Content Type: Article

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 56

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 56

    January, 2009

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In Depth

    Patents

    Human Stem Cell Inventions
    The Enlarged Board of Appeal of the European Patent Office has provided clarification regarding the patentability of a method for obtaining embryonic stem cell cultures from primates including humans.

    Business Methods
    In Bilski (Federal Circuit 2007-1130) the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit adopted a test for patent eligibility that effectively narrows the scope of patent-eligible subject matter with respect to business methods and process claims in general.

    UK-IPO Press Release Regarding Computer Program Patents
    On 7 November 2008 the UK Intellectual Property Office (UK-IPO) issued a press release regarding the patentability of computer programs following the Court of Appeal decision in Symbian v Comptroller General of Patents.

    Trade Marks

    Counterfeit Products: Trade Mark Use
    In R v Gary Boulter [2008] EWCA Crim 2375, the English Court of Appeal upheld the Bristol Crown Court’s ruling that it is no defence to a charge of unauthorised trade mark use that the reproduction of the mark was of such poor quality that nobody would be confused into believing that the goods originated from the owner of the trade mark.

    Medicines and The Average Consumer
    In Aventis Pharma v OHIM [2008] T-95/07 the Court of First Instance agreed with an Office of Harmonization for the Internal Market (OHIM) Board of Appeal finding that health professionals and end users of medicines are likely to pay above average attention to the differences between two trade marks, thereby diminishing the likelihood of confusion.

    Shapes: Technical Result Objection
    In Lego Juris A/S v OHIM [2008] T-270/06, the Court of First Instance has upheld an Office of Harmonization for the Internal Market (OHIM) Grand Board of Appeal decision that Lego’s Community trade mark registration of a red four-by-two brick was invalid because it consisted exclusively of the shape of goods that was necessary to obtain a technical result.

    Dilution
    The European Court of Justice has handed down its judgment in Intel Corporation Inc v CPM United Kingdom Ltd [2008] C-252/07 on the extent to which a mark that enjoys huge reputation will suffer from use of that mark on any third party goods or services.

    MONGOLSTM Injunction
    The U.S. District Court has granted an injunction prohibiting Club members, their family members and associates from wearing, licensing, selling or distributing their Club’s identifying logo, which had been registered at the U.S. Trade Mark Office.

    Intellectual Property

    UK-IPO Considers Derogation Extension for Deceased Artists
    The UK Intellectual Property Office (UK-IPO) is currently assessing the likely impact of the “Artist’s Resale Right” and the special derogation for deceased artists on the UK art market.

    Online Libel: No Inference of Substantial Publication
    In Shaun Brady v Keith Norman [2008] EWHC 2481 (QB) it was determined that the claimant in a libel action has the burden of proving that the material in question has been read by individuals in circumstances in which publication was not protected by qualified privilege.

    Commercial

    Consumer Rights Directive: Potential Changes to UK Consumer Protection Legislation and Regulation

    We review the UK Consultation paper on EU proposals for a Consumer Rights Directive for changing the way in which business-to-consumer online trading is regulated in the United Kingdom.

    Data Protection

    Data Sharing, ICO Powers and Data Breach Notification
    On 24 November 2008, the UK Ministry of Justice announced that “the Information Commissioner is to be given tougher powers to regulate the Data Protection Act”.

    Sport

    Unfair Contract Terms: Match Ticket Refunds and Health Club Membership Agreements
    The Office of Fair Trading (OFT) is calling generally on all clubs to ensure their terms and conditions are compliant with the law. The move comes after the OFT took action against Tottenham Hotspur FC and Fitness First for potential breaches of the Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts Regulations 1999.

    Advertising and Marketing

    TV and Radio Codes: Reflecting the CPRs
    The Broadcast Committee of Advertising Practice (BCAP) has revised its TV and Radio Advertising Standards Codes to reflect the requirements of the Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations 2008 (CPRs).

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 55

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 55

    November, 2008

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In Depth

    Patents

    Software protection—dynamic links
    In Symbian Ltd v Comptroller General of Patents [2008] EWCA Civ 1066, the English Court of Appeal provides guidance on the test for establishing whether a software program is patentable.

    Cross-undertaking of compensation for an interim injunction
    The decision of the High Court in Les Laboratoires Servier v Apotex Inc[2008] EWHC 2347 demonstrates how costly it can be for a claimant in a patent action who, having given a cross-undertaking on an interim injunction, ultimately loses the main battle.

    UK Manual of Patent Practice updated
    The UK Manual of Patent Practice was recently updated. It is an invaluable tool for anyone needing access to the nuts and bolts of patent procedure before the United Kingdom Intellectual Property Office.

    Patent Prosecution Super Highway
    The Patent Prosecution Highway (PPH) trial scheme was launched on 29 September 2008. This new scheme is designed to promote cooperation between the European Patent Office and the United States Patent and Trademark Office.

    Trade Marks

    Slogans and distinctive character
    In Imperial Chemical Industries v OHIM [2008] T-224/07 (unreported), the Court of First Instance has upheld OHIM’s refusal of a Community Trade Mark application for LIGHT & SPACE in respect of paint and related products, on the basis that it is devoid of distinctive character.

    Parallel Imports

    “Unwellcome” news for drugs companies
    Following a reference from the Supreme Court of Austria to the European Court of Justice, the Advocate General, in The Wellcome Foundation Ltd v Paranova Pharmazeutica Handels GmbH [2008] C-276/05, has addressed the question of the repackaging and parallel importation of pharmaceuticals.

    Databases

    Sui generis right—concept of extraction
    Following a reference from the German courts, the European Court of Justice has, in Directmedia Publishing GmbH v Albert‑Ludwigs-Universität Freiburg [2008] C‑304/07 (unreported), provided guidance on the concept of extraction in the context of infringement of the database right.

    Commercial

    The importance of registering transactions relating to intellectual property in Europe
    A recent UK case, Thorn Security Ltd v Siemens Schweiz AG, has emphasised the need to register certain transfers of patent and trade mark rights with national patent offices.

    EU consumer rights online—overhaul and upgrade
    The European Commission has proposed an overhaul and upgrade of EU consumer rights online. The draft Directive on Consumer Rights sets out the proposed framework for the changes.

    New Company Names Tribunal—opportunistic registrations
    A new UK Company Names Tribunal has been established to enable brand owners to prevent the registration of company names similar to their company or business names.

    Advertising & Marketing

    Guidance on gambling advertisements
    The Committee of Advertising Practice and the Broadcast Committee of Advertising Practice have published guidance on the rules for gambling advertisements.

    Sport

    Conditional access and sports rights—good and bad news
    The European Commission’s second report on the implementation of the Conditional Access Directive 98/84/EC was published on 6 October 2008. There are a number of implications for sports events rights holders and their licensees.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 54

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 54

    October, 2008

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In Depth

    Hot Topics

    Preventing parallel trade in the European Union
    In its recent decision in Lelos and Others v GSK C-468/06, the European Court of Justice has ruled that pharmaceutical companies can take measures to ensure that their commercial interests are not threatened by parallel traders within the European Union. However, the pharmaceutical companies will not be able to stop supplies to wholesalers completely—instead they must continue to meet supplies that are “not out of the ordinary”.

    E-Commerce

    Keyword advertising and use as a trade mark—Cour de Cassation refers keyword suggestion tools to the European Court of Justice
    An increasing number of companies are bringing actions in Europe against internet search engines in respect of their keyword advertising programs. The reaction of the European courts to these cases has differed from one jurisdiction to another. Consequently, the French Cour de Cassation has asked for clarification from the European Court of Justice (ECJ). Simone Blakeney, an Associate in the London office of McDermott Will & Emery, sets out the decisions of the different courts and outlines the reference to the ECJ.

    Patents

    Ironing out inconsistencies between UK and EPO decisions
    On 21 June 2008, in Merck & Co Inc v Actavis UK Ltd [2008] EWCA Civ 444, the Court of Appeal allowed the appeal of the Defendant, Merck, against the decision of the High Court that its patent was invalid for lack of novelty.

    Exhaustion doctrine is very exhausting in the United States
    The U.S. Supreme Court has finally ruled in the patent royalties case Quanta Computer v LG Electronics No. 06-937 [2008] in respect of exhaustion of patent rights in the United States.

    Trade Marks

    Can a shopping centre register a trade mark for retail services?
    The UK High Court has allowed the registration of trade marks by shopping centres in relation to “retail services” in its decision in Land Securities plc v Registrar of Trade Marks [2008] EWHC 1744 (Pat).

    Fir trees and air fresheners
    In P L&D SA v OHIM C-488/06 [2008] (unreported), the European Court of Justice (ECJ) rejected the contention that the word element of a complex mark is systematically dominant in the overall impression given by that mark. The ECJ accordingly refused to reverse the Court of First Instance’s decision upholding an opposition to the registration of a composite mark featuring a fir tree shape for air fresheners.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Value Added Services and Privacy Law (Data Protection) – Processing of Personal Data generated through Telephone based Raffles and Data Services

    ARTICLE

    Value Added Services and Privacy Law (Data Protection) – Processing of Personal Data generated through Telephone based Raffles and Data Services

    August, 2008

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 53

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 53

    August / September 2008

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Summary

    In a previous version of The European IP Bulletin Issue 53 August/September 2008 the piece on Aerotel v WaveCrest Group Enterprises [2008] EWHC 1180 (Pat) reported in error that Aerotel alleged that WaveCrest had dishonestly doctored a document being relied on as prior art in this case. Although Aerotel in this case did reassert the allegations of doctoring it had made in a separate US action, at no time was it alleged that WaveCrest was in any way involved in or responsible for this. This error has now been corrected. We apologise to WaveCrest and our readers for this error and any confusion that it may have led to.

    Patents

    Methods of doing business—the sequel to Aerotel
    In Aerotel Ltd v WaveCrest Group Enterprises [2008] EWHC 1180 (Pat), HH Judge Fysh has essentially disregarded the previous Court of Appeal decision and revoked the Aerotel patent as being obvious and comprising unpatentable subject matter (i.e.,for being a method of doing business).

    If it is obvious to try, it still might not be obvious (obviously)
    In Conor Medsystems Inc v Angiotech Pharmaceuticals Inc[2008] UKHL 49, the House of Lords has revisited the test of “obvious to try” most often raised in patent validity actions. The House has also reversed decisions of both the High Court and Court of Appeal that Angiotech’s patent for taxol coated stents was invalid for obviousness.

    Loose lips sink ships: posting inventions on secure internet servers may affect your patent rights in USA
    InSRI International v Internet Security Systems Inc and Symantec Corp(US Federal Circuit) [2008] 2007-1065, a U.S. court held that a disclosure posted onto a computer server that is for all intents and purposes “secure” could still irrevocably destroy the novelty of a U.S. patent.

    Trade Marks

    Suspension of earlier declaration of invalidity of trade marks
    On 18 July 2008, the English High Court handed down its decision in Rousselon Freres et cie v Horwood Homewares Ltd [2008] EWHC 1660 (Ch), in respect of an appeal against an earlier decision of Mr Justice Warren granting Rousselon Freres a declaration of invalidity against two UK trade marks registered to Horwood Homewares for knives in Class 8.

    IT marks and likelihood of confusion
    In SHS Polar Sistemas Informáticos SL v OHIM [2008] T-79/07 (unreported), the Court of First Instance has rejected an opposition, originally upheld by the Office of Harmonization for the Internal Market (OHIM) Opposition Division, brought by the owner of the Community trade mark POLAR, registered for computer software, against an application to register the figurative mark POLARIS for computer software specifically for financial institutions.

    Promotional slogans—registrability
    In the recent decision of the Court of First Instance (CFI) in Ashoka v OHIM [2008] T-186/07 (unreported), the Applicant tried to persuade the Court that the word mark DREAM IT, DO IT! was registrable as a Community trade mark for various services. However, the CFI refused to overturn a Board of Appeal decision and rejected the mark on the basis that it would be perceived as a promotional and advertising slogan and not as an indication of the commercial origin of the services in question.

    How not to run a CTM opposition
    In El Corte Inglés SA v OHIM [2008] T-420/03 (unreported), the Court of First Instance (CFI) refused to overturn an Office of Harmonization for the Internal Market (OHIM) Board of Appeal decision rejecting an opposition to the registration of a Community trade mark. The CFI also held that the Board had been entitled to exercise its discretion to refuse to allow the opponent, the well known Spanish department store chain, El Corte Inglés, to submit evidence it had failed to adduce to the Opposition Division.

    Adidas wins U.S. case against two and four stripe logos
    Less than a month after the European Court of Justice ruling in Adidas v Marca Mode [2008] C-102/07, Adidas has won a U.S.$305 million payout in the United States from Collective Brands in a lawsuit that was seven years in the making. A federal jury in Adidas AG v Collective Brands Inc(Portland, Oregon, Federal District Court, 8 May 2008) decided that both the two and four stripe logos used by Collective Brands on its various ranges of footwear infringed the well known and, in the jury’s collective mind, “iconic” three stripes of Adidas.

    Copyrights

    Sound recordings and co-written musical works—term of protection
    The European Commission has issued a formal proposal to extend the term of copyright protection for sound recordings from 50 to 95 years.

    Entertainment & Media

    Privacy—freedom of expression and exemplary damages
    The well publicised decision in Max Mosley v News Group Newspapers Ltd [2008] EWHC 1777 (QB) is set out in this article.

    Data Protection

    Binding corporate rules—consolidated guidance
    The Article 29 Working Party has published more detailed “guidance” on the Binding Corporate Rules (BCRs) that goes some way to making the role of Data Protection Officer in a multinational organisation one of the most challenging back office roles of any industry.

    Domain Names

    Nominet—changes to dispute resolution policy and procedure
    Nominet has finalised revisions to its policies and procedures, which took effect on 29 July 2008. This article summarises the most relevant changes.

    Narnia.mobi-use as an email address
    The panel in CS Lewis (PTE) Ltd v Richard Saville-Smith [2008] WIPO D2008-0821 was not convinced that the Respondent had registered the domain name narnia.mobi for use only as a Narnia-related email address for his son, apparently a big Narnia fan. Whilst such use could not of itself constitute a legitimate interest for the purposes of the Uniform Dispute Resolution Policy (UDRP), the panel also found “opportunistic” bad faith on the basis that Mr Saville-Smith used the domain name to mislead users to an advertising site while being aware of the fame and distinctiveness of the term “Narnia”.

    Sport

    Conditional access-“illicit device” and Euro defences
    In Karen Murphy v Media Protection Services Ltd [2008] EWHC 1666 (Admin), the High Court of England and Wales agreed to seek guidance from the European Court of Justice on a number of Euro defences relied on by Mrs Murphy in her appeal against convictions under the conditional access provisions of the Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988 (CDPA). This latest judgment relates to her defence based on the free movement and competition rules of the EC Treaty along with the crucial issue of whether the Greek decoder card and box were “illicit” in the sense intended by the Conditional Access Directive (98/84/EC), upon which the CDPA provisions are based.

    E-Commerce

    Second EU enforcement sweep–websites selling ring-tones and other mobile phone services
    On 17 July 2008, the European Commission announced the results of the second EU consumer protection enforcement sweep, this time into websites offering mobile phone services such as ring-tones and wallpapers. The sweep, which covered more than 500 websites across the 27 EU Member States plus Norway and Iceland, revealed suspected breaches of EU consumer protection rules on 80 per cent of the sites checked. This article sets out the main problems that were identified.

    In depth

    Summary

    In a previous version of The European IP Bulletin Issue 53 August/September 2008 the piece on Aerotel v WaveCrest Group Enterprises [2008] EWHC 1180 (Pat) reported in error that Aerotel alleged that WaveCrest had dishonestly doctored a document being relied on as prior art in this case. Although Aerotel in this case did reassert the allegations of doctoring it had made in a separate US action, at no time was it alleged that WaveCrest was in any way involved in or responsible for this. This error has now been corrected. We apologise to WaveCrest and our readers for this error and any confusion that it may have led to.

    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 52

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 52

    July, 2008

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In Depth

    Patents

    A patent too far
    In Les Laboratoires Servier v Apotex Inc [2008] EWCA Civ 445, the English Court of Appeal has dismissed an appeal against a finding of invalidity of a patent, holding that it was clearly unpatentable.

    EPO Enlarged Board of Appeal invites the public to determine whether stem cells are contrary to morality
    On 24 and 25 June 2008, in Public hearing on Wisconsin Alumni Research Foundation (WARF) Stem Cell patent application (G-02/06), the European Patent Office (EPO) sought guidance from the public in relation to patent applications involving inventions in the controversial area of stem cell patenting.

    Trade Marks

    No free ride for Mineral Spa
    In Mülhens GmbH & Co KG v OHIM [2008] (T-93/06) unreported, the Court of First Instance (CFI) has upheld an opposition to an application to register the word mark MINERAL SPA as a Community trade mark for soaps and cosmetics, on the grounds that it would take unfair advantage of the reputation of the earlier Benelux word mark SPA registered for mineral water. The CFI held that the Applicant would take unfair advantage of the image of the earlier trade mark and the message conveyed by it.

    “Euro” marks—distinctive character and descriptiveness
    Eurohypo’s gallant (and expensive) campaign to register its name as a Community trade mark for financial services has failed. Whilst the European Court of Justice (ECJ) set aside the Court of First Instance (CFI) decision rejecting the mark on the basis that the CFI had assessed distinctiveness solely by reference to descriptiveness, the ECJ ultimately held that the mark EUROHYPO did indeed lack distinctive character under Article 7(1)(b) of the Community Trade Mark Regulation (40/94/EC).

    Copyrights

    Claim for implied assignment of copyright in software development agreement
    On 4 June 2008, the English Court of Appeal upheld a ruling of Deputy Judge Robert Ham QC in Meridian International Services Ltd v Richardson [2008] EWCA Civ 609 that it was neither necessary, nor obvious, to imply into an oral agreement a term that the copyright in computer software for a financial forecasting system belonged to the claimant.

    Domain Names

    Criticism sites and free speech
    In the recent case of Patel v Allos Therapeutics Inc (20/6/2008, unreported), the legitimacy of using trade marks in domain names for websites that criticise the activities of the trade mark holder was called into question. Striking out a challenge to a Uniform Dispute Resolution Policy ruling, the English High Court provides some rare judicial insight into the factors that may determine the legitimacy of trade mark use in domain names for criticism sites.

    ICANN announces biggest expansion to internet in 40 years—recommendation for liberalisation of domain system approved
    On 26 June 2008, of the Board of the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) announced that it had approved a recommendation to liberalise the rules on the allocation of top level domains that could see a whole range of new domain names introduced to the internet’s addressing system from next year. This article examines the proposal and its effects.

    Sport

    Circumventing conditional access, “illicit device” and copyright
    On 24 June 2008, in The Football Association Premier League Ltd v QC Leisure [2008] EWHC 1411, the FA Premier League suffered another potential setback in its campaign against pub landlords using foreign decoder cards in the United Kingdom to access foreign transmissions of live Premier League football matches, and the decoder suppliers. This article examines some of the highlights of the detailed judgment.

    UEFA challenges the UK list of events of major importance to society
    The Union of European Football Associations (UEFA), European football’s governing body, has put together submissions to the Court of First Instance challenging the designation of all matches in the European Championship as “listed events” in the United Kingdom. The UK list, formally approved by the Commission in October last year, includes the European Championship Finals as a whole (all 31 matches) and UEFA takes issue with the notion that matches in the group stages of the tournament, which do not even involve a national team from the United Kingdom, can somehow be considered as events of “major importance” for UK society.

    Euro 2008—ambush marketers find holes in fan zone
    Euro 2008 could not escape from ambush marketing. Although, as the tournament was worth an estimated two billion Swiss francs in media rights, tickets and sponsorship from Carlsberg, MasterCard and Adidas amongst others, the Union of European Football Associations (UEFA) did its utmost to prevent it from occurring. This article examines the steps taken by UEFA to safeguard its investments and combat ambush marketing.

    Entertainment & Media

    Gambling Commission FAQs on reverse auctions—distinguishing prize competitions from lotteries
    The Gambling Commission has published guidance in the form of frequently asked questions (FAQs) on reverse auctions, setting out how it will determine whether a reverse auction is lawful under the Gambling Act 2005.

    Band formation, ownership of songs and partnership
    On 6 June 2008, in Kiley McPhail (aka Kiley Fitzgerald) v James Bourne[2008] EWHC 1235, the English High court upheld a settlement agreement resolving a dispute between the original members of the band Busted over the ownership of the rights in six songs. This article summarises the decision.

    Advertising & Marketing

    Regulation of unfair commercial practices in advertising—BCAP consultation and changes to CAP Code
    Following the implementation of the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (2005/29/EC) in the United Kingdom on 26 May 2008 by the Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations 2008 (CPRs), the Advertising Code of the Committee of Advertising Practice (CAP) has been revised to take into account the new Regulations. Now, the Broadcast Committee of Advertising Practice (BCAP) is consulting on its proposals to bring the BCAP TV and Radio Advertising Standards Codes into line with the CPRs. This article examines the proposed changes.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 51

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 51

    June, 2008

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In Depth

    Trade Marks

    The bubble bursts for O2
    In the recent European Court of Justice (ECJ) decision in O2 Holdings Limited and O2 (UK) Ltd v Hutchinson 3G UK Limited [2008] C-533/06, the ECJ has provided new guidance on the use of competitors’ trade marks in comparative advertising. Amanda Easey, an Associate in the London office of McDermott Will & Emery, outlines the decision.

    The knives are out—Sabatier composite trade marks
    In Rousselon Freres et cie v Horwood Homewares Ltd [2008] EWHC 881 (Ch), Mr Justice Warren has given a long and considered judgment on the assessment of the likelihood of confusion between an earlier trade mark and a later registered composite trade mark containing that earlier mark.

    The likelihood of confusion and EU languages
    In Redcats SA v OHIM, [2008] T-246/06, the Court of First Instance has dismissed a French company’s attempts to argue that a Community trade mark application should be compared at a phonetic and conceptual level by reference only to the language in which registration was made and not in light of the language of any earlier trade mark. The judgment sets out the steps required when comparing trade marks containing different Community languages.

    Patents

    High Court tells Patent Office to think again on “mental acts”
    In its decision in Kapur v Comptroller-General of Patents [2008] EWHC 649 (Pat), the High Court of England and Wales has given a narrow interpretation to the mental acts exclusion from patentability in respect of a claimed method for preserving documents which have been deleted or overwritten.

    Copyrights

    Software ownership
    On 9 April 2008, the UK Court of Appeal handed down its decision in Laurence Wrenn v Stephen Landamore [2008] EWCA Civ 496. Mr Wrenn’s appeal was dismissed and he was held liable to pay Mr Landamore royalties for his work. Mr Wrenn was also precluded from pursuing his copyright claim.

    Confidential Information

    NICE drug appraisal process and procedural unfairness
    In this recent decision, the UK Court of Appeal has ordered the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) to allow pharmaceutical manufacturers access to information on the decision making process regarding recommendations for the prescription of the Alzheimer’s drug ARICEPT. This article examines the Court’s decision and, in particular, the Court’s analysis of whether NICE could restrict access to the information on the grounds of confidentiality.

    Data Protection

    New powers for Information Commissioner’s Office to fine for data protection breaches
    The Criminal Justice and Immigration Act received Royal Assent on 8 May 2008. This article examines the new legislation and sets out the new powers of the Information Commissioner’s Office to impose substantial fines on organisations that deliberately or recklessly commit serious breaches of the Data Protection Act 1998.

    Communications and New Media

    Communications data retention—internet access, IP telephony and email
    The UK Government’s proposal for a Communications Data Bill was announced on 14 May 2008. This article examines the Bill that is intended to transpose the remaining provisions of Directive 2006/24/EC on the retention of communications data into UK law.

    Commercial

    Unfair commercial practices and misleading and comparative advertising
    This article examines the new Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations (CPRs) and the Business Protection from Misleading Marketing Regulations (BPRs) that came into force in the United Kingdom on 26 May.

    Sport

    Sport White Paper: Parliament, specificity of sport and the FIFA 6+5 rule
    The European Parliament has adopted a White Paper on Sport in response to the Commission’s 2007 White Paper on Sport. This article outlines the main issues raised by the Parliament.

    Domain Names

    myspace.co.uk: not abusive, just lucky
    The Nominet Appeal Panel has ruled in Myspace Inc v Total Web Solutions Ltd (DRS 04962) [2008] that the myspace.co.uk domain name registered by Total Web Solutions does not have to be transferred to MySpace Inc. This article analyses the decision.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 50

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 50

    May, 2008

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In Depth

    Patents

    Sufficiency—when is a product a product (Biogen v Medeva revisited)?

    InH Lundbeck A/S v Generics (UK) Ltd and ors [2008] EWCA Civ 311 (10 April 2008), the Court of Appeal handed down an important judgment concerning patent sufficiency. This article reviews the Court’s decision.

    Designs

    Dryer spiky balls—novelty and the relevant sector

    In Green Lane Products Ltd v PMS International Group plc [2008] EWCA Civ 358 (23 April 2008), the English High Court has clarified that the correct “audience” or “sector” for determining novelty in a design is the sector of the alleged prior art and not the sector for which the design was registered.

    Trade Marks

    Likelihood of confusion, the availability requirement and the mere embellishment defence

    In Case C-102/07 Adidas AG v Marca Mode 10 April 2008 (unreported), the European Court of Justice, following a reference from the Supreme Court of the Netherlands, has found that the requirement of availability of certain signs for use by competitors is not one of the relevant factors to be taken into account in the assessment of the likelihood of confusion in trade mark cases. This ruling has effectively curtailed the so called embellishment defence—that the sign consisted of something that was perhaps a decoration and therefore not inherently distinctive— that defendants have sought to rely on in trade mark infringement cases.

    Copyrights

    Format shifting exception—industry response

    The Music Business Group (MBG) has taken exception to how the UK Government plans to “take forward” the Gowers recommendation to introduce a private copying exception to copyright infringement that would allow consumers to format shift music for use on different devices. This article examines the MBG’s position.

    E-Commerce

    EU study and recommendations on the regulation of video games

    The European Commission has published a Communication on the protection of consumers, in particular minors, in respect of the use of video games. This article reviews the Communication, in which the Commission has set out its expectations in respect of the video games industry and the duty of public authorities in EU Member States to improve upon existing measures protecting minors from harmful video games distributed in the European Union.

    File sharing and ISP responsibility

    This article examines the ongoing debate over whether to mandate internet service provider responsibility for preventing online file sharing that breaches copyright.

    Unfair contract terms—National Consumer Council survey and findings

    The National Consumer Council (NCC) has continued its campaign against onerous terms in IT and user licence agreements (EULAs) with the publication of its findings following a survey conducted last year into B2C software supply. The findings of the NCC are summarised in this article.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 49

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 49

    April, 2008

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In Depth

    Patents

    The London Agreement

    The London Agreement will enter into force on 1 May 2008 and will apply to all patents granted after that date. This article examines the effect of the Agreement in respect of the translation process under the European Patent Convention.
    Symbian – more hope for patentability of computer program inventions

    On 18 March 2008, the English High Court allowed the appeal in Symbian Ltd v Comptroller-General of Patents [2008] EWHC 518 (Pat) from the decision of the UK Intellectual Property Office refusing the grant of a patent on the grounds that the claims related to a program for a computer and therefore were unpatentable. This is a pivotal decision which provides a glimmer of hope for companies developing new technology which has a computer program(s) at its core.

    Designs

    Choos and handbags – no such thing as innocent infringement of design right in Europe?

    The English High Court’s decision in J Choo (Jersey) Ltd v Towerstone Ltd [2008] EWHC 346 (16 January 2008) heralds the possibility of strengthened protection for handbag and shoe designs and similar accessory items under Community registered design (CRD) legislation. Granting summary judgment to Jimmy Choo, Mr Justice Floyd denied the “innocent infringer defence” to CRDs, thereby providing a clear advantage in having a CRD as opposed to a UK registered design.

    E-Commerce

    maestro.co.uk – no evidence, no transfer

    In a rare appeal of the Nominet Appeal Panel, Maestro has failed in its bid to have the domain name maestro.co.uk transferred to its stable of existing domain names. The Appeal Panel rejected Maestro’s arguments regarding abusive registration and, in doing so, emphasised that regardless of how well-known a brand may be, complaints filed with Nominet must be supported by evidence.

    ISP data “pimping” – Phorm under fire over privacy concerns for targeted advertising technology

    Three of the UK’s top internet service providers are considering deploying technology that would enable them to track users’ browsing data and provide this information to advertisers via an exchange platform in return for a share of revenue. The effect of the technology being that users visiting certain websites would be targeted with relevant advertisements based on their previous browsing activity. This article reviews the legality of this technology and discusses its potential impact.

    Commercial Transactions

    Construction of contractual terms – private dictionary principle

    On 12 March 2008, in Chartbrook Ltd v Persimmon Homes Ltd [2008] EWCA Civ 183, the English Court of Appeal rejected an appeal from a decision of Mr Justice Briggs in a dispute over the construction of a term relating to the price under a development agreement. In its decision, the Court analysed the so-called “private dictionary” exception, whereby the meaning of a contractual term may be determined from prior negotiations, where the words or phrase in issue are not defined in the contract.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 48

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 48

    March, 2008

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In Depth

    Trade Marks

    European Court of Justice grants protection to registered designation of origin Parmigiano Reggiano

    On 28 February 2008, the European Court of Justice (ECJ) ruled in European Commission v Federal Republic of Germany C-132/05 that protection granted to Parmigiano Reggiano extends to the word “Parmesan”. Francesco Mattina, a Partner in the Rome office of McDermott Will & Emery, outlines the decision.

    MySpace.co.uk—Use or abuse?

    In a Nominet Dispute Resolution Service decision, MySpace Inc., the US company behind the famous social networking website, has won the right to the domain name myspace.co.uk despite the domain name having been registered by another company six years prior to MySpace starting its business. Rohan Massey, a Partner in the London office of McDermott Will & Emery, outlines the decision.

    Budweiser should have been wiser

    In Budejovicky Budvar Narodni Podnik v Anheuser-Busch Inc [2008] EWHC 263(Ch), the English High Court has confirmed that the critical date for determination of statutory acquiescence by the proprietor of an earlier trade mark to the use of a later identical mark, is the date of registration of the mark.

    Branding and parallel importations: further guidance from the Court of Appeal

    In Boehringer Ingelheim v Swingward Limited, the Court of Appeal has given further guidance on parallel importation and trade mark infringement. The Court ruled that until co-branding or re-boxing of pharmaceutical products results in actual damage to the trade mark or the reputation held in the trade mark, the owners of the mark cannot stop parallel importations of their products. Moreover, the assessment of damage is essentially a question of fact to be determined on the basis of evidence provided by the trade mark owner. The mere act of re-branding and re-boxing by the parallel importer is not in itself sufficient to cause damage to the reputation held in the trade mark.

    Media & Sports

    Ricky “Hitman” Hatton out-punched by Frank Warren

    On 20 December 2007, the English High Court delivered its judgment in an interim application filed in the case Frank Warren v The Random House Group Ltd [2007] EWHC 3062 (QB). The Court used legal principles to reinforce case management practices by ensuring that it restricted itself to the real matters at issue between the parties.

    Competition & Commerce

    Caution for competition defence

    In The Football Association Premier League Limited & Others v LCD Publishing Limited [2007] EWHC 3171 (CH), the English High Court refused to allow an interim application to strike out an incomplete competition defence against the claims of copyright and trade mark infringement.

    Confidentiality or disclosure—who is a better mate for competition and fair play?

    In the case of Varec SA v Belgium, Diehl Remschied GmbH & Co intervening [2008] C-450/06, the European Court of Justice held that the relevant Council Directives had to be interpreted in such a way that the organisation responsible for the appraisal of decisions regarding contract award procedures had to guarantee the preservation of confidentiality and business secrecy of information communicated to it by the parties to an action. This is the case even though it might evaluate such information and deliberate upon it.

    Patents

    The BlackBerry struggle

    In the recent case of Research In Motion UK Ltd v Visto Corp., [2008] EWHC 335 (Pat), the English High Court considered Research In Motion’s claim for revocation and non-infringement relating to a patent held by Visto. The court ruled that the patent was not valid, but would have been infringed if valid.

    Legislation News

    • Proposed changes to copyright law
    • UK Government reveals plan for creative industries
    • Illegal downloaders to face UK broadband ban
    • Term extension for the protection of performances and sound recordings—European developments
    • Copyright in Sound Recordings and Performers’ Rights (Term Extension) Bill 2007-08
    • Future of European-wide music licences for online exploitation—Commission publishes summary report and list of contributions to monitoring
    • The Advertising Standard Authority (ASA) says that gambling advertisements are a safe bet
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights