Content Type: Article

  • The Duty of the Joint Federal Committee in the Formation of Level 3 Reference Price Groups

    ARTICLE

    The Duty of the Joint Federal Committee in the Formation of Level 3 Reference Price Groups

    February, 2017

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Deniz Tschammler authored the article “Zur Pflichtenstellung des Gemeinsamen Bundesausschusses bei der Bildung von Festbetragsgruppen der Stufe 3” (with Prof. Dr. Dirk Uwer), featured in GesR 2017, p. 76-819. in February 2017.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Recent Developments in Tax Law: New Regulations in Tax Law

    ARTICLE

    Recent Developments in Tax Law: New Regulations in Tax Law

    February 2017

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Dr. Gero Burwitz authored the article “Recent Development in Tax Law: European Court of Justice on the Restructuring Clause: Annulment of the Commission Decision”, featured in Neue Zeitschrift für Gesellschaftsrecht (NZG), p. 133-135 in February, 2017.

    In depth
    Authors

    Dr. Gero Burwitz

    Partner

    Munich

    More insights

  • Final Rule Modernizes Substance Use Disorder Patient Record Confidentiality Regulations

    Final Rule Modernizes Substance Use Disorder Patient Record Confidentiality Regulations

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Final Rule Modernizes Substance Use Disorder Patient Record Confidentiality Regulations

    February 7, 2017

    Read time: 11 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On January 18, 2017, the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) released its long-awaited final rule amending the confidentiality regulations at 42 CFR Part 2 (Part 2) that apply to federally assisted substance use disorder treatment programs (Part 2 Programs). SAMHSA concurrently issued a supplemental notice of proposed rulemaking (SNPRM) to further modify the regulation in light of commenter feedback, with a comment period ending February 17, 2017.

    In depth

    On January 18, 2017, the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) released its long-awaited final rule amending the confidentiality regulations at 42 CFR Part 2 (Part 2) that apply to federally assisted substance use disorder treatment programs (Part 2 Programs). SAMHSA concurrently issued a supplemental notice of proposed rulemaking (SNPRM) to further modify the regulation in light of commenter feedback, with a comment period ending February 17, 2017.

    Part 2 has not been modernized in nearly 30 years. Since the last modification of Part 2 in 1987, the health data sharing landscape has changed dramatically as has the public and medical community’s understanding of and attitudes towards individuals with substance use disorders. As a result, Part 2 provisions designed to protect patients from stigma and other privacy concerns may have the unintended consequence of making it more difficult for providers to deploy data-driven tools and outreach to help these patients. In addition, since Part 2 was last modified, state and federal regulators have adopted other privacy frameworks, leaving providers with an array of overlapping and sometimes conflicting requirements.

    Against this backdrop, SAMHSA stated that its goal in this rulemaking cycle was to reduce compliance burdens associated with Part 2 by making it easier for Part 2 Programs to exchange records and patient identifying information covered by Part 2 (Part 2 Records) with a patient’s treating health care providers through clinically integrated care networks, health information exchanges (HIEs) and accountable care organizations (ACOs). Notwithstanding that goal, SAMHSA acknowledged that further alignment with Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA) beyond those set forth in the final rule likely cannot occur without legislation from US Congress.

    In addition, SAMHSA acknowledged that health care providers, clinically integrated care networks, HIEs and ACOs may incur significant costs to facilitate data sharing in light of the final rule’s corresponding consent requirements. SAMHSA estimates that the regulation will cost the industry $241 million dollars over the next 10 years. Thus, while the final rule is a step toward modernizing Part 2, and does reduce some burdens on the exchange of Part 2 Records, Congress will likely need to amend the statute authorizing Part 2 if it wants to advance efforts to harmonize Part 2 with the protections in place for other types of health information.

    The following sections of this On the Subject discuss the key changes included in the final rule and the SNPRM.

    New General Designation Pathway

    Part 2 applies to (1) patient identifying information (2) that has been obtained from a Part 2 Program and (3) indicates that the individual has a substance use disorder. Part 2 Programs and health care providers that receive Part 2 Records must obtain a patient’s written consent to share Part 2 Records for treatment, payment and health care operations purposes. In addition, Part 2 generally requires that the written consent form specify, among other things, the name or title of the individual or the name of the organization to which the disclosure is to be made. As a result of this specificity requirement, historically patients could not sign a general consent form permitting Part 2 Programs and others to share Part 2 Records with anyone involved in their care. Conversely, the HIPAA Privacy Rule permits authorizations to describe a class of recipients and does not require each recipient to be named.

    Additionally, Part 2 Programs could not share Part 2 Records with other health care providers and payers for important health care operations such as care coordination, case management and population health activities unless they first obtain consent. The Privacy Rule permits such disclosures without patient authorization.

    Making only minor changes from its proposed rule, SAMHSA finalized a new general designation consent pathway that permits Part 2 Programs and other lawful recipients of Part 2 Records to disclose Part 2 Records to all of a patient’s past, present and/or future treating providers through third parties, such as clinically integrated care networks, HIEs and ACOs, without naming each treating provider. The consent form must list by name the third parties (such as a HIE, ACO or clinically integrated care network) that will facilitate the exchange of the Part 2 Records and generally permit such third part(ies) to redisclose Part 2 Records to all health care providers involved in the patient’s past, present and/or future care. To offer this “general designation” pathway, however, the third party would be required to both: have the technological capability to limit access to Part 2 Records to providers involved in the patient’s care (as instructed by the patient’s consent); and produce to the patient upon demand a “list of disclosures” showing the providers that have received access to the patient’s Part 2 Records.

    This second requirement goes beyond the HIPAA Privacy Rule’s accounting of disclosures requirement, which does not currently require covered entities and business associates to keep an accounting of routine disclosures for treatment, payment or health care operations purposes. Notably, the Office for Civil Rights (OCR) has been unable to implement, due to technological limitations, a similar provision of the HITECH Act that requires OCR to amend the Privacy Rule’s accounting of disclosures provision to require HIPAA covered entities to account for (i.e., track) disclosures for treatment, payment and health care operations purposes made through an electronic health record system.

    SAMHSA reiterated in the final rule that Part 2 Programs are not required to offer this new general designation pathway if they do not participate in health information exchange facilitated by third parties. Given the investment of resources likely needed to implement the rule’s requirement to track disclosures under general designations, many clinically integrated care networks, HIEs and ACOs may determine that they cannot implement the pathway, or can only do so after a sustained delay to develop such features.

    Additional Updates: Qualified Service Organizations, Research & Claims Data

    While the new consent pathway might be the most newsworthy change included in the final rule, other changes finalized by SAMHSA may offer relief to health care providers, payers and researchers seeking to review Part 2 Records to conduct research, improve care quality and manage population health outcomes.

    Qualified Service Organizations

    SAMHSA finalized an expanded definition for “Qualified Service Organization” to include “population health management.” This change clarifies that Part 2 Programs may engage an ACO, managed care organization or other contractor to perform population health management activities, such as the identification and monitoring of particular patients within the Part 2 Program’s patient population, to improve health outcomes. As a result of this change, Part 2 Programs may seek increased assistance from vendors to perform these activities on their behalf.

    Relatedly, the SNPRM responds to commenters who expressed concern that Part 2 does not currently allow recipients of Part 2 Records, such as third party payers, to disclose the records to subcontractors and other vendors that perform administrative functions on their behalf. Under SAMHSA’s current interpretation of Part 2 and the final rule, non-Part 2 Program recipients of Part 2 Records cannot engage such downstream contractors as Qualified Service Organizations because, by definition, Qualified Service Organizations provide services directly to Part 2 Programs.

    Under the SNPRM, persons and entities that receive Part 2 Records pursuant to a Part 2-compliant consent would be permitted to disclose the Part 2 Records to contractors, subcontractors and legal representatives for the purpose of carrying out 17 specific payment and health care operations activities, including utilization review and quality assessment and improvement activities. The parties would need to enter into a contract (similar to a business associate agreement under HIPAA) which fully binds the contractor to Part 2.

    However, payers and other entities that receive Part 2 Records could not use this contract pathway to engage a contractor to perform treatment-related activities such as care coordination or case management because SAMHSA only included health care operations and payment activities in the 17 specific functions. Under the SNPRM, written consent from the patient would be needed for a Part 2 Record holder (other than the Part 2 Program) to perform treatment-related activities.

    While this much-needed new pathway would permit critical activities that health care providers and payers typically engage in, a broader HIPAA-like business associate pathway that includes care coordination and case management would be needed to allow contractors to assist health care providers and health plans to engage patients, better coordinate care and improve outcomes.

    Research

    SAMHSA finalized proposed changes to make the research exception to the Part 2 consent requirement more consistent with the Privacy Rule and the Federal Policy for the Protection of Human Subjects (Common Rule). Under the revised research exception, Part 2 Programs and other lawful holders of Part 2 Records may disclose patient identifying information to a researcher who: obtains approval to conduct research of Part 2 Records from an institutional review board (IRB) or privacy board formed under the requirements of the Privacy Rule or the Common Rule; and agrees to be fully bound by Part 2 with respect to the Part 2 Records and resist in judicial proceedings any efforts to obtain access to such records unless provision of the records is required by law.

    In the final rule, SAMHSA declined to finalize a restriction in the proposed rule that would have only permitted researchers to link Part 2 Records with data from federal data repositories. Researchers may now link Part 2 Records to other data repositories upon approval of the appropriate IRB or privacy board, provided that the repository agrees to be fully bound by Part 2. This change in the final rule will create new opportunities to conduct research on substance use disorders.

    Medicare Claims Data

    SAMHSA offered guidance in the final rule in response to concerns that CMS is currently withholding claims data relating to substance use disorder treatment from the claims data it typically provides to CMS-regulated ACOs due to Part 2’s restrictions. ACOs want access to substance use disorder claims data in order to offer their patients comprehensive treatment and to assist with fully informed patient engagement and quality improvement efforts. The omission of Part 2 data from the patient file could understandably lead to ineffective and/or incomplete management of a patient’s care. According to SAMHSA’s guidance, CMS may disclose patient identifying information to CMS-regulated ACOs without first obtaining written consent, but only for the purpose of facilitating audits or evaluation activities, such as “reviews of financial performance or the quality of health care services delivered, [which are] undertaken by the CMS regulated organization itself to review its own performance.” ACOs will now need to wait and see if CMS will change its current policy, and release substance use disorder claims data for these limited purposes. Thus, SAMHSA does not appear to be enabling CMS to provide the Part 2 Records to ACOs for the clinical and care coordination purposes they sought.

    Implications for Value-Based Payment Programs

    As Medicare and private payers and providers shift from fee for service to value-based payment models and alternative payment models, the pressures to use and exchange patient information for care coordination, patient engagement, population health management and research intensify. While the Part 2 final rule and SNPRM includes helpful changes for Part 2 Programs and others seeking to more efficiently use and disclose Part 2 Records for research, population health management and care coordination, it maintains restrictions that prevent the sharing of Part 2 Records when otherwise permissible under HIPAA.

    As long as Part 2 Records remain separated out from other types of health information, substance use disorder patients may continue to lag behind other patients in their access to improved care coordination, case management and population health activities. Pressure is likely to increase on Congress to enable better harmonization of privacy laws.

    In the recently passed 21st Century Cures Act, Congress requires SAMHSA to convene stakeholders within the next year to determine the final rule’s effect on patient care, health outcomes and patient privacy. This provision signals that Congress may be willing to act if stakeholders conclude the final rule does not allow them to share Part 2 Records as needed to improve patient care and health outcomes. Part 2 Programs, clinically integrated care networks, HIEs, ACOs and other stakeholders should therefore continue to make their voices heard to SAMHSA and on Capitol Hill if they would like to see changes to Part 2 that align it more closely with HIPAA’s use and disclosure pathways.

    Authors

    Jennifer S. Geetter

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Daniel F. Gottlieb

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • Courts Rejecting Connection Between FCA, Medical Necessity

    ARTICLE

    Courts Rejecting Connection Between FCA, Medical Necessity

    February 6, 2017

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Rebecca Martin and Laura McLane wrote this bylined article on recent court rulings which held that a mere difference of opinion between physicians is not enough to establish falsity under the False Claims Act. The authors called the rulings “welcome developments for providers, who often confront both audits and FCA actions premised on alleged lack of medical necessity, even in situations where physicians vigorously disagree about the appropriate course of treatment.”

    In depth
    Authors

    Laura McLane

    Partner

    Boston

    More insights

  • Telehealth Benefits on the Rise Despite Low Employee Utilization

    ARTICLE

    Telehealth Benefits on the Rise Despite Low Employee Utilization

    February 2017

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Lisa Schmitz Mazur wrote this bylined article on the challenges employers face in getting employees to use telehealth benefits. Suggesting that employees either are unaware of or are hesitant to use these benefits, Ms. Mazur wrote that “employers and telehealth providers must develop and implement (often in tandem) strategies for addressing these barriers to increase employee utilization.”

    In depth
    Authors

    Lisa Mazur

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • HHS Finalizes Toned-Down Version of Common Rule Overhaul

    HHS Finalizes Toned-Down Version of Common Rule Overhaul

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    HHS Finalizes Toned-Down Version of Common Rule Overhaul

    February 6, 2017

    Read time: 24 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Final Rule published by the US Department of Health and Human Services on January 18, 2017, largely avoids major modifications to the Common Rule. However, it specifically addresses creation of biospecimen and data repositories and use of those repositories for secondary research. All stakeholders involved in federally funded research should be aware of the Final Rule’s changes and prepare to implement them.

    In depth

    On January 18, 2017, the US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) issued long-awaited amendments (Final Rule) to the Federal Policy for the Protection of Human Subjects (Common Rule). HHS’s stated goals for these changes are to align the Common Rule with the modernization of the research and privacy landscape and to otherwise strengthen the Common Rule while reducing administrative burdens for researchers. All institutions that accept federal funding from HHS or any of the 15 other federal departments and agencies that have now signed on to the Common Rule (Common Rule Agencies), as well as other stakeholders, need to understand and prepare to implement these changes. Affected entities include, among others, investigators; research sites; institutional review board (IRB) administrators and members; independent research organizations; Institutional Officials and staff; and the pharmaceutical, medical device and biotechnology industries.

    The Final Rule retreats from several key proposals in HHS’s September 2, 2015, notice of proposed rulemaking (NPRM) that have been the subject of significant debate since HHS issued the advance notice of proposed rulemaking in 2011. Of particular note is HHS’s decision to abandon several controversial proposed changes to the Common Rule that would have materially altered how research—particularly genomic and biospecimen research—is conducted in the United States. In particular, the Final Rule does not include the proposal to consider biospecimens that are unannotated with identifying data as “human subjects” under the Common Rule. HHS’s about-face on this proposal, as well as its retreat from several other controversial proposals, underscores the extent of opposition to such proposals expressed in stakeholders’ reactions to the NPRM. The Final Rule also leaves unresolved the ambiguities that health care providers and researchers have consistently encountered in trying to determine the line between human subject research and quality assurance/quality improvement activities.

    Nonetheless, the Final Rule adopts a number of changes that will have a noticeable impact on the Common Rule’s informed consent, waiver and IRB review requirements. While some of these changes may ease the administrative burden on researchers, others (particularly the new informed consent and waiver requirements) may impose new challenges in pursuing secondary research. The particularly notable changes of the Final Rule are as follows:

    • While HHS did not adopt the controversial proposal to consider biospecimens that are unannotated with identifying data to be human subjects, the Final Rule requires HHS to periodically assess the Common Rule’s identifiability standards, including whether the presence of genetic material embedded in biospecimens constitutes identifiable information, and permits HHS to update such standards through guidance.
    • The Final Rule imposes new informed consent form requirements. These requirements, including the requirement that consent forms disclose certain details regarding secondary use of data and biospecimens, obligate researchers to provide more specific information about the research study and potential future use than under the prior Common Rule.
    • The Final Rule also adds specific requirements for researchers who wish to obtain “broad” informed consent from subjects for the storage, maintenance or secondary research use of identifiable private information or identifiable biospecimens. Although HHS’s stated objective for this change is to provide enhanced flexibility to researchers, it is unclear whether it will minimize burden in a significant way compared to existing pathways under both current Common Rule regulations (Pre-2018 Rule) and the Final Rule, such as waiver of informed consent.
    • The Final Rule revises and expands the categories of exempt research to include, among others, certain secondary research activities regulated under the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) and certain other secondary research activities. These changes meaningfully lessen the administrative burden researchers will bear when conducting secondary research that is regulated under HIPAA.
    • The Final Rule streamlines requirements for study recruitment and screening activities.
    • The Final Rule includes revisions to the criteria for waiver or alteration of informed consent that may make it more challenging to obtain waiver or alteration of informed consent.
    • The Final Rule eliminates the authority of the Common Rule Agencies to oversee and enforce compliance with the Common Rule with regard to human subjects research that is not federally funded or supported. Institutions may still choose to conduct such research in accordance with the Common Rule; those that do should ensure that their internal oversight and compliance mechanisms align with this new framework.

    Based on the version of the Final Rule as published in the Federal Register, January 19, 2018, is both the effective date of the Final Rule and the compliance date for all provisions except those relating to cooperative research, for which the compliance date is January 20, 2020. The day after the Final Rule’s publication in the Federal Register, President Trump’s chief of staff, Reince Priebus, issued a regulatory freeze that asks regulatory agencies, in part, to postpone by 60 days the effective dates for all regulations that were published in the Federal Register but are not yet effective so that the new administration will have the opportunity to review new regulations. Given that the Final Rule does not become effective until 2018, however, it seems that with or without this freeze, the Trump administration will have ample opportunity to revisit this effective date or, conceivably, other aspects of the Final Rule, if it chooses to do so.

    Following is an overview of these and other notable changes to the Common Rule that are implemented by the Final Rule.

    Scope and Jurisdiction

    Definition of “Human Subject” and Potential for Future Revision

    Departing from one of the NPRM’s most significant and controversial proposals, the Final Rule does not expand the Common Rule’s definition of “human subject” to include all biospecimens whether or not annotated with identifiable information. Rather, HHS retained identifiability as the “North Star” for determining when research uses of data and biospecimens constitute human subjects research and defines an “identifiable biospecimen” as one “for which the identity of the subject is or may readily be ascertained by the investigator or associated with the biospecimen.” HHS conceded that the genetic material embedded in biospecimens is not per se identifiable such that biospecimens will remain “de-identified.”

    The Final Rule, however, may not be the final word on this important issue. The Final Rule requires the Common Rule Agencies to periodically consult with experts and assess the research landscape with respect to (1) the meaning of identifiability in the Common Rule context and (2) new technologies and techniques that can generate identifiable private information or identifiable biospecimens. The Final Rule provides a pathway for the Common Rule Agencies to update their interpretation of “identifiable private information” and “identifiable biospecimen” based on these periodic assessments, including through the use of guidance, as appropriate and permitted by law. The Final Rule also contemplates updates to the list of technologies and techniques that generate identifiable private information and identifiable biospecimens as appropriate based on these periodic assessments, but only after notice and an opportunity for public comment. Significantly, technologies and techniques included on this published list may “only be used in instances where the person has provided their consent (broad or study-specific), or where an IRB has waived the requirement for consent.” Finally, the Final Rule does not resolve the question of whether information that constitutes a limited data set under HIPAA would be considered identifiable private information.

    Jurisdictional Scope and Federalwide Assurances

    HHS did not implement the proposal in the NPRM to extend the Common Rule to any clinical trial, regardless of funding source, that is conducted at a US institution that receives funding for non-excluded, non-exempt human subjects research from a Common Rule Agency. Thus, the scope of the Common Rule with respect to clinical trials will remain unchanged.

    In addition, the Final Rule narrows the scope of Common Rule Agencies’ enforcement authority and the corresponding authority of IRBs. The Final Rule discontinues the authority of the Common Rule Agencies to review, oversee and enforce compliance with the Common Rule with regard to non-federally funded research. Institutions that receive federal funding or support for human subjects research will still have the option to choose to apply the Common Rule requirements and standards to their conduct of non-federally funded human subjects research either because they believe that applying a single set of standards to all of their human subjects research is more efficient and effective, or because they want to demonstrate a comprehensive commitment to the highest ethical standards. However, institutions will now be fully responsible for overseeing adherence to the Common Rule requirements and standards under their internal policies and procedures. Accordingly, the Final Rule eliminates the option for institutions to “check the box” in response to Question 4(b) of the current Federalwide Assurance (FWA) form (commonly known as the 4(b) election). Human subjects research that is not federally funded or supported will no longer be subject to HHS oversight, and institutions that choose to conduct such research in accordance with the Common Rule should ensure that their internal operations align with this new framework, which will require increased reliance on internal oversight and compliance mechanisms.

    HHS went in the opposite direction with respect to applying the Common Rule to IRBs not operated by an FWA-holding institution (Independent IRBs). Previously, other than requiring that IRBs overseeing Common Rule-regulated research register with HHS to provide certain information, including composition of the IRB’s membership, Common Rule Agencies did not have oversight or enforcement authority over Independent IRBs; as a result, institutions relying on Independent IRBs could be held responsible for compliance violations caused by the IRB of record. The Final Rule adopts the NPRM proposal to subject Independent IRBs to direct oversight with respect to Common Rule compliance. This modification will likely reduce researchers’ potential exposure to liability for the actions of third-party IRBs.

    Updates to Exempt Categories of Research, Including New Secondary Use Pathways

    HHS also retreated from the broad structural overhaul of the categories of research subject to the Common Rule. The NPRM had proposed a new category of “excluded” research, which would have been distinguishable from “exempt” research in that it would not be subject to administrative or IRB review. While the Final Rule does not adopt the “excluded” research category itself, it incorporates certain proposed excluded activities elsewhere in the Final Rule.

    The Final Rule revises the categories of exempt research. Significantly, three of the new or revised exempt research categories under the Final Rule relate to secondary research, which the Pre-2018 Rule did not specifically recognize or address:

    • Exemption for storage or maintenance of identifiable private information or identifiable biospecimens for secondary research. The Final Rule creates an exemption related to the storage or maintenance of identifiable private information or identifiable biospecimens for secondary research for which the “broad consent” now specifically provided for in the Final Rule (and discussed below) has been obtained for such storage or maintenance. Under this exemption, an IRB must still conduct a limited review and must confirm that broad consent was properly obtained and is appropriately documented (or that documentation was waived), and that there are provisions to protect privacy and confidentiality if there is a change made for research purposes to the manner of storage or maintenance. (See discussion below regarding the new “broad consent” pathway for secondary research.)
    • Exemption for secondary research use of identifiable private information or identifiable biospecimens that requires consent. The Final Rule creates an exemption related to secondary research uses of identifiable private information or identifiable biospecimens contained in a biorepository created through the new “broad consent” pathway if, in addition to complying with the broad consent requirements for storage, maintenance and secondary research use specifically set forth in the Final Rule (and discussed below), investigators (1) obtain limited IRB review and have the IRB confirm that the secondary use project falls within the scope of the broad consent, (2) have documentation of informed consent or waiver of documentation of consent on file, and (3) do not officially include in the study plan the return of individual research results (unless required by law).
      • Note that this exemption for secondary use in a federally funded study requires that researchers have also initially obtained broad consent for the storage or maintenance of the information or biospecimens, which on its face would require consent for the original creation of a biospecimen or data repository in accordance with the Common Rule even if the creation of the repository itself is not federally funded and thus not subject to the Common Rule.
    • Exemption for secondary research use of identifiable private information or identifiable biospecimens for which consent is not required. The Final Rule expands an existing exempt category to exempt from all Common Rule requirements, including the consent and IRB review requirements, activities involving secondary research uses of identifiable private information and/or identifiable biospecimens if the study meets one of the following four criteria:
      • The information or biospecimens are publicly available.
      • The investigator records information (including information about biospecimens) in such a way that the investigator or others cannot readily ascertain the identity, directly or through identifiers linked to the subjects, and the investigator does not contact or re-identify the subjects.
      • The research only involves information collection and analysis of health information, when such use is regulated under HIPAA for the purposes of “health care operations,” “research,” or “public health activities and purposes” (as defined in HIPAA).
      • The research is conducted by or for a federal department or agency using government-generated or -collected information obtained originally for non-research purposes, if (1) the research generates identifiable private information that is or will be maintained on IT systems compliant with and subject to 208(b) of the E-Government Act of 2002; (2) all of the identifiable private information collected, used or generated as part of the activity will be maintained in records systems subject to the Privacy Act of 1974; and, if applicable, (3) the information used in the research was collected subject to the Paperwork Reduction Act.

    As discussed further below, the Final Rule introduces certain requirements for obtaining broad consent and finalizes restrictions on IRB waivers that, taken together, may discourage some researchers from seeking broad consent from subjects, including to qualify for the above-described exemptions for secondary research.

    Stakeholders should also note that the new exemption category for secondary research regulated as health care operations, research or public health activities under HIPAA perpetuates the notion that HHS considers certain activities that constitute “health care operations” under HIPAA to be “research” under the Common Rule without clarification as to when an activity would fall into the grey area. On the other hand, this new exemption provides substantial new flexibility for secondary research and will almost certainly be welcomed and invoked by researchers and others involved in conducting secondary research.

    A number of other exclusion categories proposed in the NPRM were not incorporated into the Final Rule. The proposed exemption for certain secondary research involving identifiable information where notice was given to subjects, which related to a requirement to clarify the applicability of the Common Rule to clinical data registries under the Medicare Access and CHIP Reauthorization Act of 2015 (MACRA), was not finalized. Other notable omissions include the proposed exclusions for quality assurance/quality improvement activities and for internal monitoring and program improvement purposes, despite HHS’s acknowledgement that these proposals were supported by a majority of NPRM commenters. HHS’s failure to include these activities in the Final Rule, alongside its affirmative statements that certain quality assurance/quality improvement and internal monitoring activities “involve research and deserve the protections” of the Common Rule, contributes to the ambiguity regarding the overlap between research and activities that are regulated as health care operations under HIPAA.

    Informed Consent

    Basic Informed Consent: New Content and Organization Requirements

    The Final Rule articulates a number of new requirements for the organization and content of informed consent forms, including that such forms must begin with a “concise and focused presentation of the key information” that is most likely to help a potential subject or authorized representative to understand why he or she may or may not want to participate in the research. The Final Rule notes that HHS may issue future guidance to provide further clarity on the information that must be included in the beginning section of a consent form. Consent forms must also include a number of new elements that are relevant to the conduct of secondary research:

    • With respect to research involving the collection of identifiable private information or identifiable biospecimens, one of the following statements, as applicable:
      • That identifiers may be removed from the information or biospecimens, and thereafter, information or biospecimens may be used for future research without additional informed consent
      • That the information or biospecimens collected will not be used or distributed for future research, even if de-identified
    • A statement that biospecimens, even if de-identified, may be used for commercial profit, and a statement indicating whether the subject will be able to share in such profit
    • A statement describing whether and under what conditions clinically relevant results will be shared with subjects, including their own results
    • To the extent the research involves biospecimens, a statement indicating whether the research will or might include whole genome sequencing

    These additional requirements are aimed at increasing transparency for prospective subjects about the nature of the research in which they are being asked to participate. Institutions should note the organizational changes and additional level of detail that informed consent forms must reflect under the Final Rule.

    Broad Informed Consent for Secondary Research Using Identifiable Information or Biospecimens

    The Final Rule includes provisions for obtaining a one-time, upfront broad consent to cover the storage, maintenance and secondary research use of identifiable biospecimens and identifiable private information. Although the Pre-2018 Rule already allows researchers to obtain informed consent for future research use of identifiable private information and identifiable biospecimens, the Final Rule articulates specific requirements that would apply in the event researchers opt to pursue this new broad consent pathway. More importantly perhaps, a study that meets these broad consent requirements may qualify for treatment as exempt from certain requirements under the Common Rule.

    These new broad consent requirements include, but are not limited to, the following:

    • A description of the types of research that may be conducted with the information or biospecimens used that satisfies a “reasonable person” standard. Researchers are expected to provide more detail when there is reason to believe the research may be considered controversial or when specific future research studies are contemplated.
    • A description of the information or biospecimens that might be used, whether the information or biospecimens might be shared, and what kinds of investigators or institutions might use the information or biospecimens.
    • A description of how long information or biospecimens may be stored, maintained or used, even if indefinite.
    • When appropriate, a statement informing subjects that information that has been de-identified might not be traceable and that, as a result, it may not be possible for them to withdraw their consent in the future.
    • A statement that clinically relevant research results may not be disclosed, unless it is known that they always will be disclosed.
    • As appropriate, a statement as to whether research involving biospecimens will or might include whole genome sequencing.
    • Unless researchers will provide the subject with “details about specific research studies” in connection with satisfying the above elements for broad consent, an affirmative statement that the subject will not be informed of the details of any specific research studies that the researcher might conduct using the subject’s identifiable private information or identifiable biospecimens, and that the subject might not have chosen to provide consent for some of these specific research studies.

    The Final Rule does not adopt the NPRM’s proposal to limit the scope of the broad consent to information or biospecimens existing or collected within a certain time period, or the proposal to provide templates for broad consent. Thus, researchers who wish to use the broad consent pathway will need to develop their own broad consent forms, subject to appropriate IRB approvals.

    Whether researchers will find significant advantages to this new specific pathway for obtaining broad consent remains to be seen. As noted above, the ability to obtain informed consent for secondary use of identifiable private information or identifiable biospecimens existed under the Pre-2018 Rule. In addition, the requirements under the Pre-2018 Rule for obtaining consent for such secondary research use arguably are more general and less prescriptive than those articulated under the Final Rule for broad consent. Moreover, the HIPAA privacy standards (Privacy Rule) for obtaining authorization for future research gives researchers considerable discretion in satisfying the requirement that a valid authorization describe each “purpose” of a requested use or disclosure, including for future research activities. The HHS Office for Civil Rights has indicated that it will not require researchers to specify each future study for which protected health information (PHI) may be used; rather, the “purpose” requirement would be considered satisfied if “it would be reasonable for the individual to expect that his or her [PHI] could be used or disclosed for the future research purpose.” Accordingly, the Pre-2018 Rule and the Privacy Rule can be and have been interpreted to permit a consent to secondary use that is broader than the broad consent concept established by the Final Rule. The much more specific requirements under the Final Rule’s new broad consent provisions have the potential to create disharmony between the HIPAA authorization and the Common Rule informed consent forms used for secondary research activities.

    A key advantage of the new specific pathway for obtaining broad consent appears to be the ability of researchers to avail themselves of the exemption pathways discussed above that allow researchers to conduct certain secondary research with limited initial IRB review and without the need for continuing review. Researchers should note, however, that the Final Rule prohibits IRBs from omitting or altering any of the elements of broad consent specified under the Final Rule “if a broad consent procedure is used.”

    HHS describes this broad consent pathway as a “new alternative” for researchers, noting that researchers who choose not to obtain broad consent may still seek study-specific informed consent or a waiver of informed consent to use identifiable private information and identifiable biospecimens. Some researchers may find (1) the nature and extent of the required elements of the broad consent to result in increased time and effort devoted to the consent process, (2) the process for obtaining the broad consent to be more rigid, and (3) an increased reluctance by subjects to sign the consent. As a result, some researchers may choose the study-specific consent pathway, to seek waiver of informed consent altogether, or to conduct research using de-identified or coded information or biospecimens. The disadvantage of the study-specific consent option and the waiver option, however, is that the study would not qualify for the exemption pathways discussed above that require only limited IRB review and no continuing IRB review. Further, use of only de-identified or coded information will be infeasible for some research studies.

    Waiver or Alteration of Consent

    The Final Rule includes some, but not all, of the NPRM’s proposals to limit the circumstances under which an IRB may waive or alter informed consent. In particular, the Final Rule added a specific criterion requiring an investigator seeking a waiver for research using identifiable private information or identifiable biospecimens to demonstrate that the research “could not practicably be carried out without using such information or biospecimens in an identifiable format.” HHS notes that the requirement embodies the principle that “nonidentified information should be used whenever possible in order to respect subjects’ interests in protecting the confidentiality of their data and biospecimens.” This specific waiver provision related to secondary research is essentially the same as the Pre-2018 Common Rule requirements to demonstrate “minimal risk” and that “the research could not be practicably carried out without the waiver or alteration itself,” and is the same as the corresponding criterion for waiver of authorization under the HIPAA Privacy Rule. However, this more specific waiver requirement is yet another acknowledgement of the increased prevalence and prominence of secondary research arising out of the prevalence of electronic sharing of private information in the health care delivery and research context.

    The Final Rule also prohibits IRBs from waiving consent for the storage, maintenance or secondary research use of identifiable private information or identifiable specimens if an individual was asked and declined to provide broad consent for such research. This requirement may create a disincentive for investigators to seek the new broad consent set forth in the Final Rule and prompt them instead to pursue other pathways, such as seeking an upfront waiver of informed consent or using de-identified or coded information or specimens (which may be less useful for their research needs).

    Liberalization of Requirements for Screening, Recruitment and Eligibility Determination Activities

    With minor modifications, HHS finalized its proposal to allow IRBs to approve proposals involving obtaining identifiable private information or stored identifiable biospecimens without informed consent to screen, recruit or determine the eligibility of prospective subjects. HHS explains that the Pre-2018 Rule required researchers to obtain informed consent or IRB waiver thereof for such use of identifiable private information or identifiable biospecimens, which created a lack of harmonization between the Common Rule and US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) regulations (which do not require consent or waiver thereof for such activities). That Pre-2018 Rule requirement was also inconsistent with HIPAA where the HIPAA “reviews preparatory to research” pathway was available. Note, however, that this amendment does not eliminate the requirement to obtain IRB review of the screening or recruitment activity, and does not clearly extend to other “research development” activities that would be considered “reviews preparatory to research” under HIPAA, such as the use of identifiable private information for protocol development.

    Publication of Informed Consent Forms

    Despite opposition from a majority of commenters to the NPRM, HHS finalized the requirement that investigators post on a publicly available federal website an IRB-approved informed consent form for each clinical trial that is conducted or supported by a Common Rule Agency. Notably, the posted form need not be the “final” or last amended version of the form; rather, it merely needs to be a form that was used for enrollment and approved by an IRB. The Common Rule Agency supporting or conducting the trial may permit or require redactions to the extent it determines that certain information should not be publicly available. Although the Final Rule softens the NPRM’s proposed approach, institutions and investigators involved in Common Rule-regulated clinical trials should be mindful that their informed consent forms for federally funded clinical trials will now have a much broader potential audience.

    IRB Review

    Single IRB for Cooperative Research

    Central IRB review is optional under the Pre-2018 Rule but mandatory under the Final Rule for cooperative research studies. The Final Rule adopts the NPRM proposal to require all US institutions engaged in a cooperative research study to rely on a single central IRB for that study, except where (1) more than a single IRB review is required by law (e.g., FDA-regulated device studies), or (2) the Common Rule Agency supporting the research determines that use of a single IRB is not appropriate. Lead institutions will have the ability to propose which IRB should be used, although the applicable Common Rule Agency will make the final decision. Although this new requirement may bring certain efficiencies and streamlining to research in the long term, the short-term transition may be a challenging one. Therefore, the Final Rule delays the deadline for compliance with this provision until January 2020.

    Expedited and Continuing Review

    The Final Rule eases IRB requirements for research involving certain types of minimal risk activities. Under the Pre-2018 Rule, research activities are eligible for expedited review if they fall within an expedited review category on the list published and maintained by the Secretary of HHS and are found by an IRB to pose no more than minimal risk to research subjects. Under the Final Rule, such activities will no longer require a minimal risk determination from an IRB and will instead be presumed eligible for expedited review by default. However, if in the course of conducting its expedited review, the IRB determines that such research involves more than minimal risk, the research would be required to undergo full IRB review.

    The Final Rule also made changes to the continuing review process. Expedited research on the list published by HHS will no longer be required to undergo continuing review, unless the reviewer requires otherwise. In addition, the following types of research and activities, among others, will be exempt from continuing review:

    • Research that has reached the point at which it only involves data analysis and/or accessing follow-up clinical data
    • Research that has satisfied the exemption for storage or maintenance of identifiable private information or identifiable biospecimens for secondary research use for which broad consent was obtained
    • Research that has satisfied the exemption for secondary research using identifiable private information or identifiable biospecimens for which broad consent was obtained

    Privacy and Security

    The Final Rule does not adopt the NPRM’s proposals regarding privacy and security safeguards, including but not limited to the proposal that HHS publish a set of uniform, specific measures that investigators could implement to satisfy its proposed requirements regarding security and privacy. HHS cited commenters’ significant concerns about adhering to new requirements when the safeguards had yet to be proposed (or even developed) as contributing to this decision. The Final Rule does, however, maintain the requirement that IRBs review the quality of privacy and security measures protecting research subjects in each study. It also includes a new requirement that the Secretary of HHS issue guidance to assist IRBs in assessing privacy and confidentiality protections.

    Conclusion

    The Final Rule largely avoids major modifications to the Common Rule. However, it specifically addresses creation of biospecimen and data repositories and use of those repositories for secondary research. It also implements new provisions that are relevant and should be noted by all stakeholders involved in federally funded research, including, without limitation, investigators; research sites; IRB administrators and members; Institutional Officials and staff; and the pharmaceutical, medical device and biotechnology industry. View the full text of the Final Rule, most of which goes into effect January 18, 2018.

    Authors

    Jiayan Chen

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Jennifer S. Geetter

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Lisa Mazur

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • Is it Time to Roll Back the Conflict Minerals Rule?

    ARTICLE

    Is it Time to Roll Back the Conflict Minerals Rule?

    February 5, 2017

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Gary Emmanuel wrote this bylined article on the Dodd-Frank Act requirement that US public companies disclose use of conflict minerals from the Democratic Republic of Congo. Noting that the acting SEC Chair made “an extraordinarily harsh critique of the conflict minerals rule,” Mr. Emmanuel wrote that it is “based on dubious evidence of effectiveness and questionable purpose. With a new administration intent on reforming Dodd Frank, the time has come to roll back the conflict minerals rule.”

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Planning for International Couples

    ARTICLE

    Planning for International Couples

    February 2, 2017

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Nicole K. Mann and Leigh-Alexandra Basha wrote this bylined article “Planning for International Couples” for The Tools and Techniques of Estate Planning for Modern Families, 2nd edition.

    In depth
    Authors

    Leigh-Alexandra Basha

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • What You Need to Know About President Trump’s Executive Order on Immigration Issues

    What You Need to Know About President Trump’s Executive Order on Immigration Issues

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    What You Need to Know About President Trump’s Executive Order on Immigration Issues

    February 2, 2017

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    President Trump’s January 27, 2017, Executive Order on US immigration has immediate ramifications for millions of legal immigrants, nonimmigrants and US businesses. Businesses and individuals should stay apprised of the latest developments.

    In depth

    Over the past week, President Donald J. Trump signed three Executive Orders involving US immigration issues. The Executive Order signed on January 27, 2017, was somewhat unexpected in terms of its focus and the extent of its reach. Entitled “Protecting the Nation from Foreign Terrorist Entry into the United States,” the order has an immediate impact on millions of legal immigrants, nonimmigrants and US businesses.

    Since the order was signed, there have been numerous announcements from the US Department of Homeland Security, including US Citizenship & Immigration Services and US Customs & Border Protection, as well as the US Department of State. Many of these announcements have been contradictory or have been superseded immediately by other information. This is an ever-changing situation, but the following information is current as of press time:

    • Nonimmigrant and immigrant visa processing has been suspended for nationals of Iraq, Iran, Syria, Libya, Somalia, Sudan and Yemen.
    • Issuance of visas has been suspended for a period of 90 days. The US embassies and consulates have cancelled immigrant visa appointments for the month of February. Further cancellations are expected.
    • Suspension of visa processing does not include those traveling on diplomatic visas; NATO visas; C-2 and C-3 visas for UN and foreign transit; and G-1, G-2, G-3 and G-4 visas.
    • Nationals of Iraq, Iran, Syria, Libya, Somalia, Sudan and Yemen in possession of valid nonimmigrant and immigrant visas are barred from entry to the United States for a period of 90 days.
    • Immediately after the Order was signed, many nationals of the aforementioned countries boarded flights to the United States. These travelers experienced long waits in the inspections area, only to be denied admission to the United States. At the present time, airlines will not board individuals from the aforementioned countries who hold nonimmigrant or immigrant visas.
    • Nonimmigrant and immigrant visas of nationals of Iraq, Iran, Syria, Libya, Somalia, Sudan and Yemen have been provisionally revoked.
    • Revocation goes hand-in-hand with the ban on travel to the United States, but it is still unknown whether those holding such visas will need to have them reissued in the future or if their visa status will be reinstated in some manner.
    • Nationals of Iraq, Iran, Syria, Libya, Somalia, Sudan and Yemen may be issued visas or granted other immigration benefits on a case-by-case basis if the Secretaries of State and Homeland Security determine it is in the national interest to issue visas or benefits to such individuals.
    • At the present time no procedure has been announced for requesting review of a visa application under the “national interest” exception.
    • It has been determined that nationals from the seven countries who are US permanent residents will be readmitted to the United States as being in the national interest, provided no derogatory information about an individual is uncovered.
    • The policy on readmission of permanent residents was a tremendous relief to many who initially feared being stranded abroad despite their permanent resident status. Although such individuals are being readmitted to the United States, they may experience lengthy inspection delays at US airports before being admitted to the United States.
    • The Visa Interview Waiver Program has been suspended for a period of 90 days.
    • Under the program, nationals of certain countries who were frequent travelers to the United States were able to have their nonimmigrant visas reissued without interview at a US consulate or embassy. Because of the suspension, anyone who needs to have a visa reissued must follow the usual procedure for scheduling an interview at a US consular post. It is unknown how many individuals will be subject to the suspension; therefore there may be substantial delays in securing a visa appointment at a consular post in the future.
    • The Visa Interview Waiver Program is separate and distinct from the Visa Waiver Program, which allows nationals of select countries to travel to the United States as visitors for periods of up to 90 days without a visa. At the present time there have been no changes to this program.
    • The US refugee program has been suspended for 120 days.
    • The suspension applies to all refugees from any country. The Order indicates that the refugee program will be reviewed to determine procedures to ensure that refugees are appropriately screened prior to admission to the United States.
    • Sources have indicated that naturalization and citizenship applications continue to be adjudicated for applicants from all countries, including the seven listed countries. Additionally, interviews continue to be conducted for immigrant visa petitions and applications for adjustment of status filed in the United States. This policy may vary from office to office and may change in the future. The status of nonimmigrant visa petitions filed on behalf of individuals from the seven countries is currently unknown, although rumors have circulated that such petitions are currently being held without adjudication until further notice.

    The Executive Order has left many questions unanswered and many individuals stranded outside the United States. The impact on families, businesses, nonprofit organizations, medical facilities, scientific research centers and universities has been profound. The Order indicates there may be other countries added to the list, raising concerns among nationals from other countries. Clearly, anyone who is a national of one of the seven countries and who is in the United States with a valid nonimmigrant visa should not leave the United States. It is recommended that nationals of the seven countries who are permanent residents carefully consider their travel needs before scheduling travel. Other foreign nationals who will be traveling and need to have a visa reissued while abroad should be sure to plan their consular visit well in advance of their departure from the United States and leave enough time abroad for the visa to be issued.

    Authors

    Joan-Elisse Carpentier

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue, San Francisco

    More insights

  • FDA Clarifies “Intended Use” for Drugs, Devices, and Tobacco Products

    FDA Clarifies “Intended Use” for Drugs, Devices, and Tobacco Products

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    FDA Clarifies “Intended Use” for Drugs, Devices, and Tobacco Products

    February 2, 2017

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In its Clarification of When Products Made or Derived From Tobacco Are Regulated as Drugs, Devices, or Combination Products; Amendments to Regulations Regarding “Intended Uses” (Final Rule), FDA codifies its long-standing interpretation of the “knowledge” prong of its definition of “intended use.” In the Final Rule, FDA clarifies that tobacco products marketed for therapeutic purposes are subject to regulation as a drug or device separate from their counterpart “customarily marketed” tobacco products.

    In depth

    In its Clarification of When Products Made or Derived From Tobacco Are Regulated as Drugs, Devices, or Combination Products; Amendments to Regulations Regarding “Intended Uses” (Final Rule), FDA codifies its long-standing interpretation of the “knowledge” prong of its definition of “intended use.” Knowledge of a product’s actual use can be evidence of intended use, because claims about a product impact how FDA will regulate the product. FDA has provided guidance on intended use, which it applies to its framework for the regulation of tobacco products as well. In the Final Rule, FDA clarifies that tobacco products marketed for therapeutic purposes are subject to regulation as a drug or device separate from their counterpart “customarily marketed” tobacco products.

    Knowledge and Intended Use

    An article’s intended use—i.e., the objective intent of the individual(s) legally responsible for the labeling of the article—determines the nature and extent of the FDA’s oversight of such articles. Under existing FDA regulations, “intended use” can be demonstrated by labeling claims, advertising matter or oral or written statements made on or behalf of the manufacturer. Existing regulations also state that the manufacturer’s actual knowledge of the article’s use for a purpose for which is it neither labeled or advertised (an unapproved or “off-label” use) may be evidence of intended use. 21 C.F.R. §§ 201.128 and 801.4. Historically, FDA relied on this provision for regulatory or information collection purposes (e.g., physician labeling and safety data). In a 2015 proposed rule, FDA proposed striking the language from the regulation that allowed the agency to consider a manufacturer’s knowledge of actual use as evidence of intended use.

    In an apparent reversal, the Final Rule retains actual knowledge of an article’s use as a relevant source of evidence of intended use and clarifies that any relevant source of evidence, whether direct or circumstantial, may be used to demonstrate intended use. If strictly interpreted, this language would allow FDA to take enforcement action against manufacturers for off-label promotion even if the manufacturer did not affirmatively promote or support such use. However, consistent with the agency’s historical position, the agency explicitly notes that it does not intend to bring enforcement action if the sole evidence of off-label promotion is such knowledge. The agency’s clarification of this point is critical because of recent case history in which the agency predicated enforcement against speech regarding a purpose for which it is labeled or advertised (“on-label” speech) to “off-label” populations. The agency’s statement seems to suggest it recognizes the inherent problem in enforcing requests for information from manufacturers on off-label uses while simultaneously prohibiting manufacturer off-label promotions or on-label promotions to off-label populations.

    Intended Use of Tobacco Products

    Next, in the Final Rule, in light of frequent inquiries regarding jurisdictional distinctions for products made or derived from tobacco since the passage of the Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act of 2009, FDA also clarifies that tobacco products “marketed for therapeutic purposes” are subject to regulation as drugs, devices or combination products under Chapter V the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (FDCA), whereas “customarily marketed tobacco products” are subject to regulation as tobacco products under Chapter IX of the FDCA.

    FDA’s stated purposes for the clarification are:

    • To help sponsors determine which FDA Center to consult and to which Center sponsors should make submissions in product development or postmarketing phases;
    • To assist investigators in determining investigational use requirements that apply to studies when using products made or derived from tobacco for investigational use; and
    • To clarify to consumers which products are intended for medical uses versus recreational or other uses.

    Manufacturers making comparative claims, i.e., wishing to claim a lower tobacco-related disease risk profile or lower relative risk than another tobacco product, can file a modified risk tobacco product (MRTP) application under section 911 of the FDCA. However, manufacturers wishing to claim that a medical product acts affirmatively to combat a disease or health conditions must file a New Drug Application (NDA) under section 505(b) of the FDCA or Premarket Authorization (PMA) under section 510(k) of the FDCA.

    The Final Rule creates 21 C.F.R. § 1100.5, which codifies FDA’s interpretation that a product made or derived from tobacco that is intended for human consumption will be regulated as a drug, device, or combination product if it is intended for therapeutic purposes, specifically:

    • For use in the diagnosis of disease or other conditions, or in the cure, mitigation, treatment or prevention of disease, including use in the cure or treatment of nicotine addiction (e.g., smoking cessation), relapse prevention, or relief of nicotine withdrawal symptoms (“therapeutic claims”); or
    • Is intended to affect the structure or any function of the body in any way that is different from effects related to nicotine that were commonly and legally claimed in the marketing of cigarettes and smokeless tobacco products prior to March 21, 2000 (the date of the US Supreme Court’s decision in FDA v. Brown & Williamson, 529 U.S. 120 (2000) (“structure/function claims”).

    Examples of structure/function claims “commonly and legally” claimed prior to Brown & Williamson—and therefore, which do not trigger FDA regulation as a drug, device or combination product—include:

    • Satisfaction (including of addiction)
    • Pleasure
    • Enjoyment
    • Refreshment

    FDA also noted that in the absence of additional evidence of marketing pre-March 21, 2000, it will not consider the following claims as “commonly and legally” claimed prior to Brown & Williamson:

    • Cessation or withdrawal relief
    • Weight loss
    • Maintaining memory
    • Sedation
    • Stimulation

    The Final Rule is effective February 8, 2017.

    On January 20, 2017, Reince Priebus, assistant to the president and chief of staff, issued a memorandum (Priebus memo) postponing the effective date of regulations and guidance documents that have been published in the Federal Register but not yet taken effect for 60 days from the date of the memorandum. While the Final Rule appears to be subject to the Priebus memo, the agency has not made any official statements regarding its status or delayed implementation as of this writing.

    Authors

    Michael W. Ryan

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    More insights