and $2,020,000 per couple.

    What goes up, however, can always come down through future legislation.

    Estate planning in 2026

    Starting January 1, 2026, the amounts that individuals can gift free of federal gift and GST tax rose to $15,000,000 for individuals and $30,000,000 for married couples, as a result of the latest tax bill signed into law on July 4, 2025, formerly known as the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA). The federal annual gift tax exclusion remains at $19,000 per person (or $38,000 for married couples who elect to split gifts).

    This marks the highest federal transfer‑tax exemption in history, creating an unprecedented opportunity to transfer significant wealth free of federal estate, gift, and GST tax. Yet, at the same time, the broader political landscape remains uncertain. With ongoing volatility in Washington and the possibility that future election results – particularly, a potential shift in congressional control during the midterms – could result in changes to tax policy, it is important to recognize that today’s historically high exemption may not remain in place indefinitely.

    With this in mind, individuals who have not already maximized the use of their exemptions may wish to act sooner rather than later. Although there are no longer any “hardwired” sunset provisions in the current legislation, future acts of Congress could reduce the exemptions. Most importantly, there are tremendous potential benefits of implementing strategies now, as they may enable some taxpayers to capture more appreciation and insulate income from future taxation.

    This client alert describes some of the more effective estate planning techniques you may consider implementing now. See our related client alert for an overview of the key documents you should have in place, regardless of what happens in Washington.

    In depth

    Expanded gifting opportunities

    • In 2026, individuals can transfer $15,000,000 free of estate, gift, and GST tax during their lives or at death; married couples can transfer $30,000,000 during their lives or at death.
    • Individuals who exhausted their gift tax exclusion amount and GST tax exemption prior to 2026 can gift an additional $1,010,000 in 2026 free of gift and GST tax. Similarly, married couples who previously exhausted their exclusion and exemption amounts can gift another $2,020,000 in 2026.
    • Because of the portability provisions made permanent in 2013 by the American Taxpayer Relief Act of 2012, the surviving spouse may use the deceased spouse’s unused federal estate tax exclusion (but not GST tax exemption) for lifetime gifting or at death.
    • The annual per-donee gift tax exclusion amount for 2026 remains at $19,000 per donee (or $38,000 per donee if spouses elect to split gifts). This amount is subject to indexing in future years. Gifts in any amount for tuition or medical expenses (including health insurance) paid directly to the educational institution, medical provider, or insurance company continue to remain exempt from gift tax.

    At this time, individuals who have not already secured the full use of their exemptions should consider establishing a trust or adding to existing trusts and funding them with assets which they currently feel comfortable gifting.

    Special considerations for New York, New Jersey, and Connecticut residents

    New York residents

    For New Yorkers, market volatility, depressed values for certain asset classes (e.g., commercial real estate) and soaring inflation-related federal exclusion amounts all enhance powerful gifting and other leveraged-transfer opportunities in 2026. Explore our related article to learn how the expanded amounts give New Yorkers a greater opportunity to plan to permanently reduce their New York taxable estates and avoid the New York estate tax cliff.

    New Jersey residents

    New Jersey has neither a gift tax nor an estate tax. It does, however, have an inheritance tax that applies to property passing at a decedent’s death and to gifts made within three years of death to persons other than the decedent’s spouse, parents, children, or more remote descendants. The tax is imposed at rates as high as 16%. New Jersey residents who want to benefit other family members should consider making lifetime gifts to those individuals or to trusts for their benefit using the temporarily high exclusion amounts to protect their gifts from federal estate tax and New Jersey inheritance tax.

    Connecticut residents

    Connecticut is the only state that imposes a gift tax. Until the end of 2022, the Connecticut exclusion amount was well below the federal exclusion amount. As a result, Connecticut residents who utilized their entire federal exclusion amount incurred a substantial Connecticut gift tax. As of January 1, 2023, this is no longer an issue, since the Connecticut exclusion matches the federal exclusion.

    The increase presents a valuable opportunity for Connecticut residents who previously capped their gifts well below the federal exclusion amount in order to avoid the Connecticut gift tax.

    Popular wealth-transfer techniques

    Here are some planning techniques to consider:

    • Topping off prior planning by making additional gifts to existing or new family trusts to shift future appreciation out of the estate.
      • For example, if you made a $10 million gift to a trust last year and simply invested the funds in the S&P 500, the $10 million would have increased to roughly $11.7 million, resulting in $1.7 million growing outside of your future taxable estate in just 12 months. In addition, if you made a gift of a minority interest in an operating business or closely held investment, valuation discounts in the range of approximately 25% to 35% can be applied to the net asset value of the entity with a qualified appraisal. For example, if the net asset value of the business is $50 million, then, on a minority interest basis, the value of the gift for gift-tax purposes could be reduced based on a $32.5 million value rather than a $50 million value. A gift of a 45% interest in the business would be valued at approximately $14,625,000 (after the discounts) and would be below the donor’s $15,000,000 gift exemption, leveraging the use of the exemption.
      • If the gift is made to an intentionally defective grantor trust (discussed below), then the grantor is responsible for paying the income taxes generated by the trust assets, allowing the trust assets to essentially grow tax free. Shifting the tax burden to the grantor reduces the grantor’s future taxable estate without using additional gift exemption and without being subject to gift tax. The benefits of the grantor paying the income taxes can be exponentially effective, particularly over a long time horizon, if the gifts are made to a dynasty trust (which trusts are free from estate, gift, and GST taxes for multiple generations).
    • Gifting residences or other assets to existing or new trusts that include spouses as discretionary beneficiaries, commonly referred to as spousal lifetime access trusts (SLATs).
    • Funding grantor-retained annuity trusts (GRATs) to take advantage of current stock-market volatility, depressed valuations for various asset classes, and/or valuation discounts in valuing closely held business interests.
    • Selling assets to grantor trusts or, where appropriate, making cash gifts to facilitate the prepayment of existing loans from senior family members.
    • Making new intrafamily loans, particularly if interest rates decline.
    • Allocating increased GST tax exemption to existing family trusts that are not exempt from GST tax.
    • Securing the use of younger family members’ exclusion amounts and exemptions with gifting to family trusts for siblings and future descendants.

    Additional detail on these popular techniques is provided below.

    Dynasty (generation-skipping) trusts

    Through coordinated use of the federal gift exclusion and GST tax exemption, a taxpayer may create trusts with an aggregate value of up to $15,000,000 ($30,000,000 per married couple) with no gift or GST tax. These trusts may benefit several generations of descendants while insulating the assets from gift, estate, and GST taxes. Transfer tax-protected multigeneration trusts are sometimes referred to as “dynasty trusts,” particularly if they are situated in jurisdictions such as Delaware and New Jersey that permit trusts to last indefinitely.

    The creator of a dynasty trust allocates GST tax exemption to the trust and funds it with assets likely to appreciate. Those assets and all post-funding income and appreciation are removed from the taxable estate of the creator of the trust and would not be included in the estate of his or her children and grandchildren, allowing the trust to grow free of transfer taxes for multiple generations. In addition to mitigating the impact of transfer taxes, a dynasty trust can help shield a family’s assets from creditors, claims in the event of divorce, and poor decisions of future beneficiaries.

    Spousal lifetime access trusts (SLATs)

    Trusts, including dynasty trusts, may be structured to give your spouse, as well as your children and more remote descendants, access to the trust as discretionary beneficiaries. SLATs appeal to individuals who want the comfort of knowing that transferred wealth could still be available for family needs through distributions to the spouse. The trust assets can serve as a “rainy day fund” while allowing the grantor to take maximum advantage of the current levels of exclusion and exemption.

    It is possible for each spouse to create a trust that includes the other as a beneficiary. So long as the two trusts are not interrelated, and do not leave each spouse in approximately the same economic position in which either would have been had they named themselves as a beneficiary of the trust they created, neither trust should be included in either spouse’s taxable estate. One way of satisfying this test is to create the trusts at different times (preferably in different years) and to provide each spouse with different types of beneficial interests.

    Grantor-retained annuity trusts(s)

    Grantor-retained annuity trusts are a popular technique that can be used to transfer a portion of the appreciation on assets to family members without the imposition of any gift or estate tax (assuming the grantor survives the initial term, which can be as short as two years). GRATs are particularly useful in a time of extreme market turbulence. Turbulence creates an opportunity to fund a GRAT when there is a downswing in values that is expected to be temporary. GRATs are also particularly attractive gifting vehicles for hard-to-value assets.

    The grantor of a GRAT transfers assets to a trust while retaining the right to receive a fixed annuity for a specified term. The retained annuity is paid with any cash on hand, or, if there is no cash, with in-kind distributions of assets held in the trust. At the end of the term, the remaining trust assets pass to the ultimate beneficiaries of the GRAT (for example, a trust for the benefit of the grantor’s spouse and children), free of any estate or gift tax.

    Some of the key features of a GRAT include the following:

    • GRATs are structured so that the transfers they receive produce little or no taxable gifts. A GRAT that provides its grantor with an annuity stream equal to the value of the property transferred to it is known as a “zeroed-out” GRAT. A grantor’s gift to a zeroed-out GRAT is not subject to any gift tax.
    • Grantors can fund GRATs with any type of property, such as interests in closely held businesses; venture, hedge and private equity funds; and marketable securities. The best assets to transfer to GRATs are those that are likely to appreciate during the GRAT term at a rate that exceeds the IRS hurdle rate (an interest rate published by the IRS every month). The rate in March 2026 is 4.8%. The value of the grantor’s retained annuity is calculated based on the IRS hurdle rate.
    • The grantor of a GRAT runs no gift tax risk if he or she undervalues the transferred assets. If an asset for which there is no readily ascertainable market value is transferred to a GRAT and the IRS later challenges the value reported for gift tax purposes, the GRAT annuity automatically increases to produce a near-zero gift.
    • The downside of planning with GRATs is the difficulty of protecting the value of the assets that move to trusts for family members at the end of the annuity term from the GST tax.

    Younger generation planning

    The younger members of wealthy families should consider using their exclusions and exemptions by creating trusts for the benefit of their unborn descendants and other family members. Senior generations can also be included as discretionary beneficiaries if warranted.

    If a young family member lacks funds to use to make gifts, the trustees of non-GST tax-protected trusts held for their benefit (such as a follow-on trust for a GRAT) could consider making distributions to them to enable them to make gifts. The assets in such non-GST tax-exempt trusts would be subject to GST tax if the assets remain in the trust when the younger family member dies, so distributing property from such trust does not forego a preserved tax benefit.

    Income tax considerations

    GRATs and SLATs enjoy an income tax advantage that further enhances their appeal. GRATs and SLATs are both grantor trusts. Dynasty trusts can also be structured to be grantor trusts. When a trust is a grantor trust, its assets are treated as owned by the grantor and the grantor must pick up all items of income, credit, and deduction attributable to the trust on the grantor’s personal income tax return. Because the trust’s grantor pays income tax on all trust income, the trust property will be able to grow free of income tax. Under current law, the payment by the grantor of the income tax on income earned by his or her grantor trust is not considered a taxable gift.

    Because the grantor of a grantor trust is treated as owning the trust’s assets, transactions between the trust and its grantor are ignored for income tax purposes. This permits the grantor to exchange assets owned by the grantor with assets of equal value owned by the trust. Exchanges can be a very valuable technique for income tax basis planning. If, for example, a grantor trust owns an asset worth $10 million with a tax basis of $5 million, the grantor could acquire that asset from the trust in exchange for $10 million. No tax would be imposed on the sale and the built-in income tax gain at the trust level is eliminated. If the grantor retains that asset until death, under the current tax law the asset will receive a new tax basis equal to its value on the date of the grantor’s death.

    The grantor can rent an asset that he or she transferred to a grantor trust, provided that the rent is a fair-market rent. Paying rent enhances the effectiveness of the gift because the rent will shift additional wealth out of the estate. The rent payment to the trust is not taxable income to the trust because the transaction is disregarded for income tax purposes, even if the rent payments are substantial.

    Intrafamily loans

    The IRS publishes interest rate tables each month that establish the lowest rate that, if properly documented, can be safely used by you for loans to family members without producing taxable gifts. The growth rate of your funds that are lent to children, or to trusts for their benefit, will be limited to that interest rate. Those funds, in turn, can be used by the junior family members to be invested in a manner that hopefully will achieve a rate of return in excess of the interest rate charged on the loans.

    Making a loan to a trust for your children may be even more advantageous than making a loan outright if the borrowing trust is a grantor trust for income tax purposes. Ordinarily, the interest payments on a note must be included in the taxable income of the lender, but if the payments are made by a grantor trust, they will be free of income tax, because it is considered a payment from the grantor to himself or herself for income tax purposes.

    In March 2026, the applicable federal rate for mid-term loans (between three- and nine-year terms) is 3.93%, and the applicable federal rate for long term loans (more than nine years) is 4.72%.

