Content Type: Article

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 13

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 13

    June, 2004

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY

    1. In The UK New Legislation Extends The Right To Opt-Out Of Telephone Marketing To Corporate Subscribers

    The Privacy and Electronic Communications (EC Directive) (Amendment) Regulations 2004 come into force on 25 June 2004. They extend The Privacy and Electronic Communications (EC Directive) Regulations 2003 and enable corporate subscribers to register their desire not to receive unsolicited telephone calls for direct marketing purposes.

    2. The IP Value of Business Plans: Protection for the Entrepreneur

    A business plan is rarely thought of as being valuable because of the protectable IP rights contained and embodied in it. While it is usually treated as confidential and disclosed through a non disclosure agreement, it is usually considered as the vehicle to get money and not intrinsically valuable in its own right. However, the issue of value was recently shown in the English case of Ball v Druces and Attlee (a firm).

    3. Hungarian IP Law: Beyond National Frontiers After EU Accession

    Harmonisation of intellectual property rights in new member countries has been a hotly debated and eagerly awaited consequence of EU enlargement. Hungary has recently updated its law relating to Trademark and Design in line with its commitment to the treaty of accession. Other new member states like Lithuania are also undertaking statutory revisions to fulfil their treaty obligations.

    4. Griggs v Evans: Are Foreign IPRs Subject To Equities Recognised By The English Courts?

    For the first time, the High Court has addressed an important point of private international law concerning its jurisdiction to order the assignment of foreign copyrights that are subject to equities under English law. This case serves as a reminder that intellectual property rights are creatures of national law, and should be treated as such in the course of commercial negotiations. Nevertheless, by holding that the court has jurisdiction to order the assignment of all foreign copyrights subject to equities, this decision will come as a relief to those commissioning copyright works in the UK.


    COPYRIGHT

    5. Collective Society Of Music In The Information Society

    The European Commission has warned collecting societies that their so-called Santiago Agreement, which aims at simplifying the licensing of music to be used online by allowing them to grant “one-stop shop” copyright licenses, may be in breach of European Union competition rules.

    6. Irish Copyright Act Amended To Prevent Infringement Action Against National Library

    Ireland recently amended its copyright legislation to clarify that literary and artistic works may be displayed in public without infringing the author’s copyright. The change came in response to threats by James Joyce’s estate that it was considering bringing an infringement action against the National Library of Ireland if the library went ahead with a display of various manuscripts written by Joyce as part of celebrations to mark the centenary of Bloomsday.


    PATENTS

    7. EPO Revokes Myriad Breast Cancer Patent

    The opposition division of the European Patent Office has decided to revoke a patent, which had been granted to Myriad Genetics in 2001, relating to a method for diagnosing a predisposition for breast and ovarian cancer on the grounds that it did not meet the requirements of the European Patent Convention.

    8. Commission Welcomes Council Agreement On Directive On Computer-Implemented Inventions

    The Council of Ministers of the European Union has agreed a compromise over the Directive on computer-implemented inventions. However, important differences remain between the positions of the Council and European Parliament.

    9. Celltech v Medimmune: ‘Infringement’ In German Patent Law Defined by English Courts

    This case explains and formulates the precise scope of the test that a Court would adopt in determining the issue of patent infringement under the German law, if applicable in English proceedings. The Court, assisted by expert witnesses, accepted the “test of infringement” as laid down by German Supreme Court in the case of Formstein and Custodial II.

    10. The End Of The Italian Torpedo

    The Supreme Court of Italy has rejected the so-called Italian Torpedo as a way to tie-up cross-border patent infringement litigious with the Italians courts.

    11. Kambly SA Spécialités de Bisuits Suisses v Intersnack Knabber-Gebäck GmbH & Co KG

    This case, which started with a trade mark application in 1989 for the mark Goldfish, in English and German, and which went under opposition in about 1998, is an example of a case where nothing went right for the opponent to the registration of the mark.


    TRADE MARKS

    12. Violin-Maker’s Descendant Wins Case To Protect Stradivari Name

    In a test case, a descendant of the violin-maker Antonio Stradivari has persuaded an Italian court to order an estate agent to stop using the name Stradivari. She is now threatening similar legal action against anybody who uses the Stradivari name.

    13. Coco De Mer v Chanel

    In a trade mark dispute over bottled perfume, Coco de Mer, named after an exotic Seychelles palm tree, failed in their appeal against the refusal of the Registrar of Trade Marks in the UK to register the mark COCO DE MER in a number of classes of goods, including class 3 (perfumery, essential oils, cosmetics).


    ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

    McDermott Will & Emery would like to acknowledge the invaluable contribution to the Bulletin made by Angel Adrian, Lucas Arrivillaga, John Cahir, Malcolm Langley, YunJoo Lee, Rajesh Sagar, Ilanah Simon and Daphne Zografos from the Queen Mary Intellectual Property Research Institute, University of London.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 12

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 12

    May, 2004

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY

    1. New EC Technology Transfer regime

    The revised EC TECHNOLOGY TRANSFER BLOCK EXEMPTION REGULATION (“TTBE”) came into force on 1 May, 2004. The TTBE is the European Commission’s “safe harbour” from the application of Article 81 EC for certain technology licences (patent/know how licences).

    2. Naomi’s Privacy – Breach of Confidence

    This is the first media case to have reached the House of Lords following implementation of the Human Rights Act 1998 and is therefore significant. However, creation of a “back door privacy law” as a result of this judgment appears unlikely. Clare Sellars, an Associate in McDermott Will & Emery’s London office, reviews this case which, it is claimed, has extended the existing law of breach of confidence in English law.

    3. Ukraine Targeted By USTR In 2004 “Special 301” Report

    The Office of the United States Trade Representative (USTR) released its annual report on the adequacy and effectiveness of intellectual property rights relating to its industries around the globe. IPR protection in the Ukraine remained inadequate and would continue to be designated a Priority Foreign Country.


    COPYRIGHT

    4. ECJ Judgment In IMS Health v NDC Health

    In this case, the European Court of Justice has confirmed that in the absence of an objective reason, an intellectual property right owner enjoying a dominant position on a given market does not have the right to refuse to license a competitor, if such a refusal will block the competitor’s access into the market and stifle innovation.

    5. Communication And Consultation on Copyrights And Related Rights In The Internal Market

    The European Commission will adopt Community legislation on the collective management of rights, especially with respect to the governance of collecting agencies. An interoperable Digital Rights Management system will be instituted along with a Community-wide licensing scheme for the exploitation of these rights.

    6. New Software Makes It Possible To Copy Music From Protected CDs

    A computer magazine and a software company in Germany have released a software that makes it possible to bypass any form of anti-copying technology used to protect music CDs.


    PATENTS

    7. Supplementary Protection Certificates: Application Of Pharmacia Italia SPA

    The Advocate-General disappointed many pharmaceutical companies when he confirmed that references to first authorisation of medicinal products in Council Regulation No. 1768/92 providing for supplementary protection certificates include reference to both human and veterinary applications of medicinal products. Pharmacia Italia SPA, therefore, lost its opportunity to obtain extension of its patent term.


    TRADE MARKS

    8. Challenge To The Ownership Of The State Symbols Of Former East Germany

    The registration of the state symbols of the former East Germany, including the iconic hammer and compass symbol, is to be challenged before the German Patent Office.

    9. Generic To Whom? Björnekulla Fruktindustrier v Procordia Food

    In this case, the European Court of Justice has considered if the determination of whether a mark has become generic under Article 12(2)(a) of Directive 89/104 must be made through the eyes of consumers or from the perspective of those in the trade.

    10. Imitation Of International Emblems: Concept-Anlagen v OHIM

    Under Community trade mark law, marks that consist of important state symbols or imitations of them from a heraldic point of view which have not been authorised by the competent authority are to be refused registration pursuant to the Paris Convention.

    11. Construction Of Trade Mark Agreements: Apple Corps v Apple Computer

    In what could prove to be the opening moves for future litigation for breach of contract, the Trade Mark Agreement between Apple Corps and Apple Computer was brought before the English High Court to determine where the contract was made and which jurisdiction applies, given that neither was specified in the agreement.


    ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

    McDermott, Will & Emery would like to acknowledge the invaluable contribution to the Bulletin made by Angel Adrian, Lucas Arrivillaga, Afegieme Komolafe, Malcolm Langley, YunJoo Lee, James Mitchiner, Ilanah Simon and Daphne Zografos from the Queen Mary Intellectual Property Research Institute, University of London.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • Transfer of Clinical Research Data from the European Union to the United States

    ARTICLE

    Transfer of Clinical Research Data from the European Union to the United States

    April 7, 2004

    Read time: 1 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 11

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 11

    April, 2004

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY

    1.EC Commission Rules Against Microsoft For Abuse Of Its Dominant Position

    After a five-year investigation, the EC Commission has found that Microsoft has abused its dominant position in the market and thus violated Article 82 of the EU treaty.


    COPYRIGHT

    2.Ownership of Copyright in Research Partnerships: Cyprotex Discovery v University of Sheffield

    Events in this case highlight the need for parties to clearly identify their respective capabilities, contributions and intentions in research agreements as well including clauses to deal with ownership of IP rights. at the earliest opportunity.

    3.Director And Writer In Copyright Spotlight

    The problems surrounding joint ownership of copyright are explored in light of Pam Brighton, the former director of the play “Stones in his Pocket”, claiming joint copyright ownership of the play from writer Marie Jones.

    4.Protection Of Technical Drawings: Ultra Marketing v Universal components

    The case determined that copyright protection in a drawing protected the artistic characteristics of the work and not the technical idea that it embodied. This meant that a competitor could use the drawing to inspire a progressive development without infringing design rights.


    PATENTS

    5.Once Bitten Not Twice Shy: Rockwater v Technip France

    This interesting case involved a patent claim that was earlier litigated before the Court of Appeal in relation to its novelty, obviousness and claim construction. Yet, the patent was again challenged on similar grounds for its lack of novelty and being obvious by another party in light of further prior art being discovered.

    6.Collateral Use Of Patent Evidence: Dendron v Regents Of University Of California

    This case is the first authority in the European Union, which encapsulates the law in respect of the collateral use of evidence obtained by one of the parties pursuant to a letter of request made under EC regulation 1206/2001 and under Common Law. It further elaborates the considerations that the Court will weigh before allowing collateral use of such evidence in other proceedings between the same parties.

    7.Russell Finex v Telsonic

    The main issue in that case refers to the determination of the scope of a patent; more precisely it is the application of the Improver test which is specified. The Improver test is used to assist in the understanding of the construction of a claim by providing a method to define its purposive construction. This is especially useful in patent litigation when the supposedly infringing entity does not fall within the literal wording of a claim.


    TRADE MARKS

    8.Passing Off: McAlpine v McAlpine

    The shared rights to goodwill of Sir Robert McAlpine and Alfred McAlpine in the name “McAlpine” could be damaged if one of them abandoned its distinguishing prefix and arrogated to itself the use of the name in circumstances where such an action amounts to a misrepresentation. This unusual case illustrates the flexibility of passing off rights compared with trade mark rights.

    9.CTM Exclusive Right: Compass Publishing v Compass Logistics

    The case at issue discusses the overlap between Community Trade Mark (CTM) and national trade mark. One of the objectives of the CTM Regulation is to protect the interests of owners of earlier rights whether they are registered or not.

    10.Own Name Defence: IBM v Web-Sphere

    The case at issue refers to the registration of a Community Trade Mark and an unregistered mark which came into existence after the CTM application had been filed but before it had been granted. The CTM Regulation provides that rights conferred by CTM registration prevail against third parties from the date of publication of the registration.

    11.Distinctive Character: SAT.1 Satelliten Fernshehen v OHIM

    This opinion of AG Jacob lays down the rules for interpretation of Art 7 (1)(b) of Community Trade Mark Regulation, in assessing registrability of a sign in relation to a particular services or goods. It further elaborates the policy consideration and the test to be followed in applying the said provision to a given set of facts.


    ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

    McDermott, Will & Emery would like to acknowledge the invaluable contribution to the Bulletin made by Angel Adrian, Lucas Arrivillaga, Afegieme Komolafe, Malcolm Langley, Florian Leverve, Rajesh Sagar and Daphne Zografos from the Queen Mary Intellectual Property Research Institute, University of London.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • IP Review

    ARTICLE

    IP Review

    Spring, 2004

    Read time: 2 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    Summary

    IP Review is a publication that contains insights into the various topics of IP while incorporating the authors points of view.

    In Our Spring 2004 issue:

    • The Role of Patents in the Standard-Setting Process
    • Exculpatory Opinions and Willful Infringement Charges
    • Equivalents in the Age of Festo
    • Dispositive Motions in Patent Cases
    • Integra v. Merck: Is There Safe Harbor for Research?
    • Trademark and Unfair Competition in Europe
    • The Importance of Sound Damages Models
    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 10

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 10

    March, 2004

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY

    1. Proposal For A Directive On Enforcement Of Intellectual Property Rights

    The European Parliament has voted in favour of a Directive to harmonise national laws on the means of enforcing intellectual property rights and to establish a framework for the exchange of information in order to help fight piracy and counterfeiting.


    COPYRIGHT

    2. EMI Takes Action Against Beatles Album Remix

    Record label EMI issues “cease and desist” orders to stop DJ Danger Mouse and record stores from selling the Grey Album, which uses unauthorised samples of the Beatles’ White Album.

    3. Moral Rights: Anya v Wu

    This decision shows how the moral right of an author to be identified attaches to copyright expression and not necessarily to underlying ideas. It also shows the usefulness of the Court’s power to strike out hopeless cases, and perhaps the difficulties faced by litigants in person.

    4. Database Rights: Royal Mail v i-CD Publishing

    The issues central to this case are how to create a balance between the commercial interests of a copyright holder and the public interest to be advanced through the use of a copyrighted database, and how far this balance affects the interpretation of the terms of a copyright licence.

    5. Equitable Remuneration Defined: SENA v NOS

    In this case, the ECJ laid down the essential principles relating to the interpretation of Article 8(2) of Community Directive 92/100 EEC of 19 November 1992 on rental and lending rights and on certain rights related to copyright in the field of intellectual property.


    PATENTS

    6. Electronic Filing Of International Patent Applications

    From February 2004, applicants seeking patent protection in multiple countries through the Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT) have the possibility to electronically file applications using the PCT-SAFE (Secure Applications Filed Electronically) system. This System offers applicants using the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) as a receiving office a more economic, safe and quicker procedure to obtain patent protection.

    7. Europe Revokes Rambus Patent

    The revocation of a European patent held by Rambus Inc. has brought a reprieve for major memory chip manufacturers in Europe, who have been sued in various member states by Rambus Inc. for infringement of its patented technology. However, the ruling does not bring much hope for them in US, where FTC has already ruled in favour of Rambus Inc. despite the objections of fraud against it. The trials of the infringement case are slated to begin in the coming summer in the US.

    8. CIPA Proposes Code Of Practice

    A Code of Practice for pre-action conduct in intellectual property disputes was released by the Skrein Committee to assist and guide those who are dealing with intellectual property issues.


    TRADE MARKS

    9. ECJ Refuses 3-Dimensional Mark: Deutsche SiSi-Werke v OHIM

    The case between Deutsche SiSi-Werke v OHIM refers to the registration of a drinks packaging as a three-dimensional mark and the need for the mark to be distinctive so as to prevent a monopoly for a form of packaging. Under trade mark law, a mark has to be distinctive in order to qualify for trade mark protection.

    10. New Regime For Registration Of .FR Domain Names

    Association Française pour le Nommage Internet en Coopération (AFNIC) is introducing a new regime for registration of .fr domain names. Under the new regime, applications will be considered on a “first come, first served” basis, hence abolishing the need to prove ownership of the domain name.

    11. Scottish & Newcastle To Stop Brewing Newcastle Brown Ale in Newcastle?

    Rumours that Scottish & Newcastle, the brewers of Newcastle Brown Ale, are to move production of “broon” (as it is affectionately known) from its Tyne Brewery in Newcastle could have serious implications for its intellectual property assets because Scottish & Newcastle is the named producer of the Newcastle Brown Ale geographical indication.


    ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

    McDermott, Will & Emery would like to acknowledge the invaluable contribution to the Bulletin made by Lucas Arrivillaga, Alison Firth, Afegieme Komolafe, Malcolm Langley, Rajesh Sagar, Ilanah Simon and Daphne Zografos from the Queen Mary Intellectual Property Research Institute, University of London.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 9

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 9

    February, 2004

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    NTELLECTUAL PROPERTY

    1. INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS IN SPORT: VICTORIES FOR COLE AND BEDFORD

    The cases of Joe Cole and David Bedford illustrate the growing awareness and need felt by sports personalities to protect their image, goodwill or popularity from unauthorised commercial use and exploitation. These cases underline the use of intellectual property rights to protect legitimate interests in the absence of specific personality or image rights in UK.


    COPYRIGHT

    2. THE MUSIC INDUSTRY TAKES ACTION AGAINST PARALLEL IMPORTS

    The British Phonographic Industry is taking action against online retailers selling CDs sourced outside the European Economic Area. In January it reached a favourable settlement with CD WOW!, an online CD retailer, over parallel imports.

    3. GOOGLE DEMANDS BOOBLE CHANGE ITS NAME

    The most popular Internet search-engine, Google, which accounts for more than 70% of the global search engine market, has demanded the new adult Internet search-engine Booble change its name and refrain permanently from using a variation of Google’s name.

    4. NELLIE THE ELEPHANT PART 1

    The UK Trade Marks Registry has rejected an application by Dash Music to declare invalid the “Nellie the Elephant” trade mark even though they own the copyright to the well known children’s song.


    PATENTS

    5. NEW PATENTS BILL INTRODUCED INTO THE HOUSE OF LORDS

    A Patents Bill has been introduced by Lord Sainsbury, the Minister for Science and Innovation, to bring the Patents Act 1977 into line with recent changes to the European Patent Convention. It will be called the Patent Act 2004 but will only amend the Act. The Bill results from a consultation procedure in 2003 by the UK Patent Office, but some of the drafting does not reflect that envisaged by the UKPO.

    6. EUROPEAN COMMISSION PROPOSES COMMUNITY PATENT COURT

    The EC has finally presented its proposals for establishing the Community Patent Court, which will have exclusive jurisdiction in dealing with the issues of infringement and validity of Community Patents. This will ensure enhanced legal certainty and harmonisation of patent law and procedures, while avoiding much of the expenses and inconvenience for future applicants seeking patent protection in EU.


    TRADE MARKS

    7. NELLIE THE ELEPHANT PART 2

    At the second time of asking, the UK Trade Marks Registry has revoked the “Nellie the Elephant” Trade Mark on the basis of “non-use”.

    8. NICHOLS PLC V REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS

    The UK trade marks registry has a long standing practice of accepting rare surnames as trade marks but refusing registration to those which are common surnames. This case considers whether or not this practice complies with the Trade Mark Directive 89/104/EC requirement that surnames be treated as any other type of mark.

    9. THE MINT HAS A HOLE – THE CASE HAS A HOLE

    In Mars UK Ltd v Societe des Produits Nestlé SA the question arose as to the scope of permissible amendments to a trade mark application. Nestlé, having earlier in the year been refused “Have a Break” by the Court of Appeal, although subject to a reference to the ECJ, were chancing their arm by seeking to register a graphical or three dimensional trade mark, the shape of the well known Polo mint but without the word “Polo” on it.


    ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

    McDermott, Will & Emery would like to acknowledge the invaluable contribution to the Bulletin made by Lucas Arrivillaga, Afegieme Komolafe, Malcolm Langley, James Mitchiner, Rajesh Sagar, Ilanah Simon and Daphne Zografos from the Queen Mary Intellectual Property Research Institute, University of London.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 8

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 8

    January, 2004

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    COPYRIGHT

    1. BELGIAN WATCHDOG SUES MAJOR RECORD LABELS OVER ANTI-COPY CDS

    Belgian-based watchdog Test-Achats is suing some of the world’s largest record labels for selling copy-protected CDs that prevent consumers from playing the CDs on PCs and car stereos and from making legitimate back-up copies. It wants the record labels to stop releasing copy-protected CDs and to reimburse consumers.

    2. DVD ‘PIRATE’ CLEARED BY NORWEGIAN COURT OF APPEAL

    Jon Johansen, one of the creators of the program DeCSS, which allows DVDs to be played on PCs running the Linux operating system, was acquitted by the Norwegian Court of Appeal after being sued for piracy by the Motion Picture Association of America.

