ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
Supreme Court OKs CMS Vaccine Mandate but Blocks OSHA Rule
January 14, 2022
Read time: 10 min
UPDATE (1/19/2022):
To align with the US Supreme Court’s January 13, 2022, decision, the Texas injunction referenced below was lifted on January 19, 2022. Accordingly, the CMS vaccination mandate is now enforceable nationwide.
On January 13, 2022, the Supreme Court of the United States released two emergency opinions that change the landscape of the three federal vaccine rules. In summary:
- A 5-4 Court majority let the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) enforce its vaccine mandate nationwide, impacting specified healthcare facilities.
- A 6-3 majority blocked the US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) from enforcing its vax-or-test Emergency Temporary Standard (ETS) applicable to large employers.
- The third federal vaccine rule—the federal contractor vaccine mandate—remains subject to multiple legal challenges and, at this time, the government is blocked from enforcing the mandate nationwide. The Court has not yet weighed in on this mandate.
This On the Subject addresses next steps and strategies for employers, whether covered by the in-effect Interim Final Rule with Comment that creates the CMS vaccine mandate (CMS Rule), or by one of the stayed OSHA or federal contractor rules.
THE CMS VACCINE MANDATE IS ENFORCEABLE IN EVERY STATE
The CMS Rule is now enforceable in every state except Texas (which has a separate injunction in place), across the full spectrum of the 15 provider types covered by the rule.
Who does this impact? The CMS Rule applies to 15 specific healthcare provider/supplier types (such as hospitals, ASCs, hospices, and other specified facilities and providers) that participate in Medicare and Medicaid programs and are therefore CMS-regulated. Not all Medicare/Medicaid participating providers are covered by this rule—only those operating specified facilities.
What does the CMS Rule require? The facilities covered by the CMS Rule must comply with its requirements within the time frames developed by CMS:
- All individuals working in covered facilities (including employees, contractors, volunteers, etc.) must have their first vaccine dose (or make an exemption request based on disability/medical or religion) by January 27, 2022 (if in Group 1), or February 14, 2022 (if in Group 2); and
- The same individuals must have their second vaccine dose for a two-dose vaccine regimen (or exemption approval from the facility) by February 28, 2022 (if in Group 1), or March 15, 2022 (if in Group 2).
- Group 1 states include: California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Florida, Hawaii, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, North Carolina, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Tennessee, Vermont, Virginia, Washington and Wisconsin.
- Group 2 states include: Alabama, Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, Georgia, Idaho, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, New Hampshire, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, South Carolina, South Dakota, Utah, West Virginia and Wyoming.
What should covered providers and suppliers do now? Providers that paused or slowed compliance efforts during the pendency of the stay will now need to re-evaluate their plans and move quickly towards compliance. This movement must occur in an extremely short timeline—unless further extended by CMS—as the first compliance date is only two weeks away. The CMS Quality, Safety and Oversight Group released a memorandum on December 28, 2021 (QSO-22-07-ALL), which set forth modified compliance dates for both “phases” described in the IFR and detailed a graduated enforcement mechanism, as outlined below:
| Phase | Basic Requirement | Enforcement Risks |
|---|---|---|
| Phase 1
January 27, 2022 (Group 1; see above) OR February 14, 2022 (Group 2; see above)
|
Vaccination policies in place and covered staff have received the first dose of a multi-dose vaccine or requesting a federally recognized exemption |
|
| Phase 2
February 28, 2022 (Group 1; see above) OR March 15, 2022 (Group 2; see above) (unless modified by CMS)
|
Vaccination policies fully implemented and covered staff have received the second dose of a multi-dose vaccine (or a single dose of a single-dose vaccine) or have received a federally recognized exemption |
|
(Read more about the graduated enforcement approach, the potential severity level of survey findings and the specific requirements applicable to the various categories of covered providers in our prior On the Subject.)
Note that 90 days after the applicable Phase 2 date has passed (meaning March 28, 2022 (Group 1), or April 14, 2022 (Group 2), any covered provider that is found to have less than 100% compliance with the CMS Rule requirements will be subject to enforcement action.
Covered providers that are located in states that have laws or other restrictions prohibiting vaccine mandates will need to work closely with their counsel to determine how best to manage the conflict between federal and some states’ laws. While CMS has asserted that the CMS Rule preempts inconsistent state and local laws, those states that prohibit healthcare facilities from requiring the COVID-19 vaccine as a condition of employment may still take steps to enforce such state laws notwithstanding the Court’s decision. The January 13 decision will bring this issue to the fore, and the ultimate resolution of this regulatory “catch 22” will almost certainly involve further litigation.
OSHA “VAX-OR-TEST” RULE IS STAYED PENDING SIXTH CIRCUIT RULING ON THE MERITS
The OSHA “vax-or-test” ETS is stayed nationwide and is unlikely to come back into effect prior to its expiration. In other words, the OSHA ETS is dead, and employers need not comply with its requirements at this time.
How did we get here? The OSHA ETS would have required employers with 100 or more employees to require masking and weekly COVID-19 testing of unvaccinated employees, and provide PTO to employees to get vaccinated. The ETS was immediately challenged in multiple forums, and the US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit stayed enforcement nationwide. The cases were then consolidated before the US Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, which dissolved the stay, allowing the ETS to be enforced nationwide. The decision on the stay was then appealed to the Supreme Court, which reinstituted the nationwide stay. Thus far, the litigation has been over whether OSHA should be enjoined from enforcing its ETS, not whether the ETS is definitively enforceable; the stay has been issued pending resolution of the litigation on the merits at the Sixth Circuit.
What happens now? Until the case resolves on the merits, and unless the Sixth Circuit rules in OSHA’s favor, any large employer that would have been covered by this rule no longer needs to comply with its requirements. Moreover, given that the OSHA ETS is a temporary standard lasting only six months, it is unlikely that the Sixth Circuit litigation will come to a close with enough time for OSHA to win and begin any meaningful enforcement prior to the expiration date. This is why the OSHA ETS is effectively dead.
What should large employers do now? With no OSHA ETS enforcement in sight, companies that have already issued OSHA ETS-compliant vaccine and testing policies may choose to withdraw or modify those policies. In addition, companies that wish to continue with their vaccine or testing policies should review their policies with counsel and confirm that these policies remain compliant with all applicable state or local laws, as the OSHA ETS will not take precedent over any conflicting state law given the stay. That said, employers know that these frequent changes in company policy may cause workforce disruption and employee confusion. Therefore, employers must weigh the benefits and risks that further policy changes may garner.
What will happen next? OSHA has not yet issued any statement, but there may be several options for OSHA and its state counterparts in the near future:
- OSHA could pursue a permanent rule, or simply forego further rulemaking along these lines.
- OSHA could try its hand at another, narrower ETS. Notably, in the Supreme Court’s majority opinion that stayed the OSHA ETS, it signaled openness to permitting OSHA to promulgate a rule more narrowly tailored to address particular worksites where “the virus poses a special danger because of the particular features of an employee’s job or workplace,” giving examples of researchers who work with the COVID-19 virus, or workers who work in “particularly crowded or cramped environments.” Thus, OSHA may try again at a narrower rule focused on industry-specific dangers.
- Twenty-two states have their own state-level OSHAs that cover both private and government workers, with another six state plans covering state and local government only. Those state plans could issue their own rules, which would only add to the patchwork of COVID-19 laws and requirements already burdening large, multi-state employers. That said, many state plans have indicated that they would only issue an OSHA ETS-like standard if the OSHA ETS was permitted to go forward, so it may be unlikely that most state OSHAs will do so. Illinois, which adopted the OSHA ETS prior to the Supreme Court’s stay, did so with the caveat that it would rescind the ETS if the Supreme Court issued a stay.
THE FEDERAL CONTRACTOR VACCINE MANDATE REMAINS STAYED NATIONWIDE
Pursuant to a series of court rulings, the federal contractor vaccine mandate is stayed nationwide at this time.
How did we get here? The federal contractor vaccine mandate would have required certain covered federal contractors and subcontractors to impose vaccine mandates on all employees who provide services related to the federal contracts, as well as certain workplace-safety requirements. However, this vaccine mandate faces challenges in multiple federal courts, including a litigation pending before the US Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit in which the Court issued a nationwide injunction blocking the government from enforcing the rule. The litigation matters are all currently pending in Circuit and lower courts, none of which have yet sought Supreme Court review.
What happens now? The contractor mandate remains stayed nationwide and cannot be enforced. The Eleventh Circuit—which issued a nationwide stay of the rule pending further litigation on the merits—has issued an expedited briefing schedule which will conclude on January 24, 2022. Oral arguments will be scheduled during the next available hearing session, but the exact timeline is not yet available as of this On the Subject‘s publishing.
* * *
McDermott Will & Emery is closely tracking developments in these litigation matters and assisting companies across industries with strategy and compliance efforts related to these developments. Please do not hesitate to reach out to the authors of this article or your McDermott Will & Emery lawyer for more information.

Are Out-of-Pocket Costs on Their Way Out? At-Home COVID-19 Testing and Expanded Preventative Healthcare for Women and Children
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
Are Out-of-Pocket Costs on Their Way Out? At-Home COVID-19 Testing and Expanded Preventative Healthcare for Women and Children
January 14, 2022
Read time: 5 min
In response to a directive from the White House, based on provisions of the Families First Coronavirus Response Act (FFCRA) and the Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security (CARES) Act that eliminated cost sharing for COVID-19 diagnostic testing, three federal government departments—the US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), the US Department of Labor (Labor) and the US Department of the Treasury (Treasury)—issued guidance in the form of frequently asked questions (FAQs) that states group health plans and insurers must also cover over-the-counter (OTC) COVID-19 diagnostic testing. This guidance is effective beginning January 15, 2022.
In addition, the Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA) updated the Affordable Care Act’s (ACA) comprehensive preventive care and screening guidelines for women and children to cover additional services and supplies without a copay or deductible, effective 2023.
COVID-19 AT-HOME TESTING COVERAGE
On January 10, 2022, HHS, Labor and the Treasury together issued FAQs that elaborated on prior guidance and indicated that group health plans and insurers are required to cover OTC COVID-19 diagnostic tests without cost sharing. Because of the recent spike in COVID-19 cases resulting from the rapid spread of the Omicron variant, the guidance will continue for the duration of the public emergency.
Most consumers with private health coverage will be able to buy OTC COVID-19 tests and either have the cost covered upfront or be reimbursed later by submitting a claim to their health plan. The new requirement only applies to “diagnostic” OTC COVID-19 testing. It does not include the treatment of COVID-19 or testing that is for employment purposes.
The guidance provides that health plans and insurers must cover at least eight OTC COVID-19 diagnostic tests per covered individual per a 30-day period. Insurers will be able to set up networks of preferred suppliers to provide OTC COVID-19 tests directly to participants without upfront costs. Insurers must still reimburse OTC COVID-19 tests purchased outside the direct coverage program, however, the reimbursable amount is limited to $12 per test if the health plan also provides tests through its preferred pharmacy network and through a direct-to-consumer shipping program without upfront costs.
Besides the risk of increasing the average cost of OTC COVID-19 tests, the new initiative raises concerns over fraud and abuse. For health plans and insurers to protect themselves, the FAQs provide several examples of permissible activities to prevent fraud and abuse, like requiring proof of purchase or an attestation that the test was purchased for proper purposes (i.e., is being used by the covered individual, is not being reimbursed by another source, is not being resold and is not for employment purposes).
HRSA Updates ACA Preventive HealthCare Guidelines
On January 11, 2022, HRSA announced that it updated the preventive health and screening guidelines for women, infants, children and adolescents. Under the ACA, certain group health plans and insurers must provide coverage with no out-of-pocket costs for preventive health services within these HRSA-endorsed comprehensive guidelines.
HRSA accepted the updates recommended by the Women’s Preventative Services Initiative that expand the existing Women’s Preventative Services Guidelines (WPSG) regarding breastfeeding services and supplies (including no out-of-pocket costs for a double electric breast pump), well-woman preventive care visits, contraceptives and contraceptive counseling, screening for human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), counseling for sexually transmitted infections (STIs) and counseling for obesity in midlife women.
HRSA also accepted updates recommended by the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) to the existing Bright Futures guidelines, which added the following:
- Universal screening for suicide risk to the current depression screening category for individuals ages 12 to 21;
- New guidance for behavioral, social and emotional screenings;
- New guidelines for assessing risks for cardiac arrest or death for individuals ages 11 to 21; and
- New guidelines for assessing risk for hepatitis B infection in newborns to 21-year-olds.
NEXT STEPS
In addition to ensuring the updated preventative health guidelines are implemented, plan sponsors should work with their third-party administrator or insurer to develop a process for coverage of OTC COVID-19 tests and to develop procedures to reduce the risk of participant fraud. The new requirements should be incorporated into relevant participant communications, such as open enrollment and communication materials, plan documents, summary plan descriptions and summary of material modifications.
For further information on applying the above rules, please contact your regular McDermott lawyer or one of the authors of this article.
Confusion About Shortening the Corona Quarantine – What Applies Now and from When?
ARTICLE
Confusion About Shortening the Corona Quarantine – What Applies Now and from When?
January 12, 2022
Read time: 2 min
Last Friday, the Conference of Ministers decided that the quarantine period should be shortened. The background to this decision is the fear that with rapidly increasing numbers of Omikron infections and the associated quarantine times, there is a risk that the critical infrastructure can no longer be maintained. However, health departments have reported confusion among affected citizens in recent days, as it has not been clearly communicated in the press when the new regulations will apply.

FinCEN Issues Notice of Proposed Rulemaking Regarding Beneficial Ownership Information Reporting Requirements Under the Corporate Transparency Act
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
FinCEN Issues Notice of Proposed Rulemaking Regarding Beneficial Ownership Information Reporting Requirements Under the Corporate Transparency Act
January 14, 2022
Read time: 20 min
On Dec. 8, 2021, the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, a bureau of the United States Department of the Treasury (“FinCEN”), issued a notice of proposed rulemaking (“NPRM”)[1] continuing the process of implementing regulations required under the Corporate Transparency Act (“CTA”).[2] Enacted by Congress on Dec. 31, 2020, as part of the National Defense Authorization Act, the CTA requires certain domestic and foreign companies created or registered to do business in the United States (each, a “Reporting Company”) to report certain identifying information, including their 25% or more owners and control persons, directly to FinCEN.[3] That information is to be held in a non-public database maintained by FinCEN and will be shared with law enforcement, federal regulators and financial institutions, among others.
FinCEN intends to issue three rulemakings to fully implement the requirements of the CTA — the first will implement the beneficial ownership information reporting requirements, the second will implement the CTA’s protocols for access to and disclosure of beneficial ownership information and the third will revise the existing Customer Due Diligence rule (“CDD Rule”) to align it with the new requirements imposed by the CTA. The NPRM seeks comments initially only on the beneficial ownership information reporting requirements.
The reporting obligations discussed herein will only take effect upon the promulgation of final regulations by FinCEN. The NPRM follows an advanced notice of proposed rulemaking (“ANPRM”) that was issued on April 5, 2021 and requested public comment on numerous questions relevant to the implementation of the CTA.[4] Comments in response to the NPRM are due February 7, 2021.
Information to be Reported
The CTA requires each Reporting Company to disclose beneficial ownership information (“BOI”) regarding (1) its beneficial owners, including 25% or more owners and control persons; (2) individuals who register the Reporting Company or file the application necessary for the Reporting Company to do business in the United States (“Company Applicant”); and (3) other identifying information regarding the Reporting Company. Reporting Companies may also voluntarily report the taxpayer identification number of their beneficial owners (after receiving consent from such beneficial owners) to help ensure that the BOI is highly useful to those with access.
Beneficial Owners (Ownership and Control)
The CTA defines a “beneficial owner” as an individual who, directly or indirectly, through any contract, arrangement, understanding, relationship or otherwise (i) owns or controls not less than 25% of the ownership interests of the Reporting Company (“ownership prong”) or (ii) exercises substantial control over the Reporting Company (“control prong”)(each, a “Beneficial Owner”). While not defined in the CTA, the NPRM proposes definitions for “ownership interests” and “substantial control” to clarify which individuals fall into each of the ownership and control prongs.
The CTA requires each Reporting Company to identity each of its Beneficial Owners by:
- Full legal name
- Date of birth
- Complete current residential street address
- A unique identifying number from an acceptable identification document[5]
- Image of the document from which the unique identifying number was obtained
Ownership Prong. Ownership interests includes both equity in the Reporting Company and other types of interests, such as capital or profit interests (including partnership interests) or convertible instruments, warrants or rights or other options or privileges to acquire equity, capital or other interests in a Reporting Company. Debt instruments are included if they enable the holder to exercise the same rights as one of the specified equity or other interests, including the ability to convert the instrument into one of the specified equity or other interests. This is similar to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission’s definition of “equity security” in 17 C.F.R. § 230. The proposed language also aims to make clear that an individual may own or control ownership interests through a trust by way of the individual’s position as a grantor or settlor, a beneficiary, a trustee or another individual with authority to dispose of trust assets. An individual may reach the 25% threshold by jointly owning or controlling with one or more other persons an undivided ownership interest in a Reporting Company. FinCEN declined to follow the CDD Rule in defining ownership interests where only “equity interests” are relevant.
Control Prong. The CTA requires Reporting Companies to report the BOI of each control person. There are three specific indicators of substantial control: (1) service as a senior officer of a Reporting Company; (2) authority over the appointment or removal of any senior officer or dominant majority of the board of directors (or similar body) of a Reporting Company; and (3) direction, determination or decision of, or substantial influence over, important matters of a Reporting Company. The NPRM also includes a catch-all provision to make clear that substantial control can take additional forms not specifically listed. An individual may directly or indirectly exercise substantial control over a Reporting Company through a variety of means, including through board representation; through ownership or control of a majority or dominant minority of the voting shares of the Reporting Company; through rights associated with any financing arrangement or interest in a Reporting Company; through control over one or more intermediary entities that separately or collectively exercise substantial control over a Reporting Company; through arrangements or financial or business relationships, whether formal or informal, with other individuals or entities acting as nominees, or through any other contract, arrangement, understanding, relationship or otherwise. While FinCEN acknowledged concerns raised in the comments to the ANPRM that a definition of substantial control that is too broad may cause confusion, FinCEN believes that the proposed rule provides sufficient specificity while being flexible enough to account for unique ways in which individuals can exercise substantial control over an entity. FinCEN also believes that entities are already aware of their own ownership structures, regardless of complexity and should be able to readily identify their beneficial owners. Unlike the CDD Rule, the NPRM-proposed definition could require information to be provided on more than one individual under the control prong. FinCEN considered, but decided not to follow, the CDD Rule because the limitation on the number of control persons, FinCEN says, is inconsistent with the CTA’s objective of establishing a comprehensive BOI database for all beneficial owners of Reporting Companies.
Exclusions. Beneficial Owner does not include an individual acting as: (i) a nominee, intermediary, custodian or agent on behalf of another individual; (ii) an employee of a Reporting Company, acting solely as an employee and not as a senior officer, whose substantial control over or economic benefits from such entity are derived solely from the employment status of the employee; (iii) an entity’s creditors, unless the creditor holds at least 25% of the entity or has substantial control over the entity; (iv) an individual whose only interest in a Reporting Company is a future interest through a right of inheritance; or (v) a minor child if the information of a parent or guardian is reported.[6]
Company Applicants
A Company Applicant is defined as any individual who files a document that creates a domestic Reporting Company or who first registers a foreign Reporting Company with a secretary of state or a similar office within the United States. This includes any individual who directs or controls the filing of such a document by another person. Reporting Companies are required to disclose the same BOI for Company Applicants as for Beneficial Owners, except a business address rather than residential address may be used.
Information About the Reporting Company
While not specifically mentioned in the CTA, the NPRM proposes that each Reporting Company be required to report to FinCEN:
- Full name of the Reporting Company
- Any trade name or “doing business as” name of the Reporting Company
- Business street address of the Reporting Company
- State or tribal jurisdiction of formation of the Reporting Company
- IRS Taxpayer Identification Number (or, if not available, a DUNS number or Legal Entity Identifier)
FinCEN Identifier
The NPRM provides that an individual may obtain a FinCEN identifier by providing FinCEN with the information that the individual would otherwise have to provide to a Reporting Company if the individual were a Beneficial Owner of the Reporting Company; an entity can obtain such FinCEN identifier from FinCEN when it submits a filing as a Reporting Company or any time thereafter. This means that an individual or legal entity must still disclose information to FinCEN, but once an individual or legal entity has a FinCEN identifier, the individual or legal entity can provide the FinCEN identifier to a Reporting Company in lieu of the personal details required to be disclosed.
Reporting Companies
Subject to numerous exceptions which are designed to exclude many regulated entities and operating business, as discussed below, the CTA broadly defines a Reporting Company as any:
Corporation, limited liability company or other similar entity that is (i) created by the filing of a document with a secretary of state or a similar office under the law of a state or an Indian tribe or (ii) formed under the law of a foreign country and registered to do business in the United States by the filing of a document with a secretary of state or a similar office under the laws of a state or an Indian tribe.[7]
The NPRM breaks out Reporting Companies into domestic Reporting Companies and foreign Reporting Companies. A domestic Reporting Company is defined to include: (1) a corporation, (2) a limited liability company or (3) other entity that is created by the filing of a document with a secretary of state or a similar office under the law of a state or Indian tribe. FinCEN believes that the proposed definition of domestic Reporting Company would likely include limited liability partnerships, limited liability limited partnerships, business trusts (a/k/a statutory trusts or Massachusetts trusts), and most limited partnerships, in addition to corporations and limited liability companies (LLCs), because such entities appear typically to be created by a filing with a secretary of state or similar office.
The NPRM defines a foreign Reporting Company as any entity that is a corporation, limited liability company, or other entity that is formed under the law of a foreign country and that is registered to do business in the United States by the filing of a document with a secretary of state or equivalent office under the law of a state or an Indian tribe.
Entities Exempt from Definition of Reporting Company
The CTA provides 23 exemptions from the definition of Reporting Company, many of which are designed to exclude entities already required to disclose beneficial ownership information publicly or to federal regulators. Subject to a few clarifications and minor alterations to paragraph structure and the addition of short titles, FinCEN proposes to adopt verbatim the statutory language contained in the CTA. The exemptions include, among others[8]:
- An investment company[9] that is registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) under the Investment Company Act of 1940[10] (“40 Act”).[11]
- An investment adviser[12] that is registered with the SEC under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940[13] (“Advisers Act”).[14]
- A venture capital fund adviser: (i) described in section 203(l) of the Advisers Act, and (ii) that has filed Item 10, Schedule A, and Schedule B of Part 1A of Form ADV, or any successor thereto, with the SEC.[15]
- Banks.[16]
- Federal or state credit unions.[17]
- Broker-dealers.[18]
- Futures commission merchants, introducing brokers, swap dealers, major swap participants, commodity pool operators, and commodity trading advisers that are registered with the Commodities Futures Trading Commission.
- An insurance company as defined in section 2 of the 40 Act.
- Any “pooled investment vehicle” that is operated or advised by a (i) bank, (ii) federal or state credit union, (iii) SEC-registered broker or dealer, (iv) SEC-registered investment adviser or (v) venture capital fund adviser.[19]
- The CTA defines a “pooled investment vehicle” to mean (i) any investment company, as defined in section 3(a) of the 40 Act;[20] or (ii) any company that (a) would be an investment company under that section but for the exclusion provided from that definition by paragraph (1) or (7) of section 3(c) of the 40 Act,[21] and (b) is identified by its legal name by the applicable investment adviser in its Form ADV (or successor form) filed with the SEC.
- Large operating companies that (1) employ more than 20 employees on a full-time basis in the United States; (2) who have “filed in the previous year Federal income tax returns in the United States demonstrating more than $5,000,000 in gross receipts or sales in the aggregate,” including the receipts or sales of other entities owned by the entity and through which the entity operates; and (3) who have “ an operating presence at a physical office within the United States.
The CTA also provides for a “subsidiary exemption”—a truncated filing for Beneficial Owners of Reporting Companies that are, themselves, exempt from the definition of Reporting Company. If an entity that is exempt from the definition of Reporting Company is a Beneficial Owner of a Reporting Company, the Reporting Company is only required to report the name of the exempt entity Beneficial Owner and need not report any other information with regard to that exempt entity.[22] The NPRM proposes that in order to take advantage of this “subsidiary exemption,” the entity must be owned entirely by one or more specified exempt entities. While the subsidiary exemption provides for simpler filings than required in other instances, complex entity structures with many subsidiaries may have to file many truncated reports, including the same Reporting Company as the only beneficial owner. FinCEN did not consider ways to simplify the reporting process for such complex entity structures.
While commenters to the ANPRM proposed adding additional exemptions to the definition of Reporting Company, including for certain commodity pools, additional pooled investment vehicles, additional investment advisors, and family offices, FinCEN did not include those exemptions, but welcomed additional comments on whether to adopt exemptions beyond those specifically required by statute.
Exemptions to the Definition of Reporting Company Relevant to Investment Funds and Investment Advisers
The exemptions to the definition of Reporting Company include most private investment funds and their advisers, relieving most funds and advisers from reporting their beneficial ownership information to FinCEN. More specifically, the CTA exempts from the definition of Reporting Company: a mutual fund; an SEC-registered investment adviser; a venture capital fund adviser, as defined under Rule 203(l)-1; and a pooled investment vehicle that is formed under the laws of the United States that is operated or advised by a bank, a credit union, a broker-dealer, an SEC-registered investment adviser or a venture capital fund adviser. Each of these entities is not required to submit a report to FinCEN with BOI.
Certain advisers that are not registered with the SEC, such as state-registered investment advisers and advisers relying on the “private fund adviser exemption,” as defined under Rule 203(m)-1, available to advisers that solely advise private funds if the adviser has assets under management in the United States of less than $150 million, are not currently exempt from the definition of Reporting Company. As presently drafted, such advisers will be required to report beneficial ownership information to FinCEN unless another exemption applies. For example, an investment adviser that is not otherwise exempt may be able to rely on the exemption available for an entity that employs more than 20 employees on a full-time basis in the United States, has more than $5 million in gross receipts or sales in the aggregate and maintains a physical office presence within the United States.
Similarly, the pooled investment vehicles advised by advisers that are neither registered with the SEC nor advisers relying on the venture capital exemption may not be exempt from the definition of Reporting Company. For example, a pooled investment vehicle advised by an adviser relying on the “private fund adviser exemption” available to advisers that solely advise private funds if the adviser has assets under management in the United States of less than $150 million, may be required to submit a report to FinCEN with beneficial ownership information. Moreover, pooled investment vehicles managed by commodity trading advisers are not currently exempt from the reporting requirements.
The CTA provides a modified reporting requirement for foreign pooled investment vehicles. The NPRM proposes that if an entity would be a Reporting Company but for the exemption provided for pooled investment vehicles operated or advised by a bank, credit union, broker or dealer, or SEC-registered investment company or adviser, or venture capital fund adviser (“Exempt Pooled Investment Vehicle”), and is formed under the laws of a foreign country, such entity shall be deemed a Reporting Company, but only required to provide information to FinCEN with respect to an individual who exercises substantial control over the entity. Under this modified reporting requirement, such entity would be required to report information with respect to “the individual who has the greatest authority over the strategic management of the entity.” It is unclear if this modified reporting requirement is intended to apply only to foreign pooled investment vehicles that are Exempt Pooled Investment Vehicles and meet the definition of “foreign reporting company,” which is limited to entities formed under the law of a foreign country and registered to do business in the U.S., or if it is intended to apply more broadly to an Exempt Pooled Investment Vehicle that is formed under the laws of a foreign country. If the latter approach is the intended approach, then the modified reporting requirement would apply, for example, to all foreign-domiciled pooled investment vehicles operated or advised by an SEC-registered investment adviser.
Because private investment fund managers often advise numerous funds and special purpose vehicles, both foreign and domestic, it is important for them to understand the CTA’s requirements and FinCEN’s implementing regulations, once promulgated, and incorporate any applicable reporting obligations into their compliance functions.
Report Timing
The timing requirements to file an initial report with FinCEN differ based on whether the Reporting Company is formed before or after the effective date of the CTA’s implementing regulations. FinCEN proposes in the NPRM that:
- Any domestic Reporting Company formed on or after the effective date of the final rule shall file a report within 14 calendar days of the date it was formed as specified by a secretary of state or similar office. Similarly, any entity that becomes a foreign Reporting Company on or after the effective date of the final rule shall file a report within 14 calendar days of the date on which it first becomes a foreign Reporting Company.
- Any domestic Reporting Company created before the effective date of the final rule and any entity that became a foreign Reporting Company before the effective date of the final rule shall file a report not later than one year after the effective date of the final rule.
- Any entities that are no longer Reporting Companies by virtue of one or more exemptions are required to file a report within 30 calendar days after the date on which the entity no longer meets any exemption criteria.
FinCEN proposes that Reporting Companies be required to file an updated report within 30 days after the date on which there is any change with respect to any information previously submitted to FinCEN, including any change with respect to who is a beneficial owner of a Reporting Company, as well as any change with respect to information reported for any particular Beneficial Owner. If a Reporting Company becomes exempt after filing an initial report, this change will require an updated report.
FinCEN also proposes requiring Reporting Companies to file a report to correct inaccurately filed information within 14 days after the date on which the Reporting Company becomes aware or has reason to know that any required information contained in any report that the Reporting Company filed with FinCEN was inaccurate when filed and remains inaccurate. This would include information about any Beneficial Owner and the Reporting Company.
Penalties
The CTA prescribes penalties for failing to report or reporting inaccurate or incomplete information. Any person who (i) willfully provides, or attempts to provide, false or fraudulent beneficial ownership information, including a false or fraudulent identifying photograph or document; or (ii) willfully fails to report, complete or update beneficial ownership information (a) shall be liable for a civil penalty of not more than $500 for each day that the violation continues or has not been remedied and (b) may be fined not more than $10,000, imprisoned for not more than two years or both.[23] The NPRM clarifies that this applies to individuals, including Beneficial Owners, as well as Reporting Companies. However, there is a safe harbor if a report that contains inaccurate information is voluntarily corrected within 90 days, so long as the inaccurate report was not submitted to evade the reporting requirements or with actual knowledge of its inaccuracy.[24]
Conclusion
The CTA is an important step toward revealing BOI often used to hide money laundering and terrorist financing. The centralized BOI database will provide law enforcement, financial regulators and financial institutions with important information that Congress has determined necessary in order to combat financial crime.
The goal of the CTA is to require BOI be reported to FinCEN where that information is not available elsewhere. However, as noted in Schulte Roth & Zabel’s comment letter to the ANPRM, [25] there are several types of entities which we suggest should be exempt from reporting BOI when that information is available elsewhere to regulators. Those include exempt reporting advisers relying on Section 203(m) of the Advisers Act and the funds they operate or advise and pooled investment vehicles operated or advised by CFTC-registered commodity pool operators or commodity trading advisors. It remains to be seen whether FinCEN will exempt those entities.
The full impact of the CTA will not be clear until FinCEN concludes this and its two other rulemakings in connection with the CTA. Although this NPRM provides some clarity regarding FinCEN’s interpretation of the CTA, many issues remain unclear. For example, how FinCEN will share information in the BOI database with authorized government authorities and financial institutions and how the CDD Rule will be adjusted based on the CTA implementing regulations. FinCEN is also seeking comment from the public on (1) the need for additional special reporting rules, (2) the practicality of the proposed timing of reports and relevant updates and (3) the effective date of the rule. Clients that may be affected by the CTA should monitor the continued rulemaking process in the meantime for additional clarification from FinCEN.
Schulte Roth & Zabel’s lawyers are available to assist you in addressing any questions you may have regarding these developments. Please contact the Schulte Roth & Zabel lawyer with whom you usually work, or any of the following attorneys:
Authored by Betty Santangelo, Melissa G.R. Goldstein and Kyle B. Hendrix.
If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.