    Alternatively, it may be more advantageous for senior family members to put some of their expanded federal gift exclusions and GST tax exemptions to work by making cash gifts to facilitate the prepayment of existing loans to family members and to trusts established for the benefit of family members.

    Sales to grantor trusts

    A sale to a grantor trust for cash or a note can be an extremely effective planning strategy. In the case of a sale of a minority interest in an entity or a fractional interest in real property, valuation discounts can apply to limit the amount of purchase price necessary to avoid a taxable gift. As is the case with gifts, the income and appreciation generated by the sold property after the sale will be protected from future estate taxes. If you don’t already have a grantor trust in existence, consider using your current gift tax exclusion to create one.

    A grantor trust provides you with two independent planning opportunities. First, as discussed above, you will pay the income tax on the income generated by the trust, including tax on capital gains, thereby allowing the trust to grow tax-free while reducing your future estate taxes. In addition, you may engage in transactions with your grantor trust without any income tax consequences.

    If you have previously exhausted your exclusion and exemption amounts through prior gifting to grantor trusts, you may want to leverage the value of your prior gifts through new sales to grantor trusts or, where appropriate, by making cash gifts to facilitate the prepayment of existing installment obligations owed to you by your grantor trusts from prior sales.

    Summary

    The current lifetime gift tax exclusion and GST exemption offers an opportunity to leverage gifting and preserve wealth for multiple generations. Thoughtful planning and careful implementation are essential to a successful estate plan that preserves wealth in the most tax-efficient manner and fulfills the family’s personal objectives.

    Authors

    Anita S. Rosenbloom

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    Jay J. Scharf

    Partner

    Miami, Boca Raton

    Inri Panajoti

    Associate

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • Is your ERC claim protected? Keep an eye on litigation deadlines

    Is your ERC claim protected? Keep an eye on litigation deadlines

    ARTICLE

    Is your ERC claim protected? Keep an eye on litigation deadlines

    Mar 13, 2026

    Read time: 4 min

    In February 2026, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) announced that, as of December 31, 2025, it had closed all non-examined Employee Retention Credit (ERC) claims. This development could compel businesses to pursue litigation to secure their ERC refunds. In its announcement, the IRS also noted that approximately 41,000 claims remain under IRS examination or appeal.

    The IRS’s announcement brings renewed focus to a risk we have been highlighting for some time: Statutes of limitation can quietly extinguish otherwise valid refund claims. As discussed in our article in Bloomberg on how to litigate and resolve ERC claims, administrative delay does not eliminate judicial deadlines. For taxpayers whose claims have been formally disallowed, Internal Revenue Code Section 6532(a) provides only two years to file a refund suit. A protest to the IRS Independent Office of Appeals (IRS Appeals) does not suspend that deadline. Without filing suit or obtaining a written extension (Form 907), the right to a refund can be permanently lost.

    For taxpayers with ERC claims that are pending without action (i.e., those described in the IRS’s announcement), the statute of limitations analysis is more complex. Some courts have dismissed taxpayer suits that were filed more than six and a half years from the time the claim arose.[1] Under the logic of these cases, there may be a six-and-a-half-year limit in effect from the date a refund claim is filed – the six months a taxpayer must wait before filing a refund suit plus six years during which the government is susceptible to suit under a general statute of limitations on civil claims against the government (31 U.S.C. § 3702(b)). For ERC claims submitted in 2020, the end of this possibly applicable six-and-a-half-year period is quickly approaching. To the extent a court will apply this limitation, a taxpayer with an ERC refund claim may be barred from suit even without a formal disallowance by the IRS.

    The message for businesses is consistent with our earlier guidance: Protecting the right to an ERC refund requires a proactive strategy. Taxpayers must identify which limitations periods apply to their claims, manage calendar critical deadlines, and evaluate whether protective litigation is necessary to preserve their potential refunds. Businesses facing challenged, delayed, or disallowed ERC claims should evaluate their statute posture urgently. Our tax controversy & litigation team continues to advise clients on navigating ERC audits, IRS Appeals proceedings, and refund litigation to ensure procedural missteps do not foreclose recovery.

    In depth
    Authors

    Akiva B. Ungar

    Associate

    Chicago

    Samuel F. Hamer

    Associate

    Washington, DC

    Edward L. Froelich

    Counsel

    Washington, DC

    More insights
    Endnotes

    [1] See Wagenet v. United States, No. CV 08-01234, 2009 WL 4895363, at *5 (C.D. Cal. Sept. 14, 2009) (dismissing tax refund action as filed outside the six-year statute). See also Bowman Transp., Inc. v. United States, 220 Ct. Cl. 36, 40–41 (1979) (interpreting 28 U.S.C. § 2501 and explaining that “[d]espite the fact that the carrier has only two years from the date on which the refund claim is expressly disallowed or apparently the regular six-year period of limitations contained in 28 U.S.C. § 2501 when no express disallowance of the refund claim is issued (the six-year period of limitations would start six months after the date on which the refund claim was filed)”); cf. Hartman v. United States, 99 Fed. Cl. 168, 179 n.17 (2011) (citing Bowman with approval for this interpretation as applied to 28 U.S.C. § 2401).


  • Good-faith investigation defeats preindictment delay challenge

    Good-faith investigation defeats preindictment delay challenge

    ARTICLE

    Good-faith investigation defeats preindictment delay challenge

    Mar 12, 2026

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Addressing the constitutional limits of preindictment delay in a trade secret and wire fraud prosecution arising from alleged misuse of proprietary unemployment insurance software, the US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit clarified both the standard of review for due process claims based on delay and the substantive threshold required to dismiss an indictment on that basis. United States of America v. David Gerald Minkkinen, Case No. 23-4443 (4th Cir. Feb. 26, 2026) (Wynn, Richardson, Rushing, JJ.)

    Between 2009 and 2013, David Minkkinen and Sivaraman Sambasivam worked at a business management consulting firm, where they helped develop a proprietary unemployment insurance software platform called uFACTS. In 2013 they both joined Sagitec, where they participated in building a new unemployment claims system for the Maryland and West Virginia Consortium. In 2016, state employees identified references in Sagitec materials that suggested possible use of the prior company’s intellectual property, prompting a federal investigation. Investigators examined whether other former employees transferred design documents or source materials to Sagitec. While some individuals acknowledged retaining prior project materials, they disputed ownership or claimed the materials were only used as templates. The investigation was prolonged and complicated by the unexpected deaths of key witnesses.

    In August 2022, Minkkinen and Sambasivam were indicted on charges including trade secret misappropriation, wire fraud, and false statements. Efforts by the defendants to obtain historical project documents were hindered by routine document destruction policies at state agencies. The government also later filed a superseding indictment focused on alleged misuse of the prior company’s proprietary files. The defendants moved to dismiss for unconstitutional preindictment delay, arguing that the loss of witness testimony and documents prejudiced their defense. The district court agreed in part, finding the missing evidence highly significant and the government’s justification for the lengthy investigation insufficient, and dismissed 10 of 14 counts. The government appealed.

    The Fourth Circuit determined that in reviewing a claim of unconstitutional preindictment delay, it would apply clear-error review of the district court’s factual findings and de novo review to its legal conclusions. The Court further determined that the specific issue at stake here (i.e., whether the prosecution offended “fundamental conceptions of justice” and society’s sense of “fair play and decency”) was a mixed question of law and fact that should be reviewed de novo. The Court reasoned that the second prong of the preindictment delay test requires courts to apply a broad constitutional standard by balancing the government’s justification for delay against prejudice to the defendant, and appellate courts have a special role in defining the limits of constitutional standards through case-by-case adjudication. Accordingly, the Court concluded it would apply de novo review to the district court’s ultimate due process determination regarding the dismissed counts.

    The Fourth Circuit determined that the district court erred in dismissing counts based on unconstitutional preindictment delay. Applying the second prong of the due process analysis, the Court concluded that the government’s delay was attributable to a prolonged good-faith investigation and not to any improper motive, tactical advantage, or reckless disregard for the defendants’ rights. Relying on Supreme Court precedent, the Fourth Circuit emphasized that investigative delay, even if it causes actual prejudice, does not violate due process where prosecutors continue gathering evidence and evaluating whether to bring charges.

    The Fourth Circuit further determined that the record fully accounted for the timing of the indictment, including interviews, document review, coordination with Sagitec’s internal investigation, and ongoing preindictment discussions with defense counsel. It rejected the district court’s view that the length of the investigation was unjustified or outweighed the defendants’ prejudice, explaining that due process does not require prosecutors to indict before completing a reasonable investigation. The Fourth Circuit also found the district court’s reliance on prior precedent misplaced, noting that this case involved a complex multistate criminal investigation rather than administrative delay or negligence.

    Accordingly, the Fourth Circuit found that, even assuming the defendants suffered substantial prejudice, the government’s good-faith investigative delay did not offend fundamental conceptions of justice or fair play and reversed the district court rulings and remanded the case.

    Authors

    Keval Amin

    Associate

    Chicago

    More insights
    Endnotes

  • Family office investing in private funds: The principal’s short-list

    Family office investing in private funds: The principal’s short-list

    ARTICLE

    Family office investing in private funds: The principal’s short-list

    March 11, 2026

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    As the family office principal, you likely do not live in the weeds of fund documents. However, you do need clarity on the handful of issues that most directly affect your wealth, influence, and legacy. You need a clear picture of alignment, liquidity, reputation, and governance, plus confidence that your team will escalate “red” issues to you.

    Gray and orange spiral stairs (credit: Getty Images)

    In depth

    1. Alignment of interests

    Do the sponsors make money only when you do? Watch for fees, expenses, or affiliated services where the sponsor received economic benefits even if returns lag. Ask your team about perceived misalignments.

    2. Liquidity and commitments

    Hedge funds can often sequester assets in side pockets, whereas private equity and credit funds may be able to call capital unpredictably, at best. Ensure your office maps cash draws and likely distributions against your liquidity needs (e.g., philanthropy, lifestyle, new ventures).

    3. Conflicts and reputation

    Many larger sponsors use affiliated servicers, and many sponsors trade positions between funds. Some of the related conflicts are routine, but poor handling can cause regulatory or reputational fallout. Ask your team to summarize any material concerns.

    4. Governance and visibility

    A position on an investor advisory committee (limited partner advisory committee, or LPAC) and robust reporting provide more of a “seat at the table.” Even if you delegate, insist on visibility into material conflicts, valuations, and expenses. If you are represented, ensure that you are adequately protected under the fund documents.

    Exceptional family office executives expect to have their interests aligned with those of the family. Thoughtfully structured participation – such as co-investment rights or performance-linked incentives – can help attract and retain talent and ensure long-term alignment.

    5. Using your leverage

    Personal prestige and capital can unlock concessions from sponsors. Do not intervene on every point, but be ready to call the sponsor directly on the issues you care about most.

    6. Demand a translation

    Require your team and counsel to deliver conclusions in plain English, e.g., distinguishing market standard, aligned versus tolerable but monitor versus unacceptable risk. Ask for bottom-line recommendations; invest, negotiate, or walk away.

    7. Select counsel carefully

    When hiring outside counsel, look for lawyers who have worked on both the sponsor and investor sides. They will know which terms really matter, what is achievable, and how to secure protections without wasting time on the immaterial.

    Authors

    Peter G. Naismith

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Invest with confidence: Private equity funds for family offices

    Invest with confidence: Private equity funds for family offices

    ARTICLE

    Invest with confidence: Private equity funds for family offices

    March 11, 2026

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The portion of US family offices with private equity fund exposure is reportedly very significant and still growing – in early 2025, surveys reported that more than two-thirds of family offices proposed to increase their private equity exposure during the year. Investments in private equity funds are extremely long-term investments, with a 10- to 12-year period being common. As a result, private equity fund investments demand particular attention (investors cannot “vote with their feet”). Some considerations are discussed below.

    Angled shot of steps in a building (credit: Getty Images)

    In depth

    Investment lifecycle: Commitment, capital calls, recycling, harvesting, and extensions

    • Capital commitments/calls. Unlike (usually) an investor in a hedge fund, a private equity fund investor makes a “capital commitment” that is called in over a fixed “commitment period” (or “investment period”) as investment opportunities are identified by the sponsor. Although family offices are often more nimble than other institutional investors, a reasonable period of notice should be expected (10 business days is common). Further, given the potentially drastic consequences of missing a capital call, investors may wish to seek enhanced notice and cure rights before default remedies are exercised by the sponsor.
    • Recycling and reinvestment. Investors should focus upon what, if any, investment proceeds can be recycled and reinvested during the commitment period. And can the sponsor return unused capital without paying the investor the preferred return in respect of the amount that was initially called?
    • Extensions. It is common for the commitment period and the term of the fund to be subject to extension. Investors should note all unilateral extension rights of the sponsor and consider whether consent of an independent body (e.g., a limited partner advisory committee (LPAC)) or a supermajority of investors is required for extensions beyond stated periods. In certain cases, management fee step-downs could be triggered by extensions to the fund’s term.

     


    Key consideration

    Consider whether extension rights are reasonable. Is it possible to tie any extension of the fund term to a reduced management fee, or require that a near-term exit plan for remaining assets be delivered to investors if the fund’s term drags on?
     


     

    Waterfalls and carry: “European” versus “American,” catch-ups, givebacks

    • Waterfalls. A key distinction among private equity funds is whether carried interest, or “carry,” is paid on the basis of a “European” or “whole fund” waterfall, where the sponsor earns carry only after all contributed capital is returned and a preferred return (often 6% to 8%) is paid to the investor, or on the basis of an “American” or “deal-by-deal” waterfall, where carry is determined on a deal-by-deal basis and thus paid earlier. In each case, attention should also be paid to the sponsor’s giveback obligations, with interim giveback testing (i.e., not only upon fund dissolution) particularly desirable in the case of a deal-by-deal waterfall.
    • Catch-ups. In a private equity fund, after the preferred return is paid, a “general partner (GP) catch-up” in respect of that preferred return is common. Modified catch-ups (less than 100%, e.g., 50:50) are seen relatively often and are beneficial to investors.
    • Givebacks. Receipt should be assured by way of guarantees provided by carry recipients (sometimes an escrow regime is included). Unless supported in this way, the investor’s exposure may be to a limited liability entity without assets.

     


    Key consideration

    If the fund is deal-by-deal, check for interim giveback calculations, with appropriate credit support.
     


     

    Sponsor perspective

    Customary waterfall structures ensure significant alignment of interests – carried interest is paid when investors have made money, and giveback obligations operate to back stop any concerns about the risk of overpayment.

     

    Fees and expenses: Offsets, caps, and other key terms

    • Offsets. Private equity fund sponsors often earn income through monitoring, transaction, and similar fee streams, in additional to management fees and carry. Investors should seek to ensure that monitoring, transaction, and other similar fees are offset against and reduce the fund’s management fees – this remains an important economic protection.
    • Organizational expenses. Organizational expenses are often very significant for private equity funds, given the extensive investor comments and requests that they attract during the formation phase. The portion borne by investors will usually be capped, but often at a relatively high level, and the sponsor is often able to use the fund’s assets to meet the excess over the cap, with a corresponding management fee offset to follow. Investors should consider requesting an organizational expense estimate, even if a cap is included.
    • Broken-deal expense allocation. Many private equity funds co-invest alongside other products with the same sponsor, and sponsors typically reserve the ability to allocate opportunities away from the fund to co-investors. Investors should pay attention to the manner in which shared expenses are apportioned; often, investors in a fund will bear a disproportionate share of broken-deal expenses if an expected co-investor does not complete its investment.
    • Other fund expenses. Often, an extensive litany of permitted expenses is disclosed. Although digesting these disclosures can be challenging, investors should consider whether expense categories seem reasonable in light of the given strategy and program.

     

    Sponsor perspective

    Permitted expense categories are benchmarked against industry standards, negotiated with anchor investors, and fully disclosed. Actual expenses are the subject of extensive reporting. Greater granularity in expense-related disclosures does not necessarily reflect a change of practice.

     

    Conflicts management

    The private equity business model can present a number of potential conflicts of interest:

    • Affiliated servicers. If affiliates of the sponsor provide consulting, financing, administration, or other services to the fund, investors should seek to ensure arm’s-length terms, third-party fee benchmarking, and LPAC preapproval for arrangements that are not easily benchmarked.
    • Cross-fund transactions. Generally, some form of independent valuation/fairness opinion and LPAC consent is required before a private equity fund sells its position to another of the sponsor’s products. Investors should consider what process is described in the fund documents and what exceptions apply.
    • Co-investment allocations. As noted earlier, private equity fund sponsors typically reserve to themselves the ability to allocate opportunities away from the fund to co-investors. Investors will want the documents to set forth as objective an allocation policy as practicable (e.g., pro-rata to commitments, subject to speed and strategic fit).

     


    Key consideration

    Understand the scope and extent of the sponsor’s use of affiliated servicers and ensure that the related costs will be appropriately reported to investors.
     


     

    Sponsor perspective

    Affiliated servicers may present inherent conflicts, but such arrangements are market practice, fully disclosed, and often subject to third-party benchmarking and/or LPAC approval. The use of affiliated servicers is often more efficient and cheaper than using third-party firms for the same services.

     

    Governance

    In private equity funds, LPAC rights often include consent rights with respect to material conflicts, valuation policy changes, continuation fund deals, and term extensions, to name a few. But LPAC members serve the interests of the investor that nominates them, rather than the interests of all investors. And a family office that will be represented on an LPAC should look carefully at the express roles and responsibilities of the LPAC, the rights of members to convene meetings, the exculpation and indemnification rights of members (and their appointors), and the right of the LPAC to engage counsel and other experts as and when required (at the fund’s expense).
     


    Key consideration

    If you will not sit on the LPAC, consider seeking observer rights and/or access to LPAC materials.
     


     

    Continuation funds

    “Continuation funds” – vehicles that let a sponsor allow its thesis to play out longer by moving a position from an older fund into a new home, while giving investors the choice to cash out or stay invested – are now mainstream. Faced with continuation elections, investors often take the cash-out option, sometimes purely in an effort to avoid the burden of reviewing an entirely new fund offering, but factors worthy of consideration include:

    • Independent valuation/fairness and LPAC approval. Investors should carefully review the materials provided and resist compressed decision windows.
    • Fee/carry-related conflicts. Investors should consider the inherent conflicts of interest, which will usually be addressed by the sponsor in detail in the election materials.

     


    Key consideration

    New private equity funds are launched by established sponsors on a regular basis and (where applicable) usually strongly resemble their immediate predecessor. If the terms of a predecessor fund are available, family offices should use a “redline” to consider the extent to which the expense practices of the sponsor are changing over time, among other things.
     


     

    In investing in private equity funds, a family office’s priorities and side letter concerns are likely to be more extensive than they are in the context of a hedge fund investment. Side letters may address fee and expense allocations, the use of alternative investment vehicles, co-investment opportunities, limits on recycling or reinvestment of proceeds, distributions in-kind, reporting and LPAC participation, conflicts, and transfer restrictions, to name a few. Further guidance on side letter protections can be found in The family office playbook for investing in private funds.

    Authors

    Peter G. Naismith

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Private credit funds: How family offices can protect the downside

    Private credit funds: How family offices can protect the downside

    ARTICLE

    Private credit funds: How family offices can protect the downside

    March 11, 2026

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    One early 2025 survey reported that about a third of family offices intended to increase their allocations to private credit during 2025 and 2026 – the highest among alternative asset classes. “Private credit” is, however, a label given to a wide range of strategies and structures. It spans direct lending, mezzanine, asset-backed/specialty finance, opportunistic/special situations, distressed, NAV lending, and litigation finance, among others, and each of those strategies can be wrapped in an open-ended, closed-ended, or “hybrid” fund format.

    Given this broad spectrum, experience with hedge funds or private equity funds may lend itself to analysis of only certain of a private credit fund’s terms and features. As a result, for family offices, investments in private credit funds can demand significant legal review.

    Cable-stayed bridge (credit: Getty Images, source: iStockphoto)

    In depth

    Structures: Open-ended, closed-ended, hybrid

    • Open-ended (evergreen): Funds that permit periodic subscriptions and redemptions (e.g., quarterly or semi-annual), and often have net asset value (NAV)-based fees, gates, and lock-ups. These private credit funds should be expected to hold shorter-duration, tradeable, or refinance-able assets.
    • Closed-ended: Funds that have commitment and capital call features, fixed investment and harvesting periods, and distributions upon realizations post-commitment period, with no redemption rights. These private credit funds are most commonly targeting illiquid assets such as originations with bespoke terms and workout potential.
    • Hybrids: Funds that may combine features of open-ended and closed-ended funds, such as commitments and capital calls, combined with investor-specific commitment periods and periodic liquidity windows. These private credit funds are built for extreme flexibility, and the risks for an investor include over-estimating the level of liquidity they offer. Depending on the terms, actually exiting vehicles of this kind can take some time.

     


    Key consideration

    Depending on the nature of the private credit fund, consider whether the team has the right expertise to perform an informed review.
     


     

    Sponsor perspective

    Flexibility is a feature of hybrid private credit funds, not a bug. It allows a sponsor to pivot, as is often necessary in volatile credit markets. Hybrid funds offer the potential for the use of bespoke solutions to match investor liquidity needs with asset liquidity.

     

    Leverage: Subscription lines, asset-level debt, NAV facilities – and cross-collateralization

    Credit funds often carry fund-level or asset-level leverage:

    • Subscription lines: Borrowings secured by investor commitments. Helpful for cash management.
    • Asset-level leverage: Warehouse lines or term financing against loan pools, for example.
    • NAV facilities: Facilities secured by portfolio NAV.

    In all cases, investors should strive to understand the usage and likely covenants and consider whether limitations are appropriate. Further, where the sponsor has multiple products, consider the sponsor’s approach to cross-collateralization. If one product’s assets back another’s borrowings, risk can migrate.
     


    Key consideration

    Cross-collateralization across unrelated sleeves or vehicles can be a concern. Seek details of what steps the sponsor takes to address such risks.
     


     

    Valuation

    Illiquid credit instruments may not have screen prices, leaving investors to rely upon:

    • The existence of a clear valuation policy, with notice to investors required in the event of material policy changes, and independent oversight through a committee or third-party agent for subjectively marked assets.
    • Performance-based compensation on illiquid products tied to realized gains or at least multi-period, high-confidence marks, not transitory model outputs. In some cases, funded givebacks will provide additional support.
    • Write-down/write-up discipline.

     


    Key consideration

    Where a fund will invest in liquid and illiquid credit, consider whether the performance-based compensation bases are appropriately segregated, and whether incentive on illiquid positions should be deferred until realization. Consider requiring quarterly valuation memos for material non-performers.
     


     

    Conflicts: Origination platforms, syndication, and opportunity allocation

    Private credit fund sponsors may originate loans through affiliates, syndicate deals across funds, or sell positions into co-invest pockets. Investors should look for:

    • Clear and objective allocation policies, with documented, periodic oversight.
    • Affiliate fee transparency, particularly origination/monitoring/special servicing fees.
    • Cross-trade rules and processes, especially when affiliates retain junior tranches.

     

    Liquidity tools

    In evergreen credit funds, voluntary redemptions can be gated or subject to “fast-pay, slow-pay” mechanics. Understand how the sponsor has approached:

    • Queue transparency: One’s place in line.
    • In-kind redemption protections: Is there a right to make a cash election?
    • Asset transfers to affiliates/managed structures to meet redemption obligations.
    • Slow-pay features. These provisions allow sponsors to satisfy withdrawal requests by carving off the redeeming investor’s pro-rata slice of the portfolio and holding those positions in a segregated account until their realization. During that period, the investor remains exposed to performance risk, continues to bear fees and performance-based compensation, and may be subject to an ongoing obligation to meet follow-on capital calls in respect of those sequestered positions. While slow pay is a useful liquidity management tool and a protective feature for investors, investors should understand these items and consider seeking limits on the permissible duration of slow-pay treatment, clarity regarding any follow-on funding obligations, and enhanced reporting regarding the timing and path to ultimate distributions.

     


    Key consideration

    Consider pushing for a cap on how long slow pay can last, require clear disclosure of follow-on obligations, and insist on regular updates on the disposition of sequestered assets.
     


     

    In investing in private credit funds, family office priorities can vary dramatically, depending on the nature and features of the applicable product. They may include negotiating limits on slow-pay withdrawals, clarity around the use of unfunded commitments post-withdrawal, restrictions on re-underwriting or recycling provisions, and enhanced reporting on portfolio company credit performance and default management.

    Authors

    Peter G. Naismith

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Family office investments: What’s different about venture capital funds?

    Family office investments: What’s different about venture capital funds?

    ARTICLE

    Family office investments: What’s different about venture capital funds?

    March 11, 2026

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Family offices may from time to time be presented with opportunities to invest in venture capital funds. Although venture capital and private equity funds traditionally share the same broad closed-end fund architecture, they differ in meaningful ways that affect expenses, governance rights and remedies, liquidity assumptions, and side letter priorities. This article explores some areas in which these fund terms diverge.

    Modern apartment building with curved balconies amid a blue sky backdrop (credit: Getty Images)

    In depth

    Fees

    Private equity funds often charge headline management fees of 1.5% to 2.0% per annum during the commitment period, with a step-down thereafter to a fee base that is tied to invested capital (or, less commonly, net asset value). This approach reflects the predictability of private equity deployment and the reduced sourcing intensity that exists once the portfolio is substantially constructed. Under this approach, post-commitment period fee revenues for the sponsor decline as realizations occur. By comparison, venture capital funds will more frequently charge headline management fees at or above 2.0% per annum, and the fee base often remains committed capital for a much longer period – sometimes for the full term. This can be attributed to the fact that early stage portfolios are assumed to require follow-on rounds and more substantial reserves; even after the commitment period, a significant portion of the committed capital may be needed for these future rounds. Because venture capital fee structures are built around this reserve-intensive model, a comparison of headline fee rate may obscure meaningful differences in net investor outcomes between these two fund types.
     


    Key consideration

    Fee bases (committed versus invested capital, for example) can have a larger impact on net returns than headline fee rates. But, from the sponsor’s perspective, the committed capital fee base in venture capital is not a windfall; it is more of a structural necessity. Follow-on rounds in venture capital are less predictable, require rapid decision-making, and often occur long after the commitment period has ended.
     


     

    Transaction fees and offset mechanisms

    Private equity transactions routinely generate monitoring, advisory, director, and financing fees payable by portfolio companies, and these fees are typically the subject of a 100% offset against management fees – a useful investor protection. Venture capital funds operate in an environment in which transaction fees are less common and, if they arise, more often retained by the sponsor without a full offset. Director fees are still typically offset in full, but other categories are not always subject to offset, as venture capital investors focus less on offset mechanics and more on evaluating the overall fee load relative to the strategy and the sponsor’s involvement.
     

    Investment period and deployment cadence

    Private equity fund commitment periods often run for four years or more, and deployment follows a structured and relatively predictable cadence tied to negotiated transactions. Venture capital deployment tends to be more episodic and dependent on founder pipelines, competitive rounds, and market timing. Venture capital fund commitment periods are sometimes shorter, and the deployment pattern is less regular. Further, as discussed earlier, venture capital earmarks for follow-on rounds affect liquidity expectations and pacing analyses for investors, including family offices.
     

    Fund term and extension dynamics

    Private equity funds often target a 10-year term with one or two extension periods. Realizations generally occur in a reasonably compact window once the portfolio enters the harvest phase. Venture capital funds have a similar nominal term length but are somewhat more likely to seek extensions. Early stage companies may need to remain private for longer periods than originally envisaged, and tail positions may continue to hold meaningful upside potential. Venture capital funds therefore exhibit longer liquidity profiles and less predictability in return timing.
     


    Key consideration

    Early stage venture capital assets often remain private longer than expected, requiring extensions to the stated fund term.
     


     

    Waterfall mechanics

    Private equity fund waterfalls will often include a preferred return (8% remains common), followed by a catch-up and a carry (often the classic 20%). Whole-fund European waterfalls remain common among institutional sponsors, reinforcing alignment by ensuring that carry is earned only after the portfolio as a whole meets base-case return expectations. Venture capital funds, by comparison, more frequently omit a preferred return altogether and more often rely on deal-by-deal carry structures. Investors may accept these terms because in early stage portfolios, deployment is irregular and the distribution of outcomes is highly skewed, so that a significant preferred return rate could prevent a sponsor from ever earning carry, with the risk of that outcome operating to undermine team incentives, discourage risk-appropriate decision-making, and ultimately disadvantage investors.
     

    Progressive (tiered) carried interest

    Private equity fund carry structures tend to be uniform – commonly 20% after the preferred return – with tiered or progressive rates rarely seen outside bespoke mandates. By comparison, we see tiered carry more often in venture capital, especially among established franchises, where outlier performance, rather than fee load, is the primary economic driver for both sponsor and investor. Emerging sponsors and micro-venture capital funds may also use tiered carry as an economic lever in an effort to compete on leaner fee structures or demonstrate alignment.
     

    Sponsor commitments

    Private equity sponsor commitments can be significant (1% to 5% is not uncommon), serving as an excellent alignment mechanism. Venture capital sponsor commitments are often smaller. As a result, alignment in venture capital may rely less on the sponsor’s personal capital and more on the long-term economic incentives inherent in the model, particularly the need to demonstrate performance in order to raise subsequent funds, maintain access to high-quality founder networks, and sustain a durable franchise.
     

    Key-person, no-fault, and other investor protections

    Private equity funds routinely include key-person triggers, no-fault removal rights, no-fault termination mechanics, and successor fund limitations. Venture capital fund governance protections can be less robust, particularly in early stage funds, where sponsors may have smaller teams, dynamic roles, and prize rapid execution in competitive rounds. These differences sometimes disappear when institutional investors dominate the investor base of the given fund.
     


    Key consideration

    Family offices should not assume that private equity governance terms – key-person triggers, no-fault provisions – necessarily apply equally to venture capital. Sponsors may point out that early stage companies move quickly and founder relationships are delicate; rigid governance mechanics can impair their speed and flexibility.
     


     

    Co-investment rights

    Co-investments are a core feature of private equity fund sponsor strategies. For many sponsors, transaction sizes, control rights, and structured processes allow for repeatable and scalable co-investment programs, often governed by formal allocation policies. In the venture capital space, co-investments may be more opportunistic. They may arise through follow-on rounds or special allocations into breakout companies. Co-investment in venture capital may also be significantly more capacity constrained. Family offices should not assume that the formalized co-investment programs they may see in private equity can be translated into predictable venture capital allocations.
     

    Successor fund limitations

    Private equity funds commonly include explicit restrictions on raising successor funds that overlap materially with the current vehicle, preserving alignment during the commitment period. Venture capital funds will sometimes include less onerous restrictions, perhaps where sponsors envisage the pursuit of seed, early-stage, and growth strategies that are not directly overlapping. As venture capital platforms mature, however, investors will increasingly push for clearer boundaries to ensure appropriate opportunity allocation and avoid strategy drift or dilution of attention.
     

    Continuation funds

    Continuation funds are, as discussed earlier, now a widely used tool in private equity, allowing sponsors to retain assets, offer liquidity to existing investors, and reset economics around longer hold periods. In venture capital, continuation funds are somewhat less common and are more likely to involve exceptional assets that need to remain private longer than expected, rather than the multi-asset secondary processes that are seen in private equity. Because these continuation vehicles often have single assets, pricing, conflicts analysis, and LP roll-over mechanics tend to be particularly important.

    Private equity and venture capital funds share a common legal chassis, but can diverge materially when it comes to factors such as fee structures, deployment patterns, alignment mechanisms, and liquidity timelines. For family offices, these distinctions matter at the underwriting, negotiation, and monitoring stages. Understanding them should allow family offices to calibrate expectations appropriately, tailor side letter requests, and integrate both fund types into a coherent long-term portfolio strategy.

    Authors

    Peter G. Naismith

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • No guesswork: Building a playbook for family office private fund investing

    No guesswork: Building a playbook for family office private fund investing

    ARTICLE

    No guesswork: Building a playbook for family office private fund investing

    March 11, 2026

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    For sophisticated investors, including family office principals and executives, investing in private funds requires more than a red flag review of the governing agreement and a completed subscription agreement. Across hedge, private equity, venture capital, and private credit funds, certain of the points of interest for legal reviews are consistent, e.g., conflicts of interest, liquidity, transparency, fees, and governance. But other items are specific to the fund category. Hedge funds may raise unique concerns in their use of side pocket mechanics or their approach to incentive crystallization; private equity and venture capital funds often present issues tied to certainty of capital obligations and allocation of investment opportunities; while private credit funds may challenge investors to analyze complex slow-pay withdrawal terms.

    In practice, meaningful investor protections are often secured through side letters, which adapt the fund’s otherwise standardized terms to the specific needs of the investor. Thus, a critical step for family office principals and executives is to translate their broader concerns into contractual protections, and this requires efficient legal reviews that are focused on clear up-front objectives. Even the leanest internal teams can run institutional-grade reviews if they look to standardize their inputs and asks, allocate their time and resources appropriately, and monitor closely what they arrive at in the key documentation.

    Multi colored facade of modern architecture in a global city (credit: Getty Images)
     


    Key consideration

    Increasingly, family offices access alternative assets through multifamily office platforms, private bank–affiliated wealth managers, and conduit or feeder sponsors. While such arrangements inevitably introduce another layer between investor and fund (therefore, no direct privity with the fund or its manager), they can deliver meaningful advantages, particularly through administrative scale and collective negotiation leverage, streamlined oversight, and easier access to top-tier managers. Even so, a family office should be sure to understand how investor-specific rights – such as MFN elections, liquidity preferences and reporting entitlements – flow through to the underlying investor, as the platform may hold the fund interest notwithstanding that the underlying investor ultimately bears the economic exposure. In addition, a family office should understand the fees and expenses being charged at the conduit and underlying fund level.
     


    In depth

    Standardize inputs: The “investment brief” counsel needs

    Before outside counsel opens the partnership agreement, investors should consider providing a summary:

    • Strategy and other basics: Liquid/illiquid; expected duration; how the investment will be held; what history the investor has with the sponsor.
    • Key objectives: On fees; liquidity; valuation; leverage; conflicts; governance.
    • The “never-agains”: What experiences are to be avoided at all costs, e.g., unfunded givebacks; cross-collateralization downsides.
    • Side letter precedent: The house template, with any deal-specific annotations.

     


    Key consideration

    Consider including in the brief a list of must-haves/non-starters, negotiation targets, and items that will be accepted/monitored. Should counsel’s issues list focus only on the first two categories?
     


     

    Allocate resources strategically

    Distinguish between core items (e.g., economics, liquidity, governance, conflicts), operational items (e.g., reporting cadence and formats, notice rights, audit timetables), and bespoke items (e.g., co-invest priority, observer seats, special information rights). Where appropriate, let the sponsor and counsel know of precedent wins (e.g., “we have managed to get these terms in three very similar funds”). Sponsors respond better to a well-reasoned ask than what might be perceived to be a one-off experiment.
     

    Sponsor perspective

    While family offices can seek side letter protections, in high-demand funds, particularly those launched by top-quartile sponsors, or where an ask demands a material departure from precedent, investors may have insufficient leverage. In an extreme case, an investor’s choice to push for too much in a negotiation may result in allocation loss.

     

    Write side letters like you plan to implement them

    A side letter is a contract that is meant to be monitored and implemented. If the investor cannot track whether the sponsor is performing its obligations, then it is of little use. Therefore, use clear triggers (e.g., “within 30 days of quarter-end, deliver X”).
     

    Manage costs and calendars

    • Consider whether and how your practices and legal-review needs should differ for vanilla strategies and offerings, and/or reviews where predecessor documents and “redlines” are readily available.
    • Commence legal review once near-final documents are available; do not wait for final operational due diligence (ODD) and/or investment committee (IC) approval.
    • Most-favored nations windows need to be monitored closely. Strive for consistency in approach to MFN elections.

     

    Track your experiences

    Track, portfolio-wide, your accumulated knowledge and precedents:

    • Where you won particular protections.
    • Provisions and processes that worked well, and with which sponsors.
    • Improvements that can be imported into your templates.
      Future asks become: “We have had this term with three sponsors this year and would like to start with that approach.”

     


    Key consideration

    Build a short playbook that includes standardized side letter asks, with priorities, rationales, and acceptable compromises identified, and keep records of the forms accepted by particular sponsors.
     


     

    Ensure a disciplined process

    Family office investments often depend on the sophistication and professionalism of the in-house team. These executives – often seasoned investors or legal professionals – bring deep market experience and alignment with the family’s long-term objectives. The role of the process is not to second-guess that judgment, but to support it; this may involve ensuring that any material deviation in process or key terms from the initial investment mandate or expectations is summarized to the investment committee or family principal. This practice strengthens transparency, maintains institutional consistency, and reinforces confidence among all stakeholders that decisions are made within a disciplined and well-documented framework.
     


    Key consideration

    An effective way to attract and retain senior investment professionals within a family office is to align compensation with performance through thoughtfully structured participation, such as co-investment rights, performance-based bonuses, or carried-interest-style incentives. Addressing these arrangements transparently reinforces trust, clarifies expectations, and helps the family compete for institutional-caliber talent without undermining governance discipline.
     


     

    Select counsel with experience on both sides of the table

    When selecting external legal counsel, family offices should prioritize firms and advisors that possess deep experience on both sides of the table – representing sponsors as well as investors. Counsel who have structured funds and advised sponsors will often anticipate sponsor pushback, understand what is truly “market,” and know where flexibility may exist. Conversely, their work for institutional investors gives them credibility in negotiating protections and insight into how peer family offices approach similar issues. This dual perspective allows counsel to cut through boilerplate, focus on the terms that materially affect alignment, liquidity, and governance, and deploy negotiation strategies that resonate with sponsors. In short, counsel with balanced sponsor-investor experience can deliver more efficient reviews, more pragmatic outcomes, and better long-term protection of family capital.

    Authors

    Peter G. Naismith

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights