ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
CMS Seeks to Provide Flexibility and Facilitate Innovation in Medicare Advantage and Part D
February 7, 2019
Read time: 15 min
The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) recently released several significant Medicare Advantage (MA) and Part D guidance documents outlining new Center for Medicare and Medicaid Innovation (CMMI) programs and proposed MA and Part D program changes. These new participation options and proposals, summarized in greater detail here, would give MA and Part D plans greater flexibility to customize and tailor their benefit packages to differentiate their products from competitors.
This On the Subject was co-authored by Mara McDermott, Vice President at McDermott+Consulting.
The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) recently released several significant Medicare Advantage (MA) and Part D guidance documents outlining new Center for Medicare and Medicaid Innovation (CMMI) programs and proposed MA and Part D program changes. A consistent theme throughout the new guidance is the agency’s emphasis on expanding flexibility and encouraging innovation in the MA and Part D programs. These new participation options and proposals would give MA and Part D plans greater flexibility to customize and tailor their benefit packages to differentiate their products from competitors, for example.
CMS proposed these policy changes in the following guidance documents:
- Part I of the CY 2020 Advance Notice, released on December 20, 2018
- Part II of the CY 2020 Advance Notice and Draft Call Letter (Draft CY 2020 Call Letter), released on January 30, 2019
- An application and fact sheet for a new payment model for Medicare Part D, released on January 18, 2019
- Proposed updates to the existing MA Value-Based Insurance Design (VBID) model, released on January 18, 2019
Read on for a summary of the agency’s new programs and proposals.
Supplemental Benefits for Chronically Ill Enrollees
The Bipartisan Budget Act of 2018 amended the Social Security Act to allow MA plans to offer chronically ill enrollees supplemental benefits that are not primarily health-related. The Draft CY 2020 Call Letter proposes criteria to govern which members CMS would consider “chronically ill” and therefore eligible for these benefits. Specifically, this guidance clarifies the first of three statutory criteria, which requires members to have one or more comorbid and medically complex chronic conditions that are life threatening or that significantly limit the overall health or function of the enrollee. The member must also have a high risk of hospitalization or other adverse health outcomes and require intensive care coordination to satisfy the remaining statutory criteria for the supplemental benefits.
With respect to the first statutory criterion, CMS proposes to consider members “chronically ill” if they have one or more of the 15 conditions listed in existing CMS guidance applicable to Special Needs Plans. This list was developed in 2008 and has not been updated since. In connection with this list of 15 conditions, CMS states that in future years it will convene a technical advisory panel to provide periodic updates, and requests comments as to whether MA plans should have flexibility to go beyond this list and make these eligibility determinations themselves.
Regardless of whether CMS finalizes the use of a defined list to satisfy the first criterion, the agency expects MA plans to develop and document their own processes to identify which members are chronically ill and thus eligible for the expanded supplemental benefits. Further, CMS reiterates that a member request for a supplemental benefit will be treated similarly to requests for other benefits; therefore, a request for a supplemental benefit may be considered a request for an organization determination and, as a result, a challenge to such a determination will be processed as an appeal.
Another factor that may add complexity to member appeals is the ability of MA plans to vary benefits for different members within chronic condition groups. The MA uniformity rules are waived for these supplemental benefits, so MA plans may offer the benefits to individual members based on whether they are likely to benefit from the service or intervention, instead of offering the same benefits to all members with a particular chronic condition. This is a key distinction from the targeted supplemental benefits that MA plans have been able to offer since the beginning of 2019, which can be targeted at members based on condition but cannot be further targeted based on other factors. CMS has also requested comments on whether MA plans should be able to condition the receipt of supplemental benefits on financial need.
New CMMI Model for Part D and Updates to MA VBID Model
On January 18, 2019, the CMMI announced a new payment model for Medicare Part D—the Part D Payment Modernization model—as well as updates to the existing MA VBID model. Both of these models are voluntary and will run from contract years 2020 through 2024.
Part D Payment Modernization Model
The new Part D Model will allow for (1) enhanced risk sharing between Part D plans and CMS, and (2) the creation of new flexibilities and incentives for plans, providers and beneficiaries to choose lower cost drugs. Both standalone Part D plans and MA-Part D (MA-PD) plans may participate in the new model.
Plans that participate in the Part D Model will assume greater risk in the catastrophic phase of Part D than traditional Part D plans. CMS will calculate the shared savings or losses owed to or by the plan for a given contract year by retrospectively establishing a spending target benchmark. CMS will set the benchmark at the amount of the federal reinsurance subsidy (80 percent of the Part D catastrophic phase costs after rebate) that CMS projects Part D plans would receive if they were not participating in the model. Plans with federal reinsurance subsidy spending that is lower than the benchmark will receive performance-based payments that are based on the total amount of savings; plans with federal reinsurance spending that is higher than the benchmark will owe 10 percent of the difference back to CMS. CMS will calculate savings or losses at the parent organization level.
CMS also plans to roll out tools for beneficiary use, including a Part D Rewards and Incentives program, that will help beneficiaries understand their options (for example, generic versus brand name options that are clinically equivalent) and out-of-pocket costs, and help them become more active and engaged consumers. In addition, plans will be able to propose drug utilization management techniques to encourage the use of lower priced drugs without impeding beneficiaries’ access to medically necessary drugs.
MA VBID Model
CMS announced the national expansion of the MA VBID model, which first launched in 2017 in a limited number of states. Similar to the proposals regarding supplemental benefits for chronically ill beneficiaries described above, participating VBID MA plans enjoy additional flexibility with respect to benefits, such as reduced cost sharing or additional benefits for beneficiaries with particular health conditions. Beginning in 2020, the VBID model will be available to MA plans in all 50 states and territories, as well as to Regional Preferred Provider Organizations, Chronic Condition special needs plans (SNPs), Dual-Eligible SNPs and Institutional SNPs. For MA plans that apply and are approved by CMS, the 2020 VBID model will further enhance flexibility in several ways:
- Participating MA plans may provide reduced cost-sharing or additional supplemental benefits for items or services that are “non-primarily health related,” such as transportation. Plans may target such benefits to particular beneficiaries based on chronic condition, socioeconomic status or both. Socioeconomic status will be measured by either eligibility for the low-income subsidy or dual eligibility for Medicare and Medicaid.
- Participating MA plans may offer increased rewards and incentives for beneficiaries who participate in programs designed to promote improved health and prevention and improve efficiency in the use of health care resources. MA plans may propose programs “with allowed values that more closely reflect the expected benefit of the health related service or activity, up to an annual limit.” MA-PD plans will also be able to offer additional rewards and incentives to enrollees who take Part D covered drugs and proactively participate in their care, such as through medication therapy management programs or receipt of preventive health services.
- In addition to new flexibility to offer telehealth benefits as part of the basic benefit package beginning in 2020, MA plans participating in the VBID model will be able to use telehealth to meet network adequacy requirements, subject to approval by CMS, as long as access to in-person visits remains available. CMS intends to explore how telehealth can “complement and augment” current provider networks, and how telehealth can expand access to care in underserved and rural areas.
- Beginning in 2021, the VBID model will also test the administration of the Medicare hospice benefit through certain MA plans. By statute, hospice benefits are provided through Medicare fee-for-service and are not part of the MA benefit package. MedPAC and other organizations have long called for a reversal of this hospice “carve out” from the MA program. CMS appears to be utilizing its demonstration authority to test and gather data on how this policy proposal would work in practice.
MA plans that apply to CMS by March 1, 2019, may seek to participate in one or more of the interventions described above. All MA plans that choose to participate in any of these interventions will also be required to offer wellness and health care planning.
Part D Mail Order Auto-Ship
The Draft CY 2020 Call Letter would allow mail order pharmacies to auto-ship refills to members. Since the 2014 contract year, CMS has required Part D plan sponsors (other than non-employer group waiver plans (EGWPs)) to obtain member consent prior to shipping each refill prescription. CMS proposes that, for the 2020 contract year, Part D plan sponsors would be permitted to auto-ship refills of drugs that a member has been on for at least four consecutive months. The Draft CY 2020 Call Letter outlines CMS’s expectations regarding any auto-ship program, including the following:
- Members would need to confirm their enrollment in the auto-ship program at least annually.
- Plan sponsors would be required to send two reminders to the beneficiary well in advance of shipment (e.g., 25 and 10 days prior). The reminders could be by phone, email, text, direct mailing or other comparable means based on the beneficiary’s preference.
- Members would be permitted to choose to participate for none, all or a subset of their medications.
- Plan sponsors would be required to refund any refills that the beneficiary reports as unneeded or unwanted.
The proposed change in policy follows CMS’s requests for comments in the Draft CY 2019 Call Letter on the current auto-ship restrictions that were adopted in 2014. Since the 2014 policy was initially announced, CMS has created a limited exception for auto-ship of initial fills for all Part D plans and a broad exception for EGWPs permitting auto-ship of initial fills and refills. The requirements CMS has proposed for auto-shipping are similar but not identical to the current exceptions to the auto-ship prohibition. For example, CMS does not currently limit auto-ship of refills by EGWP sponsors to drugs that a beneficiary has taken for four months, and does not currently require two reminders in advance of each refill.
EGWP Buy-Down of Part B Premiums
CMS proposes permitting EGWPs to use a designated portion of their capitated payments to buy down the Part B premium, as individual market MA plans have been able to do. CMS formerly prohibited the practice for EGWPs both because of certain CMS operational limitations and because EGWPs could not distinguish the respective portions of their payments for basic benefits versus rebates. However, CMS was convinced to propose changing this policy after receiving feedback from stakeholders that the policy “hinders [EGWPs’] ability to function in the market and unnecessarily restricts their benefit offering beyond what was intended in its implementation.” If the proposal is finalized, EGWPs that choose to take advantage of this option will be required to comply with uniformity of benefit rules and apply the buy-down consistently to every enrollee in a particular plan. EGWPs will also be subject to the same buy-down maximum as individual market MA plans.
Risk-Based Contracting for Pharmacy Benefits
CMS requests comments on “the barriers, feasibility, and benefits/drawbacks” of including the cost of Part B and D drugs in MA plans’ risk arrangements with non-pharmacy providers (e.g., physician groups or accountable care organizations) in a request for information set out in the Draft CY 2020 Call Letter. CMS appears to be interested in facilitating the inclusion of these Part B and Part D prescription drug costs in provider risk arrangements based, at least in part, on the statutory prohibition on Part D plan sponsors requiring pharmacies to take on insurance risk. By giving non-pharmacy providers a financial incentive to manage prescription drug costs, including physician-administered drugs, CMS hopes that MA plans and Part D plan sponsors will be able to “drive down the cost” of such drugs.
Updates to MA Risk Adjustment
Payment Condition Count Model
CMS has proposed to move forward in 2020 with the Payment Condition Count model it initially proposed in the CY 2019 Advance Notice Part I. This model includes a coefficient for a variable that counts the number of conditions that a beneficiary has, which stems from the 21st Century Cures Act mandate to “take into account the total number of diseases or conditions of an individual enrolled in an MA plan.” Under the proposed model, each condition will have two impacts on the beneficiary’s risk score. First, it will affect the coefficient for the specific condition. Second, it will affect the coefficient for a variable that counts the number of conditions the beneficiary has.
MA plans must consider the important implications of this new model. First, the model increases the additional value of each diagnosis identified and submitted—and increases the consequences of omitting a diagnosis—because each diagnosis is factored in the model twice. Second, it may make it harder to predict risk scores and make the bidding process more complicated. As CMS noted, the “incremental predicted expenditure for a given HCC [Hierarchical Condition Category] is dependent on the number of conditions the beneficiary may have, regardless of what those conditions may be.”
CMS asserts that it does not have a choice in whether to implement a revised model. The Social Security Act requires that the revised model be phased in over three years, with full implementation by 2022. CMS proposes to calculate risk scores used in payment year 2020 by blending (at 50/50) the risk score calculated with the new model and the risk score calculated with the 2017 CMS-HCC model.
Encounter Data
CMS proposes to increase the weighting of encounter data from 25 percent to 50 percent. The transition from Risk Adjustment Processing System (RAPS) data to encounter data began in 2016 and was initially scheduled to be complete in 2020. CMS has delayed the transition amidst concerns in the industry and from the US Government Accountability Office regarding the accuracy and reliability of encounter data. As proposed, the encounter data score would use diagnoses from encounter data and fee-for-service claims, would continue to be supplemented with RAPS inpatient records, and would be calculated using the new Payment Condition Count model. The RAPS score would use diagnoses from RAPS and fee-for-service claims and would be calculated using the 2017 CMS-HCC model.
Star Ratings Measures Appeals Auto-Forward (Part D) and Appeals Upheld (Part D)
CMS proposes to remove the two Part D appeals measures from the Star Ratings beginning with the 2020 measurement year (which will affect the CY 2022 Star Ratings). These measures evaluate the timeliness of processing coverage determinations and redeterminations and the rates at which appeals are upheld. However, CMS has expressed concerns that the measures are not statistically reliable because, among other issues, they rely on Part D plans to identify untimely cases and send them to an Independent Review Entity. CMS requests comments on whether the two Part D measures should remain on the Display Page. CMS also reminds Part D plans that Part D appeals will continue to be monitored through program audits, annual reporting requirements and other monitoring activities, and that the agency will continue to take action to address noncompliance.
Provider Directory Accuracy
Like the annual Call Letters for the past several years, the Draft CY 2020 Call Letter includes a discussion of provider directory accuracy audits. In prior years, CMS emphasized the consistently high rates of provider directory inaccuracies and warned that the agency may take enforcement action for the most egregious instances of noncompliance. CMS recently concluded the third round of provider directory audits and, in keeping with its Call Letter warnings, the audits resulted in a combined 18 Notices of Non-Compliance, 15 Warning Letters and 7 Warning Letters with a Request for a Business Plan. In the current Draft CY 2020 Call Letter, CMS does not warn MA organizations about potential compliance actions, and the overall tone seems to signal that the agency may take a more collaborative approach to working with plans to address what the agency acknowledges is a “complex problem.”
Part D Risk Corridors
Although CMS has the authority to widen risk corridor thresholds, after evaluating risk sharing amounts for 2008–2017 and finding that they have varied significantly from year to year and between Part D sponsors, CMS proposes leaving the risk corridor parameters unchanged for 2020.
Addressing the Opioid Crisis
Addressing the opioid crisis remains a priority for the US Department of Health and Human Services. The Draft CY 2020 Call Letter contains several policies that continue to address this problem. For example, CMS is encouraging plans to reduce beneficiary cost-sharing for naloxone to treat overdose, and reminds MA organizations that medically approved non-opioid pain management can be offered as a supplemental benefit. CMS also proposes to advance opioid-related measures through the Star Ratings process.
Administrative Guidance, Ethical Standards, and Tax Return Positions
ARTICLE
Administrative Guidance, Ethical Standards, and Tax Return Positions
February 5, 2019
Read time: 2 min
Todd Welty and Lowell Yoder authored this bylined article on navigating the uncertainties created by the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act and other longstanding tax risks.
Global Actions
ARTICLE
Global Actions
February 1, 2019
Read time: 2 min
James Ross and Sarah Gabbai authored this bylined article looking at the national and international responses to tax challenges exacerbated by digitalization as they await proposals from the OECD to address these issues.

No significance of the prospectus statements for the investment decision without knowledge of the prospectus by the investor if a liability is asserted under c.i.c.
ARTICLE
No significance of the prospectus statements for the investment decision without knowledge of the prospectus by the investor if a liability is asserted under c.i.c.
February 2019
Read time: 2 min
In his article Dr. Sebastian Keding anlyses and comments on the ruling of the German federal high court II ZR 13/17 dealing with damage claims under cic in connection with an incorrect prospectus.

NFA Update: New Supervision and Cybersecurity Obligations for Private Fund Managers Registered with the National Futures Association
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
NFA Update: New Supervision and Cybersecurity Obligations for Private Fund Managers Registered with the National Futures Association
February 1, 2019
Read time: 12 min
The National Futures Association issued two Interpretive Notices that will affect all private fund managers that are NFA members (i.e., managers with funds or accounts that trade commodity interests and that are not eligible for an exemption from registration with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission). While the Interpretive Notices address different areas of risk — one is focused on the need for more formal supervision of key financial functions, and the other is focused on addressing cybersecurity risks — they both require the attention of senior administrative personnel. Given that the obligations set forth in these notices will become effective on April 1, 2019, all affected managers should take steps to ensure timely compliance.
The Internal Control Systems Interpretive Notice
On Jan. 31, 2019, the NFA announced that it had adopted a new interpretive notice, “Compliance Rule 2-9: CPO Internal Control System” (the “Internal Controls Notice”)[1], which is directed at commodity pool operators with control over customer funds.
As background, NFA Compliance Rule 2-9 imposes a general requirement for NFA members (including CFTC-registered private fund managers) to “diligently supervise” their personnel. The NFA interprets that general rule as requiring a “strong control environment” with internal controls that are designed to deter fraud and errors in order to safeguard customer funds, to reliably produce accurate and timely financial reports, and to cause compliance with all regulations addressing the control of customer funds. The Internal Controls Notice is intended to supplement Compliance Rule 2-9 and provide CPOs with guidance on the design of an adequate financial controls system as well as to set forth certain “minimum components” of such a system.
A Strong Control Environment. Unsurprisingly, the Internal Controls Notice expressly requires the adoption and implementation of written compliance policies. However, compliance personnel should note that the Internal Controls Notice specifically requires the adoption of two different sets of written policies and procedures:
- Policies and procedures reasonably designed to ensure that a CPO’s operations are in compliance with all applicable NFA rules and CFTC regulations; and
- Policies and procedures that fully explain a CPO’s internal controls framework and describe the CPO’s supervisory system, “which should be reasonably designed to ensure that [they] are diligently followed by all employees.”
While the obligation to address both policy objectives is a fairly subtle point in the Internal Controls Notice, legal and compliance personnel should ensure that the design of their policies, as well as all periodic reviews of their effectiveness, expressly benchmark the firm’s systems against both objectives.
The NFA also made clear in the Internal Controls Notice that the behavior of senior personnel is an integral element of a strong control environment. The notice states that “management must demonstrate its commitment to integrity and ethical values and emphasize the importance of establishing and following the internal controls” and that “no employee, including senior management, should inappropriately circumvent the firm’s internal controls system.” While these concepts are not new in the asset management industry, this express individual mandate for senior personnel (and not just for compliance personnel) is consistent with a broader regulatory shift.
The non-circumvention concept is also expressed in a requirement that the firm have an “escalation policy” that (1) provides a mechanism for reporting attempts to improperly override a firm’s internal controls system “in any respect” and (2) addresses “whether and when a matter should be reported to the firm’s regulator.” Legal and compliance officers should consider these aspects of the Internal Controls Notice carefully, as they may differ in some details from many firms’ current practices.
In a footnote, the NFA also set forth an additional element of an effective internal controls system, stating that the overall compliance program “should be supported by strong information technology controls operating within the firm’s Information Systems Security Program.” Compliance officers, when performing reviews and assessments, should take note of this and ensure that reviews of their information security systems and their cybersecurity measures are incorporated into their overall control system assessments.
Separation of Duties. The Internal Controls Notice also advises that, to the extent possible, persons who perform day-to-day functions in the following areas should be different from the persons who supervise those functions:
- Handling funds;
- Trade execution activities;
- Financial records; and
- Risk management.
And, where a supervisor also handles day-to-day functions, a principal of the CPO (or other supervisory person) should periodically review the supervisor’s work. In other words, whenever possible, the CPO’s policies should require that:
- There is cross-checking of work in key areas, either by assigning duties to different employees or by implementing automated controls;
- Operational functions that involve handling or the custody of pool assets are separated from financial reporting functions; and
- No one person should be responsible for the full lifecycle of subscriptions, transfers and redemptions to or from a pool (or transactions that present similar risks).
The NFA believes that the separation of duties is “widely accepted as a key control activity.” Therefore all CPOs should review their operational processes and financial controls to carefully consider the adequacy of their supervision framework in light of the NFA’s advice on separation of duties.
Controls Over Investment Activity and Financial Transactions. The Internal Controls Notice also highlighted two common areas of risk (financial transactions between pools and their investors and investment decision-making) and suggested specific steps that would “form the basis of” adequate internal controls in these areas.
The Internal Controls Notice proposes that, to reduce the financial and operational risks associated with pool subscriptions, redemptions and transfers (and to protect participant and pool assets), a CPO should:
- Verify that pool investments are held in accounts properly titled with the pool’s name and are not commingled with the assets of any other person;[2]
- Periodically reconcile transactions between the pool’s general ledger, banks and other third-party depositories;
- Include authorization of redemptions as a process subject to explicit verification and confirmation checks (check that the request is made by a participant; that adequate funds are available; that the NAV calculation is correct; that funds are actually released and timely rendered to the correct party, etc.); and
- Verify that transactions involving pool funds do not violate NFA Compliance Rule 2-45, prohibiting direct or indirect loans from a pool to a member CPO or affiliates.
The NFA also regards investment activity and valuation process as common high-risk areas for CPOs and expects that a CPO will:
- Include approvals of investments within its control framework (for example, ensuring that each type of investment is authorized and consistent with the pool’s strategy);
- Verify that investments are valued in accordance with its valuation policies;
- Perform ongoing due diligence of counterparties and other third-party depositories (including reviewing reputation, trading strategy, past performance and regulators’ actions);
- Monitor risks associated with investments held at third parties on an ongoing basis, including market and credit risk; and
- Continually monitor pool liquidity to ensure its capacity to meet financial obligations such as redemption requests and margin calls.
When implementing such controls, the NFA advises that business and trading principals play a direct and primary role in monitoring and assessing risks within their areas of responsibility.
Use of Administrators. Third-party administrators that perform back office and other basic operational functions should be included within the internal controls system. A CPO should consider whether maintaining a set of “shadow books” is advisable and also:
- Perform both initial and ongoing due diligence on its administrator (including factors such as costs, reputation, expertise, timeliness, responsiveness, attention to detail, work history and cybersecurity); and
- Obtain evidence a test of the effectiveness of the administrator’s own controls and security measures, conducted by an internal or independent auditor as appropriate.
Impact on CPOs. The Internal Controls Notice, at least in terms of the specificity of its requirements, in many ways breaks new ground for the NFA. While many managers, especially managers registered as investment advisers with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, will have many of these practices in place, all CPOs will need to carefully review their compliance and operational policies and procedures to ensure that they are in compliance by April 1, 2019. The Internal Controls Notice also served to expressly remind all CPOs that they must maintain records sufficient to demonstrate the effectiveness of their programs.
Cybersecurity Amendments
On Jan. 7, 2019, the NFA announced that it had amended its 2016 Interpretive Notice, “Compliance Rules 2-9, 2-36 and 2-49: Information Systems Security Programs.”[3] This amendment (the “Cybersecurity Notice Amendment”)[4] underscores the importance of matters such as training on cybersecurity topics and creates a new, “narrowly drawn,” cybersecurity breach notification requirement for members (such as private fund managers registered with the CFTC).
Background. The NFA’s 2016 cybersecurity interpretive notice prescribed that members create a written framework of supervisory practices to address unauthorized access risks and established general requirements relating to such programs, while leaving the exact form of the information systems security program up to each member.
In particular, the 2016 Interpretive Notice required that covered entities create an incident response plan that addresses how the member will communicate externally with customers, counterparties, financial industry regulators, self-regulatory organizations and law enforcement in the event of a cybersecurity incident, but it did not explicitly require members to notify the NFA in connection with such an event.
New NFA Notification Requirement. The Cybersecurity Notice Amendment, however, contains a new requirement that a CPO must have procedures in place to promptly notify the NFA of a cybersecurity breach or similar incident that results in:
- Any loss of customer or counterparty funds;
- Any loss of a member’s own capital; or
- The member providing notice to customers or counterparties under state or federal law.
When notifying the NFA, the member must provide a written summary of the incident, unless the member provides a notice to customers or counterparties (in which case it may provide a copy of the notice to NFA instead of a separate written summary).
ISSP Approval. In the Cybersecurity Notice Amendment, the NFA has also clarified that a CPO’s ISSP must be approved by:
- The CEO;
- Another senior level official with primary responsibility for information technology security (such as a CTO or CISO); or
- A senior official who is listed as a principal and has authority to supervise the NFA member’s execution of the ISSP.
There are different approval requirements for situations where committees approves an ISSP, or where there are approvals at different levels in a multi-entity organization, but all CPOs should confirm that the actual technicalities of the approval satisfy the new guidance.
Other Regulatory Regimes. The Cybersecurity Notice Amendment adds that a covered CPO should be familiar with notice requirements contained in applicable data security and privacy laws of the United States and other jurisdictions. The NFA encouraged members to obtain necessary contact information from regulators and law enforcement in advance of a breach. In addition, as an aid to the development of an appropriate ISSP, members are encouraged to review the practices and standards promulgated by various professional associations identified in the NFA’s Frequently Asked Questions on Cybersecurity.[5]
Information Security Training. Under the NFA’s prior release, members are required to provide training in information security to their employees both at hiring and “periodically” on an ongoing basis. The Cybersecurity Notice Amendment clarifies that such training should be provided both at hiring and at least annually thereafter, with more frequent training as circumstances warrant. A description of such training that identifies the topics covered in the training contents should be included in the firm’s ISSP.
Action Items
Many of the NFA’s recommendations for internal controls will be familiar to established private fund managers that are registered CPOs. While the NFA states that it recognizes that size and operational differences among CPOs require a degree of flexibility for self-determinations as to what constitutes an “adequate” control system, these Interpretative Notices contain a level of detail and prescription that is new.
All private fund managers should:
- Consider the adequacy of their current controls, including those established under the parallel requirements of other regulators, in light of the NFA’s recommendations;
- Plan to conduct a review for any other member-specific factors that should be included in a control framework given the CPO’s unique characteristics; and
- Roll out any new or amended policies in the next two months (i.e., before April 1).
More broadly, the two Interpretative Notices should encourage legal and compliance personnel to view their internal controls systems as living instruments that require constant engagement, reevaluation and renewal. NFA members should ensure that they are prepared to demonstrate to the NFA and other regulators that their control systems and cybersecurity policies and procedures are documented and in full effect.
Authored by Brian T. Daly and Joshua B. Wright.
[1] See NFA Interpretive Notice I-19-03, NFA adopts Interpretive Notice entitled NFA Compliance Rule 2-9: CPO Internal Controls System (Jan. 31, 2019), available here.
[2] Note that failure to properly segregate pool assets is also a violation of CFTC Rule 4.20(c) and often a predicate offense in CFTC enforcement actions.
[3] See NFA Interpretive Notice 9070, NFA Compliance Rules 2-9, 2-36 and 2-49: Information Systems Security Programs (effective March 1, 2016).
[4] See NFA Interpretive Notice I-19-01, NFA Amends Interpretive Notice Regarding Information Systems Security Programs—Cybersecurity (Jan. 7, 2019), available here.
[5] See NFA Cybersecurity FAQs, available here.
This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2019 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.
All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

The Taxation of Blockchain-Based Assets
ARTICLE
The Taxation of Blockchain-Based Assets
January 2019
Read time: 2 min
Despite its high practical relevance, relatively little is known so far about the tax treatment of blockchain-based assets. Occasional comments are made on individual issues, but the literature published so far is limited to certain tokens and/or individual tax types. Inheritance and gift taxes are not dealt with at all. Dr. Nils Wighardt and Jan Krekeler give a holistic overview of the taxation of such assets and complement existing considerations on a technology that is celebrated by the press as “hope for the future” and even “IT revolution”.

Real Estate 2019
ARTICLE
Real Estate 2019
January 2019
Read time: 2 min
Maximilian Clostermeyer authored this chapter on real estate regulations in Germany and answers common questions involving land records, protection against liability and acquisitions.
Reproduced with permission from Law Business Research Ltd. This article was first published in Lexology Getting the Deal Through – Real Estate 2019 (Published: January 2019). For further information please visit www.gettingthedealthrough.com.

Constitutional Challenges to State Income Taxation of Trusts
ARTICLE
Constitutional Challenges to State Income Taxation of Trusts
January 25, 2019
Read time: 1 min
Toni Ann Kruse and Melissa Price coauthored this article discussing state income taxation of trusts.
4 Keys to Successful Collaborative Transformations in Healthcare
ARTICLE
4 Keys to Successful Collaborative Transformations in Healthcare
January 22, 2019
Read time: 2 min
Stephen Bernstein authored this bylined article on how to ensure a successful healthcare collaboration, including managing culture change and utilizing an experienced team to help guide the decision-making process.

Capital Markets & Public Companies Quarterly
ARTICLE
Capital Markets & Public Companies Quarterly
January 2019
Read time: 10 min
For many companies, closing out 2018 means it is time to prepare an annual report and shift attention to the upcoming proxy season. This is an opportune time to take a look back at rulemaking, interpretive guidance and enforcement activity from the SEC in 2018 to determine potential changes to your disclosure going forward. One theme over the last year is the SEC’s strong interest in public company cybersecurity, illustrated by new guidance and enforcement actions.
Other notable developments in the last quarter of 2018 include: for the second year in a row the SEC issued guidance relating to the role of company boards in the shareholder proposal process; environmental, social and governance matters remained a strong focus of the annual updates to the Institutional Shareholder Services and Glass Lewis proxy voting guidelines; and the SEC staff settled an enforcement action that gave all public companies a strong reminder of the SEC’s position with regard to “equal prominence” of GAAP and non-GAAP financial metrics in earnings releases.
Updates and Reminders for 2018 Form 10-K and 2019 Proxy Statement
Over the past year, the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has revised a number of disclosure requirements, most notably its adoption of a wide range of Disclosure Update and Simplification amendments, which took effect November 5, 2018. For many calendar year reporting companies, the 2018 Form 10-K will be the first time that many of these new provisions (or deletions) are implemented. As such, public companies should keep the following in mind as they prepare to file their Form 10-K and proxy statement this year:
- Disclosure Update and Simplification Amendments – These revisions to public company disclosure obligations were adopted for the purpose of simplifying and updating reporting requirements that had become redundant, duplicative, outdated or superseded. Changes to the Form 10-K include: the elimination of the requirement to provide segment or geographic-based financial information in the description of the company’s business (Item 1); the inclusion of changes in financial condition and results of operations based on geographic area in the company’s MD&A (Item 7); and the elimination of the requirement to provide the high and low sales prices for the company’s common stock over the last two fiscal years (Item 5). For additional detail and commentary on the SEC’s Disclosure Update and Simplification amendments, see our On the Subject.
- Cybersecurity Disclosure – The SEC has heightened its focus on public company disclosures related to cybersecurity risks and breaches, and this trend is likely to continue into the new year. In the Commission Statement and Guidance on Public Company Cybersecurity Disclosures, the SEC staff illustrated how disclosure of cybersecurity risks and preventative measures may be appropriate throughout a company’s annual report, including in sections dealing with business and operations, risk factors, legal proceedings, financial performance and corporate governance. Although the disclosures need not be so specific as to provide a roadmap for bad actors, the SEC staff requested that public companies tailor and contextualize their disclosure and avoid boilerplate or generic language. Companies should review their cybersecurity disclosures from prior years in light of this new guidance.
- Hedging Disclosure – On December 18, the SEC adopted final rules (including a new Item 407(i) of Regulation S-K) requiring companies to disclose in any proxy statement for the election of directors any practices or policies regarding the ability of employees or directors to engage in certain hedging transactions with respect to the company’s equity securities. Although most companies will not be required to include this disclosure until they report on fiscal years beginning on or after July 1, 2019, companies would be well-served to plan ahead for such disclosure. Consideration should be given to the terms of existing policies, such as the scope of transactions that are—and are not—prohibited, and any disclosures that the company has historically provided with regard to its hedging practices.
For additional commentary on the SEC’s new hedging disclosure rule, see our On the Subject and our comment letter to the SEC.
SEC Issues Report on Cyber-Related Frauds
On October 16, 2018, the Enforcement Division of the SEC released a 21A report warning public companies that inadequate prevention of cyber fraud – the use of digital deception to extract wire transfers from company employees and executives – may violate the internal accounting control provisions of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (the Exchange Act).
The report sets out two common types of cyber scams and cautions companies to take adequate precautions. As the report emphasizes, “issuers themselves are in the best position to develop internal accounting controls that account for their particular operational needs and risks.” That said, two specific compliance takeaways that emerge from the report are (1) improving transaction authorization procedures and (2) implementing personnel training designed to highlight red flags for cyber scams.
Incidences of cyber fraud have increased in recent years and the SEC’s actions with regard to cybersecurity coincide with a global trend toward increased regulation. As cyber-related incidents and scandals continue to dominate the headlines, domestic and international regulators rush to keep pace and demonstrate vigilance. To survive in this regulatory environment, it is essential that companies design and implement a robust cybersecurity strategy.
For additional commentary on the SEC’s 21(a) Report Regarding Certain Cyber-Related Frauds Perpetrated Against Public Companies and Related Internal Accounting Controls Requirements, see our On the Subject. You can also get the latest updates on privacy and cybersecurity regulation from McDermott’s Global Privacy and Cybersecurity practice.
SEC Issues Staff Legal Bulletin 14J on Shareholder Proposals
For the second year in a row (and the third time in four years), the staff of the Division of Corporation Finance of the SEC issued fourth quarter guidance relating to the shareholder proposal process. The interpretive guidance, in the form of Staff Legal Bulletin No. 14J (SLB 14J), addresses the substantive review of no-action requests from public companies that seek to exclude shareholder proposals from their proxy materials pursuant to the “ordinary business” and “economic relevance” exclusion principles found in Exchange Act Rule 14a-8.
Of note, SLB 14J provides additional guidance to companies that seek to include a summary of the discussions and analysis of its board of directors regarding the significance of a shareholder proposal, a practice that was first suggested by the SEC staff in Staff Legal Bulletin No. 14I (SLB 14I). In SLB 14I, the SEC staff signaled that, although not required and not dispositive of the issue, a no-action request premised on the “ordinary business” and “economic relevance” exclusion principles could benefit from the analysis and findings of a company’s board of directors.
SLB 14J expands upon SLB 14I by reflecting on best practices. The SEC staff stated that no-action requests benefit from the inclusion of board analysis when the request includes specific substantive factors the board considered in arriving at its conclusion, including a description of how and the extent to which the proposal relates to the company’s core business activities, an analysis of quantitative data (including financial statement impact) illustrating the significance of the proposal on the company and whether the company has already taken action to address the issue by some other method. SLB 14J clarifies that the SEC staff find it less helpful if a request detailing the board’s process does not also include a discussion of the specific factors considered.
SLB 14J confirms that companies may still receive no-action relief under the “ordinary business” and “economic relevance” exclusion principles without including in their request a determination of their board of directors.
In laying out the SEC’s agenda for 2019, Chairman Jay Clayton signaled that the SEC will continue to review the shareholder proposal and adopt new requirements and procedures, including the potential review (and presumed heightening) of the ownership and resubmission thresholds for shareholder proposals.
For additional commentary on SLB 14J and the shareholder proposal process, see our On the Subject.
Updates to the 2019 Proxy Voting Guidelines and ISS Governance QualityScore
Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS) and Glass Lewis issued their respective proxy voting guidelines for the 2019 proxy season. Updates to the guidelines primarily affect environmental, social and governance (ESG) policies which have attracted increased interest in recent years.
Both proxy advisors (as well as large institutional shareholders) have placed increased emphasis on gender diversity in the boardroom. As discussed in our prior quarterly update, leading up to the 2018 proxy season ISS and Glass Lewis expressed their intentions to highlight or generally discourage the re-election of boards with no women directors.
In their guidelines for 2019, both ISS and Glass Lewis adopted stronger policies regarding gender diversity, stating that adverse voting recommendations may be issued against nominating committee chairs if the company’s board has no female members. The Glass Lewis policy will be in effect during this proxy season while the ISS policy will take effect for meetings held on or after February 1, 2020, essentially adopting a one-year grace period. On November 29, 2018, ISS also updated its ISS Governance QualityScore methodology, creating a new subcategory of Board Diversity that will track diversity among members of a company board and its named executive officers.
In addition, both ISS and Glass Lewis adopted policies regarding management proposals that have been structured to conflict with a properly submitted shareholder proposal, providing company management a substantive argument for exclusion of the shareholder proposal (pursuant to Rule 14a-8(i)(9)). ISS and Glass Lewis both argue that this tactic is used to avoid the adoption of shareholder-sponsored charter or bylaw proposals that may provide more onerous conditions than the proposal supported by management. The guidelines include factors by which the proxy advisors will determine whether or not to withhold recommendations.
For additional commentary on these and other updates to the ISS and Glass Lewis proxy voting guidelines, see our On the Subject.
Renewed SEC Staff Focus on “Equal Prominence” of GAAP Numbers in Earnings Releases
On the day after Christmas, the SEC issued a settled enforcement action for violations of the “equal prominence” rules that apply to non-GAAP financial disclosure in earnings releases.
The enforcement action cited the use of non-GAAP financial measures, such as “adjusted EBITDA,” “adjusted net income” and “free cash flow before special items,” in the headlines and “highlights” sections of two consecutive earnings releases without providing equal or greater prominence to the comparable GAAP financial measures. The GAAP equivalents to these non-GAAP metrics were disclosed only in the body of the earnings release.
While not dispositive of the SEC staff’s decision to bring an enforcement action, it is worth noting in this case that the non-GAAP metrics in the headline and bullets were significantly “positive” (i.e., 26 percent increase in Adjusted Net Income), while the GAAP equivalents in the body of the earnings release indicated trends in the opposite direction (i.e., an increase in net loss reported on a GAAP basis).
The takeaway: the SEC staff is still closely monitoring non-GAAP disclosure in earnings releases and is willing to bring an enforcement action when the circumstances warrant (i.e., in lieu of issuing a comment letter to correct in the future).