[1] NPRM, Beneficial Ownership Information Reporting Requirements, 86 Fed. Reg. 69,920 (Dec. 8, 2021), available here (hereinafter, “NPRM”).
[2] National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2021 (CTA §§ 6401–03), available here.
[3] For more information regarding the CTA and AML Act generally, please see our prior Alert “Passage of Anti-Money Laundering Act of 2020 Includes Comprehensive BSA/AML Reform Measures.”
[4] For more information regarding the ANPRM, please see our prior Alert “FinCEN Commences Rulemaking Process for Implementation of Corporate Transparency Act Requiring Disclosure of Beneficial Ownership Information.”
[5] Acceptable identification documents include: (1) a non-expired passport issued by the United States government; (2) a non-expired identification document issued by a state, a local government or an Indian tribe for the purpose of identifying the individual; (3) a non-expired driver’s license issued by a state; or (4) a non-expired passport issued by a foreign government.
[6] CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(a)(3)(B)).
[7] CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(a)(11)(A)).
[8] For a full list of exemptions see CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(a)(11)(B)).
[9] As defined in section 3 of the Investment Company Act of 1940 (15 USC § 80a-3).
[10] 15 USC § 80a-1, et seq.
[11] CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(a)(11)(A)(x)).
[12] As defined in section 202 of the Advisers Act (15 USC § 80b-2).
[13] 15 USC § 80b-1, et seq.
[14] CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(a)(11)(A)(x)).
[15] CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(a)(11)(A)(xi)).
[16] As defined in (i) section 3 of the Federal Deposit Insurance Act (12 USC § 1813); (ii) section 2(a) of the 40 Act (15 USC § 80a-2(a)); and (iii) section 202(a) of the Advisers Act (15 USC § 80b-2(a)).
[17] As defined in section 101 of the Federal Credit Union Act (12 USC § 1752).
[18] That is registered under section 15 of the Securities Exchange Act (“Exchange Act”). 15 USC § 78o (and as defined in 15 USC § 78c).
[19] CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(a)(11)(A)(xviii)).
[20] 15 USC § 80a-3(a).
[21] Id.
[22] CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(b)(2)(B)).
[23] CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(h)).
[24] See CTA § 6403 (adding 31 USC § 5336(h)(4)(3)(C)(i)).
[25] For more information, please see the full Comment Letter.
This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2022 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.
All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

A Sit-Down with Andrew VanSingel
ARTICLE
A Sit-Down with Andrew VanSingel
January 12, 2022
Read time: 2 min
Andrew Roberson interviewed Andrew VanSingel, who dedicated his career to providing pro bono and public services to low-income taxpayers, for an American Bar Association Pro Bono Matters column. They discussed VanSingel’s work in the disaster relief area and at TAS, shared advice for young lawyers who want to get more involved in pro bono work and more.

What You Need to Know About the Taxation of NFTs
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
What You Need to Know About the Taxation of NFTs
January 2022
Read time: 3 min
Non-fungible tokens (NFTs) are today’s hottest digital assets. They are also completely ignored by the Internal Revenue Service—to date, at least—even in the agency’s pronouncement on the taxation of cryptocurrencies.
In this series of articles, we’ll start cracking the NFT code: what they are, how they are created, bought and sold, how they might be taxed by the IRS, and the use of NFTs for charitable contributions and fundraising purposes.
- Introduction to NFTs – As today’s hottest digital assets, non-fungible tokens (NFTs) have taken the arts and investment worlds by storm. But what are they, exactly, and how are they to be treated for tax purposes? This article provides an overview of need-to-know information regarding these exciting—and potentially risky—assets. Read more.
- Taxation of NFT Creators – NFTs offer artists, musicians, celebrities, influencers and other creators an opportunity to develop, market and control the future of many types of digital content that they produce. Less understood is how these assets will be categorized and taxed by the Internal Revenue Service. This article reviews how creators of NFTs will likely be treated by the IRS and what that means for them. Read more.
- Taxation of the Purchase and Sale of NFTs – Given a lack of guidance on the tax treatment of non-fungible tokens (NFTs), taxpayers can be forgiven for experiencing a certain level of uncertainty with respect to how the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) will apply its tax rules to purchases and sales of these assets. IRS reasoning on other asset classes, however, sheds some light on this otherwise uncharted territory. This article reviews the various factors that are likely to play a role in determining the classification and treatment of NFT transactions for tax purposes. Read more.
- NFTs and Charitable Fundraising: Navigating Tax Hurdles – As the creation of and transactions involving non-fungible tokens (NFTs) have increased dramatically, so has interest in using NFTs as donations to charitable organizations and for other charitable fundraising tools. Given the lack of guidance from the IRS on such gifts, donors and recipient charities face a number of tax uncertainties. This article examines the tax hurdles involved in using NFTs for charitable fundraising purposes and offers suggestions for compliance with recordkeeping and tax reporting requirements. Read more.
Andrea (Andie) Kramer is a recognized thought leader on tax related cryptocurrency matters. She was named the 2020 Go-To Thought Leader in Virtual Currency Tax by the National Law Review and a 2021 Readers’ Choice Top Author in cryptocurrency taxation by JD Supra for her article series on cryptocurrency tax.

NFTs and Charitable Fundraising: Navigating Tax Hurdles
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
NFTs and Charitable Fundraising: Navigating Tax Hurdles
January 11, 2022
Read time: 20 min
As the creation of and transactions involving non-fungible tokens (NFTs) have increased dramatically, so has interest in using NFTs as donations to charitable organizations and for other charitable fundraising tools. Given the lack of guidance from the IRS on such gifts, donors and recipient charities face a number of tax uncertainties. This article examines the tax hurdles involved in using NFTs for charitable fundraising purposes and offers suggestions for compliance with recordkeeping and tax reporting requirements.
The explosive growth in 2021 of non-fungible tokens (NFTs) is evidence of their increasing popularity and the acceptance of cryptocurrency, digital tokens and other digital assets as a new investment asset class. (Luke Conway, “Why Does the Price of Bitcoin Keep Going Up?” Investopedia, last updated Dec. 17, 2020; Daniele Bianchi, “Cryptocurrencies As an Asset Class? An Empirical Assessment,” J. of Alternative Investments, 23(2), Fall 2020, 162-179, site visited April 29, 2021; David Lee Kuo Chuen, Li Guo, Yu Wang, “Cryptocurrency: A New Investment Opportunity,” J. of Alternative Investments, 20(3) Winter 2018.) As of October 30, 2021, Coin Market Cap reported all-time market capitalization for NFTs at $780 billion, with all-time sales volume of $11 billion and all-time total sales of $2.1 billion.
In an article published by The Financial Times on December 30, 2021, analysts noted that by the end of 2021 nearly $41 billion had been spent on NFT purchases, making this market almost as valuable as the global art market (Hannah Murphy and Joshua Oliver, “How NFTs became a $40bn market in 2021”).
NFTs are unique digital tokens that are recorded and transferred on a blockchain. An NFT can be a representation of something (a work of art, a photograph, a piece of music), or it can be an original creation that exists only in digital form. An NFT can be a single, one-of-a-kind asset, or one of any number of replicates of the same thing. Because each NFT is uniquely identified on the blockchain, it is not fungible with any other NFT or asset. (For a discussion of NFTs, see the first article in this series, “Introduction to NFTs.”)
INTEREST IN CHARITABLE CONTRIBUTIONS
With huge appreciation in the value of many investors’ cryptocurrency positions and the increased interest in NFTs, there has likewise been an increased interest in charitable contributions of NFTs. NFTs, however, as nonfungible assets, are not suitable for most direct charitable contributions. Typically, only those cryptocurrencies that are convertible into a fiat currency (such as the US dollar) are of value to most charities. This is because those charities that are set up to accept cryptocurrency generally convert crypto to fiat currency as soon as possible. NFTs are not convertible into currency, so it is unlikely that a charity would be able to sell an NFT once it is donated. This poses unique challenges for those charities that want to benefit from the exploding NFT market.
NFTs provide a new marketplace for artists, which has in turn introduced a new generation of investors and collectors to NFTs. This makes the NFT market attractive to those charities that want to reach new donors and maximize funding opportunities. The GivingBlock, for example, is one organization that has been active in efforts to allow charities to benefit from NFTs. A quick look at the GivingBlock website gives a detailed picture of the ways in which charities can benefit from the NFT craze.
What we are seeing is that many charities are partnering with NFT creators to expand their fundraising efforts and create a positive buzz among prospective millennial and Gen Z donors. Instead of contributing NFTs directly to a favorite charity, NFT creators are auctioning off NFTs with all or a portion of the sales proceeds donated to charity. This article addresses some of the tax considerations faced by charities, donors and NFT creators in cashing in on the NFT boom. For a discussion of the tax issues with respect to charitable contributions of cryptocurrency in general, see our special report, “A Primer on Charitable Contributions of Virtual Currency.”
DIRECT CHARITABLE CONTRIBUTIONS
Theoretically, a donor holding an NFT can donate it directly to a charity if the charity is set up to accept such a donation. Although most charities would want to immediately convert an NFT to cash, an obvious exception is donating an NFT to an art museum that would make the NFT part of its collection.
Direct contributions of appreciated NFTs can provide donors that are not NFT creators with significant tax advantages. (For a discussion of NFT creators, see the article “Taxation of NFT Creators.”) Donors who can meet IRS reporting requirements can avoid paying tax on the amount of gain they would otherwise incur if they had sold the appreciated NFT in the market and donated cash to the charity. Donors can receive a deduction for an appreciated NFT’s full value up to the percentage cap of their adjusted gross income. (Although there have been beneficial changes to charitable deductions under the 2020 CARES Act that have carried over to 2021, deductions of noncash property are capped to a percentage of an individual taxpayer’s adjusted gross income. Deductions for contributions to donor-advised funds (DAFs) are also capped.) This means that the best NFT for a direct charitable contribution is one that has significantly appreciated in value and that has been held by a taxpayer classified as an investor for the long-term capital gain holding period (that is, for more than one year) (Code §1222(3)). A tax deduction for a noncash property donation is only available if the donation is itemized on the donor’s tax return, and it meets all other IRS requirements.
Note that the 2020 CARES Act (as extended into 2021) permits taxpayers that do not itemize their deductions to deduct up to $300 in charitable contributions that are made in cash to charitable organizations. This above-the-line deduction does not apply, however, to noncash donations.
The unique, non-fungible nature of NFTs makes direct charitable donations difficult, if not impossible. How are they to be valued? How can they be subject to a qualified appraisal issued by a qualified appraiser? Can a charity actually accept an NFT as a donation? And, how does the charity know it is receiving something of value for the donation?
Treas. Reg § 1.170A-1(g) denies fair-market value deductions for services performed on behalf of a charitable organization. This raises an additional issue with respect to those NFTs that might be viewed as providing services, not property. If we generally apply Notice 2014-21 to NFTs, many types of NFTs would be treated as property, not services. For those NFTs, this position might be supported by analogous case law (see, e.g., Cupler, 64 T.C. 946 (1975); Gross, 59 T.C. (1973); and Holmes, 57 T.C. 430 (1971)). But NFTs are unique, and it is possible that certain types of NFTs could be viewed as services, not property.
NO DIRECT IRS GUIDANCE
Potential NFT donors and possible charitable recipients can look to the IRS’s 2019 Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs; last updated March 3, 2021) for some guidance about the requirements for charitable contributions of cryptocurrency, although NFTs are not specifically mentioned. Question 34 says that the donation of cryptocurrency is not a sale or exchange of a capital asset. Rather, it is treated as any other noncash contribution of property. Question 35 addresses how a donor should calculate the charitable deduction. For capital assets held for the long-term capital gain holding period, the charitable deduction equals the cryptocurrency’s fair market value at the time of the donation.
On December 26, 2019, the IRS added two additional FAQs addressing cryptocurrency donations. In Question 36, the IRS says that a charity must provide a contemporaneous written acknowledgment for donations of $250 or more. In addition, a donor must complete Form 8283, Noncash Charitable Contributions, and obtain a qualified appraisal for deductions of more than $5,000. Question 37 addresses the charity’s reporting requirement. First, the charity should report the donation as a noncash contribution on a Form 990 series annual return and Schedule M (if applicable). If the charity sells, exchanges or disposes of the donated cryptocurrency within three years after originally receiving it, the charity must file Form 8282, Donee Information Return, providing a copy to the donor.
If cryptocurrency was not held by the donor for the long-term capital asset holding period prior to donation, the charitable deduction is limited to the lesser of the donor’s tax basis or the cryptocurrency’s fair market value (FAQ 35). For cryptocurrency that is an ordinary asset in the donor’s hands (as would be the situation for most NFT creators and dealers), the charitable deduction is limited to the fair market value of the NFT minus any appreciation (basically, the donor’s tax basis) (see also IRS, “Charitable Contributions,” Publication 526). Costs incurred to tokenize the NFT could be included in an NFT creator’s tax basis.
If the taxpayer holds an NFT with a loss—that is, the donor’s tax basis is greater than its fair market value—the donor’s deduction would be limited to the NFT’s fair market value. In addition, the difference between the taxpayer’s tax basis and the fair market value would not be a capital loss. Therefore, it is more tax efficient for a taxpayer with a loss in an NFT that is a capital asset to sell it in the market, report a capital loss for tax purposes, and donate US dollars to the charity to receive a charitable contribution equal to the amount of cash contributed.
INSURMOUNTABLE HURDLES
What this all suggests is that direct NFT contributions pose what appear to be insurmountable hurdles. The following offers a discussion of some of those hurdles.
Fair Market Value
In determining gain, loss and the amount of charitable deductions, taxpayers must first determine the fair market value of the NFT they intend to contribute. This is more complicated for NFTs than it is for cryptocurrencies that trade on an exchange or trading platform. Such cryptocurrencies are likely to have a fair market value equal to the spot price (if such a price is available) on the date and time the cryptocurrency is donated. If a spot price is not available but a third party tracks and values that cryptocurrency, its fair market value is likely to be the value assigned on the applicable dates and times by that third party. One or the other of these methods of determining fair market value is likely to be available for convertible cryptocurrency.
On the other hand, because each NFT is unique, it is likely to be impossible in many (if not most) situations to determine an NFTs fair market value. Although many NFTs are available for sale on one or more NFT platforms, an NFT only sells when a willing buyer and willing seller agree to a price. As a result, NFTs without a market value are not appropriate for direct charitable donation unless they fit a charity’s mission. An art museum, for example, might be interested in acquiring an NFT to be displayed as part of its art collection.
If a donor is not the creator of the NFT, the donor can deduct the fair-market value of the contribution with the amount of the contribution reduced by the amount of short-term capital gain that the donor would have reported if the donor had sold the NFT (Code § 170(e)(1)(A)). Contributions of tangible personal property receive a fair-market value deduction only if the charity uses the tangible property in a way that relates to its charitable purpose (Code § 170(e)(1)(B)). This requirement would not apply to NFTs because they are intangibles.
Identification
As unique digital assets, NFTs are individually identified when they are purchased and sold.
Recordkeeping and Reporting Requirements
The IRS treats convertible cryptocurrency as property for tax purposes, not as fiat currency. Although the IRS does not address NFTs or non-convertible cryptocurrencies, given the IRS’s reasoning, it is likely that most NFTs and cryptocurrencies are property for tax purposes. It stands to reason that if convertible cryptocurrency is not currency for tax purposes, other digital assets and NFTs are not currency. It is also likely that NFTs are subject to the general tax rules that apply to noncash property (Notice 2014-21, I.R.B. 938). At the date of this writing, the IRS has not provided any guidance with respect to NFTs or non-convertible cryptocurrencies.
As noncash donations, NFTs require donors to carefully document the amount and type of their contributions:
- For donations valued at less than $250, donors must keep a contemporaneous receipt from the charity, showing the charity’s name and address.
- Donations of more than $250 require a contemporaneous written acknowledgement from the charity. This acknowledgment must be obtained before the donor files her or his tax return, or before the date—including extensions—when the tax return is otherwise due (FAQ 36; see also Publication 1771 (REV. 3-2016) Charitable Contributions).
- Donations of more than $500 require a completed Form 8283, Noncash Charitable Contributions, to be filed with the donor’s tax return (FAQ 36).
- Donations of more than $5,000 require a qualified appraisal from a qualified appraiser. In addition, the charity must sign the donor’s Form 8283 to substantiate the deduction (Form 8283). The charity’s signature does not mean that it agrees with the appraised value (FAQ 36). Rather, the charity is simply acknowledging receipt of the assets on the date specified.
- Donations of more than $500,000 have the same requirements as donations that are greater than $5,000, except that the donor must also attach the appraisal to the tax return.
QUALIFIED APPRAISALS
A qualified appraisal for charitable purposes must meet the requirements of Treas. Reg § 1.170A-17, including the requirement that the appraisal be prepared by a qualified appraiser in accordance with generally accepted appraisal standards that meet the substance and principles of the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (Treas. Reg. § 1.170A-17(a)(2)). As noted above, donations of more than $5,000 require the donor to complete IRS Form 8283, Section B, and to obtain a qualified appraisal that meets generally accepted appraisal standards (FAQ 36; Jeremy Naylor and Brianna Reed, “IRS Issues New Guidance for Virtual Currency Donations,” National Law Review, Volume X, Number 30, January 30, 2020). Donations of more than $500,000 also require the donor to attach the qualified appraisal to the tax return.
In addition, a qualified appraisal must include the following information about the contributed property:
- A description providing sufficient detail, and taking into account the value of the property, that a person who is not generally familiar with the type of property can determine that the appraised property is the contributed property
- The condition of real property or tangible personal property
- The valuation effective date
- The fair market value, within the meaning of Treas. Reg. § 1.170A-1(c)(2), of the contributed property on the valuation effective date ( Reg. § 1.170A-17(a)(3)(i).).
Further, a qualified appraisal must disclose the terms of any agreement or understanding by or on behalf of the donor and charity as to the use, sale or other disposition of the contributed property, including, for example, any agreement or understanding that (1) restricts (temporarily or permanently) a charity’s right to use or dispose of the contributed property, (2) reserves to, or confers upon, anyone, other than a cooperative fundraising agreement, any right to the income from the contributed property, or (3) requires possession of or earmarks the contributed property for a particular use (Treas. Reg. § 1.170A-17(a)(3)(ii)).
And finally, a qualified appraisal must provide specified information about the appraiser, including the appraiser’s name, address, taxpayer identification number and qualifications (including the appraiser’s education and experience) to value the type of property being donated.
QUALIFIED APPRAISER
It is likely that the requirements set out in the Treasury regulations for a qualified appraiser are difficult—if not impossible—for an appraiser to meet.
A qualified appraiser is defined for these purposes as someone who is a recognized appraiser with at least two years of experience in valuing the type of property that is being appraised. Although there have been some NFTs in the market since 2014, NFTs only started to take off in 2021 (Allyson Versprille, “IRS Update Reignites Concerns About Crypto Donation Appraisals,” Bloomberg Tax, January 10, 2020).
Further, a qualified appraiser must have verifiable education and experience in valuing the type of property being appraised (Treas. Reg. § 1.170A-17(b)(1)) by meeting one of the following criteria:
- Successfully completed professional or college-level coursework in valuing the type of property, and has two or more years of experience in valuing the type of property donated
- Earned a recognized appraiser designation, for the type of property donated ( Reg. § 1.170A-17(b)(2)).
The appraiser’s coursework must be obtained from an educational organization; generally recognized professional trade or appraiser organization that regularly offers educational programs in valuing the type of property; or an employer apprenticeship educational program (Treas. Reg. § 1.170A-17(b)(2)(ii)).
Similar Items Requirement
Another problematic provision is the requirement that a qualified appraiser must appraise “similar items” in the same appraisal and in determining whether the $5,000 threshold is met to require an appraisal. But what does this mean for NFTs? How does an appraiser determine what NFTs are similar items? Those with the same content but different metadata? How can the appraiser determine the $5,000 threshold?
For purposes of the like-kind exchange rules at Code § 1031, for example, the IRS has said that bitcoin (BTC) and ether (ETH) are not of a like kind for purposes of Code § 1031 (CCA 2021-24-008, June 18, 2021). IRS Publication 561, Determining the Value of Donated Property, provides some guidance when it says that the phrase “similar items” means “property of the same generic category or type (whether or not donated to the same donee), such as stamp collections, coin collections, lithographs, paintings…nonpublicly traded securities other than nonpublicly traded stock, land, buildings,…or silver” (Publication 561, p. 9). Publication 561 goes on to say that a donor who gives similar items to different charities needs a qualified appraisal of the items for each charity and must attach the fully completed Form 8283, Section B, to the donor’s tax return.
USING NFTs TO FUNDRAISE FOR CHARITY
To overcome many of the questions and the hurdles raised when considering direct donations of NFTs, some charities are issuing NFTs directly or they are partnering with NFT creators to use NFTs to fundraise. Rather than contributing NFTs directly to the charity, creators are selling or auctioning off NFTs, with all or a portion of the proceeds donated to the charity.
Some charities are partnering with celebrities, athletes, musicians and other public figures to create NFTs. Other charities are creating their own NFTs and auctioning them off to buyers, selling them at fixed prices, or providing NFTs at no cost or as part of charitable packages to donors and other supporters of their missions.
The NFT creator would report taxable income on the amount of taxable gain on the NFT (sales price minus adjusted tax basis), and the creator would report a charitable deduction for the amount of money or cryptocurrency donated to the charity from NFT sales.
Typically—although not always—the charity receives cryptocurrency that the purchaser delivered to buy the NFT. As a result, the charity must be prepared to accept cryptocurrency. (This is discussed in the next section, “Charitable Organizations.”) The proceeds from the sale or auction can generally be paid directly to the charity’s cryptocurrency wallet address.
CHARITABLE ORGANIZATIONS
Charities must address several issues in accepting donations of NFTs or cryptocurrency received from sales of NFTs. They must determine the suitability of accepting such donations, the protocols for accepting NFTs and cryptocurrency, and the ways in which donated digital assets can be converted to US dollars. In addition, a charity must also familiarize itself with the unique issues raised by accepting, storing and displaying NFTs.
Suitability Considerations
Charities must determine the suitability of accepting donations of digital assets. Considerations may include whether such donations are acceptable under applicable laws, permissible under their enabling document, congruent with their mission, and suitable given their financial situation.
Evaluating Whether to Accept Direct Donations
In evaluating whether to accept direct donations of virtual currency, charities should consider the following:
- Donations through a third-party provider or DAF means that the charity receives US dollars so the charity does not need to set up a cryptocurrency account or wallet, and it need not assume the risks and expense of converting cryptocurrency to fiat currency.
- Donations through a third-party provider or DAF might allow the charity to insulate itself from undesirable donors that could potentially hurt its mission or pose a reputational risk to the charity.
- Accepting direct contributions of NFTs and cryptocurrencies might attract potential donors that do not want to set up a DAF.
- Direct contributions might allow the charity to benefit from market-value increases but also to suffer from market-value declines. This is a real concern, given the volatility of digital assets.
Policies and Procedures
Charities should consider the following internal policies and procedures with respect to the acceptance of cryptocurrency and NFT donations:
- Determine whether the charity will work with a third-party processor or platform to set up its program.
- Determine whether it will directly accept NFTs and which cryptocurrencies it will accept.
- Determine, if the charity decides to accept NFTs and cryptocurrency donations, whether it will immediately convert the cryptocurrency or NFTs to US dollars or identify any circumstances under which it would be willing to hold onto digital assets (such as an NFT donated to an art museum for its collection).
- Determine, if the charity has existing policies against accepting anonymous gifts, whether it will accept anonymous or pseudonymous cryptocurrency donations. Under the charity’s disclosure policies, donors might be required to provide information about themselves, creating compliance complications for charities and disincentives to those donors seeking anonymity.
- Identify procedures to protect the charity from security breaches and hackers. For example, a charity should not post its digital wallet address on its website where transfers are visible to everyone. This could result in a “redirect hack” where a hacker changes the wallet address posted on the website to an address that the hacker controls (Andy Greenberg, “Hacker Redirects Traffic from 19 Internet Providers to Steal Bitcoins,” Wired, August 7, 2014). The charity might, instead, require potential donors to complete an information form before providing the donor with a wallet address, and donations can be assigned unique digital addresses. Third-party service providers are available to serve as middlemen for such transactions (Jane M. Searing and Deby Macleod, “Cryptocurrency gift strategies for not-for-profits,” Journal of Accountancy, February 1, 2019).
- Consider engagement with a blockchain analytics firm, such as Chainalysis or Elliptic, that offers software products that analyze transactions and wallet addresses for purposes of determining whether a donation raises any concerns with respect to money laundering, terrorist financing, or other criminal or reputational risk (“Top Blockchain Analytics Companies and What They Do,” Analytics India Magazine, July 24, 2020 (visited May 12, 2021)).
Documentation of Donations
The charity must provide all donors with the documentation needed to meet their recordkeeping and reporting obligations:
- For donations valued at less than $250, the charity should provide the donor with a receipt that includes the charity’s name and address.
- For donations of more than $250, the charity should provide a contemporaneous written acknowledgement.
- For donations of more than $5,000, the charity needs to sign IRS Form 8283, Part V, acknowledging that the charity is a qualified charity under Code § 170(c) and that it has, in fact, received the noncash property donation described on the form. By signing the form, the charity does not agree with the appraised value (FAQ 36). Rather, it is acknowledging receipt of the virtual currency and that the charity will meet its information-reporting requirements when disposing of the virtual cryptocurrency (FAQ 36).
IRS Reporting Obligations
Charities must report the NFTs and cryptocurrency they receive as noncash donations on Schedule M (Noncash Contributions) of their Form 990. As a general rule, if they dispose of all or any portion of the virtual currency within three years after the date of receipt, they must file IRS Form 8282 (Donee Information Return) and provide a copy to the donor of the cryptocurrency (Form 8283).
The donor use limitation, however, does not apply to contributions of intangible property. This means that the charity does not need to use or hold onto NFTs or cryptocurrency once donated.
CONCLUSION
As NFT markets are exploding and more people are accumulating substantial cryptocurrency portfolios, NFTs will be playing a bigger role in charitable contributions and fundraising. As a result, those charities seeking to benefit from NFTs will need to establish policies to accept NFTs and cryptocurrencies. Many tricky issues need to be carefully considered by prospective donors and charities.
If NFT and cryptocurrency owners choose to sell their digital assets in the market and subsequently make cash charitable deductions, neither the prospective donors nor the charities would need to navigate the tax hurdles addressed in this article. Unfortunately, that path would not provide donors with the tax advantages that can be available to donations of appreciated assets.
Read the previous article in the series: Taxation of the Purchase and Sale of NFTs

Introduction to NFTs
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
Introduction to NFTs
January 11, 2022
Read time: 10 min
As today’s hottest digital assets, non-fungible tokens (NFTs) have taken the arts and investment worlds by storm. But what are they, exactly, and how are they to be treated for tax purposes? This article provides an overview of need-to-know information regarding these exciting—and potentially risky—assets.
NFTs, or non-fungible tokens, are now the hottest digital assets recorded and transferred on a blockchain. They are so hot that the Collins Dictionary named “NFT” its 2021 word of the year. Compared to a year ago, purchases of NFTs are up 11,000%, with final 2021 numbers not available yet.
The explosive interest in NFTs “demonstrates a ‘unique technicolour collision of art, technology and commerce’ that has ‘broken through the Covid noise’ to become ubiquitous” (Alison Flood, “NFT Beats Cheugy to be Collins Dictionary’s Word of the Year,” November 24, 2021). Take for example the widely reported March 2021 auction of an NFT that consisted of 5,000 individual pieces of digital art created by the artist known as Beeple. It sold for more than US$69.3 million.
The first NFTs were reported to have been sold in 2014 (Andrew Steinwold, “What is a Non-fungible Token (NFT)?” October 7, 2019, Medium), but the NFT market did not really begin to take off until late 2017 when CryptoKitties NFTs “congested the Ethereum network” (Joon Ian Wong, “The Ethereum network is getting jammed up because people are rushing to buy cartoon cats on its blockchain,” Quartz, December 4, 2017). For the next two years, CryptoKitties were basically the only popular NFTs.
But in July 2020, the NFT market started growing. Approximately $500 million were spent on NFTs in 2020, according to NonFungible.com, a website that tracks the NFT market. In the first quarter of 2021, NFT sales grew to over $2 billion (Robin Barber, NFT Statistics, Facts & Trends in 2021, Cloudwards, June 29, 2021). In the period from November 1, 2020, to November 1, 2021, 5.5 million NFT sales valued at $9.4 billion were reported—again according to NonFungible.com—with 3.1 million “primary market” transactions (that is, transactions representing the first time a given NFT was sold) and 2.4 million “secondary market” transactions (all subsequent sales of an NFT after its initial sale). Over that same time period, the NFT art market grew over 800% (www.businessinsider.com.au/nft–art–market).
Like its dramatic growth, the NFT market has experienced dramatic swings. Some months have huge sales and other months do not. In May 2021, for example, the aggregate value of NFTs sold was less than half of those that had been sold the prior month (Market Insider May 18, 2021).
Interestingly, creators of NFTs are adding physical goods as well as virtual goods and services to their NFT offerings. The tax and regulatory issues with respect to those types of products can be very complex, and such NFTs are beyond the scope of this article.
CHARACTERISTICS OF NFTS
What’s an NFT?
Each NFT is a unique digitized certificate (referred to as a token) that is a digital unit of data stored on a blockchain. It can be a representation of something (a work of art, a photograph, a piece of music, a game or a collectible), or it can be an original creation that exists only in digital form. NFTs are typically purchased and sold using the type of cryptocurrency or digital token (collectively referred to as tokens) used or accepted on that particular blockchain. Initially, NFTs were almost exclusively created on the ethereum blockchain and purchased with ether tokens (ETH). (Ether is the native token of the ethereum blockchain, which has functionality for smart contracts. ETH “acts as the primary ‘fuel’ that powers all activity on [the ethereum blockchain]” (“About Ethereum,” CoinDesk)).
More recently, additional blockchains are being created to implement NFTs that are native to those blockchains (T.W. Lounge, “Choosing the Right Blockchain for Your NFT, Medium, 2020).
Once an NFT is created on a blockchain, all of its subsequent sales are tracked and recorded. Each token’s metadata allows such tracking because it contains information as to ownership and all other terms and conditions applicable to that token. Each token is non-fungible because its metadata cannot be duplicated or replicated. In other words, one NFT is not interchangeable with another NFT or with any other asset. Even if multiple replicas are created using the same content, each NFT has unique metadata. Once an NFT is recorded on a blockchain, its provenance can be tracked, indicating “who owns, previously owned, and created the NFT, as well as which of the many copies is the original” (Matthieu Nadini et. al., “Mapping the NFT Revolution: Market Trends, Trade Networks, and Visual Features, Scientific Reports, Vol. 11, 20902 (2021)).
An NFT cannot be divided into smaller units or used in the same way as fungible convertible cryptocurrency such as bitcoin (BTC) or ETH. (Convertible cryptocurrency has an equivalent value in real currency or acts as a substitute for real currency. In this article, the term cryptocurrency is used for “virtual currency,” “tokens” and “digital assets.”) One NFT cannot be exchanged for another, and an NFT’s value, if any, is based solely on what someone is willing to pay the seller to buy it.
NFTs are marketed through online marketplaces, including the popular OpenSea as well as Nifty Gateway, Rarible, SuperRare and MakersPlace. Scott Nover reported recently, “Of the $2.8 billion spent on NFT marketplaces in September [2021], $2.72 billion changed hands on OpenSea, according to data from the crypto websites Dapp Radar and CryptoArt, compiled by the The Blck.” On October 12, 2021, Coinbase announced that it is creating its own NFT marketplace. (“What Coinbase’s Entry into the NFT Market Means for OpenSea,” Quartz, October 14, 2021). All NFT platforms host blockchain technology. Although OpenSea provides a general marketplace, many of the other NFT marketplaces are more specialized and cater to particular types of NFT, such as sports, visual arts or games.
An NFT participant needs a crypto wallet, such as MetaMask, to connect to the NFT platform. Once the participant has a crypto wallet, she or he can transfer the type of token needed to buy the NFT and can hold NFTs in the wallet. Popular tokens used to purchase NFTs include ETH, dai (DAI) and solana (SOL). Dai is a decentralized stablecoin that runs on the ethereum blockchain and which attempts to maintain a value of USD $1.00. Unlike centralized stablecoins, Dai is backed by collateral on the maker platform. (“Dai (DAI) Price, Charts, and News,” Coinbase.) Sol is the token that is the “gas” that pays for transactions on the Solana decentralized computing platform. (“Solana Price (SOL)” price charts, Coinbase.) “Gas” refers to the amount of a token that is needed to perform a certain function on the blockchain network. NFTs are typically sold at auction (both online auctions and more recently through traditional auction houses), at a fixed price, or through a declining price listing.
Smart Contracts
As a “smart contract,” each NFT’s embedded metadata allows relevant information to be visible and stored on the blockchain in a transparent and immutable way. The metadata verifies ownership, transferability (and if so, under what circumstances), links to other digital assets, license fees, royalties and any other payment obligations. Upon transfer, an NFT’s metadata assures that required payments are accepted and confirmed, the correct payment amount is transferred to the seller, and any license fee or royalty amount is deducted from the payment made to the seller and transferred to the NFT’s creator or the owner of the intellectual property.
Intellectual Property Rights
Many legal and regulatory issues are currently unanswered with respect to NFTs. With that said, a number of open questions “touch on copyrights, intellectual property rights, ownership of tokens vs. ownership of the content, and authentication.” Given the current lack of regulatory guidance, NFTs are “vulnerable to copyright theft, unauthorized replication and fraud, and storage failure,” as well as “protocol risks like hacking, platform risks related to governance, and high gas fees stemming from the Ethereum network.” (Matthew Fox, “The NFT Market is Now Worth More than $7 billion, But legal Issues Facing the Nascent Sector Could Hinder Its Growth, JP Morgan Says,” Business Insider, November 19, 2021.)
Because NFT purchasers only receive the rights granted to them as noted in the NFT metadata, creators can—and often do—retain their ownership of the content that underlies an NFT. The artist Beeple, for example, retained his copyright to the art underlying the NFT mentioned at the start of this article. As a result, Beeple can create and sell countless other NFTs and other types of artwork from the same content.
HOW ARE NFTs TAXED?
At the date of this writing, there is no specific guidance from the US government as to how NFTs are taxed. Indeed, NFTs are not mentioned in any of the IRS’s cryptocurrency tax pronouncements. Therefore, one must look to general tax principles to determine, by analogy, how NFTs are likely to be taxed.
The first point of reference is Notice 2014-21 (2014-16 I.R.B. 938) and the 2019 Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) which were the IRS’s first attempts to address convertible cryptocurrency taxation (IRS, “Frequently Asked Questions, 2019,” most recently updated March 2021). Convertible cryptocurrency has an equivalent value in real currency, can be purchased for or exchanged into real currency, and can be used to buy goods and services. For example, BTC and ETH are convertible cryptocurrencies. The IRS treats convertible cryptocurrency as property, not currency. As a result, the general tax principles that apply to property transactions apply to convertible virtual currency. Although Notice 2014-21 does not address non-convertible cryptocurrencies or NFTs, it is likely that many other cryptocurrencies and tokens are property for tax purposes.
Because NFTs are property, not real currency, such transactions are taxed as barter transactions. Both the NFT buyer and an NFT seller¾not just the seller ¾have a taxable transaction when the buyer pays for an NFT with “property” such as cryptocurrency or a digital token. (Gain would be taxable if the fair market value of the cryptocurrency used to buy the NFT is greater than the taxpayer’s tax basis in that cryptocurrency.) The seller has taxable gain (or loss) equal to the difference between the seller’s tax basis and the value of the property received in payment for the NFT. (Losses are not deductible in certain situations. If the NFT is a personal transaction, loss on disposing of it might not be deductible.)
If, on the other hand, the NFT is purchased with actual currency such as US dollars, the seller has a taxable sale but the buyer does not. The seller’s gain (loss) is the difference between the NFT’s adjusted tax basis and the amount of currency used to purchase it. If the buyer uses appreciated property to buy the NFT (that is, the fair market value in the property used to buy the NFT is greater than the buyer’s tax basis), the buyer has taxable gain equal to the amount of this appreciation. The buyer’s tax basis in that property is what is relevant for tax purposes.
Gain or loss is treated as capital or ordinary, depending on whether the taxpayer is an investor or trader (capital), or a creator or dealer (ordinary). Ordinary losses are fully deductible; capital losses are subject to the special loss limitations that apply to capital assets. As a result, some capital losses might not be deductible. In addition, if the taxpayer holds an NFT as a personal asset, not for investment (or as part of a trade or business), losses can be permanently denied under rules that prohibit deductions for losses incurred on activities that are not engaged in for profit (Code § 183).
Read the next article in the series: Taxation of NFT Creators

Taxation of the Purchase and Sale of NFTs
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
Taxation of the Purchase and Sale of NFTs
January 11, 2022
Read time: 10 min
Given a lack of guidance on the tax treatment of non-fungible tokens (NFTs), taxpayers can be forgiven for experiencing a certain level of uncertainty with respect to how the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) will apply its tax rules to purchases and sales of these assets. IRS reasoning on other asset classes, however, sheds some light on this otherwise uncharted territory. This article reviews the various factors that are likely to play a role in determining the classification and treatment of NFT transactions for tax purposes.
The taxation of NFTs has not been addressed in any of the pronouncements on cryptocurrency, digital tokens and other cryptocurrency-related digital assets from the IRS. As a result, general tax principles must be applied to identify the likely tax treatment of purchases, sales and other transactions involving NFTs, which are a form of digital tokens. (For a discussion of NFTs generally, see “Introduction to NFTs.”) This means that the tax treatment of a purchase or sale of an NFT depends on a number of factors, including whether the seller created the NFT; whether the seller is a dealer, trader, investor, collector or personal user; how long the seller has held the NFT; whether the NFT has appreciated in the seller’s hands; what type of property is used to purchase the NFT; and, if the buyer used appreciated property to buy the NFT, how long the buyer held the property.
CLASSIFICATION OF NFTs FOR TAX PURPOSES
The first question to be answered is whether NFTs are currency or property for tax purposes. In Notice 2014-21 (2014-16 I.R.B. 938) and the 2019 Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs, most recently updated March 2021), the IRS addressed the taxation of convertible cryptocurrency, which is cryptocurrency with an equivalent value in fiat currency (such as the US dollar) that can be purchased for or exchanged into such currency or used to buy goods and services. Under this definition, bitcoin (BTC) and ether (ETH) are convertible cryptocurrencies. According to the IRS, convertible cryptocurrency is property, not currency. As a result, the general tax principles that apply to property transactions apply to convertible cryptocurrency transactions.
Although Notice 2014-21 does not address the tax character of non-convertible cryptocurrencies or NFTs, given the IRS’s reasoning, it is likely that other cryptocurrencies and digital tokens (including NFTs) are property for tax purposes. It stands to reason that if convertible cryptocurrency is not treated as currency for tax purposes, other digital assets including NFTs will not be treated as currency.
CAPITAL OR ORDINARY ASSETS
Ordinary Assets
In the hands of creators of and dealers in NFTs, NFTs are ordinary assets. Such taxpayers have ordinary income and loss on their NFT transactions. (For a discussion of NFT creators, see “Taxation of NFT Creators.”) For creators, an NFT is an ordinary asset because it is in the nature of a patent, model, copyright, literary composition, musical composition, artistic composition or similar property created through the taxpayer’s personal efforts or is property that was prepared or produced for the taxpayer (Code § 1221(a)(3)). An NFT is also an ordinary asset in the hands of a dealer because the taxpayer is holding it as inventory or for sale to customers in the ordinary course of business (Code § 1221(a)(1)). An NFT dealer receives ordinary income and loss on sales of NFTs (Code § 61 and 1221(a)(1)).
For a taxpayer who is not a creator or dealer but, instead, uses the NFT in its trade or business, there are many tax issues that need to be addressed, including rules under Code § 1231 for property used in the taxpayers trade or business, so that gains might be capital and losses ordinary (In addition to Code § 1231, other relevant rules include possible recapture under Code § 1245, as well as the impact of Code § 1245(b)(8) on Code § 197 intangibles.)
Because an NFT is an intangible asset, creators cannot amortize their tax basis in an NFT. This is because Code § 197(c)(2) allows certain taxpayers—other than creators—to amortize tax basis on an intangible asset that was (1) acquired by the taxpayer and which is used in the taxpayer’s trade or business or (2) is an investment activity described in Code § 212 (Code §§ 197(c)(1), (2)). If an amortizable NFT becomes worthless, a deduction might be available (Code §§ 197(f) and Treas. Reg. § 1.197-2(g)(1)(i)).
Capital Assets
NFTs held by traders, investors, collectors and personal users are treated as capital assets. Short-term capital assets are those that are held for one year or less, while long-term capital assets are held for more than one year. This statement of black-letter law, however, does not take into account all of the additional issues that need to be consider in addressing the taxation of NFTs held by these taxpayers. Some of these rules are mentioned in the remainder of this section.
Because NFTs are intangible assets, taxpayers holding NFTs for investment can amortize their adjusted basis in their NFTs (Code § 197).
A taxpayer’s intent in acquiring an NFT must be established to determine if the NFT is a collectible or a personal asset not held for investment.
Collectibles
Collectibles are a unique category of items subject to a special capital gain tax rate. While the Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997 reduced the maximum capital gain rate to 20%, it left the maximum rate at 28% for collectibles. Collectibles include alcoholic beverages, works of art, rugs, antiques, stamps, certain coins, gems and precious metals (Code §408(m)). Because each NFT is unique, those that are similar to works of art and other collectibles might be treated as collectibles. Those that are held for the long-term holding period are subject to the higher 28% capital gain rate. Taxpayers need to be aware of this higher rate so they properly report and pay estimated taxes. Short-term capital gains are subject to the same tax rates that generally apply to capital assets, without regard to whether they would be treated as collectibles. Losses on the sale of collectibles are subject to the limitations on losses that generally apply to capital assets.
It seems likely that those NFTs that qualify as works of art will be subject to the 28% maximum rate. Other types of NFTs, however, such as NFTs that represent ownership of actual assets or provide for experiences, might not be classified as collectibles, and would instead be subject to regular capital gain tax rates.
Personal-Use NFTs
Personal-use assets are assets that are neither held in a trade or business nor held for investment. Such assets include assets used by taxpayers in hobbies and for recreational use.
A taxpayer’s intent is determinative as to whether an NFT is taxed as a personal-use asset. A taxpayer’s NFTs would probably be treated as personal-use assets if the activities are too infrequent to rise to the level of investment activities, or the taxpayer does not maintain adequate books and records to support an investment intent.
If a taxpayer wants its NFTs to be considered as investments, the taxpayer has the burden of proving investment intent. Whether an activity is an investment turns on whether the activity is engaged in for profit, after considering all applicable facts and circumstances (Treas. Reg. § 1.183-2(a)). Treas. Reg. § 1.183-2(b) sets out nine factors for determining whether an asset is held for investment, without any one factor being determinative (Code § 183(d); Treas. Reg § 1.183-2(b)):
- The manner in which the taxpayer carries out the activity
- The taxpayer’s expertise or that of the taxpayer’s advisors
- The time and effort expended to carry on the activity
- The expectation that the assets used in the activity may appreciate in value
- Success in carrying on other activities
- History of income and losses with respect to the activity
- Amount of occasional profits, if any
- Financial status of the taxpayer
- Elements of personal pleasure or recreation
If an activity produces a profit during three or more years out of a five-year period, the taxpayer is presumed to be in the activity for profit, unless the IRS proves otherwise (Code § 183(d)).
Under Code § 212, a taxpayer with a personal-use NFT cannot deduct investment expenses because the taxpayer’s expenses are not incurred for the production or collection of income. A taxpayer can, however, deduct certain expenses to the extent that gross income from these personal activities exceeds the tax deductions otherwise allowable to the taxpayer without regard to whether the activities were engaged in for profit (Code § 183(b)).
Personal-use assets are treated the same as other capital assets, with a few important differences:
- Gains are taxable as capital gains at the same rates as other capital assets.
- Expenses attributable to personal-use NFTs cannot be deducted except for those allowed under Code 183.
- Losses are not deductible (since tax changes in 2017).
- If a personal-asset NFT becomes worthless, losses are not deductible under Code § 165(c).
Sale or Exchange of an NFT
Because NFTs are recorded and generally transferred on a blockchain, NFTs are typically purchased using cryptocurrency, not fiat currency (although some NFTs can be purchased with fiat currency or with a credit card). When a taxpayer purchases an NFT using cryptocurrency to make the purchase, both the seller and the buyer have engaged in a taxable barter transaction. The NFT (property) is acquired using other property (cryptocurrency).
Sellers have ordinary or capital gain or loss, depending on whether the NFT is an ordinary or capital asset in the taxpayer’s hands, as is discussed above. If the NFT is a capital asset, the taxpayer has capital gain or loss. If it is held for the long-term holding period (more than one year), the gain is taxable at the long-term capital gain rate, unless it is a collectible held for the long-term. Collectibles are subject to a 28% maximum rate. If an NFT is held for one year or less, gain is taxed at the taxpayer’s short-term capital gain rate. Losses are subject to the limitations on capital losses, with losses prohibited on personal transactions.
A buyer paying for an NFT in fiat currency would not have a barter transaction and, as a result, would not have a taxable event on the purchase. (The tax laws do not treat US currency as appreciated or depreciated property in the hands of US taxpayers.) If an NFT is purchased with cryptocurrency, however, the transaction is treated as a barter transaction. Gain or loss is based on whether the cryptocurrency used to buy the NFT is appreciated or depreciated in the hands of the buyer. Gain or loss on the barter transaction is capital or ordinary, depending on whether the cryptocurrency used to make the purchase is a capital or ordinary asset in the buyer’s hands.
For a buyer using cryptocurrency that is a capital asset in the buyer’s hands to buy an NFT, the buyer has long-term capital gains or loss if the cryptocurrency was held for the long-term holding period. Gain or loss would be short-term if the buyer held the cryptocurrency for one year or less.
A buyer who holds appreciated cryptocurrency can avoid paying tax on the purchase of an NFT if the buyer does not use the appreciated cryptocurrency to make the purchase. Rather, the buyer can acquire the required amount of cryptocurrency in the market and deliver the newly acquired cryptocurrency in payment for the NFT. There would not be any appreciation in the newly acquired cryptocurrency so the taxpayer would not have any gain or loss on the NFT purchase.
State Tax
Buyers and sellers of NFTs need to consider possible state taxation on their NFT transactions. Purchases and sales might trigger state income tax, sales tax and use tax. As a result, taxpayers need to be aware that different tax rules might apply to capital transactions and those generating ordinary income and loss. Some states, for example, tax capital gains as ordinary income, while others do not.
Read the previous article in the series: Taxation of NFT Creators
Read the next article in the series: NFTs and Charitable Fundraising: Navigating Tax Hurdles

Taxation of NFT Creators
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
Taxation of NFT Creators
January 11, 2022
Read time: 7 min
NFTs offer artists, musicians, celebrities, influencers and other creators an opportunity to develop, market and control the future of many types of digital content that they produce. Less understood is how these assets will be categorized and taxed by the Internal Revenue Service. This article reviews how creators of NFTs will likely be treated by the IRS and what that means for them.
An NFT, or non-fungible token, is a unique digital asset that is recorded and transferred on a blockchain. (For a discussion of NFTs, see the previous article in this series, “Introduction to NFTs.”) An NFT can be a representation of something (a work of art, a photograph, a piece of music or a collectible), or it can be an original creation that exists only in digital form. It can be a single, one-of-a-kind item or one of any number of replicas of the same content. Just about anything can be represented in an NFT.
People that create NFTs are often referred to as “creators” and the process of initially recording the NFT on the blockchain is often referred to as “minting.” Creators include artists, musicians, celebrities, influencers, athletes, sports fans, collectors and authors.
Each NFT has its own unique metadata, making it non-fungible and not interchangeable with another NFT or any other asset. Ownership is recorded and authenticity is confirmed on the blockchain. NFTs are “smart contracts,” which means that their metadata includes the contractual terms and conditions that govern their use. NFTs are generally sold to buyers for an agreed-upon amount of cryptocurrency or the digital token that is native to the blockchain on which the NFTs are recorded. (Some NFTs can be purchased using actual currency or with a credit card.) The value, if any, of an NFT is only what a willing buyer will pay a willing seller for it.
Although the market for NFTs is too new to make sweeping generalizations about their taxation, the tax treatment of creators of NFTs should be fairly straightforward (Notice 2014-21, 2014-16 I.R.B. 938). Minting an NFT should not be a taxable event because it does not arise from or represent the sale or exchange of property (Code §§ 61(a)(3), 1001). The creator has a taxable event, however, when an NFT is sold or exchanged for real currency, cryptocurrency, a digital token, another NFT or any other type of property. (When a buyer pays for an NFT using property, rather than real currency such as the US dollar, the transaction is taxed as a “barter transaction.” The buyer, not just the seller, has a taxable event upon the purchase. For a discussion of barter transactions, see our forthcoming article “Taxation of the Purchase or Sale of an NFT.”)
Under the IRS analysis for convertible cryptocurrency set out in Notice 2014-21, an NFT, by analogy, is likely to be taxed as property. The creator thus has taxable gain or loss on the sale or exchange of an NFT.
ORDINARY OR CAPITAL ASSETS?
Whether an NFT sale triggers ordinary or capital gain or loss turns on whether it is an ordinary or capital asset in the hands of the creator. There are two possible ways in which an NFT could be treated as an ordinary asset for the creator.
First, an NFT is likely to be an ordinary asset if (a) the creator’s personal efforts produced it and the NFT is “a patent, invention, model, design (whether or not patented), a secret formula or process, a copyright, a literary, musical or artistic composition, a letter or memorandum, or similar property” (Code§1221(a)(3)(A).) or (b) if the NFT is a letter, memorandum, or similar property that was prepared or produced for the creator (Code § 1221(a)(3)(B)).
The second way in which an NFT is likely to be treated as an ordinary asset is if it is part of the creator’s stock in trade, of a kind of property included in inventory, or held for sale to customers in the ordinary course of the creator’s trade or business (Code § 1221(a)(1)). The easiest way for a creator to fall into this category is for the creator to be in the trade or business of selling NFTs and to have customers.
Ordinary and necessary expenses are deductible expenses if paid or incurred by a taxpayer in carrying on the trade or business of creating and selling NFTs (Code § 162). Those expenses would include the costs of creating the NFT, adding the NFT to a blockchain and all expenses incurred for its sale.
The creator’s tax basis is determined by reference to the creator’s costs and expenses in creating the NFT (Code § 1221(a)(3)(C)).
Those NFTs that are capital assets are subject to the imitations that apply to capital losses.
TAXATION ON THE SALE OR EXCHANGE OF AN NFT
A creator realizes gain or loss when selling an NFT for real currency or exchanging it for other property that differs materially from the NFT (Code § 1001). Gain or loss is taxable when it is realized or sustained. It is the amount by which the value of the cash or property received on the sale or exchange is more (or less) than the amount of the taxpayer’s adjusted tax basis (Treas. Reg. § 1.61-(a)).
Rules for computing the amount of gain or loss are contained in Code § 1001 and the regulations issued under that section. Although NFTs are intangible assets, the tax rules that allow for the amortization of the tax basis in certain intangible assets do not apply to creators of intangible assets (Code § 197). Only holders of NFTs that are in a trade or business can amortize NFT basis, provided they did not create the NFT.
Installment Method
In an installment sale, the seller of the property receives at least one payment in a tax year after the year in which the sale occurs (Code § 453(b)). Reporting income on the installment method might be available to certain NFT creators, allowing the seller to recognize income as payments are received.
Code § 453 and the regulations issued under that section set out the rules that must be met for a transaction to qualify for the installment method. As an initial matter, however, the seller cannot be a dealer and the NFTs cannot be treated as inventory for tax purposes.
LICENSING OR ROYALTIES
As of the date of this writing, the copyright and intellectual property ownership rights associated with an NFT are often retained by the creator. This means that copyright ownership, license fees, and whether any royalties are due to the creator would be coded into the NFT’s metadata. As a result, an NFT purchaser does not obtain the copyright or other intellectual property associated with an NFT unless those rights were explicitly transferred to the purchaser as part of the NFT purchase. Upon subsequent sales, license and royalty payments may be due to the creator or subsequent license holders. If so, these requirements would be reflected in the NFTs metadata. This additional revenue would be taxed as ordinary income (Code § 1221(a)(3)).
CHARITABLE CONTRIBUTIONS OF NFTS
Because each NFT is unique and value is only set by a willing buyer and a willing seller, it is difficult—if not impossible—to value it. This makes it impossible for many people looking to make charitable donations to meet necessary tax requirements. To overcome this valuation problem, creators that want to support charities are, instead, partnering with their favorite charities to auction off NFTs, where some or all of the proceeds benefit the charity. For a discussion of the tax issues faced by creators with respect to charitable fundraising using NFTs, see “NFTs and Charitable Fundraising: Navigating Tax Hurdles.”
Read the previous article in the series: Introduction to NFTs
Read the next article in the series: Taxation of the Purchase and Sale of NFTs
