Content Type: Article

  • New EMIR Variation Margin Requirements

    New EMIR Variation Margin Requirements

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    New EMIR Variation Margin Requirements

    28 February 2017

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    From 1 March 2017, the new variation margin (‘VM’) rules for over-the-counter (‘OTC’) derivatives contained in the regulatory technical standards adopted by the European Commission (the ‘Delegated Regulation’)[1] will apply to certain European counterparties.

    In anticipation of the 1 March deadline, European counterparties (and any non-EU entities, including funds, that trade with European financial institutions) are in the process of putting in place appropriate risk management procedures and compliant netting and collateral documentation to implement the new VM requirements.

    To address industry concerns as to parties failing to meet the deadline, a joint-association letter (consisting of, amongst others, ISDA, SIFMA and ABA) was sent[2] to regulators and central banks requesting forbearance. In response, the European Supervisory Authorities (the ‘ESAs’) did not grant a forbearance but encouraged national competent authorities (such as the FCA in the United Kingdom) to adopt a risk-based approach in the application and enforcement of the rules. The FCA has stated[3] that it will be taking into account ‘the credibility of the plans [parties] have made’.

    Legal Review of Netting and Collateral Arrangements

    As well as the implementation of new VM documentation and risk management procedures, the Delegated Regulation requires each party to an OTC derivative (including investment managers on behalf of the funds they manage) to undertake an independent legal review of its exchange of collateral and netting arrangements to confirm that they are in compliance with the Delegated Regulation. In the EU, parties to OTC derivatives may be required by national competent authorities to demonstrate that a legal review has been undertaken.

    Counterparties are also required to review their risk management procedures on an annual basis, which may also necessitate the legal review of any new arrangements or updates to existing margin and collateral arrangements.

    Authored by Craig Stein, Ron Feldman and Anthony Lombardi.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2016/2251 supplementing Regulation (EU) No. 648/2012 of the European Parliament and of the Council on OTC derivatives, central counterparties and trade repositories with regard to regulatory technical standards for risk-mitigation techniques for OTC derivative contracts not cleared by a central counterparty published on the Official Journal on 15 Nov. 2016.

    [2] The joint-association letter can be viewed here.

    [3] The FCA’s statement can be viewed here.


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP and Schulte Roth & Zabel International LLP (“SRZ”) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.

     

    In depth
    Authors

    Craig Stein

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • USA: Recent Developments

    ARTICLE

    USA: Recent Developments

    February 2017

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Leigh-Alexandra Basha wrote this bylined article on recent US developments that have impacted trust and estate planning law, ranging from new requirements that were announced for consistent basis reporting to announced changes in Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts (FBAR) due dates for the 2016 tax year.

    In depth
    Authors

    Leigh-Alexandra Basha

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • Reconstruction of the BMF Rejected – Is There Now a Risk of the Destruction of Companies Capable of Restoration?

    ARTICLE

    Reconstruction of the BMF Rejected – Is There Now a Risk of the Destruction of Companies Capable of Restoration?

    February 27, 2017

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth

    Philipp Kutscher commenting on the BFH decision of 28 November 2016 on the rejection of the BMF’s reorganization decree and the imminent demolition of refurbishable companies.

    Authors
    More insights

  • Trump Administration Takes First Steps to Support Exchanges, but Key Questions Remain

    Trump Administration Takes First Steps to Support Exchanges, but Key Questions Remain

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT / US POLICY

    Trump Administration Takes First Steps to Support Exchanges, but Key Questions Remain

    February 27, 2017

    Read time: 9 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In an effort to stabilize the Exchanges and encourage issuer participation, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) recently extended the federal Exchange application and rate filing deadlines and published a proposed rule affecting the individual health insurance market and the Exchanges. While issuers will likely see these actions as encouraging signs of the Trump administration’s willingness to support the Exchanges, these actions do not resolve the political uncertainty regarding the Affordable Care Act’s fate or whether cost-sharing reductions will be funded for 2018. These outstanding questions will likely be a key factor in Exchange stability going forward.

    In depth

    On February 17, 2017, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) published a proposed rule in the Federal Register outlining a series of proposals intended to stabilize the individual health insurance market and the Exchanges created by the Affordable Care Act (ACA). Comments on the proposed rule are due to CMS on March 7, 2017.

    On the same day as the proposed rule was published, CMS announced that it was extending the federal Exchange application and rate filing deadlines with the apparent goal of ensuring that the proposed rule changes could be finalized and taken into account when issuers make Exchange participation and rate decisions for 2018. Although issuers are likely to support the proposed rule and delayed federal filing deadlines, it is not clear what effect these changes will have since they do not resolve the ongoing uncertainty regarding the fate of the ACA repeal effort in Congress and federal funding of cost-sharing reductions in 2018.

    CMS believes that the proposed “changes are urgently needed to stabilize markets, to incentivize issuers to enter or remain in the market and to ensure premium stability and consumer choice.” The agency’s urgency is underscored by recent reports that Humana would exit the Exchanges entirely for 2018 and other companies have publicly stated that they are uncertain about the extent of their participation in 2018. Looking just at states using healthcare.gov, there are 960 counties with only one issuer in 2017. Additional issuer defections for 2018 would increase the odds that certain counties will have no issuers participating on the Exchange. This would result in residents of such counties being unable to utilize premium or cost-sharing subsidies for which they otherwise qualify.

    The proposed rule addresses long-standing issuer concerns about special enrollment periods and perceived gaming of the 90-day grace period available to enrollees receiving premium subsidies. Looking beyond the specific proposals, the proposed rule is significant for the simple fact that it is the Trump administration’s first concrete step to support and stabilize the Exchange market. This likely provides a measure of relief for industry stakeholders that were unsure whether Republicans would be willing to support the Exchanges, which were a key focus of Republican opposition to the ACA. There had been mixed signals during the Trump administration’s first weeks about how it would approach ACA implementation. President Trump issued an executive order his first day in office directing the Secretary of Health and Human Services (HHS) and other agencies to “exercise all authority and discretion available to them to waive, defer, grant exemptions from, or delay the implementation of” ACA requirements, creating uncertainty regarding how this broad directive would be implemented. In addition, the administration reportedly pulled back on advertising healthcare.gov during the final weekend of open enrollment, leading some to speculate that the Trump administration would be less supportive of Exchange stability than the Obama administration. In the proposed rule, however, CMS tries to make clear that it shares issuers’ goals of “improv[ing] the risk pool and promot[ing] stability in the individual market.”

    The question remains whether the proposed changes (and the directional signal of Trump administration support) are sufficient to achieve their stated policy goals. That question is significantly influenced by the status of the ongoing legislative process seeking to quickly repeal the ACA. Although CMS has in this proposed rule endorsed the goal of Exchange market stability in anticipation of CY 2018 open enrollment proceeding as planned, a Republican-led Congress and the Trump administration have continued to signal their commitment to repeal the ACA. Even with the recent delay in Exchange product and rate filing deadlines, the political process (and the related uncertainty about the ACA’s fate) may not be resolved by the time issuers need to begin developing their rates and making decisions on CY 2018 participation. The proposed rule also does not resolve lingering questions related to Exchange funding, such as the availability of cost-sharing reductions for 2018, that will likely be a key factor in Exchange stability going forward.

    Summary of Proposed Rule Changes

    The proposed rule changes are largely designed to close potential avenues of adverse selection and improve the overall risk pool by encouraging healthier individuals to enroll in coverage.

    Open Enrollment

    CMS proposes shortening the 2018 open enrollment period from November 1, 2017, through January 1, 2018, to November 1 through December 15, 2017. CMS originally proposed that the shortened open enrollment period would be effective for the 2019 open enrollment period, but the agency is now proposing to move this up by one year. CMS expects that this change would improve the risk pool by reducing enrollments late in the open enrollment period spurred by an applicant’s recent discovery of a need to access health care services. This policy would also increase premium payments to plans, as more enrollees would begin the year’s coverage in January instead of February.

    CMS likely would need to extensively market the shortened enrollment period to ensure public awareness. It remains to be seen whether the Trump administration is comfortable with such a commitment to marketing the program given the pull back on marketing efforts for the end of CY 2017 open enrollment.

    Special Enrollment

    CMS proposes a series of limitations on special enrollment periods intended to reduce adverse selection. Previously, issuers had complained that many healthy individuals were forgoing coverage until they were sick, taking advantage of lax special enrollment period rules to enroll in coverage only when it was needed.

    To limit gaming, CMS proposes to expand an enrollment verification pilot program for states using healthcare.gov, planned to begin in summer 2017. CMS proposes that applicants enrolling in coverage under a special enrollment period would have their enrollment pended until they provide documentation that they actually qualify for the special enrollment period. Where providing and processing documentation would result in a delay in coverage after the requested coverage effective date, this policy would result in retroactive coverage. As such, where verification results in a delay in coverage of two months or more, CMS proposes to permit enrollees to request a later effective date.

    Guaranteed Availability

    CMS also proposes to reinterpret the “guaranteed availability” standard, which requires health plans in the individual market to sell coverage to any willing buyer during open or special enrollment periods. CMS proposes to create an exception to guaranteed availability for individuals with unpaid premiums due to the issuer from which the individual is seeking to purchase new coverage. In part, this proposal seems to address issuers’ concern that some individuals have taken advantage of generous grace periods to discontinue premium payment towards the end of a benefit year only to reenroll with the same plan for the next benefit year. Individuals could still enroll in coverage without coming due on unpaid premium amounts by enrolling with a different issuer (if there is more than one issuer participating in the service area).

    Accepting Comments on Continuous Coverage Proposals

    CMS requests comments on potential policies it could implement to promote continuous coverage, but the agency is not proposing any specific policies at this time. A continuous coverage requirement is a central feature of many Republican ACA replacement proposals as an alternative to the ACA’s individual mandate. The ACA’s statutory guaranteed availability protections are broad, so adoption of a generally applicable continuous coverage requirement would likely require a legislative change. This is, however, a signal that CMS, under HHS Secretary Price and congressional Republicans, is considering similar policy solutions.

    De Minimis Variation

    CMS proposes to expand the definition of de minimis variation, the amount by which a qualified health plan’s (QHP’s) actuarial value may vary from the statutorily mandated value. CMS proposes to increase the amount of permissible variation to -4/+2 percentage points from the +/-2 percentage points currently permitted. CMS argues that this policy will promote market stability by permitting plans to maintain the same plan design year over year. CMS additionally argues that this policy may promote competition and put downward pressure on premiums, encouraging healthier individuals to participate in the plan.

    Network Adequacy

    CMS also proposes to defer to states with respect to network adequacy for Exchange plans in federally facilitated Exchange (FFE) and state-based Exchange states. In past years, CMS has proactively verified that QHPs in FFE states have an “adequate” network of providers. Through such reviews, CMS has enforced “maximum time and distance standards” requiring, for at least 90 percent of enrollees, that certain types of providers be within a specified distance and travel time. These quantitative standards mirrored the Medicare Advantage program requirements. CMS proposes to discontinue its analysis of QHP time and distance, instead deferring to state regulators and accrediting bodies.

    Network adequacy requirements vary significantly across states, so this change will affect issuers differently. While the National Association of Insurance Commissioners has adopted a new Health Benefit Plan Network Access and Adequacy Model Act, it has not been adopted in any states and defers to individual states to set applicable time and distance standards. Thus, CMS’s deferral of network adequacy to states may permit narrower networks than under CMS’s quantitative standards.

    Executive Order on Significant Regulatory Actions

    Also of note is CMS’s approach to President Trump’s recent executive order, which requires that any “significant regulatory actions that [impose] costs” be offset through the elimination of costs associated with at least two prior rules. The proposed rule offers an early opportunity to examine how the administration will implement this executive order. CMS determined that the proposed rule “is not a significant regulatory action that imposes cost” under the recent executive order. The basis for this finding appears to be CMS’s belief that the proposed rule results in a net cost reduction. Thus, while CMS characterized the rule as “significant” for creating separate costs and benefits that exceed $100 million, the net cost reduction allows the agency to avoid eliminating two rules. Industry stakeholders should continue to monitor how CMS implements President Trump’s recent executive order.

    Authors

    Jeremy Earl

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    More insights

  • How Chicago’s Rental Car Tax Crossed the Line

    ARTICLE

    How Chicago’s Rental Car Tax Crossed the Line

    February 27, 2017

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Catherine Battin and Lauren Ferrante co-authored this bylined article on Hertz Corp v. City of Chicago, in which the Illinois Supreme Court overturned as unconstitutional the City of Chicago tax on vehicle rentals outside the city. “Hopefully, the court’s ruling will stymie the city’s expansive interpretation of its taxing powers,” the authors wrote, adding that the city’s recent extension of its lease tax to cloud computing “is now particularly susceptible to challenge.”

    In depth
    Authors

    Catherine A. Battin

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • New York State Industrial Board of Appeals Revokes Payroll Debit Card and Direct Deposit Regulations Set to Take Effect on March 7

    New York State Industrial Board of Appeals Revokes Payroll Debit Card and Direct Deposit Regulations Set to Take Effect on March 7

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    New York State Industrial Board of Appeals Revokes Payroll Debit Card and Direct Deposit Regulations Set to Take Effect on March 7

    February 23, 2017

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On Feb. 16, 2017, the New York State Industrial Board of Appeals (“Board”) issued a Resolution of Decision[1] invalidating and revoking New York State Department of Labor (“NYSDOL”) regulations related to methods of payment of wages that were set to go into effect on March 7, 2017. In its decision, Global Cash Card, Inc. v. Commissioner of Labor (Docket No. PR 16-120), the Board reasoned that the regulations exceeded the rulemaking authority of the Commissioner of Labor (“Commissioner”) and encroached upon the jurisdiction of banking and financial services regulators.

    Background

    The relevant regulations, adopted by the Commissioner on Sept. 7, 2016, were to be codified as Part 192 of Title 12 of the New York Code of Rules and Regulations. The regulations would have, among other things: (1) required employers to provide written notice in plain language to employees describing all options for receiving wages and obtain consent from those who elected to receive wages via direct deposit or payroll debit card; (2) required employers to provide access to one or more ATMs that offer withdrawals at no cost to employees; and (3) prohibited employers from charging employees certain fees related to the use of payroll debit cards, including but not limited to fees for receiving wages or holding such cards, point-of-sale transactions, account inactivity, maintenance, telephone or online customer service, or closing an account.

    Board’s Decision

    On Oct. 21, 2016, Global Cash Card, Inc. (“GCC”), a national payroll debit card vendor that provides custom payroll debit card programs to New York employers, filed a petition with the Board for review of the regulations, alleging that they exceeded the Commissioner’s authority by placing restrictions on financial products and institutions and were thus invalid. The Board agreed with GCC, holding that the regulations were invalid because they exceeded the Commissioner’s statutory authority under the New York Labor Law (“Labor Law”) by regulating banking services provided by financial institutions. Such regulations, the Board held, fall under the purview of the New York State Department of Financial Services, which governs banks and financial institutions and the fees they may charge for banking services, including those related to checking accounts to which employers may legally deposit wages and licensed check cashers where employees may choose to cash their paychecks.

    In its decision, the Board noted that “by prohibiting all fees associated with use of a payroll debit card, the regulations depart significantly from the plain language of [Article 6 of the Labor Law],” specifically Section 192, which provides the manner in which an employer may pay wages to an employee. Because the regulations governed the methods of payment of wages, including requiring employers to provide access to one or more ATMs that offer withdrawals at no cost to employees and prohibiting payroll debit card issuers from charging employees certain fees related to use of such cards, the Board found that the regulations went beyond that necessary to carry out Section 192 and Article 6 of the Labor Law.

    The Board also cited prior NYSDOL opinion letters that conflicted with the Commissioner’s position and recent legislative efforts concerning payroll debit cards as additional support for the regulations’ invalidation and revocation. The Board noted that several bills addressing payment of wages by payroll debit cards have failed to gain sufficient support to be enacted into law, and reasoned that this degree of legislative activity demonstrated that this issue is a matter of public concern being debated by legislators.

    We expect the Commissioner to appeal the Board’s decision and will keep you updated on any new developments.

    Authored by Donald J. Mosher, Gary Stein, Scott A. Gold, Jessica Sklute and Adam J. Barazani.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] A copy of the decision is available on the Board’s website.


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP (“SRZ”) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.

    In depth
    Authors

    Donald J. Mosher

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Adam J. Barazani

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Making a Difference in Pro Bono Tax Cases

    ARTICLE

    Making a Difference in Pro Bono Tax Cases

    February 2017

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Andrew Roberson (who has served as chair of the ABA Tax Section’s Pro Bono and Tax Clinic Committee) wrote this bylined article on notable pro bono tax cases handled for the low-income taxpayer community. Such cases “demonstrate the difference that practitioners can make by volunteering their time on a pro bono basis to those individuals who cannot afford legal counsel,” Mr. Roberson wrote.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Increased HSR Act Thresholds Announced for 2017

    Increased HSR Act Thresholds Announced for 2017

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Increased HSR Act Thresholds Announced for 2017

    February 17, 2017

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Hart-Scott-Rodino Antitrust Improvements Act of 1976, as amended (the “HSR Act”), requires parties to acquisitions of voting securities, assets or non-corporate interests meeting certain thresholds to make a premerger notification to the Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”) and the Antitrust Division of the Department of Justice, and to observe a waiting period prior to consummating such acquisitions. On Jan. 19, 2017, the FTC announced its annual adjustments to the current HSR Act thresholds. Any transaction that will be consummated on or after the Feb. 27, 2017 effective date of such adjustments may be reportable under the HSR Act if, as a result of such transaction, the acquiring person will hold voting securities, assets and/or non-corporate interests of the acquired person valued above $80.8 million (the current adjusted minimum threshold is $78.2 million). The new adjusted thresholds reflect changes in the gross national product for the preceding fiscal year. The size-of-person threshold looks at the total sales or assets of each party to a transaction, including its ultimate parent and certain affiliates, and is also being increased.

    The updated size-of-transaction and size-of-person thresholds under the HSR Act are set forth below:

    Threshold

    HSR Act Original

    2017 Adjusted

    Size-of-transaction when size-of-person test is met

    $50 million

    $80.8 million

    Size-of-person (if applicable)

    $10 million and $100 million

    $16.2 million and $161.5 million

    Size-of-transaction above which size-of-person test does not apply

    $200 million

    $323.0 million

     

    The filing fees applicable to premerger notifications filed under the HSR Act have not changed in over a decade and will continue as follows:

    Size-of-Transaction (as adjusted)

    Filing Fee

    Valued at greater than $80.8 million but less than $161.5 million

    $45,000

    Valued at $161.5 million or greater but less than $807.5 million

    $125,000

    Valued at $807.5 million or greater

    $280,000

     

    When a premerger notification has been filed under the HSR Act, and the applicable waiting period has expired or been terminated, any additional acquisitions by the same acquiring person of the same issuer’s voting securities will be exempt from notification, so long as:

    • The acquiring person’s holdings crossed the notification threshold with respect to which the premerger notification was made, within one year of the expiration or early termination of the HSR Act waiting period; and

    The subsequent acquisition is consummated within five years following the expiration or early termination of the HSR Act waiting period unless a higher notification level is met or exceeded. The various notification levels are set forth below:

    HSR Act Original

    2017 Adjusted

    $50 million

    $80.8 million

    $100 million

    $161.5 million

    $500 million

    $807.5 million

    25 percent if value of voting securities to be held is greater than $1 billion

    25 percent if value of voting securities to be held is greater than $1,615.0 million

    50 percent if value of voting securities to be held is greater than $50 million

    50 percent if value of voting securities to be held is greater than $80.8 million

     

    Any subsequent acquisition would be subject to the adjusted thresholds in effect when such subsequent acquisition is consummated.

    Maximum Civil Penalty for HSR Act Violations Also Increased for 2017

    New for 2017, the maximum civil penalty for violations of the HSR Act will begin to be adjusted annually. This follows on last year’s substantial hike in the maximum penalty from $16,000 to $40,000 per day. On Jan. 12, 2017, the FTC announced the new maximum will increase to $40,654 per day. The new maximum applies to penalties assessed after its effective date — meaning the maximum allowable penalty is based on the date that the penalty is imposed by the FTC or DOJ — and not the dates of the alleged violation.  

    Authored by Peter Jonathan Halasz and Gregory L. Kinzelman.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    This information has been prepared by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP (“SRZ”) for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and is presented without any representation or warranty as to its accuracy, completeness or timeliness. Transmission or receipt of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Electronic mail or other communications with SRZ cannot be guaranteed to be confidential and will not (without SRZ agreement) create an attorney-client relationship with SRZ. Parties seeking advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular circumstances. The contents of these materials may constitute attorney advertising under the regulations of various jurisdictions.

     

    In depth
    Authors

    Peter Jonathan Halasz

    Of Counsel

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • New York City Tax Tribunal Properly Limits NOL Deductions to Same Source Year

    ARTICLE

    New York City Tax Tribunal Properly Limits NOL Deductions to Same Source Year

    February 17, 2017

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Alysse McLoughlin wrote this bylined article about the impact of the Plasmanet and TD Holdings cases on New York’s rules to claim net operating loss (NOL) deductions for all but S corporations. Because NOLs even out business gains and losses, Ms. McLoughlin wrote, “wasting of the NOL in every year that the taxpayer has an NOL available for use in New York … completely contradicts the policy behind preservation and use of NOLs to offset income generated in different years.”

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Third Circuit Upholds Dismissal of Indirect Purchaser Class in Auto Transmission Case, Revives Individual Claims

    Third Circuit Upholds Dismissal of Indirect Purchaser Class in Auto Transmission Case, Revives Individual Claims

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Third Circuit Upholds Dismissal of Indirect Purchaser Class in Auto Transmission Case, Revives Individual Claims

    February 16, 2017

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On February 9, the US Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit upheld a ruling by the US District Court for the District of Delaware that indirect purchasers of Class 8 transmissions did not meet the requirements for class certification. The Third Circuit found that only the individual claims may proceed in the case. The opinion is significant because it reaffirms the difficulty indirect purchaser plaintiffs face when attempting to certify a class.

    In depth

    On February 9, the US Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit upheld a ruling by the US District Court for the District of Delaware in In re: Class 8 Transmission Indirect Purchaser Antitrust Litigation that indirect purchasers of Class 8 transmissions did not meet the requirements for class certification. The Third Circuit found that only the individual claims may proceed in the case, overturning the district court’s dismissal of those claims.

    Background

    In the case, indirect purchaser plaintiffs (IPPs) allege that there was a conspiracy among Eaton Corporation (Eaton) and a group of truck manufacturers to maintain a monopoly over the heavy-duty truck transmissions market. The truck manufacturers include Daimler Trucks North America LLC, Navistar International Corporation, Inc., PACCAR Inc. (through the Kenworth Truck Company and Peterbilt Motors Company divisions) and sister companies Volvo Trucks North America and Mack Trucks, Inc. IPPs allege that defendants entered into anticompetitive exclusive dealing agreements aimed at keeping Eaton’s largest competitor, ZF Meritor, out of the market. IPPs consist of parties who purchased trucks that contained Class 8 transmissions manufactured by Eaton.

    Rule 23 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure governs class certifications and requires that 1) the class is so numerous that joinder of all members is impracticable; 2) there are questions of law or fact common to the class; 3) the claims or defenses of the representative parties are typical of the claims or defenses of the class; and 4) the representative parties will fairly and adequately protect the interests of the class. In addition, Rule 23(b)(3) requires that the court find the questions of law or fact common to class members predominate over any questions affecting only individual members, and that a class action is superior to other available methods for fairly and efficiently adjudicating the controversy. On October 21, 2015, the district court denied class certification to IPPs because they didn’t meet the standard of Rule 23(b)(3).

    The district court found that common issues did not predominate over issues affecting only individuals, and that the proposed class was not sufficiently cohesive. The court recognized that neither the presence of an individual inquiry in the case, nor individualized damages calculations, necessarily defeat the analysis. However, the IPPs’ varied positions when it came to calculating overcharges failed to pass muster. Examples include that certain resellers had an interest in proving they did not pass through an overcharge so they could recover all damages themselves, rebates for the transmissions sales were not applied uniformly to the class, and certain rebates may have offset the alleged overcharge altogether such that certain class members did not suffer an injury at all. The district court found that IPPs had not established common proof that all—or nearly all—class members suffered antitrust injury in the form of higher prices than they otherwise would have paid, following the standard set forth in Hydrogen Peroxide. IPPs were not required to prove antitrust impact at the class certification stage, but must show that impact would at least be capable of proof at trial through common evidence. The district court found that IPPs did not meet this showing.

    IPPs appealed the decision and argued that the district court abused its discretion by failing to conduct a “rigorous analysis” of IPPs’ arguments and evidence for class certification. The US Supreme Court has long held that district courts must conduct a “rigorous analysis” of the requirements of Rule 23 before certifying a class, a principle reaffirmed by the Comcast decision in 2013. (McDermott previously reported on the Comcast decision and its effect on certification in antitrust cases.)

    In an opinion submitted in September 2016, but only filed last week, the Third Circuit denied this appeal and agreed with the district court’s denial of class certification. The Third Circuit agreed with the district court that IPPs failed to show that class-wide evidence could prove antitrust impact, so common questions did not predominate over any questions affecting only individual members. Specifically, in its analysis of IPPs arguments and evidence, the Third Circuit agreed with the district court that the analysis and report by IPP’s expert were insufficient to demonstrate overcharges and class-wide impact for pass-through costs because his sales data was so limited and his analysis was based on less than 1 percent of total truck sales from the class.

    Moving Forward

    Though the Third Circuit agreed with the dismissal of the motion for class certification, effectively ending the class claims, it also found that the district court erred in dismissing the individual claims. The district court pointed to IPPs’ request to withdraw and substitute certain class representatives, filed the same day as the motion for class certification, as “potential upheaval” a full four years into litigation that called into question whether class representatives could fairly and adequately protect the interests of the class. The district court then concluded that “because the proposed class lacks representation, the case does not present a case or controversy under Article III.”

    However, the Third Circuit clarified that there is no case or controversy when the parties “lack a legally cognizable interest in the outcome,” but here IPPs brought their claims explicitly in the complaints both on behalf of the putative indirect purchaser class and “on behalf of themselves” as individuals, so the district court erred in dismissing all of the claims when the errors existed only with class certification. Therefore, the Third Circuit vacated only the portion of the order dismissing the individual claims, reviving them and remanding to the district court for further proceedings.

    Authors
    More insights