Content Type: Article

  • NLRB Attacks Non-Disparagement and Confidentiality Clauses in Employee Releases, Severance Agreements

    NLRB Attacks Non-Disparagement and Confidentiality Clauses in Employee Releases, Severance Agreements

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    NLRB Attacks Non-Disparagement and Confidentiality Clauses in Employee Releases, Severance Agreements

    February 24, 2023

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Employers, especially in the context of workforce reductions, may provide departing employees with severance agreements in exchange for a release. Those agreements often include non-disparagement clauses and confidentiality clauses regarding the terms and the amount of the agreement.

    On February 21, 2023, in McLaren Macomb, the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) held that such clauses infringe on employees’ rights under the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA). Importantly, McLaren applies to both unionized and non-unionized workplaces alike.

    In depth

    McLaren limits use of confidentiality and non-disparagement provisions within employee-employer agreements. Under McLaren, employers can violate Section 8(a)(1) of the NLRA by merely offering unlawful terms, regardless of whether the employee ever signs such an agreement and regardless of whether the employer actually seeks to enforce such clauses.

    FACTS OF McLAREN MACOMB

    McLaren Macomb operates a teaching hospital in Michigan. There was a reduction in force with the hospital eliminating its outpatient services, resulting in the furlough of 11 union-represented employees. McLaren provided a severance agreement that included a release, as well as standard clauses prohibiting either disparaging McLaren (a non-disparagement clause) or disclosing the terms of the agreement itself (a confidentiality clause).

    Looking at each, the clauses were facially neutral on any NLRA rights:

    Confidentiality: “The Employee acknowledges that the terms of this Agreement are confidential and agrees not to disclose them to any third person, other than spouse, or as necessary to professional advisors for the purposes of obtaining legal counsel or tax advice, or unless legally compelled to do so by a court or administrative agency of competent jurisdiction.”

    Non-Disclosure: “At all times hereafter, the Employee promises and agrees not to disclose information, knowledge or materials of a confidential, privileged, or proprietary nature of which the Employee has or had knowledge of, or involvement with, by reason of the Employee’s employment. At all times hereafter, the Employee agrees not to make statements to Employer’s employees or to the general public which could disparage or harm the image of Employer, its parent and affiliated entities and their officers, directors, employees, agents and representatives.”

    THE LEGAL BASIS OF McLAREN MACOMB

    This NLRB decision takes an expansive view of employee rights under Section 7 of the NLRA. This is one of a series of cases in which the NLRB has used its test of “whether a reasonable employee would find that the proffer of the settlement agreement would interfere with, restrain, or coerce them in the exercise of their Section 7 rights.”

    That test permits regulation by the fiat of an NLRB majority. This is an issue on which the NLRB has swung back and forth from presidential administration to presidential administration. NLRB members are appointed by the President, so the current NLRB (and this decision) reflect a policy pronouncement reversing prior precedent. The NLRB has a history of showing little deference to stare decisis (adherence to prior decisions).

    Here, there is certainly a basis for connecting such clauses to Section 7 rights under the NLRA, as the NLRB majority in McLaren Macomb explained:

    A severance agreement is unlawful if it precludes an employee from assisting coworkers with workplace issues concerning their employer, and from communicating with others, including a union, and the Board, about his employment. Conditioning the benefits under a severance agreement on the forfeiture of statutory rights plainly has a reasonable tendency to interfere with, restrain, or coerce the exercise of those rights unless it is narrowly tailored to respect the range of those rights.

    The flaw in McLaren Macomb is the failure to fairly balance those considerations versus employer interests. (Textile Workers Union of Am. v. Darlington Mfg. Co., 380 U.S. 263, 269 (1965) (“[I]t is only when the interference with [Section] 7 rights outweighs the business justification for the employer’s action that [Section] 8(a)(1) is violated.”).)

    That flaw will be central to appellate review of this decision.

    THE FATE OF NON-DISPARAGEMENT PROVISIONS POST-McLAREN

    Here, the NLRB found the non-disparagement provision to be unlawful because it:

    • Prohibited the employee from making a statement that the employer had violated the NLRA to their former coworkers, their union, the NLRB and others
    • Was not limited to matters regarding past employment with the hospital
    • Was not limited in time
    • Failed to cabin its definition for “disparagement” to the narrow circumstances set out in NLRB v. Electrical Workers Local 1229 (Jefferson Standard Broadcasting Co.), 346 U.S. 464, 477 (1953).

    Whether the NLRB will permit any non-disparagement clauses remains to be seen. What is clear from the criticisms of McLaren Macomb’s vanilla version of non-disparagement is that any such clause that this NLRB will permit will be too limited to have value for most employers.

    THE FATE OF CONFIDENTIALITY PROVISIONS POST-McLAREN

    This confidentiality provision, like many others, prohibited the employee from disclosing the terms of the severance agreement “to any third person.” The NLRB took issue with the fact that the clause might be read to prohibit employees from discussing the terms of the severance agreement with their union or their coworkers.

    The NLRB also objected that the clause might be read to forbid an employee from going to the NLRB to file an unfair labor practice charge over either the layoff or the severance agreement. What the NLRB did not say, however, was that a carve-out for going to the NLRB would make this clause permissible. The NLRB, unfortunately, has never been a fan of providing safe harbors or bright lines. Realistically, broad confidentiality regarding the fact and amount of settlement will be effectively unattainable in most situations (pending appellate review of this decision).

    THE SILVER LINING: THE NLRA’S LIMITED DEFINITION OF EMPLOYEE

    Agreements with managers or supervisors are unaffected by McLaren Macomb.

    Supervisors are explicitly excluded from the definition of employee under the NLRA. (29 U.S.C. §152(3).) Managers are likewise excluded as a matter of legislative intent and policy by virtue of Supreme Court decisions. (NLRB v. Bell Aerospace Co., 416 U.S. 267, 267 (1974) (“[T]he purpose and legislative history of the [Act], the Board’s subsequent and consistent construction of the Act …, and the decisions of the courts of appeals all point unmistakably to the conclusion that ‘managerial employees’ are not covered by the Act.”).)

    WHAT’S NEXT?

    Employers should consider eliminating both non-disparagement clauses and clauses seeking broad confidentiality on the terms and amounts of the release payments with rank-and-file employees. Those clauses are seldom enforced and now create a downside risk of their own, including NLRB litigation and uncertainty as to enforceability.

    Employers who continue with such clauses should draft narrowly and add two safety valves: First, a severability clause is now essential so that the intended release is not lost if the agreement is challenged on McLaren Macomb grounds. Second, a carve-out (equivalent to those often found in federal age claim releases) to allow employees to contact the NLRB should be added.

    Lastly, many are left asking, “Can an employee who signed a release with clauses just like McLaren Macomb now turn around and sue under the Age Discrimination in Employment Act, Title VII or any other statutory or common law claim”? This will undoubtedly occur; let us know if you get tagged because our team has been there before.

    Christopher Foster | Marjorie Soto Garcia | Elvira Kras |  Julie McConnell | Stephania Sanon

    Authors

    Nicholas C. Meyer

    Associate

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • US Supreme Court Rules Highly Compensated Employee Is Not Exempt from Overtime

    US Supreme Court Rules Highly Compensated Employee Is Not Exempt from Overtime

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    US Supreme Court Rules Highly Compensated Employee Is Not Exempt from Overtime

    February 24, 2023

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On February 22, 2023, the US Supreme Court held in Helix Energy Solutions Group, Inc. v. Hewitt that an employee who was paid nearly $1,000 each day he worked was not exempt from the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) and therefore owed overtime for the work he did.

    In depth

    This case turned on an interpretation of the FLSA regulations, which exempt from the overtime requirement certain bona fide executive, administrative and professional employees. Specifically, the regulations provide that, to qualify for these “white collar” exemptions, the employees “must be compensated on a salary basis.” 29 C.F.R. § 541.600; see also 29 C.F.R. § 541.601(b)(1). Section 541.602(a), in turn, provides that “[a]n employee will be considered to be paid on a ‘salary basis’ . . . if the employee regularly receives each pay period on a weekly or less frequent basis, a predetermined amount constituting all or part of the employee’s compensation, which is not subject to reduction because of variations in the quality or quantity of work performed” and subject to certain exceptions, is paid in full “for any week in which the employee performs any work without regard to the number of days or hours worked.”

    The question presented to the Court was “whether a high-earning employee is compensated on a ‘salary basis’ when his paycheck is based solely on a daily rate.” Construing just Section 541.602(a), the Court held that, even though the employee made nearly $1,000 a day and received over $200,000 annually, the employee was not exempt from the FLSA’s overtime requirements because the employee did not receive a flat, fixed predetermined amount that was not dependent on days worked. The Court rejected the employer’s argument that a separate regulation—Section 541.601—that eliminates the need for an in-depth analysis of an employee’s work duties to satisfy exempt status for employees making over $107,432 eliminated the need to satisfy the “salary basis” test. This regulation, however, is still useful for highly compensated employees because it does make it easier to show the employee performed white-collar work.

    Notably, employees whose earnings are calculated on “an hourly, a daily or a shift basis” can still satisfy the “salary basis” test and be exempt if they are paid a minimum guaranteed weekly amount and “a reasonable relationship exists between the guaranteed amount and the amount actually earned.” 29 C.F.R. § 541.604(b). Because the employer in Helix conceded that Section 541.604(b) could not be met, the Majority did not analyze its applicability, including opining on what minimum guarantee is enough in relation to the employee’s total compensation. Justice Brett Kavanaugh’s dissent nevertheless highlights a US Department of Labor (USDOL) opinion letter (FLSA 2018-25, 2018) providing that a reasonable relationship exists when “at least two-thirds of their total compensation comes in form of a weekly guarantee.” In the context of a six-day work week, the day rate employee must therefore receive guaranteed pay equivalent to four days worked regardless of days actually worked.

    The Court also declined to address an argument raised for the first time on appeal that USDOL’s regulations requiring payment on a “salary basis” were inconsistent with the statutory exemption. Justice Kavanaugh endorsed this approach, writing that because the FLSA “focuses on whether the employee performs executive duties,” “it is questionable whether the Department’s regulations—which look not only at an employee’s duties but also at how much an employee is paid and how an employee is paid—will survive if and when the regulations are challenged as inconsistent with the Act.” Defense counsel should take note of this argument for future cases.

    Authors

    Joseph Mulherin

    Partner

    Chicago

    Barrick Bollman

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • Employment Law Updates

    Employment Law Updates

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Employment Law Updates

    February 24, 2023

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On Dec. 29, 2022, President Joe Biden signed an omnibus spending bill, which included the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (“PWFA”) and the Providing Urgent Maternal Protections for Nursing Mothers Act (“PUMP Act”). The measures expand protections for pregnant and nursing workers.

    The PWFA, which goes into effect on June 27, 2023, requires employers with 15 or more employees to make reasonable accommodations for a qualified employee affected by pregnancy, childbirth or related medical conditions, provided the accommodation would not impose an undue hardship on the employer. A “qualified employee” is an employee or applicant who, with or without reasonable accommodation, can perform the essential functions of their position.[1] The PWFA makes it unlawful for an employer to require a qualified employee to accept an accommodation other than any reasonable accommodation arrived at through an interactive process, or require a qualified employee to take paid or unpaid leave if another reasonable accommodation can be provided. Employers may not deny employment opportunities to, or take adverse action against, qualified employees on the basis of an employee needing, requesting or using a reasonable accommodation.

    The PUMP Act, which goes into effect April 28, 2023, expands existing employer obligations under the Fair Labor Standards Act to provide accommodations in the workplace for nursing employees. Employers in New York State and City are already subject to lactation accommodation laws, discussed in the following Alerts “End-of-Year Employment Law Developments” and “New York City Adopts Lactation Accommodation Law,” which afford nursing employees broad protections.

    The PUMP Act mandates that an employer shall provide (1) an employee with reasonable break times to express breast milk for the employee’s nursing child for one year after the child’s birth and (2) a place, other than a bathroom, that is shielded from view and free from intrusion from coworkers and the public, which may be used by an employee to express breast milk. The Act clarifies that while employees are not entitled to compensation if no work is being performed, the breaks will be considered “hours worked” subject to compensation if the employee is not completely relieved from duty for the entirety of each break. Employers with fewer than 50 employees may be exempt from complying if they can establish that doing so would impose an undue hardship by causing the employer significant difficulty or expense. Employees have a private right of action under the PUMP Act, though an employee alleging a violation of the Act’s lactation space requirement must notify their employer of the violation and allow the employer 10 days to remedy the situation before the employee may commence any action. Damages for violations of the PUMP Act include the payment of unpaid wages, reinstatement, back and front pay, and liquidated damages.

    New York State Poster Requirements

    All New York State employers with more than 50 full-time employees are now required to display the Veterans’ Benefits & Services poster in a conspicuous place accessible to employees in the workplace. Additionally, an amendment to New York State Labor Law Section 201, now mandates that employers make notices required to be physically posted at a worksite under federal and state law also be available digitally through the employer’s website or by email. The employer must also provide notice that documents required for physical posting are available electronically. Although the State law does not require posters required by local law, such as by New York City, be made available electronically, employers may do so.

    New York State Adds Citizenship and Immigration Status as Protected Characteristics

    The New York State Human Rights Law was amended to add citizenship and immigration status to the list of covered protected characteristics. Covered employers are now prohibited from discriminating, harassing or retaliating against any individual because of their citizenship or immigration status. The law defines “citizenship or immigration status” as “citizenship of any person or the immigration status of any person who is not a citizen of the United States.”

    Artificial Intelligence Tools Updates

    On Dec. 23, 2022, the New York City Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (“DCWP”) issued a notice with updated proposed rules to the Automated Employment Decision Tools (“AEDT”) law, previously discussed here. The proposed changes clarify certain standards for conducting bias audits, including requiring a separate calculation of “impact ratio” comparing AEDT’s impact on race, ethnicity and sex categories. The enforcement date for the proposed law was recently pushed back four months to begin on April 15, 2023.

    The federal Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (“EEOC”) has indicated that the agency will focus on targeting potential bias from artificial intelligence (“AI”) tools used by employers. While there is no current guidance on preventing AI bias for protected groups other than disability, it is expected that the EEOC and the Department of Justice will increase their focus on the use of AI in hiring and recruiting across all protected groups in the coming years.

    Authored by Mark E. Brossman, Ronald E. Richman, Martin L. Schmelkin, Max Garfield, Scott A. Gold, Donna K. Lazarus and Laura R. Horowitz.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] If an employee or applicant’s inability to perform such essential functions is temporary, the individual should still be considered “qualified,” so long as the essential function could be performed in the near future and the inability to perform the essential function can be reasonably accommodated.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2023 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

     

    In depth
    Authors

    Mark E. Brossman

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Ronald E. Richman

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Martin L. Schmelkin

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Max Garfield

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Donna K. Lazarus

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • The Secure Act 2.0 — Expansion of Retirement Security and Financial Well-Being Initiatives

    The Secure Act 2.0 — Expansion of Retirement Security and Financial Well-Being Initiatives

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    The Secure Act 2.0 — Expansion of Retirement Security and Financial Well-Being Initiatives

    February 24, 2023

    Read time: 14 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Securing a Strong Retirement Act of 2022 (“SECURE Act 2.0”), which became law as part of the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023, builds on the Setting Every Community Up for Retirement Enhancement Act (“SECURE Act”), enacted in December 2019. The SECURE Act 2.0 seeks to further improve workers’ long-term retirement security and financial well-being through numerous changes to workplace provided retirement and savings plans that are intended to (i) expand coverage and improve retirement savings; (ii) preserve income; and (iii) simplify and clarify retirement plan rules. From the 359 pages of the SECURE Act 2.0, we provide highlights of the key provisions impacting retirement plans and IRAs.

    1. Changes to Contribution Rules

    • “Savers” Match for Low-Income Earners. Prior to the SECURE Act 2.0, a participant who was age 18 or older and was neither claimed as a dependent nor a student, could take a tax-credit equal to 50 percent, 20 percent or 10 percent of the contribution made to a 401(k) plan or an IRA, provided that their adjusted gross income (“AGI”) was below certain income thresholds (e.g., a 50 percent credit if their AGI was not more than $43,500 for married filing jointly, $32,625 for head of household and $21,750 for all other filers). Beginning in 2027, the Secure Act 2.0 replaces the tax-credit with a matching contribution to be made by the Federal government into the employer’s plan for the employee. The contribution will be equal to 50 percent (or less, based on AGI) of the first $2,000 the employee contributed.

    2. Changes to Catch-Up Contributions

    • Option to Treat Student Loan Repayments as Elective Deferrals for Matching Contributions. Prior to the SECURE Act 2.0, an employee who did not make elective deferrals, Roth contributions or after-tax contributions, to a 401(k) or 403(b) plan, was ineligible for an employer matching contributions. For plan years beginning after Dec. 31, 2023, the SECURE Act 2.0 allows employers to treat an employee’s qualified student loan repayment as if it were an elective deferral for purposes of employer matching contributions. For an employer to make matching contributions in respect of an employee’s qualified student loan repayments, an employer may rely on an employees’ certification that such individual made the loan repayment.
    • Option for New Linked Emergency Savings Accounts. Beginning in 2024, the SECURE Act 2.0 permits retirement plans to offer linked “emergency savings accounts” that allow non-highly compensated employees to make Roth contributions in a separate account up to $2,500 (indexed for cost-of-living). Employees can take penalty-free withdrawals at least once per month. Employers may automatically enroll employees at a rate of up to 3% of compensation, and there is a fiduciary safe harbor for automatic enrollment.
    • Option to Treat Matching Contributions as Roth Contributions. Prior to the SECURE Act 2.0, matching contributions could be made only on a pre-tax basis. The SECURE Act 2.0 gives sponsors of 401(k), 403(b) and governmental 457(b) plans the immediate option to permit participants to receive matching contributions on a Roth basis, in which case such amounts will not be excluded from gross income (but generally will be tax-free when disbursed from the plan).
    • Higher Catch-Up Limits for Ages 60-63. Prior to the SECURE Act 2.0, employees who attained age 50 could make catch-up contributions to a 401(k), 403(b) Plan or similar plan (i.e., $7,500 in 2023). The SECURE Act 2.0 increases the catch-up contribution limit to the greater of $10,000 or 150 percent of the annual regular catch-up contribution dollar limit (i.e., $7,500 in 2023) for participants aged 60 through 63 in each tax year after 2024.
    • Indexing Catch-up Contribution Limit. Beginning in 2024, the regular catch-up contribution dollar limit for participants age 50 will be indexed for cost-of-living.
    • Certain Catch-Up Contributions Required to be Roth Contributions. Prior to the SECURE Act 2.0, catch-up contributions to a 401(k), 403(b) and 457(b) plans could be made on a pre-tax or Roth basis if the plan permitted such additional deferrals and permitted contributions to be made on a Roth after-tax basis. The SECURE Act 2.0 requires that participants, whose wages exceeded $145,000 (indexed) in the prior calendar year, make catch-up contributions as Roth after-tax contributions, effective for taxable years beginning after Dec. 31, 2023.
    • Catch-Up Contributions After 2024. Beginning in 2024, due to a drafting error, the ability to make pre-tax catch-up contributions was inadvertently eliminated. The Treasury Department acknowledged the technical error, and it is anticipated that it will be resolved in technical corrections.

    3.  Changes to Required Minimum Distributions

    • Required Beginning Date Further Delayed to Age 75. Prior to the SECURE Act 2.0, an individual was generally required to start withdrawing required minimum distributions (“RMD”) from a qualified plan, 457(b) plan, or IRA on the April 1 following the year in which the individual attained age 72 (which the SECURE Act raised from age 70½). The SECURE Act 2.0 again raises the RMD age to age 73 for individuals who attain age 72 after Dec. 31,2022, age 74 for individuals who attain age 73 after Dec. 31, 2029 and age 75 for individuals who attain age 74 after Dec. 31, 2032. Individuals who have already begun taking RMDs are not allowed to stop taking RMDs. These changes apply with respect to distributions required to be made after Dec. 31, 2022 for employees who attain age 72 after such date.
    • Elimination of RMDs from Roth 401k Plans. Prior to the SECURE Act 2.0, Roth IRAs were exempt from the requirement to take RMDs but Roth 401(k) Plans were not exempt. The SECURE Act 2.0 eliminates the RMD requirement for Roth 401(k)s beginning in 2024 (but does not apply to RMDs for calendar year 2023 that are permitted to be paid by April 1, 2024).
    • Reduced Excise Tax for Failure to take Required Minimum Distributions. Prior to the SECURE Act 2.0, if the amount distributed to an individual during a taxable year was less than the RMD, an excise tax of 50 percent of the shortfall was applicable. The SECURE Act 2.0 reduces the excise tax to 25 percent, and the excise tax is further reduced to 10 percent if the individual corrects the shortfall and files a tax return reflecting the excise tax during the correction window (which ends on the earliest of (1) the date of mailing a notice of deficiency with respect to the excise tax imposed, (2) the date on which the excise tax is assessed and (3) the last day of the second taxable year that begins after the end of the taxable year in which the excise tax is imposed).
    • Surviving Spouse Election to be Treated as IRA Owner. Prior to the SECURE Act 2.0, a surviving spouse of an individual with an IRA account who died before commencing RMDs could elect to be treated as the IRA owner for purposes of RMDs. Payments could be “stretched” over the surviving spouse’s lifetime and RMDs could be deferred until the time when the deceased spouse would otherwise have been required to commence RMDs had the spouse not died. The Secure Act 2.0 expands this rule to qualified retirement plans beginning in 2024.
    • Required Minimum Distribution Barriers Removed for Life Annuities. The SECURE Act 2.0 eliminates barriers that restricted 401(k) plans and other qualified retirement plans from offering lifetime income annuities as a retirement plan investment option. The purchase of commercial annuities with certain increases (such as annual percentage increases, dividend payments or accelerated payments) would satisfy RMD requirements.

    4. Expansion of Penalty Free Withdrawals

    Until the SECURE Act 2.0, a 10 percent penalty tax applied to distributions from a qualified retirement plan or IRA prior to age 59½ unless an exception applied. The SECURE Act 2.0 adds the following new exceptions, with varying effective dates, for penalty-free distributions to an individual who:

    • Has an “unforeseeable or immediate financial need” relating to necessary personal or family emergency expenses” of up to $1,000 (but in no event more than their vested benefit). Only one emergency personal expense distribution is permitted every three years, or one per year if the distribution is repaid within three years. The Plan may rely on the employee’s certification to the individual’s financial need.
    • Is a victim of domestic abuse (based on self-certification of physical, psychological, sexual, emotional or economic abuse by a spouse or domestic partner) and is in need of funds can withdraw the lesser of $10,000 (indexed for cost-of-living) or 50 percent of the individual’s vested benefit. The amount distributed can be repaid to the plan over a three-year period, in which case the income taxes paid will be refunded.
    • Needs funds due to a terminal illness. The amount distributed can be repaid to the plan.
    • Has completed 25 years of service.
    • Has a primary residence in a federally declared disaster area and who has sustained an economic loss as a result of such qualified disaster, up to a maximum of $22,000. The amount distributed can be repaid to the plan.
    • Pays premiums on certain types of long-term care insurance contracts, up to the lesser of (i) the amount paid for the employee or employee’s family member, or (ii) 10 percent of the employee’s vested benefit, but in no event more than $2,500 per year (indexed for cost-of-living).

    5. Mandatory Distributions

    • Increased Dollar Limit for Mandatory Distributions. Before the SECURE Act 2.0, a qualified retirement plan could transfer a former employee’s retirement benefit to an IRA without the employee’s consent provided that the value of the benefit was $5,000 or less at the time of the former employee’s termination of employment. The SECURE Act 2.0 increases the dollar limit for mandatory distributions from $5,000 to $7,000 with respect to distributions made after Dec. 31, 2023.
    • Automatic Portability Rules. Retirement plan service providers may transfer amounts that were previously distributed by an employer plan to a default IRA into the individual’s new employer’s plan to consolidate the employee’s accounts from their various employers, unless the participant elects otherwise.

    6. Automatic Enrollment Required for New Defined Contribution Plans

    Prior to the SECURE Act 2.0, automatic enrollment was an optional design feature that allowed plans the choice to have employees opt out, rather than opt into the plan. The SECURE Act 2.0 requires defined contribution plans that are newly established after Dec. 29, 2022 to automatically enroll all eligible employees at a salary deferral rate of at least three percent but no more than 10 percent of the employee’s pay. This deferral rate must increase annually by one percent to at least 10 percent, but no more than 15 percent, of the employee’s pay. Employees can affirmatively opt out of enrollment or elect a different salary deferral rate. Existing plans are grandfathered, and therefore, exempt from this requirement. These changes apply for new plans established after Dec. 31, 2024.

    7. Improving Coverage for Part-time Workers

    Prior to the SECURE Act 2.0, a 401(k) plan was required to permit part-time workers to begin to participate in the 401(k) plan after completing 500 hours during three consecutive 12-month periods. For plan years beginning after Dec. 31, 2024, the SECURE Act 2.0 shortens the eligibility period from three to two consecutive years in which the employee completes at least 500 hours. Each year that an employee has at least 500 hours will be treated as a year of vesting service. An employer is not, however, required to make employer contributions or matching contributions on behalf of such part-time workers. The SECURE Act 2.0 also extends these rules to 403(b) plans.

    8. Changes Only Applicable to Pension Plans

    • PBGC Variable Rate Premium Indexing. Prior to the SECURE Act 2.0, the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation (“PBGC”) imposed variable rate premiums for single employer defined benefit plans equal to a dollar amount for each $1,000 of unfunded vested benefits, which amount was adjusted for inflation. The SECURE Act 2.0 freezes the applicable dollar amount for calculating the variable rate premium at $52.00, ending future indexing of the premium rate.
    • Lump Sum Window Disclosures. Prior to the SECURE Act 2.0, plan sponsors were permitted to offer a lump sum option for a limited period as a cost-savings tool. The SECURE Act 2.0 requires a new notice and content to be provided to eligible participants at least 90 days prior to the commencement of the window, and notification to the PBGC 30 days prior to the commencement of the window. The PBGC and Department of Labor (“DOL”) must also be notified of the participants who accept the lump sum offer.
    • Cash Balance Plans Interest Credits. Prior to the SECURE Act 2.0, a cash balance plan could use a reasonable rate to project the accrued benefit to normal retirement age to satisfy anti- backloading requirements, which rate was permitted to be tied to a market index or the plan’s rate of return. The SECURE Act 2.0 allows plans to use any reasonable rate provided it does not exceed six percent.

    9. Changes Only Applicable to IRAs and Roth IRAs

    • Increases to IRA Catch-up Contribution Limit. Prior to the SECURE Act 2.0, the limit on IRA contributions had increased by $1,000 (which was not indexed for cost-of-living) for individuals who had reached age 50. The SECURE Act 2.0 indexes the IRA catch-up contribution limit beginning in 2024, effective for taxable years beginning after Dec. 31, 2023.
    • Rollovers Allowed from 529 Plans to Roth IRAs. Prior to the SECURE Act 2.0, amounts remaining in a taxpayer’s Section 529 Plan for Long-Term Qualified Tuition Programs were treated as taxable income upon withdrawal. The SECURE Act 2.0 allows taxpayers who have maintained a 529 Plan for 15 years to transfer the remainder to a Roth IRA by a direct trustee-to-trustee transfer for the benefit of the designated beneficiary, subject to the annual Roth contribution limit and an aggregate limit of $35,000. The transfers are tax and penalty free for distributions made after Dec. 31, 2023.
    • Simplification of Rollover Rules. To simplify, standardize and expedite the direct rollover process, the SECURE Act 2.0 requires the Treasury Secretary to develop sample forms, procedures and protocols for rollovers.
    • IRA Qualified Charitable Distribution Limit Indexed for Inflation. Prior to the SECURE Act 2.0, an IRA owner who reached age 70½ was permitted to direct a distribution of up to $100,000 per year to a charity. The SECURE Act 2.0 indexes the $100,000 limit for cost-of-living, beginning in 2024.
    • Qualified Charitable Distribution to Split-Interest Entity. The SECURE Act 2.0 allows an individual to make a one-time, $50,000 charitable distribution directly from an IRA to a split-interest trust, such as a charitable remainder trust, beginning Dec. 29, 2022.

    10. Changes Only Applicable to 403(b) and 457(b) Plans for Tax-Exempt Employers

    • Multiple Employer 403(b) Plans. Prior to the SECURE Act 2.0, unrelated employers were unable to adopt a “multiple employer” 403(b) Plan. Under the SECURE Act 2.0, unrelated non-profit employers may provide a single 403(b) plan for all of their employees starting in 2023.
    • Expanded Hardship Distributions. Prior to the SECURE Act 2.0, hardship withdrawals from 403(b) plans were limited to employee contributions, less earnings. The SECURE Act 2.0 expands the sources to include earnings, which is the same rule that applies for 401(k) plans, effective for 2024.
    • Extension of 457(b) Plan Amendment deadline for SECURE Act 1.0 RMD Rules. Tax-exempt employers were required to amend 457(b) plans to adopt the new RMD rules under SECURE Act 1.0 by Dec. 31, 2022. The SECURE Act 2.0 extends the deadline to Dec. 31, 2025, which is the date that applies to 401(k) plans.
    • Mandatory Participation of Part-Time Employees. As discussed earlier, employees who work 500 or more hours in two consecutive years must be permitted to make salary deferral contributions after Dec. 31, 2024.

    11. Simplification of Plan Administration

    • Expansion of Employee Plans Compliance Resolution System.
      • Recovery of Retirement Plan Overpayments. Prior to the SECURE Act 2.0, if a retiree was paid more money from a retirement plan than actually entitled, plan fiduciaries had a duty to recover the amount of the overpayment, plus interest, or make a contribution to the plan to make the plan “whole.” The SECURE Act 2.0 gives plan fiduciaries broader latitude not to recoup overpayments that were inadvertently made.
      • New Safe Harbor for Correction of Employee Elective Deferral Failures. Prior to the SECURE Act 2.0, the IRS required that errors in administering automatic enrollment and automatic escalation features or a failure to give an eligible employee the opportunity to make an election and receive a matching contribution, if applicable, be corrected by the employer making a non-elective contribution to the plan on behalf of the excluded employee. The SECURE Act 2.0 provides that an employer has no obligation to restore any missed elective deferrals provided that the errors are corrected within 9½ months after the end of the plan year during which the error occurred, and provided further that if there was also a missed matching contribution, the plan sponsor makes a corrective matching contribution allocation.
    • New National Retirement Savings Lost and Found System. The SECURE Act 2.0 mandates the DOL establish a national online database of lost retirement accounts. The database will enable retirement savers, who might have lost track of their benefits under a pension plan or 401(k) plan, to search for the contact information of their plan administrator.

    Call to Action

    Now is a good time to review your plan design and work with your attorney to determine which plan amendments are necessary and make conforming changes to your summary plan description and other employee communications.

    Authored by Mark E. Brossman, Ronald E. Richman, Ian L. Levin and Susan E. Bernstein.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2023 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Mark E. Brossman

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Ronald E. Richman

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Ian L. Levin

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Hospitals and Health Systems 2023 Outlook

    Hospitals and Health Systems 2023 Outlook

    ARTICLE / REPORT

    Hospitals and Health Systems 2023 Outlook

    February 2023

    Read time: 2 min

    Overview

    Historically viewed as recession-proof, 2023 is expected to be a challenging year for the healthcare industry as macroeconomic factors – inflation, high labor expenses, volatile markets, supply chain snarls and other issues – exert their influence in ways not previously seen.

    In addition, healthcare providers – including hospitals and health systems – must grapple with the end of the COVID-19 public health emergency (PHE), which will require unwinding the multi-layered changes that were put into effect during the PHE.

    This report examines key trends impacting hospitals and health systems in 2023, including:

    • Mega-mergers and FTC scrutiny
    • Dealing with distressed assets
    • Increased focus on value-based care
    • Pursuing investments and partnerships
    • Returning to pre-PHE operations
    In depth
    Tabs

    Charles R. Buck

    Partner

    Boston

    Kerrin B. Slattery

    Partner

    Chicago

    Ashley M. Fischer

    Partner

    Chicago

    Patrick F. Healy

    Partner

    Boston

    Travis Jackson

    Partner

    Los Angeles

    More insights
    Endnotes

  • Preparing for the End of the COVID-19 Emergency: Coverage of COVID-19 Testing

    Preparing for the End of the COVID-19 Emergency: Coverage of COVID-19 Testing

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Preparing for the End of the COVID-19 Emergency: Coverage of COVID-19 Testing

    February 23, 2023

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Our April 3, 2023, webinar explored the impacts that the end of the PHE and NE will have on employee benefit plans and what actions employers and benefit plan sponsors should be taking to prepare. Watch the “How Employers Should Prepare for the End of the Covid-19 National and Public Health Emergencies” webinar recording to learn more.


    The Biden administration has announced its intention to end the COVID-19 National Emergency (NE) and the COVID-19 Public Health Emergency (PHE) on May 11, 2023 (read our series introduction for more information). A key feature of the NE and the PHE was the government’s ability to provide access and coverage of COVID-19 tests. This resulted in overlapping legislation targeted at providing tests to benefit plan participants for free.

    This article explores COVID-19 testing after the end of the PHE and NE. The PHE is the important period to watch for COVID-19 testing coverage under employee benefit plans.

    In depth

    COVID-19 TESTING COVERAGE REQUIREMENTS

    Starting on March 18, 2020, the Families First Coronavirus Response Act (FFCRA) required all public and private insurance coverage, including self-funded plans, to cover COVID-19 tests and costs associated with diagnostic testing with no cost-sharing for the duration of the PHE. The Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act enacted shortly after expanded this requirement to cover out-of-network tests during the PHE. The Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2021 (CAA) then took a new approach and applied the requirement to over-the-counter (OTC) COVID-19 tests and added additional obligations. Under guidance issued by the US Departments of Labor, Health and Human Services, and Treasury, effective January 15, 2022, health plans were required to cover up to eight free OTC at-home tests per covered individual per month. Health plans could limit the reimbursement of these tests to the lesser of the actual or negotiated price or $12 per test. Health plans could also provide tests through participating network providers, such as pharmacies or retailers.

    When the PHE ends, health plans will no longer be required to cover COVID-19 tests, either diagnostic or OTC, or testing-related services with no cost-sharing.

    Action Items: Employers should consider whether they want to continue to cover COVID-19 tests as required by a doctor or OTC without cost sharing. There is no requirement to stop doing this after the PHE but doing so may have some implications on group health plans. Importantly, if an employer decides to continue covering testing at no cost, they should consider how this affects any employer-sponsored high-deductible health plan (HDHP). IRS Notice 2020-15 permitted HDHP coverage of COVID-19 testing with no cost-sharing without conflicting with HSA eligibility (see our article here). This relief continues until further guidance is issued. Though COVID-19 testing could be considered preventative care under Section 223 of the Internal Revenue Code, the US Department of Treasury will need to provide further clarification. Employers should also consider whether they want to continue to apply a $12 reimbursement cap on COVID-19 or some other limitation.

    After the PHE, employers who choose to continue to cover COVID-19 tests at no cost or apply a reimbursement cap may need to amend their plans or summary plan descriptions for these practices. They will also need to coordinate with any insurer or third-party administrator of the employer’s group health plan to ensure proper administration. Depending on the timing of these amendments, they may also need to provide a summary of material modifications to participants. Employers who decide not to continue coverage of COVID-19 tests or apply a reimbursement cap may need to amend their plans, depending on whether the changes announced were tied to the PHE. These employers may also be required to send a 60-day advance notice of a material reduction in benefits. Employers may also want to consider communications regarding the price of testing. Doing so may help to minimize claims under the plan and ensure that participants understand the benefits available to them.

    For any questions regarding the end of the PHE and/or NE, please contact your regular McDermott lawyer or one of the authors.

     

    Authors

    Jacob M. Mattinson

    Partner

    Chicago

    Sarah G. Raaii

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • How Employers Should Prepare for the End of the COVID-19 National and Public Health Emergencies

    How Employers Should Prepare for the End of the COVID-19 National and Public Health Emergencies

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    How Employers Should Prepare for the End of the COVID-19 National and Public Health Emergencies

    February 23, 2023

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Our April 3, 2023, webinar explored the impacts that the end of the PHE and NE will have on employee benefit plans and what actions employers and benefit plan sponsors should be taking to prepare. Watch the “How employers should prepare for the end of the COVID-19 national and public health emergencies” webinar recording for more information.


    On January 30, 2023, the Biden administration announced its intention to make final extensions of both the COVID-19 National Emergency (NE) and the COVID-19 Public Health Emergency (PHE) through May 11, 2023, at which point both will end. These emergency declarations have been in place for nearly three years and have enabled the government to modify certain coverage requirements by Medicare, Medicaid and private insurance plans, as well as benefits administration rules. The end of the PHE and NE may mean added costs for benefits plans and new questions regarding compliance.

    The differences between and impact of the PHE and NE are commonly misunderstood. While both are declared by different individuals, both are ultimately controlled by the current administration. The PHE and NE have different impacts on plan administration and benefit plan requirements.

    This series will explore the implications of the PHE and NE and what their impending end may mean for benefit plan sponsors. These articles will be released periodically before May 11.

    In depth

    PHE VERSUS NE

    The Secretary of the US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) first declared a public health emergency in January 2020 for the COVID-19 pandemic. This PHE has been routinely renewed in 90-day increments.

    Former President Trump first issued a national emergency declaration in March 2020. A national emergency declaration is in effect until it is terminated by the president or through a joint resolution by Congress.

    In response to these federal emergency declarations, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) and other government agencies have issued various forms of regulatory and other relief. Further, Congress has enacted legislative relief, including certain provisions in the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act and the Consolidated Appropriations Acts (CAA). Much of this relief is tied to the end of both the NE and the PHE.

    EMPLOYEE BENEFITS IMPACTED BY THE PHE AND NE

    There are several important benefit coverage and administration requirements connected to the PHE and/or NE that may remain the same, remain for a temporary period or may need to be discontinued upon the end of these federal emergencies. Over the course of the upcoming weeks, we will cover the key topics that may be triggered by the end of the PHE and/or NE, including:

    Note that the items covered above are not an exhaustive list of all legislative and regulatory changes that could affect employee benefit plans. This series is meant to keep employers informed about some of the most important upcoming changes and the impending decisions and disclosures that need to be made.

    For any questions regarding the end of the PHE and/or NE, please contact your regular McDermott lawyer or one of the authors.

    Authors

    Jacob M. Mattinson

    Partner

    Chicago

    Sarah G. Raaii

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • Message Received: US Courts Are Appropriate, More Convenient Venue to Adjudicate US IP Disputes

    Message Received: US Courts Are Appropriate, More Convenient Venue to Adjudicate US IP Disputes

    ARTICLE

    Message Received: US Courts Are Appropriate, More Convenient Venue to Adjudicate US IP Disputes

    Feb 23, 2023

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Addressing personal jurisdiction and forum non conveniens in a software licensing dispute, the US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit upheld a district court’s exercise of personal jurisdiction over a Dutch entity and the court’s decision to not dismiss the case for forum non conveniens. dmarcian, Inc. v. dmarcian Europe BV, Case Nos. 21-1721; -2005 (4th Cir. Feb. 14, 2023) (Wilkinson, Heytens, Hudson, JJ.)

    dmarcian is a North Carolina-based software company that developed software to help email users authenticate incoming emails. A Dutch businessman who owned Mailmerk contacted dmarcian to offer to market the software in Europe. While dmarcian was initially unreceptive to the offer, the two parties eventually reached an oral agreement for Mailmerk to rebrand as dmarcian Europe BV (dmarcian BV) and sell the dmarcian software in Europe and Africa.

    A dispute arose when dmarcian BV claimed ownership of portions of the dmarcian source code. dmarcian BV filed suit in the Netherlands, eventually filing for and winning injunctive relief in the Netherlands when dmarcian terminated dmarcian BV’s license. dmarcian then filed suit in the Western District of North Carolina asking for a preliminary injunction against dmarcian BV, which dmarcian BV opposed with a motion to dismiss for forum non conveniens. The district court denied the motion to dismiss and entered a preliminary injunction that precluded dmarcian BV from operating outside of Europe and Africa and required dmarcian BV to stop using the registered “dmarcian” trademark without a disclaimer. The district court later found dmarcian BV in contempt for violating the preliminary injunction and ordered dmarcian BV to pay $335,000 in sanctions. dmarcian BV appealed the injunction and the sanctions.

    dmarcian BV argued that the district court did not have personal jurisdiction. The Fourth Circuit rejected that argument, finding that the North Carolina long-arm statute authorized jurisdiction over dmarcian BV. The Court found that the application of the long-arm statute to dmarcian BV complied with due process because dmarcian BV worked closely with the dmarcian team in North Carolina (e.g., receiving sales leads, attending virtual meetings, coordinating software development), dmarcian BV sought out dmarcian to initiate business, and there was a strong interest in protecting intellectual property rights in North Carolina.

    The Fourth Circuit also upheld the denial of the dismissal for forum non conveniens because the Dutch court was not an adequate alternative forum since Dutch courts cannot effectively adjudicate US trademark claims. The Fourth Circuit found that any judgment by the Dutch court would have little effect in the United States and would deny relief to dmarcian for the infringement of its rights.

    The Fourth Circuit upheld the preliminary injunction grant, finding that the district court properly applied US and North Carolina law extraterritorially and that dmarcian was likely to succeed on all claims. The Court found that US laws properly applied and that dmarcian was likely to succeed on the following claims:

    • Copyright infringement, because there was a registered copyright, dmarcian BV reproduced elements of the source code outside of the licensing agreement, and dmarcian BV committed a domestic act by servicing US customers
    • Trademark infringement, because dmarcian owned a registered trademark, the two parties had virtually identical website designs and business services, and multiple customers confused the two entities
    • Trade secret misappropriation, because dmarcian’s source code, customer database and business accounts were likely trade secrets; dmarcian BV took the trade secrets to compete with dmarcian; and dmarcian BV used the trade secrets in foreign commerce
    • Tortious interference, because dmarcian BV poached a US dmarcian customer and because the licensing agreement would have continued if dmarcian BV did not intervene.

    Lastly, the Fourth Circuit addressed the contempt order and resulting sanctions. The Court found that the district court correctly found dmarcian BV in contempt for its failure to comply with the disclaimer requirement and remanded the sanctions order for recalculation.

    Authors

    Courtney Cecile Seams

    Associate

    Washington, DC

    More insights
    Endnotes

  • Real Estate Update: Changeover of the Consumer Price Index to the New Base Year 2020

    Real Estate Update: Changeover of the Consumer Price Index to the New Base Year 2020

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Real Estate Update: Changeover of the Consumer Price Index to the New Base Year 2020

    February 22, 2023

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Consumer Price Index for Germany (CPI) is both updated monthly in line with current price developments and, as a rule, subjected to a fundamental revision at five-year intervals and switched to a new base year.

    This changeover is intended to take account of changes in consumption and purchasing habits and to reflect new developments. Today (February 22, 2023) – with some delay due to technical problems – the final results for the reporting month January 2023 are published by the Federal Statistical Office. In this context, the previous base year 2015 will be changed to the new base year 2020. As a result, all indices will be recalculated as of the reporting month January 2020, which may lead to changes in inflation rates for the years 2020 to 2022.

    What does the changeover to the 2020 base year mean for landlords and tenants?

    • Publication on the new 2020 base will not affect any adjustments that have already been made.
    • Insofar as the value adjustment clause agreed in the lease is based on the percentage change in the CPI, the changeover of the base year does not result in any need for action. In the case of future adjustments of the rent, the index levels of the current base year can always be directly reckoned with, even if an earlier base year is stated in the lease. Therefore, the rental agreement does not have to be adjusted.
    • If, on the other hand, a so-called points clause has been agreed between the parties, which is based on the change in the CPI by a certain number of points, in order to be able to adjust the rent, it must be rebased to the new base year 2020, as the data is no longer available on the old basis. The parties must now either convert the points change to be achieved to the current base year or the index levels of the current base year to the originally agreed base year. Only then can it be checked whether the agreed point change has been achieved and thus whether an adjustment is due. Furthermore, in the case of the points adjustment, the change must be determined as a percentage in the second step so that the specific increase in the amount of money to be paid can be determined.
    In depth
    Authors

    Frank Müller

    Partner

    Frankfurt

    More insights

  • PPP Loan Appeals, SBA Clawbacks and More: What You Need to Know

    PPP Loan Appeals, SBA Clawbacks and More: What You Need to Know

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    PPP Loan Appeals, SBA Clawbacks and More: What You Need to Know

    February 21, 2023

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Last year, we published an article titled “What to Do if Your PPP Forgiveness Application Is Denied.” Today, we share some insights into the Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) and appeals process based on our representation of dozens of small businesses in appeals of adverse Small Business Administration (SBA) loan forgiveness decisions at the SBA’s Office of Hearings & Appeals (OHA).

    In depth

    1. Do not assume that the SBA has carefully reviewed documentation you provided or that SBA correctly applied its rules and guidance.

    Given that there were more than 11 million PPP loans issued in 2020 and 2021, it was inevitable that a substantial number of forgiveness applications would be denied based on borrower errors. It was also inevitable that the SBA would make errors when reviewing such an influx of loans and forgiveness applications. This plays out every day, as many of the SBA’s denial decisions are contrary to law, the SBA’s own rules and guidance, and even facts and documentation submitted to the SBA.

    For example, many borrowers have received denial decisions based on the SBA’s misapplication of the “single corporate group” rule that imposed an aggregate group limit of $20 million for first draw loans issued after April 30, 2020, and a limit of $4 million for second draw loans.

    In many other instances, the SBA has taken an aggressive position—in apparent contradiction of its own regulations—with its application of the ineligible businesses list in 13 CFR 120.110, including certain types of financial businesses.

    Additionally, the SBA will at times hang its hat on facts or documents from decades prior to the PPP to deem that businesses were affiliated, without considering the businesses’ changed circumstances and actual realities.

    Finally, the SBA has issued many denial decisions that seem to come out of nowhere for borrowers because of communication issues between the SBA and lenders. Borrowers in these situations are forced to go through the appeals process and effectively resubmit documents that the SBA should have already received or respond to old requests that borrowers never received from their lenders.

    In light of the above, borrowers should not simply accept the SBA’s denial decision if there is a chance it was made in error.

    2. After appeals are filed with OHA, SBA counsel is usually open to remedying SBA errors prior to a final decision from an OHA administrative law judge.

    SBA’s lawyers want to cooperate with borrowers during the appeals process. This usually means that the SBA’s counsel is receptive to requests from borrowers to have the SBA program office re-review the challenged denial in light of the arguments and information provided in the appeal. This re-review frequently (but not always) results in the SBA reversing the challenged denial decision prior to any finding from the OHA administrative law judge.

    3. If the SBA forgave your loan in 2020 or 2021, do not get too comfortable.

    Many PPP borrowers likely think that their PPP saga ended when the SBA forgave the loan. However, the SBA is showing no indication that it intends to move on from its reviews of PPP loans, including previously forgiven loans. With a six-year audit window from the time of forgiveness for loans over $150,000, the SBA has an extended period to review the loans. If the SBA issues your business a request for information, make sure to respond in a timely and thorough manner. Given the above, do not be surprised to see requests for completely irrelevant information or even information you already provided to the SBA.

    4. Government contractors should keep in mind the Defense Contract Audit Agency’s (DCAA’s) guidance on PPP loans.

    Along those same lines, borrowers that hold government contracts may see their PPP headaches continue for some time. Businesses that hold government contracts were eligible to receive PPP loans. However, in September 2021, the DCAA released a series of frequently asked questions (FAQs) that included a discussion of how the government will treat PPP loans awarded to government contractors. The FAQs provide that to “the extent that PPP credits are allocable to costs allowed under a contract, the Government should receive a credit or a reduction in billing for any PPP loans or loan payments that are forgiven.” Government contractors that believed they had finally finished navigating the PPP process when the SBA forgave their loans might face a later DCAA audit to determine whether they must credit the government with any of the forgiven amount.

    5. Forgiven PPP loans still carry potential M&A risks and considerations.

    SBA loan reviews of previously forgiven loans—even if the re-review does not ultimately result in a denial of loan forgiveness—will cause headaches and confusion for businesses (and the new owners of those businesses) that had their loans forgiven and subsequently underwent a change of ownership. The personnel who handled a company’s loan application, forgiveness application and correspondence with the lender may be long gone from the company. But the company must retain PPP records and comply with any future SBA reviews of the loan. If the SBA does end up determining that a previously forgiven loan should have been denied, there will be a scramble to figure out who must pay it back—and who should pay it back.

    6. The 30-day clock to file an appeal begins on the date the borrower actually receives the final loan review decision document, not the date listed on the final loan review decision.

    If the SBA elects to deny—in full or in part—a borrower’s forgiveness application, the SBA will send the borrower’s lender a final loan review decision. Lenders must then pass this decision along to the borrower within five business days. The SBA’s Final Rule on Borrower Appeals of Final SBA Loan Review Decisions Under the Paycheck Protection Program stipulates that a borrower has 30 calendar days after “receipt of the final SBA loan review decision” to appeal the SBA’s decision to the OHA. (See 13 CFR § 134.1202(a).) Accordingly, the 30-day clock begins to run from the date a borrower receives the decision from its lender, rather than from the date listed on the final loan review decision.

    The authors of this article have successfully represented dozens of small businesses in PPP appeals before the OHA. We have extensive experience advising clients on issues relating to affiliation rules, PPP loan eligibility, PPP loan forgiveness, mergers and acquisitions involving PPP loans and government investigations and audits. If you have any questions or need assistance regarding the denial of a PPP forgiveness application or any PPP-related issue, please contact the authors of this article or your regular McDermott lawyer.

    Authors

    Llewelyn M. Engel

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    More insights