ARTICLE
M&A Break-Up Fees in the Age of Covid-19
July 15, 2020
Read time: 1 min

ARTICLE
July 15, 2020
Read time: 1 min

ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
July 15, 2020
Read time: 4 min
On July 2, 2020, the US Department of Labor’s Office of Federal Contract Compliance Programs (OFCCP) published its final rule amending regulations regarding the OFCCP’s authority over TRICARE healthcare providers with respect to anti-discrimination, affirmative action and other requirements. The changes are intended to increase the availability of healthcare for veterans and provide guidance and cost savings to TRICARE healthcare providers.
On July 2, 2020, the US Department of Labor’s Office of Federal Contract Compliance Programs (OFCCP) published a final rule in the Federal Register, “Affirmative Action and Nondiscrimination Obligations of Federal Contractors and Subcontractors: TRICARE Providers” (Final Rule) to amend regulations regarding OFCCP’s authority over TRICARE healthcare providers. TRICARE is a federal healthcare program for uniformed service members, retirees and their families. The regulatory changes reflected in the Final Rule are intended to increase the availability of healthcare for veterans and provide guidance and cost savings to TRICARE healthcare providers.
OFCCP is responsible for enforcing federal laws and regulations that require entities holding covered government contracts and subcontracts to refrain from discriminating on the basis of race, sex and other grounds, and to take affirmative action to ensure equal employment opportunity. These federal laws include the Executive Order 11246 (E.O. 11246), Section 503 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (Section 503), and the Vietnam Era Veterans’ Readjustment Assistance Act of 1974 (VEVRAA). OFCCP also has the authority to grant exemptions to these requirements if it determines that special circumstances in the national interest require such an exemption.
In March 2014, Congress introduced the Protecting Health Care Providers from Increased Administrative Burdens Act to exempt all healthcare providers from OFCCP’s enforcement activities. In lieu of this legislative action, OFCCP opted to issue Directive 2014-01 in May 2014, which established a five-year moratorium on the enforcement of affirmative action obligations for TRICARE healthcare provider subcontractors. OFCCP extended this moratorium in 2018 for another two years, until May 7, 2021, and expanded it to cover healthcare providers participating in Department of Veterans Affairs’ health benefits programs. The Final Rule makes permanent this moratorium on the enforcement of equal employment opportunity requirements on TRICARE providers, including the requirement for an Affirmative Action Plan pursuant to Executive Order 112536 (E.O. 11246) for certain TRICARE providers.
Below are three (3) key takeaways from the Final Rule for current and potential TRICARE providers to consider:

ARTICLE
July 14, 2020
Read time: 1 min

ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
July 14, 2020
Read time: 6 min
On July 6, 2020, the SEC adopted amendments to Rule 0-5 under the Investment Company Act of 1940, as amended (“1940 Act”), establishing an expedited review process for exemptive applications submitted under the 1940 Act that are substantially similar to prior precedent.[1] The amendments to Rule 0-5 (“Amendments”) represent an effort by the SEC to balance the desire for prompt decisions by SEC staff (“Staff”) on applications with the timeframe needed by the Staff to review requests for exemptive relief appropriately. The Amendments should benefit registered investment companies, business development companies and their respective investment advisers and affiliated private fund platforms that have historically sought exemptive relief to solve certain structural challenges posed by the 1940 Act, or to permit them to operate in a more efficient and low-cost manner. Moreover, the Amendments should enable applicants seeking exemptive orders under the 1940 Act to obtain such relief in a more expeditious manner in many cases. We expect, however, that the Staff will likely rigorously enforce the “substantially similar to prior precedent” prong set forth in the Amendments, meaning that applicants needing only slight deviations from prior precedent could still fall outside the scope of the expedited review process.
The Amendments reflect a continuing effort by both the Staff and the SEC to streamline the process for more routine exemptive relief under the 1940 Act, including through the proposal and adoption of new exemptive rules to supplant previously required exemptive relief. For example, the SEC has proposed a set of rule changes permitting fund-of-funds arrangements without the need for obtaining separate exemptive relief.[2] The proposed Rule 12d1-4 would, if adopted, create a consistent framework for the formation and regulation of fund-of-funds under the 1940 Act by codifying the set of preexisting conditions previously established by the SEC through exemptive orders.[3] Additionally, the SEC recently adopted Rule 6c-11, which permits Exchange Traded Funds (“ETFs”) to operate under the 1940 Act and “come directly to market” without first obtaining an exemptive order from the SEC.[4] The SEC had issued roughly 300 exemptive orders allowing ETFs to operate under the 1940 Act prior to the adoption of Rule 6c-11.[5]
In order to qualify for the expedited review process, an application must meet two requirements established under the Amendments. First, an application must be “substantially identical” to two prior applications in which the SEC granted relief.[6] Based on recent informal Staff guidance provided prior to adoption of the Amendments, we anticipate that this prong of the Amendments will be construed narrowly, at least at the outset. As a result, we expect that even minor modifications of definitions or conditions included in applications for exemptive relief may cause those applications to fall outside of the expedited review process. Second, both “substantially identical” applications must have been approved within the preceding two years of the current application.[7] This second prong may in certain cases limit the availability of expedited review to more common applications, such as those for co-investment relief. If an application qualifies for the expedited review process, a decision on the application will be issued by the SEC within 45 days of the application being filed with the SEC.[8] Applicants will be notified by the Staff should their application be ineligible for expedited review.[9] Once the Staff has issued comments on an application under expedited review, applicants have 30 days to respond to Staff comments.[10]
While the Amendments provide a significantly faster path forward for routine applications for exemptive relief that can meet both prongs of the test for expedited review, the nature of the those prongs may pose challenges for certain applicants that may need slight deviations from prior precedent. As a result, prospective applicants may want to consider forgoing even minor changes to the wording of defined terms or conditions included in proposed applications from prior precedent if the timing of exemptive relief is critical to their operations. In addition, prospective applicants who may require even minor deviations from the wording of prior applications may wish to discuss such changes with the Staff in advance of filing to confirm whether their application would continue to qualify for expedited review.
If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.
Authored by Karen Spiegel and Noah B. Aschen.
[1] Investment Company Act Release No. 33921, July 9, 2020, available here.
[2] Investment Company Act Release No. 33329, Dec. 19, 2018, available here.
[3] The proposed rule, if enacted, will permit a registered investment company or business development company to acquire the securities of any other registered investment company or business development company in an amount that exceeds the limits in section 12(d)(1) of the 1940 Act.
[4] Investment Company Act Release No. 33646, Sept. 26, 2019, available here.
[5] Id.
[6] The Amendments define “substantially identical” as applications “requesting relief from the same sections of the Act and 17 CFR part 270, containing identical terms and conditions, and differing only with respect to factual differences that are not material to the relief requested.” Supra note 1.
[7] Id.
[8] The SEC is also establishing a timeframe for applications ineligible for expedited review. All applications (the initial filing through the third amendment) will be considered within 90 days of filing. All subsequent amendments to an application will be considered within 60 days of filing. Id.
[9] Id.
[10] Under the standard review process, applicants have 120 days to respond to Staff comments. Id.
This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2020 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.
All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

ARTICLE
July 2020
Read time: 1 min

ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
July 10, 2020
Read time: 8 min
The German Federal Court of Justice (FCJ) has issued its decision in a landmark case regarding standard essential patents (SEPs) and fair, reasonable and nondiscriminatory (FRAND) licensing of SEPs. The judgment, dated 5 May 2020, was handed down in litigation between the Sisvel patent pool and Chinese consumer electronics manufacturer Haier (FCJ docket no. KZR 36/17). The judgment will shape FRAND licensing negotiations and impact the enforcement of SEPs before German courts.
Key Takeaways
Background
Sisvel sued Haier for infringement of a patent that Sisvel alleged was essential for the GPRS wireless communication standard. The FCJ judgment focuses on FRAND aspects of the case.
In the lower instance, the Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf (Appeal Court) found Sisvel’s patent in suit to be standard essential and infringed by Haier. However, the Appeal Court also found that Sisvel violated its FRAND obligations by granting significant benefits (discounts in a range of 80%) to an existing licensee (Hisense), while not offering equivalent benefits to Haier. Lacking sufficient justification for treating Haier differently from Hisense, as the Appeal Court said, Sisvel was found to abuse a dominant market position.
The FCJ overruled the Appeal Court findings in part. While confirming that Sisvel had a dominant position on the market for licensing its SEP, the FCJ did not find any abuse of this dominant position. The FCJ discussion of FRAND obligations, which primarily emphasizes the obligations that implementers have in license negotiations, is mostly favorable to Sisvel and to other SEP holders. Read our IP Update article, “Landmark decision in German FRAND case,” for prior coverage of this case.
The Judgment
First, the FCJ confirmed that Sisvel held a dominant position during the lifetime of its relevant patent, since the patent was standard essential for GPRS and since GPRS compliance was market necessary for the relevant products that Haier and others made. However, the FCJ also confirmed what the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) established in its Huawei v. ZTE decision: An SEP holder is not necessarily precluded from enforcing its patent against an implementer. Depending on whether the SEP holder and an implementer have taken certain steps in FRAND negotiations, the SEP holder may be free to seek an injunction against the respective implementer.
Infringement Notice
The FCJ further confirmed that as a first step in the FRAND negotiation procedure, the SEP holder should notify the respective implementer of the alleged patent infringement. To satisfy this obligation, a notice to the parent company of the implementer will usually suffice.
The infringement notice is intended to make an implementer aware of its alleged use of the relevant patent(s), and of the alleged need to obtain a license. It is sufficient for an SEP holder to briefly identify the relevant patent(s), to specify the nature of the alleged infringement and to identify the allegedly infringing products. Detailed technical or legal explanations of the infringement allegation are not required. The implementer need only be sufficiently informed to understand the infringement allegation. The burden then shifts to the implementer to further investigate its possible infringement, if necessary with expert or outside counsel assistance. It is usually sufficient and customary, but not strictly necessary, for an SEP holder to explain the infringement allegation by providing claim charts.
Furthermore, an SEP holder who has identified relevant SEP(s) and the relevant standard may expect an implementer to provide notice within a short period should the implementer believe the information provided is insufficient to understand the infringement allegation. Depending on the circumstances, the SEP holder may be obliged to add to its initial explanations of the alleged infringement.
Willingness to Take a License
It will constitute an abuse of a dominant market position if an SEP holder asserts claims for an injunction, destruction and recall of products against an implementer if that implementer has made an unconditional offer to conclude a license agreement on terms that the SEP holder may not refuse without violating FRAND principles. The FCJ further noted that while a declaration of willingness to license must be unconditional, an implementer may reserve the right, even after a license agreement has been concluded, to challenge use and validity of any licensed patents.
After receiving an infringement notice, it will not suffice for an implementer to merely indicate that it will consider concluding a license agreement or entering into licensing negotiations. Rather, an implementer must clearly and unambiguously declare its willingness to conclude a license agreement on FRAND terms. In this respect, the FCJ cited with approval the ruling of Judge Colin Birss of the High Court of Justice of England and Wales in the judgment rendered in Unwired Planet v. Huawei: “a willing licensee must be one willing to take a FRAND licence on whatever terms are in fact FRAND.” Furthermore, the FCJ clarified that an implementer must expediently engage in actual licensing negotiations. The FCJ found that Haier had not met these requirements.
Moreover, the FCJ found that an implementer who remains silent for several months after receiving an infringement notice may be taken not to be interested in obtaining a license. However, the FCJ did not decide whether a declaration of license willingness that comes only after expiration of a reasonable response time may be considered irrelevant, or whether a late declaration can still obligate an SEP holder to engage in FRAND negotiations.
FRAND Offer
Upon receiving a timely and sufficient license willingness declaration from an implementer, an SEP holder is obliged to make a FRAND license offer. In doing so, the SEP holder is obligated to explain why the offered licensing terms should be regarded as FRAND. This is particularly true if the SEP holder offers a portfolio license covering a number of patents, rather than offering to license a single patent. Still the FCJ confirmed that portfolio licensing per se will usually not violate FRAND principles.
What constitutes fair, reasonable and nondiscriminatory terms of a license agreement will be case specific and will depend on the circumstances. In any event, under case law on the abuse of a dominant market position, and under a FRAND declaration made toward a standard-setting organization, an SEP holder will usually not be obliged to grant licenses on uniform terms to all licensees. There will be room for a variance in terms, if the differences in circumstances justify the variance in terms. In the case between Sisvel and Haier, the FCJ considered that differences between the terms offered to Haier on the one hand, and to Hisense on the other hand, may be justifiable in view of acts of state that may have caused Sisvel to grant extraordinary discounts to Hisense.
Gist
The FCJ judgment in Sisvel v. Haier does not answer all questions around SEP enforcement and FRAND licensing that are being heavily debated before German lower instance courts. For example, the FCJ does not rule on specific questions of determining actual amounts of FRAND royalties, which is a ground that German courts have been more reluctant to cover than courts in the United States or the United Kingdom. Also, the FCJ did not have to decide questions around licensing SEPs to supply chains. However, the FCJ gave guidance on the FRAND negotiation procedure. Both implementers and SEP holders should consider this guidance, and implementers in particular should note that the FCJ has stressed their obligations.
ARTICLE
July 2020
Read time: 1 min
ARTICLE
Summer 2020
Read time: 1 min

ARTICLE
July 2020
Read time: 2 min
Julie Miraglia Kwon co authored this three part series focused on Qualified Small Business Stock for July editions of Tax Notes.
Access all three parts of the series, “Qualified Small Business Stock: Quest for Quantum Exclusions.”

ARTICLE
July 9, 2020
Read time: 1 min