Content Type: Article

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 32

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 32

    June, 2006

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Hot Topics

    1. Pirate Bay Shut Down

    Swedish authorities announced that they have shut down “The Pirate Bay”, one of the world’s largest and most well known facilitators of online piracy.

    Copyright

    2. The Legacy of Bob Marley and The Wailers

    The High Court in the United Kingdom has dismissed claims by Mr. Aston Barrett, a former member of the band, the Wailers, for a share of income from songs that were recorded prior to Bob Marley’s demise in 1981. The court further dismissed Mr.Barrett’s subsequent claims for infringement of performers’ rights as well as the claim for damages by way of counterclaim by the defendants for breach of a settlement agreement.

    Patents

    3. IVAX Pharmaceuticals UK Ltd V AKZO Nobel UK

    The UK Patents Court gave its judgment in a case concerning the revocation of a third generation patent belonging to Akzo on the steroid Tibolone used in hormone replacement therapy for women. Lewison J found the patent to be invalid on grounds of obviousness in light of prior first and second generation patents owned by Akzo. It was found to be obvious in light of both common general knowledge and prior art.

    Trademarks

    4. Shifting Test in Likelihood of Confusion

    The European Court of Justice handed down a decision denying the upholding of an opposition based on the mark PICASSO by the Picasso estate against the mark PICARO applied for by Daimler Chrysler for inter alia motor vehicles. In their decision the Court stated that a tribunal deciding such matters should not be expected to consider the consumer’s average attention level for each different situation and concluded also that the post sale confusion test applied in Arsenal v Reed could not be used to mitigate against a finding of a lack of confusion.

    5. Doncaster Pharmaceutical V Bolton Pharmaceutical

    This was an appeal from Doncaster Pharmaceutical on the summary judgment granted earlier to Bolton Pharmaceutical. The UK Court of Appeal found the case not suitable for summary judgment as there was insufficient evidence before the Court regarding the ownership of the mark in different countries. Moreover, it was difficult to clarify whether the doctrine of exhaustion applied where there were possible economic links between the Assignor and the Assignees.

    6. Are Sausages All the Same?

    On 31 May 2006 the European Court of First Instance handed down a decision in the case Wim De Waele v Office for the Harmonization in the Internal Market (OHIM) which concerned OHIM’s partial refusal to register a three-dimensional trademark in the shape of a sausage.

    7. Compare with Care

    The European Court of Justice clarified that a competing supplier does not take unfair advantage of the distinguishing mark of the manufacturer by using it when it is known in the ‘specialist circles’, reinstating its interpretation of Art 3a(1)(g) held earlier in the Toshiba Europe case, adding that absence of such use would affect consumers and competition.

    Technology

    8. Research in Motion UK LTD V Inpro Licensing SARL

    In Research in Motion v Inpro Licensing SARL the main question before the Court was whether patent rights of Inpro were infringed by the operation and supply of the Blackberry mobile communications system in the UK.

    Media

     9. Champions League On the Internet is Off-Side, Says UEFA

    By disseminating broadcasts of European Champions League Football matches over their website “www.sportingstreams.com” for viewing by subscribers, the High Court in Union Des Associations Europeennes de Football & Ors v Briscomb & Ors found that the website owners had infringed the copyright in those live broadcasts and ancillary works owned by the Union of Football Associations.

    10. Phones4U Wins Passing Off Appeal Against Online Seller Phone4U

    In a Court of Appeal judgment, the trade mark of the High Street mobile phone chain Phones4U was not infringed by online mobile phones seller when it used the domain name “phone4u.co.uk.” However, the Court of Appeal found that the Phones4U chain had goodwill that was protected by passing off.


    Acknowledgements

    McDermott Will & Emery would like to acknowledge the invaluable contribution to the Bulletin made by Dr. Uma Suthersanen, Angel Adrian, Jerry Hsiao, Maria Mercedes Frabboni, James Mitchiner, Marisella Ouma, Rajesh Sagar, Pekka Valo, Ramneek Jutla, Luca Escoffier, Ayan Roy Chowdhury from the Queen Mary Intellectual Property Research Institute, University of London.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • International News: Focus on International M&A

    ARTICLE

    International News: Focus on International M&A

    April, 2006

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Summary

    In this Issue
    David Ryder

    Common Errors To Avoid In Drafting An International Arbitration Clause
    B. Ted Howes

    Royalty Investing: How Do You Spell R-E-T-U-R-N?
    Jeffrey A. Jung

    Harmonising Sarbanes-Oxley Whistle-Blower Hotlines With French Data Protection Laws
    David A. Cifrino, Thomas P. Conaghan and Mélanie Bruneau

    Ambush Marketing
    Larry Cohen, Dr. Boris Uphoff, Dr. Thies Bösling, Sarah Brown and Rohan Massey

    Age Discrimination In The UK
    Rebecca Harding-Hill and Paul Reeves

    The Effects Of Sarbanes-Oxley On U.S. Listings
    Luke J. Albrecht and Jeff Turner

    The Return Of Complex Cross-Border M&A
    Konstantin Günther, Dr. Robert Manger, Richard Mitchell, Jeffrey Rothschild, Thomas Sauermilch and Sonya Ahuja

    SEC Interpretations Of Hedge Fund Rules
    Ted Laurenson

    Corporate Mobility And Cross-Border Fusions Within The EU
    Philip Bentley and Patrice Corbiau

    Ensuring The Viability Of Procuring Patent In The United States
    Paul Devinsky

    Foreign Waters, Paper Currency

    FTC Introduces Merger Review Process Reforms
    Jon B. Dubrow, Joel R. Grosberg and Carla A. R. Hine

    AIM In 2006: The New NASDAQ?
    Andrew Croxford and John Hession

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 30

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 30

    March, 2006

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Copyright

    1. French Court Rules That Scents are ‘Works of Art’

    On 25 January 2006, the L’Oreal group won a lawsuit against Bellure, a perfume firm that produced near-identical copies of some of its major perfumes. The Paris Court of Appeal confirmed that a scent is a work of the mind, just like a sculpture, a photograph or a musical work and that copying a fragrance constitutes a breach of author’s right.

    2. The Droit De Suite Comes Into Force in the UK

    With the introduction of the Resale Right Regulations 2006, living British artists can now enjoy remuneration from subsequent sales of their works of art. The Regulations enforce the Resale Right Directive that requires resale rights to be implemented across the entire EEA.

    3. Allan Williams Entertainment v Hurd

    Where a compromise agreement specified that former members of a band could not trade as the original band. It was held that a proper construction of the agreement meant that each party was obliged to prevent the promotion of themselves as the original band. This obligation was deemed to include the parties taking reasonable steps to correct erroneous third party descriptions that breached the compromise agreement.

    Patents

    4. Research in Motion UK v Inpro Licensing Sarl

    Research in Motion v Inpro Licensing SARL was a patent action for revocation of a European Patent (UK) belonging to the defendant, Inpro Licensing SARL (Inpro). The grounds for revocation were invalidity for lack of novelty, obviousness and excluded subject matter. Inpro’s patent claimed a computer system that reduced the processing power used by portable computers making for quicker and easier to access the internet.

    5. Rhone-Poulenc Rorer v Yeda Research and Development

    In this case, Lewison J held that there is a strict limitation period under s.37 of the Patents Act, 1977, within which the parties should raise any proprietary objection in relation to a patent. Once this period is over, an amendment to bring a new claim will not defeat the defence of limitation by relating back to the original reference. He further clarified that in such proceedings, the hearing officer is not bound by the Civil Procedure Rules.

    6. Non-Disclosure Agreements: Markem v Zipher Applied – Is There Any Change?

    In the recent case of GE Healthcare (Amersham) v PerkinElmer Life Sciences, the Patents Court applied the test for entitlement to a patent confirmed last year by the Court of Appeal in Markem v Zipher for the first time. The case concerned the alleged disclosure of the invention in issue to Amersham who subsequently obtained the patent. Though Markem was not really put to the test, it appears to have changed little in the day-to-day application of the law on patent entitlement.

    Trademarks

    7. Polo-Playing Horseman, Soaps and Abrasives

    On 21 February 2006, Court of First Instance delivered its judgement in the Royal County of Berkshire Polo Club Ltd v OHIM, allowing the Polo/Lauren Co. LP to retain its proprietary rights over the sign of a ‘polo-playing horseman’ drawing a comparison between toiletries and laundry products.

    8. Compatative Advertising: When Do We Take Advantage Unfairly?

    On 23 February 2006, the European Court of Justice handed down a decision in Siemens AG v. VIPA Gesellschaft für Visualisierung und Prozeβautomatisierung mbH. The case refers to the interpretation of Article 3a(1)(g) of Council Directive 84/450/EEC concerning misleading and comparative advertising, as amended by Directive 97/55/EC.

    Technology

    9. Yahoo Search Marketing Stops Bid on Competitors’ Trade Marked Keywords

    Yahoo Search Marketing recently announced in an email to its advertisers a new policy to be implemented on 1 March 2006, which no longer allows bid on competitors’ trade marked keywords.

    10. Google Image Search Thumbnails Breach Copyright

    Internet search engine Google was found to be breaching copyright laws with its Google Image Search by a US Federal Court. Thumbnail images displayed on search results were found to have been copied from adult website Perfect 10.


    Acknowledgements

    McDermott Will & Emery would like to acknowledge the invaluable contribution to the Bulletin made by Professor Michael Blakeney, Ayan Roy Chowdhury, Luca Escoffier, Jerry Hsiao, Ramneek Jutla, Malcolm Langley, Tina Loverdou, Maria Mercedes Frabboni, James Mitchiner, Marisella Ouma, Rajesh Sagar, Ken Shao, Pekka Valo and Daphne Zografos from the Queen Mary Intellectual Property Research Institute, University of London.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • An Overview of the Latest Developments in German Gaming Law

    ARTICLE

    An Overview of the Latest Developments in German Gaming Law

    March, 2006

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 29

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 29

    February, 2006

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Hot Topics

    1. Comparison: Divisional Patents in Europe and the United States

    Decisions of the European Patent Office (EPO) Technical and Legal Boards of Appeal have demonstrated a clear desire by the EPO to distinguish the system of divisional applications under the European Patent Convention from the system of continuations and continuations-in-part that exist before the US Patent and Trade mark Office.

    Copyright

    2. Copyright on Papal Documents

    The Secretary of State for the Vatican has recently decreed that the Vatican publishing house is entrusted with the right to enforce the Pope’s copyright worldwide. This supports the Vatican’s desire for better protection of the Pope’s writings against unauthorised use. Remuneration that could be derived from enforcement of the decree is another key aspect of the initiative.

    3. Nova Productions v Mazooma Games: Copyright Infringement of Video Games

    The High Court of Justice has given its judgment in two copyright infringement actions concerning coin operated video games. Both claims failed. The court analysed whether a substantial part of any copyright work had been reproduced.

    4. The Performance (Moral Rights, etc.) Regulations 2006

    The Performance (Moral Rights, etc.) Regulations 2006 came into force on 1 February 2006 to implement the UK government’s community obligation under EU law, pursuant to ratification of the World Intellectual Property Organization’s Phonograms and Performances Treaty 1996.

    Patents

    5. The EPO Clarifies the Concept of Diagnostic Methods

    On 16 December 2005, the Enlarged Board of Appeal of the European Patent Office delivered an opinion concerning the interpretation of the concept of “diagnostic methods practised on the human or animal body” and the cases in which their patentability is excluded under the European Patent Convention.

    6. Tamglass v Luoyang North Glass

    In this case, Justice Mann held that a fax sent to a potential customer containing a list of infringing machines was an “offer to dispose” within the meaning of Section 60 of the Patents Act, 1977. The party sending such a fax was found to be guilty of infringement, and could not argue that it was merely an “invitation to treat”. Furthermore, the knowledge that the use of the machine would infringe the patent could be imputed on the guilty party either indirectly or by necessary inference.

    Trademarks

    7. Deutsche SiSi-Werke v Ohim

    The German company SiSi-Werke has lost its latest battle to register a product shape as a trade mark across the EU.

    8. Emanuel v Continental Shelf: Name of Fashion Designer as a TradeMark

    The Advocate General (AG) gave his opinion as to whether the transfer of a trade mark, which is the name of a fashion designer, to other parties is deceiving or misleading to the customer. The AG found that the trade mark does not deceive the customer if the trade mark is assigned with the goodwill.

    Media

    9. George Galloway MP v The Telegraph Group

    On 25 January 2006, the Court of Appeal delivered its judgment in George Galloway MP v The Telegraph Group. The Daily Telegraph did not succeed in its bid to overturn a 2004 ruling that it had libelled politician George Galloway. The Court of Appeal dismissed all three grounds put forward by the newspaper, namely, the defence of qualified privilege, the defence of fair or honest comment and the claim that the £150,000 damages originally awarded were excessive.

    10. HRH The Prince of Wales v Associated Newspapers

    The High Court in London has made a temporary order restraining the publication or disclosure of Prince Charles’ private journals pending the judgment on the summary judgment application or further order. Copies of the journals, which contained the Prince’s views on the 1997 handover of Hong Kong to the Chinese, had come into possession of the Mail on Sunday.

    Technology

    11. Microsoft Agrees to Licence Windows Source Code

    Microsoft announced on 25 January 2006 that it would licence some of its secret software source code under the threat, from the European Union, of fines of up to $2.45 million a day. However, its rivals have said that it is merely a “ploy” as large amounts of source code will be useless.


    Acknowledgements

    McDermott Will & Emery would like to acknowledge the invaluable contribution to the Bulletin made by Professor Michael Blakeney, Angel Adrian, Sofia Casimiro, Claudio Chiarolla, Luca Escoffier, Jerry Hsiao, Afe Komolafe, Malcolm Langley, Tina Loverdou, Maria Mercedes Frabboni, James Mitchiner, Marisella Ouma, Rajesh Sagar, Ken Shao and Pekka Valo from the Queen Mary Intellectual Property Research Institute, University of London.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Germany: World Cup Ambush Marketing

    ARTICLE

    Germany: World Cup Ambush Marketing

    February, 2006

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors

    Dr. Boris Uphoff

    Partner

    Munich, Düsseldorf

    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 28

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 28

    January, 2006

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Hot Topics

    1. World Trade Organisation Members Agree to Amend the Trips Agreement on Patents and Public Health

    The decision of the General Council of 6 December 2005 on the amendment of the TRIPS Agreement makes the flexibilities contained in the 2003 decision on patents and public health permanent. This in effect will lead to the first amendment of a core WTO Agreement.

    2. UK Chancellor Announces Intellectual Property Review

    As part of his Pre-Budget Report Package, the Chancellor of the Exchequer, Gordon Brown, has announced the launch of an independent review of intellectual property in the UK, to be headed by the former editor of the Financial Times.

    Copyright

    3. Sony BMG’s Anti-Piracy Software in Big Trouble

    Sony BMG’s trouble started immediately following Windows programming expert Mark Russinovich’s discovery that Sony’s anti-piracy software used virus-like techniques to stop illegal copies being made. There have been several class action lawsuits launched against both Sony BMG and First4Internet. Widespread pressure has made Sony BMG take actions to settle the dispute.

    4. Evaluation of EU Rules on Databases

    The European Commission has published an evaluation of the protection EU law gives to databases. With disappointing findings, one of the proposed options is to repeal the whole Database Directive and allow Member States to revert to their former legislation.

    5. Online Management of Music Rights: the EU Commission’s Impact Assessment

    On 11 October 2005, the European Commission released an Impact Assessment to accompany the Recommendation on Collective Cross-border Management of Copyright and Related Rights for Legitimate Online Music Services. The document summarised the discussion on collective management in the online context and explained the possible effects of the Recommendation and the Commission’s broader initiatives.

    Patents

    6. Supplementary Protection Certificates for Combination Medicinal Products

    On 24 November 2005, Advocate General Léger delivered an opinion concerning the construction of Article 1(b) of Council Regulation 1768/92/EEC concerning the creation of a supplementary protection certificate for medicinal products and provided an interpretation of the concept of “combination of active ingredients of a medicinal product”.

    7. Roche Makes U-Turn on Tamiflu Patent

    Roche, the Swiss drugs manufacturing company, has bowed to international pressure and agreed to meet with generic manufacturers with a view to sub-licensing its patent for the antiviral drug Tamiflu in the wake of a possible bird flu pandemic.

    8. European Telecommunications Standards Institute Reviews its IPR Policy to Prevent Patent Ambushes

    Standard-setting bodies are coming under increasing pressure to review and strengthen their IP Rights policies to prevent “patent ambushes”. After the reported inadequacy of the IPR policy of the JEDEC Solid State Technology Association, which is responsible for setting standards for semiconductor industry, the European Telecommunications Standards Institute (ETSI) came under investigation by the European Commission.

    Trademarks

    9. When is a Descriptive Mark Not a Descriptive Mark?

    The Advocate-General has handed down some valuable guidance on the examination of potentially descriptive foreign language trade marks by national trade mark authorities. Importantly, if the Opinion is adopted by the full Court, then national examiners will not be allowed to take into account the possible restrictions on inter-state trade.

    10. Starbucks Regains the Right to Use its Brand in Russia

    On 17 November 2005, Rospatent, Russia’s intellectual property agency, announced that Starbucks Corp. had regained the right to use its brand on coffee houses in Russia. The decision followed a legal battle with a trade mark squatter who was asking $600,000 for the logo.

    11. Federal Republic of Germany and Kingdom of Denmark v Commission of the European Communities

    On 25 October 2005, Germany and Denmark brought an action for the annulment of the Commission’s decision to register Feta as a protectable designation of origin for Greece, on the basis that Feta had become a generic name. The European Court of Justice ruled that Feta is protectable under the European Geographical Indication registration regime.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 27

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 27

    November, 2005

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Hot Topics

    1. House of Lords Clarifies Novelty in Synthon v Smithkline Beecham PLC

    The judgment of the House of Lords in the case of Synthon v Smithkline Beecham Plc clarifies when an invention can be considered new and patentable within the UK Patent Act 1977. In the leading decision for the House of Lords, Lord Hoffman stated that both “disclosure” and “enablement” are distinct concepts, each of which has to be satisfied before a patent can be held as anticipated and invalid.

    Copyright

    2. Campbell v MGN: Naomi Campbell Wins Again

    Campbell v MGN Limited is the latest appeal in the action brought by Naomi Campbell against the publishers of the Daily Mirror for breach of confidence over the publication of information relating to her treatment for drug addiction. This case is the first occasion where the House of Lords have considered the consequences of the Conditional Fee Agreement regime as it relates to claims affecting the freedom of expression.

    3. English High Court Refuses Interim Order Barring Similar Art Work on CD Covers

    The claimants in GMG Radio Holdings Ltd & Ors v Tokyo Project Ltd & Anor argued that the art covers on CD compilations created by the same artist were confusingly similar and applied for an injunction based on a claim for passing off.

    4. Online Management of Music rights: the Commission’s Recommendation

    The European Commission, in its recommendation on collective cross-border management of copyright and related rights for legitimate online music services, has offered guidelines to Member States on how to shape further legislative initiatives at the local level in order to enhance the provision of music products on the internet. The Recommendation is a compromise between the calls for an innovative legal instrument and the need to maintain stability within the working rules of collective management.

    Patents

    5. Obviousness – Conflicts Between EPO and UK Approach

    In October at first instance in the UK Patents Court, Mr Justice Pumfrey handed down his judgment in a case which highlights the different approaches of the European Patent Office and UK law in approaching the question of obviousness in patents. Whilst Justice Pumfrey did not go so far as to say that there was a conflict between the approaches, the case nevertheless provides ammunition to critics of the EPO formulaic approach to obviousness.

    6. London Search Facility of the UK Patent Office Merges with the British Library

    The British Library has merged with the London Search Facility of the Patent Office to become the entrepreneurs’ chief information source on intellectual property. This has created a superior service in the United Kingdom for comprehensive database searching of patents, trade marks and designs, as well as viewing cases, journals and specifications.The British Library has merged with the London Search Facility of the Patent Office to become the entrepreneurs’ chief information source on intellectual property. This has created a superior service in the United Kingdom for comprehensive database searching of patents, trade marks and designs, as well as viewing cases, journals and specifications.

    Trademarks

    7. Thomson Will Sell Without ‘Life’

    The European Court of Justice decision in Medion AG v Thomson multimedia Sales Germany & Austria GmbH has interpreted Directive 89/104/EEC (to approximate the laws of Member States concerning trade marks), and provides a new approach to ascertaining the likelihood of confusion between two marks when one is a composite sign that consists of a company’s name, and the other a registered mark belonging to a third party and used to sell identical products.

    8. Eden Sarl v OHIM

    On 27 October 2005, the Court of First Instance delivered its judgment in Eden Sarl v OHIM. It dismissed an attempt to register a trade mark for the smell of ripe strawberries on grounds of lack of graphic representation.

    9. Vodafone Launches in Romania Following Trade Mark Dispute

    Vodafone, the British mobile telephone service provider, has launched its first service in Romania. The launch follows a legal dispute with a rival telephone company which held a long-standing registration of the VODAFONE trade mark in Romania.


    Acknowledgements

    McDermott Will & Emery would like to acknowledge the invaluable contribution to the Bulletin made by Professor Michael Blakeney, Angel Adrian, Luca Escoffier, Maria Mercedes Frabboni, Jerry Hsiao, Malcolm Langley, Tina Loverdou, James Mitchiner, Rajesh Sagar, Ken Shao, Ilanah Simon, Pekka Valo and Daphne Zografos from the Queen Mary Intellectual Property Research Institute, University of London.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Foreign Group Financing Companies in International Tax Law…

    ARTICLE

    Foreign Group Financing Companies in International Tax Law…

    2005

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    – At the same time an analysis of Dublin Docks companies of German parent companies.

    In depth
    Authors

    Dr. Gero Burwitz

    Partner

    Munich

    More insights

  • Intellectual Property

    ARTICLE

    Intellectual Property

    October 8, 2005

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors

    Dr. Boris Uphoff

    Partner

    Munich, Düsseldorf

    More insights