Content Type: Article

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 40

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 40

    May, 2007

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In Depth

    Hot Topics

    Repackaging and parallel import of pharmaceutical products

    On 27 April 2007, the European Court of Justice handed down yet another decision in the case of Boehringer Ingelheim & others v Swingward Ltd and Dowelhurst Ltd, Case C-348/04 (“Boehringer II”). Simone Blakeney, an associate in our London office, outlines the decision.

    Copyright & Technology

    The House of Lords’ OK to damages against Hello

    The House of Lords has decided in favour of OK! magazine in Douglas v Hello [2007] UKHL 21, overruling of the Court of Appeal’s decision and upholding the High Court’s decision which ordered Hello to pay £1million in damages for breach of confidentiality.

    Threats against an allegedly dormant company

    The High Court faced a problem when it was suggested that alleged infringements of Microsoft’s copyright and trade marks, and passing off took place when the first defendant company was dormant. The court did not accept an application for summary judgment seeking relief against Microsoft for making a groundless threat to sue a dormant company for trade mark infringement.

    Patents

    Liability for infringing a patent that never existed

    On 25 April 2007,the Court of Appeal decided that a defendant who had been successfully sued for infringement of a patent, which the Court found to be valid, could not delay the inquiry as to damages, notwithstanding that the European Patent Office (“EPO”) had yet to rule in revocation proceedings on the validity of the same patent.

    Trademarks & Domain Names

    Celltech: What’s in a name?

    In the case of Office for Harmonisation in the Internal Market v Celltech R&D Ltd., the European Court of Justice held that just because a sign is a combination of two terms, it does not in itself becomes unregistrable though it may describe the goods and services that can fall within the field earmarked by the sign. It has to be shown that the relevant public would make a definite and direct association between the goods and services and the meaning of the mark before it can be rejected for being descriptive.

    ECJ enjoys drinking “Champagnebier”

    The European Court of Justice ruled in De Landtsheer Emmanuel SA v Comité Interprofessionnel du Vin de Champagne, Veuve Clicquot Ponsardin SA providing extensive guidance on comparative advertising under EC Directive 84/450, including a perspective on comparative advertising of products or services protected by designations of geographical origin.

    Entertainment

    High Court clears gamble over Gambling Commission’s implied powers.

    Leicester Gaming Club Limited v The Gambling Commission was an application to the High Court Queen’s Bench Division for judicial review of a decision by the Commission when it refused to amend or re-issue a certificate of consent issued to the claimant under the Licensing Act 1968. Under the Act and its Schedule, an application for a casino licence has to be made to a licensing authority. However, prior to the making of the application for a casino licence, the intending applicant must obtain a certificate of consent to make an application from the Commission.

    Privacy

    Public recognition of the right to a private life: two effective implementations of the European Convention of Human Rights

    In Copland v UK, the European Court of Human Rights recently held that pursuant to Article 8 of the European Convention of Human Rights, the Government has a duty to respect a person’s email correspondence, and that the interference in question was not justified as no national law existed at the relevant time which permitted such actions by a public authority towards an employee. In the UK, in Ash v McKennitt, the House of Lords rejected a request to rehear a case in which the Court of Appeal had established that it constituted a tort of breach of confidence to write about the private life of an individual in a book.

    Commercial information, the press and privacy: Lord Browne of Madingley

    The claimant, the CEO of British Petroleum, sought to restrain the defendant from publishing, in the Mail on Sunday, any details of the relationship between the claimant and his former partner, and any confidential or private information that his partner had obtained in the course of their relationship on the ground that they were matters in respect of which the claimant had a ‘reasonable expectation of privacy’.

    Boehringer Ingelheim Ltd v Vetplus Ltd

    Boehringer Ingelheim has succeeded in obtaining an ex parte interim injunction to prevent the publication by Vetplus of scientific results relating to a Boehringer product.

    E-Commerce

    The new Rome II Regulation and its implications for e-commerce

    The European institutions are currently discussing the Draft Regulation on the Law Applicable to Non-contractual Obligations (Rome II) which attempts to harmonise the relevant rules on the law applicable to non-contractual liability.

    News

    • UK Intellectual Property Office Reviews 2006
    • European Commission plans after European Patent Litigation Agreement
    • Enforcement Directive: approval for tougher sanctions against counterfeiters

    Legislation

    • Trading Standard Officers to act against piracy and counterfeiting goods
    • Copyright in works of the National Assembly for Wales
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 39

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 39

    April 30, 2007

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In Depth

    Hot Topics

    Pot Luck – the difficulty of proving copyright infringement in computer programs

    On 14 March 2007, the Court of Appeal in, Nova Productions Ltd v Mazooma Games Ltd [2007] EWCA Civ 219, upheld the decision of Mr Justice Kitchin dismissing claims of copyright infringement in the software and graphics for a pool based video game, Pocket Money. Rohan Massey, an associate in our London office, outlines the decision.

    Fortress Europe and exhaustion of rights – Mastercigars Direct Limited v Hunters & Frankau Limited & ors

    For the first time since the European Court of Justice set out its strict requirements for consent to parallel importing from outside the EU in its 2001 decision in Davidoff, the English Court of Appeal has ruled that a trade mark owner did give implicit unequivocal consent to the parallel import of its goods into the UK from Cuba. In the article below, Duncan Curley and Shona Harper, from our London Office, examine the facts and reasoning behind this important decision for both trade mark owners and parallel importers alike.

    Copyright & Technology

    WOW – Online CD retailer was caught by test purchases

    The High Court found that the Hong Kong-based online music retailer CD-Wow was in substantial breach of a 2004 court agreement whereby the company had undertaken to cease importing and selling albums in the UK through its website, in particular albums which had not yet entered the European Economic Area. The court rejected the defence that these “alleged” breaches were just human errors.

    The Da Vinci Code and dichotomy of copyright

    The Court of Appeal upheld the High Court’s decision in The Da Vinci Code case confirming the fundamental idea-expression dichotomy within copyright law in the context of non-literal copying. The Court also refused to allow monopolisation of materials of historical research or knowledge which may prevent legitimate use of such material

    English Court of Appeal Narrows the Meaning of ‘Processing’ in the Context of the Data Protection Act 1998

    On 28 March 2007, the English Court of Appeal handed down a far-reaching decision significantly narrowing the meaning of data processing. The majority of the Court of Appeal found that the processing complained of was the manual selection of data, which was done by a human being and not a computer and hence, that it fell outside the scope of the Data Protection Act 1998.

    Patents

    Let me patent my algorithms!

    On 13 March 2007, the High Court of Justice handed down a decision in a case concerning two appeals lodged by Mr Pablo Cappellini and Bloomberg LP against the refusal by the Comptroller-General of their patent applications. This is another case concerning the patentability of inventions that fall within the realm of methods for performing mental acts, doing business or programs for computers as such.

    Owning Duties in Derivatives

    On 15 March 2007, the Court of Appeal in Liffe Administration and Management v Pinkava [2007] EWCA handed down further useful guidance on the interpretation of patent ownership rules contained the Patents Act 1977.

    Trademarks & Domain Names

    Microsoft and Motorola: Being Proactive is the way forward in cybersquatting

    Microsoft recently made an announcement that it would expand its global effort to combat cybersquatting through a number of lawsuits around the world. In contrast, Motorola, another major trade mark owner, has just lost the dispute for motorazr.com at World Intellectual Property Organisation Dispute Resolution Centre. These two incidents highlight the importance of managing a trade mark portfolio in sync with a company’s domain name strategy.

    WWW.WHO-IS-DIDDY.COM

    On 28 February 2007, in Richard Dearlove v Sean Combs, the English High Court gave useful guidance on whether the use of a mark on the internet can constitute use of that mark in a particular territory.

    European Court of Justice ignores time limits for “essential facts”

    The European Court of Justice gave an important decision stating that the Board of Appeal of Office of Harmonisation for the Internal Market has a discretion to admit submissions of new facts and evidence, which have not previously been submitted to the opposition division. The Court emphasised the need to use this discretionary power in a positive manner.

    Sports & Entertainment

    Lonsdale brand owners’ hands tied by acceptance of royalties

    On 8 March 2007, the English High Court, in Leofelis SA and Leeside SA vLonsdale Sports Ltd, Trade Mark Licensing Company Limited and Sports World International Limited, held that intellectual property licensing is a contractual matter. As such, principles and cases which are relevant in other types of contractual licensing, like landlord and tenant, may be relevant in intellectual property licences, despite the different types of relationships involved.

    Italian gambling provisions at odds with rules of the EC Treaty: ECJ raises the chances of liberalisation

    A decision by the European Court of Justice reaffirms that provisions of national law laying down the limit for a company to engage in gambling activities must respect Articles 43 and 49 of the EC Treaty and the principle of proportionality. It is for the Italian national court to ascertain, in the specific circumstances, the compatibility of national rules in Italy with the standard set by the ECJ.

    Procedure & Cross-Border Measures

    PCT applications in UK: when late declarations on priority can be accepted?

    Mr Justice Lewison in the case of In the matter of Abaco Machines (Australasia) PTY LTD’s Application [2007] EWHC 247 (Pat), has held that where a request for extension of time under s 5 of the Patents Act 1977, relates to PCT applications, it can only be considered in the cases where the PCT application has actually been filed and entered into the national phase. It can not apply to a PCT application per se that is still under the international phase.

    TaiwanUnder CD-R Scrutiny

    A Taiwan based CD-R manufacturer obtained a compulsory licence for essential CD-R technology owned by Philips, which lead to Philips’ patent rights and licensing strategy being undermined, Phillips therefore asked the European Commission to take action under the TRIPs Agreement.

    News

    • IViR study on the implementation of the InfoSoc Directive
    • Public consultation on WIPO
    • Broadcasting Treaty New Patents Rules under Consideration
    • Re-christening of UK Patent Office

    Legislative News

    • Family entertainment gaming machine – permit fees
    • Prize gaming – permit fees
    • Minor amendments to the Patent Rules
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 38

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 38

    March, 2007

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In Depth

    Hot Topics

    Apple of the industry’s eye? Steve Jobs’ address on the DRM dilemma

    Apple Inc. CEO, Steve Jobs’ open letter entitled ‘Thoughts on Music’ suggesting that record labels should sell songs online, unencumbered by Digital Rights Management (DRM), caused quite a stir within the music industry and consumer groups in Europe and USA. This letter presents potential economic/legal implications for the entertainers and the entertained.

    Copyright & Technology

    When exceptions confirm the rule: Google’s use of cached news items infringes copyright

    In Google Inc v Copiepresse (No. 06/10.928/C – Tribunal de premiere instance de Bruxelles), the Belgian court confirmed an injunction preventing Google from including newspaper extracts on its services, on the ground that the unauthorised use of the material did not to benefit from the copyright exceptions.

    Upsetting the court could upset the other party too

    Breach of undertakings to the court given as part of copyright infringement settlement was held to be a breach of contract. Thus, a claim based on breach of contract is allowed as an alternative to contempt of court.

    Patents

    Is BlackBerry safe now?

    On 7 February 2007, the English Court of Appeal handed down a decision in the case Inpro Licensing S.A.R.L. v Research In Motion UK Limited (RIM) and T-Mobile (UK) Limited  which concerned an appeal lodged by Inpro against a decision declaring its patent invalid for obviousness. It had previously been held that RIM’s “BlackBerry” computer system was “infringing” as its features fell within certain of Inpro’s patent claims which were allowable in principle.

    Trademarks & Domain Names

    OHIM got a lesson from playing Pointy Guitar

    During the evaluation of the application, a trade mark applicant has an absolute right to be informed at every stage by the Office for Harmonisation of the Internal Market (OHIM) of the grounds which can affect their rights including an appropriate opportunity to present their case in response thereof. In Kustom Musical Amplification, Inc. v Office for Harmonisation in the Internal Market (Trade Marks and Designs) (OHIM), Case No. T-317/05, the Court of First Instance (Third Chamber) ruled that OHIM failed to fulfil this obligation when it merely provided internet links of the material without forwarding the hard copies to the applicant.

    Naming Pharmaceutical Products: Be More Careful

    On 13 February 2007, in Mundipharma AG v OHIM-Altana Pharma (Case T-256/04), the Court of First Instance clarified the assessment of likelihood of confusion in the dispute between the Community Trade Mark application of RESPICORT for goods in Class 5 against an application of RESPICUR for “ therapeutic preparation for respiratory illness” in the same class. The core implication of the case is that the CFI will be very cautious in dealing with pharmaceutical marks so as to prevent the possibility of incorrect prescriptions from health care professionals and to increase the safety of patients.

    The Kitchen Company in search of the successful recipe

    On 15 February 2007, the European Court of Justice gave its preliminary ruling in BVBA Management, Training en Consultancy v Benelux-Merkenbureau, defending the right of the Member States to regulate trade mark procedural matters at their discretion.

    Confidentiality and Data Protection

    Post-employment non-compete clauses: Are you protecting yourself?

    Incorporating post-employment non-compete clauses into employment contracts is a necessity for employers today. Their importance arises from the potential harm employers can suffer if the confidential information relating to their businesses, products or services is either shared with a competitor through the recruitment of an ex-employee, or is used by the ex-employee himself. Given this background, the case of Huw John Phillip Thomas v Farr PLC [2007] EWCA Civ 118, discusses two main issues: the confidential information that can be subjected to a post-employment non-compete clause, and the reasonable time period during which such an obligation can be enforced.

    Business Creativity: Copyright in Trade Disputes

    The High Court handed down its decision recently in Cembrtt Blunn Ltd v Apex Roofing Services LLP & anor [2007] EWHC 111 (05.02.07) on a claim for copyright infringement and breach of confidence, made as part of a claim over faulty roofing tiles, which highlights the effective use of copyright and trade secrets law against opponents in trade disputes.

    Data security-fined for failure

    The decision of Financial Services Authority to impose a financial penalty on Nationwide Building Society to the tune of about £1 million comes as wake-up call for all the regulated financial services companies dealing with customer data, who should be highly cautious in the handling of data.

    Injunctions and Piracy

    Potter prevents piracy

    The legendary author, J. K. Rowling is suing the online auction hosting service eBay, at the Delhi High Court in India, for the alleged piracy of her work ‘Harry Potter’. This action was brought by Rowling and Warner Bros (the studio responsible for the Harry Potter films) after the listing of the Harry Potter books for auction sale on ‘Baazee.com’, the previous Indian version of eBay.com.

    News

    • Proposed Patent Litigation Agreement is Illegal – European Parliament
    • Gambling Act Consultation on Casino Premises Licences
    • Consumer Protection Green Paper and Consultation

    Legislative News

    • Licensing Scheme for Educational Recording of Broadcasts
    • Copyright and Performances – application of protection to other countries
    • Council Regulation on international non-proprietary names (INN)
    • The Patents (Convention Countries) Order 2007 & The Designs (Convention Countries) Order 2007
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 37

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 37

    February, 2007

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In Depth

    Hot Topics

    Weighing up the Gowers Review

    On 2 December 2005, the Chancellor, Gordon Brown, announced as part of his pre-Budget Review package that he Andrew Gowers, former editor of the Financial Times, would head a review of the UK’s intellectual property framework. The backdrop to the Gowers Review was the UK Government’s recognition of the increasing importance of knowledge-based industries in the global economy, especially in manufacturing, science and the creative industries. Duncan Curley, a Partner in our London Office outlines the Gowers Review.

    ‘Horses for courses’: Should competition law shape IP rights?

    In Attheraces Ltd and another v The British Horseracing Board and another [2007] EWCA Civ 38, the appeal by the British Horseracing Board was allowed in the context of a dispute over whether pricing policies adopted by the Board for the use of pre-race information by stakeholders of the betting industry were excessive. In overturning the trial judge’s approach, the Court of Appeal provided guidance on the tests to be used when assessing the economic value of a product supplied in a downstream market.

    Prince, privacy, press and public interest

    Should the right of the press to freedom of expression override an individual’s right to privacy? And if that individual is a member of royalty, does public interest dictate protecting his privacy or satisfying our curiosity? The discussion of the UK Court of Appeal in Associated Newspapers Ltd v HRH Prince of Wales [2006] EWCA Civ. 1776 highlights the emerging problem between protecting the privacy of a public figure vis-à-vis freedom of expression and the public interest, and the balance that is required to be achieved between these two rights.

    Copyright & Technology

    Music copyright in 40 year old organ solo: Who owns this golden oldie?

    In December 2006, the High Court, in the case of Matthew Fisher v Gary Brooker and Onward Music Ltd [2006] EWHC 3239 (Ch), had to address some difficult issues in respect of the authorship and ownership of music copyright in an arrangement of A Whiter Shade of Pale – a successful song from the 1960’s.

    Patents

    Inconsistent interpretations of patents between different European jurisidctions: Angiotech v Conor Medsystem

    In the case of Angiotech v Conor Medsystem [2007] EWCA Civ 5, the only difference between the patent and prior art was the fact that the patentee had named one specific drug along with many others, without disclosing why it was better or different than the others. According to Court of Appeal, this will not entitle him to claim an invention, as merely naming one more drug does not involve making a further valuable contribution to the existing human knowledge. Howveer, the same patent had previously been held partially valid by the Dutch District Court in an earlier case.

    UKPatent Office’s Consultation Report: has it re-invented the “inventive step”?

    The UK Patent Office has just released the findings of its consultation relating to the assessment of the inventive step requirement in United Kingdom patent law and practice. There have been calls in the past for a change in the approach of the UK Patent Office in relation to how it applied the inventive step to new technologies such as computer implemented inventions and biotechnological inventions. The conclusion: the basic law relating to inventive step does not require any changes. However, the report expressed the necessity to maintain consistency in the application of the “inventive step” requirement in high technology fields such as biotechnology.

    Trademarks & Domain Names

    Dyson’s transparent trade mark muddied by the ECJ

    On 25 January 2007, in Case C-321/03, the European Court of Justice refused to allow the vacuum cleaner company Dyson to register a mark which was “a transparent bin or collection chamber” for vacuum cleaners. Cheng Tan, a European trade mark attorney in our London Office, outlines the decision.

    High Court approved Yarns for ELLE

    On 24 January 2007, the Chancery Division of the High Court in Hachette Filipacchi Presse S.A. v Saprotex International (Proprietary) Limited [2007] EWHC 63 (Ch), dismissed an appeal by the publisher of ELLE magazine that was made against the registration of the trade mark ELLE in relation to knitting wools and yarns. The case affirms that if there is no similarity between the products, the “likelihood of confusion” between the marks is unlikely.

    CFI prevents free-riding on the coat-tails of famous trade marks – like TDK

    In a recent decision, the Court of First Instance upheld the rejection of a trade mark application on the basis of reputation and distinctive character acquired by an earlier identical mark through sponsorship activities. The Court also highlighted the fact that a non-hypothetical future risk of unfair advantage from an earlier mark is sufficient to bar the application.

    Legislative News

    • New European Patent Convention is available now at EPO website
    • New Codified Misleading and Comparative Advertising Directive adopted
    • New Codified legislation on copyright protection
    • The UK impose Regulations on the Advertising of Foreign Gambling
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 36

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 36

    November, 2006

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In Depth

    Hot Topics

    1. English Court of Appeal Clarifies Position in Respect of Computer Programs and Business Methods 

    On 27 October 2006, the English Court of Appeal handed down an important and timely decision clarifying its position as to the patentability of computer programs and business methods. Justin Hill, Director of Prosecution in our London Office, outlines the decision.

    2.  YouTube Dare to Share

    The rise, merger and predicted fall of video share site, youtube.com is discussed, as it tries to push the boundaries of copyright law in the US and worldwide in spite of a number of decisions of the US Supreme Court including Grokster and Napster, as well as the changing approach of Big Brother entertainment houses to distribution, which has, in the past, and will, in the future, determine the course of copyright laws.

    Copyright and Technology

    3.  Spain and Italy Forced to Adopt a More Restrictive Public Lending Exemption

    Facing claims that they had too loosely implemented the provision of the Rental and Lending Directive that grants an exemption from the requirement to pay remuneration for public lending, Italy and Spain were found to have failed to fulfil their obligations under Articles 1 and 5 of the Directive in Commission of the European Communities v Kingdom of Spain (C-36/05) and Commission of the European Communities v Italian Republic (C-198/05).

    4. Sony puts Grey Importers Out of Business

    On 18th October 2006, the Chancery Division of the High Court gave a helpful ruling for IP owners in KK Sony Computer Entertainment v Pacific Game Technology [2006] EWHC 2509 (Pat). This is another ‘exhaustion of rights’ case, with a factual variation in that it involves sales of the claimants’ goods into the EEA via an internet website.

    Patents

    5. Is Treating Pain a Novel Issue?

    On 30 October 2006, the English Patents Court handed down a decision in the case Merz Pharma GmbH & Co. KGaA v Allergan Inc. which concerned an action to revoke a European patent for added matter, lack of novelty, obviousness and insufficiency.

    Trademarks & Domain Names

    6. Look Alikes and Smell Alikes

    Trade mark infringement under s 10(3) of the UK Trade Marks Act 1994 can be established where similar packaging takes unfair advantage of the reputation of an existing brand, even in the absence of any likelihood of confusion.

    7. Reckitt & Colman LTD – Appeal For “Bladeless”

    The Second Board of Appeal annulled the decision made by the examiner regarding the registration of “BLADELESS”, since there was no public interest or other valid reason why the term could not be a trade mark. Furthermore, the Board found the meaning of the word mark, and its connection to the goods sought was not descriptive at all, but believed that no other competitors of the same goods would want to use the same word mark.

    8. Stonygate 48 Limited and Wayne Mark Rooney v. Huw Marshall

    Stoneygate 48 Limited et al v Huw Marshall relates to a recent domain name dispute with the well-known footballer, Wayne Rooney, in England.

    Media & Advertising

    9. LIDL Belgium GMBH & CO KG V Etablissementen Franz Colruyt NV

    The European Court of Justice has clarified the rules relating to comparative advertising in a case between supermarket chains Lidl and Colruyt. While general price comparisons were allowed and there was no necessity to display all individual prices, it was important that all information was verifiable and that different competitors could be distinguished in comparisons between several competitors.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 35

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 35

    October, 2006

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In Depth

    Hot Topics

    1. Creative Commons Licences Upheld by the Dutch Court

    In March 2006, the District Court of Amsterdam handed down its decision in Adam Curry v. Audax Publishing B.V., the first case in Europe to consider the legal effect of a Creative Commons licence.

    Copyright

    2. Laserdisk: European Court Rejects International Exhaustion (Again)

    The European Court of Justice has confirmed that the exhaustion principle may not have international application. Hence, the importation of copyright-protected works which are put onto the international market by the right holder, or with his consent, outside the European Union may infringe copyright.

    3. Tortious Liability for links to mp3 files: Further Obstacles to Illegal Downloads in the Netherlands

    In Stichting Bescherming Rechten Entertainment Industrie Nederland (BREIN) V Techno Design “Internet Programming” B.V., the Court of Appeal of Amsterdam quashed a previous District Court judgment and held that the act of a website owner in offering links to illegal music material in the form of mp3 files constituted a tortious act, which may result in injunctive relief and damages in favour of the victims

    Patents

    4. Extending Pharmaceutical Monopolies

    Another attempt at using a later patent to prolong a patentee’s monopoly on his pharmaceutical product has been defeated. In so doing, the Scottish Court of Session has demonstrated the flexibility of the rule of novelty and provided evidence that Scottish courts may hope to entertain a larger proportion of patent cases in the future.

