ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
Insurance Protection Gaps: Searching for Solutions
February 10, 2023
Read time: 13 min
Given the vast number of proposals to close “the protection gap” offered by regulators, reinsurers, insurers, brokers and other industry participants in recent years, it is a wonder that it persists. But to many observers, it seems blindingly obvious that there are multiple protection gaps—functions of geography, known perils and other factors—some of which are explored in this article. And it seems equally obvious that neither insurance regulators nor insurers know how to close the gaps—or that they alone have the tools to do so.
There is a behavioral science principle, variously attributed, stating that if the only tool one has in hand is a hammer, every problem looks like a nail. After decades of fruitless attempts to close the protection gap in the United States, it seems likely that insurance education efforts, calls for lower-cost insurance products, or attempts to develop new insurance products are inadequate solutions to the challenge. To be sure, insurers and insurance regulators have roles to play. But we need to cast a wider net. This article is a step in that direction.
THE MOST RECENT GAP
After every natural catastrophe, one can rely on seeing press reports about the low take-up of insurance coverage that would have responded to the peril that caused the uninsured losses. The most recent examples of this were just last month, following epic rainfall and flooding in California, where we learned that approximately 98% of Californians were not insured for flood. Moody’s RMS estimated total economic damage from those December 2022 to January 2023 floods to be between $5 billion and $7 billion, with a range of insured losses between $500 million and $1.5 billion. AM Best’s report on California losses in mid-January 2023 noted that even for Californian homeowners with flood insurance provided via the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP), coverage would be capped at $250,000 as compared with the state’s median home value of almost $685,000. So, even for properties with NFIP coverage, there will be insurance gaps, as there are generally around the country for homeowners who have not been boosting coverage limits to keep pace with increasing home values in recent years.
MULTIPLE GAPS
For homeowners in Florida and along the Gulf Coast, the flood and basic property insurance-coverage gaps are well known. Similarly, every time there is wind and water in the New York metropolitan area we find out how few homeowners carry flood insurance. In 2021, after Hurricane Ida and Tropical Storm Henri hit the US northeast, homes located miles from coastal floodplains were inundated. Tragically, a number of people living in basement apartments in Queens, New York, drowned. We also learned that “Among the roughly 10,000 homes in [the Jamaica neighborhood of Queens], just 16 were protected by flood insurance, according to a database compiled by the Association of State Floodplain Managers.”
There are huge protection gaps in various states—not just in California—for earthquake coverage. In California, the California Earthquake Authority (CEA) estimates that roughly 13% of homeowners are covered. West of the Cascades, where the Cascadia Subduction Zone presents major quake risk, the take-up rate of a little more than 13% is about the same as in California, according to a 2018 study by Washington insurance regulators. In the country’s other major earthquake-exposed area, the New Madrid zone, approximately 11.5% of homeowners in that multi-state region were covered for quake exposure, per a 2022 report from Missouri insurance regulators, with coverage down 49% from 2000 to 2021.
Despite mandatory vehicle financial responsibility laws, take a guess at the percentages of uninsured vehicles on the road: One in eight nationwide in 2019, with a high of 29.4% in Mississippi, 20.4 % in Florida (where third-party liability coverage is not mandated), 16.6% in California, 19.5% in Alabama and 8.3% in Texas. This is why roughly 40% of states mandate uninsured motorist protection.
How many Americans don’t have life insurance? Slightly less than half. (See this lengthy review in Forbes of life insurance take-up and the reasons why more people don’t purchase it (for 60% of those who do not, the primary issue is cost).
Despite these statistics, the proposals to close “the protection gap” keep coming from all and sundry. It’s time to get a grip on the situation, and the first step in doing so is to understand what led to the current state of affairs.
ROOT CAUSES
This week, Neptune Flood, an intermediary that offers private flood insurance (and also parametric earthquake coverage in several states) published the results of a survey, conducted in conjunction with the University of South Florida, seeking to answer this question: “Why don’t homeowners buy flood insurance?” The results?
According to the authors, the primary causes are as follows:
- A misunderstanding that their home insurance policy covers flooding when it does not.
- A perception that the risk of flooding at their home is lower than it really is.
- The fact that flood insurance is often not mandatory, unlike home and auto insurance.
Explaining the survey results, Neptune Flood continued:
Among the 266 respondents who claimed not to have a flood insurance policy, the most cited reason (60.9%) was, “I don’t believe I’m at risk,” while 30.4% said, “It’s just not on my mind.” Almost 30% cited not having the disposable income, and 27.8% cited that flood insurance was too expensive.
HOW MUCH OF A FACTOR IS COST?
The issue of cost starts to get at an aspect of the debate about low insurance take-up rates that most commentators seem to skate right by. A recent Bloomberg News article reported on a survey that found that 64% of American consumers (166 million) were living “paycheck to paycheck” at the end of 2022, an increase of 9.3 million Americans from the end of 2021. A Bloomberg Business item from January 24, 2023, reported that one-third of US consumers could not afford a $400 emergency expense.
When asked to explain, after Hurricane Ida, why homeowners in Jamaica, Queens, were not insured for flood, one response was “[i]t’s not a rich community…. People try to save every dollar they have to do something else with it, instead of buying flood insurance.”
Based on these findings, it doesn’t appear too bold to offer cost or expense as one of the root causes for going without insurance. But it seems deeper than that. No matter how low the cost of some barebones or basic coverage is, many folks simply do not possess the ability to pay for coverage.
But there are almost certainly more root causes.
IGNORANCE IS FAR FROM BLISS
There is some percentage of Americans who apparently are simply unaware of the exposure they may face from one peril or another or do not appreciate the odds that their exposure may one day manifest itself in a loss-causing event. For flood exposure, some of the flood maps that the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) uses, or that banks use in determining whether a borrower must purchase flood insurance, are outdated. Since most Californians live within 30 or 40 miles of a fault line, it would be reasonable to assume that they have some awareness of exposure—but a 13% take-up rate statewide clearly suggests a lack of awareness.
Consumer education has not helped. Large percentages of insured homeowners—75%, according to the Neptune Flood/University of South Florida survey—erroneously believe their homeowners coverage includes flood protection. As one of the leading consumer advocates noted during a December 15, 2022, presentation (entitled “Addressing Flood Peril as Climate Changes: State Insurance Regulators Must Step Up to Offer A New National Strategy”) delivered at a meeting of the Property and Casualty Insurance (C) Committee of the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), “[d]ecades of consumer education has not moved the needle on voluntary purchase of flood insurance.”
It is difficult to imagine that many Americans voluntarily visit insurance department websites or FEMA’s website to read helpful natural catastrophe risk awareness and risk management brochures prepared by regulators, government officials and consumer advocates, or that they visit insurer websites for their explanatory materials. Instead, what are we bombarded with? Commercial after commercial featuring Mr. Mayhem, or NFL stars being treated just like the rest of us by Jake when it comes to coverage, or the long-running series of ads (since 2008!) featuring Flo and her companions or, finally, the uniformed emu and human sidekick helping us buy only the coverage we need. These are what America sees and hears, week in and week out, about insurance products.
What would a “new national strategy” to increase consumer awareness entail? Perhaps one or more blitzes of professionally produced commercials and public service announcements on every imaginable media about natural catastrophes and homeowner-risk topics. Maybe a lottery game could be developed and launched to spark some interest—and bombard participants with those educational/awareness messages at every step of the way.
Regardless, exposure unawareness and ignorance of coverage afforded (and excluded) by homeowners’ policies would seem to comprise another root cause for going without appropriate insurance.
CHOICES?
Giving consumers the “choice” to go uninsured for a peril they can’t meaningfully assess isn’t doing anyone a favor. Withholding the true cost of protection and the cost of maintaining a property isn’t doing anyone a favor and generates huge societal costs for everyone.
— December 15, 2022, CEJ Presentation (see above)
For more than 75 years we have, as a country, been developing and building—in hell-bent-for-leather fashion—along the Atlantic and Gulf coasts, particularly in Florida and in California. It doesn’t seem that we have missed any areas exposed to wind, storm surge, quake or wildfire—we’ve been building everywhere. According to Core Logic, in 2022 the aggregate value of wind- and storm-surge-exposed residential properties along the Gulf and Atlantic coasts was in excess of $10 trillion, up from roughly $2 trillion 15 years ago.
At the same time that we have been building and paving huge chunks of our country, we’ve been destroying or degrading parts of the environment—coastal wetlands, stretches of mangroves, barrier beaches—that used to provide a fair amount of protection to settled areas just inland from the coasts. In the western United States, we have been building in the “wildland-urban interface,” aka invading territory that is particularly prone to wildfires. In short, the supply of structures that are at risk has mushroomed since the end of World War II. Our collective ability to protect those structures has not kept pace, whether one speaks about land use policies broadly, zoning laws, construction codes, etc., or whether one considers insurance requirements.
Generally, mortgaged residential properties require property and flood coverages. Are those coverage amounts sufficient? Likely not, particularly with federal flood insurance providing maximum coverage at $250,000, as compared to median home prices of approximately $800,000 in the New York metropolitan area, $480,000 in Miami-Dade and $260,000 in Newport News, Virginia.
And quake coverage? Not mandated at all!
KEY STEPS
It has taken 75 years to get into “the protection gap” mess our country is in, and it is going to take us a while to extricate ourselves. Rising sea levels and more intense, more frequent weather events are going to complicate things and lengthen disaster-recovery periods. However, we need to heed the advice (political, to be sure, but equally applicable to the topic at hand) of a well-known 20th-century UK Labor politician, Denis Healey: When one finds oneself in a hole, the first thing to do is to stop digging.
So, once we put the shovels and pickaxes down on new construction in flood-prone and coastal areas—if we can do so—the task is to develop a list of priority projects to climb out of the hole and get them funded using varying combinations of public and private funds (depending on the project).
But even before that, we must use existing technology to maximize our understanding of risk exposures and enhance our ability to adjust as exposures change over time.
Second, we need to develop insurance coverages that are, as our friends in the United Kingdom say, “fit for purpose.” For starters, at the risk of continuing to breach the most fundamental principle of insurance that the losses of a few should be paid by the many, the coverages need to be universal. Homeowner policies should provide coverage for ALL natural catastrophe perils. We need to leave behind the dead end of “adverse selection,” in which those on high ground don’t buy flood insurance; indeed, we can’t even persuade most folks in low-lying areas to do so. Yet, as FEMA’s website advises, since 1996, flood events have occurred in 99% of US counties. To be sure, we will need to recognize that for some perils (e.g., earthquakes) there are locations in which, objectively, there is no exposure or only really low exposure. So, might it be possible to set a low minimum premium for structures in those locations? Some of us will pay not so much; others, using risk-based pricing, will have higher premiums. But there is no free lunch here. And for those of us able to foot the bill for mandated coverages (i.e., for those with second (or third) homes to protect), there would be no subsidies. For those unable to foot the bill, there could be subsidies that reduce over time.
For insurers aghast at the prospect of aggregate exposures that reach to the stratosphere, we will need regional and/or federal natural catastrophe insurance backstops—perhaps peril by peril, perhaps multiperil—that offer protection above reasonably robust estimates of damage that will be caused by mega-events.
Then what? Repetitive loss properties? Why not start with those that have produced the most losses over a period of time, buy out the owners, and begin relocating homes and businesses?
The most exposed coastal and riverine properties? Why not develop a plan that looks ahead 50 or 75 years to gauge whether projected rising sea and river levels make it likely or unlikely that “reasonable” adaptation measures will succeed and can allow the structure to remain in place? For homeowners in reasonably “safe” locations, why not offer tax incentives to fortify/retrofit homes against whatever perils pose threats in particular locations (in the same manner that we are now offering tax incentives to install solar panels or purchase electric vehicles)?
To conclude, the multiple insurance protection gaps that we confront in the United States have grown over time, fed and impacted by a variety of factors, including unchecked, unregulated property development, poorly understood risk exposure, individual and family financial pressures, and severe natural catastrophe events that are increasing both in frequency and in the amount of damage they cause. To shrink protection gaps and increase resiliency for society as a whole will require, over reasonably long periods of time, an array of fixes that only coordinated efforts by federal, state and local legislators, state insurance regulators, and insurance-industry participants will be able to develop and apply, collectively.
Now would be an ideal time to begin.

UmRUG Update: Implementation of the Reorganization Directive (“UmRUG”)
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
UmRUG Update: Implementation of the Reorganization Directive (“UmRUG”)
February 10. 2023
Read time: 10 min
Düsseldorf, February 10, 2023 – On Friday, February 10, 2023, the Federal Council (Bundesrat) approved the “Gesetz zur Umsetzung der Umwandlungsrichtlinie” (UmRUG), which had already been passed by the German Parliament (Bundestag) on January 20, 2023. In addition to the modernization of national transformation processes, the UmRUG for the first time regulates the cross-border change of legal form and the cross-border division into several enterprises of companies. The Act enters into force immediately after promulgation in the Federal Law Gazette – expected until the end of February.
1. BACKGROUND
The UmRUG serves to implement the Transformation Directive (EU) 2019/2121 (“UmwRL”), which was adopted by the EU on November 27, 2019, as part of one of the largest reform packages of European company law, the so-called “Company Law Package“ and represents an important normative consolidation and continuation of the case law of the ECJ on the European freedom of establishment. The long-awaited harmonization by regulating cross-border division into several enterprises and cross-border changes of legal form of corporations in EU and EEA countries creates legal certainty and opens up new structuring possibilities. The UmRUG is completed by the Measures Act Preparatory Act (Maßnahmengesetzvorbereitungsgesetz, “MgVG”) concerning cross-border mergers and by the Act Implementing the Co-determination Regulation of the Transformation Directive (Gesetz zur Umsetzung der mitbestimmungsrechtlichen Regelung der Umwandlungsrichtlinie, “MgFSG“) for cross-border division into several enterprises and changes of legal form.
2. ESSENTIAL INNOVATIONS IN A NEW SIXTH BOOK IN THE GERMAN TRANSFORMATION ACT
The provisions on cross-border transformations are summarized in a new sixth book of the German Transformation Act (“UmwG”). The proven principles and the reference-rich system of the German Transformation Act are retained. As a result of the UmRUG, cross-border mergers in which the entire assets of a company are transferred to another existing company or to a new company established as a result are amended in Secs. 305-319 of the amended version of the German Transformation Act (“UmwG n.F.”). In addition, for the first time, provisions on cross-border division into several enterprises are created in Secs. 320-332 UmwG n.F. on new formations and on cross-border changes of legal form in Secs. 333-345 UmwG n.F. Whereas in the case of a merger of two legal entities, their assets are combined, in the case of a division into several enterprises, the assets of an entity are either
- divided as a whole between at least two existing or newly established companies (split-up);
- only part of the assets are transferred to one or more existing or newly established companies, whereby the shareholders of the company being spun off receive shares in the acquiring company (spin-off);
- or part of the assets are transferred to one or more existing or newly established companies, with the new shares being transferred to the transferring company (hive-down).
The cross-border change of legal form is primarily accomplished by transferring the registered office of a company to another state while retaining its identity. A transfer of assets does not take place.
In order to meet the increased need for protection of the parties involved as a result of the increase of the possibilities, new and, in part, more specific provisions have been included for the protection of creditors, employees, and minority shareholders. The procedure for cross-border restructuring measures involving a German corporation and their (legality) review basically follows the familiar procedure for cross-border mergers.
a) Protection of creditors
The new possibilities are not intended to allow companies to use clever structural measures to evade claims or make it more difficult to enforce them. Therefore, creditors of the transferring company or the company changing its legal form may, in accordance with Secs. 314, 328, 341 UmwG n.F., demand security in court insofar as the fulfillment of claims which are not yet due, but which already arose prior to the publication of the merger plan, division plan, or change of legal form plan (or its draft) are endangered by the transformation process. If the creditor has made this credible before the competent court, Secs. 316 para. 2 sent. 3, 329, 343 para. 2 sent. 3 UmwG n.F. provide in particular for a block on the register as long as the proceedings have not yet been fully completed. Pursuant to Secs. 314 para. 5, 328, 341 para. 1 UmwG n.F., the court having jurisdiction in this respect shall be the court in the district in which the competent registry court is also located. Upon request, this competent court shall inform the registry court whether such proceedings have been asserted in court (Secs. 315 para. 5, 329, 342 para. 5 UmwG n.F.).
b) Extension of the Examination Duties of the Registry Court – Abuse Control
The UmRUG extends the powers of the Registry Court. In addition to the existing examination duties, the register court must carry out an abuse control insofar as there are indications that a transformation is to be carried out for abusive purposes, in particular with the aim of evading or circumventing Union law or national law (Secs. 316 para. 3, 329, 343 para. 3 UmwG n.F.). According to the new act, indications exist in particular if:
- aa) a negotiation procedure to be conducted pursuant to Article 133 (2) to (4) of Directive (EU) 2017/1132 (to ensure co-determination) has only been initiated at the request of the court;
- bb) the number of employees is at least four-fifths of the threshold relevant for corporate co-determination, no value is added in the target country and the administrative seat remains in Germany;
- cc) a foreign company becomes the debtor of company pensions or entitlements as a result of the cross-border transformation and this company has no other operating business.
If the existence of the indications triggers a duty to examine on the part of the register court, the latter has the option of hearing the trade unions represented in the transferring legal entity pursuant to Secs. 317 No. 5, 329, 344 No. 5 of the Transformation Act (UmwG), as amended, insofar as this is necessary for the examination of the unfairness.

CMS Issues New Policy Allowing Medicaid and CHIP Coverage of Interprofessional Consultations
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
CMS Issues New Policy Allowing Medicaid and CHIP Coverage of Interprofessional Consultations
February 10, 2023
Read time: 5 min
The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) has revised its policy guidance on the coverage and payment for interprofessional consultations under Medicaid and the Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP). Interprofessional consultations refer to requests by a patient’s treating practitioner for second opinions or treatment advice from a specialist practitioner. These types of services do not require face-to-face contact between the patient and the consulting practitioner. In a significant reversal from CMS’s previous policy on interprofessional consultations, CMS published a letter to state health officials in January 2023 clarifying that Medicaid and CHIP coverage and payment of interprofessional consultation is permissible, even when the beneficiary is not present, as long as the consultation is for the direct benefit of the beneficiary. The letter grants states the ability to provide coverage for interprofessional consultations, with flexibility to develop their own payment methodologies. Interprofessional consultations can expand access to specialty care, foster interdisciplinary input on patient care and reduce administrative burdens on treating practitioners.
BACKGROUND
Since 2019, Medicare has provided separate payment for interprofessional consultations in a continuing effort to recognize a patient-centered care management model that acknowledges the value of integrating primary care and specialists to provide coordinated care to patients. In the absence of payment for interprofessional consultations, the alternative is frequently a separate patient visit with a specialist to obtain the specialist’s input. Permitting payment for these services permits a straightforward phone or internet-based consultation between a primary care practitioner and a specialist. This significantly reduces the burden on the patient, who is relieved of another appointment, and promotes integrated care.
In a similar letter to state Medicaid directors issued in November 2018, CMS prohibited the coverage and payment for interprofessional consultation in the absence of the in-person presence of the patient. Under this policy, the costs of such consultations were incorporated into the underlying rate paid to the treating practitioner for a covered Medicaid service. The treating practitioner would then have to pay the consulting practitioner out of that payment rate through a separate arrangement between the two providers. This approach was administratively complex and created barriers to specialty input on beneficiary care.
NEW GUIDANCE FOR COVERAGE OF INTERPROFESSIONAL CONSULTATIONS
The January 2023 letter represents a significant reversal from CMS’s previous policy on interprofessional consultations. Under the new policy, Medicaid and CHIP coverage and payment of interprofessional consultation is permissible, even when the beneficiary is not present, as long as the consultation is for the direct benefit of the beneficiary. Interprofessional consultations may be delivered in via synchronous (including audio-only) or asynchronous telehealth modalities.
The letter specifies that for an interprofessional consultation to be covered, it must be for the direct benefit of the beneficiary. This means the services must be directly relevant to the individual patient’s diagnosis and treatment, and the consulting practitioner must have specialized expertise in the particular health concerns of the patient. Additionally, in order for interprofessional consultation to be covered under Medicaid or CHIP, both the treating and the consulting practitioners must be enrolled in their state as a Medicaid or CHIP provider. For consultations that cross state lines, the consulting practitioner must be enrolled in Medicaid or CHIP in the state where the beneficiary resides, but only needs to be licensed in the state in which they are practicing.
The decision whether and how to provide coverage for interprofessional consultations is ultimately up to states. Interprofessional consultation services may be covered under a variety of existing mandatory and optional Medicaid state plan benefits, with CMS suggesting that states consider a physician services, services of other licensed practitioners, rehabilitative services and health homes. States also have considerable flexibility to develop payment methodologies for interprofessional consultation services. The letter notes the similar expansion of payment for interprofessional consultations under the Medicare program, using CPT codes 99447-99449. CMS encourages states to review and consider the Medicare billing codes and payment rates for interprofessional consultations, along with behavioral health integration codes (99493, 99494, 99484), when determining state payment rates for the same services. If states choose to pay for interprofessional consultation services, they must submit a state plan amendment to add a payment methodology for the qualifying interprofessional consultation service.
As part of the coverage of interprofessional consultations, CMS encourages states to eliminate or modify prohibitions on same-day billing (the ability of a beneficiary to see more than one Medicaid provider in the same day) that may impede interprofessional consultations and prevent the integration of care between behavioral healthcare and primary care.
WHY IT MATTERS
The letter signals an important shift in CMS policy, allowing interprofessional consultation as a distinct coverable service in Medicaid and CHIP programs for which payment can be made directly to the consulting provider. Allowing direct payment to consulting practitioners expands access to specialty care, fosters interdisciplinary input on patient care and may help reduce administrative burdens on treating practitioners. This new policy aligns Medicaid and CHIP with Medicare, which has had a similar policy allowing for coverage and payment of interprofessional consultation services since 2019. States have considerable flexibility in deciding whether and how to implement coverage and payment for interprofessional consultations in their Medicaid and CHIP programs, and CMS encourages them to take advantage of this flexibility.

DEA Supports Elimination of X-Waiver Requirement for Prescribing of Buprenorphine
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
DEA Supports Elimination of X-Waiver Requirement for Prescribing of Buprenorphine
February 9, 2023
Read time: 5 min
On January 12, 2023, the US Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) released a letter to registrants announcing DEA’s support of Congress’s recent removal of the requirement that healthcare providers possess a DATA-Waiver, commonly referred to as an X-Waiver, to prescribe buprenorphine to treat opioid use disorder (OUD). The elimination of the X-Waiver will help increase access to buprenorphine, a lifesaving medication, for those with OUD, and has potentially significant operational implications for office-based opioid treatment (OBOT) practices.
BACKGROUND
On December 29, 2022, the US Congress signed into effect a year-end omnibus legislative package, the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2023 (CAA 2023), consisting of all 12 fiscal year 2023 appropriations bills and many other provisions, including health policy changes. The bipartisan Mainstreaming Addiction Treatment Act included in the omnibus package eliminated the DATA-Waiver Program under the Drug Addiction Treatment Act (DATA 2000). DATA 2000 had required that healthcare providers possess an X-Waiver to prescribe buprenorphine, a Schedule III drug, for outpatient use for the treatment of OUD.
For a provider to prescribe buprenorphine for OUD, DATA 2000 required practitioners to submit a notification of intent to the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA), hold an active state medical license, have a current DEA registration number and obtain an additional certification in addiction through an approved eight-hour training course, among other requirements. DEA would then issue the provider an X-Waiver, named after the additional DEA number that begins with the letter “X” given to providers who obtain the waiver. The number of patients a provider could treat under an X-Waiver was strictly capped. In a provider’s first year with the waiver, the provider could prescribe buprenorphine for up to 30 patients at a time. After their first year, eligible providers could apply to treat up to 100 patients, followed by up to 275 patients thereafter.
In recent years, the Biden Administration has incrementally loosened the requirements for providers to obtain an X-Waiver while also expanding the use of the waiver. In 2021, the US Department of Health and Human Services issued guidance removing the eight-hour training requirement for practitioners who treat no more than 30 patients at a time. The guidance also expanded waiver eligibility to include physician assistants, nurse practitioners, clinical nurse specialists, certified registered nurse anesthetists and certified nurse midwives. The provision included in the CAA 2023 has now eliminated the X-Waiver requirement entirely. In turn, any healthcare provider with a standard DEA controlled medication license can now prescribe buprenorphine, subject to state requirements, without any federal patient caps.
DEA SUPPORTS ELIMINATION OF THE X-WAIVER
On January 12, 2023, DEA announced its full support for Congress’s policy reform, explaining that the removal of the X-Waiver will help increase access to buprenorphine for those in need nationwide. In concert with the change, all DEA registrants should be aware of the following:
- An X-Waiver registration is no longer required to treat patients with buprenorphine for OUD.
- All future prescriptions for buprenorphine only require a standard DEA registration number. X-Waiver registration numbers are no longer needed for any prescription.
- There are no longer any limits or patient caps on the number of patients a prescriber may treat for OUD with buprenorphine.
- CAA 2023 does not impact existing state laws or regulations that may be applicable.
SAMHSA and DEA are also working on the implementation of a separate provision of the CAA 2023 related to training requirements for DEA registration. The provision requires all providers who apply for a DEA license to prescribe controlled substances to undergo a one-time, non-repetitive, eight-hour training on managing patients with opioid and other substance use disorders. These requirements will go into effect on June 21, 2023.
IMPLICATIONS FOR OBOT PRACTICES
The elimination of the X-Waiver has potentially significant operational implications for OBOT practices. To increase “prescribing power” relative to the federal patient caps, OBOT practices engaged more prescribers (whether physicians, physician assistants or nurse practitioners) than would otherwise be optimal operationally, often on a part-time basis. The removal of federal patient caps means that OBOT practices can move to more optimal modes of engaging providers, shifting prescribing capability to full-time prescribers, and future recruitment can occur on that basis. This shift in provider engagement may allow practices to satisfy certain Stark Law exceptions, as well as Ant-Kickback Statute and Eliminating Kickbacks in Recovery Act safe harbors, that permit flexibilities on payment of clinical productivity compensation.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
The removal of the X-Waiver requirement presents a significant opportunity to expand access to buprenorphine treatment for OUD and reflects the DEA’s recent trend of liberalizing access to treatment for OUD. It also presents significant operational implications for OBOT practices, allowing practices to move to a more optimal mode of engaging clinicians, including full-time clinicians, which may allow for flexibilities on payment of clinical productivity compensation.

Proposed Universal Contraceptive Coverage in Response to Roe Reversal
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
Proposed Universal Contraceptive Coverage in Response to Roe Reversal
February 9, 2023
Read time: 4 min
The US Departments of Health and Human Services, Labor and Treasury (the Departments) recently issued a proposed rule (the proposed rule) to eliminate a moral exemption to the Affordable Care Act (ACA) contraceptive mandate and establish an “individual contraceptive arrangement” to permit individuals to obtain contraceptive services at no cost in instances in which their employer does not offer coverage based on its religious beliefs (objecting entities). This is the latest development in the Biden administration’s efforts to increase reproductive health access after Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization. The Departments previously issued a reminder to health plans and insurers that the ACA requires contraceptive coverage at no additional cost to individuals, noting that they had received reports of individuals experiencing trouble accessing contraceptive coverage.
The ACA requires most individual and group health plans to cover preventive services, screenings and vaccines without cost sharing. Preventive services include contraceptive services consistent with guidelines supported by the Health Resources and Services Administration. While there is generally widespread agreement on the value of preventive services, implementing the ACA’s contraceptive coverage requirement has met opposition from those with religious or moral objections to contraception, including many larger employers. From 2010 to 2022, the Departments issued a Request for Information, two proposed rules, four interim final rules, five final rules, an advanced notice of proposed rulemaking and four sets of Frequently Asked Questions. Much of the back-and-forth over the limits of the contraceptive service mandate was driven by more than a half dozen cases in federal court.
Under a 2018 final rule issued by the Trump administration, objecting entities could avoid compliance with the contraceptive services mandate in a manner that the Departments found objectionable. In the Departments’ view, the regulation unreasonably impaired important ACA policy goals.
The proposed rule would, if adopted in final form, establish an “individual contraceptive arrangement,” which may have originated with the US Supreme Court in Burwell v. Hobby Lobby Stores, Inc., 573 U.S. 682 (2014). Burwell held that privately held for-profit corporations are exempt from a regulation their owners religiously object to, if there is a less restrictive means of furthering the law’s interest, according to the provisions of the Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 1993. Claiming that the least-restrictive standard is exceptionally demanding, the Court said that the most straightforward way of ensuring access to contraceptives:
“[W]ould be for the Government to assume the cost of providing the [ ] contraceptives at issue to any women who are unable to obtain them under their health-insurance policies due to their employers’ religious objections.” Id. at 728.
The individual contraceptive arrangement established by the proposed rule would not require any involvement on the part of an objecting entity. Rather, providers or facilities that furnish contraceptive services could be reimbursed by offsets to their liability user fee adjustment. Notably, the proposed rule would leave in place the existing religious exemption for entities and individuals with religious, though not moral, objections.
The individual contraceptive arrangement relies on providers of contraceptive services to offer these services at no cost to individuals. The provider is instead reimbursed from a participating qualified health plan under a state marketplace of exchange.
To date, many objecting entities have not supported any mechanism that would give their employees access to contraceptive services. As their objections have focused on their need to be involved in the process of providing access, it remains to be seen whether they will strongly oppose the proposed rule. In the meantime, employers and plan sponsors who did not previously satisfy an exemption should continue to provide contraceptive coverage with no cost-sharing under their health plans, and employers and plan sponsors who may be interested in this limited exception to the contraceptive coverage requirement may want to submit comments to the proposed rule.
For more information, please contact your regular McDermott lawyer or one of the authors listed below.

CMS Releases the CY 2024 Advance Notice for Medicare Advantage and Part D
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
CMS Releases the CY 2024 Advance Notice for Medicare Advantage and Part D
February 8, 2023
Read time: 9 min
On February 1, 2023, the US Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) released the Advance Notice of Methodological Changes for Calendar Year (CY) 2024 for Medicare Advantage (MA) Capitation Rates and Part C and D Payment Policies. The Advance Notice is released on an annual basis and includes proposed updates to the capitation and risk adjustment methodologies used to calculate payments to MA plans, as well as other payment policies that impact Part D. Comments are due March 3, 2023.
Comments on the Advance Notice are due March 3, 2023. The final Rate Announcement will be published no later than April 3, 2023. Among other provisions, the Advance Notice includes the following proposals:
Payment Changes / Growth Rates: The effective growth rate for 2024 MA non-End-Stage Renal Disease (ESRD) rates is estimated to be 2.09%. Accounting for the impact of the benchmark rate cap, MA rebate and other policies, the net impact on the Medicare Trust Funds for CY 2024 is expected to be $7.3 billion.
CMS estimates the expected average change in revenue for MA organizations (MAOs) to increase by 1.03% in CY 2024, down from an 8.50% increase in CY 2023. Normalization and changes to the Part C risk adjustment model resulting in a -3.12% decrease, plus a -1.24% decline due to changes in Star Ratings, are driving the lower increase in revenue. Below is the Year-to-Year Percentage Change in MAO payment.
| Impact | 2023 Rate Announcement | 2024 Advance Notice |
|---|---|---|
| Effective Growth Rate | 4.88% | 2.09% |
| Rebasing/Re-Pricing | 0.39% | TBD in Final |
| Change in Star Ratings | 0.54% | -1.24% |
| MA Coding Pattern Adjustment | 5.9% | 0.00% (Proposed 5.9%) |
| Risk Model Revision and Normalization | -0.81% | -3.12% |
| MA Risk Score Trend | 3.5% | 3.30% |
| Expected Average Change in Revenue | +8.50% | +1.03% |
Part C Risk Adjustment Model Revision: CMS proposes several changes to the Hierarchical Condition Category (HCC) risk adjustment model. The impact of the proposals on MA risk scores is projected to be -3.12%, which represents $11.0 billion in estimated net savings to the Medicare Trust Fund in 2024. The proposed changes include:
- Restructuring of condition categories using the ICD-10 code classification system instead of the ICD-9 classification system.
- Updating the FFS data years underlying the model from 2014 for diagnoses and 2015 for expenditures to 2018 for diagnosis and 2019 for expenditures.
- Revising the denominator year that is used in determining the average per-capita predicted expenditures to create relative factors in the model from 2015 to 2020.
- Clinical revisions to the model adding constraints and removing several HCCs to reduce the effect of MA coding variation from FFS on risk scores (e.g., removal of HCC 47 Protein-Calorie Malnutrition).
Specifically, the Advance Notice discusses:
- Clinical Revisions: CMS explains that it reviewed conditions where coding variation in MA was highest relative to FFS with its clinical experts to identify conditions with discretionary coding variation. Pursuant to Risk Adjustment Model Principle 10, discretionary diagnostic categories that are “particularly subject to intentional or unintentional discretionary coding variation or inappropriate coding by health plans/providers, or that are not clinically or empirically credible as cost predictors,” should be excluded from the model. CMS proposes to constrain (i.e., apply equal coefficients) the values of all diabetes HCCs and all congestive heart failure HCCs. The proposal would also remove HCC 47 Protein-Calorie Malnutrition, HCC 230 Angina Pectoris, and HCC 265 Atherosclerosis of Arteries of the Extremities, with Intermittent Claudication.
- Changing HCCs: CMS would increase the number of payment HCCs from 86 in the current model to 115 in the proposed model. This is due to newly created HCCs and the splitting of existing HCCs as a result of moving from ICD-9 to ICD-10. The number of ICD-10 diagnosis codes mapped to an HCC for payment would decrease from 9,797 to 7,770. The proposed reclassifications reflect findings from CMS’ assessment of conditions that are coded more frequently in MA relative to FFS. The specific proposed changes to HCCs can be found in Table II-4 of the Advance Notice.
- ESRD Risk Adjustment Model: For CY 2024, CMS will continue to use the 2023 ESRD risk adjustment models for MA plans and the 2019 ESRD risk adjustment model for Program of All-Inclusive Care for the Elderly (PACE) organizations.
- Frailty Adjustment for PACE Organizations and Fully Integrated Dual Eligible Special Needs Plans (FIDE SNPs): CMS must account for the frailty of the PACE population when establishing capitated payment amounts. It must also make a payment adjustment to account for the frailty of beneficiaries enrolled in FIDE SNPs, if the average frailty level in the FIDE SNP is similar to the PACE program. For 2024, CMS is proposing to update the frailty factors used to calculate the frailty scores for those enrolled in FIDE SNPs. CMS will continue to calculate the risk scores for PACE beneficiaries using the 2017 CMS-HCC model and related factors.
On February 3, 2023, CMS announced that it had provided MAOs plan-specific risk scores for the 2021 plan year (using 2020 diagnosis data) calculated pursuant to the proposed model, as well as risk scores calculated using a version of the proposed CMS-HCC model that does not include the Principle 10-focused clinical updates.
Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 (IRA): The Advance Notice discusses several updates made by the IRA for 2024, including the following:
- Part D Drug Cost Sharing: Cost sharing for covered Part D drugs will be eliminated for beneficiaries in the catastrophic phase. This means Part D sponsors will be on the hook for 20% of the costs incurred after a Part D beneficiary’s costs exceed the annual out-of-pocket threshold, compared to roughly 15% of costs in prior years.
- Low-Income Subsidy (LIS) Program: The income limit for the full LIS benefit will increase from 135% to 150% of the federal poverty level (FPL). Individuals who earn between 135% and 150% of the FPL and who meet certain resource requirements will now be eligible for the full low-income premium and cost-sharing subsidies, as well as a $0 deductible.
- Insulin Cost Sharing: In the initial coverage and coverage gap phases, cost sharing may not exceed $35 for a month’s supply of covered insulin products. The deductible will not apply to Part D-covered insulin products.
- Adult Vaccine Cost Sharing: The deductible will continue to not apply to adult vaccines that are recommended by the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP). At any point in the benefit, these vaccines are exempt from cost sharing when administered consistent with ACIP’s recommendations. Part D sponsors will provide this coverage as a basic benefit and such costs should be reflected in plan bids.
- Base Beneficiary Premium: The base beneficiary premium growth will be capped at 6%.
IRA provisions that take effect in 2025 and later will be addressed in future Advance Notices and Rate Announcements.
Part C and D Star Ratings: CMS includes in the Advance Notice a list of the measures that will be used to calculate the 2024 Star Ratings, as well as a list of the emergency areas that were affected by emergency declarations in 2022 for purposes of making adjustments under the extreme and uncontrollable circumstances policy. CMS is also soliciting comment in the following areas:
- Universal Foundation Measures: For the 2023 measurement year and beyond, CMS is considering a core set of measures that are aligned across quality rating and value-based care programs, in what CMS is calling a “Universal Foundation” of quality measures. Each program would add aligned or program-specific measures to this measurement base. The Advance Notice outlines a preliminary set of measures that would be included in the Adult Universal Foundation, including Adult Immunization Status, Screening for Depression and Follow-Up Plan, and Screening for Social Drivers of Health/Social Need Screening and Intervention, among others.
- Substantive Measure Updates: CMS outlines potential updates to a number of measures, including possibly retiring the Care for Older Adults (COA)–Pain Assessment (Part C) measure, re-evaluating the specifications of the Diabetes Care–Eye Exam and Diabetes Care–Blood Sugar Controlled (Part C) measures, and revising the eligible population for the Breast Cancer Screening (Part C) measure, among other changes.
- New Measure Concepts: CMS also requests feedback on potential new measure concepts for future years, including Health Equity (Part C and D), Chronic Pain Assessment and Follow-Up (Part C), Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity for HEDIS Measures (Part C), Identifying Chronic Conditions in HEDIS Measures (Part C), Blood Pressure Control Measures (Part C), Kidney Health (Part C) and more.
ESRD Payment Adequacy: In recent years, stakeholders have expressed concerns that MA ESRD rates are not adequate to cover the cost of care for beneficiaries with ESRD. This concern has attracted more attention given the increase in ESRD enrollment in MA plans as a result of the 21st Century Cures Act. CMS previously analyzed stakeholders’ concerns and studied possible approaches to modifying MA ESRD rates. CMS reports that it has continued to study these concerns, including potentially basing rate changes on the area deprivation index of each county. However, at this time CMS is not proposing any changes to the MA ESRD rate methodology for 2024. CMS will continue to use statewide MA ESRD rates.
Annual Adjustments to Part D Benefit Parameters: CMS is required to update the parameters for the defined standard Part D drug benefit each year. This is meant to ensure that the actuarial value of the drug benefit tracks changes in Part D expenses. For non-LIS beneficiaries, the Advance Notice outlines the benefit parameters for defined standard benefits in 2024 as follows:
| 2023 | 2024 | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Deductible Phase | Cost Sharing: 100% | Cost Sharing: 100% | ||
| Deductible: $505 | Deductible: $545 | |||
| Initial Coverage Phase | Cost Sharing: 25% | Cost Sharing: 25% | ||
| Initial Coverage Limit: $4,660 | Initial Coverage Limit: $5,030 | |||
| Coverage Gap | Applicable Drugs: Cost sharing: 25% |
Non-Applicable Drugs: 25% |
Applicable Drugs: Cost sharing: 25% |
Non-Applicable Drugs: 25% |
| Out-of-Pocket Threshold: $7,400 | Out-of-Pocket Threshold: $8,000 | |||
| Catastrophic Coverage | Cost Sharing: Greater of 5% or $4.15 (generic / preferred multi- source drug / $10.35 (other)) |
Cost Sharing: 0% | ||
See Table III-6 of the Advance Notice.

BIPA Broader, Plaintiffs Bolder after Latest Defense Setback at Illinois’ Highest Court
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
BIPA Broader, Plaintiffs Bolder after Latest Defense Setback at Illinois’ Highest Court
February 8, 2023
Read time: 5 min
On February 2, 2023, the Illinois Supreme Court held that all causes of action brought under the Illinois Biometric Information Privacy Act (BIPA), 740 ILCS 14/1 et seq., are subject to a five-year statute of limitations. Tims v. Black Horse Carriers, Inc., 2023 IL 127801 (Ill. 2023). The Court’s holding is the latest disappointment for Illinois companies defending BIPA actions. The holding means the scourge of BIPA litigation will continue.
WHAT HAPPENED
BIPA, on its face, does not include any express limitations period. The plaintiffs asserted that Illinois’ catch-all five-year limitations period applied while the defendants argued that the one-year limitations period related to privacy speech and publication applied. After a multiyear journey through the courts, the Illinois First District Appellate Court ultimately split the baby in Tims and held that both time periods applied:
- The one-year period would apply to claims made under Sections 15(c) and 15(d) of BIPA.
- The five-year period would apply to claims brought under Sections 15(a), 15(b) and 15(e).
As with most attempts at compromise, the appellate court’s formulation left neither the plaintiffs nor the defendants satisfied, and the appeal followed to the Illinois Supreme Court with the parties seeking one limitations period to rule all BIPA claims.
Ultimately, the Illinois Supreme Court reversed Tims, holding that the five-year limitations period governs all causes of action made under BIPA. Critics of the opinion might suggest that the opinion was written as a justification for a desired result (i.e., another significant BIPA victory for plaintiffs and a further expansion of BIPA liability). However, the Court attempted to justify its ruling by explaining its views that (1) a single limitations period would create finality and predictability and (2) the one-year limitations period was inconsistent with the plain language of BIPA, the intent of the legislature and the purposes to be achieved by the statute, and that court precedent consistently applied the five-year limitations period to statutes lacking a specific limitations period.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- BIPA is broader than ever. The Illinois Supreme Court’s ruling significantly expands the scope of cognizable BIPA claims. Plaintiffs will now have more time to file actions and more prospective members to include in the class, meaning BIPA class actions are likely to grow in number and size and thus will be more expensive to resolve.
- Plaintiffs have certainty on their side. No matter where you look, from the photograph exemption, to constitutionality, to actual harm, to (now) the statute of limitations, the winning streak for plaintiffs on BIPA defenses is real, and it leaves defendants with few places to turn.
- Urgency for compliance increases. Companies now face up to five years’ worth of BIPA claims. For companies not currently in compliance, the potential universe of claims grows each day. The risk is particularly acute for companies that have only started processing biometric data in the past few years.
- It is past time for BIPA to be amended. An old, poorly written law continues to oppress and burden companies, hamstring litigants and vex the courts in Illinois. There are gaps in application and understanding, and there is inconsistent application, all of which are hallmarks that should lead to a bipartisan desire to make the law better. And yet, here we are. BIPA amendments have crept closer and closer to each of the past legislative cycles, but the time has to come when legislators stop letting the Illinois Supreme Court legislate and take responsibility for curing the deficiencies of BIPA through amendment.
WHAT’S NEXT?
The Illinois Supreme Court remanded the case to the circuit court for further proceedings. While that case continues, the Illinois Supreme Court is expected to soon issue another watershed ruling in Cothron v. White Castle Sys., Inc., where it will settle the question of when claims accrue under BIPA. Specifically, the Illinois Supreme Court is considering whether an injury occurs each time a finger is scanned or whether a violation is on a per-person basis. The significance of Tims will only serve to magnify the ultimate ruling in Cothron, however. The good news for defendants with respect to Cothron is that even some plaintiffs’ counsel are taking the position that an injury is per person.
If you have questions about BIPA compliance or are a facing a BIPA claim, please reach out to your regular McDermott lawyer or contact Daniel Campbell, David Saunders or Jonathan Ende.

Energy Tax Credits with a String Attached
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
Energy Tax Credits with a String Attached
February 7, 2023
Read time: 8 min
The Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 (IRA) grants tax credits to clean energy and infrastructure projects. But there is a string attached: to receive the tax credits, workers doing the construction, as well as those doing any subsequent alteration or repair, must be paid the prevailing wages set under the Davis-Bacon Act. In addition, there are apprenticeship requirements that must be met for that work. Thus, attention to detail is critical when it comes to those prevailing wage and apprenticeship requirements.
WHICH PROJECTS ARE ELIGIBLE FOR THE TAX CREDITS?
Tax credits are available for:
- Facilities that produce electricity from certain renewables (e.g., wind, biomass, geothermal, solar, landfill gas, trash, qualified hydropower or marine and hydrokinetic resources)
- Energy storage facilities
- Industrial carbon capture or direct air capture facilities
- Energy-efficient upgrades to commercial buildings
- Dwellings that meet certain Energy Star efficiency standards
- Certain qualified nuclear power facilities
- Alternative vehicle refueling properties
- Qualifying advanced energy projects
- Clean hydrogen facilities
- Clean fuel production facilities.
To qualify for the full credit amount, taxpayers must satisfy certain labor and apprentice requirements related to the “construction, alteration or repair” of such projects. Detailed guidance on what constitutes “construction, alteration or repair” is still outstanding. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) issued guidance on November 30, 2022, referencing the Davis-Bacon Act regulations. There, under 29 CFR § 5.2(j), those terms are defined to include not only on-site construction but also painting and decorating; on-site manufacturing of material for the construction; on-site altering, remodeling and installation of items fabricated off-site; and transportation between the work site and a facility dedicated to the construction of the building or work deemed a part of the work site.
WHAT IS THE PREVAILING WAGE OBLIGATION?
Under the Davis-Bacon Act, the prevailing wage is determined by the US Department of Labor (DOL) locality by locality. Typically, it matches the wages set in union contracts and is a combination of the basic hourly rate and any fringe benefits. Prevailing wages must be paid to those workers whose duties “are manual or physical in nature (including those workers who use tools or who are performing the work of a trade), as distinguished from mental or managerial.”
Prevailing wage determinations are based on the type of construction applicable to the project and with detailed rates for each skill set within each type. For each worker, the actual duties must be mapped back to the most applicable labor classification in the DOL determination. Illustrations of these can be found on the DOL’s website; for starters, here is the current listing for Chicago.
WHAT IS THE APPRENTICESHIP REQUIREMENT?
This is where the IRA goes beyond the Davis-Bacon Act rules, which permit but do not require apprentices. The IRA goes further, setting both a ceiling (borrowed from Davis-Bacon) and two discrete floors that require minimums for apprentice work.
The ceiling is the ratio set by each apprenticeship program: “The allowable ratio of apprentices to journeymen on the job site in any craft classification shall not be greater than the ratio permitted to the contractor as to the entire work force under the registered program.” (29 CFR 5.5(a)(4)(i).)
There is also a pair of floors that are unique to the IRA:
- Section 45(b)(8)(A)(i) sets a floor based on hours worked. Hours performed by qualified apprentices must be 10% (for projects that began before January 1, 2023); 12.5% (for projects that begin in 2023); or 15% (for projects that begin in 2024 and beyond) of the total covered work hours.
- Section 45(b)(8)(C) separately requires an additional floor that will impact smaller jobs or smaller work crews. Whoever employs four or more individuals must employ one or more qualified apprentices to perform such work.
There is one more BIG thing. Apprentices must come from an apprenticeship program registered with the DOL’s Bureau of Apprenticeship and meet all the requirements of 29 CFR parts 29 and 30. Those are typically multiyear indentures where apprentices receive paid work experience and classroom instruction with progressive wage increases during that apprenticeship.
HOW WILL THE TAX CREDITS WORK?
There are two primary types of tax credits: (1) the investment tax credit (ITC) and (2) the production tax credit (PTC). The ITC is a one-time credit received when the project is placed into service. Whoever is the owner of the project at that time receives the credit. The PTC is an ongoing 10-year credit based on actual production from the facility and is calculated based on how much electricity is produced.
To receive the ITC, compliance with prevailing wage rates during the construction period and during the five-year period after the facility goes into service is required. To receive the PTC, compliance with prevailing wage rates is needed for all alteration and repair work during that 10-year period. These ongoing prevailing wage requirements will plainly impact operating costs.
The application of the apprenticeship requirements beyond initial construction is clouded by imperfect legislative drafting. Section 45(b)(7) addresses the “prevailing wage requirement” and is explicit in limiting the prevailing wage to post-construction “alteration or repair” only within the duration of the tax credit. Section 45(b)(8) addresses “apprenticeship requirements” but with no durational limit.
Applying those apprenticeship requirements in perpetuity is neither explicitly required nor needed for any statutory purpose. But, reading out the apprenticeship requirements for “alteration or repair” is difficult when that phrase appears twice in that section, even though the lead-in sentence is more limited (i.e., “The requirements described in this paragraph with respect to the construction of any qualified facility are ….”).
This inartful drafting will likely be cured in due course with final regulations. Meanwhile, there is a practical answer to this ambiguity. First, “alteration or repair” will be later, not sooner. Second, taxpayers whose compliance with the apprenticeship requirement falls short don’t lose the tax incentive but merely are subject to paying a penalty.
WHAT ARE THE CONSEQUENCES FOR NONCOMPLIANCE?
For violations of the prevailing wage requirements, the IRA requires taxpayers to (1) pay laborers the difference between the actual wage paid and the prevailing wage determined to be appropriate, with interest, and (2) pay a fine of $5,000 per worker. This penalty increases if the employer was found to have intentionally disregarded the prevailing wage provisions.
For violations of the apprenticeship requirements, the IRS will levy a penalty of $50 multiplied by the total number of hours during which the requirement was not met (e.g., if the apprentice minimum was missed by 1000 hours, then the fine is $50,000.) This penalty increases to $500 for noncompliant hours if the taxpayer’s violation is found to be intentional.
The IRA also provides a “good faith effort” exception to the apprenticeship requirements if the taxpayer can show (1) that it requested qualified apprentices from a registered apprenticeship program but was denied (for a reason other than that the taxpayer refused to comply with the program’s requirements), or (2) the apprenticeship program failed to respond to the taxpayer’s request within five business days.
NEXT STEPS
Entities contemplating taking advantage of these energy tax credits made available under the IRA will need to plan with that statute’s twin obligations of prevailing wages and apprenticeship floors in mind. Those obligations are critical to qualify for these tax credits.
The IRA includes multiple references to the Davis-Bacon Act, and thus it is an important reference for taxpayers planning compliance with IRA requirements. To the extent the IRS decides to adopt the Davis-Bacon Act in its entirety (as it is relevant to IRA requirements), taxpayers will be able to look to those rules for planning purposes.
For construction, energy entities may prefer to hire contractors who are experienced with Davis-Bacon Act prevailing wage obligations and also participate in a DOL-approved apprenticeship program. Such contractors can simplify the obligations, which can be inserted into any agreement with such contractors along with indemnification for any shortfalls.
For post-construction “alteration or repair,” it is important to track what work will be needed at each energy project. “Alteration or repair” sweeps broadly in the context of the Davis-Bacon Act, but the regulations offer only gnomic guidance. Covered work includes “construction activity as distinguished from … servicing and maintenance work” but also includes “landscaping,” even where no further construction will follow that landscaping. (29 CFR §5.2(i).) Covered work also includes subsequent painting and decorating. (29 CFR §5.2(j).)
For such covered post-construction work, again, it may be prudent to retain a contractor with Davis-Bacon Act experience. Alternatively, entities that undertake that work with their own staff will need to take the following steps to protect their tax credits:
- Determine which work falls within “alteration or repair”
- Determine the applicable prevailing wage for each worker
- Prepare a weekly certified payroll with a record of precise hours worked
- Pay for prevailing fringe benefits
- Post required notices at work sites
- Ensure appropriate apprentice ratios
- Ensure that apprentices are registered in DOL-approved programs
- Timely cure violations.
Professor Milton Friedman, a Nobel laureate in economics, once famously quipped that “there ain’t no such thing as a free lunch.” Nor, he might add today, a tax credit without strings.

FinCEN Issues Proposed Access Rule and Proposed Forms to Further Implement the CTA
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
FinCEN Issues Proposed Access Rule and Proposed Forms to Further Implement the CTA
February 7, 2023
Read time: 13 min
In December 2022, the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, a bureau of the United States Department of the Treasury (“FinCEN” and “Treasury,” respectively), issued a notice of proposed rulemaking (“Proposed Access Rule”)[1] continuing the process of implementing regulations required under the Corporate Transparency Act (“CTA”).[2] The CTA requires certain companies created or registered to do business in the United States (each, a “Reporting Company”) to report certain identifying and beneficial ownership information (“BOI”) directly to FinCEN to be maintained in a database managed by FinCEN.[3] The Proposed Access Rule addresses which persons will be authorized to access such BOI, how such persons will receive BOI that is reported, how FinCEN would implement the strict protocols on security and confidentiality required by the CTA to protect sensitive personally identifiable information (PII) reported to FinCEN, and the penalties associated for failing to adhere to the regulatory requirements. FinCEN is accepting public comments on the Proposed Access Rule until Feb. 14, 2023.
The Proposed Access Rule is the second of three rulemakings that will be conducted by FinCEN to implement the CTA. FinCEN completed the first rulemaking on Sept. 30, 2022, by issuing a final rule (“BOI Final Rule”) that sets forth the BOI reporting obligations required by the CTA.[4]
Separately, related to the rulemaking, on Jan. 17, 2023, FinCEN issued two notices seeking comment on (1) the mechanism FinCEN proposes to use in collecting BOI from covered companies (the “BOI Report Notice”),[5] and (2) the application FinCEN proposes to use when requiring individuals to obtain a FinCEN identifier (“FinCEN Identifier Notice”).[6] Comments on both notices are due on or before March 20, 2023.
Provisions of the Proposed Access Rule
Authorized Recipients of Reported Beneficial Ownership Information
Pursuant to the requirements of the CTA, the Proposed Access Rule authorizes FinCEN to disclose BOI to five general categories of recipients in certain circumstances:
- U.S. federal, state, local and tribal government agencies (collectively, “Law Enforcement Requesters”). Mirroring the requirements of the CTA, the Proposed Access Rule would permit FinCEN to disclose BOI to U.S. federal agencies engaged in “national security, intelligence, or law enforcement activities,” such that the BOI would be in furtherance of those activities. Under the Proposed Access Rule, if a federal agency requests access to the FinCEN database for BOI, the federal agency would have to submit justification to FinCEN for the searches. FinCEN could then audit the justifications and searches to ensure the federal agencies are using their access appropriately.
State, local and tribal law enforcement agencies could access BOI if “a court of competent jurisdiction” ruled that those agencies should be allowed access to that information. The Proposed Access Rule defines a “court of competent jurisdiction” as “any court with jurisdiction over the criminal or civil investigation for which a State, local, or Tribal law enforcement agency requests BOI.”[7] Before being allowed to access BOI, the authorized user of the agency would need to upload the permitting document (which FinCEN could review) from the court of competent jurisdiction.
- Foreign law enforcement agencies, judges, prosecutors, central authorities and competent authorities (collectively, “Foreign Requesters”). Under the Proposed Access Rule, unlike Law Enforcement Requesters, Foreign Requesters would not have open-ended query access to the database. Foreign Requesters would have to request access to BOI through intermediary U.S. federal agencies and show that either (1) the request is authorized under an international treaty, agreement, or convention or (2) the request is being made by law enforcement authorities in a “trusted” foreign country. No definition of a “trusted” foreign country is provided in the Proposed Access Rule.
- Financial institutions (“FIs”) in connection with customer due diligence (“CDD”) requirements. The Proposed Access Rule proposes that the following types of financial institutions will have access to the BOI reported: banks, brokers or dealers in securities, mutual funds, futures commission merchants and introducing brokers in commodities (collectively, “FI Requesters”). Other types of financial institutions, such as money services businesses and insurance companies, and other entities not yet subject to FinCEN’s regulations, such as registered investment advisers and the private funds they manage, will not have access. Under the Proposed Access Rule, FI Requesters could only access BOI about a specific Reporting Company in order to facilitate CDD compliance, and the FI Requester must obtain consent from the Reporting Company prior to making the request to FinCEN.[8] FinCEN notes that this consent provision “reflects FinCEN’s assessment that FIs are best positioned to obtain and manage consent through existing processes and by virtue of having direct contact with the [Reporting Company] as a customer.”[9] The Proposed Access Rule, however, does not specify how an FI Requester should obtain consent from the Reporting Company, nor does it delineate procedures if a Reporting Company should not grant consent or later revoke consent.
In addition, the Proposed Access Rule uses the definition of CDD provided under 31 CFR 1010.230 (“CDD Rule”), which only requires covered FIs to identify and verify each 25% or more beneficial owner and a single person with operational control of a legal entity customer. FinCEN notes that proposing this narrower definition of CDD will be “easier to administer, reduce uncertainty about what FIs may access BOI under this provision, and better protect the security and confidentiality of sensitive BOI by limiting the circumstances under which FIs may access BOI.”[10] We note, however, that the definition of CDD may change when FinCEN revises the CDD Rule to align with the requirements of the CTA.
- Federal functional regulators and other regulatory agencies, acting in a supervisory capacity (“Regulator Requesters”). The Proposed Access Rule envisions two scenarios in which Regulator Requesters could access BOI. The first scenario, which is outlined in the CTA, provides for access to federal functional regulators and other appropriate regulatory agencies for purposes of assessing a financial institution’s compliance with the CDD Rule (which is expected to be modified in the near future), subject to three conditions: (1) the Regulator Requester must be “authorized by law to access, supervise, enforce, or otherwise determine the compliance of [a particular FI] with its CDD requirements,” (2) the BOI must only be used “for the purpose of conducting [an] assessment, supervision, or authorized investigation or activity related to the CDD requirements the regulator is responsible for overseeing,” and (3) the Regulator Requester must “[enter] into an agreement with the Secretary providing for appropriate protocols governing the safekeeping of the information.” In the second scenario, a Regulator Requester could have the same access that Law Enforcement Requesters have if the Regulator Requester “engages in civil law enforcement activities,” such as the SEC, for example, which “investigates and litigates civil violations of Federal securities laws.” The Proposed Access Rule contemplates that the Federal functional regulators with access to BOI will include the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (“FRB”), the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC), the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (“FDIC”), the National Credit Union Administration (“NCUA”), the SEC, and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (“CFTC”). The Proposed Access Rule also provides that Financial Institution Requesters could share BOI that they have obtained from FinCEN with their financial self-regulatory organization (“SRO”) for use in complying with CDD requirements under applicable law. Specifically, the Proposed Access Rule states that “[a] qualifying SRO would need to satisfy the same three conditions applicable to [Regulator Requesters], and a qualifying SRO that receives BOI from an FI it supervises may in turn use the information for the limited purpose of examining compliance with those same CDD obligations.”[11]
- U.S. Department of the Treasury. Finally, Treasury, including its offices and bureaus, such as the Office of Foreign Assets Control, FinCEN and the Internal Revenue Service, would have broad access to BOI. The Proposed Access Rule would allow access to Treasury officers and employees who require BOI for their official duties requiring BOI access, or for tax administration. FinCEN envisions Treasury components using BOI for “tax administration, enforcement actions, intelligence and analytical purposes, use in sanctions designation investigations, and identifying property blocked pursuant to sanctions, as well as for administration of the BOI framework, such as for audits, enforcement, and oversight.”[12] FinCEN invites comments on the proposed scope of the term “tax administration.”
Safeguards
The Proposed Access Rule states that BOI will have strong access-control protocols such that recipients of BOI will be required to have standards and procedures for storing the information in a secured system that will limit access to the information only to authorized personnel. These standards and procedures could be subject to audit, and authorized recipients of BOI would have to maintain information about specific beneficial ownership information searches or requests such that the searches or requests could be reviewed.
IT System Development for Beneficial Ownership Information Storage
The Proposed Access Rule states that the IT system for the BOI database will be cloud-based and will meet the highest Federal Information Security Management Act (FISMA) level. The Proposed Access Rule says that FinCEN completed the initial engineering and programming activities required for constructing the beneficial ownership IT system, and that the target date for the system to begin accepting BOI reports is Jan. 1, 2024.
Penalties
In general, it is unlawful under the CTA for any person to knowingly disclose or use BOI obtained by the person from a report submitted to or an authorized disclosure made by FinCEN, unless authorized under the CTA. Under the Proposed Access Rule, an “unauthorized use” of BOI would be any “unauthorized access of [BOI] submitted to FinCEN . . . including any activity in which an employee, officer, director, contractor, or agent of an authorized recipient knowingly violates applicable security and confidentiality requirements in connection with accessing such information.”[13] The CTA generally contains serious civil and criminal penalties that may be imposed for violations of the CTA. Violations can result in a civil penalty of $500 per day for each violation that has not ceased or been remedied. Enhanced criminal penalties can result in up to 10 years’ imprisonment.
FinCEN Identifiers
A FinCEN identifier is a unique identifying number that FinCEN issues to individuals who have provided FinCEN with their BOI, as well as to Reporting Companies that have filed initial BOI reports. The Proposed Access Rule includes proposed amendments to the BOI Final Rule[14] such that Reporting Companies can, in some cases, report to FinCEN a FinCEN identifier instead of BOI associated with certain beneficial owners. The CTA provides that, if an individual “is or may be a beneficial owner of a [Reporting Company] by an interest held by the individual in an entity that, directly or indirectly, holds an interest in the [Reporting Company],” the Reporting Company may submit the intermediate entity’s FinCEN identifier instead of the individual’s BOI.[15] Accordingly, and following the CTA, the Proposed Access Rule would allow a Reporting Company to report an intermediate entity’s FinCEN identifier instead of a beneficial owner’s BOI only when (1) the intermediate entity has obtained a FinCEN identifier and provided that identifier to the Reporting Company, (2) an individual is or may be a beneficial owner of the Reporting Company via an interest in the Reporting Company that the individual holds through the intermediate entity, and (3) “only the individuals that are beneficial owners of the intermediate entity are beneficial owners of the [Reporting Company], and vice versa.”[16]
BOI Report Notice
As discussed above, FinCEN separately released its BOI Report Notice proposing the mechanism by which FinCEN will collect BOI information. Specifically, the BOI Report Notice provides a summary of the data fields proposed to be included in the BOI collecting report: (1) filing information (i.e., whether this report is an initial report, a corrected report, an update to a prior report, or if the Reporting Company becomes newly exempt from BOI reporting requirements), (2) reporting company information (including legal name, U.S. state or country of formation, EIN or other tax identification number, business address, etc.), (3) Company Applicant information,[17] and (4) beneficial owner information.[18] FinCEN invites comment on the report itself as well as FinCEN’s estimate of the burden in completing the report, which FinCEN notes could range from 90 to 650 minutes, depending on the complexity of the Reporting Company’s ownership structure.
FinCEN Identifier Notice
FinCEN also released its FinCEN Identifier Notice proposing the application by which individuals who opt to seek a FinCEN Identifier would obtain one. Specifically, the FinCEN Identifier Notice proposes the application information fields, which include (1) individual information (name, date of birth, address, identifying document information and identifying document image), and (2) certification by the applicant that the information provided is true, correct, and complete and that willfully providing false or fraudulent beneficial ownership information to FinCEN may be subject to civil and criminal penalties.[19] FinCEN invites comment on the application itself as well as FinCEN’s estimate of the burden involved in completing the application, which FinCEN approximates to be about 20 minutes total.
Schulte Roth & Zabel’s lawyers are available to assist you in addressing any questions you may have regarding these developments. Please contact the Schulte Roth & Zabel lawyer with whom you usually work, or any of the following attorneys:
Betty Santangelo – New York (+1 212.756.2587)
Melissa G.R. Goldstein – Washington, DC (+1 202.729.7471)
Gary Stein
Hannah M. Thibideau – New York (+1 212.756.2382)
Kyle B. Hendrix – Washington, DC (+1 202.729.7465)
Rebecca A. Raskind – New York (+1 212.756.2396)
Jesse Weissman – New York (+1 212.756.2460)
[1] Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, Beneficial Ownership Information Access and Safeguards, and Use of FinCEN Identifiers for Entities, 87 Fed. Reg. 77,404 (Dec. 16, 2022), (hereinafter, “Proposed Access Rule”); Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, Fact Sheet: Beneficial Ownership Information Access and Safeguards Notice of Proposed Access Rulemaking (NPRM) (Dec. 15, 2022), [hereinafter, “Fact Sheet”].
[2] National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2021 (CTA §§ 6401–03), [hereinafter CTA].
[3] For more information regarding the CTA and AML Act generally, please see our prior Alert “Passage of Anti-Money Laundering Act of 2020 Includes Comprehensive BSA/AML Reform Measures.”
[4] Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, Beneficial Ownership Information Reporting Requirements, 87 Fed. Reg. 59.498 (Sept. 30, 2022). For more information on FinCEN’s September 2022 final rule, please see our prior Alert “FinCEN Issues Final Rule Requiring Reporting of Beneficial Ownership Information.”
[5] Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, Agency Information Collection Activities; Proposed Collection; Comment Request; Beneficial Ownership Information Reports, 88 Fed. Reg. 2760 (Jan 17, 2023), [hereinafter “BOI Report Notice”].
[6] Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, Agency Information Collection Activities; Proposed Collection; Comment Request; Individual FinCEN Identifiers, 88 Fed. Reg. 2764 (Jan. 17, 2023), [hereinafter “FinCEN Identifier Notice”].
[7] Proposed Access Rule, 87 Fed. Reg. at 77,414.
[8] Id. at 77,415.
[9] Id.
[10] Id.
[11] Proposed Access Rule, 87 Fed. Reg. at 77,416.
[12] Proposed Access Rule, 87 Fed. Reg. at 77,417.
[13] Proposed Access Rule, 87 Fed. Reg. at 77,423-24.
[14] For more information regarding the beneficial ownership reporting requirements of the CTA and FinCEN identifiers, please see our prior Alert “FinCEN Issues Final Rule Requiring Reporting of Beneficial Ownership Information.”
[15] CTA § 6403(a); 31 U.S.C. § 5336(b)(3)(C).
[16] Proposed Access Rule, 87 Fed. Reg. at 77,424.
[17] For more information on the definition of “Company Applicant” and requirements of such individuals, please see our prior Alert “FinCEN Issues Final Rule Requiring Reporting of Beneficial Ownership Information.”
[18] BOI Report Notice, 88 Fed. Reg. at 2763–64.
[19] FinCEN Identifier Notice, 88 Fed. Reg. at 2766.
This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2023 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.
All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

“Control” of Insurers: A Concept That Remains a Work in Progress
ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT
“Control” of Insurers: A Concept That Remains a Work in Progress
February 6, 2023
Read time: 6 min
The concept of “control” of insurers received significant attention from state insurance regulators last year and will receive even more in 2023. We wrote a brief report in April 2022 following the New York Department of Financial Services’ (NYDFS) publication of Circular Letter No. 5. That letter reminded the industry that neither acquiring less than 10% of the voting equity of an insurer nor limiting board representation to a single seat would guarantee a finding of no control (thus absolving investors of the need to obtain regulatory approval to acquire the minority interest and provide detailed biographical and financial information). As Circular Letter No. 5 stated, “[a] determination of ‘control’ under Insurance Law § 1501(a)(2) depends on all the facts and circumstances… [there is no] safe harbor for acquisitions below the 10% threshold, which may still result in a control determination.”
We followed up with another report in May 2022 in which we discussed the ongoing work of multiple National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) committees, task forces and working groups under the overall direction of the Macroprudential (E) Working Group to address 13 “regulatory considerations” relating to control of insurers by, among others, private equity funds (PE Funds). One of the key regulatory considerations being handled by the NAIC’s Group Solvency (E) Issues Working Group concerns persons/entities that do not have 10% or more ownership of voting securities of an insurer, including consideration of:
- Non-customary minority shareholder rights
- Investment management agreement provisions, such as costly termination provisions or excessive control over investment decisions.
On December 20, 2022, NYDFS published a “Request for Comments regarding the Presumption of Control” (the December 20 RFC)—not control of insurers, but of New York-regulated banks. What can we learn from comparing the approach of the banking side of NYDFS with their counterparts in the insurance division and with the NAIC’s developing approach as a whole?
THE DECEMBER 20 RFC
New York banking regulators began their request for comments by identifying “investment management companies” as the specific investors they were concerned about rather than listing all “potential investors” (as their insurance counterparts did back in April 2022). Throughout the remainder of the December 20 RFC, bank regulators continued to focus on investment management companies and the various funds (such as mutual, exchange-traded and PE), including individual and pooled accounts “sponsored, managed or advised” by investment managers and their affiliates with power to vote those shares. As the December 20 RFC went on to explain, certain fund managers had suggested various limitations and constraints that regulators could impose to allow the fund managers to hold large “passive” equity positions—perhaps significantly more than 10% positions that would trigger the presumption of control—without the need to be classified as controllers.
“PASSIVITY COMMITMENTS”
The December 20 RFC reviewed several proposed passivity commitments ranging from voting cutbacks, seat limitations on boards of directors and committees of boards of directors, prohibitions on serving as officers or employees of the controlled entity to soliciting proxies or exercising operational control or discretion as to a controlled entity’s “major policies and decisions.” All of these proposed commitments replicate or, at the very least, echo those found in NYDFS’ required “Special Commitment” that must be agreed upon before NYDFS will consent to a finding of no control of a domestic insurer, including a final commitment prohibiting disposals or threatened disposals of equity that implicitly or explicitly act as conditions to or inducements for the controlled entity to take or refrain from taking some action. Other states besides New York have taken similar stances.
The December 20 RFC then goes on to review multiple additional limitations or prohibitions on:
- Selling shares in the controlled entity, including single transaction sale limitations (e.g., no more than 5% of the controlled entity’s equity)
- Entering into banking or non-banking transactions with the controlled entity.
The December 20 RFC concludes by requesting comments and responses to 13 questions, including maximum percentages of equity, voting and non-voting, that fund managers ought to be able to acquire without a finding of “control” (assuming compliance with voting cutback commitments). Other questions are specific to investment managers, e.g., should regulators regard equity ownership by index funds as inherently “passive” and therefore unobjectionable? Should regulators care about ownership of voting equity by multiple investment managers and managed funds? Should regulators care about equity ownership of funds sponsored by investment managers but managed by “external managers”? If so, how independent must the external managers be? Additional questions seek comments on “abrupt dispositions” of equity and “alternative structures” (e.g., “certain types of derivatives” that act as substitutes for holding voting equity).
While several of the proposed commitments being considered by the NYDFS banking division seem similar to (if not identical with) those that the insurance side of NYDFS have employed for many years, the kinds of questions being posed by the NYDFS banking division as it engages with the investment management industry might be answered differently by insurance regulators. Indeed, insurance regulator reactions to certain asserted passive investments, the size of such investments (i.e., those well in excess of 10%) and to certain fund investors (i.e., PE Funds) might be quite different. Perhaps the differences in approach have more to do with insurance regulators considering an extremely wide range of potential acquirers of control, ranging from already regulated industry participants, including licensed insurers and managing general agents, to unregulated fund managers, with many categories of potential acquirers in between. Regardless, the NAIC’s Macroprudential (E) Working Group (now being chaired by NYDFS Acting Deputy Superintendent of Insurance Robert Kasinow, one of the country’s most experienced insurance regulators) will have additional issues to consider in 2023 if the December 20 RFC is any indication.
