Content Type: Article

  • Leasehold Compact I Part 2 Establishment of the heritable building right

    Leasehold Compact I Part 2 Establishment of the heritable building right

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Leasehold Compact I Part 2 Establishment of the heritable building right

    May 24, 2024

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Leaseholds play an important role in the practice of the property industry. For property investors, project developers and the public sector, it is therefore becoming increasingly important to take an in-depth look at the content, structure and legal consequences of leaseholds. In addition, politicians are increasingly recognising leaseholds as an ‘instrument of strategic land policy in Germany’, with the result that local authorities in particular are increasingly only issuing larger project developments on the basis of leaseholds.

    Our newsletter series ‘Erbbaurecht kompakt’ presents the key topics and regulations as well as current case law relating to leaseholds. The second part of our ‘Leasehold compact’ series deals with the establishment of a leasehold.

    In depth
    Authors

    Philipp-Gerald Hammes

    Partner

    Düsseldorf

    More insights

  • REMINDER: T+1 Settlement Cycle and Corresponding RIA Books and Records Rules Go Into Effect May 28

    REMINDER: T+1 Settlement Cycle and Corresponding RIA Books and Records Rules Go Into Effect May 28

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    REMINDER: T+1 Settlement Cycle and Corresponding RIA Books and Records Rules Go Into Effect May 28

    May 24, 2024

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Effective Tuesday, May 28, 2024, the US will transition from a “T+2” settlement cycle to a “T+1” settlement cycle.[1] This change will impact all transactions in subject securities[2] effected through an SEC-registered broker-dealer absent an express agreement to the contrary.[3]  The US Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”), in adopting the rule changes implementing the T+1 settlement cycle,[4] separately adopted an amendment to Rule 204-2 (“Books and Records Rule” or “Rule”) under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, as amended, that also go into effect on May 28. For most registered investment advisers (“RIAs”) to private funds, the amended Books and Records Rule should not require significant changes to current operations.

    The Books and Records Rule Amendment

    The amendment to the Books and Records Rule requires that, in connection with any transaction subject to T+1 settlement,[5] an RIA must maintain records of each confirmation received and any allocation or affirmation sent or received. Such allocations and affirmations must include a timestamp indicating when the allocation and affirmation was sent or received.[6]

    More specifically, the amendment to the Books and Records Rule revises paragraph (a)(7)(iii) of Rule 2024-2 to add the following bolded language:

    The placing or execution of any order to purchase or sell any security; and, for any transaction that is subject to the requirements of § 240.15c6-2(a) of this chapter, each confirmation received, and any allocation and each affirmation sent or received, with a date and time stamp for each allocation and affirmation that indicates when the allocation and affirmation was sent or received[.]

    As is currently the case with records required to be maintained under the Rule, such records “be maintained and preserved in an easily accessible place for a period of not less than five years from the end of the fiscal year during which the last entry was made on such record, the first two years in an appropriate office of the investment adviser.”[7]

    RIAs must maintain required records in “a way that permits easy location, access, and retrieval of any particular record” and provide “legible, true, and complete” copies “promptly” if requested during an examination or in connection with an enforcement inquiry.[8]

    Allocations, Confirmations and Affirmations

    The Books and Records Rule amendment will likely have the greatest impact on transactions effected through an executing broker (that is, a broker-dealer other than the adviser’s prime broker or bank custodian, prime brokers and bank custodians collectively, “Clearing Agents”).[9] In such transactions, the executing broker transmits a “confirmation” to the Clearing Agent noting the terms of the transaction effected by the executing broker on behalf of their common customer.[10] Depending on the arrangement, either the RIA or its Clearing Agent then affirms the details of the confirmation provided by the executing broker; such instructions help facilitate the transfer of the position from the executing broker to the Clearing Agent. Where received or sent by an RIA, these confirmation and affirmation instructions must be retained in accordance with the Books and Records Rule.

    Separately, in such transactions an adviser typically submits allocation instructions to its executing broker and/or Clearing Agent. These allocation instructions identify the Clearing Agent where a trade, or portion thereof, should be allocated and may separately identify the relevant underlying customer(s) accounts. Under the amended Books and Records Rule each such allocation transmitted by an adviser should be retained, whether submitted to the executing broker or the firm’s Clearing Agent. 

    Operational Impact

    Confirmations

    Under the amended Books and Records Rule, RIAs should be retaining a copy of any confirmation received. It is not uncommon, however, for an executing broker to send a confirmation to the Clearing Agent rather than the adviser itself.

    Allocation Instructions

    An RIA must maintain timestamped copies of allocation instructions sent to, or received from, its brokers and Clearing Agents.[11]

    Affirmations

    Where an RIA uses a “prime broker” as a fund’s custodian, the prime broker will typically affirm each trade submitted to it by an executing broker. We understand this process will continue unchanged in a T+1 environment and, as such, the adviser will typically neither send nor receive affirmations for trades cleared to their prime broker(s). However, in instances where an RIA does send or receive a copy of an affirmation, the amended Rule requires that the RIA retain it.

    For advisers using agent banks as their Clearing Agents, certain bank custodians have requested that advisers obtain a TradeSuite ID[12] and otherwise subscribe to certain TradeSuite services.  Requiring that each adviser have its own TradeSuite ID will help bank custodians segregate confirmations and other transaction records maintained by such bank custodian. Further, depending on the TradeSuite services to which the adviser subscribes, this will permit the adviser to self-affirm transactions cleared to the bank custodian (where desired).  

    In all instances, where an adviser is itself the party submitting the affirmation instructions, the adviser will need to maintain timestamped copies of each such affirmation and will need to maintain copies of affirmations otherwise received by the adviser. Notwithstanding the foregoing, neither the amended Books and Records Rule nor the related Exchange Act amendments require that an adviser self-affirm transactions, regardless of the type of Clearing Agent used.

    Division of Examinations Risk Alert

    The SEC’s Division of Examinations published a Risk Alert in March announcing its intention to examine Registrants on their compliance with the new requirements, including evaluating, among other things, Registrants’ “readiness” for the new recordkeeping requirements. [13]

    Conclusion

    To confirm preparedness for the Rule change, RIAs should:

    • Ensure books and records policies have been updated to reflect the new requirement;
    • Confirm the RIA is keeping a copy of all allocation instructions sent or received in a place and format where such instructions could be readily collected and produced in response to an SEC request; and
    • Identify whether the RIA (1) receives trade confirmations from any Clearing Agent, broker or custodian or (2) affirms trades directly with a custodian and, if so, ensure such confirmations or affirmations, as applicable, could be readily collected and produced in response to an SEC request.

    Authored by William J. Barbera, Kelly Koscuiszka and Matthew I. Schecter.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] That is, the scheduled settlement date for subject transactions will transition from two (2) business days after the relevant trade date (“T+2”) to one (1) business day after the relevant trade date (“T+1”).

    [2] Generally, all securities other than exempted securities, government securities, municipal securities, commercial paper and security-based swaps. See rule 15c6-1 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended (“Exchange Act”) for a complete list of securities not subject to the T+1 settlement requirements.

    [3] See rule 15c6-1(a) of the Exchange Act.

    [4] See Exchange Act Release Nos. 34-96930 (Feb. 15, 2023), available at

    https://www.sec.gov/files/rules/final/2023/34-96930.pdf (“Adopting Release”).

    [5] That is, subject to T+1 settlement under Exchange Act rule 15c6-1(a).

    [6] See 17 CFR § 275.204-2(a).

    [7] See 17 CFR § 275.204-2(e)(1).

    [8] See 17 CFR § 275.204-2(g).

    [9] Although, for clarity, it will impact any transaction in which an RIA is sending or receiving allocation instructions.

    [10] See Adopting Release at 84.

    [11] The phrase “sent or received” is intended to apply to “any allocation” as well as each affirmation. See, e.g., Adopting Release at 107 (“As discussed above, in recognition of the role of third parties, the Commission is requiring advisers to keep records of allocations or affirmations sent or received, in the event that the adviser receives a copy of such records from a third party.”); see also id. at 297 (“These records include each confirmation received, and any allocation and each affirmation sent or received, with a date and time stamp for each allocation and affirmation that indicates when the allocation and affirmation were sent or received.”).

    [12] TradeSuite is a product offered by the Depository Trust & Clearing Corporation (DTCC) that allows participants to, among other things, affirm institutional trades.

    [13] See Shortening the Securities Transaction Settlement Cycle (March 27, 2024). The appendix to the Risk Alert includes representative questions that the SEC staff may ask on examinations focused on T+1 compliance, noting that different questions will apply to different registrant types. Of note for RIAs are sample questions regarding changes to policies and procedures, operational risk management, any funding/liquidity concerns foreseen for trades that do not settle T+1 and outreach to vendors.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. © 2024 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP. All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    William J. Barbera

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Kelly Koscuiszka

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Matthew I. Schecter

    Associate

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Danger Ahead? Graham and KSR Now Apply to Design Patents

    Danger Ahead? Graham and KSR Now Apply to Design Patents

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Danger Ahead? Graham and KSR Now Apply to Design Patents

    May 23, 2024

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On May 21, 2024, the US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit issued an en banc opinion overruling the long-standing Rosen-Durling test for obviousness of design patents in favor of the analytical framework used for utility patents outlined in Graham v. John Deere Co. and KSR Int’l Co. v. Teleflex Inc. LKQ Corporation et al. v. GM Global Technology Operations, LLC, Case No. 2021-2348 (Fed. Cir. May 21, 2024) (Stoll, Moore, Dyk, Prost, Reyna, Taranto, Chen, Hughes, Stark) (Lourie, concurring).

    In depth

    LKQ Corporation and Keystone Automotive Industries, Inc. (collectively, LKQ) filed an inter partes review (IPR) of GM’s design patent for a car part, asserting that it was unpatentable as obvious. The Patent Trial & Appeal Board applied the Rosen-Durling test and found that GM’s patent claim was not obvious. LKQ appealed the Board’s decision and a Federal Circuit panel affirmed the Board’s decision, declining to overrule the Rosen-Durling test for obviousness of design patents. The Court subsequently granted rehearing en banc.

    Sitting en banc, the Federal Circuit overruled the Rosen-Durling test for obviousness of design patents and explained the new standard.

    The Federal Circuit first addressed the Rosen-Durling test’s applicability for obviousness of design patents by reviewing Section 103 of the Patent Act, the Graham and KSR standards for obviousness of utility patents and the Supreme Court of the United States’ 1893 decision in Smith v. Whitman Saddle Co. Based on its review, the Federal Circuit determined that the Rosen-Durling test does not align with KSR, Whitman Saddle or any other precedent because of the rigidity of its framework. Specifically, the Court determined that the first part of the Rosen-Durling test was unduly rigid for requiring that the primary reference be “basically the same” as the challenged design claims, as Section103 and this approach conflicts with KSR’s flexible and expansive inquiry for obviousness.

    In assessing the second part of the Rosen-Durling test, the Federal Circuit found that the requirement that the secondary reference be “so related” to the primary reference that the appearance of a certain ornamental feature in one would suggest the application of those features to the other did not align with Section 103 or Whitman Saddle, resulting in a rigid application of the obviousness inquiry.

    After overruling Rosen and Durling, the Federal Circuit determined that the proper inquiry to assess the obviousness of design patents was to apply the Graham factors, which is used to assess utility patents. The Court proceeded to explain the application of the Graham factors to design patents.

    In applying the first Graham factor, the Federal Circuit confirmed that the analogous art requirement applies to design patent obviousness instead of the “so related” test of Rosen-Durling, finding that the analogous art requirement should not be abandoned because it’s a flexible fact-based analysis. The Court further discussed the traditional two-part test for analogous art of utility patents, finding that the first part of the test (whether the art is from the same field of endeavor as the claimed invention) would apply to design patents in a straightforward manner.

    As to the second part of the test, which is whether a reference that is not in the same field of endeavor is reasonably pertinent to the problem with which the inventor is involved, the Federal Circuit reasoned that it could not apply in the same manner because design patents do not clearly indicate any particular problem to be solved. The Court did not delineate what the full analogous art test would be for design patents, instead leaving future cases to address it on a case-by-case basis. The Court then went on to say that once analogous art was found, the first Graham factor required the identification of a primary prior art reference and, in the case of design patents, that reference would be the prior art that is the most visually similar to the claimed design and would typically be in the same field of endeavor (but did not have to be).

    In applying the second Graham factor, the Federal Circuit explained that the visual appearance of the claimed design must be compared to that of the allegedly infringing design. In applying the third Graham factor, the Court determined that the level of ordinary skill of the art for design patents is the knowledge of a designer of ordinary skill who designs articles of the type involved.

    According to the Federal Circuit, once the Graham factors have been applied, the obviousness of the claimed design is evaluated with an inquiry that focuses on the visual impression of the claimed design as a whole as opposed to selected individual features. The Court reiterated that a primary reference can be combined with secondary references to render a design obvious, but those secondary references do not need to be “so related” and instead need to be analogous art. Further, the motivation to combine these references must be supported by the record and indicate that an ordinary designer in the field of the article of manufacture would have modified the primary reference with the features from the secondary references to create the same overall appearance as the claimed design.

    Further, consistent with Graham, the Federal Circuit found that obviousness for design patents still requires assessing secondary considerations as indicia of obviousness or nonobviousness, including commercial success, industry praise and copying. The Court did not decide whether other secondary considerations apply to design patents, like unsolved needs or failure of others, leaving it open for future cases to determine whether they could apply in the design patent context.

    Numerous amici filed briefs stated concerns that eliminating the Rosen-Durling test creates uncertainty for many design patents. The Federal Circuit disagreed, finding that courts could draw on precedent that applies the Graham test to utility patents when assessing the obviousness of design patents.

    Lastly, the Federal Circuit addressed the merits of case. The Court remanded to the Board to apply the newly promulgated standard and address whether GM’s patent would have been obvious under Section 103 based on the prior art references raised by LKQ. In doing so, the Court also rejected the Board’s alternative ground for obviousness, finding that the Board cannot rely on claim construction in design patent cases for a detailed verbal description of the claimed design because it’s better represented by an illustration.

    Judge Alan Lourie concurred in the Federal Circuit’s decision to vacate and remand the case for reevaluation of the claimed design in light of the majority opinion but did not agree that Rosen and Durling needed to be overruled. He believed that all that was necessary was to make the Rosen and Durling precedents less rigid by removing the use of “must” and “only” in their analyses. Judge Lourie further opined that the Rosen-Durling test has been applied to design patents for decades and that overruling the standard was destabilizing.

    Practice Note: The Federal Circuit’s ruling changes the obviousness requirements for design patents to a less rigid standard, which can open design patents to additional scrutiny and validity challenges. Design patents should be sought with this new framework in mind and design patent owners should be aware of this new standard and its implications as it relates to the validity of their design patents.

    Authors

    Amol Parikh

    Partner

    Chicago

    Courtney Cecile Seams

    Associate

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • ESG Update for Funds Offered in the EU: What’s in a Name?

    ESG Update for Funds Offered in the EU: What’s in a Name?

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    ESG Update for Funds Offered in the EU: What’s in a Name?

    May 23, 2024

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Managers that offer ESG-focused funds to European investors should take note of the final “Guidelines on Funds’ Names Using ESG or Sustainability-related Terms” (“Guidelines”) published by the European Securities and Markets Authority (“ESMA”) on 14 May 2024.[1] The Guidelines will affect funds established in the EU and, depending on the approach of the local EU member state regulators, are also likely to affect non-EU funds marketed in accordance with the EU national private placement regimes (“NPPRs”) established under the Alternative Investment Fund Managers Directive.

    The Guidelines will not apply to non-EU funds that have not been notified for marketing in EU countries, such as when a fund is offered to a professional investor in the EU on the basis of a valid reverse solicitation. Equally, the Guidelines will not apply to funds marketed in the United Kingdom.

    Managers of EU funds (both alternative investment funds (“AIFs”) and UCITS) and AIFs registered under NPPRs are already required to comply with Article 6 and, if applicable, Articles 8 or 9 of the EU Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation[2] (“SFDR”) which set out pre-investment disclosure obligations related to sustainability. The Guidelines expand these disclosure obligations where the fund’s name contains any ESG, transition, impact or sustainability-related terms.

    The stated objectives of the Guidelines are to protect EU investors from unsubstantiated or exaggerated sustainability claims and to provide clear and quantifiable criteria for fund managers to determine whether they can use ESG or sustainability-related terms to promote their funds. The basic assumption of the Guidelines is that any fund that uses such terms in its name will either fall within the SFDR disclosure regime under Article 8 (as a fund promoting one or more environmental or social characteristics) or Article 9 (as a fund with a sustainable investment objective).

    The Guidelines require EU regulators (that will commit to the Guidelines) to consider the conditions set out below in their supervisory approaches to funds throughout the life of the fund. A temporary deviation from the threshold and exclusions should be treated as a passive breach which the manager must correct in the best interests of investors, unless such a breach is deliberate.

    Requirements for Funds With ESG or Sustainability-Related Names

    The Guidelines will apply to any funds with environmental, social, governance, transition, impact or sustainability-related terms in their names. ESMA has provided the following definitions and examples of such names:

    • Transition-related names are any terms derived from “transition” (such as “transitioning” “transitional”) or terms such as “improve”, “progress”, “evolution”, “transformation” or “net zero”.
    • Environmental-related terms encompass any word that gives an investor an impression of the promotion of environmental characteristics, such as “green”, “environmental”, “climate”, “ESG” or “SRI”.
    • Social terms include “social”, “equality” or similar.
    • Governance-related terms are “governance”, “controversy” or any other term which gives an impression of a focus on governance.
    • Impact-related names will include any word derived from “impact”, such as “impacting” or “impactful”.

    Funds with “transition”, “social” or “governance”-related names should:

    • Have 80 percent of their portfolio of investments meet, as applicable, the relevant environmental or social characteristics (within the meaning of Article 8 of SFDR) or sustainable investment objectives (within the meaning of Article 9 of SFDR); and
    • Exclude investments in companies involved in: (i) any activities related to controversial weapons, (ii) cultivation and production of tobacco, and (iii) in companies that administrators of EU Paris-aligned Benchmarks exclude on the basis that they are in violation of the United Nations Global Compact (UNGC) principles or the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises (collectively, the “Climate Transition Benchmark Exclusions”).[3]

    Funds with “environmental” or “impact”-related terms in their name must also meet the above 80 percent investment proportion threshold and the above Climate Transition Benchmark Exclusions. In addition, these funds must also exclude investments in companies that derive (i) 1 percent or more of their revenues from exploration, mining, extraction, distribution or refining hard coal and lignite, (ii) 10 percent or more of their revenues from the exploration, extraction, distribution or refining of oil fuels, (iii) 50 percent or more of their revenues from the exploration, extraction, manufacturing or distribution of gaseous fuels, or (iv) 50 percent or more of their revenues from electricity generation with a GHG intensity of more than 100g CO2e/kWH (together with the Climate Transition Benchmark Exclusions, the “Paris-aligned Benchmark Exclusions”).[4]

    Funds with “sustainability”-related terms in their name must (i) meet the above 80 percent investment threshold, (ii) excludes investments falling within the Paris-aligned Benchmark Exclusions; and (iii) commit to invest meaningfully in sustainable investments as referred to in Article 2(17) of SFDR. The term “meaningfully” has not been defined and no specific threshold of sustainable investments has been proposed.

    Funds with “transition” or “impact”-related terms in their names should additionally ensure that investments that are used to meet the 80 percent threshold are on a “clear and measurable path to social or environmental transition or are made with the objective to generate a positive and measurable impact alongside a financial return”.

    Funds with names combining multiple terms are subject to the above requirements cumulatively. The only exception is for “transition”-related terms where only the requirements applicable to “transition”, “social” and “governance” fund names apply.

    Funds designating an index as a reference benchmark should only the use the relevant ESG or sustainability names if the fund also satisfies the guidelines associated with the name, as set out above.

    All funds falling within the above categories must disclose the binding elements of their investment strategy using the pre-contractual disclosure templates set out in the Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2022/1288.[5]

    Next Steps

    The Guidelines will apply three months following their publication on ESMA’s website in the official languages of EU member states. There will a six-month transition period for existing funds. Any new funds established after the application date should apply the Guidelines immediately.

    Authored by Anna Maleva-Otto and Matthew Dow.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] European Securities and Markets Authority, Final Report, Guidelines on funds’ names using ESG or sustainability-related terms, 14 May 2024.

    [2] Regulation (EU) 2019/2088.

    [3] Articles 12(1)(a) to (c) of Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2020/1818.

    [4] Articles 12(1)(a) to (g) of Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2020/1818.

    [5] Annex II & III of the Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2022/1288  


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel International LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. © 2024 Schulte Roth & Zabel International LLP. All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • The Gopher State Goes for It: Minnesota Passes Consumer Data Privacy Law

    The Gopher State Goes for It: Minnesota Passes Consumer Data Privacy Law

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    The Gopher State Goes for It: Minnesota Passes Consumer Data Privacy Law

    May 22, 2024

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Consult our interactive state privacy law map to learn more about all of the enacted state consumer privacy laws.


    On May 19, 2024, the Minnesota Legislature passed a comprehensive privacy bill, sending the Minnesota Consumer Data Privacy Act (MCDPA) to Governor Tim Walz’s desk for signature into law.

    The law, which would take effect July 31, 2025 (except for postsecondary institutions, which could have until July 31, 2029), is similar to prior state consumer privacy laws but with several twists. These differences will require additional compliance steps for companies that might have been subject to previously implemented state consumer privacy laws.

    In depth

    Who Does MCDPA Apply To?

    MCDPA applies to any person that conducts business in Minnesota or provides products or services that are targeted to Minnesota residents and, during the immediately preceding calendar year, either:

    1. Controlled or processed the personal data of at least 100,000 Minnesota consumers (excluding that personal data controlled or processed solely for the purpose of completing a payment transaction); or
    2. Controlled or processed the personal data of at least 25,000 Minnesota consumers and derives more than 25% of their gross revenue from the sale of personal data.

    These conditions track with what had been (before the recent trend of state consumer privacy laws) the norm from the Connecticut and Virginia models. However, MCDPA also applies to technology providers under Minnesota’s educational data laws (i.e., entities that provide technology to schools).

    Who Is a “Consumer”?

    MCDPA follows the majority of other states and defines a consumer to be an individual who is a resident of Minnesota acting only in the individual context (i.e., excluding employment or commercial actors).

    What Is “Personal Data”?

    The definition of “personal data” looks familiar as well: information that is linked or reasonably linkable to an identified or identifiable natural person but excluding de-identified data or publicly available information.

    Who Can Enforce?

    Minnesota’s attorney general has exclusive enforcement power. With respect to an alleged violation on or before January 31, 2026, the attorney general must provide a warning letter and a 30-day cure period prior to initiating any action. Civil penalties can be up to $7,500 per violation.

    Who Is Exempt?

    MCDPA includes a short list of entity-level exemptions, including for government entities, certain financial entities such as banks and insurance companies, small businesses, airlines and federally recognized American Indian tribes. Minnesota continues the state-law trend of applying to nonprofits unless the entity is engaged in certain conduct (here, to detect and prevent fraudulent acts in connection with insurance).

    MCDPA’s list of data-level exemptions is fairly standard, including data processed in accordance with a variety of federal laws, such as the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act, federal research laws, the Fair Credit Reporting Act, the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act, the Driver’s Privacy Protection Act and the Farm Credit Act, among others.

    What Obligations Are Imposed?

    Controllers under MCDPA are subject to a number of obligations, including requirements to:

    1. Limit the collection of personal data to what is adequate, relevant and reasonably necessary in relation to the purposes for which the data is processed and disclosed to the consumer;
    2. Avoid processing personal data for secondary reasons (purposes that are neither reasonably necessary to nor compatible with the initial disclosed purposes) without the consumer’s prior consent;
    3. Establish, implement and maintain reasonable administrative, technical and physical data security practices (to protect the confidentiality, integrity and accessibility of personal data appropriate to the volume and nature of the personal data at issue);
    4. Not collect, process or share sensitive data except where strictly necessary to provide or maintain a specific consumer-requested product or service;
    5. Not process personal data in violation of laws that prohibit unlawful discrimination against consumers, and refrain from discriminating against consumers that exercise their rights;
    6. Not process personal data for the purposes of targeted advertising or sell personal data if the controller knows that the consumer is between 13 and 16 years old;
    7. Provide consumers with a reasonably accessible, clear and meaningful privacy notice that includes the disclosures now common under state consumer privacy laws. Thankfully, MCDPA expressly states that a Minnesota-specific privacy notice or section of a privacy policy is not required where the body of the privacy policy otherwise includes the required disclosures; and
    8. Document and maintain a description of the policies and procedures developed to comply with the requirements of MCDPA. Those documents must (i) include the name and contact information for the individual with responsibility for the policies and (ii) include a description of policies and procedures developed to implement different aspects of MCDPA including, for example, data minimization principles.

    Of all these requirements, the last is a twist on other state laws. While most companies have likely already adopted some policies to implement other state privacy laws, companies will need to check those polices – or draft new ones – to ensure that they address the requirements of MCDPA.

    What Consumer Rights Are Created by MCDPA?

    MCDPA provides Minnesota consumers with consumer rights that should look familiar, with one notable exception relating to profiling:

    1. The right to confirm whether or not the controller is processing the consumer’s personal data and to access that data, if being processed;
    2. The right to correct personal data, taking into account the nature of the data and the purposes of the processing of that data;
    3. The right to require the controller to delete personal data concerning the consumer, unless required by law to retain the data;
    4. The right to data portability when data processing is done through automated means;
    5. Opt-out rights for targeted advertising, the sale of personal data and profiling, where profiling is being performed by automated means that produce legal or similarly significant effects concerning a consumer;
    6. Where a consumer’s personal data is profiled to advance decisions that produce legal effects or similarly significant effects (e.g., housing, lending, financial, education), a right to request the result of the profiling, to be informed of the reason that the profiling resulted in the decision and, if feasible, to be informed of what actions the consumer might have taken to secure a different decision. Where the profiling was performed on incorrect data, the consumer has the right to request a correction of the information and a reevaluation of the profile;
    7. A right to obtain a list of specific third parties to which a company has disclosed the consumer’s personal information; and
    8. The right to appeal rights requests that have not been fulfilled.

    Sensitive Data

    MCDPA has a list of sensitive data that generally tracks with other state consumer privacy laws:

    • Racial or ethnic origin, religious beliefs, mental or physical health condition or diagnosis, sexual orientation, or citizenship or immigration status;
    • The processing of biometric or genetic information for the purpose of unique identification;
    • Personal data of a known child (under 13); or
    • Specific geolocation data.

    The twist here is in the definition of “specific geolocation data.” Whereas other state laws define that or similar terms as within a radius of a certain number of feet, under MCDPA, specific geolocation data includes (i) GPS-level latitude and longitude or (ii) other mechanisms, that directly identify the geographic coordinates of a consumer or device linked to a consumer with an accuracy of more than three decimal degrees of latitude and longitude or the equivalent in an alternative geographic coordinate system or (iii) a street address derived from either set of coordinates in (i) or (ii).

    Response to Consumer Requests

    Following the same framework as most states, under MCDPA, controllers must respond to a data subject request within 45 days after receipt, with a 45-day extension available as reasonably necessary. If denied, the controller must provide a method to appeal the denial of a request and make the process conspicuously available. A decision on the appeal must be provided within 45 days of receipt of the consumer’s appeal, which can be extended by 60 additional days. If an appeal is denied, the decision must include a method for the consumer to submit a complaint with the Minnesota attorney general.

    Data Protection Assessments

    MCDPA also requires controllers to conduct “data privacy and protection assessment[s]” for:

    1. Processing personal data for targeted advertising;
    2. Selling personal data;
    3. Processing sensitive data;
    4. Processing involving personal data that presents a heightened risk of harm to consumers (an undefined phrase in MCDPA); and
    5. Processing personal data for purposes of profiling, where the profiling presents a reasonably foreseeable risk of (i) unfair or deceptive treatment; (ii) financial, physical or reputational injury; (iii) a physical or other intrusion on the private affairs of a consumer; or (iv) other substantial injury to consumers.

    The assessments must identify and compare the processing activity’s benefits that may flow to all parties and potential risks to consumer rights. Like other state privacy laws, MCDPA allows impact assessments performed for other state privacy laws to satisfy its assessment requirements.

    When Does MCDPA Take Effect?

    Assuming it is signed into law, MCDPA will go into effect on July 31, 2025.

    ***

    The plethora of unique state privacy laws is becoming more challenging as each new version is introduced. In addition to implementing comprehensive privacy programs, organizations need to ensure they are reviewing applicability and updating internal policies and procedures as needed to maintain compliance. If you have questions or need assistance in readiness work for the new state consumer laws, please contact your regular McDermott lawyer or reach out to David Saunders.

    Authors

    David P. Saunders

    Partner

    Chicago

    James S. Mann

    Associate

    Los Angeles

    More insights

  • Supreme Court: Pure Omissions Cannot Support Rule 10b-5(b) Liability

    Supreme Court: Pure Omissions Cannot Support Rule 10b-5(b) Liability

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Supreme Court: Pure Omissions Cannot Support Rule 10b-5(b) Liability

    May 22, 2024

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On April 12, 2024, the Supreme Court of the United States unanimously held in Macquarie Infrastructure Corp. v. Moab Partners, L.P. that pure omissions are not actionable under Rule 10b-5(b), promulgated by the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) pursuant to Section 10(b) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (Exchange Act). The failure to make a material disclosure required by Item 303 of Regulation S-K cannot support a right of action under Rule 10b-5(b) when such failure does not render any “statements made” misleading.

    Key Takeaways:

    • Pure omissions are not actionable under Rule 10b-5(b). The omission of information from a public disclosure may only serve as the basis for Rule 10b-5(b) liability if that omission renders an affirmative statement misleading.
    • This case may not change market practice with respect to disclosure drafting because public companies remain obligated to disclose known trends or uncertainties as required by Item 303 of Regulation S-K and could face liability for omissions under other statutory provisions.
    In depth

    Case Background

    Section 10(b) of the Exchange Act makes it unlawful for any person to “use or employ, in connection with the purchase or sale of any security . . . any manipulative or deceptive device or contrivance in contravention of such rules and regulations as the [SEC] may prescribe.” Rule 10b-5(b) implements Section 10(b), making it unlawful for a person to “make any untrue statement of a material fact or to omit to state a material fact necessary in order to make the statements made, in the light of the circumstances under which they were made, not misleading.” Separately, Item 303 of Regulation S-K requires public companies to disclose in periodic filings with the SEC any “known trends or uncertainties that have had or that are reasonably likely to have a material favorable or unfavorable impact on net sales or revenues or income from continuing operations.” Item 303 is required in an issuer’s quarterly (10-Q) and annual (10-K) reports as part of Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations.

    As alleged in the underlying complaint, Macquarie Infrastructure Corporation owned infrastructure-related businesses, including terminals that stored high-sulfur fuel oil. In 2016, the United Nations International Maritime Organization adopted a regulation severely limiting the use of that same high-sulfur fuel oil by early 2020 (IMO 2020). Macquarie did not discuss IMO 2020 in its public disclosures or in its filings with the SEC. In 2018, Macquarie announced that business for its fuel storage terminals dropped, due in part to IMO 2020. Macquarie’s share price declined by approximately 41% following the announcement. Investors brought a securities class action, alleging that Macquarie’s failure to disclose the anticipated effect of the IMO 2020 ban on its fuel storage business violated Item 303 of Regulation S-K and that Macquarie’s alleged omission triggered liability under Rule 10b-5(b). The US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, under its precedent, decided in the investors’ favor.

    The Supreme Court’s Decision

    The Supreme Court rejected the investors’ claim and vacated the Second Circuit’s decision, reasoning that the text of Rule 10b-5(b) only prohibits omitting a material fact necessary “to make the statements made . . . not misleading.” The Court emphasized that the focus of Section 10(b) and Rule 10b-5 is fraud, not disclosure: “Section 10(b) is . . . a catchall provision, but what it catches must be fraud.”

    Other disclosure requirements generally support claims based on pure omissions. Section 11(a) of the Securities Act of 1933 proscribes any registration statement that “omit[s] to state a material fact required to be stated therein.” The Court reasoned that the absence of such language in Rule 10b-5(b) made clear that it was written only to prohibit (i) affirmative false statements and (ii) misleading half-truths, defined as “representations that state the truth only so far as it goes, while omitting critical qualifying information.” Under Macquarie, to succeed in claiming that an omission violates Rule 10b-5(b), a plaintiff must identify an affirmative statement that was rendered misleading as a result of the omission.

    McDermott Insight

    In some ways, the Court’s holding may not change much for public companies. Even if disclosure of certain information may not be required to escape liability under Rule 10b-5(b), public companies are still required to comply with Item 303 of Regulation S-K’s requirements to disclose known trends and uncertainties. The decision also does not impact the SEC’s ability to bring actions based on reporting and other violations, and individual plaintiffs may still pursue claims under Section 11(a). A market trend has yet to emerge indicating whether and how public companies may adjust disclosures in response to the Court’s decision, but issuers who previously included additional disclosures of arguably immaterial detail to err on the side of caution could rethink that balance as affirmative statements of any kind – material or not – could provide a foothold for plaintiffs and the SEC.

    Macquarie could have serious ramifications for fraud claims brought by securities plaintiffs and the SEC. In our view, the Court’s holding will likely push plaintiffs one of two directions: they will either (i) look for textual hooks, such as generic compliance statements and risk factors that are rendered misleading by omission of a known trend or uncertainty or (ii) attempt to pursue traditional misstatement claims under scheme liability theory. The first path presents difficulties for private plaintiffs, who must wrestle with recent jurisprudence questioning whether a specific negative development renders a prior generic statement materially misleading. Plaintiffs will also face challenges when those textual hooks are forward-looking or opinions. As to the second path, both plaintiffs and the SEC could run headlong into caselaw that preserves the distinctions between misstatement liability under Rule 10b-5(b) and scheme liability under Rules 10b-5(a) and (c). Notwithstanding the Supreme Court’s decision in Lorenzo v. SEC, which permitted scheme liability claims based on the knowing dissemination of false statements, many courts continue to require conduct beyond an alleged misstatement or misleading omission to support fraud claims under Rules 10b-5(a) and (c).

    Authors

    Paul M.G. Helms

    Partner

    Chicago, Washington, DC

    Todd R. Kornfeld

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    Daniel L. Woodard

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    Eric Cunningham

    Associate

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • The ACA 1557 final regulations: Plans and plan sponsors as covered entities

    The ACA 1557 final regulations: Plans and plan sponsors as covered entities

    ARTICLE

    The ACA 1557 final regulations: Plans and plan sponsors as covered entities

    May 21, 2024

    Read time: 4 min

    In a recent client alert, we reported on the impact of the final rule interpreting Section 1557 of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) on self-funded group health plans that contract with licensed health insurance issuers to provide administrative services. That article considered instances in which neither the plan sponsor nor the group health plan was a covered entity for Section 1557 purposes. This post starts by assuming that either the plan sponsor or the group health plan is or at least may be a covered entity.

    Section 1557 prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, national origin, sex, age or disability, or any combination thereof, in a health program or activity, any part of which is receiving federal financial assistance. The final rule makes clear an employer’s employment practices, including the sponsorship of a group health plan, are not generally subject to the rule. Thus, an employer does not become subject to Section 1557 by simply offering a group health plan, and a group health plan is not a covered entity where it does not receive federal financial assistance. The preamble cites examples of plans that may (or may not) receive federal financial assistance: Employer Group Waiver Plans (EGWPs), Medicare Advantage plans and Medicare Part D plans.

    Plan Sponsor/Covered Entity

    There are clearly instances in which a plan sponsor is itself a covered entity for Section 1557 purposes. This is the case wherever the plan sponsor is itself principally engaged in providing or administering health programs and activities (e.g., a hospital that accepts Medicare). Where that is the case, all the entities’ operations are also subject to Section 1557. The reference to “all” an entities’ operations usually conjures up images of separate legal entities under common control (e.g., a subsidiary or affiliate of the plan sponsor). But is the covered entity’s group health plan part of the covered entity’s operations? (See, e.g., T.S. v. Heart of CarDon, LLC, holding that Section 1557 applies to all the activities of a covered entity plan sponsor, including its group health plan, regardless of whether the group health plan itself received federal financial assistance.) In the context of the final rule, we are not sure that it matters. The plan sponsor is itself a covered entity that is subject to, and will need to comply with, Section 1557 irrespective of the status of the plan.

    Part D and EGWPs

    According to the preamble to the final rule, EGWPs, Medicare Advantage plans and Part D plans are covered entities where the plan receives federal financial assistance. EGWPs are types of Medicare Advantage plans or Part D prescription drug plans that qualify for waivers of certain Medicare regulations. Prior to the 2003 Medicare Modernization Act, employer-sponsored Part D coverage was the primary source of coverage for retirees. EGWPs, which came later, provided a more flexible alternative for employers seeking the benefits that could be captured through waivers. Whether the EGWP, Medicare Advantage plan or Part D plan is a covered entity for Section 1557 purposes depends on whether the subsidy goes to the plan sponsor or the plan.

    Although some waivers may be restricted to particular entities and/or plans, prescription drug subsidies may generally be paid directly to an employer or to a Medicare Advantage organization or Part D plan sponsor, which is typically a licensed carrier. Where the subsidy is paid to the employer, Section 1557 will not apply (assuming that the plan sponsor is not itself a covered entity, such as a hospital that accepts Medicare). The plan sponsor is not a health program or activity, and the plan does not receive federal financial assistance. But where the subsidy is paid to the plan, then the plan is a covered entity because it is a health program or activity that receives federal financial assistance. This would include most carrier-sponsored arrangements since most carriers qualify as health programs or activities that receive federal financial assistance.

    * * * * *

    A special note of thanks to Chris J. Rylands, Esq., Associate General Counsel, ERISA Compliance & Commercial Transactions, Hub International Limited for calling the Part D-related issues discussed above to my attention.

    More insights

  • The Domestic Content Bonus Credit’s Promising New Safe Harbor

    The Domestic Content Bonus Credit’s Promising New Safe Harbor

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    The Domestic Content Bonus Credit’s Promising New Safe Harbor

    May 21, 2024

    Read time: 11 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On May 16, 2024, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) published Notice 2024-41 (Notice), which modifies Notice 2023-38 (Prior Notice) by providing a new elective safe harbor (Safe Harbor) that will allow taxpayers to use assumed domestic cost percentages in lieu of percentages derived from manufacturers’ direct cost information to determine eligibility for the domestic content bonus credit (Domestic Content Bonus). The Notice grants a promising reprieve to the Prior Notice’s relatively inflexible (and arguably impracticable) standard on seeking direct cost information from manufacturers, raising novel structuring considerations for energy producers, developers, investors and buyers.

    The Notice also expands the list of technologies covered by the Prior Notice (Applicable Projects).

    In this article, we share key takeaways from the Notice as they apply to energy producers, developers and investors and provide a brief overview of the Domestic Content Bonus as well as a high-level summary of the Notice’s substantive content.

    In depth

    Key Takeaways From the Notice

    The Notice provides a key step forward in eliminating qualification challenges for the Domestic Content Bonus by providing an alternative to the Prior Notice’s stringent requirement of seeking direct cost information from manufacturers. In short, a taxpayer can aggregate the assumed percentages in the Notice that correspond with the US-made manufactured products in its project. If the assumed percentages total is greater than the manufactured product percentage applicable to such project (currently 40%), then the taxpayer is treated as satisfying the manufactured product requirement. Although the Notice promises forthcoming proposed regulations that could amend or override the Notice, this gives taxpayers time to appropriately interpret the latest rules and respond accordingly.

    The new guidance’s impact will likely require restructuring to the existing development of energy projects as it relates to the Domestic Content Bonus. Below, we outline some key considerations for energy producers, developers, investors and buyers alike:

    • The Safe Harbor is expected to dramatically increase the availability of the Domestic Content Bonus. The Prior Notice’s challenging cost substantiation requirements left most industry participants on the sidelines. Initial feedback from developers, investors and credit buyers was extremely positive, and we have already seen fulsome renegotiation and speedy agreement between counterparties over domestic content contractual provisions in project documents.
    • While the Safe Harbor eliminates the requirement to seek direct cost information from manufacturers for certain Applicable Projects, a taxpayer’s obligations with respect to substantiation requirements for manufacturers’ US activities is not clear in the Notice. Given the standing federal income tax principles on recordkeeping and substantiation, taxpayers should carefully reconsider positions on diligence and review existing relationships with manufacturers.
    • Although the Notice expressly provides that the Safe Harbor is elective with respect to a specific Applicable Project, it’s unclear whether the Safe Harbor is extended by default to any and all of a taxpayer’s Applicable Projects upon election effect or whether an elective position is required with respect to each Applicable Project. Taxpayers, especially those with multiple Applicable Projects, should consider the various implications resulting from an elective position prior to reliance on the Safe Harbor.
    • For Safe Harbor purposes, the Notice provides a formula for computing a single domestic cost percentage for solar energy property and battery energy storage technologies that are treated as a single energy project (PV+BESS Project), but ambiguity exists as to whether such technologies should be aggregated for other purposes under the investment tax credit.
    • It’s unclear how the calculations would operate for repowered facilities given the assumed domestic cost percentage approach.
    • The Notice limits the Safe Harbor to solar photovoltaic, onshore wind and battery energy storage systems, leaving taxpayers with other types of Applicable Projects stranded with the Prior Notice. For example, the Notice does not cover renewable natural gas or fuel cell. The IRS seeks comments on whether the Safe Harbor should account for other technologies, the criteria and how often the list of technologies should be updated. Affected taxpayers should fully consider the requested comments and provide feedback as necessary.
    • The IRS seeks comments on various issues with respect to taxpayers who have a mix of foreign and domestic manufactured product components (mixed source items). Taxpayers with mixed source items that the Notice attributes as disregarded and entirely foreign sourced (notwithstanding the domestic portion) should take cautionary note and provide feedback as necessary.

    Background: The Domestic Content Bonus Credit

    The Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 spurred the creation of “adder” or “bonus” incentive tax credits. In pertinent part, Applicable Projects could further qualify for an increased credit (i.e., the Domestic Content Bonus) upon satisfaction of the domestic content requirement.

    To qualify for the Domestic Content Bonus, taxpayers must meet two requirements. First, steel or iron components of the Applicable Project that are “structural” in nature must be 100% US manufactured (Steel or Iron Requirement). Second, costs associated with “manufactured components” of the Applicable Project must meet the “adjusted percentage” set forth in the Internal Revenue Code (Manufactured Products Requirement). For projects beginning construction before 2025, the adjusted percentage is 40%.

    The Prior Notice provided guidance for meeting these requirements. Taxpayers should begin by identifying each “Applicable Project Component” (i.e., any article, material or supply, whether manufactured or unmanufactured, that is directly incorporated into an Applicable Project). Subsequently, taxpayers must determine whether the Applicable Project Component is subject to the Steel or Iron Requirement or the Manufactured Products Requirement.

    If the Applicable Project Component is steel or iron, it must be 100% US manufactured with no exception. If the Applicable Project Component is a manufactured product, such component and its “manufactured product components” must be tested as to whether they are US manufactured. If the manufactured product and all its manufactured product components are US manufactured, then the manufacturer’s cost of the manufactured product is included for purposes of satisfying the adjusted percentage. If any of the manufactured product or its manufactured product components are not US manufactured, only the cost to the manufacturer of any US manufactured product components are included.

    The core tension lies in sourcing the total costs from the manufacturer of the manufactured product or its manufactured product components. There’s a substantiation requirement on the taxpayer imposed by the Prior Notice, but there’s also a shrine of secrecy from the corresponding manufacturer.

    Apparently acknowledging the need for reconciliation, the Notice aims to pave a promising path for covered technologies (i.e., solar, onshore wind and battery storage).

    The Modifications: A Promising Path for the Domestic Content Bonus Credit

    New Elective Safe Harbor

    Generally

    The Safe Harbor allows a taxpayer to elect to assume the domestic percentage costs (assumed cost percentages) for manufactured products. Importantly, the election eliminates the requirement for a taxpayer to source a manufacturer’s direct costs with respect to the taxpayer’s Applicable Project and instead allows for the reliance on the assumed cost percentages. The Notice prohibits any partial Safe Harbor reliance, meaning taxpayers who elect to use the Safe Harbor must apply it in its entirety to the Applicable Project for which the taxpayer makes such election.

    The Safe Harbor only applies to the Applicable Projects of solar photovoltaic facilities (solar PV), onshore wind facilities and battery energy storage systems (BESS). Taxpayers with other technologies must continue to comply with the Prior Notice. Notably, the Notice expands Solar PV into four subcategories: Ground-Mount (Tracking), Ground-Mount (Fixed), Rooftop (MLPE) and Rooftop (String), each having differing assumed cost percentages for the respective manufactured product component. Similarly, BESS is expanded into Grid-Scale BESS and Distributed BESS, each with differing assumed cost percentages for the respective manufactured product component.

    For solar PV, onshore wind facilities and BESS, the Safe Harbor provides a list via Table 1[1] (Safe Harbor list) that denotes each relevant manufactured product component with its corresponding assumed cost percentage. Each manufactured product component (and steel or iron component) are classified under a relevant Applicable Project Component.

    Of note are the disproportionately higher assumed cost percentages of certain listed components within the Safe Harbor list. For solar PV, cells under the PV module carry an assumed cost percentage of 36.9% (Ground-Mount (Tracking)), 49.2% (Ground-Mount (Fixed)), 21.5% (Rooftop (MLPE)) or 30.8% (Rooftop (String)).

    For onshore wind facilities, blades and nacelles under wind turbine carry an assumed cost percentage of 31.2% and 47.5%, respectively.

    For BESS, under battery pack, Grid-scale BESS cells and Distributed BESS packaging carry an assumed cost percentage of 38.0% and 30.15%, respectively. Accordingly, projects incorporating US manufactured equipment in these categories are likely to meet the Manufactured Products Requirement with little additional spend. Conversely, projects without these components are unlikely to satisfy the threshold.

    Mechanics of the Safe Harbor

    Reliance on the Safe Harbor is a simple exercise of component selection and subsequent assumed cost percentage addition. Put more specifically, a taxpayer identifies the Applicable Project on the Safe Harbor list and assumes the list of components within (without regard to any components in the taxpayer’s project that are not listed). Then, the taxpayer (i) identifies which of the components within the Safe Harbor list are in their project, (ii) confirms that any steel or iron components on the Safe Harbor list fulfill the Steel or Iron Requirement, and (iii) sums the assumed cost percentages of all identified listed components that are 100% US manufactured to determine whether their Applicable Project meets the relevant adjusted percentage threshold.

    The Notice addresses nuances in situations involving mixed 100% US manufactured and 100% foreign manufactured components that are of like-kind, component production costs and treatment for PV+BESS Projects.

    The Notice also provides that a taxpayer adjusts for a mix of US manufactured and foreign manufactured components by applying a weighted formula to account for the foreign components.

    Consistent with the Prior Notice, the Notice provides that the assumed cost percentage of “production” costs may be summed and included in the domestic cost percentage only if all the manufactured product components of a manufactured product are 100% US manufactured.

    Lastly, in accordance with the view that a PV+BESS Project is treated as a single project, the Notice provides that a taxpayer may use a weighted formula to determine a single domestic content percentage for the project.

    The numerator is the sum of the (i) aggregated assumed cost percentages of the manufactured product components that constitute the solar PV multiplied by the solar PV nameplate capacity and (ii) aggregated assumed cost percentages of the manufactured product components that constitute BESS multiplied by the BESS nameplate capacity and the “BESS multiplier.” The BESS multiplier converts the BESS nameplate capacity into proportional equivalency (i.e., equivalent units) to the solar PV nameplate capacity. The denominator is the sum of the solar PV nameplate capacity and the BESS nameplate capacity. Divided accordingly, the final fraction constitutes the single domestic content percentage that the taxpayer uses to determine whether its PV+BESS Project meets the relevant manufactured product adjusted percentage threshold.

    Additionally, the Notice confirms that taxpayers can ignore any components not included in the Safe Harbor list. Compared with the Prior Notice, this can be a benefit for taxpayers with non-US manufactured products that are not on the Safe Harbor list. Conversely, for taxpayers with US manufactured products that are not on the Safe Harbor list, they lose the benefit of including such costs in the Manufactured Products Requirement. However, this is mostly a benefit because it eliminates any ambiguity surrounding the treatment of components not listed in the Prior Notice.

    Expansion of Covered Technologies

    The Notice adds “hydropower facility or pumped hydropower storage facility” to the list of Applicable Projects as a modification to Table 2 in the Prior Notice. The modification is complete with a list of a hydropower facility or pumped hydropower storage facility’s Applicable Project Components that are delineated as either steel or iron components or manufactured products, though no assumed cost percentages are provided. Further, the Prior Notice’s “utility-scale photovoltaic system” is redesignated as “ground-mount and rooftop photovoltaic system.”

    Certification

    To elect to rely on the Safe Harbor, in its domestic content certification statement, a taxpayer must provide a statement that says they are relying on the Safe Harbor. This is submitted with the taxpayer’s tax return.

    Reliance and Comment Period

    Taxpayers may rely on the rules set forth in the Notice and the Prior Notice (as modified by the Notice) for Applicable Projects, the construction of which begins within 90 days after the publication of intended forthcoming proposed regulations.

    Comments should be received by July 15, 2024.

    Conclusion

    While this article provides a high-level summary of the substantive content in the Notice, the many potential implications resulting from these developments merit additional attention. We will continue to follow the development of the guidance and provide relevant updates as necessary.

    If you have questions about the tax implications of the Notice or other Domestic Content Bonus concerns, including project development or related investment structuring, please reach out to the authors of this article or your regular McDermott lawyer(s).

    Authors

    Heather Cooper

    Partner

    Miami

    Philip Tingle

    Partner

    Miami

    John Zhang

    Associate

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • Colorado Changes Rules for Determining Members of Combined Filing Group

    Colorado Changes Rules for Determining Members of Combined Filing Group

    ARTICLE

    Colorado Changes Rules for Determining Members of Combined Filing Group

    May 20, 2024

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Colorado Governor Jared Polis has signed legislation that would replace Colorado’s unique “3 of 6” rule for determining the members of a unitary group for combined reporting purposes and instead adopt what Legislative Council Staff has called “the Multistate Tax Commission’s standard” for determining the members of a combined filing group.

    Under current law, a combined report may only contain those members of an affiliated group of corporations as to which three of the following six facts have been in existence in the tax return year and the two preceding years:

    1. Sales or leases between one affiliate and another constitute 50% or more of the gross operating receipts or cost of goods sold of the entity making the sales/leases
    2. Certain back-office services are provided by one affiliate for the benefit of another
    3. Twenty percent or more of the long-term debt of one affiliate is owed to or guaranteed by another affiliate
    4. One affiliate substantially uses certain intellectual property of another affiliate
    5. Fifty percent or more of the board of one affiliate are members of the board or are corporate officers of another affiliate
    6. Twenty-five percent or more of the 20 highest ranking officers of an affiliate are members of the board or are corporate officers of another affiliate.

    Under the new law all members of a “unitary business” will be required to file a combined report. A “unitary business” is defined as an affiliated group of entities “that are sufficiently interdependent, integrated, and interrelated through their activities so as to provide a synergy and mutual benefit that produces a sharing or exchange of value among them and a significant flow of value to the separate parts.”

    The new law keeps Colorado’s water’s-edge rule in place, but it’s notable that said rule provides an exception for any entity “incorporated in a foreign jurisdiction for the purpose of tax avoidance” while identifying a list of nations where a corporation will be presumed to be incorporated for tax avoidance purposes (including the Cayman Islands, Luxembourg, Monaco, etc.).

    Presuming Colorado voters don’t file a referendum petition and get the legislation overturned in November, the new standard would go into effect for tax years beginning on or after January 1, 2026.

    Authors

    Stephen P. Kranz

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Michael J. Hilkin

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights
    Endnotes

  • On the Stand With Doug Carsten

    On the Stand With Doug Carsten

    ARTICLE

    On the Stand With Doug Carsten

    May 20, 2024

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Doug Carsten is the co-head of McDermott’s life sciences industry practice and focuses on complex patent litigation disputes. His substantial first-chair trial experience includes litigating high-profile and billion-dollar patent cases.

    In this Q&A, Doug shares what he enjoys most about being a trial lawyer, his go-to advice for junior lawyers and how “My Cousin Vinny” has played a pivotal role in his career.

    In depth

    Why did you become a trial lawyer?

    The short answer is “My Cousin Vinny.” I was in graduate school for chemistry, and I was miserable. I saw the movie “My Cousin Vinny” and thought, “That’s exactly what I want to do.”

    The longer answer is there’s absolutely nothing like trying a case. In my view, it’s the pinnacle of lawyering. Being a trial lawyer requires you to think incredibly quickly on your feet with every ounce of concentration you can muster. You play the part of psychotherapist, strategist, field marshal, counselor, ringmaster and actor. You need to excel at the different skill sets required for each role.

    You also never know where the next hour of trial is going to go, but it’s up to you to create it. Trial lawyers build that universe that exists within the courtroom for everyone to see. I love doing that.

    What is a common issue you see clients face going into trial, and how do you avoid it?

    In trial, unlike many things in life, you have a definite winner and a definite loser. There’s a lot of risk involved, and it’s a risk that’s outside of the client’s hands.

    The clients that I work with are sophisticated C-suite executives at big companies. They’re used to their word being taken at face value. They’re not used to dealing with a situation where so much authority and power is taken out of their hands.

    To get my clients in front of this uncertainty, I have important discussions with them ahead of trial. I must make sure they are OK with giving up some of that power. I also help them decide whether they can get comfortable relinquishing power and if they prefer a potential resolution instead of going to trial.

    A good trial lawyer should always be ready to try the case, but you must also recognize when the client can achieve a better result elsewhere. I give clients my best advice as to when to play it out and when to fold the hand.

    What is the proudest moment of your career to date?

    I like to think that my proudest moment in the courtroom is going to be some time in the future.

    I’ve been able to get some great results for my clients. But what I’m most proud of is giving younger lawyers every opportunity to become a far better trial lawyer than I could ever hope to be. I’m fortunate to have been able to watch some amazing younger lawyers develop and grow into the trial lawyers they are today, knowing that I’ve had a small hand in shaping their careers.

    We are stewards of our profession, and mentoring young lawyers is the thing I love best about what I do.

    What advice do you give to junior trial lawyers before their first trial?

    My advice is you must know who you are. I learned to practice law by essentially watching people who had been practicing a lot longer than I had. I watched what they did and how they behaved in certain situations. And I constantly asked myself, “Is that something that resonates with who I am? Is that something that I could do and would be comfortable doing?”

    I often give the example of watching Johnnie Cochran arguing to the jury, “If it doesn’t fit, you must acquit.” I could never pull that off, but I admired and respected the concept of distilling a very complicated case into something so simple. That’s a lesson I apply in a way that is consistent with who I am.

    So, I encourage every young lawyer to soak up everything they can when working with very skilled and successful trial lawyers, retaining the traits that resonate with who they are. Juries can easily sniff out insincerity, and they’ll know if you’re not being authentic. You need to figure out who you are as a trial lawyer and play to those strengths. That’s when great things happen and lawyers can really shine in court.

    What is one thing people wouldn’t learn about you by looking at your bio?

    Working through cases with a team and being in the courtroom energizes me. In a perfect job, I would try three or four big cases a year. I would learn everything I could about a case, try it, forget it and then pick up the next one.

    Unfortunately, cases don’t quite work that way, so I value any time I get to have in the courtroom. And I try to get a line from “My Cousin Vinny” on the transcript in every trial.

    Authors

    Douglas H. Carsten

    Partner

    San Diego

    More insights