Content Type: Article

  • Quarterly Sanctions Update | Q3 2024

    Quarterly Sanctions Update | Q3 2024

    ARTICLE / REPORT

    Quarterly Sanctions Update | Q3 2024

    October 8, 2024

    Read time: 11 min

    Overview

    Although the European Union and the United Kingdom did not introduce new sanctions against Russia over the summer, they extensively focused on the implementation of the existing measures and their enforcement. This week, however, a new package of sanctions aimed at tackling hybrid operations by the Russian government has been agreed upon, and is expected to be published in the coming weeks. In the same period, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) issued a number of landmark judgments clarifying certain aspects of the EU sanctions regime and has, in one instance, openly disagreed with the interpretation of the regime by the European Commission.

    Furthermore, in line with the overarching goal of EU sanctions against Russia, which is to support Ukraine, for the first time, the European Union has transferred profits from frozen assets of the Russian Central Bank to the European Peace Facility and the Ukraine Facility, which will used the monies in support of Ukraine’s military and reconstruction needs.

    Finally, acknowledging the current geopolitical situation in the Middle East, the European Union and United Kingdom continued to issue new sanctions against Hamas and Iran. The United Kingdom has also revoked certain licences allowing the sale of arms to the Israeli government.

    In this Quarterly Sanctions Update, our team summarizes the most recent changes introduced between July 2024 and September 2024.*

    In depth

    Russia Sanctions

    G7 Level

    • G7 Guidance: The G7 group published joint guidance for industry on preventing evasion of Russia sanctions. The guidance contains: (i) a list of items which pose a heightened risk of being diverted to Russia, (ii) updated red flag indicators of potential export control and/or sanctions evasion, (iii) best practices for industry to address red flags, and (iv) screening tools and resources to assist with due diligence. See the full text: “Preventing Russian Export Control and Sanctions Evasion: Updated Guidance for Industry.”

    European Union

    • New sanctions package: On October 8, 2014, the European Council agreed to establish a new sanctions regime aimed at tackling Russia’s hybrid operations on EU territory, expected to be released in the coming weeks. Interestingly, new sanctions will be published as a new regulation (separate to EU Regulations 833/2014 and 269/2014) which will target specific individuals or entities for their actions world-wide (noting that the existing regulations only cover Ukraine-related activity). As explained by the Council, the new sanctions package will focus on addressing a variety of hybrid threats, such as: (i) the undermining electoral processes and the functioning of democratic institutions, (ii) threats against and sabotage of economic activities, services of public interest or critical infrastructure, (iii) the use of coordinated disinformation, foreign information manipulation and interference (FIMI), as well as (iv) malicious cyber activities, the instrumentalization of migrants, and other destabilizing activities. See the article, “Russia: New Sanctions Framework Against Those Responsible for Destabilising Activities Against the EU and Its Member States,” for further details.
    • Updates to EU Best Practices: In July 2024, the EU Council updated the EU Best Practices for the effective implementation of restrictive measures against Russia, providing guidance on the criteria of “ownership” and “control”. Specifically:
      • The minimum threshold for assessing whether the “ownership” criterion is satisfied has been changed from holding “more than 50%” of an entity’s proprietary rights to “50% or more”, aligning the European Union with the US sanctions regime; and
      • A number of factors which should be taken into consideration when assessing the “control” criterion have been listed. These include: new “indicators” of potential red flags, including majority shareholdings by designated individuals, buyback options, share transfers just prior to designation, the use of front individuals and the involvement of trusts and shell companies.

      See the updated EU Best Practices.

    • Updates to Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ): A number of updates to the FAQ were published. Specifically:
      • “No re-export to Russia” clause: The European Commission provided further details on the rationale for, and the correct implementation of, the “no re-export to Russia” clause. The Commission has emphasized that exporters should not sell their products to any non-EU operator unwilling to incorporate a “no re-export to Russia” clause in contracts falling under the scope of Article 12g of EU Regulation 833/2014. For further details, see the FAQ.
      • Chemicals: The European Commission clarified that registrants owning the relevant data must refrain from entering into data sharing negotiations and granting letters of access to any potential registrants who are sanctioned by the European Union or are owned/controlled by a sanctioned person, as any such action would amount to “making economic resources available” to sanctioned persons which is prohibited under EU sanctions. Furthermore, the Commission confirmed that it is for the data communication platform to ensure compliance with the asset freeze obligations, taking into account business operations and existing agreements. For further details, see the FAQ.
    • New case law: The CJEU issued several judgments clarifying numerous provisions of EU sanctions.
      Specifically:

