Taxation of Stock Options Granted to Expats
By Dr. Gero Burwitz
The secondment of employees from U.S. parent companies to German subsidiaries or branches is a well-established tool to enhance cooperation between the offices and promote the exchange of knowledge, experience and cultural understanding. However, the tax issues raised by secondment must be considered carefully. At the level of the parent organization, the formation of a permanent establishment should be avoided. The costs related to the expatriate employees’ functions must be allocated for tax purposes between parent and subsidiary, and this allocation is a crucial issue often challenged by fiscal authorities. The expatriate often receives an attractive package including a top executive compensation (possibly combined with a tax-equalization clause), fringe benefits, payroll slit-models and continued participation in the various plans set up by the employer (deferred compensation, pension, stock options, restricted stock units, etc.)
The taxation of stock options granted before the secondment but exercised in Germany, and the taxation of stock options granted during the secondment in Germany but exercised after the return to the United States, often is addressed during tax audits. On September 14, 2006, the German Federal Ministry of Finance issued a decree that addresses this topic and is being applied to the upcoming tax audits. The taxation of stock options is a crucial issue for employers, because they must withhold wage tax on behalf of the employee on every taxable pecuniary benefit, and are liable if they do not do so.
The decree qualifies the pecuniary benefit derived from a grant of option rights for the acquisition of shares as income from employment. Therefore, the tax rate applied to the benefit is the same individual rate as that applied to any other income from employment. As a consequence, the flat rate for income from capital will not be applied to this pecuniary benefit starting in 2009. Income an employee earns from holding the shares after exercising the option or from the subsequent disposal of the shares, is assessed separately, using the rules for income from capital.
For tax purposes, a distinction must be made between tradable and non-tradable options. An option is tradable if it is traded at a stock exchange. For this delimitation, it is irrelevant whether the option is assignable or transferable by succession, or whether it is subject to a period of non-negotiability under the option terms and conditions. The option can be granted by the employer directly or by an affiliated undertaking. What is decisive is that the grant by the third party constitutes a wage for the employee in consideration for his or her services to the employer, and, from the grantor’s point of view, is rendered in connection with said employment.
If an option is tradable, a pecuniary benefit accrues to the employee already, by virtue of the grant of the option. Because this option usually is granted as remuneration for services rendered in the past, the pecuniary benefit must be classified according to the circumstances of the period for which the option is granted. If during this period the employee was resident in the United States, the pecuniary benefit may be exempt from German taxation pro rata temporis in accordance with the German U.S. Double Taxation Convention, which states that income from employment is taxable in the state where the services are rendered. However, the tax-exempt income is taken into account to determine the progressive tax rate on the income taxable in Germany, according to the exemption with progression rule.
If an employee is granted a non-tradable option to later acquire shares at a specific acquisition price, this constitutes only the grant of an opportunity. The beneficiary does not accrue a pecuniary benefit until the option is exercised and the quoted price of the shares exceeds the acquisition price. The point in time when the employee is first eligible to exercise the option is non-decisive in this regard. The pecuniary benefit is calculated as the difference between the quoted price upon actual exercise and the exercise price paid by the employee.
A non-tradable option usually is not granted to compensate services rendered in the past, but rather to create an additional motivation for the future. It therefore constitutes remuneration for the period between the grant and the time when it first is possible to exercise the option. If the income earned by the employee in that period is tax-exempt in Germany under the Double Taxation Convention because the services are rendered abroad, the pecuniary benefit accrued upon actual exercise of the option must be apportioned to the period between the grant of the option and the time when exercise is first possible, and must be exempt pro rata temporis. The “exemption with progression rule” is applicable to determine the progressive tax rate on the income taxable in Germany.
The Future of Competing Tender Offers in Germany
By Dr. Patrick Nordhues
Competing tender offers are parallel offers by independent bidders to the same target company. Although competing tender offers are common in other regions, they are rarely seen in Germany. The failed takeover of stock-listed Techem AG in 2006 was the first bidder competition under the German Securities acquisition and Takeover Act, or Wertpapiererwerbs- und Übernahmegesetzes (WpÜG).
The high transaction volumes at a takeover of a publicly listed corporation might prevent potential bidders from entering a bidding competition. However, such reluctance might be diminished by the increased funds raised by private equity firms and their increasing activity in the sector of stock-listed companies. In the past year, the press has reported several attempts by private equity investors to take over Continental AG. As a result, competing offers might be seen more frequently.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Competing Tender Offers
Usually, competing tender offers result in higher offer prices for the shareholders. The quoted takeover of Techem led to a final offer price of €55 per share, compared to an initial price of €44 per share. However, bidding competition also has several disadvantages, particularly for the target company. For example, the takeover process consumes a substantial portion of existing management resources. Under the WpÜG, the management and supervisory board of the target company must issue a thorough statement on the offer. This statement must include an opinion on the fairness of the offered price and must be renewed after each increase in the offer price.
Another disadvantage is that contractual partners and banks will await the result of the takeover and the completion of a new shareholder structure before making substantial investments in the target company or granting credit. As a result, the management will endeavor to end the pending phase of a takeover process as soon as possible. Competing offers increase this pending phase, since the WpÜG does not contain any provision regarding the maximum term of a takeover process in case of competing offers.
WpÜG Provisions Regarding Competing Tender Offers
The only WpÜG provision for competing tender offers states that the target company shall not be impaired in its business operations. However, each amendment to a tender offer (e.g., an increase in the offer price) results in an extended offer period for the relevant tender offer and also for the competing offer, to balance out the offers. In theory, tender offers could be extended ad infinitum, which is, of course, not acceptable for the target company. Therefore, some scholars in Germany argue that a bidder should be able to increase the offer price only once. The British Takeover Code resolves such dilemma by the so-called “guillotine”—the Takeover Panel may impose a final time limit for announcing revisions to competing offers.
BaFin Intervention
Under German law, it may be possible for the German Federal Financial Supervisory Authority, or Bundesanstalt für Finanzdienstleistungsaufsicht (BaFin), to intervene in the case of extensive competing offers. In general, the BaFin may prohibit a tender offer that causes damage to the target company. In such cases, the BaFin has broad discretionary power. It may even be possible for the BaFin to recommend and enforce an auction process such as that set forth in the British Takeover Code.
Such an auction process might be more appropriate than a total prohibition of further increases in the offer prices. A balance between the interests of the bidder, the target company and the shareholders is possible, and the target company is freed from the restrictions of a current takeover process. In addition, the shareholders receive a higher price for their shares than they would under a prohibition of further increases in the offer price, and they also receive an appropriate term to decide on the acceptance of the offer. However, such an order by BaFin remains without legal basis in Germany so far.
Conclusions
Competing tender offers cause problems for the target company, and these problems are insufficiently governed by the WpÜG. Because of the incomplete provisions regarding competing takeover offers, it would be advisable for the BaFin to issue certain guidelines. Alternatively, the legislator could enact an auction process similar to the British example. As a result of the increasing activity of private equity investors in the public sector, such a provision could become relevant very soon.
“Second Basket” of German Copyright Reform Closes Loophole on File-Sharing, Frees Treasures from Studios’ Archives
By Ralf Weisser
In July 2007, the Lower House of German Federal Parliament (Bundestag) passed a long-awaited bill to amend the German Copyright Act. Following the approval by the Upper House in late September 2007, the new law became effective January 1, 2008. The bill, known as the “Second Basket” of copyright reform, is a follow-up to an earlier Copyright Act amendment that went into effect in September 2003. This “First Basket” transferred mandatory provisions of the European Copyright Directive (2001/29/EC) and the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) Performances and Phonograms Treaty (WPPT) into German law. The “Second Basket” addresses several controversial issues that initially were put on hold in order to meet the deadlines set by the Copyright Directive and the WPPT. Among other actions, the bill readjusts the Copyright Act’s fair use provisions, provides for a new scheme of statutory remuneration of copyright owners and lifts the ban of the transfer of rights in unknown exploitation methods.
Readjustment of Fair Use Provisions
The new law aligns the Copyright Act’s fair use provisions with the requirements of the digital age. Most importantly, it closes a loophole regarding the reproduction of copyright-protected works for private use. Previously, Section 53 of the Copyright Act permitted reproductions of a work to be made for private use, provided that the original was not obviously produced unlawfully. As a consequence, the downloading of music or films from peer-to-peer file-sharing platforms—which under German law constitutes a reproduction of the work—generally was permissible, because in the majority of cases the original was not produced unlawfully (even though it was made available to the public unlawfully). The reproduction of a work from an original unlawfully made available to the public now also excludes the application of the fair use provision.
New Scheme of Statutory Remuneration
The new law also provides for a new scheme to compensate copyright owners for copies made under the fair use provisions of the Copyright Act. In principle, copyright owners (acting through their industry’s collecting societies) may claim an adequate compensation for fair use copies from the manufacturers of copying devices and storage media (such as hard drives, memory sticks or blank DVDs). Previously, the amount of compensation was determined in a detailed attachment to the Copyright Act, which proved to be rather inflexible in the face of rapid technological change. After the reform, the amount of compensation will be negotiated between the collecting societies and the manufacturers directly, allowing a more effective remuneration scheme.
Transfer of Rights in Unknown Exploitation Methods
When the German Copyright Act first was enacted in 1965, it included a provision prohibiting the transfer of rights in unknown exploitation methods. Originally intended to protect authors from “selling” all rights in their works across the board, this provision now in many cases impedes the digital exploitation of films and musical works. Since the rights in many works originally were granted only for the analogue exploitation methods known at that time, the rights for digital exploitation (e.g., via DVD, IPTV or mobile TV) now must be renegotiated with the authors or, more frequently, with their heirs. In many cases this has proved to be extremely difficult, particularly with respect to co-authored works, such as films. The new law principally allows the transfer of rights in unknown exploitation methods. With respect to existing contracts, it provides for a transitional arrangement. According to this arrangement, the rights in unknown exploitation methods are deemed also to have been transferred if all relevant exploitation rights known at the time were assigned to another party without any territorial or time limitation. The author of the work may, however, object to such transfer of rights within certain time limits. The author is entitled to a fair and equitable consideration for the exploitation of his or her work. It is expected that this provision will free many digitally unexploited cinematic treasures from film studios’ archives. This bill is a major improvement to the German Copyright Act, allowing it to meet the challenges of the digital age.
Proposed Control of Foreign Investment in German Companies
Despite significant criticism from German economy and industry leaders, the German Federal Government currently plans to enlarge the possibilities of controlling and prohibiting foreign investments in German companies in order to protect “public security and order.” The present legal situation in Germany allows restrictions of transactions, especially in the arms industry and the field of encryption technology. A foreign investor that wishes to acquire more than 25 percent of the shares in an arms or encryption manufacturer is obliged to notify the German Federal Ministry of Economics and Technology (FME) of the intended investment. The FME may interdict the proposed transaction within one month.
Pursuant to the recent German Federal Government’s proposal to amend the German Foreign Trade and Payments Act (Außenwirtschaftsgesetz) as well as the related directive (Verordnung zur Durchführung des Außenwirtschaftsgesetzes), the FME may examine any investment leading to a shareholding of at least 25 percent in a German company by a foreigner or a foreign company, or by a company with a foreign shareholding of at least 25 percent. Contrary to the origin of the discussion, the FME’s right to examine or prohibit such transactions shall not be limited to investments by public funds, but extend to all foreign investors and all sectors. After having examined the proposed investment, the FME may authorize it, authorize it under conditions or even prohibit it, provided that that “public security and order” require such measures. The period of time in which the FME may commence its examinations shall be limited to three months from signing or the publication of the resolution concerning the offer, or the acquisition of control.
Under the proposed amendment, however, the foreign investor shall no longer be obliged to notify the FME of the intended investment. The draft act does not yet establish criteria for when “public security and order” shall be deemed to be in danger of being breached. Also, by equally extending to foreign investors resident in the European Union, the draft act raises concerns regarding compliance with European law and is currently being reviewed by the European Commission.
As a result, future share purchase or swap agreements concerning a shareholding being possibly precarious with respect to the (amended) German Foreign Trade and Payments Act may be concluded on the condition subsequent of an interdiction by the FME. Thus, such agreements may become retroactively invalid upon interdiction by the FME. This provision shall motivate foreign investors to notify the FME of their intended investments—even if they are not obliged to do so—in order to abbreviate the time of legal insecurity from three months to only one month. If an investment is prohibited by the FME, the transaction will need to be reprocessed. If this is not possible, as in the case of a stock market transaction, the shares shall be sold by force. Because of the legal insecurity, it will be advisable to ask the FME at an early stage of the transaction, at least before signing, to provide a document of compliance of the intended transaction with the provisions of the (amended) German Foreign Trade and Payments Act.
McDermott News from Germany
Dr. Stephan Brandes recently joined the Munich office as a partner in the corporate law and mergers and acquisitions (M&A) practice. His main focus is on stock corporation law and corporate restructuring. In particular, he has specific experience with European corporate law, and is also well-versed in M&A transactions, capital markets, insolvency and insurance matters. Stephan previously worked for Sherman & Sterling.
In February 2008, Paul Melot de Beauregard will transfer from the Düsseldorf office to launch the employment practice in the Munich office. His practice covers the entire spectrum of national and international labor and employment law. His special focus is on restructuring, close-downs, transactions and negotiations with works councils. Additionally, he also advises on service agreements with board members, managing directors and senior executives as well as on pensions and outsourcing.
Decryption of Premier League matches with imported decoder cards: is there a competition defence?
In Football Association (FA) v QC Leisure & Others [2008] EWHC 44 (Ch), Mr Justice Barling dismissed the FA’s application for summary judgment. The Defendants were importing and selling non-UK decoder cards, which allow access to Premier League football matches, despite the fact that this was explicitly forbidden by the Defendants’ contract with the FA. The Defendants relied on Article 81 of the EC Treaty. Barling J. did not accept the FA’s submission that this defence had no prospect of success at trial and refused to enter summary judgment.
Privacy v Copyright—the dispute continues
In the case of Productores de Música de España (Promusicae) v Telefónica de España SAU (Telefónica)[2008] (C-275/06), the European Court of Justice ruled that the exclusion of communication of personal traffic data by Member States for the purposes of initiating civil proceedings against copyright infringement was compatible with EC law.
Media
Defamation in the media: Reynolds privilege
On 23 November 2007, in Malik v Newspost Ltd & Others [2007] EWHC 3063 (QB) Eady J. decided as a preliminary issue that certain reporting by the Dewsbury Press could not rely on the defence of “qualified privilege”. In so doing, he stated that although the well-known Reynoldsmedia defence did not apply, there was still a possible defence of privilege, provided that safeguards had been taken by the newspaper.
Defamation v Freedom of Expression
In the recent case of Edward Seaga v Leslie Harper [2008] UKPC 9, the Privy Council has upheld the decision of the Court of Appeal of Jamaica in dismissing qualified privilege as defence to defamatory statements published in the media on the basis of the test outlined by the House of Lords in Reynolds v Times Newspapers Ltd.
Trade Marks
No confusion over IKEA and IDEA
The Court of First Instance (CFI) has dismissed an application for annulment of the trade mark IDEA in Inter-Ikea Systems BV (IKEA Systems) v the Office for Harmonisation in the Internal Market (OHIM). IKEA had objected to the registration of the mark on the basis of its earlier rights to the IKEA trade marks. However, the CFI found that there was no similarity and no likelihood of confusion between the IKEA marks and the IDEA mark even used in relation to identical goods.
The Court of Appeal overturns Eli Lilly’s interim injunction
On 5 February 2008, the Court of Appeal confirmed that the criterion for establishing trade mark infringement in cases involving importation and/or transhipment is whether or not there is an interference with the owner’s right of first marketing within the European Union.
Patents
Improved Search Interface is a computer programme “as such” In Autonomy Corporation Limited v The Comptroller General of Patents, Trade Marks and Designs [2008] EWHC 146 (Pat), the Comptroller successfully resisted a patent application for a method to improve the search interface between a user and a computer, on the ground that it consisted of a presentation of information and a computer program “as such”.
M-Systems v Trek: Issue estoppel in patent litigation and the future of post-grant amendments
In his recent decision in M-Systems Flash Disk Pioneers Ltd v Trek 2000 International Ltd & Anor [2008] EWHC 102 (Pat), Kitchin J. held that a foreign judgment in a case involving the same parties and the same patent will not operate as an issue estoppel between those parties in UK proceedings.
Commercial & Confidential Transactions
Database right and duties of fidelity can be useful alternatives to an action in breach of confidence
The decision in Crowson Fabrics Ltd v Paul Rider, Warren Stimson and Concept Textiles Limited [2007] EWHC 2942 (Ch) addresses the relationship between ex-employer and ex-employees, the duties of confidentiality, fiduciary, fidelity and the database right.
Legislation News
Pharmaceutical sector under European Commission Scanner
Copyright exceptions—Consultation on the recommendations of the Gowers Review
Google-Doubleclick merger will not involve the merger of the two companies’ databases
How legal are football broadcasts in pubs? Karen Murphy v Media Protection Services Limited [2007] EWHC 3091 (Admin) is an English High Court appeal against a decision of the Portsmouth Crown Court which held that the Appellant had committed an offence under Section 297(1) of the Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988. The offence was dishonestly receiving a programme included in a broadcasting service provided from a place in the United Kingdom, with the intent to avoid payment of any charge applicable to the reception of the programme. The High Court upheld the Crown Court’s decision and maintained that the Respondent had the exclusive rights to screen the football matches in question in the UK.
SIAE labels against counterfeit CDs: is Italy facing the end of an era?
In response to the reference for a preliminary ruling made by Karl Josef Wilhelm Schwibbert (C-20/05), the European Court of Justice affirmed that the mandatory requirement in Italian copyright law, whereby a distinctive sign to be affixed to any medium containing a copyright protected work, constitutes a “technical regulation” within the meaning of Article 1 of Directive 98/34. Consequently, not providing the necessary notification to the European Commission would prevent SIAE, the Italian collecting society responsible of the sign, from taking action against individuals who failed to apply it.
Trade Marks
No infringement arises from the use of a trade mark within a computer system
In Rx Works Ltd v Hunter [2007] EWHC 3061, the use of the term “vet.local” as an internal name for a folder, or as a local domain name within specialist computer software, did not infringe the trade mark “vet.local”, registered in classes 9, 16, 41 and 42 for computer software, hardware and firmware, because the uses at issue did not and/or were not liable to affect the functions of the mark.
Distinctiveness of wind turbines
In Enercon GmbH v Office for Harmonisation in the Internal Market(Trade Marks and Designs) (OHIM) (Court of First Instance (Fifth Chamber), 15 November 2007, T-61/06), a manufacturer of wind turbines tried to obtain a trade mark on the three-dimensional shape of a wind turbine. OHIM rejected the application because of a lack of a distinctive character and the manufacturer appealed to the Court of First Instance.
Disguised drugs guilty of trade mark infringement
The English High Court has confirmed that trade mark infringement by importation can be established even if the goods have not been released into free circulation within the Community.
Patents
<>Final battle over 3G handsets? On 21 December 2007, the English High Court handed down a decision in the case Nokia Corporation v Interdigital Technology Corporationwhich concerned an action proposed by Nokia claiming that certain patents of Interdigital were not essential to the 3G telecommunications standard in Europe.
Litigation & Procedure
Monsanto v Cargill: Who picks up the final bill?
With rising expenses being incurred in conducting intellectual property litigation, apportionment of costs in patent litigation is becoming a significant issue. The judgement, by Pumfrey LJ in Monsanto v Cargill[2007] EWHC 3113 (Pat), lays down general principles that the Court should follow in deciding the issue of apportionment of costs amongst winning and losing parties.
Making patent decisions quick, cheap and yet reliable
On 16 November 2007, in the case of DLP Ltd, Re UK Intellectual Property Office Decision, [2007] EWHC 2669 (Pat), the English High Court dismissed an appeal against a decision of the UK Intellectual Property Office (UKIPO) on the question of an infringement under the new patent rules. The Court agreed that the Appellant had a right to an appeal, but this was only a right to a review of the decision made and not a right to a re-hearing.
Late Submission of Evidence to OHIM.
A party in opposition proceedings at the Office for Harmonisation in the Internal Market (OHIM) submitted evidence after the deadline. The Opposition Division rejected the evidence and the Board of Appeal agreed. However, the Court of First Instance has annulled the Board of Appeal’s decision.
Commercial & Confidential Transactions
Confidential information: a tool in competition The Commercial Division of the English High Court has upheld the decision of a single judge in restraining the Defendants from using the Claimants’ confidential information to gain an unfair competitive advantage by way of an injunction without notice to the Defendants.
E-Commerce
UK House of Lords rules that credit card issuers are jointly liable with foreign suppliers The House of Lords has, in a landmark decision, held that UK credit card issuers are jointly liable with foreign suppliers in breaches of contract and misrepresentation under Section 75 (1) of the Consumer Credit Act 1974. This liability is in relation to UK consumers who enter into transactions with foreign suppliers.
Legislation News
Final changes to Patents Act 2004
Companies Act 2006
European Media Law—Audiovisual Media Services Directive has come into force
News
European Commission—Communication on Creative Content Online in the Single Market
Technology to avoid disputes between search engines and newspapers—the ACAP project
Yeda v Rohne: House of Lords rule on patent entitlement
The House of Lords has clarified the rules relating to patent entitlement in the case of Yeda v Rohne [2007] UKHL 43. According to the ruling, where a person seeks joint entitlement to a patent, he merely has to prove his contribution to the inventive concept underlying the claimed invention. On the other hand, where he seeks to be substituted as the sole inventor, not only does he have to prove that he contributed to the inventive concept, but also that the inventor named in the patent has not made any contribution towards the inventive step. In its ruling, the Law Lords unanimously overturned the Markem v Zipher principle.
Sport & Media
The FA goodwill in “World Cup Willie” In Jules Rimet Cup Ltd v The Football Association [2007] EWHC 2376 (Ch), the Football Association successfully defended its interests in “World Cup Willie”, the mascot of the 1966 World Cup. In light of the residual goodwill associated with the mascot in the United Kingdom, the judge concluded that the applications by the Claimant to register two trade marks related to World Cup Willie were filed in bad faith.
Court of Appeal unbends “Bent Coppers” decision
The Court of Appeal overturned the decision of the High Court in the case Michael Charman v Orion Publishing Group Limited, Graeme McLagan [2007] EWCA Civ 972. In doing so, the Court agreed with the Defendants that, although the book had a defamatory meaning, the defence of qualified privilege applied.
Trade Marks
CFI speaks out for the pencil-shaped loudspeaker The Court of First Instance (CFI) annulled the decision of the First Board of Appeal of the Office for Harmonization in the Internal Market (OHIM) in Bang & Olufsen A/S v OHIM regarding an application for a three-dimensional mark for loudspeakers. The CFI laid down two important factors to determine the distinctive character of a trade mark according to Article 7(1)(b) of Council Regulation No. 40/94.
Squeeze Bottle Lacked Distinctive Character The European Court of Justice has confirmed that the distinctiveness criterion is crucial for the registration of a three-dimensional shape as a Community trade mark, even if it has already been registered nationally.
Designs
The informed user of air freshener In Procter & Gamble Co v Reckitt Benckiser (UK) Ltd [200] EWCA Civ 936, the Court of Appeal has confirmed that, in considering an allegation of breach of design right, the court should adopt the standpoint of an “informed user” who is more familiar with the product than the average consumer. This is the first case clarifying the scope of Registered Community Designs
Patents
How micro is a micro-emulsion?
The Court of Appeal has handed down its decision in the case Novartis (AG) v IVAX Pharmaceuticals UK Limited, which concerned an appeal lodged by Novartis against a decision declaring IVAX’s Equoral product, as not infringing Novartis’ UK patent.
Patent Amendments: discretion after trial
The Court of Appeal has handed down its judgment on the allowability of an amendment to a patent, refusing the final amendment requested, based not on an objection to the amendment itself, but on the consequences for future litigation.
Legislation News
Further changes to the Patents Act
European Community Accedes to International Design Treaty
Swiss Parliament ratifies WIPO Internet Treaties
Companies Act 2006 and Registration of a Company Name
News
DEFRA consultation—protection of Scotch whisky
€ 12 million administrative fine for illegal downloads in Italy
Gambling Commission—Position Paper on integrity in sports betting
EU web security—ENISA concerns over MySpace and other online social networks
A global assessment is necessary in QUICKY case
On 20 September 2007, in Société des Produits Nestlé SA v OHIM, Quick restaurants SA(Case C-193/06P), the European Court of Justice handed down its decision in respect of an appeal against the decision of the Court of First Instance in Case T-75/04.
Defensive trade mark series
Following, rejection of an opposition to a Community Trade Mark by the Opposition Division of OHIM, the Fourth Board of Appeal of OHIM and the Court of First Instance (“CFI”), the ECJ recently confirmed these decisions and upheld the registration of the Community Trade Mark in Il Ponte Finanziaria SpA v Office for Harmonisation of the Internal Market (Trade Marks and Designs) (OHIM) and F.M.G. Textiles Srl, C-234-06 P, (13 September 2007).
ECJ washes away an appeal for washing tablet
Lately, there have been a number of Community Trade Mark applications being made for the registration of figurative trade marks used for washing and cleaning products. Some can be registered while the others cannot, the basic principle is that a trade mark is that the figurative mark must be distinctive and the distinctiveness must be assessed on a global basis. Applying this principle, on 4 October 2007, the European Court of Justice dismissed the appeal in Henkel KGaA (Henkel) v Office of Harmonisation in the Internal Market (OHIM) involving a non-distinctive figurative mark.
Trade mark infringement by company name
In the recent case of Céline Sàrl v Céline SA, Case C-17/06, (11 September 2007), the ECJ answered the preliminary question from a French Court of Appeal as to whether or not use of a trade mark in a company’s name was infringing use under the Trade Mark Directive.
Is your Vogue old enough?
The Court of First Instance, in Advance Magazine Publishing Inc. v OHIM, Case T-481/04, held in favour of the applicant in respect of a case relating to opposition proceedings for a Community Trade Mark, when the applicant had not relied on an earlier international registration in an earlier appeal.
Copyright, Media & Entertainment
Curbing online piracy-rethinking strategy? On 4 October 2007, the U.S. District Court of Minnesota handed down its decision in the case of Capitol Records v Jammie Thomas Civil no. 06-1497 (MJD/RLE) (also known as RIAA v ). This was the first file sharing case filed by the music industry against an individual to go to trial. The Court found the defendant guilty of wilfully infringing copyrighted sound recordings and fined her $222,000 in damages.
What Price Stress?
On 25 June 2007, the High Court ruled that a Labour MP who had successfully sued a national newspaper for libel was not entitled to enhanced or ‘indemnity’ costs under the new Civil Procedure Rule (CPR) rule 36.14.
Commission clears BMG – Sony joint venture…again!
In July 2004, the European Commission authorised the creation of a joint venture between BMG and Sony, but in 2006 the Court of First Instance annulled the decision. Now three years later, and after a new notification from the parties, the Commission has announced the results of an ‘in-depth investigation’ confirming its initial decision to allow the transaction.
Legislation News
French Senate adopts London Agreement
The Enterprise Act 2002 (Disclosure of Information for Civil Proceedings etc.) Order 2007
The European Commission has sent a Statement of Objections to Rambus Inc., stating that its behaviour is in contravention of Article 82 of the EC Treaty as it amounts to an abuse of a dominant position. Rambus is alleged to have been charging unreasonable royalties for the use of certain patents subsequent to a “patent ambush”.
Nike European Operations Netherlands NV v Tomas Rosicky
In a recent English High Court decision, an interim injunction was granted pursuant to Article 31 of the European Jurisdiction Regulation 44/2001 in support of substantive proceedings to be commenced in the Netherlands.
Trade Marks(click the header at left to view all of the Trade Mark case notes)
esure’s computer mouse trapped for free riding
The English High Court has confirmed that the likelihood of confusion is not a requirement for the establishing that a trade mark takes unfair advantage of, or can be detrimental to, the reputation of an earlier mark.
O2lacks distinctiveness
On 6 July 2007, seven applications submitted by O2 Holdings LTD in respect of icons used for computer and mobile telephone screens were refused on appeal by the UK Trade Mark Registry. The applications were refused as being devoid of distinctive character.
Copyright & Design(click the header at left to view all of the Copyright & Design case notes)
Good news for illegal file sharers?
The Attorney General has recommended, in Productores de Música de España Promusicae v Telefónica de España SAU (C-275/06), that the European Court of Justice should rule that ISPs are not allowed to disclose the personal details of suspected file sharers.
ISP ordered to police internet traffic for copyright infringement
In an unprecedented and surprising decision, the Belgian Tribunal de Première Instance has ordered the internet service provider, Scarlet, to filter all internet traffic for music files that are protected by copyright owned by companies and individuals represented by SABAM. The case, SABAM v Scarlet (formerly Tiscali), has sent shock waves through the ISP community, but has been celebrated as a success by the music rights sector.
The great balls of laundry design
The English High Court has ruled (as a preliminary issue) on what the relevant sector is when assessing novelty and individual character of a registered design.
Software as commissioned work: Who can use it and on what conditions?
In the case of Laurence John Wrenn v Stephen Landamore [2007] EWHC 1833 (Ch), the English High Court held that, where a computer program has been written as a commissioned work, the commissioner will be entitled only to an exclusive licence rather than an assignment. The programmer will be entitled to reasonable royalties.
Privacy in public appearances: no ‘press-free zone’ for children of celebrities
A picture of the two year old child of celebrity parents was taken in an Edinburgh street and published in a magazine. Despite objections raised by the parents, the English High Court ruled that the action of taking the picture did not constitute a breach of the right for respect of private and family life.
Privacy right versus public interest
In T (By Her Litigation Friend The Official Solicitor) v British Broadcasting Corporation [2007] EWHC 1683 (QB), the High Court had to balance the privacy rights of a mother, under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights, against the right of freedom of expression of the BBC under Art. 10 of the Convention.
Responsible journalism and the reportage defence
In Christopher Roberts, Barry Roberts v Gerry Gable, Steve Silver and Searchlight Magazine Ltd [2007] EWCA Civ 721, the Defendants published a magazine that contained an article in which the appellants were accused of various crimes. The Appellants sued the magazine, its editor and the article’s author for libel. The Defendants successfully invoked the reportage defence.
Procedure(click the header at left to view all of the Procedure case notes)
To disclose or not to disclose: is that the question?
In a recent appeal for further disclosure in Nichia Corp v Argos Ltd[2007] EWCA Civ 741 (19 July 2007), the Court of Appeal asked the parties to agree a more limited scope of disclosure, or send the matter back to the Judge at first instance to review the case.
Global nature of IP rights does not affect English jurisdiction
In Crucial Music Corporation et al. v Klondyke Management AG et al. [2007] EWHC 1782 Ch., German and Swiss parties were sued for damages in England for breach of warranties given in an English contract for the transfer of intellectual property rights. The Defendants alleged that the global nature of the intellectual property rights prevented the Lugano Convention from being applied. The High Court held differently and confirmed the decision of Master Moncaster, which was under appeal.
Voice over Internet Protocol company voices concern over T- Mobile’s anti-competitive conduct.
In a ruling on an application for interim orders against T-Mobile (UK) Ltd, Truphone intended to launch a new telephone service using Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP) technology. However, T-Mobile had declined to activate Truphone’s numbers, rendering Truphone unable to launch its service. The Court granted interim orders against T-Mobile.
Arrow on target with its suit for non-infringement declaration
In the case of Arrow Generics Ltd v Merck & Co., Kitchin J held that the Court has a jurisdiction to grant negative declarations. However, such relief is merely discretionary, and the grant should serve a useful purpose. Moreover, the relief sought should be clearly defined to make it properly justiciable, and there should not be any exceptional circumstances that could deprive the Court from exercising its jurisdiction from granting such a relief.
PennWell Publishing v Isles: Who owns the contact list—employer or employee? In the case of PennWell Publishing (UK) Limited v Isles and others [2007] ALL ER (D) 180, the Court held that an address list contained in any e-mail system, compiled by an employee, belongs to the employer. Andrew Sharples, a European Patent Attorney in the London office of McDermott Will & Emery, outlines the decision.
Copyright & Design
Imported flashing novelty badges found to infringe
Unauthorised copies of badges produced by the Claimant were reproduced and imported from China by the Defendant. The Defendant rejected the allegation of copyright infringement on the basis of s. 51(1) of the Copyright Designs and Patents Act.
Patents
Are gaming systems patentable subject matter?
The recent case of IGT v The Comptroller General of Patents [2007] EWHC 1341 (Pat) concerns an appeal against a decision of the Comptroller-General of Patents who refused collectively four patent applications relating to gaming systems. Applying the Aerotel four-step test, the patents were excluded from patentability as they fell within the excluded subject matter and were devoid of any technical contribution.
Can foreign and international laws affect domestic patent cases? Pozzoli Spa v BDMO SA and Moulage Industriel de Perseigne SA [2007] EWCA Civ 588 led to an interesting decision that raises the possibility of invoking international agreements, such as the WTO-TRIPS Agreement, to manage domestic court procedure. Pozzoli appealed against a decision of the Chancery Division and claimed that, because of the relevant provisions in Article 32, TRIPS Agreement, an appeal should be granted with a full judicial hearing on the merits of the case. The appeal was granted on other grounds, but the trial judge’s findings of obviousness and non-infringement remain untouched.
Trade Marks
Limonchelo v Limoncello: A sour taste for Shaker
On 12 June 2007, the ECJ confirmed in OHIM v Shaker di L. Laudato & C. Sas [Case C-334/05], that the likelihood of confusion between a word mark and a complex word and figurative mark should be globally assessed, taking into account all the visual, phonetic and conceptual elements of the marks at issue.
Comparative advertisement and freedom of expression
In its recent decision in Boehringer Ingelheim Limited & Ors v Vetplus Limited [2007] EWCA Civ. 583, the Court of Appeal considered the overlap between trade mark infringement, comparative advertising and the right to freedom of expression.
Media & Competition
European Commission probes the anticompetitive nature of international collecting societies
The European Commission invited interested third parties to comment on the commitments proposed by the International Confederation of Societies of Authors and Composers and 18 European Economic Area collecting societies in response to the Commission’s Statement of Objections of January 2006. The Commission is concerned that certain clauses in the collecting societies’ agreements may contain anticompetitive elements.
Procedure
Allowing concurrent patent proceedings: when does business get a stay?
In Glaxo v Genentech [2007] EWHC 1416, the High Court has handed down judgment allowing proceedings in the English courts to proceed to trial in parallel with concurrent proceedings in the European Patent Office. This case distinguished the traditional rules of the English courts with respect to staying concurrent proceedings on the basis that the action concerned questions of patent validity.
Legal News
US Court of Appeals moves towards limiting ISP immunity
In Fair Housing Council of San Fernando Valley et al v Roommates.com, the US Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit has ruled that an online letting service was not immune from potential liability for the profiles entered by the users of its services.
The Liberalization of the German Health Care Service Sector
German Cabinet Approves Corporate Tax Plan 2008
New German Telemedia Legislation Clarifies Some Issues; Clouds Others
Squeeze-Outs in Germany: Becoming Stale for Hedge Funds?
In Depth
The Liberalization of the German Health Care Service Sector
By Dr. Stephan Rau
The introduction of the medical ambulatory service center has changed Germany’s health care industry in ways not seen since 2003. Prior to 2004, only physicians working in their sole local offices or in local partnerships could provide ambulatory medical services. However, effective in 2004, a new form of ambulatory medical service provider was introduced: the Medizinische Versorgungszentren, medical ambulatory service center, or MVZ. An MVZ may be owned by anyone having any license within the public health care system, and this license is not very difficult to obtain. For example, all a company has to do is sell wheelchairs or similar products to apply for a license, and, as a result, an investor in such company may become the beneficial owner of an MVZ.
Panel Physicians Amendment Act
On January 1, 2007, the Panel Physicians Amendment Act (Vertragsarztrechtsänderungsgesetz or VÄndG) came into force, further advancing the deregulation of the ambulatory health care service sector in Germany. Until 2006, a license to provide ambulatory medical services only entitled its bearer to do so at a certain location. Physicians and MVZs were not allowed to apply for two licenses in two different locations. Following the enactment of the VÄndG, MVZs and groups of physicians may now open branches and provide services in various regions and—theoretically—all over Germany.
However, a system of determination of need (Bedarfsplanung) still limits this possibility. According to Bedarfsplanung, regulatory health care bodies may decide that in certain areas a “market” need for general practitioners or physicians of certain specializations does not exist and that further applications will be rejected. In this case, any new applicant—be it a physician or an MVZ—has to buy a license from a retiring physician with comparable qualifications. According to the government’s current plans, however, the entire system of determination of need may be abolished within the next two years.
MVZ Business Models
The MVZ not only enables investors to enter the ambulatory medical market, it also significantly eases the strict separation between inpatient and outpatient services. Traditionally, German hospitals were—except for cases of urgencies—not allowed to provide outpatient services to the vast majority of the population, i.e., the publicly insured. This changed in 2004 when hospitals could legally own an MVZ, thereby entering the outpatient sector. Until 2006, however, hospitals were largely not allowed to employ physicians who provided both inpatient services in the hospital and outpatient services in the MVZ. Rather, employed physicians could only work in one or the other. The VÄndG has abolished this inconvenient prohibition.
To enter the outpatient sector, hospitals generally tend to establish MVZs through wholly owned subsidiaries. Because this practice often provokes the resistance of their new competitors, i.e., physicians working in private offices, some hospitals prefer to enter joint ventures with leading entrepreneurial physicians.
This model appears more promising—in particular, one can look at the U.S. experience and the failures of physician practice management organizations (PPMs) versus the successes of ambulatory service centers (ASCs). PPMs were providers of outpatient services that were solely owned and run by investors who had previously purchased the physicians’ offices and employed those physicians. Many of those PPMs became insolvent because the physicians did not have sufficient incentive to generate wealth for the company. ASCs, however, are an entirely different story. Most of them are highly profitable, and some of their providers are publicly listed. ASCs are usually run by management companies who also hold shares in the ASCs—albeit with physicians as co-shareholders.
Conclusion
Germany’s health care service system has been opened up to new investment and structuring opportunities. While they may seem commonplace to anyone familiar with the U.S. health care system, in Germany such structures would have been unthinkable only a few years ago.
In its deregulation plans, the German government is pursuing its objective to increase competition among various health care service providers and to realize greater synergies across the industry. While this has been the case for hospitals and nursing homes for quite some time, the German health care service sector has finally nailed its intentions for the ambulatory and outpatient sector to the door—private investments are wanted.
German Cabinet Approves Corporate Tax Plan 2008
By Dr. Gero Burwitz and Dr. Dirk Pohl
On May 25, 2007, the German Parliament approved a draft corporate tax plan (enterprise tax reform), which is scheduled to become effective on January 1, 2008. The reform seeks to create a more competitive tax environment for companies by reducing the nominal tax rates, avoiding the (further) erosion of the tax base in Germany by limiting in particular the amount of interest companies can deduct from their taxable income, and limiting the use of loss carry-forwards by significantly tightening the change of control rules. It is very likely that the new law will be implemented. The second chamber of the Parliament still has to approve the tax plan. A final decision is planned on July 20, 2007.
Notwithstanding the reduction of the tax rates, U.S. investors likely will find that the limitation of the deduction of interest will result in a notably higher effective tax burden on leveraged financing structures in Germany.
Reduction of Nominal Tax Rates
The draft bills provide a reduction of the average tax burden for corporations from 38.65 per cent to 29.83 per cent, consisting of a corporate tax of 15 per cent (currently 25 per cent), a solidarity surcharge of 0.83 per cent (5.5 per cent of the corporate tax) and an average trade tax of 14 per cent, depending on the tax rate of the local community.
In van Generics Limited et al. v H. Lundbeck A/S [2007] EWHC 1040 (Pat), Lundbeck obtained a patent on Escitalopram, a component of the previously patented drug Citalopram. Genericset al. asserted that the patent lacks novelty, was obvious and insufficient.
Comptroller can raise additional grounds of objection
In the case of Raytheon v Comptroller General of Patents, Designs and Trade marks, [2007] EWHC 1230 (Pat), Kitchin J allowed the Comptroller to raise additional grounds of objection against a patent application on appeal even though they had not originally been argued during the examination procedure.
Trademarks & Domain Names
Consent, trade mark infringement and passing off: Anglo-Dutch Ltd paint themselves into a corner
Trade mark infringement and passing off can be established where a party, who has an agreement with the trade mark owner, uses the marks and embarks on acts not covered by that agreement, without the trade mark owner’s consent.
Clear identification of trade marks in Oppositions considered by CFI
The Court of First Instance (CFI) in the Black Decker Corporation v Office for Harmonisation in the Internal Market (OHIM) allowed the submission of documents accompanying a notice of opposition by means of facsimile after the limitation period had expired. The judgement gave clear criteria for accepting such a notice of opposition.
Trademark Dilution – the UK Approach
On May 15 2007, Jacob LJ addressed several important questions regarding the s.5(3) of the Trade Mark Act 1994 and Art.4(4)(a) of the Trade Marks Directive in the case Intel Corporation Inc v CPM United Kingdom Ltd. [2007] EWCA Civ 431.
A question of distinctiveness in three dimensional marks
In Procter & Gamble Company v Office for Harmonisation in the Internal Market (Trade Marks and Designs) (OHIM) (Joined Cases T-241/05, T-262/05, T-263/05, T-264/05, T-346/05, T-347/05, T-29/06, T-30/06, T-31/06), the Court of First Instance of the European Communities (Fourth Chamber) heard an appeal against the decision of OHIM to uphold the examiner’s refusal to register three dimensional trade marks in respect of detergent products. The Court confirmed the Board’s decision and maintained that the trade mark applications were devoid of any distinctive character and thus not registrable pursuant to Article 7(1)(b) of Regulation (EC) No 40/94.
E-Commerce
The licensing of online gambling
The Gambling Commission has published a new regulatory regime for remote gambling, which contains provisions for licensing of online casinos. However, other countries remain wary of remote gambling and continue to take a more stringent approach to licensing.
Enforcement & Procedure
Damages are set in the CD WOW dispute
The UK record industry was awarded significant damages following the High Court decision of March 2007 against CD-WOW, when CD-WOW’s practice of importing cheap CDs and DVDs from Asia and selling them over the internet in UK and Ireland was deemed illegal.
Parliamentary Committee calls for more creativity in balancing Copyright Law to promote Creative Industries.
The House of Commons committee on Culture, Media and Sport in May 2007 has published a report entitled “New Media and the Creative Industries”. The report deals mainly with the challenges created by recent technological developments in the production, supply and consumption of creative media. The report also raises issues of copyright law and its enforcement with regard to the creative industries and makes specific recommendations for reforming the law and for strengthening its enforcement as a way of creating a new balance between the needs of creators and consumers of media content.
Legislation
Draft Trade Marks (Relative Grounds) Order 2007
Report on the Review of the Copyright Tribunal
Indications from the WIPO Standing Committee on the Law of Trademarks, Industrial Designs and Geographical Indications (SCT)
Do not send any information or documents that you want to have treated as secret or confidential. Providing information to McDermott Will & Schulte via email links on this website or other introductory email communications will not create an attorney-client relationship; will not preclude McDermott Will & Schulte from representing any other person or firm in any matter; and will not obligate McDermott Will & Schulte to keep confidential the information you provide. McDermott Will & Schulte cannot enter into an attorney-client relationship with you until McDermott Will & Schulte has determined that doing so will not create a conflict of interest and until you and McDermott Will & Schulte have entered into a written agreement or engagement letter that sets forth the terms of our relationship.