    3. KAZAA: NOTHING ILLEGAL ABOUT IT!

    The Dutch Supreme Court has ruled that Kazaa’s creator cannot be held liable for the use of its file sharing software. The ruling first by a highest court of any country implies that providers of peer to peer file sharing software cannot be held guilty of piracy and copyright infringement of music, films and other material that is transmitted using their software. It may now leave the beleaguered music industry to haunt the individual users in its efforts to quell piracy.

    4. UNREGISTERED DESIGN RIGHTS

    Two recent cases, Intercase v Time Computers and Ultraframe v Fielding have cast light on the ownership of UK unregistered design right, as between individuals and the companies they own or direct.

    5. NEW ONLINE SYSTEM FOR DIGITAL SIGNATURES

    JADE is a new online system of digital signatures that has been developed to assist in the process of copyright assignation for authors.

    6. GRIGGS V EVANS

    The issue in this case is to judge who the owner of a copyright is over a logo made by a freelance artist, contracted by an advertisement company to satisfy the request of a client that was trying to reinforce its ‘Dr Martens’ trade mark.


    PATENTS

    7. APOTEX EUROPE V SMITHKLINE BEECHAM

    The determination of exact scope of monopoly conferred by any claim is a fundamental necessity to resolve questions of infringement, anticipation and obviousness. The subject matter of this case deals with the law applicable to construction and interpretation of claims as embodied in a patent specification.

    8. OSTEOPOROSIS MEDICINAL PATENTS

    Two recent cases, Instituto Gentili v Teva and Merck v Generics, relate to the same type of medicine to treat osteoporosis. In the first case, a patent was challenged on the grounds of novelty and fairness and in the second Merck brought an infringement action to protect its best-selling osteoporosis medicine.


    TRADE MARKS

    9. GEROLSTEINER BRUNNEN V PUTSCH

    The case at issue refers to the interpretation of ‘honest practices’ where an undertakeing uses a trade mark that poses a likelihood of confusion with an earlier registered mark.

    10. MICROSOFT ‘WINDOWS’: A GENERIC TERM OR VALID TRADE MARK?

    Having failed to obtain a preliminary injunction in US, Microsoft challenged Lindows.com in the Benelux countries over infringement of its ‘Windows’ trade mark. The courts of Sweden and Finland have granted preliminary injunction in favour of Microsoft but the actions have exposed ‘Windows’, one of Microsoft’s most famous trade marks, to the threat of being declared a generic term. Such a declaration would mean that ‘Windows’ would lose its validity as a trade mark.

    11. DIXY FRIED CHICKENS

    A UK trade mark registration may be opposed or challenged by an earlier user who enjoys passing off rights over the mark. An attack may also be based upon a third party’s passing off rights. However, credible prima facie evidence of the rights must be adduced. In this case the applicant for revocation had not reached the evidential threshold. On the contrary, the judge described the evidence as a “shambles”, “voluminous”, “much of it irrelevant…, a lot of it inadequate and all in a disorganised state”.

    12. AUDI AG V OHIM

    The issue in this case is the dismissal by the European Union’s Court of First Instance (CFI), of an appeal from a decision made by the European trade mark office, OHIM, refusing to register a word mark ‘TDI’ used in the automobile industry as a Community trade mark for its lack of distinctiveness.

    13. SHIELD MARK V KIST

    A decision from the ECJ on whether sounds can be registered as trade marks. The ECJ considered: (i) whether sounds are capable of distinguishing the goods of one undertaking from those of other undertakings; and (ii) whether sounds are capable of being graphically represented. The ECJ also provided guidance on which sorts of representations of sounds meet the graphical representation requirement.


    ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

    McDermott, Will & Emery would like to acknowledge the invaluable contribution to the Bulletin made by, Lucas Arrivillaga, Alison Firth, Afegieme Komolafe, Malcolm Langley, Florian Leverve, Rajesh Sagar, Ilanah Simon and Daphne Zografos, from the Queen Mary Intellectual Property Research Institute, University of London.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 7

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 7

    December, 2003

    Read time: 4 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    HOT TOPICS 

    1. SPAM AND COOKIES – NEW UK PRIVACY LEGISLATION

    On 11 December the Privacy and Electronic Communications Regulations came into force in the UK. Rohan Massey, an Associate in McDermott Will & Emery’s London office reviews the implications of the new legislation.

    2. WHEN IS AN EXCLUSIVE LICENCE NOT AN EXCLUSIVE LICENCE?

    A recent case highlights the fact that parties to an agreement must not only use the correct wording and precise drafting to achieve their commercial objectives, but also to construct other aspects of the agreement in accordance with those objectives.

    3. FADE – THE BRIGHT COPY-PROTECTION SYSTEM

    FADE is a unique PC-based piracy protection system that can degrade illegally copied games. Counterfeited copies of games protected by the system work properly at first but start to fall apart after the player has had enough time to get hooked, actually encouraging people to buy the genuine software.


     COPYRIGHT

    4. BELGIUM FOUND IN BREACH OF EU COPYRIGHT OBLIGATIONS

    The ECJ has found that Belgium was in breach of its obligation to implement the Directive on rental right and lending rights by failing to provide for the remuneration of authors whose works were exempted by national law from the public lending right.

    5. “1860” BRICK STRUCTURE: ABUSE OF DOMINANCE OR LEGITIMATE IPR REFUSAL?

    A ruling in the case of IMS v NDC is expected from the ECJ which will establish the legal principles relating to the circumstances in which refusal by a dominant company to license its assets can be justified on the grounds of Intellectual Property Rights protection. The decision in this case is likely to have major ramifications both for dominant companies, as owners of IPR protected assets, and the competition in common market.

    6. P2P UNITED LAUNCH MEMBER CODE OF CONDUCT

    P2P United has launched a code of conduct in September 2003 to encourage responsible behaviour among their users.


     PATENTS 

    7. PATENT LITIGATION – A JOB FOR THE PROFESSIONALS

    Cintec International Ltd v Parkes & Anr provides a fine illustration of the perils of representing one’s self in the highly complex world of a patent infringement lawsuit.


    TRADE MARKS

    8. ADIDAS SOLOMAN AG V FITNESS TRADING LTD ECJ CASE C-408/01

    A case concerning the limits of trade mark protection, and where it impinges on embellishment or commonplace design features which have to be open to everyone.

    9. OHIM V WM WRIGLEY COMPANY (DOUBLEMINT), ECJ CASE C-191/01P

    The issue in this case relates to one of the tests to be applied in deciding whether a work mark is capable of distinguishing the goods of one undertaking from those of other undertakings. This is the fundamental test for registrability of a trade mark under EU law.

    10. PROPOSAL TO AMEND THE CTM REGULATION

    On 23 September, changes to European Union trademark legislation were approved by the European Parliament.

    11. CFI PROVIDES RESTITUTIO IN INTEGRUM GUIDANCE

    In Classen Holding v OHMI – International Paper Company the CFI considered the date from which the time limit for a restitutio in integrum claim runs and the method by which such a claim must be made.

    12. KIK’S “EQUALITY OF COMMUNITY LANGUAGES” PRINCIPLE REJECTED BY ECJ

    In Kik v OHIM, the ECJ held that an Applicant while filing an application for Community TM under Regulation 40/94 does not automatically enjoy a right to participate before the Office in the same language used for filing application, and shall as a procedure formality indicate a second language, if the language of application is different from the official language of OHIM.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights

  • European IP Bulletin, Issue 6

    ARTICLE

    European IP Bulletin, Issue 6

    November, 2003

    Read time: 5 min

    Key takeaways
    Overview

    HOT TOPICS

    1. European Parliament Adopts Controversial Amendments to Proposed Directive on Computer Implemented Inventions

    Justin Hill, a patent attorney in the London office and a Fellow of the Computer Technology Committee assess the practical implications of the European Parliament adopting controversial amendments to the proposed Directive on Computer Implemented Inventions. The amendments illustrate the extent to which the Open Source Community has succeeded in lobbying MEPs with a view to severely limiting the level of protection afforded to Computer Implemented Inventions, including software inventions.

    2. European Trade Mark Protection And Unfair Competition –Views From the UK & Italy

    Margherita Barié and Pietro Pouchè from McDermott Will & Emery’s Milan office and Ian Harrington, and associate in McDermott Will & Emery’s London office give their perspectives of tensions existing between trade mark protection and unfair competition which, despite harmonizing European legislation, represent one of the most significant examples of the inconsistencies in intellectual property protection across the EU Member States.

    3. New EU Council Regulation To Strengthen Custom Action Against Counterfeit Goods

    The European Community have adopted council regulation 1383/2003concerning customs action against goods suspected of infringing intellectual property rights.

    4. Procedural Amendments For Appeals In The UK Patent Office

    The UK Patent Office has, by Revised Tribunal Practice Notice TPN 1/2003 dated August 6, 2003, amended procedures relating to appeals made to the Court from decisions of the Comptroller.


    COPYRIGHT

    5. Deal Memos: A Burnin’ Issue?

    In Confetti Records v Warner Music [2003] EWCH 1274 (Ch) the defendant needed to establish the existence of a licence for the inclusion and mixing of the garage music track ‘Burnin’ into a compilation album to avoid a claim for copyright infringement.

    6. Incidental Intent?

    The case between FA Premier League & Others v Panini UK Ltd [2003] EWCA Civ 995 provides trade mark owners with hope when they are unable to prove that an alleged infringer has used their mark in a trade mark sense.

    7. High Court of Justice Decision in X v Nowacki

    In X v Nowacki and Another, [2003] EWHC (Ch) the claimant, a wholesaler of high value ornate tableware, claimed exclusive rights to the copyright and design of the defendant’s range of china and porcelain tableware.

    8. Registrability Of Designs Dictated By Their Technical Function

    The UK Patent Office has, by Designs Practice Note DPN 5/03 dated 18 August 2003, explained its interpretation of Section 1C of the Registered Designs Act 1949, as amended to implement Directive 98/71/EC on the legal protection of designs.


    PATENTS

    9. Coflexip SA v Stolt Offshore MS

    In Coflexip SA v Stolt Offshore MS ltd & Ors [2003] EWHC 1892, Stolt sought the revocation of its outstanding damages for patent infringement following the revocation of the Coflexip patent earlier this year.

    10. Storage Computers v Hitachi Data Systems

    In Storage Computers Ltd v Hitachi Data Systems Ltd [2003] EWCA 1155 Civ, Storage Computers appealed against their failed infringement proceedings against Hitachi over patent EP 0294287 regarding irrecoverable computer hard disk-drive errors.

    11. Progress of UK Patent Amendment Bill

    The Patent Office has published a Notice of Progress on their consultation on proposed changes to UK patent legislation.


    TRADE MARKS

    12. True. The CFI Agrees with Anheuser-Busch Over ‘Budmen’ Mark

    In José Alejandro v OHIM – Anheuser-Busch, T-129/01, the Court of First Instance decided that the word sign BUDMEN couldn’t be registered as a community trade mark because of the existence of the BUD mark in Denmark, Ireland and the United Kingdom.

    13. Grey Day For Stihl As CTM Appeal Rejected

    In Stihl v OHMI, T-234/01, the Court of First Instance held that Stihl’s application for a Community Trade Mark of an orange rectangle above a grey rectangle was devoid of any distinctive character.

    14. Can Surfers Become Elegant?

    In H Young (Operations) Ltd v Medici Ltd [2003] EWHC 1589 (Ch) the question of how a trade mark specification in relation to goods that ascribes to a particular image or lifestyle should be construed is raised.

    15. Exclusive Rights in Trade Marks

    In Inter Lotto v Camelot Group Plc [2003] EWHC 1256 (Ch) and Inter Lotto (UK) Ltd v Camelot Group Plc [2003] EWCA Civ 1132 exclusive rights to the mark ‘HOT PICKS’ was contested.

    16. Timetable for Trade Mark Refusals Tightened

    In Practice Amendment Notice 2/03, The UK Trade Marks Registry has announced that applicants will be given only 3 months instead of 6 months to respond to most official objections.

    17. EU Pushing for Tougher Rules to Protect Geographical Indications

    Within the framework of the Doha Round, the EU has proposed a three-step process to improve the way in which geographical indications are protected.


    ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

    McDermott, Will & Emery would like to acknowledge the invaluable contribution to the Bulletin made by the following individuals at Queen Mary Intellectual Property Research Institute:

    Alison Firth, Afe Komolafe, Malcolm Langley, Florian Leverve, James Mitchiner, Aditya Nagarsheth, Mike Rhys-Thomas and Daphne Zografos.

    In depth
    Authors
    More insights