    • Enforcement: Enforcement efforts across all EU Member States has significantly increased. For example:
    • First Transfer of Profits from the Russian Central Bank’s Frozen Assets Sent to Ukraine: Following the imposition of EU sanctions on the Russian Central Banks, its financial reserves held at Euroclear in Belgium have been frozen, together with any net profits from such reserves. On May 21, 2024, EU Regulation 833/2014 has been amended to allow Euroclear to transfer these profits to the European Commission, and enabling the Commission to further transfer them to the European Peace Facility (in 90%) and the Ukraine Facility (10%), both established to support Ukraine’s military and reconstruction needs. On July 26, 2024, the European Commission made a first transfer under this regime sending EUR 1.5 billion to the European Peace Facility and the Ukraine Facility. Read the following article, “First transfer of €1.5 billion of proceeds from immobilised Russian assets made available in support of Ukraine today,” to learn more.

    United Kingdom

    • Office of Trade Sanctions Implementation (OTSI): On September 12, 2024, the UK government published the regulatory framework outlining the scope and powers of OTSI, the authority responsible for the implementation and enforcement of certain trade sanctions in the United Kingdom. OTSI will have the authority to impose monetary penalties on a ‘strict liability’ basis, and will be allowed to publicly disclose information about trade sanctions breaches. For further details, see the regulatory framework.
    • Updated guidance on ownership and control: The UK government clarified, amongst other things, that control can be established through ownership of more than 50% of shares, the right to appoint a majority of directors, or the ability to influence an entity’s operations. Read the updated guidance.
    • Changes to the legal advisory prohibition & revocation of the General Licence: On September 5, 2024, the United Kingdom modified the prohibition on legal advisory services set out in Regulation 54D of the Russia (Sanctions) (EU Exit) Regulations 2019 (“UK Russia Regulations”), expressly permitting legal advisory services related to compliance with all UK or non-UK sanctions, Russian countermeasures, and criminal legislation from any jurisdiction. As a result, the General Licence, which previously allowed said activity, became defunct, and was revoked on September 6, 2024. Read the article, “Notice to exporters 2024/21: update on Russia sanctions legal services and revocation of legal advisory services general trade licence.”
    • Changes to the business services prohibition in the context of Russian subsidiaries: From October 31, 2014, UK parent companies intending to provide professional and business services to their Russian subsidiaries will not be able to rely on an intra-group services licencing group, but will have to demonstrate that the services fall within the scope of any of the remaining exemptions (i.e., those covering humanitarian activity or divestments from Russia). Read the article, “NTE 2024/26: update on Russia sanctions licensing for intra-corporate services.”
    • Enforcement: The UK authorities have published the outcomes of their sanctions-related investigations. Specifically:
      • GBP 15 thousand penalty for breach of licence reporting obligations: On August 29, 2024, the UK Office of Financial Sanctions Implementation imposed a penalty against a UK company specialised in concierge services for breaching reporting requirements under the Gas and Electricity General Licence. Read the press release “Report of Penalty for Breach of Financial Sanctions.”
      • GBP 29 million penalty for sanctions compliance failings: On October 10, 2024, the UK Financial Conduct Authority imposed a penalty against a UK bank for failings in financial sanctions screening systems, calling the controls “shockingly lax”. Read the press release, “FCA fines Starling Bank £29m for failings in their financial crime systems and controls.”

    Other Sanctions

    • New sanctions against Iran: On September 10, 2024, Germany, France, the United Kingdom and others condemned Iran for allegedly supplying ballistic missiles to Russia for use in the war in Ukraine, and announced new sanctions targeting air transport, bilateral air services agreements, and Iran Air airlines.

    European Union

    • New sanctions against Hamas: The EU has sanctioned several persons and entities under sanctions against Hamas and the Palestinian Islamic Jihad introduced on January 19, 2024. For further details, see Decision (CFSP) 2024/385.

    United Kingdom

    • Restriction on the sale of arms to Israel: On September 2, 2024, the UK Foreign Secretary announced the suspension of 30 export licenses to Israel. These include components for fighter aircraft (F-16s), parts for Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs or drones), naval systems, and targeting equipment.

    *Trainee Marine Bahaderian also contributed to this update.

