Content Type: Article

  • CFTC Update: Certain Equity Total Return Swaps to Count Toward De Minimis Exemption Starting July 1

    CFTC Update: Certain Equity Total Return Swaps to Count Toward De Minimis Exemption Starting July 1

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    CFTC Update: Certain Equity Total Return Swaps to Count Toward De Minimis Exemption Starting July 1

    June 18, 2013

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Approximately six months ago (on Dec. 21, 2012), the Commodity Futures Trading Commission staff provided temporary no-action relief[1] allowing certain equity total return swaps on foreign securities — which have been termed “compo equity swaps” or “compo equity total return swaps”[2] — to be treated as “securities-based swaps” (which are regulated by the Securities and Exchange Commission) and not as “mixed swaps” (which are regulated by both the CFTC and SEC).[3] Based on that relief, fund managers claiming a de minimis commodity pool operator registration exemption — either Rule 4.13(a)(3) (for private funds) or Rule 4.5 (for mutual funds) — have heretofore been able to exclude compo swaps from their calculations.

    This relief, however, is set to expire on June 30 and, unless additional relief is granted (which is not anticipated at the moment), fund managers — from and after July 1, 2013 — will have to count compo swaps as “commodity interests” when determining their eligibility for a de minimis exemption. Managers should note that the classification of compo equity swaps as mixed swaps could also be applied to other equity swap transactions that have “non-incidental” foreign currency components.[4]

    As a result, fund managers relying on either of the two de minimis exemptions should examine their equity-related swaps to determine if they will remain eligible for that exemption after July 1. A fund manager in danger of exceeding a de minimis threshold may need to employ alternative instruments to obtain similar exposures (or may need to register as a commodity pool operator).

    The expiration of the interim relief also means that other CFTC swap-specific requirements, such as adherence to the Dodd-Frank Protocols and swap reporting obligations, will be applicable to compo and similar mixed swaps.

    Authored by Craig Stein, Brian T. Daly, Kristin Boggiano and Jacob Preiserowicz.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] http://www.cftc.gov/ucm/groups/public/@lrlettergeneral/documents/letter/12-64.pdf.

    [2] A “compo equity total return swap” exposes a counterparty to changes in the value of the underlying (foreign) equity as well as the foreign currency in which the underlier is quoted. Economically (and ignoring numerous friction costs), it is similar to taking a position directly in the foreign equity.

    [3] In August 2012, the CFTC and the SEC jointly published final rules which defined the term “swap” and “securities-based swaps.” They also defined “mixed swaps,” which are instruments that have both a commodity interest component (e.g., currency or interest rate exposure) and a securities component and are therefore regulated by both commissions. Nonetheless, for purposes of the de minimis exemptions, mixed swaps are treated as swaps (e.g., the initial margin or notional value of mixed swaps must be counted as commodity interests in determining the availability of a de minimis exemption). 77 FR 48207 (Aug. 13, 2012).

    [4] Total return swaps on a single security or narrow-based index are generally considered “securities-based swaps” (which are not counted for purposes of the de minimis exemptions); however, in the August 2012 joint release, the CFTC and the SEC concluded that because (i) “in a compo equity swap, the parties assume exposure to, and the total return is calculated based on, both the performance of specified foreign stocks and the change in the relevant exchange rate” and (ii) that exposure to the foreign exchange rate can be easily avoided (e.g., by entering into a “quanto” total return swap with an embedded currency hedge), that currency exposure is “not [merely] incidental to the equity exposure” and a compo swap is — therefore — a mixed swap.


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP (“SRZ”) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.

    In depth
    Authors

    Craig Stein

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • The New ISDA Protocol: What Investment Managers Need to Know

    The New ISDA Protocol: What Investment Managers Need to Know

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    The New ISDA Protocol: What Investment Managers Need to Know

    June 12, 2013

    Read time: 12 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Investment funds (or investment managers on their behalf) may now adhere to the ISDA March 2013 DF Protocol Agreement (“Protocol 2.0”). Protocol 2.0, as with the ISDA August 2012 DF Protocol (the “August Protocol”), is an efficient means for swap dealers to comply with certain new Commodity Futures Trading Commission (“CFTC”) rules applicable to bilaterally negotiated swap transactions. Adherence to the Protocol 2.0 is in addition to, and not in lieu of, adhering to the August Protocol. Protocol 2.0 provides a mechanism for compliance with three separate CFTC rules.[1] One rule, in particular, regarding trading documentation and reconciling trade data[2] (the “Documentation Rules”) is relevant to investment managers (and the funds they manage) and is the subject of this Alert. The final rule was published in the Federal Register on Sept. 11, 2012,[3] and will be effective on July 1, 2013.[4] If an investment fund were to adhere to Protocol 2.0, it would incorporate additional terms into their existing swap documentation including, among others, valuation processes for collateral and risk management, dispute resolution provisions, portfolio reconciliation provisions, and statements regarding the dealer’s and investment fund’s status as a financial company or insured depository institution.

    Process to Adhere to Protocol 2.0

    The process of adherence is similar to that of the August Protocol. Investment funds may adhere to Protocol 2.0 through the ISDA website by paying a one-time fee of $500 and submitting an adherence letter. An investment manager may adhere once on behalf of multiple investment funds that it manages. Subsequent to the submission of an adherence letter, funds may access the Markit website and submit the Protocol Questionnaire, which allows counterparties to make certain elections and fill in appropriate data.

    Not Retroactively Applicable

    The Documentation Rules will not apply retroactively — compliance with these rules will only be required with respect to swaps entered into after the date that the rules go into effect (currently, July 1, 2013).

    Applicability of Documentation Rules

    The Documentation Rules apply only to bilaterally negotiated swap transactions. They do not apply to trades executed on a swap execution facility or designated contract market, or that are cleared on a derivatives clearing organization. The Documentation Rules do not provide parties to a swap with a basis for voiding or rescinding a swap transaction based solely on the failure of the parties to document the swap transaction in compliance with the Documentation Rules.

    Trading Documentation

    According to the Documentation Rules, each swap dealer must have policies and procedures reasonably designed to ensure that such dealer has certain swap trading relationship documentation with all counterparties, including investment funds, with certain terms prior to (or contemporaneously with) entering into a swap transaction. The Documentation Rules require that swap trading documentation include terms addressing events of default or other termination events, payment obligations, calculation and netting of obligations upon termination, transfer of rights and obligations, governing law, valuation and dispute resolution. The CFTC does not require specific provisions in the trading relationship documentation to address the foregoing terms — for example, the Documentation Rules do not dictate that particular events of default must be specified in such documentation. Current market documents (such as an ISDA Master Agreement) generally satisfy many — but not all — of the Documentation Rules. Current market documents typically include events of default and other termination events, payment obligations, calculation and netting of obligations upon termination, transfer of rights and obligations, and governing law provisions.

    However, the CFTC requires that certain additional provisions that are not currently included in the typical swap documentation be included. The Documentation Rules require parties to incorporate provisions, including, among others, valuation processes for collateral and risk management, dispute resolution provisions and statements regarding the dealer’s and investment fund’s status as a financial company or insured depository institution. Protocol 2.0 provides a means for dealers to incorporate such additional provisions.

    Protocol 2.0 also provides that if funds do not have an ISDA Master Agreement (or other form of appropriate derivative documentation) in place, there is an option for a fund to incorporate by reference the form of 2002 ISDA Master Agreement (with certain elections set forth in Protocol 2.0). Protocol 2.0 would allow a fund the option to incorporate the standard 2002 ISDA Master Agreement template of terms, including standard events of default and termination events defined in the 2002 ISDA Master Agreement form. Funds may not want to elect to incorporate such form because it may not have the protections and other terms generally present in negotiated swap documentation.

    Protocol 2.0 provides for the additional provisions that will need to be incorporated into the documentation between swap dealers and investment funds, including:

    • Valuation: According to the Documentation Rules, swap dealers must have in place policies and procedures to ensure that their documentation with “financial entities” (e.g., investment funds) includes valuation processes.[5] The valuation process may be based on objective criteria rather than internal valuation models or, if the parties agree, the valuation process may be based on a proprietary trading model. Protocol 2.0 has a valuation methodology based upon the “Risk Valuation.” The Risk Valuation is either a process specified in writing by the investment fund and the dealer (which may be in the form of an ISDA Credit Support Annex) or, if there is no process identified, the Risk Valuation is the “risk exposure” determined by the swap dealer based on the “close-out” provisions of its ISDA Master Agreement (unless the swap dealer has elected to use a valuation provided by the investment fund counterparty).
    • Dispute Resolution: The Documentation Rules require that trading documentation include a method to dispute any valuation provided pursuant to the valuation process. With respect to dispute resolution provisions, the CFTC states that no specific procedures have to be followed. Protocol 2.0 provides a method of dispute resolution with respect to valuations. If the parties have agreed in writing to a specific process of dispute resolution, such dispute resolution process will govern. If the parties have not agreed to a dispute resolution provision, the swap dealer will attempt to resolve the dispute by consulting with the investment fund counterparty. If there is no resolution in a timely manner, then the swap dealer will recalculate the risk valuation by seeking four actual quotations at mid-market. If four quotations are not available, then fewer will be used and, if no quotations are available, then the swap dealer’s original calculation will be used.Protocol 2.0 states that any calculation of value and dispute of the value is only relevant for the sole purpose of complying with the risk management provisions of the Documentation Rules related to swap dealers. In addition, Protocol 2.0 clarifies that when margin regulations are published, additional agreements related to the calculation of value may be necessary. These clarifications in the text of Protocol 2.0 were added because of market participants’ concerns about the potentially significant implications of providing a value in a swap for matters such as posting collateral, investor concerns, audits, potential litigation and other regulatory contexts. If investment funds wish to have an agreed-upon method to value a swap and do not currently have such a method, such method may be agreed upon outside the scope of entering into Protocol 2.0. Protocol 2.0 explicitly states that any other procedure to determine value or dispute may be agreed upon between the parties in addition to or in substitution for the procedures set forth in Protocol 2.0.
    • Orderly Liquidation Authority Under Title II of the Dodd-Frank Act: The Documentation Rules also require a statement as to whether the swap dealer and the investment fund are “financial companies” or “insured depository institutions.” In addition, the Documentation Rules require that swap dealers include a statement in documentation that if a counterparty is deemed to be a covered financial company or an insured depository institution for which the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation has been appointed (a ‘‘covered party’’), certain limitations under Title II of the Dodd-Frank Act or the Federal Deposit Insurance Act may apply to the right of the non-covered party to terminate, liquidate, or net any swap, notwithstanding the contractual agreement of the parties. Protocol 2.0 includes both of these statements, therefore satisfying the Documentation Rules.
    • Notice that Original Swap is Extinguished upon Acceptance by a DCO: Swap trading relationship documentation, pursuant to the Documentation Rules, obligates swap dealers to provide a notice to investment funds that, upon acceptance of a swap by a derivatives clearing organization (“DCO”): (i) the original swap is extinguished; (ii) the original swap is replaced by equal and opposite swaps with the DCO; and (iii) all terms of the swap shall conform to the product specifications of the cleared swap established under the DCO’s rules. This notice provision is also provided in Protocol 2.0, therefore satisfying the Documentation Rules.

    Swap Confirmations

    According to the Documentation Rules, swap dealers must have written policies and procedures in place that are reasonably designed to ensure that they execute confirmations with investment funds “as soon as technologically practicable” but in any event, by the end of the first business day following the date that the transaction is entered into between the parties. Protocol 2.0 addresses the timing obligation of the Documentation Rules by stating that the terms delivered by each party (provided that they match) will evidence a binding agreement. This provision in Protocol 2.0 is intended to clarify that the exchange of matching terms through an electronic messaging platform or otherwise may serve as one means for effecting confirmations within the time periods required by the Documentation Rules.[6]

    Portfolio Reconciliation

    The Documentation Rules require that dealers have policies and procedures in place to ensure that they enter into a post-execution process to reconcile discrepancies in the material terms of trade and valuation data with investment funds. The CFTC “prefers to permit maximum flexibility and innovation in the process” and Protocol 2.0 does not dictate a specific format or process for reconciling such data other than as discussed below. A swap dealer is required to reconcile portfolios quarterly with investment funds if such funds have more than 100 existing swaps at any time during a calendar quarter; otherwise, such reconciliation may instead be done annually.

    Protocol 2.0 provides three options to funds to reconcile trade and valuation data: (i) one-way delivery of portfolio data, (ii) two-way exchange of portfolio data or (iii) reconciliation of portfolio data against a swap data repository. One-way delivery data requires that the swap dealer deliver portfolio data to the investment fund for verification. For investment funds and their investment managers, one-way delivery may be the least burdensome means in which to operationally resolve discrepancies. In the event that one-way delivery is selected, investment funds must affirm the data or identify discrepancies within two business days. Two-way exchange of portfolio data requires that each party deliver portfolio data to the other party for a reconciliation of such material terms or valuation. Alternatively, parties may reconcile their books and records against portfolio data in the swap data repository.[7] In each case, the Documentation Rules provide that a third-party service provider may be utilized.

    Portfolio Compression

    Swap dealers are obligated under the Documentation Rules to compress portfolios (that is, net offsetting positions in order to reduce risk) with other swap dealers. However, swap dealers are obligated to compress the portfolios of investment funds only at the request of such fund. Investment funds may not want to compress portfolios for a variety of reasons — they have a very small number of offsetting positions, or they may have complex arrangements with different counterparties that make compression less useful. Because there is no regulatory obligation by a swap dealer to provide an option to investment fund counterparties to compress their portfolios, if funds wish to compress portfolios, they will need to request such compression. Because compression is only offered at the request of a fund, it falls outside the scope of Protocol 2.0.

    Authored by Craig Stein and Kristin Boggiano.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] The three rules subject to Protocol 2.0 are as follows: (i) Confirmation, Portfolio Reconciliation, Portfolio Compression, and Swap Trading Relationship Documentation Requirements for Swap Dealers and Major Swap Participants; (ii) End-User Exception to the Clearing Requirement for Swaps; and (iii) Clearing Requirement Determination Under Section 2(h) of the CEA. To the extent that rules (ii) and (iii) are relevant to Protocol 2.0, they are not relevant to investment funds because such funds do not qualify for the end-user exemption due to their status as “financial entities.” A financial entity is defined, in relevant part, as a commodity pool, a private fund, one of certain types of benefit plans as defined under ERISA, or a person predominantly engaged in activities that are in the business of banking or in activities that are financial in nature as defined in section 4(k) of the Bank Holding Company Act of 1956. 

    [2] Confirmation, Portfolio Reconciliation, Portfolio Compression, and Swap Trading Relationship Documentation Requirements for Swap Dealers and Major Swap Participants, 77 Fed. Reg. 55904 (Sept. 11, 2012).

    [3] See http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/FR-2012-09-11/pdf/2012-21414.pdf.

    [4] Business Conduct and Documentation Requirements for Swap Dealers and Major Swap Participants; Extension of Compliance Date, 78 Fed. Reg. 17 (Jan. 2, 2013).

    [5] The concept of including “valuation” in swap documentation has been controversial for both the dealer and investment manager communities, primarily due to the possibilities that proprietary trading models would have to be disclosed and that there would be a heavy, pre-execution burden of agreeing upon a model for complex swaps, which could impede timely trading.

    [6] Parts of the Documentation Rule provisions on confirmations are not addressed by Protocol 2.0.

    [7] As of the date of this Alert, there is no swap data repository that can provide this service but it is anticipated that this service may be provided in the future.


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP (“SRZ”) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.

    In depth
    Authors

    Craig Stein

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Reminder: Swaps Compliance Dates for Commodity Pool Operators and Investment Fund Managers

    Reminder: Swaps Compliance Dates for Commodity Pool Operators and Investment Fund Managers

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Reminder: Swaps Compliance Dates for Commodity Pool Operators and Investment Fund Managers

    May 31, 2013

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Given the large number of regulatory developments coming from the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, the National Futures Association and other regulatory agencies, we have compiled a short list of important recent and upcoming deadlines facing commodity pool operators and investment advisers. Along with each deadline, the list provides a concise summary of certain actions that may need to be taken and the relevant guidance provided by the applicable regulator.

    In depth
    Authors

    Craig Stein

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • UK Tax Authority Consultation on the Taxation of Partnerships

    UK Tax Authority Consultation on the Taxation of Partnerships

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    UK Tax Authority Consultation on the Taxation of Partnerships

    28 May 2013

    Read time: 11 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    HM Revenue & Customs (“HMRC”), the United Kingdom tax authority, has published its Consultation Document on proposed changes to the tax rules for partnerships. The Consultation Document is focussed in two areas: (i) preventing the avoidance of tax and national insurance contributions (“NICs”) by the “disguising” of employees as members of limited liability partnerships (“LLPs”); and (ii) preventing LLPs from deriving a “tax advantage” from the use of a corporate member of the LLP.

    Summary

    The proposed changes will be relevant to all investment managers operating in the UK as LLPs, including US managers with UK subsidiaries who have frequently used the LLP as an entity by which to carry on their UK activities. Where an LLP is used, individuals engaged in the UK business may become members (partners) of the LLP, which gives a more favourable tax treatment than if the individuals were employees. It is also common to include a UK limited company (a corporate member) as a member of the LLP, so that some part of the profits of the LLP may be taxed at more favourable corporation tax rates, rather than at individual income tax rates. In some cases, LLPs have sought to achieve a more favourable tax treatment for individual members from the use of a corporate member, by allocating profits to the corporate member and subsequently enabling individual members, directly or indirectly, to receive a benefit from that allocation to the corporate member.

    All investment managers structured as LLPs (including US managers with UK subsidiary LLPs) are likely to have to review their arrangements to determine compliance with the proposed changes. The position of individual LLP members should be considered carefully, to ensure that the membership terms of those individuals are not such that the individual is at risk of being deemed to be an employee of the LLP. Where one of the members of the LLP is a corporate member, the LLP will need to review the role and function of that corporate member, and consider to what extent it remains appropriate to allocate profits to the corporate member in the future.

    Responses to the Consultation Document are requested by 9 Aug. 2013. The proposed new rules (with any changes to the detail of the proposals resulting from the consultation process) will take effect from 6 April 2014, with no grandfathering for arrangements entered into before this date.

    Disguised Employment Relationships

    The current tax rules treat individual LLP members as partners, even if the membership terms for individual members are such that their relationship with the LLP is equivalent to an employer/employee relationship. This partner status gives rise to income tax and NIC advantages for individual LLP members (since LLP members are required to account for income tax and NICs on their remuneration much later than they would if they were employees) and is also advantageous for the LLP itself. Because individual LLP members are treated as self-employed for tax purposes, the LLP is not required to pay Class 1 (employer’s) NICs — currently a rate of 13.8 percent — in regard to an individual member’s remuneration from the LLP. The only NIC charge applicable to individual LLP members is Class 4 NICs, which are charged at a rate of approximately two percent on the member’s remuneration, the same rate at which an employee is subject to Class 1 (primary) NICs on remuneration from an employer.

    HMRC proposes to remove this “presumption of self-employment” by classifying an individual LLP member as a “salaried member,” where either one of two conditions (designed to identify situations where an individual’s relationship with an LLP is tantamount to employment) is met. Where an individual LLP member is classified as a “salaried member,” the individual LLP member will be treated as an employee of the LLP for all tax purposes, so that the LLP would be obliged to pay Class 1 NICs (including 13.8 percent Class 1 (employer’s) NICs) in regard to the individual LLP member’s remuneration. The LLP also would have an ongoing obligation to deduct income tax and Class 1 (primary) NICs from the individual LLP member’s remuneration and account to HMRC for the amounts deducted, under the PAYE system.

    The first condition states that an individual LLP member will be regarded as a “salaried member” where that individual, if the LLP had been a traditional partnership with two or more partners, would have been regarded as employed by that partnership (and not as a partner in that partnership). This is effectively a removal of any presumption of self-employment, which permits HMRC to apply its normal tests (as set out in HMRC’s Employment Status Manual) to determine whether an individual should be regarded as employed or self-employed.

    HMRC considers, however, that this first condition may not be applicable to certain individual LLP members whose relationship with the LLP is expressed in terms that are of a type found in a traditional partnership agreement, even if the practical effect of those terms is equivalent to employment. Accordingly, HMRC proposes a second condition under which an individual LLP member will be classified as a “salaried member” where that individual LLP member:

    • Has no economic risk (loss of contributed capital or repayment of drawings) in the event that the LLP makes a loss or is wound up;
    • Is not entitled to a share of profits (but receives only salary or other fixed compensation); and
    • Is not entitled to a share of any surplus assets on a winding-up of the LLP.

    The Consultation Document also proposes there should be a targeted anti-avoidance rule so that taxpayers are not able to circumvent the proposed changes by putting in place arrangements that are intended to have no practical effect other than to disapply the legislation. If, for example, an individual LLP member’s terms provided that the member would be entitled to receive a 10 percent share of profits only if profits exceeded a figure that was, in reality, many times the actual turnover of the LLP, no account would be taken of these terms and the individual LLP member would be treated as not entitled to a share of profits.

    HMRC does, however, confirm that these two conditions are not intended to apply to individual LLP members who, if the LLP had been a traditional partnership and not an LLP, would have been properly regarded as partners in that traditional partnership. The changes are not, therefore, intended to affect the status of members who carry on the business in common with a view to profit, who take risk in the business and who are to a significant degree rewarded on the basis of a share in the profits. It is also acknowledged that some persons may be taken on as members at an appropriate point in their career and may sacrifice an entitlement to salary in exchange for the opportunity to participate in the business in much the same way as a senior partner, even if as junior partners they are substantially rewarded by a fixed profit share.

    Profit and Loss Allocation Schemes

    It has become commonplace for LLPs (and other partnerships) to include among their members a limited company (a corporate member) which is liable to corporation tax on its allocation of profits from the LLP. Since the rates of corporation tax are generally lower than the income tax rate that is payable by individual LLP members, this ability to allocate profits to a corporate member can be used in a variety of ways to minimise the overall amount of tax paid by the members. For example, where profits are to be retained in the business and not distributed to the members, allocation of those profits to a corporate member allows profits to be invested in the business after being taxed at the lower corporation tax rate. HMRC is also aware of what it considers “tax-motivated arrangements” under which profits are first allocated to a corporate member, but then wider arrangements are put in place which result in those profits flowing to the economic benefit of individual members, in some cases in such a way that the individual members suffer no further tax on those profits.

    HMRC proposes to counteract these arrangements by introducing measures applicable to “mixed partnerships” — partnerships where some of the members are subject to income tax (individual members) and others are subject to corporation tax (corporate members) — such that where there is an “economic connection” which enables individual members subject to income tax to benefit, directly or indirectly, from partnership profits allocated to corporate members subject to corporation tax, all or part of the profits allocated to a corporate member will be reallocated for tax purposes (on a just and reasonable basis) and treated as profits allocated to individual members. Individual members will then be subject to income tax on the profits so reallocated to them for tax purposes.

    Some interested parties (particularly in the banking and hedge fund sectors) have outlined to HMRC the use of corporate members to facilitate profit-deferral and staff-retention arrangements, where it may be considered to be unfair to tax profits on individual members in a period during which those individuals are unable to access those profits or while the profit allocation remains to some extent contingent. New regulatory rules on remuneration to be introduced under the EU Alternative Investment Fund Managers Directive (“AIFM Directive”) may soon mean that LLPs that are alternative investment fund managers will be required to defer a portion of the remuneration of their individual LLP members. HMRC states that whilst the UK Government acknowledges these arguments, it considers that they do not override the risks of unfairness and market distortion. In particular, it is considered that allowing the use of corporate members for these purposes (or for the retention of working capital) would put those partnerships that do not have a corporate member in a disadvantageous position, such that the use of corporate members might become the norm resulting in overall tax loss.

    Generally, it is clear that HMRC does not propose to limit the scope of the measures on the use of corporate members and profit and loss allocation schemes to what it considers “abusive tax avoidance schemes.” HMRC intends that these new rules should also apply to the use of corporate members in what might in the past have been regarded as acceptable tax-planning arrangements, such as the use of a corporate member as a tax-efficient means of retaining working capital for use in the business or in deferral and retention arrangements.

    The Consultation Document also sets out how HMRC intends to introduce counteracting measures in two other areas:

    • The allocation of losses to individual members who pay a higher rate of tax; and
    • The transfers of partnership interests (including income streams) between members with different tax attributes, whereby a more highly taxed member may agree to reduce his profit entitlement in return for a payment made by another member who will be more favourably taxed on those profits (e.g., a corporate member or a non-UK resident member).

    Future Action

    Although these proposed changes are set out only in a Consultation Document, it is highly likely that HMRC will introduce measures in both these areas. HMRC states that it is seeking responses on the detailed design and potential impact of these changes so as to inform the detailed policy design, and is not seeking comments on the substance of the measures themselves.

    LLPs and their members should review their arrangements in both these areas. The position and membership terms of individual LLP members — particularly more junior members — should be considered to determine the risks of those members being treated as “salaried members” (effectively as employees) under the new proposals. It may be necessary to alter the terms of membership of certain individual LLP members to ensure that such members are subject to economic risk and have a genuine entitlement to share in profits of the LLP. In some cases, LLPs may conclude that it would be more appropriate for such members to become employees of the LLP.

    LLPs with corporate members that are allocated a share of profits of the LLP will also need to review these arrangements and may have to vary their practice in the future. Where corporate members are used as part of more sophisticated tax planning arrangements (such as in member deferral or remuneration planning), LLPs may have to proceed on the basis that such arrangements are unlikely to be effective after April 2014, when the measures proposed in the Consultation Document are to be introduced.

    Authored by Nicholas Fagge.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney or the author.

    In depth
    Authors

    Nick Fagge

    Partner

    London – One Eagle Place

    More insights

  • New York State Minimum Wage Increases and New York City’s Paid Sick Days Requirements

    New York State Minimum Wage Increases and New York City’s Paid Sick Days Requirements

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    New York State Minimum Wage Increases and New York City’s Paid Sick Days Requirements

    May 14, 2013

    Read time: 7 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Two recently passed laws will soon impact New York State and New York City employers. The first law involves an increase in New York State’s minimum wage over a two-year period beginning Dec. 31, 2013. The second law is the Earned Sick Time Act, which was recently passed by the New York City Council and will require most New York City employers to provide leave time beginning, at the earliest, on April 1, 2014.

    Minimum Wage Increases

    On March 29, 2013, Governor Andrew Cuomo signed legislation increasing the state’s minimum wage. The legislation, passed as part of the legislation implementing the New York State 2013-2014 budget, will increase the minimum wage in steps from the current $7.25 per hour. The minimum wage will increase to $8.00 per hour effective Dec. 31, 2013, to $8.75 per hour effective Dec. 31, 2014, and to $9.00 per hour effective Dec. 31, 2015. The minimum wage for tipped workers will remain $7.25 per hour, and the tip credit for those workers remains the same under the new legislation. The legislation, however, authorizes the creation of a wage board to consider increases for tipped workers. We expect the New York State Department of Labor to update its regulations to bring the salary level needed for the exemptions from overtime pay regulations into conformity with the new minimum wage increases.

    New York City’s Paid Sick Time Law

    On May 8, 2013, the New York City Council passed, by a 45–3 vote, the Earned Sick Time Act, which will require most New York City employers to provide paid sick time to their employees. While not yet signed into law, the vote is enough to override a veto by Mayor Michael Bloomberg.

    Due to concerns about the law’s economic impact during the current economic climate, there is an elaborate system to determine when it will be effective. If the New York City Independent Budget Office (“IBO”) determines that the New York City Coincident Economic Index (the “Index”) is at or above its January 2012 level on Dec. 16, 2013, then, on April 1, 2014, all New York City employers with 20 or more employees will be required to begin providing paid sick leave and all other employers covered under the law must begin providing unpaid sick leave at that time. On Oct. 1, 2015, all employers with 15–19 employees, or who employ a domestic worker, will be required to begin providing paid sick time. The law’s implementation will be delayed until a later date if the IBO determines on Dec. 16, 2013 that the Index is below its January 2012 level.

    Under the law, all employers will be required to provide their employees with one hour of sick time for every 30 hours they work, up to a maximum of 40 hours of sick time during the employer’s calendar year. The larger employers referenced above will eventually be required to provide their employees with paid sick time, and all other employers will be required to provide their employees with unpaid sick time. Domestic workers will be entitled to two days of paid sick time in addition to any paid days of rest the domestic worker is already entitled under any applicable law. Employers will not be required to provide sick time to hourly professional employees.[1]

    An employee may use sick time for:

    (a)  The employee’s mental or physical illness, injury or health condition or need for medical diagnosis, care or treatment of a mental or physical illness, injury or health condition or need for preventive medical care;

    (b)  Care of a family member who needs medical diagnosis, care or treatment of a mental or physical illness, injury or health condition or who needs preventative medical care; or

    (c)  Closure of the employee’s place of business by order of a public official due to a public health emergency or the employee’s need to care for a child whose school or childcare provider has been closed by order of a public official due to a public health emergency.

    Employers who already provide their employees with leave sufficient to meet the law’s requirements, whether vacation, personal or any other type of leave, and allow such leave to be used for the same purposes as required under the law, will be in compliance with the law and not required to provide any additional leave time.

    If an employee is absent for more than three consecutive days, the employer may require reasonable documentation that the use of sick time was for an approved purpose. Additionally, an employer may require an employee to provide notice, when practicable, of the employee’s intention to use sick time.

    Except for domestic workers, unused sick time in one calendar year shall be carried over to the following year, unless the employee is paid for the unused paid sick time at the end of the calendar year in which it accrues and the employer provides the employee with an amount of paid sick time that meets or exceeds the law’s requirements on the first day of the next calendar year. In no event, however, is the employer required to allow the use of more than 40 hours of sick time in a calendar year. The law does not require that an employer pay an employee for unused sick leave upon the employee’s separation from employment.

    The legislation does not apply to any employee covered by a collective bargaining agreement if the agreement: (a) expressly waives the provisions of the law; and (b) the agreement provides a comparable benefit for employees. Additionally, the law does not apply to employees in the construction or grocery industries who are covered by a collective bargaining agreement if the agreement expressly waives the provisions of the law, regardless of whether there are comparable benefits.

    Employers must notify their employees of their right to sick time at the commencement of their employment. The New York City Department of Consumer Affairs is required to create and make available downloadable notices that contain the required information and allow the employer to fill in the applicable dates for each employer’s calendar year. Violations of the law will be enforced by the Department of Consumer Affairs.

    We recommend that employers review their current leave time policies to ensure they are in compliance the new law. Employers should pay close attention to their carry over and accrual policies to ensure they meet all of the law’s requirements.

    Authored by Mark E. Brossman, Ronald E. Richman, Holly H. Weiss, Scott A. Gold and Adam B. Gartner.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] An hourly professional employee is defined as “any individual (i) who is professionally licensed by the New York state education department, office of professions, under the direction of the New York State Board of Regents under education law sections 6732, 7902 or 8202, (ii) who calls in for work assignments at will determining his or her own work schedule with the ability to reject or accept any assignment referred to them and (iii) who is paid an average hourly wage which is at least four times the federal minimum wage for hours worked during the calendar year.”


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP (“SRZ”) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.

    In depth
    Authors

    Mark E. Brossman

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Ronald E. Richman

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Holly H. Weiss

    Retired Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Adam B. Gartner

    Special Counsel

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Ninth Circuit Allows Bankruptcy Courts to Recharacterize Loans as Equity, Applying State Law

    Ninth Circuit Allows Bankruptcy Courts to Recharacterize Loans as Equity, Applying State Law

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Ninth Circuit Allows Bankruptcy Courts to Recharacterize Loans as Equity, Applying State Law

    May 10, 2013

    Read time: 10 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Ninth Circuit held on April 30, 2013 that a bankruptcy court “has the authority to determine whether a transaction creates a debt or an equity interest for purposes of [Bankruptcy Code] § 548, and that a transaction creates a debt if it creates a ‘right to payment’ under state law.” In re Fitness Holdings International, Inc., 2013 WL 1800000, *1 (9th Cir. April 30, 2013). The court agreed with five other circuits, but explicitly followed the reasoning of the Fifth Circuit’s recent In re Lothian Oil, Inc. decision. 650 F.3d 539, 543-44 (5th Cir. 2011) (looked to state law to “distinguish between debt and equity”).

    The debtor in Fitness had made a pre-bankruptcy transfer of cash to its sole shareholder in repayment of a purported loan. Although the lower courts held they lacked the power to go behind the loan documentation, the court of appeals remanded for further litigation, holding that the bankruptcy court, in fact, had the power to recharacterize the transaction. Essentially, the Ninth Circuit interpreted the bankruptcy trustee’s claim “as a request for a determination that [the debtor’s payment] to [its shareholder] was not made in repayment of a ‘debt’ as that term is defined in the Code.” Id. at *2, n.4. If the payment was, in substance, a dividend when the debtor was insolvent, the insider shareholder would have received a fraudulent transfer under Code § 548.

    Relevance

    Creditors regularly scrutinize a debtor’s payment to insiders such as a sole shareholder. Whether and how recharacterization is a weapon in the creditors’ arsenal has troubled the lower courts. Fitness shows that the courts of appeals are now coalescing on how to treat repayment of insider “loans.” Lothian, moreover, held that “recharacterization extends beyond insiders and is part of the bankruptcy courts’ authority to allow and disallow claims under [Code] § 502.” 650 F.3d at 542.

    Facts

    A bank and the debtor’s sole shareholder in Fitness had provided the debtor with “significant funding.” Id. at *1. The shareholder’s loan to the debtor was unsecured, and the shareholder had also guaranteed the debtor’s obligations to the bank. Id. The bank later loaned additional sums to the debtor for the purpose of paying off the shareholder’s unsecured loan, while also releasing the shareholder from its guaranty to the bank. Within the following year, the debtor filed a Chapter 11 petition. The creditors’ committee sought to “recover the payments made to [the shareholder] as a result of the refinancing transaction with” the bank, asking the court to “characterize the financing [the shareholder] provided to [the debtor] … as equity investments, … rather than extensions of credit.” Id. Thus, reasoned the committee, the cash payment to the shareholder was a “constructively fraudulent” transfer. Id.

    Analysis

    The district court affirmed the bankruptcy court’s dismissal of the claims against the shareholder prior to conversion of the case to a Chapter 7 liquidation. Id. at *2. In affirming the bankruptcy court, the district court held that the shareholder’s “advances to [the debtor] were loans and, as a matter of law, it was barred from recharacterizing such loans as equity investments.” Id., relying on In re Pacific Express, 69 B.R. 112, 115 (B.A.P. 9th Cir. 1986). Id. According to the court of appeals, the “district court erred in holding it was bound by a decision of the Bankruptcy Appellate Panel,” citing Bank of Maui v. Estate Analysis, Inc., 904 F.2d 470, 472 (9th Cir. 1990) (“As Article III courts, the district courts must always be free to decline to follow BAP decisions and to formulate their own rules within their jurisdiction.”). Id., n.3.

    Whether the sole shareholder had a “right to payment constituting a ‘claim’” under the Code, explained the Ninth Circuit, turns on “state law.” Id. at *3. “. . . [T]he basic federal rule in bankruptcy is that state law governs the substance of claims, Congress having generally left the determination of property rights and the assets of a bankrupt estate to state law.” Id., quoting Travelers Cas. & Sur. Co. of Am. v. Pacific Gas & Elec. Co., 549 U.S. 443, 450 (2007). Thus, “when the Bankruptcy Code uses the word ‘claim’ — which the Code itself defines as a ‘right to payment’ — it is usually referring to a right to payment recognized under state law.” Id. at *3, quoting Travelers, 549 U.S. at 451.

    The Code defines debt as “liability on the claim,” § 101(12), and defines “value” as including “satisfaction or securing of a . . . debt.” Code § 548(d)(2)(A). Thus, reasoned the court, in the fraudulent transfer context, “a transfer is for ‘reasonably equivalent value’ for purposes of § 548(a)(1)(B)(1)(i) if it is made in repayment of a claim, i.e., a ‘right to payment’ under state law.” Id. at *4.

    The Ninth Circuit in Fitness dealt with the trustee’s request for recharacterization of the purported debt to the sole shareholder as follows: “[I]f any party claims that the transfer constituted the repayment of debt (and thus was a transfer for ‘reasonably equivalent value’), the court must determine whether the purported ‘debt’ constituted a right to payment under state law.” Id. “If it [was not a right to payment as a debt], the court may recharacterize the debtor’s obligation to the transferee under state law principles.” Id. In reaching this conclusion, the court explicitly rejected the BAP’s holding in Pacific Express that the Code “did not authorize courts to characterize claims as equity or debt.” Id. Finding that the Code gives a bankruptcy court “the authority to recharacterize claims in bankruptcy [cases],” the Ninth Circuit joined other circuits reaching the same conclusion. Id. at *5. It agreed “with the approach adopted by the Fifth Circuit in In re Lothian Oil, Inc., 650 F.3d 539, 543 (5th Cir. 2011), which is consistent with the [Supreme Court’s] Butner principle.” Id. at *5. Butner v. United States, 440 U.S. 48, 54 (1979) (“Congress has generally left the determination of property rights in the assets of a bankrupt’s estate to state law.”). Thus, “in order to determine whether a particular obligation owed by the debtor is a ‘claim’ for purposes of bankruptcy law, it is first necessary to determine whether that obligation gives the holder of the obligation a ‘right to payment’ under state law.” Id. If there is no debt under state law, the bankruptcy court has the power to recharacterize the purported loan as equity.

    Remand

    For the trustee in Fitness to state a claim, he “was required to plausibly allege that the interest created by [the sole shareholder’s] agreements with the [the debtor] constituted equity investments (rather than debt) under applicable state law, and that therefore [the sole shareholder] had no ‘right to payment’ . . . from [the debtor].” Id. at *6. The trustee could therefore “claim that [the debtor’s] transfer was not for reasonably equivalent value,” an essential material allegation of a constructively fraudulent claim under Code § 548(a)(1)(B). Id. The district court, therefore, had mistakenly held that it was “barred from considering whether the complaint plausibly alleged that the [sole shareholder’s] promissory notes could be recharacterized as creating equity interests rather than debt . . . .” Id. Instead of ruling on the merits, the Ninth Circuit vacated the lower courts’ dismissal of the trustee’s fraudulent transfer claim, and remanded the matter to them for further disposition. Id.

    Limited Consensus Among Appellate Courts

    At least five other circuits had agreed that bankruptcy courts could recharacterize claims. Lothian, supra, 650 F.3d at 544 (5th Cir. 2011) (courts must define “claim” under state law; “Texas law controls the agreements underlying [the] claims in this case”; purported debt may be equity when state law would treat it as such); In re Submicron Sys., 432 F.3d 448, 454 (3d Cir. 2006) (court has equitable power to recharacterize debt depending on whether it is more like equity); In re Dornier Aviation, 453 F.3d 225, 231 (4th Cir. 2006); In re Hedged-Investments Associates, Inc., 380 F.3d 1292, 1298 (10th Cir. 2004); In re Autostyle Plastics, Inc., 269 F.3d 726, 748 (6th Cir. 2001) (court had power to recharacterize claim under 11-factor test derived from federal tax law). Nevertheless, despite different methodologies among the circuits, the Ninth Circuit found the approach taken by the Fifth Circuit in Lothian to be “more consistent with Supreme Court precedent [i.e., Butner].” Id. at *5.

    Delaware and New York Case Law On Recharacterization

    Under Delaware state law, for example, the “question of whether or not the holder of a particular instrument is a stockholder or a creditor depends upon the terms of his contract.” Wolfensohn v. Madison Fund, Inc., 253 A.2d 72, 75 (Del. 1969) (when preferred stock holders received debentures and certificates to eliminate arrearage in corporate debt, issuance of debentures and certificates created a debtor-creditor relationship). Delaware courts have considered numerous facts to determine whether a debtor-creditor relationship was created, including: (1) the name given to the instrument; (2) the right to enforce payment of principal and interest; (3) presence or absence of a fixed maturity date; and (4) presence or absence of right to share in profits or participate in management. Moore v. American Fin. & Secs. Co., 73 A.2d 47, 47-48 (Del. Ch. 1950) (held, holders of certificates should be treated as stockholders and not creditors because of lack of definite maturity date).

    Bankruptcy courts in New York follow the Sixth Circuit test when doing a recharacterization analysis: “Courts analyzing recharacterization claims balance the factors laid out by the Sixth Circuit in [Bayer Corp. v. MascoTech, Inc. (In re Autostyle Plastics, Inc.), 269 F.3d, 726, 749-50 (6th Cir. 2001)]: (1) the names given to the certificates evidencing the indebtedness; (2) the presence or absence of a fixed maturity date and schedule of payments; (3) the presence or absence of a fixed rate of interest and interest payments; (4) the source of repayments; (5) the adequacy or inadequacy of capitalization; (6) identity of interest between creditor and stockholder; (7) the security, if any, for the advances; (8) the corporation’s ability to obtain financing from outside lending institutions; (9) the extent to which the advances were subordinated to the claims of outside creditors; (10) the extent to which the advance was used to acquire capital assets; and (11) the presence or absence of a sinking fund to provide repayments.” In re BH&S Holdings LLC, 420 B.R. 112, 157 (Bankr. S.D.N.Y. 2009) (dismissing recharacterization claim for failure to plead facts supporting the AutoStyle factors). See also In re Adelphia Communications Corp., 365 B.R. 24, 73-74 (Bankr. S.D.N.Y. 2007) (same); In re General Motors Corp., 407 B.R. 463, 498-99 (Bankr. S.D.N.Y. 2009) (prepetition debt was, in fact, debt and should not be recharacterized as equity).

    Recharacterization Different From Equitable Subordination

    Code § 510(c) authorizes a bankruptcy court to subordinate a claim “to all or part of another allowed claim . . . under principles of equitable subordination . . . .” Although subordination and “recharacterization [may be]” based on the same facts,” they “are directed at different conduct and have different remedies.” Lothian, 650 F.3d at 543; In re Winstar Commc’ns., Inc., 554 F.3d 382, 414 (3d Cir. 2009). Equitable subordination is remedial, not punitive, meaning that the remedy is available only to the extent necessary to repair the harm suffered by the debtor and its creditors. See, e.g., Wooley v. Faulkner (In re SI Restructuring, Inc.), 532 F.3d 355 (5th Cir. 2008) (subordination “inappropriate” when trustee failed to prove harm from insider loans).

    Authored by Michael L. Cook.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or the author.


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP (“SRZ”) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • UK Supreme Court Issues Authoritative Decision on ‘Balance Sheet Insolvency Test’

    UK Supreme Court Issues Authoritative Decision on ‘Balance Sheet Insolvency Test’

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    UK Supreme Court Issues Authoritative Decision on ‘Balance Sheet Insolvency Test’

    9 May 2013

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The UK Supreme Court today delivered an important decision on the meaning of the so-called ‘balance sheet insolvency test’ in s.123(2) of the Insolvency Act 1986 (UK) (BNY Corporate Trustee Services Limited v Eurosail 2007-3BL PLC [2013] UKSC 28 (“Eurosail”)).

    Section 123(2) provides that a company is deemed unable to pay its debts if it is proved to the satisfaction of the court that the value of the company’s assets is less than the amount of its liabilities, taking into account its contingent and prospective liabilities. The parameter of s.123(2) is of significance for almost all English law financing transactions (including structured financings, of which Eurosail is an example), since, if the debtor falls foul of it, it will invariably trigger a right on a creditor to default the transaction and enforce the debtor’s security. In today’s environment of strained ‘Loan to Values’ and lack of liquidity, an authoritative decision on the matter has anxiously been awaited by debtors and creditors alike. The investment community, whether debtor or creditor, should be breathing a sigh of relief with this decision for its pragmatic and common sense approach.

    In the case of Eurosail, the debtor’s recently audited balance sheets showed a net liability (largely due to the insolvency of a key swap counter-party to the transaction, Lehman Brothers Special Financing Inc.) and, on the strength of that, one class of its creditor’s (the “Class A3”) asserted that it must therefore fall foul of s.123(2). If the Class A3 were right in their argument, the triggering of an Event of Default would result in a change in waterfall from the Pre-Enforcement Waterfall to the Post-Enforcement Waterfall, in which the Class A3 creditors have an elevated position and rank pari passu with another class of creditors (the “Class A2”). The debtor (an issuer of long-dated publicly tradable notes (commonly referred to as ‘RMBS Notes’), that owned assets comprising a static pool of residential mortgage loans), on the other hand, argued that, in the context of this transaction and at this point in time, it was premature and inappropriate to determine that its assets are less than its liabilities. The issuer specifically pointed to the fact that the bulk of its liabilities did not fall due until 2045 and that the performance of its assets could be subject to fluctuation and that there were various factors embedded within the transaction which were difficult to predict (including foreign exchange and interest rates and the performance of the UK property market). The issuer also pointed out that it had been paying its debts as they fell due (and was, therefore, ‘cash-flow’ solvent). The issuer’s position was supported by the Class A2.

    The Supreme Court agreed with the issuer, noting that an audited balance sheet, which is drawn in accordance with technical accounting standards and rules, is not decisive on the question set out in s.123(2), which rather involves a factual enquiry based on “all the available evidence and the circumstances of the particular case.” The Supreme Court stated:

    “. . . in the case of a company’s liabilities that can as matters now stand be deferred for over 30 years, and where the company is (without any permanent increase in its borrowings) paying its debts as they fall due, the court should proceed with the greatest caution in deciding that the company is in a state of balance-sheet insolvency under section 123(2) . . . Eurosail’s ability or inability to pay all its debt, present or future, may not be finally determined until much closer to 2045, that is more than 30 years from now.”

    The Supreme Court rejected the Court of Appeal’s preferred touchstone for the test (as being whether the debtor is “beyond the point of no return”), stating rather that the court must simply be satisfied, on the balance of probabilities, that a company has insufficient assets to be able to meet all its liabilities, including its prospective and contingent liabilities.

    The balance sheet insolvency test is to be distinguished from the other main test for insolvency in the Insolvency Act 1986, the so-called ‘cash-flow’ insolvency test. The Supreme Court affirmed past authority, that the cash-flow test involves a consideration of the debtor’s ability to pay its presently due debt and also a consideration of its ability to pay debts falling due in the reasonably near future.

    The decision is to be welcomed for its good sense and refusal to be drawn into catchphrases for the parameters of s.123(2). There will, however, undoubtedly be others who will criticise it for failing to provide a precise ‘check-list’ style of guidance on the test. There will be others, too, who will no doubt be disappointed at the failure of a tidal wave of defaults that a contrary decision would have yielded.  

    Sonya Van de Graaff and Peter Declercq[1] represented the Class A2 in support of the debtor’s arguments and they are currently working on the restructuring of a number of similar securitization structures.

    Authored by Sonya Van de Graaff, Peter J.M. Declercq, David J. Karp and Adam C. Harris .

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] Sonya Van de Graaff and Peter Declercq are business reorganization partners in the London office, where their respective practices focus on European restructuring, financing, distressed investing and debt trading, and on cross-border insolvencies, restructurings, financing and distressed mergers and acquisitions.


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP and Schulte Roth & Zabel International LLP (“SRZ”) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.

    In depth
    Authors

    Adam C. Harris

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • CFTC Grants Temporary Relief for FX and Swaps Prime Brokerage Arrangements: Context for Private Fund Managers and Other Investment Advisers

    CFTC Grants Temporary Relief for FX and Swaps Prime Brokerage Arrangements: Context for Private Fund Managers and Other Investment Advisers

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    CFTC Grants Temporary Relief for FX and Swaps Prime Brokerage Arrangements: Context for Private Fund Managers and Other Investment Advisers

    May 6, 2013

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On April 30, 2013, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission staff issued a letter granting temporary relief to swap dealers from compliance with certain “external business conduct standards” related to foreign exchange and swap prime brokerage arrangements. This relief is not expected to impose any new obligations on investment advisers. However, it forestalls a potential market disruption by providing swap dealers the ability to resolve certain issues in applying the external business conduct standards to current foreign exchange and swap prime brokerage arrangements. Private fund managers and other investment advisers that engage in such prime brokerage arrangements should expect notices from their prime brokers indicating their compliance with this CFTC staff letter.

    The Commodity Exchange Act (as amended by the Dodd-Frank Act) requires the CFTC to impose certain business conduct standards on swap dealers in their dealings with counterparties. These external business conduct standards place direct obligations on swap dealers, but also have an indirect effect on private fund managers and other investment advisers.[1]

    The central issue necessitating the relief arises in two commonly utilized foreign exchange and swap prime brokerage arrangements. In the first arrangement addressed by the CFTC staff letter, funds (or managers on their behalf) enter into swaps or certain foreign exchange transactions with an executing dealer and those transactions are subsequently “given-up” by the executing dealer to the prime broker. The second arrangement addressed by the letter involves funds entering into transactions on the prime broker’s behalf, as agent for the prime broker. In each case, the final private fund transaction is between the fund and the prime broker, and there is an equal but opposite transaction between the prime broker and the executing dealer.

    Where the prime broker and the executing broker are both swap dealers, each is subject to and required to fully satisfy the external business conduct standards; however, because the prime broker and the executing dealer each possesses only the information relating to its portion of the overall transaction, neither party can easily satisfy such standards. Similar issues affect a prime broker dealing with an executing broker that is not a swap dealer, because the prime broker is obligated to fully satisfy the external business conduct standards but it may not have complete information relating to the executing broker’s portion of the overall transaction.[2] Left unaddressed, the intermediated market would have been adversely affected, which could have led to serious market disruptions.

    This temporary relief permits prime brokers and executing dealers that are swap dealers to allocate between themselves the responsibility to comply with the external business conduct standards. The CFTC staff letter requires that swap dealers (in their role as prime broker and executing dealer) enter into an agreement allocating such responsibilities by May 15, 2013. Today, the International Swaps and Derivatives Association published a protocol for swap dealers to facilitate and expedite the implementation on an industry-wide basis. In a situation where an executing dealer is not a registered swap dealer (which relief is limited to non-swap foreign exchange transactions), the CFTC staff’s action relieves the prime broker from certain external business conduct standards. The temporary relief ends on the later of the effective date or the compliance date of any final rule or final order providing similar relief to swap dealers from compliance with the external business conduct standards.

    Authored by Craig Stein , Kristin Boggiano, Brian T. Daly and Jacob Preiserowicz.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] As a result of the external business conduct standards, an investment adviser is effectively required by its swap dealer counterparties to provide a number of representations and warranties contained in the ISDA August 2012 Dodd-Frank Protocol (among other things, these relate to suitability, independence and sophistication) and will receive certain disclosures with respect to their swap transactions. A copy of the Dodd-Frank Protocol can be accessed at http://www2.isda.org/functional-areas/protocol-management/protocol/8. 

    [2] For example, if a manager were to trade an aggregated or bunched order and allocate it among its managed funds after the trade is given-up to the prime broker, the executing broker would not be able to comply with the “know-your-counterparty” external business standard under CFTC rule 23.402. Conversely, in such a scenario, the executing dealer will have access to trade information and risks related to the transaction at the time that the funds (or manager on its behalf) enter into the trade and will therefore be in a better position to comply with the pre-trade, mid-market-quote and risk-disclosure obligations under CFTC rule 23.431. 


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP (“SRZ”) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions. 

    In depth
    Authors

    Craig Stein

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • US Private Fund Advisers Likely to Have Another Year to Comply with the AIFM Directive for Marketing in the UK

    US Private Fund Advisers Likely to Have Another Year to Comply with the AIFM Directive for Marketing in the UK

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    US Private Fund Advisers Likely to Have Another Year to Comply with the AIFM Directive for Marketing in the UK

    2 May 2013

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Summary

    HM Treasury, which is the legislative body responsible for implementing the Alternative Investment Fund Managers Directive (“AIFM Directive”)[1] into UK law, has just published a Q&A document on proposed amendments to the draft regulations “for the implementation of the AIFM Directive in the UK (the “Q&A Document”).[2] The Q&A Document clarifies that HM Treasury will amend the current draft of The Alternative Investment Fund Managers Regulations 2013 (the “Regulations”)[3] and will enable non-UK AIFMs[4] to take advantage of a 12-month transitional provision such that the AIFM Directive rules will not apply to marketing in the UK until 22 July 2014.

    Proposed Changes

    The Q&A Document covers a wide range of issues pertaining to the implementation of the AIFM Directive in the UK, but the most important development for non-UK managers is the statement in the Q&A Document that the Regulations, which are the draft rules implementing the AIFM Directive into UK law, will be amended to extend the 12-month transitional period for UK AIFMs that are in existence on or before 22 July 2013 to all AIFMs in existence on that date, irrespective of where they are established.

    Under the current draft of the Regulations, only UK AIFMs that manage funds before 22 July 2013 will have the benefit of the proposed 12-month transitional period, allowing such AIFMs to delay authorisation and compliance with the AIFM Directive until the end of that 12-month period. By announcing that it intends to extend the relevant Regulation to all AIFMs, including US AIFMs, HM Treasury has effectively pushed back the start date for the AIFM Directive in the UK for existing AIFMs until 22 July 2014.

    Assuming that the final Regulations are consistent with the Q&A Document, US AIFMs will be able to market their funds in the UK until 22 July 2014 without having to register with the Financial Conduct Authority (“FCA”) or comply with any of the requirements otherwise imposed by AIFM Directive. All AIFMs marketing their funds in the UK must still comply with the UK’s existing marketing rules during that period.

    The proposed transitional period will only apply to those AIFMs that are managing a fund or carrying out other activities[5] before 22 July 2013. Any managers (whether established in the UK or elsewhere) that come into existence after 22 July 2013 must comply with the AIFM Directive for any UK marketing activities conducted after 22 July 2013. For non-EU AIFMs that come into existence after 22 July 2013, this will mean that prior to marketing in the UK they will need to notify the FCA, update all marketing materials for compliance with the AIFM Directive (make the required “pre-investment disclosures”), make quarterly or semi-annual risk report filings with the FCA[6] and make the annual and other filings required under the Directive.

    The Q&A Document states that existing AIFMs will not be required to comply with any procedure to benefit from the 12-month transitional period in the UK.

    Marketing in Other EU Jurisdictions

    As the Q&A Document is UK-specific, a US AIFM or other non-EEA[7] AIFM that wishes to market its funds in other EU jurisdictions (pursuant to such jurisdictions’ private placement rules) will still have to comply with the AIFM Directive requirements in such jurisdictions from 22 July 2013 (unless those jurisdictions implement a similar transitional period). As of the date of this Alert, it is unclear whether other EU countries will implement similar transitional periods.

    Authored by Neil Robson, Christopher Hilditch and Josh Dambacher .

    For more information on the issues set forth in this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] For more information on the AIFM Directive, please refer to our Briefing Notes in our SRZ AIFM Directive Resource Center.

    [2] We understand that the Q&A Document was initially distributed to those firms with whom HM Treasury has engaged on the AIFM Directive. The Q&A Document contains answers to a number of questions received in response to the HM Treasury consultation published in January 2013.http://www.hm-treasury.gov.uk/d/consult_transposition_of_the_alternative_investment_fund_managers_directive_110113.pdf.

    Further questions will be addressed in a follow-up policy statement, and it is understood that the Q&A Document will be available on the HM Treasury website shortly.

    [3] The Regulations are an annex to HM Treasury’s January 2013 consultation paper: “Transposition of the Alternative Investment Fund Managers Directive.” http://www.hm-treasury.gov.uk/d/consult_transposition_of_the_alternative_investment_fund_managers_directive_110113.pdf.

    [4] For more information and analysis as to which manager or adviser is an AIFM in a particular fund structure, see the SRZ Briefing, AIF, AIFMs and EU Authorisation Requirements.

    [5] The Q&A Document does not specify what these other activities are. We anticipate that HM Treasury’s forthcoming policy statement, which will include revised Regulations, will provide more guidance with respect to which non-UK AIFMs may be able to take advantage of the extended transitional period.

    [6] For more information on the general marketing rules under the AIFM Directive, see the SRZ Briefing, Marketing Requirements.

    [7] The European Economic Area (“EEA”) comprises the countries of the European Union (Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, the Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden and the UK) together with Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway.


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP and Schulte Roth & Zabel International LLP (“SRZ”) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.

    In depth
    Authors

    Christopher Hilditch

    Partner

    London – One Eagle Place

    Josh Dambacher

    Partner

    London – One Eagle Place

    More insights

  • Independent Schools Should Review Student Travel Policies in Light of Recent Jury Verdict

    Independent Schools Should Review Student Travel Policies in Light of Recent Jury Verdict

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Independent Schools Should Review Student Travel Policies in Light of Recent Jury Verdict

    April 22, 2013

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    A former student at The Hotchkiss School won a $41.75 million dollar jury verdict against the school for injuries sustained after contracting tick-borne encephalitis while on a school trip to China. The student’s attorneys argued that Hotchkiss, a private boarding school in Connecticut, was negligent in allowing students to walk through an area known for insect-transmitted diseases without taking safety precautions. The lawsuit further alleged that the trip leaders “did not appreciate the significance of the initial symptoms of the illness” and lacked protocol for handling medical emergencies. Plaintiffs alleged that parents were told that the trip went to three urban centers: Beijing, Shanghai and Tianjin. The school’s trip leader failed to communicate that a hike in a rural area, 100 kilometers from Tianjin, was part of the trip.

    Hotchkiss argued that infections of this sort are so rare that they are not reasonably foreseeable or preventable. After eight hours of deliberations, the jury found that the school was negligent. The school intends to appeal the verdict.

    In light of this verdict and regardless of what happens on appeal, all independent schools should review their travel policies and procedures, including medical documentation, emergency protocols, and permission forms and releases. Some specific considerations/best practices include:

    • Permission forms/releases. Schools should always have students and parents sign permission slips specifically allowing a student to attend a trip, and a release to protect the school and school employees. In New York, releases from gross negligence are rarely enforceable, but a well drafted release can still serve to protect a school from most other claims. It is important that permission forms and releases be as detailed as possible. They should include detailed lists of the risks specific to the trip. The U.S. State Department and the Center for Disease Control should be used as resources to identify current risks in particular areas. Additionally, all permission forms should indicate how much supervision by school employees will be provided during the trip and clearly state if students will be unsupervised at any time during the trip.
    • Emergency procedures. Every school should review their emergency procedures during trips, especially when travelling abroad. The procedures should be reviewed and updated regularly and, where appropriate, should include procedures specific to the location of the trip. The procedures should specify who has the authority to decide when there is a crisis and next steps. Emergency protocols should be clearly communicated with faculty, trip supervisors, students and their families. In the Hotchkiss case, it was alleged that the trip leaders had no medical training, did not appreciate the significance of the initial symptoms of the illness, had no protocol for notifying parents and failed to undertake pre-trip planning and make pre-trip arrangements for the transfer back to the United States of students with medical emergencies.
    • Insurance. Schools should contact their insurance providers to ensure that they have appropriate coverage for all trips. Some schools purchase kidnap/ransom coverage, for example, if they are travelling to a dangerous area. In light of the Hotchkiss case, schools should review their coverage with their providers.
    • Due diligence. Schools should research travel plans in advance, including itineraries and accommodations. If students are staying with host families, schools should ensure background checks are conducted, living accommodations are satisfactory, etc. In the Hotchkiss case, it was found that the trip leaders failed to require the students to take proper precautions against potential mosquito or tick bites, such as requiring the students to wear protective clothing or utilizing protective insect repellent.
    • School sponsorship. Schools frequently permit a faculty member, parent or outside organization to organize a trip. If a school allows such an arrangement, the school must make it clear to students, parents, teachers, insurance providers, etc., that the event is not school sponsored or endorsed. The organizer and all participants and their parents should be required to acknowledge that they understand that the trip is not school sponsored.

    School-sponsored travel always involves some risk. By properly identifying risks, communicating the risks with students and families, and maintaining proper releases, insurance and emergency protocols, schools can both minimize liability and protect students.

    Authored by Mark E. Brossman and Donna Lazarus.

    If you have any questions concerning this Client Alert, please contact your attorney or one of the authors.

    In depth
    Authors

    Mark E. Brossman

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Donna K. Lazarus

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights