ARTICLE
Concept Protection of Agencies
October 5, 2005
Read time: 1 min
ARTICLE
October 5, 2005
Read time: 1 min
ARTICLE
October, 2005
Read time: 4 min
Copyright
1. Change of Artist Name Does Not Allow Rights Holder of Existing Recordings to Use New Name
The Finnish Supreme Court has ruled against a record company who used an artist’s new name on old recordings in which they owned the rights.
2. Belgium and the Netherlands Scrap Their Restrictions on Licensing Music to Online Users
Belgium and the Netherlands have announced plans to scrap their restrictions on licensing music to online users. Sabam and BUMA, the Belgian and Dutch collecting societies, propose commitments that they shall no longer be party to any agreement containing an ‘economic residency clause’ in the case of online music.
3. Liability for Linking to Infringing Material
In Germany, the Motion Picture Association of America has been granted a temporary injunction against a website operator for linking to eDonkey’s peer-to-peer network. This decision emphasises the fact that liability for disseminating infringing material can rise not only from making available copyrighted works, without consent, but also from linking to them.
4. LexisNexis Copyguard: Trust in Technology to Fight Copyright Theft
LexisNexis has launched a new anti-plagiarism device, called Copyguard, a product developed through a joint project with iParadigms. The device will allow users, in particular corporate organisations, to regularly and rapidly check originality of content, and will contribute to efforts to control the problem of unauthorised use of copyrighted material.
5. Sony Loses Playstation Copyright Case in Australia
The High Court in Australia has ruled that the modifying of Sony PlayStation games console chips so that the consoles can play imported games does not breach copyright law.
Patents
6. NSA “Geo-Locating Patent” Raises Privacy Concerns
A patent secured by the National Security Agency of USA for a technology that can locate physical where-about of any web surfer has raised privacy concerns amidst growing fears as to how the technology will be ultimately used by the top security organisation of USA.
Trademarks
7. Scandinavian Typo Squatting Cases Successful
European brand owners have been reassured by three recent decisions of the WIPO Mediation and Arbitration Center in domain name dispute resolution procedures confirming transfer of domain names registered in the style of mis-spelt brand names. These decisions were made despite the registrant originating from Panama.
8. Agfa Photo Faces Trade Mark Disputes
This case illustrates the problems that arise when a trade mark proprietor assigns the mark separately from the business that underpins it. Insolvent Agfa Photo was unable to sell its manufacturing plant separately from the trade mark, which was in the hands of a private investor.
9. Nothing Immoral About Intertops
Sportwetten GmbH, a German company, appealed a decision of the OHIM with regard to the trade mark Intertops for services as bookmakers and betting services of all kinds. The company complained that the trade mark was contrary to public policy and against accepted principles of morality.
Acknowledgements
McDermott Will & Emery would like to acknowledge the invaluable contribution to the Bulletin made by Professor Michael Blakeney, Angel Adrian, Sofia Casimiro, Claudio Chiarolla, Maria Mercedes Frabboni, Jerry Hsiao, Afe Komolafe, Malcolm Langley, Tina Loverdou, James Mitchiner, Marisella Ouma, Rajesh Sagar, Pekka Valo and Daphne Zografos from the Queen Mary Intellectual Property Research Institute, University of London.
ARTICLE
September, 2005
Read time: 6 min
Hot Topics
1. The Beginning of the End for P2P Technology?
On 5 September 2005, the Australian Federal Court handed down its much anticipated decision in case of Universal Music Australia Pty Ltd v Sharman Networks and ors [2005] FCA 1242). This decision followed closely in the wake of the United States Supreme Court decision in Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Studios Inc v Grokster (545 US (2005)). Simone Blakeney of McDermott Will & Emery’s London Office examines these recent US and Australian decisions on the liability of the developers and owners of peer-to-peer file sharing systems and the development of the law of copyright infringement by “authorisation” in England and abroad, and speculates upon the future course of the law in England.
IP Rights
2. US Removes Ukraine Trade Sanctions in Recognition of Improvements Made to Protect Intellectual Property Rights
On 31 August 2005, US Trade Representative Rob Portman announced that the Bush Administration has lifted 100% tariff sanctions that had been imposed since 2002 on $75 million worth of exports from the Ukraine. In July 2005, the Ukraine’s approval of a package of amendments to the Laser-Readable Disk Law improved the Ukraine’s licensing regime preventing the manufacture of pirate CDs.
3. Ghost of Rover Haunted By Intellectual Property Disputes
The Shanghai Automotive Industry Corporation (SAIC), which spent £67 million buying Rover’s intellectual property rights, has threatened Nanjing Automotive, the successful bidder of Rover, with intellectual property court action. It is SAIC’s contention that Nanjing cannot produce any cars without its permission. However, Nanjing claims that SAIC holds very few of Rover’s intellectual property rights.
Copyright
4. Google’s Online Books Project Under Attack
Despite Google’s announcement that it is postponing its plans to scan the texts of millions of books and place them online, the Authors Guild, America’s largest and oldest society of published authors, has sued Google for copyright infringement.
5. A Hectic Time for Developments in Copyright Collective Management
The Santiago Agreement may now fail now that two of the collecting societies, BUMA and SABAM, have decided to reject one of its driving principles, that of maintaining territorial exclusivity for the national collecting societies. This will contribute to the changes that the European Commission and the stakeholders involved are likely to promote in the field of collective management of rights.
6. Moral Rights for Performers in the UK
The United Kingdom Patent Office has published the guidance on moral rights of the performers. These are meant to explain in simple terms, the intended effect of the Regulations seeking to introduce the moral rights of the performers into the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. The Regulations are expected to come into force on 1 February 2006. They will, for the first time, provide a basis for the moral rights of the performers in the United Kingdom.
Patents
7. Euro Notes in the Midst of Patent Infringement
A US company has sued the European Central bank claiming that every euro banknote in circulation infringes its anti-counterfeiting patent. In its suit before the European Court of First Instance, Document Security Systems Inc has sought to recover damages “at the rate of a reasonable royalty” from the European Central Bank in Frankfurt, Germany.
8. OSDL Announces Patents Common Project
The Open Source Development Labs (OSDL), a global consortium dedicated to accelerating the adoption of Linux, announced on 9 August at LinuxWorld, that it would be creating a patent commons project designed to provide a central location where software patents and patent pledges will be housed for the benefit of the open source development community and industry.
9. One More Avenue for a Reduced Disclosure Closed
One criticism of the patent system has been that whilst a sufficient disclosure is required to support claims to a patent the patentee is able to restrict the amount of information he provides for example in disclosing his know-how surrounding the invention. The Patents Court recently moved to close off the incorporation of documents obliquely referred to in disclosure where there is a lack of the requisite full explanation.
Trademarks
10. Kabushiki Kaisha Sony Computer Entertainment V Nuplayer
On 14 July 2005, the Chancery Division of the England & Wales High Court of Justice delivered a judgement in Kabushiki Kaisha Sony Computer Entertainment and another v Nuplayer Ltd, a case that concerned the question whether a trade mark owner can prevent internet sales in the United Kingdom of parallel imports from outside the European Economic Area.
11. Laboratories Goemar V La Mer Technology
On 29 July 2005, the Court of Appeal (Civil Division) delivered its judgment in Laboratoires Goëmar SA v La Mer Technology Inc. [2005] EWCA Civ. 978. This appeal is about the application of the “genuine use” provisions in articles 10 and 12 of the Trade Marks Directive EEC/89/104, which were implemented in section 46 of the Trade Marks Act 1994. The Court of Appeal, allowing the appeal, set aside an order for revocation of the registered trade mark on the ground of non-use of the mark for a period of five years. The fact that the use in question was limited to importation into the UK and that it had not reached end-users and consumers did not preclude it from being “genuine use”.
12. English High Court Confirms the Scope of Trade Mark Disclaimers
In General Cigar Co Inc v Partagas y Cia SA [2005] EWHC 1729 (Ch), Lawrence Collins J ruled on the scope of disclaimers of rights in non-distinctive elements of trade marks. In particular, he had to adjudicate on whether such disclaimers could only be taken into account in registrability cases or if they were also relevant in infringement cases. The court also considered the correct approach to be taken when the Trade Marks Registry subsequently alters its practice on what it considers distinctive once a mark has been registered subject to a disclaimer.
Acknowledgements
McDermott Will & Emery would like to acknowledge the invaluable contribution to the Bulletin made by Professor Michael Blakeney, Angel Adrian, Claudio Chiarolla, Maria Mercedes Frabboni, Afe Komolafe, Malcolm Langley, Tina Loverdou, James Mitchiner, Marisella Ouma, Rajesh Sagar, Ken Shao, Ilanah Simon, Pekka Valo and Daphne Zografos from the Queen Mary Intellectual Property Research Institute, University of London.
ARTICLE
July 1, 2005
Read time: 1 min
ARTICLE
July 1, 2005
Read time: 1 min
ARTICLE
July, 2005
Read time: 5 min
Hot Topics
1. P2P In Light of the Supreme Court Decision in Grokster
Last month, on the last day of the judicial term, the US Supreme Court issued its opinion in Grokster v MGM. The Supreme Court was asked to rule on the liability of peer-to-peer software providers for the infringements of those who use their networks. In doing so, the Court commented more generally on the scope of US secondary infringement of copyright works. This article discusses the Grokster decision and contrasts the decision with developments relating to file sharing in Europe.
2. Software Patents Remain Available in Europe
On 6 July 2005, European technology industries sighed with relief as the European Parliament voted, overwhelmingly, to reject the draft Directive on patent protection for computer-implemented inventions. Justin Hill, Director of Prosecution in our London Office, outlines what this means for patent prosecution in Europe.
Copyright
3. Olympic Struggle
The essence of the issue of appropriation of personality is simply, a person (X, here, Lord Coe) uses in a commercial context the name, voice or likeness of another person (Y, Bob Beamon) without his consent. To what extent does Y have a remedy to prevent such an unauthorised exploitation?
4. AOL and Google: Search For Video-On-Demand
The provision of video-on-demand services has recently been integrated into the business portfolio of America Online, which comes shortly after the launch of Google Video. Both services enable internet users to search a comprehensive archive of televised content. These developments show that internet-based companies are continuing to assimilate most of the commercially valuable activities related to the entertainment industry.
Patents
5. Patents and Design Rights in Ultraframe v Eurocell
In Ultraframe v Eurocell, the English Court of Appeal provided guidance as to how one can undertake the contextual reading of a claim in a patent to determine a patentee’s monopoly, as per the test laid down by Lord Hoffmann in Kirin Amgen. The judgment also discussed issues relating to licences of right for unregistered design rights arising from the application of s239 of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988.
6. Glasgow University in Legal Battle Over Spin-out Technology Patents
The central issue in this matter is the ownership of the patents for a sleep monitor, aepEX, which was developed by one of the University of Glasgow’s spin out companies. This company subsequently transferred the patents to a third party. The University contends that it is still the owner of the patents as its spin out company had only been granted a licence.
7. The European Commission Fines Astrazeneca €60 million For Misusing Patent System to Delay Generic Drug Competition
The European Commission fined AstraZeneca for misusing its dominant market position and delaying generic competition by misusing the patent system and procedures for marketing pharmaceuticals, a violation of Article 82 and EEA Article 54. This case is the first time that European competition law has been used to combat patent misuse.
Trademarks
8. The UK’s Logo for the EU Presidency Under Attack
The UK’s logo for the presidency of the European Union is under attack from the Euroseptic Bruges Group, which is threatening legal action for copyright infringement to stop the logo being used.
9. Directive 2005/29/ec: the ‘Unfair Commercial Practices Directive’
Directive 2005/29/EC on Unfair Commercial Practices was signed by the European Parliament and the Council on 11 May 2005. The Directive aims to clarify consumers’ rights and harmonise rules on business-to-consumer commercial practices within the European Union (“EU”) by defining and banning “sharp practices”. Although the main objective of the Directive is consumer protection, it also aims to indirectly protect legitimate businesses from competitors who do not play by the rules. Some of the prohibited activities have implications for the protection of intellectual property, especially trade marks.
10. Eurocermex Three-Dimensional Trade Mark Finally Defeated By the ECJ
The European Court of Justice (“ECJ”) announced on 30 June 2005 that it had dismissed the appeal of the Community trade mark applicant in Eurocermex SA v OHIM, whereby the ambitious effort seeking to register a bottle-shaped three-dimensional trade mark finally failed.
Acknowledgements
McDermott Will & Emery would like to acknowledge the invaluable contribution to the Bulletin made by Professor Michael Blakeney, Angel Adrian, Maria Mercedes Frabboni, Jerry Hsiao, Afe Komolafe, Malcolm Langley, James Mitchiner, Marisella Ouma, Rajesh Sagar, Ken Shao, Ilanah Simon, Pekka Valo and Daphne Zografos from the Queen Mary Intellectual Property Research Institute, University of London.
ARTICLE
June 1, 2005
Read time: 1 min
ARTICLE
June 1, 2005
Read time: 1 min
ARTICLE
June 1, 2015
Read time: 1 min
ARTICLE
June, 2005
Read time: 5 min
Hot Topics
1. The Many Parts of a Patent
Stephen J. Akerley and Bijal V. Vakil, partners in the Intellectual Property Department of McDermott Will & Emery LLP in the Firm’s Silicon Valley office, provide an explanation of patents, patent protection and increasing the value of a firm’s investments.
2. The Douglases & OK! v Hello! Ltd
In the latest decision Douglas & OK! v Hello!, the Court of Appeal reviewed and developed the laws of privacy and confidential information.
3. What Future for a Treaty on the Protection of Broadcasting Organisations?
The second revised consolidated draft text for a WIPO treaty on the Protection of Broadcasting Organisations was released in early May 2005 and contains the developments which emerged from the twelfth session of the Standing Committee on Copyright and Related Rights.
4. BHB Enterprises PLC -v- Victor Chandler (International) Limited – Action and Counterclaim – Cost to Produce Bears No Resemblance to Value
This decision of the English High Court examines the effect of the European Court of Justice’s decision in William Hill v BHBE in relation to the question of whether a database is entitled to sui generis intellectual property rights under the Database Directive, and the effect of the decision on trade in data in the EC.
Copyright
5. Has Interlego been Waltered Down?
In deciding that copyright can subsist in the annotations made to an ancient piece of music by a modern scholarly effort, the Court of Appeal has confirmed that criticisms levelled against the Privy Council decision in Interlego v Tyco [1988] RPC 343 are justified based on the continued application of Walter v Lane [1900] AC 539.
6. Sony BMG Tests ‘Sterile Burning’ to Bar Unlimited CD Burning
Sony has released at least 10 commercial titles to test the new technology solution known as ‘sterile burning’, allowing consumers to make limited copies of protected discs but blocking them from making any further copies. Sony says this solution will not violate the fair-use doctrine.
Patents
7. Nokia Commits Not to Assert Any of its Patents Against the Linux Kernel
Nokia Corporation has made a legally binding commitment not to assert any of its patents against the Linux Kernel. In making this declaration Nokia has become the first company to make a binding commitment in support of the Linux open source environment.
8. Tercia Inc v Avecia Ltd – Summary Judgement in Patent Disputes
This decision provides an insight into the principles, and their application, in respect of the grant or dismissal of an application for summary judgement in a patent dispute. After a careful analysis, the Court rejected the application of Avecia Ltd seeking relief for revocation of a patent held by Genentech.
Trademarks
9. Celltech v OHIM
The Court of First Instance delivered a judgment clarifying the distinctiveness requirement under Article 7(1)(b) of EC Regulation No. 40/94. It was held that when considering whether or not a mark consisting of a combination of two simple English words lacks distinctive character, the mark must be evaluated as a whole and not by looking at the separate meanings of the words.
10. Budweiser Budvar’s EU Victory
The European Union recognized the Czech brewery Budweiser Budvar’s claim for protection of its beer under one of the Union’s two regional designations when the Czech Republic joined the bloc last May.
11. WIPO Recommends Uniform IP Protection Mechanism to Regulate Domain Name Registrations
On June 1, 2005, the World Intellectual Property Organisation recommended the introduction of a uniform intellectual property protection mechanism with a view to controlling unauthorised registration of domain names by cyber-squatters in all new generic Top-Level Domains (gTLDs).
12. CFI Delivers First Substantial Dilution Decision
In Spa Monopole, compagnie fermiere de Spa SA/NV v OHIM, Case T-67/04, the Court of First Instance has provided the first definitions of unfair advantage and detriment under the Community Trade Mark (CTM) Regulation. The Court also discusses the controversial issue of whether actual dilution is necessary in order to succeed in European dilution proceedings.
Acknowledgements
McDermott Will & Emery would like to acknowledge the invaluable contribution to the Bulletin made by Professor Michael Blakeney, Angel Adrian, Maria Mercedes Frabboni, Jerry Hsiao, Afe Komolafe, Malcolm Langley, Tina Loverdou, James Mitchiner, Rajesh Sagar, Ken Shao, Ilanah Simon and Pekka Valo from the Queen Mary Intellectual Property Research Institute, University of London.