Content Type: Article

  • Minority Holders’ Challenge to Wesco’s Multi-Step Uptiering Transaction Largely Survives Summary Judgment

    Minority Holders’ Challenge to Wesco’s Multi-Step Uptiering Transaction Largely Survives Summary Judgment

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Minority Holders’ Challenge to Wesco’s Multi-Step Uptiering Transaction Largely Survives Summary Judgment

    January 29, 2024

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Executive Summary

    In two opinions issued earlier this month, Judge Marvin Isgur of the Bankruptcy Court of the South District of Texas denied motions for summary judgment. The movants sought to ratify and validate Wesco’s uptiering transaction that resulted in the payment, subordination and lien stripping of Wesco’s existing pre-exchange notes. The Court will focus at trial on whether or not the multi-step transaction should be treated as one integrated transaction and how to interpret certain ambiguous provisions of Wesco’s note indentures. See In re Wesco Aircraft Holdings, Inc., et al. v. SSD Investments Ltd., No. 23-90611, 2024 WL 156211 (Bankr. S.D. Tex. Jan. 14, 2024).

    Background

    Wesco Aircraft (d/b/a Incora), an aerospace hardware and service company, issued approximately $2 billion in notes under three Indentures – the 2024 Secured Indenture, the 2026 Secured Indenture and the 2027 Unsecured Indenture. The notes financed its 2019 leveraged buyout. By late 2021, the company needed more liquidity due to business setbacks related to COVID.

    To address this need, certain of Wesco’s existing noteholders offered new financing through an uptiering transaction. However, the participating noteholders did not have the two-thirds supermajority necessary to amend the 2026 Secured Indenture and authorize the uptiering. The Indentures did, however, permit the issuance of new notes by a simple majority vote. Therefore, Wesco and the participating noteholders implemented the uptiering transaction by:

    1. Amending the Indentures by majority vote to allow for the issuance of additional notes under the 2026 Indenture (the “3rd Supplemental Indentures”);
    2. Wesco’s issuance of the additional notes to the participating noteholders under a Note Purchase Agreement;
    3. Amending the Indentures again (the “4th Supplemental Indentures”), this time with two-thirds supermajority vote due to the participating noteholders’ purchase of the additional notes, to authorize the exchange of the participating noteholders’ existing notes for new notes with higher-priority liens and strip liens from the remaining 2024 Notes and 2026 Notes held by non-participating noteholders; and
    4. Consummating the exchange by the Exchange Agreement.

    Non-participating (formerly secured) noteholders under the 2024 and 2026 Secured Indentures and Langur Maize, a non-participating noteholder under the 2027 Unsecured Indenture, filed lawsuits in New York state court against Wesco, the participating noteholders and Wilmington Savings Fund Society, FSB (“WSFS”), as the trustee under the Indentures, challenging the uptiering transaction on numerous grounds, including breach of contract, tortious interference with contract and fraudulent conveyance.

    In June 2023, Wesco filed for bankruptcy in the Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of Texas. Wesco then filed an adversary proceeding against the non-participating noteholders seeking a declaratory judgment that, among other things, the uptiering transaction was valid. The non-participating noteholders filed a counter-complaint reasserting many of the claims asserted in the New York state court actions. All parties moved for summary judgment.

    Summary Judgment Decision

    On Jan. 14, 2024, Judge Isgur issued his decision on the summary judgment motions. He then supplemented this opinion on Jan. 23, 2024.

    Courts grant summary judgment only if the moving party shows that there is no genuine dispute of material fact and that the moving party is entitled to judgment as a matter of law. Otherwise, the Court should preserve those issues for a trial on the merits.

    Judge Isgur denied summary judgment on most of the causes of action alleged by the minority noteholders against Wesco and the participating noteholders, clearing the way for a trial on whether the uptiering transaction was valid. The Court granted summary judgment and dismissed the causes of action alleging (i) breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing as being duplicative of the breach of contract claims, (ii) conversion, because there was no property that could have been converted, (iii) breach of contract against WSFS, as trustee, because it was contractually protected from liability under the Indentures and (iv) unjust enrichment claims, because the Indentures are valid contracts.

    The Court cited two principal grounds to support denial of summary judgment on the causes of action that will proceed to trial. First, the Court denied summary judgment of the breach of contract claims and the tortious interference of contract claims (a component of which is a finding of breach of contract) because disputed facts exist regarding whether the agreements implementing the uptiering transaction should be treated as a single, integrated transaction and, if so, whether that would result in one or more breaches of the Indentures. The integrated transaction doctrine provides that when different components, or steps, of a transaction are sufficiently interrelated, they should all be considered within the same transaction, rather than distinct from one another. The doctrine permits a court to elevate substance over formal labels of the agreements based on the intent of the parties and the net effect of the transaction as a whole.

    Specifically, the Court held that whether the uptiering transaction improperly modified the minority noteholders’ collateral in a manner adverse to them depends on whether it could be considered an integrated transaction, as opposed to multiple transactions. Similarly, the Court held that whether the additional notes authorized by the 3rd Supplemental Indenture constituted a breach of contract:

    depends on whether the 2022 Transaction should be considered a single transaction. If the 2022 Transaction was one transaction, Wesco appears to have violated the Indentures when Wesco amended the Secured Indentures without a two-thirds vote of the outstanding notes. If each transaction should be viewed separately, then there was no apparent violation.

    The Court’s language, emphasized above, does not provide certainty that it would find that Wesco breached the Indentures, even if the integrated transaction doctrine does apply. However, the Court certainly leaves the door open for this outcome. The Court held that resolution of the integrated transaction issue “will be based on the parties’ intentions” regarding the uptiering transactions.

    Second, the Court denied summary judgment on the breach of contract claims, including the question of whether the uptiering transaction breached the pro rata redemption provisions of the Indentures, on the ground that the Indentures are ambiguous. Thus, the Court will need extrinsic evidence at trial to determine the meaning of certain provisions of the Indentures. Most notably, Wesco and the majority noteholders argue that the transaction was not a redemption but, instead, an exchange pursuant to “an open market or privately negotiated transaction”, which is not required to be pro rata among noteholders. The court ruled that there is a “genuine dispute” regarding whether the uptiering transaction constituted a redemption or an exchange.

    Takeaways

    • Courts generally have not “rubber-stamped” uptiering and similar transactions. Disputes largely turn on the facts of a given case – and thus warrant a full trial typically.
    • Courts continue to focus on whether each transaction complies with the terms of the governing agreement. What may be permissible under one agreement may be prohibited by another.
    • Most courts presiding over uptiering lawsuits have rejected claims for breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing and have focused more on whether the transaction complied with the indenture or credit agreement. Similarly, arguments that uptiering transactions violate open market purchase provisions have largely been unsuccessful.
    • As these trends emerge, minority noteholders are being more creative in their arguments to challenge uptiering transactions. For instance, here, the minority noteholders have argued that the exchange was actually a redemption, which can only be done pro rata under the Wesco Indentures – rather than challenging whether the exchange complied with the “privately negotiated transaction” provision.
    • While precedent can be instructive, any institution seeking to protect itself from being left behind in an uptiering transaction should carefully read the governing debt documents and understand the potential for a borrower to implement a liability management transaction.

    Authored by Douglas S. Mintz, Peter J. Amend and Abbey Walsh.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. © 2024 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP. All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Estrada Is Not a Death Knell to PAGA Defenses

    Estrada Is Not a Death Knell to PAGA Defenses

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Estrada Is Not a Death Knell to PAGA Defenses

    January 26, 2024

    Read time: 10 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On January 18, 2024, in a highly anticipated and unanimous decision, the Supreme Court of California barred striking a claim under the Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA) on trial manageability grounds alone, instead authorizing due process defenses to PAGA claims (Estrada v. Royalty Carpet Mills, Inc.). The decision also commented approvingly on representative testimonies, surveys and statistical analyses. As a result of the decision, employers now face a new challenge of marshalling such evidence to their defenses and challenging the misuse of such evidence on due process grounds in future PAGA litigation.

    In depth

    Quick Refresher on PAGA

    Enacted in 2004, PAGA authorizes allegedly aggrieved employees to sue their employers for additional civil penalties for various alleged Labor Code violations on behalf of themselves, other employees and the state of California. Allegedly aggrieved employees act as “private attorneys general” seeking remedies against their employer for alleged violations against them and other employees. Unique to PAGA, typical class action requirements such as superiority and the predominance of common issues do not apply. Under PAGA, an allegedly aggrieved employee only needs to demonstrate that a single violation of a particular Labor Code statute was committed against them during the PAGA period to prosecute the case as a representative action and represent other employees as to any and all allegedly violated Labor Code statutes. In other words, a plaintiff need only be aggrieved as to a particular violation (e.g., missed meal periods) to assert that they may represent all other employees as to all other alleged violations (such as wage statement noncompliance, missed rest periods, overtime or failure to pay paid sick leave using the regular rate calculation). This concept has led to trial manageability and due process issues in these cases.

    California Courts of Appeal Split

    Prior to the California Supreme Court’s recent ruling, the California Courts of Appeal were split on whether trial courts possess the inherent authority to strike or dismiss a PAGA claim with prejudice by employing manageability requirements. (See Estrada v. Royalty Carpet Mills, Inc. (2022) 76 Cal.App.5th 685, 697 (concluding that trial courts lack such inherent authority.)) (See also Wesson v. Staples the Office Superstore, LLC (2021) 68 Cal.App.5th 746, 766–767 (concluding that trial courts possess such inherent authority.))

    Estrada Lower Court Decision

    Royal Carpet Mills, a California carpet manufacturer, employed Jorge Luis Estrada at one of its two Orange County locations. Estrada filed a complaint against Royalty, alleging various class action claims, including a failure to provide first and second meal periods, and a PAGA claim seeking penalties for various alleged Labor Code violations. Additional plaintiffs later joined as named plaintiffs, and the claims largely remained the same in each iteration of the complaint.

    After the meal period class was certified, the trial court held a bench trial where the plaintiffs presented live testimony from a dozen named plaintiffs, deposition testimony from different managers and officers of Royalty, live testimony from two of Royalty’s human resources employees and live testimony from an expert witness. In its defense, Royalty presented testimony from two former employees and a single expert witness.

    Following the presentation of evidence, the trial court decertified the class on the basis that too many individualized issues predominated, citing inconsistent testimonies from the plaintiffs and varying reasons why meal periods were late. The trial court also dismissed the PAGA action as unmanageable for trial. The Court of Appeal overturned, leading Royal to petition the California Supreme Court to resolve the conflict among the Courts of Appeal over a trial court’s inherent authority to manage PAGA claims.

    Trial Manageability

    Defendants have often successfully argued that the California Supreme Court’s decade-old Duran decision applies to representative actions insofar as the representative action must be manageable for trial. In Duran v. U.S. Bank National Assn., the California Supreme Court reversed a $15 million judgment based on a flawed statistical sample and acknowledged the importance of due process and managing individual issues fairly and efficiently in a class action.

    The Decision

    In the opinion and at oral argument, the California Supreme Court grappled with the source of the trial court’s authority to strike claims, concluding that the inherent authority of trial courts to dismiss claims is limited to circumstances not present in Estrada. The decision is not too surprising considering the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit recently came to the same conclusion. (See Hamilton v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. (9th Cir. 2022) 39 F.4th 575, 590 (“The [manageability] requirement cannot be imposed in PAGA actions under the guise of a court’s inherent powers.”)) Both courts focused on whether trial courts possess the broad inherent authority to dismiss claims.

    In its January 18 opinion, the California Supreme Court highlighted structural differences between class and PAGA actions to support its view that imposing class-action-based manageability requirements on PAGA actions is inappropriate, emphasizing that concepts such as superiority and predominance do not apply to PAGA claims. The California Supreme Court went so far as to suggest that manageability is derived from class action requirements:

    [M]anageability in the class action context is a factor in demonstrating that class-wide issues predominate and that a class action is superior to individual actions. Given that a PAGA plaintiff need not demonstrate that common issues predominate or that a representative or non-individual PAGA claim is superior to other forms of adjudication, the requirement that a plaintiff demonstrate the manageability of a class claim does not establish a similar manageability requirement for any related PAGA action.

    Op. at 23.

    The Estrada court was quick to highlight that PAGA actions are not class actions and the California legislature declined to add class action requirements to the statute.

    While the California Supreme Court found that PAGA claims cannot be stricken, it is important to note that “striking” PAGA claims is only one defense of many, including showing that the individual employee is not aggrieved (on summary judgment, which if successful precludes the PAGA representative action), due process issues, dispositive evidence related to the allegedly aggrieved employees and, of course, a host of legal arguments related to the various Labor Code claims. Estrada suggests that the use of representative testimonies, surveys and statistical analyses is allowable to streamline evidence presented at trial, and that statistical analysis can be used to “estimate the number of aggrieved employees, even if the evidence cannot demonstrate the extent of any particular injury.” (Op. at 42.) This battle of the experts and testimonies typically becomes a question of whether the sampling is statistically sound and can be used to demonstrate that employees were aggrieved and to estimate damages, or – conversely – whether the employer’s statistics and analysis show otherwise. The answer is case specific and depends on the claims, data and evidence. (For example, a standalone wage statement violation may lend itself to a sound statistical sample, but a missed meal periods claim may not.)

    The California Supreme Court expressly made the important distinction that striking claims may be an option to preserve a defendant’s due process rights but declined to comment on the hypothetical situation where that may be necessary.

    Other Tools and Considerations to Limit Needless, Expensive PAGA Cases

    While many in the plaintiff’s bar may argue that Estrada is a death knell to employers defending against PAGA claims, such is not the case. Many tools remain at the disposal of employers (no two being the same) that warrant individual consideration by each employer facing the threat of PAGA claims:

    • Proactive Compliance Measures. Employers should review and ensure compliant wage and hour policies and practices. Estrada demonstrates the importance of having Labor-Code-compliant timekeeping and meal and rest break policies and practices. Employers should ensure that employees are accurately reporting their time worked, completing attestations affirming their time and meal break records, and training their managers and employees regularly on wage and hour policies.
    • Review Existing Arbitration Agreements or Consider Whether Implementing One Makes Sense. While employers are still reeling from the California Supreme Court’s rejection of the Viking River case in Adolph v. Uber Technologies Inc. (holding that an employee can pursue their individual claim under PAGA in arbitration without losing standing to serve as the plaintiff of the representative PAGA case as it moves forward in court), reviewing or implementing arbitration agreements with mandatory class action waivers should also be top of mind. These can be used to successfully compel plaintiffs’ individual claims to arbitration, avoid class actions and limit representative cases to PAGA only until the Supreme Court of the United States decides to weigh in.
    • Plaintiff Must Still Meet Their Burden. For employers already facing PAGA claims, Estrada leaves undisturbed the requirement that a plaintiff prove that they are an aggrieved employee – meaning that the plaintiff must be able to show a Labor Code violation against them. A plaintiff also has the burden to show that all aggrieved employees suffered violations. Where employers are dedicated to compliance and documentation, this becomes a much more difficult burden for an allegedly aggrieved employee. The plaintiff also has the burden to produce a “trial plan” – explaining how they will seek to adjudicate their claims at trial. A PAGA plaintiff must set forth some type of trial plan demonstrating how the defendant’s due process rights won’t be infringed if they go to trial on behalf of the entire PAGA class.
    • Narrowing PAGA Claims in Litigation. Estrada affirmed that where a PAGA case is unwieldy, a court may still limit the scope of the PAGA claims and the evidence presented at trial, including witness testimony, and may limit penalties when a plaintiff who has alleged widespread violations is unable to prove PAGA claims in an efficient manner. The Estrada plaintiff limited his claim to two Royalty locations with largely similar policies and practices. PAGA defendants with varying work locations and practices should highlight the challenges presented by a large and complex PAGA action and the potential for dozens, hundreds or thousands of mini trials involving diverse questions, depending on the breadth of the plaintiff’s claims. This can be done using tools such as a demurrer, summary judgment/adjudication and judgment notwithstanding the verdict.
    • Protecting Due Process. A PAGA action may cover a vast number of employees, each of whom may have a markedly different experience relevant to the alleged violations. Under those circumstances, determining whether the employer committed Labor Code violations with respect to each employee may raise practical difficulties and lead to due process violations. While the California Supreme Court declined to opine in its Estrada decision on the circumstances in which due process violations may exist, it left open the possibility that PAGA claims could be stricken where a defendant’s due process claims were infringed.
    • Repealing PAGA. In November 2024, California voters will have an opportunity to vote on the future of PAGA directly by choosing whether to repeal it and replace it with the California Fair Pay and Employer Accountability Act of 2024 (CFPEAA). The purpose of the CFPEAA is to streamline the current enforcement system and help employees collect any amounts they are owed quickly without the need for a private lawyer. Most importantly, a private right of action and attorneys’ fees would cease to exist under the proposed CFPEAA.
    Authors

    Pankit J. Doshi

    Partner

    San Francisco, Silicon Valley

    Yesenia M. Gallegos

    Partner

    Los Angeles

    Maria C. Rodriguez

    Partner

    Los Angeles

    More insights

  • CMS Interoperability and Prior Authorization Rule Significantly Impacts Payers’ Approval and Denial Practices

    CMS Interoperability and Prior Authorization Rule Significantly Impacts Payers’ Approval and Denial Practices

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    CMS Interoperability and Prior Authorization Rule Significantly Impacts Payers’ Approval and Denial Practices

    January 25, 2024

    Read time: 15 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On January 17, 2024, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) issued the CMS Interoperability and Prior Authorization final rule (Final Rule) (fact sheet, CMS’ interoperability website), which aims to improve prior authorization processes and enhance patient, provider and payer access to interoperable patient data.

    The Final Rule builds on the technological foundation implemented in CMS’ May 2020 CMS Interoperability and Patient Access rule and broadly applies to Medicare Advantage (MA) organizations, state Medicaid and the Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP) fee-for-service (FFS) programs, Medicaid managed care plans, CHIP managed care entities, and Qualified Health Plan (QHP) issuers on the federally facilitated exchanges (FFEs) (collectively referred to as Payers).[1]

    The Final Rule requires Payers to, among other things, implement certain application programming interfaces (APIs) to improve electronic data exchanges, adds a new measure to the Merit-based Incentive Payment System (MIPS) to encourage the adoption of electronic processes, and streamlines prior authorization to reduce the burden on providers and facilitate patients’ timely access to care. This On the Subject focuses on key changes to Payers’ prior authorization practices.

    In depth

    Implementation and Maintenance of Prior Authorization API

    Beginning in 2027, Payers must implement Prior Authorization API to further “support and streamline” prior authorization decisions. The API must (i) be populated with the Payer’s list of covered items and services that require prior authorization, (ii) identify the documentation required to obtain approval of the item/service, (iii) support a Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA)-compliant request and response, and (iv) communicate whether the Payer approves, denies or requires more information regarding the request. With respect to an approval, a Payer must communicate the date or circumstance under which an authorization ends. As for a denial, a Payer must communicate the specific reason for the denial (as discussed further below).

    The implementation of a Prior Authorization API may require Payers to make substantial investments. CMS delayed the proposed implementation date of this requirement by one year to allow Payers additional time to develop, test and maintain their platforms, as well as to conduct outreach and education to providers. Providers are not required to use the Prior Authorization API; however, the Final Rule includes incentives to encourage certain providers to take up the platforms (e.g., by finalizing new electronic prior authorization measures for MIPS-eligible clinicians).

    Providing Reasons for Denials

    When Payers deny prior authorization requests today, the information they provide often varies from one Payer to the next. Beginning in 2026, the Final Rule will require Payers to provide a specific reason for denying a prior authorization request, regardless of the method used to send the request (calls, email, standard transactions, etc.). A “specific reason” for denial may include referencing the plan provision on which the denial is based, citing to coverage criteria, providing a narrative explanation, or noting that the documentation submitted did not support the plan of care. In comments to the Final Rule, CMS indicates that a “specific reason” for the denial means a Payer must provide sufficient information in the denial response so that a provider understands what action they must take to obtain coverage, which may include an appeal, submission of additional information or identifying alternative treatment options.

    Depending on the line of business, Payers may already be subject to certain denial notification standards (e.g., before an MA plan can issue a denial based on medical necessity, the decision must be reviewed by a healthcare professional with relevant expertise). Those standards remain intact and are not changed by the Final Rule.

    Prior Authorization Decision and Notification Timeframes

    The Final Rule meaningfully shortens Payers’ decision and notification timeframes for standard prior authorization requests (i.e., a non-expedited, non-urgent request), while establishing decision timeframes for expedited prior authorization requests (i.e., an urgent request) for Medicaid FFS and CHIP FFS, which are not currently specified in federal regulations. Generally, Payers must now respond as expeditiously as a patient’s health condition requires but no later than 72 hours after receiving an expedited request (unless a shorter timeframe is required by applicable state law)[2] and no later than seven calendar days after receiving a standard request. In some instances, the timeframe for responding to a standard request may be extended to up to 14 calendar days. The reduced timeframes do not apply to QHP issuers on the FFEs since those issuers are subject to unique claims and appeals, external review and pre-service claims processes.

    The new standards will apply beginning in 2026.

    Depending on the line of business, the timeframes for standard prior authorization requests are noticeably shorter than current standards. For example, for MA plans, existing regulations require organizations to notify a beneficiary of its determination for a standard prior authorization request within 14 calendar days after the organization receives the request. Under the Final Rule, this timeframe would be cut in half for standard requests.

    Current vs. Finalized Prior Authorization Timeframes

    Line of Business Current Standard Finalized Standard
    Expedited Standard Expedited Standard
    Medicare Advantage and Applicable Integrated Plans As expeditiously as the enrollee’s health condition requires, but no later than 72 hours after receiving the request As expeditiously as the enrollee’s health condition requires, but no later than 14 calendar days after receiving the request As expeditiously as the enrollee’s health condition requires, but no later than 72 hours after receiving the request As expeditiously as the enrollee’s health condition requires, but no later than 7 calendar days after receiving the request
    Medicaid Managed Care As expeditiously as the beneficiary’s health condition requires, but no later than 72 hours after receiving the request As expeditiously as the beneficiary’s health condition requires and within state-established time frames that may not exceed 14 calendar days following receipt of the request As expeditiously as the enrollee’s health condition requires and no later than 72 hours after receipt of the request As expeditiously as the enrollee’s health condition requires and within State established timeframes that may not exceed 7 calendar days after receiving the request
    CHIP Managed Care As expeditiously as the beneficiary’s health condition requires, but no later than 72 hours after receiving the request As expeditiously as the beneficiary’s condition requires and within state-established time frames that may not exceed 14 calendar days following receipt of the request As expeditiously as the enrollee’s health condition requires, but no later than 72 hours after receipt of the request, unless a shorter minimum time frame is established under state law As expeditiously as the enrollee’s condition requires but no later than 7 calendar days after receiving the request, unless a shorter minimum time frame is established under state law
    Medicaid FFS Not specified in federal regulation Not specified in federal regulation As expeditiously as a beneficiary’s health condition requires, but in no case later than 72 hours after receiving the request, unless a shorter minimum time frame is established under state law As expeditiously as a beneficiary’s health condition requires, but in no case later than 7 calendar days after receiving the request, unless a shorter minimum time frame is established under state law
    CHIP FFS Not specified in federal regulation 14 calendar days following receipt of the request for items and services In accordance with the medical needs of the patient, but no later than 72 hours after receiving the request for an expedited determination In accordance with the medical needs of the patient, but no later than 7 calendar days after receiving the request
    QHP Issuers on the FFEs As soon as possible, taking into account the medical exigencies, but not later than 72 hours after receipt of the claim Within a reasonable period of time appropriate to the medical circumstances, but not later than 15 days after receipt of the claim No change No change

    Authors’ summary of CMS’ proposed rule (Table 4) and Final Rule (Table E1), with a few modifications to reflect more detail. Extensions of timeframes are not included in the chart.

    Public Reporting: Approvals, Denails and Appeals

    Beginning in 2026, Payers must post on their websites prior authorization data, including:

    • A list of all items and services that require prior authorization
    • The percentage of standard prior authorization requests that were approved, denied and approved after appeal
    • The percentage of prior authorization requests for which the timeframe for review was extended
    • The percentage of expedited prior authorization requests that were approved and denied
    • The average and median time that elapsed between the submission of a request and a determination by the Payer for both standard and expedited requests.

    MA plans will report at the contract level (a change from CMS’ proposed rule), Medicaid managed care plans and CHIP managed care entities will report at the plan level, QHP issuers on the FFEs will report at the issuer level, and state Medicaid and CHIP FFS programs will report at the state level.[3] Payers must post the initial set of metrics by March 31, 2026, and then provide updates annually thereafter. At this time, CMS will not collect the prior authorization data itself. However, the agency will continue to monitor complaints received by beneficiaries and providers for potential discrimination through prior authorization and utilization management programs and will take action, as necessary.

    Note that none of the prior authorization policies included in the Final Rule apply to drugs.[4] CMS may consider options for improving the prior authorization processes for drugs in future rulemakings.

    Authors

    Jeremy Earl

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Erin Kelly

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Emily R. Curran

    Associate

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • EU Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism: Reporting Deadlines Approaching

    EU Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism: Reporting Deadlines Approaching

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    EU Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism: Reporting Deadlines Approaching

    January 29, 2024

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    By 1 March 2024, as part of the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism, importers of cement, iron and steel, aluminium, fertilisers and hydrogen must report to the European Commission the embedded carbon emissions relating to goods imported into the EU between October and December 2023.

    In depth

    What is the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism?

    The Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism is an environmental policy of the EU designed, in the context of the global carbon tax initiative, to support the EU climate ambitions of reaching climate neutrality and addressing the risk of carbon leakage.

    The mechanism is being introduced in two phases.

    • In the Transitional Phase (from 1 October 2023 to 31 December 2025), importers have to quarterly report a set of data, including carbon emissions embedded in the goods they import into the EU.
    • In the Definitive Phase (starting from 1 January 2026), importers will pay the CO2 price for their emissions and will have to surrender relevant certificates relating to such emissions.

    Transitional Phase

    The Transitional Phase imposes certain reporting obligations on importers of the goods listed above into the EU. However, it is crucial to assess which entity has to comply with these obligations, whether these obligations can be delegated to a third party, and whether they impact other obligations of such entity, for instance in the context of the EU REACH Regulation.

    Regarding the reporting in the Transitional Phase:

    • In case of EU established importers: These importers are responsible to submit the reports themselves, although they can delegate these obligations to a third party (called an indirect customs representative), which can file the reports on their behalf.
    • In case of non-EU established importers: These importers have to appoint a third party (an indirect customs representative), to file the reports on their behalf.

    Broadly speaking, the reports should contain:

    • The total quantity of goods listed above imported into the EU during the relevant period.
    • Data on direct and indirect total embedded emissions of these goods.
    • Where applicable, the carbon price due in a country of origin for the embedded emissions.

    During the Transitional Phase, the importers may use default values published by the European Commission to determine the embedded emissions. The European Commission have published sample report excel sheet for download, available here.

    The reports are to be submitted on a quarterly basis, noting that the first report for the goods imported into the EU between October and December 2023 must be completed by 1 March 2024 (the initial deadline of 31 January 2024 was extended due to technical issues with the Transitional Registry).  . The two first reports can however be modified or corrected until 31 July 2024 (the submission deadline for the third report).

    The reports should be uploaded onto the Transitional Registry (access to which is given by the national customs authorities).

    How can McDermott assist you?

    The Trade & Regulatory Team of McDermott Will & Emery, led by Raminta Dereskeviciute, is here to help you in assessing your new obligations under the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism and preparing you for its Definitive Phase. Please do not hesitate to reach out.

    Authors

    Raminta Dereskeviciute

    Partner

    London – 22 Bishopsgate

    More insights

  • The Supply Chain Duty of Care Act in the Real Estate Sector

    The Supply Chain Duty of Care Act in the Real Estate Sector

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    The Supply Chain Duty of Care Act in the Real Estate Sector

    January 26, 2024

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The scope of application of the Supply Chain Due Diligence Act (“LkSG”) was significantly expanded on January 1, 2024. Since then, companies with 1,000 employees or more (in the entire domestic group of companies) have been covered by the scope of application. Many companies in the real estate sector now also have to deal with the LkSG for the first time and implement the obligations arising from the law, as the acquisition and development of real estate or the rental of corresponding premises may also fall within the supply chain under certain circumstances. Furthermore, it cannot be ruled out that further tightening of the LkSG will follow due to the currently planned EU Supply Chain Directive.

    In view of the current political discussion regarding the LkSG and the severe fines for non-compliance with the requirements of the LkSG, the objectives, scope of application and main obligations of the LkSG should be known.

    Find the full article, “Das Lieferkettensorgfaltspflichtengesetz in der Immobilienbranche,” in German.

    In depth
    Authors

    Dr. Ulrich Flege

    Partner

    Düsseldorf

    More insights

  • And Another: New Hampshire Passes New Consumer Privacy Law

    And Another: New Hampshire Passes New Consumer Privacy Law

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    And Another: New Hampshire Passes New Consumer Privacy Law

    January 24, 2024

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On January 18, 2024, the New Hampshire Senate passed by voice vote SB255, the New Hampshire Privacy Act (NHPA), amended by the New Hampshire House of Representatives. The bill will head to Governor Chris Sununu’s desk. After his signature, the bill is slated to take effect January 1, 2025.

    As has become the norm, while this new state privacy law largely tracks the Virginia model, there are some nuances that make it unique.

    Below is an overview of key aspects of the NHPA. You can access information about all of the state consumer laws that have been enacted by consulting our interactive state privacy law map.

    In depth

    Who Does the NHPA Apply To?

    The NHPA does not include a revenue threshold. Rather, it applies to any business or person that produces products or services that are targeted to residents of New Hampshire, and either:

    1. Controls or processes the personal data of at least 35,000 unique New Hampshire consumers, excluding personal data controlled or processed solely for the purpose of completing a payment transaction; or
    2. Controls or processes the personal data of at least 10,000 unique New Hampshire consumers and derives more than 25% of its gross revenue from the sale of personal data.

    New Hampshire is the first state to add the “unique” descriptor to consumers in this context, though most industry readers have read that qualification into other state privacy laws to date.

    Who Is a “Consumer”?

    Under the NHPA, a consumer is an individual who is a resident of New Hampshire, but it excludes individuals acting in commercial or employment context.

    What Is “Personal Data”?

    Personal data is information that is linked or reasonably linkable to an identified or identifiable individual. The NHPA specifically excludes de-identified data or publicly available information from the definition of personal data. In turn, the definitions of de-identified data and publicly available information track closely with the Virginia model.

    Who Can Enforce?

    New Hampshire’s attorney general has exclusive enforcement power. Through the end of 2025, the attorney general must provide businesses with a 60-day notice and cure period prior to taking any action in response to a violation if the attorney general determines a cure is possible. Beginning January 1, 2026, the attorney general will have the option to provide notice with the opportunity to cure. Violations of the NHPA can accrue at a rate of up to $10,000 per violation.

    Who Is Exempt?

    The NHPA includes several broad entity-level exemptions, including common ones for:

    • Any government body or agency;
    • Nonprofit organizations;
    • Higher education institutions;
    • Covered Entities and Business Associates under the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA); and
    • Any financial institution or data subjected to the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act.

    The NHPA also includes 19 data-level exemptions, including data processed in accordance with a litany of federal laws including, but not limited to, HIPAA, the Fair Credit Reporting Act, the Drivers Privacy Protection Act, the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act and the Farm Credit Act.

    What Obligations Are Imposed?

    The NHPA imposes controller obligations that largely mirror what we have seen in other states. The obligations include requirements to:

    1. Limit the collection of personal data to what is adequate, relevant and reasonably necessary in relation to the purposes for which such data is processed;
    2. Establish, implement and maintain reasonable administrative, technical and physical data security practices;
    3. Prohibit processing personal data in violation of the laws that prohibit unlawful discrimination against consumers, and refrain from discriminating against consumers that exercise their rights;
    4. Provide an effective mechanism such that a consumer can revoke their consent; and
    5. Prohibit processing for targeted advertising or selling the consumer’s personal data without the consumer’s consent where the controller knows that the consumer is at least 13 years of age but younger than 16 years of age.

    What Consumer Rights Are Created by the NHPA?

    The NHPA will require controllers to provide New Hampshire consumers the following rights:

    1. A right to confirm whether or not the controller is processing the consumer’s personal data and provide access to that data unless access would require the controller to reveal a trade secret;
    2. Correction rights, considering the nature of the personal data and the purposes for processing the personal data;
    3. Deletion rights, with respect to the data provided by or obtained about the consumer;
    4. Opt-out rights related to the sale of personal data, targeted advertising and profiling, where profiling is being used to produce a legal or similarly significant effect;
    5. Appeal rights; and
    6. Data portability rights.

    Sensitive Personal Data

    The NHPA includes a definition of sensitive personal data, which should look familiar, and includes information that reveals:

    • Racial or ethnic origin, religious beliefs, mental or physical health condition or diagnosis, sex life, sexual orientation, or citizenship or immigration status;
    • The processing of genetic or biometric data for the purpose of uniquely identifying an individual;
    • Personal data collected from a known child (under 13); or
    • Precise geolocation data (within a 1,750-foot radius).

    Controllers may not process sensitive data without first obtaining the consumer’s consent (or a parent’s consent where processing data about a known child).

    Response to Consumer Inquiries

    Under the NHPA, controllers must respond to a data subject request within 45 days after receipt, with a 45-day extension available as reasonably necessary. There must be a method of appealing the controller’s denial of a request, and a decision on the appeal must be provided within 60 days of receipt of the appeal. If an appeal is denied, the decision must include a method for the consumer to submit a complaint with the attorney general.

    Data Protection Assessments

    The NHPA requires “data protection assessments” be conducted whenever the controller is:

    1. Processing personal data for targeted advertising;
    2. Selling personal data;
    3. Processing personal data for the purposes of profiling, where such profiling presents a reasonably foreseeable risk of unfair or deceptive treatment of consumers or result in other substantial injury to consumers; and
    4. Processing sensitive data.

    The assessment must identify and weigh the benefits to all stakeholders against the risks and potential harms, accounting for any potential mitigating steps that the controller could employ. Thankfully, the NHPA allows impact assessments completed pursuant to other state privacy laws to satisfy the assessment requirements of the NHPA.

    Assessments are only required for any processing activities that occur on or after July 1, 2024.

    When Does the NHPA Take Effect?

    The NHPA is slated to take effect January 1, 2025.

    ***

    Creating a successful, effective, and comprehensive privacy program for your organization requires a thorough understanding of both the relevant legal obligations and the personal data subject to compliance. Setting up a program that is prepared to respond to various state privacy laws as they come into effect will save organizations time in the long run, especially as many of these laws reflect one another.

    If you have questions or need assistance in readiness work for the new state consumer laws, please contact your regular McDermott lawyer or reach out to David Saunders, Allison Tassel or John Ying.

    Authors

    David P. Saunders

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • New Proposed Rules Aim to Enhance Healthcare Accessibility for People With Disabilities

    New Proposed Rules Aim to Enhance Healthcare Accessibility for People With Disabilities

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    New Proposed Rules Aim to Enhance Healthcare Accessibility for People With Disabilities

    January 24, 2024

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) and the US Department of Justice (DOJ) recently published new proposed rules that update and create various requirements under Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 and Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (ADA). In this article, McDermott’s Healthcare Group highlights some of the biggest changes.

    In depth

    Furthering the Biden administration’s efforts to ensure comprehensive and equitable access to health services for individuals with disabilities, the DOJ’s Office of Civil Rights and HHS recently proposed significant updates to regulations under the ADA and Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973.

    HHS’s proposed rule under Section 504 aims to advance equity and bolster protections for people with disabilities in programs and activities that receive federal financial assistance or are conducted by a federal agency. Complementing HHS’s proposed rule, the DOJ’s Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM) under Title II of the ADA focuses on medical diagnostic equipment (MDE), establishing enforceable standards for state and local government entities providing healthcare services to address existing barriers and enhance accessibility. Together, these proposed rules represent a concerted effort by the Biden administration to further equity and accessibility in the healthcare space in a manner that will directly impact the provision of care.

    HHS Proposed Rulemaking on Nondiscrimination on the Basis of Disability Under Section 504

    As we previously reported, on September 14, 2023, HHS issued a proposed rule that updates, clarifies and strengthens the implementing regulation for Section 504, which prohibits discrimination against otherwise qualified individuals on the basis of disability in programs and activities that receive federal financial assistance or are conducted by a federal agency. Specific to entities receiving money from HHS, federal financial assistance includes credits, subsidies, or contracts of insurance, including Medicare Part A, Medicare Part C and Medicare Part D; the Children’s Health Insurance Program; the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program; Head Start; the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program; childcare, foster care and adoption program; and human subjects research protection.

    HHS’s proposed rule ensures that people with disabilities are not subjected to discrimination in any program or activity receiving funding from HHS, including the provision of healthcare services. HHS observed that such discrimination may occur in medical treatment, value assessment methods, child welfare programs and activities, web and mobile accessibility, accessible medical equipment, and integration for individuals with disabilities. Impacted providers should remove any barriers causing inaccessibility based on an individual’s disability. HHS proposed that noncompliance will result in penalties that may include loss of federal funding; administrative remedies such as corrective action plans, monitoring, and reporting requirements; legal action from individuals subjected to discrimination; investigations and audits; and risk of loss of accreditation or certification. More than 5,000 comments were received by the time the comment period closed on November 13, 2023. No final rule has been published to date.

    DOJ’s Proposed Rulemaking on Accessibility of MDE

    On January 9, 2024, the DOJ released an NPRM aimed at updating regulations under Title II to establish specific requirements for the accessibility of MDE and articulated the importance of coordinating its efforts with the aforementioned HHS proposed rule based on US Congress’s intent to interpret Section 504 and Title II consistently. Title II mandates that state and local government services, programs and activities be accessible to individuals with disabilities. Title II applies to all public entities, including state and local governments and departments, agencies, special purpose districts, special districts governments, and other instrumentalities of state or local government. State and local government entities that offer healthcare services, programs, and activities through the use of MDE, such as public hospitals and healthcare clinics, would be covered by this proposed rule and would also be subject to Section 504 if they receive federal funding from HHS. State and local government entities that contract with other entities to provide services (like state agencies that contract with nonprofit organizations that run clinics on the state’s behalf) also have an obligation to ensure that their contractors follow Title II, and the contractors likely would be obligated to comply in their own regard with Section 504.

    MDE is equipment used in, or in conjunction with, medical settings by healthcare providers for diagnostic purposes. MDE includes examination tables, examination chairs (including chairs used for eye examinations or procedures and dental examinations or procedures), weight scales, mammography equipment and x-ray machines.

    The DOJ has identified that people with disabilities continue to experience barriers to accessing medical care because of inaccessible MDE. Barriers such as exam tables that are not height adjustable, mammography machines that require a person to stand, and weight scales that do not accommodate wheelchairs result in inequities and exclusion from basic health services. The NPRM highlights five key proposals to mitigate discrimination caused by inaccessible MDE:

    1. Adoption of US Access Board Standards – The proposed rule advocates for Title II to adopt the Access Board’s MDE standards as technical requirements for accessible MDE. Issued in 2017, these standards provide specific requirements for MDE accessibility in physician offices, clinics, emergency rooms, hospitals and other medical settings. The proposal would make the Access Board’s MDE standards enforceable by the DOJ under the ADA.
    2. Denial of Service – The Title II proposed rule prohibits healthcare-providing state and local government entities from denying services to patients with disabilities because of a lack of accessible MDE. It also prohibits state and local government healthcare providers from requiring a patient with a disability to bring someone to assist during an examination.
    3. Requirements for Newly Acquired MDE – The Title II proposed rule requires that all MDE that state and local government entities purchase, lease, or otherwise acquire after the rule goes into effect be accessible until they have a sufficient amount of accessible MDE, which the DOJ proposes to be at least 20% of equipment in mobility-treating facilities and at least 10% of other equipment. The proposal states that these entities do not need to make changes, including purchasing, leasing, or acquiring accessible MDE, if doing so would be a fundamental alteration or cause undue financial and administrative burdens. However, the existence of such a burden would not excuse a covered entity from taking another action that would ensure equitable access to the applicable benefits and services.
    4. Requirements for Existing MDE – The proposed rule does not require state and local government entities to make all their existing MDE accessible. Instead, it adopts an approach analogous to the concept of program accessibility that already exists in the DOJ’s existing regulation implementing Title II. This rule would require that services, programs, or activities of state and local government entities, when viewed in their entirety, be readily accessible to and usable by individuals with disabilities, including taking meaningful actions to ensure accessibility if retrofitting existing MDE is unduly burdensome.
    5. Staff Competency – The final proposal requires state and local government entities to ensure that their staff are qualified to successfully operate accessible MDE, assist with the transfer and positioning of individuals with disabilities, and carry out the rule’s requirements for existing MDE.

    Timeframe to Comply and Penalties for Failure to Comply With the DOJ’s Proposed Rule

    If the DOJ’s proposed rule is adopted as written, it will require all MDE that state and local government entities purchase, lease, or otherwise acquire to be accessible until the entity has enough equipment to satisfy the rule’s 20% and 10% scoping requirements previously described. Moreover, within two years after the publication of the final rule, state and local government entities that use exam tables or weight scales would be required to have at least one exam table or weight scale that meets the MDE standards.

    Failure to comply with Title II may result in penalties, such as fines of up to $75,000 for a single violation, $150,000 for additional violations, and the risk of legal action brought by individuals claiming discrimination.

    Conclusion

    These concerted efforts of HHS and the DOJ to implement rules to advance access and equitable treatment marks a significant milestone in historical efforts to remove barriers for individuals with disabilities.

    Both proposed rules have been published in the Federal Register; public comments for HHS’s proposed rule closed on November 13, 2023, and comments are open for the DOJ’s proposed until February 12, 2024. Based on the 5,000 predominantly supportive comments submitted in response to the Section 504 proposed rule, we anticipate both rules will be finalized in materially the same format as proposed unless stakeholders raise material concerns.

    For more information, please contact the authors or your regular McDermott lawyer.

    Authors

    Sandra M. DiVarco

    Partner

    Chicago

    Joshua Neumann

    Associate

    Chicago

    More insights

  • New Rules Make Tracking Long-Term, Part-Time Employee Service a Full-Time Job

    New Rules Make Tracking Long-Term, Part-Time Employee Service a Full-Time Job

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    New Rules Make Tracking Long-Term, Part-Time Employee Service a Full-Time Job

    January 23, 2024

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In this series of articles, we explore the implications of the long-term, part-time employee rules under the SECURE Act and SECURE 2.0 and the impact those rules have on employers and their workforces.

    Under the SECURE Act and the SECURE 2.0 Act, employers must provide so-called long-term, part-time employees—i.e., those who complete at least 500 hours of service in three consecutive years (reduced to two years in 2025) and are at least 21 years old—the opportunity to make elective deferrals under their 401(k) plans and, beginning in 2025, their 403(b) plans.

    Most employers with impacted plans reviewed their eligibility-tracking processes some time ago in anticipation of the initial effective date of the new rule. However, with that new rule now effective—and last-minute guidance now available—it is important for employers to review those processes to determine if further changes are needed or desired.

    In depth

    Eventually, it may become easier to think of service tracking under the new rule as a largely set-it-and-forget-it process. However, for now, employers will likely want to continue revisiting, reviewing and refining their eligibility-tracking processes around the new rule. This will help ensure that hours are accurately aggregated over relevant periods of time to facilitate timely plan entry.

    In doing so, it will be important for employers to establish procedures for periodically reviewing eligibility data to ensure that their tracking systems are working as expected. This approach will allow employers to timely identify and correct eligibility errors when things don’t go quite as planned. Going forward, employers may also want to talk with their human resources information system (HRIS) providers and recordkeepers to see if they offer additional services that might make service tracking easier under the new rules.

    As an alternative, given the added complexity around hours counting and tracking, some employers may want to explore design changes that would help reduce the administrative burden associated with complying with the new rules. This might include eliminating eligibility waiting periods for making elective deferrals or eliminating waiting periods altogether, even those that can still be applied to receipt of employer contributions. Although eliminating waiting periods for employer contributions could increase total plan cost, for employers with small part-time employee populations, that increase in cost might prove a relatively small price to pay for avoiding the administrative complexity of the new rule.

    For the same reasons, some employers may also consider whether the use of equivalencies or moving away from the hours-counting method to the elapsed-time method of tracking eligibility service might prove an effective way to ease or eliminate the compliance burden. That said, employers with large part-time, seasonal or continent workforces often find these methods of tracking service less desirable, as they don’t align as well with how employers think about the hours-based work performed by employees in those positions. In addition, use of equivalencies and elapsed-time methods for tracking service can accelerate plan entry for individuals who have otherwise performed very little work for the business.

    Ultimately, the options available to help reduce the administrative burden of complying with the new rules will not make sense for every employer, as plan eligibility criteria has as much to do with the goals of the business and the makeup of an employer’s workforce as it does with minimum legal requirements. But with the added complexity of the new rules, it is worth taking a little time to consider what measures might be a good fit. Even where such measures are not available, employers may still find ways to lean on their HRIS providers and recordkeepers for additional support.

    For any questions regarding the proposed regulations or SECURE 2.0, please contact your regular McDermott lawyer or one of the authors.

    ***

    Read First Article: A Long-Term, Part-Time Employee or Not a Long-Term, Part-Time Employee, That Is the Question

    Read Second Article: A Long-Term, Part-Time Employee or a Former Long-Term, Part-Time Employee, That Is the Question

    Read Third Article: Under Long-Term, Part-Time Employee Rules, Some Things Change, and Some Things Stay the Same

    Read Fourth Article: IRS Confirms Same Hours-Counting Rules Still Add Up for Long-Term, Part-Time Employees

    Read Fifth Article: When It Comes to Vesting, IRS Says Once a Long-Term, Part-Time Employee, Always a Long-Term, Part-Time Employee

    Read Sixth Article: This Is Not a Test! IRS Confirms Long-Term, Part-Time Employees Excludible From Certain Nondiscrimination Testing

    Authors

    Brian J. Tiemann

    Partner

    Chicago

    Haley M. Dow

    Associate

    Chicago

    More insights

  • This Is Not a Test! IRS Confirms Long-Term, Part-Time Employees Excludible From Certain Nondiscrimination Testing

    This Is Not a Test! IRS Confirms Long-Term, Part-Time Employees Excludible From Certain Nondiscrimination Testing

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    This Is Not a Test! IRS Confirms Long-Term, Part-Time Employees Excludible From Certain Nondiscrimination Testing

    January 23, 2024

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In this series of articles, we explore the implications of the long-term, part-time employee rules under the SECURE Act and SECURE 2.0 and the impact those rules have on employers and their workforces.

    Under the SECURE Act and the SECURE 2.0 Act, employers must provide long-term, part-time employees the opportunity to make elective deferrals under their 401(k) plans and, beginning in 2025, their 403(b) plans. When this occurs, certain special rules apply to such employees that impact whether they must be included in annual nondiscrimination testing or receive required top-heavy vesting and benefits. As a result, it is important for employers to understand these requirements, as they may impact how annual testing is performed and the results.

    In depth

    Employers are required to perform certain annual tests on their retirement plans to confirm that the plans do not violate the tax code by favoring highly paid employees over their lower-paid counterparts. In doing so, the tests evaluate various areas of plan operation. This includes:

    • Assessing who is and is not eligible to receive benefits under the plan (coverage testing);
    • Reviewing the relative amounts contributed on behalf of higher- and lower-paid workers under the plan (Actual Deferral Percentage (ADP) and Actual Contribution Percentage (ACP) testing);
    • Analyzing the extent to which benefits, rights or features available under the plan differ for higher- and lower-paid workers (benefits, rights and features testing); and
    • Determining whether a vastly disproportionate amount of the benefits payable under the plan go to a very select group of key individuals (top-heavy testing).

    To reduce some of this testing burden, the tax code also allows employers to adopt so-called safe harbor plans that, by design, are deemed to satisfy certain required tests (specifically, ADP/ACP testing).

    These testing rules and requirements have been around for some time. And, like any test, passing is ultimately all about the numbers. Employers care not only about whether their plans pass testing but also by how much and whether a shift in plan design or employee demographics might change that in the future. As a result, who must be included in testing can become very important—so important, in fact, that pages and pages of the tax code are devoted to explaining exactly who must be, can be and can’t be included in running the various tests. Any time new rules change this (as is the case under the new long-term, part-time employee rules), it is important to consider if and how that might impact passage rates and testing margins in the future.

    The recently proposed regulations issued by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) confirm that employees who enter a plan as long-term, part-time employees may be excluded from coverage testing, ADP/ACP testing, and benefits, rights and features testing. The rules also confirm that, for employers with safe harbor plans, choosing to exclude long-term, part-time employees from receipt of safe harbor contributions (i.e., only making them eligible for elective deferrals) will not jeopardize a plan’s safe harbor status. In addition, the rules explain that while such long-term, part-time employees must be counted for purposes of completing top-heavy testing, they are not required to receive enhanced top-heavy vesting or benefits (which applies when plans fail to pass such testing).

    However, the rules also explain that employers cannot choose to exclude long-term, part-time employees from some types of testing but not others (or to exclude some long-time, part-time employees from testing but not the rest). It’s all or nothing. If an employer elects to exclude long-time, part-time employees from one test (e.g., coverage, ADP/ACP, or benefits, rights and features), they must exclude them—all of them—from other testing as well. The IRS does draw one distinction for this purpose, though, explaining that the decision to include or exclude such employees from coverage, ADP/ACP, and benefits, rights and features testing is distinct from the decision regarding whether they receive enhanced top-heavy vesting or benefits. Put another way, employers can choose to exclude employees from coverage, ADP/ACP, and benefits, rights and features testing but not from receipt of top-heavy vesting and benefits (or vice versa).

    Importantly, though, when employees are no longer considered to be long-term, part-time (e.g., because they transitioned into full-time roles), the former long-term, part-time employees can no longer be excluded from testing or from enhanced top-heavy vesting and benefits.

    Because most employers rely heavily on their recordkeepers or other service providers to assist with annual nondiscrimination testing, the intricate implementation (yes, the math, the math!) around this will be largely driven by those service providers. However, it is important for employers to understand the general contours of the rules, as excluding long-term, part-time employees from testing will require that internal and external systems (e.g., human resources information systems and recordkeeping) are appropriately updated to track who may be excluded and when their status as excludible changes, if ever. In addition, the proposed regulations indicate that compliance with these rules will be more than just operationalized in the testing process. Instead, most plan documents will need to be updated to include specific language addressing the potential application of these rules. So, it will be important for employers to know what is being done so it can be properly incorporated into the plan.

    For any questions regarding the proposed regulations or SECURE 2.0, please contact your regular McDermott lawyer or one of the authors.

    ***

    Read First Article: A Long-Term, Part-Time Employee or Not a Long-Term, Part-Time Employee, That Is the Question

    Read Second Article: A Long-Term, Part-Time Employee or a Former Long-Term, Part-Time Employee, That Is the Question

    Read Third Article: Under Long-Term, Part-Time Employee Rules, Some Things Change, and Some Things Stay the Same

    Read Fourth Article: IRS Confirms Same Hours-Counting Rules Still Add Up for Long-Term, Part-Time Employees

    Read Fifth Article: When It Comes to Vesting, IRS Says Once a Long-Term, Part-Time Employee, Always a Long-Term, Part-Time Employee

    Read Seventh Article: New Rules Make Tracking Long-Term, Part-Time Employee Service a Full-Time Job

    Authors

    Brian J. Tiemann

    Partner

    Chicago

    Haley M. Dow

    Associate

    Chicago

    More insights

  • When It Comes to Vesting, IRS Says Once a Long-Term, Part-Time Employee, Always a Long-Term, Part-Time Employee

    When It Comes to Vesting, IRS Says Once a Long-Term, Part-Time Employee, Always a Long-Term, Part-Time Employee

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    When It Comes to Vesting, IRS Says Once a Long-Term, Part-Time Employee, Always a Long-Term, Part-Time Employee

    January 23, 2024

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In this series of articles, we explore the implications of the long-term, part-time employee rules under the SECURE Act and SECURE 2.0 and the impact those rules have on employers and their workforces.

    Under the SECURE Act and the SECURE 2.0 Act, employers must provide long-term, part-time employees—i.e., employees who complete at least 500 hours of service in three consecutive years (reduced to two years in 2025) and are at least 21 years old—the opportunity to make elective deferrals under their 401(k) plans and, beginning in 2025, their 403(b) plans. However, long-term, part-time employees are not required to be eligible for employer matching or profit-sharing contributions until they satisfy the regular plan rules. Despite this fact, one of the most salient issues surrounding the implementation of the new rule is how it impacts—and complicates—tracking when employees become vested in such contributions.

    In depth

    Under the new rule, starting with service performed on and after January 1, 2021, employers are required to credit long-term, part-time employees with one year of vesting service for each 12-month measurement period during which the employee is credited with at least 500 hours of service. Service prior to that date is not counted for this purpose.

    In its simplest form, theoretically, the rule makes some sense. If an employee is going to be subject to a lesser 500-hour service requirement to enter the plan, as compared to the older 1,000-hour rule, the employee should have an opportunity to vest in matching or profit-sharing contributions made to a plan under a similarly reduced standard. But the application of the rule doesn’t play out quite so simply. This is in large part because the new long-term, part-time employee rule only applies to elective deferrals—which are always fully vested—and does not accelerate plan entry for employer contributions, like matching and profit-sharing contributions, which might be subject to a vesting schedule.

    As a result, employers are required to track vesting service for long-term, part-time employees even though this may have no practical effect. Because long-term, part-time employees are not required to be eligible for employer matching or profit-sharing contributions until they satisfy the regular plan rules (e.g., completing 1,000 hours of service in a 12-month period), those employees may never qualify to receive those contributions, at least not while they’re still working a part-time schedule.

    And there’s the rub. Employers will need to know how vested a long-term, part-time employee should be in employer contributions if the employee ever qualifies to receive them. But many long-term, part-time employees will only qualify to receive employer contributions after they’re no longer working a long-term, part-time schedule.

    Then, things get more complicated.

    You might reasonably assume that once long-term, part-time employees stop working long-term, part-time schedules, you should start treating those employees like everyone else, subject to the same rules and vesting terms. But the proposed regulations issued by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) indicate that is not the case—at least not as it relates to vesting. Instead, less intuitively, the rules provide that employees who enter the plan as long-term, part-time employees must continue to be credited with vesting service for completing 500 hours of service in the designated 12-month measurement period, even if they later stop being considered long-term, part-time employees.

    This can produce a somewhat odd result, as a former long-term, part-time employee who becomes a regular employee will still be subject to a vesting schedule based on 500 hours of service, even though other regular employees may be subject to a higher vesting standard (e.g., completing 1,000 hours of service to earn a year of vesting service). Put another way, employers may now find themselves with two employees performing the same job and working the same amount of time but subject to two different vesting standards—all because one employee originally entered the plan as a long-term, part-time employee and the other did not.

    As a result, employers will need to take care to establish processes to monitor how vesting is tracked for long-term, part-time employees throughout their careers to ensure that they continue to be subject to more favorable vesting terms even if they eventually begin to work a more full-time schedule.

    For any questions regarding SECURE 2.0 changes, please contact your regular McDermott lawyer or one of the authors.

    ***

    Read First Article: A Long-Term, Part-Time Employee or Not a Long-Term, Part-Time Employee, That Is the Question

    Read Second Article: A Long-Term, Part-Time Employee or a Former Long-Term, Part-Time Employee, That Is the Question

    Read Third Article: Under Long-Term, Part-Time Employee Rules, Some Things Change, and Some Things Stay the Same

    Read Fourth Article: IRS Confirms Same Hours-Counting Rules Still Add Up for Long-Term, Part-Time Employees

    Read Sixth Article: This Is Not a Test! IRS Confirms Long-Term, Part-Time Employees Excludible From Certain Nondiscrimination Testing

    Read Seventh Article: New Rules Make Tracking Long-Term, Part-Time Employee Service a Full-Time Job

    Authors

    Brian J. Tiemann

    Partner

    Chicago

    Haley M. Dow

    Associate

    Chicago

    More insights