    Explore Further Insights


    • Vilnius Arbitration Day 2024: Partner, Raminta Dereskeviciute participated in the 2024 Vilnius Arbitration Days and had the opportunity to discuss sanctions and export control matters with fellow lawyers and regulators. A number of panels related to sanctions and export controls, specifically: ‘National Security in Investment and Commercial Arbitrations’, ‘Compensation of Damages to Investors Caused by Russia’s Military Action in Ukraine’, and ‘Sanctioned Parties and Awards: Cause for Concern?’ and ‘Are Energy and Infrastructure Disputed Forerunners of Turbulence?’.
    • Association of Certified Sanctions Specialists, Le French Chapter: Associate Michal Chajdukowski participated in the conference on ‘The Latest in Global Enforcement Trends’ in Paris and had the opportunity of discussing with officials from the US Office of Foreign Assets Control and the French Treasury and Customs.

    Recent sanctions-related posts on our Regulatory and International Trade Blog:

    Tabs

    Raminta Dereskeviciute

    Partner

    London – 22 Bishopsgate

    Sabine Naugès

    Partner

    Paris

    More insights
    Endnotes

     


  • Preparing for CIRCIA’S Reporting Requirements and Avoiding Its Harsh Penalties

    Preparing for CIRCIA’S Reporting Requirements and Avoiding Its Harsh Penalties

    ARTICLE / REPORT

    Preparing for CIRCIA’S Reporting Requirements and Avoiding Its Harsh Penalties

    October 7, 2024

    Read time: 3 min

    Overview

    The US Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) recently published a Notice for Proposed Rulemaking intended to supplement the Cybersecurity Incident Reporting for Critical Infrastructure Act (CIRCIA). The notice offers additional information on how CISA intends to implement CIRCIA, outlining how covered entities must report, and retain information on, substantial cyber incidents and ransom payments once CIRCIA’s reporting and retention requirements take effect in 2026. While CIRCIA is subject to further rulemaking before a final rule is published, the reporting and retention requirements outlined within the notice are the most sweeping to date, posing harsh penalties for noncompliance.

    The notice makes clear that the federal government intends to impose criminal and civil liability on individuals, including corporate employees reporting on behalf of a covered entity, who interfere with CISA’s ability to obtain accurate information. The information CISA asks of those entities is wide-ranging and includes a description of security defenses the entity had in place at the time of the incident. Penalties for providing false statements or representations include fines, imprisonment of up to five years, or – if the offense involves international or domestic terrorism – imprisonment of up to eight years. Further, in cases of noncompliance with a request for information (RFI) or a subpoena, CISA reserves the right to refer cases to the attorney general for civil actions or to pursue other punitive measures against the individuals involved, such as contempt of court, penalties, suspension, or disbarment.

    In depth
    Tabs

    Sagar K. Ravi

    Partner

    Washington, DC, New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    Katelyn N. Ringrose

    Associate

    Washington, DC

    More insights
    Endnotes

  • Reciprocal Jurisdiction Reinsurers: Where Are They Now?

    Reciprocal Jurisdiction Reinsurers: Where Are They Now?

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Reciprocal Jurisdiction Reinsurers: Where Are They Now?

    October 3, 2024

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In September 2017, the European Union and the United States executed a bilateral treaty called the US-EU Covered Agreement, which for the first time ever permitted US ceding insurers to receive 100% credit on their statutory financial statements for reinsurance purchased from EU reinsurers – without EU reinsurers having to post any collateral. Under the terms of the US-EU Covered Agreement and a copycat US-UK Covered Agreement after Brexit, US states had five years to amend their credit for reinsurance laws to recognize this new status, now known as reciprocal jurisdiction reinsurers. So, two years after the implementation deadline, what does the landscape look like?

    Today, every US state has implemented a version of the National Association of Insurance Commissioners’ (NAIC) new Credit for Reinsurance Model Regulation, permitting the recognition of reciprocal jurisdiction reinsurers. In addition to the EU and the UK, reinsurers domiciled in reciprocal jurisdictions, which include Japan, Bermuda, and Switzerland, can also apply for approval as reciprocal jurisdiction reinsurers, provided they possess at least $250 million in capital and surplus. Reciprocal jurisdiction reinsurers must select a so-called “lead state” to apply for their initial approval. Once approved by a lead state, the reinsurer can apply (if desired) to the NAIC’s Reinsurance Financial Analysis (E) Working Group (ReFAWG) for a “passport” so they can be recognized as a reciprocal jurisdiction reinsurer in other US states.

    More recently, the US Department of the Treasury finalized its “T-listing” rules to allow certified and reciprocal reinsurers to apply to be recognized. This new status is not available on a passport basis; it requires a separate application to the Treasury. The key advantage for non-US reinsurers to be listed by the Treasury is to provide credit for reinsurance for the US insurers/cedents currently listed by the Treasury. Financial analysts within the Treasury will not allow US insurers/cedents to take financial statement credit for liabilities ceded to non-US reinsurers unless the non-US reinsurer has applied for and received listing approval from the Treasury.

    To date, more than 90 reinsurers received approval by ReFAWG as reciprocal jurisdiction reinsurers and have “passported” into at least one state. Does this mean reinsurance collateral has gone the way of the dodo? As some reinsurers begin the process of winding down their multi-beneficiary reinsurance trusts while others contemplate not renewing their certified (reduced collateral) status, some might say it has. However, collateral still has a role to play for non-US reinsurers in the US reinsurance market, such as newly formed reinsurers, those not domiciled in a reciprocal jurisdiction, or those with less than the minimum $250 million capital and surplus, and, importantly, for securing “old” reinsurance liabilities. And of course, US cedents can still require collateral as a commercial matter. There is no denying that the advent of reciprocal jurisdiction reinsurers has changed the landscape of the US reinsurance market.

    In depth
    Authors

    Andrea T. Best

    Partner

    London – 22 Bishopsgate

    Thomas M. Dawson

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • HPE Europe 2024: Key Takeaways

    HPE Europe 2024: Key Takeaways

    ARTICLE

    HPE Europe 2024: Key Takeaways

    September 19, 2024

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On 19 September 2024, we were once again delighted to assemble hundreds of healthcare professionals, investors, and industry changemakers at The Langham  in London for our annual Healthcare Private Equity (HPE) Europe conference.

    Joined by keynote speaker the Right Honourable Rory Stewart OBE, we explored a wide range of hot topics in our community, including PE trends in life sciences and pharma, the future of medicine, and the current shape of the financial markets.

    The following is a summary of the themes that were front of mind for those present and will no doubt shape our deals and discussions over the months ahead. Should you wish to explore any of these with us further, please reach out to your usual McDermott Will & Emery contact.


    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • California Amends Key CCPA Definitions

    California Amends Key CCPA Definitions

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    California Amends Key CCPA Definitions

    October 2, 2024

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    California is set to amend the California Consumer Privacy Act of 2018 (CCPA) with two recent amendments that have been signed into law. Assembly Bill (AB 1008) and Senate Bill 1223 (SB 1223) aim to clarify how the law defines personal information and double down on the recent focus on biometric information among the states. The amendments carve out the scope of what is publicly available information and expand the breadth of the definition of sensitive personal information to include neural data.

    In depth

    SB 1223

    SB 1223 expands the CCPA’s definition of sensitive personal information to include neural data. The bill defines neural data to mean “information that is generated by measuring the activity of a consumer’s central or peripheral nervous system, and that is not inferred from nonneural information.” This expansion of the definition of sensitive personal information follows Colorado’s recent passage of HB 24-1058, which specifically expanded the safeguards for neural data. SB 1223 will require businesses that collect neural data to include proper disclosures in their privacy policies and respect a consumer’s right to limit the use of that data.

    AB 1008

    Assembly Bill 1008 includes two significant definitional updates to the CCPA. First, it clarifies that “personal information” can exist in various formats, including artificial intelligence (AI) systems that are capable of outputting personal information. Second, it makes clear that biometric information collected without a consumer’s knowledge can never be deemed “publicly available” and therefore not exempt from the definition of “personal information.”

    Key Takeaways

    • Companies that collect neural information must now consider that information “biometric” information under the CCPA, and they must comply with the CCPA rules related to sensitive personal information, such as providing consumers with the right to limit the use of their sensitive personal information.
    • Biometric information collected without a consumer’s knowledge cannot be considered “publicly available” and will not be exempt from the definition of “personal information.”
    • AI systems can contain and create personal information.

    Our cross-practice team continues to closely monitor global privacy and cybersecurity developments. To learn more, reach out to one of the authors or your regular McDermott lawyer to discuss the potential legal implications for your business.

    Authors

    Amy C. Pimentel

    Partner

    Boston

    David P. Saunders

    Partner

    Chicago

    Dalyn D. Dessaure

    Associate

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • ITFA Is Alive and Well: New York Advisory Opinion Reaffirms Sales Tax Exemption for Internet Access Services

    ITFA Is Alive and Well: New York Advisory Opinion Reaffirms Sales Tax Exemption for Internet Access Services

    ARTICLE

    ITFA Is Alive and Well: New York Advisory Opinion Reaffirms Sales Tax Exemption for Internet Access Services

    Oct 2, 2024

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In its latest Advisory Opinion, TSB-A-24(4)S (June 26, 2024), the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance (the Department) reaffirmed the broad protections offered by the Internet Tax Freedom Act (ITFA) against state and local taxation of internet access. The Petitioner, a New York-based business, sought clarity on whether its subscription to a secure hosted exchange service, which facilitates critical email functions without requiring internal IT infrastructure, would be subject to New York State sales tax.

    KEY FACTS AND BACKGROUND

    The Petitioner subscribes to a secure hosted exchange service from a provider located in Florida. This service offers comprehensive email management, including mobile device synchronization and Microsoft Exchange functionalities. The service includes (1) unlimited mailbox storage, (2) premium email security protection, (3) anti-virus protection, and (4) live phone support. The service relies on the Petitioner maintaining its own internet connection, with software licensing obligations dictated by agreements with third-party vendors.

    THE DEPARTMENT’S RULING

    After acknowledging that email service qualifies as taxable telephony or telegraphy service under New York Tax Law § 1105(b)(1), the Department concluded unequivocally that “[e]lectronic mail services are included in the ITFA definition of Internet access, regardless of whether such services are provided independently or packaged with Internet access” and are, therefore, not subject to New York State sales tax. This decision hinges on the protections established by ITFA, which precludes state and local governments from imposing taxes on Internet Access.

    ITFA: A CRITICAL SAFEGUARD AGAINST STATE TAXATION

    ITFA, enacted in 1998 and made permanent in 2016, has consistently served as a bulwark against state efforts to impose tax on Internet Access and multiple or discriminatory taxes on electronic commerce. See ITFA § 1101(a). Under ITFA’s Internet Access prong, services that enable users to access content, information, email, or other services offered over the internet are shielded from state and local sales taxes.[1] The Advisory Opinion underscores this federal protection, categorizing the Petitioner’s email services as an Internet access service, which is exempt from New York State sales tax under ITFA.

    REINFORCING ITFA’S PREEMPTIVE POWER: RECENT CASES

    This is not an isolated application of ITFA. ITFA has recently been at the center of significant legal challenges, reinforcing its importance in protecting digital services from state taxation. For example, in Petition of Verizon New York Inc., DTA No. 829240 (N.Y. Div. Tax App. May 4, 2023), an administrative law judge (ALJ) ruled that the gross receipts tax on transportation and transmission corporations could not be applied to revenues from asymmetric digital subscriber line and fiber broadband services because these services are federally preempted under ITFA as Internet Access. In rejecting the Department’s narrow interpretation of internet access services, which only included services provided to end-user consumers, the ALJ emphasized that US Congress intended ITFA’s prohibition on taxing Internet Access to be broad, using the definition from ITFA rather than state tax law.

    ITFA’S ONGOING RELEVANCE

    New York’s Advisory Opinion highlights the continued importance of ITFA in today’s digital economy. As businesses increasingly depend on internet-based services, ITFA helps keep these services free from state and local taxes.

    For businesses and tax professionals, it’s essential to stay up to date on how ITFA applies. This Advisory Opinion serves as an important affirmation that services facilitating internet access remain outside the reach of New York sales tax, thanks to ITFA’s broad protections.

    Authors

    Eric D. Carstens

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Jonathan C. Hague

    Associate

    Austin

    More insights
    Endnotes

    [1] Effective November 1, 2007, Congress expanded ITFA’s definition of Internet Access to include: “a homepage, electronic mail and instant messaging (including voice- and video-capable electronic mail and instant messaging), video clips, and personal electronic storage capacity, that are provided independently or not packaged with Internet access.” ITFA § 1105(5)(E).


  • Court Holds That False Claims Act’s Qui Tam Provision Is Unconstitutional

    Court Holds That False Claims Act’s Qui Tam Provision Is Unconstitutional

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Court Holds That False Claims Act’s Qui Tam Provision Is Unconstitutional

    October 1, 2024

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On September 30, 2024, the US District Court for the Middle District of Florida dismissed a False Claims Act (FCA) case on the grounds that the qui tam provision of the FCA is unconstitutional. This ruling will almost certainly be appealed to the US Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit and could reach the Supreme Court in the next year or two. If the decision is upheld, it would have extraordinary consequences for FCA enforcement, which is driven primarily by qui tam relator claims. At a minimum, this ruling has important litigation and strategic implications for anyone involved in qui tam litigation today or in the future.

    In depth

    The FCA allows private whistleblowers – called relators – to file and prosecute FCA cases. When the government declines to intervene and take over the case (which it frequently declines to do), relators can continue the case and represent the government on their own, through discovery, trial, and any appeals. If they win, relators can keep as much as a third of the recovery, plus attorney fees. As the district court noted, these self-appointed relators act with “great independence” and “unfettered discretion” to “decide whom to investigate, whom to charge in the complaint, which claims to pursue, and which legal theories to employ” in cases where the government declines to intervene.

    Over the last few decades, the volume of FCA whistleblower cases (i.e., qui tam cases) has increased dramatically due to expanded qui tam provisions designed to incentivize claims. But a recent decision from Judge Kathryn Kimball Mizelle of the US District Court for the Middle District of Florida threatens to upend the status quo, at least if it is upheld on appeal.

    The district court’s decision breaks new ground, but the issue is not new. A footnote in the Supreme Court’s 2000 opinion (by Justice Antonin Scalia) in Vermont Agency of Nat. Res. v. U.S. ex rel. Stevens, 529 U.S. 765, expressly reserved the question that Judge Mizelle analyzed, noting that “we express no view on the question whether qui tam suits violate Article II, in particular the Appointments Clause of § 2 and the ‘take Care’ Clause of § 3.” And, more recently, Justice Clarence Thomas’s dissent in United States, ex rel. Polansky v. Exec. Health Res., Inc., 599 U.S. 419 (2023), described in detail the argument why “Article II does not permit private relators to represent the United States’ interests in FCA suits,” while signaling that Justice Thomas is receptive to this position.

    We have been tracking the development of this issue for over a decade and have briefed it extensively on behalf of our clients before district courts, courts of appeal, and the Supreme Court in a certiorari petition for which the Court requested the government’s response on this question.

    The Ruling

    After almost five years of litigation, the defendants in Zafirov changed course and challenged the constitutionality of the qui tam provision. They raised two separate arguments: (1) that the qui tam provision violates the Take Care Clause and the Executive Vesting Clause of Article II because the FCA “den[ies] the President necessary removal authority and sufficient supervisory control over” a relator; and (2) that the qui tam provision violates the Appointments Clause because a relator is an officer of the United States but is not appointed under proper procedures (or at all). The court agreed with the second argument and dismissed the case on that ground, and accordingly determined that it did not need to reach the first argument.

    The defendants faced an initial hurdle: waiver. The relator argued that the defendants had missed their chance to raise this argument and waived the issue. The court disagreed. Although it found that it is possible to waive the issue (i.e., it is not about subject-matter jurisdiction), the court indicated that it would permit the defendants to raise the issue late given the trial schedule in the case. However, this close brush with waiver illustrates the importance for other defendants of raising this issue early and preserving their rights.

    Tracking the argument outlined in Justice Thomas’s Polansky dissent, Judge Mizelle (who clerked for Justice Thomas before taking the bench) found that an FCA relator satisfies both of the required prongs necessary to be considered an “officer” of the United States. First, the court found that relators possess and exercise “significant” civil enforcement authority on behalf of the government. Examining other similarly situated officials such as independent counsels, the court reasoned that relators’ powers are a “textbook” exercise of significant executive authority. Second, the court found that an FCA relator “occupies a continuing position established by law” which is analogous to other “temporary-yet-continuing” officers like bank receivers. Because relators are not appointed in a way permitted by the Constitution, the qui tam provision is unconstitutional.

    The court rejected the relator’s historical argument that qui tam actions date back to the nation’s founding and are thus part of the constitutional scheme. Instead, it held that notwithstanding historical practice, the plain text of the Constitution prohibits the FCA’s qui tam scheme.

    The court held that the only remedy is dismissal with prejudice as to the relator.

    Key Takeaways

    This is a district court ruling and is not binding precedent. However, Judge Mizelle’s opinion makes it far easier for other defendants to persuade other courts to follow the same path. Further, the relator in this case will almost certainly appeal to the Eleventh Circuit, and the government will likely intervene to defend the qui tam provisions of the FCA (as it did unsuccessfully in the district court).

    If the Eleventh Circuit agrees with Judge Mizelle’s analysis, declined qui tam cases will be dismissed across the Eleventh Circuit (and relators will likely hunt for other forums). Further, such a ruling would create a split from other circuits that have rejected constitutionality challenges (including the Second, Sixth, and Ninth Circuits), and it seems quite likely that the Supreme Court would take up the issue to resolve such a split and determine whether the law is constitutional.

    For now, this decision is another tool for defendants facing qui tams where the government has declined to intervene. Such defendants should – at a minimum – preserve the issue through an affirmative defense and give serious consideration to a motion to dismiss, a motion for judgment on the pleadings, or a summary judgment motion at the appropriate time.

    The most dramatic consequences will follow if the Eleventh Circuit and Supreme Court uphold this analysis and strike down the qui tam provision, which is certainly a possible outcome. In that event, the government would lose a key enforcement mechanism, as declining to intervene would result in the end of a case. These would be difficult problems to remedy with changes in law, so the government may face pressure to take more cases. Likewise, defendants might consider expanding their arguments to suggest that qui tam complaints are unconstitutional even before an intervention decision.

    In short, anyone with possible FCA exposure should track this issue carefully, and those with pending cases should immediately review their litigation strategy to account for this development.

    Authors

    Matthew L. Knowles

    Partner

    Boston

    Laura McLane

    Partner

    Boston

    Natasha L. Dobrott

    Partner

    Boston

    More insights

  • SEC Amends Schedule 13G Beneficial Ownership Reporting Deadlines

    SEC Amends Schedule 13G Beneficial Ownership Reporting Deadlines

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    SEC Amends Schedule 13G Beneficial Ownership Reporting Deadlines

    October 1, 2024

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On September 30, 2024, the revised Schedule 13G filing deadlines became effective. In this article, we provide an overview of the new regime and provide a comparison with the corresponding notification deadlines in the EU and UK.

    In depth

    On October 10, 2023, the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) adopted amendments to Sections 13(d) and 13(g) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (Securities Act), which, among other things, accelerate the filing deadlines for Schedules 13D and 13G. In announcing these changes, SEC Chairman Gary Gensler stated that the old reporting requirements did not reflect the current pace of information in the modern capital markets, and the changes to the Schedule 13D and 13G reporting rules would “reduce information asymmetries.” While the amendments and revised Schedule 13D deadline became effective 90 days after publication of the amendments in the Federal Register, compliance with the revised Schedule 13G filing deadlines will be required beginning September 30, 2024. Refer to our previous client alert on this topic for more background.

    Changes to Schedule 13D Filing Deadlines

    Sections 13(d) and 13(g) require persons or groups who own or acquire beneficial ownership of more than 5% of certain classes of “equity securities” registered under the Securities Act to file ownership reports with the SEC. Prior to September 30, 2024, a Schedule 13G report was generally required to be filed annually, within 45 days of the end of the calendar year in which the investor’s beneficial ownership exceeded 5% of a class of securities or, for certain passive investors, within 10 calendar days of the acquisition of more than 5% of a class of securities.

    As of September 30, 2024, the Schedule 13G filing deadlines will change as follows:

    • For certain qualified institutional investors filing under Rule 13d-1(b) (such as registered broker-dealers, registered investment advisers or registered investment companies) and exempt investors (investors filing under Rule 13d-1(d) because they own more than 5% but have not made an acquisition subject to Section 13(d), such as founders and other pre-initial public offering investors), the amendments have shortened the initial filing deadline from 45 calendar days after the calendar year-end to 45 calendar days after the end of the calendar quarter in which the investor beneficially acquired more than 5% of the covered class.
    • For passive investors (investors who own less than 20% and do not hold with the purpose or effect of changing or influencing control of the issuer) filing under Rule 13d-1(c), the amendments shorten the initial filing deadline from 10 calendar days to 5 business days.
    • The amendments require that an amendment be filed 45 calendar days after the calendar quarter in which a material change occurred rather than 45 calendar days after the calendar year in which any change occurred.
    • Upon exceeding 10% beneficial ownership of a covered class, the amendments require that (1) qualified institutional investors file an amendment within 5 business days after the end of the month in which they cross the 10% threshold and (2) passive investors file an amendment within 2 business days of acquiring more than 10%.
    • The amendments also extend the Electronic Data Gathering, Analysis and Retrieval (EDGAR) submission deadline for Schedule 13G filings to the SEC, adjusting it from 5:30 pm to 10:00 pm (ET).

    EU and UK Major Shareholding Notification Deadlines

    The equivalent requirements to Sections 13(d) and 13(g) in the EU and UK are the major shareholding notification rules of EU Directive 2004/109/EC (Transparency Directive), as implemented into national legislation of EU Member States and the UK (remaining applicable despite Brexit).

    Under the Transparency Directive, persons acquiring, or disposing of, shares of an issuer whose shares are admitted to trading on an EU-regulated stock exchange, must notify the issuer and the competent authority of the relevant EU Member State or, in the UK, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) if, as a result of the acquisition or disposal, their ownership would reach, exceed, or fall below, the thresholds of 5%, 10%, 15%, 20%, 25%, 30%, 50% or 75%.

    The Transparency Directive provides that the notification shall be made “promptly”, but no later than 4 trading days after the date on which the person learns of the acquisition or disposal. This period may, however, be further limited by national legislation of each EU Member State. Before Brexit, the UK utilized this possibility when implementing the Transparency Directive into the Disclosure Guidance and Transparency Rules sourcebook of the FCA Handbook. Specifically, while the FCA requires notification within 4 trading days in the case of non-UK issuers, this period is limited to 2 trading days for all other issuers.

    If you have any questions about the SEC’s amendments or the EU or UK rules, please reach out to the authors of this article or your regular McDermott lawyer.

    Authors

    Vlad Maly

    Partner

    London – 22 Bishopsgate

    Heidi J. Steele

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • On the Stand With Kevin Meek

    On the Stand With Kevin Meek

    ARTICLE

    On the Stand With Kevin Meek

    September 30, 2024

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Kevin Meek litigates patent disputes in federal courts across the country, before the US International Trade Commission, and in post-grant proceedings before the US Patent and Trademark Office. He has led dozens of trials involving a wide variety of advanced technologies, including consumer products, complex software, and semiconductor and telecommunications applications.

    In this Q&A, Kevin shares how his scientific background influenced his legal career, which trial victory he’s proudest of, and why accepting critiques are key to being a successful trial lawyer.

    In depth

    Why did you become a trial lawyer?

    I didn’t start out as a trial lawyer, and I didn’t even start my professional career intending to be a lawyer.

    I went to Texas A&M University for electrical engineering and planned to get my PhD, be a professor, and do advanced research on semiconductors. I worked in a lab with a very high-powered laser, which was the primary focus of my research. But then the company that owned the laser wanted it back, and there went my career plan. With my scientific background, it made sense to be a patent lawyer.

    Scientific fluency is the defining characteristic of a patent practice. Patent lawyers are technology teachers with law degrees. As I got more experienced, I started working on more trials through my litigation docket. My job is to take something that’s on the cutting edge of technology (computers, cell phones, airplanes, etc.) and distill it in a way that the jury can understand and use to draw the right conclusion. To present highly technical subject matter to that audience, I must understand it to begin with. My technology subject matter knowledge is largely what defines my value as a lawyer.

    How do you prepare for each day when you’re at trial?

    Everyone on the team has the same job, which is to focus on their assigned role. I’m the old guy on the trial, so I’m going to open, close, take the corporate witness, and cross the opposing side’s corporate witness. That’s my role, and I put all my focus on that.

    When I’m preparing for an opening, I grab a few people, and I run my opening argument over and over again in front of them. And they critique it so that it gets better and better. When I stand up in front of the jury on that first day of trial, it’s my 20th time giving the oral argument.

    What is the proudest moment of your career to date?

    My team won a $278 million jury verdict on behalf of Bell Helicopter in a trial against a Chinese drone manufacturer. I’ve been in trials where we win and I’m sitting there thinking, “How did we win?” But in this trial, we were so far ahead from the beginning and ready for every single thing that happened. The team was ready to go.

    That’s the most fun – when you know there isn’t a better team on the planet that could have handled it better. We got the best people to do the best job. If we had lost, I wouldn’t have been happy about it, but I would have also known that nobody could have won it.

    What advice do you have for junior lawyers who are thinking about going into trial law or are about to go into their first trial?

    If you’re thinking about going into trial law, you need to seek out public speaking opportunities. You can do this through community organizations, internal practice group meetings, continuing legal education (CLE) courses – anything that puts you in front of an audience.

    And you need to have someone watching you and telling you how you screwed up. You need to acknowledge that you’re not going to be very good at it right away. If you do think you are going to be good at it right away, you’re not going to be a very good lawyer. You can be confident, but don’t be cocky.

    If you’re going into your first trial, organization and preparation are key. Know your role on the team, know where your documents are, know who the witnesses are. When you’re arguing a motion, you should know the question the judge is going to ask before he or she asks it.

    You need to understand that “I don’t know,” isn’t acceptable to say during a trial. Know your role and know your stuff.

    If you could try any case, what would it be?

    The Scopes Monkey Trial. And I’d be on the side of the monkey (evolution). That would have been fun.

    Authors
    More insights

  • Panoramic: Product Recall 2025

    Panoramic: Product Recall 2025

    ARTICLE

    Panoramic: Product Recall 2025

    October 2024

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Dr. Boris Uphoff and Bianca Zagatta outline the main legal and practical considerations regarding product recall requirements in Germany in “Panoramic: Product Recall 2025 ”, published in Lexology.

    In depth
    Authors

    Dr. Boris Uphoff

    Partner

    Munich, Düsseldorf

    More insights