    Trademarks

    5. Cheeses to Chose

    In an intriguing decision by the Nominet Dispute Resolution Service in Fine Cheese Company Ltd v Lawson’s Cheeses, registered domain names and the common law rights of a trader over its trading name have taken precedence over trade mark law.

    6. Hormel Foods Corporation

    Hormel Foods Corporation, the company behind the spicy luncheon meat, SPAM, has failed in an attempt to register Community Trade Marks in respect of the term ‘spam’ for unsolicited bulk email.

    7. PAMPAM and PAMPIM Confused OHIM

    The European Court of First Instance in the case of PAM-PIM’S BABY-PROP followed the Puma v Sabel “global appreciation of the likelihood of confusion” test in order to identify similarity between marks as a way to find the likelihood of confusion according to Art 8(1)(b) of Council Regulation (EC) 40/94.

    8. L & D v OHIM, Julius Sämann Ltd: Likelihood of Confusion

    The European Court of First Instance dismissed an action by L&D to annul an earlier decision of the Second Board of Appeal. The CFI showed clearly how two similar marks should be compared and what elements are to be considered in determining whether there is a likelihood of confusion.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Monsters Inc

    ARTICLE

    Monsters Inc

    October, 2006

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors

    Dr. Boris Uphoff

    Partner

    Munich, Düsseldorf

    More insights

  • An Overview of the Latest Developments in German Gaming Law

    ARTICLE

    An Overview of the Latest Developments in German Gaming Law

    August, 2006

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 34

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 34

    August/September 2006

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In Depth

    Copyright

    1. Five Year Interim Injunction in Copyright Case Continues

    An application to dismiss an interim injunction granted in 2001, in the case of Clarke v Artprints UK, against the reproduction and distribution of several Francis Bacon works was unsuccessful, despite the length of time that had passed.

    Patents

    2. Yeda Research V Rhone_pulenc Rorer & Comptroller of Patents Designs and Trade Marks

    The judgment of the Court of Appeal in the case of Yeda Research & Development Ltd v Rhône-Poulenc Rorer Holdings, Imclone Systems and the Comptroller, provides an interpretation of section 37 of the Patents Act 1977, in respect of patent entitlement proceedings. The judgment also considers the effect of the limitation period under section 37(5) on such entitlement proceedings.

    3. To Amend or Not to Amend

    On 7 July 2006, the High Court, handed down a decision in the case Vector Corporation v Glatt Air Techiniques Limited concerning an action for a declaration of invalidity of a patent belonging to Glatt.

    4. Inventive Concept: Prejudice and False Prejudice

    Case law at the highest level of appeal has noted the problems that courts face when establishing the inventive concept in a patent in suit. A recent case decided in the UK Patents Court has highlighted some of these difficulties.

    Trademarks

    5. “Warm Welcomes” Umwelcomed by OHIM

    On 22 June 2006, the second Board of Appeal of the Office of Harmonisation of the Internal Market (OHIM) rejected an appeal by Overseas Real Estate Limited to register “WARM WELCOMES” as a community trade mark due to lack of distinctiveness. The case reinforces the basic function of a registered trade mark that it must be able to identify the origin of goods or services.

    6. Intel Corporation Inc. V CPM United Kingdom

    Intel Corporation, which owns a large number of UK and Community Trade Marks, has failed in a bid to cancel the registered trade mark INTELMARK, owned by global marketing firm CPM.

    7. Sergio Rossi V Office For Harmonisation in the Internal Market

    The European Court of Justice (ECJ) has held that the function of the Community Courts is to review the legality of previous decisions rendered by Community Offices or the Courts of First Instance, and is not intended to re-examine the facts.

    Designs

    8. Honda Giren Kogyo Kabushiki Kaisha (also trading as Honda Motor Co. LTD)

    On 30 and 31 August 2006, the Invalidity Division of OHIM made two decisions regarding Honda Motor’s requests in respect of the invalidation of two registered community designs. These two cases in industrial design field emphasise the substantiation requirements such as “novelty” and “individual character”.

    Confidential Information and Privacy

    9. Hughes V Carratu International PLC

    The case offers clarification on the legal implications of the conduct of enquiry agents who, when obtaining personal information concerning members of the public, should keep in mind the rules set out in the Data Protection Act 1998.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 33

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 33

    July, 2006

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Hot Topics

    1. Human Embryonic Stem Cell Research and the European Patent Conundrum

    Although the EU Competitiveness Council has decided to allow European funding for human embryonic stem cell research, the patent situation remains inconsistent and unclear. This is especially pronounced when reviewing the patent history in the area as well as the divergences between the UK Patent Office and the EU Patent Office.

    2. Creative Commons Licence Upheld by Dutch Court

    On 9th March 2006, the District Court of Amsterdam decided in the first known court decision involving a Creative Commons licence that a magazine’s republication of photos taken from a photo-sharing site, and used for commercial purposes, violates the terms of the applicable Creative Commons licence.

    Copyright

    3. New French Copyright Law

    The French legislators recently approved the controversial copyright law that will force Apple to make songs purchased from its online music store iTunes compatible with other music players made by rival companies. The new law, which could be effective within a month of its passing, is meant to deter a company from dominating the music download market.

    4. Collective Management of Cable Retransmission Rights

    In Uradex SCRL v Union Professionnelle de la Radio et de la Télédistribution (RTD) and Société Intercommunale pour la Diffusion de la Télévision (Brutele) the European Court of Justice considered Article 9(2) of the cable retransmission directive. The court clarified the scope of the powers of collecting societies in managing the right of artists even where there has not been any transfer of these rights by the artist to the collecting societies. The scope has been defined as not limited to the financial aspects but also to the management of cable retransmission rights on behalf of the artists.

    5. TV Adverts Infringe Moral Rights in Film

    A Swedish Court of Appeal has decided that a TV channel breached the moral rights of the directors and the scriptwriters of two films when the presentations were interrupted by commercial breaks without the authors’ permission.

    Patents

    6. Under Hand and Overhead? Patent Co-Ownership Explained

    The UK Court of Appeal recently ruled on an appeal of a decision of the Patent Office Comptroller which granted a patent licence from one co-owner to a third party against the wishes of the other co-owner. The Comptroller used a power under section 37 of the Patent Act 1977 despite the rule contained in section 36 that co-owners may not grant licences to third parties without the consent of the other co-owners.

    7. Ranbaxy Loses in Court of Appeal on Lipitor

    The Court of Appeal in Ranbaxy UK Ltd v Warner-Lambert [2006] clarified the law relating to the interpretation of claims covering enantiomers and racemates. The decision is a major set back to Ranbaxy, who has long aimed to launch a generic version of Lipitor in the UK and other countries.

    8. Patent Injunctions in the US and UK

    In ebay Inc et al v MercExchange the US Supreme Court issued guidance on granting permanent injunctions in cases of alleged patent infringement. Although on the face of it the decision appears to mirror the position in the UK, important differences with regard to the consideration of damages and public interest remain.

    Trademarks

    9. Louis Vuitton Defeats Google in France

    On 28 June 2006 the Paris Court of Appeals handed down its decision in the case Louis Vuitton Malletier v Google Inc. upholding the lower court decision of 4 February 2005, which had previously ruled against Google and its French subsidiary, Google France.

    10. Easynet Group PLC V Eastygroup IP Licensing LTD

    The High Court held that a trade mark, which is composed of two descriptive elements, will fall foul of the Trade Marks Act 1994 s.3(1)(c) unless it can be shown that the mark overall is merely descriptive or whether as a whole it adds something more than its parts. Such an overall assessment is not qualified by concepts such as unusualness or out-of-the-ordinary.


    Acknowledgements

    McDermott Will & Emery would like to acknowledge the invaluable contribution to the Bulletin made by Dr. Uma Suthersanen, Angel Adrian, James Mitchiner, Lois Muraguri, Marisella Ouma, Rajesh Sagar, Pekka Valo, Luca Escoffier, Ayan Roy Chowdhury Ke Shao, from the Queen Mary Intellectual Property Research Institute, University of London.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights