Content Type: Article

  • Non-Subpart F Sales Income: Employee Substance Generally Is Not a Requirement

    ARTICLE

    Non-Subpart F Sales Income: Employee Substance Generally Is Not a Requirement

    September/October 2017

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Lowell Yoder wrote this bylined article, which discusses the scope of the definition of Subpart F sales income. It points out that while employee-substance is required to satisfy the manufacturing exception, this is not a requirement to fall outside the general definition of Subpart F sales income. The plain language of the Code and Regulations as well as case law supports this conclusion, Mr. Yoder wrote.

    In depth
    Authors

    Lowell D. Yoder

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • New Cybersecurity Report Asks the Private Sector to Join Forces with the Government

    New Cybersecurity Report Asks the Private Sector to Join Forces with the Government

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    New Cybersecurity Report Asks the Private Sector to Join Forces with the Government

    September 13, 2017

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The government is continuing to ask for more help from the private sector to defend against cyber attacks. The National Infrastructure Advisory Council (NIAC) recently published a report discussing current cyber threats and urging private companies and executives to join forces with the government to better address those threats. The report proposes “public-private and company-to-company information sharing of cyber threats at network speed,” among other things discussed here.

    In depth

    The National Infrastructure Advisory Council (NIAC) recently published a report that identifies cyber threats and urges private companies and executives to join forces with the government to better address those threats. See The President’s National Infrastructure Advisory Council, Securing Cyber Assets, Addressing Urgent Cyber Threats to Critical Infrastructure (Aug. 15, 2017) (NIAC Report). Among other things, the report cites the lack of information sharing and coordination between private parties and various governmental bodies as a primary reason why the nation “remain[s] unable to move actionable information to the right people at the speed required by cyber threats.” NIAC Report, at 5. According to NIAC, “it is imperative that Federal and private roles in defending these systems are aligned and mutually supportive.” NIAC Report, at 5.

    In short, the government is asking for private sector help in its fight against cyber attacks. NIAC’s proposals include “public-private and company-to-company information sharing of cyber threats at network speed.” NIAC Report, at 8. NIAC refers to risks associated with sharing “real-time system data with the Federal Government” including unspecified “significant business risks and liability” issues. NIAC Report, at 8. NIAC does not propose any specific way to alleviate those risks, but states that a pilot program should be used to “work through legal and liability barriers.” NIAC Report, at 8. NIAC also makes some general references to incentives that could be provided to private parties for their participation. While NIAC does provide a number of useful suggestions, many of the issues that are most important to private sector participants are not described in detail. First, NIAC has not provided any specifics about the incentives the government would be willing to offer. Second, though NIAC has identified unspecified risks associated with sharing information with the government it has not provided any guidance about how to limit those risks.

    The President Ordered a Review of the Nation’s Cybersecurity System

    On May 11, 2017, President Trump issued Executive Order 13800 titled Strengthening the Cybersecurity of Federal Networks and Critical Infrastructure. The president noted that “the executive branch has for too long accepted antiquated and difficult-to-defend IT.” Exec. Order No. 13800, ¶ 1(b)(ii). The Executive Order also states that “known but unmitigated vulnerabilities are among the highest cybersecurity risks faced by executive departments and agencies” and the “known vulnerabilities include using operating systems or hardware beyond the vendor’s support lifecycle, declining to implement a vendor’s security patch, or failing to execute security-specific configuration guidance.” Exec. Order No. 13800, ¶ 1(b)(iv).

    NIAC was established in 2001 to advise the president on practical strategies for industry and government to reduce complex risks to the designated critical infrastructure sectors. In support of Executive Order No. 13800, the National Security Council asked NIAC to identify cybersecurity issues and examine “how Federal authorities and capabilities can best be applied to support cybersecurity of high-risk assets.” NIAC Report, at 2. On August 15, 2017, NIAC issued its report.

    NIAC’s Report Asks Private Parties to Coordinate with the Government to Defend against Cyber Attacks

    NIAC’s Report contains a number of suggestions and requests for participation from private parties. The Report remarks that NIAC “believes the U.S. government and private sector collectively have the tremendous cyber capabilities and resources needed to defend critical private systems from aggressive cyber attacks—provided they are properly organized, harnessed, and focused. Today, we’re falling short.” NIAC Report, at 3, 5. Most of NIAC’s suggestions relate to information sharing and the need for “the Federal Government to apply its collective authorities and capabilities in concert with the private sector.” NIAC Report, at 5.

    NIAC recommends a “private-sector-led pilot of machine-to-machine information sharing technologies” in order to “test public-private and company-to-company information sharing of cyber threats at network speed.” NIAC Report, at 3. One key task that the NIAC recommends is to “work through legal and liability barriers that hamper or limit company-to-company and government-to-company sharing today.” NIAC Report, at 8. The report notes that this sort of information sharing would require “significant trust regarding how information will be protected, shared, and used.” NIAC Report, at 8. NIAC also notes that “leaked data creates significant business risks and liability protections are not court-tested.” NIAC Report, at 8. NIAC makes various references to “business risks and liability protections,” “legal and liability barriers that hamper or limit company-to-company and government-to-company sharing today” and “significant legal, liability, technology, trust, and cost challenges.” NIAC Report, at 8, 15. However, NIAC does not provide any information as to what those business risks and liability barriers actually are and what private sector participants can do to alleviate those concerns.

    It further recommends a public-private “task force of experts in government and the electricity, finance, and communications industries” and an “optimum cybersecurity governance approach to direct and coordinate the cyber defense of the nation.” NIAC Report, at 4. NIAC states that the government “must champion cybersecurity with the private sector” and “direct an operational team of cross-agency, public-private staff to triage and make headway on the biggest needs.” NIAC Report, at 17. NIAC also suggests detailed testing of the government’s reactions to cyber incidents and to “invite executives and representatives from the Financial Services and Communications sectors to participate in exercise planning, ownership, and execution.” NIAC Report, at 18. NIAC also recommends expedited declassification of cyber threat information to be shared with owners and operators of critical infrastructure. NIAC Report, at 4. It states that the present “inability to rapidly declassify and share the less-sensitive elements of a potential threat, like threat indicators or vulnerabilities, leaves private companies in the dark for too long.” NIAC Report, at 14. To help with the declassification, NIAC also wants to “engage and embed cleared private sector representatives from the most critical infrastructure asserts in government intelligence and information sharing centers to help inform and prioritize information declassification.” NIAC Report, at 14.

    Incentives for Upgrading Cyber Infrastructure and Attempting to Increase the

    Cybersecurity Work Force

    NIAC also references unspecified incentives that should be given to those private sector parties who strengthen cybersecurity infrastructures. It suggests “limited time, outcome-based market incentives that encourage owners and operators to upgrade cyber infrastructure, invest in state-of-the-art technologies, and meet industry standards or best practices.” NIAC Report, at 12. NIAC also suggests that organizations should be incentivized to adopt the NIST Cybersecurity Framework (which was itself created “through collaboration between government and the private sector”). See National Institute of Standards and Technology, Framework for Improving Critical Infrastructure Cybersecurity, Version 1.0 (Feb. 12, 2014). A draft version of a revised framework was released on January 10, 2017. National Institute of Standards and Technology, Framework for Improving Critical Infrastructure Cybersecurity, Draft Version 1.1 (Jan. 10, 2017); NIAC Report, at 12. However, there are no specifics as to what incentives will be given or how “out-come based market incentives” could or would be determined. NIAC Report, at 12.

    NIAC notes a shortfall of qualified cybersecurity professionals which it estimates will result in 1.8 million unfilled positions by 2011. NIAC Report, at 11. It suggests scholarships and sponsorship clearances for college-age prospective cyber professionals. NIAC Report, at 11. In this area too, NIAC suggests private sector participation stating that “federal cyber experts have a limited understanding of unique private sector systems, which limits their ability to provide technical assistance.” NIAC Report, at 11. NIAC also recommends identifying and employing “best-in-class Scanning Tools and Assessment Practices” and streamlining and significantly expediting the Security Clearance Processes and declassification processes to ensure that key persons can “access secure facilities within one hour of a major threat or incident.” NIAC Report, at 10, 13.

    Conclusion

    NIAC states that the “time to act is now” and “as a Nation, we need to move past simply studying our cybersecurity challenges and begin taking meaningful steps to improve our cybersecurity to prevent a major debilitating attack.” NIAC Report, at 21. NIAC has doled out a number of tasks to various government agencies and requested significant assistance from private parties. However, the government has yet to give guidance to private sector participants related to the incentives it will offer and how to limit the unspecified liability concerns referenced in the NIAC Report. The private sector will need to continue waiting for guidance on these critical issues, each of which contributes to the lack of information sharing and increased cybersecurity infrastructure that NIAC hopes to address.

    Authors

    Michael G. Morgan

    Partner

    Los Angeles, Silicon Valley

    More insights

  • US Immigration under the Trump Administration: What We Know and What We Think We Know

    US Immigration under the Trump Administration: What We Know and What We Think We Know

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT / US POLICY

    US Immigration under the Trump Administration: What We Know and What We Think We Know

    September 12, 2017

    Read time: 11 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    President Donald J. Trump recently issued an Executive Order, followed by a proposed bill and other guidance, which would drastically change the current immigration system. Based on these developments, employers should be prepared for immigration hiring changes and may want to consider applying now for immigrant status for affected key employees.

    In depth

    After months of discussions on immigration issues, promises of sweeping reform and rumors about what reform would entail, President Donald J. Trump recently issued an Executive Order, followed by a proposed bill and other guidance, which would drastically change the current immigration system. The following summary highlights some of the proposed changes, actual changes and rumors which may or may not be based on fact.

    Buy American, Hire American

    The Buy American, Hire American Executive Order, signed by President Trump on April 18, 2017, promises a commitment to protect jobs for US workers, create higher wages and increase job opportunities and employment rates. The Executive Order broadly demonstrates an intent to vigorously enforce immigration laws, taking particular aim at the H-1B visa program.

    The H-1B specialty occupation visa is available to those who hold at least a bachelor’s degree and who will work for US companies in positions which require the specific degree. Under the current H-1B visa program, 65,000 visas are available each fiscal year, with an additional 20,000 visas reserved for graduates of US master’s programs or higher. A “specialty occupation” is loosely defined as one which requires at least a bachelor’s degree based on education or a combination of education plus experience. Due to high demand for H-1B visas, over the past few years petitions have been selected by US Citizenship & Immigration Service (USCIS) for adjudication through a random lottery. The number of petitions submitted has been almost three times the number of available visas, leaving both employers and visa candidates disappointed. While there has been criticism that the current H-1B program may allow foreign workers to take coveted jobs from US workers, many employers feel the H-1B program is not generous enough to allow them to fill open positions.

    While the Executive Order does not specify how the H-1B visa program will change, rumors have abounded. There have been discussions of limiting H-1B visas to those with both higher education and significant experience, as well as requiring that a position offered to an H-1B applicant must pay a minimum salary in the area of $120,000 or more. Filing fees for H-1B visa petitions may also be raised. Though currently there are no formal changes to the program, practitioners are seeing increased scrutiny of pending H-1B visa petitions. In particular, H-1B visa petitions filed for entry-level positions and/or lower paying positions are receiving requests for evidence, asking petitioning employers to explain how such positions qualify as a “specialty occupation.” The definition of specialty occupation in current regulations does not include a review of the level of position or the salary offered, provided that the salary meets at least the “prevailing wage” which can be determined in a number of ways. Though the increased scrutiny is under fire by immigration law groups and some business organizations because it is considered rule-making without an actual rule, the current trend does provide a glimpse into what a future H-1B visa program could require.

    RAISE Act

    The Reforming American Immigration for Strong Employment Act (S. 354), known as the RAISE Act, was introduced by President Trump, Senator Tom Cotton (R-AR) and Senator David Perdue (R-GA) on August 2, 2017. The RAISE Act would make the kind of sweeping immigration reforms that have been promised by the Trump administration. Not only would the RAISE Act decrease the number of immigrant visa to 140,000, half the current number allowable each fiscal year, but it would move the process to a point system. The Diversity Visa Lottery, a true lottery offering a limited number of immigrant visas each fiscal year to those from certain countries, would no longer exist.

    Under the present immigrant visa system, visas are allotted in one tier based on family relationships and in another tier based on employment offers. Employers can petition for immigrant visas on behalf of individuals they have selected to fill a need within their businesses. The process is rigorous and involves scrutiny and evaluation by both the US Department of Labor and USCIS. Point systems are a part of legal immigration in Canada, the UK, Australia and New Zealand. Under the RAISE Act, individuals would qualify for immigrant visas based on points assigned for a number of factors including age, education, English language proficiency, job offer, extraordinary achievement and intent to invest in the US. The job offer awards points based on salary, using the median household income as a measuring stick.

    Notably, under the RAISE Act, family-based immigration would all but disappear, allowing US citizens and legal permanent residents to petition only for spouses and minor children under age 18. Under the present system, a US citizen can petition for a parent or sibling and US citizen parents can petition for adult children age 21 and over. These categories would not exist under the RAISE Act.

    Similar points systems were proposed in the US in 2007 and in 2013. Criticism of both systems is applicable to the RAISE Act in that the RAISE Act does not favor family unity, limiting the rights of US citizens by prohibiting them from applying for immediate family members. Moreover, the RAISE Act favors highly educated and skilled workers over less-skilled workers and disadvantages middle aged and older people. Under the RAISE Act many much needed lesser skilled jobs in agriculture, childcare, food and beverage, elder care, manufacturing and construction would suffer.

    Entrepreneur Rule Delayed

    The Obama administration supported a new visa program known as the International Entrepreneurs Rule (IER), commonly referred to as the “entrepreneur visa” or “startup visa.” The IER is very popular with and supported by many Silicon Valley and other tech innovators in the US as a step toward ensuring that the US can continue to compete with the tech industry in China and Europe.

    Proposed more than a year ago, and based on another program several years in the making, the goal of the IER is to facilitate US entry for entrepreneurs who want to invest their talents in the US. The rule would require applicants to have a track record, funding of at least $250,000, a business plan and a substantial interest in a business which was established less than five years ago. The business must also be of a “public benefit” to the US. Applicants who meet the above criteria will be issued parole status to work in the US. Parole status avoids some of the lengthy processing and documentation required of nonimmigrant visas, offering a more generous option for those who do not want to be tied to a particular company.

    The IER was to have been implemented earlier this year. While official word is that the launch has merely been delayed until March 2018, there has also been discussion that it may be totally eliminated.

    Increased Scrutiny of Visa Petitions and Travelers upon Entry to the US

    Pending H-1B visa petitions are not the only visa petitions which are receiving additional scrutiny by USCIS. Employers and immigration practitioners are reporting an increase in the number of Requests for Evidence (RFE) issued by USCIS in a wide variety of petitions including nonimmigrant L-1 visas, as well as immigrant visa petitions based on the multinational executive/managerial category, extraordinary ability and other employment-based petitions. Again, this level of scrutiny may be aimed at what the new administration views as the direction in which immigration should go in the future.

    In a related development, on August 28, 2017, USCIS announced that it would begin scheduling in-person interviews for certain individuals applying for adjustment of status to permanent residence in the US (“green card” applicants). Notably, those who are applying under employment-based petitions will be scheduled for interviews. With an effective date of October 1, 2017, the move to interview is a reversal of a long-standing USCIS policy waiving interviews for most applicants filing for green cards through employers. At this point it is unclear whether those with pending applications will be scheduled for interviews or this will only impact those who file on or after October 1, 2017. What does seem clear is that without a significant increase in resources at USCIS, the wait for interviews, and therefore the wait to complete the green card process, will become increasingly long.

    Perhaps most troubling are the reports received about travelers being extensively questioned upon entry or reentry to the US, including those who have been legal permanent residents for many years. Some of the conduct by US Customs & Border Protection (USCBP) officers has been deemed abusive, resulting in complaints being lodged against USCBP. While traditionally visitors have been questioned upon entry to the US to ensure an intent only to visit, some holding valid nonimmigrant work visas are being detained upon reentry to the US, even if they have never had a problem in the past. There have also been reports of those with valid visas being denied reentry to the US. In addition, some legal permanent residents are being pressured to give up their resident status, based on USCBP officers’ opinions that the residents are spending too much time abroad and therefore do not truly intend to reside in the US permanently, as required. Travelers with nonimmigrant work visas are cautioned to come prepared with a current job letter or contact information for their employers in case questions are raised. Legal permanent residents should be prepared to answer questions about their intent to remain in the US. While questioning by a USCBP officer can be intimidating, travelers do have a right to speak with a supervisor if an officer appears to be acting inappropriately.

    Deferred Action for Childhood Arrival Program Terminated

    On September 5, 2017, the Trump Administration announced that the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrival Program (DACA) would be terminated in six (6) months. Created by an Executive Order in 2012, DACA has enabled approximately 800,000 otherwise undocumented individuals who were brought to the US as children to be protected from deportation and obtain work authorization. At the present time there is no indication of how current DACA recipients will be handled once the program has been terminated, raising fears of mass deportations. Many employers and employment groups have expressed disappointment about this new development based on their employment of DACA individuals. In particular, the health care and hospitality industries expect to be widely impacted by the DACA termination. Businesses are now in a position of considering how to fill positions once their DACA employees are no longer employable.

    Will Visa Status under the NAFTA Survive?

    While the future of the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) clearly has a great impact on a number of areas, there is a concern about the future of visa categories specifically created by the NAFTA. Citizens of Canada and Mexico may be eligible for nonimmigrant NAFTA Professional (TN) status to work in the US if they will be filling certain positions listed on the NAFTA. These positions include engineers, accountants, nurses, scientists and many other job categories. A TN applicant must have a specific job offer in a listed job category and must have the qualifications outlined in the NAFTA for the particular job. TN status has been a good option for many employers and employees because it can be done very quickly and efficiently at a much lower cost than many of the other visa categories. If NAFTA no longer exists, the TN category will clearly disappear, however there is some thought that even if the NAFTA is revamped in some way, the TN visa may no longer be an option.

    Conclusion

    Though there is no certain path to reforming US immigration, it is safe to assume that changes will be made in both current law and policy. Employers should be prepared for changes in hiring and may want to consider applying for immigrant status for key employees at this time. Travelers also are cautioned to be prepared to answer questions upon entry to the US.

    Authors

    Joan-Elisse Carpentier

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue, San Francisco

    More insights

  • Game Over for the „Sausage Gap“: Germany Adopts a Comprehensive Amendment to its Competition Law

    ARTICLE

    Game Over for the „Sausage Gap“: Germany Adopts a Comprehensive Amendment to its Competition Law

    September 2017

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In July 2014, Germany’s competition authority, the Federal Cartel Office (FCO), imposed fines totalling around 1338 million on 21 sausage manufacturers and 33 senior managers. Over the following months, several of the companies fined made use of a loophole in German competition law by engaging in international restructuring measures. The companies were dissolved and their assets transferred to sister companies or other group companies. The FCO ultimately grudgingly acknowledged that it had had to forfeit around 1238 million, and the loophole became widely known as the “sausage gap”.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Contracts with the Interim Managers –Term, Liability, and Remuneration

    ARTICLE

    Contracts with the Interim Managers –Term, Liability, and Remuneration

    September 9, 2017

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Dr. Paul Melot de Beauregard with an article on “Contracts with the Interim Managers –Term, Liability, and Remuneration”.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Connecticut Supreme Court Lets Jury Verdict Stand in Munn v. Hotchkiss School

    Connecticut Supreme Court Lets Jury Verdict Stand in Munn v. Hotchkiss School

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Connecticut Supreme Court Lets Jury Verdict Stand in Munn v. Hotchkiss School

    September 7, 2017

    Read time: 18 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Connecticut Supreme Court (the “Court”) has issued a ruling supporting a Connecticut jury’s decision in 2013 to award $41.75 million dollars[1] to a student for injuries sustained as a result of contracting tick-borne encephalitis on a school trip abroad.[2] The Hotchkiss School organized a month-long trip to China in 2007. During the trip, students hiked to the top of the forested Mount Panshan. A few students decided to hike down, while the others took a cable car. The students who hiked followed narrow dirt trails, getting lost among trees and through brush. One student received multiple insect bites, and began feeling ill 10 days later. Her condition worsened rapidly and she was taken to a local hospital, then transferred to Beijing, and ultimately was airlifted to New York. The student suffered extensive injuries, including partial paralysis, loss of the ability to speak, and loss of some cognitive function. She sued the school, alleging that the school was negligent in failing to warn students and their parents about the risks of insect-borne diseases and failing to provide protective clothing and insect repellant.[3]

    The school appealed to the Second Circuit Court of Appeals, which in turn certified two questions of law to the Connecticut Supreme Court for guidance: (1) whether Connecticut public policy supported imposing a duty on a private school to warn about or protect against the risk of insect-borne diseases when organizing a trip abroad and (2) if so, is a jury award of $41.5 million for a student who contracted such a disease on a school trip excessive?

    On Aug. 11, 2017, the Court issued a ruling, answering the first question by finding that the state’s public policy does impose an affirmative duty on a school to warn about or to protect against the risk of serious insect-borne diseases when organizing a trip abroad. This Court did not address the issue of whether the injuries were reasonably foreseeable because the Second Circuit Court of Appeals had already determined in its 2015 decision that the evidence presented at trial was sufficient to support the jury’s verdict that the student’s illness was foreseeable. Schools are obligated to exercise reasonable care to protect students from foreseeable harms, and the Court found “no compelling reason to create an exception in this case for foreseeable serious insect-borne diseases.”[4] 

    In considering whether the state’s public policy imposes a legal duty, the Court examined the following four factors:

    1. Normal expectations of the participants in the activity. The Court found that the normal expectations of students and parents in a school sponsored educational trip abroad are that the “organizer of the trip would take reasonable measures to warn participants and their parents about the serious insect-borne diseases that are present in the areas to be visited and to protect children from those diseases.” The Court reasoned that the school and its personnel have superior knowledge regarding the nuances of travel plans and itineraries. Most importantly, the school has a responsibility to protect minors “in assuming physical custody and control over its students, effectively [taking] the place of parents and guardians … .” Because of the serious dangers posed by insect-borne diseases, the availability of information regarding the trip and risks thereof, and the existence of low-cost measures to prevent such illnesses, students would normally expect the school to pass along appropriate warnings and to use reasonable care to minimize the risk of insect-borne diseases in the areas to be visited.
    2. Encouraging participation, while weighing the safety of the participants. Although the policy of the state encourages its students, teachers, and administrators to travel, the Court disagreed with the school that recognizing the school’s legal duty in these circumstances would have a chilling effect on school trips and travel. The Court stated that the “school’s general duty to protect its students [including] the responsibility to take reasonable measures to warn about, and to protect against, serious insect-borne disease risk” will not disincentivize travel, and may even encourage travel, if unnecessary risks can be minimized with little effort and little cost.
    3. Avoiding increased litigation. The Court was skeptical that the recognition of a school’s duty to warn or protect against a serious insect-borne illness when organizing a trip abroad will lead to increased litigation. The Court noted that cases with similar facts are uncommon. Not many children are seriously injured by insect-borne diseases while abroad on a school trip, especially when appropriate measures are in place. The Court found that this factor supported the imposition of a legal duty to warn students about, and to protect them against, foreseeable insect-borne diseases. The Court emphasized that it was not recognizing a new cause of action, but rather clarifying a “specific aspect of the already well-established general duty of schools to take reasonable measures to ensure safety of the minors whom they have assumed custody.”
    4. Decision from other jurisdictions. The Court found this last factor to be neutral as no other jurisdiction had an analogous decision.

    With respect to the second question, the Court did not find the verdict excessive as a matter of law and the award, which included $31.5 million of noneconomic damages, did not warrant remittitur. The Court explained that the trial court’s decision on damages is entitled to great weight, especially where, as here, the jury and trial court agreed in the determination and there was no allegation that the jury was “prejudiced, incompetent, or otherwise compromised, but only that its verdict was improperly large.” The Court noted that the student’s physical injuries and psychological effects will probably worsen as she ages, and that the student’s injuries were “uniquely cruel.” 

    In light of the Connecticut Supreme Court’s decision, all independent schools should review their travel policies and procedures. Some best practices include: 

    • Due Diligence and Risk Analysis. Schools should research travel plans in advance, including itineraries and accommodations. Schools should review activity risks, environmental risks, safety/security risks, etc. If students are staying with host families, schools should ensure background checks are conducted and living accommodations are satisfactory. In Hotchkiss, the trip leaders failed to require the students to take proper precautions against potential mosquito or tick bites, such as requiring the students to wear protective clothing or utilizing protective insect repellent. The Connecticut Supreme Court stressed that information directed at travelers is freely available on travel pages published by the Center for Disease Control and Prevention (“CDC”) and foreign governments. The Court explained that “when insect-borne diseases present serious risks, they become the subject of government warnings and media attention … [and] when a particular disease is brought to an individual’s attention, he or she can learn about the disease’s prevalence, the areas in which the disease is endemic, whether there is a vaccine available and, if not, what other measures may be effective to prevent it.” The Court noted that, although the risk of tick-borne encephalitis is remote, the results can be fatal and the measures a school might take to protect its students are minimal (e.g., applying insect repellant or checking a student’s body for ticks). Schools should consider the likelihood and the gravity of potential harm, in addition to the burden of taking adequate precautions. Schools should review the risks identified by the CDC, local governments, the U.S. State Department, and other resources. Such risks are foreseeable risks, and the school must then take appropriate reasonable precautions to address them and to warn parents and students about them. 
    • Permission Forms and Releases. Schools should always have students and parents sign permission forms specifically allowing a student to attend a trip, and a release to protect the school and the school’s employees. In New York, releases from gross negligence are rarely enforceable, but a well-drafted release can serve to protect a school from many other claims. In Hotchkiss, the district court excluded the school’s waiver, finding that its language was ambiguous and against public policy under Connecticut law. It is important that permission forms and releases be as detailed and clear as possible, laying out the foreseeable risks. The U.S. State Department and the CDC should be used as resources to identify current risks in particular areas. Additionally, all permission forms should indicate how much supervision by school employees will be provided during the trip and clearly state if students will be unsupervised at any time during the trip.
    • Emergency Procedures. Schools should review their emergency procedures during trips, especially when travelling abroad. The procedures should be reviewed and updated regularly and, where appropriate, should include procedures specific to the location of the trip. The procedures should specify who has the authority to decide when there is a crisis and next steps. Emergency protocols should be clearly communicated with faculty, trip supervisors, students and their families. In Hotchkiss, it was alleged that the trip leaders had no medical training, did not appreciate the significance of the initial symptoms of the illness, had no protocol for notifying parents and failed to undertake pre-trip planning and make pre-trip arrangements for the transfer back to the United States of students with medical emergencies.
    • Schools should contact their insurance providers to ensure they have appropriate coverage for all trips. Some schools purchase kidnap/ransom coverage, for example, if they are travelling to a dangerous area.

    The Connecticut Supreme Court emphasized that it is “beyond dispute that, as a general matter, a school having custody of minor children has an obligation to use reasonable care to protect those children from foreseeable harms during school-sponsored activities, including educational trips abroad.” School-sponsored travel always involves some risk. By properly identifying foreseeable risks, communicating those risks, and taking appropriate precautions to address those risks, schools can help protect their students, and minimize liability for negligence claims. 

    Authored by Mark E. Brossman, Donna K. Lazarus and Aaron S. Farovitch.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] This figure was reduced to $41.5 million dollars.

    [2] View the full decision. The case remains on appeal at the U.S. Second Circuit Court of Appeals. 

    [3] See SRZ’s April 22, 2013 Alert. 

    [4] In a concurring opinion, Connecticut Supreme Court Justice Carmen Espinosa encouraged the Court of Appeals to “revisit its legal determination that there was sufficient evidence to support the jury’s finding that the injuries suffered by the plaintiff Cara L. Munn were reasonably foreseeable.” View the text of this concurring opinion.


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP (“SRZ”) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.

    In depth
    Authors

    Mark E. Brossman

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Donna K. Lazarus

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Euratom: Where Are We Now?

    ARTICLE

    Euratom: Where Are We Now?

    September 7, 2017

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Hamid Yunis wrote this bylined article on the potential negative impact for UK cancer care if Brexit causes the UK to leave the European Atomic Energy Community (Euratom). “The UK relies on Euratom for the diagnosis and treatment of some cancer patients,” Mr. Yunis wrote. “Leaving Euratom, without an appropriate alternative, will make it much harder for the UK to access key nuclear isotopes used in such diagnosis and treatment.”

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • International News: Focus on Health Care

    International News: Focus on Health Care

    INTERNATIONAL NEWS / REPORT

    International News: Focus on Health Care

    September 2017

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • No End (Result) in Sight

    ARTICLE

    No End (Result) in Sight

    September 5, 2017

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Britt Haxton and Philip Levine wrote this bylined article on developments regarding the step transaction doctrine, focusing on the elimination of various no-rules. “The guidance issued regarding the removal of the no-rules does little to resolve the underlying substantive issues and, in some cases, raises as many questions as it answers,” the authors wrote.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Summary Judgment ‘Disfavored’ for Resolving Fair Use Trademark Defense

    ARTICLE

    Summary Judgment ‘Disfavored’ for Resolving Fair Use Trademark Defense

    September 5, 2017

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Sarah Bro wrote this bylined article on Marketquest Group, Inc. v. BIC Corp, in which the Ninth Circuit reversed a district court grant of summary judgment in favor of a promotional products company and remanded the case for reconsideration of the lower court’s finding that the company’s use of a competitor’s trademarks was wholly protected by the fair use defense.

    In depth
    Authors

    Sarah Bro

    Partner

    Orange County, Los Angeles

    More insights