Content Type: Article

  • Unfair Play: Unjust Enrichment for Copying and Using Non-Trade-Secret Spreadsheet

    Unfair Play: Unjust Enrichment for Copying and Using Non-Trade-Secret Spreadsheet

    ARTICLE

    Unfair Play: Unjust Enrichment for Copying and Using Non-Trade-Secret Spreadsheet

    Nov 9, 2023

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit reversed a district court’s dismissal of an unjust enrichment claim, finding that unjust enrichment claims do not necessarily rise or fall with trade secret misappropriation claims and may be advanced where there is a dispute as to whether a contract’s scope covers the parties’ disagreement. Pauwels v. Deloitte LLP, Case No. 22-21 (2d Cir. Oct. 6, 2023) (Sacks, Robinson, JJ.) (Jacobs, J., dissenting in part).

    Andre Pauwels is a contractor who was retained without written agreement by The Bank of New York Mellon and its parent company (collectively, BNYM) to work on investment valuation. In 2014, while working for BNYM, Pauwels developed the “Pauwels Model” for valuation, which was implemented in Excel spreadsheets. Pauwels typically would send BNYM only the outputs from the Pauwels Model. According to Pauwels, the Pauwels Model and spreadsheets were confidential and proprietary, although the spreadsheets were not password-protected, encrypted or labeled confidential, and Pauwels sometimes shared the spreadsheets with BNYM.

    In 2016, BNYM engaged Deloitte and related entities (collectively, Deloitte) to take over Pauwels’s duties. Pauwels never authorized BNYM to share the Pauwels Model spreadsheets with Deloitte, and BNYM assured Pauwels that Deloitte was not using those spreadsheets. In April 2018, Pauwels discovered that BNYM had given Deloitte the spreadsheets and that Deloitte had copied the Pauwels Model. BNYM terminated its relationship with Pauwels in May 2018.

    In March 2019, Pauwels sued BNYM and Deloitte for trade secret misappropriation, unfair competition and unjust enrichment and further alleged that BNYM committed fraud and negligent misrepresentation. After BNYM and Deloitte moved to dismiss, the district court granted the motion in relevant part. The district court dismissed the unjust enrichment claim as duplicative of the trade secret misappropriation claim, citing the 2009 Second Circuit case Faiveley Transp. Malmo v. Wabtec for the proposition that “where an unfair competition claim, and a misappropriation claim arise from the same factual predicate . . . the two claims generally rise or fall together.” The district court dismissed the remainder of the claims for failure to plausibly allege the existence of trade secrets, that BNYM and Deloitte had “misappropriated” anything, or that Pauwels suffered damages. Pauwels appealed.

    The Second Circuit reversed the dismissal of Pauwels’s unjust enrichment claim as to BNYM. Initially, the Court found that Pauwels’s unjust enrichment claim was not duplicative of his trade secret misappropriation claim, distinguishing Faiveley Transp. and explaining that misappropriation is not an element of unjust enrichment claims. The Court rejected BNYM’s argument that Pauwels’s unjust enrichment claim was precluded by the contract between the parties. The Court found that Pauwels could maintain his claim because there was “a bona fide dispute . . . whether the scope of an existing contract covers the disagreement between the parties.” According to Pauwels, he was engaged and paid for his advice and expertise only, meaning that BNYM had no right to benefit from the Pauwels Model spreadsheets by sharing them with Deloitte. According to BNYM, Pauwels was engaged and paid to develop and deliver the Pauwels Model spreadsheets.

    The Second Circuit also affirmed the district court’s dismissal of the unjust enrichment claim against Deloitte on alternative grounds, finding that a “plaintiff cannot succeed on an unjust enrichment claim unless it has a sufficiently close relationship with the other party.” Pauwels failed to allege facts establishing a sufficient relationship with Deloitte and mere knowledge that Pauwels created the spreadsheets was insufficient.

    In dissent, Judge Jacobs disagreed with the majority’s unjust enrichment analysis, contending that any contract dispute could be described as a dispute over whether the contract’s scope covered the parties’ disagreement. According to Judge Jacobs, if BNYM received more than the contract allowed, Pauwels should have asserted a breach of contract claim rather than unjust enrichment.

    Authors

    Maxwell C. Preston

    Staff Attorney

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights
    Endnotes

  • No Fifth Chances: Ignoring Court’s Warning Leads to Terminal Sanctions

    No Fifth Chances: Ignoring Court’s Warning Leads to Terminal Sanctions

    ARTICLE

    No Fifth Chances: Ignoring Court’s Warning Leads to Terminal Sanctions

    Nov 9, 2023

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    In an appeal from litigation-ending sanctions, the US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit held that misconduct in the face of judicial warnings supports the use of litigation-ending sanctions and that evidence a party forgot about does not count as “new” evidence when remembered for the purpose of a motion for reconsideration. Calsep A/S v. Ashish Dabral, Case No. 22-20440 (5th Cir. Oct. 11, 2023) (Clement, Elrod, Willett, JJ.)

    Insights Reservoir Consulting (IRC), a company owned by Ashish Dabral, was hired to make a computer program that assesses oil-well efficiency. To develop that software, Dabral turned to his college friend who worked at Calsep A/S, a software company that designs and sells oil-well assessment software. Dabral hired his friend away from Calsep, and IRC subsequently developed and sold its own oil-well efficiency software.

    Surprised at the sudden appearance of a competitor, Calsep investigated and found that IRC had recently hired one of its former employees. Calsep conducted an internal audit and found that its former employee had absconded with trade secrets just before leaving. Calsep sued Dabral and IRC.

    In discovery, Calsep requested the complete development history of IRC’s new software. Dabral resisted such disclosure as “overbroad,” but the district court ordered production of the requested materials. Shortly thereafter, the district court further entered an order specifically enjoining the parties from the “destr[uction] of any potentially relevant evidence, including electronically stored information.”

    In response to the discovery request, Dabral only produced portions of the development history, and its produced history included sections that were either incomplete or manipulated. In response, Calsep filed another motion to compel. The district court ordered Dabral to “come clean” and comply “voluntarily” before the court resorted to sanctions. Dabral represented that the entire history had been produced and that it was missing only portions deleted before the lawsuit.

    The district court held an evidentiary hearing, and Dabral admitted that many of the deletions actually occurred during the lawsuit. The district court levied terminal sanctions based on Dabral’s violation of four separate court orders and serial discovery misconduct. Seven months later, Dabral filed a motion for reconsideration based on new information he found in his storage unit in India. The district court denied the motion. Dabral appealed both the sanctions ruling and the denial of the motion for reconsideration.

    The Fifth Circuit first analyzed the sanctions. It limited its analysis to sanctions under Rule 37, which (in the Fifth Circuit) requires four specific findings before terminal sanctions can be levied:

    1. The violation was willful or bad faith.
    2. The client was responsible.
    3. The violation caused substantial prejudice.
    4. A lesser sanction would not have the desired deterrent effect.

    The Fifth Circuit held that Dabral’s pattern of conduct supported a finding of bad faith. Dabral admittedly deleted evidence, delayed discovery and ignored several court orders. And when the district court gave him a last chance to “come clean,” he instead deleted more data and made a false representation.

    The Fifth Circuit also held that Dabral’s conduct resulted in prejudice. The district court found—based on expert testimony—that Dabral’s deletions made it impossible to analyze IRC’s software as required to satisfy Calsep’s evidentiary burden. The Court noted that Dabral’s constant misleading productions and dilatory conduct itself was substantial prejudice.

    The Fifth Circuit then considered whether lesser sanctions would have had the desired effect. Because Dabral was given multiple opportunities to address the discovery issues and still did not comply with the district court’s orders despite an explicit admonition to do so, the Fifth Circuit agreed that the district court did not err by concluding that lesser sanctions would not have worked. As the Fifth Circuit noted, the district court need not consider specific lesser sanctions when “it’s plain that a lesser sanction wouldn’t have done the trick.” That is “especially true” when a party fails to comply with explicit warnings. In fact, as the Court explained, warnings and second chances are themselves a lenient sanction, which supports a subsequent terminal sanction.

    Finally, the Fifth Circuit affirmed the district court’s denial of Dabral’s motion for reconsideration. Dabral based his motion on the allegation that seven months after entry of the sanctions order he found many of the files that had previously been reported as deleted in a storage unit in India. The Court explained that such evidence is not “new”—the data was under Dabral’s control the entire time. Newly produced is different from newly discovered. The Court also noted that the “new” evidence did not include all the deleted data and thus would not have changed the outcome of the sanctions even if the evidence was considered new.

    Authors
    More insights
    Endnotes

  • Protected: Hospitals and Health Systems Summit 2023: Session Recordings

    Protected: Hospitals and Health Systems Summit 2023: Session Recordings

    This content is password-protected. To view it, please enter the password below.

  • Employers Be Forewarned and Forearmed: Recent IRS Announcements Require Action on ERTC Claims

    Employers Be Forewarned and Forearmed: Recent IRS Announcements Require Action on ERTC Claims

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Employers Be Forewarned and Forearmed: Recent IRS Announcements Require Action on ERTC Claims

    November 8, 2023

    Read time: 6 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Promoters and tax advisors have extensively marketed the Employee Retention Tax Credit (ERTC) as a way for employers to reclaim Federal Insurance Contributions Act (FICA) payroll taxes paid during the first two years of the COVID-19 pandemic. The rules governing ERTC claims are complex and nuanced, resulting in increased scrutiny by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). Asserting that many employers have improperly claimed these heavily marketed ERTC refunds, the IRS released two announcements on September 14, 2023, and October 19, 2023, that address ERTC claims. In conjunction with these announcements, the IRS has already named fraudulent ERTC claims as number one on its “Dirty Dozen” tax scams list for 2023.

    Specifically, the IRS will now target erroneous ERTC claims with penalties and interest. If a case is deemed fraudulent, the IRS will investigate and may impose civil and criminal penalties. The IRS has also suspended ERTC refund claims and provided a new withdrawal process for potentially fraudulent claims.

    Following these announcements, employers should consult their legal and tax advisors to ensure they understand how to respond to previously filed ERTC claims that the IRS may deem aggressive or fraudulent.  Employers also should consider filing protective refund claims to preserve their employment and income tax positions.

    In depth

    BACKGROUND

    US Congress enacted the ERTC to help employers retain employees who might otherwise have been terminated or furloughed due to the COVID-19 pandemic. To encourage ongoing employment and reduce expensive claims for extended unemployment, an “eligible employer” that paid “qualified wages” to its employees could potentially claim $26,000 of refundable tax credits per employee ($5,000 per employee for 2020 and $21,000 per employee for 2021).

    Many promoters and tax advisors marketed their unique ability to file and recover tax credits for employers, often imposing success fees of 20% or more of the refund amounts received by the employer. Although tens of thousands of valid ERTC claims have been filed, the IRS is now targeting thousands of other ERTC claims that may be considered aggressive, erroneous and even fraudulent.

    A WARNING FROM THE IRS

    Even though the IRS fully concedes that the ERTC is a legitimate refundable tax credit, it is aggressively targeting ineligible employers who have been encouraged to file refund claims to recoup their FICA taxes. To assess promoters who publicize ERTC refunds, the IRS identified certain red flags, such as any of the following.

    • Statements that ERTC eligibility can be determined immediately and without any additional knowledge of the employer’s specific situation;
    • Substantial up-front fees to claim the ERTC;
    • Contingency fees based on a percentage of the refund amount of the ERTC claimed; or
    • Preparers refusing to sign the ERTC return.

    Even if these red flags are not present and an employer believes its ERTC claims are bona fide, an employer can be forced to repay an erroneous ERTC credit and can face significant corresponding tax penalties and interest. Employers also may be unable to recoup the success fees paid to promoters and corrections of an employer’s tax return could fall outside the statute of limitations period to reverse the ERTC wage deduction disallowance. Furthermore, the IRS warns that the most aggressive ERTC claims may lead to criminal investigations and notes that some individuals have already been tried in federal court and sentenced to prison terms averaging 21 months.

    AN OPPORTUNITY TO WITHDRAW

    The new IRS guidance outlines a process that allows employers to withdraw pending ERTC refund claims to avoid future ERTC repayment and corresponding tax penalties and interest. The procedures for requesting a withdrawal can vary, so employers should consult with their legal and tax advisors regarding the exact requirements based on the employer’s specific situation.

    OBSERVATIONS AND POTENTIAL NEXT STEPS

    Although many ERTC claims may be aggressive and even fraudulent, the IRS’s recent announcements arguably fail to consider that the rules governing eligibility and calculation of the ERTC are subjective and complex. In the absence of clear and concise IRS guidance, many employers (and their advisors) are left to interpret the statutory text in a way that is potentially far more expansive than Congress intended.

    To combat increasingly aggressive promotion and marketing of the ERTC, the IRS seeks to swing the pendulum in the opposite direction. Many valid ERTC claims soon will be caught up in IRS challenges. The IRS generally has two years to challenge and seek recovery for an erroneous ERTC refund. Given the size of many of these claims, we anticipate both significant ERTC refund challenges by the IRS and significant ERTC litigation with the IRS.

    To respond to the new IRS guidance, employers should consider the following.

    • Consult with trusted legal and tax advisors to review ERTC claims and confirm eligibility;
    • To avoid penalties and interest, consider amending current ERTC refund claims using regular tax refund procedures or withdrawing the ERTC claims using the new IRS procedure;
    • To prevent double dipping for the same expense, ensure deduction disallowances associated with the ERTC have been properly applied to federal income tax returns;
    • Consider suspending success fee payments or placing success funds in escrow until the two-year statute of limitations period on erroneous refunds has expired;
    • Consider refiling any amended or withdrawn claims as “protective” ERTC employment tax refund claims, which can also be done for employers who were considering ERTC claims but decided against filing; or
    • File “protective” federal income tax refund claims to address the deduction disallowance on a potential IRS challenge to the ERTC claims.

    The last two considerations may seem counterintuitive but are the most important steps an employer can take to respond to the recent IRS announcements and potential audits. Each protective refund claim serves a different purpose. An employment tax protective claim recognizes that some claims deemed aggressive by the IRS might be upheld in federal court. The protective claim also may allow an employer to best leverage its tax position by (i) avoiding penalties and interest, (ii) preserving its ERTC claims and (iii) awaiting the outcome of legal challenges to the IRS’s ERTC positions. Even if a protective employment tax return is not filed, an employer should file a protective income refund tax claim in almost all ERTC situations to avoid paying excess federal income taxes with a disallowed or repaid ERTC.

    CONCLUSION

    Employers who have not yet filed ERTC refund claims should consult their legal and tax advisors to understand the complex eligibility rules and potential tax challenges. Based on this advice, employers may need to amend or withdraw their ERTC claims or repay ERTC refunds. Employers also should immediately seek advice on filing protective refund claims to preserve their employment and income tax positions for any ERTC claims.

    Authors

    Jennifer D. Hill

    Associate

    Atlanta

    More insights

  • CMS Finalizes Remedy for 340B-Acquired Drugs Purchased in CYs 2018–2022

    CMS Finalizes Remedy for 340B-Acquired Drugs Purchased in CYs 2018–2022

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    CMS Finalizes Remedy for 340B-Acquired Drugs Purchased in CYs 2018–2022

    November 7, 2023

    Read time: 9 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On November 2, 2023, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) issued the final payment rule establishing the remedy to the payment cuts to 340B drugs under the Medicare Outpatient Prospective Payment System (OPPS). The payment cuts were in place from 2018 to 2022, but last year, the Supreme Court of the United States found that the Social Security Act’s Medicare payment provisions did not allow CMS to implement the cuts.

    The new rule largely mirrors the proposed rule published on July 11, 2023. Notably, it does not remove the “budget neutrality” payment adjustments to offset lump sum payments that will be made to certain 340B hospitals, nor does it provide instructions to Medicare Advantage plans on how to implement a payment remedy.

    In depth

    Background

    In 2018, CMS reduced Medicare payments to most hospitals paid under the OPPS for certain separately payable drugs or biologicals acquired through the 340B Program, from the average sales price (ASP) plus 6% to the ASP minus 22.5%. The policy was in effect from January 1, 2018, through September 27, 2022, and affected 1,686 340B covered entity hospitals.

    To comply with the budget neutrality requirements of the Social Security Act, CMS increased the payment rates for non-drug items and services to all hospitals paid under the OPPS by 3.19%. The redistribution led to increased payments from Medicare on most non-drug items and services to hospitals paid under OPPS.

    In June 2022, the Supreme Court held that CMS could not vary its payment rates as in the 2018 policy. Accordingly, on September 28, 2022, the US District Court for the District of Columbia vacated the reimbursement rate of ASP minus 22.5% for the remainder of 2022. CMS complied with the district court’s decision by reverting the payment rate to ASP plus 6% for drugs acquired through the 340B Program from September 28, 2022, through the end of CY 2022. CMS then finalized the CY 2023 OPPS/ASC rule to extend that rate through CY 2023 and reduce the 2023 OPPS conversion factor by 3.09% to offset the previous increase of 3.19%. On January 10, 2023, the district court issued a remand without vacatur to allow CMS the opportunity to determine the appropriate remedy for the reduced payments.

    On July 7, 2023, CMS published a proposed rule intended to establish this remedy. For an overview of the proposed rule, please see our On the Subject, “CMS Releases Proposed Remedy for 340B-Acquired Drugs Purchased in CYs 2018–2022.”

    The Final Rule’s Remedy

    The final rule made very few changes to the proposed remedy, limited to adjusting the amount to be repaid and extending the period that hospitals will be subject to a downward adjustment in their OPPS payment rates to account for the repayment to 340B hospitals of the prior payment cuts. As discussed above, funds deriving from these payment cuts were used to increase OPPS payments on most other items and services. For a summary of the provisions of the final rule, please see the article prepared by our colleagues at McDermott+Consulting, “CMS Finalizes Remedy for 340B-Acquired Drugs Purchased in CYs 2018–2022.”

    Budget Neutrality Considerations

    The Social Security Act provides that CMS must at least annually revise the OPPS payment information to account for certain developments, including changes in medical practice, changes in technology, the addition of new services, new cost data, and other “relevant information and factors.” When CMS makes such adjustments, the adjustments for a year must not cause the estimated amount of OPPS expenditures for the year to increase or decrease from the estimated amount of expenditures that would have been made if the adjustments had not been made. This provision is commonly referred to as the “budget neutrality” requirement.

    CMS indicated in the final rule that it believes that OPPS spending resulting from the prior payment increases funded through the 340B payment cuts should be offset prospectively to maintain budget neutrality and to prevent hospitals from receiving a “windfall” from the improperly higher levels of reimbursement received in prior years.

    Beginning in CY 2026 (one year after the target CY 2025 in the proposed rule), and continuing for approximately 16 years thereafter, CMS will reduce all payments for non-drug items and services to all OPPS hospitals by 0.5% each year until the total offset is reached. The delay in implementation is to allow CMS time to finalize its methodology and publish the rates in the CY 2026 OPPS/ASC proposed rule.

    The final rule responds to extensive comments challenging the legality of the budget neutrality adjustments. Challenges to the adjustments claimed:

    • The budget neutrality provision allows adjustments for a particular “year,” not multiple years retrospectively or prospectively
    • The lump sum payment is not an additional payment under the OPPS that can be taken into account in subsequent years or to which the budget neutrality provisions apply
    • Hospitals’ payment reductions will not equate to the payment increases they received
    • The budget neutrality calculations are imprecise

    While CMS defended its position that the budget neutrality provisions support its prospective downward adjustments, it also stated that such adjustments are an “appropriate exercise of the agency’s statutory and common-law or inherent recoupment authorities as a policy matter.” CMS then referred to its authority to make certain changes retroactively if failure to apply such changes would be contrary to the public interest. CMS also cited its authority to establish adjustments to the OPPS as necessary to ensure equitable payments in support of the prospective downward adjustments.

    Medicare Advantage

    CMS recognized that many commenters expressed concern that Medicare Advantage organizations (MAOs) would realize a “windfall” as a result of CMS reducing outpatient payments without making corresponding repayments to hospitals. The commenters argued that MAOs would see the benefit of reduced outpatient payments to all hospitals for non-drug items and services going forward but would not be required to repay affected 340B covered entity hospitals the amounts that were withheld for 340B drugs from 2018 through 2022. CMS responded that such comments were out of the scope of the final rule and noted that CMS may not require MAOs to use particular pricing structures with contracted providers or interfere in their payment rates.

    Analysis

    The final rule’s prospective budget neutrality adjustments will be of keen interest to hospitals impacted by the adjustments. CMS defended the adjustments at length in the final rule and cited to several statutory authorities in support, at one point recognizing that the budget neutrality adjustment may not be “statutorily required.” Elsewhere, CMS stated, “in our view,” CMS’s proposed remedy is not unreasonable or unsupported by “the statutory scheme as a whole,” in that it accomplishes “nearly the same result” as if CMS had reprocessed all the overpaid and underpaid claims. CMS has taken a similar approach in the past when it has anticipated that litigation might render one or more underlying statutory justifications of an action invalid.

    In the final rule, CMS defended the lengthy timeline of the budget neutrality adjustment as a necessary balance to ensure that the offset was not “immediately, in the short-term, overly financially burdensome on some impacted entities.” CMS acknowledged that the budget neutrality adjustment was “similar to the original budget neutrality adjustment . . . that increased the payment for every non-drug item and service for CY 2018 through CY 2022.” However, the multi-year adjustment timeframe is one of several grounds raised by commenters as rendering the adjustments unauthorized under the statutory provisions that CMS cited in support of the adjustments.

    The final rule only briefly addresses commenters’ concerns regarding the “windfall” that certain MAOs may receive from the prospective downward payment adjustments during the budget neutrality offset period, when many MAOs reimburse contracted providers based on a percentage of Medicare rates and will therefore benefit from the prospective downward adjustments in OPPS rates. In other words, the payment structure set forth in the final rule is likely to result in lower payments for hospital outpatient services under some MAO contracts for the duration of the budget neutrality offset, without the corresponding lump sum payment to 340B hospitals. In the final rule, CMS declined to discuss the MAO issues on the basis that they were outside of the scope of the final rule. CMS further cited the statutory provisions that prohibit the agency from dictating the rates that MAOs pay providers under negotiated Medicare Advantage contracts.

    Key Takeaways

    • CMS will begin issuing instructions to Medicare Administrative Contractors (MACs) to make lump-sum payments to affected 340B hospitals after November 30, 2023, when the technical correction request period ends. MACs will have 60 days from receipt of these instructions to make the payment, but will not begin issuing payments until after the rule becomes effective on January 7, 2024.
    • Affected 340B hospitals should review Addendum AAA to determine whether there are any errors in their respective lump sum payments. Hospitals disputing the lump sum amounts will likely have their lump sum payments delayed until sometime after payments are made to non-disputing hospitals. CMS does not place a time requirement on resolving the disputes, so the delay could be lengthy. Hospitals should weigh the potential for delayed payment with the amounts in dispute before reporting an error to CMS. Hospitals choosing to dispute the lump sum amounts should email CMS at outpatientpps340b@cms.hhs.gov no later than 11:59 pm EST on November 30, 2023, with the following information:
      • A description of the nature of the error
      • A designated contact person for the purposes of addressing the error
      • Any relevant supporting documentation such as claim numbers, total units, payment amount received and date of payment
    • CMS will make a 0.5% downward adjustment of payments for non-drug items and services paid under OPPS starting CY 2026 and continuing for approximately 16 years thereafter.
    • Based on public statements made by hospital associations both prior to and following release of the final rule, ongoing litigation should be expected. This could result in further delays to the lump sum payments and budget neutrality adjustments.
    Authors

    Emily Jane Cook

    Partner

    Los Angeles, Washington, DC

    Steven J. Schnelle

    Partner

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    Eric Zimmerman

    Partner

    Washington, DC

    Jae Hyun Lee

    Associate

    New York – One Vanderbilt Avenue

    More insights

  • Private Client Magazine Issue 12 – Next Gen Wealth Edition

    Private Client Magazine Issue 12 – Next Gen Wealth Edition

    ARTICLE

    Private Client Magazine Issue 12 – Next Gen Wealth Edition

    November, 2023

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Jonathon Goldstone authored the article, UK Residence and “Exceptional Circumstances” – Not a Moral Dilemma, featured in Private Client Magazine. Read the full article here.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Mobility@McDermott: Monthly Update (10/2023)

    Mobility@McDermott: Monthly Update (10/2023)

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    Mobility@McDermott: Monthly Update (10/2023)

    November 6, 2023

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    1. European Court of Justice rules on access to electronic vehicle data system

    The European Court of Justice („ECJ“) on 5 October 2023 ruled that car manufacturers cannot impose conditions on independent repairers‘ access to electronic vehicle data that are not required by European law.

    In the case at hand, two independent repair chains had sued a car manufacturer because access to the manufacturers‘ „gateway system“ in which repair shops can perform write operations, erase error codes, perform recalibrations and activate vehicle parts required prior registration with that manufacturer, logging on to a portal designated by the manufacturer using personal connection data, purchasing a paid subscription for use of multi-make diagnostic tools and connecting them to that server via the internet.

    The repair chains sued the manufacturer at the District Court (Landgericht) of Cologne, Germany, for free access to the data when using diagnostics tools. The Landgericht referred questions of European law to the ECJ.

    The ECJ ruled that making access to the data subject to the conditions imposed by the manu-facturer violated the manufacturers‘ oligations under European law to provide unrestricted, standardized and non-discriminatory access to the data. Such access should not be limited to reading the data, but should also include the ability to process and write the data.

    Relevant for: Manufacturers, service providers

    Further details here (available in English)

    2. German parliament extends truck toll

    The German parliament, the Bundestag, has extended the truck toll in Germany. From December 1, vehicles weighing more than 7.5 tons will have to pay not only a truck toll but also a CO2 compensation payment. Emission-free vehicles, however, will be completely exempt from the toll obligation until 31 December 2025.

    In addition, the decisive factor that determines whether and how much toll is due will change. In the future, a vehicle’s weight class will be determined by its technically permissible total mass instead of the permissible total weight. As a result of this change, previously unaffected vehicles may now be subject to tolls (or a higher tolls than before).

    Relevant for: Logistic service providers.

    Further details here : (available only in German)

    3. European Court of Justice judgment on right of withdrawal after end of free trial period

    In a preliminary ruling on 5 October 2023, the European Court of Justice („ECJ“) provided guidance on the question whether consumers have a separate right of withdrawal from a contract that arises after the end of a free trial period. An Austrian online learning platform had offered a 30 day period during which consumers could use the platform’s services free of charge. If they entered into a distance contract, users were informed by the platform of their statutory right of withdrawal after signing up for the trial period. The platform’s general terms and conditions provided that if users did not terminate their contract with the platform during the free trial period, the contract would be automatically prolonged with costs.

    The plaintiff, a consumer right protection agency based in Austria, argued that consumers have a (second) right of withdrawal in case the free trial period is converted into a paid subscription. They further argued that a right of withdrawal arises each time the subscription is renewed and that the platform is obliged to inform consumers about such rights of withdrawal.

    In its judgment, the ECJ ruled that no further rights of withdrawal arise where a free trial period is prolonged into a paid contract or where such a paid contract is subsequently renewed, provided that the terms and conditions governing the contractual relationship remain the same. The information on the right of withdrawal provided by the platform after the start of the trial period was therefore sufficient.

    However, the ECJ pointed out that a new right of withdrawal could arise if the terms and conditions of the prolonged contract differ fundamentally from the terms and conditions that the consumer was informed about when the contract was initially concluded.

    Further details here (available in English)

    Relevant for: Mobility providers, vehicle platform providers

    4. EU Council adopts new Consumer Credit Directive

    On 9 October 2023, the EU Council adopted the new EU Consumer Credit Directive (Verbraucherkreditrichtlinie). The aim of the changes to the Directive is to improve the protection of consumers applying for credit. While previously, loans of less than EUR 200 and buy-now-pay-later products were not covered, they have now been added to its scope. In addition, protection mechanisms for interest-free loans and short-term, low-interest credit arrangements are now part of the directive. Lenders are now also required to screen consumers more thoroughly before granting credit to consumers.

    Further details here (available in English)

    Relevant for: Finance providers

    5. New subsidies for climate-friendly vehicles implemented by German government

    As a reminder, the German government launched a new subsidy program to incentivize the leasing of climate-friendly machinery and vehicles. It will be funded with up to EUR 500 million per year. Previously, similar subsidies were only made available for loans.

    Under the program, KfW, Germany‘s state-owned investment and development bank, will provide subsidised loans to leasing providers and banks which in turn will be able to offer attractive rates to their customers. The program is also open to small and medium-sized banks and leasing providers.

    Further details here (available only in German)

    Relevant for: Finance and leasing providers

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • SEC Adopts Short Reporting Rule for Institutional Investment Managers With Global Scope

    SEC Adopts Short Reporting Rule for Institutional Investment Managers With Global Scope

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    SEC Adopts Short Reporting Rule for Institutional Investment Managers With Global Scope

    November 7, 2023

    Read time: 24 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On Oct. 13, 2023, the SEC adopted new rule 13f-2 (“Rule 13f-2”) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended (“Exchange Act”).[1] Rule 13f-2 requires institutional investment managers to report equity security short positions to the SEC on new Form SHO. Since publishing the proposed rule changes in February 2022,[2] industry groups and market participants have raised concerns about the broad scope of the proposed rule, the operational expense of compliance and the risks to market quality that might follow, including the potential that proprietary information could be discovered by those who reverse engineer the statistics that the SEC plans to publish.

    In spite of these concerns, which were all presented to the SEC, the SEC adopted a rule that imposes significant costs and risks on a broad swath of managers, including US managers with investment discretion over limited assets and foreign managers with limited US jurisdictional ties. Unlike Rule 13f-1, which only imposes a Form 13F filing obligation on institutional investment managers who exercise investment discretion over $100 million or more in Section 13(f) securities, there is no exclusion under Rule 13f-2 for managers who exercise investment discretion over equity securities below a certain threshold. Additionally, while Section 13(f)(4) of the Exchange Act requires the SEC to make available to the public a list of Section 13(f) securities that can be relied upon by Form 13F filers, institutional investment managers will need to individually assess whether the securities over which they exercise investment discretion qualify as equity securities, as that term is defined under Section 3(a)(11) of the Exchange Act and Rule 3a11–1 thereunder.

    To ensure compliance with Rule 13f-2, most institutional investment managers that engage in any form of short selling,[3] regardless of whether they will ultimately be required to file Form SHO, will need to adopt procedures to assess whether they exceeded any of the applicable filing thresholds during the prior month. To conduct this assessment, institutional investment managers will first need to categorize their global equity securities positions into Reporting Company Issuers and Non-Reporting Company Issuers and then assess, on a security-by-security basis, whether they exceeded the relevant Rule 13f-2 filing threshold. For Reporting Company Issuers, the filing threshold is the exercise of investment discretion over a monthly average gross short position of $10 million or more or which constituted 2.5 percent or more of the shares outstanding in the equity security. For Non-Reporting Company Issuers, the filing threshold is the exercise of investment discretion over a gross short position of $500,000 or more at the close of regular trading hours on any settlement day during the preceding calendar month. Institutional investment managers will have 14 calendar days after the end of a calendar month to perform the necessary computations and submit a Form SHO filing to the SEC. The SEC plans to publish aggregated short position information derived from Form SHO filings approximately 14 days after the filing deadline.

    Rule 13f-2 will go into effect on Jan. 2, 2024.[4] However, compliance with the Rule 13f-2 reporting requirements will not be required until 12 months later, January 2025, with the SEC commencing the publication of aggregated short position data collected under Rule 13f-2 three months later.

    Who is Required to File

    Like Form 13F, the requirement to file Form SHO applies to institutional investment managers, which are broadly defined under Section 13(f)(6)(A) of the Exchange Act to cover “any person, other than a natural person, investing in or buying and selling securities for its own account, and any person exercising investment discretion with respect to the account of any other person.” In the Adopting Release, the SEC notes that the definition is intended to cover “investment advisers exercising investment discretion over client assets, including investment company assets such as mutual funds, ETFs, and closed-end funds; banks and bank trust corporations offering investment management services; pension fund managers; firms, including broker-dealers and insurance companies, managing corporate or employee investment assets; and individuals exercising investment discretion over the accounts of others.”[5]

    Notably, the definition of institutional investment manager does not require prospective reporters to primarily operate in the US or impose any minimum standard on the size of the advisory business. Nearly any domestic person or entity investing (other than a natural person investing for their own account) would need to perform the threshold calculations under Rule 13f-2(a)(1) and (2) (detailed below) to determine if a Form SHO filing is required in a given month. For foreign institutional investment managers, the SEC’s jurisdictional analysis in the Adopting Release suggests that “operating in the US securities markets such that the investment manager is subject to filing reports with the Commission,”[6] is sufficient to require compliance with Rule 13f-2 on the foreign institutional investment manager’s global operations. It is currently unclear whether the SEC intends to limit the application of Rule 13f-2 to just foreign institutional investment managers that are subject to Form 13F filing obligations (managers that exercise investment discretion over $100 million or more in Section 13(f) securities) or more broadly to any SEC filing obligation. Accordingly, nearly any manager who has investment discretion over an account that may engage in short selling of an equity security — even if those sales occur outside of the US, are not subject to a long/short order marking requirement under SEC Regulation SHO, or typically occur at a de minimis level — will need to adopt an operational process to determine whether any of the monthly average or end-of-day reporting thresholds were triggered in the prior month.

    What Securities are in Scope

    Rule 13f-2 applies to equity securities, as defined in Section 3(a)(11) of the Exchange Act and Rule 3a11–1 thereunder.[7] As a general matter, institutional investment managers will be required to perform the calculations under Rule 13f-2(a)(1) and (2) across any exchange-listed and over-the-counter stock, warrant, convertible debt, ADR and ETF positions. The definition of “equity security” is not limited to securities issued by US issuers or traded on US markets. As discussed in the Adopting Release, the SEC intends Rule 13f-2 to have an extra-territorial effect and require the disclosure of “short selling by Managers of securities of US and non-US issuers … regardless of where those sales occur.”[8]

    Listed options, swaps and certain other derivatives are generally not expected to be directly reportable under Rule 13f-2, however, the SEC notes that certain of these products may meet the definition of an “equity security” and therefore would be directly reportable under the rule. Given the potential confusion, we are optimistic that the SEC staff will provide additional guidance on the application of Rule 13f-2 to securities that may meet the technical definition of equity security under in Section 3(a)(11) of the Exchange Act and Rule 3a11–1 thereunder but are not typically subject to a Regulation SHO order marking requirement prior to the compliance date for the rule.

    With respect to ETFs, the instructions to Form SHO are clear that while managers must report the gross short position in the ETF over which they exercise investment discretion on Form SHO, they should not consider short positions that the ETF holds in individual underlying equity securities that are part of the ETF basket when calculating a gross short position in each underlying equity security (that is, the manager’s short position in the ETF and its short positions in any underlying equity security should be considered and, where applicable, reported separately).

    Reporting Thresholds

    Unlike Rule 13f-1 for Form 13F filers, there is no exclusion under Rule 13f-2 for managers who exercise investment discretion over equity securities below a certain threshold. Each institutional investment manager must determine if it has a reporting obligation on an individual equity security basis by aggregating its gross short exposure in that security and comparing it to the thresholds defined in Rule 13f-2(a)(1) and (2) (“Filing Thresholds”). The term “gross short position” means the number of shares of the equity security that are held short as a result of short sales defined under Rule 200(a) of Regulation SHO, without the inclusion of any offsetting positions. For purposes of the calculations under Rule 13f-2(a)(1) and (2), the institutional investment manager’s calculation is on the basis of the aggregate gross position of the institutional investment manager and all accounts over which the institutional investment manager (or any person under the institutional investment manager’s control) has investment discretion.

    Reporting Company Issuers

    The Filing Thresholds for reporting gross short positions of an equity security of a reporting company issuer is the lesser of:

    • a monthly average gross short position at the close of regular trading hours in the equity security with a US dollar value of $10 million or more, or;
    • a monthly average gross short position at the close of regular trading hours as a percentage of shares outstanding in the equity security of 2.5 percent or more.[9]

    Non-Reporting Company Issuers

    The Filing Thresholds for reporting gross short positions of an equity security of a non-reporting company issuer is:

    • a gross short position in the equity security with a US dollar value of $500,000 or more at the close of regular trading hours on any settlement date during the calendar month.

    The reporting company issuer Filing Thresholds apply to an equity security: 1) if the class of security is registered pursuant to Section 12 of the Exchange Act; or 2) to any equity security of the issuer if the issuer is required to file reports pursuant to Section 15(d) of the Exchange Act. As a general matter, any security listed on a US stock exchange or any security of an issuer that files periodic reports (e.g., 10-Q, 10-K, 8-K, etc.) would be subject to the reporting company issuer Filing Thresholds. Certain equity securities traded over-the-counter in the US, as well as certain securities of large foreign issuers, may also qualify for the reporting company issuer Filing Thresholds.

    Any equity security that is not registered pursuant to Section 12 of the Exchange Act or issued by an issuer subject to the filing requirements under Section 15(d) of the Exchange Act must be treated as a non-reporting company issuer subject to a reporting obligation if the institutional investment manager maintains gross short exposure in the security in excess of $500,000 at the close of regular trading on any settlement date during the month. Given the extraterritorial effect of Rule 13f-2, this may have significant unintended consequences for institutional investment managers who exercise investment discretion over foreign equity securities or for managers that exercise investment discretion over more complex products or in special situations.

    Publication of Aggregate Information

    While Form SHO filings will be treated as confidential,[10] the SEC plans to publish aggregated data derived from Form SHO submissions within a month (currently targeted at 28 days) of the end of each reporting period. With regard to Table 1 information (further detailed below), this will be the aggregated gross short position calculated as the number of shares and US dollar notional value reported by all managers for each class of equity security. With regard to Table 2 information (further detailed below), the SEC will publish the aggregate of the net activity reported by all reporting managers for each equity security. In addition to the statistics reflecting the prior month’s activity, each month the SEC also plans to publish similar aggregated Form SHO data for the prior 12 months that reflect updated information that accounts for any changes that result from amendments and restatements to Form SHO filings.

    Takeaways

    The SEC appears not to appreciate the operational complexity and costs associated with the requirements it adopted under Rule 13f-2. By failing to adopt a requirement that the SEC create a list of equity securities subject to the rule, institutional investment managers likely will need to develop complex systems to evaluate their global securities positions across the Filing Thresholds. As there are no current readily available data sources linking individual securities in the US, let alone globally, to the Reporting Company Issuer Filing Thresholds, less sophisticated institutional investment managers may need to evaluate all positions under the Filing Threshold applicable to Non-Reporting Company Issuers and then to determine if the relevant security qualifies as an equity security as defined in Section 3(a)(11) of the Exchange Act (and Rule 3a11–1 thereunder), or if one of the higher Reporting Company Issuer Filing Thresholds applies.

    Similar to FINRA’s short interest reporting regime, aggregation of securities positions that trade across markets is likely to be challenging (i.e., systematically identifying and aggregating positions in securities that trade in different jurisdictions under different symbols, such as dual-listed securities and the securities of foreign listed companies that trade over-the-counter in the US). For foreign securities that do not trade in the US, determining whether the security meets the definition of an equity security, whether the sale meets the definition of a short sale under Regulation SHO, or whether the security should be evaluated under the Reporting Company Issuer or Non-Reporting Company Issuer thresholds may also be difficult. This issue is compounded by the fact that Regulation SHO, which is incorporated by reference into the definition of “gross short position,” is a requirement of US broker-dealers, not institutional investment managers, and largely limited to equity securities traded in the US[11]

    In addition to operational cost and complexity, by incorporating the definition of Regulation SHO into a filing requirement applicable to institutional investment managers, the SEC has an additional tool to impose liability on managers for inadvertent order marking mistakes.[12]

    Lastly, while aggregation may limit the risks of market participants being able to reverse engineer and identify the institutional investment managers underlying a publicly disclosed short position, managers are rightly concerned about the risks. In the Adopting Release, the SEC acknowledges that an estimated 39 percent of the stocks reported on Form SHO would only have one manager above the Filing Thresholds for Reporting Company Issuers. Coupled with the near real-time and granular disclosure requirements of security lending information adopted pursuant to newly adopted Rule 10c-1a, the new rule may provide opportunities for third-parties to reverse engineer and engage in targeted manipulative trading activity against short sellers.

    Outside of the US, the significantly lower Filing Threshold applicable to Non-Reporting Company Issuers and asymmetrical application to only US institutional investment managers or foreign institutional investment managers that are subject to other SEC filing obligations will likely have unintended consequences.

    Reporting Mechanics

    Form SHO Requirements

    Once an institutional investment manager determines that it has a filing obligation under one of the Filing Thresholds, it will need to complete and submit Form SHO to the SEC through EDGAR (although the form will not be publicly available on EDGAR) within 14 days of the conclusion of the month.

    Cover Page

    Each institutional investment manager required to report under Rule 13f-2 must complete a cover page and two informational tables. The cover page contains basic biographical information about the institutional investment manager, including its name, address, contact information, an employee contact for the filing and a non-lapsed Legal Entity Identifier (“LEI”), if they have one. Currently, the SEC is not requiring institutional investment managers to obtain or maintain an LEI solely as a result of a Rule 13f-2 filing requirement, however, the adopting release notes that “[t]he Commission may consider this issue in the future.”

    Table 1 (Summary Information)

    For each equity security that an institutional investment manager is required to report on Form SHO,[13] the manager must complete an entry on Table 1 of Form SHO. For each reportable security, Table 1 requires the institutional investment manager to identify the settlement date for the position (i.e., the last settlement day of the calendar month of the relevant reporting period), the name of the issuer, the LEI of the issuer (if the issuer has one), and the title of the class of securities being reported (reasonable abbreviations are permitted).

    Table 1 of Form SHO also requires the institutional investment manager to report the Committee on Uniform Securities Identification Procedures (“CUSIP”) and Financial Instrument Global Identifier (“FIGI”) for each security being reported, if applicable. While FIGIs are available in the public domain and available for free, the use of CUSIPs by institutional investment managers may involve significant licensing costs.[14]

    For each entry in Table 1, the institutional investment manager must identify the gross short position over which it exercised investment discretion in the relevant security at the close of regular trading hours on the last settlement date of the calendar month of the reporting period. Similar to the calculation of the Reporting Thresholds detailed above, this calculation is done without the inclusion of any offsetting economic positions — including long positions of the reportable equity security or derivatives of that security. Further, as noted below, short positions reported by another manager should be excluded under the Anti-Duplication instructions, and short positions of an equity security held within an ETF should not be considered when calculating a short position in an underlying security (a short position in the ETF itself, however, may be separately reportable).

    Gross short positions must be identified both in terms of the number of shares of the security for which information is being provided and as a US dollar amount. Calculation of the US dollar value of an equity security is based upon the closing price at the close of regular trading hours on the last settlement date of the calendar month or, if a closing price is not available, the price at which the institutional investment manager last purchased or sold any share of that security.

    Minimal information is currently available on how to interpret these requirements outside of the standard US context. Regular trading hours are defined by reference to Regulation NMS, Rule 600(b)(77), which sets the conclusion of regular trading hours at 4:00 P.M. Eastern Time. How this timing requirement will be applied more broadly to the full universe of securities covered by Rule 13f-2 is unclear. Similarly, there is currently no guidance as to how the notional value of equity securities that do not trade or get reported in US dollars should be reported or how share equivalents should be calculated for equity securities that do not trade as shares.

    Table 2 (Detailed Information)

    For each equity security included in Table 1, the institutional investment manager must also complete a Table 2 entry reflecting daily activity that affected the manager’s short positions during the reporting period. For each such entry, the institutional investment would identify the settlement date on which a trade settles, similar biographical information about the issuer and security as required in Table 1, and a single number reflecting the net change in the short position as a number of shares on the relevant settlement date.

    The detailed net change in short position information required in Table 2 should reflect how the gross short position reported in Table 1 was closed out or increased as a result of the acquisition or sale of shares of the equity security on each settlement date during the month. This includes:

    1. Short sales of the security that settled on that date,
    2. Shares of the security that were purchased to cover, in whole or in part, an existing short position and settled on that date,
    3. Shares of the security that were acquired in a call option exercise that reduces or closes a short position on that security and settled on that date,
    4. Shares of the security that were sold in a put option exercise that creates or increases a short position on that security and settled on that date,
    5. Shares of the security that were sold in a call option assignment that creates or increases a short position on that security and settled on that date,
    6. Shares of the security that were acquired in a put option assignment that reduces or closes a short position on that security and settled on that date
    7. Shares of the security for which information is being reported that were acquired as a result of the tendered conversions that reduces or closes a short position on that security and settled on that date,
    8. Shares of the security that were obtained through a secondary offering transaction that reduces or closes a short position on that security and settled on that date,[15]
    9. Shares of the security that resulted from other activity not previously reported on this form that creates or increases a short position on that security and settled on that date, or that reduces or closes a short position on that security and settled on that date,
    10. Activity other than (1) through (9) above that creates or increases, or reduces or closes, a short position on that security, including, but not limited to, shares resulting from ETF creation or redemption activity.

    Any activity that results in the reduction of a short position must be netted against activity that increases a short position for purposes of Table 2 (unless the underlying position is excluded on Table 1 as a result of the Anti-Duplication instructions). By way of example, the purchase of shares of an equity security that are delivered to an account and reduce a short position over which the institutional investment manager exercises investment discretion is reportable in Table 2. Similar purchases of shares that do not result in the reduction of short positions, however, are not reportable even if they result in an increase in the net position of the accounts over which an institutional investment manager exercises investment discretion (e.g., purchases that are not used to close a boxed short position or are delivered to a prime broker that does not maintain a short position on behalf of the underlying account are not included in the Table 2 net change calculation).

    Additionally, while the acquisition of shares acquired or sold as a result of option exercises or assignments, warrant exercises, ETF creations or redemptions, tenders and other transactions involving the conversion, creation, redemption of a related or derivative instrument that creates or reduces ones short position in an equity security are reportable, the existence of the related or derivative instrument is itself not reportable unless that instrument is also an equity security that meets one of the Filing Thresholds.

    Finally, while the preface to the instructions for calculating the net change in a short position expressly limits the calculation to transactions that “result … in the acquisition or sale of shares of that equity security,” the SEC may require changes in a gross short position that result from operational movements (e.g., collapsing a box by delivering shares that a manager previously owned or allocating positions across prime brokers that results in the increase or reduction of a short position) to trigger a Table 2 disclosure obligation under item 9(g)(10) of the instructions to Form SHO.

    Filing Deadlines

    An institutional investment manager that exceeds any of the Filing Thresholds in the prior month must submit Form SHO to the SEC via an EDGAR filing within 14 days of the conclusion of the month.

    Obligation to Amend and Restate

    To the extent that an institutional investment manager identifies an inaccuracy on a previously filed Form SHO, it is required to submit an amended and restated Form SHO for the impacted period within 10 calendar days of discovering the error. To submit an amendment and restatement, an institutional investment manager must restate the original version of the Form SHO in its entirety and note on the cover page that the submission is an amendment and restatement, provide a description of the revision being made, explain the reason for the revision, and indicate whether any data from any additional Form SHO reports within the prior 12 calendar months were impacted (and if so, file amendment and restatements for each such impacted report).[16]

    Importantly, the SEC declined to include any materiality threshold in the requirement that an institutional investment manager amend any previously identified Form SHO reports. Additionally, while the Adopting Release states that the purpose of the amendment and restatement process is to facilitate the SEC’s publication of updated aggregated Form SHO data for a rolling 12-month period after initial publication and that the amendment and restatement process is limited to errors impacting Form SHO data in the prior 12 months, neither Rule 13f-2 nor Form SHO explicitly limit the amendment and restatement process to errors that impacted filings in the prior 12 calendar months (the instructions just limit the requirement to identify “additional” impacted Form SHO reporting periods impacted during the prior twelve months).

    Anti-Duplication

    To prevent duplicative reporting, if two or more managers, each of which would be required by Rule 13f–2 to file Form SHO, exercise investment discretion with respect to the same security for the same period, only one such manager would be required to report information regarding that security on Form SHO in the relevant informational tables. This relief, however, does not extend to filing the cover page of Form SHO, which must identify whether any information for the reporting institutional investment manager is reported on Form SHO by other manager(s), and if so, identify the name and LEI of the relevant manager(s).

    Form of Filing

    The Form SHO filing must be made in a custom eXtensible Markup Language (“XML”) specific to Form SHO. We expect that the SEC will update the EDGAR Filer Manual and publish additional technical specifications regarding this custom XML format and electronic filing process for Form SHO in advance of the compliance date for Rule 13f-2.

    While not anticipated to be used by larger institutional investment managers, the SEC will also permit Form SHO to be submitted using a fillable web form prepared by the SEC that will render data submitted by a manager into Form SHO-specific XML in EDGAR.

     Authored by Adriana Schwartz, William J. Barbera and Derek N. Lacarrubba

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] Exchange Act Release No. 34-98738 (Oct. 13, 2023), available at https://www.sec.gov/files/rules/final/2023/34-98738.pdf (“Adopting Release”).

    [2] “SEC Proposes Short Sale Disclosure Rule, Order Marking Requirement, and CAT Amendments,” SEC Press Release, Feb. 25, 2022, available at https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2022-32.

    [3] The term “gross short position” in Rule 13f-2 incorporates the definition of short sale under Rule 200(a) of Regulation SHO. Rule 200(a) of Regulation SHO defines a short sale as “any sale of a security which the seller does not own or any sale which is consummated by the delivery of a security borrowed by, or for the account of, the seller.” (emphasis added). As such, even where an institutional investment manager sells securities that they are deemed to own, they still may have a Rule 13f-2 filing obligation if those sales are consummated by the delivery of borrowed securities.

    [4] The effective date for Rule 13f-2 is 60 days after the date of publication in the Federal Register, which occurred on Nov. 1, 2023.

    [5] Adopting Release at 175.

    [6] Adopting Release at 36.

    [7] Rule 3a11-1 broadly defines equity security to include “any stock or similar security, certificate of interest or participation in any profit sharing agreement, preorganization certificate or subscription, transferable share, voting trust certificate or certificate of deposit for an equity security, limited partnership interest, interest in a joint venture, or certificate of interest in a business trust; any security future on any such security; or any security convertible, with or without consideration into such a security, or carrying any warrant or right to subscribe to or purchase such a security; or any such warrant or right; or any put, call, straddle, or other option or privilege of buying such a security from or selling such a security to another without being bound to do so.”

    [8] Adopting Release at 36.

    [9] The number of shares outstanding of a security shall be determined by reference to an issuer’s most recent annual or quarterly report, and any subsequent update thereto.

    [10] The instructions to Form SHO include a notation that all information included in a Form SHO report is deemed subject to a confidential treatment request under 17 CFR 200.83. Based on the Adopting Release, it does not appear that an institutional investment manager would be required to take any additional action to avail itself of the protections under FOIA, section 13(f)(4) through (5), SEC Rule 83, and any other applicable law against disclosure.

    [11] While Regulation SHO has extraterritorial effect, the limitation that it only applies to orders placed with a US broker-dealer largely limits its application to foreign securities.

    [12] Section 10(b) of the Exchange Act and SEC Rules 10b-5 and 10b-21 thereunder impose liability on any person for deceiving a broker-dealer, registered clearing agency, or purchaser about its ability or intent to deliver securities. The SEC has also charged managers for causing a violation of a broker-dealer’s books and records violation.

    [13] Unless another manager also has investment discretion over that security, the institutional investment manager has noted this on the cover page to their Form SHO, and another manager has reported on Form SHO.

    [14] See Comment Letter on File No. S7-08-22, available at https://www.sec.gov/comments/s7-08-22/s70822-20126773-287490.pdf.

    [15] For shares of a security obtained through a secondary offering subject to Regulation M, Rule 105, the instructions to Form SHO remind institutional investment managers that any such shares received must be reported regardless of whether they were used to close out a position acquired outside of the Rule 105 Restricted Period.

    [16] Rule 13f-2 and the instructions to Form SHO leave it ambiguous as to whether the 12-month limitation is intended to limit the amendment of additional months impacted by an issue or whether it also applies to the initial identification of an inaccuracy.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. © 2023 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP. All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    William J. Barbera

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • SEC Securities Lending Rule: Increased Transparency and the Risk of Information Leakage

    SEC Securities Lending Rule: Increased Transparency and the Risk of Information Leakage

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    SEC Securities Lending Rule: Increased Transparency and the Risk of Information Leakage

    November 7, 2023

    Read time: 35 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    On Oct. 13, 2023, the SEC adopted new Rule 10c-1a under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended (“Exchange Act”), which the Federal Register officially published on Nov. 3, 2023.[1] The Adopting Release states that Exchange Act Rule 10c-1a (“Rule 10c-1a”) is designed to “increase the transparency and efficiency of the securities lending market” by requiring the reporting, and subsequent public dissemination, of information on “covered securities loans.”[2] Rule 10c-1a represents a significant expansion of broker-dealer and securities lender intermediary regulatory reporting obligations and may have significant unintended consequences on private fund securities lending programs. Additionally, Rule 10c-1a, in conjunction with the Institutional Investment Manager Short Reporting Rule (Rule 13f-2),[3] dramatically increases the risk that competitors may be able to reverse engineer and anticipate a market participant’s trading strategy. While “covered persons” will not need to begin reporting loan information under Rule 10c-1a until early 2026 (at the earliest), firms that anticipate having substantial reporting obligations under the rule may want to begin planning in the near term.

    As adopted, Rule 10c-1a represents an entirely new regulatory reporting regime, effectively requiring that all securities loans be reported to FINRA[4] on the day the loan is entered into or modified. Information about such loans, including aggregated loan activity by security, will be made publicly available by no later than the morning of the following business day.

    We anticipate that the majority of reporting under Rule 10c-1a will be conducted by broker-dealers and securities lending intermediaries. Due to the same-day reporting requirement and inconsistency between how the rule is structured and how securities lending markets currently operate, these entities will likely need to make significant technological and compliance investments to comply with Rule 10c-1a. Private funds and other persons who operate securities lending programs or agree to a covered securities loan on behalf of a lender (e.g., private fund advisers) may discover that their current lending program does not comport with the allocation of reporting responsibility provisions in Rule 10c-1a and may become primarily liable for reporting certain securities lending transactions.

    Regardless of whether a market participant engages in securities lending activity, competitors may be able to reverse engineer their trading strategies and expose them to risks of coordinated short squeezes and front running attempts. To mitigate these risks, private fund advisers and other market participants may need to re-examine their securities lending and borrowing relationships and should actively engage with FINRA in connection with implementing the data collection and public dissemination requirements of Rule 10c-1a. Schulte will issue a subsequent Alert once FINRA’s rule proposal is announced.

    Rule 10c-1a will go into effect on Jan. 2, 2024, although, as noted above, “covered persons” will not need to begin reporting information to FINRA until early 2026 (at the earliest).

    Who is Required to Report

    Rule 10c-1a requires “covered persons” to report any “covered securities loan” to FINRA by no later than the end of the day on which the covered securities loan was effected. A covered person is defined in Rule 10c-1a(j)(1) as: “(i) [a]ny person that agrees to a covered securities loan on behalf of a lender (“intermediary”) other than a clearing agency when providing [certain defined services]; (ii) [a]ny person that agrees to a covered securities loan as a lender when an intermediary is not used unless [clause (iii)] applies; or (iii) [a] broker or dealer when borrowing fully paid or excess margin securities pursuant to Rule 15c3-3(b)(3) of the Exchange Act.”

    Importantly, where an “intermediary” agrees to a covered securities loan,[5] or a broker-dealer borrows fully paid or excess margin securities from a lender, the underlying lender has no reporting obligation under Rule 10c-1a (although, if structured as a back-to-back loan, the underlying lender or other person may have a reporting obligation on the separate loan). The underlying lender does not, for instance, have to ensure that the intermediary or broker-dealer reports the covered securities loan or otherwise complies with Rule 10c-1a (the SEC recognized that, where an intermediary arranges a loan or a broker-dealer borrows fully paid or excess margin securities, the underlying lender may not realize its securities have been loaned).

    Notwithstanding the foregoing, Rule 10c-1a does not provide a de minimis exemption from the definition of covered person. Accordingly, a person who arranges for a loan of a reportable security (whether as lender or intermediary) must, under Rule 10c-1a, report all required information to FINRA or arrange for a reporting agent to report on such person’s behalf, even on isolated transactions. As such, private funds and their advisers may wish to engage a “reporting agent” to ensure they have the capability to comply with Rule 10c-1a and, as further discussed below, relieve themselves of certain obligations under the rule.

    What Type of Securities Loans are In-Scope

    Rule 10c-1a requires the reporting of all “covered securities loans” agreed to by any covered person. Subject to certain exceptions,[6] a covered securities loan is defined as “[a] transaction in which any person on behalf of itself or one or more other persons, lends a reportable security to another person.” (Emphasis added). Accordingly, key to determining what types of securities lending transactions are in-scope of the rule are the definitions of “reportable security” and “lends.”

    Reportable Security

    “Reportable security” is defined in Rule 10c-1a(j)(3) as any security that is required to be reported under (i) the CAT NMS Plan (“CAT”), (ii) FINRA’S Trade Reporting and Compliance Engine (“TRACE”), or (iii) the MSRB’s Real-Time Transaction Reporting System (“RTRS”).[7] The Adopting Release expressly notes that the term incorporates any exclusions from those reporting regimes (e.g., securities that fall outside of the existing reporting regimes would not be reportable securities under Rule 10c-1a). This may ease the compliance burden for broker-dealers that separately report securities transactions to these systems, although covered persons who are not broker-dealers will likely need to develop processes and procedures to track the universe of reportable securities (particularly covered persons that may not otherwise be familiar with those reporting systems and related rules).

    Lends

    While a threshold concept for purposes of Rule 10c-1a, the SEC elected not to define the term “loan” or what it means to “lend” a reportable security to another person. Rather, the SEC noted that certain factors flagged by commenters were not necessarily dispositive in determining whether a transaction represented a loan for purposes of Rule 10c-1a, including (i) whether the transaction was recorded as a loan, (ii) the fee arrangement associated with the transaction (including the absence of any fee or rebate),[8] (iii) whether collateral was provided,[9] (iv) whether the parties were affiliates,[10] (v) whether there was a loss of voting right,[11] and (vi) whether the transaction was for a “permitted purpose” under Regulation T.[12]

    Notwithstanding the above, the Adopting Release states that repurchase transactions (“repos”) are not subject to the reporting requirements of Rule 10c-1a,[13] although the Adopting Release seems to indicate that functionality equivalent transactions may be within scope.[14]

    Given the lack of clarity under Rule 10c-1a and the Adopting Release, Private Fund Advisers and other market participants may want to review whether certain funding transactions are considered “loans” by their counterparties and adopt policies and procedures to address potential questions from regulators.

    Covered Person Reporting Requirements

    Timing

    Rule 10c-1a requires that covered persons report all required data elements to FINRA by the end of the day on any day on which a covered securities loan was agreed to. Certain modifications to covered securities loans[15] must also be reported to FINRA by the end of the day on any day on which the modification occurred. Notably, Rule 10c-1a uses the term “day” rather than “business day” when discussing the reporting requirements applicable to covered persons and reporting agents under sections (c) (initial reporting) and (d) (reporting of loan modifications) of the rule, which indicates that loans entered into on non-business days may still be subject to end of reporting, notwithstanding that the rule only requires that FINRA publish information by “not later than the morning of the business day” following such covered securities loan (or, where applicable, not later than the “twentieth business day after the covered securities loan is effected…”). While this may be addressed in the FINRA rulemaking, it may represent an oversight by the SEC, as Rule 10c-1a(g)(1)(i) notes that FINRA’s reporting obligations apply to “each covered securities loan effected on the previous business day….”

    Additionally, while only “finalized loan terms” must be reported,[16] intra-day modifications to loans must be reported even if such modifications result in multiple reports for the same covered securities loan on a given day.

    Rule 10c-1 does not define “end of the business day” or what holidays should not be considered a “business day.” Rather, this and other terms remain subject to FINRA rulemaking.

    Data Elements

    For each finalized covered securities loan or modification, a covered person must report public data elements, a delayed reporting data element and confidential data elements to FINRA on the day of the loan.

    Public Data Elements

    Each of the below elements becomes publicly available on a loan-by-loan basis the business day after the covered securities loan has been agreed to:

    • The legal name of the security issuer, and the Legal Entity Identifier (“LEI”) of the issuer, if the issuer has a non-lapsed LEI;
    • The ticker symbol, International Securities Identification Number (“ISIN”), Committee on Uniform Securities Identification Procedures (“CUSIP”), or Financial Instrument Global Identifier (“FIGI”) of the security, or other security identifier;
    • The date the covered securities loan was effected;
    • The time the covered securities loan was effected;
    • The name of the platform or venue where the covered securities loan was effected;
    • The type of collateral used to secure the covered securities loan;
    • For a covered securities loan collateralized by cash, the rebate rate or any other fee or charges;[17]
    • For a covered securities loan not collateralized by cash, the securities lending fee or rate, or any other fee or charges;
    • The percentage of collateral to value of reportable securities loaned required to secure such covered securities loan;
    • The termination date of the covered securities loan; and
    • Whether the borrower is a broker or dealer, a customer (if the person lending securities is a broker or dealer), a clearing agency, a bank, a custodian or other person.

    Delayed Reporting Data Element (Loan Size)

    Covered persons must also report the “amount, such as size, volume, or both, of the reportable securities loaned” to FINRA. While this information will be reported to FINRA along with the public data elements, FINRA will delay the public dissemination and enrichment of loan-by-loan data with respect to the size of the loan[18] for a period of 20 business days.

    Confidential Data Elements

    While not intended to become public, covered persons must also report the following data elements to FINRA on the day the covered securities loan has been agreed to.

    • If known, the legal name of each party to the covered securities loan, including the person’s CRD or IARD No., MPID and LEI, and whether such person is the lender, the borrower or the intermediary;
    • If the person lending securities is a broker or dealer and the borrower is its customer, whether the security is loaned from a broker’s or dealer’s securities inventory to a customer of such broker or dealer; and
    • If known, whether the covered securities loan is being used to close out a fail to deliver (whether pursuant to Regulation SHO or otherwise).

    While the confidential data elements are not intended to ever become publicly available, FINRA may share such data with the SEC and such “other persons as the Commission may designate by order upon a demonstrated regulatory need.”

    Loan Modifications

    A supplemental report must be made to FINRA on the day that any modification is made to a loan that impacts any previously reported “data element” (that is, the public data elements and Delayed Reporting Data Element discussed above). Modification reports must note (i) the date and time of the modification, (ii) the data element being modified, including the “specific modification” thereof (e.g., the amount of the security loaned increased by 200 shares, rather than a general description of the modification), and (iii) the unique identifier assigned to the original covered securities loan by FINRA (discussed below).

    Similar to the data elements on the initial report, the modification of any Public Data Element will be made public by FINRA on a loan-by-loan basis on the day after the modification and a modification to the Delayed Reporting Data Element (Loan Size) will be made publicly available by FINRA 20 business days later.

    Aggregate Reporting by FINRA

    In addition to the publication of loan-by-loan information on a T+1 and T+20 basis by FINRA, FINRA will also make publicly available the aggregate transaction activity and distribution of loan rates for each reportable security that is derived from the reports submitted by covered persons. Such aggregated data will be made publicly available by FINRA not later than the morning of the business day after the covered securities loan is effected (e.g., on a “T+1” basis). For clarity, this means that while the size of an individual covered securities loan will not be made publicly available until the twentieth business day after the covered securities loan is effected, aggregate loan activity on a security-by-security basis will be available on T+1.

    Key Considerations

    Cross-Border Implications

    In the Adopting Release, the SEC discussed the intended cross-border application of Rule 10c-1a. As may be expected, the SEC views Rule 10c-1a’s reach as fairly extensive such that the rule’s reporting requirements may be triggered “whenever a covered person effects, accepts, or facilitates (in whole or in part) in the US a lending or borrowing transaction.”[19]

    Notably, the SEC stated that loans involving non-US persons are not excluded from Rule 10c-1a’s scope, nor are loan transactions that are subject to a separate reporting regime (e.g., loans by EU or UK lenders that are subject to reporting under the EU or UK SFTR).

    Information Leakage

    While the Adopting Release attempted to allay market participants’ concerns by noting that short sales are not required to be reported under Rule 10c-1a, loans used in connection with short sales are reportable. As the majority of short sales are settled through the delivery of borrowed shares, this reporting regime has the potential to leak sensitive information relating to market participant’s short positions and trading strategies. Given advancements in the use of predictive data analytics, artificial intelligence, machine learning and similar technologies, private fund advisers and other market participants who wish to keep their securities positions and trading strategies confidential and avoid coordinated short-squeeze attacks and front-running attempts may need to adapt their trading strategies to these new disclosure requirements.

    Operational Burdens

    For broker-dealers and other firms that anticipate having reporting obligations under Rule 10c-1a (whether as covered persons or by providing reporting agent services, further discussed herein), the rule represents a new comprehensive regulatory reporting regime with which they will have to comply. While firms will not have to begin reporting loan information to FINRA until early 2026 (at the earliest), compliance with the reporting requirements may require complicated system buildouts, as well as coordination among compliance, legal, and business groups. Further, specifics of the reporting requirements remain subject to FINRA rulemaking, which may not be finalized until early 2025. Accordingly, broker-dealers and other covered persons may find themselves pressed for time to ensure compliance by the initial reporting date.

    As noted above, as a result of the SEC’s failure to include a de minimis exemption or similar carve-out from the requirement of Rule 10c-1a, covered persons without the institutional sophistication or resources necessary to build complex reporting systems may nevertheless find themselves subject to Rule 10c-1a’s reporting requirements. We expect most such entities will elect to utilize a “reporting agent” to satisfy their reporting obligations under Rule 10c-1a. While Rule 10c-1a relieves a covered person from liability if they utilize a reporting agent, the relief is only available if (i) the covered person has entered into a written agreement with the reporting agent and (ii) the covered person actually provides such reporting agent with timely access to the necessary Rule 10c-1a information. Further, simply providing a reporting agent will timely access to the data elements on a covered securities loan is not necessarily sufficient to ensure the covered person has complied with its obligations under Rule 10c-1a; rather, covered persons will still need to ensure they have processes in place to identify covered securities loan for which they have a reporting obligation.

    FINRA Rulemaking

    As noted above, specifics around the manner in which data elements will be reported and disseminated by FINRA remain subject to FINRA rulemaking.[20] Accordingly, covered persons and other interested parties should review FINRA’s rulemaking around the requirements, which must be proposed for comment no later than four months after the effective date of Rule 10c-1a.[21]

    Of particular interest is the process by which FINRA will collect and disseminate the unique identifiers associated with each covered securities loan. As required by Rule 10c-1a, FINRA is required to assign a unique identifier to each covered securities loan and covered persons and reporting agents must utilize that same unique identifier whenever the loan is modified. Commenters requested that the Commission allow flexibility in the implementation of this requirement such that market participants could create their own unique identifiers that would be used by FINRA as the publicly reportable unique loan identifier.[22] While the SEC acknowledged that it was indifferent to how unique loan identifiers would be generated, it left the decision to FINRA. Given the potential for information leakage, participants concerned about the use of non-randomized identifiers may wish to flag to such concerns to FINRA.

    Compliance Timeline

    Rule 10c-1a will go into effect on Jan. 2, 2024. FINRA must propose rules pursuant to final Rule 10c-1a(f) within four months of the rule’s effective date (presumably, April 2024). Final FINRA rules must be adopted within 12 months of Rule 10c-1a’s effective date (in or prior to January 2025).

    Regardless of the date the final FINRA rules are adopted, covered persons will not have to report Rule 10c-1a information to FINRA until the first business day 24 months after the effective date of final Rule 10c-1a (January 2026).

    Finally, FINRA will not publicly report Rule 10c-1a information until 90 calendar days after covered persons are required to start reporting Rule 10c-1a information to FINRA.

    Authored by Marc E. Elovitz, Julian Rainero, William J. Barbera and Derek N. Lacarrubba.

    If you have any questions concerning this Alert, please contact your attorney at Schulte Roth & Zabel or one of the authors.


    [1] Reporting of Securities Loans, 88 Fed. Reg. 75644 (Nov. 3, 2023).

    [2] Exchange Act Release No. 34-98737 (Oct. 13, 2023), at 1, 16 (“Adopting Release”).

    [3] See Short Position and Short Activity Reporting by Institutional Investment Managers, 88 Fed. Reg. 75100 (Nov. 1, 2023).

    [4] In its capacity as the sole existing national securities association.

    [5] “A beneficial owner cannot assign the reporting obligation when an intermediary is used, as the intermediary has the reporting obligation under final Rule 10c-1a(j)(1)(i).” Adopting Release at 27 n.115.

    [6] Rule 10c-1a(j)(2)(ii) and (iii) excludes “a position at a clearing agency that results from central counterparty services pursuant to Rule 17Ad-22(a)(2) of the Exchange Act or central securities depository services pursuant to Rule 17Ad-22(a)(3) of the Exchange Act” and “the use of margin securities, as defined in § 240.15c3-3(a)(4) … by a broker or dealer” (except lending margin securities to another person) from the definition of a covered securities loan. See Adopting Release at 79-85.

    [7] Including any successor system(s).

    [8] Adopting Release at 71-72.

    [9] Adopting Release at 70-71.

    [10] Adopting Release at 67.

    [11] Adopting Release at 78.

    [12] Adopting Release at 81.

    [13] “Accordingly, at this time, it is not necessary to include repos within the scope of the final rule’s information reporting requirements…” Adopting Release at 74.

    [14] Adopting Release at 84-85.

    [15] Generally, modifications to any of the public data elements, including the delayed reporting data element.

    [16] Adopting Release at 134-35.

    [17] While Rule 10c-1a requires that covered persons report the loan fee or rebate rate for a covered securities loan, the rule does not dictate how such information should be reported. For instance, where a loan fee or rebate rate is structured as a spread to an identified benchmark, whether covered persons will be required to only report the spread and relevant benchmark, or if covered persons will instead be required to separately report the total fee (which would result in significantly more frequent modification submissions), remains subject to FINRA rulemaking.

    [18] While Rule 10c-1 requires that a covered person report the size of a covered securities loan, how that data is reported for different types of securities (e.g., par value of debt securities) remains subject to FINRA rulemaking.

    [19] Adopting Release at 165.

    [20] “Because an RNSA would be required to implement rules regarding the format and manner to administer the collection of information, proposed Rule 10c-1 lists the data elements that persons would be required to provide to an RNSA, but does not specify granular instructions for data elements or the formatting required for submission of the information to an RNSA.” Adopting Release at 87.

    [21] FINRA rulemaking will be subject to notice, public comment, and Commission review pursuant to section 19(b) and Rule 19b-4 prior to implementation.

    [22] E.g., by including the identifier when reporting the covered securities loan to FINRA, and effectively having FINRA report back the same identifier to the covered person or reporting agent.


    This communication is issued by Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship. In some jurisdictions, this publication may be considered attorney advertising. © 2023 Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP. All rights reserved. SCHULTE ROTH & ZABEL is the registered trademark of Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP.

    In depth
    Authors

    Marc E. Elovitz

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    William J. Barbera

    Partner

    New York – 919 Third Avenue

    More insights

  • New FEHA Regulations Alter How, When Employers Can Consider Applicant’s Criminal Histories

    New FEHA Regulations Alter How, When Employers Can Consider Applicant’s Criminal Histories

    ARTICLE / CLIENT ALERT

    New FEHA Regulations Alter How, When Employers Can Consider Applicant’s Criminal Histories

    November 6, 2023

    Read time: 8 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    The California Civil Rights Council (CRD) (formerly the DFEH) has issued new regulations that modify the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA), the law that governs how and when California employers can consider a job applicant’s criminal history when making employment decisions. The new regulations took effect on October 1, 2023, and provide more coverage, prohibitions and requirements for potential employers to consider.

    In depth

    THE LAW

    Under the FEHA, employers are prohibited from inquiring into a job applicant’s criminal history prior to extending a conditional offer of employment, including through job applications, background checks and internet searches.

    The FEHA also requires that if an employer is considering taking an adverse action with respect to a job applicant or employee, the employer must first conduct an individualized assessment of the job applicant’s criminal history—including determining whether the applicant’s criminal history has a “direct and adverse” effect on their ability to perform the functions of the position.

    While the thrust of the law remains the same, the new regulations expand the scope of who is covered by the FEHA, the kinds of inquiries the law prohibits, the kinds of evidence employers must accept and consider regarding an applicant’s justification for the past offense in question and the process for recission of a conditional offer of employment.

    EXPANDED COVERAGE

    First, the new FEHA regulations expand the definitions of “employer” and “applicant.” Previously, an “employer” was defined as “a labor contractor or client employer.” The updated regulations clarify that the definition of employer additionally encompasses any direct or joint employers, agents of the employer, staffing agencies, entities that evaluate the applicant’s criminal history on behalf of an employer, and entities that select or provide workers to an employer from a pool or availability list.

    Similarly, the updated regulations clarify that an “applicant” may include, in addition to an individual who has been conditionally offered employment, existing employees who have applied to a different position with their current employer, those who have indicated a specific desire to be considered for a different position with their current employer, and even an existing employee who is subjected to a review and consideration of their criminal history because of a change in ownership, management, policy or practice.

    Employers should note that job applicants are still considered “individuals who have been conditionally offered employment” even if they have commenced employment during the post-conditional offer review and criminal background check process. In other words, employers cannot transition an applicant to an employee before beginning the background check process to avoid the FEHA.

    EXPANDED PROHIBITIONS

    The new regulations make clear that employers are prohibited from including statements in job advertisements, postings, applications or other materials indicating that they will not consider applicants with criminal histories, including statements such as “no felons” or “must have clean record.”

    In addition, employers are prohibited from conducting pre-hire internet searches on job applicants, and they cannot consider criminal history even if voluntarily provided by the job applicant during the application or interview process.

    Moreover, employers are now barred, at any stage of the hiring process, from the following:

    • Refusing additional evidence voluntarily provided by an applicant contextualizing the offense in question (or another party at the applicant’s request);
    • Requiring an applicant to submit additional evidence, or a specific type of documentary evidence, regarding the offense in question; and
    • Requiring an applicant to disclose their status as a survivor of domestic abuse or comparable statuses, medical records, or the existence of a disability or diagnosis.

    EXPANDED ADVERSE EMPLOYMENT ACTION REQUIREMENTS

    Currently, employers are required to conduct an individualized assessment of an applicant’s criminal offense and its bearing on the individual’s candidacy before rescinding a conditional offer of employment if the decision is based in whole or in part on the applicant’s criminal history. However, the updated regulations explain that employers must additionally conduct a reassessment after the job applicant has had an opportunity to respond to the pre-adverse action notice and before making a final decision. The result is a four-step process: (1) the initial individualized assessment, (2) the pre-adverse action notice and applicant response, (3) reassessment and (4) the final decision. We discuss each step below.

    1 – Initial Individualized Assessment

    The new regulations expand the scope of the employer’s individualized assessment. The regulations require the assessment to be reasoned and evidence-based, take place prior to sending the pre-adverse action letter and consider the following factors:

    • The nature and gravity of the offense or conduct;
    • The time that has passed since the offense or conduct;
    • The nature of the job held or sought; and
    • Evidence of rehabilitation or mitigating circumstances.

    2 – The Pre-Adverse Action Notice and Applicant Response

    If an employer wishes to rescind a conditional offer of employment after conducting an individualized assessment, the employer must notify the applicant in writing. The notice requirements largely remain the same: Employers must identify the conviction(s) they based their decision on, provide a copy of all the reports they utilized (including internet search results), inform the applicant that they have a right to respond before the decision is finalized and explain the kinds of evidence the applicant may provide evidence as part of their response. However, the new regulations do make a few notable changes to the notice requirement:

    • The regulations require the employer to provide the job applicant with notice of their right to respond to a pre-adverse action notice and with a response deadline that is at least five (5) business days from the date the applicant receives the notice.
    • If an applicant timely notifies the employer in writing that additional time is needed to respond, the employer must give the applicant at least five additional business days to respond to the notice before making a final decision. The regulations contain ambiguity regarding what is a “timely” notification.
    • If the pre-adverse action notice is sent to the applicant through email, the notice is deemed received two business days after it is sent, meaning that the five-day response deadline begins to run after the second day post-transmittal.

    3 – Reassessment

    If the applicant provides evidence related to mitigating circumstances or their rehabilitative efforts since the conviction at issue, the employer must consider the information—a process the new regulations call “reassessment.” The employer must consider factors such as the applicant’s conduct during incarceration, employment history since the conviction or release from incarceration, community service and engagement, and other rehabilitative efforts.

    4 – Final Decision

    There are no new requirements for employers to consider when making their final decision to rescind a conditional offer of employment.

    EMPLOYER LIABILITY IMPOSED BY FEHA

    Job applicants may allege violations of the FEHA by arguing that there is a less discriminatory policy or practice that serves the employer’s goals as effectively as its current background check policy or practice without significantly increasing the cost or burden on the employer. These allegations can be lodged through a complaint filed with the CRD or a civil lawsuit for discrimination. A variety of remedies are available for possible violations of the FEHA, such as reinstatement of back pay and benefits, compensatory damages for emotional distress and out-of-pocket losses, injunctive relief and punitive damages. Courts also regularly award attorneys’ fees if job applicants prevail.

    PRACTICAL CONSIDERATIONS AND NEXT STEPS

    Employers with background check programs can start implementing the following key action items in response to the updated FEHA regulations:

    • Review and update job postings and applications to ensure that they do not include statements suggesting that job applicants are barred from the process because of their criminal history, including “no convicted felons,” “criminal background check required” and language referring to “ex-offenders.”
    • Review background check policies as necessary to ensure compliance with the FEHA’s new requirements, including expanded time periods in communications with job applicants consistent with the four-step process above if considering an adverse action.
    • Ensure detailed and organized documentation of all discussions with job applicants who may be subject to an adverse action in preparation for future challenges to the employer’s hiring process under the new regulations.
    • Consider providing additional or updated trainings to human resources professionals who handle the application and new-hire process, especially to emphasize that internet searches (including social media) of job applicants are strictly prohibited prior to extending a conditional offer of employment. All inquiries should be saved until after a conditional offer of employment has been extended.

    For assistance in complying with the new FEHA regulations, please contact McDermott’s Employment Practice Group.

    Authors
    More insights