Content Type: Article

  • First Circuit Allows Bankruptcy Trustee to Recover College Tuition Payments

    First Circuit Allows Bankruptcy Trustee to Recover College Tuition Payments

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    First Circuit Allows Bankruptcy Trustee to Recover College Tuition Payments

    November 15, 2019

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    An insolvent parent’s college “tuition payments… depleted the [debtor’s] estate and furnished nothing of direct value to the [debtor’s] creditors…,” held the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit on Nov. 12, 2019. In re Palladino, 2019 WL 5883721, *3 (1st Cir. Nov. 12, 2019). Reversing the bankruptcy court on a direct appeal, the First Circuit rejected its reasoning “that a financially self-sufficient daughter offered [the debtor parents] an economic benefit.” Id. at *2. Instead, held the First Circuit, because the tuition payments were fraudulent transfers, the trustee “is entitled to avoid the tuition payments” and recover them from the college. Id. at *3n. 5.

    Relevance

    “Tuition payments made by insolvent parents have divided the courts,” said the Court of Appeals, “although the recent cases have mostly ruled for trustees.” See Geltzer v. Oberlin College, et al., 2018 WL 6333588 (Bankr. S.D.N.Y. Dec. 4, 2018) (trustee permitted to claw back payments that parents made to their financially independent adult children for college-related costs); Pergament v. Brooklyn Law School, et al., 2018 WL 6182502 (E.D.N.Y. Nov. 27, 2018) (schools may assert a “good faith” defense for tuition payments received before a student enrolls in classes, but not those payments received after student has enrolled). The National Association of Bankruptcy Trustees filed an amicus brief for the trustee here, as did the American Council on Education and others for the appellee college.

    The college defendant in Palladino accepted tuition payments in exchange for an intangible service —teaching the debtor’s children. When schools are required to disgorge tuition payments, they are worse off than a seller of goods who may seek to reclaim those goods under the Uniform Commercial Code. Innocent schools and colleges have nothing to reclaim.

    Palladino is the first fraudulent transfer/tuition payment case to be handed down by any federal Court of Appeals. Because the court relied on the fraudulent transfer provisions of the Bankruptcy Code (“Code”) and because Congress “made the trade offs which are set forth in the statute, courts must enforce those statutes. Absent constitutional challenge, when confronted with a clear statutory command like the one in the Code, that is the end of the matter.” Id. at *3, citing TVA v. Hill, 437 U.S. 153, 194 (1978).

    Facts

    The debtor parents paid roughly $65,000 in college tuition for their 18-year-old daughter between 2012 and 2014. In 2014, the parents were convicted for fraud in operating a Ponzi scheme and subjected to a $9.7-million civil judgment obtained by the Securities and Exchange Commission. They filed a Chapter 7 petition in April 2014, when the bankruptcy trustee was appointed. The trustee sued the college to avoid and recover the tuition payments under federal and state fraudulent transfer law, but “the only issue on appeal” was the trustee’s constructive fraud claim under Code §548 (transfer by insolvent debtor for less than “reasonably equivalent value”). Id. at *2.

    The Bankruptcy Court

    The bankruptcy court, in disposing of cross motions for summary judgment, held that having “a financially self-sufficient daughter” constituted “reasonably equivalent value” under Code §548(a)(1)(B)(i). Under Massachusetts law, where the parents were domiciled, and under Connecticut law, where the defendant college was located, “the age of majority…” is 18. 2019 WL 5883721, at *1n. 1.

    The Court of Appeals

    The court stated the rationale for avoiding fraudulent transfers: “the law prohibiting fraudulent transfers protects creditors from transactions undertaken by the debtor prior to bankruptcy… which deplete the pool of assets that would eventually be available to satisfy the creditors’ claims.” Id. “Such a [fraudulent] transfer operates to prioritize the friend or family member over bona fide creditors, which in turn ‘violates the principle, be just, before you are generous.’” Id. quoting Bos. Trading Grp., Inc. v. Burnazos, 835 F.2d 1504, 1508 (1st Cir. 1987) (Breyer, J.).

    Relying on Code §548(a)(1)(B)(i), dealing with constructively fraudulent transfers, the court stressed that an insolvent debtor’s transfer “made… within two years before” bankruptcy for “less than a reasonably equivalent value” is voidable. Id. at *2. “Reasonably equivalent value” is “not defined in the statute,” said the court, “but it does not include intangible, emotional and non-economic benefits.” Id. citing Tavenner v. Smoot, 257 F.3d 401, 408-09 (4th Cir. 2001).

    Fraudulent transfer law is intended to “preserve the debtor’s estate for the benefit of unsecured creditors,” explained the court. Id. “Courts evaluate transfers from the creditors’ perspective… measuring value at the time of the transfer.” Id.

    The First Circuit’s reasoning in Palladino is “straightforward.” Id. at *3. “The tuition payments here depleted the estate and furnished nothing of direct value to the creditors who are the central concern of the Code provisions at issue.” Id. Because the college could show no value being conferred on the parent debtors, and because the parent debtors were “under [no] legal obligation to pay college tuition for their adult children,” the college had to return the tuition payments. Id. at *3n. 4. Nevertheless, if state law had required the expenditure, the outcome might have been different. Id. The college “invoke[d] a ‘societal expectation’ that parents will pay college tuition for their adult children, but… this does nothing for the creditors.” Id. The court would reach the same result for payments to “elderly parents or needful siblings.” Id. at *3.

    Comment

    Palladino may lead to draconian results for innocent, tuition-dependent schools and colleges. A legislative solution is the most effective way of resolving the problem. See e.g., Religious Liberty and Charity Donation Protection Act, 1998, Pub. L.No. 105-183 (1998) (amended Code’s fraudulent transfer provisions to prevent trustee from challenging good faith charitable gifts; “transfer of a charitable contribution to a qualified religious or charitable entity… shall not be considered to be a [constructively] fraudulent transfer…”).

    Authored by Michael L. Cook.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or the author.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2019 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Dental Company’s Indemnification Claim “Bites”

    ARTICLE

    Dental Company’s Indemnification Claim “Bites”

    October 2019

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Are Businesses Ready for the Tax Implications of a Change of Government?

    ARTICLE

    Are Businesses Ready for the Tax Implications of a Change of Government?

    November 13, 2019

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • New SEC Proxy Voting Guidance — What Private Fund Managers Need to Do

    New SEC Proxy Voting Guidance — What Private Fund Managers Need to Do

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    New SEC Proxy Voting Guidance — What Private Fund Managers Need to Do

    November 5, 2019

    Read time: 10 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission and the SEC staff have long maintained that a tailored proxy voting policy, consistently applied, is part of a registered investment adviser’s fiduciary duty to its clients. The SEC recently issued guidance (“Proxy Guidance”)[1] that details several issues that investment advisers should address in their proxy voting policies.

    The Proxy Guidance was approved by a split 3 – 2 vote of the SEC, and some industry representatives have suggested it should be withdrawn and re-proposed subject to notice and comment. Unless and until such action is taken, the Proxy Guidance reflects the SEC’s views as to advisers’ obligations and the SEC staff can be expected to rely on such guidance in administering their examination and enforcement program.

    Background

    The Proxy Guidance is grounded in the SEC’s position (as set forth in the “Fiduciary Interpretation”[2] issued earlier this year) that “investment advisers owe each of their clients a fiduciary duty under the Advisers Act” which “must be viewed in the context of the agreed-upon scope of the relationship between the adviser and the client.” The Fiduciary Interpretation specified that voting decisions fall within the (fiduciary) duties of care and loyalty owed to clients by investment advisers.

    In addition, Investment Advisers Act Rule 206(4)-6 specifically requires registered investment advisers that seek “to exercise voting authority with respect to client securities” to adopt and implement written policies and procedures that are reasonably designed to ensure that the investment adviser votes proxies in the best interest of its clients.

    Many fund managers engage proxy advisory firms from their research and recommendations, and many advisers empower them to cast ballots on behalf of the investment fund clients. Some public companies and other commenters challenged what they saw as the increasing power of these proxy advisory firms and, in response, the SEC engaged in a sustained outreach effort over the past decade seeking comments and offering guidance, including the issuance of a 2010 SEC concept release,[3] a 2014 Staff Legal Bulletin,[4] and several roundtables.

    How the Proxy Guidance Applies to Private Fund Managers

    Private fund managers’ proxy voting practices can be divided into three categories (and some managers will employ more than one of these categories for different situations):

    • Managers that engage a proxy advisory firm to provide research and recommendations, but weigh each vote themselves and make specific decisions on how to vote;
    • Managers that elect not to vote proxies for their clients’ holdings because they have determined that any benefits of voting are outweighed by the costs directly or indirectly borne by its clients; and
    • Managers that engage a proxy advisory firm to assess situations and empower the proxy advisory firm to vote on behalf of the manager’s clients.

    The Proxy Guidance contains directives and advice for each of these categories of managers.

    Provisions Applicable to All Managers

    Irrespective of which category a particular manager falls into, there are a number of points made in the Proxy Guidance that should be considered by all private fund managers, including the following.

    Annual Reviews. The Proxy Guidance makes it clear that the SEC expects an investment adviser to review and document, “no less frequently than annually,” the overall adequacy of its proxy voting program. The SEC noted that such a review allows the adviser to confirm that its voting policies and procedures have been:

    • Reasonably formulated (both in the abstract and in actual operation); and
    • Effectively implemented.

    Most registered investment advisers cover proxy voting in their annual compliance review under Rule 206(4)-7.

    Compliance Confirmations. The SEC states that a registered investment adviser “should consider reasonable measures to determine that it is casting votes on behalf of its clients consistently with its voting policies and procedures.” The Proxy Guidance suggests that reviewing a sampling of voting decisions, presumably by a compliance officer, is a viable way for an adviser to evaluate its compliance with Rule 206(4)-6 and confirm compliance with the manager’s policies and procedures.

    To the extent that a manager does not have some kind of forensic compliance review process for its proxy voting program, the manager should consider whether such a review would be a useful improvement to the compliance program.

    Multiple Clients. The Proxy Guidance also focuses on how the actions of an investment adviser should change when the adviser has multiple clients; in fact, the SEC questioned whether a single policy for all of the adviser’s clients would be in the best interest of each of its clients. To drive this point home, in a footnote, the SEC included language that said “nothing in [Rule 206(4)-6] prevents an investment adviser from having different policies and procedures for different clients or different categories of clients.”

    Given this focus, all managers with more than one client relationship should consider reviewing how the existing proxy voting policy or policies address the various investment programs that it administers, and documenting the results of that review. To the extent that multiple voting policies are warranted, the manager should consider what consents and disclosures may be appropriate.

    Managers That Make Specific Voting Decisions

    The Proxy Guidance expressly states that advisers exercising voting authority must “conduct a reasonable investigation into matters on which the adviser votes and to vote in the best interest of the client.” The SEC notes that any conflict of interest the adviser has in connection with a proxy vote must be carefully addressed. The SEC also indicates that a “reasonable investigation” should consider whether particular votes request a more detailed analysis (e.g., mergers and acquisitions). Given the focus on this topic, private fund managers should consider reviewing how they would demonstrate that their investment personnel are satisfying this responsibility.

    Managers That Abstain from Voting

    The Proxy Guidance confirms that an investment adviser is not required to cast votes on behalf of its clients, but this ability to abstain is limited only to two situations:

    • Where an investment adviser and the client have agreed in advance to limit the conditions under which the investment adviser would exercise voting authority; and
    • When an investment adviser has determined that refraining from voting is in the best interest of that client (such as where the adviser determined that the cost to the client of voting the proxy exceeds the expected benefit to the client).

    The SEC did caution, however, that — when abstaining under a “best interests” analysis — the adviser is still subject to the undertakings it made to its clients and, more broadly, to its duty of care.

    In light of this guidance, private fund managers that do not vote, either on a categorical basis (like, e.g., many quantitative managers) or a case-by-case basis, should consider preparing an assessment of the foundation for such a determination, which should include an assessment of the disclosures made to clients.

    Managers That Employ a Proxy Advisory Firm

    The primary focus of the Proxy Guidance is on advisers’ use of proxy advisory firms. The guidance applies not only to firms that empower proxy advisory firms to formulate positions and cast ballots on behalf of an adviser’s clients, but also to advisers that utilize proxy firms for research and recommendations while retaining the ultimate decisions for itself.

    Additional Steps. The Proxy Guidance recommends that advisers employing a proxy advisory firm “consider additional steps to evaluate whether the investment adviser’s voting determinations are consistent with its voting policies and procedures and in the client’s best interest before the votes are cast.” Note that there are three elements in that one sentence:

    • Evaluating whether the votes cast are “consistent with” the adviser’s voting policies and procedures;
    • Evaluating whether the votes cast are “in the client’s best interest”; and
    • Performing these evaluations “before the votes are cast.”

    Examples of “additional steps” proposed in the Proxy Guidance include reviews of the proposed voting slates (perhaps on a sampled basis) and additional substantive analysis of proposed votes on matters that are contested or controversial, that are not subject to any specific guidance in the manager’s policies, or that may have been recommended prior to new information coming into the market.

    Capacity and Competence Assessment. The SEC also has suggested that an adviser – as a condition of continued engagement – should evaluate the “capacity and competence” of any proxy advisory firm, suggesting a focus on “the proxy advisory firm’s staffing, personnel, and/or technology.” In that vein, the Proxy Guidance further recommends that the adviser “should also consider whether the proxy advisory firm has an effective process for seeking timely input from issuers and proxy advisory firm clients” in formulating its recommendations; in other words, the adviser’s investment staff should understand:

    • How the proxy adviser formulates its recommendations;
    • How it deals with conflicts of interests (examples of several kinds of conflicts are included in the Proxy Guidance); and
    • How it utilizes technology in disclosing conflicts.

    The adviser should also consider whether the proxy advisory firm is updating its methodologies, guidelines and voting recommendations on an ongoing basis.

    Effectiveness. In particular, the Proxy Guidance states that an investment adviser should consider the “effectiveness” of the proxy advisory firm’s process for obtaining “current and accurate information” related to matters on which is makes voting recommendations. The SEC guidance suggests that advisers consider matters such as how a proxy advisory firm engages with issuers and ensures that it has complete and accurate information; how the firm tries to identify and correct deficiencies in its analysis; the quality of the proxy advisory firm’s disclosure of these matters to the adviser; and whether and how the adviser employs factors specific to a given issuer or proposal.

    Investigating Errors. Situations where an adviser becomes aware of potential factual or methodological errors in a proxy advisory firm’s work are also raised, with the SEC suggesting that an adviser “should conduct a reasonable investigation into the matter” and, more generally, review its own policies and procedures to ensure that they have been “reasonably designed to ensure that its voting determinations are not based on materially inaccurate or incomplete information.” Managers should consider whether they have feedback systems in place to deal with proxy adviser errors and make changes accordingly.

    Next Steps

    With the publication of the Proxy Guidance, the SEC has indicated that private fund managers of all stripes need to reassess and likely augment their proxy voting policies and procedures. This new guidance indicates that expectations of oversight and involvement in the proxy voting process have increased, particularly for the compliance functions, and chief compliance officers should assess what resources and processes are needed to respond.

    Authored by Brian T. Daly and Marc E. Elovitz.

    If you have any questions concerning this Memorandum, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] See “Commission Guidance Regarding Proxy Voting Responsibilities of Investment Advisers,” Aug. 21, 2019, available here.

    [2] See “Commission Interpretation Regarding Standard of Conduct for Investment Advisers,” Release No. IA-5248, June 5, 2019, 84 FR 33669, at 33671, July 12, 2019.

    [3] See “Concept Release on the U.S. Proxy System,” Release No. 34-62495, July 14, 2010, 75 FR 42982, July 22, 2010.

    [4] See “Proxy Voting: Proxy Voting Responsibilities of Investment Advisers and Availability of Exemptions from the Proxy Rules for Proxy Advisory Firms,” Staff Legal Bulletin No. 20 (IM/CF), June 30, 2014, available here.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2019 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Marc E. Elovitz

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • Final §956 Regulations: DRD for Corporate U.S. Shareholders

    ARTICLE

    Final §956 Regulations: DRD for Corporate U.S. Shareholders

    November 2019

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors

    Lowell D. Yoder

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • In The Pink: Lack of Personal Jurisdiction Results in Dismissal of Non-Infringement Verdict

    ARTICLE

    In The Pink: Lack of Personal Jurisdiction Results in Dismissal of Non-Infringement Verdict

    November 12, 2019

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • CFTC 2020 Examination Initiative – Guidance for Private Fund Managers

    CFTC 2020 Examination Initiative – Guidance for Private Fund Managers

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    CFTC 2020 Examination Initiative – Guidance for Private Fund Managers

    November 8, 2019

    Read time: 3 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On Oct. 30, 2019, Joshua B. Sterling, the Director of the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s Division of Swap Dealer and Intermediary Oversight (“DSIO”), spoke about DSIO’s new “thematic review” initiative, which is slated to commence in 2020.[1] The discussion was held at Schulte Roth & Zabel and was cohosted by the firm and the Alternative Investment Management Association.

    Director Sterling summarized several aspects of the examination initiative that will be applicable to private fund managers registered with the CFTC. The director emphasized that the examinations are intended to allow DSIO staff and the CFTC to better understand the environment in which their registrants operate. He stated that, “We are looking to gather information from individual firms, assess that information on an individual basis and compare our assessments across firms to identify potential better ways of doing things.” As a corollary to that point, he emphasized that “we will not be issuing deficiency letters.”

    The director discussed how “thematic reviews” will be focused on a small number of issues DSIO may consider recommending to the CFTC for rulemaking or other action. In other words, they should be shorter and more focused than examinations carried out by other regulators and self-regulatory organizations.

    At some point, the results of the 2020 examination effort will be summarized in a general report that will disclose:

    • The scope of the review initiative;
    • The types of firms selected; and
    • A summary of different ways firms address certain compliance issues.

    Although the examinations, in general, will remain confidential, DSIO also intends to share findings about “good practices” to serve as guidance for all registrants. The director noted that they “will be unlikely to fit every firm because firms have different businesses and structures … firms will have flexibility to decide whether or how to implement our guidance as [a] result. To insist otherwise would not promote smart, effective and practical regulation of our registrants.”

    Authored by Brian T. Daly and Joshua B. Wright.

     If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] The full text of Director Sterling’s comments are here.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2019 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Giving Back—An Inside Look at Pro Bono at a Law Firm

    ARTICLE

    Giving Back—An Inside Look at Pro Bono at a Law Firm

    November 2019

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • SEC Proposes Advertising and Cash Solicitation Rules Overhaul

    SEC Proposes Advertising and Cash Solicitation Rules Overhaul

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    SEC Proposes Advertising and Cash Solicitation Rules Overhaul

    November 6, 2019

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On Nov. 4, 2019, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission issued proposed amendments to the Advertising Rule (“Proposed Advertising Rule”) and Cash Solicitation Rule (“Proposed Solicitation Rule”) under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940 (“Advisers Act”) (collectively, the “Proposed Rules”).[1]

    The Proposed Advertising Rule represents a comprehensive overhaul of the existing “Advertising Rule” (Rule 206(4)-1), which has not been substantively updated since it was adopted in 1961. The Proposed Advertising Rule seeks to dramatically shift the model for regulating advertisements under the Advisers Act from a prescriptive to a principles-based approach. The proposing release runs over 500 pages and provides detailed and thoughtful analyses of a broad range of issues under the Advertising Rule, seeking to update the Rule for the current era. We have highlighted some of the key proposals below, including with respect to the Cash Solicitation Rule, Books and Records Rule, and Form ADV.

    The SEC is soliciting comments on a wide range of items relating to the Proposed Rules, with all comment letters due within 60 days after the publication of the Proposed Rules in the Federal Register. Schulte Roth & Zabel will be submitting a comment letter on the Proposed Rules and we welcome any thoughts or suggestions from our clients. Given the importance of this proposal, we are hosting an in-person discussion session for our clients on this topic later this month at our offices in New York.  We look forward to discussing these issues then (or, if interested clients are not able to join us in person, to discussing these points separately).

    Amendments to the Advertising Rule

    Some of the most significant changes for private fund managers include:

    • Distinguishing Between Retail and Non-Retail Advertisements. The Proposed Advertising Rule creates a new category of “Non-Retail Advertisements,” which would permit greater latitude in content and presentation, but the dissemination of which would be limited to “qualified purchasers” and “knowledgeable employees.” For example, advisers would be permitted to show gross performance without accompanying net performance in Non-Retail Advertisements; provided that the advertisement contains or offers to promptly furnish a schedule of specific fees and expenses. Non-Retail Advertisements are also exempt from new performance reporting requirements that would require advisers to (i) show performance over specified time periods and (ii) affirmatively provide certain disclosures relating to the risks and limitations of hypothetical performance.
    • Case Studies. The Proposed Advertising Rule incorporates a “fair and balanced” principle to evaluate the use of case studies and other past specific recommendations. The SEC notes that while the guidance from several staff no-action letters can be useful in applying the “fair and balanced” standard, the standard exists independently and advisers would not be obligated to follow the requirements of those letters. Not surprisingly, “cherry-picking” and other presentations of specific investment advice and related performance that are misleading would be prohibited under the “fair and balanced” standard.
    • Hypothetical Performance. The Proposed Advertising Rule permits the use of hypothetical performance where advisers (i) provide sufficient information to enable the recipient to understand the criteria and assumptions underlying the performance and (ii) provide (or, if a Non-Retail Advertisement, offer to provide) similar information addressing the risks and limitations of the use of hypothetical performance in making investment decisions.
    • “Extracted” Performance. Under the Proposed Advertising Rule, advisers would be permitted to provide extracted performance in advertisements; provided that such advertisements contain or offer to promptly furnish the performance results of all investments in the portfolio from which the performance was extracted.
    • Related Performance. The Proposed Advertising Rule would prohibit advertisements that show the performance of a “related portfolio” (which are those portfolios with substantially similar investment policies, objectives and strategies as those of the services being offered or promoted) unless the advertisement shows the performance of all related portfolios. Advisers would be able to exclude the performance of a related portfolio only when the performance shown would be no higher than if the performance of all related portfolios were included.
    • New Compliance Requirements. The Proposed Advertising Rule would generally require review and pre-approval of advertisements by a designated employee. This review and approval requirement also applies to updates to previously-reviewed advertisements. The Proposed Advertising Rule would also require advisers to adopt policies and procedures with respect to the use of Non-Retail Advertisements and hypothetical performance.
    • Testimonials, Endorsements and Third-Party Ratings. The Proposed Advertising Rule would generally permit the use of testimonials, endorsements and third-party ratings in advertisements, provided that they are accompanied by certain disclosures, such as whether compensation has been provided by or on behalf of the adviser to the person providing the testimonial or endorsement, or whether that person is a client.
    • Revised Definition of “Advertisement.” The Proposed Advertising Rule fundamentally reworks the definition of an advertisement to cover “any communication, disseminated by any means, by or on behalf of an investment adviser, that offers or promotes the investment adviser’s advisory services or that seeks to obtain or retain one or more investment advisory clients or investors in any pooled investment vehicle advised by the investment adviser,” subject to certain enumerated exceptions. The Proposed Advertising Rule would make it clear that communications with existing clients and investors that “offer or promote” advisory services, which could, in certain circumstances, include the adviser’s market commentary and discussions of the adviser’s investing thesis, are considered advertisements.
    • Additional General Prohibitions. The Proposed Advertising Rule expands on the general prohibitions currently included in the Rule. Advisers would be prohibited from disseminating advertisements that: (i) contain any material claim or statement that is not substantiated; (ii) contain untrue or misleading implications about material facts relating to the adviser, or that are reasonably likely to cause an untrue or misleading inference to be drawn concerning any material facts; (iii) discuss or imply any potential benefits connected with or resulting from the adviser’s services or methods of operation that do not also “clearly and prominently” disclose associated material risks or other limitations; (iv) include or exclude performance results, or contain presentations of performance time periods, in a manner that is not fair and balanced; or (v) are otherwise materially misleading.

    Amendments to the Cash Solicitation Rule

    The SEC also proposed amendments to the “Cash Solicitation Rule” (Rule 206(4)-3) to expand the types of activities and compensation covered by that Rule and update certain compliance obligations under the Advisers Act, including:

    • Solicitors to Private Fund Investors. The Proposed Solicitation Rule would expand the applicability of the Cash Solicitation Rule to include solicitors of private fund investors (currently the Rule only covers solicitors of “clients,” not of “investors” in funds that are clients). An adviser’s officers, directors, partners and employees would continue to remain exempt from the written agreement, compliance and oversight provisions of the Cash Solicitation Rule; provided that the affiliation is disclosed to clients or private fund investors.
    • All Forms of Compensation. The SEC proposed expanding the applicability of the Cash Solicitation Rule to cover all forms of compensation, including non-cash compensation such as awards, prizes, free or discounted services, or directed brokerage. (The Proposed Solicitation Rule would retitle the existing Rule as “Compensation for Solicitations.”)
    • Elimination of Brochure Delivery and Disclosure Acknowledgement Requirements. The Proposed Solicitation Rule would eliminate the requirement that a solicitor deliver the adviser’s brochure to clients and obtain from each client acknowledgements of receipt of the solicitation disclosures.

    Amendments to the Books and Records Rule and Form ADV

    The Proposed Rules also contain amendments to the “Books and Records Rule” (Rule 204-2) to conform existing recordkeeping requirements to the scope of the Proposed Rules, as well as to require recordkeeping of written approvals of all advertisements by designated employees. The proposed amendments to Form ADV would include new questions requiring disclosure of whether an adviser’s advertisements contain performance information, references to specific investments, testimonials, endorsements or third-party ratings; other proposed new questions relate to third-party verification of performance results and compensation for the use of testimonials, endorsements or third-party ratings.

    Transition Period and Existing No-Action Letters

    The SEC is proposing a one-year transition period from the effective date of the rules to formal implementation. Advisers would be permitted to rely on the amended rules during the period after the effective date but before the compliance date. The proposing release contains a list of no-action letters under the Advertising and Cash Solicitation Rules that the staff is reviewing for potential withdrawal in connection with the adoption of final rules.

    Authored by Brian T. Daly, Marc E. Elovitz and Christopher S. Avellaneda.

     If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] The SEC’s proposing release can be found here.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2019 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Marc E. Elovitz

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Christopher S. Avellaneda

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • What Are the Retirement Plan Dollar Limits for 2020?

    What Are the Retirement Plan Dollar Limits for 2020?

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    What Are the Retirement Plan Dollar Limits for 2020?

    November 6, 2019

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The Secretary of the Treasury announced the 2020 limits for qualified retirement plans and IRAs based on cost of living increases. The Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers is the benchmark used to determine the index. As a result, most of the 2020 dollar limits will increase as noted in the included chart. IRS Notice 2019-59 sets forth the annual dollar limitations effective Jan. 1, 2020, as required under Section 415(d) of the Internal Revenue Code. For 2020, employees will be able to defer up to $19,500 into their qualified defined contribution plans, and an additional $6,500 for those over the age of 50, for a combined total of $26,000. Highly compensated employees who earn more than $130,000 and who participate in both qualified and nonqualified plans will have a slightly greater amount of their compensation allocated to the qualified plan with the increase of the compensation limit from $280,000 to $285,000.

    Read this Alert.

    Authored by Mark E. Brossman, Ian L. Levin and Susan E. Bernstein.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2019 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Mark E. Brossman

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Ian L. Levin

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights