Content Type: Article

  • New York State Department of Labor Publishes Standard for Prevention of Airborne Infectious Diseases

    New York State Department of Labor Publishes Standard for Prevention of Airborne Infectious Diseases

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    New York State Department of Labor Publishes Standard for Prevention of Airborne Infectious Diseases

    July 13, 2021

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Update: On September 6, 2021, New York Governor Kathy Hochul designated COVID-19 as a disease to be covered by the NY HERO Act. McDermott has provided updated guidance, available here. 

    On July 6, 2021, the New York State Department of Labor (NYSDOL) published its Airborne Infectious Disease Exposure Prevention Standard (Standard), as required under the New York Health and Essential Rights (HERO) Act. Under the Standard, employers with worksites located in New York are required to either adopt the NYSDOL’s model exposure prevention plan or develop their own alternative prevention plan no later than August 5, 2021, and circulate their plan to employees no later than September 4, 2021.

    Employers must adopt a prevention plan but are not required to implement the plan until the New York State Commissioner of Health (Commissioner) designates an airborne disease as a “highly contagious communicable disease that presents a serious risk of harm to the public health.” As of the date of this alert, the Commissioner has not issued any such designation so employers need not implement their plans just yet.

    In depth

    HERO ACT SIGNED INTO LAW

    On May 5, 2021, New York Governor Andrew Cuomo signed the HERO Act into law, which mandates that employers adopt a number of workplace safety measures in order to prevent occupational exposure to airborne infectious diseases. (Please see our previous alert for a detailed summary of the HERO Act’s provisions.)

    NYSDOL STANDARDS PUBLISHED

    The NYSDOL published the Standard on July 6, 2021, and it applies to all employers with worksites located in New York State. By August 5, 2021, employers are required to either (1) adopt NYSDOL’s model exposure prevention plan or (2) develop their own alternative prevention plan which meets or exceeds the requirements of the model plan. Employers will then have until September 4, 2021, to make their written prevention plan available to their employees in both English and their employees’ primary language(s) (if applicable).

    In addition to the model exposure prevention plan, the NYSDOL released industry-specific templates for the following 11 industries: Agriculture, construction, delivery services, domestic workers, emergency response, food services, manufacturing and industry, personal services, private education, private transportation and retail. The NYSDOL’s Standard and industry-specific templates can be found here.

    While employers are required to adopt a prevention plan by August 5, 2021, they are not required to implement the plan until the Commissioner designates an airborne disease as a “highly contagious communicable disease that presents a serious risk of harm to the public health.” Because COVID-19 has not been designated as such a disease as of the date of this update, there is no requirement for employers to implement their plans at this time. Given the spread of COVID-19 variants, however, that may change in the future.

    KEY EXPOSURE PREVENTION PLAN REQUIREMENTS

    Employers are required to establish a written prevention plan containing, among other things, the following key exposure controls:

    • Perform health screenings at the beginning of each workday and limit exposure to employees with any symptoms of an airborne infectious disease. Employers must also follow protocols for testing, isolation and quarantine before allowing employees to return to the workplace;
    • Implement physical distancing requirements to keep employees at least six feet apart;
    • Provide appropriate face coverings to employees and require face coverings when physical distancing cannot be maintained;
    • Provide either adequate handwashing facilities or hand sanitizing facilities/supplies to employees;
    • Implement an appropriate plan for cleaning and disinfecting frequently touched surfaces, shared tools, equipment, workspaces and common areas;
    • Provide and require that employees use personal protective equipment (PPE), as required or recommended by the New York State Department of Health (NYSDOH). The employer is responsible for ensuring that the PPE fits the employee, that employees receive training on how to use the PPE and that PPE is provided, used and maintained in a sanitary and reliable condition.

    Employers operating in one of 11 specified industries above must also consider and incorporate relevant requirements from the industry-specific templates posted on the NYSDOL’s website.

    Upon request, employers must make the exposure prevention plan available to all employees, employee representatives, collective bargaining representatives, independent contractors, the NYSDOL and the NYSDOH.

    ADDITIONAL REQUIREMENTS FOR ALTERNATIVE PREVENTION PLANS

    If an employer chooses not to adopt the NYSDOL’s model prevention plan, it may instead draft its own alternative prevention plan. Employers choosing to do so must (1) meet the minimum standards of the model plan and (2) develop the plan in conjunction with the employees’ collective-bargaining representative, or, if not applicable, then with “meaningful participation” of employees.

    Next Steps for Employers

    • By August 5, 2021, employers with worksites located in New York must either adopt NYSDOL’s model exposure prevention plan or develop their own alternative prevention plan.
    • By September 4, 2021, employers must provide their written prevention plan to their employees in both English and their employees’ primary language(s) (if applicable).
    • If and when the Commissioner designates an airborne disease as a “highly contagious communicable disease that presents a serious risk of harm to the public health,” employers must activate their prevention plan. COVID-19 has not been designated as such a disease at this time.

    Your McDermott attorney can help you with adopting NYSDOL’s model prevention plan or assist you with drafting a customized alternative prevention plan. We are also available to answer any of your questions related to the NYSDOL’s Standard.

    Authors

    Abigail M. Kagan

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • Damages in the Millions: Judgement on Liability Risk for Supervisory Board Members

    ARTICLE

    Damages in the Millions: Judgement on Liability Risk for Supervisory Board Members

    July 13, 2021

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Recently, a judgement was handed down in which the members of the supervisory board of a public limited company were ordered to pay millions in damages. This is likely to further intensify the recurring debate on the professionalisation of supervisory boards. An article by Renate Prinz and Katharina Gerdes (Law firm BRL).

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Parent and Subsidiary Responsibilities and Oversight: A Primer for New Relationships

    ARTICLE

    Parent and Subsidiary Responsibilities and Oversight: A Primer for New Relationships

    July, 2021

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    This article provides a high-level reminder of the powers held and obligations owed by subsidiary board members and how parent organizations can maintain oversight of subsidiary boards without micromanaging their operations and risking veil-piercing for lack of corporate independence.

    This article is available to Governance Institute members only.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • The New German Supply Chain Due Diligence Act (With a View Across the Border)

    The New German Supply Chain Due Diligence Act (With a View Across the Border)

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    The New German Supply Chain Due Diligence Act (With a View Across the Border)

    July 13, 2021

    Read time: 11 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On 11 June 2021, the German Federal Parliament approved the draft bill on corporate due diligence in supply chains (Supply Chain Due Diligence Act), which was approved by the German Federal Council without any changes on 25 June 2021. The act will come into force on 1 January 2023. The change of the abbreviation from Due Diligence Act to Supply Chain Due Diligence Act in the course of the legislative process is very welcomed as a specification of the purpose of the law. The act is also referred to as Supply Chain Act. It implements the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights, dated June 2011 (like the Modern Slavery Act 2015 in the United Kingdom).

    In depth

    Intended Purpose of the Law
    The Supply Chain Due Diligence Act is intended to protect human rights and to ensure a sustainable production. Under the Supply Chain Due Diligence Act, companies are obliged to identify and assess human rights and environmental risks and to establish an adequate and effective risk management system. This includes the prohibition of child labour, forced labour, slavery, servitude and the prohibition to disregard occupational health and safety, freedom of association, etc. Based on such an analysis, the respective companies have to take adequate measures to prevent or minimise the risk of human rights and environmental violations in these areas.

    The law establishes a duty of effort, but neither a duty to succeed nor a guarantee liability, since no company may be required to do something that is legally and factually impossible. The due diligence obligations are therefore already considered to have been fulfilled if a company has made a serious effort, even if it could not trace its entire supply chain or take certain preventive or remedial measures because this was actually or legally impossible.

    Scope of Application
    The new law is applicable to companies having their head office, principal place of business, administrative headquarters or registered office in Germany and employing more than 3,000 employees. In addition, foreign companies with a branch office and a corresponding number of employees in Germany are also subject to the new law. From 2024 onwards, this threshold shall be reduced to 1,000 employees.

    Scope of Due Diligence Obligations
    The scope of the due diligence obligations under the new law covers both direct and indirect suppliers. However, the extension of the due diligence obligations to indirect suppliers requires substantial knowledge which presupposes actual indications of a (potential) violation of human rights or environmental obligations of its indirect supplier. The risk analysis regarding direct suppliers is to be carried out at least once a year as well as on an as-needed basis if the company expects a significant change or significant expansion of the risk situation in its supply chain. In addition, a risk analysis has to be carried out also for indirect suppliers in case intermediaries are used only to avoid a risk analysis for such suppliers.

    Companies in scope of the Supply Chain Due Diligence Act have to issue a policy statement on their human rights strategy and introduce appropriate preventive measures in their own businesses and procure the same at their direct suppliers. In the event of any (actual or imminent) human rights or environmental duties violations within its own business or at a direct supplier, the company must immediately take appropriate remedial action (including prevention, reduction, remediation, suspension of business relationship and termination in case of material violations). However, the non-ratification of human rights or environmental agreements or their non-implementation into national law does not by itself constitute an obligation to terminate business relationships with companies based in these countries.

    According to the original draft bill, remedial action should lead to the cessation of violations of human rights or environmental obligations in the company’s own business area. In this respect, a regional differentiation is now made in such a way that the remedial measures (i) must lead to the cessation of violations in the company’s own business operations in Germany and (ii) must generally lead to the cessation of violations in the company’s own business operations abroad. However, since even under German law supplier contracts cannot always be terminated without further ado in the event of violations of human rights or environmental obligations (burden of proof), the unrestricted obligation in Germany will present the companies concerned with corresponding legal challenges. In case the company obtains substantial knowledge of a potential violation by an indirect supplier, a risk analysis must be conducted on the indirect supplier, and appropriate preventive measures must be taken.

    Whistleblower System and Annual Report
    The new law obliges companies to set up a whistleblower system. The law does not require the whistleblower to be personally affected. Such a restriction was discussed, but in the end did not find its way into the new law. In the context of harmonization on a European level, this aspect should be monitored and further discussed in order to keep an appropriate internal company complaints procedure practicable.

    Affected companies must publish an annual report on the fulfilment of their due diligence obligations in the preceding business year on the company website within four months after the end of the business year.

    Competent Authority
    The Federal Office for Economic Affairs and Export Control (BAFA) is responsible for monitoring and enforcing the new law by requesting information, issuing remediation orders and imposing civil fines. Complaints regarding (potential) violations can be directly reported to the BAFA.

    Liability and Sanctions
    The Supply Chain Due Diligence Act does not introduce an additional legal basis for civil law damage liabilities of companies resulting from any human rights or environmental duties violations in their supply chain. Instead, companies will face fines for failure to comply with their due diligence obligations. The new law stipulates fines of up to EUR 800,000, while for companies with an average worldwide annual turnover of more than EUR 400 million, fines of up to 2 % of their total worldwide annual group turnover can be imposed. If a potential fine exceeds EUR 175,000, companies can also be barred from public tender offers in Germany for a period of up to three years.

    ESG and M&A
    The Supply Chain Due Diligence Act is to be considered as part of the general international development that companies should increasingly assume responsibility, especially in the areas of environment, social and governance (ESG). The obligations under the Supply Chain Due Diligence Act should therefore be integrated into companies’ general ESG strategies.

    In addition, the new requirements of the Supply Chain Due Diligence Act should be increasingly taken into account in the context of legal due diligence and ESG due diligence in M&A transactions as well.

    European and International Dimension
    The Supply Chain Due Diligence Act represents only the beginning of a new development towards increased due diligence obligations for German corporates. A new directive on corporate due diligence and accountability is currently being discussed at European level. On 10 March 2021, the European Parliament presented a recommendation to initiate the preparation of such directive. Similar to the Supply Chain Due Diligence Act, additional reporting obligations and duties to monitor supply chains will be introduced at a European level. The EU directive could in particular extend the scope of application to significantly more companies and possibly also introduce civil liability. The German Supply Chain Due Diligence Act would then have to be adapted to the EU directive accordingly.

    For international companies compliance with different local requirements in various countries regarding supply chain due diligence will be an increasing challenge in the future. In order to ensure supply chain due diligence programs can be set-up and managed with more legal certainty, harmonization also on an international level would be very welcome.

    France
    In France, since 2017 the Duty of Care Act requires companies to develop, implement and publish in their annual report a vigilance plan (including a risks map, assessment proceedings and alert mechanisms) to identify and prevent risks and serious violations of human rights/fundamental freedoms in relation with human health and safety and the environment. The vigilance plan must cover the activities of: (i) the company itself; (ii) its direct and indirect affiliates; and (iii) its subcontractors and suppliers (solely those having an established commercial relationship with the concerned company). The Duty of Care Act applies to companies (i) having their headquarters in France and employing at least 5,000 employees themselves and through direct or indirect affiliates or (ii) having their headquarters in or outside of France and employing at least 10,000 employees themselves and through direct or indirect affiliates. Failure to comply with the Duty of Care Act is not subject to fines. However, such failure can lead to a formal “letter to comply” from an interested party (e.g., NGOs or employees’ associations). The request for issuance of a judicial “injection to comply” (possibly subject to daily fines) can also be considered. Finally, interested parties may consider engaging civil lawsuits against companies that are not in compliance with the Duty of Care Act (subject to the evidence of a damage, a fault of the company and a causal link).

    Italy
    The Italian legislation does not provide for a specific law to implement the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights (dated June 2011), and a structured debate is still far from being concluded in such direction. However, the Italian legal system includes several statutory provisions and regulations which may have indirectly similar functions. As an example, as far as working conditions are concerned, a due diligence process shall be made in order to comply with occupational health and safety obligations provided for by Legislative Decree no 81/2008, but also those concerning corporate responsibility according to Legislative Decree no 231/2001, as well as to comply with the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR).

    United Kingdom

    In the United Kingdom, the Modern Slavery Act was already introduced in 2015 to ensure transparency in supply chains. The Act requires the publication of a statement setting out steps that companies have taken to ensure that their businesses are free from modern slavery (including slavery, servitude, forced and compulsory labour and human trafficking). The Modern Slavery Act has a global reach and applies to any corporate body with a minimum annual turnover of £36 million (including subsidiaries), which carries on business or a part of a business in the United Kingdom. The UK government has published statutory guidance on the reporting requirements, which sets out expectations about areas that the statement should cover. The UK government also encourages publication of the statement on a central registry launched in February 2021, and legislative changes enhancing the Modern Slavery Act are expected to make publication on this registry compulsory. In practice, appropriate measures are to be taken by companies in the UK to ensure that the declaration can be made and that the implemented risk protection measures can be outlined.

    United States
    There are a number of laws and rules in the US in particular on federal and states level comprising risks for civil action as a result of violations of human rights, other international laws or treaties and addressing supply chain due diligence duties more broadly or sector-specific (e.g., Alien Tort Claims Act, California Transparency in Supply Chains Act to combat human trafficking and slavery). In addition, under the Conflict Minerals Rules, listed companies are required to review their supply chains for certain minerals if they may originate in conflict regions, and take action to address any human rights-related risks found. However, so far there is no comprehensive or single source of US law providing for supply chain due diligence duties like in other European jurisdictions.

    Practical Implications
    National and international corporates with activities in Germany and more than 3,000 employees will have to comply with the requirements of the new German Supply Chain Due Diligence Act starting from 1 January 2023. Accordingly, they should review and update their supply chain due diligence processes and systems for risk management and align them with requirements in other applicable jurisdictions. We are here to support you with our international network in Germany, France, Italy, the United Kingdom, the United States and worldwide, in implementing the requirements of applicable Supply Chain Due Diligence Acts in an efficient manner and in order to ensure compliance with legal requirements.

    Authors

    Florian Lechner

    Partner

    Frankfurt

    Sharon Lamb

    Partner

    London – 22 Bishopsgate

    Ettore Scandale

    Partner

    Milan

    More insights

  • Changes of the Notification Requirements for the Transparency Register

    Changes of the Notification Requirements for the Transparency Register

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Changes of the Notification Requirements for the Transparency Register

    July 12, 2021

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    When the Transparency Register and Financial Information Act comes into force on 1 August 2021, many companies in Germany will actually have to notify their beneficial owners to the transparency register for the first time. The most important legal aspects for the changeover are briefly presented below by Dr Sabine Balda and Sebastian Bonk.

    In depth
    1. Zweck der Neuregelung
      Am 1. August 2021 tritt das Gesetz zur europäischen Vernetzung der Transparenzregister und zur Umsetzung der Richtlinie (EU) 19/1153 des Europäischen Parlaments und des Rates vom 20. Juni 2019 zur Nutzung von Finanzinformationen für die Bekämpfung von Geldwäsche, Terrorismusfinanzierung und sonstigen schweren Straftaten (Transparenzregister- und Finanzinformationsgesetz) in seinen wesentlichen Teilen in Kraft. Zweck dieses Gesetzes ist – unter anderem – die Aufwertung des Transparenzregisters zum Vollregister mit einheitlichen und vollständigen Datensätzen aller mitteilungspflichtigen Rechtseinheiten. Hierdurch möchte der Gesetzgeber auf deutscher Seite die Voraussetzungen für eine Vernetzung der europäischen Transparenzregister und damit für eine effizientere Geldwäschebekämpfung schaffen.
    2. Wegfall der Mitteilungsfiktionen
      2.1 Die praktisch bedeutsamste Neuregelung betrifft die Verpflichtung aller juristischen Personen des Privatrechts und aller eingetragenen Gesellschaften mit gesellschaftsvertraglichem Sitz im Inland, ihre wirtschaftlich Berechtigten dem Transparenzregister mitzuteilen. Nach bislang geltendem Recht konnte sich die weit überwiegende Zahl der Organisationen darauf berufen, dass eine Mitteilung ihrer wirtschaftlich Berechtigten zum Transparenzregister nicht erforderlich sei, da sie von der sogenannten Mitteilungsfiktion nach § 20 Abs. 2 GWG profitierten. Danach kann eine Meldung der wirtschaftlich Berechtigten zum Transparenzregister unterbleiben, wenn die erforderlichen Angaben zu den wirtschaftlich Berechtigten unmittelbar aus einem öffentlichen Register, in dem die meldepflichtige Einheit eingetragen ist (insbesondere dem Handelsregister), elektronisch abgerufen werden können. Diese Regelung kam bislang vor allem GmbHs und – in bestimmten Konstellationen – Kommanditgesellschaften (bzw. GmbH & Co KGs) zugute. Diese Mitteilungsfiktion wurde im Zuge der Neuregelung ersatzlos aufgehoben. Nunmehr müssen die Mitteilungspflichtigen die erforderlichen Angaben zum wirtschaftlich Berechtigten dem Transparenzregister in jedem Fall tatsächlich übermitteln.Wirtschaftlich Berechtigte im gesetzlichen Sinne sind grundsätzlich die natürlichen Personen, in deren Eigentum oder unter deren Kontrolle eine juristische Person oder Gesellschaft steht, wobei der Begriff des wirtschaftlich Berechtigten in § 3 GWG weiter differenziert wird. Im Einzelfall kann die Ermittlung des wirtschaftlich Berechtigten schwierig sein, insbesondere bei Beteiligungsketten oder in Konzernstrukturen. Die in solchen Konstellationen regelmäßig auftretenden Rechtsfragen würden den Rahmen dieser Kurzdarstellung überschreiten, so dass insofern auf eine Klärung im jeweiligen Einzelfall verwiesen werden muss.

      Alle mitteilungspflichtigen Rechtseinheiten sollten berücksichtigen, dass sie einen sogenannten fiktiven wirtschaftlichen Berechtigten angeben müssen, wenn sich kein wirtschaftlich Berechtigter ermitteln lässt. Fiktive wirtschaftlich Berechtigte sind in der Regel die Geschäftsführungs- und Vertretungsorgane eines Mitteilungspflichtigen (§ 3 Abs. 2 S. 5 GWG).

      2.2 Weil börsennotierte Gesellschaften bereits in erheblichem Umfang Transparenzpflichten auf Grund anderer gesetzlicher Vorgaben erfüllen müssen, insbesondere nach dem Wertpapierhandelsrecht, galten ihre Mitteilungspflichten gegenüber dem Transparenzregister bislang pauschal als erfüllt. Auch dies ändert sich nach neuem Recht. Mit Inkrafttreten des neuen Rechts müssen börsennotierte Gesellschaften, wie auch deren Tochtergesellschaften, ihre wirtschaftlich Berechtigten wie alle anderen Mitteilungspflichtigen dem Transparenzregister melden.

      2.3 Für Personenvereinigungen mit Sitz im Ausland wurden die Mitteilungspflichten erweitert. Bislang mussten diese ihre wirtschaftlich Berechtigten dem Transparenzregister mitteilen, wenn sie sich verpflichteten, Eigentum an einer im Inland gelegenen Immobilie zu erwerben. Nach der gesetzlichen Neuregelung müssen sie nunmehr auch bei einem indirekten Immobilienerwerb im Wege eines Share Deals i. S. v. § 1 Abs. 3 Grunderwerbsteuergesetz eine entsprechende Mitteilung an das Transparenzregister machen.

    3. Übergangsfristen zur Erfüllung der Mitteilungspflichten
      Der Gesetzgeber hat Übergangsfristen vorgesehen, damit die betroffenen Organisationen sich auf die Änderungen im Zusammenhang mit den Mitteilungspflichten gegenüber dem Transparenzregister einstellen können.
      3.1 Danach müssen sämtliche juristischen Personen des Privatrechts und eingetragene Personengesellschaften i. S. v. § 20 Abs. 1 GWG, die sich bis zum 31. Juli 2021 auf die dargestellten Mitteilungsfiktionen nach altem Recht berufen konnten, ihre Mitteilungen nachholen und zwar
      3.1.1 Gesellschaften in der Rechtsform der AG, KGaA und SE bis zum 31. März 2022,
      3.1.2 Gesellschaften bzw. juristische Personen in der Rechtsform der GmbH, Genossenschaft, Europäischen Genossenschaft und der Partnerschaftsgesellschaft bis zum 30. Juni 2022 und
      3.1.3 alle anderen Mitteilungspflichtigen bis zum 31. Dezember 2022. Diese Regelung betrifft vor allem die Personenhandelsgesellschaften, vornehmlich Gesellschaften in der Rechtsform der Kommanditgesellschaft bzw. GmbH & Co. KG.
      3.2 Wichtig: Diese Übergangsfristen können nur juristische Personen oder Gesellschaften in Anspruch nehmen, für die die Mitteilungsfiktionen nach altem Recht galten. Mitteilungspflichtige, die bereits vor der Rechtsänderung dem Transparenzregister gegenüber Angaben zum wirtschaftlich Berechtigten hätten machen müssen, sowie nach dem 1. August 2021 neu errichtete Gesellschaften oder juristische Personen müssen unverzüglich Mitteilung machen. Bei Gesellschaften, deren Gründungsprozess zurzeit noch nicht abgeschlossen ist, wird man im Einzelfall prüfen müssen, ob auch sie von den Übergangsfristen profitieren können.
    4. Umfang der Mitteilungspflichten
      4.1 Erweitert wurde auch der Umfang der Angaben, die zu den wirtschaftlich Berechtigten erfolgen müssen. Praktisch relevant ist hier vor allem die Angabe sämtlicher Staatsangehörigkeiten der wirtschaftlich Berechtigten. Bislang genügte es, dem Transparenzregister eine Staatsangehörigkeit mitzuteilen.
      4.2 Allgemein ist zu berücksichtigen, dass sich die Mitteilungspflichten nicht in einer einmaligen Angabe zu den wirtschaftlich Berechtigten erschöpfen. Die Verpflichteten müssen diese Angaben einholen, aufbewahren und auf aktuellem Stand halten (§ 20 Abs. 1 GWG).
    5. Nichterfüllung der Mitteilungspflichten
      5.1 Wer vorsätzlich oder leichtfertig eine Pflicht im Zusammenhang mit der Mitteilung des wirtschaftlich Berechtigten an das Transparenzregister verletzt, begeht eine Ordnungswidrigkeit (§ 56 Abs. 1 Nr. 55 GWG), die mit erheblichen Bußgeldern sanktioniert werden kann.
      5.2 Zu Gunsten von Mitteilungspflichtigen, die erstmals auf Grund des Wegfalls der Mitteilungsfiktionen gegenüber dem Transparenzregister Angaben machen müssen, ist die Verhängung von Bußgeldern jedoch einmalig ausgesetzt und zwar für
      5.2.1 Gesellschaften in der Rechtsform der AG, KGaA und SE bis zum 31. März 2023,
      5.2.2 Gesellschaften bzw. juristische Personen in der Rechtsform der GmbH, Genossenschaft, Europäischen Genossenschaft und der Partnerschaftsgesellschaft bis zum 30. Juni 2023 und
      5.2.3 alle anderen Mitteilungspflichtigen bis zum 31. Dezember 2023.
    6. Hinweis: Dieses Memorandum soll einen Überblick über die Neuregelung in Kurzform geben und erhebt keinen Anspruch auf Vollständigkeit. Es dient nur zu allgemeinen Informationszwecken und stellt keine Rechtsberatung oder sonstige Beratung dar. Wenn Sie auf der Grundlage der hierin enthaltenen Informationen Handlungen vornehmen oder unterlassen möchten oder weitere Fragen haben, wenden Sie sich bitte an Ihren Ansprechpartner bei McDermott.
    Authors

    Sebastian Bonk

    Partner

    Düsseldorf

    More insights

  • Taxonomy and Transparency: EU Delays Implementation and Presents Further Plans

    Taxonomy and Transparency: EU Delays Implementation and Presents Further Plans

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Taxonomy and Transparency: EU Delays Implementation and Presents Further Plans

    July 12, 2021

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The EU Commission presented its current strategy for financing the transition to a sustainable Economy. Participants of the financial market will face more comprehensive and severe regulation compared to the rules already in place or currently being drafted. At the same time, implementation slows down: Level 2 delegated rules supplementing the SFDR are delayed for another six months.

    In depth
    Authors

    Frank Müller

    Partner

    Frankfurt

    More insights

  • FinCEN Issues First National AML/CFT Priorities and Defers Implementation of Priorities and No-Action Letter Process to Future Rulemakings

    FinCEN Issues First National AML/CFT Priorities and Defers Implementation of Priorities and No-Action Letter Process to Future Rulemakings

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    FinCEN Issues First National AML/CFT Priorities and Defers Implementation of Priorities and No-Action Letter Process to Future Rulemakings

    July 12, 2021

    Read time: 11 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On June 30, 2021, pursuant to the recently passed Anti-Money Laundering Act of 2020 (“AML Act”),[1] the U.S. Department of the Treasury’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (“FinCEN”) issued for the first time government-wide priorities for anti-money laundering and countering the financing of terrorism (“AML/CFT”) (“Priorities”). The Priorities identify and describe the most significant AML/CFT threats currently facing the United Sates. FinCEN also issued two statements, one to banks and the other to non-bank financial institutions (“NBFIs”), providing additional guidance regarding the Priorities (collectively, “Statements”)[2] and making it clear that banks and NBFIs will only be required to incorporate the Priorities into their risk-based AML/CFT programs after FinCEN issues implementing regulations.[3]

    Also on June 30, 2021, FinCEN released a report summarizing its assessment of whether to establish a process for issuing no-action letters regarding the application of the Bank Secrecy Act and its implementing regulations (“BSA”)[4] to specific conduct (“No-Action Letter Assessment”).[5] The No-Action Letter Assessment concludes that FinCEN will enact a no-action letter process, but will only do so pursuant to formal rulemaking, the timing of which will be subject to FinCEN’s resource limitations and competing priorities.

    AML/CFT Priorities and Statements

    FinCEN issued eight AML/CFT Priorities following consultation with other Treasury Offices,[6] the Attorney General, as well as relevant federal and state regulators, law enforcement and national security agencies.[7] According to the Priorities, “[t]hese threats exploit some perceived ‘vulnerability’ in the U.S. financial system that may be in law, regulation, supervision, or enforcement, or may stem from a unique attribute of a product, service, or jurisdiction.”[8] They include predicate crimes that generate illicit proceeds which actors may then launder through the financial system.

    • The Priorities note that countering corruption is a core national security interest because, among other things, “[m]isappropriation of public assets, bribery, and other forms of corruption affects individuals and entities across the world, threatens the national security of the United States and the global financial system, degrades the rule of law, perpetuates conflict, and deprives innocent civilians of fundamental human rights.”
    • FinCEN includes cybercrime in the Priorities because of the national security risks involved in cyber-enabled financial crime, ransomware attacks and the misuse of virtual assets that exploit and undermine their innovative potential. The Priorities define cybercrime broadly as any illegal activity that involves a computer, another digital device or a computer network, and they note that it includes activities involving convertible virtual currencies (“CVCs”) to purchase illicit products and services. With respect to ransomware, the Priorities provide that “[i]n some instances, ransomware campaigns have been associated with adversary governments, sanctioned entities, or jurisdictions with weak AML/CFT regimes and high AML/CFT and sanctions risks, such as Russia, North Korea, and Iran” and note that the Department of the Treasury’s Office of Foreign Assets Control “has designated numerous malicious cyber actors under its sanctions programs in response to aggressive and harmful malicious cyber activities by state actors targeting U.S. government and private sector networks.”[9] With respect to CVCs, the Priorities note that “[c]riminals use a number of techniques to obscure the source of illicit funds when conducting transactions involving CVCs, including the use of mixers and tumblers” and “CVCs have been used by some of the highest-priority threat actors,” such as North Korea, “to advance their illegal activities and nuclear weapons ambitions.”[10]
    • Terrorist Financing. The Priorities describe both foreign and domestic terrorist financing as a risk to national security. They also note that terrorist financing has evolved to include a growing number of homegrown, self-radicalized individuals who carry out low-cost attacks with support from overseas organizations, in addition to proliferating domestic racially- and ethnically-motivated violent extremists.
    • The Priorities note that fraud, such as bank, consumer, health care, securities and investment, and tax fraud, is believed to generate the largest share of illicit proceeds in the United States.[11] Increasingly, fraud schemes are internet-enabled and may launder assets through a variety of methods, including transfers through accounts of offshore legal entities, accounts controlled by cyber actors and money mules.
    • Transnational Criminal Organization Activity. Transnational criminal organizations (“TCOs”) are noted on the list of Priorities due to the crime-terror nexus and their engagement in a wide range of illicit activities, including cybercrime, drug trafficking, fraud, wildlife trafficking, human smuggling, human trafficking, intellectual property theft, weapons trafficking and corruption. The Priorities note that TCOs increasingly employ professional money laundering networks and often use their specialized expertise to launder proceeds generated by others, regardless of the predicate criminal activity.
    • Drug Trafficking Organization Activity. The Priorities explain that drug trafficking organizations (“DTOs”) have contributed to a significant public health emergency in the United States involving drugs like fentanyl and cocaine, which are brought to the United States from Mexico, Colombia and China. DTOs have developed schemes to launder proceeds of drug sales by facilitating their exchange, including to Mexico or to Chinese citizens residing in the United States, who may make use of front companies or couriers to deposit funds into the banking system. These schemes allow DTOs to repatriate proceeds to Mexico and sidestep Chinese capital flight restrictions.
    • Human Trafficking and Human Smuggling. Human traffickers and smugglers use several mechanisms to move illicit proceeds, ranging from cash smuggling by individual victims to sophisticated operations that rely on professional money laundering networks and criminal organizations. Human trafficking proceeds can derive from the housing, transportation and exploitation of victims. Human traffickers and smugglers may establish shell companies to hide their activities and may receive payments in a variety of ways, such as funnel accounts and trade-based money laundering schemes.
    • Proliferation Financing. The Priorities describe proliferation financing as the act of providing funds or financial services used for the manufacture, acquisition, possession, development, export, trans-shipment, brokering, transport, transfer, stockpiling or use of nuclear, chemical or biological weapons, in contravention of national laws or international obligations. Global correspondent banking is a principal vulnerability and driver of proliferation financing risk within the United States due to its central role in processing U.S. dollar transactions, which comprise a substantial proportion of cross-border trade.

    In describing each of these eight Priorities, FinCEN cites to numerous guidance and advisory releases that it has previously issued, some in consultation with other government entities. As required by the AML Act, FinCEN will update the Priorities at least once every four years to account for new and emerging threats to the U.S. financial system and national security.[12]

    The Statements issued by FinCEN concurrently with the Priorities clarify that publication of the Priorities does not create an immediate change in the BSA requirements or regulatory expectations for banks or NBFIs. Such financial institutions will not be required to incorporate the Priorities into their risk-based AML/CFT programs until the effective date of the final regulations. The Statements further provide, however, that banks and NBFIs “may wish to start considering how they will incorporate the AML/CFT Priorities into their risk-based AML programs, such as by assessing the potential risks associated with the products and services they offer, the customers they serve, and the geographic areas in which they operate.”[13] FinCEN has acknowledged that not every Priority will be relevant to every covered financial institution.

    The bank-specific Statement also provides that the federal banking agencies, state bank and credit union regulators, and FinCEN “recognize the need to provide revised regulations and timely guidance to assist banks in complying with the BSA” and that they are committed to working together “to develop any necessary corresponding guidance and examination procedures for [bank] examiners.” The NBFI-specific Statement makes similar points and provides that FinCEN is committed to working with the staff of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Commodity Futures Trading Commission, Internal Revenue Services and state financial regulators to develop and publish NBFI-specific guidance and examination procedures.

    No-Action Letter Assessment

    According to the No-Action Letter Assessment, FinCEN will institute a no-action letter process in addition to its existing forms of regulatory guidance and relief, such as administrative rulings and exceptive or exemptive relief.[14] However, that no-action letter process will only be implemented after FinCEN conducts a formal rulemaking. The No-Action Letter Assessment describes a no-action letter as an acknowledgement by FinCEN that FinCEN will not take enforcement action against the requesting party for engaging in the specific activities as described in the request. FinCEN cautions, however, that issuing a no-action letter will require additional resources as “[a]ny request for no-action relief would need to be carefully reviewed in consultation with other regulators.”[15]

    The No-Action Letter Assessment notes that FinCEN considered a cross-regulator no-action letter process, in which FinCEN could issue a no-action letter that would apply to FinCEN as well as other regulators, but ultimately determined, after consultation with the Attorney General, the federal functional regulators, state bank supervisors, state credit union supervisors, and other federal agencies (the “Consulting Agencies”), that it presented significant hurdles to implementation because “while FinCEN is the administrator of the BSA, it does not have authority to administer or enforce all AML and CFT laws that are administered or enforced by other regulators, departments, and agencies” and “[i]f FinCEN were to issue a no-action letter, it would not have the ability to prevent another agency from bringing an enforcement action under that agency’s own authority.” The No-Action Letter Assessment nonetheless makes clear that coordination among FinCEN and the Consulting Agencies may be part of any future no-action letter process. It provides that the “the degree of consultation with other regulators would vary on a case-by-case basis and, in some instances, a coordinated response among relevant agencies may be appropriate” depending on the nature of the request, the type of requesting entity, and the activity at issue. The No-Action Letter Assessment further states that “[c]onsultation carries the substantial benefit of helping to ensure that regulated persons are not subject to conflicting requirements, and that regulators are not working at cross purposes.”

    Authored by Betty Santangelo, Donald J. Mosher, Kara A. Kuchar and Melissa G.R. Goldstein.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] “Passage of Anti-Money Laundering Act of 2020 Includes Comprehensive BSA/AML Reform Measures,” SRZ Alert (Jan 7, 2021), available here.

    [2] “Anti-Money Laundering and Countering the Financing of Terrorism National Priorities,” FinCEN (June 30, 2021), available here (“Priorities Statement”); “Statement on the Issuance of the Anti-Money Laundering/Countering the Financing of Terrorism (AML/CFT) National Priorities,” FinCEN (June 30, 2021), available here (“NBFI Statement”); “Interagency Statement on the Issuance of the Anti-Money-Laundering/Countering the Financing of Terrorism National Priorities,” FinCEN (June 30, 2021), available here (“Bank Statement”).

    [3] On Sept. 17, 2020, prior to the passage of the AML Act, FinCEN issued an advanced notice of proposed rulemaking soliciting comment on enhancing the effectiveness of AML programs, which included significant discussion on how financial institutions should incorporate strategic and national AML priorities into their risk-assessment process and overall BSA/AML programs. See FinCEN, ANPRM, Anti-Money Laundering Program Effectiveness, 85 Fed. Reg. 58023 (Sept. 17, 2020), available here.

    [4] 31 U.S.C. §§ 5311-5330; 31 C.F.R. Chapter X.

    [5] “A Report to Congress Assessment of No-Action Letters in Accordance with Section 6305 of the Anti-Money Laundering Act of 2020,” FinCEN (June 28, 2021), available here (“No-Action Letter Assessment”); See also “FinCEN Completes Assessment on the Use of No-Action Letters,” FinCEN Press Release (June 30, 2021), available here. FinCEN’s issuance of the No-Action Letter Assessment was required pursuant to Section 6305 of the AML Act of 2020, and it incorporated feedback received by FinCEN from the Attorney General, the federal functional regulators, state bank supervisors, state credit union supervisors, and other federal agencies.

    [6] The Treasury Offices consulted were the Office of Terrorist Financing and Financial Crimes, the Office of Foreign Assets Control and the Office of Intelligence and Analysis.

    [7] The AML/CFT Priorities were issued pursuant to Section 6101(b)(2)(C) of the AML Act (31 U.S.C. § 5318(h)(4)(A)).

    [8] Priorities Statement at 2.

    [9] Priorities Statement at 5.

    [10] Id.

    [11] U.S. Department of the Treasury, National Money Laundering Risk Assessment, at 2 (Dec. 20, 2018), available here.

    [12] 31 U.S.C. § 5318(h)(4)(B) (as amended by AML Act § 6101(b)(2)(C)).

    [13] NBFI Statement at 2; Bank Statement at 2.

    [14] Administrative rulings are written rulings that have precedential value, could apply to a given situation and “may be relied upon by others similarly situated.” Report at 9; 31 C.F.R. §§ 1010.710-1010.717. Exceptive or exemptive relief applies to situations in which FinCEN, as delegated by the Secretary of Treasury, grants an exception or exemption to “particular persons or to classes of persons, and may apply to particular transactions or classes of transactions.” No-Action Letter Assessment at 9; 31 C.F.R. § 1010.970.

    [15] No-Action Letter Assessment at 14.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. ©2021 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Betty Santangelo

    Counsel

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Donald J. Mosher

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    Melissa G.R. Goldstein

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • State Privacy Patchwork Spreads with Signing of Colorado Privacy Act

    State Privacy Patchwork Spreads with Signing of Colorado Privacy Act

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    State Privacy Patchwork Spreads with Signing of Colorado Privacy Act

    July 9, 2021

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On July 7, 2021, Colorado Governor Jared Polis signed the Colorado Privacy Act (CPA) into law, the latest in the recent wave of state privacy legislation but unlikely to be the last. The CPA will take effect July 1, 2023, six months after Virginia’s Consumer Data Protection Act (CDPA) and the California Privacy Rights Act (CPRA) become effective. Organizations subject to the new Colorado law will have to prepare for new consumer rights and restrictions with respect to Colorado consumers’ personal data. What follows are key takeaways from the CPA and the implications for businesses grappling with the changing privacy landscape in the US.

    In depth

    Applicability and Exemptions

    Not all organizations will be covered by the new CPA. To be subject to the law, an organization must do business in Colorado and meet one of the following requirements:

    • The organization processes data on 100,000 or more Colorado consumers annually.
    • The organization processes data on 25,000 or more Colorado consumers annually and “sells” any personal data.

    This applicability threshold sets a relatively high bar, and many companies that are subject to the California Consumer Privacy Act of 2018 (CCPA)/CPRA may not meet these thresholds in Colorado.

    There are a number of exemptions and limitations built into the Colorado law. Personal data regulated under existing federal privacy regimes, such as the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA), will be exempt from the CPA, as will personal data about employees and others “acting in a commercial or employment context.” Further, the CPA’s substantive requirements will not limit organizations’ ability to process data for legal compliance, fraud prevention, security, contract fulfillment or any “internal operations that are reasonably aligned with the expectations of the consumer based on the consumer’s existing relationship” with the organization.

    Substantive Rights Largely Mirror Other State Privacy Laws

    The CPA establishes a number of substantive rights that Colorado consumers will have with respect to their personal data. In general, these rights mirror those in the existing laws in California and Virginia, including the following:

    • Notice. Covered organizations will be required to disclose data collection and processing details in their public-facing privacy policies. In addition, a new “duty of purpose specification” requires that companies identify the “express purposes for which personal data are collected and processed.” Whether existing privacy policies are sufficiently “express” for these purposes will be an important consideration for organizations under the CPA and one that will likely lead to both confusion and potential regulation in the future.
    • Access, Correction and Deletion. Consumers will have the right to access, correct and delete their personal data. For the right to access, businesses will be required to provide data in a portable format where feasible.
    • Opt Out. Consumers have the ability to opt out of data “sales,” targeted advertising and high-risk automated “profiling.”
    • Opt In. As with the CDPA, businesses must seek opt-in consent before collecting or processing “sensitive personal data,” which includes data revealing an individual’s race, ethnicity, religious beliefs, health conditions, genetic or biometric information, sex life or sexual orientation and citizenship status. Notably, geolocation information is not “sensitive” for these purposes, unlike the CDPA.

    In addition, for any of the activities that give rise to opt-out or opt-in rights, companies will be required to conduct and document “data protection assessments.” These assessments align with a similar requirement under the CDPA, and they must be made available to the Colorado Attorney General upon request.

    “Secondary Uses” Restricted

    One area where the CPA goes beyond the CCPA/CPRA and the CDPA is with the introduction of a new “duty to avoid secondary use.” This duty prohibits covered organizations from using data for purposes that “are not reasonably necessary or compatible with the specified purposes for which the personal data are processed.” Businesses can override this prohibition by obtaining the consumer’s consent for new processing activities.

    Colorado’s prohibition on secondary uses—in conjunction with its requirements that businesses expressly identify the purpose of data collection—reflects a longstanding Federal Trade Commission (FTC) position that post-collection data practices must be consistent with pre-collection disclosures. However, due to the emphasis on “specified purposes” and the express “consent” requirement for new uses, the CPA arguably goes beyond FTC guidance by imposing a more explicit prohibition on such uses. Companies will need to scrutinize their privacy notices to ensure that any purposes are adequately specified to avoid running afoul of this new statutory requirement under the CPA.

    Controller/Processor Contracting

    Like other states and the European Union’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), the CPA distinguishes between data “controllers” and “processors,” requiring mandatory contract terms between these entities. However, the new CPA adds some requirements not otherwise contained in existing US law or the GDPR. In particular, controllers and processors are expressly prohibited from introducing contract terms that “relieve a controller or a processor from the liabilities imposed on them by virtue of its role in the processing relationship.” This language could potentially undermine any indemnification terms the parties may have negotiated in their existing agreements. Covered organizations should examine their current vendor and customer contract templates to re-evaluate their exposure and to ensure that the contract complies with the CPA’s contracting requirements.

    Next Steps for Business

    With the array of new privacy laws set to take effect in 2023, in-house counsel and privacy professionals have their work cut out for them in aligning their businesses with the expanding patchwork of state laws. As an initial step, organizations should evaluate whether they meet the applicability requirements for the CPA. As mentioned, many businesses will not trigger the high bar for applicability of these laws. If the CPA is applicable, an important second step will be evaluating exposure to the new “sensitive data” requirements by updating or creating data maps that include the sensitive data categories.

    Finally, companies should be careful not to lose sight of the bigger picture. While state legislative momentum may be slowing for the remainder of 2021, activity is expected to pick back up when many state legislatures reconvene in the beginning of 2022. As businesses take steps to understand and comply with the CPA and other laws, they should do so with future developments in mind, focusing on creating dynamic and “agile” privacy programs that can react quickly and adapt to the changing landscape.

    Authors

    Amy C. Pimentel

    Partner

    Boston

    David P. Saunders

    Partner

    Chicago

    More insights

  • Recent Developments in Tax Law: Act on the Modernization of the Corporate Income Tax Act

    ARTICLE

    Recent Developments in Tax Law: Act on the Modernization of the Corporate Income Tax Act

    July 2021

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Dr. Gero Burwitz authored the article “Recent Developments in Tax Law: Act on the Modernization of the Corporate Income Tax Act”, published in Neue Zeitschrift für Gesellschaftsrecht (NZG), p. 869-872 in July 2021.

    In depth
    Authors

    Dr. Gero Burwitz

    Partner

    Munich

    More insights

  • Temporary Relief for Debt Collectors: 11th Circuit Withholds Hunstein Mandate

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Temporary Relief for Debt Collectors: 11th Circuit Withholds Hunstein Mandate

    July 7, 2021

    Read time: 10 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On June 14, 2021, the US Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit issued an order withholding issuance of the mandate for its April 21, 2021, holding in Hunstein v. Preferred Collection and Management Services, Inc. In Hunstein, the 11th Circuit held that a debt collector faces potential liability under the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) for transmitting a consumer’s personal information to any third party, including a mailing service used by the debt collector to send dunning letters when attempting to collect on a debt. The withholding of the mandate provides at least some temporary relief for debt collectors, which routinely outsource mailing and other activities as part of their debt collection services to merchants and other creditors and have faced an onslaught of FDCPA class action lawsuits based on the Hunstein rationale related to their use of commercial mail services and other outsourced service providers since the April decision. The full 11th Circuit is expected to reconsider the Hunstein decision, as the defendant debt collector requested on May 25, 2021.

    Yet the ultimate impact of Hunstein is unpredictable. New cases and events are happening almost daily, and the uncertainty may last for months or years. The time period in which Hunstein may be finally resolved, and whether Hunstein will be adopted or rejected by the full 11th Circuit or in other circuits, is not clear. Companies are adopting a variety of strategies based on this uncertainty, as outlined in this On the Subject.

    In depth

    On June 14, 2021, the US Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit issued an order withholding issuance of the mandate for its April 21, 2021, holding in Hunstein v. Preferred Collection and Management Services, Inc., that a debt collector faces potential liability under the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) for transmitting a consumer’s personal information to any third party, including the debt collector’s subcontractors, in connection with collection of a debt unless expressly permitted by the FDCPA. The withholding of the mandate may provide at least temporary relief for debt collectors, which routinely outsource mailing and other activities as part of their debt collection services to merchants and other creditors and have faced almost 300 FDCPA individual and class action lawsuits related to their use of outsourced service providers since the April decision.

    Consistent with the internal operating procedures of the 11th Circuit, the order delays the return of jurisdiction over the case to the district court but does not affect the binding nature of the decision on courts in the 11th Circuit. However, the full 11th Circuit is expected to consider the Hunstein decision en banc as requested by Preferred Collections & Management Services, Inc., the defendant debt collector, on May 25, 2021.

    Further briefs were filed with the 11th Circuit recently based on a footnote in the new Supreme Court of the United States case TransUnion LLC v. Ramirez, stating that giving customer information to a mail vendor is not “dissemination” and therefore is not an injury in fact. Other amicus briefs assert commercial free speech grounds and a variety of other challenges.

    Yet the ultimate impact of Hunstein is unpredictable. New cases and events are happening almost daily, and the uncertainty may last for months or years. The time period in which Hunstein may be finally resolved, and whether Hunstein will be adopted or rejected by the full 11th Circuit or in other circuits, is not clear. Companies are adopting a variety of strategies based on this uncertainty.

    This On the Subject discusses the relevant provision of the FDCPA, the district court and 11th Circuit decisions in Hunstein, and implications and suggested next steps for debt collectors and other revenue cycle management companies. In particular, revenue cycle management companies subject to the FDCPA that send dunning letters and other communications through third-party service providers should consider the feasibility of insourcing these functions or other contingency plans, particularly those revenue cycle management companies located or conducting activities in the 11th Circuit, which includes Alabama, Florida and Georgia.

    FDCPA Disclosure Prohibition

    The FDCPA regulates the debt collection practices of persons that meet its definition of a “debt collector.” The FDCPA broadly defines “debt collector” to mean any person who uses any instrumentality of interstate commerce or the mails in any business the principal purpose of which is the collection of any debts, or who regularly collects or attempts to collect, directly or indirectly, debts owed or due or asserted to be owed or due another. The definition includes exceptions for entities that collect debts owed to themselves rather than a third party. Thus, the definition may include, for example, revenue cycle management companies that send account statements for debts owed by patients to healthcare providers and debts owed by other consumers to merchants that do not require payment in full at the time that a good or service is delivered.

    With limited exceptions, section 1692c(b) of the FDCPA broadly prohibits debt collectors from communicating a consumer’s personal information, such as an individual’s status as a debtor and the amount of the debt, with anyone other than the consumer in connection with the collection of a debt. The FDCPA defines “communication” broadly to mean the conveying of information regarding a debt directly or indirectly to any person through any medium. The definition does not expressly distinguish between the conveyance of information to a debt collector’s service providers and other persons. Further, the FDCPA’s communication prohibition does not include an express exception for disclosures to service providers, unlike the disclosure pathways for service providers under the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (GLBA), service providers under California Consumer Privacy Act, business associates under the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA), or processors under the European Union’s General Data Protection Regulation.

    In practice, however, debt collectors, like other businesses, routinely outsource functions to mail vendors or other third-party service providers, and often need to communicate specific information regarding debtors to such service providers to receive the benefit of the outsourced services.

    Hunstein District Court Decision

    The plaintiff in Hunstein incurred a debt to a hospital arising out of his son’s medical treatment. The hospital assigned the debt to Preferred Collections, which in turn hired a third-party mail vendor to send letters and handle the collection. The plaintiff argued that the debt collector violated the FDCPA’s communication prohibition when it electronically transmitted the plaintiff’s name, outstanding balance and information regarding the source of debt to the mail vendor. The district court dismissed Hunstein’s action for failure to state a claim after concluding that Preferred Collections’ conveyance of information to the mail vendor did not qualify as a communication made “in connection with the collection of any debt.”

    Hunstein Court of Appeals Decision

    The 11th Circuit reversed the district court’s decision dismissing Hunstein’s complaint on April 21, 2021. In reversing the district court, the appellate court looked no further than the plain meaning of the phrase “in connection with the collection of any debt” and held that the defendant’s transmittal of specific information to the mail vendor was sufficiently related to its debt collection activity and therefore constituted a communication in connection with the collection of a debt for purposes of the FDCPA’s communication prohibition. While the court recognized that its ruling would upset the status quo in the debt collection industry and was unlikely to materially enhance consumer privacy protections, it nevertheless determined that its role was to interpret the law as written, regardless of whether the resulting implications were sensible or desirable.

    On May 25, 2021, Preferred Collections requested that the full court reconsider its decision en banc. On June 14, 2021, the court issued the order withholding issuance of a mandate for its April 21, 2021, decision. We are monitoring docket activity in the 11th Circuit for a decision regarding whether the court will reconsider its ruling en banc.

    NEXT STEPS

    This decision by the 11th Circuit appears to require a significant change in existing operations of revenue cycle management companies that meet the definition of a debt collector under the FDCPA. While the court of appeals may rehear the case en banc, it is not clear that a different reading of the FDCPA will result. Thousands of debt collection communications will be sent to debtors in the interim, which, depending on the en banc case outcome, will arguably allow the one-year statute of limitations under the FDCPA to continue to run.

    For now, debt collectors face the risk of FDCPA class action lawsuits if they outsource functions to third-party service providers and communicate debtors’ personal information as part of the outsourcing. Accordingly, some debt collectors subject to the FDCPA are considering bringing such functions (or at least some of them) back in-house for collection activities, particularly if they are located or conduct activities in the 11th Circuit, which includes Alabama, Florida and Georgia. Key to any plan is identifying each of the third-party relationships of the debt collector, the technologies and information transmitted to each third party, and the creditor agreements that impact or protect such transmissions.

    Debt collectors may wish to consider the following options:

    1. Do nothing different and wait for the final outcome of Hunstein.
    2. Bring third-party vendors’ services in-house, where feasible and not overly costly or disruptive.
    3. Adopt a multi-pronged approach, which can be adjusted over time as events unfold, that includes the following potential steps:
      • Identify relevant data flows, pathways, and other transmission features or technologies from the debt collector to any third parties, to better develop the factual analysis and defense arguments. Debt collectors should understand which transmissions to third-party service providers are automated communications, with no human “eyes on” viewing or processing of debtor personal information. Debt collectors may be able to successfully assert a defense that there is no “invasion of privacy” (as referenced by the 11th Circuit in the Hunstein opinion) because no person at the service provider actually views the debtor’s personal information.
      • Suspend, adjust or terminate relationships between the debt collector and service providers, at least temporarily. This step might involve leasing or licensing third-party equipment, processes and/or employees of the service provider, if feasible. If relevant third-party activities are curtailed, this may also help limit the one-year statute of limitations under FDCPA.
      • Identify and compile existing individual consent language in customer/client agreements and notices. The consent language may support the defense of debtor consent, which is an exception to the FDCPA’s communication prohibition. To be effective, such consent of the debtor must be communicated directly to the debt collection agency.
      • Compile relevant agreements between the debt collector and its customers to determine how customer agreements allow transmission to the debt collector and the legal justifications for same. The agreements, including HIPAA Business Associate Agreements for debt collectors serving HIPAA covered entities, may support arguments that other laws, such as HIPAA or GLBA, allow transmission of the identical personal information to service providers, including debt collectors, as long as certain precautions are in place. The agreement review should also identity privacy and security precautions regarding data transmission to third parties.

    We will continue monitoring developments in the 11th Circuit and any federal legislation proposing amendments to the FDCPA to address debt collectors’ use of service providers.

    If you have questions about the decision or its implications for your debt collection practices, please contact any of the authors or your regular McDermott lawyer.

    Authors

    Daniel F. Gottlieb

    Partner

    Chicago

    Sam Siegfried

    Partner

    Chicago

    Mark E. Schreiber

    Counsel

    Boston

    More insights